-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
1/78
!"#$#
"%%&
''
()
* )
* + * ,
* -
./
0
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
2/78
"
!"!
#$
"%&
0 1(../ 23(/456
7+423(/489
0 1(...:.4456
; 1(....
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
3/78
&
'()*+
(*),')-./*0*))1-2,
(*0%(
. :454)(;6(4(.1=.
". (84)(4
(..(.
&. :4565)4(.54
540=456.
>. (4)((4(.?.=.
$. !/204564)44(.0!.
@. =(((7=.(.(.9554) ,
(4(..=..
A. (.,.5.(!)40()-4)
3)0B45.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
4/78
>
C!C?.>.(.5.759.C!C?.$.(.5.7569.C!C?.
.@.(..!.
C!C?.A.(.5...
C!C?.D.(..:.C!C?.E.(.5./8.C!C?.".(..(.C!C?."".(.5../7-9.C!C?.
F&.(..5.?).
C!C?.F>.(...(.C!C?."(.(.!...=.C!C?."@.(..=8.C!C?."A.(..5.(.C!C?."D.(.=6=.C0C709.(.
.:.C2C?..(.5.?./.
C-C.2,.456.C+C.(.((.
C,C.?.C:C#?.3"(.:.C:C?.&(.5.759.C:C?.>
(...
C:CG?.$(.()!.C:C?.@(.?.!?.C:C?.A?
C:C?.D2,.456.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
5/78
$
1 4 0 H 0
) " . . ! ,
4)$..0
04))560)
(.)
(5))
)4 ) )
0))4
"..&>##%""#$#"%%&.4
4 )
#:#
# :
). 4
4 4
) )
6).
$)
.
))4)
(,4
4($&..0..04
)4).4
) @ .&% .. "#$#"%%&4 ) E%
4 !
:. 4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
6/78
@
0 0 0 5 >$%&4 0
4 (. 5) @%%&4 54 (
&%&4,4(.04$$%&424(.(4
@$%&. 8 4 (.4 !) "%%&4
(4 (. =8 "@%& ) : 04
4 (. )) ) 0
. @ 8.
0400
.:.!
0?. D"%& .(
4@&64
)4/8.B4
( ,4 0.!.0..2.4 56
A#"%%&4
>D ) ( "% !4 >&4 >A4
>D4 >"A4 >>D4 >>E4 &">4 &"@4 &%A4 &%"4 >&$ $&.
(&>>E.04("A794(&4>
$-'()(&4>E
( A = 7 9 .
0.!.0..2.44
)0
&>##"%%")4"%%"
"#$#"%%& /844
/84
))4))4)4444
.4 )
) :. 4
4.
0 !
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
7/78
A
88)
.:6
.) 0 !
')
)0!70.!..9.
)??.">$%A((#""%%&.
:4"D#"%%&)(,.)
,'(.
&04E$"70@%E$"9
, 0
!4 56 "#$#"%%&. + 4
? ?. ">$%A ((" "%%&4 : . "A#E#"%%&4
, ) 0
1
=
. !456"#$#"%%&EI4
8J
. '
66 '
J
.
J
. ()
JJ
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
8/78
D
.)
.
0)
'7"A#D#%&9
". ) ?4 0
??.%%#"%%&)
-2 (
54 6
4
) # ( 6 '.;4
&@ 6 ) 0.
0 4 56 0
.;))
6
4 '
"#%$#%&40.
& . ) .
0
.
(4
6)4
:.
5 ( 5.
: .
)
:
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
9/78
E
2).
##%"4
0 79
:)
. 0 79 )
4 :.
)4079
:
?K)2)4"%%40
79
&>##%". + 4 (
,.
. ( ,
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
10/78
%
.
> . 6 4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
11/78
0 ( "%% .
!/=((#;#%"4
"#;$#%& )
))
)). + "#$#%& 4
2 .
)2
)0
) 0
).
A.4567+9)
0 4 56 0. )
+ ) ) (. .5. 54 0
560.
E$>
. )
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
12/78
"
.)"A#E#%%
4 7 ?. D"% &
!(9?."%7
9!.
!/=((.
? K ) 2)4 "%%
)&>##%"4
).
. (
. L5H
)
) . 5
.4)
).4
):(8
0 "#$#%&. /
84:
. 4D 79:.)
