![Page 1: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
BestAvailableTechniquesforWasteIncinera7on
LigheaSpeziale
16June2016,Ro6erdam 8thCEWEPWaste-to-EnergyCongress2016 1
![Page 2: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
Acronyms
![Page 3: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
TableofContents
Ø LegalFramework
Ø Howdoesthereviewwork?
Ø CriIcalaspectsoftheBREFWIReview
Ø Currentstatus
Ø CalibraIonstandard
3
![Page 4: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
TableofContents
Ø LegalFramework
4
![Page 5: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
LegalFrameworkIPPC (1996)
Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control (96/61/EC)
WID 2000 2nd Waste Incineration Directive (2000/76/EC )
IED (2010) (2010/75/EU)
5 other directives 5 other
directives 5 other
directives 4 other
directives
5
• prevent and, if not feasible, reduce pollution • high level of protection for the environment as a whole • Permits of plants based on Best Available Techniques (BAT)
BAT are determined by a Technical Working Group steered by the JRC (EIPPCB) and documented in BREFs
‘BAT conclusions’ are secondary legislation
LCP (2001) Large Combustion Plants (2001/80/EC)
![Page 6: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Revised BAT conclusions are the reference for setting/updating permit conditions (within four years from the publication)
“Permits to contain emission limit values (ELVs) to ensure that, under normal operating conditions, emissions do not exceed BAT-associated emission levels (BAT-AELs)”
Changesinthelegalframework
BAT Conclusions
Permit of WtE plant
6
![Page 7: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
TableofContentsØ Howdoesthereviewwork?
The “Sevilla process”: a complex consensus-building exchange of information with numerous stakeholders
and underpinned by sound techno-economic information that has been enshrined into law by:
Commission Implementing Decision 2012/119/EU
7
![Page 8: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Forum members: • guidance to COM • nominate in TWGs • formal opinion on BREFs
BREF authors team: • lead TWGs • validate/check information • draft BREFs
TWG members: • research information • peer review draft BREFs
Members of the Committee: • vote the BAT conclusions
CEWEP represented in the WI BREF TWG by 9 people, from the secretariat and the members (Itad, BW2E, Utilitalia, SVDU, Avfall Sverige)
Howdoesthereviewwork?
European IPPC Bureau (EIPPCB)
Technical Working Group (TWG)
• Industry • Member States
• NGOs • Commission
‘Forum’ (IED Article 13) lead by the Commission: industry, Member States, environmental NGOs
EU Member States Committee (IED Article 75)
8
![Page 9: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Industry EU Member States
+ EFTA and Accession Countries
Environmental NGOs European Commission/
EIPPCB
The‘Sevillaprocess’
Bulk of info. needed (incl. questionnaires)
Comments
BREF
• Forum opinion on BREF • Adoption of BAT
conclusions through the IED Art. 75 Committee
* D2 optional Total duration: • 24 – 29 months (without D2) • 29 – 39 months (with D2)
TWG Kick off Meeting
Draft 1 (D1)
Draft 2 (D2)*
Final TWG Meeting
Final draft BAT Conclu
sions BAT Conclusions
Howdoesthereviewwork?
9
![Page 10: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
• Participants: experts from CEWEP and ESWET members
• Chairs: Ella Stengler (CEWEP) and Edmund Fleck (MARTIN/ESWET)
• Observers: FEAD and Municipal Waste Europe (MWE)
• Regarding critical issues: JWG makes proposals which will be formally approved by the board of each association
CEWEP is involved in the Review as member of the TWG. The preparation for the work is developed within CEWEP – ESWET Joint Working Group (JWG) on BREF WI
Howdoesthereviewwork?
10
![Page 11: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
TableofContents
Ø CriIcalaspectsoftheBREFWIReview
11
![Page 12: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
BREFsreferonlytoEUlegisla7onbuttheyaredraJedfromdatadeliveredwithna7onal/regionalrules
TheBREFsmustbedrawnupEXCLUSIVELYincompliancewiththeEUregula7on*
And to make it more complicated… It is crucial to identify the national rules which may affect the nature of the data collected, e.g.: • How some data can be discarded from the yearly set in some MS • How is the confidence interval deducted • How are the Limits of Detection/Quantification taken into account • How is compliance checked (column A or B, 4-hr/60-hr counter…)
The experts involved in the review must clear their mind and disregard their national implementation rules
12*IED 2010/75/EU), Guidance (Annex to Decision 2012/119/EU), Monitoring ref. report (Revised final draft 2/2015)
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview1/
![Page 13: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
IEDGeneralregime:complianceinNormalOpera7ngCondi7ons(NOC)
IED does not define NOC nor OTNOC (Other Than Normal Operating Conditions) but gives examples of OTNOCs.
