Download - Elias 1970 State Formation and Nation Building

8/12/2019 Elias 1970 State Formation and Nation Building

1/15

PROCESSES OF STATE FORMATION AND NATION BUILDING

NORBERT ELIAS (ENGLAND)

Transactions of the 7th World Congress of Sociology 1970, Vol. 3 Sofia: ISA, 1972:

274!4

O"# of $%# &$'a"#&$ a*$& of $%# +##-o.#"$ of &o*io-o/ +0'i" i$& fi'&$ *#"$0'/ a"+

a %a-f o' &o a& a '#-a$i#-/ a0$o"o.o0& +i&*i-i"# i& $%# *%a"# f'o. a -o"$#'.

#'*i# $o a &%o'$$#'. #'*$i#, a i"+ of "a''oi" of $%# &o*io-oi&$&3 i"$#'#&$

$o *o"$#.o'a'/ &o*i#$i#& a"+ ao# a-- $o $%#i' o" &o*i#$i#& a& $%#/ a'# %#'# a"+

"o, a"+ a i$%+'aa- of i"$#'#&$ f'o. $%# 'o-#. %o a"+ %/ &o*i#$i#& o#' $%#

*#"$0'i#& %a# #*o.# %a$ $%#/ a'#5 T%# "a''oi" of $%# fo*0& %a& fo0"+ i$& .o&$

&$'ii" #6'#&&io" i" $%# *%a"# i" $%# +o.i"a"$ $/# of &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'/5 Fo' $%#

'#a$#' a'$ of $%# 19$% *#"$0'/ $%# .o&$ '#'#"$a$i# &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& #'#

*#"$'#+ o" $%# -o"$#'. +##-o.#"$ of &o*i#$/, $%o of $%# *o"+ a'$ of $%# 2$%

*#"$0'/ #6*#$ a f#, a.o" $%#. ./ o" %a# *o.-#$#-/ aa"+o"#+ $%# *o"*#$

of &o*ia- +##-o.#"$5 Fo' a $i.#, i$ %a& +i&a#a'#+ f'o. &o*io-oi*a- $#6$oo&5

I"&$#a+, $%# *o"*#$ 8&o*ia- &/&$#.8 %a& .o#+ i"$o $%# *#"$'# of &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#&

a"+ o$%#' *o"*#$& '#-a$#+ $o i$, &0*% a& 8&o*ia- &$'0*$0'#8 a"+ 8&o*ia- f0"*$io",8

*o"*#i#+ i" &0*% a .a""#' $%a$ $%#/ *a" o"-/ '# a& $%#o'#$i*a- $oo-& fo' a &$0+/ of

&o*i#$/ i" a i#" &$a$#, a$ a i#" $i.#, %o *%a"#& a'# #'*#i#+ a& 0"&$'0*$0'#+ o',

i" o$%#' o'+&, a& %i&$o'i*a- *%a"#&5 T%# &%if$ of i"$#'#&$ f'o. $%# -o"$#'. +/"a.i*&

$o $%# &%o'$$#'. &$a$i*& of &o*i#$/ %a& .a"/ '#a&o"& %i*% "##+ "o$ # +i&*0&+ %#'#,

a$ -#a&$ "o$ #6-i*i$-/ (I %a# +i&*0&+ &o.# of $%#. #-%#'# (1))5 B0$ $%# fa*$ $%a$

$%# -a"& of $%# 7$% o'-+ Co"'#&& of So*io-o/ i"*-0+# a Ro0"+ Ta-# +i&*0&&io" o"$%# $%#.# G'a"+ T%#o'i#& of D##-o.#"$3 .a/ #'%a& # '#a'+#+ a& a &$'a i" $%#

i"+5 T%#'# a'# a "0.#' of &i"& $%a$ $%# 'o-#. of $%# -o"$#'. +##-o.#"$ of

&o*i#$i#& &o.#$i.#& .i&$a#"-/ *a--#+ #o-0$io", fo' $%i& +##-o.#"$ i& a 0#"$ia-

o'+#' &0i #"#'i& a"+ %a& "o$%i" %a$##' $o +o i$% $%# io-oi*a- 0#"*# *a--#+

#o-0$io" #i"& $o .o# o"*# .o'# i"$o fo*0&5
http://www.usyd.edu.au/su/social/elias/state.html#1.http://www.usyd.edu.au/su/social/elias/state.html#1.


2/15

A.o" $%# .a"/

'#a&o"& fo' $%# *%a"# f'o. -o"$#'. +##-o.#"$a- $o &%o'$$#'. &$a$i* $%#o'i#& i"

&o*io-o/, $%i& i& *#'$ai"-/ o"#: T%# '#"$ *o"+i$io"& of a+a"*#+3 &o*i#$i#& a'# i"

&o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& $'#a$#+ a-.o&$ a& if $%#/ #'# a" 0"*%a"i" fi"a- &$a$#5 T%# &%o'$


3/15

$#'. #'*$i# of .a"/ of $%# .o&$ '#&$iio0& &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& of o0' $i.# fi"+&

i$& #6'#&&io" i" -a-i# a&$'a*$io"& f'o. -#*$#+ a*$& of *o"$#.o'a'/

8a+a"*#+8 &o*i#$i#& '#"$#+ i$% $%# *-ai. $o # a-i*a-# $o &o*i#$i#& of a-- a#&

a"+ '#io"&5 So*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& o#" a'o0"+ *o"*#$& &0*% a& 8&o*ia- &/&$#.8 a'#

a" #6a.-#5 T%#/ '#+0*# $%# -o"$#'. 'o*#&& of &$'0*$0'#+ a"+ +i'#*$io"a- *%a"#&,

$o %i*% $%# *o"*#$ of +##-o.#"$ a-i#& a"+ of %i*% 'o*#&& of

i"+0&$'ia-i&a$io", 0'#a0*'a$i&a$io", &*i#"$ifi*a$io", 0'a"i&a$io" o' &$a$# a"+ "a$io"

0i-+i" 'o*#&& a'# #6a.-#&, $o a" 0"*%a"i" &$a$# a& i$& #'.a"#"$ *o"+i$io",

%i-# $%# *%a"#& $%#.-#& a'# #'*#i#+, a$ $%# .o&$, a& a" 0"&$'0*$0'#+ f-o, a&

3%i&$o'/35

A f# '#-i.i"a'/ '#.a'&, I $%o0%$, .i%$ %#- *-#a' $%# +#*&5 Fo' i" o'+#' $o

*o"$'i0$# $o a Ro0"+ Ta-# +i&*0&&io" ao0$ 3G'a"+ T%#o'i#& of D##-o.#"$3 o"# %a&

$o +#*i+# %a$ i$ i& o"# $& o0$ $o +i&*0&&: %i&$o'i*a- $%#o'i#& ? -a To/"## o' S#"-#'

o' &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& of -o"$#'. +##-o.#"$5 A& o"# *a" %a'+-/ $a# i$ fo' 'a"$#+

