Transcript
Page 1: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

HAL Id: inria-00071724https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00071724

Submitted on 23 May 2006

HAL is a multi-disciplinary open accessarchive for the deposit and dissemination of sci-entific research documents, whether they are pub-lished or not. The documents may come fromteaching and research institutions in France orabroad, or from public or private research centers.

L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, estdestinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documentsscientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non,émanant des établissements d’enseignement et derecherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoirespublics ou privés.

Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data ModelsGilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington

To cite this version:Gilles Celeux, Florence Forbes, Christian Robert, Mike Titterington. Deviance Information Criteriafor Missing Data Models. [Research Report] RR-4859, INRIA. 2003. �inria-00071724�

Page 2: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

ISS

N 0

249-

6399

ISR

N IN

RIA

/RR

--48

59--

FR

+E

NG

ap por t de r ech er ch e

THÈME 4

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Deviance Information Criteria for Missing DataModels

Gilles Celeux — Florence Forbes — Christian Robert — Mike Titterington

N° 4859

Juin 2003

Page 3: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4
Page 4: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Téléphone : +33 4 76 61 52 00 — Télécopie +33 4 76 61 52 52

����������� ������������ �������� ����� �����!�"� �#���%$ �"&�&'�")( �*���+�$ �-,)�/.�&

0�132424576�895:2;57<�=?>A@B2;CED"57F!GH5I@+CED"JK576L>A8NM!DO146"PQ1SRTFVUWCXJK57D�PY>AZ[14\T5] 1;P"P^57DO13F+_�POCEF

`/acb�dfe�gih j:kld9mcnpo#qrklsutfe�qBsuvwqrkld-klxro#qykzsut{ e�x}|7x}qrb"d-e"xB~"sud-vcnle �:e"x

���rs��}e�q�������Bo�vcv�su��q { e��re�~�ace"�}~�ace�tT��g������Yh ��mckltL�����u�h �u�iv�o��ue�x

�������O �¡c¢���£ `/ace { e�¤:klo�tc~�e-kztw¥;su�}d�o#qrklsut�~"�}kzqre"�rkzsut§¦4¨�©�ª/«¬klt�qy�}s { mw~"e {I­ |Ij7vckle��ue"n¯®a�o�nzqre"�Ke�q�o�nS°�¦3���u����«�kzx { kl�re�~�qrnz|Wkltwxrvckz�re {f­ |fnzkltce"o��Ao�t { �ue"tce��yo�nzklx}e { nzkltce"o��Kdfs { e�nlx"±­ mwqAkzq�kzx�tcs�qKx}s�t�o�qymc�ro�nln²| { e�³�tce { ¥;su��d-klx}xrkltw� { o#qyo�d-s { e"nzx"°�©´tWqyawklx�v�o�v�e"��±�µ¶e·�re ®o�xrx}e"xrx�qrace�~��rkzqre"�}klsut¥;su��x}mc~�aWdfs { e"nzx"±�qye"x�qykztc��qyawe ­ e�a�oO¤7klsumc�!s�¥�¤#o��rkzsumcx!e��7qye�tcxrkzsutcxklt)qyace�~"o�xre�xBs#¥�d-k²�7qymw�re�o�t { �yo#t { sud¸e�¹Xe"~�qºd-s { e�nlx�°»L¼�½E¾}¿iÀ  �Á!��£ ¨�e�¤:klo�tc~�e�±+ª¶sud-vcnle�qykzsut±'Ã�Ĭ�!±+Ã�k²�7qymc�}eWÃLs { e"n3±��ºo#t { sudÆÅ�¹Ee�~�qÃLs { e"nlx

Page 5: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

���!�������!�·& ,)� ,����f�"���¶���������·&'���·�)�� ����%,)�·&� �-,��/.��·& � ,������/�·& � �������N���·&

��� ����� � £�� eB~��rk²qyb"�}e { e {�� ¤7klo�tc~"e·¨º©�ª klt�qy�}s { mckzq�v�o��Aj:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye���e�q¶o#nS°�¦3���u����«e"x}q { kz�re"~�qye�dfe�tHqºkltwxrvckz� � v�o��·nle�x·dfs { b"nze"x·nlkzt � o#kl�re�x/e�qºnle�xBd-s { b"nze"x·nlkzt � o�kz�re�x/� � t � ®�yo�nzklx � x"°/©´n+t�� klt { mwkzqºv�o�x { e {�� ³�tckzqrklsut�t�o#qrmc�re�nlnze�v�sumc�Bnle�x�d-s { b�nle�x��fx}qy�}mc~�qrmc�re { e{ sutct � e"x¬dfo�t��Hm�o#tHqre"x�°º¨�o�tcx¬~�e�q�o#�}qykz~"nze�±�tcsumwx�� � klt�qye��rvc� � qrsutcx�~�e9~��rkzqrb"�}e�v�sumc� { eqye"nzx�d-s { b�nle�x�e�qKtwsumcx � ¤�o#nlmcsutwx�nle�~�sud-vXsu��qye�dfe�tHq { e { k²¤ue"�}xre�xAe �7qye"twxrkls�tcx�vXs�xrxrk ­ nle�x{ eB¨�©�ª { o�twx nze/~"sut�qye �7qye { e"xAd � npo�tc��e"x { eBnlsukzx�e�q { e�x d-s { b"nze"x ��e�¹Xe�qyx o�n � o#qrsukl�}e"x"°!�À �Q� ¾ ¢#" � �£ ¨ � ¤:klo�tc~�e�±�~"s�dfvcn � qrklsut±#ÃLÄ��!±#dfs { b"nze { e�d � npo#tc�ue�±�d-s { b�nle ��e�¹Ee�qyxo�n � o#qysukz�re�x

Page 6: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

. ��W�'�!�-, ��A������

/[ace"t { e�¤ue�nlsuvwkltc� qrace"kz�-qrace"s��}| s�¥�qyawe0*&��������� �1�������������2����3����������������[¦3¨�©�ª/« ±j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�·e�q�o�n3°�¦3���u����« { k { tws�q¬�uk²¤ue�dimc~�aY~�sutcxrk { e"�ro#qykzsutLqrs�d-s { e"nlxBsumwqrxrk { eqyace�xr~�suv�e�s�¥��ue"twe"�yo#nlklx}e { nlkztceOo#�/dfs { e"nzx"±�o#nzqyawsumc�ua)qyawe�|�~"s�tc~"nzm { e { qyawe"kl�·x}e"d-klt�o�nv�o�v�e"�/µ·kzqraLo { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut�s�¥!qrace�vXs�xrxrk ­ klnzkzqrkle"x s�¥!e��7qye�t { kltw�-qracklx·tcs�qrklsut)qrs-d-s { e"nzxnlk$4#e)dfk¯�7qymc�}e"xWs�¥ { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsutcx�° `/ace�e"tcx}mckltc� { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut vXsukzt�qye { sumwqWqrace�vXsux ®xrk ­ nle { k65-~"mwnzqykze"xWs�¥ { e�³�tckztc� ¨�©�ª vc�}e"~�klxre�nz| klt qyace�xreYx}~"e�t�o��rkzsux"° ©´t v�o���qykz~"mcnlo��"±¨�e"©´su�}kls9o�t { �·s ­ e��}q�¦S���u�u�u« { e"xr~��rk ­ e { xrsud-e�v�suxrx}k ­ nzeºkztc~"s�tcxrkzx}qye�tc~"kze"x�kztfqrace { e�³w®tckzqrklsutNs�¥Eo¨�©�ª ¥;su��d-k²�7qymw�re/d-s { e�nlx�±uqyace·d-sux}qAo�vwv�o��re�t�q ­ e"kztc��qyace·s7~"~"mw�r�re�tc~"eBs�¥tce"��o�qykz¤�e { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx87:9 ±Âµ·acklnzei�·kl~�a�o�� { xrs�t ¦3���u����«Bvc�}e"xre�t�qye { o�tIo�n¯®qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue/tws�qykzsutNs�¥X¨�©�ª�±Ho���o#kltikztiqyace·~"s�tHqre��7qAs�¥�dfk¯�7qymc�}e�dfs { e�nlx"°+`/ace { k;5f~�mcnzq´|µ·kzqya�d-su�re���e"tce��yo�n'd-s { e"nlx¶klx/qya�o�q ­ o�xrkz~�tcs�qrklsutcx/nzk$4#e�*&��������� �¶dfoO|�q�o<4�e�xre�¤ue"�ro�ne �Hm�o�nznz| o#~"~"e�vwq�o ­ nle�dfe"o�tckztc�ux"±�µ·k²qya { kl�}e"~�q-~�sutcxre �Hmce"tc~�e"x�¥;s��Wqrace�vc�rs�vXe��}qykze"xWs�¥qyace~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc��¨�©�ª¶x�°º`/awe"�re�klx·qyaHmcx�oftce�e { qrs�e�¤#o�nzm�o#qre9o�t { ~"s�dfv�o#�re�qyace�xrevc�rsuv�e"��qykze"x�¥;su��qrace�dfsux�q·t�o#qrmc�yo�nE~�acsukl~�e"xBs�¥�¨�©�ª¶x"°

`/awe�vc�}e"x}e"t�q�v�o�v�e"�·�}eOo�x}xre"x}xre�x¬qyackzxBvw�rs ­ nze"d kzt��u�re"o#qye�� { e�vwqya o�t { �ue"tce��yo�nzkzq´|¥;su�fd-klx}xrkztc� { o#q�o dfs { e�nlx"° ©´t j:e"~�qykzsut �:±�µ e �}e"~"o�nln/qyawe tcs�qrklsutwx-kzt�qy�rs { mc~�e { kztj:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"��e�q o�nS°c¦S�������u«�°�j:e"~�qykzsut���vc�}e"x}e"t�qyx¶o�q´|7v�sunls���|Ns�¥�qyace·v�suxrx}k ­ nze/e��7qye�t:®xrkls�tcx¶s�¥+¨º©�ª[kzt�d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo9dfs { e�nlx"±Hµ·ackznle�j:e"~�qykls�t�gi~"s�tcx}qr�rmc~�qyx·o�t { ~�sud-v�o��re�xqyace�xre e �7qye"twxrkls�tcx�klt �yo#t { sud e�¹Ee�~�q�d-s { e"nzx"±�o#t { j:e�~�qrklsut � { s7e"x-qyace�xyo�d-e�¥;su�dfk¯�:qrmc�re�x�s�¥ { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsutcx�°=/ eY~"s�tc~"nzm { e qrace v�o#vXe���µ·kzqra o { kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut s�¥¬qrace�re"nze�¤#o�tc~�e�s�¥!qrace�¤#o��rkzsumcx�e �:qre"tcx}klsutwxºkzt j7e"~�qrklsut1>w°

? @ ���i�·&'�"� � �·�&�)�!�·&����[�¶��� �.��8A�� � � ���, B��

CTs���~"sud-v�e�qykztc� v�o��ro�d-e�qy�}kl~Yx�q�o#qrklx�qykl~"o�n�d-s { e"nzx"±�DFEHGJI KML ±Bqrace ~"sutwx}qy�}mc~�qrklsut[s�¥9o�ue"tce��rkz~�d-s { e�n²® ~"sud-v�o��}klxrs�tYqys7sunKklxio { k65-~�mcnzq�vc�rs ­ nle�d µ·k²qya o nlsutw�Lackzx}qrsu�}|�°L©´tv�o��}qrkl~�mcnpo���±�qyaweºkzxrxrmweºs�¥ { e�¤7kzxrkltw�9o�xre�nle"~�qykzsutf~��rk²qye"�}klsutNqra�o#qKµ¶s��N4Hx ­ s�qyafo�x od-eOoQ®xrmc�}e�s�¥�³cqºo�t { o#x�oWdfe"o�xrmw�res�¥�~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|�klx �Hmckzqre~�aco�nlnze"tc�ukztc�c°A©´tLqracklxBv�o�v�e"��±µ¶e�e �co#dfkztce�xrsunze"n²|-qrace�~"�}kzqye��rklo { e�¤�e"nzsuvXe { klt�j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��¶e�qBo�nS°E¦S�������u«�±:kltc~�nlm { ®kltc�c±Eklt ~"s�tctce"~�qykzsut µ·kzqyaId-s { e"n�~�sud-vcnle �wk²q´|u±Âqrace"kz�¬dfe"o�xrmw�re�±O7:9 ±'s�¥KqyaceWe�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤uet7mwd ­ e��!s#¥cv�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx+klt�oBd-s { e"n3°+`/awklx �7mco�t�qykzq´|�kzx ­ o�xre { sut9oP*&��������� ��± { e�³�tce {­ | Q

E�KMLSRUT!V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I^KL`_aV�W6XMYcb�EH\dL8e

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 7: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

g � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·ace"�}ePbdEH\dL klx/x}sud-e¬¥;mcnln²|fx}vXe�~"k²³�e { x}qyo�t { o�� { k���kltc�iqre"�}d¸µ·ackz~�aLkzx¶¥;mctc~�qykls�t�s#¥+qrace{ o#q�oWo�nzsutce#°�`/ace"t�qyace ��� � ��������'*���F��k#����� 7:9 klx { e�³�tce { o�x

7O9 RQE2KLdT

QE��KL�e ¦��Q«

µ·ace"�}eQE�KML¶kzx�qyace�v�sux}qre"�rkzsu��d-eOo�t { e�¤7kpo�tc~�e�±Q

E�KMLZR������ T V�W6XMYZDFE�\]I^KML�I \�� _ V�W$XMYcb�E�\dL�eµ·ackl~�a ~Oo�t ­ e-�re���o�� { e { o�x9o! �oO|ue�xrklo�t d-eOo�x}mc�re-s�¥ ³cqO±!o�t {"�K�kzxo�t e�x}qykzd�o�qyeNs�¥K { e�vXe�t { kltw�Ysut \A°�`/ace�v�sux}qre"�}klsu�dfe"o�t K R��#� K I \$�ºklxs�¥�qre"t o tco#qymc�ro�nK~�acsukz~"e¥;su�%�K ­ mwq9qrace�v�sux�qye"�}klsu��dfs { e-su�9d-e { kpo�t ~Oo�t o#nlxrs ­ e��}mcx}qrkz³�e { °%&Bs�qye-qya�o#q�7:9klxN~"s�dfvcnze�qre"nz| klt { e"v�e"t { e"t�q-s�¥ºqrace)~�acsukz~"e�s�¥Bqyace)x�q�o�t { o�� { k��"kztc�)b!° ĺxWo�nl�}eOo { |vXsukzt�qye { sumwq�kzt�j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��Ke�q·o�n3°X¦S���u�u�u«�±Hqyaceº¥4o�~�q qya�o#q 7:9 dfoO| { e�vXe�t { sut�qrace~�acsukl~�e�s�¥!qrace�e"x�qykldfo#qre'�KNklx/sutce�s�¥+qyawe { k65-~"mcn²qykze"x�s�¥+qyawklxBo�vcvc�}s�o�~�a°

