5 Things You Can Do NOW5 Things You Can Do NOWto Calm Down Reactivityto Calm Down Reactivity
Presented by: Ricky Smith, CMRPMarch 2011
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
March 2011
It isn’t what you know that will kill you, it h t d ’t k th t illwhat you don’t know that will
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
“Your system is perfectly designed to give you the results you get”y g
– W. Deming PhD
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Reactive Maintenance Attributes• Ineffective or No Planning and Scheduling• PM Compliance has a wide variancePM Compliance has a wide variance• Performing PM on Equipment that continues
to breakdown• Overnight deliveries sit for weeks, months• Everyone works as hard as they can withEveryone works as hard as they can with
little if any movement seen toward proactive• Storeroom is Chaos (people standing in line (p p g
at 7:00am waiting on parts)
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Do you want to be Proactive or Reactive?
Not enough hours in the day
Proactive ReactiveWe need to cut back on contractors
Proactive Reactive
Hurry and get those PMs doneHurry and get those PMs done
We need to stop ordering parts
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
World Class – What does it look like?
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
World Class Standards• PM Execution – 15%• PM Results – 15%• PdM Execution – 15%• PdM Results – 35%• Total Work “Planned” – 90%• Reactive Work – Less than 2%• Stock outs less than 2%• Stock-outs – less than 2%• Scheduled compliance by day/week – 85 to 90%• Failure Reporting, Analysis, Corrective ActionFailure Reporting, Analysis, Corrective Action
System in place and eliminating failures by changing maintenance strategy and equipment modificationsW k d l d i h ALL C d ID
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
• Work orders are closed out with ALL Codes ID
Information you must know
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Let’s start with the basics – Lessons Learned
• Maintenance – To Maintain• Maintenance Planning – parts staged/kitted, labor hours
estimated coordination identified step-by-step procedure withestimated, coordination identified, step-by-step procedure with specifications
• Maintenance Procedures – Repeatable, Effective ProceduresMean Time Between Failure The most basic measurement of• Mean Time Between Failure – The most basic measurement of equipment reliability
• Preventive Maintenance – To Prevent Failure• Condition Monitoring (aka, Predictive Maintenance)
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
What Is a Failure?“A functional failure is the inability of an item (or the equipment containing it) to meet a ( g )specified performance standard and is usually identified by an operator.”- F. Stanley Nowlan and Howard F. Heap, Reliability-Centered Maintenance, Department of Defense Report Number AD-A066-579, December 1978
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
What Is a Failure?“A potential failure is an identifiable physical condition which indicates a functional failure is i i t d i ll id tifi d bimminent and is usually identified by a Maintenance Technician using predictive or quantitative preventive maintenance ”quantitative preventive maintenance.- F. Stanley Nowlan and Howard F. Heap, Reliability-Centered Maintenance, Department of Defense Report Number AD-A066-579, December 1978
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Failure Patterns
BathtubPattern A = 4%
Initial Break-in periodPattern D = 7%
W O tRandom
Pattern E = 14%
Time Time
Wear OutPattern B = 2%
Time Time
FatiguePattern C = 5% Infant Mortality
Pattern F = 68%
Age Related = 11% Random = 89%
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Source: John Moubray, Nowlan & Heap
PF Curve
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
5 Things You Can Do NOW to Calm Down Reactivity5 Things You Can Do NOW to Calm Down Reactivity
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Variation is Your Enemy - Causes• No Repeatable/Effective Procedures• Lack of Discipline in maintenance executionLack of Discipline in maintenance execution• The wrong maintenance approach to reliability• Production not operating the equipment toProduction not operating the equipment to