4.
. 0
.+
)
. +
)4
).
D.,)
(,.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
13/78
&
E. L-H 4 56 2 0
. ' 2 04 ( . .;. (8.
4 L+H 4 0
. 4 (
0
. ) ( 0
2 ) :H) : 0.
.;4
L+H ) '. 4 LH
4 LH
'.!4:H):0
4 0
.4
L+H'.4">#@#"%%$
4
D !
6.44#A#"%%$
D !
6
;6
. !/
7?.$9
204
56
).". =(
((7
?@9(0
-
),
(.
.
=
&>M#"%%"
)
"#$#"%%&
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
14/78
>
&.
7'9L!H
?.>!
B0
)
(.>. 0
7'97!
?.E92
04564
)
(
=
:
4&>M#"%%")
"#$#"%%&
$.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
15/78
$
046
)
,(
&>M#"%%&"#
$#"%%&
E. 2
7+
?.9)204
56
%.0
7+
?9)
0
00.
=
)
"#$#"%%&
.
.9(.;(84
+2045
)9(.(85
84+
0
400
=
&>M#"N"%%"4
4
#
"#$#"%%&
".(..)=
+.
0
7(95
=
)"#$#"%%&
.
&.(.5
(4
,
79
=
')
"#$#"%%&
)(,
IO
.
>.:(4
,5
=:
2
&>##"%%"4
)"#$#"%%&
:
2,
EE@
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
16/78
@
(4)
)
"#$#"%%&
%.)679)))04
4'
04
4)0$#A#"%%$.
.;$#A#"%%$4)>6
.D!)
0. 6
4
: D.
( .D! 4
'.
.4"'@""
.L
. )
0
.4
.
./
0;+?P
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
17/78
A
0:-=#
0!/=((!&>##"%%".
!"#$#"%%&
))4 K 5
!&>##"%%".4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
18/78
D
)L0)
"#$#"%%&
6)
'.(.4:
(. : ) ?.2.+. #
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
19/78
E
0 ) 0!02
)?2+.
4?.2.+.)-'.!EE%E#
)6
) : 6 . .
0)
?2+. : 4 4
?2+.:
!A!D-'.!>@!>E
' ?2+. B
))
( . :
-'. !E794! $4! @794!">! "E4! &!&>
-'.!!&E!#@!#A
( 0.
-'.!"&4(
A$ .
-'. "% " (
.-'.!&!A(
.-'.!
&% / 0
(. 4
E$>.
&>##"%%". )
))4>##"%%"
"#$#"%%&.
) A
)
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
20/78
"%
(.4
) (
).
&. ! ? >4$4E4"%
!:
.4=.(.(.
!
4 EDD. ) ##"%%""#$#"%%&.
> . ! ? $4@ 4>4 D : ? . &
##"%%""#
$#"%%&.4.##"%%".
4 0
.
@. 0 + )
0 !.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
21/78
"
4)))
. :
)+ .0: ?.> 7-#9 )
)
#&% :?.>.4
-'.:E)
. :
:?.>)B40
4
.
.
0
) : ?. >. 0 #&" 7: ?.$9
#&" ) "E
4.D! &"
7:?.$9))))"E
&".? ) )
&"
040E#"%%&..
A.0)-'.0A4
)2(!456EED)>
) &>##%" ) . :
)5
7 ?. "EA@94
4 .
)
4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
22/78
""
. = 7
94EDD.
)"#$"%%&4
) 0.!.0..2.
4
>D0D""%%&!
70@0"%%&0.!.0..2.94.A&7D90
0 . :
= ? . ( 72 .9 7EAE 0 . B./ .
&>@94(.!(().(
7EEE7@9(>A9:))P.(
,87"%%>7&9(A9.
D..
. ?4 4
# ) )
0.
:;(./;(-:
0;((;?;+?P
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
23/78
"&
4
0
"$"%%&.2&>##
"%%"4!"
:0&04
8
. , ) -'.(& 4
.&>##"%%"
)
0) (4 ! ? K
"#HF%% . 4
(8 ) D
( H H .
.;##"%%"4
!)(8(.
) . ) A #"%%" (8
)(.)A.$.:4)
)(.B4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
24/78
">
(
.4
"#"%%4 : )
.=
!. ) A."% .. #"%%"4
4 4 . ) A.>$
..4 ( 5.
