-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
1/64
NEB Fe OFFacOV040201001 0201
32011
.
52
8 2011
.
. 6
6.1
: )
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.6.7,
age 27 (PDF age 35) [A1X5W0]
) CSA Z66207 O ad ga ee e, Cae 4.14.3.2
: Refeece () dcae e fae e be deged accdace
CSA Z66207 de eee e Hg Va Pee (HVP)
d, f eeded. Hee, efeece de de a dea
afe cec f e ea fd eeae (c a ea ea), a
eed efeece (), aaga (d).
Adda fa ea deec a eed.
: Peae de:
a) dea a ea be deeced a ad
a eae be ae afe cec e eeaed
dc;
b) a dec f e bd e deg c afe
e eee f CSA Z66207, Cae 4.14.3.2 (a), decbg ee a e ed bd e a eg
caac ad beg caed b acc eed
dg bd;
c) dea e eee f CSA Z66207, Cae
4.14.3.2 (d) be e; ad,
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
2/64
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
3/64
3
: Refeece () dcae a e ed ee be ed
ad ced 24 e da, 365 da e ea, f a Cea
C Fac (CCF) g a aefea SCADA e. Bc
ae caed a e a ae e a f e
ee e ee f a eegec.
Refeece () de eee f eee ec
e. Accdg, eee ec be e ee
Ma Oeag Pee (MOP) eceedg e a 10%
b 35 Pa (cee geae).
Adda fa e SCADA e ad eee
ec f e ed ee ad face eed.
: a) Peae de:
a.1) dea e SCADA e. Te ee dcde, b be ed , a dec f eab,
afe ad ec aaee be ed ad
ea, ca f e ee ea (RTU)
ad cca, ad g e, aa
aca ad acedgee;
a.2) dea e a g ad c
e. Te ee d cde, b ed , a
dec f e a g ad c e
c a PLC (Pgaabe Lgc Ce), ESD
(Eegec Sd), a ee cdgaa e, ea, cca
e SCADA, a ad d ea,
a ae eg ad cg ea;
a.3) a dec f e eddac aeg f e
eee ec e e e f e e
e fa (e.g. cca e SCADA);
a.4) a ge aa f ea ce f eee
(e.g. eeced ae ce) ad gae eae
(e.g. b fage);
a.5) dea a eee ec aeg f a
ea cca age. Te ee d
a cde e daa f eac ae ca be
aed e SCADA e, f e cca
eed; ad,
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
4/64
4
a.6) fa a ee e deeg ae e
aaca f e ee eeed:
) f e, dcae e dc be aded
ad a be cde, cdeg e dc
HVP dc. Te ee d a dcaeee ee a cede ace f e afe
cec f e dc; f e cede
ace, ade e be aaabe f e Bad
ee; ad,
) f , dcae e ee eea
be aded;
b) Peae dcae:
b.1) ee e eee ec e beaac ad be eag c, a
eace aa ee; ad,
b.2) ee e eab f e eee ec
e ad acaed ce be aeed. If ,
eae de fee e eab f e
e ce be aeed.
: a) a.1) Te deaed egeeg ae f e ec a
ceced ad ce ceded cece
ea 2012. Te deaed deg f e SCADA e (e.g.ea, cca, RTU ca ad
eab , afe ad ec aaee) a e a
deaed eaa deg (e.g. cca, aa
aca ad acedgee) cece
dg e deaed egeeg ae. I acaed
a e SCADA g e f e gdee
CSA Z66207, Aed E, Tabe E.1.
a.2) Te fa eeed ce aaabe. Te
deaed egeeg ae f e ec ce
ceded cece ea 2012 ad afe
ae a bee ceed e eeed fa
be aaabe.
a.3) Te a eee ec e be
aaed g ee g ad
d ce. Te eee e be deged
ae f f eddac: ee ad
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
5/64
5
ce be aed a e dcage f eac
(.e. ge f ee); ad eac
a be deged ad eed ecaca
(.e. eeged ced) aac ee
afe ae a eee e fae e e
ee f a eee a a eeeeded b e aaed e (e.g. e ee f
e SCADA cca fae).
a.4) Te fa eeed aaabe. Sge be
eaed e deaed dg e deaed
egeeg ae f e ec c ce
ceded cece ea 2012. Vaage de
ce ed cdc a f ge aa. A ge
aa a ceed f eae ee.
Sce eae a e ceb caacec
eae cebe fd, eae ee ae e
e eee de ge.
a.5) Peae ee e ee : (a.1), (a.2) ad (a.3).
a.6) () Ye, e ee f a eee a e
aac ee afe ae e
aaca. Te aac ee afe ae
eee e fae e ad
aee. Peae a ee e ee NEB
IR 6.1(b).
a.6) () /a.
b) b.1) Ye. Peae ee e ee (a.3) ad (a.6).
b.2) Ye. Te feec f ec f e eee
ec e be cdced accdace
CSA Z66207, cae 10.7.5.
6.3
()
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Oea, Sec 7.2.3, age
38 (PDF Page 46) [A1X5W0]
) CSA Z66207 O ad ga ee e, Cae 4.20.1
) CSA Z66207 O ad ga ee e, Ae
Receded acce f d dcab ee e
ea deec
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
6/64
6
) Oe Pee Rega 1999 (OPR99), Sec 37 ad 56
) API RP 11302007 Caa Pee g f
d, Sec 4
: Refeece () dcae Vaage dee ad a a LDS f eee a e C Se Fac (CSF) ea e
deec f dac aae ee ea.
Refeece () ee e d dcab ee e ae
deged de aae ea deec caab
Refeece () de eceded acce f ea deec.
Refeece () ee cae dee ad ee a ee
ea deec e cdg e feec f ecd ee ad
e ag eee.
Refeece () de def eabaed ad eea
baed ea deec ed.
Fe dea e ea deec e f e ed ee
ad face ae eed.
: Peae de:
a)
e LDS Maa f e ed ee a d cde,
b be ed a dec f e:
a.1) e aagee' ce a effece ad
effce ea deec e;
a.2) ca c defe bece ad
age cdeg e f ae, e f dc ad
ceece aea;
a.3) e, ebe, accabe, ad ae
acaed e ee ea' aff (e.g.
ea aage, e egee, ce, fed
ea ad aeace ee) cdg a
ca dece ce a ad
eb ae ac e a ea eced;
a.4) e f ea, aae f eec, aca,
ad e feae f e ea deec e
cdg cca ea eee;
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
7/64
7
a.5) edg ad ea eee;
a.6) accac, eab ad e f e ed ea
deec e (e f e HVP ee). Ne
a eab eaed e ba f ed be
f fae aa ad e deecabeea e;
a.7) f ea aa ad dagc eage cdg aa
def, acceabe eace, cca daa be
daed SCADA, dagc cede f
cfg, cag ad ag a ea, ad cac
f eeda ac. A efeece a deaed
Aa Maagee Pcede d be cded a;
a.8)
fa ded b e ea deec e ef
f ea aff e e age;
a.9) adeae cede f eg e afe f bc ad
eee cae a ea cc; Vaage a dcae
ee e cede ae acc e fac a
eae a eae a a ad a g
ae ad faabe;
a.10) eeced a age e a ea deeced ad
aed; ad,
a.11)
ea deec e c ee cecdg cf defca eaed ea
deec cede ad/ eface, ea ad
ad acaed c, cece ac a, ad
f;
b)
e dae e e Lea Deec Se Maa be
aaabe f e Bad' ee;
c) a dec f ca eee f ea deec
e ecd eeg ad acg, cdg , ag,
aeace, eg, ad eface;
d) e dea deec caab f a e a ea. F
eae, ea ac dcae a fee ccg
ea ae ee e a (e a 0.1% f e deg f),
e age f e e. If e ed ea deec
e ca deec c a a ea, a e ed()
de Vaage e?
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
8/64
8
e) dea Vaage ee a e ea deec
e ef a eeced e f eg ed ad
feec a e ee e aeace f e
acaed ea; ad,
f)
a dca f ee eeabaed ea deeced be ed f ad cg. If , eae de
e aae ad a dec f e ed eabaed
ea deec ed a ad cg cdg a
aee e f e, eab ad accac.
: a) Deaed egeeg eed be baa cee
ceg e LDS Maa. Vaage dee e LDS
Maa cce ad fg ce f e
deaed egeeg ae f e ec. Vaage' e
aagee ced a effece LDS a ed
CSA Z66207. Adda, e LDS Maa adde adde dea ea e eee ad gdee f
CSA Z66207 Aed E cdg, b ed :
bece, age ad eace ag acc e
e f dc ed ad ceece aea;
e e, ebe ad ae f ee e
ee f eced ea;
e e ad aae f e LDS deg ad aca;
edg ad e eee;
accac, eab ad e f e eaee
dece ed;
ea aa ad dagc eagg a e a eaed
cede;
a fa be ded b e LDS a
eag e LDS ad edg a ea ea;
e eaed a a f eae eeaed e a
ea deeced; ad
e ce be fed eec c
ee, cf, ad ad cec
c.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
9/64
9
Adda, Vaage e a a cede f eg e
afe f e bc ad eee e ee f a ea be
deaed eegec ee aa c ae
acc e de f eae. Peae a ee ee NEB
IR 5.12.
b) Te LDS Maa be aaabe f NEB ee a ea ee
e Vaage ee beg aced ece.
c) Te ca eee f LDS ecd eeg, ag,
aeace, eg ad eface be ed e
LDS Maa ad f e gdee CSA Z66207,
Aed E.
d) Te LDS e ae a e e f ea a
caabe f deec. T a (.e. e ad
accac) be eaed ce e LDS deged ad
ceed. T adde e ad accac, e
ea LDS cde a cba f e ea deec
ed cdg: a ad aea e f ea dca
(e.g. egea/ dca); ga deec; ad fge
e ga.
e) Te eaee e ed daa e LDS be
eed . Te LDS Maa e e eg
ed ad feec f eg e LDS ef.
f) N eea baed ea deec e be ed f ad
cg. Te LDS cae ea deec f e ee
ee e, cdg ad cg. Te accac,
eab ad e f e LDS be deeed e
deaed egeeg ae f e ec. Peae a ee
ee (a) abe. Te ad cg be deged
accdace CSA Z66207, ec 4.12.3.
6.4
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.5, age
25 (PDF Page 33) [A1X5W0]
) Fg Maa, Cae 4, Sec A Egeeg
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Aedce AC, Aed 4
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
10/64
10
Sceac Ee P Sa, (PDF Page 47) [A1X5W3]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.3.1 ,
age 20 (PDF Page 28) [A1X5W0]
: Refeece () ae a e eeg fa be ed fcd afe ad be ed b e ea deec e
g e ee.
Refeece () ee a aca de dea eeg
face c a a dec f e ga fd aa e, a
a ceac g bdg ad a a g ad ae,
e aea ad e, ec.
Refeece () cde e eeg fac f Ee P Sa,
ee de de a dea a g ce,
a eeed e efeece ().
Refeece () decbe e eae caacec ad c.
Te eae de ae f 349g/ 383g/
, b a
eeeae eae ecfca ded.
Fe fa eeg face eed.