Ä ~"s��r�re�xrv�sut { kztc� ����������� � ������������������ ������� ���������¦3¨�©�ª/«�¥;su��dfs { e�n�~"sud-v�o�� ®klxrs�t�kzx·o { ¤#o�tc~�e {�­ |Lj:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"� e�qºo�n3°�¦S�������u«A¥;�}sud¸qracklx/~�sutcx}qr�rmc~�qykzsut)(Q+*�,

RQE2KL _ 7:9

RQE��KL _aV�7:9 ¦3�u«

R VQE2KLdT

QE��KML

R T.-������^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K<L0/CTs��!d-s { e"nH~"sud-v�o��}klx}sut±Qµ¶e�~"o�tWo�x}xrmcd-e µ·k²qyacsum:q�nzsuxrx!s�¥T�ue"twe"�yo#nlkzq´|�qra�o#q�b�EH\dLSR21�±¥;su�·o�nlnXdfs { e�nlx"±wxrsNµ¶e�q�o<4�e Q

E�KML R T!V�W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL0/ ¦4��«�K�}s^¤:k { e { qyaco#q

QE2KLEklx'oO¤#o�kznpo ­ nze�kzt~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�}dL±

QE�KMLE~"o�t�e"o�xrkznz| ­ eAo�vwvc�rsO�:kldfo#qye {

mcxrkztc� o�t ÃYª/à ª��}mct ­ | qyo4Hkltc� qrace�xro�dfvwnle�d-eOo#t s�¥/qyawe)xrkld9mcnpo#qre { ¤�o#nlmce�x9s�¥QE2KL�° /[awe"t K R3�#� K I \$��kzxKmcxre { ±

QE KML�~"o�t�o#nlxrs ­ eBo�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre {-­ |Wvcnlmc���ukltc��kzt

qyaceBxyo�d-vcnzeºd-eOo�tfs�¥Eqrace�x}kldimwnpo#qre { ¤�o#nlmce�x s�¥ K:°�Ä�xAv�suklt�qye { sum:q ­ |�j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�e�q)o#nS°B¦S�#�u���u« ± qyawklx�~�awsukl~�e s�¥ �KIe"twxrmc�}e"x�qyaco#q'7O9 klx-v�suxrk²qykz¤�e�µ·awe"t qyawe { e�tcxrk²q´|klxnlsu�#® ~"sutw~OoO¤ue-klt K:± ­ m:q9k²q9kzx�tcs#qio�vwvc�rsuvw�rkpo�qyeWµ·ace"t0K�klx { klx}~"�}e�qye ® ¤#o�nzmce { xrkltw~"e�#� K I \��·mcxrm�o#nlnz|L¥4o�klnzx¬qys)q�o<4�e-sutceWs�¥¶qrace"x}e-¤#o�nzmce"x�°fĺnlx}sc±+o�x��}e�¤�eOo�nze { ­ | ¨ºe"©´su�}klso�t { �Bs ­ e��}qB¦3���u���u« ±�qyawe/e�¹Xe"~�qrkz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsut�7:9 d�oO|µ¶e�nln ­ e/tce"�uo#qyk²¤ue/kltiqrace/~Oo#xres�¥�d-k²�7qymc�}e"xºs�¥ { kzx}qy�}k ­ m:qykls�tcx"° / e�µ·klnzn { klx}~"mcx}x�¥;mc�}qrace"�Bqyace�klx}xrmce�s�¥K~�acs7suxrkztc� ¦;su�tcs�q·~�acs7suxrkztc�H« �KNklt)qrace�¥;sunlnzsQµ·kztc�9x}e"~�qykls�tcx"°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 8: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

� �*��� & ���� � �"&�&'�")( ,����+� � �f,)�/.�&

©´tfqyawklxKxre�~�qykzsut±Hµ¶e { e"x}~"�}k ­ eºv�suxrx}k ­ nze·e��7qye�tcxrkzsutcx¶s#¥'¨�©�ª kztfd-klx}xrkltw� { o#q�o�dfs { e�nlx"±qya�o#q·kzx"±wµ·awe"t

D[EH\]I^KL�R��hD[EH\ce��`I^KL�����e­ |Yo#qrqre"d-vwqykztc��qys�µ·�}kzqreWo�q´|:v�sunzsu��|Ls�¥¶tco#qymc�ro�n�¨º©�ª¶x�kzt xrmc~�a xre�qrqykztc�ux�°NÃLkzxrxrkztc�{ o#q�oºdfs { e"nzx!qra7mwx�klt�¤usun²¤ue�¤#o��}kpo ­ nze"x���µ·ackl~�a-o��}e�tcsut:® s ­ x}e"�}¤�e { ±Hsu�!dfkzxrx}kltc�c±#kltNo { ®{ kzqrklsutNqys�qyaceBs ­ x}e"�}¤�e { ¤#o��rklo ­ nze"xS\A°·¦H/[ace�qyace���su�Atcs�q�iklxAvca�|7xrkz~Oo�nznz|Wd-eOo�tckztc��¥;mcn¥;su�/qyacevc�rs ­ nle�d klxBtcs�qB�re�nle�¤�o#tHqºace��re�° «�`/ace�s ­ xre��}¤�e {Y{ o�q�o-o�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·k²qya�qyackzxdfs { e"n�µ·kznln ­ e { e"tcs#qye {)­ |�\ R EHG��e /�/�/�e G �ML o�t { qyace�~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw� � �$# #���&%(* �� �­ |�� R E�� �e�/�/ /+e����ML�°1C�sunlnzs^µ·kltc��qrace�ÅAà qre"�}dfkztcsunls���|u±'qyawefnzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { D[EH\]I^KL�kzxs�¥�qye�t ~Oo#nlnle { qyace ����#�������N*F, ��� ��, ���O���+*�µ·ackznle D[EH\ce��`I^KL¶klxB~Oo�nznle { qrace1� ����� ,$����� , ��� ���, ���O���+*�°d/ e¬µ·kznln�mcxreo�x/kznlnzmcx}qr�yo#qrklsutcxKs�¥+x}mc~�a d-s { e"nlxAqyace�x}vXe�~"klo�nÂ~Oo#xre"x·s�¥+�ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�qºo�t { d-k²�7qymw�re¬d-s { e"nlx/kztLj:e"~�qykls�tcx/g�o#t { �:°

����� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"Ä ³��rx�qW~Oo#qre"�usu��| s�¥º¨�©�ª¶x-klxio�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·kzqra qyace)s ­ xre"��¤ue { nlk64�e�nlklaws:s { ±�D[EH\]I KML�±mct { e��iqyace�o�x}xrmcd-vwqrklsut qra�o#qNk²qi~"o�t ­ e�~�sud-vcmwqye { klt ~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd ¦;µ·awkl~�a§klx¥;su�kltcx�q�o�tc~�eYqyace ~"o�xre ¥;su�)d-k²�7qrmc�reYd-s { e"nzx ­ mwq { s7e"x)tws�q�o�nzµ¶oO|7x)acsun { ¥;s��)ack {c{ e"tà o��N4#s^¤�dfs { e"nzx�« °SC�sunlnzsQµ·kztc��¥;�}sud ¦4��«�±wµ·awklnleQ

E�KMLSRUT!V �$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\�I KML�I \��klxB~"nle"o��rn²|�o�t { mwtck �Hmce�nz| { e�³ctce { ±Xe�¤�e"t qyacs�mc�uaYk²qºdfoO|��re �Hmckz�re�¦SÃYª/ÃYª/«Bxrkld9mcnpo�®qykls�t qys ­ e�~�sudfvwmwqye { o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre"n²|u±�~�aws:sux}kltc� �KLklx9d-su�}e { e�nlkl~"o#qyefxrsYqra�o#q9qrace{ e�³�twkzqykzsut)s�¥+qyace�x}e"~"s�t { qre"�rd

QE��KL¶klt ¦ �Q«¶kzx/tcs�qBmctck �Hmce�°

©´t�¥4o�~�q"±cµ·kzqracklt�dfkzxrx}kltc� { o#qyo-d-s { e"nzx/nlk$4#e�qyace�d-k²�7qymc�}e�dfs { e"n's#¥Kj:e�~�qykzsut �:° �7±qyace v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}xdKBo��}e¶tcs�q�o�n²µ�oO|7x8��*&��O��� 2 � �+,$��o�t { qyawe¶v�sux}qre"�rkzsu��dfe"o�t K R3�$��� K I \��~Oo�t�qyace�t ­ e9o-¤�e"�}|�v�s:s��ºe�x}qykzd�o�qysu��° C�su�·kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±Xklt�qyace�dfk¯�:qrmc�re�~"o�xre#±Ekz¥ ­ s#qyavc�rkzsu�rxNo#t { nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { o��re)kztH¤#o��}kpo�t�qiµ·k²qya§�re�xrv�e"~�q-qrs qyace�npo ­ e�nlxis�¥Bqyawe)~"sud-vXs�®tce"t�qyx�±Âo�nzn�vXsux�qye��rkls��ºd-eOo�twx�o��}e9k { e"t�qykz~Oo�n+o�t { qyace�dfk¯�7qymc�}e�~�sunlnlo�vcxre�xBqrs�o-xrkltw�unle ®~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q·d-k²�7qymc�}e-¦Sª¶e�nle"m7��e�qºo�n3°z±T�#�u�u��« °�Ä�xBoN�re�xrmcn²qO±

¨º©�ª�SRUT -��$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\�I KML�I \�� _ V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �6� � K I \$� L

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 9: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

klxis�¥�qre"t§tcs�q-oY��s:s { ~�acsukz~"e�°�CTs��ikltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±Aklt qrace)d-k²�7qymc�}e�~Oo#xre�± ¨�©�ª io�nld-sux}qo�nzµ¶oO|:x·nzeOo { x�qrs-o-tce���o#qrkz¤ue¬¤#o�nzmce¬¥;su��7:9 ¦3¨ºe"©´su�}kls-o�t { �·s ­ e��}q"±����u���u« °

Ä�d-su�re��}e"nze�¤#o�t�q·~�acsukz~"e�¥;su�+�KNklx�qrace�vXsux�qye��rkls���dfs { e�su�/d-s { e"x�±�KkEH\dLSR ��� Y�� ���� D[E2K:I \dL�e

xrkltw~"e9qracklx { e"v�e"t { x�s�tYqyaceiv�sux�qye"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutLs�¥�qyawe9µ·acsunze9¤ue�~�qys�� K:±Â�ro#qyace��qya�o�t9sut9qyawe¶dfo��r�ukzt�o�n�v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsuts�¥Tk²qyx+~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�o�x�kzt�qyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}e~Oo�x}e�°K`/acklx·nzeOo { x�qrsNqyaceo�n²qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue´s ­ x}e"�}¤�e {�� ¨�©�ª

¨�©�ª� 8RUT.- ��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K EH\dLNL /�Be�~Oo�nznE¥;su�·kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�qya�o�qO±c¥;su�/qyawe��L® ~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q·d-k²�7qymc�}e�vc�rs ­ nle"d�±wqrace"�}e�e �wkzx}qºodimcnzqrklvcnze�s�¥�����dfo��r�ukzt�o�nuv�sux�qye"�}klsu��d-s { e"x"°�&ºs�qreAqra�o#q"±#µ·ace�t9qyace vc�rkzsu��sut K·klx+mctck¯®¥;su�rd�±#x}s�qyaco#q �K EH\dL�kzx�o#nlxrsBqyace d�oQ�wkzdimcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu�"±Qqyawe¶~"s��r�re�xrv�sut { kztc�7:9¶±

7O9 RUT!V �$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\]I^KML�I \��M_aV�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �KkE�\�L L�eklx/tce�~"e"x}xyo��}kln²|)vXs�xrkzqrkz¤�e�°

©´t-qyaceBd-k²�7qymc�}e·~Oo�x}e�±:µ·awe"�reºtcsutck { e"t�qrkz³To ­ klnlk²q´|9kzxKe"t { e�dfkz~�±7o�t { ¥;su�Ao�nln�d-s { e"nzxµ·ace"�}e�qyackzx�klxAqyace�~Oo�x}e�±coid-su�}eºt�o�qymc�ro�nE~�acs�kl~"eº¥;su�

QE �KLAklx qrsixre�nle�~�q·o�t�e"x}qrkldfo#qys���D[E�\dLAs�¥'qrace { e�tcxrk²q´| D[EH\]I^KL�±7xrkztc~"e�qracklxA¥;mctc~�qykls�t�klx klt�¤#o��rklo�t�q¶mct { e"��v�e"�}dimwqyo#qykzsut

s�¥�qyace9~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q¬nlo ­ e"nlx�° C�su�ºkltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±Xsutcei~"o�t mcxre�qyaceiv�sux�qye"�}klsu�ºe��:v�e"~�qyo#qykzsut�$� � DFE�\]I^KML�I \��;°/¦ &ºs�qre qra�o#q+qyackzx!kzx�o�nzxrsºklt { e�vXe�t { e�tHq�s�¥cqyawe¶�re�vc�re�xre�tHqyo#qykzsut�¦4��«�° «©´tqye"�}dfx/s#¥!¥;mctw~�qykzsut�o�nEe"x}qrkldfo#qykzsut±Hqyackzx·o�vcvc�}s�o�~�a�vc�rs^¤7k { e"x·x}qyo ­ nle�e�¤#o�nlm�o�qykls�tcx¶qyaco#qo��re�x}mcv�e"�rkzsu�9qrsYqyace�vwnlmc�#® klt e"x}qrkldfo#qye�x D[EH\]I �K<L��Aqyace { e"tcx}kzq´| e�x}qrkldfo#qysu��klxie"o�xrkznz|o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qre {)­ |�o�tLÃYª/à ª e�¤#o�nzm�o#qykzsut°dCTs���kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±c¥;s��/o��o�mwxrxrklo�t�dfk¯�7qymc�}eµ·kzqya { e�tcxrk²q´|