) D.% ..4 ) K.
)D.%..4B84
=.(.(.74)0...9
84(8.
84)
4 ) . ) D."% ..
5.204
56 ) !
.>>0..0."..>##"%%".)
D .. >##"%%"4 4
( )) )
.4
8.+4
0 4
56)(,4
. . 55 7
H9L.07(
() 294 56 . - )
)55.
)))
55. . 0
=!.?7E9
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
25/78
"$
.4L!
) @.$ . "#$#"%%&. ) E%
!
:.4D:
.4)
8#.:)
8 . 4 . E . (
8 . B ) 4 () 4
!J)(..5.5
7+. @94 0 4 0 .
)4)"%%:
.)
0 7+ @9 4
0 .
B /
8!4.
) ) .
% 4 . .
! 0 ?.D"%& # .
0 ! 0..2.D
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
26/78
"@
4/.+..0#456A#"%%&.7-'.0E0.0
. -'.0%40.0. )
0!0..2.:
0.&"%#&%D4
#$DD >"> . L
"#$#"%%&)4(..5.
5 ) )
07(()294(.)=.
L "#$#"%%&
4
)0.
) 0
"#$#"%%&.
4 0
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
27/78
"A
4
.4
4
) !
)"#$#"%%&
0.
&.!4
) )
)0.04;
"E#"%%>(
. "& F> - .
-'.(.
:H):0..709?.$%%@%>.L
:H) : 0 4
..?.@"D%>0
4
( "& "> - 4
0.4
. ( ) 0
! 4 7
-'.(E9.?
2 , 794
0 4 56.
. )
00)4.
"@#"%%$40)8
;-'.(@(D7-'.(($
9
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
28/78
"D
."& "> - . :4
))0.
>.!.B..4(..5.0.5.:
! "%%" "%%& . :
4 ! . ;
L 7) % 9 .
.L(.(.B.0.?)
, .
. &>##"%%"4
! ; $##"%%".
) .
0200
=2;7=.2.;.90.0
)).=
)H8:04
.0...794
4 !
7!"9. (..5.0. 5
! 4 )
4.
.).:
.0".@."%%".-'.
!D% . 0
4-'.!DE#@#"%%".:
) . 4
"D##"%%& 7-'.!D"9 0
!
4.#
2 0 7- 9 0 56
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
29/78
"E
7&"9)).-'.*4
4 ( B ) @#A#"%%".
-'.*!)
!4
)07294)
.
) !4 0
=. . -'.*"
) "D##"%%&. 4
=. @4&>4%%%#
) 4 .
.B..))8)
.
! 4 . .
7!9
!)8.
@#"#"%%4
. -'.D> 79 ?
-' H@#A#"%%>. (. (
0 , ( )
!4"%%$4
0,()4(,
:.:!
0 , ( )
' ) L
56H)4
4).-'.D$79D@
79 Q H Q)H
@#A#"%%>Q.!"0...79
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
30/78
&%
! . !&
! , . "%%%#"%%$.
! !
E$>.
EE&.
$.2(..5.40L(
. : !
) !. 4
"#$#"%%&.
@. @4 (. . (4 ( 8 &>##
"%%"4 ' 4
)?.2.+.
:.L
!.:)
Q5 H ) 0 4
7(94 ( . ) = 5H ""#"%%&4 )
)/
4
L5H )
0 7(94 (. ) = )
) . 0 7(9 4
4)
) 4 : )
.4
) ) .( ?4
.;>#>"%%&4)
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
31/78
&
/84.
: 4
L74:9.
4
. : 0. . .79 4
).B..7!9
.
A."A4()562(
!##"%%")
"#$#"%%& )
.4
:).:
=). .
) )
4
4)
.?
"#$#"%%&."D
).:)
)"#$#"%%&.
D.&;2.(.4((!456
. ! . :
4
L . : )
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
32/78
&"
))))
>##"%%". : !8 4
(.)) ) )
?.2.+..2.
:. : :
P. 0
: ) - 4 2 04 56
7(..;.(89. J
.420.
(..;.(8))
.40:
4)4
. 7
9 4 0 :
)
0 7 0
: 9.:
) . !
)L)4/4
"%%&.(
4
) .:
).!