: Peae de e fg:
a) ce ad Iea Daga (P&D) f eeg
face;
b) dea e aea ad e, de daee ad e
a ce;
c) a dec f e fd aa e e f aa
ed (ab e e), de caca, feec,
ca, ec;
d) dec f e ee g a cdg e g f
feec;
e)
dea a ee e f ee ae ed f ea
deec. If , eae de e deecabe ea
e ad eaed f ee accac; ad,
f) dea a e ea deec e be effeced f
f ee ae aed a e Aba a ( f
ee ed a e Aba a).
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
11/64
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
12/64
12
6.5
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Cc, Sec 6.12,
age 32 (PDF age 40) [A1X5W0]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.3.1,age 32 (PDF age 40) [A1X5W01
: Refeece () dcae e ee be daca eed
cc ce. Fee, e ae efeece dcae
ae be ed f ee ad ea eg.
I efeece (), Tabe 51 de a eae e ecfca,
dcag a e e cde 6% CO2ad
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
13/64
13
c) Te ee eg ga f b e ee ad a
g be aaabe f NEB ee a ea ee
Vaage cdcg a deg.
6.6
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, Ree IR N. 3.31, age 52 (PDF
age 52) [A1Z7T7]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.3.1,
age 20 (PDF age 28) [A1X5W0]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Aee f Eea
effec e aec ee, Sec 6.2.1, age 40
(PDF age 6) [153]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.6.2,
age 26 (PDF age 34) [A1X5W0]
: Refeece () dcae e eag cd be e
dee ae.
Refeece () dcae e dc de age f 349g/3
383g/3.
Refeece () dcae e aa eeae ca a beee 40
+40.
Refeece () dcae e a g " be aedabe gade ac de e ead acce ae ad
e g ce".
Te ee e Bad' IR 3.31 cde e eeea
daga; ee, de deae a e ad
a eag cd be adeae f e dc be
e dee ae. Te Bad e a e eeea
daga dcae a, f e a eag eeae (+27
) ad e eag ee (4500 Pag) e dc cd
be a ae.
Refeece () dcae e dc de cage. T de
cage cd ea cae cage a ee. T
deee e eag ee ad a aa
e ee, e eeea daga f e cae f e
e eae de d be baed.
Fee, de abe eeae +40, e eae
eeae abe gd g ceae, c a cae
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
14/64
14
a ee ceae. Te ae ee ceae cd be eeced
e e bed ee f e ged ed e
e ea.
Adda fa eaed deg cea f e ed
ee eed.
: Peae de:
a) e aae a Vaage a ee e dc
e dee ae f e eaa cd ded e
efeece (). Te ee d cde, b be ed
:
a.1) a egeeg aee ed b a ae
daga cea dcag e dee ae f e
c ecfed Tabe 51 (efeece ())cdg e eag cd ad de a c
e caca a efed; ad,
a.2) dea f e aa be aded f
e a eag eeae (+27 ) a e
eag ee (4500 Pag);
b) dea ee e abe gd g ad g
ce be aed e e effec f e
abe eeae (a g a +40 ) effec, aca
e eag a eag ee (4500 Pag). If gg be aed, eae de e gae
eae adde e effec f e abe eeae;
ad,
c) cfa a e ee ceae de ge abe
eeae (+40 ) a ae cdea f e ee
ad a deg.
: a) Vaage eae e ee a ae a ee e
fd ea a ge d dee ae ae a a e.
T be de b aag ffce bac ee a e
e f e ee e. T ee a a a
e e ge f eea ag e ee
aa a e ee f a ea 200 KPa abe e bbbe
f e fd.
Geea, e ee eae g a defed age f
eeae ad ee. Te eeae ad ee
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
15/64
15
be ge a e ece f e ee. B
eeae ad ee dece a e fd e ag
e e e eae eace a eb eeae
e dg gd (0 5 degee Ce). Oce
eb eeae eaced e eae aa
eeae g e eg f e ee. Teeag eee f e ee ca be da e ae
eee a ee NEB IR 3.31. A ca be ee
a ae eee, e fd ea e ge d
dee ae eg de a ccace. T ae
aa a ceed g a d adad ea f
ae (.e. BWRS). Te a ae acc e
aab de g e eag age f ee.
We e ee ea e a eag
eeae f 27 degee Ce be eaced. Oce
eeae eb eaced e eae dc a
a a eeae f 0 5 degee Ce. If e ee
d f a eg f e, abe gd g a abb
eg ea f e dg aee cage e
eae f d ga. Te a f eae ga ae
be e a caed e a eae d ae
e ee e. Ude ee ccace a eae
ga ae a e a be eed g e
fae e eag e a e a.
I e ee a ee a eae ga ae a bc
ae, a ga ae eae cdee a d e ed e d ae eae e ee a f e
eabed e ee.
b) Vaage de ce a ag a g
g ce e e effec f abe
eeae. Mgae eae a Vaage ce
ed e cde aac ee afe ae
e a g a eee e fae e
accdace e eag cede ed (a) abe.
c) Cfed. Te ee ceae de ge abeeeae be ae acc dg e deaed
egeeg ae f e ec.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
16/64
16
6.7
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, Ree NEB IR N. 3.31, age 52
(PDF age 52) [A1Z7T7]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Egeeg, Sec 5.3.2,
age 21 (PDF age 29) [A1X5W0]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, Ree NEB IR N. 3.35, age 57
(PDF age 57) [A1Z7T7]
) Vaage Pee Pec, Adda We Edece, Pec
Udae 14 Je 2011, age 1 f 1 [A1Z7L9]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, Ree NEB IR N. 3.35 Aace 3.35 (a2), age 1 f 1[A1Z7V3]
: Refeece () dcae e eag eeae f e
ee 10 .
Refeece () dcae e e f e ec be Caeg II
baed c ge caacec. Fee, e ae
efeece dcae e e eeae a be ecfed a 5
ce e e be aed degd. Te ae efeece
dcae e e be abe gd be ecfed a 45 . I
add, Tabe 53 f e ae efeece de e ecfcaf e ed ec, dcag e a ce f
e ee be 5.6 .
Refeece () ee 3.35 () dcae e g f e
deeg ae e fae ad e fae be deged e
eeae ee ecaca eg e e e
ced.
Refeece () dcae a e de daee (OD) be
caged f e ga ed 323.9 (12 c) 273
(10 c).
Refeece () dcae e a ce f NPS 10 (273 ) g
be 4.8 ad cagg 6.4 a e a .
Fe cafca egadg aea eed
: Peae de e:
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
17/64
17
a) aae f cg e e c ge a 5 C, e
e dc eeae 10 . Te aae
d be ed b a egeeg aee c
deae a e eag eeae (10 )
affec e ecaca ee f e e e
eeced c ge;
b)
cfa a a abe gd g ce (
e ae e c ge a 45 ;
c)
aea ecfca (gade, ce, daee) f e g
f e deeg ae e fae ad e fae ef,
cdg e ae f " eeae" dced
efeece (); ad,
d)
dea c a ce be ed f e ed
ee. Accdg, Vaage eed ee adeb Tabe 53 f e aca Aace 3.35 (a2).
: a) Te eb eeae f e eae e be gd
ee e fg aac gd eeae. Te
gd eeae a eaa beee 0 ad 5
degee Ce. Te e eag eeae
be 0 degee Ce. Te eec f 5 degee Ce f
deeg e c ge ee aae
ge e e eag ee. Peae a ee
ee NEB IR 6.6(a).
b) Cfed. A abe gd g ce ae e
c ge ee a 45 degee Ce.
c) Te ea deg daee f e fae e f e
aac ee afe ae e fae ce NPS 4
(114.3 ). Te aea ecfca f e ce:
114.3 OD 10S, BE ASTM A312 G. T304L, SMLS. Te
aea ae a deg eeae f 100
degee Ce. Te g ad aea ecfca be
cfed dg e deaed egeeg ae f e ec.
d) Be a daed Tabe 53 efecg cage e
daee ad acaed a ce:
Pe Se
()
See Gade
(MPa)
W.T. () Leg () Ca
Lca
273.1 359 4.8 528 Geea
Ca 1 Le
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
18/64
18
Pe
273.1 359 7.8 .05 Raa
Cg
273.1 359 6.0 50.5 Ca 2 ad
Rad
Cg
6.8
: ) Aace Vaage' ee NEB IR N. 3.33, Vaage
Pee R Aee [A1Z7V1]
) Vaage Pee Pec, Eea Age See,
age 6163 (PDF age 13) [166]
)
Jace Wfd AXYS Ld e "Te Effec f HVP Seaaee de ad ea ada aad
ee" (efeeced CAPP "Ca Pag Gde
ERCB Dece 071") (ad c aaced)
) Vaage Pee Pec, Eea Age See,
age 12 (PDF age 12) [164]
) Vaage Pee Pec, Aedce AC, Aed B2
Ped bc ae ca, age 119 (PDF age 42)
[A1X5W3]
: Refeece (), "Ceece Aa" Sec ae a, accdg
ERCB Dece 071, Aed 10, Eegec Pag Ze (EPZ)
f 10c ad 12c ee a be 900 ee ad 1100 ee
f eae. Fee, e ae efeece ee a "ce e
EPZ eee e dace f e ce e ed,
be ed b a fac f ba a bdeca dace".
Refeece (), Tabe 2, de e EPZ dace ed b
ba e aad dace f ea ad e. Accdg Tabe
2, aad dace f a NPS 10 HVP ee ea 100 ee ad
f e 1800 ee.
Refeece () a dcag a e ed ee
e aea aae e Hga 13. Te eaa dace
beee e ee ad Hga 13 age f 100 ee
ab 1800 ee a eea ca.
Refeece () de e ee f e ea ada
ceece f HVP ee cdg eae. Fge 21 dcae
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
19/64
19
a e edced dace a ceece f 2d
Degee B f
NPS 10 ee eae beee 200 ad 300 ee. Fge 14 f
d a dcae a e eaed dace e Le
Faab L/2 ca (eeaed fe g cb f
g ce ee dded b 2) beee 600 900 ee.
I add, Tabe 6 e a Eegec Pag Ze dacef NPS 10 (273.1 ) f 900 ee.
Refeece () dcae ee ag eab eea aed
aea ad ba cae c a Ada, Cadac, Begg,
ec.
Refeece () de ca f bc ae. Hee, e a
(efeece ()) dcae f ee aed aea c
a Cadac ad Ada, c ae cdeed f e ae
ca.
Vaage eed de fe cafca e
aee f e ed ee.
: Peae de e:
a) f a ga ad bc ad a ae a 900 ee
ad f e ee;
b) f aed aea, ba ad a cae a ae
caed a 900 ee ad f e ee;
c) f e bc ae ca acaed e ee
ege (.e. 900 ee) ceece aea
(e.g. aed aea, a ad ba cae ad
ga ad bc ad) ad e aae f e eeced
bc ae ca;
d) f a ea e ee eg addeed e
aee, cdg e aae f e cce ad e e
gae e; ad,
e)
gae ad eeae eae f edcg eceece f a fae (e.g. ea e) e aea ed
(a) ad (b) abe.
: a) Peae ee Aace 6.8(a).
b) Peae ee Aace 6.8(b).
c) Te cea CSA Z66207, ec 4.4, a ed deee
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
20/64
20
ae ca ad acg. Te aae f cag bc
ae dced Ve 1, ec 5.3.4 f e Aca.