DFEHGJI KML�R �� �� 7

���EHGJI � � e � � L�e

µ¶e�a�oO¤ue�D[E�GkL�R 1

!"� #�

�� �� 7%$

#'&� �E�G I �($

#'&�e � $

#)&�L+* ����� D[E�G I^KL I \$�Me

µ·ace"�}e�E�G I � � e � � L { e�tcs�qye�x)qyace { e�tcxrk²q´| s�¥�qrace tcsu�}d�o�n-, E.� � e � � L { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsut±

K'R0/ 7 e ��e1� 32 µ·kzqra4� R E.���e�/�/�/�e � � L65 ±7� RUE.� e /�/�/1� � L65+o�t { 7 R E 7 �e /�/�/+e27 � L85 ±

4�5Jf64�7

Page 10: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

o�t { ! { e�tcs�qre"xiqyawe�tHmcd ­ e"�is#¥BÃYª/ÃYª xrkzdimcnpo�qykls�tcx"°�`/ackzx9klx9o�nlx}sLqrace)ÃYª/à ªvc�re { kl~�qykz¤�e { e"twxrkzq´|�±�o�t { qyackzx/nleOo { x�qys-o�tcs#qyace��B~��rk²qye"�}klsut

¨�©�ª�� R T.-���� � W6XMYZD[EH\]I^KL I \�� _aV�W$XMY �D�E�\�L�eµ·ace"�}e �D[EH\dL�R�� �� � �D�EHG � L ° &ºs�qreNqya�o#q�qracklx�kzx�o�nlx}s�qyaceWvc�}suv�suxyo�n�s�¥��·kl~�aco�� { x}sut¦S���u�u�u«¬klt ace"� { klx}~"mcx}xrkls�t s�¥·j7vckle��ue"nza�o�nzqre"��e�q9o�n3°¶¦3���u����«�°�`/ackzx9kzx��Hmck²qyefoLxre�tcxrk¯®­ nle�o�nzqre"�rtco#qyk²¤ue�±�xrkltw~"e�qyawe�vc�re { kl~�qyk²¤ue { kzx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsut kzx �Hmckzqre�~"e�t�qy�yo#n¶qys% ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�tkltw¥;e��re"tw~"e�°�¦3j:e"e#±'¥;su��kltcx�q�o�tw~"e�±ÂqraceWtcs�qrklsut s�¥# �oO|ue�x¥4o#~�qys��rx"±Âµ·awkl~�a o��reN�ro#qykzsux¬s�¥vc�re { kl~�qykz¤�e"x�±��·s ­ e��}qL¦3���u� �Q« ° « &Bs�qye�o�nzxrsYqra�o#qWqyace��}e"npo�qykz¤�e�¤#o�nlmce�xNs�¥ �DFE�\�L ±�¥;su�{ kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q·dfs { e�nlx"±w~"sutcx�qyk²qymwqre�qrace�vXs�x}qye��rkzsu� �oO|ue�xB¥4o#~�qys��rx·s�¥!Ä�kzqN4Hklt ¦ �O�u� �Q« °����� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"`/aceNdfkzxrx}kltc� { o#q�o�x�qy�}mc~�qrmc�reNdfo4�e�x�oO¤�o#klnpo ­ nle�dfo�t�| o�n²qye"�}t�o#qrkz¤ue��re�vc�re�xre"t�qyo#qykzsutcxs�¥Eqrace¬¨�©�ª�± ­ |W�re"o�nlnzs:~"o#qykztc�¬qyaceBv�suxrk²qykls�tcxKs�¥Eqrace!W6XMY9o#t { s�¥Eqyace·¤#o��rkzsumcxKe��:v�e"~�qyo�®qykls�tcx"°c/ e~Oo�t�³��rx�q�tws�qye�qya�o�qO±Tmcxrkztc�Wqyace~"sud-vcnze�qye�nzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { D[EH\ce��`I KML�±cµ e9~"o�txre�q

QE�KML¬o�x¬qraceWvXs�x}qye��rkzsu��e��:v�e"~�qre { ¤�o#nlmce�¦;sQ¤�e"��qyawe-d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo�«�s�¥Aqyace��}sukzt�q

{ e�¤7kpo#tc~"e#± QE2KML R T!V �$�-/���� � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \ce K �&I \ 2

R T!V ��� /��$� �^W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \ e�� �kI \ 2R T!V �$��� � �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \���/

©´tIo {c{ k²qykls�t�qrs�qyace { k65-~"mwnzq´|�s�¥K~�acs7suxrkztc� �K�o#x�kltLqyaceivw�re�¤7kzsumcx¬x}e"~�qrklsutE±Xµ eNa�oO¤ueqyace)vc�}s ­ nze"d s�¥ { e�³�twkltc�Yqrace�³w�:e { v�suklt�q { e�¤7kpo�tc~�e�±

QE �KML�°��¬t qyace ­ o�xrkzxis�¥ºo�t

klt�qye��rvc�}e�q�o�qykls�t�s�¥'qrace¬¨�©�ª[o�xAqyace¬e �:vXe�~�q�o�qykls�t�s�¥'qyaweA�}suklt�q¶¨�©�ª s^¤ue"��qrace¬d-klx}xrkltw�{ o#q�o:±�oNt�o#qymw�yo�n'k { eOoNklx�qrsNq�o4#eQ

E �K:I \ce��&L R T!V�W$XMYZD[EH\ce��`I ����� K:I \ce�� � L¨�©�ª EH\ce��&L R T -��$�#� W6XMYcDFE�\ e �`I^KML�I \ce�� �_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\ce��`I ����� K I \ce�� ��L�e

o�t { qyace�t { e�³�tce¨�©�ª�� R ��� � ¨�©�ª EH\ce��cL�I \��

R T -��$��� � � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \�� _ V ���+�^W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I �$��� K I \ce�� � L I \$� /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 11: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

`/acklxB�re �7mwkl�re�xºqrace9~�sudfvwmwq�o#qrklsut�s�¥Ko-vXs�x}qye��rkzsu�·e��:vXe�~�qyo#qykzsutL¥;su�BeOo#~�a ¤#o�nlmces�¥��±­ mwq�qyackzx�klx�mcx}m�o�nln²| tcs�q { k65-~"mcn²qo�x�qyaceW~"s�dfvcnze�qreNdfs { e"n�kzx�s�¥�qye�t ~�awsuxre�t ¥;su��kzqrxxrkld-vcnzkl~"k²q´|u°

Ä�x}e"~"s�t { x}sunlmwqrklsut)kzx/qysW~"sutwxrk { e"� � o#xºo#t o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#nEv�o��ro�d-e�qye��/�yo#qrace"�/qra�o�to�x�o9d-klx}xrkztc�¤#o��}kpo ­ nleBo�t { qrsimcx}e�o�vck²¤us�qyo�n �7mco�t�qykzq´|

QE��KML ­ o�xre { sut�e�x}qykzd�o�qye"xAs�¥

­ s�qra � o#t { K �wqyaco#qBklx"±wkltw¥;su�}d�o#nlnz|�±QE �KMLZR T!V�W$XMYcD[EH\ce � � EH\dL I �KkE�\dLNL /

��tw~"e)o��uo�klt±+µ¶e�dimcx}qix}qy�}e"x}xiqya�o#q"±�klt dfkzxrxrkztc� { o#q�oYvw�rs ­ nze"d-x�nzk$4#efqyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}edfs { e"n3±�qracei~�acs�kl~"e�x¬¥;su�ºqrace"x}eNe"x�qykldfo#qrsu�rx�o��re��7mwkzqye { e"nzkl~Oo�qyeio#x�qyace9e��:vXe�~�qyo#qykzsutcxs�¥ ��±!�uk²¤ue�t)\A±!o��reWv�s:su��e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�}x"± ­ e�kltc�)¥;su��kztcx}qyo�tc~"efo�nzn�k { e�t�qykl~"o�n�mct { e"��e��H®~�a�o�tc�ue"o ­ nzeivc�rkzsu�rxi¦4x}e"e-j:e�~�qykzsut �:° �u«�°�`/aceNs�tcnz|��re�nle�¤�o#tHq¬e"x}qrkldfo#qys���E ���EH\dL�e �KkE�\�L Lklt qracklx�xre�qrqykztc�LqraHmcxixre�e"d-x9qys ­ e-qyace�������O��ÃLÄ��?e"x}qrkldfo#qys���s�¥¶qyace�vco�kl�FE � e KML ±�ukz¤�e"tF\A±wmwtcnle�xrx�sutwe�klx �re"o { |-qys { e�³�tce�o9vw�rsuv�e"� nlsux}x ¥;mctc~�qykzsut)o�x�kzt)ª¶e�nle"m7��e�q·o�nS°¦S���u����«�°��kz¤�e"t qyaco#q�qyawklx�e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�fklx�tcs#q�o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle�klt ~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd�±/µ¶eI~�acs7sux}eYqysmcxreqyace ­ e�x}qi¦4klt�qye��rd-xºs�¥�qyace�¤#o�nlmce�x�s�¥!qyace�vXs�x}qye��rkzsu� { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsut�vc�rs�vXsu��qykzsut�o�nqys(D[EH\ce��`I^KL D[E2KLr«�v�o�kl� qya�o#q/o��rsux}e { mc�}kltc�iqraceÃYª/ÃYª[kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx"° &Bs�qye¬qra�o#q�qracedfkzxrxrkztc�#® { o#q�o·x}qr�rmc~�qymc�}e·klx�mwxrm�o�nznz|~�acsux}e"t-xrs¬qra�o#q�qrace+�}sukztHq { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutPDFE�\ce��`I^KLklx o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle·klt�~�nlsux}e { ¥;s��rd�°�`/aHmcx"±�e�¤ue�t)kz¥Âqrace�ÃLÄ�� e�x}qykzd�o�qyeB~Oo�tctws�q ­ e { e��rkz¤�e {o�t�o�n²|7qrkl~"o�nln²|u±Âqyawef¤#o�nlmwe"x9s#¥]DFE�\ce��`I^KL D[E2KML�o#qqyawe�xrkzdimcnlo#qye { v�o#kl�rxFE��Oe KML~"o�t ­ e~"sud-vcmwqre { °

`/awe9¨�©�ª[~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc�-qrsNqyackzx·o�t�o�n²|:x}klx/kzx�qyace�t¨�©�ª��8RUT.- �$��� � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \�� _aV�W$XMYZD[EH\ce � � EH\dL�I �K EH\dLNL�e

µ·ackl~�a± ­ o��}�rkztc�BoBv�s:s��+ÃYª/ÃYª o�vcvw�rsO�:kldfo#qykzsut�qys·qyawe�ÃLÄ�� e"x�qykzd�o#qre�±�xracs�mcn { nle"o {qysiovXs�xrkzqrkz¤�eºe�¹Ee�~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7:9��O±7�uk²¤ue"tfqya�o#q"±Hmct { e��/o��To�q¶vc�}klsu��±�qyaceºxre"~�sut {v�o��}qKs#¥Â¨�©�ª��Aklx�qrace·d�o��:kzdimcd ¦;dfs { mcnzs Vu«�s�¥�qyawe·¥;mwtc~�qrklsutWklt�qre"�u�ro#qye { kztiqyace/³��}x}qv�o��}q�o���o�kztcx}qdK¬o�t { �/°�&ºs�qre�acs^µ¶e�¤ue��"±�qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���klx!xrsud-e�µ·aco#q�kztc~"sutwxrklx�qye�tHq�klt�qraceµ�oO|�kzq¶q�o4#e"x���klt�qrsfo#~"~"s�mct�qO°K`/acevXsux�qye��rkls�� { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e�kltw~"su�}vXsu�ro#qye�x ��o�x·d-klx}xrkltw�¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�x�µ·acklnze

QE �K<L�o�t { qyace��re�¥;su�re 7:9����re���o�� { x �Yo�x�o�t o {c{ kzqykzsut�o�n+v�o��ro�d-e�qye��

¦4xre�e�j:e"~�qykls�tLgN¥;su�·o�t�kznlnlmwx}qy�ro#qykzsutT« °Äºtcs�qrace"��kzt�qye"�}vc�re�q�o#qrklsutE±uo�t { qyaHmcxKo�tcs#qyace���¨�©�ª�±u~"o�t ­ e { e��rkz¤�e { ¥;�}sud?qyace/ÅAÃ

o�t�o�n²|:x}klxAs�¥'qyawe�d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo9d-s { e�nS°��Be�~Oo�nzn�¦4¨�e"d-vcx�qye"�¶e�q/o#nS°²± �O���u�7�7�·s ­ e��}q�o�t {

4�5Jf64�7

Page 12: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �

ª�o�xre�nlnpo:± �^�u���w±�� �7° �w° ��« qra�o#q·qyace�~�su�re¬¥;mctw~�qykzsut�s�¥+qyaceÅAà o�nz�usu�}kzqyawd kzx� E2K I \ce K���LZR���� � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I KML I \ce K�� �Ze

µ·ace"�}e'K��·�}e"vc�}e"xre�t�qyx·qyace ~�mc�r�}e"t�q � ¤#o�nzmce¬s�¥ K:±co�t { � E�K I \ e K���L¶klx�dfo��:kld-klx}e { s^¤�e"�Kkztfqyawe �à � x�qye"v)s#¥Eqyawe¬o�nz�usu�rk²qyacd�±�qrs9vc�}sQ¤7k { eBqraceº¥;s�nlnls^µ·kztc� ~"mw�r�re�t�q � ¤#o�nzmce�K �°`/ace�¥;mctc~�qykzsut � kzx9mcx}m�o�nznz| eOo�x}kln²| ~�sud-vcmwq�o ­ nle#±�o�x9¥;s��9kltwx}q�o#tc~"e�kzt qyawe�dfk¯�7qymc�}e~Oo�x}e�°K`/ace"�}e�¥;su�}e�±�o�tcs#qyace��/t�o#qymw�yo�n'~�acs�kl~"e�¥;su�

QE �K<L/kzx�qysNq�o<4�eQ

E��KMLSRUT!V � E �KOE�\dL I \ce � K&E�\�L LZR T!V � � � W6XMYZDFE�\ce�� I �K EH\dL L I \ce � K&E�\�L � eµ·ace"�}e �K EH\dLºkzx¬o�t e�x}qrkldfo#qysu�ºs�¥ K ­ o�x}e { sut D[E2K:I \dL�±Xxrmc~�a o�x¬qraceidfo��r�ukzt�o�n!ÃLÄ��e"x}qrkldfo#qys��"±�su� o³w�:e { vXsukzt�q s#¥ � ±7xrmw~�a�o�x¶o#t)ÅAÃÆd�oQ�wkzdimcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e�x}qykzd�o�qye�°`/acklx/~�acs�kl~"e�nzeOo { x/qrsfoN~�su�r�}e"xrv�sut { kltc�f¨�©�ª