$o+a/ $%a$ $%# +iff#'#"*# #$##" a" a'oa*% $o *%a"#& of &o*i#$i#& a& %i&$o'/ a"+ a"

a'oa*% $o $%# *%a"#& a& +##-o.#"$ i& #-- 0"+#'&$oo+, I $%o0%$ i$ .i%$ #

0f0- if I &$a$# #6-i*i$-/ $%a$ I a. *o"*#'"#+ i$% $%# -a$$#'5 I$ .i%$ %#- $%#+i&*0&&io" a-o", I $%o0%$, if I $ o0$, i" *o"$i"0a$io" of ./ $%#o'/ of -o"$#'. &$a$#

fo'.a$io" 'o*#&&, &o.# of $%# 'o-#.& %i*% o"# #"*o0"$#'& if o"# &$0+i#& "a$io"

0i-+i" 'o*#&&, $%# -a$#&$ %a of a -o" -i"# of &$a$# fo'.a$io" 'o*#&& a$ -#a&$ i"

$%# +##-o.#"$ of E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#&5

T%# 'o-#. i$-f i& "o$ 0"*%a'a*$#'i&$i* of $%# *%a"# i" o"#3& #'*#$io" i.-i#+ i"

$%# *%a"# f'o. a &$a$i* $o a +##-o.#"$a- &o*io-oi*a- a'a+i.5 O"# ai"& a**#&& $o'#io0&-/ "#-#*$#+ 'o-#.&5 i$% $%# #6*#$io" of R#i"%a'+ B#"+i6, f#

&o*io-oi&$& %a# -oo#+ i"$o $%# 'o-#. of "a$io" 0i-+i" a"+ "o"#, a& fa' a& I "o,

i"$o $%o of -o"$#'. &$a$# fo'.a$io" 'o*#&& a"+ $%#i' '#-#a"*# fo' &o*io-oi&$&

o$% o" $%# #.i'i*a- a"+ $%# $%#o'#$i*a- -##-5 T%# #i+#"*# fo' $%i& $/# of 'o*#&& i&

a-- a'o0"+ 0&5 B0$ i" o'+#' $o 'i" i$ i"$o o"#3& *o"*#$0a- "#$ o"# '#;0i'#& a $/# of

$%#o'#$i*a- a'a+i. %i*% +o#& "o$ a&$'a*$ f'o. $%# f-o of $i.# a"+ '#+0*#, i"

'#f-#*$io", $o &$a$i* *%0"& $%a$ %i*% o"# o'#& a& a *o"$i"0o0& .o#.#"$5 Ma"/


4/15

*o"$#.o'a'/ &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'/ 0i-+#'& a#a' $o $a# i$ fo' 'a"$#+ $%a$ a $/# of

a&$'a*$io" .o+#--#+ o" *-a&&i*a- %/&i*&, a&$'a*$io"& i" $%# fo'. of -a-i#

#"#'a-i&a$io"& %i*% #6*-0+# f'o. $%# '#&0-$ of $%# a&$'a*$io" a-- $%a$ %a#"& i" $%#

0#"*# of $i.# i& $%# $'0# a+# of a &*i#"$ifi* #"$#''i P#'%a& i$ %a& "o$ ##"

&$a$#+ *-#a'-/ #"o0% $%a$ $%# a&$'a*$io"& o"# #"*o0"$#'& i" io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& a"+

*o"*#$& a'# #'/ +iff#'#"$ f'o. $%# -a-i# #"#'a-i&a$io"& of *-a&&i*a- %/&i*&5 So.#

of $%#. i"*-0+# &a$ia- fi0'a$io"& a"+ $i.# 0#"*#& of -o" +0'a$io"5 O"# *a" a-'#a+/

# #'/ *-#a'-/ $%a$, i" i$& o" a/, &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'/ .ai" i-- %a# $o .o# i" a

&i.i-a' +i'#*$io"5 T%# +iffi*0-$/ i& $%a$ $%# $/# of $%#o'/ %i*% #.#'#& i" $%a$ *a

+o#& "o$ *o''#&o"+ $o $%# i+#a- i.a# of a $%#o'/ %i*% $%# .o&$ 'o.i"#"$ $%#o'#$i*a-

&o*io-oi&$& of o0' $i.# a#a' $o $a# fo' 'a"$#+ a"+ %i*% i& a i"+ of %i-o&o%i*a-

%a"o#' f'o. $%# $i.# of *-a&&i*a- %/&i*&5

Ta# o"# of $%# #&$ "o" #6a.-#& of a" #&"$ia--/ &$a$i* &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'/ of o0'

$i.#, $%# $%#o'/ %i*% $'i#& $o *o.# $o 'i& i$% $%# 'o-#.& of &o*i#$/ / '#"$i"

&o*i#$/ a& a 8&o*ia- &/&$#.85 I a. -a+ $o fi"+ $%a$ $%# -#a+i" #6o"#"$ of *o"$#.o'a'/

&o*ia- &/&$#. $%#o'i#&, Ta-*o$$ Pa'&o"&, i& a.o" 0&5 I a. *'i$i*a- of $%# i"$#--#*$0a-

&/&$#. %# %a& 0i-$ 05 A Ro0"+ Ta-# +i&*0&&io" a$ a o'-+ Co"'#&& of So*io-o/ i&,i$ #.& $o .#, $%# 'i%$ -a*# fo' &$a$i" &o.# of $%# '#a&o"& fo' ./ *'i$i*a- a$$i$0+#,

o"-/ &o.#, fo' ./ $i.# i& #'#-/ -i.i$#+, a"+ I -i# $o *o.i"# / *'i$i*a- '#.a'&

i$% a$ -#a&$ a f# %i"$& ao0$ $%# o&i$i# a*$& of a +##-o.#"$a- &o*io-oi*a-

$%#o'/ %i*% a-o"# *a" @0&$if/ *'i$i*i&.5 Mo'#o#', ./ *'i$i*a- a$$i$0+# $oa'+& Pa'&o"&3

i"$#--#*$0a- &/&$#. i& ;0a-ifi#+ / ./ '#*$ fo' %i& #'&o"5 O"# .a/ +i&a'## i$%

%i., 0$ o"# *a""o$ +o0$ %i& i"$#--#*$0a- &i"*#'i$/ a"+ i"$#'i$/5 No' $%# i+$% of %i&

o#' of &/"$%#&i& %i*% i& o"# of $%# ;0a-if/i" if$& of $%# +i&$i"0i&%#+ $%#o'/.a#'5