Te ee e a e eeced a eaed
a ece f 900 ee da f aed aea.
d) Te aee a eed a cae cea f af ee e, e cae beg a ecaca de
ecaa. Mga f ecaca cde: adeae
gage ag e ee e, bc edca ga
g aaee f ee ad e e f e f ca
ga, aea e, ad eegec ee ga.
e) Mgae ad eeae eae f edcg e
ceece f a ee fae ae a e fc f
eegec ee cede. Vaage' Eegec
Peadee ad Ree Pga cae eae
e ceece f a ee fae. Peae ee e
ee NEB IR 5.12.
6.9
: Vaage Pee Pec, Ree NEB IR N. 3.35, age 57 (PDF
age 57) [A1Z7T7]
: Te abe efeece dcae a e ee be deeed
g e e f a abe fae a be caed a e
aae ca ag e ee e.
I cea c e abe fae ca be ceced e
a ae.
Adda fa eed egadg ee deea.
Ree: Peae de:
a) dea g d ae bg e abe fae
e ca a ee deeg a cae f e
eegec. Te ee d cde b be ed
e be f abe fae, e ca ad e a
e eed f bgg ad cecg e abe fae()
eegec e(). Te ee d a cde e
aae f cg e be ad cfa a e
eeced be f abe fae, ca ad e be
adeae afe ad effce deee e ee a
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
21/64
21
cae f e eegec;
b) fa a ee ee cede ace f
bgg e abe fae e eed ca, cecg
e ee ad eag afe; f e cede
ace, ade e be aaabe f e Bad ee;ad,
c) dea e deg cea f e abe fae ee e
e de f bed gae aee.
: a) Ce Vaage ed de ee abe fae
caed a Ee, Aba ad a ca ce e
Caada/U.S. bde. T add e eae fae
be caed a e Ee ad Aba a.
Tee a be abe fae caed N Daa
f e U.S. ea f e ee. Ag a caecea ee e ea cc a a ca fe f a f
e abe fae, e eaed e de a abe
fae a e aae ae a aae 4 .
T eae deeed a f:
Oea daced abe fae e 1
Oea cec abe fae ece 0.5
Oea ae ae e 1
Oea cec abe fae ad cece fag
1.5
Te Jace Wfd AXYS Ld. e "
" dcae a e e f abe fae f
deea effece f e e f 1 c e
ee da f e eeae eceed 22 . F e
e geae a 2 ce, e eeae da 5
e. S f e e ece f 2 ce e a f
eae e ecae aee befe a abe fae
a be deed (.e. aae 4 de). I c
ccace aeae ga, addeed g e
cce eea f eegec ee cede,
be eeed ce adda abe fae
be a e effece de e a f ee e
acaed cecg e fae ce e ae ca.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
22/64
22
b) Ce e cede f deg e abe fae a
bee fa deeed ad dceed. Te abe
fae dee cede be aaabe f NEB ee a
ea ee e Vaage ee beg aced
ece.
c) Te fa eeed ce aaabe. Te
deg cea f e abe fae be deeed dg
e deaed egeeg ae f e ec c ce
ceded cece ea 2012.
6.10
: Vaage Pee Pec, Ree NEB IR N. 3.40, age 67 (PDF
age 67) [A1Z7T7]
: I e efeece, ee () ae a a ee eg be
ceed afe e ea ea. Hee, e ee de
dcae c eg be ed f e e ec.
Fe fa e eg a be ed f e
ec f e ed ee eed.
: Peae de dea c e f e ec (c a
cae , cac deec , ec) be ed ec e
ed ee, ad e ea f cg e f .
: Afe e ea f ea, Vaage b defa ad
ea ea ec cf ee eg ad
eab a baee f fe ea ec. Te ea
be agec f eaage baed ad a ac
ce ac d ge de fd c a
eae.
/ /
6.11
: Vaage Ree NEB IR 3.6 (b) [A1Z7T7]
: I e efeece, Vaage ae a e eed e caa be
acaed f Ree/Cae Gba eeg ad Pe Fd IV a
g a e caa c f e ec d ceae gfca ad
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
23/64
23
ega aa ae gaed.
: a) Peae eabae a d ce a "gfca
ceae caa c."
b)
Peae ea Vaage aage f adda caa fe caa c f e ec ee ceae gfca.
: a) A eced caa c ceae f 20% d be a gfca
ceae caa c.
b) Ude e ceca facg e, ce cc a
ceced e face ae ced cee e
ec ad a a e d de a adda facg
eed. Ude e ceca facg e, f, adace
f cc, a gfca ceae caa c ee
eced, e e face a ce ceed facg e ec ee adda fdg c
a ae adda deb caac.
6.12
: ) Vaage Ree NEB IR 3.8 (d) [A1Z7T71
)
Vaage Pee Eae Taa Sece Ageee
(Caada) daed 31 Jaa 2011, beee Vaage Pee
Caada Ic. ad NOVA Ceca Ca (NCC) [A1Z7W9]
: I efeece (), Vaage ae a eee f ced
e d edce e cage NCC; ee, e
NOVA Ceca Eae Taa Sece Ageee daed 31
Jaa 2011 de de f a dc NCC f e
e ed e ee b a e eceed a ageed
a.
: Peae ae ee, add NCC, e dc be
ded e e a e, ee ced ced.
: A f aa Vaage ee ae egaed
cac beee Vaage ad e ca eeg a
aa aagee. Te de c cac be
baed a be f fac, c a, b ed , e,
e ad ced ag. Vaage ca ecae a e
ee a dc be ded c ace.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
24/64
24
6.13
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 1.11, age 8 (PDF age
16) [A1X5W0]
) NEB Rea f Dec RH22008 [A1J9R9]
)
4 Mac 2010 Re Pea Bae Cae A[A SOC 1 ]
) 21 Decebe 2010 Lee ad Aeded abe [A1W9T1 &
A1W9T3
) 7 Mac 2011 ee adg ee [13]
: I efeece (), e Aca ae a e ec be deged
ad aaed f a ef fe ece f 30 ea. I be
deced ad abaded accdace a acabe
ega eee a e e f decg ad
abade.
Refeece () g () de gdace f eag a ea
abade a ad a eae f fe abade c.
F a G 1 ee, ea ca a ae de b 31 Ma
2011 ad c eae ae de b 30 Nebe 2011. F G 2
ee, ea ca a ad c eae ae de b 30
Nebe 2011. A ee fg ae eeced f cae ae
ee G 1 G 2 cae ad e Vaage eag
ceded a 1 Nebe 2011, aae f Vaage
fe a fa a e eag dae.
: Peae de e Bad a ea abade a ad a
eae f fe abade c e a f e a
eag 1 Nebe 2011.
: Vaage cf a fe e NEB a ea
abade a ad a eae f fe abade c
e a f e a eag 1 Nebe 2011.
&
6.14
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 1.2, age 1 (PDF age 9)
[A1X5W0]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 5.5, age 25 (PDF age
33) [A1X5W0]
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
25/64
25
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 1.4, age 3 (PDF age
11) [A1X5W0]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 2.5, age 11 (PDF age
19) [A1X5W01
: I efeece (), Vaage ae a e 12c Vaage ee bececed e Abea Eae Gaeg Se (AEGS) ea
Ee, Abea.
I efeece (), Vaage ae a e eeced eae f a e
cd afe eeg a e Ee P a (befe
e afe f e Vaage ee e AEGS e)
d be 9,500 3/d (59,800 bId), a f f 3,970
3/d
(25,000 bId).
I efeece () Vaage ae, a e f aa caac
caced b NCC 30,000 b/d f e ea, dedf 5ea ee.
I efeece (), Vaage ceed ea e acce
e ee b e e a NCC a e f e eee
f acce ae a ffae ageee AEGS.
Ifa g e aca ab e aaabe aeaa
caac e AEGS e a Ee ecee e e a
d be deeed b Vaage. A, ee fa ab a
ffae ageee beee AEGS ad Vaage NCC ecee e
eae a d be aed b e ee.
: Peae ed e fg:
a) Wa e caac f e AEGS e dea f e
Vaage dee a Ee?
b) Wa e eeced aaabe ae caac a e AEGS
e dea f Ee a d be aaabe f
Vaage e e ee a ea?
c)
I ee a eg ffae ageee beee Vaage adAEGS? If e, eae de dea. If , eae f f NCC
a eeed a ffae ageee AEGS.
: a) I Vaage' deadg a e caac f e AEGS
dea f e Vaage dee 23,850 cbc ee
e da (150,000 bae e da).
b) Vaage dee eae NCC a Ee. NCC a a
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
26/64
26
ffae ageee e e caced e AEGS
f Vaage e Jffe ececa ce. Baed a
eaa f eae dc f Ee aea a e
e e 12 (Je 2010 Ma 2011), c aeaged
15,250 cbc ee (95,927 bae e da), aea a e
AEGS ad 8,600 cbc ee (54,073 bae e da) f ae
caac e e a 12 .
c) N. NCC a eeed a ffae ageee AEGS. See
e ee (b) abe.
6.15
: )
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 3, age 13 (PDF age 21)[A1X5W0]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 4, age 15 (PDF age 23)
[A1X5W0]
) Vaage Pee Pec, Adda We Edece Pec
Udae 14 Je 2011, age 1 [A1Z7L9]
: I efeece (), Vaage ae, "Eae gge a ee be
aae 40,000 50,000 bd f eae aaabe e Vaage
Pee. Ge e ce f fe deee e ee
ada f N Daa, ee a eaabe bab aeg ga ceg face cd be eaded e face
cd be b ce e ga ad dce ee e eae."
I efeece (), eec Abea eae dead, Vaage
ae, "Ge a e ae eae fa feca be
geae a 76,000 bd, Vaage a decded e 323.9 [12
c] O.D. e adda aa caac a be aaabe
e eed f adda a."
I efeece (), Vaage ae, "A a e f fe dc
aa ga dce ad ce N Daa, Vaage adecded deceae e e f e e f 323 9 (12 c)
273 (10 c) O.D."
: Peae ed e fg:
a) I e dec deceae e e f e e eaed a
aea edc e f eae eaed be
aaabe f ec? If e ae e, e aee
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
27/64
27
a e feca aaabe Vaage e age f
40,000 50,000 bd accae? Peae ea.
b) I e dec deceae e e f e e eaed a
aea edc e feca eae dead fa
Abea? If e ae e, e aee a e aeeae fa feca be geae a 76,000 bd
accae? Peae ea.
: a) N. Te feca age f 40,000 50,000 bae e
da ad ad dd f a f Vaage' dec
deceae e e e. Te dec a baed a ecc
a f caa ad eag c ag f a
cba f e e ad g ee eed
de ece e a age f be e cea,
cdg ea cea e ece f feca.
b) N.
6.16 ()
: )
Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, IR 3.12 Cc
Med S Dbace, age 1719 [A1Z7T71
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14, Tabe 143, age276278 (PDF age 1012) [251]
) Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, IR 3.19 Cc Taffc
Maagee Pa, age 3134 [A1Z7T71
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed A, 3.1 Taffc
Maagee Pa, age 6667 (PDF age 56) [161]
: I efeece (), Vaage ed a f ag ec ad
g d f e ec a cde e f adg f
ad b g affc aea, ea ad
b cac.
