![Page 1: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Edinburgh Research Explorer
Designing from, with and by Data: Introducing the ablativeframework
Citation for published version:Speed, C & Oberlander, J 2016, Designing from, with and by Data: Introducing the ablative framework. inProceedings of DRS 2016 International Conference: Future–Focused Thinking. Proceedings of DRS 2016,vol. 1, pp. 2991-3004, 50th Anniversary Design, Research, Society Conference: Future–Focused Thinking,Brighton, United Kingdom, 27/06/16. <http://www.drs2016.org/proceedings>
Link:Link to publication record in Edinburgh Research Explorer
Document Version:Peer reviewed version
Published In:Proceedings of DRS 2016 International Conference: Future–Focused Thinking
General rightsCopyright for the publications made accessible via the Edinburgh Research Explorer is retained by the author(s)and / or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing these publications that users recognise andabide by the legal requirements associated with these rights.
Take down policyThe University of Edinburgh has made every reasonable effort to ensure that Edinburgh Research Explorercontent complies with UK legislation. If you believe that the public display of this file breaches copyright pleasecontact [email protected] providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately andinvestigate your claim.
Download date: 21. Feb. 2021
![Page 2: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Copyright©2016.Thecopyrightofeachpaperinthisconferenceproceedingsisthepropertyoftheauthor(s).Permissionisgrantedtoreproducecopiesoftheseworksforpurposesrelevanttotheaboveconference,providedthattheauthor(s),sourceandcopyrightnoticeareincludedoneachcopy.Forotherusespleasecontacttheauthor(s).
Designingfrom,withandbyData:IntroducingtheablativeframeworkChrisSpeeda*,JonOberlanderbaCentreforDesignInformatics,UniversityofEdinburghbCentreforDesignInformatics,UniversityofEdinburgh*Correspondingauthore-mail:[email protected]
Abstract: This paper introduces a framework for designers in which existingmethodologiescanbeplacedinordertobetteracknowledgehowtheyworkwithdataindifferentways to support theirpractice.Thepaper startsbydistinguishing threekindsofvalueassociatedwithdata:(i)rawmeasurements;(ii)commercialandsocial;and (iii) moral and ethical. We then note that changes in computing andcommunications technologies serve tode-emphasisecomputersasdevices,and re-emphasisetheflowofdatabetweenpeople,machines,andthings;thus,wesharetheviewthathuman-datainteractionisakeychallengefordesigners.Inaddressingthechallenge,weintroducetheframeworkfordesignerstodistinguishdesignfrom,with,andbydata.Wenotethat informaticsprovidesthetheoryfor,andtechnologiesof,information processing, while design provides the methods to adapt and createproductsandservices.Thepaperusescasestudiestoillustrateourapproach.
Keywords:Design,Data,Informatics,Framework
1.Introduction.Designhasusedqualitativeandquantitativedatatoinformthedevelopmentofproducts,servicesandsystemsformanyyears.Frommarketanalyticstoobservationalanalysis,andquestionnairestodesignprobes,designersunderstandimplicitlytheneedtowatch,listenandlearnfromthedatathatisgatheredbyprototypesbeforeandduringthedesignprocess.However,whilstthemethodsforgatheringdatahavegrowntoreflectresearchthroughdesignapproaches,therehasbeenlittleclassificationofthekindsofdatathatweareencounteringinanageofbigdata,nortoframehowwedesignalongsideit.
Thispaperintroducesaframeworkfordesignerstoreflectontheirexistingmethodsofworkingwithdata,inordertoanticipateitsabilitytotransformdesignprocessasitslevelofperformativityincreases.Thepaperbeginsbyoutliningthreekindsofvaluethatdataisinvolvedinmediatingandthenestablishesacomplexityinwhichqualitativeandquantitativedatabecomesentangledacrosssocial,economic,moralandethicalvalues.The
![Page 3: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
2
secondpartofthepaperintroducesanemergingfieldofenquirythatsupersedesHumanComputerInteraction,thatofHumanDataInteraction(HDI).HDIdemandsthatseriousattentionisnowrequiredtoaddressthesystemsthatplacestressonconventionalethicalandmoralmodelsofhandlingpersonaldata.Ourpapertakesthismantleandproposesthatdesignersplayavitalroleinthedesignoffuturesystemsinwhichpeople,thingsandcomputersco-existintheproductionofdata.
However,inordertounderstandbetterhowtodesignalongsidedata,theauthorsgoontointroduceaframeworkforrecognisinghowexistingandemergingresearchmethodsaddresstheincreasingperformativityofdata.Thepapercloseswithreflectionsonthethreecasesofdesigningfrom/with/bydata,andthenexplorestheimplicationsfortheframework.
2.Datainvolvesatleastthreekindsofvalue.Acollectionofdatacanbethoughtofasasetofvaluesforsomevariables,acquiredoriginallybymeasurementsofsomekind.Underanappropriateinterpretation,datacountsasinformation,andinformationprocessingcanrefine(relatively)rawdataandmakeituseful,bycapturing,transformingandcommunicatingit.