5/15

$%#o'/ *a" '0" i" %a'"#&&, a& a %o' f'o. $%# &a.# &$a-#, i$% a +#*i+#-/ "o$ a$o.i&$i*

$%#o'/ a**o'+i" $o %i*% ##'/$%i" i" &o*i#$/ i& a +##"+#"$ a'$ of a %i%-/

i"$#'a$#+ a"+ "o'.a--/ &.oo$%-/ f0"*$io"i" %o-#5 T%i&, $oo, $%# .o+#- of &o*i#$/ a&

a 3&o*ia- &/&$#.3 a "o'.a--/ #-- oi-#+ &o*ia- .a*%i"#'/ %#'# a-- a'$& a'#

%a'.o"io0&-/ #a'#+ $o #a*% o$%#', i& 'a$%#' '#.o$# f'o. $%# 'o0% a"+ $0.-# of .#"3&

&o*ia- -if#, a& o"# *a" a*$0a--/ o'# i$5

I$ i& *#'$ai"-/ +iffi*0-$ $o a-/ $o $%# -a'#' &o*i#$i#& of $%# a&$ %i*% #'# .o'#

i"$#'a$#+ i" $#'.& of '#io"& of &o*ia- &$'a$a a"+ ##" of i..i'a"$&, $%a" .o&$ of o0'

*o"$#.o'a'/ E0'o#a" "a$io" &$a$#&5 Pa'&o"3& $%#o'/ of &o*i#$/ a& a "o'.a--/ #-- a"+

%i%-/ i"$#'a$#+ &/&$#. a#a'& $o *-ai. $%# &$a$0& of a #"#'a- &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'/

a-i*a-# $o a-- &o*i#$i#& of .#"5 O"# *a""o$ %#- o"+#'i" %#$%#' i$ i& "o$ i" fa*$ a"

o#'#6$#"+#+ a"+ 'a$%#' i+#a-i&i" #"#'a-i&a$io" a&$'a*$#+ f'o. .o+#'" "a$io" &$a$#&

a"+ 'o@#*$#+ i" a-- $%# o'-+5 Ca" $%# Pa'&o"ia" .o+#- of a 3&o*ia- &/&$#.3 i$% i$&

&0o+-/ i"$#'a$i" 0"i$/ of a-0#& a"+ of *0-$0'# '#a--/ a-/ $o $%# &-a# &$a$#& of

a"$i;0i$/ %#'# &o*ia- +i&$a"*#&, i"#;0a-i$i#& of &o*ia- &$'a$a a"+ +iff#'#"*#& i" $%#i'

*0-$0'# a"+ $%#i' a-0#& #'# of$#" #'/ .0*% '#a$#' a"+ '#io"a- i"$#'a$io" of$#"

#'/ .0*% -#&& '#a$ $%a" o0' *o"$#.o'a'/ i"+0&$'ia- "a$io" &$a$#& Do#& i$ a-/ fo'i"&$a"*# $o $%# A&&/'ia" o' $%# Ro.a" E.i'# O' $o $%# Co"f#+#'a$# S$a$#& of $%# 1!$%

a"+ 19$% C#"$0'/ i$% $%#i' .a&&i# &-a# o0-a$io" O' $o +/"a&$i* R0&&ia i$% %#'

%i#'a'*%/ of 'ii-##+ -a"+o"#'& a"+ &$a$# offi*ia-& a"+ $%# .a&& of %#' #a&a"$ 'f&

If o"# -oo& a'o0"+ i" $%# &o*io-oi*a- -i$#'a$0'# of o0' $i.#, i$ *a" #a&i-/ a#a' $%a$

"a$io"&$a$#& a& a *ifi* $/# of &o*ia- fo'.a$io" %a# "o -a*# a$ a-- i" $%#

&o*io-oi&$&3 fi#-+ of #";0i'/5 I$ $a#& &o.# $i.# #fo'# o"# +i&*o#'& $%a$ "a$io" &$a$#&.a# $%#i' a#a'a"*# a& a $oi* of *o"$#.o'a'/ &o*io-o/ i" a *%a'a*$#'i&$i* +i&0i

T%# '#f#'#"*#& $o $%#. a'# .a+ / a *ifi* $/# of a&$'a*$io"5 T%#/ a'# %i++#"

#%i"+ &0*% *o"*#$& a& 3$%# &o*ia- %o-#3 a"+ 3$o$a- &o*i#$/3 a"+ ao# a-- 3$%# &o*ia-

&/&$#.35 A-$%o0% $%# *o"*#$& *a" # a-i#+ $o o$%#' '#-a$i#-/ %i%-/ i"$#'a$#+

&o*ia- fo'.a$io"&, &0*% a& $'i#&, .0*% $%a$ i& &ai+ ao0$ &o*i#$/ a& a 8%o-#8 o' a& a

8&o*ia- &/&$#.8 i" &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#&, &0*% a& $%a$ of Pa'&o"&, i& -#*$#+, a&$'a*$#+

a"+ +i&$i--#+ f'o. $%# .o&$ %i%-/ a"+ *-o-/ i"$#'a$#+ &o*i#$i#& of o0' o" $i.#


6/15

f'o. "a$io" &$a$#&5 A& 'o-#.& of "a$io" &$a$#& fo'. $%# .ai" $oi* of ./ *o"$'i0$io"

$o $%i& +i&*0&&io", I $%o0%$ i$ .i%$ # 0f0- $o i"+i*a$# $%# *o""#*$io" #$##" $%#

'o-#.& a"+ $%# .o&$ 'o.i"#"$ of $%# *o"$#.o'a'/ &/&$#. $%#o'i#&5 T%# -a$$#' %a# a

0'#-/ +#&*'i$i# *%a'a*$#' of$#" i$% &$'o" $#-#o-oi*a- 0"+#'$o"#&5 I" Pa'&o"&3 .o+#-

$%# .ai"$#"a"*# of a 0"ifi#+, #;0i-i'a$#+ a"+ #-- f0"*$io"i" &o*ia- &/&$#. of$#"

a#a'& a& $%# 0'o a"+ ai. $oa'+& %i*% a-- a'$##"$& a'# +i'#*$#+5 A" #6a.-#

o"# of .a"/ i& $%# +#&*'i$io" of o#' a& 3fa*i-i$/ fo' $%# #'fo'.a"*# of f0"*$io" i"

a"+ o" #%a-f of $%# &o*i#$/ a& a &/&$#.35 S#"$#"*#& &0*% a& $%i& &%o #'/ *-#a'-/ $%#

a&$'a*$io" i" $%# 'i*# of a *ifi* i+#a-5 A& i" .a"/ o$%#' *a&, i+#a- $/#& &0*% a&

