Download - ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
1/13
Eastern Neighborhood TRIPS
Community Task Force meetingEVALUATION FRAMEWORK ROADMAP & TOOLKIT
Eastern Neighborhood TRIPS
Community Task Force meetingEVALUATION FRAMEWORK ROADMAP & TOOLKIT
08 | 23 | 2010 | SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
2/13
2
EN Area Plans
/Other City
Projects &
Plans
ENTRIPS
Existing
Conditions
Analysis
Modeling
Scenarios
Existing
System
Deficiencies
Universeof
Potential
Projects
Model
Traffic (No
Project)
Circulation
Alternatives
Model
Traffic
(Project)
Develop/
Refine
Corridor
Project
Concepts
EVALUATION
FRAMEWORK
TRACK1 NetworkCirculationProjects
MAJOR
NETWORK
PROJECT
PACKAGES
Future
Conditions
Modal
Analysis
Future
System
Deficiencies
/ Universe of
PotentialProjects
Included in
another
plan?
TRACK2 NeighborhoodScaleProjects
NEIGHBORHOOD
SCALE
PROJECT
PACKAGES
TRACK3 AreawidePolicy
Goods Movement Policy
Shuttle Policy
Parking Policy
TDM Policy
EN TRIPS
Potential
Projects
List
Conceptual
Design
Environmental
Review
Prioritized List
of Future
Investments
(Capital and
Programming)
Fast Track
Improvements/
Pilots
BSP
Street
Typology
Street
Design
Guidance
City Policy,
FuturePlanning
Studies
DRAFT Project Development Work Flow
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
3/13
3
Preliminary Evaluation Framework Mix of qualitative & quantitative criteria
Key Goals-identifies the issue
Evaluation Criteria-identifies the objective:
Three Integrated Sets of Priority Settings:
1. Systemwide Network (operational, modalcapacity/priority, right of way reconfiguration,directional changes)
2. Neighborhood/specific (cross-walks, parking,
loading, specific traffic calming)3. Policies to aid street design/land-use
(shuttles, parking, loading & travel demand
management)
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
4/13
4
Model
Traffic (No
Project)
Circulation
Alternatives
Model
Traffic
(Project)
Develop/Refine
Corridor
Project
Concepts
EVALUATION
FRAMEWORK
TRACK1 NetworkCirculationProjects
MAJOR
NETWORK
PROJECT
BUNDLES
Future
Conditions
Modal
Analysis
Future
System
Deficiencies
/ Universe of
PotentialProjects
Included in
another
plan?
TRACK2 NeighborhoodScaleProjects
NEIGHBORHOOD
SCALE
PROJECT
PACKAGES
TRACK3 AreawidePolicy
Goods Movement Policy
Shuttle Policy
Parking Policy
TDM Policy
EN TRIPS
Potential
Projects
List
Conceptual
Design
Environmental
Review
Prioritized List
of Future
Investments
(Capital and
Programming)
Fast Track
Improvements/
Pilots
BSP
Street
Typology
Street
Design
Guidance
City Policy,
FuturePlanning
Studies
DRAFT Project Development Work Flow
EN Area Plans
/Other City
Projects &
Plans
ENTRIPS
Existing
Conditions
Analysis
Modeling
Scenarios
Existing
System
Deficiencies
Universeof
Potential
Projects
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
5/13
5
Model
Traffic (No
Project)
Circulation
Alternatives
Model
Traffic
(Project)
Develop/Refine
Corridor
Project
Concepts
EVALUATION
FRAMEWORK
TRACK1 NetworkCirculationProjects
SYSTEMWIDE
NETWORK
PROJECT
BUNDLES
Future
Conditions
Modal
Analysis
Future
System
Deficiencies
/ Universe of
PotentialProjects
Included in
another
plan?
TRACK2 NeighborhoodScaleProjects
NEIGHBORHOOD
SCALE
PROJECT
PACKAGES
TRACK3 AreawidePolicy
Goods Movement Policy
Shuttle Policy
Parking Policy
TDM Policy
EN TRIPS
Potential
Projects
List
Conceptual
Design
Environmental
Review
Prioritized List
of Future
Investments
(Capital and
Programming)
Fast Track
Improvements/
Pilots
BSP
Street
Typology
Street
Design
Guidance
City Policy,
FuturePlanning
Studies
DRAFT Project Development Work Flow
EN Area Plans
/Other City
Projects &
Plans
ENTRIPS
Existing
Conditions
Analysis
Modeling
Scenarios
Existing
System
Deficiencies
Universeof
PotentialProjects
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
6/13
6
Preliminary Evaluation Framework Evaluate the performance of the systems
Prioritize and rank projects/policies:
Identify & Prioritize EN-TRIPS systemsnetwork packages
Complete major environmental clearance
Identify EN-TRIPS neighborhood projects that canbe fast-tracked:
Low-cost/Street Innovative type pilots/trials
(develop toolkit) Policies that can be implemented in short-term
(e.g. loading/ parking)
Complete with minor environmental clearance
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
7/13
7
TypicalOneWaySoMaStreetscape
62.5FeetRoadwayWidth
82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
8/13
8
TypicalSoMaStreetscapewithWiderSidewalks
52.5FeetRoadwayWidth
82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth
Trade offs: travel lane or parking lane removal
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
9/13
9OnewaySoMaStreetscapewithDedicatedTransitLane
49FeetRoadwayWidth
82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth
Trade offs: travel lane or parking/bicycle lane removal
18.5 ft sidewalk (Bus Loading)
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
10/13
10OneWaySoMaStreetscapewithCycleTracks
52.5FeetRoadwayWidth
82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth
Trade offs: travel lane and parking lane removal
3-10.5 ft buffer
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
11/13
11OneWaySoMaStreetscapewithTwoWayToolkit
52.5FeetRoadwayWidth
82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth
Trade offs: travel lane and bicycle/parking lane removal/lefts turns
ParkingorbufferedBicycleLane 6-7.5 ft
ParkingorbufferedBicycleLane 6-7.5 ft
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
12/13
12
Next Steps
Future Conditions Analysis
Develop future conditions modeling inputs Perform future condition model runs using
base network assumptions
Identify initial key-corridor intersections forModeling analysis
-
8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation
13/13
13
EN-TRIPS 6 month Look AheadTask Milestone Date
CompleteEvaluationFramework&Sorting Sep2010
TaskforceStreet/NeighborhoodImprovementProjectsUpdate Dec2011
TaskforceFundingandImplementationStrategyUpdate Jan2011
ENTRIPSFundingandImplementationStrategyReport Feb2011
ENTRIPS
update
Citywide
Community
Meeting Mar
2011
BeginSystemwideEnvironmentalReview Jan2011
BeginNeighborhood
Pilots/Trials Jan
2011
ENTRIPSupdateCitywideCommunityMeeting Jan2011
TaskforceFuture
Conditions
Assumptions
Update Sep
2010
ENTRIPSupdateCitywideCommunityMeeting Sep2010
FutureYearLandUse&TransportationConditionsReport Sep2010
KeyENPriorityCorridorStreetscapesPublicWorkshops(Taskforce/Citywide) OctNov2010
PreliminaryStreet/Neighborhood RedesignOptions/ProjectSortingPrioritization Nov2010
KeyEasternneighborhoodsTransportationPublicRealmImprovementProjectsReport Jan2011