Hg affc aea ca a ac dfe. I efeece (), a
de ece c ed a a ea effec/a
ece ac e a f ece g.
Vaage a ed eea ga eae eded edce
ac f affc e ROW. I efeece () Vaage dcaed
a cac d e be a e a f e
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
28/64
28
f e aag e ROW, e ede, cac
e ad fea d de e ece.
Refeece () decbe acce c eae c a fece,
bae, faggg gage acce ee aea ad
bc acce e e. Acce c eae d be
ed ad aeed b e Eea Iec. Addaeae c a edced eed aea f g dfe
ea, a ece affc g ee aba aea, ad
ec eea ece affc e ROW, ae ed
efeece ().
Ag Vaage a decbed ea effece ga
eae, cea e effecee be eed (.e.,
g efcee).
: Peae de e fg:
a) fa ab e acaed affc e ROW dg e
cc ed, cdg affc ece e, e,
ad da f eac a ae f cc (e.g.,
ceag, gadg, ecg, ec.) f a e dace; ad,
b) a cea dec f Vaage a ad
efce ec ROW affc ad age.
: a) Te fa eeed ce aaabe. I
eag e deaed affc aagee a fa
eag acaed affc e ROW, cdg e affcece e, e ad da, be ced,
cdeed ad caed. Peae a ee e ee
NEB IR 3.19(a).
b) Vaage e b eea ad cc
ec ad efce ec ROW affc
ad age.
6.17
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 2.3 Pec
Ce, age 1315 (PDF age 13) [A1X5W9]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed A, Sec 3.1 Taffc
Maagee Pa, age 66 (PDF age 5) [161]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 6.7, age 30 (PDF age
38) [A1X5W0]
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
29/64
29
) Vaage Pee Pec, Aed A, Sec 1.4 Seg
ad Ceag, age 8 (PDF . 13) [A1X5Z8]
: Refeece () defe e eed f eae acce ad f
ee ea a e a ad a e bc ae
e. Tee ad d be 6 d. Refeece () a ae aa adda ad eed f ee ea ce fa
g deeed d be geae a 10 d ad
d be f a dbace. Accdg efeece (), e eed
f deeg e acce ad edced ce e ed
ee aae a be f eg ad. Refeece () ae a
a Cc Acce, Gade ad Cea Pa be deeed
befe cc cece.
Tea ad d a be eed f cc f e
ed ec, cdg ea acce ad, ea
face (e.g., e age e, cac ad) ad addaace a daage, ad, aa ad feg e cg,
debed, ad aea eca ea cdea
(efeece () ad ()).
I de eaae e ed ga f ea ac,
fe dea ae eed cceg Vaage' eea
cdea eec eae acce ad ad ea
ad eee.
: Peae de e fg:
a) dea e eae acce ad, cdg:
a.1) ee e 6 10 d decbed efeece
() eee e ad e f ROW;
a.2)
e aae f e ad ad ROW d, cdg
e e, e ad feec f affc eeced;
ad,
a.3) e ed aea f e aea (.e., ad
face, e f ROW);
b) e cea f defg 'a dbace' eec
eae acce ad;
c) cfa a e Cc Acce, Gade ad Cea
Pa be fed e Bad, ad e acaed g f
fg;
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
30/64
30
d) ca cea f e eec f ea ad f
acce, face ad ace ee ffce
eea ec; ad,
e) cfa a ecc e ad dae e
Eea Pec Pa b cde e adeed f ea acce, face ad ace.
: a) Vaage acae a a ad cced be 6 ee
d ad a a acaed ROW be 10 ee
d. Te ad ad ROW d a deeed baed e
eeced a e f ee eed f cc,
ea ad aeace f e a ad ae
e. Dg a ea e a be
acceed bee ad e ae a acceed . I
e ee f aeace a a f ee e, e e
e be acceed a e da e aeace cee. Te ad face be gae ad e eade f
e ROW be eeabed e ae ae a e ad
adace e ROW.
b) Te a cea f deeg ee a acce ad
e "a dbace" a f face
ac (.e. g e eg f a acce ad) e
ag e a f eg ad face. A f
e aed a ad face ae ca ae
adace eg ad c e e e f egad face ad e e acce ad cc a e
eg f e acce ad be ed. Peae a ee
e ee (d) be.
c) Te Cc Acce, Gade ad Cea Pa be fed
e NEB a ea 3 cc
cecg.
d) Ca cea cde: eg f acce ad, edea
ad bc ac eec e, d, afe, ec
ad eea ac c a e f ad, eadac, dfe ac, face ad gdae ac,
egea ac, aceg ad ada e ac.
e) Cfed.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
31/64
31
6.18
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 13.3.5, Mga
O f Pea Pec Ieac Rae Pa
age 239241 (PDF age 8183) [150]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Tabe 135, age 242246[PDF age 8488] [150]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Sec 4.10 Rae Pa
Cgec Pa, age 102103 (PDF age 4142) [161]
) Vaage Eea ad ScEcc Aee
Udae, Sec 8.2.5, age 3M14 (PDF age 1617) [A1Z7Q3]
: Refeece () decbe geea ga f ae a
ece cdg eg, aag ece, ecg ece
ceg, ad e, deedg e ed
e ad ece caacec. Refeece () ae e geea
ga eeed efeece () eac f e 23 aea ece fd a e, b ae ec ad b a
ca (ee e a cc ff e Pec Sd Aea
(PSA)). Refeece () de cea f deeg aae
gae ac f ae a ae eceed dg cc
ace. Te efeed ed ed efeece () adace.
Refeece () decbe e ca f eaeaed aa
( P b. ), aed a S2S3 b e
Saacea Cea Daa Cee, e ed ee
e. Accdg e efeece, "I e ae ec e ececeed a e ee eg f e ed ROW, ad
eeded e ff b de f a e f ee."
I efeece (), Vaage ae a e ceae ga
eae ae efeed f ece a ae a Sbaa
Cea Sa Ra f Cca Ieed (51), Ieed (S2)
a eedae aa f Ieed (S2S3 ad S2S4). F Ieed
(S2, S2S3) ece ee d be a 10 25 ebac, ee
be (efeece ()).
F eac f e 23 ae a ece a eed, a e a 13adda ece decbed efeece (), cea c f
e geea ga ded efeece (), () ad (),
cdg adace, d be efeed ad a cea d be
aed ce e . I a cea Vaage d
a e cea a ae a ece c a eaeaed
aa a ce a age f e ed ROW a ae
ec.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
32/64
32
: Peae de e fg:
a) cea cea f defg a ad eecfc ga
eae f ag e geea ga f ae
a ece;
b) ee Vaage a ced aae agece
eec e cea deeed (a), ad:
b.1) f , a a f ca ce; ,
b.2) f , a dca f e Vaage fe a
dae ca ad ga f ae a
ece;
c) e efeed ga f eaeaed aa, ag
e cea decbed (a); ad,
d) ee Vaage a ced aae agece
eec e eaeaed aa, ad:
d.1) f , a a f ca ce cdg
ca a f e eaeaed aa ad ea
ga eae; ,
d.2) f , e Vaage fe a dae
ca ad ga f ece.
: a) Cea c ed deee eecfc ga
eae cde (Fe e. a. 2002):
ad ca f dda ea e
ROW bdae;
be f dda a a ge e;
db f dda a a ge e;
degee ad e f a;
acaed cc ec (eee
f ea ace, feab f aed ROW,
ec.)
Adda bgca fac affecg a a' a a
(Rb 1999) c a be cdeed cde:
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
33/64
33
ee e a a aa eea;
ee e ece a ecfc ca,
ac, aac, a ea a
affec e ab agae;
ee e ece a a ea ae ea
c aca; ad aba ecfc cdea c a aba
e
Te efeed ga f ae ece ccece
ae a f:
1. Adace e ecag ccece
g GPS daa f fed e, ag f
a fag ec fecg, g
f cc ace b a afed bg, eaca f eceded ebac eee be
g eg f e ROW, aca
cg f e ed e, ag f
e ROW e c f e a, ad c
g e ee e ROW ad e
a.
2. Ce: Wee e ee ca be eed
aed, ae a ccg ea
ace, cea ccace, cd be
ea ceed b ece a geee
eae edce cg cac b
cc ece. Ceg e a ee
edce e ac f cg cac e
a ad e e f e ee ed
dg e cc ce.
3. Taaa/ Cec f eed ad/ ec f
eed ba : I ca e
aae ega agece, aaa ad
eed cec a be abe eec ccecebaed e bg f e a ece, ad aba
e, ee eg e ee ad a
a a acca . Paca e
cae f aa, e ec f e eed ba
a be a ag e ea f
ccef eeabe f e ece e
dbed aea. Te cec f eed, ec f e
eed ba e , aaa f cea
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
34/64
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
35/64
35
6.19
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.1.1 Ecgca
Ce, age 267268 (PDF age 12) [A1X5Y1]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 7.3.5, Oea age
67 (PDF age 10) [155]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.3.5, Accde ad
Mafc, age 291292 (PDF age 2526) [A1X5Y1]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 19.4.8 Wdfe ad
Wdfe Haba, age 441442 (PDF age 910) [A1X5Z01
: Refeece () decbe e f e ed ec ROW Ia Bd Aea (IBA), a e a Dc Ued (DU) ad
N Aeca Waef Maagee Pa (NAWMP)ad. Tee
ae a a cdeabe be f ead ag e ec e.
Refeece () ad () ae a, ce ced, e Vaage
ee e be f bee (ee ee) b fed g
acaf. Tee bee eace fg eee a ce f
ee e dg ea f e ee ad be f a
200 300 fee abe gd ee (efeece ()).
Refeece () decbe ea cae effec dfe eaea, cdg dbace de cc f e adace
Kee XL ee, bd e e e, ad e.
Te ac f ega efg bd ece e aea, eeca
ece a , ad e ga eae edce ee ac
ae cea.
: Peae de e fg:
a) defca f ece a a be ee e ac f
efg f e ec aea a 200 300 fee, cdgdefg e ee f ece a ;
b) g f fg g affec e ac (.e., e f da,
ea);
c)
ee Vaage aae f e fg e a d be
ag ace adace ee, ad f , e g, ade
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
36/64
36
ad ca feec f e e; ad
d) ga eae ed b Vaage f b dec ad
cae effec f acaf ee eace
: a) Te ea effec f acaf dfe ae beeeee ded f a eea aa ad bd
ece. Te ca ee acaf ca age f d
(aed ead, bd f), deae (eae aea f
e), eee (aced fg) (NeQe 2011; Naa
Pa Sece 2004). Te ge cc effec ae e
ded (Naa Pa Sece 2004).
Bd
F a a bd ece, ecae fg a aa ee
a bec fg eead, cdg acaf (Kef ad H1998). Hee, bd ece ded ada ad accae
fa c e , ad e fg bea
eaced e ee ee bea (c a aed
ead bd f) (Kef ad H 1998).
