![Page 1: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Artificial Reef Performance in Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, LouisianaLake Pontchartrain, Louisiana
Thesis DefenseThesis Defense
Kelly A. Whitmore Kelly A. Whitmore Department of Biological SciencesDepartment of Biological Sciences
University of New OrleansUniversity of New Orleans
![Page 2: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Artificial Reefs• What is an artificial reef?
• Object of natural or human origin, deployed on seafloor to influence aquatic species for biological or economic gain
– Enhance fisheries– Enhance tourism– Protect habitats– Restore coral reefs– Stabilize shorelines
• Attraction vs. production• Attraction known• Production debatable
![Page 3: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Lake Pontchartrain
» 1,632 km2 estuary» Mean salinity 4 ppt, oligohaline» Average depth 3.7 m» Sediment bottom, no natural reefs
Artificial reefs developed to:• Enhance recreational fisheries and fishing• Promote awareness of improved water
quality and environmental conditions• Supplement hard substrate lost by shell
dredging
![Page 4: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Artificial Reef Artificial Reef DevelopmentDevelopment
Louisiana Artificial Reef Program 1986• Convert offshore oil/gas platforms to artificial reefs• Oyster reef restoration, inshore
Lake Pontchartrain Artificial Reef Working Group Organized in June 2000
• NGOs, state and federal fisheries agencies, parishes, sportsmen’s organizations, commercial fishing associations
• 2001: 1st reef by Lakefront airport, limestone rubble• 2003/2004: reef ball reefs – 3 south shore/ 1 north shore
![Page 5: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Material: Reef Balls
• Concrete, perforated domes • Durable, stable • Non-toxic, pH adjusted• Faster invertebrate colonization• Heavy base• Two sizes:
– Bay: 0.9 m diameter, 340 kg – Pallet: 1.2 m diameter, 1000 kg
![Page 6: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
![Page 7: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
.
New Orleans
IHNC
LAKE PONTCHARTRAIN
Bonnet CarreSpillway
Mississippi R.
Cau
sew
ay B
ridg
e
N1
H1, H3, H4
Coordinates of Artificial Reef Sites
H1 – N 30° 05.028’ W 090° 12.096’H3 – N 30° 05.034’ W 090° 12.582’H4 – N 30° 05.289’ W 090° 12.336’N1 – N 30° 16.296’ W 090° 03.753’
0 10 20Scale (km)
South shore reefs (H1, H3, H4) North shore reef (N1) ~200 balls each ~80 balls
![Page 8: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Lake Pontchartrain Artificial Reef Evaluation
Assess performance and efficacy of artificial reefs in low-salinity estuary
Management concerns:• Do reef balls move with strong storms?• Not a “natural habitat”, what fish and
invertebrate assemblages are present?• Will anglers/divers use the reefs?• Is the cost worth the benefit?
![Page 9: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Evaluation Components
Structural Integrity
Water Quality
Benthic Macroinvertebrate Colonization
Fish Assemblage
Recreational Activity
![Page 10: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Reef Structural Integrity
• Purpose– Storms could cause movement or sinking of balls, or
scouring around balls – Compromise colonization and persistence of reef
• Methods– Monitored reef ball locations before and after
2004 hurricane season• Identified survey area and reef balls• Measured distances to balls
and markers • Measured depth of base in substrate
![Page 11: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Reef Structural Integrity
• Results:– Storms of 2004
• Hurricane Ivan, 16 September • Tropical Storm Matthew, 10 October
– 37 hours of underwater survey effort
– No sinking, sliding, or scouring around balls detected– Reef balls are stable material for Lake Pontchartrain
![Page 12: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Water Quality• Purpose:
