Download - 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
1/68
Bhagavad-gtBy His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktiveda
Founder-crya of the International Society fo
Chapter Sevefrom
J. Swamis edited cof the 1972 edition
This is a chapter from the copy of the 1972 edion which Jaydvaita Swami marked the revisio
The translations were revised
This copy of the book was used only fo
This document is made available so tha
can see what revisions were made and why. It i
The yellow annotations were made in
by Jaydvaita Swami and Matsya Avatra D
under Gopparnadhana Dsa. (Matsya Avatra was
This file is best viewed with Adobes free Acrobat Read
Other PDF readers may not properly show the atta
To view an image or the text of an annotatio
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
2/68
Notes for Chapter Sevenby Jaydvaita Swami
Thischapterrepresentsaturningpointfor rlaPrabhupdaswr
gt AsItIsbecauseinthischapter,forthefirsttime, rlaPrabhimselftospeakingitintoadictatingmachineforotherstotrans
Thestartofthedictatingmachine
InaninterviewinAprilof2003,GargamuniPrabhutoldmehow
dictatingmachine.Onedayin1966Gargamuniasked rlaPrabh
todoforyou?Whatisourjob?Yourefeedingus.Youregivingu
Whatdowedoforyou?And rlaPrabhupdasimplysaid,The
spiritualmasterinhiswork.
Gargamunitoldme,Iknewhisworkwastranslating,butIdidnt
dayonthewaytoabookstore,Orientalia,ontheothersideofto
officemachinestorecaughthiseye,somethingthatlookedlikea
Gargamuniwentinandaskedthemanager,Whatisthat?
Themansaid,Itsadictaphone.
Gargamuniasked,Whousesit?
Themansaid,Doctors,lawyers...
Howaboutpeoplewhowritebooks?
Oh,yes.
Gargamuniatoncethoughtthemachinecouldbeuseful.Swm
Prabhupdausedtotypewithonlyhisindexfingers.SoGargamu
increasethetranslation!
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
3/68
Prabhup
atitand
Butthed
thetapes
Neil.And
organizat
aproble
dictapho
school.
SoNeilg
standard
books.
daSwm
tonceknew
voteesinth
seemedsom
hesayshes
ionandwrite
here:Wen
eandwene
tstarted,an
toolbywhic
j,IthinkIh
howtousei
estorefront
ehowbeyon
fromAntioch
aboutitsac
edsomeone
edsomeone
dotherdevo
rlaPrabhu
vesomethin
.
emplewere
dthem.But
Collegeand
ivitiesandd
whosatypi
totranscribe
teeslearned
pdawrote
gthatwillh
tquitesocl
Allofasudd
partofhissu
thingsfort
st.Hesaid,
.Hesaid,I
fromhim,an
herestofBh
lpy
ever
ens
mm
em
Oh,
now
dth
aga
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
4/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
5/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
6/68
whichwouldhavebeenpage3(or215)isabsent.It
Thenextpage(againwerelookingatacarboncopy)bearlaPrabhupdahasfirstmarkedit215andthencross
Thiswouldsupportthenotionthatpage215wasmissing
sentence,withthelastlineofthepurporttotext11,tran
livlihoodthatisnotkama.Sincethisdoesnotmatchany
book,andsinceafullmanuscriptpageoughttohaveyiel
book,Isuspectthattheoriginalpurportwaslostand rla
Pages217and218followrightalong.Page218endsabrupurporttotext14.Inthepublishedbookthepurportfor
sentencesfromthispageandthenpicksupfromthenex
Page219,whichgivesafullpurportfortext14,appearstPrabhupdahimself,exceptthatitsheadersaysTheBha
Geetopanisad.Whysuchapageamidstthepagesoftra
thispageandthenewlyfoundpage212partofaset?Id
thispageformstherestofthepurportfortext14giveni
thepage, rlaPrabhupdagivesthetransliterationforte
Ref.BacktoGodheadTheLowestoftheMankind.This
thearticleTheLowestoftheMankindfromBacktoGo
IndiaonApril5,1956.Pages220through226arearetyp
abbreviated,somespellingsrevised,andsomeothermin
Onpage227 rlaPrabhupdaprovides,handwritten,thetext16.