Inthepast,andstilltoday,almostalldataisimpersonal;measurementsintheLargeHadronCollider,orintheSquareKilometerArrayaimtoprovideextraordinarynumbersofvaluesforvariableseveryday.Ofcourse,inthepast,atleastsomedatawaspersonal,asinpopulationcensuses.However,anincreasingamountofdataispersonal.Thatis,becausetheirpreferences,attitudesandbehaviourcanbemeasuredonlineinmanyways,peoplenowadaysgeneratelotsofdata,bothconsciouslyandunconsciously.This“bigdata”ofapersonalnaturecapturesaspectsoftheirbehaviourasconsumers,communicators,andashealthyorunhealthyphysicalandsocialbeings.
Sothefirstsetofvalues,thedatavaluesthataremeremeasurements,canbecomeentangledwithtwootherimportantkindsofvalue.
Thesecondkindofvaluearisesbecausebyaggregatinganykindofdataatscale,corporationsandagenciescangeneratenewcommercialorsocialvalue:theycancreateproductsandserviceswhichincreaseindividualorcollectiveutility,andwhichcanbemonetisedinatleastsomecases.
Thethirdkindofvaluearisesbecausethewaysinwhichcorporationsandagenciestreatallkindsofdata(butespecially,personaldata)reflectsasetofmoralorethicalvalues,including:theprotectionorviolationofprivacy;thepromotionorpreventionofreciprocityinrelationships;respectorrejectionofthecustomsandattitudesoflesspowerfulpeoples–suchastheirattitudestotime,diet,orsexuality;andtheenhancementorerosionoffairnessinsocietiesmostgenerally.
![Page 4: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
3
3.ThefallofcomputersandtheriseofdataThepervasivenessoftheinternet,andofwirelessnetworking,haveenabledwidespreadadoptionofcloudcomputingservices.Forourpurposes,whatmattersaboutthecloudisthatitopensupgapsbetweentheplaceswheredataisgenerated,processed,andactedupon.Inthepast,thecapture,transformationandcommunicationofinformationmightallhavehappenedinoneplaceononematerialdevice:acomputerwithsuitableperipherals.Now,wefrequentlydonotcarewherethecomputingtakesplace.Inlightofthis,someaspectsofhumancomputerinteractionarebetterframedintermsofhumandatainteraction.Ifhumancomputerinteractionstudiesthewaysinwhichhumansinteractwith,andthrough,computers,wemightnowde-emphasisethematerialdevicesdoingthecomputing,andfocusmoreattentiononthewaysinwhichhumansinteractwith,andthrough,data.
Onegroupofresearchersconcernedwiththeprocessingofpersonaldatahavealreadyusedtheterm“humandatainteraction”tocoverthe“theindividualandcollectivedecisionsthatwemakeandactionswetake,asusersofonlinesystems,orassubjectsofdatacollectionpractices”(Mortieretal.2014).Theypointtotheneedto“makedataandanalyticsalgorithmsbothtransparentandcomprehensibletothepeoplethedataandprocessingconcerns”,andtogivepeople“thecapacitytoactwithinthesedatasystems,toopt-inortoopt-out,tocontrol,informandcorrectdataandinferences”.Onthisaccount,theproperstudyofhumandatainteractiongoeswellbeyondtraditionalinterestsindatavisualisation,toexploresocial,legalandethicalaspectsofpersonaldataprocessing.Thus,thethreekindsofvalueintroducedaboveareallimplicated.
Buttwoothertrendsrelatingtodataandinteractionareworthyofnote.Thecloudacceleratestheharvestingofpersonaldata,tobesure.Butitalsoenablesothernewdataflows,throughboththeInternetofThings,andsystemswhichsupportsocialcomputing.TheInternetofThings(IoT)is“thesetoftechnologies,systemsandmethodologiesthatunderpinstheemergingnewwaveofinternet-enabledapplicationsbasedonphysicalobjectsandtheenvironmentseamlesslyintegratingintotheinformationnetwork”(UKInternetofThingsSIGRoadmap,March2013).Socialcomputingiswheresocialbehaviourmeetscomputationalsystems.Itencompassescurrentonlinesocialinteraction,butalsogeneratespeople-poweredcomputation,withapplicationsfromonlineauctionstorecommendationsystems,fromelectionmonitoringtocitizenscience.
Mortieretal.’sconceptofhumandatainteractionisfocussedonpersonaldata,andtheproblemsandneedsassociatedwithit.TheIoTandsocialcomputingintroduceatleasttwonewoptions.ConsidertheIoT.First,weneedtointeractwithdata,andperhapswecanusethingstohelpusdothat.Butsecondly,wewillsometimesneedtointeractwiththethingsthemselves,andwewillthereforelikelyneedtotransformIoTdataintoformswithwhichwecaninteract.Thirdly,anynewinteractionwithdataorthingscanitselfgeneratefurtherdata,givensuitableinstrumentation.Finally,itwouldbenaturalforlevelsofaccesstodependuponontherolesindividualactorsplaywithrespecttocollectionsofthings.Inthese
![Page 5: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
4
respects,socialcomputingisanalogous:peoplecanusesocialcomputingsystemstointeractwithdata;theycanusedatatointeractwiththesystems;theirinteractionsgeneratefurtherdata;andwhattheycandowilldependupontheirroleinthelargersystem.