.4
.:
.-'.(&79"#"#"%%")
. 0
0456.-'.(&7)9
@E#"%%" 0 L 4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
33/78
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
34/78
&>
L5H :
)07(9.
E."E2..,.45=D#>#"%%"#"#"%%&.
:040&%#H#EE
E#"#EE>.:)E.&%..&%
. ">D#"%%" =
0) .
.24
.
).2">D#"%%"4
0 4 564 > (.
(85 / 7&"#:. ?.$9
0 7(94(.)=7+"#:.?.@9
! 7
9 ) ) ).:
0) 7
0) ) ) 4
.=..0. #9.: 0
0 794
.-'.L%$)0
">#D#"%%.-'.%$
0 0 = 70 9
0=.
0 = )
0 70 =9 0.
4
! (. ? 0)
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
35/78
&$
.=..0. . -'. %$ 0
70=90)
)
0) .
0 7(9
L !H ) ) ) 0)
. "E !84 (. ))
4 !8
))
:."E.
04(.(85/
. -' .( ." 2.;.B ">#"%%&.
4 )
04 ( . / ) . :
04 (. (85
87&"#:.?.$9
; . -'1 %@ $#@#"%%"
007(94
."E2
045604(.(858
0 :
0.4"E(.(858.
-'. "@#D#"%%".-'."
)(.8"@#D#"%%"."E4
04(.(85/
4"#$#"%%&).
%.&02.(.!.456
. : "A
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
36/78
&@
4#)
)
.:0.:
0:
)044
) # . : L "A
)%#$)"#$#"%%&
.:
0 7(9 .
)
.))40
.07(9
.!4&
) "#$#"%%&. :
: . :
)) .
-'.( &789 ) ) 04
0,79
)(.(.!.40
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
37/78
&A
.- 7:?.>94(..;.(8420456
)0
4 .
:7E9.
0#
%#"%%".!"#%#"%%".(
))4&%
.0=."D4@A4%%%#
/4 "%%" "#$#"%%&. :
0 0 :. :
(.(.!.2.(.!..
.:
! ) ) .
: I )
) 4 )
) )4
.(D!
4'E#E#"%%$4
) .
(-40(#"(07:&9
. 2 4 56 7:>9
0:4
) . "4 =.2.. 4 56
L)!.:
) ( %A 0 0
.
".0456"#"%%E#
"%%& 7( .(8 8 # : ?.(9
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
38/78
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
39/78
&E
4
))).)
)"42,
) .
!4 ' 4 "
)
)
4 . ;
,,)
.))
((
. (
; ?
?.
. 4 (
.?L(
.
7)'9
.
) 4
14))
.?
.
.(=)
)4
0 4 56 )
) .:
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
40/78
>%
0
) R 4
))4
.:)0
) . -
)
. 4 ) ) (
) )
4).;
)4
)((!4
56>#"%%"
0 ,.
.)
4 / ) ?.
5BB&D>D 4 ) )
6 ) .
#6
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
41/78
>
$#"%%&.+4
6
4)
4(."A -.
)"42.,&;4
2.(.4 ((!4
) ) 4
)
"#$#"%%&E#"%%&.-'.
0E4 0 % -'. ( (( ) "E
&")
#"#$#"%%&0&>#
;#"%%"4
)))
.4).)
4
8."4
2.,.))4)
(.(.!.4 56
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
42/78
>"
4
LH
).
>.!4.B..
0(.
$&;))
/844
)"#$#"%%&)4)
0
7(9
L5 H "#"%%&. + 4
4
,)4)
4 )
.
$.-7:?.>#(..;.(89 L ) )
404
-..H4(..;.(8'
"E#"#"%%&.4
L "#$#"%%&4 ) )
.:
( (! 2 (
!. !
. : )
'4
. :
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
43/78
>&
.:
"#$#"%%&
.:47'
"E#"#"%%&9
) 4 .
) .
. :
) ) :
. :
0:.
6
562. .D! 0
4
) L
))
2 4
.
' E#E#"%%$4 &; 72.(.4
(. =8 9 0 :
) ) . &;
. : ' 7 "E#"#
"%%&9
)4)4
0 ?.D"%&. ) - 4
&;
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
44/78
>>
@. :& (. ()4 0 (" ( 2
0H;#D#"%%$#"%%$.
