Click to edit Master title style Click to edit Master subtitle style
Conducting An Accident Investigation
Paul Cox Senior Air Safety Investigator
Eastern Region
2
Additional Purposes of this Presentation
• To note that just because the NTSB, BEA, AAIB, TSB, etc. does something a certain way, it might not be your way.
• However, it should be noted that there ARE common practices, which then used by most States to enhance communications.
• To give you ideas.
3
• Man, Machine, Environment
4
What is an Accident?
5
What is an Accident?
An occurrence associated with the operation of an aircraft which:
• Takes place between the time any person boards
the aircraft with the intention of flight and all such persons have disembarked, and in which
• Any person suffers death or serious injury, or in which
• The aircraft receives substantial damage
• Missing aircraft?
6
Unmanned Aircraft
An occurrence associated with the operation of any public or civil unmanned aircraft system that takes place between the time that the system is activated with the purpose of flight and the time that the system is deactivated at the conclusion of its mission, in which: 1. Any person suffers death or serious injury; or 2. The aircraft has a maximum gross takeoff weight of 300 pounds or greater and sustains substantial damage.
Serious Injury Any injury which: Requires hospitalization for more than 48 hours, commencing within 7 days of the date that the injury was received; Results in a fracture of any bone (except simple fractures of fingers, toes, or nose); Causes severe hemorrhages, nerve, muscle, or tendon damage; Involves any internal organ or; Involves 2nd or 3rd degree burns, or burns affecting more than 5% of the body surface
8
Substantial Damage
Substantial Damage is… Damage or failure which: • Adversely affects the structural
strength, performance, or flight characteristics of the aircraft, and which
• Would normally require major repair or replacement of the affected component
Substantial Damage is not… • Engine failure or damage limited to
an engine if only one engine fails or is damaged,
• Bent fairings or cowling • Dented skin • Small punctured holes in the skin
or fabric • Ground damage to rotor or
propeller blades • Damage to landing gear, wheels,
tires, flaps, engine accessories, brakes, or wingtips are not considered “substantial damage” for the purpose of this part.
Incident Investigation • U.S. - “An incident is an occurrence
other than an accident, associated with the operation of an aircraft, which affects or could affect the safety of operations.”
• ICAO – Same, except a “Serious Incident” involved circumstances indicating a high probability of an accident . Attachment C of Annex 13 lists examples.
10
Special Notification and Reporting
The operator of an aircraft shall immediately and by the most expeditious means available notify the nearest NTSB Field Office when an aircraft accident or any of the following incidents occur:
11
• Flight control system malfunction
• Inability of any crew member to perform normal flight duties as a result of injury or illness
• Uncontained engine failure (turbine) • Release of propeller blade • Failure of 50% of EFIS, PFD, etc. • TCAS resolution advisory with risk of
collision
Important to Adequately Assess Level of Effort for Each Case •
Public Visibility
Complexity Injury Severity
Public Trust
Fleet Issues
13
Accident?
14
Accident?
15
Accident?
16
Accident or Incident?
17
Accident or Incident?
18
Accident?
19
Accident?
20
Accident or Incident?
21
Accident?
22
23
24
Break
• So, you got yourself an accident…
• Let’s start with the big picture…
Questions for the “Big Picture” • What?
• When?
• Where?
• Who?
• Challenges/Dangers?
Where can I get more information?
• First responders/local law enforcement/on-scene commander?
• Press?
• Internet?
• Other government agencies?
Who do I need to contact? • On-scene commander?
• Other government agencies?
• State of manufacture/design/etc.?
• Boss?
When can I get there? • Where is it?
– Distance? – Busy area/must be moved?
• What means of transport?
• What are the barriers to a quick response?
• When do I have to be there?
– Degree of interest? – Political interest?
30
Response Time
What do I need to take with me? • Environment?
• Type of accident?
• Luggage limits?
• Paperwork?
32
Go-Bag Equipment
33
Credentials
34
Mode of Transportation
35
Jump seat
• Official business only
• “Must Ride” only to the site
• Dress & act appropriately
Jump seat
What about the victims? • When can they be moved?
– Is it safe to move them? – How will it affect your investigation? – Is removal needed quickly?
• Local concerns? • Religious concerns?
• Where will they go? • Autopsy/toxicology? • Family concerns?
What about the wreckage? • Dangers?
• Burnt?
• Location?
• Need to move?