$%#, 0'#-/ +#&*'i$i# -a-i# a&$'a*$io"& '# i$%o0$ +o0$ 0"i"$#"$io"a--/ i"

$%i& *a a& +i&0i& fo' &0@#*$*#"$'#+ a-0#&5 T#-#o-o/ '#& a& a &0&$i$0$# fo'

#6-a"a$io"5 If o"# 'i"& $%# 3&/&$#.3*o"*#$ +o" $o #a'$%, if o"# a&& %o a"+ %/

-o"$#'. 'o*#&& of i"$#'a$io" of %i*% &$a$# fo'.a$io" a"+ "a$io"0i-+i"

'o*#&& a'# #6a.-#&, a*$0a--/ o**0''#+ a"+ o**0', o"# '#a'#& $%# a/ fo' a"

#6-a"a$o'/ &o*io-oi*a- .o+#-= o"# +i'#*$& a$$#"$io" $o $%# 'o-#. %/, i" $%# *o0'

of $i.#, '#-a$i#-/ -a'# 3&/&$#.&3 #*a.# a"+ #*o.# i" $%# *a& .o'# %i%-/

i"$#'a$#+ a"+ $%#i' 3a'$&3 f0"*$io"a--/ .o'# i"$#'+##"+#"$5


7/15

#6#*0$# &0*% a -a" I %a# i#" a a'$ a"' $o $%i& 'o-#. #-%#'#5(2)I$ .0&$ #

#"o0% %#'#, a& a *o"$'i0$io" $o o0' 'o-#. of &o*io-oi*a- $%#o'i#& of -o"$#'.

+##-o.#"$&, $o *o"*#"$'a$# o" a f# 'o-#.& of $%# -a$#&$ %a i" $%i& 'o*#&&, of

"a$io"0i-+i" 'o*#&&5

B/ "#-#*$i" -o"$#'. 'o*#&& of i"$#'a$io" a"+ +i&i"$#'a$io" a& a $%#o'#$i*a- a"+

#.i'i*a- $oi* of &o*io-oi*a- #";0i'/, &o*io-oi&$& %a# &$##'#+ $%#i' +i&*i-i"# i"$o a

#-- "o" +i-#..a= $%# "#-#*$ %a& *#.#"$#+ $%#i' +ii&io" i"$o $o +ia.#$'i*a--/

oo+ &*%oo-&, o"# of %i*% -a*#& *o--ao'a$io", f0"*$io"a- i"$#'a$io" a"+

i"$#'+##"+#"*# i"$o $%# *#"$#' of i$& .o+#- of &o*i#$/, $%# o$%#' $#"&io", fi&&io" a"+

*o"f-i*$5 %a$##' $%# .o+# i+#o-oi*a- '#a&o"& fo' $%i& +ii&io" a'#, a"/ -o"$#'.

#";0i'/ i"$o &$a$# fo'.a$io" a"+ "a$io" 0i-+i" 'o*#&& *a" &%o $%a$ ##'/ &0'$

$oa'+& '#a$#' i"$#'+##"+#"*#, $oa'+& *-o' i"$#'a$io" of %0.a" 'o0& %i*%

#'# '#io0&-/ i"+##"+#"$, o' -#&& +##"+#"$, o' -#&& '#*i'o*a--/ +##"+#"$, o" #a*%

o$%#', '0"& $%'o0% a 'i#& of *ifi* i"$#'a$io" $#"&io"& a"+ *o"f-i*$&, of a-a"*# of

o#' &$'0-#& %i*% a'# "o$ a**i+#"$a-, 0$ &$'0*$0'a- *o"*o.i$a"$& of $%# &0'$&

$oa'+& '#a$#' f0"*$io"a- i"$#'+##"+#"*# of 3a'$&3 i$%i" a 3%o-#35 Fo' if $o 'o0&

#*o.# .o'#, o' .o'# '#*i'o*a--/, i"$#'+##"+#"$ $%a" $%#/ #'# #fo'#, #a*% of $%#.%a& '#a&o" $o f#a' $%a$ i$ .a/ # +o.i"a$#+, o' ##" a""i%i-a$#+, / $%# o$%#'5 T%#

&$'0-# .a/ '#&0-$ af$#' .a"/ $#&$& of &$'#"$% i" a f0&io"5 I$ .a/ '#&0-$ i" $%# *o.-#$#

+i&a#a'a"*# of o"# of $%#. i" $%# "# 0"i$ #.#'i" f'o. $%#i' &$'0-#&5 T%#'# a'#

.a"/ .o'# o&&ii-i$i#&5 T%# *o.-#6i$/ of $%# i"$#'a$io"& "##+ "o$ *o"*#'" 0& %#'#5

I$ i& #"o0% $o oi"$ o0$ $%a$ ##'/ .o# $oa'+& '#a$#' f0"*$io"a- i"$#'+##"+#"*#

#$##" %0.a" 'o0& #"#"+#'& &$'0*$0'a- $#"&io"&, *o"f-i*$& a"+ &$'0-#&, %i*%

.a/ o' .a/ "o$ '#.ai" 0".a"a#a-#5

Na$io" 0i-+i" 'o*#&& &%o $%a$ #'/ *-#a'-/5 To .ai" $/#& of i"$#'a$io"

'o*#&& &$a"+ o0$ i" $%#i' *o0', #a*% i$% i$& *ifi* i"$#'a$io" &$'0-#&: 'o*#&&

of $#''i$o'ia- o' '#io"a- i"$#'a$io" a"+ 'o*#&& of &$'a$a i"$#'a$io"5 A-$%o0% o"#

*a" +i&$i"0i&% $%#., $%#/ a'# &$'0*$0'a--/ *o""#*$#+5 I" +i&*0&&i" &o.# of $%#i'

a*$&, $%#'#fo'#, o"# of$#" %a& $o .o# f'o. $%# o"# $o $%# o$%#'5 O"# of $%# fi'&$ a"+

o"# of $%# f# #o-# %o %a# a+ +i'#*$-/ a"+ i$%o0$ *i'*0.-o*0$io": 8%a$ i&


8/15

"a$io"8 a& $%# '#a$ F'#"*% &aa"$ E'"#&$ R#"a"5 So.# of $%# o'a$io"& a"+

'#f-#*$io"& *o"$ai"#+ i" %i& -#*$0'#, 803#&$*# ;030"# Na$io"8() a'# of &i"ifi*a"*#

%#'#5


9/15

fo' $%#. a$ -#a&$ a .o+i*0. of $%#i' fo'.#' o#' &0'-0& i" '#-a$io" $o .i++-# a"+

-o#' *-a&&5

I$ i& 0f0- $o ## i" .i"+ $%# -#a+i" a'$ %i*% '#'#"$a$i# *$io"& of $%#

$'a+i$io"a- E0'o#a" 0#' *-a&& *o"$i"0#+ $o -a/ i" $%# affai'& of E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#&

a$ -#a&$ 0 $o $%# Fi'&$ o'-+ a', if o"# a"$ $o 0"+#'&$a"+ $%# 'a+0a-"#&& i$% %i*%