A de age f ee ae bee beed bd ece,
cdg ceaed ea ae, ceaed cag, ee acg,
fg, adace f aea ( ed, ge a
abade) (Kef ad H 1998), ceaed eeg
c, e fd ae, e eg e (Keda
Zede, Cea ad Bdee 2003; Ie f EeaMg ad Reeac). M bd e cc beee 50
ad 800 fee abegdee (AGL).
Waef fed ff a aebd ca ea e a f
aae 5 e (KedaZede, Cea ad
Bdee 2003). Geee ae aca ee acaf;
geae geee ee beed edce aba e b
50% fg a dbace f e 2 fg e (USDA
APHIS Wdfe Sece 2001). A d f Aeca ge,
gada ad geeged ea fd e bd eded (fg,g ae bea) f aae 10 40 ecd
e efg (C . 1998).
Ce f bd ece, c a e ad eca, ae a
cebe (Kef ad H 1998). Gd ad ce
ae a bee eeece egae ac (USDA
APHIS Wdfe Sece 2001). A e d f eeeg
ca aebd fd deae eee eac
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
37/64
37
ee ee fe (USDAAPHIS Wdfe Sece
2001). A a d ebd fd e ee
fg 195309 fee AGL, b eg bd eaced e
a eg bd (NeQe 2011). G ad ca ae
c egg f e e e fed dde,
c ca ead edced eg cce (Naa Pa Sece2004). Tda a ad eca ae bee abad
e de cc f acaf (Naa Pa Sece 2004).
Sad cae abad ecfc aea f eeded ed
f e e efg ae ccg (Naa Pa Sece
2004).
Redaed a aea abae ee fg, ad
eeece aae effec eg cce; gde eage
aea ea ea (USDAAPHIS Wdfe Sece 2001).
M a ece a ge eac ece a
fedg acaf (NeQe 2011). A d f bad eage
fd aae af (3761%) fed ee
ece ac (Saae ad Kae 1997). Te ae d
fd a ee bad eage fed e fe a ad,
ad dda e gd fed e ead a e
ee (Saae ad Kae 1997). Te ed e ee f
a ece beee 6285 db (NeQe 2011).
Ma f e de ed a e bd daed e eac
eea dbace a aea e (NeQe 2011).
Sbe effec eege fac aeg bea de dbace caed b acaf ae bee beed. Te effec
f dbace ceae dg e cbabdg ed
(Pae, Ndee ad Rb).
Maa
Maa ae e ee e e acaed acaf
a bd ae. Ne ee f 120 dBA ca cae daage
aa ea, e ee f 95 dBA ca cae ea
f eag e (NeQe 2011). Ne acaed
aae a bee cae cage e age,fagg ae, ad beedg bea age cae.
Me dee da e ee acaf (USDAAPHIS Wdfe
Sece 2001).
Peae a ee e aace 6.19(a) beg a abe dg
ece' ee efg.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
38/64
38
:
Kef, N. ad O. H. 1998. Wa effec d aae ae bd? A
a. I Nae ad Ladcae 30(1): 1728 (aaed f ga Gea).
KedaZede, S., M. Cea ad B. Bdee. 2003. Effec f dbace b
acaf efg aebd a eeea aac. Ieaa Bd SeCee e IBSC26/WPLE2.
Ie f Eea Mg ad Reeac. Dae. Effec f ee
efg e bea f g agg aef cea Labad.
USDAAPHIS Wdfe Sece. 2001. Eea Aee Mg: Eae
Maa Peda Daage Maagee.
Pae, A.G., D.L. Ndee, ad D.D. Rb. Effec f e acaf efg
aea cae f eege fac. Wdfe Sce Be V. 31(2):499509.
NeQe. 2011. Aa Ne Ifa ad Rece. Webe.
Naa Pa Sece. 1994. Cae 5: Effec f Oefg Wdfe. I Re
Effec f Acaf Oefg e Naa Pa Sece.
C, J.T. e a. 1998. Dabbg dc bea ad acaf ac caa N
Caa. Ja f Wdfe Maagee 62(2): 11271134.
Saae, M.V. ad J.L. Kae. 1997. Fg ee f eg bad eage
a ac. Ja f Wdfe Maagee 61(4):13071313.
b) Acaf efg dg eg ea ca dace ad
bd f e ad ae a e f egg cce
ad deceaed g f e ece, e
efg dg fa e a affec eeg eede
b dacg bd f agg aba feedg gd.
Lee acaf efg dg cea e f da a
cae a cage ac ae f e dfe ece
(Beage ad Bedad 1989; Gee . 1989).
Wdfe ca abae acaf dbace (Wa .
1992; Kaa . 1993, 1998; Weebege .1996)
ad ac ee fd be bef, gfca ad
deea edce cce f e dfe ece(S . 1998; La 1989; E .1991; Gbb ad
Bea 1997).
:
Beage, L. ad J. Bedad, 1989b. Eegec c f adced dbace
agg geee. Ja f Wdfe Maagee 54: 3641.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
39/64
39
E, D.H., C.H. E, ad D.P. Mde. 1991. Ra Ree Lee Je
Acaf ad Sc B. Eea P 74:5383.
Gee, E. M., Rgad, O. J., ad M, W. R. 1989. Cage ce ee
de a ac. , 53:334339.
Gbb, T.G. ad W.W. Bea. 1997. Vaa Beedg Bad Eage Ree Je, Lg Pae, ad Hece. Ja f Ra Reeac, 31:213222.
La 1989. Mg e Effec f Ma A Oea a Naa A Sa
Fa e Ba f Neada. Neada Deae f Wdfe, Re.
Kaa, P.R., M.C. Waace, D.W. DeYg, M.E. Weebege, ad C.L. Hae.
1993. Te Effec f Lade Je Acaf Dee Ugae. Ieaa
Cge: Ne a a Pbc Hea Pbe 6:471478.
S. D.G., D.H. E, ad T.H. J. 1988. Ra ad Acaf. R.L. G, B.
G Pede, M.B. M, M.N. LeFac, J. B.A. Ma, ad S.W. Hffa, ed.
Pceedg f e Se Ra Maagee S. P. 360367.
Naa Wdfe Fedea, Wag, D.C.
Weebege, M.E., P.R. Kaa, M.C. Waace, D.W. DeYg, ad O.E. Maga.
1996. Effec f Saed Je Acaf Ne Hea Rae ad Bea f Dee
Ugae. Ja f Wdfe Maagee 60:5261.
Wa, G.W., T.D. Bc, J.W. Ca, R.C. Ea, L.S. Ne, ad E.M. Rag.
1992. Sc B/Aa Dbace Sde Pg Aee, Rc
Ma E, ad Bg ee. Ua Sae Ue Fda, Lga. Peaed
f U.S. A Fce, H AFB, Cac F4265087C0349.
c) Te TaCaada Kee Ieg Maagee Pga
cde edc aea a b ece fed g
acaf. Dea f aea a g, ade ad feec
ae aaabe a e. Tca e fg cc a
500 fee abe gd ee (AGL).
d) Mga eae a a e dbace dfe
cde:
Rec efg e aea ee
eaeed ece dg e beedg ea;
aa ca eed, dace, ad eg e
cdcg fe;
e a a dace f e ee, ae a
dec eead;
e fedg acaf ae a ece; ad
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
40/64
40
e e f acaf aea e eg
dbace (.e. aea ad a e, fa
eed f ba cee d).
6.20
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.2 Baee
Cd Sa, age 270273 (PDF age 47) [A1X5Y1]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed J, Tabe J3, age 51
52 (PDF age 1415) [A1X6D81
: I efeece (), ad g Aca, Vaage eea
Sece a R ad Sece f Seca Sa a a cc e
c f e ed ee a ee fd dg dfe
e cdced dae, ad decbe eea a abaf ee ece. I efeece (), Vaage ae a e ee f
W Bc Lae Ia Bd Aea degaed a cca g
e aba de e Saacea
(WHPA). I cea f a f e e a aba decbed
b Vaage ae degaed cca aba a defed b e
(SARA) ca ega.
: Peae de:
a) cafca f a aba cc e ec Rega
Sd Aea (RSA) a ae bee defed a cca aba a
defed b e SARA ca ega; ad,
b)
f cca aba e e ec RSA, e fg
fa f eac cca aba e:
b.1) e acaed eac beee ec ace
ad e cca aba, cdg e f a
ac e cca aba ee f dec cac
acaed;
b.2) eecfc ga eae; ad,
b.3) edece f ca eecfc ga
eae aae ega agece,
ade, e ae.
: a) Tee ae defed cca aba a defed b e SARA
ca ega f ed ece ccg e
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
41/64
41
ec' Rega Sd Aea (beg a 30 de cd
ceed e ed ROW). Te Saacea
a aeded 1992 b
g e e "cca" f e Ac, ad b a e cage
e .
I efeece (), Vaage aed a e ee f W
Bc Lae Ia Bd Aea degaed a cca g
e aba de e Saacea
(WHPA). Hee, a e a e
Saacea a
aeded 1992 b g e e "cca" eee
cced e Ac, ad b a e cage e WHPA.
Cca aba defed e WHPA.
b) b.1) N eac beee ec ace ad cca
aba acaed.
b.2) Sce cca aba aeed b e ec, ad
eac beee e ec ad cca aba
acaed, eecfc ga eae f
cca aba be eed.
b.3) Vaage de beee a eecfc ga
eae f cca aba be eed.
Regade, Vaage c SE ad EC
fg e ce f e 2011 fed ea.
Vaage b e e f ca
e Bad a a aaabe.
:
Gee f Saacea. 1992. A Ac aed
. Qee' Pe f Saacea, Rega,
Saacea.
Gee f Saacea. 1992. .
Cae W132. Qee' Pe f Saacea, Rega, Saacea.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
42/64
42
6.21
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Tabe 143, age 276278 (PDF
age 1012) [151]) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.3.4, Dbace f
Wdfe, age 282 (PDF age 16) [151]
: Refeece () ae eea ac f ece a dfe,
cdg affecg fagg aba ad ea deceag
a edc f Od' aga a. Refeece () add a
ceaed ac, e ad ge a de
cc a cae dbace dfe ad cae edced
dc e beedg e dee ad edced e
dacee f aba.
: Peae de Vaage' c afca a dg
cc ad ea, cdg:
a) a e ee gg d be eed (facg
eaa aa f dag ad dfe ac);
b) a e ca ee gg d be bed; ad
c)
f afca gg d be ed dg cc
ea:
c.1) e g ee ad dace a c aba ad
Od' aga a ae affeced; ad,
c.2) e ga eae Vaage d e edce
ac f a dfe.
: a) Lgg a be eed dg HDD ace. M f e
ed HDD be ceed a eae
e fae. A Eea M be ee dg
a HDD ace.
I add, a dag e, eca gg be
eed ad f e cc e.
Dg ea, g a a be ed
e eeg f ee ae ee.
b) Vaage aae f a e ca ee gg
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
43/64
43
d be bed.
c) c.1) Od' Kaga Ra Reeac gge a ceaed
ge a ea de ad e age
cage e bea f Od aga a cdg
edcg e fagg bea (Kafa adKafa 1982; Ke 1984, COSEWIC 2006). Te
a
dcaed a ca a a e ea
c ee g cd, cee
ceag eda g e abe gd
e aga a ed fagg ad a ae
cae a deceae a edc.
