Download - Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
1/22
UNIVERSIDAD NACIONALUNIVERSIDAD NACIONALDE INGENIERADE INGENIERA
Facultad de IngenieraFacultad de Ingeniera
Industrial y de SistemasIndustrial y de Sistemas
.
Ing. Margarita D. Mondragn
MarzoMarzo Julio 2009Julio 2009
M I C R O E C O N O M I AM I C R O E C O N O M I A
Clase 5, Abril 13,2009
1
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
2/22
HalVarian on how the Web challenges managers
Googles chief economist says executives in wired organizations need a sharper
understanding of how technology empowers innovation.
http://www.mckinseyquarterly.com/Strategy/Innovation/Hal_Varian_on_how_the_
Web_challenges_managers_2286
Article
Interactive: Hal Varian on how the Web challenges managers
JANUARY 2009
Source: Business Technology Office
2
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
3/22
More than ten years into the widespread business adoptionof the Web, some managers still fail to grasp the economicimplications of cheap and ubiquitous information on and
about their business.Hal Varian, professor of information sciences, business,and economics at the University of California at Berkeley,says its imperative for managers to gain a keener understanding of the potential for technology toreconfigure their industries.Varian, currently serving as Google's chief economist,compares the current period to previous times of industrialization when new technologies combined to
create ever more complex and valuable systemsand thusreshaped the economy.Varian spoke with McKinseys James Manyika, a director inthe San Francisco office, in Napa, California, in October2008.Watch the video or read the transcript of his comments below. 3
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
4/22
On flexible innovation
Were in the middle of a period that I refer to as a period ofcombinatorial innovation. So if you look historically,youll find periods in history where there would be theavailability of a different component parts that innovators
could combine or recombine to create new inventions. Inthe 1800s, it was interchangeable parts. In 1920, it waselectronics. In the 1970s, it was integrated circuits.
Now what we see is a period where you have Internetcomponents, where you have software, protocols,languages, and capabilities to combine these componentparts in ways that create totally new innovations. The greatthing about the current period is that component parts are
all bits. 4
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
5/22
That means you never run out of them.
You can reproduce them, you can duplicate them, you
can spread them around the world, and you can havethousands and tens of thousands of innovatorscombining or recombining the same component partsto create new innovation.
So theres no shortage. There are no inventory delays.Its a situation where the components are available foreveryone, and so we get this tremendous burst of innovation that were seeing.
5
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
6/22
On corporations andwork
The question is, What are other periods where we sawtechnology influence the way organizations work?One nice example comes from the works of AlfredChandler, where he describes how the telegraph and
the railroad had a big impact on the development of themodern corporation.And this was a synergistic operation: one, you had tohave a large organization to manage thesetechnologies, and two, you had to have the
communications and transportation infrastructure toenable the management at a distance.
So I think now, with what were seeing with mobility,
were going to have a totally different concept of what itmeans to go to work.6
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
7/22
The work goes to you, and youre able to deal with yourwork at any time and any place, using the infrastructurethats now become available.
At the base, theres the innovation infrastructure makingbetter, faster, cheaper networks. Theres the improvementin the humancomputer interface because the big
challenge in mobile communication has always beendealing with thisquite limitedinterface.
But then, the kinds of innovations I think will arise on topof that will be innovations in how work is done. And thats
going to be one of the most exciting aspects, in myopinion.
If you look at the beginning of the 20th century, we saw the
rise of mass production. 7
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
8/22
Henry Ford and the entire team were down on thefactory floor raising this, lowering that, speeding up
the assembly line, changing the way things werebuilt, and were able to extract far more efficienciesthan were available before.
I think the same thing is happening now with digital
technology.
When were all networked, we all have access to thesame documents, to the same capabilities, to this
common infrastructure, and we can improve theway workintellectual work, knowledge workflows through the organization. And again, in myopinion, that will lead to a substantial advantage interms of productivity.
8
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
9/22
On free goods and valueBack in the early days of the Web, every document had
at the bottom, Copyright 1997. Do not redistribute. Nowevery document has at the bottom, Copyright 2008.Click here to send to your friends.
So theres already been a big revolution in how we view
intellectual property. So its not so much the question ofwhats owned or whats not owned. Its a question of howcan you leverage the assets you have to realize the mostvalue.
I think that the availability of these very inexpensiveplatforms youre creating, in disseminating content,means that its become intensely competitive. Thecontent is as valuable as it ever was, its just thecompetition thats pushed the prices down to something
that approximates zero. 9
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
10/22
So its not something that the content producersnecessarily embrace, but its something theyre forced intoby the nature of the technological change.
In these models, there is typically a revenue-generatingcomponent somewhere in the value chain.
And most commonly today were seeing it on the
advertising side.To look at this from a historical perspective, its really notso new.If you look at the 1920s, the technological question in the
20s was, H
ow can we build a business model aroundbroadcast radio?And nobody really had a good idea. And back in the mid-1990s we asked, How can we build a business modelaround the Internet? And the preferred model at the time
was a micropayments system. 10
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
11/22
That never happened, for some reasons, but what didhappen instead is we moved into the advertising model,
and the advertisings model been phenomenallysuccessful.We have to look at todays economy and say, What is itthats really scarce in the Internet economy? And theanswer is attention.