¨�©�ª�� R T.-��$��� � �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \�� _ V ��� �^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �K E�\dLNL I \ce �K&EH\dL�� /Ä�xf¥;s���¨�©�ª��Q±�qyawklx�x�qy�ro#qye���| klx�~�sutcx}klx}qre"t�q)kzt qyace�µ�oO| kzqf�re"�uo�� { x �§o�x�d-klx}xrkltw�kltw¥;su�}d�o�qykls�t �yo�qyace��Wqra�o�t o�x-o�t e��7qy�ro v�o��yo#dfe�qye"��± ­ mwq-kzqNkzx-tws�qW�um�o��ro�t�qye�e { qysnleOo { qys¬o �O��#����������e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�7:9��"±�o�x!qrace¶dfo��:kld9mcd?nlk64�e"nzklacs7s { e"x}qrkldfo#qys���ukz¤�e"x/qyace�dfo��:kldimwd¸s�¥

W6XMY�� � � D[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K ��yo#qrace"��qra�o�t�s�¥

��� �^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K �qyaceWnpo�qrqye���s�¥Aµ·ackl~�a klx�x}d�o�nznle��¬xrkztc~"e(W$XY�kzxo�~�sutc~"o^¤�e-¥;mwtc~�qrklsut°Wĺt o�n²qye��rt�o#qrkz¤�eqys qyace)dfo��:kld9mcd nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { e"x}qrkldfo#qys���µ sumcn {§­ e)qys ~�acs7suxre �KOE�\dLqysIdfo��:kld-klxre� E�K I \ce KL�±wµ·awkl~�a��re"vw�re"x}e"t�qyx�oNdfsu�}e�~�a�o�nznle"tw�ukltc�Nvw�rs ­ nze"d�°

����� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�"ħqrackl� { o#vcvc�rsuo�~�a�qrs�¨�©�ª¶x!klt�qyaceA~"s�tHqre��7q�s#¥cd-klxrx}kltc�/¤#o��}kpo ­ nze�d-s { e�nlx�klx'qrsºmcx}eAqrace~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�n+nlk64�e�nlklaws:s { ± DFE�\�I �Oe KML ±Xµ·ace��re ��klx�qrace"tI~"s�tcxrk { e"�}e { o�x�o�t o {c{ k²qykzsut�o�nv�o��yo#dfe�qye"��°�`/ackzx�o�vcvw�rs�o�~�a aco�x¬s ­ ¤7klsumwx¬o�x�|:d-vwqrs�qykz~io�t { ~"suace��re�tc~�| { k65-~"mcn²qykze"x"±o�x { kzxr~�mcxrx}e { klt qyace�vco�x}q9nlkzqre"�ro#qymc�}eL¦Sà o��}�rkzs�qrq�¦ �^�u�u�u«�� �}|�o#tHqNo�t { /[kznlnlklo�d-xrsut¦ �^���#��«�� � k²qrqrnle-o�t { �Bm ­ klt ¦��^�u�u�u«r«�± ­ mwq9kzqklx~"s�dfvcm:q�o#qrklsut�o#nlnz|�¥;eOo#xrk ­ nle-o�t { ~"o�tqyaHmcx ­ e·~"s�dfv�o#�re { µ·k²qyaNqyaceBs�qrace"�Kxrs�nlmwqrklsutcx�o ­ s^¤�e�°B¦ &Bs�qye·kztfo {c{ kzqrklsutiqra�o#qA¨�©�ª��

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 13: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�^� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

klx�x}kzqrm�o#qye {N­ e�q´µ¶e�e"tNqyawe�~"sud-vcnze�qye¶o�t { qrace�~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n7o�vcvc�}s�o�~�ace�x�klt9qra�o#q�k²q�mcx}e"xqyace�~"s�dfvcnze�qre�nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s {f­ mwqBxrkzdfkznpo��}nz|Ne�x}qrkldfo#qye�x���° «

Ä t�o#qymw�yo�n!xrsunzmwqykzsutYkltLqyackzx�¥;�yo�d-e�µ su� 4Lkzx�qys�o�vwvcnz|�qyace9su�rkz�uklt�o#n { e�³�tck²qykzsutYs�¥¨�©�ª[qrs-qrace�~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�n { kzx}qy�}k ­ m:qykls�t±:µ·ackz~�aLnzeOo { x�qys

¨�©�ª��8R T -������ � �^W$XYZDFE�\�I � e KL I \$� _aV�W$XYZDFE�\�I � �:EH\dL�e �KkE�\dLNL�eµ·ace"�}eNo���o�kzt�qrace9vco�kl�'E��Oe KML/klx�e�x}qrkldfo#qye {L­ |�qyace/�}suklt�q¬ÃLĬ� e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu�"±�o�vwvc�rsO�H®kldfo#qye {)­ |Là ª/ÃYª�°X`/awklxBo�vcvc�}s�o�~�aLnleOo { x/qysfoWv�sux}kzqyk²¤ue�e�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7:9���±mct { e��ºo �To�qºvw�rkls��¶¥;su� �fo�t { K:±c¥;su��qrace�xyo�d-e��re"o�xrsutwx�o�x�¥;s��·¨�©�ª��^°

ĺt o�n²qye��rt�o#qrkz¤�e�x}sunlm:qykls�t kzxNqys xre"vco��yo#qre"K ¥;�rsud �/±/o�x-klt ¨�©�ª�� �·qya�o�qfkzx"±Aqys~"sut { kzqykzsut�³��}x}qBsut � o�t { qyace�tLkztHqre"�u�ro#qye�s^¤�e"� � ~�sut { k²qykzsut�o�nXsut \ ±w�ukz¤7kltw�

¨�©�ª��8R T -������ � � W6XMYcDFE�\]I � e KML I \�� _ V �����6W$XY D[EH\]I � e � K EH\ce��ZLNL I \�� eµ·ace"�}e �K EH\ce��&LXkzx�o�t�e�x}qrkldfo#qysu�Es�¥ K ­ o�xre { sut D[EH\ce��`I^KL�±^x}mc~�aio�x'qraceKvXsux�qye��rkls��Âdfe"o�t¦;µ·ackz~�a�klxAtcs^µ[o~"su�}�re"~�q¶e�x}qrkldfo#qysu� ­ e"~"o�mcxreºkzqAklx ­ o#xre { sutfqrace��}s�klt�q { klx�qy�rk ­ mwqrklsutT«su��qyaceºÃLÄ�� e"x�qykzd�o#qrsu��s�¥�KW¦4~�sut { k²qykzsut�o�n:sut ­ s�qra \Io�t { �7«�°ºe"�}e � kzx { eOo#nzq�µ·k²qyao�xºd-klx}xrkztc�N¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�x/�yo#qrace"�·qya�o#tYo�xºo�tLo {c{ k²qykls�t�o�nÂv�o#�yo�d-e�qre"�"°¶`/ace�x}kldimwnpo#qrklsutcxkltNj7e"~�qrklsutN�:° �·klnznlmcx�qy�yo�qye�qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���o�~�qym�o#nlnz| ­ e"aco^¤�e"x { k²¹Ee��re�tHqrnz|�¥;�rs�d�¨�©�ª���µ·ace"te"x}qrkldfo#qykztc�9qrace�~"sud-vcnle �:kzq´|�qrac�rs�mc�ua 7:9¶°

� ��,���� ���I�·� � � �f,)�/.�&

©´t qyawklx-xre"~�qykzsut µ e nzklx}qNqraceL¤#o��}klsumwxf¨º©�ª¶x�klt qyace�~"s�tHqre��7q�s#¥�o x}kld-vcnle��ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�q¶dfs { e�nS°�j:sud-eºs�¥Xqyace { e�q�o�kznlxKs�¥Âqraceº~"o�nl~�mcnpo�qykls�tcxKo��reBtcs�q �uk²¤ue"tface"�}e ­ m:q�o��}eo^¤#o�kznpo ­ nleN¥;�rsud qrace)o�mwqracsu�}x"° `/ace)d-s { e"nKµ�o�x { klx}~"mcx}xre { kzt§j:vckze"�ue�nla�o�n²qye���e�qWo�nS°¦S���u�u�u«�± ­ mwqface"�}e�µ e x}e�qfkzq-mcv o�xfo d-klx}xrkltw� { o#q�o vc�rs ­ nle"d�±Kµ·kzqya§qyaweL�ro�t { sude�¹Xe"~�qrx/�re���o�� { e { o�x dfkzxrxrkztc��¤#o�nzmce"x�± ­ e"~"o�mcxre�~�sud-vcmwq�o�qykls�tcx�o��}eº¥;e"o�xrk ­ nleºklt�~�nlsux}e {¥;su�rd%¥;su��qyawklx�d-s { e�n�o�t { o�nznls^µ�¥;su��o ­ e�qrqre"��~"s�dfv�o#�rklx}sut s�¥Aqyace { k²¹Ee��re�tHq¨º©�ª¶x"°ÃLsu�reºxrv�e"~�kz³�~"o�nln²|u±�µ¶eº¥;s:~�mcx¶sut-qyaceBµ�oO|-qyace�|�o#~"~"s�mct�q¶¥;su�A~"sud-vcnze��:kzq´|�±:k3° e#°�sutfqrace7:9�x"±�x}kltc~�e�qyace��re�klx/tcs-�re"o�nÂd-s { e"n²® xre�nle"~�qykzsut�klx}xrmce�kzt�qracklx/x}e�q}qykltw�c°

j7mcvcv�suxre�qyace��re�¥;su�re�qyaco#qO±w¥;s����dR 1Me�/�/�/�e�7 eG�R � � _�� � e

4�5Jf64�7

Page 14: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# � �

µ·ace"�}e � ��� , E�K e���� L·o�t { � ��� , E��ke� � �L�e�µ·kzqya o�nln'�ro�t { s�d ¤�o#�rkpo ­ nle�xBkzt { e�vXe�t:®

{ e"t�qºo�t { µ·kzqra�Lo�t { qyace�� � � x]4Htcs^µ·t°K`/ace�tnlsu�(D[EH\ce��`I KML R nzsu�(DFE�\]I �&L�_§nlsu��D[E��`I KML

R TZ7 nzsu��V �F_ 1V � � nzsu� E���� � LdT 1

V � � � � E�G � T � � L T 1V � � � E � � T KML /

à o��r��klt�o�nznz|�±<G��� , E2K&e�� � �

_�� � L � , E2K&e�1�� E���� � LNL ±uµ·ace"�}e�� � R�� � �kE��c_�� � L /�`/aHmcx

nzsu�(D[EH\]I^KL�RUT 7 V nlsu�[V �[_ 1V � � nlsu�1E���� � LdT � V � � � � E�G � T0KML /

©´t�qyawklx/xre�~�qrklsut±cµ e�mcxre�o �To#qBvc�}klsu�¶¥;s��]K:°� ��� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"CTs��¶qyackzx·e��wo�d-vcnle

K:I \� , ��� � � � G �� � � � e 1� � � � ��� e

o�t { qyace��re�¥;s��refqrace-vXsux�qye��rkls���dfe"o�t o#t { d-s { e-s#¥ K:±+�uk²¤ue"t)\A±�o��}e ­ s�qra e �7mco�n�qys�K EH\dLSR � � � � G � � � � � � /c`/aHmcx

¨�©�ª SRV¨�©�ª� 8R 7�nlsu��V �1T � � nzsu�OE���� � L _ � � � � � EHG � T �KkEH\dLNL _ V /

CTmw�}qyawe"�rd-su�}e�±7:9 SR 7O9 R21�/C�su�·¨º©�ª �Bkzq¶qymc�}tcxºs�mwq/qya�o�q

�D�EH\dL R ����� DFE�\]I^KML�I \��R V � �! D[EH\]I �K EH\dLNL�e ¦;gH«

xrsWqya�o#q¨�©�ª�� R ¨�©�ª �T nzsu�[V

o�t { 7:9 �8R21]T nlsu�[V /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 15: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�Q� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

j7mc�rvc�}klx}kltc�un²|u±�qyaceN�}e"npo�qykls�tcxrackzv§¦4g�«ºklx�¤#o�nzk { e�¤ue�t qracsumc�ua ­ s�qra D[E���I �K EH\dLNLºo�t {�D[E�� L�o#�re { e�tcxrk²qykze"x"°©´t { e�e { ±'qracklx¬k { e"t�qrkzq´|Lsutcnz|Lacsun { x�¥;su�ºqyaceNv�o#�}qykz~"mcnlo��·¤�o#nlmceP\~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw�-qrsWqraces ­ xre��}¤#o#qrklsutcx�°8C�su�/s#qyace��B¤#o�nzmce"x·s�¥ �w± �DFE�� L/klx/tcs�qBe �7mco�n'qysDFE�� I �KkEH\dLNL� � V7° &ºs�qreio�nzxrs-qya�o#q¬kzqºd�o4#e"x¬x}e"tcx}eiqya�o�q87:9 ��kzxºx}d�o�nznle��Bqra�o�tF7:9 �kztqya�o#qAqyawe�vc�}e { kz~�qyk²¤ueºklx¶tws�q¶twe"~"e�xrxro��rkznz|-s�¥'qyawe�xyo#dfeB~"sud-vcnze��:kzq´|-o�xAqyaceºxrmcd s�¥Âqrace{ kld-e"tcx}klsutwx�s�¥!kzqyx/vco��yo�d-e�qre"�}x"°

� ��� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"CTs��¶qyace��ro�t { sud e�¹Xe"~�qBd-s { e"nS±Q

E�KML R T!V �$��� � � W$XYZDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$�R T!V ��� /��$�#�^W$XMYcD[EH\ce�� I KML�I \ce�� �&I \ 2R V�7�nls���V �1T � � nlsu� E���� � L

_ � ��� � � � � EHG � T � � L _ � � � E�� � T��� L _ 1kI \�R T!V ���+�^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I ����� K I \ce�� � L I \$� _ 1Me

xrkltw~"e K I \ e � � , E �ke �� L /�Ä�xBoN�re�xrmcn²qO±7:9�� R21u°ÄB¥�qye��·¥;mw�}qyawe"� { e�qyo�klnze { ~"o�nl~�mcnpo#qrklsutwx µ e�s ­ q�o�kzt