13
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview2/
IED special regime for incineration: compliance in Effective Operating Time (EOT)
VS
![Page 14: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
IEDGeneralregime:► ComplianceofemissionstoairassessedinNormalOpera7ng
Condi7ons(NOC)• IED,ArIcle15:“Thecompetentauthorityshallsetemissionlimitvaluesthatensurethat,undernormaloperaIng
condiIons,emissionsdonotexceedtheemissionlevelsassociatedwiththebestavailabletechniquesaslaiddowninthedecisionsonBATconclusionsreferredtoinArIcle13(5)…”
► BAT-AELsdefinedinNormalOpera7ngCondi7ons(NOC)• ArIcle3.13defines:“emissionlevelsassociatedwiththebestavailabletechniques'as'therangeofemissionlevelsobtained
undernormaloperaIngcondiIonsusingabestavailabletechniqueoracombinaIonofbestavailabletechniques,expressedasanaverageoveragivenperiodofIme,underspecifiedreferencecondiIons”.
IED does not define NOC nor OTNOC (Other Than Normal Operating Conditions) but gives examples of OTNOCs.
14
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview2/
![Page 15: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
EOT
All½-hrand10-minvalues*mustbecalculatedandcomplywithELVswithintheEffec7veOpera7ngTime(EOT)(AnnexVI,Part8,§1.2)“1.2.Thehalf-hourlyaveragevaluesandthe10-minuteaveragesshallbedeterminedwithintheeffec7veopera7ng7me(excludingthestart-upandshut-downperiodsifnowasteisbeingincinerated)(…)”
ü IEDdoesnotdefineEOT* By default, daily average values must comply with ELVs within EOT too Indeed Annex VI, Part 8, §1.2 adds: “The daily average values shall be determined from those validated average values.” (i.e. from the ½-hr values)
15
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview2/
IED special regime for incineration:
NOC
![Page 16: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
FutureBAT-AELsmustbehigherthanformerBAT-AELs
Set limits in the permits that do not exceed the BATAELs - Art. 15.3 of IED
IPPC IED
LIMIT according to WID 2000 The same values became Max ELVs (“Safety net”)
(mg/Nm3)
16
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview3/
IPPC-BATAELs = Typical LEVELS obtained in
operation when using BATs
IED-BATAELs = Ceiling for the ELVs set out in permits
New ceiling for permits
![Page 17: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
FormerBATAELsaretypicalvaluesmeasuredinopera7on
BATAEL (= LEVELs) Range according to 1st BREF
(IPPC regime)
mg/m3
0
17
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview3/
Maximal ELV (LIMIT) according to IED
Range of OBSERVED TYPICAL values (LEVELs)
![Page 18: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
FormerBATAELsarenotconsistentwithIED
BATAEL Range according to
1st BREF (IPPC regime)
mg/m3
0
Range of OBSERVED AVERAGE values (LEVELs)
Maximal ELV (LIMIT) according to IED
Art. 15.3 gives two options with the same results: (a) “ELVs that do not exceed the BATAELs” (b) “ELVs that ensure that the emissions do not exceed the BATAELs” 18
Cri7calaspectsoftheBREFWIReview3/
Under IED: this would become the range of NEW LIMITs (ELV) for the permits
NEWBATAELsmusttakeintoaccountMAXvalues
![Page 19: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
TableofContents
Ø CurrentstatusoftheReview
19
![Page 20: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Industry EU Member States
+ EFTA and Accession Countries
Environmental NGOs European Commission/
EIPPCB
Bulk of info. needed (incl. questionnaires)
Comments
BREF
• Forum opinion on BREF • Adoption of BAT
conclusions through the IED Art. 75 Committee
* D2 optional Total duration: • 24 – 29 months (without D2) • 29 – 39 months (with D2)
TWG Kick off Meeting
Draft 1 (D1)
Draft 2 (D2)*
Final TWG Meeting
Final draft BAT Conclu
sions BAT Conclusions
20
TheSevillaprocess
![Page 21: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Currentstatus:Datacollec7onBREFWIdatacollecIonclosedon15thApril2016(about300WIlines)
Austria 4%
Belgium 6%
Czech Republic
0.3%
Denmark 2%
Finland 3%
France 15%
Germany 34%
Italy 10%
Norway 2%
Poland 3%
Portugal 2%
Spain 6%
Sweden 2%
The Netherlands
2%
United Kingdom
9%
SeveralTWGmembers,includingCEWEP,requestedthattheEIPPCBorganiseaworkshopontheprocessingofthedatacollectedinordertoderiveBATconclusionsandBAT-AELs.CEWEPsecretariatwillworkoncheckingandprocessingthedatacollectedinordertohaveamethodologyathandtoderivesoundBAT-AELs.
![Page 22: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
► ToexpressBAT-AELsinconcentra7onsasadailyaverageorasanaverageoverthesamplingperioddependingontheavailabilityofconInuousmonitoringforagivenpollutant.