38
On-Scene Management
• Large vs. Small
• Residential vs. Remote
• Assistance vs. No Assistance
• Wreckage Examination
• Time & People Management
39
Major “Stake Down”
• Make your presence known
• Wreckage preservation
• Initial photo documentation
• Extract & secure FDR/CVR
• Press may be optional
• Brief the additional investigation team members
On-Scene Management - People • Bringing order out of chaos….
• Investigative Team
– NTSB • Specialists • Group Chairmen
– Parties – Accredited Representatives
• Advisors
• Other Participants/Responders
41
Other Responders
• Local authorities/politicians
• Insurance adjusters
• Recovery personnel
• News media
• Families of the victims
42
Local Authorities
• The incident commander
• On-site safety
• On-site security
• Attitude and cooperation
• All politics are local
• Witness statements
43
Insurance Adjusters
What information do they want… • Information
What they can provide… • Financial resources • Assistance with wreckage
that is difficult to access • Pilot background information
44
Dealing With Insurance Adjusters
Do… • Allow them to establish that
this is their claim (let them see the logbooks)
• Tell them your plans • Release wreckage to them
with the approval of owner (if possible)
• Provide them the same factual information as the family and the press
• Allow them to quickly photograph the site under your supervision
Do Not… • Allow them to participate in
the investigation (no observers)
• Discuss possible cause • Provide them with
photographs or let them see your photographs
Recovery Personnel • Normally selected by insurance adjuster
• Normally has secure storage facility
• What the options if insurance can not be
determined? – Recovery personnel willing to take risk – Local/police recovery – Leave it
46
News Media • Not your enemy, not your friend; they also have job to do • Take control • Coordinate briefing times (might ask when they need it) • Discuss processes • Could prepare/read a statement • Facts only • Could involve headquarters Public Affairs • State preliminary report will be available in 10 days • Practice beforehand!
Parties to the Investigation – Why?
• Force multipliers • Possess unique knowledge/technical expertise • Participant specific • Can effect positive change within their organization • Cannot withhold information • Full time employees • Responsive to NTSB personnel
Parties to the Investigation • May work for IIC or Group Chairman • Must work under direction of IIC/Group Chairman • Release of factual information to outside by
appropriate NTSB personnel only • Opportunity to review factual information and can
submit proposed conclusions and safety recommendations
• Cannot be litigants, must be full time • FAA always a party; others (manufacturers,
unions, etc.) determined by IIC.
49
Coordination of Parties/Specialists
Organizational Chart: Regional Investigation
NTSB IIC
NTSB Specialists
FAA
Engine
Airframe
Component
Manufacture Operator AccRep/Other Government
Agency
50
Coordination of Parties/Specialists
Organizational Chart: Major Investigation
Board Member
PA/TDA
NTSB IIC
NTSB Group Chairman
Systems
Structures
Maintenance
Powerplant
Operations
ATC
Weather
Human Performance
Human Factors
Recorders
Party Coordinators/AccRep
FAA
Airframe
Powerplant
Operator
Unions
Other Government
Agency
Deputy IIC
On-Scene Goal
• Collect Perishable Information – Environment – Wreckage Path (Direction & Angle)
• Tree Strikes/De-foliage – Four Corners – Flight Control Continuity – Evidence of Engine Power – Recorders; GPS/NVM; Video – Witness Interviews – Forensics
52
A Documentation Procedure
• Aerial photographs
• Out to In
• Aircraft four corners
• Compass Rose • Four cardinal points • 15 Degree segments
53
Aerial Photos
54
Wreckage Documentation
Glasgow, Montana (-35 degrees F), Cessna 182G
• Flags
• Measuring tape
• GPS
• Pacing off
55
Wreckage Documentation
Wreckage Diagramming Grid • Straight-line • Most Common
Polar • Compact accident sites • “Smoking hole” accident sites
56
ATM/Security Cameras
57
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
58
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
59
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
60
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
61
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
62
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
63
Wreckage Documentation/Photos
64
Cut Branches
Clean, 45-degree cut usually means power
65
Ground Scars
66
Wreckage Distribution Pattern - Wide
67
Wreckage Distribution Pattern - Localized
68
Wreckage Dristribution
69
Wreckage Distribution – In-Flight Breakups
70
Wreckage Distribution – Mid-Air Collisions
71
Helicopters
• Many of the same principles apply
• Rotating parts can give qualitative assessment if engine(s) were running or not at impact
• Other evidence may be contradictory
Helicopters
Check for witness marks on airframe structure from rotating engine and drive train components
Helicopters
Rub mark on skin from coupling
Helicopters
Scoring marks from coupling on adjacent structure
Helicopters/Rotorcraft • Main rotor blade coning indicates
low rotor rpm. • Possible loss of power • Possible loss of airspeed
(gyroplanes)
Semi-Rigid - Teetering Rotors
• During low g maneuvering, the rotor system does not control the fuselage.