Drawingthesepointstogether,weseethattheyaresimplyfacetsofaworldofdistributedcomputinginwhichthecloudhelpsseparatethephysicalmechanismsofsensing,storing,processing,communicatingandactinguponinformation.Somemechanismsarelocal,othersremote.Somemechanismsareobviouslycomputers,otherslookjustlikethings,andyetothersarepeople.Thispicturemultipliesthenumbersandtypesofagentsatlooseintheworld,butitisobviousthatallthedataflowsandinformationprocessingarestillentirelysupervenientonphysicalmechanisms.Butsomeofthemechanismsareoutofsightofthepeopleinvolvedinthedataflows,andsoitisquiteunderstandablethattheydistinguishthematerial,visiblethingsfromtheimmaterial,andsometimesinvisibledataflows.
Someofthedatawhichpeopleinteractwithcanbeconsidered“researchdata”,inthesensethatitiscollectedtoinformthedesignofproductsandservices;atthesametime,sometimesdata(bigorsmall)isitselfamajorpartofaproductorservice.Intheformercase,themainpeopleinteractingwithdataaredesigners;inthelattercase,itisenduserswhodomostoftheinteracting(thankstothedesigners).Sodataplaysmultiplerolesindesignresearch.Moreover,theproblemsofhumandatainteractionidentifiedbyMortieretal.areimportant,buttheyarenotinfactspecifictopersonaldata;theyapplyalsototheotherdataflows,includingthoseinvolvingIoTdata,andsocialcomputingdata.Thisbeingso,howcantheseproblemsbetackledbydesignersoffuturesystemsofpeople,thingsandcomputers?
4.AframeworkfordesignersWithanestablishedhistoryinthedevelopmentofcreativemethodstowardthegatheringofempiricaldata,designershavemadesignificantcontributionstohowquantitativeandqualitativedatasupportamoreuser-centreddesignofproductsandservices.Howevertheadventofmobileandubiquitouscomputingpresentsthedisciplinewithamorecomplexarrayofdataformsthataremediatedindifferentwaysandassuch,theydemandthatwethinkabouthowdesignersdesignarounddata.Inlookingforameansofdistinguishingbetweentheformsofdatathatdesignersarenowfacedwithengagingwith,theauthorsidentifiedanincreaseintheperformativityofdata.Fromtypesofstabledatathatremainimmutable,throughdatathatistransformedwiththenetworksthatitisassociatedwith,todatathatisbeginningtoproduceitsowndata,thereisacontinuuminwhichdatabeginstospeakforitself(Cox2014).PerformativityisacomplextermthatDewsburydescribesas“thegap,therupture,thespacingthatunfoldsthenextmomentallowingchangetohappen.”(2000),andtraditionallyperformativityisusedtoexplainthecapacityofspeechandgesturestoactandofferemergentstructures.ThetermisattributedtothelanguagephilosopherAustinwhoestablishedthatwordscanbeusednotonlytodescribesomething,butcanusedtodosomething.Hismostpoignantexampleofwhathecoinedas
![Page 6: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
5
‘performativeutterances’beingwhenweusethewords“Ido”toinstantiateanaction(suchasmarriage)(Austin1962).
Acknowledgingthatdataisstartingto‘do’things,weturnedtotheablativecaseinLatinthatindicatesanagent,instrument,orsourcewithinarelationshipexpressedby‘by’,‘with’,or‘from’.Ifdesignersarehavingtoadapttohowtheyderiveknowledgethroughdata,theablativecasemightbestdescribehowthedatathattheyareworkingwithisincreasinginitsperformativequalities.Byreversingthetraditionalablativecaseinwhich‘by’isgivenagency,‘with’isco-producedand‘from’istaken,itispossibletoexpresstheshiftinpracticesthatdesignershavebeguntodevelopasdatamovesfrombeingsomethinglikeasourcetodesign‘from’,toacomplexandfluidsettingtodesign‘with’,andfinallytoaconditioninwhichdesignisproduced‘by’dataitself.
4.1DesignfromdataDesignfromdata:whensystemsaredesignedbypeople,wheretheyareinspiredbymeasurablefeaturesofhumans,computers,things,andtheircontexts.
Therearemanymethodsthatdesignersusetoelicitdatafromsocial,technicalandenvironmentalsettings:fromestablishedethnographicmethodsfromuserobservations(Abrams2000,Stempfle2002andKawulich2005)andinterviews(Bernard2000,Byrne2001,Rubin2005);tomoredesignerlymethodsincludingculturalprobes(Gaveretal1999),technologyprobes(Hutchinson2002)andContextualmapping(Stappersetal2005).
