- 1 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Estates Content of Business Cases
This document is intended to update NHS Trusts and Local Health Boards in Wales on the requirements of the Welsh Assembly Government for supporting documentation outlining the estates content of Capital schemes in Strategic Outline, Outline and Full Business Cases. This information is complementary to the Five Case Model and would be required to produce any robust Business Case. Some of the documentation has been produced to line up the requirements of the Business Case process with the Designed for Life: Building for Wales construction procurement initiative. These documents must be used for all major Capital Projects where the total Capital Cost exceeds £5 million. Estates Component Annex Many Business Cases in recent years have failed to provide sufficient information on the current estate and the proposed scheme. In future it is a requirement that all Business Cases contain an Annex which provides the fundamental estates information to inform and assist the Business Case scrutiny process. Annexure A to this document includes three outlines of the minimum information required to be included in Strategic Outline, Outline and Full Business Cases. Provision of this information will assist a speedy scrutiny of the Business Case. Revised Cost Forms Revised Cost Forms for Strategic Outline, Outline and Full Business Cases have been produced and are attached as Annexure B. Quantified Risk DoH guidance states that ‘Quantified risk analysis’ refers to the work undertaken in business cases to obtain the expected value of risks in monetary terms. This is through the development of a risk register and for each individual risk the estimation of impact values and probabilities of occurrence. “Quantified risk” can be separated into two elements:
Quantified Trust managed risk Quantified Supply Chain Partner (SCP) managed risk.
Quantified risks should be recorded in a project specific Risk Register. A typical example is attached as Annexure C. The register has been populated with a starting list of risks that have been identified on previous major projects and may be applicable on other schemes. NHS Trusts and SCPs should use the list as a checklist only and develop a project specific register for the intended scheme. Once a specific risk has been identified it should be recorded in the Risk Register. Only one Risk Register should exist for the project but the data should be sorted into various configurations to suit specific purposes, e.g. by Risk Owner, by Risk Type, etc.
- 2 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
The potential impact of each risk and the likelihood of occurrence should be determined and the effect on these of putting in mitigating elements should follow. If the impact or chance of occurrence can be influenced by mitigation, then if it is agreed to put in place the mitigation, the cost consequence of the mitigation should be taken into account in the Risk Register and the cost of mitigation added to the project base cost. The Risk Register therefore covers the chance that the risk will still occur with either a reduced likelihood or potential impact or both. The Quantified Supply Chain Partner’s managed risk identified in the Target Cost will be used in the eventual calculation of the Pain/Gain share. Risks should be fairly borne and NHS Trusts should give due consideration to their risk exposure balanced against the financial consequences of passing unfair or unreasonable risks onto the SCP. No risks should be shared. NHS Trusts in Wales shall confirm in writing at the commencement of FBC the cost figure they expect the SCP to progress the design and construction of the scheme. It will normally be the approved OBC Works Cost (line 5 on Cost Form OBC1) with the addition of the SCPs Fees and the SCPs Quantified Risk. Inflation Fixed Price Contracts (less than 24 months) Strategic Outline (SOC) and Outline Business Case (OBC) costs are compiled on the basis of Departmental Cost Allowances and On-costs and are related to a MIPS index level (currently 455). For Fixed Price Contracts, projected inflation costs to project completion will need to be calculated and provided to and agreed with Welsh Health Estates. These costs should be compiled by Trust Cost Advisors (TCAs) at SOC stage and by Supply Chain Partners (SCPs) in collaboration with the TCA at OBC and FBC stages and shall be agreed with Welsh Health Estates prior to submission of the Business Case. After OBC the method of cost compilation changes to an elemental cost plan arrangement which ultimately becomes the Target Cost. This cost plan should contain an item to cover inflation through the construction period to completion. This should be based on the figure agreed with Welsh Health Estates. Once the Target Cost is agreed no further adjustment will be made for inflation. The Target Cost would be based on costs to completion. Valuations are subsequently based on actual costs with reconciliation between Target Cost and Actual Cost at the end determining the gain/pain share. Variation of Price Contracts (greater than 24 months) Strategic Outline (SOC) and Outline Business Case (OBC) costs are compiled on the basis of Departmental Cost Allowances and On-costs and are related to a MIPS index level (currently 445). For Variation of Price Contracts, projected inflation costs to project completion will need to be calculated and and provided to and agreed with Welsh Health Estates. These costs should be compiled by Trust Cost Advisors (TCAs) at SOC stage and by Supply Chain Partners (SCPs) in