– Abiotic conditions influence fish and invertebrate assemblages
– Vertical relief of reefs could offer protection from bottom hypoxia
• Methods: – Water quality sampled at all reef visits– Measured dissolved oxygen, temperature, and salinity
• Results:– Salinity ranged: 2.3 – 5.0 ppt– Temp ranged: 22- 32°C– DO ranged: 5.5 – 8.6 mg/L– Hypoxia not detected at reefs
![Page 13: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Benthic Macroinvertebrates
• Purpose:– Compare faunal composition
• Over time• South shore reef to north shore reef• South shore reef to other artificial substrates
• Methods:– Sampled
• Reefs• Oil platform pilings• Causeway pilings
– 10 x 10 cm replicate scrape samples– Stained, preserved, and sorted– Compared presence/absence
![Page 14: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Benthic Macroinvertebrates
10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef Causeway Oil Platform N1 reefPorifera Spongilla albaSpongilla alba X - - - X
S. alba gemmules X X X X X XCnidaria Garveia franciscana X X - X X X
Cordylophora caspiaCordylophora caspia X - - - - -Bryozoa Victorella pavida X - X X X X
Conopeum sp. X X - X X X
Nematoda nematode worms X X X X X XAnnelida Polydora websteri X X X X X X
Neanthes succineaNeanthes succinea - - X - - XClass OligochaetaClass Oligochaeta - - X - - X
Mollusca Congeria leucophaetaCongeria leucophaeta X X X - - XIschadium recurvum - - - - - X
Arthropoda Balanus improvisus - X - X X -B. subalbidus X X - X X -Corophium lacustre - X X X X -Uromunna reynoldsiUromunna reynoldsi X X - - - XMelita sp. - X - X X -Rhithropanopeus harrissii - X - X X X
Balanus sp.
-
![Page 15: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Bray-Curtis Similarity IndexBenthic macroinvertebrates
% s
imila
rity
![Page 16: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
August 2005
May 2005
![Page 17: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Fish Assemblage
• Purpose:– Compare species composition and abundance of fishes
• South shore reef • Nearby shell pad (no reef balls)• Mud-bottomed site
• Methods:– Visual surveys by SCUBA divers
• Roving Diver Technique – Paired divers, timed swim over survey areas– 2 - 10 minute surveys per pair per site per day
» 2 m visibility, measured vertically and horizontal– Recorded all fish and mobile macroinvertebrates
![Page 18: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Visual Surveys
• Results:– 30 hrs of survey effort over 10 days
in summer 2005
Fishes:• Number of species greater over
reef than shell and mud• Total abundance over reef
higher than shell pad and mud
Mobile Macroinvertebrates:• Abundance highest over reef
Archosargus probatocephalus
Ictalurus furcatus
![Page 19: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Fishes Species Common Reef Shell MudAnguillidae Anguilla rostrata american eel 2 0 0Atherinidae Menidia beryllinaMenidia beryllina tidewater silversidetidewater silverside 0 70 0Batrachoididae Opsanus beta oyster toad fish 1 0 0Blennidae Hypsoblennius iothonasHypsoblennius iothonas freckled blennyfreckled blenny 15 9 0Bothidae Paralicthys lethostigma Southern flounder 4 2 0Carangidae Carnax hippos jack Crevalle 4 0 0Dasyatidae Dasyatis sabina Atlantic stingray 1 0 0Gobisocidae Gobiesox strumosus skilletfish 2 8 0Gobiidae Gobiosoma boscGobiosoma bosc naked gobynaked goby 466 122 8Ictaluridae Ictalurus furcatus blue catfish 3 0 0Mugilidae Mugil cephalus striped mullet 6 0 0Ophichthidae Myrophis punctatus speckled worm eel 0 1 0Sciaenidae Micropogonias undulatus Atlantic croaker 1 0 0Sciaenidae Aplodinotus grunniens freshwater drum 1 0 0Soleidae Trinectes maculatus hogchoker 0 1 0Sparidae Archosargus probatocephalusArchosargus probatocephalus sheepsheadsheepshead 37 2 0Sparidae Lagodon rhomboides pinfish 7 0 0