CriticisedbyNormanifsolelyusedatthebeginningofadesignprocess(2006),userandparticipantobservationshelpdesignersgatherdatafrompeopleinspecificsituations.From‘flyonthewall’approachestotheuseofvideo,stillphotographandnotetaking,thegatheringdatafromcontextsinwhichpeoplearecarryingouteverydaypracticesorusingprototypes,isafamiliarmethodfordesignerstounderstandsocialpractices.Similarly,theuseofstructured,semi-structuredandun-structuredinterviewsalsooffersavaluablemethodtogatherdataabouttheperceptions,behaviourandopinionsofpeoplewhoareengagedintheconsumption,useorinteractionwithparticularproductsandcontexts.Whilstparticipantobservationandinterviewsareextendedfromestablishedethnographicmethods,culturalprobesandcontextmappingaremoreuniquetodesignanduseartefactsandmaterialstogatherdata.Packsconsistingofvariouselementssuchasdiaries,disposablecameras,postcardsanddrawingmaterialsthataredistributedtoprojectparticipants,encouragethemtodescribetheirexperienceswithoutthepresenceofthedesignresearcher.Useofgraphics,metaphorsandpersonalisedtouchescansupportparticipantstoofferimaginativematerialtoinspirethedesignprocess.Inthedevelopmentoftechnologyprobes,Hutchinsonetal.acknowledgehow“probeswillchangethebehaviourofourusers”(2002)andsubsequentlydevelopedaprobethatusestechnologytofosteraco-adaptiverelationshipwiththeuserinwhichthedeviceprovokesandpromotesinteractionsfromwhichunderstandingsofuseandcontextcanbeelicited.Explicitlynotaprototype,technologyprobesstimulateuseoveraperiodoftime,andallowresearcherstoreflecton
![Page 7: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
6
thisuseinordertogatherinformationabouttheusersaswellasinspireideasfornewtechnologies.Contextmapping,alsoadesigntechnique,usesaseriesofphasesthatbeginwiththecaptureofthedesigners’preconceptionsforasetting,followedbytheuseofavarietyofstimuli(includingquestionsandculturalprobes)tohelpparticipantsreflectonacircumstanceorsituation.Sessionsareusuallyrecordedtosupporttheidentificationofpatternsinlanguage,experienceandpractice.
Thevarietyofmethodsforgatheringdataisnotlimitedtothefourexamplesabovebutextendstoallprocessesinwhichdataisgathered‘from’settingsbeforebeinganalysedandusedtoinformsubsequentdesigndecisions.Throughthemulti-disciplinaryEquatorproject,agooddealwasestablishedabouttheappropriatewaysthatdatacanbegatheredandusedtoinformdesign.Hemmingsetal.listsevenstepstowarddesign:1.Planning;2.RecruitingParticipants;3.SelectingVolunteers;4.AssemblingDomesticProbes;5.DeployingDomesticProbes;6.RetrievingandAnalysingProbes,before7.SpeculativeDesign(2002).Thisorderofdatacaptureultimatelyendsinthestudio,wherethedesignercanlearnanddesign‘from’thematerials.
Figure1 TheHaggle-O-Tronwasdevelopedusingacombinationofdesignfromdatamethods
includingvideoethnographyandparticipantobservationthroughtheuseofatechnologyprobe.
AnexampleofhowtheauthorshavedevelopedaDesignFromDataapproachisintheirdevelopmentoftheHaggle-O-Tron(Speedetal2014).TheHaggle-O-TronisaninteractivekettlethatwasdevelopedforplacementwithinanOxfamsecondhandshoptoexplorehow
![Page 8: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
7
haggling(apracticecurrentlyprohibitedinOxfamshops)mightbehelpfulinrevealingsecondhandgoods’financial,moral,social,andaestheticproperties.Visitorstotheshopwereinvitedtousethekettletohaggleoverthepriceofanarticlethattheywereinterestedinbuying.Amemberofthedesignteamwhowaslocatedintheshop’sbackroomandwasconnectedtotheHaggle-O-Tronviaawebcameraandmicrophone.This‘WizardofOz’techniqueallowedustosimulatethekettle’ssentience,inordertosustainarealistichaggle.Fromreviewingfootageandidentifyinginteractionsbackinthestudio,theresearchersgainedabetterunderstandingofbargainingtactics,theuseofincentivesandtheeffectivevocabularythatwouldsupportOxfam’swidercharitableprojects,whilstofferingthemaninsightintohowtheymightchangetheirin-storepolicies.
4.2DesignwithdataDesignwithdata:whensystemsaredesignedbypeople,wheretheytakeintoaccounttheflowsofdatathroughsystems,andtheneedtosustainandenhancehumanvalues.