- 3 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
collaboration with the TCA at OBC and FBC stages and shall be agreed with Welsh Health Estates prior to submission of the Business Case. After OBC the method of cost compilation changes to an elemental cost plan arrangement which ultimately becomes the Target Cost. The Target Cost allows for inflation up to the submission of the Full Business Case and will be adjusted monthly during the construction phase in accordance with the contract requirements for construction inflation to “keep pace” with actual cost and allow the calculation of “the preliminary assessment of the Contractor’s share” at project completion. The Target Cost inflation assessment would then be adjusted when the published firm indices have been issued and “the final assessment of the Contractor’s share” made. During the project valuations are based on actual costs. Rules for payment of project sponsorship costs Project sponsorship costs are internal NHS Trust costs that are necessary to initiate, develop and complete a capital project. One of the key success factors for a capital project is the management and resources input by the NHS Trust to identify their requirements and respond to the needs of the Supply Chain in progressing the project to programme. These costs would not exist if there were no capital project. Project sponsorship costs must be capital costs. The NHS Capital Accounting manual states: “The costs of an NHS body’s capital projects department may only be allocated to individual capital schemes where it can be demonstrated that these costs relate to the production of a capital asset (and not its management or maintenance), and that the basis of apportionment is reasonable” The WAG accepts the need to fund the internal resources necessary to enable the NHS Trust to progress and support the capital project with the following conditions:
There is no scheme until the Strategic Outline Case has been approved by the Capital Investment Board. Trusts should therefore be aware that if a project does not progress after SOC any costs attributable to the capital project must be written off as a revenue item.
Project sponsorship funding can only be drawn down after approval of the SOC.
The Project sponsorship team must be a distinct unit. Staff can be specifically recruited or be
transferred or seconded into the unit from other departments. Only the costs associated with staff who are not currently employed by the NHS Trust or whose post will require “backfilling” during their transfer or secondment period will be allowed. Once the capital project is completed funding will cease and these staff will either be redeployed or return to their original departments or come to the end of their contractual employment and move on to other projects either within the NHS Trust or elsewhere.
Pre-OBC an organisational structure chart identifying the proposed internal project structure
must be provided by the Trust to the Capital, Estates and Facilities Branch together with a costed resource schedule spanning the whole project duration. This chart and schedule should be refreshed and updated at OBC and FBC submission stages.
- 4 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Programme guidance The Business Case Cost Forms all include a section at the end for NHS Trusts and LHBs to identify their key programme dates. These will be used by the Welsh Assembly Government to inform the ongoing Capital Programme planning process and identify future funding requirements and priorities. It is vital that realistic programmes are submitted and kept to as failure to meet a submission date may result in projects missing their funding slot and others taking up that funding. To assist NHS Trusts and LHBs in planning major Capital Projects tables of typical project durations for new build and refurbishment schemes is attached as Annexure D. These durations allow reasonable periods for the delivery of each phase. However refurbishment projects need to be adjusted to take account of the number of phases, the extent and sequencing of works and the presence of materials such as asbestos which can significantly affect programme. Value Added Tax The Outline and Full Business Cases should include a statement indicating the status of the project with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC), the identity of the Trust VAT advisor and an outline of the proposed VAT Recovery Strategy. The VAT costs identified on the Capital Cost forms should reflect the implications of the proposed VAT Recovery Strategy. Whole Life Costing Annexure E includes for use at FBC stage a suggested process for the application of Whole Life Costing on major Capital Projects as well as typical proforma that would assist the process. Further work will be done over the next twelve months or so to rationalise the process within the NHS in Wales. Queries Any queries on the contents of this guidance should be directed to Patrick Riordan, Welsh Health Estates, telephone 02920 315545; e-mail: [email protected] Electronic copies of the forms, in Excel format, are available on the Welsh Health Estates website www.wales.nhs.uk/whe and Designed for Life : Building for Wales extranet.