standard• PM Compliance is Too WidePM Compliance is Too Wide• Doing Too Much PM
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Number 1 – Awareness of a Problem (baby steps)
• Track Self/Human Induced Failures• Set up a chart listing these failures and causes /Set up a chart listing these failures and causes /
No names or blaming• Establish an atmosphere of calmness but p
focused• Use Tool Box Training Sessionsg• Apply the “D” Word (Discipline)
“YOU CANNOT CHANGE AN ENVIRONMENT OVERNIGHT”
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Tool Box Talk – Single Point Learning
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 [email protected]
70 to 80% of Failures are Self / Human Induced
• Lubricating bearing improperly• Adding oil to a hydraulic reservoir with a bucket
and f nneland funnel• Over-tensioning V-Belts• Welding on Equipment• Use of Half Links on Chain Drives• Not having a procedure for rebuild of gearbox• Not using a torque wrenchNot using a torque wrench• PM Execution Variance is High
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Number 1 - Identify Human Induced Failures• Identify and Post all Human Induced Failures• No judgment, solutions identified with yourNo judgment, solutions identified with your
crew at end of each week, 30 minute meeting
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Variation Continues - A Deadly Killer
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Number 2 – Reduce Variation in PM Compliance“C iti l A t O l ”“Critical Assets Only”
10% Rule of PM
2 28 282 2 28
10% Rule of PM
30 Day PM = Due in 3 daysy y
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Number 3 – Break out crew • 20% of crew to emergencies• 20% to PMs• 20% to results from PM• 20% to Lubrication• 20% to Priority 2 – 3 work (backup for emergency
crew)
EM 2 PM 2EM -2 PM -2
PMR -2Pri. 2 -2
Lube -2
Pri. 2 2
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Continuous Improvement – Failure Elimination
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
a
Number 4 – Failure Identification/Elimination
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Failure Elimination• Measure Mean Time Between Failure (MTBF)
(MTBF Users Guide)
• Post in the shopp• Talk to your maintenance techs• Ask for suggestions
• Measure EM vs PM Labor Hours
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Number 5 - Perform a PM Evaluation
PM Task ActionRecommendation # of Tasks % of Tasks Man-Hours
RepresentedNon-Value Added (Delete) 1,640 8.2% 6,661
Reassign to Operator Care 1,380 6.9% 5,605Care , ,
Reassign to LubeRoute 2,856 14.3% 11,600
Replace with PdM 6,437 32.2% 28,222
Re-Engineer 5,200 26.0% 26,221
No ModificationsRequired 2,487 10.4% 8,987
Totals 20,000 100.0% 87,297
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Example PM Task – No value (Delete)1. Check pump2. Check motor2. Check motor3. Check conduit
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Labor Hours to Use for Proactive Work
PM Task ActionRecommendation # of Tasks % of Tasks Man-Hours
RepresentedNon-Value Added (Delete) 1,640 8.2% 6,661
Reassign to Operator Care 1,380 6.9% 5,605Care , ,
Reassign to LubeRoute 2,856 14.3% 11,6006 more Maintenance TechsReplace with PdM 6,437 32.2% 28,222
Re-Engineer 5,200 26.0% 26,221ONo ModificationsRequired 2,487 10.4% 8,987
Totals 20,000 100.0% 87,297
Iii
12,266
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Questions“It is all about the Failure Modes”
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Let’s Review• Number 1 - Identify Human Induced Failures• Number 2 - Reduce Variation in PM ComplianceNumber 2 Reduce Variation in PM Compliance• Number 3 - Break out crew • Number 4 - Failure EliminationNumber 4 Failure Elimination• Number 5 – Perform a PM Evaluation
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied
Education - Options to Increase Effectiveness
1. Maintenance Tips – send me an email2. Up Coming Workshops in Charleston, SC Introduction to Condition Monitoring Planning and Scheduling Reliability Engineering Fundamentals Developing Effective Work Procedures Routine Equipment Care Routine Equipment Care RCM Blitz Root Cause AnalysisRoot Cause Analysis Leading Sustainable Change
3. Private Workshops are available
Copyright 2011 Copyright 2011 GPGPAlliedAllied