Asthenetworksocietyhasdeveloped,ethnographyinturnhasdevelopedmeansofexpandingitspracticestoutilisesocialmedia,telecommunicationsandinternetcommunicationsinordertogatherdata.Virtualethnography(Hine2000),netnography(Kozinets2006),cyber-ethnography(Keeley-Browne2011)andonlineethnography(Wilson2002)allrefertoonlineresearchmethodsthathaveadaptedtraditionalethnographicmethodstostudyparticipantsthroughcomputer-mediatedsocialinteractions.Whilstthesemethodslargelygathermaterialandreport‘from’sourcesbeforeanalysis,easyaccesstoubiquitouscomputingtechnologiesisenablingresearcherstosustainalink‘with’aparticipantorcommunitytobetterunderstandhowdata-centricprototypes,productsandserviceshaveanimpactontheuser.Wedescribethisemergingresearchscenario,inwhichinformationcanflowinmorethanonedirection,asoneinwhichitispossibleto‘designwithdata’.
Theconstantconnectiontotheinternetbetweenproductssuchasmartphonesorservicessuchasenergythroughsmartmetersinhomes,istransformingtheindustryofdesign.Nolongeraredesignerssimplycontributingtostagesinavaluechainasaproductmovesfrommanufacture,packaging,distributiontoconsumption;designersareretainedtomediatethevalueofproductsandserviceswithinacomplexnetworkofsocialandenvironmentalconnections.CoinedbyNormannandRamirez(1994),theterm‘value-constellations’describestheeconomicsystemsthatemergedattheendofthe20thcenturyasglobalisationandnewtechnologiesinfluencedthewaythatvaluewassustained.Recognisingtheroleofco-createdvaluewithinnetworks,NormannandRamirezhighlightthat“successfulcompaniesconceiveofstrategyassystematicsocialinnovation:thecontinuousdesignandredesignofcomplexbusinesssystems”(1994).Withinavalue-constellation,thevalueofaserviceisconstantlymediatedaccordingtotheflowsofdatathatallowusersandstakeholderstosustainthevaluepropositionassociatedwithaproduct,serviceorexperience.Thesemoredynamicmodelsofvaluecreationandrelationrepresent
![Page 9: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
8
adifferentopportunityfordesigntoretainarelationshipwithusersthroughouttheirengagementwithproducts(Speed&Maxwell2015).Theopportunityfordesignersto‘designwithdata’thatisderivedfromtheinteractionsofusersenablesadifferentunderstandingofhowthefeedbackfromusercommunitiesaffectsthevalueofaproductorservice.
Figure2 Fiveinternetconnectedtoiletrollholderswaitingfordeployment,andascreencaptureof
datastreamedtotheinternetannotatedwithreflectionsfromoneowner.
Anexampleofhowtheauthorsareinvolvedindesigningwithdataarisesinthedeploymentoffiveinternetconnectedtoiletrollholdersthatfedbackdatatotheirowners.Thedesignoftheflowofdatawasrelativelysimple:eachdeviceconcurrentlymeasuredthemass(andhencelength)ofremainingtoiletpaper,andstreamedthevaluestoadesignatedrecipient.
ThedesignsolutionwasdevelopedforanInternetofThingsresearchprojectthatprovidesaplatformforownersofconnecteddevicestolayclaimtothedatathattheyproduceandbegintoexplorewaysinwhichtotradewithit.CurrentbusinessmodelsforIoTdevicesinvolvethecustomerpurchasingadevicethatsupportsparticularnetworkfunctions,butoftenstreamsdatabacktothemanufacturerwhomaysellthedatatothirdparties,oruseittoinformtheirowneconomicstrategies.TheHubofAllThingsproject(www.hubofallthings.com)seekstoprovideaplatformforpeopletomanagetheuseoftheirowndataandinturnidentifyvaluefromitbyeitherchoosingtoprotectit,shareitorpotentiallysellit.
OriginallyidentifiedbytheresearchteamasarelativelyeasyInternetofThingsdevicetodesign(comparedtofridgesandotherdomesticappliances),thetoiletrollisatthecentreofhighlypersonalpracticesthattakeplacebehindlockeddoorsandexemplifiesthetypeofpersonaldatathatpeoplemaywanttomanage.Throughthegraphthatisfedtoapersonaldatastoreandvisibleinabrowser,itispossibletoclearlyidentifyeventsthatusesignificantamountsoftoiletpaperfromwhichitisfurtherpossibletoinferparticulartoiletactivities;seeFig.2.Uponfurtheranalysis,thegraphalsorevealedaseriesoflesslikelyevents
![Page 10: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
9
includingcleaningupaftercats,therunningoutoftoiletpaper,extrahouseguests,andsomebodyhavingarunnynose.Theperformativenatureofthedataemergesasfamiliesbegintointerpretthedatatoinferdomesticpractices,andinonecaseidentifythepresenceofastrangerinthehouse,whilstafamilywereawayonholiday.