Invertebrates Species Common Reef Shell MudPenaeidae Farfantepenaeus aztecus brown shrimp 2 0 0Portunidae Callinectes sapidusCallinectes sapidus blue crabblue crab 63 39 2Xanthidae Rhithropanopeus harrisii mud crab 0 2 1
![Page 20: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Fish AssemblagesVisual Surveys
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
# of
indi
vidu
als
Reef Shell Mud
Trinectes maculatusAplodinotus grunniensMyrophis punctatusMenidia beryllinaMicropogonias undulatusDasyatis sabinaOpsanus betaGobiesox strumosusAnguilla rostrataIctalurus furcatusCarnax hipposParalicthys lethostigmaMugil cephalusLagodon rhomboidesHypsoblennius iothonasArchosargus probatocephalusGobiosoma bosc
reef vs. shell: p=0.016reef vs. mud: p<0.001shell vs. mud: p=0.185
![Page 21: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
# of
indi
vidu
als
Reef Shell Mud
Rhithropanopeus harrisiiFarfantepenaeus aztecusCallinectes sapidus
Mobile MacroinvertebratesVisual Surveys
reef vs. shell: p=0.435reef vs. mud: p<0.001shell vs. mud: p=0.049
![Page 22: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Mobile MacroinvertebratesVisual Surveys
• Callinectes sapidus (blue crab)• Occupied cavities in and
under reef balls• Molted shells observed• Pairs in mating pose
– Reefs offer protection during vulnerable life stages
![Page 23: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Recreational Activity• Purpose:
– Determine if public is aware of and using reefs
– What species are being caught
• Methods:– Vessel observations at reefs– Interviews at local fishing rodeos– Online recreational fishing and diving
survey:• Lake Pontchartrain Basin Foundation
http://saveourlake.org Oct 2004 -present
• Louisiana Fishing and Huntinghttp://rodnreel.com June – Aug 2005
![Page 24: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Recreational Fishing & Diving Survey
• Results:– 21 respondents (2 in 2004 / 19 in 2005)
• 16 visited south shore; 3 north shore; 2 limestone– Target species
• Speckled trout, redfish, flounder– Catch
• 8/21 speckled trout (mean 21/ range 10-35)• Flounder, white trout, sheepshead, catfish, croaker
– Disposition• 16/21 reefs enhanced fishing• 5 reef enhanced diving (4/5 reported both)• 12 fished more / 4 dived more
![Page 25: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Conclusions
• Reef balls are stable reef material in the lake • Artificial reefs support more fish and
macroinvertebrates than surrounding habitat• Recreational users are aware of reefs, feel they
have enhanced fishing/diving opportunities
![Page 26: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Future Work
• Predation experiments/trophic level interactions• Expand hypoxia monitoring in Lake
Pontchartrain• Identify innovative techniques for sampling
reefs/ structural habitat• Cost worth the benefit?
![Page 27: Artificial Reef Performance in Lake Pontchartrain, Louisiana · Benthic Macroinvertebrates 10/28/04 5/04/05 8/05/05 5/17/05 5/17/05 8/21/05 Phylum Species H3 reef H3 reef H3 reef](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071010/5fc7a21832634908943f3e80/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Acknowledgements•• Lake Pontchartrain Basin FoundationLake Pontchartrain Basin Foundation•• J. Bennett Johnston Science FoundationJ. Bennett Johnston Science Foundation
•• Dr. James GradyDr. James Grady•• Dr. Michael PoirrierDr. Michael Poirrier•• Dr. John LopezDr. John Lopez
•• Field and lab assistance: Field and lab assistance: Beth Spalding, Ashley Walker, Chip Crews, Zoe Rodriguez del Rey,Beth Spalding, Ashley Walker, Chip Crews, Zoe Rodriguez del Rey,Willie Whitmore, Ryan Poirrier, Carol Willie Whitmore, Ryan Poirrier, Carol FranzeFranze, Kenny Blanke, Chad , Kenny Blanke, Chad Ellinwood, Les Ellinwood, Les DautriveDautrive, and Mark Schexnayder, and Mark Schexnayder
•• Collaboration:Collaboration:Audubon Aquarium of the AmericasAudubon Aquarium of the AmericasHammerhead Dive Club of Mandeville Hammerhead Dive Club of Mandeville