(Ee Caada 2011) A eaa f ee
ace dg ad cc f e N
Sffed ee dcaed a ag ge
cc a deae, Od aga a
aeaed edce e e age e a ae
ce aea ee dae dbace. Te
d eceded a ge ace
g d be aed ee Od aga a ae
cc (Ge ad Rbe 2003).
Te ed a c g ee ad dace effec
Od aga a ee fe ega
(Ke 2009). ASRD F&W eced ee a
a ac d be ccded befe e ad e afca a 1000 f Od
aga a age (ASRD F&W 2011)
Aba Reeac a dcaed a g
a affec aba ace cdg
fagg ad b ag (Bcaa 1993, Haa
1984, Bae ad Rcad 2006). T a ead
eca a ece a a beedg d
de ad ga deee ace a ae a
ac aba edce cce (Ee
Caada 2009).
Cce eeac abe g ee ad dace
ed a c aba ae affeced geea
acg. A ee f e be effec f g gg
a ece f aba ad ee dcae
a e fe de e ceece f afca
g aba ad ee ece ae bee
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
44/64
44
cdced dae. Hee e a f e ee
d dcae g a ea aba ad
fe fa eed de e ecfc
aagee eceda (Pe . 2008).
Tee edece eegg a dffee ece a
a ee g f ag effec, a beefca effec a egae effec a
aca a (Pe . 2008). Dbace
ed f afca a ae bee
ded f aba Sece f Maagee Cce
(.e., e ead fg, gea a ad
adef ad) c ae bee beed e
ec aea. Te ea effec f afca
a ee ece a bee ecfca
ed a a ea g fac ece
ca ad Cee e Sa f Edageed
Wdfe Caada (COSEWIC) e (Aea 2009,
COSEWIC 2009 ad 1010, La 1999).
c.2) Od' Kaga Ra Se' f Od' aga a
be cdced dg aae e ad
cd def e eece f ece ad
deee e ece ca f b aba
ea f ece. Se be baed
c ed b Abea Saabe
Rece Deee 2010. Seea e
ae ceded f Ag 2011, a a e ea dee ae ge de ae e
bab f eceg ece (ASRD 2010,
Bede . 2007).
I aea ee Od' aga a ae fd dg
eea e, eceded a
deee ace cc e e ad a
edeee e be deae
cc. Pedeee e d be
deae edae ce ee
a a e abed e ae ecded (Ke
2009).
Sebac dace f e ed deee f
ee Od' aga a b ae fd be
dced ega ae a e b e
ba. I aea ee Od' aga a b ae
fd, eceded a a ac (cdg
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
45/64
45
ge affc) be ccded befe e ad a
afca a be ed 1000 f
Od' aga a age ag e ed ee
ROW. I a eceded a face c
ee gg (.e. a) be caed
1000 f Od' aga a b.
Aba Ng a be eed f
HDD. I eceded a ee ace, ad a
e ee ge a a be eed,
be deae e fa dg dea ad de f
e beedg ed f aba Sece f
Maagee Cce (.e. d A J) aea
ee aba Sece f Maagee Cce
ae bee fd, a e ea f d f
aba ag ad edc ace f
a edced.
I a eceded a face c ee
gg (.e. a) be caed e
c f eecfc aba f aba
Sece f Maagee Cce.
:
Abea Saabe Rece Deee F ad Wdfe 2011.
Receded Lad Ue Gdee f Pec f Seeced Wdfe
Sece ad Haba Gaad ad Paad Naa Reg fAbea Gee f Abea
Abea Saabe Rece Deee F ad Wdfe 2011 See
Sece Ie Gdee Ag 2010.
Aea, A.A. 2009. Dbace ac ed: eceded ad
e gdee f ec f eebae ece f cce
Saacea. Saacea M f Ee. Lad Bac F
ad Wdfe Bac Tecca Re 200906. 93 .
Bae, B.J. ad J.M.L. Rcad 2006. Te effec f afca g ae
beedg ea bea geed ee fg. Caada Ja f Zg
84: 15281532 (2006).
Bede, D.J., D.L. Ge ad R.E. De. Mg Pc f e
Od Kaga Ra. Abea Sece a R Re N. 113 Mac 2007.
Ue f Caga, Ra Abea Me, Abea Saabe Rece
Deee F ad Wdfe. 21 .
Bcaa, B.W. 1993 Effec f eaced gg e bea f
ca fg. Aa Bea 45: 893899.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
46/64
46
COSEWIC 2006. COSEWIC aee ad dae a e e Od
aga a Caada. Cee e Sa f
Edageed Wdfe Caada. Oaa. V + 34 .
COSEWIC 2010. COSEWIC aee ad a e e Gea Pa
Tad Caada. Cee e Sa f
Edageed Wdfe Caada. Oaa. V + 54 .
COSEWIC 2009. COSEWIC aee ad a e e e
ead fg , Rc Ma a, We
Bea/PPae Pa ad Eae Pa Caada. Cee
e Sa f Edageed Wdfe Caada. Oaa. 69 .
Ee Caada. 2009 Pee Id Ac Gdee f
Wdfe Sece a R e Pae ad Ne Reg. Caada
Wdfe Sece, Ee Caada, Pae ad Ne Reg,
Ed, Abea. 64.
Ee Caada. 2011. Rece Saeg f e Od Kaga Ra
( ) Caada [Ped]. Rece
Saeg See. Ee Caada, Oaa. + 28 . + Aedce.
Ge, D. ad S. Rbe 2003. Eaa f ace ad a f
Od aga a dg ad cc f e N Sffed
ee. Fa Re bed ECaa Sffed GaPee Ic.
Mag Pga, Pca Me f Abea. 42 .
Haa, J.P. 1984. Bda ca ac f e ee ad
ea abe a Cea (2) 283290.
Kafa, D.W., ad G.A. ad G.A. Kafa Effec f Mg Ac
ad Mcaba Ue b Od Kaag Ra (Dd d) Ja fMaag, V. 63, N. 2 (Ma 1982) 309312.
Ke, K.J., 2009 Beefca Maagee Pacce f Od Kaga Ra
Abea. Abea Saabe Rece Deee. Abea Sece a
R Re N. 125 42 .
Ke, B.P. 1984 Effec f Ia e Rae f Rece Haeg
a C f Dee Rde Aeca Mdad Naa, V. 111,
N. 2 (a 1984) 383389.
La, R.D. 1999. Sa f e Pa Sadef
Abea. Abea Ee, Fee ad Wdfe Maagee D,
ad Abea Cea Aca, Wdfe Sa Re N. 25,Ed, Abea. 17 .
Pe, G., B.W. Bcaa, R.N. Fe, M. Sa ad S.E. We. 2008.
Effec f afca g gg aba ad ee ba
ee. Page 239256 J.C. Mce, R.E. Jg B ad B.
Bae ed, Uba Heeg Sce f e d f
Aba ad Ree, Sa Lae C, UT. Heegca Cea
Nbe Tee.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
47/64
47
6.22
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 13.1.1 Ecgca
Ce, age 222 (PDF age 64) [150]) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14, Tabe 143, age
276278 (PDF age 1012) [1511
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed J, Tabe J4, age 53
64 (PDF age 1627) [A1X6D8]
)
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 13.3.4, Deaed
Aee f Pea Pec Ieac Vegea,
age 233237 (PDF age 7579) [150]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.5.3 Idefca f
Pbe Ieac, age 326329 (PDF age 6063)
[A1X5Y1]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 13.3.6.3 Pea
Reda Effec ad e Deea f e Sgfcace,
age 255259 (PDF age 97101) [150]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed J, Tabe J5, age 65
67 (PDF age 2830) [A1X6D8]
)
Vaage Pee Caada Ic. Ree IR 3.16, age 2426
[A1Z7T7]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 14.3.11 Pea
Reda Effec, age 320324 (PDF age 5458) [A1X5Y1]
)
Naa Eeg Bad Fg Maa, Reed Ma 2011, Tabe
2 Fg Reee f Bca Eee, Wdfe ad
Wdfe Haba, age 454 455
: Refeece () dce e ace ad ae f e eag
ac f ae egea e ae. Haba fagea e
gaad ed a ad dece f dfe ece, a
f c ae ece a (efeece () ad ()).
Refeece () e a aba fagea eg f e
ed ec eeced be ed, a cae a ae e
e ec adace eg ee ad ad, ee be.
Hee, ee e ec cg ad aee ae
ae, fagea a e a be f ece. Refeece ()
decbe aba fagea ad edc f ac e f aba
eg f cae ac f deee.
Refeece () defe e dec f f e ed ec
ae ae a 61.9 a baed aed a. Te eg f
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
48/64
48
ee cg ae ae 63.29 a f 2010 fed e,
11.22 f e, cg ROW (efeece ()). Oe
ded ad e ae ec ced b e ed
ee ae Hg Pea Wdfe Aea (efeece (); 33 f ee
ae ced b e, cg ROW (efeece ()).
I efeece (), Vaage ca a eaabe effec e
aab f ae ae e eg ae eeced. Accdg
efeece (), eec ac dfe de aba
fagea, Vaage e a ee ae ce gee
d eae ed f ea effec.
Hee, e cefc eae ca cdeabe ad e
eabed aae aae ad eae f adcae effec
c a aba fagea gaad ece, aca ece
a .
Refeece () gde e decbe e cae
dbace f e aba ad db f
a f, efeab aae, ad cae e
cae effec a aaabe eceecfc ed
ce. Te gdace ded efeece () eae f
a a be ed ae cae effec cdg aa aa
ad adcae ee dca f cage c a ea de.
: Peae de e fg:
a)
e ce ac e f ceced ae aba (cdgae, ead ad daage) eac aeec
g f ceced aeec defed a Hg Pea
Wdfe Aea efeece ();
b) e eced ac e f ceced ae aba, a
decbed (a), afe cc f e ed ee;
c) eaed ae f ac e f ceced ae aba
cdg b e ed ee ad ec cdeed
e cae effec aee, cea a
aed;
d) e ce ae f ea dbace de e RSA,
/2, a aae aea ceeed eac ae
ec g f ceced aeec defed a
Hg Pea Wdfe Aea efeece ();
e) e eced ae f ea dbace de, a decbed
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
49/64
49
(d), afe cc f e ed ee;
f) eaed ae f ea dbace de cdg b
e ed ee ad ec cdeed e
cae effec aee, cea a aed;
g) ed ae f ea dbace de aaabe e
cefc eae (e.g., adcae ecg, cea
bg) f ece f aagee cce e RSA; ad
) eae cae eac f e ae deed (d), (e), ad (f)
e ed aed (g).
: a) f) Peae ee Aace 6.22.
g) ) We cefc ad gee eae eee dc
ece ed ea dbace, geeabece ae ( e ece f e ece c
d ab e ec aea c a g bea ad
dad cab). I add, e eae eg ea
ad ad ae a ee. Aea (2009) ad
Wfed . (2008) ae a ee a eee edge
ga (c) f dbace ac ed f ece,
ee c ed fe ecbed bffe.
N ecfc aae ed ae f ea dbace
de ( /2) ae dceed f ece f aagee
cce c a cc e ec aea.
:
A.A. Aea 2009. Dbace Iac Ted: Receded Lad Ue
Gdee f Pec f Veebae Sece f Cce Saacea.