Designingwithdataacknowledgesthatdataisnotacoldresourcetobetakenbacktothelaborstudioforexamination,butaconditioninwhichdesignersshouldanticipatethedisruptivepotentialthatisproducedfromstreamsoflivedatafromnetworkedartefacts.Trust,privacy,identityandsecurityareconceptsthatashumans,wedeterminethevalueofwithincomplexsocialandmaterialpractices.Inorderfordesignerstounderstandthebreachesanddisruptionsinvolvedinthehumandatainteractionsbetweeninternetconnectedthings,wewillneedtodevelop‘designwithdata’methodsinordertounderstandthevalueconstellationsthatareproducedandco-producedtosupportbettermanagement.
4.3DesignbydataDesignbydata:whensystemsaredesignedbyothersystems,largelyautonomously,wherenewproductsandservicescanbesynthesisedviathedata-intensiveanalysisofexistingcombinationsofhumans,computers,things,andcontexts.
Thefinalareaisintheemergingprospectthatdataitself,supportedbyanalgorithm,willbecomeadesigner.Suchacircumstanceisnotsofaraway,accordingtoGartner,whopredict:“By2017,asignificantdisruptivedigitalbusinesswillbelaunchedthatwasconceivedbyacomputeralgorithm.”(Gartner2014)
Thescaleofdatathatisbeingproducedandco-producedthroughmachinetomachineandmachinetohuman/humantomachineinteractionshasproventobeexponential.Ithasbeenobservedthatapproximately90%ofallofthedataintheworldhasbeenproducedinthepast2years(Arthur2013);whetherthisisinfacttruenow,theexactproportionisperhapsirrelevant.Astheflowofdatamovesfromwebbasedapplications,throughmobiledevicestonetworkedobjects,thedatathatisproducedbecomestheprimaryassetwithwhichtosustainthevalueofproductsandservices.Iftheinformationthatisderivedfromthedataandreturnedtotheuserdoesnotdemonstrategoodvalue,thentheusermaydroptheproduct.Inordertoidentifyvaluableinformation,machinelearningisbeingusedacrossawidevarietyofdatabasestoidentifypatternsinordertoelicitnewinsights(Bandyopadhyay&Sen2011).Designbydatasuggeststhatasthesealgorithmsbecomefasterandbetteratidentifyingnewopportunitiestosustainoraddvaluetoproductsandservices,itwon’tbelongbeforedata-drivenobjectsbegintobecomedesignerswithinourlives.
![Page 11: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
10
Figure3 TheThingTankprojectadoptsadesignbydataapproach.Camerasattachedtodomestic
objectsallowedhumanresearcherstoidentifyactivities,whilstdatafrominternetconnecteddevicesallowedmachinestolearnabouthumanactivity.Thiscombinationenabledtheresearcherstoidentifymorethanhumanactivitiesthatweredonewhilewaitingforthewatertoboil(fromakettle’sperspective).
Thecasestudythattheauthorshavecontributedtothatbestexemplifiesascenarioof‘designbydata’istheThingTankproject.Theprojectwasfundedtoexplorethepotentialforidentifyingnovelpatternsofusewithindatathatisstreamedthroughtheinteractionbetweenpeopleandthings,andthingsandthings.Throughanunderstandingofwhatdatacantellusabouthowweuseobjectsinpractice,theprojectpositedthatnewmodelsofusewouldemergeandreinvigoratetheroleofthingsandpeoplewithindesignandmanufacturing.Inthepast,manyInternetofThingsprojectshaveusedthenetworkconnectionofartefactstoidentifycostsavingandprocessefficiencies(e.g.,vehiclemanufacturers),ortotrackgoodswithinlargenetworks(e.g.,logisticscompanies),ortomonitorthehealthandsafetyofsystems(e.g.,aircraftmanufacturers).Suchprojectslookforregularpatternswithindatasetswhichsuggestefficienciesthatwillreinforcetheidentityofaproductorservicebymakingitsfunctioneasiertouseormoreeconomical.Bycontrast,theThingTankprojectproposedthatlookingforanomaliesandoutliersindatasetscouldsuggestmoreradicaldesignopportunities.Duringstudies,theresearchteamdevelopednon-anthropocentricmethodsbygatheringandstreamingdatafrombothmaterialobjectsandhumansthatwereinvolvedinadomesticrelationship,tobetterunderstandhowmachinescouldidentifypracticesthatwentunidentifiedbyhumanresearchers(Giaccardietal2016).
Althoughthemajorityofususeproductsasintended,manyofusalsoinventnovelusagesofobjectsbyadaptingorusingthemforunintendedpurposes.Byscanninglargedatasetsforevidenceofmis-useandthenusingthemtobuildnewassemblages,theThingTankproject
![Page 12: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
11
proposesthatalgorithmsmayexploitdatatodesignthingsthathumandesignerscouldhaveneverhaveconceived.