¨º©�ª�� R V�7�nzsu�[V � T � � nlsu� E���� � L _ � � � � � E 1]T � � L+E�G � T �K E�\�L L _ � � � �� � T �M7 �K EH\dL _aV]_ 7

R ¨�©�ª� d_ 7 W$XMYFV �F_ 7P_ � � W6XMY � �� � // eo�nlx}sWs ­ q�o#klt�7:9��8R21c_ 7`eM7:9�� R 1u±

¨�©�ª�� RV¨º©�ª��d_)7`eo�t {

¨�©�ª�� R ¨�©�ª��cT"7 R ¨º©�ª�� /

4�5Jf64�7

Page 16: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �^�

`/awe ¤#o�nlmwe s�¥!7:9��Lklx�tcs�qLxrmw�rvc�}klxrkztc�§xrkztc~"e#±�klt ¨�©�ª��O± � kzx��}e"��o#� { e { o�xLo�te��7qy�roIvco��yo�d-e�qre"�is#¥ { kld-e"tcx}klsut 7° `/ackzxNklxitcs#qiqyace�~"o�xre)kzt§¨�©�ª��-x}kltc~�e�±Aklt qrace~"sud-vcmwqyo#qykzsut)s�¥

QE��KL�± �-klx�qr�reOo�qye { o�x·d-klxrx}kltc�i¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x�°

� ��� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�" � *�����% ����$&% % $ � %�� "¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª��klt�¤�sunz¤�e(DFE�\�I �Oe KML °i©´t qyaceW�ro�t { sudÆe�¹Xe"~�q�d-s { e"n3±Eqyackzx �Hm�o�t�qyk²q´|{ s:e�x�tcs�q { e"v�e"t { sut vco��yo�d-e�qre"� K xrs qyaco#q)~"s�dfvcm:qykltw� qyawe 7:9�x)o�t { qyace��re�¥;s��reqyace-¨�©�ª¶x { s7e"x�tcs�q�re"o�nln²| dfo4#e-x}e"tcx}e�°FCTs���kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±:7:9 ��µ¶sumwn {I­ e-��o�t { 7:9��o�nzqracsumc�ua { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q�¥;�rs�d¸�:± ­ e"~Oo#mcxre �Nklx¶~"sutcx}k { e��re { o�x·o�t)o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#n�vco��yo�d-e�qre"��±µ¶sumwn { tcs�q·q�o<4�e KNklt�qysWo�~�~"sumwtHqºe"k²qyace��"°

&Bs�qye�acs^µ e�¤�e"�ºqra�o#q¨�©�ª�� R 7Lnlsu��V �1T � � nzsu� � � _ � � � � � E�1�T � � L+EHG � T �K E�\dLNL

_ V � ��� � _ / �

�� � E 1]T � � L 2 � E �

�� � L��2e

µ·ackl~�a o�vcv�eOo#�rx�o#q¬qraceNe"t { s#¥�j7e"~�qrklsut �:° ��s�¥¶j:vckze"�ue�nla�o#nzqye��������,�)¦3���u���u« ±Â~"s��r�re ®xrv�sut { kztc�Nqys-o� ~�a�o#tc�ues�¥!¥;s7~"mwx �²°

`/aweN¨�©�ª¶x-¦3¨º©�ª� � �� � � ��«Bnle"o { kztc�fqrs�qyace�xyo�d-e9d-eOo#xrmc�}eis�¥K~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|)qrac�rs�mc�ua7:9aR 1 ­ mwq¬qrs { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�q�v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { e�¤7klo�tc~"e�x�xracs^µ acs^µ qraceinlo#qrqre"�B~Oo�t kztc~"su�}vXs�®�yo#qrefo#t o {w{ kzqrklsut�o#n�v�e"t�o�n²q´| ­ | d-eOo�x}mc�rkztc�)qyacefo�d-sumct�q�s�¥�d-klx}xrkztc�)kltw¥;s��rdfo#qykzsut±~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw��qys ��±'kltY¨�©�ª �o#t { ¨�©�ª��^°9¨�©�ª���kltw~"su�}vXsu�ro#qye�x�qyaweNdfkzxrxrkztc��kztw¥;su��®d�o#qrklsut9kltiqyaweBv�sux�qye"�}klsu� { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e/µ·ackznled7:9��K�}e"��o�� { x ��o�xAo�tNe��7qy�ro]7:® { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�o�nv�o��yo#dfe�qye"�i¦ 7:9�� R 1]_ 7�« °�`/ackzx¬klnznlmcx�qy�ro#qye�xºqyaweimctcxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu��|Ykltw~"sutcx}klx�qye"tw~�|Ykztqyace�µ¶o^|)¨�©�ª �·q�o<4�e"x �fklt�qysWo�~�~"sumwtHq"±�o�x·dfe�tHqrklsutwe { klt�j:e�~�qrklsutL�w° �:°

� $ ��Af� ����·&¸��� ,)��&Â�'��� ��)�������&

Ä�x�d-e"t�qrklsutce { klt j:vckle��ue"nza�o�n²qye"�·e�q�o�n3°�¦3���u����«Bo�t { kltLqraceie�tcxrmckztc� { kzxr~�mcxrx}klsut±Eo�to��r~�ace�q´|7vckl~"o�n�e��wo�d-vcnle s�¥�o§d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo dfs { e"nºklx�qrace �L®´~�sud-vXsutwe"t�q�tcsu�}d�o�ndfk¯�:qrmc�re�klt)µ·ackl~�a

D[E�G I^KL�R �� � 7

�E�G I � e � L�e ��

� 7 R 1Ze

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 17: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�Og � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·kzqya�tcs#q�o#qrklsut�o�x { e�³�tce { klt�j7e"~�qrklsutL�w° �u°�`/ace�s ­ x}e"��¤ue { nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { klx

DFE�\]I^KMLSR�� ��

�� � 7

�EHG�I � e �

L /

`/acklx!dfs { e"nH~"o�t ­ e¶klt�qre"�rvw�re�qre { o�x�oºd-klx}xrkltw�#® { o�q�o·dfs { e"nHvc�}s ­ nze"d?kz¥wµ¶e�kzt�qy�rs { mc~�eqyace�d-e"d ­ e��rxrawklv ¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x � R E�� �e�/�/�/ne����ML�±�o x}e�qNs#¥ �L® { kzdfe�tcxrkzsut�o�nKklt { kl~"o#qysu�¤ue"~�qysu�}x"± { e�tcs�qre {�­ | � � R / � � �e /�/�/+e�� � � 2�� / �ke�1 2 � ±wx}sNqya�o#q � � R21¬k²¥+o�t { sutwnz|fkz¥G�kzx��ue�tce"�ro#qye { ¥;�rsud�qyace�tcsu�rdfo�n { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsut

�E�/�I � e �

L ±w~�sut { k²qykls�t�o�nTsut � � ±wo�t {DFE �� R21 LSR 7 °K`/ace�~�su�r�}e"xrv�sut { kltc�W~"s�dfvcnze�qre�nlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { klx�qrace"t

D[EH\ce��`I KML R�� ��

�� � �� 7

�E�G

�I � e � L���� ��/ ¦3�u«

� ��� �! #"�$&%(')$+*-,/.10�"j:kltc~�e DFE�\]I^KMLklxWoO¤#o�klnlo ­ nle-klt§~�nlsux}e { ¥;su�rd�±�qyawe�d-klx}xrkztc� { o#qyo � ~"o�t ­ e�kl��tcsu�re {o�t { qrace�e �:vc�re�xrxrkzsutcx�¦3�u«o#t { ¦4��«�¥;su��qyawe { e�¤:klo�tc~�e�o�t { ¨�©�ª ~Oo�t ­ ef~"sud-vcmwqre {mcxrkztc� ! xrkzdimcnpo�qye { ¤#o�nzmce"x�K $

&e�/�/�/ne K $ "

&¥;�}sud o�t ÃYª/ÃYª �}mct° ¦H/ e��}e�¥;e��Wqrace

�reOo { e"�/qys�ª¶e"nze"m:�)e�qºo�nS°'¦S���u����« ¥;su� { e�q�o�kznlx/s�¥+qyacetcs^µ�®´x�q�o�t { o�� { kld-vcnze"d-e"t�q�o#qrklsuts�¥·o�t§Ã ª/ÃYª o#nl�usu�}kzqracd�kzt dfk¯�7qymc�}efx}e�qrqrkltc��x"° « `/ace�³��}x}q�qye"�}d s�¥B¨�©�ª ±�¨�©�ª� o�t { ¨�©�ª �Bkzx/qyace��re�¥;s��re

QE�KML * T V

!"� #� W$XMYcD[E�G I^K $

#'&L

R T V!

"� #�

�� �� W$XMY�

�� � 7%$

#)&

�EHG�I � $

#'& e1� $

#'& L�� /

CTs��¶¨�©�ª �±7qyaceºvXsux�qye��rkls��¶d-eOo�tcx s�¥'qyawe¬v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx�o#�re�~�sud-vcmwqye { o�x qrace�ÃYª/à ªxyo�d-vcnleKd-eOo�twx!s�¥:qyace xrkzdimcnpo�qye { ¤#o�nzmce"x+s�¥:K7± ­ m:qO±�o�x+d-e"t�qykzsutce { klt9j:e�~�qykzsuti�:° �¶o�t {¥;mc�}qrace"� { klxr~�mcxrx}e { kltWª¶e�nle�m:�Ne�qKo�nS°w¦S�#�u�u��« ±#qyawe"xre·e�x}qykzd�o�qysu�}x�o��}e�tcs�q�dfe"o�tckltw��¥;mcn7kz¥tcs·k { e�tHqrkz³To ­ klnzkzq´|B~"sutwx}qy�ro�klt�q�kzx'kld-vXsux}e { sut�qyaweAd-s { e"nT¦3j7qye�vcace�tcx"±#���u����«�±�o�t { e�¤ue"tqyace�t qyace�|�s�¥�qye�tYnle"o { qrs�tce���o#qyk²¤ue�7:9 � x"°B©´t ¤7kle�µ�s#¥�qyackzxº~�sutcx}k { e��yo ­ nze { �yoOµ ­ o�~ 4T±qyace¨�©�ª ¶~"�rk²qye��rkls�t)klx/tcs�q/qrs ­ e�~"s�tcxrk { e"�}e { ¥;mw�}qyawe"��¥;su��qracklx·vc�}s ­ nle�dL°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 18: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �Q�

� ��� 0���� � $��1$�,/.10�"`/aceA³c�rx}q�qre"�rd-x�s�¥w¨�©�ª��Q±�¨�©�ª��!o�t { ¨�©�ª���o��}eAo�nln#k { e�tHqrkl~"o�nS°�©´t�¤:kze�µ s#¥:qracklx�±�µ e ~"o�tmcxre9qraceixro�dfeiÃYª/ÃYª�o�nl��su�rk²qyacd o#x ­ e�¥;su�}e9qysf~"sud-e9mcvYµ·k²qya o#t o�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�tqys �$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$�4±ce �:~"e"v:qºqra�o#q·µ¶eo�nzxrsWtce�e { qys-xrkld9mcnpo#qreºqrace � � x�°

�·e"~"o�nln+qya�o�q �$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I^KL I \$� R �$� / � � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K � I \ 2 ¦Sj:e�~�qykzsut�w° ��«�° ��kz¤ue�t qya�o#q"±º¥;su�)d-k²�7qrmc�re d-s { e"nlx�± ��� �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K �¬kzx�o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nle kzt~"nls�xre { ¥;su�}d o�x

��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\ce��!I^KML�I \ce K �:R�� ��

�� � D[E �

� R21 I^K e \�LkW6XMYkE 7

�EHG�I � e �

LNL�e

µ·kzqyaDFE �

� R21kI K eN\dLSR 7

�EHG�I � e �

L� �� � 7 �

�E�G�I �

�e �

�L{ e�¥R �

� EH\ce KML�e

qyackzx·o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qrklsut�klx/s ­ qyo�kltwe { ¥;�rsud qyace�ÃYª/à ª sumwqrvcmwq�K $ &e�/ /�/ne K $ "

&o�x

1!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� EH\ce K $

#'&LkW6XMY / 7%$

#'&

�E�G�I �($

#'& e � $

#)& L 2 / ¦�>�«

`/ace"t�qyace�x}e"~"s�t { qre"�rd klt�¨�©�ª��^±V ��� �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I ����� K I \ce�� � I \�� e

~Oo�t ­ e�o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qre {�­ |

V!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � � $

#'&� W$XY / 7 $

#)&

�EHG�I � $

#)& e � $

#'& L 2 ¦3�u«

µ·ace"�}e K $#'&R KOE�\ e�� $

#'&LcR��#� K I \ce�� $

#)&�S±cµ·awkl~�a ~"o�t ­ e�~"s�dfvcm:qye { e��wo�~�qyn²|u±To�xBxracs^µ·t

­ e�nls^µ�±Emcx}kltc�)x�q�o�t { o�� { �}e"x}mcnzqrx¬klt% ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�tIo�tco�nz|7xrkzxN¦4�Bs ­ e"��qO±E���u� �^«�°¬`/aceNvw�rkls��sut1KWkzx·o�xrx}mcd-e { qys ­ eoNvc�}s { mw~�qBs�¥!~"sut��}mw��o#qye { e�tcxrk²qykze"x"±

D[E2KMLSR DFE 7 L �� � D[E.� e1� L�e

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 19: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

��> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

µ·ace"�}e D[E 7 L'klx!o�¨�kz�rkz~�acnle�q { e"tcx}kzq´|�� E /�I � �e /�/�/+e�� � L�±MD[E.� I � L�kzx�o�twsu�rdfo�n { e�tcxrk²q´|�E /SI � e �

��� L�o�t { D[E.� Lºklx�o#t klt�¤ue��rxreN�uo�dfdfo { e�tcxrk²q´|���E /SI�� �MV e� �MVL�°�`/ace

�7mco�t�qykzqrkle�x�� e�/�/�/ne�� � ±�� ±�� ±�� o�t { o��}ei³w�:e { a�|:v�e"�}v�o��ro�dfe�qye��rx"°9© q¬¥;sunlnzs^µ·xqya�o#q