Page228(whichgivesthetranslationfortext16andbegtranscribeddictation,whichcontinuesuntiltheendofth
Thepageafter233isnumbered224insteadof234.Thenumberingcontinuesaccordinglyuntilpage239,whiche
portionofthemanuscriptisatopcopy,notacarbon.P
bottomhalfofthepage,whichcompletesthepurportto
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
7/68
Thismanuscript,likealltheotherGtmanuscriptsintheArchive
thesecondedition.
Chapterfive,asmynotesforthatchapterdiscuss,musthavebee
1966andmorelikelyinOctoberNovember.Andatranscriptionf
date12/27/66,tellingus rlaPrabhupdamusthavefinishedcha
havethelowerandupperlimitsforwhen rlaPrabhupdamust
assumehewrotemostorallofitinDecemberof1966.
rlaPrabhupdasrevisionsandannotationsin
Frompage214onwards,thepagenumberspennedinatthetop
Prabhupdashand.Atthetopofpage238hehaswritten7thch
correctionsorinsertions(sometimesextensive)onpages227thr
numberedpages228,234,and237.Butonotherpages,despite
in rlaPrabhupdashandappears,otherthanthepagenumber
Inthreeplaces rlaPrabhupdahasputanotedirectingthatone
theseslipsareincludedinthemanuscript.Thecontextmakescle
wouldhavegiventhetextfortheanybhilit nyamverseof
Editorsrevisionsinthemanuscript
Pages204through219bearhardlyanyeditorialmarks.Thenext
that,practicallyeverypageshowsfairlyextensiveediting,apartf
theeditingmightbeHayagrvaPrabhus,butmostofitlookstom
Goswm.Theeditingisnotthorough,butsomeofitseemstohainthepublishedbook.ThereisnosignofeditingforSanskrit.
Featuresofthetranscribeddictations
Oncetheportionofthemanuscriptbeginsthathasbeentranscri
featurescommoninsimilarmanuscriptsforlaterchapters.Forex
mishearings(AccordingtoourVedic[ratherthanAyurv profuseabbreviations(Ved.lit.,Sup.Lord,mat.desiKrishna,andK.C.)
abundanttypographicalerrors guessingaboutwhereonesentenceendsandanewone blanks left for words the transcriber couldnt make out i
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
8/68
Revisionsandannotationsseeninthisfile
TheredrevisionsseeninmycopyoftheGt wereallputthereb
thetechnicalchangesmadetothetransliterationsandwordmea
wastransferringrevisionsmadeseparatelybytheBBTsSanskrit
ChangestothewordmeaningsmadepurelyforthesakeofEnglis
Atvariousplacesinthebook,thecomposersthatis,thedev
notesshowingwheretheybeganorleftofftheirwork.Asddst
AmericanAasakh,nottheAasakhfromBritain),mddstan
DuhkhaforDukhahantrDevDs.
MatsyaAvatraDsa,astudentofGopparadhanaPrabhus,co
thewordforwordmeanings.MatsyaAvatraisnowinchargeof
theBBTsSanskritschool,startedbyGopparadhanaPrabhu,a
on rlaJvaGosvmsgrammar.Hewasnotinvolvedineditinge
Viewingthisfileandgivingfeedback
Thisfileincludesattachedimagesfromtheoriginalmanuscript.T
thefileusingAdobeAcrobatReader.OtherPDFreadersmaynot
attachments.Toopenthetextofanannotation,clickonittwice.
Thoughtfulquestionsandcommentsarewelcome.Youcanwrite
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
9/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
10/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
11/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
12/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
13/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
14/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
15/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
16/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
17/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
18/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
19/68
BG 07: Macmillan hard with corrs. for
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
20/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
21/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
22/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
23/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
24/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
25/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
26/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
27/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
28/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
29/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
30/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
31/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
32/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
33/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
34/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
35/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
36/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
37/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
38/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
39/68
BG 07: Macmillan hard with corrs. for 1
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
40/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
41/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
42/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
43/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
44/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
45/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
46/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
47/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
48/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
49/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
50/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
51/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
52/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
53/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
54/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
55/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
56/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
57/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
58/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
59/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
60/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
61/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
62/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
63/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
64/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
65/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
66/68
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
67/68
From the Second Edition
-
7/27/2019 72 Gita Showing Revisions 07 Chapter 7
68/68