• The fuselage can assume a position controlled by momentum and tail rotor thrust.
• This can result in the blade roots contacting the main rotor mast (Mast bumping) or the blade tips contacting the tail rotor boom.
Taking Good Photos
• Be systematic
• Establish a flow (out-in, circle, left-right, etc.) • Framing the subject
• Capture orientation of subject with respect to wreckage/terrain
• Take LOTS of photos from different
perspectives
• A rough diagram will help you remember what is what
• Check the quality of your photos before departing
78
79
80
81
82
Photo Orientation
83
Photo Orientation
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
Cockpit Examination
• Instrument Panels • Needle Slap Marks
• Throttle Quadrant
• Avionics
• Non-volatile memory
• Annunciators • Light bulb analysis
91
92
Cabin Examination
• Seats & Cargo Restraint System
• Survivability Concerns
93
Seats and Restraints
94
Seat Tracks
95
Flight Control Continuity
• Control Cable Continuity
• Trim Tab Actuators
• Flap Drive Mechanism
96
Flight Control Continuity
97
Flight Control Continuity
98
Landing Gear
• Drive Mechanisms
• Up Locks & Down Locks
• Tires • Brakes
99
Fuel System • Vegetation browning
• Fuel type & quality
• Fuel gages
• Tanks
• Fuel caps and venting
• Pumps
• Engine driven • Boost
• Selector valves
100
Electrical System
• Circuit Breakers
• Switches
• Wiring
101
Wreckage Examination
• Instrument Gyros
• Pitot Tube
• Static Port
• Vacuum Port
Pitot-Static System
102
Gyros
103
Other Systems
• De-ice
• Pressurization
• Hydraulic
• Autopilot
104
On-scene Duties
Move & Examen Wreckage
105
On-scene Duties
Wreckage Recovery – Perhaps
106
On-scene Duties
Wreckage Recovery
107
On-scene Duties
Interviewing witnesses
108
Interviewing
Interviewing
“Any person interviewed by an authorized representative of the Board during the investigation, regardless of the form of the interview has the right to be accompanied, represented, or advised by an attorney or non-attorney representative.” (49 CFR Part 831.7)
Rights of Interviewees
109
Interviewing
• Grant Immunity from Prosecution
• Assure Confidentiality
Investigators Cannot…
Interviewing
110
Interviewing
• Locating witnesses
• Types of witnesses
• Participants • Eyewitnesses • Background witnesses
• Characteristics
• Age • Professional background
Interviewing
111
Interviewing
• Problems to expect
• Reprisal • Intimidation/Embarrassment • Expectations/Perceptions
• Interview settings
• People • Location • Preparation
Interviewing
112
Interviewing
• Interview details
• Time • Establish rapport • Written statement
• Interview questions
• Non-questions • Leading, Directed, General
Interviewing
Post On-Scene Aids • Radar, GPS/NVM Processing • Radio Tapes/Transcripts/ATC Studies • FAA Documents • Pilot Records/Pilot Operator Report • Maintenance Records • Medical Records • Pilot/Maintenance Manuals • Toxicology • Component Teardowns/Testing • Human Factors/Fatigue Studies • Performance Studies
Investigation Process • On Scene Investigative Duties • Press/Family • Insurance Coordination • Wreckage Disposition • Internal Admin Functions • Preliminary Report • Follow-up Exams/Testing/Studies • Factual Report • Proposed Brief/Analysis, PC • Public Docket (Includes Redaction of Personal Data) • Peer Review • Party Review • Supervisor Approval • HQ Approval
115
On-scene
Investigation Organizational
Meeting Groups and
Parties Progress meetings
Family Briefings Media Briefings
Preliminary report Factual
information
Investigative Hearings Fact finding Depositions Witnesses
Docket
Board Meeting
Docket Findings
Conclusions Probable Cause
Safety Recommendations
Final Report
Government in the Sunshine Act
Investigative Process - Majors
116
On-scene
Investigation Organizational
Meeting Groups and
Parties Documentation
Progress meetings Family Briefings Media Briefings
Preliminary report Factual
information
Follow-up Duties
Fact finding Examinations
Testing Additional Witnesses Wreckage Disposal
Factual Report
Docket
Proposed Analysis Proposed
Probable Cause Safety Initiatives
Final Report
Government in the Sunshine Act
Investigative Process - Regionals
Investigator Tool Kit
• Includes…
• Checklists that may be of some help