Saacea M f Ee, Lad Bac F ad Wdfe Bac
Tecca Re 200906. 93 .
Abea Bg O Rece Tea. 2005. Rece Pa f Bg O
Abea. Abea Saabe Rece Deee. F ad Wdfe D,
Abea Rece Pa N. 6. Ed, AB.
Dae, B.C., We, T.S., ad Ha, L.E. 2008. Abdace f Tee Gaad
Sgbd a Aea f Naa Ga If Dg Abea, Caada. I: Pceedg f
e F Ieaa Pae Fg Cfeece: Tda Tc.
De, B.A., De B.L., Qa, R.W., Cae, O., Ree, V.J., Je P.F. 2004.
MULTISAR: Te M Re Ba Pec. Haba Sab Mde f Seeced
Wdfe Maagee Sece. Abea Sece a R Re N. 86.
Fa, R. T. T., Feda, D. S., Fe, D., Ma, J. D., Ce, A. S., ad L. E.
Aeade. 1997. Ecgca effec f ad: Tad ee a dce ad a
ee f N Aeca. Page 4054 K. Cae, ed. Haba fagea
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
50/64
50
ad face. M f Ta, Pbc W ad Wae Maagee,
Def, Te Neead.
Fa, R. T. T. ad L. E. Aeade. 1998. Rad ad e a ecgca effec.
Aa Ree f Ecg ad Seac 29: 20731.
Gde Acae Ld. 2009. Teea ece aee e f e EcaaCa Lae Tea Ea Pec, ae 1E, 1F, ad 1G. Peaed f ECaa
FCCL Ld.
Gee f Abea. 2008. Abea g bea ece a 2008 2013.
GaTe, C.L. ad Abb S. 2011. Cea f Pg Pe (Caad
ed) N Aeca: Scece, Sccee, ad Caege. Caada Ja f
Zg. 89: 401418.
Ha, L.E., Dae, B.C., ad Pa, C.A. 2011. Effec f Dbace
Acaed Naa Ga Eac e Occece f Tee Gaad
Sgbd. Aa Cea ad Ecg. 6(1): Ace 7.
Hd, P. 2008. Tad Acceabe Cage: A Ted Aac Maage
Cae Effec f Lad Ue Cage e Se F f Abea. MSc.
Te, Ue f Caga.
Lee, P. ad M. Haea. 2011 Cae aea fe ad e e: Lea dbace,
acce dee ad g bea aba ec aea.
Le, C. 2006. Te Effec f Ma Dbace Sa Ga Ac Gaad
Bd. Ne ESeac Ld.
MacFaae, B. 2006. A Ree f Pca/Mca Rega ad Gdee
Acabe Sface Dbace Acaed Naa Ga Deee C Lad e Gea Sad H, Saacea. Caada Pa Reeac Cee.
Ue f Rega.
Sa Cg Ic., A Eea Cg Ld., Fe Tecge Ld,
ad Wdfe & Ca Ld. 2004. De C Cae Effec Sd Pae I:
Maagee Idca ad Ted. Peaed f De C Lad Ue Pag
Cee, F Pdece, Ne Tee.
See, A. Ecgca Effec f Rad: A Ree. Sed Ue f Agca
Scece.
Sa, T. A. H a a: A ee f ad de ed f
dfe. Te RadRIPe. 11.
Wae, W. L., ad Ka, W. F. 1997. G Bea ad ad de
ea e Se ad Cabe Yaa Rece Ze.
Wfed, P.D., M. Rddc, ad R. Ba. 2008. Ee a a f
afg bd eace a dbace. B. C 141(11):2708 2717.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
51/64
51
6.23
: ) Vaage Pee Caada Ic. Ree NEB IR 3.12, age
1719, [A1Z7T7]) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 3, Aed A, Dg. 3 g 9,
[A1X5Z81]
: Refeece () ad () decbe dffee g ad ROW
eaa cede f dded ed ae ad
aad caed e dded ed ae ad aad. Te
def f ` dded' e 'e dded' cea.
: Peae de Vaage' def f ' dded' ad 'e
dded' ed ae ad aad.
: Te e dded ad e dded ae e ed a
cc ce deee aae g d.
Lad ae cdeed e dded e e d f ffce de
ad ce (eg) be abe e ad eace b
ag e d (ad ) dg bacfg (g a gade
bace bade). Lad a ae cdeed dded ae d
a abe eg e b g adg
dg bacf ea. I e f cc ( g),
dded ed ae ad aad ae eaed a
caed ad.
6.24
: Vaage Pee Caada Ic. Ree NEB IR 3.15, age 2324,
[A1Z7T71
: I e efeece, Vaage de fe eae f a ad d
ed ee ec ee e ed a ccef
ed. Hee, Vaage de de fe dea f ee
eae c ae a ca e Vaage ec.
: Peae de e fg:
a) e ee daee f eac f e ec ed e
efeece;
b) deeed a e ed a ccef ed
eac f ee cae ad accdg a eae f
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
52/64
52
cce, aed e a e ed;
c) cfa a ee a f e eae ae f a 10c
ee, ad f , de adda eae f 10c
ee ec f c Vaage aae; ad,
d) a dc f ee eae ed (c) ee ccef,
baed e def f cce ded (b).
: a) Ecaa Mga Pee Pec 60 f 88.9 O.D.,
114.3 O.D., 168.3 O.D. ad 219.1 O.D.
Ecaa Ade 3 Pee Pec 93 f 60.3 O.D.,
88.9 O.D., 114.3 O.D., 168.3 O.D., ad 219.1
O.D.
Ecaa Wa Pee Pec 33 f 168.3 O.D. (aeee); 2 f 88.9 O.D. ad 15.2 f 168.3 O.D.
(gaeg e)
M O M Re Pee Pec 273.1 O.D.
Sc Lg Pec S eae Abea 219.1
.O.D (ASRD).
b) & c) Abea Saabe Rece Deee Pbc Lad
Bac (PL) eed cc be ed a
Ced ad. P 2004, ecfc eeef P Cc Recaa Aee (PCRA) eed
f ee Ca 1 Ca 2 ee ec Abea. I
Ocbe 2003, Abea Ee aed a P
Cc Recaa Reg eee f a Ca I
ee ec. Te PCRA cdced e gg ea
afe cc. Dg e aee, ecaa cce
eaaed ea adace dbed ad g e
fg cea:
) ece de;
) g;
) de; ad
) eed ee.
Dg e PCRA, aea g dca f
ecaa (g e abe cea) ae eaed f
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
53/64
53
be ea ( cac, adg, cae daage ec)
ad adda eceda a be ade.
Te M O Ca Ld. M Re USA L (1995
Sec 58 NEB Refeece be 3400W02311) e
273.1 O.D (10c) ee f e ec ed eee NEB IR 3.15. A c f e P Cc
Eea Re f e ec a bee eeed
f NEB ace.
Vaage beee a ee e dffeece beee 219.1
O.D. (8c) ad 273.1 O.D. (10c) ee
e f ec d ee ed (e, be f
ece), c e e ec ee ed e
ee NEB IR 3.15. ASRD aded Vaage f e Sc
ec a beg a ec. N ecaa fa
aaabe f ec.
:
Gaeae Sece Ld Aca Aa Ragead Sece Ld., CPae
Sece, Kee Reeac Ld. LadWe Ic. ad Pegg Deed, 2007.
Reegea Saege f Pbc Lad: A Ga Aa. Peaed f: Abea
Saabe Rece Deee Lad D, Lad Maagee ad Ragead
Maagee Bace
d) Ece f aea ee eea fac (e.g. cae daage)
affeced eg, ecaa cce f e ecee PCRA ee cdced (Mga ad Ade 3) a
gd.
6.25
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, Eea ad ScEcc
Aee, Eece Sa [A1X5W6]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2, Sec 11, age 159182 (PDF
age 124) [150]
) Vaage Pee Caada Ic. Ree IR N. 2 ad
Ree Tabe NEB IR 2.2 [A1Y1J6 & A1Y1J71
)
Vaage Pee Caada Ic. Ree IR N. 3, Aace
3.16(b2) ad (b3) [A1Z7U7 & A1Z7U81
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
54/64
54
: Refeece () ad () dcae a e ed Pec ce ab
180 ead.
Refeece () ea a eea e aed f 2011
cde adda ead e ad aee cf
be, ca, e ad ca f ead. Pca geead Ee Caada ecee 2011 daa ad ee
eceded ga.
I efeece () Vaage ae a adda g be
cdeed baed fed e. M aea f e ed
g baed fed e e ae eeced e e be
ad a aea f ead ced.
I efeece () Vaage ae a dead a a ead
dbace bec ga ad cea eae, ad
a de e ee e, cae e ee be ed ad ead.
I cea e a ee ad ead d be
bed e Bad, ad e Vaage fae ga
eae.
: Peae de a cea eaa f:
a) e, afe ce f 2011 ead e, Vaage
eec c Ee Caada ad Pca
gee egadg ead ga;
b) Vaage' cea f decdg ee aeg e ed
g ad ead e efeed ga ad ee
; ad,
c) e Vaage eec def ee ee baed
ead e e ad b ee e Bad.
: a) Vaage c Saacea Ee (SE) ad
Ee Caada (EC) ce f e fed e
Seebe egadg ead ga.
b) Vaage cea f decdg ee aeg e ed
e ad ead cde:
) acceabe g ;
) e eea cdea e aea (dfe,
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
55/64
55
ae a, acaegca);
) ad e;
) e f ead;
) ca f ead; ad
) ade ca.
c) Seea ee ad ead ae ce beg
eaaed HDD ad e c . Vaage
c SE ad EC ce f e fed e
fe adde ead e. Oce e ca
cee, a ead ee eg e efeed
be bed e Bad.
6.26
: Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, Ree 3.20, age 353640, (PDF
age 3536) [A1Z7T7]
: Refeece ae a Vaage a aed a a eeed Abga
bee de fa eag e ece e cd dg cc. I fe ae a Vaage be
efg a caac aee deee e Abga
bee a bece ed dg e ee cc.
: Peae de e fg:
a) a dec f e ed a Vaage a ed cac
Abga bee, cdg ed f cac ad
fa ded;
b)
fa a Vaage a aed bee deeag ece e cd dg ee
cc; ad,
c) a dec f Vaage a e e fa
ded b Abga bee deae a caac
aee, cdg a dec f e cea Vaage
e f e caac aee.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
56/64
56
: a) A a f e gg eeg Abga g, Vaage
a decbed e beg deae cc e
ee, e a dc ad ece a be eed
ad e g f c eee. Vaage a ed a
eac c' ee ad ab de dc
ad ece ad a ecaged ce a ee cac Vaage.
b) Vaage a aed bee de a ecfc
fa e. Dc Abga bee ae
fced e ae f e ec ad e e f dc
ad ece a be eed.
c) Vaage eeed Abga bee
deee e caac ad caab de a ecfc
dc ece. Vaage a deeed a cea be
ed de ef c caac aee, b eeca e cea a deed e dc ece
be ded. Cea a a be cdeed cde
e eeece, ee ee gd cd,
e ab ee afe adad, a e a a dffeece
e caed dc ece a g be aaabe
f Abga bee.