�7%$ #'& R �$��� 7 I \ce�� $#)&� R���� _ ! $

#'& ���� ��

� � � �_��

�� $#'& R �$��� � I \ce�� $

#)&� R � � � _ ! $

#'& �� $

#'& ���� E�� _ ! $

#)& L

�� $#'&

R �$��� � I \ce�� $

#'&�:R � _ � $

#'& _ � ! $

#)& � _ ! $

#)& E ��($

#'& T�� L � � E�� _ ! $

#)& T VL�e

µ·kzqya

! $#'& R

�� �� � $

#'&� e �� $

#)& R 1

! $#'&

�� �� � $

#)&� G

�e � $

#)& R

�� �� � $

#'&� EHG

�T �� $

#'& L e

o�t { µ·kzqra�qyace � $#'&R E � $

#'& e�/ /�/+e�� $

#'&� LAxrkld9mcnpo#qre { o�q/qyace���qra�k²qye��yo#qrklsutfs�¥�qyaceÃYª/à ª

o�nl�us��rkzqracd�°© ¥!µ¶e�mcx}e9o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qrklsutI¦�>�«�±:qyace¨�©�ª ~��rk²qye"�}klsut)kzx�qyace�t

¨�©�ª�� * T -!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� E�G e K $

#'&LkW6XMY / 7%$

#'&

�E�G

�I �($

#'& e � $

#)& L 2

_ V!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � � $

#'&� W$XMY7/ 7 $

#'&

�E�G�I � $

#)& e � $

#'& L 2 /

j:kld-klnlo��¶¥;su�}dimcnpo#e�o�vcvcn²|)¥;su��¨º©�ª �^±Tµ·kzqraLqrace9~�e"t�qy�ro�n { e�¤7kpo�tw~"eQE KML ­ e"kltw� ­ o�x}e {

kltcx�qyeOo { s�t�qracef¦ �}sukztHq�«�ÃLÄ�� e"x�qykldfo#qrsu�"°©´t qyacef~Oo�x}e�s�¥·¨�©�ª��^±+qyacef~"e"t�qr�yo�n { e�¤7kpo#tc~"e�o�nlx}s �re �Hmckl�}e"x9nze"x}x9~"s�dfvcm:q�o#qrklsut±

xrkltw~"e)kzqiklx ­ o�x}e { sut o�t§e"x�qykldfo#qre�s�¥!K qya�o#q { s:e�x-tws�q { e"v�e"t { sut ��°�/ e�qrace"t

4�5Jf64�7

Page 20: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �Q�

s ­ q�o#klt

T -!

"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� E�\ e K $

#)&LkW$XMY E 7 $

#'&

�E�G

�I�� $

#'& e1� $

#'& LNL

_ V�� ��

�� � �

� E�\ce �KLkW6XMY:E �7 � E�G � I �� e ��

L L�e

o�xBo�t�o�vcvc�}s^�:kzd�o#qrklsutfqys-¨�©�ª��^°

� ��� 0����*� �� ��� � , .�0�"j:kltc~�eqrace~"sut { kzqykzsut�o�nEnlk$4#e"nzklacs7s { D[E�G I � e KML�klxBoO¤#o�klnlo ­ nze�±wµ e9~"o�tYo�nzxrs-mcxre~"�}kzqre"�rklo¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨�©�ª��O°W`/aceN³��}x}q�qye��rd*~"o�t ­ e-o�vcvw�rsO�:kldfo#qye { kzt o�x}kld-klnlo��B¥4o#xrackzsut qysqyace�vc�}e�¤7klsumwxBx}e"~�qykls�t±ct�o�d-e"n²|)o�x

QE ��e KML * T V

!"� #�

�� ��

�� � �

� EH\ce K $

#'&LkW6XMY

�EHG�I � $

#'& e1� $

#'& L /

`/ace�x}e"~"s�t { qye��rd s�¥Â¨�©�ª��"± Q E �ke KL�±HklxA�re"o { kznz|Ns ­ q�o�kztce { ±�µ·ackznle/qyaweº~�sudfvwmwq�o#qrklsutwx¥;su�·¨�©�ª��ºs#¥

��� �^W$XY D[EH\]I � e � K EH\ce��ZLNL I \��o��re¬¤�e"�}|�x}kld-klnlo�� qrsWqracsux}evw�rsuv�suxre { o ­ s^¤ue�¥;su��qraceo�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�t�s�¥

Q * ,��°

&Bs�qye�acs^µ e�¤�e"��qra�o#qWqyace�µ e"kl��aHqrx 7 o��re�tcs nlsutw�ue"�Nv�o#�}q-s�¥�qraceL¨�©�ª ¥4o�~�qysu��±e��:~"e�vwqºqrac�rs�mc�ua)qyace�v�sux}qre"�}klsu��µ e"kz�ua�qyx �

� °

� � � � %($ � �� ���" �� $�����$+$ �-,/.10�� ��* ,/.10��/ e�a�oO¤ue

¨�©�ª� 8RUT.- ��� �^W$XMYcD[EH\]I^KL I \$�M_aV�W6XMYZDFE�\]I �K EH\dLNL�eµ·ace"�}e �KkEH\dL { e"tws�qye�x�oNv�sux}qre"�rkzsu��d-s { e�s�¥�K7±To�t {

¨�©�ª�� RUT.- �$��� � � W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I^KL I \�� _aV ��� � W6XMYZD[EH\ce�� I �$��� K:I \ce�����L�I \�� /

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 21: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�^� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

/ e�~Oo#t�µ·�}kzqye

�$��� � � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I KML I \�� R ���#� ��� /�W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \ce K 2 I \��R ���#� ��� /�W$XY D[EH\]I KML I \ce K 2 I \��

_.��� � � � / W$XMYcD[E �!I \ce KML�I \ce K 2 I \�� /`/ace"t

�$��� � �^W$XY D[EH\ce��!I^KL I \��OR3�$� �^W$XYZDFE�\�I KML�I \dL �:T ���#� Å�t�q(/�D[E �!I \ce KL 2 I \��e ¦4��«

µ·ace"�}eqrace�e"t�qy�}suv�|u±

Å�t�q�/ DFE � I \ e KML 2 R T � � / W6XMYZD[E � I \ce KML�I \ce K 2�� �klx¬ofdfe"o�xrmc�}eis�¥Kqyaweidfk¯�7qymc�}e�s^¤ue��rnlo�v° /[ace�tIqraceid-k²�7qymw�re9~�sud-vXsutwe"t�qyx�o#�re9µ e"nznxre"vco��yo#qre { qyackzx�e�tHqr�rsuv�|Iqye��rd kzxtweOo����Lo#t { k²q�kzx�¥4o���¥;�rsud ��µ·ace"t qyace-dfk¯�7qymc�}e~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyxBo��}e�vXs7su�}nz|fxre"vco��yo#qre { °

© q·¥;sunznls^µ·x¶qra�o#q

Q+*�,� R

Q+*�, d_ -��$�#� �t�q /�DFE � I \ e KML 2 I \��_ V ���+�^W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �$��� K I \ e�� � L I \��kT VSW6XMYZD[EH\]I �K EH\dL�e

&Bs^µ�±To�xrx}mcdfkztc�Nqya�o�q

��� � W$XMYZD[EH\ce��!I �#� K I \ e�� � L I \�� * � � � W6XMYcDFE�\ce�� I �KkE�\�L L I \ �`/acklx/x}acsumcn {L­ e�¤�o#nlk { vc�rs^¤7k { e { qra�o#q

�#� K I \ce � � EH\dL�� R �K EH\dLµ·ace"�}e � �:E�\dLcR ��� Y � ���� D[E��`I \dL /

4�5Jf64�7

Page 22: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �^�

`/awe�nlo�x}q�q´µ sfqre"�}dfx/~"o�t ­ e�¥;mc�}qrace"��µ·�}kzq}qye"tLo�xV ��� � W6XMYcDFE�\ e�� I �6��� K:I \ce�� � L I \�� T V�W$XMYZD[EH\]I �KkE�\�L+*

V � � � W6XMYcDFE � I \ce � K EH\dL L I \ � /`/awe"t

�$�#� �t�q /�D[E � I \ce KML 2 I \�� R T ���#� ��� / W$XYZDFE � I \ce KL I \ e K 2 I \��R T ����� � �^W$XMYcD[E � I \ce KML�I \��* T � � � W6XMYZD[E � I \ce �KkE�\dLNL I \ � /

`/ace¬npo#x}q/o#vcvc�rsO�:kldfo#qrklsut-xracs�mcn {�­ e¬�}eOo�x}sut�o ­ nzeºµ·ace�t)qyace¬v�sux�qye"�}klsu�K¥;su�8K9�ukz¤�e"tF\klx/xrm 5f~�kle�tHqrnz|)~�sutc~�e"t�qy�ro#qye { o��}sumct { kzqrx/dfs { e�°

/ e�qyace��re�¥;su�re�a�oO¤ue¨�©�ª�� * ¨º©�ª d_aV �$� � Å�tHq /�D[E �!I \ce KL 2 I \��Me ¦4��«

¥;�rsud µ·ackz~�a k²q�¥;sunznls^µ·x·qya�o#q�¨�©�ª�� � ¨�©�ª� o�t { qra�o#q¬qrace { k²¹Ee��re�tc~"e ­ e�q´µ e"e�t qraceq´µ¶s�~"�}kzqre"�rkloºkzx�q´µ·kl~�e¶qyace/v�sux�qye"�}klsu�!dfe"o�tNs�¥�qrace/dfk¯�7qymc�}e¶e"t�qr�rsuv�|u°�`/awklx�kztce �Hm�o�nzkzq´|~Oo�t ­ e¬¤�e"�}kz³�e { klt�qrace�e��:v�e"�rkzdfe�t�qyx/qya�o�qB¥;s�nlnls^µ�°

`/awe9kld-v�su�}qyo�t�q·vXsukzt�qBqrs�tcs#qye�o ­ s�mwq·qyackzxºkztce �Hm�o�nzkzq´|)kzx/qya�o#q�¨�©�ª���o#t { ¨�©�ª� o��re�s�¥ { k²¹Ee��re"t�qBt�o#qrmc�re�x"±cµ·k²qyaL¨�©�ª���v�e"t�o#nlk���kltc�9vXs7su�rn²|�x}e"v�o#�yo#qre { dfk¯�:qrmc�re�x"°

� �� � � � � $&% ��� �������� )% " ��/[ace"t ~"o�nl~�mcnpo�qykltw��qracef¤#o��}klsumwx9¨�©�ª¶x�¥;su�qrace�������� ����������������tcs^µ�mcxre { klt dfsux�qv�o�v�e"�rxBsut�dfk¯�7qymc�}ee�x}qrkldfo#qykzsut±wµ e9s ­ q�o�kzt�qrace�re"x}mcnzqrxºvw�re"x}e"t�qye { klt�`�o ­ nle �u° Ä�xsutce�~Oo�t§x}e"e�±�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª � { s tcs�q ­ e"a�oO¤�eLxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu�}klnz| (�qrace�¥;su�}dfe��NnleOo { xqysWe��:~"e�xrx}kz¤ue�nz|�nlo��r�ue¬o�t { tcsut:® kltc~��re"o�xrkztc� 7:9 � x"±�vc�}e"x}mcd�o ­ nz| ­ e�~Oo�mcx}e�s�¥�k²qyx/kztc~"sut7®xrklx�qye�tc~�| klt { e"o�nlkztc�)µ·kzqya � o�t { qrs v�s:s��ÃYª/ÃYª o�vcvc�}sO�wkzd�o�qykls�tcx�qys�qyace�ÃLÄ��e"x}qrkldfo#qye�x"°�`/ace��}e"x}mcnzqrx�¥;�rs�d ¨�©�ª �io��re-tcs�q9�re"nzkpo ­ nle ­ e"~Oo#mcxre�s#¥·~"sud-vcmwqyo#qykzsut�o�nvc�rs ­ nle"d-x"°¶¨�©�ª��ºnzeOo { x·qys-npo#�r�ue��Z7O9 � x·qys7sc±�vc�}e"x}mcd�o ­ nz|�o�xºoWxrk { e�e�¹Ee�~�q¬s#¥�kltw~"su� ®vXsu�ro#qykztc� � o#x�o�v�o��ro�dfe�qye��"±Xµ·awe"�re"o�x�¨�©�ª�� ­ e�a�oO¤ue�xxro#qykzx}¥4o�~�qysu�}kln²|)µ·kzqya �}e"x}vXe�~�qqys�7O9¶±w~�sutcxrk { e"�}kltc�qya�o�q¶¥;su� o��L® ~"sud-vXs�tce"t�q�d-k²�7qrmc�re·qyaceºtHmcd ­ e"��s�¥Âv�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}xklx�� � T 1u°�C�klt�o#nlnz|�±Etcs#qyeiqyaco#q�o�nln�¨�©�ª¶x�kzt { kz~Oo#qre���o#x�qrace-o�vcvc�}suvc�}kpo#qreitHmcd ­ e"�

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 23: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

��� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

s�¥�~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyx"°-©´t o {c{ kzqrklsutE±Âqyace-e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsut ¥;su��¨�©�ª���x}q�o ­ klnzklxre�x�o#¥�qye��� R �:±cklt { kl~Oo�qykltw�9qya�o�q�qyace�e �:qr�yoN~"s�dfv�sutce�tHqrx { sWtcs�q/�u�}eOo#qrnz|�~"sut�qy�}k ­ m:qye¬qysiqrace{ e�¤7kpo#tc~"e/s�¥�qrace/d-s { e�nS±Qµ·ackl~�aWdfoO|9tcs#q ­ e¶xrs�o�vcvw�rsuvc�}kpo#qre�°+`/ace/xyo#dfe�kzx�s ­ x}e"��¤ue {¥;su��¨�©�ª���qys�o)nle"x}xre��e �7qye"t�q"°f¨º©�ª �uk²¤ue"x��}eOo�x}sut�o ­ nleW�re�xrmcn²qyx�mct�qykzn+� R -w°i`/acexrm ­ x}e �Hmce�tHq { e��u�yo { o#qykzsut�¥;su� � R � o�t { � R��fd�oO|�~"sud-e�¥;�rsud qyawe9kltwx}q�o ­ klnzkzq´|klt qyace-vcnzmc�#®´kzt e"x�qykldfo#qre[D[EH\]I �KkE�\�L L�°-`/ace�o { e �Hm�o�~�|Is�¥¶qrace-vcnlmc��®´klt e�x}qrkldfo#qye�xkzxxracs^µ·t kzt C�kl��mc�re�x �9o�t { �7°