+/"a&$i* &$a$#& $'a"&fo'.#+ $%#.-#& i"$o "a$io" &$a$#&5 Fo--oi" Ma'6 a"+ #'%a&

&-i%$-/ .i&i"$#''#$i" %i& .o+#- of $%# +##-o.#"$ of E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#&, .a"/

#o-# %a# $o+a/ a" o#'&i.-ifi#+ i*$0'# of $%# *%a"# i" $%# &$'a$ifi*a$io" of

E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#& %i*% -a/& &o -a'# a a'$ i" $%# *%a"# f'o. +/"a&$i* $o "a$io"a-

&$a$#&5 A**o'+i" $o $%i& i*$0'# $%# F'#"*% '#o-0$io" '#'#"$& a" a&o-0$# *a#&0'a

#$##" a" o'+#' i" %i*% %a$ Ma'6 *a--#+ a f#0+a- *-a&&3 of 'i"*#&, -a"+#+

a'i&$o*'a$& a"+ '#-a$#+ 'o0&, fo'.#+ $%# '0-i" *-a&&3()of &o*i#$/ a"+ a &o*ia- o'+#'

i" %i*% $%# o0'#oi&i# 'o# $%# o#' of $%# f#0+a- *-a&&3 a"+ $oo i$& -a*# a& $%#

'0-i" *-a&& of &o*i#$/5 I" a*$0a- fa*$ 'i"*#& a"+ a'i&$o*'a$i* a'a'ia" 'o0& of o"# i"+

o' $%# o$%#' *o"$i"0#+ $o -a/ a #'/ +#*i&i# a'$ a& *ifi* fo*i of o#' i" .o&$

E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#& af$#' $%# F'#"*% '#o-0$io"5 Fo' $%# '#a$#' a'$ of $%# 19$% *#"$0'/,

$%# .ai" a6i& of &o*ia- $#"&io"& a"+ *o"f-i*$ of E0'o#a" &o*i#$i#& a& "o$ $%a$ #$##"o'#'& a"+ *ai$a-i&$&5 T%# 19$% *#"$0'/ a& a"+ '#.ai"#+ a #'io+ of $%'##*o'"#'#+

&$'0-#& #$##" -a"+o"i" a'i&$o*'a$i* a"+ *o0'$ #-i$#&, 'i&i" i"+0&$'ia- .i++-# *-a&&

'o0& a"+, #%i"+ $%#., $%# 'i&i" i"+0&$'ia- o'i" *-a&&5 T%# #6'#&&io" .i++-#

*-a&&3 a& a *-a&&if/i" $#'. fo' $%# #"$'#'#"#0'ia- *-a&&, %i*% i& %a'+-/ a"/ -o"#'

a'o'ia$# $o+a/, '#f#'& $o $%#i' o&i$io" i" $%i& $%'##*o'"#'#+ a$$-#5 A& $%# i"+0&$'ia-

o'i" *-a&& #'# +0'i" $%# fi'&$ a'$ of $%# 19$% *#"$0'/ a"+ of$#" .0*% -o"#',

&$i-- #'/ i"#ff#*$i#-/ o'a"i+, of$#" %a'+-/ -i$#'a$# a"+ #'/ oo', $%# &$'0-# of $%#0'a" #"$'#'#"#0'ia- *-a&& fo' &$'o"#' a'$i*ia$io" i" &$a$# affai'& a"+ aai"&$ $%#

+o.i"a"*# of $%# $'a+i$io"a- 0#' *-a&& a& fo' a $i.# .o'# a*0$# o" $%# &$a$# -##-

$%a" $%a$ #$##" 'o0& of o'#'& a"+ #"$'#'#"#0'& %i*% &$i-- '#.ai"#+ of$#" -a$#"$,

%i*%, if i$ *a.# i"$o $%# o#", '#.ai"#+ -a'#-/ &o'a+i*, +iff0, i"$#'.i$$#"$ a"+

%i*% a& %a'+-/ fo0%$ o0$ ao# $%# -o*a- -##- i$% a"/ +#'## of #ff#*$i#"#&& 'io'

$o $%# *o"+ %a-f of $%# 19$% *#"$0'/5 T%# &-o-/ 'i&i" o#' of $%# o'a"i+

i"+0&$'ia- o'i" *-a&& '#a$-/ *o"$'i0$#+ $o $%# 'a'o*%#.#"$ #$##" -a"+#+ a"+


10/15

i"+0&$'ia- i"$#'#&$&5 T%# +#*'#a i" $%# $#"&io" #$##" $%#., of$#" -#a+i" $o

*o.'o.i a"+ a--ia"*# i" a *o..o" &$'0-# aai"&$ o'i" *-a&& '#'#"$a$i#&,

$oo a +iff#'#"$ fo'. i" +iff#'#"$ &o*i#$i#&= 0$ i$ a& 0&0a--/ $%# '#-0+# $o $%# 'i of

.#" '#'#"$i" $%# $'a+i$io"& of $%# 0'a" i"+0&$'ia- .i++-# *-a&& $o $%#

*o..a"+i" o&i$io"& of $%# &$a$# a"+ $%# 'a+0a- '#$'#a$ f'o. $%# o&i$io"& of

.#.#'& of $%# o-+ 0#' *-a&&, %o '#'#+ a .o+i*0. of $%#i' $'a+i$io" a"+

i+#a-&5 %#$%#' $%# fo'.#' %a+ $%# fa*# of G-a+&$o"#, T%i#'& o' S$'#.a"", $%#i'

a+#"$ a& &/.$o.a$i* of $%# a+a"*# of *$io"& of $%# fo'.#' .i++-# *-a&&, of $%#

0'a" i"+0&$'ia- *-a&&, $oa'+& $%# o&i$io" of $%# *o'# 'o0 of $%# &$a$#5 T%# .i++-#

*-a&&, o"# .i%$ &a/, %a+ #*o.# i"$#'a$#+ i"$o $%# &$a$#, o', a& Pa'&o"& %a& 0$ i$,

i"*-0+#+35 B0$ $%i& *o"*#$0a-i&a$io" i& "o$ %o--/ a+#;0a$#5 I$ i#& $%# i.'#&&io"