0:4:
.
.-'.:E.
4
).:>4
(4 2 4 56
"%% 4 "%%> 0
:.:&;
)
0:.4
"#$#"%%&. :
0:
. " = 2 ;
4 "#$#"%%&.:
0:.:-
7: ?.>9. : &;
. ?
.
0
; ) ) ) "#$#"%%&.
) 0 4
) - 7: ?.>9
)
0
-7:?.>9.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
45/78
>$
A.,)(,
0 : . ,
) &>##"%%". , )
,4 2 0
0 0 : 4
))4
) .. -' .:E ) ;
0:4))
. &; &"
)1
4 &; &" #
4')4
. + ; 4 L
) )
0 ) 4
.
4 ;
2 0 2
) 2
,
.
-7:?.>94
)
!.
: 4 (.(.!. )
4)!
20729H
0:)
!))-F.4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
46/78
>@
F4
) - 7: ?.>9
!74,94
.:
.
207-94
4..&
, 0 0 2 )
0:4 ) 2
4
)
)
). ) '
2 0
2 ) )
).)
4)L
2 0 7-9. 4
.
) ) -
I0 O &;
. ) Q H
- ).
04(.(8587&"90
-7)
Q H4 9
4 - . 4 4
-'.:E&;20
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
47/78
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
48/78
>D
"#"%%&F'-7:
?.>9 )
)
. - 7: ?.>9
' E#E#"%%$4
= 704 569
)2(!.:
. 4 =
) 2 04 56
)
.-7:?.>9
4))0.
) 0 :
.:&4(#."(
-4
) ( ) -
.:&
. ) 4
-7:?.>94))#
7"4 :> :&4 9
4
4 0 : .
) 4
). ; 4
))
! 0
)-7:?.>9.
D?440
)
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
49/78
>E
! J 4 4
"#$#"%%&.(
0.4-"
)))
&>##"%%F.4
4 L ) )
4)
4 &%#%#"%%" 4
!"#%#"%%"4
#%#"%%"4/4"%%""#$#
"%%&4 =. "D4@A4%%%# 7= - B (' (
;9 ) 0
4 8 E
&>##"%%"4
&% !
.").%A
00.
E. 0
) ) .
--'.-)04
4LH4
.4
F,)-'.(D7
>#>#"%%"94 ) ) 0
'4=
.
J
. 7-'.(& (.D 9
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
50/78
$%
):!
: . =
74#
"#$#"%%&9 )
.!4.B..)
0
)).-'.(@)!
0.-!4
-'. +>"4 >&
!
EEE4 @#"#"%% . ) .
) ) . 4
=")!
&>#"#"%%")"#$"%%&.-)
0!
) "#$#"%%&
4
. +" 7:
?.@94!
4 # -' .(@
7)""#D#"%%""$##"%%&9!4=
; )
. )4=;
) 4 .B..
)4
= ; ' .
4 -'.: (4 - 7: 4 ?.>9
.-'.:(&%#A#"%%"
(,.542,
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
51/78
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
52/78
$"
.!4"4
).
"@."4
)4#
' 7@9 . !4 "
(.@7@900
' '
4 4 )
.4
.%A0'
' 4 "4 '
) '
. . > , 0
:4)4
4 ) (.%A 00
) 0. : 2
) - )
)4
).+4)
(.%A0.0)2
4 . 4
"
).%A0.0.
".&"404
0 0 :
. , ) &%4
0:.+4
4 0 : )
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
53/78
$&
0 . -
:>.'.)
# &;#
. G -'.:E
:&(,$#>#
"%%" 0 0 :.
.A , 0 : 4
)2
2
(4,.:
()%.!">#
># "%%" "E# "%%&4 0:
">#>#"%%"4"#@#"%%"4">#D#"%%"4D##"%%"4"#"#"%%".%#"#
"%%&"E#"%%&.4
.-'.:E">>#"%%"4
"#@#"%%"">#D#"%%"
D##"%%""E#"%%&".
"#"#"%%"%#"#"%%&(
.04)
0 : .
20)-7:G?.>9.4
C 0 :
) ) ,
4.#
0
!4
2.
"".'4
0
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
54/78
$>
F
( 0
) ! 4
!8 4 ( .
)) >##"%%" :
.