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

C�kl�umw�re � ( �o#npo��7| { o�q�o�x}e�q!s�¥�� V/s ­ x}e"�}¤#o#qrklsutwx+µ·k²qya � R V·~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�³cq}qye { (�oO¤�®e"�yo#�ue { e�tcxrk²q´| ¦��� � �No�t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±7vwnlmc�#® klt { e"twxrkzq´|-µ·kzqra)oO¤ue��yo��ue�v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x�¦ ���� ����o�t { { s#qyx�« ±�vcnzmc�#®´kzt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqya d�o#�r�ukzt�o�nAÃLÄ�� v�o#�yo�d-e�qre"�rx�¦� ���� ��������� �����Lo�t {{ s�qyx ® o�t { ® { o#xrace�x�«�±+o�t { vwnlmc�#® klt { e"tcx}kzq´|Yµ·k²qya��}sukztHq�ÃLĬ� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x-¦���������� ������o�t {){ o�x}ace"xy«�°K`/ace�tHmcd ­ e"�¶s�¥+kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx kzx �^�w± �u�u��¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«Avwnlmcx �O�w± ���u�)¦4dfo�kztT«�°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 24: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# � �

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

10 15 20 25 30 35

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

0.25

C�kl�umw�re�� ( ��o�npo��7| { o�q�o�x}e�qis#¥ � V�s ­ xre"��¤#o#qykzsutcx�µ·k²qya � R � e - e � e ��~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyx³cqrqre { (9o^¤�e"�ro��ue { e"tcx}kzq´| ¦ �� �� o#t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±+vwnlmc�#® klt { e�tcxrk²q´| µ·k²qya oO¤ue"�ro��uefv�o��yo#dfe ®qye"�}x¬¦ ���� ����9o�t {�{ s�qyxy«�±7vcnlmc��®´klt { e�tcxrk²q´|Nµ·kzqra�dfo��r�ukzt�o�nTÃ�Ĭ� v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx�¦� ���� � ������ � � �)o#t { { s�qyx ® o�t { ® { o�x}ace"xy«�±�o�t { vcnlmc��®´klt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqra��}suklt�q�ÃLÄ�� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x¦�������� � ������Io�t { { o�xrawe"x�« °�`/aceIt7mwd ­ e���s�¥9k²qye��yo#qrklsutcxfklx%�^�:± �u��� ¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«fvcnzmcx�^�w± �u�u��¦4dfo�kztT«�°

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 25: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�u� � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

−2 0 2 4 6 8

0.0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

C�kl�umw�re�� (¬j7kldimcnlo#qye { { o�q�o�x}e�q�s�¥ 1 -���s ­ x}e"��¤�o�qykls�tcxºµ·k²qya � R V e �ke - e � e � e � ~�sudN®vXsutwe"t�qyx9³wqrqye { (fo^¤�e"�ro��ue { e�tcxrk²q´| ¦��� � � o�t { ¥;mcnzn�« ±�vcnzmc�#®´kzt { e"tcx}kzq´| µ·kzqya o^¤�e"�ro��uev�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x·¦ ���� �����o�t {N{ s#qyx�« ±�vcnlmw�#®´kzt { e"twxrkzq´|�µ·kzqraNd�o��}�ukltco�n:ÃLĬ� v�o��yo#dfe�qye"�}x¦� ���� � ��� ��� ������o#t {9{ s#qyx�®´o�t { ® { o�x}ace"xy«�±Ho�t { vcnlmw�#®´kzt { e�tcxrk²q´|�µ·k²qya/�}suklt�q�ÃLĬ� v�o��ro�dN®e�qye��rxº¦���������� ������·o�t {W{ o#xrace�x�«�°�`/aweBtHmcd ­ e��As#¥Xk²qye��yo#qrklsutcx�klx �^�w± �u�u�W¦ ­ mc�}t:®´kztT«!vcnzmcx�^�w± �u�u��¦4dfo�kztT«�°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 26: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# ���

¨º©�ª ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª�� ¨º©�ª � ¨�©�ª�� ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª���� gH��� gH� � ����� ���u� ��� � g �Q� g �O�

�:° �> �w°->> �:° ��� �����:° �u� gc° gu� � ��° ��� gc° �u�� gug�� g��M> g > � >���� gH� � ����� �����

�w° ��� gc° �#g >w° g�� ��>��:° ��� �^�:° ��� �^�:° ��� �:° g��g gug > g��u� gH��� >�gu� g���� �u�u� �u�u�

� �u° ��� �:° g � �:° �u� �^�u�w° g�� ��>w° ��� �Q�7° gH� � �u° ���� gugH� gugH� g���� >��#� � � � �u��� �u���

�^�w° �u� �:° gu� �:° ��� �^�u�w° ��� ���w° �#� ���:° �u� �Q�:° �Q�> gug�� gugug g���g >��<> ����� g���� �u���

� �u° �> �:° gu� �w° g�� �^� �u° �^� gM>w° ��� ���:° ��� �^�w° ��g� g >u� gug > ���u� ����� �u� � gH�u� g����

�^�w° �> �:° ��� �w° �u� ���u�w° ��� ���u° �<> g��:° � � �#gc° �u�

`�o ­ nle!� (-�Be�xrmcn²qyx�¥;s��qrace ������� ��������� ��� ��o�t { ���w± �u�u�Yà ª/ÃYª xrkld9mcnpo#qrklsutwx (9s ­ ®xre"��¤ue { ±w~�sudfvwnle�qre·o�t { ~"sut { kzqrklsut�o#n�¨�©�ª¶x�o#t { ~�su�r�}e"x}vXsut { kltc�e�¹Xe"~�qyk²¤ue { kld-e"tcx}klsutwx7:9¶°

7 7� 7 � 7 � � � � � � � � � � � � �`!�}mce ° �> ° ��� ° �Q� ° ��� ® ��° � � �:° � �w° � ° �u� ° ��g � �u° > ° �u�à o�v ° �u� ° �u� ° ��� ° ���u� ® �u° �u� ®�° �^� �:° �u� �:° ��� ° �u� ° �^� ° ��� �u° >�gÃLeOo�t ° ��� ° ��� ° ��� ° �M> � ® �u° �u� ®�° ��� �:° �^� >w° �u� ° �Q� ° �Og ° �> �:° �u�ÃLd�o#v ° � � ° ��g ° �Og ° � � ® �u° ��� ®�° �u� �:° �Q� �w° g > ° �^� ° � � �:° �#g ° �u�

`�o ­ nle-� (Å�x}qrkldfo#qykzsutY�re�xrmcn²qyx�¥;su�¬qraceWxrkld9mcnpo#qre {I{ o#qyo�xre�q�µ·kzqya �OgM>�s ­ xre��}¤#o#qykzsutcx�±� R --o�t { 1 � e � � �WÃYª/à ª xrkzdimcnpo�qykls�tcx"°

/ e�o�nzxrsWo�t�o#nz|7xre { o { o#q�o�x}e�q·s�¥ 1�-�is ­ xre��}¤#o#qrklsutcx/x}kldimwnpo#qre { ¥;�}sud¸qrace�tcsu�}d�o�ndfk¯�:qrmc�re� / V ��3, E��ke�/-V L _ � /-V � ��, E T 1 / � e�/ � L _ � / 1 � 11, E�V�/ V e � / - L _ � / V � 11, E � / �ke�/ � L /`/acefx}kldimwnpo#qrklsutY�}e"x}mcnzqrx9o��}e-o^¤#o�kznpo ­ nleikzt `!o ­ nze-�w°FC!kl�umc�}eW���}e"vc�}e"x}e"t�qyx9qraceW~"su� ®�re"x}vXs�t { kltw� e"x�qykzd�o#qre"x�o#¥�qye�� V � e � � ��kzqre"�yo�qykls�tcx�¥;su��� R V:°1C�su��qyackzx�tHmcd ­ e��9s�¥

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 27: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�#g � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

¨�©�ª ¨�©�ª�� ¨º©�ª�� ¨�©�ª � ¨º©�ª � ¨�©�ª�� ¨�©�ª���� ��� � �#��� ���u� �u��� >u�u� g��u� ���u�

�7° �^� >w° �u� �:° �Q� ® �^�w° g�� �w° ��� �^�:° �#� gc° �^�� �u�#g ���u� �>u� g�� � ���#g � �Q� � �^�

���u° g�g �Q�:° �u� >w° �> ®´� �u° >�� � �u° �> �7° ��� �w° gH�g ���u� �#��g �u�u� �u�u� �#g � �>u� �����

�^�:° � � ��° g �w° � ® �Q���w° � ®����u° � g��:°-> �^�:° �� �#g�� ����� > �^� g���� >���� ���u� ���^�

���u°-> � ��° � �Q�:° � ® ��>��:° � ���w° � ��gc° � �^�:° g> ����� ���u� >���� g��M> ����� �u� � ���Q�

�O�w°-> �^�:° � ��>w° g ® �Q���w° � �u�w° � ���:° � ��>:° �� ����g ���> >u��� �u��� ����� �#g�� ���^�

�^�:° �> �w° ��g ���w° ��� ® � ��>w° >�� �u�:° ��� �#�w° ��g ���w° �Q�

`�o ­ nlei� (��·e"x}mcnzqrx�¥;su��qraceixrkzdimcnlo#qye {Y{ o#qyo�xre�q¬µ·kzqra �Og >�s ­ xre��}¤#o#qykzsutcx�o#t { V �ke � � �ÃYª/ÃYª x}kldimcnlo#qykzsutcx(�s ­ x}e"��¤ue { ±X~�sudfvwnle�qre�o�t { ~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n¨�©�ª¶x9¦;³c�rx}qºnlkztce^« o�t {~"su�}�re"x}vXs�t { kltw�-e�¹Ee�~�qrkz¤ue { kzdfe�tcxrkzsutcxd7:9 ¦4x}e"~�sut { nlkltwe^«�°

~"sud-vXs�tce"t�qyx�±�qyawe { k²¹Ee��re"tw~"e"x ­ e�q´µ¶e�e"t qyawe�e"x�qykldfo#qre"x�o��reftce"�unzkl�uk ­ nle#°�`/ace�xyo�d-eo�vcvcnzkle"xBqys C!kl�umc�}ei�w±X¥;su� � R �w°�`/ace { k²¹Ee��re"tw~"e"x�x�q�o���q¬qys�o�vcv�eOo���¥;s�� � R2-)kztC�kl�umw�ref�w°Ij:kztc~"e�qrace�~�su�r�}e"~�qit7mwd ­ e��is�¥·~�sudfv�sutce�t�qyxikzx9klt { e"e { -c±�µ e�~"sud-v�o��}eqyaceN¤#o��rkzsumcx�e�x}qykzd�o�qye"x¬µ·k²qya qyaweWqr�rmceN¤#o�nzmce"x�kzt `!o ­ nzef�:°(C�kl��mc�reW�)xrawsQµ·xnpo#�r�ue��{ kz¹Xe"�}e"tc~�e"x·¥;su� � R � ± � R �fo#t { � R � °#&ºs�qre�qya�o#q"±�o#¥�qye��� R -w±cqyacevc�re { kl~ ®qykz¤�e { e�tcxrk²q´|�aco�� { n²|-~�a�o�tc�ue�x"°K`/ace¬xro�d-e�vcace�tcsud-e"tcs�t)s:~�~"mc�}x�klt C!kl�umc�}e¬��¥;su�Aqrace�o�nlo��7| { o#q�o�x}e�q"°

¨º©�ª ¶o�t { ¨�©�ª�� ­ e"a�oO¤ue�xrkld-klnlo��rn²|�o�x�¥;su�AqraceB��o�npoQ�:| { o#q�o#xre�q"°�¨�©�ª��/o�t { ¨�©�ª��o��reAtcs�q�xyo#qrklx}¥4o#~�qys��}|�vc�}s { mw~"kltw��tce���o#qyk²¤ueJ7:9 � x"±�µ·ackz~�a9¥;su��¨�©�ª���klx+tcs�q�kltc~�sutcxrkzx}qre"t�qµ·kzqya)qrace��re�d�o�� 4�sut�k²qyx/v�suxrk²qykz¤7k²q´|fkztLj:e"~�qykls�tL�:° �9x}kltc~�e�¥;s��¶qyace�d-k²�7qymw�re¬e �co#dfvcnzeqyaceBvc�rkzsu�KklxKtcs�q �To�qO°K¨�©�ª�� vw�rs { mc~"e�x¶tcs�t:®´kztc~"�}eOo�x}kltc� 7:9 � x"°�¬tcn²|W¨�©�ª��/o#t { ¨�©�ª���ukz¤�e"x+�reOo#xrsut�o ­ nle 7:9 � x!µ·k²qyai¨º©�ª���xre"nze"~�qykltw� � R -ºµ·ackznleA¨�©�ª���kzx!x}e"nle�~�qrkltc� � R � °&ºs�qre�qra�o#qº¨�©�ª��¬o#t { ¨º©�ª �ºxre�nle"~�qºqrace�rkl��aHq·tHmcd ­ e��ºs�¥!~"s�dfv�sutce�tHqrx�� C�su� �O�w± ���u�dfsu�}e�ÃYª/ÃYª?kzqye��yo#qrklsutwx"±cµ e9s ­ x}e"��¤ue { qra�o#q�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨º©�ª �Bµ¶e��reix�qykznln'xre�nle�~�qykztc�

4�5Jf64�7

Page 28: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �u�

� R -Wµ·kzqraLtce���o#qrkz¤ue 7:9 � x�±T¨�©�ª���µ¶o�xºx}e"nze"~�qrkltc��� R --qrs:s-o�t { qyawes#qyace��rx·µ¶e��rexre"nze"~�qykltw� � R � °