[Psychologist] Herb Simon recognized this many yearsago. He said, A wealth of information creates a povertyof attention.So being able to capture someones attention at the righttime is a very valuable asset. And Google really has builtan entire business around this, because were capturingyour attention when youre doing a search for somethingyoure interested in. Thats the ideal time to show you anadvertisement for a product that may be related or
complimentary to what your search is all about. 11
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
12/22
On workers andmanagersI keep saying the sexy job in the next ten years will be
statisticians.People think Im joking, but who wouldve guessed thatcomputer engineers wouldve been the sexy job of the1990s?The ability to take datato be able to understand it, toprocess it, to extract value from it, to visualize it, tocommunicate itthats going to be a hugely importantskill in the next decades, not only at the professional levelbut even at the educational level for elementary school
kids, for high school kids, for college kids.Because now we really do have essentially free andubiquitous data.So the complimentary scarce factor is the ability to
understand that data and extract value from it. 12
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
13/22
I think statisticians are part of it, but its just a part. Youalso want to be able to visualize the data, communicatethe data, and utilize it effectively.
But I do think those skillsof being able to access,understand, and communicate the insights you get fromdata analysisare going to be extremely important.Managers need to be able to access and understand the
data themselves.You always have this problem of being surrounded byyes men and people who want to predigest everythingfor you.
In the old organization, you had to have this whole armyof people digesting information to be able to feed it to thedecision maker at the top.But thats not the way it works anymore: the informationcan be available across the ranks, to everyone in the
organization. 13
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
14/22
And what you need to ensure is that people haveaccess to the data they need to make their day-to-day
decisions.
And this can be done much more easily than it couldbe done in the past.
And it really empowers the knowledge workers towork more effectively.
14
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
15/22
On computermonitoringandrisks
One of the really interesting phenomena thats beengoing on in the last 20 years is what I call computer-mediated transactions.
So now, in the middle of almost every transaction fromperson to person or organization to organization, theresa computer.
And the computer can monitor that transaction, recordthe information, collect the data, and assure that the
transaction is carried out the way it was intended to becarried out.
So one of the subtle implications of this is you can nowwrite contracts and make contracts enforceable that
simply werent enforceable before. 15
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
16/22
Let me give you an example.
Suppose you go rent a car and they say, Hey, wellgive you $10 off if you dont go over the speed limit.Well, that might sound like a good deal, but whats tokeep you from going over the speed limit?
Well, the answer is now theyve got a transponder inthe trunk and it will monitor your behavior and chargeyou accordingly.
And the same thing happens with semitrucks: virtually
every semi on the road today has a computer in it.
And that computer improves the logistics. It monitorsthe performance of the driver and it helps things get to
the consumer more quickly. 16
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
17/22
So there are a lot of capabilities of that sort that allow youto contract on terms that were just not available to you
before.
[At the same time,] you get a new technology in andpeople are excited about the positive sides of it.
Then you see there are also some negative aspects.
And youll have a regulatory infrastructure that arises todeal with those.
I think everybody is very excited about the intendedaspects of this technologythe fact that you canpersonalize, the fact that you can monitor, the fact thatyou can provide products that are more closely suited toa consumers interests and needs.
17
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
18/22
What people are worried about are the unintended
consequences, the downsides, the negative sides, thesecurity, the identity theft, the possibility of extortionor embarrassment.
These are the problems: not what people wantto do
but what couldhappen if these technologies werentappropriately managed.
18
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
19/22
On reshaping industries
Were obviously going to see enormous change in the
traditional marketing industry.You look at TV, you look at print, you look at radio andother media of that sort. On the Internet, weve learned tomeasure advertising effectiveness, and the challenge nowis to move those same effectiveness measures over to theoffline media.
That can be done. I think were going to see vastimprovements in how those industries function in thefuture.
And in general, if we look at service industrieswell,everybody I think is in agreement that were going to seelots of efficiency improvements in services, because we
do have this network capability. 19
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
20/22
We have the technological infrastructure.We can improve communication flows.
The second beneficiaries of that will be with serviceindustries whove already seen a lot of advances inmanufacturing productivity. And the tough nut is the onewere working on cracking now.
What I actually work on to a large extent is a currentfeeding of the auction model that we have at Google.
As you know, all of our ads are sold by auction. Thats arelatively novel pricing mechanism in the ad world. And
therere a lot of intricacies that involve how you managethat.
Wed like to extend that model to the offline world: to
radio, TV, print, and other media. 20
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
21/22
Its a model that was enabled by the Internet. Its notsomething you couldve done without that informationtechnology there. And its a great model for all sorts of
resource allocation issues.I think the people who originally designed the modelway back in 2001 had a very, very useful insight.
They recognized that the content provider hasimpressions to sell.
So youve got some space in your TV show. Youve gotsome space on your page. Youve got some spacethats available to put an ad.
But what the advertiser wants to pay for is clicks orconversions or visits.
So they dont really care how many impressions theyshow. 21
-
8/8/2019 Clase 5 Hal Varian Web in Business 2009
22/22
Normally, what they care about is getting people
into their store and, ultimately, getting people topurchase.
So you have to build a system that allows thepublisher to sell impressions but the advertiser tobuy clicks.
And I think weve managed to accomplish that in anice, elegant way.
22