- 5 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
ANNEXURE A
Content of a SOC Estate Component Annex
Executive Summary Estates Investment Objectives Summary of Trust Estates Strategy
The Existing Estate
o Existing Estate Site Plans
Current Estate Performance
o Functional Suitability o Space Utilisation o Statutory Compliance o Physical Condition o Energy Performance o Backlog Maintenance Liability
Estate Performance Improvement Targets
Schedule of Proposed Functional Content Proposed Project Estate Options Capital Costs and projected cashflows (See SOC1- 4 forms) Inflation calculations Initial Assessments of Estate and Facilities Revenue Implications
- 6 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Content of an OBC Estate Component Annex Executive Summary of the Estate implications of the Business Case Estates Investment Objectives Summary of Trust Estates Strategy
The Existing Estate
o Existing Estate Site Plans
Current Estate Performance (identifying data collection date)
Estate Performance Improvement Targets
Proposes Changes to the Estate
Capital Investment Programme
Land and Property Disposal and Acquisition Programme Proposed Project Estate Options (minimum 1:500 scale) Preferred Option Development Control Plan (minimum 1:200 scale) Project Design Principles Project Details Site ownership status Planning Permission Status Quality Assurance and Standards Compliance
AEDET NEAT
Statement of Sustainable Development Commitment Capital Costs and projected cashflows (See OBC1- 8 forms) Inflation calculations Whole Life Cycle Cost Assessments VAT Recovery Strategy
- 7 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Assessments of Estate and Facilities Revenue Implications compared with the base option
Capital Charges Energy Rates Rent Water and sewage Maintenance Security Cleaning Linen and laundry Car Parking Waste disposal Photocopying Telecommunications Portering Postal Services Commissioning De-commissioning
Comparison and reconciliation of functional content and capital costs with SOC
- 8 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Content of an FBC Estate Component Annex Executive Summary of the Estate implications of the Business Case Estates Investment Objectives Summary of Trust Estates Strategy
The Existing Estate
o Existing Estate Site Plans
Current Estate Performance
Estate Performance Improvement Targets
Proposes Changes to the Estate
Capital Investment Programme
Land and Property Disposal and Acquisition Programme Proposed Project Estate Options (minimum 1:500 scale) Preferred Option Development Control Plan (minimum 1:200 scale) Project Design Principles Preferred Option Project Details
Gross floor area analysis Site Plan Floor Plans (minimum 1:200 scale) Elevations Outline Specification Fire Strategy M&E Design Intent
Site acquisition status Planning Permission Status Statement of Sustainable Development Commitment Quality Assurance and Standards Compliance
AEDET NEAT
Capital Costs and projected cashflows (See FBC1- 8 forms)
- 9 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Inflation calculations Whole Life Cycle Cost Assessments VAT Recovery Strategy Assessments of Estate and Facilities Revenue Implications compared with the base option
Capital Charges Energy Rates Rent Water and sewage Maintenance Security Cleaning Linen and laundry Car Parking Waste disposal Photocopying Telecommunications Portering Postal Services Commissioning De-commissioning
Comparison and reconciliation of functional content and capital costs with OBC
- 10 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
ANNEXURE B Notes on completion of Strategic Outline Case Cost Forms 1. Department Costs should be based on Departmental Cost Allowances (DCAs) where
appropriate and include allowances for essential complimentary accommodation and optional
accommodation and services where details are not available.
2. If Departmental Cost Allowances are not available state the area and rate per m2 used.
3. On-costs must be based on a project specific assessment.
4. The provisional location adjustment alters the average DCA price levels and on-costs for
local market conditions. Refer to the Department of Health: Estates and Facilities Division:
Quarterly Briefing for the latest factor.
5. Fees should include all resource costs associated with the scheme e.g. project sponsorship,
supervisors etc.
6. Note the VAT figures included on Cost Form SOC1 should be those after adjustment for any
reclaimable VAT e.g. VAT on professional fees is normally 100% reclaimable.
7. Non-works costs should include such items as contributions to statutory and local
authorities; building regulations and planning fees; land costs and associated legal fees.