$%a$ a "# &$'a$0. %a& ##" i"*-0+#+3 i" a 3&o*ia- &/&$#.3 %i*% a& &0*% '#.ai"&

0"*%a"#+5()I" a*$0a- fa*$ $%# 'i $o a o&i$io" of '#a$#' o#' i$%i" $%# &$a$#

&o*i#$/ of '#'#"$a$i#& of $%# #"$'#'#"#0'ia- *-a&& a& &/.$o.a$i* of a

$'a"&fo'.a$io" of $%# &/&$#.3 i$-f5 I$ .a'#+ $%# oi"$ of "o '#$0'" a$ %i*% $%#

#&$i#& of $%# +/"a&$i*a'i&$o*'a$i* o'+#' of &o*i#$/ &-o-/ fa+#+ i"$o $%# a*'o0"+

a"+ a$ %i*% $%# &$a$# #"$#'#+ i$& fi'&$ %a a& a f0--/f-#+#+ "a$io"a- &$a$# $%# fi'&$

%a #*a0 $%# 'oa+#&$ &$'a$a of $%# "a$io" &$i-- '#.ai"#+ -a'#-/ #6*-0+#+ a"+o0$&i+#'&5 Di&'a#-i ai" of $o "a$io"&3 fo0"+ a $#--i" o'+ fo' i$5 I$ i& #'%a& "o$

0"*%a'a*$#'i&$i* of $%# $%'##*o'"#'#+ $#"&io" fi0'a$io" of &o*i#$i#& i" $%# *o"+ a'$

of $%# 19$% *#"$0'/ $%a$ i" G#'.a"/ a& i" E"-a"+ $%# -#a+#'& of *o"'a$i# 'o0&

i$% &$'o" a'a'ia" i"$#'#&$&, Bi&.a'* a"+ Di&'a#-i, #a*% i" $%#i' o" a/ $'i#+ $o

i.'o# $%# *o"+i$io"& of $%# o'i" *-a&& a'$-/ i" $%# %o# of i""i" $%#. o#'

a& a--i#& i" $%#i' &$'0-# i$% a'$i#& .o'# '#'#"$a$i# of 0'a" .a"0fa*$0'i" a"+

-i#'a- 'o0&, a'$-/ i" o'+#' $o *o0"$#' $%# 'o$% of o'i" *-a&& a'$i#&5

O"# *a" &a/, $%0&, $%a$ i"+0&$'ia-i&a$io" a"+ "a$io" 0i-+i" a'# $o fa*#$& of $%# &a.#

$'a"&fo'.a$io" of &o*i#$i#&5 B0$ o"# *a""o$ *-#a'-/ i"+i*a$# $%# *o""#*$io" 0"-#&& o"#

-i"& o$% $%# 'o*#&& $o a" o#'a-- *%a"# i" $%# +i&$'i0$io" of o#' *%a"*#& i"

&o*i#$/5 T%#'# i& a &i.-# a/ $o +#.o"&$'a$# $%i& *%a"# a-$%o0% i$ o0-+ '#;0i'#

.0*% '#a$#' #-ao'a$io" $o +o i$ *o"i"*i"-/5 D/"a&$i* &$a$#& a'# *%a'a*$#'i&$i* of a

&$a# i" $%# +##-o.#"$ of &o*i#$i#& a$ %i*% $%# '#&o0'*#& of o#' a'# #'/ 0"##"-/


11/15

+i&$'i0$#+ #$##" '0-i" #-i$#& a"+ $%# .a&& of $%# o0-a$io"5 I" .a"/ *a& 9 o'

.o'# of $%# o0-a$io" of a *o0"$'/ %a# "o i"&$i$0$io"a- .#a"&, "o '#0-a' *%a""#-& of

*o..0"i*a$io"& %i*% #"a-# $%#. $o i"f-0#"*# +#*i&io"& of 'o0& i$% a**#&& $o $%#

*o..a"+i" o&i$io"& of $%# &$a$# %i*% aff#*$ $%#i' -i#&5 E#" a**#&& $o #&$a$#

a&.-i#&, i$% #'/ f# #6*#$io"&, i&, i" 'a*$i*#, o#" o"-/ $o &.a-- #-i$# 'o0&5 I"

.a"/ *a& 'i"*#& a"+ o#'".#"$ a'# a-# $o '0-# fo' -o" #'io+& i$%o0$ a--oi"

#&$a$# a&.-i#& $o .##$5 No$%i" i& .o'# *%a'a*$#'i&$i* of $%# *%a"# i" $%#

+i&$'i0$io" of o#' i"+i*a$#+ / $%# $'a"&fo'.a$io" of +/"a&$i* i"$o "a$io"a- &$a$#&

$%a" $%# #.#'#"*# of .a&& a'$i#& a& a '#0-a' i"&$i$0$io" of "a$io" &$a$#&5 T%#

i+#&'#a+ +i&*o"$#"$ i$% .a&& a'$i#& %i*% +o "o$ #"&0'# a #"0i"# a'$i*ia$io" of

$%# 'o0& %i*% $%#/ "o.i"a--/ '#'#"$ o&*0'#& $%# a&i* &o*io-oi*a- 'o-#.&

i$% %i*% o"# i& fa*#+ / $%# '#a$ '#0-a'i$/ i$% %i*% .a&& a'$i#& a'# fo'.#+ a&

&$a"+i" i"&$i$0$io"& i" a-- $%# .o'# a+a"*#+ a"+ ##" .a"/ -#&& a+a"*#+ &o*i#$i#& of

o0' $i.#5 O"# 0&0a--/ fai-& $o a& %i*% +##-o.#"$&, %i*% &$'0*$0'#& of &o*i#$i#&

a**o0"$ fo' $%# #.#'#"*# of "a$io"i+# o-i$i*a- a'$i#& a"+ of a'$/ o#'".#"$& a&

'#0-a' i"&$i$0$io"& i" $%# 19$% a"+ 2$% *#"$0'i#& I"#ff#*$i# o' "o$, "a$io"i+#

a'$i#& a"+ a'$/ o#'".#"$ a'# &/.$o.a$i* of a &$a# i" $%# +##-o.#"$ of

&o*i#$i#&, a$ %i*% $%# i"$#'a$io" of a &$a$#o0-a$io" %a& #*o.# *-o', a$ %i*% i$ i&"o -o"#' o&&i-# $o $a# +#*i&io"& aff#*$i" $%# -i#& of $%# o0-a$io" of a *o0"$'/

#"$i'#-/ i$%o0$ '#0-a' *%a""#-& of *o..0"i*a$io" #$##" +#*i&io".a#'& a"+ $%o

aff#*$#+ / $%#i' +#*i&io"&5 T%# a-a"*# of o#' #$##" 'o0& i$% a**#&& $o

o&i$io"& %i*% #"a-# $%#. $o $a# +#*i&io"& o#' $%# -i#& of o$%#'& a"+ 'o0& i$%

-i$$-# o' "o a**#&& $o $%# +#*i&io"& i& "o -o"#' ;0i$# a& 0"##" a& i$ a& i" #a'-i#'