► SubjecttothedatacollecIon,wherepracIcableandjusIfied,toalsoexpressBAT-AELsinconcentra7onsashalf-hourlyaveragesforthosepollutantsmonitoredconInuously.
► TogatherinformaIononannualaverageemissionsinordertoupdateChapter3oftheWIBREF,butnottoexpressaddiIonallong-termaverageBAT-AELs(withthepossibleexcepIonofNOXandHg,subjecttodatacollecIon).
Currentstatus:Afewcertain7esDecisionsonBAT–AssociatedEmissionsLevels
22
![Page 23: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
► Toestablishaclearsystemboundary,includinge.g.definiIonsoftermsandcalculaIonmethodsused► Tocollectdataondesignenergyrecoveryvaluesoftheplantandonitsactualperformance,includinge.g.presenceofadistrictheaIng/coolingnetwork► TocollectdataontheenergyconsumpIonofincineraIonplants(e.g.energydemandandcombusIonofsupportfuels).► TosetBAT-AEPLsforthedesignofnewplantstobeverifiedduringtheperformancetes7ngandtoconsidersecngBAT-AEPLsbasedonactualperformanceforexis7ngplants.
Currentstatus:Afewcertain7esDecisionsonEnergyissues
The requirements on energy in the old BREF will not be used in the revised BREF
23
![Page 24: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
TableofContents
LegalFrameworkHowdoesthereviewwork?CriIcalaspectsoftheBREFWIReviewWherearewe?ThepointofviewoftheoperatorsofWtEplantsinEurope
***ProposalforBATAELsderivaIonStudyonoperaIonaldataØ CalibraIonstandard
![Page 25: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Calibra7onstandard
IEDArt.70(3).MonitoringshallbecarriedoutinaccordancewithCENstandards[…]
WIplantsareequippedwithAutomatedMeasuringSystems(AMS)thathavetobecalibratedaccordingtoCENstandards.EN14181specifiesproceduresforQualityAssuranceLevels(QAL)forAMS:
► Aprocedure(QAL2)tocalibratetheAMSanddeterminethevariabilityofthemeasuredvaluesobtainedbyit
► Aprocedure(QAL3)tomaintainanddemonstratetherequiredqualityofthemeasurementsresults
► AprocedurefortheAnnualSurveillanceTest(AST)oftheAMStoevaluatethatitfuncIonscorrectlyanditsperformanceremainsvalidandthatitscalibraIonfuncIonandvariabilityremainaspreviouslydetermined.
IEDAnnexVI,Part6.1.2&1.3
QAL2procedureslinktheassessmentoftheAMSperformancewiththe
measureuncertaintyattheleveloftheELVappliedfortheplant.Thefactthat
calibraIonandvariabilityareinfluencedbythevalueoftheELV
meansthatthereisaminimumELVtoavoidthefailureofthemeasurement
equipment.
![Page 26: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Calibra7onstandard
BATAEL Range according to
1st BREF (IPPC regime)
mg/m3
0
Range of OBSERVED AVERAGE values (LEVELs)
IED ELV (LIMIT)
NEW LIMITs (ELV) for the permits
AccepIngthatoperaIonalvalues(usuallyverylow,especiallyforWIplants)becomethebasistoset
limitsinthefuturepermitscarrieswithintheriskoffailuretocomply
withmonitoringrequirements.
BATAELs ranges have to be checked by the CEN TC 264 before they are set in the revised BREF WI.
![Page 27: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Calibra7onstandard–INERISstudy
CEWEPandotherassociaIonsaskedINERIStoinvesIgatehowcalibraIonstandardsinfluencetheseqngofELVsandhowmuchtheycanbeloweredwithoutcausingmeasuringsystemstofail.Sinceemissionsmeasurementscomewithununcertainty,whichbecomesmoreimportant–asarelaIvevalue–whenthemeasurementsarecloseto0,wecallupondecision-makerstobecauIouswhenchoosingELVswithinthenewly-definedBATAELrangesintheBREFs,becauseloweringELVsrisksfailingcalibraIonofmonitoringinstruments.
![Page 28: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
KeyMessages
BAT-AELs• TobederivedinEOT• Methodtobediscussedwith
theTWGandnotclosedbox• HavetobesetfromMax
values• Rangecannotbetoowide
(endlessdiscussions)• Thelowerendcannotbethe
lowestvaluereported
DataCollec7on• Largedatabase–virtuallyall
theEUplants• Nodisregardofoutliers• CompaIbilitycheckwith
calibraIonstandards
28
![Page 29: Best Available Techniques for Waste ... - Waste-to-energy · Draft 1 (D1) Draft 2 (D2)* Final TWG Meeting Final draft BAT Conclu BAT sions Concl usions How does the review work? 9](https://reader035.vdocument.in/reader035/viewer/2022071001/5fbd954319171737aa60328c/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Survived!
Thankyou!
Questions?