6.27
: ) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Aace 2 Abga
Ca Ace (a f Jaa 2011), age 213291 (PDF
age 54132) [A1X5W4]
) Vaage Adda We Edece, Aed B Abga
Egagee Pga Udae [A1Z7Q2]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Aace 1 Abga
G caced b NEB, age 212 (PDF age 53) [A1X5W4]
)
Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, Ree 3.23, age 3940(PDF age 3940) [A1Z7T71
: Refeece () ad () de a dae ca ace a
ae ae ace ce Jaa 2011.
Refeece () e Abga g defed b e Ma Pec
Maagee Offce (MPMO) a ce c a be aced
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
57/64
57
b e Vaage Pee Pec.
Refeece () ae a Vaage a egaged, aeed
egage, ca a ea affeced Abga g
defed b Vaage ad e e ae ae ad e
ae ee. Te Bad e e fg 15 Abga gdefed b e a ce c a be aced b e
Vaage Pee Pec ee cded Vaage' dae
ca; Bd Tbe, Ca e Kee F Na, Cacaca F
Na, Kaeaa F Na, Lea Ma, M, G
Bea' Head F Na, Lc Ma F Na, M F
Na, Mceg F Na, Ocaace F Na,
Oaee F Na, Peeee F Na, Pa F Na,
Sadg Bffa Daa F Na, Sa Bae F Na ad
Seega F Na.
: Peae de a daed eed abe ca acedeae e Abga g ed e eabe abe. I
e ee, eae cde:
a) a a f a ace caed , cdg e dae ad
ed f cac (f eae: eee, ea eeg,
ea, ee a);
b) a a f a e ad cce aed;
c) e a Vaage a ae ae adde cce,
cdg a ed ga eae;
d) a a f a adg cce e; ad,
e) a eaa fe ac d be eed
adde a aca cce.
: a) Peae ee Aace 6.27(a).
b) W e ece f e Lc Ma ad M F
Na, ae eeeed b ce, a f e e ed
F Na ae eeed a ee e ec. Tdae, e Lc Ma ad M F Na ae aeed
a e ce eece TLU adace e ed
ROW b ae ded ecfc fa Vaage
f c ca.
c) Vaage ce ee fa f e Lc Ma
ad M F Na egadg ecfc ac f e
ec e Abga g TLU. U c fa
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
58/64
58
ded, Vaage a cde ee
ga eae ae eed.
d) Peae ee e ee (b) abe.
e) Vaage ce ae egage ca e Lc Ma ad M F Na. A f e e ed
Abga g ae eeed ee e ec ad
fe ac e a f Vaage eed.
6.28
: Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, Ree 3.23, age 3940 (PDF
age 3940) [A1Z7T7]
: Te efeece ae a Vaage' Abga ca ga
a fced aeg e caac f eac ea affeced
Abga g acae eagf e ca
ce.
: Peae de e fg:
a) a f dec f e cea Vaage g ae e
caac f eac ea affeced Abga g
acae e ca ce;
b)
a a f Vaage e fa gde
fe ca Abga g; ad,
c)
a dec f Vaage a ccae
fa Abga g.
: a) c) Vaage de ae a ecfc cea ae caac b
dead a ag e caac eagf acae
e ca ce cde ag acce e
ec fa, a e a ecca eee ad faca
ece. Dg gg dc ad ca Abga g, Vaage ae acea a
eeece, f a, Abga g ae ad ee
deee ad e ad ga d geea. Weee
eeed, Vaage ccae eeeae f e
Abga g ae aed a e Abga
g deag e ec. Vaage a a, f
eae, ffeed ae eea ca
aaabe ea e e f eea e ad
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
59/64
59
de. Wee Abga g ae bed eaabe
ee f fdg de a eeg ad
deadg e Vaage Aca, ad ccag
e c egadg e ec, Vaage a
ded e eeed fdg.
6.29
: ) Vaage Adda We Edece, Abga Egagee
Pga Udae, age 27 (PDF age 27) [A1Z7Q0]
) NEB Fg Maa, Gde A, Tabe 5 Fg Reee f
ScEcc Eee
: Refeece () dcae a be f ea e ad cce
eec ada e ae bee defed b ea affecedg. Vaage a eeed a g c ae eeed
cce de Vaage a cea dea f ac befe
e ee f fd ef a Tada Kedge d (TKS)
ca be deeed.
Refeece () ae e NEB' eee f eg e ce
e f ad ad ece f ada e e ec aea.
: Peae de e fg:
a)
a f dec f a fa Vaage ee eAbga g de de f a cea dea
f ac be deeed;
b) a dec f Vaage a e fa
ded deee e ee f ea ec ac
e F Na' e f ad e c f e ec. If
a TKS d defg a ac, deag a
ee ae ac, be deae, eae de a
deaed dec f e edg a a bee
be ed, ad a aae;
c) a deaed dec f e ga eae a
adde a ea ac defed g fa
ded b e Abga g a e ee f Vaage,
abe; ad,
d) a deaed dec f Vaage adde a
adg e cce egadg ac ada
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
60/64
60
e b ea affeced Abga g.
: a) Te fa Vaage ee a Abga g
de de deae a ac cde:
a dec f e ecfc ce ada ad e;
e e f ea e e ce ada ad e
eeced;
e e g deae e ce
ada ad e; ad
a dec f e e Vaage ec a
efee d e ce ada ad e.
b) Vaage ee Abga g dg cfa de dc ad dead e ee f
ea ec ac e Abga g e f ad
e c f e ec. I e ace, ae a
eg a TKS, Vaage ad a Abga g ae ageed
egage a de d c cde eeg ec
a c ebe ad ede de
dead e ec a affec e Abga g. A
dc egadg ee a ecfc ga eae
ae eed a cc. A e e dceg e
e f e de d eeced be eaed.
c) Vaage a bee aded f a ecfc ac
Abga g ce ada ad e adace
e ec ROW. Teefe, dffc de a deaed
dec f ga eae c a be ed f
ea ac ae defed. Teeca, be
ga eae a cde adag e g f
cc ag ade e ee e
e ed ROW.
d) Vaage a bee aded f a ecfc ac
Abga g ce ada ad e adace
e ec ROW. Teefe, dffc ecae a
Vaage adde a adg e cce f
ea ac ae defed.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
61/64
61
6.30
: )
Vaage Pee Pec, V. 1, Sec 8 Lad, age 39 (PDF
age 47) [A1X5W0]
) Vaage Pee Pec, V. 2 ESA, Sec 15 ScEcc
Aee, age 361 (PDF age 2) [1561
: Refeece () ae a e ed e aee 7% f C
ad.
Refeece () ae a e Vaage ee e ce
Saacea Wdfe Maagee Ze 1, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9 ad 15.Ace ee e cde ag, g ad fg.
Ag Vaage a ded fa egadg ca
ad e ae (feed) ad, a ded
fa egadg ca ea ad e C
ad.
Te Bad e a g, ag, fg, gdg ad fg
Saacea ae egaed b e Saacea M f e
Ee adae cee ad ee ega
ca ee ace.
: Peae de a eed abe f a eeg ca
ace a ae ae ace e Saacea M f e
Ee ad a ad e egadg ad e C ad f
e ed Vaage Pee Pec, cdg:
a) e a ced, dae f eac cac ad ed f
cac (f eae eee, ea eeg, ea, ee
a);
b)
a a f e ad cce a ee defed eAca a adg gg, e e Vaage a
ae ae adde e e ad cce; ad,
c) a a f a e e ad cce a ae bee
aed ce e Aca a fed, e e Vaage a
ae ae adde ee e ad cce, ,
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
62/64
62
d) a eaa f e be ae adde a
aca cce.
: a) Peae ee e abe be.
Saacea
Lad Bac
(SLB) C
Leae Hde
ag e Rg
f Wa
Nebe
2010
Ogg
Pea
eeg ad
Pe ca
Lad Age eeeg Vaage
Pee ee C Lad Leae
de. Dg e gg eeg,
eac eae de ded ec
dec dce a e a e
acabe NEB bca. Leae de
ee eaee ageee
Vaage Pee a eeed ae.
Lad age cee Cceae eac eaede. Te
e f e cc eae
dce def cc
cce ad deee ce ad e.
Saacea
Tae
Aca
(STA)
Je 2, 2011 Pe Ca STA dcaed a STA de ae a
ee e Vaage Pee ec a
e g de affec aea
egeed STA ebe ce e f
ag.
Saacea
Wdfe
Fedea
(SWF)
Je 2, 2011 Pe Ca SWF dcaed a SWF aa
cceed ab e dfe aba.
STA a efeed Ge
Eea.
Saacea
Wdfe
Fedea
(SWF)
Je 2, 2011
Je 3, 2011
Pe ca
F ca
Ge eed STA' ca. Refeed
STA Wdfe ec ESA (Aed J).
F ca Je 3, 2011. STA
dcaed a e ESA addeed STA'
e.
Saacea
Lad Bac
(SLB)
J 19, 2011 Pe Ca SLB ade eae f agca
e . A ad e e a
e eae de, ee
a ace f C ad f ba
ce f e eae de. Te eae
de a e g de acce e
ad f e e f e ae
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
63/64
63
ageeabe.
Saacea
Ee
ad Rece
Maagee(SERM)
J 21, 2011 Pe
ca/Ea
Dced ec SERM. SERM
dcaed a SERM ade
dffee e f fg cee
e affeced Saacea WdfeMaagee Ze. Tee cee ae
ed Ofe f e e f
gdg f ga bd ad
Caada Rede e a dee. SERM
ded a f a ace eded
fe.
Saacea
Eded
Ofe
(Mga Bd
ad Caada
Rede
Wea)
36 Regeed
fe
affeced
Wdfe
Maagee
Ze
J
Seebe
2011
Pe
ca/Pea
Meeg
Vaage eeeae ae cg
fe def aea a ae
affeced b e ce g f e
ee. Wee e aea ae defed,
Vaage e fe
dee a a e dbace
ecfed g aea.
b) Peae ee e ee (a) abe. Vaage a ccef
eed a f e e ad e aed dg
ca ce C ad e. Te e ad
e a fced geea aec f e ec ad
a ee addeed b efeg ae fa
caed e Aca. I e ace ca
gg adde e ad cce aed.
c) Peae ee e ee (a) abe. Vaage adde a
e aed b egeed fe ad dee a a
e dbace g aea.
d) T dae, Vaage a eceed a ad e e a
cd be eed.
-
8/10/2019 B25-2 - Vantage Response to NEB IR No. 6 - A2A9S9 (2)
64/64
64
6.31 ()
: ) Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, Ree 3.26, age 4345
(PDF age 4345) [A1Z7T7]
)
Vaage Ree NEB IR N. 3, Ree 3.30, age 5051(PDF age 5051) [A1Z7T71
: Refeece () ae a Saacea Wdfe Fedea (SWF) a
cce egadg e aba ad Vaage cg
SWF gae ecfc cce.
Refeece () ae SFW ad e e egadg e effec f
e ec dfe aba ad a e cce ee addeed.
: Peae caf f a adda cce ae bee aed ea
adg SWF. If , decbe a cce ae bee aed ea adg, a ac ae ed dea e
cce, de a fca f ac eed.
: N adda cce ae bee aed ea adg
SWF.