&$a#& of &o*ia- +##-o.#"$5 T%# '#*i'o*i$/ of $%# +##"+#"*# of o#'".#"$ o" $%o

$%#/ o#'" a"+ of $%# o#'"#+ o" o#'".#"$&, $%o0% &$i-- 0"##" #"o0%, %a*o.# -#&& 0"##" $%a" i$ 0+ $o #5 T%# a-a"*# of a'$i#& i" +iff#'#"$ *o0"$'i#& i& a

fai'-/ #6a*$ i"+i*a$o' of $%i& a-a"*# of o#' a"+ i$& f-0*$0a$io"&5

O"# *a" # $%# *o""#*$io" #$##" $%# &o*ia- i"&$i$0$io" of a'$i#& a"+ $%# 'o#'$i#& of

"a$io" &$a$#&5 So*i#$i#& a&&0.# $%# *%a'a*$#'i&$i*& of "a$io"& i& $%# f0"*$io"a-

i"$#'+##"+#"*# #$##" i$& '#io"& a"+ i$& &o*ia- &$'a$a a& #-- a& i$& %i#'a'*%i* -##-&

of a0$%o'i$/ a"+ &0o'+i"a$io" #*o.#& &0ffi*i#"$-/ '#a$ a"+ &0ffi*i#"$-/ '#*i'o*a- fo'


12/15

"o"# of $%#. $o # a-# $o +i&'#a'+ *o.-#$#-/ %a$ $%# o$%#'& $%i", f##- o' i&%5

Go#'".#"$ / a'$/ -#a+#'& a"+ $%# a+o$io" / o$%, o#'".#"$& a"+ a'$i#&, of

i+#o-o/ +#&i"#+ $o *o"i"*# $%# .a&& of $%# o0-a$io" $%a$ $%#/ '#a'+ $%#

i.'o#.#"$ of $%#i' *o"+i$io"&, $%# a+a"*# of $%# #-fa'# of $%# "a$io" a& $%#i' *#"$'a-

$a& a'# &/.$o.a$i* of $%# #'/ 'o"o0"*#+ *%a"# i" $%# a-a"*# of o#' #$##"

o#'".#"$& a"+ o#'"#+ of %i*% I %a# &o#"5 T%#'# i& "o +o0$ $%a$ ##" $%#

.o&$ a+a"*#+ of o0' *o"$#.o'a'/ i"+0&$'ia- "a$io" &$a$#& a'# &$i-- i" $%# #a'-/ &$a#& of

$%# 'o*#&& of "a$io" 0i-+i"5 I %a# "o$ ##" a-# %#'# $o #6-ai" $%# '#a&o"& %/

$%#/ %a# o$ 0"+#' a/5 No' o0-+ I '##.$ $%# f0$0'# a"+ &a/ $%#/ .0&$ a"+ i-- o

f0'$%#' i" $%a$ +i'#*$io"5 B0$ #'%a& I %a# *-a'ifi#+ &o.# of $%# *o""#*$io"& #$##"

##"$& %i*% a'# a*a+#.i*a--/ of$#" *-a&&ifi#+ 0"+#' +iff#'#"$ %#a+i"&5 Po-i$i*a- a'$i#&

a"+ ##" "a$io"& .a/ "o$ a#a' a& a &o*io-oi&$&3 *o"*#'", &o*ia- *-a&& "o$ a& $%a$ of

a o-i$i*a- &*i#"$i&$, %i-# i"+0&$'ia-i&a$io" .a/ # '#a'+#+ a& $%# #*o"o.i&$3& '#'#,

a"+ +/"a&$i* &$a$#& a& $%a$ of $%# %i&$o'ia"5 H#$ $%# *o""#*$io"& a'# $%#'# fo' a-- $o #

'oi+#+ o"# %a& a -o"$i.# #'*$i# a"+ fo*0& a$$#"$io" o" $%# *%a"i" o#'

'#-a$io"& #$##" +iff#'#"$ &o*ia- 'o0&5

Fo' $%# $i.# #i" I %a# &i.-/ $'i#+ $o 0$ i"$o #'*$i# $%# 'o-#. of "a$io"0i-+i"5 T%# -fi.a#& of "a$io"&, fo' '#a&o"& ao0$ %i*% I %a# $o &a/ .o'#,

0&0a--/ i# $%# i.'#&&io" $o $%# .#.#'& of #a*% of $%#. $%a$ $%#i' "a$io" #6i&$#+, i"

#&"$ia-&, 0"*%a"#+ fo' .a"/ *#"$0'i#& if "o$ fo' ##'5 %a$ i& $o+a/ $a0%$ a& %i&$o'/

of o"#3& o" *o0"$'/, %o##' .a"/ *%a"#& i$ .a/ &%o %i*% %a# o**0''#+ a.o"

$%# i"%ai$a"$& of $%a$ *o0"$'/ o#' $%# *#"$0'i#&, *a" 0&0a--/ # a**o..o+a$#+ $o $%#

'#;0i'#.#"$& of a "a$io"a- -fi.a# %i*% '#'#"$& o"#3& o" "a$io" a& 0"*%a"i"

$%'o0%o0$ $%# a#& i" i$& a&i* *%a'a*$#'i&$i*&5 Co"$#.o'a'/ &$a$#&o*i#$i#& %i*% a'#&$i-- i" $%# #a'-/ &$a#& of a &$a$# fo'.a$io" a"+ "a$io" 0i-+i" 'o*#&&, i" .a"/ *a&

a'# a-'#a+/ #i""i" $o *o"&$'0*$ a &i.i-a' i.a# of $%#.-#& a" i.a# of $%#

"a$io"a- a&$ i$% %i*% '#"$ #"#'a$io"& *a" i+#"$if/ $%#.-#&, %i*% i#& $%#.

a f##-i" of 'i+# i" $%#i' o" "a$io"a- i+#"$i$/ a"+ %i*% *a" '# a& a *a$a-/&$ i" a

"a$io" 0i-+i" 'o*#&& $%a$ 0&0a--/ i"*-0+#& $%# i"$#'a$io" of +i&a'a$# '#io"a- 'o0&

a"+ +iff#'#"$ &o*ia- &$'a$a a'o0"+ *#'$ai" +o.i"a"$ *o'# 'o0&5


13/15

T%#'# i& .0*% $o # &ai+ fo' &$0+/i" $%# 'o*#&& fa*$0a--/5 B0$ i" o'+#' $o +o &o,

o"# .0&$ # a-# $o +i&$i"0i&% #$##" "a$io"a- i+#o-oi#& %i*% .a# a "a$io" a#a'

a& a" 0"*%a"i" a"+ #-- i"$#'a$#+ &o*ia- &/&$#. of '#a$ a-0#, a"+ $%# o'a-#

-o"$#'. 'o*#&& of 2!4J i"$#'a$io" a"+ +i&i"$#'a$io" i" $%# *o0' of %i*%

$#"&io"& a"+ &$'0-#& #$##" *#"$'if0a- a"+ *#"$'i#$a- $#"+#"*i#& a"+ #$##"