&"4 (. (8 5 8
. "E4 2. .,.
5=)!">#D#"%%"
4 0
7&"9 0 7(94 ( . ) =
7+"9. "E
4 0 )
04 (. (8 5 8 7&"9 ()
2)04(.)=7+"9
)"#
$#"%%&.4"E7(.(=9
4
"#$#"%%&.:
.-'.%$4)
&"!E">#D#
"%%".-'.%@$#@#"%%")
&"4 04
0 7(9 .
-'.%A>#$#"%%""E
0 7&"904 ( 7#
+"#9 .4 4 !. "E
.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
55/78
$$
&>##"%%"
).-'.(2.;."#>#"%%""E4(.
(8 5 8 7&"9 ) .
!.J
4 ) )
))4 6
'
604
!.-'.(4"E&6
7 4 0.D"%& ! #
0.@0=%& 0.!.0..2.4 569
"E4.-'.("2.;.
">##"%%& "E4 (. (8 5 8
7&"9 4 ) !4
=(( ( =.(.(.
:
#.
-'.("!8(.))4
>##"%%"
4 '
) )
:.
.
-'.;(.(858
7&"9.-'.
"@#D#"%%"L(.(8587&"9
0:">D#
"%%"4
4/(.-'.""@##"%%"
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
56/78
$@
(.(858#7&"9'
) 0 : ">#D#"%%".
&">.">#D#
"%%",0
:H):04204D##
"%%"'4
4(;
4.
(. (8587&"94 -
7: ?.>94 2 0 )
0 : 4 ( .( .!.4
0-
7(.(8589)
( ! EE -
(!EE@4(
207-9 (.(8
5 8 ) . ( . (8 5 8
7&"9 ' I ) 0
)
O. :
/(@..I
004
O
"&.)"E4(.(858
&".:040"##
"%%"E#"%%&7."#$#"%%&9.:
)0:'
.:H
L J
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
57/78
$A
4 .4
. :
4
.
:2,
@#>#"%%". )
4
"#$#"%%&
= .
4 .%A 0. 0. &>"
.
. 4 . !4 ( .2.. 7"9
).:
8
!E#"%%&.:
-'.("
404
7#+"#9040S+&9!8
)4 !8
( %A 0.0
.; 40
7(9 !8
(.(.!0)L?H.:)
07(9
!8.07(94
!84
!8. 4
0 7(94 !8 .
07(9!8
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
58/78
$D
07(9
!8.:
-'.(&6
!. : ))
.:4)))4)
4 &%& 4 J ' 8 '
&%.=.
.4&%0)
!(
. : 0
7(94)4
) >%% . ; "E4
4 &"
8).(D!
&"4'.4
"E (..4
..(.040
E#"%%& (..5. 7+@9
0(.."%%&.&"
7J'
L 9 L
4 4 4 "E
."E7&"9
. 4 "E
) &". &" "E
0:4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
59/78
$E
.!4"E
. )8 )&". + "E
. &" -'. : $> $D -' . :@D4
)!
. (
004
)4)17
) 09. &"4
'
E#
"%%&"#$#"%%&.
">.07(()294(.)
= +". : 04
7(9 () . 2 A#@# "%%" E#$#"%%&. !
! 0
(() 2.:
A#@#"%%"4.
:.
"> ). ;
).().
B .
=EAA:.
&"% ) .
L5H ). D
4 0 7(94 0 4
0 () 4 ! ).
L5H
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
60/78
@%
. L5H "
)"D##"%%""#"%%&.7-'.+$
5AA#@#"%%"
E#$#"%%&.:)
:)
/8 4)
:4
5 "#"%%&
)).+"(
( 2.(.!. !
.:(:;4
!).-'.+@
"#"#"%%".:))
4)0)
.=. 0. 4 )
)
.
404
0.-'.(@""#D#"%%"4
@#E#"%%""$##"%%&.7-'.(@.""#D#"%%"4
0.9+"
07(9
()2.!84
(.(.!.4 0
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
61/78
@
.4
-'. (@. : > 4
"%%&. : L @#>#"%%& #$#"%%&
#$#"%%&. : ) "#$#
"%%& @ .. 4
.: -'.&4
644.4/
84$#"%%&.:
0
$#"%%&)4
)"#$#"%%&.:
H"42.,.