� � �9��¶. �&'����

`/acklx�v�o�v�e"�9aco�x9x}acs^µ·t qya�o#q�qyace { e�¤7klo�tc~"e�kltw¥;su�}d�o�qykls�t ~"�rk²qye��rkls�t s�¥Bj7vckle��ue"nza�o�n²®qye"�9e�q-o�n3°�¦3���u���u«o�t { qrace)~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc� e�¹Xe"~�qykz¤�e { kld-e"twxrkls�t o�nlnzs^µ ¥;su�No µ·k { e�yo�tc��e�s#¥�kztHqre"�}vc�re�q�o#qrklsutcxWo#t { e �7qye"twxrkls�tcxfs�mwqyx}k { e�e��:v�sutce�tHqrkpo�n�¥4o#dfkznlkle�x"±Ko�xNµ¶o�xo�nl�}eOo { | o�vcvco��re�tHq�¥;�}sudÆqraceNvcm ­ nzklx}ace {I{ kzxr~"mwxrxrkzsut s�¥KqyaceWv�o�v�e"��°P/[a�o#q�µ e-a�oO¤ue¥;sumct { kltfo {c{ k²qykzsutiqyac�}sumc�uaWqyawe"su�}e�qykz~Oo�n�o�t { e �wv�e"�}kld-e"t�q�o#n�x}qym { kle�x kzxKqra�o#qAxrs�dfe·s�¥qyace�xre�e��7qre"tcx}klsutcx�±wµ·ackznleºo�x tco#qymc�ro�n � o�x qrace¬s�qrace"�}x"±�o#�re�x}kld-vcnz|-tcs#q/o { e �Hm�o#qyeº¥;su�e�¤#o�nlmco#qykztc��qyace-~"s�dfvcnze��:kzq´|Yo�t { ³cqs�¥/o�dfs { e�nS±'e"k²qyace�� ­ e�~Oo�mcx}e-qrace�| �uk²¤ue ���% � ��2�����e�¹Xe"~�qrkz¤�e { kld-e"tcx}klsutcx�s�� ­ e"~"o�mcx}eBqrace�|We �wawk ­ k²q�qys7sd9mc~�a-¤#o��}kpo ­ klnlk²q´|�¥;�rsud s�tcedfs { e"nÂqrs-qracetce��7qO° /[awklnle�j:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"��e�q¬o�n3°+¦S�������u«�o��}�umce�qya�o#qºtce���o#qyk²¤ue 7:9 � xo��re)kzt { kl~"o#qyk²¤uefs�¥ºoIv�sux}xrk ­ nz| vXs7su�9³cq ­ e�q´µ e"e�t qrace)dfs { e�n�o�t { qrace { o#qyow±�qyace��reklx�tcs�e��:vcnlo�t�o#qrklsutIs�¥Aqyaco#q 4Hklt { klt sumw�~"o�xre�x (�¥;su�¬qyawe-xro�d-e { o#q�o�o�t { qraceWxyo�d-edfs { e"n3±wx}sudfe�¨º©�ª¶x�o��}eo�xrx}s:~�kpo#qre { µ·kzqra�v�sux}kzqyk²¤ue 7:9!xºo#t { s#qyace��rxBo��re�tws�qO°

ĺdfs�tc�)qyaceW¤#o��rkzsumcx�~"�}kzqre"�rklow±�¨�©�ª���o�t { ¨�©�ª ��x}qyo�t { sumwqo�x ­ e�kltc�)qraceWdfsux�q�re"nzkpo ­ nle)s�¥ºqyace ¨�©�ª¶xfµ e x�qym { kze { (Lqyace�| o#�re�dfsu�}e��re"x}klx�q�o�t�q�qrs v�s7su�We"x}qrkldfo#qye�xklt qra�o#q�¨º©�ª � { s:e�x�tcs�q { e"v�e"t { sut e�x}qykzd�o�qye"xi¦4kzt qyace9~"npo#xrxrkz~Oo�n+xre�tcxreO«�o�t { ¨�©�ª���re"nzkle�x�sut o�~�sut { k²qykls�t�o�n�e�x}qrkldfo#qyeiqra�o#q��ue�qyxoO¤ue"�ro��ue { s^¤ue���k²qye"�ro#qykzsutcx�° ºs^µ e�¤ue��"±qyace ­ e"a�oO¤7kls�mc�is�¥º¨�©�ª��Wklt qre"�rd-xis�¥·qrace)~"su�}�re�xrv�sut { kztc� 7:9?klx��Hmce�x}qrklsut�o ­ nle#° © ¥sutce�s�¥�qrace"x}eLq´µ s ¨�©�ª¶xftce"e { xWqys ­ e�vckl~ 4#e { sumwq�o�x � �O�N¨�©�ª¸¥;su�Wdfkzxrx}kltc� { o�q�odfs { e"nzx"± kzq-klx-mct { s�m ­ qye { nz| ¨�©�ª��Q±/o#xfk²q ­ mwkln { x-s�t qyawe d-klxrx}kltc� { o#qyo x�qy�rmw~�qymw�re�yo#qrace"��t�o#qrmc�yo#nlnz|�±ºx�q�o���qykztc� ¥;�}sud qrace ~"sud-vcnle�qyeI¨�©�ª*o#t { kzt�qye"���yo#qrkltc� s^¤ue���qracedfkzxrxrkztc�L¤#o��}kpo ­ nle"x�° BsQµ e�¤�e"��±¶¨�©�ª��Wkzx9tcs�qiklt�¤#o��rklo�t�q�qrs qyace)~�awsukl~�e�s�¥ �¸¦�µ·acklnze¨�©�ª��¶klxy«�°�`/awklx ¨�©�ª q�o4#e"x klt�qys9o�~"~�sumct�q qrace�d-klx}xrkztc� { o#q�ox}qr�rmc~�qymc�}e ­ mwq kzqK¥4oO¤us��rxdfs { e"nzx�dfkztckld-k���kltc�·qyaweºd-klx}xrkltw�kztw¥;su�}d�o#qrklsut)¦3o�xKxrawsQµ·t�kltfj:e"~�qykzsut��7° gH« °d/[ackznle·oxre"twxrk ­ nle/~�acsukz~"e#±H¨�©�ª�� { s:e�x�tcs�qKtce�~"e"x}xyo��}kln²|inle"o { qys¬qrace/d-sux}q�x}mckzqyo ­ nze�dfs { e�nS° CTs��kltcx�q�o�tc~�e�±+kltIqyacefdfk¯�7qymc�}e-~"o�xre#±�k²q�~�aws:sux}e"xqyace-dfk¯�7qymc�}e-d-s { e"n�µ·k²qyaIqyacef~"nlmwx}qye��x}qy�}mc~�qrmc�re�µ·kzqra�qrace��u�re"o#qye�x}qºe�¤7k { e"tc~�e9o�t { qracklx·d-s { e�nÂ~Oo#t ­ e { kz¹Xe"�}e"t�qº¥;�}sud¸qracedfsux�qB�re"nze�¤#o�t�qBdfs { e�nS° &Bsutce�qyace�nle"x}x"±X¨�©�ª¶x�~"o�t ­ exre"e�t o�xºo+ �oO|�e"xrklo�tL¤�e"�}xrkls�t s�¥Ä�©�ª?o�t { ±Eo�x¬v�suklt�qre { s�mwq ­ | x}e�¤�e"�yo#n { klx}~"mcx}xyo�t�qrx�kltIj:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"�·e�q�o#nS°!¦S�������u«�±

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 29: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

�> � ��,$� ������� ������ # �� ��������� ��� ���2��������&%� ��

qyace�|fdfoO|Wmct { e��rv�e"t�o#nlk���e·dfs { e"nT~�sudfvwnle��:k²q´| (�¨�©�ª���~"o�t�qyawe"�re�¥;su�re ­ eºe �wv�e"~�qye { qys�re { mc~"e�qyackzx�qye�t { e"tw~�|�klt�oNxre�tcxrk ­ nle�µ¶oO|u°

`/awe¶¥4o�~�q!qya�o�q�¨�©�ª���vc�}s { mc~"e�x�kltc~��re"o�xrkztc� 7:9!x!¥;su�+kltc~��re"o�xrkztc��~�sudfvwnle��:k²q´|�kzx!tws�q¤ue"��|ix}mc�rvc�}klx}kltc�c± ­ mwqKkzq�vXs�klt�qyx�s�mwqKo { �ro^µ ­ o�~ 49µ·kzqraiqyackzx�4Hklt { s#¥X~��rk²qye"�}kpow± ­ e�~Oo�mwxre~"sutcx}k { e��rkztc� �Vo�x�o�t o {c{ k²qykzsut�o�n+v�o��ro�dfe�qye���d�o4#e"x¬qraceL¦4~"s�t { kzqrklsutco�n�«/dfs { e�n�qys7so { o�vwqrkz¤�e�qrs ­ e�µ¶e�nln¯® { kzxr~"�}kld-klt�o�qykltw�c°�j7kld-klnpo#�rnz|�±7¨�©�ª��ºkzxBtws�q·¤ue"��| { klx}~"�}kld-klt�o#qrkltc�­ mwq�k²qAd�oO|Nµ¶o��r�ro�t�q¶¥;mc��qyace��¶klt�¤�e"x}qrkl��o�qykls�t)(�© q klxA�yo#qrace"� x}qyo ­ nle·¥;su�K¤#o��}|7kltw���:x¶o�t {kzq/nzeOo { x/qrs 7O9 ¤#o�nzmce"x·~�nlsux}e¬qysNqyace�tHmcd ­ e"�·s�¥!v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rx·klt)qrace�dfs { e"n3°

�/�#���!�·��¶�·&

à °KÄ�kzqN4Hklt° �!sux�qye"�}klsu� ­ oO|�e"x�¥4o�~�qysu�}xY¦�µ·kzqra { kzxr~�mcxrx}klsutT« °��O� � �� �,!� � � �O� ���M�,� ����2�$#������N�, � ����������� � � ������� #�·±���� ( � � �� �"gH�:± �^�u� �u°

�!° ¶�}|uo�t�q�o�t { �w°XÄ�° /[kznlnzkpo�d-xrsutE° ĺx}|7dfv:qys�qrkl~ ­ e�a�oO¤:kzsumc�Bs�¥�nlo�xrx}kz³�~"o#qykzsutLdfo��:k²®dimwd nlk64�e"nzklacs7s { e"x�qykzd�o#qre"x�°��]�����F���2�������±k>�� ( �u��� w�#� �u± �O�����w°

�W°Hª¶e�nle�m:�X±cà ° Bmc�rtE±:o#t { ª�°7�+°H�Bs ­ e"��qO°Eª¶sud-vcmwq�o�qykls�t�o�nco#t { kztw¥;e"�}e"t�qyklo�n { k;5-~"mcn¯®qrkle"x+µ·kzqraidfk¯�7qymc�}e v�sux}qre"�}klsu� { klx�qy�}k ­ mwqrklsutwx"°��O� � �� �, � � � �O���!�F�������N� � ������$#��2���N�,�!# #���������2�����±c���c¦3�u«0( ���u��:�u���w±w���u�u�w°

à °�¨�e"©´su�}kls�o�t { ª�°#�!°��·s ­ e"�}q"°7¨�klx}~"mcx}xrkls�tis�¥Tj7vckle��ue"nza�o�nzqre"��e�q�o�n3° � x�v�o�v�e"�"°��O� � �� �,� � � �O� ���M�, � ������$#��2���N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�/±O>�g ( >���� &>u�u�w±c���u���:°Ä9° �!°+¨�e"d-vcx�qye"��± &° à ° � o�kl� { ±+o�t { ¨9° º°!�·m ­ kzt°�à oQ�wkzdimcd*nzk$4#e"nlkzacs7s { ¥;�}sud*klt7®

~�sudfvwnle�qre { o#q�o¬¤7kpo�qyaweºÅAÃ%o�nl�us��rkzqracd ¦;µ·kzqra { klxr~�mcxrx}klsut�«�°��O� � �� �, � �]� �O� ���M�,� ����2�$#������N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�·±c�u� ( ��:�u�w± �^���u�7°

�°H�N° Ä9° � kzq}qynze/o�t { ¨9° �°u�Bm ­ klt° �¬t��}suklt�qyn²|9e�x}qrkldfo#qykztc�¬v�o��ro�d-e�qye��rxKo�t { d-klx}xrkltw�{ o�q�o ­ |§dfo��:kld-k���kltc��qyace�~�sudfvwnle�qre�® { o#q�o nzk$4�e�nlkzacs:s { °��!�F�������N� � � ����$#�����������±����( � �O� w�u���:± �^�u���w°

C¶° �°Xª�°ÂÃLo��r�}kls�q}qO°/j7e"v�o��ro#qykztc��d-k²�7qrmc�re�xBs#¥�dfk¯�7qymc�}e { klx}qr�rk ­ mwqykzsutcx�°��]�����F��������� #�±� ��( �>u��w�>u�:± �^�����:°

jX°��Bkz~�a�o�� { xrsut°7¨�kzxr~�mcxrx}klsut�s�¥Tj:vwkle"��e"nlaco�nzqre"�'e�q�o�n3°��:� � �� �,:� � � �O� ����, � ������$#��2���N�,� ����������� � #�������� #�/±O>�g ( >u� �u±����u���:°

4�5Jf64�7

Page 30: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

����������� ������������������������������������������! "�$# #���&%��'����( )�+*&��,-# �u�

ª�°T�!°T�·s ­ e��}q"° �&�O���� � � #������ �O����� � � #�� � �� * �N*�����������°Kj:vw�rkltw�ue"���Ke��rnpo#�c±T���u� �u°ª�°#�+°��·s ­ e"��q�o#t { �N°#ª�o�xre�nlnpo:°O )��O��� �Z���,$� � � ����$#������N�, )��� �O�+*�#�°:j:vw�rkltw�ue"���Ke"�}npo��c±&Be�µ��Asu� 4T±)�^�u�u�:°

¨9°+�w°+j:vckze"�ue�nla�o�n²qye��"±6&° �N°6 ¶e�x}qO±�ª�o��}nlklt º° �+°z±!o�t { Ä9°Â¤#o�t { e�� � kzt { e�° ¶o^|�e"x}kpo�td-eOo�x}mc�re�x�s�¥�d-s { e"n�~"sud-vcnle �:kzq´|-o�t { ³wqO° �:� � �� �, � �!� �O� ���M�, � � ����$#������N�, � ����� ������ � #�������� #�·± >�g ( ���u� >#g��w±w���u���:°

à °Xj7qye�vcace"twx"°·¨�e"o�nlkztc�-µ·k²qya�npo ­ e"n'x�µ·kzqr~�ackltc�-klt�d-k²�7qymc�}e�dfs { e"nzx"° �:� � �� �,d� � � �O� ����, � � ����$#��2���N�, � ����������� � #�������� #�·±:>�� ( ����� :�u�u�w±w���u���w°

fJfhgikj+lnm�o

Page 31: Deviance Information Criteria for Missing Data Models · Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes 655, avenue de l’Europe, 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France) Téléphone : +33 4

Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes655, avenue de l’Europe - 38330 Montbonnot-St-Martin (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)

Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis : 2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)

ÉditeurINRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)��������� ���� ���������� ��� ���

ISSN 0249-6399


Top Related