8. If Equipment Costs are to include transferred equipment an assessed abatement
percentage should be identified.
9. Inflation forecasts should be made by the NHS Trust submitting the Business Case and be
agreed with Welsh Health Estates prior to submission of the Business Case.
10. Firm and Variation of Price contracts should allow for projected inflation adjustments up to
and including the date of submission of the Full Business Case together with an assessment of
inflation during the construction period to completion. Equipment cost inflation should also
be included.
- 11 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Insert in Cost Form SOC2 the following categories against each Department:
a. N for new build,
b. A for adaptations for alternative use or
c. C for upgrading existing building retaining current use.
- 12 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Notes on completion of Outline Business Case Cost Forms 1. Department Costs should be based on Departmental Cost Allowances where appropriate
and include allowances for essential complimentary accommodation and optional
accommodation and services where details are not available.
2. Identify separately any proposed adjustment (over or under cost allowances) justifiable in
value for money terms (details to be provided).
3. If Departmental Cost Allowances are not available state the area and rate per m2 used.
4. The provisional location adjustment alters the average DCA price levels and on-costs for
local market conditions. Refer to the Department of Health: Estates and Facilities Division:
Quarterly Briefing for the latest factor.
5. On-costs must be based on project specific assessments/measurements with sufficient
information provided to define the scope of works.
6. In Cost Form OB3 the term “External” refers to the elements external to the department(s)
not just external to the building.
7. Any enabling or preliminary works to prepare the site in advance, for example demolitions;
service diversions; site investigation and other exploratory works, should be identified on
Cost Form OB3 item 5c. Any proposed additional capital expenditure justifiable in terms of
value for money terms should also be identified under this item.
8. Fees should include all resource costs associated with the scheme e.g. project sponsorship,
supervisors etc.
9. Note the VAT figures included on Cost Form OB1 should be those after adjustment for any
reclaimable VAT e.g. VAT on professional fees is normally 100% reclaimable.
10. Non-works costs should be supported by a breakdown and include such items as
contributions to statutory and local authorities; building regulations and planning fees; land
costs and associated legal fees.
11. If Equipment Costs are abated for transferred equipment details should be provided.
12. Inflation forecasts should be made by the NHS Trust submitting the Business Case and be
agreed with Welsh Health Estates prior to submission of the Business Case.
13. Firm and Variation of Price contracts should allow for projected inflation adjustments up to
and including the date of submission of the Full Business Case together with an assessment of
inflation during the construction period to completion. Equipment cost inflation should also
be included.
- 13 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
14. Insert in Cost Form OB2 the following categories against each Department:
a. N for new build,
b. A for adaptations for alternative use or
c. C for upgrading existing building retaining current use.
- 14 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Notes on completion of Full Business Case Cost Forms 1. Cost Form FBC 1 should be completed by the NHS Trust in collaboration with the Trust
Cost Advisor.
2. Cost Form FBC 2 should be completed by the NHS Trust in collaboration with the Trust
Cost Advisor
3. Cost Forms FBC 3, 4/*and 5 should be completed by the Supply Chain Partner.
4. Cost Forms FBC 6,7,8 and 9 should be completed by the NHS Trust in collaboration with
the Trust Cost Advisor and Supply Chain Partner.
5. Fees should include all resource costs associated with the scheme including expenditure to
date.
6. Note the VAT figures should be those after adjustment for any reclaimable VAT e.g. VAT on
professional fees is normally 100% reclaimable.
7. Non-works costs should be supported by a detailed breakdown of sub-elements.
8. Equipment Costs should be based on costed schedules and take account of any transferred
equipment.
9. Inflation forecasts should be made by the NHS Trust submitting the Business Case and be
agreed with Welsh Health Estates prior to submitting the Business Case.
10. Firm and Variation of Price contracts should allow for projected inflation adjustments up to
and including the date of submission of the Full Business Case together with an assessment of
inflation during the construction period to completion. Equipment cost inflation should also
be included.