"#$#"%%&4
0 4
0!.
:".
"$."42.,..)4
0 )
0! .2
4 ) +" 7(.) =9
. +" )
)"$#"%%&.:
.:
. :
) 4
. - +"
07()98)4
0!4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
62/78
@"
) .4 0 D !
+"4 " '. "
-'.%>794LH6)
". : +" 7) =9
0 7( ) 29 4
. "#$#"%%&4 "
JB
L+"07(()29.
!4 4.:
+"567(()29
2.,.:
)2.(.42.,..4
#.-',7-'.0E$
$.$."%%&9L)H+")
0 7( () 294
+"4)
$#"%%&.:4+"
)
470?.D"%&9.
"@.+&):4040"D#%#
"%%""#@#"%%&.:
.
)
.=.-'.+"1
!8 "D##"%%&
"4&.-'.+""!89)
4 "D##"%%&. +> 5.. =4 () 4
!#"%%"E##"%%&.:
E##"%%&E#"#"%%&4@#>#"%%&$#"%%&.-'.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
63/78
@&
+"&,2!
( #"%%" &%#@#"%%"4 #A#"%%"
&%#%#"%%"%#"%%""E#>#"%%&
.-'.+">
)[email protected]'.+"$+
='(%A
&E.-'.+"@+..=.6E))
#,4!.+$
()#O!@#>#"%%&$#
"%%&.:)"#>#"%%&4
:
/ 4 ) ) ) .
5#:?."#7.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
64/78
@>
.
) "#$#"%%&
4
) "#$#"%%&. - )
2.,. 7" 94 '
"#$#"%%&.
"4
. -
) !
/84
.-'.(4"
0.D"%&!70.@0=%&0.!.0..2.94
)))
4)! )4
) 4 )
.(4)
)#
.)7"#
$#"%%&94)4.(4
)R
-'.()
8786)0!9
)4!L)
4 .
' ) 4
8 .
4 ) R "E
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
65/78
@$
&"
4)
).&"+".4
+" F. : !
.
!4 4 F. - .
? &" +" D!
)
.?.
)
)4)
0!024
&>##"%%" ) 7 E% 9.
.
&" 7-' . :$> $D :@D9
+&7-'.+"9!.&"
.!)
"E&"+".
)+&A.&%
. ) &"4 %.&% . +"
.
4)4.
)4 4
"E 4 ) .
) +
&>##
"%%" 4
) !.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
66/78
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
67/78
@A
.
-'.(&794))
0)7
R9.-+."&
. 04
7"A9))
. 4 ) 4 )
) ) &;4
) ) (
( ! ) . &;
# (.(.!.
))Q)H.+
4(.(.!.))
&7>##"%%". !
4
.4
)(.(.!.Q )H. 4
, : ! E ))
)4
).6
.4&"4+"
+& ) /4
"%%" ) "#$#"%%&4
7-'.+E"&94
#"##"%%)
2(!))#7
64 )9. -'.+E4
@##"%%" @#$#"%%&. 2
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
68/78
@D
4 7D9 !
).("##"%%&.!4
,.2."##"%%&-'.+"&7)9.
;)A4
4)
4 ) ) .
4)
(.(.!. 2.(.!. ) ((! .
.$A-'.(&
.
&"+"
=
7 9 4EDD )
4
4.
) &" +".
)(.(.!.
"E. )
)!.
"E.)
"E L !8 .
)
: 4 )) >##"%%"
04 )
!810?.D"%&70.?.@0=%&
0.!.0..29 0 ! 0..2.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
69/78
@E
-'.( "4 2.;. (. (8 5 8
7&"9 ">##"%%&.&"7(. (8589
4 +" 7(.) =9
.4+"&"
!8(.(.!.0
+"!(">##"%%&.
!8)T87
&>##"%%"944(.(.!.0+"
)L?H()4!
.+"
(.(.!.40##"%%&
!8 ) L?H. L 4
+"?4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
70/78
A%
)?.2.+..
+"4?..
&%. ? +H" &
4!8.4+"
!8J4
(, 2. +"
4 !8 . 4 +&
!84
) -'.+" 7 9
)!8"@##"%%&)4
!8
. -' .+"" !8 )
)+&"D##"%%&."D##
"%%& -' .+" . 4
+& !8
) . +&
!8 "D##"%%& -'.+""4 +"
!8)4F
!8
).+."&4
00
!8)4)!8
).-'..0E0%!8
"#.$#"%%&. !8 4
)
F.
