Captology
2
Contents
Captology Computerized persuasive
techniques Ethics of persuasion Science of persuasion Credibility
3
Captology
Captology is derived from “Computers as Persuasive Technologies”
It is the study of how computers can be used to persuade people to ater their behaviour or opinions
It draws heavily on research on persuasion in psychology and marketing
4
Intentionality Persuasive technologies are those which
intend to be persuasive The introduction of the automobile caused
the development of suburbs, but that was not the intention of introducing automobiles
Computers have no intent themselves, they simply reflect the intent of the people who create them and the programs which run on them
5
Types of Intent Endogenous
Intent comes from the people who produce the technology
Exogenous Intent comes from people who give the technology to
others to distribute This is the case when large companies distribute
persuasive technologies Autogenous
Intent comes from the user’s themselves The user has decided to use a device to modify
his/her own behaviour
6
Functional Roles
Computers can act in several roles when they are used for persuasion Tools Media Social actors
7
Computers as Tools The computer provides the user with
new capabilities so that they can do things they could not otherwise
Tools can be persuasive by Reducing barriers so that certain behaviours
are promoted Making certain behaviours seem achievable Providing information for informed decisions Shaping a person’s mental model
8
Computers as Tools
An example of a persuasive tool is A heart rate monitor Can be preset to notify the user when
heart rate goes too high or low Modifies user behaviour by providing
feedback not available without the device
9
Computers as Persuasive Media One example
A computerized exhibit at the San Francisco Exploratorium allows people to make various choices about sexual behaviour
The program then shows them the consequences of their behaviour
This is an educational medium which seeks to influence behaviour by demonstrating the dangers of various behaviours
10
Computers as Social Actors
In this role, the computer acts as a character which tries to influence behaviour
Example A children’s computer game has a
central character who encourages the children to eat their fruits and vegetables
11
Persuading Groups Persuasive technology need not affect just
the individual Family’s can be persuaded by family
entertainment software Company employees can be persuaded by
software in the workplace that reminds them of good behaviour that the company wants to encourage
All users of a software product receive notices of new versions in the hope that they will upgrade
12
Domains for Persuasive Technologies Safety
Safe driving, using bike helmets, using bike helmets, Substance abuse
Environment Recycling Conservation Bicycle commuting
Personal Management Time management Study habits Personal finance
Marketing Selling products
13
Contents
Captology Computerized persuasive
techniques Ethics of persuasion Science of persuasion Credibility
14
Just in Time Persuasion Many decisions are made at the last minute Decisions on what food to purchase are
often made at the grocery store Handheld devices that offer nutritional
advice can persuade the user to make healthier choices
This type of persuasion will work best when the suggestions are made on the spot
15
Comparison Shopping When a new product is introduced, it
is difficult to attract the customer Many websites resort to comparison
charts showing their product vs. their competitors’
This provides the customer with the evidence to make an informed decision and purchase their product
16
Simulating Experience Another way to persuade the users is to
simulate an experience for them One study used a computerized baby
doll to simulate an infant It cried and required constant attention
from the people caring for it The goal was to demonstrate to teens
what having a child is like and to persuade them to act in a sexually responsible manner
17
Personalization People pay more attention to
information when it is personalized for them
www.scorecard.org provides information on pollution
It allows the user to enter their zip code and provides information on their area
This is far more relevant than information at the national level
18
Recommendation
Many e-commerce web sites use recommendation as a persuasion technique The user is asked a series of
questions about their requirements They are then presented with a list of
products that meet their needs
19
Automated Collaborative Filtering This is a way of recommending
products, not on their attributes, but based on the preferences of people similar to you Create a profile of the user Find another user with a similar profile Recommend what they bought to the user
This has proven to be a successful strategy
20
Monitoring and Tracking This monitors the users behaviour
and recommends changes It is used by companies to ensure
that employees wash hands after using the washroom
It’s use is highly controversial as it is seen as an invasion of privacy or as Big Brother
21
Competition Most people are motivated to win
competitions Some online bidding sites structure