5.ReflectionsandImplicationsCollectively,wetermthesethreeclassesofdesigningfrom,withandbydataasthe“AblativeFramework”fordesigninformatics,referencingtheablativegrammaticalcaseinLatin,whichisusedtocover“by,withorfrom”.Theflowofdata,andthegenerationofdifferingformsofvalue,arethecentralconcernsandallowdesignerstoreconfigureexistingpracticesandmethodstobetterunderstandtheincreasingperformativityofdata.Theframeworkseesdesignfromdataasestablishedmethodsfordesigners,anddesignbydataasstillhighlyemergent;whilstdesignwithdataistheimportantspaceofenquirythatrequiresurgentresearchtoaddressthefullextentofHumanDataInteractions.
TheFrameworkaimstoofferameansoforganisingbothexistingmethodsbutalsoofanticipatingemergingmethodsthatrecognisetheincreasingperformativequalitiesofdata.TheFrameworkisplacedwithinanetworksocietyinwhichdesignersareworkingalongsideawiderangeofdisciplinestomediatevaluewithinaconstellationofstakeholdersincludingalgorithms.TheFrameworkidentifiesdifferentrelationshipsbetweendesignersanddata,andhelpsusseewhentheuseofestablishedethnographicanddesignerlymethodsforgatheringdatafromisrequired,orwhenthesustainedflowsofdatarequireadesignwithdata.TheThingTankexampleinfactdemonstratesthisneatly:thedesignerspursuedtraditionaldesignmethods,andthenconstructedflowsofdatafromdevicesembeddedinusers’practicesandvalues,andthenengagedmachinelearningtoidentifyoutliers,whichpointstowardstheincreasingautomationofnewproductdesign.Sotheprojectinvolvedallthreerelationsbetweendesignanddata;theFrameworkdoesnotinstantiateahierarchyforthethreerelations,andacknowledgestheimportanceandinteractionofallthreewithindesignresearch.
Usesofthethreecasescanbeunderstoodintermsoftheneedforsomedesignprojectsthatdepartfromthestandarddoublediamondofdesign,withitspipelineoffourstages:discover,define,developanddeliver.Suchanapproachtypicallyidentifiesthebehavioursandconventionsthathavetobeobserved,andfindswaysofsustainingthem.Withtheadventofdesigningalongsidedata,thereislimitedchancetofreezethediscoveranddefinestages,becausedatawillcontinuetobereceivedfromusersandcommunitiesthatadjustthevaluepropositionoftheproductorservicethathasbeendelivered.
Designisadjustingfromprovidingservicesthataddvaluealongthetraditionalvaluechain,towardsplayinganactiveroleinthemediationofvaluewithinaconstellationinwhichdataprovidesfeedback,oreventakescontrol.Frameworkssuchastheoneproposedhereprovidetoolswhichhelpusunderstandwhichmethodstoadopt,andwhen.Someofthosetoolsshouldbeverysimple,takingtheformofchecklistsforpractitionersthatrespondtothefollowingquestions:
![Page 13: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
12
1. Incontextsinwhichhumans,computersandartefactsareincloseinteraction,howcandesignersidentifymeasurablefeaturesfromwhichdatacanbeelicitedtobetterunderstandthevaluesinplay,andhowcantheydesigninterventionstocapturedatainamannerthatissensitivetohumanvalues?
2. Incontextsinwhichdataisflowinginsuchawaythatitisperformative,informingandaffectingthebehaviorofhumansandartefacts,howcanthedesignteamdevelopsystemsthatcapturetheexistingflows,andofferinterventionsthatsupportandenhancehumanvalues?
3. Incontextsinwhichsystemsaredesignedbyothersystems,howcandesignersmediatethedevelopmentofproductsandservicesthataresynthesisedbydataprocesses,toensurethatthevaluesofthesystemsarecommensuratewiththevaluesofthehumanandmorethanhumanparticipants?
Infuturework,weaimtoexercisetheseprinciplesandmakethembroadlyavailablefordesignresearch.
1. Acknowledgements:Designresearchforthispaperoriginatedfromthefollowinggrants:TheInternetofSecondhandThingsprojectfundedbyanEPSRCgrant(EP/K012819/1)andOxfamUK;TheHubofAllThingsprojectfundedbyanEPSRCgrant(EP/K039911/1);andtheThingTankprojectfundedbytheSkoltechFoundation,Russia.Thanksgotothemanyparticipantswhosupportedtheresearch,andwearegratefultoourreviewersfortheirconstructivesuggestionsforimprovingthepaper.
5.ReferencesAustin,J.L.(1962)HowtoDoThingswithWords.Oxford:ClarendonPress.
Bandyopadhyay,D.&Sen,J.(2011)InternetofThings:ApplicationsandChallengesinTechnologyandStandardization,WirelessPersonalCommunications:AnInternationalJournalarchive,58(1),49-69.
Bernard,R.(2000).SocialResearchMethods:QualitativeandQuantitativeApproaches.ThousandOaks,CA:Sagepublications.