#&$a-i&%#+ a"+ o0$&i+#' 'o0& o**0' a& a '#0-a' f#a$0'# *%a'a*$#'i&$i* of $%# &$'0*$0'#

of $%# +##-o.#"$&5 O"# .0&$ # a-# $o #'*#i# "a$io"& a& a *ifi* $/# of

i"$#'a$io" %i*% '#;0i'#& #6-a"a$io" a"+ %i*% *a""o$ # #6-ai"#+ 0"-#&& o"#

'#*o"i#& &$a$# fo'.a$io" 'o*#&&, a"+, a& o"# of $%#i' %a&, "a$io" 0i-+i"

'o*#&&, a& -o"$#'. 'o*#&& i" $%# 0#"*# of $i.#, a"+ *o"&i+#'& $%a$ "a$io"

0i-+i" 'o*#&&, fa' f'o. '#'#"$i" $%# -a&$ a"+ 0-$i.a$# &0'$ of a &$a$# fo'.a$io"

'o*#&&, .a/ # fo--o#+ / i"$#'a$io"& o" a %i%#' o&$"a$io"a- -##- of %i*% o"#

*a" # $%# #i""i"&, fo' #6a.-#, i" #&$#'" a"+ Ea&$#'" E0'o#, a.o" 'o0& of

A'a &$a$#& a"+ &o.# of $%# Af'i*a" &$a$#&5 So*io-oi*a--/ ai" $%# &*i#"$ifi*

#6-o'a$io" of $%# *o"$#.o'a'/ i"$#'a$io" a"+ +i&i"$#'a$io" &0'$& *a" $%'o -i%$

o" a&$ &0'$& of $%i& $/#, o" #a'-i#' &$a$# fo'.a$io" 'o*#&& a"+ i*# #'&a5 T%#

"o$io" $%a$ &o*io-oi*a- 'o-#.& of o0' o" $i.# a"+ $%o of a&$ a#& .0&$ o' *a" #

0'&0#+, a& i$ #'#, i" a'a$# *o.a'$.#"$& / +iff#'#"$ a*a+#.i* +i&*i-i"#& i&'#a$-/ .i&-#a+i"5 I" fa*$, $%# &$0+/ of -o"$#'. &o*ia- 'o*#&& a"+ #*ia--/ of

'o*#&& of i"$#'a$io" a"+ +i&i"$#'a$io" &%o& #'/ *-#a'-/ $%# "##+ fo' a 0"ifi#+ a"+

i"$#'a$i" $%#o'#$i*a- f'a.#o' fo' $%# &o*ia- &*i#"*#&5 T%#i' '#"$ o0"+a'i#& a"+

$%#i' i"*#&&a"$ &$a$0& &$'0-#&, $o#$%#' i$% $%# #ff#*$& of $%# &$'0-#& o" $%#o'i#&

a"+ *o"#"$io"& of '#a'*%, %a# i"*'#a&i"-/ %a.#'#+ $%#i' a+a"*# $oa'+& '#a$#'

*#'$ai"$/ a"+ a+#;0a*/ of $%# "o-#+# $%#/ 'o+0*# of $%#i' *ia- fi#-+, of %0.a"

&o*i#$/5 T%# o0"+a'i#& a"+ &$'0-#& '#i"fo'*# $%# $#"+#"*/ $oa'+& &%o'$$#'.#'*$i#& $%a$ '#ai- i" .o&$ of $%#.5 Soo"#' o' -a$#' a '##6a.i"a$io" of $%#i'

$'a+i$io"a- '#-a$io"&%i i-- #*o.# "#*#&&a'/5


14/15

NOTES

15 S## N5 E-ia&, K#' +#" P'o#&& +#' ii-i&a$io"5 B#'"# a"+ M0"i*%, 199,

I"$'o+0*$io" $o $%# *o"+ #+i$io"5

25 N5 E-ia&, K#' +#" P'o#&& +#' ii-i&a$io", ii+5

5 E'"#&$ R#"a", 03#&$*# ;030"# Na$io"5 Pa'i&, 1!!25

45 ii+, 5 25

5 Ma'6 +o#& "o$ /#$ *-#a'-/ +i&$i"0i&% #$##" #a'-/ .#+i#a- $/#& of "o-#&

i$% "o o' -i$$-# i"*o.# i" $%# fo'. of .o"#/ a"+ $%# +o.i"a"$ 1!$% *#"$0'/

$/#&, $%# *o0'$ a'i&$o*'a*/, -ii" -a'#-/ o" a .o"#/ i"*o.#5 To *a-- o$%

3f#0+a-3 i& 'a$%#' .i&-#a+i"5 I %a# &%o" &o.# of $%# +iff#'#"*#& a"+ &o.# of

$%# '#a&o"& fo' $%# $'a"&fo'.a$io" of a -a$# f#0+a- "oi-i$/ i"$o a" a'i&$o*'a*/

*#"$'#+ o" a Co0'$, i" 3Di#


15/15

O"*# .o'# Pa'&o"&3 $#-#o-oi*a- #'*$i# a&'$& i$-f5 T%# f0"*$io"i" of

$%# &/&$#.3 i& $%# #"+5 If fo'.#'-/ #6*-0+#+ 'o0& %a# +##-o#+ -#i$i.a$#

*aa*i$i#&3 %i*% #"a-# $%#. $o *o"$'i0$# $o $%# f0"*$io"i" &/&$#., $%#" $%#/

&%o0-+ "o -o"#' # #6*-0+#+5 A& o"# *a" #, $%# &/&$#.3 +o#& "o$ *%a"#5

N#-/ a+.i$$#+ 'o0& .#'#-/ fi$ i"$o i$5 No #6-a"a$io" i& i#" a& $o $%#

#o-# %o @0+# %#$%#' a" #6*-0+#+ 'o0 %a& +##-o#+ -#i$i.a$#3

*aa*i$i#& fo' fi$$i" i"$o $%# #6i&$i" &/&$#.5 O"# +o#& "o$ "o %a$ $o a+.i'#

.o'#, $%# a$#"$ &i"*#'i$/ a"+ oo+ i-- o' $%# +i&a'.i" "aii$/ a"+

i"*o.'#%#"&io" %i*% o"# #"*o0"$#'& %#'#5

Download - Elias 1970 State Formation and Nation Building

Top Related