44;
!8 4 4
-'.+""4)
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
71/78
A
.-'.+"".04
+" +&4
!84
.!8
)44
!8)+"+&4
4 4
-*.+"" 4 !8
."E!8
4
.0J
!8.
&. -'.+"> +"$
@A%A0..0.
&E .
)(.(.!."E)!84
-'.+">+"$.!8F
%A0.0.)
. 04
'..
&"4 +" !8 = :
%A00.!41
&" # .
!8.+!8
. &" +" ) L .
) &"4 !
4
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
72/78
A"
. ! 4
.
&". "E -'.%$4 %A
L(H ) "E4
&"4 +"
!. 4 &
4):0)
7"(9."((
! 4 ) " ) 4
)"E
07E94.=.0.
E#4.0.
)"EJ-'.%$
0.
. .=.
.!4).0.)
."E-'.%$
! ">#D#"%%". , ) -'.+A4
0 ) + .
!4.0.
! A##"%%& &%#>#"%%& 7 0.4 9.
0"#$#"%%&4 & 0.#!.
!4
0.4"#$#"%%&7"##"%%&40.
"#"%%&4"%#"#"%%&4#"%%&"@#"%%&
0..!F#F%%&.0.4
E)"E9-'.+"E"#$#
"%%&4 L :0 0
0 =4 =0 ' 7@9 7"9 =0
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
73/78
A&
4&."$0=0
'."E4)
0=79"(
4
'. &"
) 4 &%& 4
0=.
40
=4"$.
. - 4
4)"(+")
.
4"A4"D&%"E
!4
-'.+A)
) 4 4 &
!1-'+A
) "#$#%&4 ):.0.
)!.
&&. -'.(@4 +"
. : 04 0 7&"9
.:
. 0J . 4 &"
+"4)
) >%% . )
!)
# . 4 +"
)4
)&"
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
74/78
A>
.04&"
).
!+")&"
4!.+"
-' . (A . "#E#%"
..!
&"+"#)
. 7-'.+A9 ) 0
4 )
!#"#$#"%%&.
,)+>4!(."#
$#"%%& . 0 4
&"
+"..
&>.
) =)4)
.
"D
4 ) "#$#"%%&.
4!R
&$.=)
/. 8 ! ) "#"%%&4
$.@ &;. +"
L5H "#"%%&. !4
.-'.+(Q5H.+"
AN"%%"4A79#
5"#"%%&7+"&6.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
75/78
A$
#A#F%%". E#D#"%%" "#"%%&9. = ?.
".#"%%& 8
) 4
))
4 )
404?.LH
) 1 # ) LH
. ) LHF. +"
) '
L5H . &;
5"#"%%&.
+>4>#"%%&
R4=?.
L5H"#"%%&)-'.+(
(4 @ &;
))4)
) 4 +"
).
&@. - ) !" "A )
)6
!1 !"4 J
).!4
H) . )((!"E
)
4..
&A.-
)E#"%%&74&"9.-
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
76/78
A@
&>##"%%".
)1L
)"E'4
07&"9+"
+"4)
!(.
)).
4
!.+@4(1.5.54
0 4 56 "%%&4
)
"%%&.-&"
!4)
4
0E#"%%&.IO
E#"%%&. - )-'. ( 4
) "#$#"%%& ) )
).4
0
!"#$#
"%%&.
&D. 7) 9
"#$#"%%&4
)0
+@(..5.5)8).
&E.(!
.I
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
77/78
AA
)"#$#"%%&.4(
, ) :
. ,
) :
( . 564
"#$#"%%&. ,
) :
)).
>%.
!"#$#"%%&.:4
"#$#"%%&. ;
"#$#"%%&)4
'.
) 4 .
).
>. )4 :6
0.!..
,
,4:6
). ). 24
0))
)
,)4
) . 4
0#2.
-
8/9/2019 Commission Report Marad-Kerala incidents-Vol I
78/78
>".)0
)!"#
$#"%%& ).0
) &>##"%%"4
) ( .
0456
44
!4"#$#"%%&.!4
04 ( . .5. 5
4
!
"#$#"%%&.