Cox,G.(2013)SpeakingCode:CodingasAestheticandPoliticalExpression.MITPress,Cambridge,MA.
Dewsbury,J.(2000)PerformativityandtheEvent:EnactingaPhilosophyofDifference.EnvironmentandPlanningD:SocietyandSpaceAugust200018:473-496,
Norman,D.(2006)Whydoinguserobservationsfirstiswrong.Interactions13,4(July2006),50-ff.
Hemmings,T.,Clarke,K.,Crabtree,A.,Rodden,T.andRouncefield,M.(2002)Probingtheprobes,Proceedingsofthe2002ParticipatoryDesignConference,pp.42-50,ComputerProfessionalsforSocialResponsibility.
Hutchinson,H.,Mackay,W.,Westerlund,B.,Bederson,B.B.,Druin,A.,Plaisant,C.,Beaudouin-Lafon,M.,Conversy,S.,Evans,H.,Hansen,H.,Roussel,NandEiderbäck,B.(2003)Technologyprobes:inspiringdesignforandwithfamilies.InProceedingsoftheSIGCHIConferenceonHumanFactorsinComputingSystems(CHI'03).ACM,NewYork,NY,USA,17-24.
![Page 14: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Designingfrom,withandbyData:Introducingtheablativeframework
13
Hine,C.(2000)VirtualEthnography.London:Sage.
Gartner(2014)GartnerRevealsTopPredictionsforITOrganizationsandUsersfor2015andBeyond.Garner.Weblink:http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/2866617Accessed10thNovember2015.
Giaccardi,E.,Speed,C.,Caldwell,M.&Cila,N.(2016)WhenObjectsBecomeCo-ethnographers:PotentialsofaThing-CentredApproachinDesignandAnthropology,in(Eds)Binder,T.,Kjærsgaard,M.&CharlotteSmith,R.DesignAnthropologicalFutures,Bloomsbury.
Kawulich,B,B.(2005)ParticipantObservationasaDataCollectionMethod.ForumQualitativeSozialforschung/Forum:QualitativeSocialResearch,[S.l.],v.6,n.2,May.
Keeley-Browne,E.(2011).Cyber-Ethnography:TheEmergingResearchApproachfor21stCenturyResearchInvestigation.InG.Kurubacak,&T.Yuzer(Eds.)HandbookofResearchonTransformativeOnlineEducationandLiberation:ModelsforSocialEquality(pp.330-238).Hershey,PA:InformationScienceReference.doi:10.4018/978-1-60960-046-4.ch017
Kozinets,RobertV.(2006),Netnography2.0,inHandbookofQualitativeResearchMethodsinMarketing,ed.Belk,R.W.Cheltenham,UNandNorthampton,MA:EdwardElgarPublishing,129-142.
leCompte,M.&Schensul,J.(1999).EssentialEthnographicMethods(vol.2):EthnographersToolkit.NewYork,NY:Altamirapress.
Miller,D.,andSlater,D.(2000).TheInternet:Anethnographicapproach.Oxford;NewYork:Berg.
Mortier,R.,Haddadi,H,.Henderson,T.,McAuley,D.&Crowcroft,J.(2014)Human-DataInteraction:TheHumanFaceoftheData-DrivenSociety.AvailableatSSRN:http://ssrn.com/abstract=2508051orhttp://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2508051
Normann,R.&Ramirez,R.(1994)DesigningInteractiveStrategy:FromValueChaintoValueConstellation.JohnWiley&Sons.
Speed,C.,Hartswood,M.,Laurier,E.,Magee,S.,deJode,M.&Hudson-Smith,A.(2014)TheHaggle-O-Tron:designinterventioninsecondhandretail.Proceedingsofthe2014companionpublicationonDesigninginteractivesystems.Pages137-140.ACMNewYork,NY,USA.ISBN:978-1-4503-2903-3doi:10.1145/2598784.2602802
Speed,C.&Maxwell,D.(2015)Designingthroughvalueconstellations.interactions22,5(August2015),38-43.DOI=http://dx.doi.org/10.1145/2807293
Wilson,S.M.,&Peterson,L.C.(2002).TheAnthropologyofOnlineCommunities.AnnualReviewofAnthropology31:449–467.
AbouttheAuthors:
Chris Speed is Professor of Design Informatics within EdinburghCollege of Art, University of Edinburgh. Chris is Co-Director of theDesign Informatics Research Centre that is home to researchersworking across interaction design, temporal design, anthropology,softwareengineeringandcryptocurrencies.
Jon Oberlander is Professor of Epistemics within the School ofInformatics,UniversityofEdinburgh.Heworksongettingcomputers
![Page 15: Edinburgh Research Explorer · Introducing the ablative framework Chris Speeda*, Jon Oberlanderb ... Design has used qualitative and quantitative data to inform the development of](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052019/6032c0e2e9d7ca328617ce9b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Speed&Oberlander
14
to talk like individual people, so he studies how people expressthemselves and develops systems that can adapt themselves topeople.