bidding as a competition between bidders
One is told the bid of the other and encouraged to win by beating the competing bid
22
Contents
Captology Computerized persuasive
techniques Ethics of persuasion Science of persuasion Credibility
23
The Ethics of Persuasion Persuasion raises many ethical concerns
It can be used on unsuspecting parties Untrue statements can be used to persuade Persuasion can be directed towards minors Persuasion can be done surreptitiously Persuasion can be done for the good of the
persuader, not the one being persuaded
24
Ethical Guidelines
Daniel Berdichevsky has proposed The motivations and intended outcome
of persuasion should not be unethical The persuasive techniques should be
visible to the users The creators of persuasive technology
should be aware of all predictable outcomes of the use of their technology
25
Ethical Guidelines The creators should respect the
privacy of the users Inaccurate information should not be
presented to achieve the persuasive goal
Users who would not consent to being persuaded should not be persuaded
26
Contents
Captology Computerized persuasive
techniques Ethics of persuasion Science of persuasion Credibility
27
The Science of Persuasion Have you ever been tricked into
saying yes? Have you ever bought something
you didn’t really want? If so, then it is time to understand
the science of persuasion We will look at six techniques
based on human psychology
28
Reciprocation When people are given something, they
feel an obligation to repay what they have received The Disabled American Veterans appealed for
contributions and got an 18% response They gave free address labels with their
request and the response doubled to 35% Offer free samples, free evaluation, or
free anything and you increase the likelihood the customer will buy from you
29
Consistency People tend to act in a consistent
manner A charity for the handicapped got potential
donors to sign a petition to support handicapped in the neighbourhood
Later they asked for donations and received far more than before they had started the petition
Once people pledge their support for something they will continue to act that way
30
Consistency Once people make a public commitment,
even a minor one, they tend to honour it A restaurant was plagued with people who
made reservations but did not show up They changed their message from
“please call if you cannot make it” to “Will you please call if you cannot make it”? And
waited for a response The number of no-shows dropped to near zero
Once people make a commitment, they tend to do what they said they would
31
Social Validation If people see a lot of others doing
something they assume it is a good idea and do it too One man stops on a street and looks at the
sky Other people simply step around him
15 people stop and look at the sky Everyone else on the street looks at the sky
to see what is happening
32
Social Validation
If you can show that Large numbers of people have bought
your product Large numbers visit your web site Many people recommend your service
Then prospective customers will assume that you must be worth doing business with
33
Liking People are more easily persuaded by
people they like People take advice from friends People buy more from attractive sales
people People vote for politicians who are better
looking Show attractive people selling and using
your products
34
Authority People respond to authority
If the man who stops to look at the sky is wearing a suit and tie more people will look at the sky
If you say, “more doctors recommend…” more people will pay attention
The problem with following authority is that few bother to discover if the authority is credible
35
Scarcity People want items more if they know
there is a scarcity of the item Sales people call customers to sell beef Then they call and tell them there is a
shortage of Australian beef and this is one of the last shipments
Sales double instantly Mark your products “last stock before
Xmas” or “with high sales volume, stock will be gone by the end of the week”
36
Knowledge is Power
These characteristics evolved in humans as they usually benefits to people living in groups
Successful people in sales and marketing know these characteristics
They also use them to best advantage in their daily business
37
Contents
Captology Computerized persuasive
techniques Ethics of persuasion Science of persuasion Credibility
38
Credible Computing
In the beginning, computers were thought to be infallible and all was believed
This is still true, but as people find more incorrect information on line, they start to doubt
39
What Affects Credibility?
Trustworthiness Whether the viewer believes what you
say Largely depends on whether you have
been right in the past Expertise
The higher expertise you can claim in an area the more likely you are to be believed
40
What Affects Credibility?
Layout Cool color tones Balanced layout of the interface
41
Regaining Credibility
You can regain lost credibility by Delivering reliable information over a
long period of time Delivering the same incorrect
information repeatedly so that users ignore it and gain trust in the rest of the information