- 15 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
ANNEXURE C
Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Notes on completion of Project Risk Register
The standard format for the project risk register is attached as Annex A. The owner of the overall project risk register is the Trust appointed Project Manager who will collate and co-ordinate inputs from both the NHS Trust and the Supply Chain Partner (SCP). This format has been agreed with IPAG and is to be used on all projects within the Designed for Life: Building for Wales framework. The project risk register should be reviewed and updated regularly by the whole project team. It should be regarded as a key project control document and should be an agenda item at every project team meeting. The register has been populated with a starting list of risks that have been identified on previous major projects and may be applicable on other schemes. NHS Trusts and SCPs should use the list as a checklist only and develop a project specific register for the intended scheme. Each version of the Risk Register should be given a version number, identify when it was last reviewed and identify the author/collator of the document. Notes are included below to assist in the completion of the Register. The headings match the column headings of the standard format. Risk Number Each risk should be given a unique number which must not be changed during the life of the project. Even if a risk is cleared the number should be retained on the Register. This will allow the history of each risk to be traced by comparison of various versions of the Risk register. Risk Description Each risk should be described briefly. Classification There are two variables of risk – likelihood and impact(consequence). The product of both identifies the seriousness of the risk exposure.
- 16 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Likelihood of occurrence There are 5 categories of likelihood of exposure:
Rare Will occur only in exceptional circumstances
Unlikely Unlikely to occur Possible Reasonable chance of occurring/
may occur occasionally. Likely Likely to occur Almost certain More likely to occur than not
Potential impact There are 5 categories of impact of exposure:
Insignificant No risk to the project. No impact on services. No impact on the environment
Minor Minimal risk to the project. Slight impact on services. Slight impact on the environment
Moderate Some impact on project Some service disruption Moderate impact on the environment
Major Significant impact on the project Cost implications in excess of £250k Major impact on the environment
Catastrophic Stops or delays project. Cost implications in excess of £1m
Risk exposure score The product of likelihood x impact identifies the seriousness of the risk exposure. There are three categories: Low risk 1-5 Medium risk 6-14 High risk 15-25 Risk Owner This will either be the Trust or the SCP. There should be no shared risks. NHS Trusts should consider the extent of their risk exposure and decide whether some risks are retained by them rather than passed over to the SCP.
- 17 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Risk Type Three groupings of risk have been identified: Planning, Design and Construction Operational External Risk Implications Risks can have an impact on generally four areas: Time Cost Quality Operations Some risks may impact on more than one area and may even affect all four areas. Risk Costs Text to be agreed. Funding Implications Identify whether the funding to remedy the risk is either Capital or Revenue. Risk Countermeasures Identify the mitigation measures that need to be put in place and other actions that could be taken if the risk occurs. Actioned By Identify the organisation tasked with implementing the countermeasures and mitigation proposals. Risk Status Cleared Current Future Comments Add any comments to remind, action or explain any special circumstances relating to the risk. Identify any links or interdependencies between risks.
- 18 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Project Risk Register
Trust _________________________________ Project ___________________________________________________
Version: Date last reviewed:
Produced by: A.N.Other, Project Management Ltd. Contact telephone : 02920 123456 Classification Risk
No. Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Risk Implications
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
Legend:
Capital
Revenue
Trust
SCP (Supply Chain Partners)
Likelihood
Rare 1 PDCR (Planning, Design and Construction Risk) Cleared
Unlikely 2 OR (Operational Risk) Current
Possible 3 ER (External Risks) Future
Likely 4
Almost certain 5
Impact
Insignificant 1 Time
Minor 2 Cost
Moderate 3 Quality
Major 4 Operational
Catastrophic 5
Score
Low risk 1-5
Medium risk 6-14
High risk 15-25
- 19 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Project Risk Register
Trust __________________________________ Project ___________________________________________________
Version: Date last reviewed:
Produced by: A.N.Other, Project Management Ltd. Contact telephone : 02920 123456
Classification Risk Implications
Risk No.
Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Time Cost Quality Operational
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
Inability to purchase suitable site Trust PDCR Capital
Site access issues Trust PDCR Capital
Site boundary issues Trust PDCR Capital
Inadequate off site service infrastructure difficulties Trust PDCR Capital
Poor ground conditions SCP PDCR Capital
Contaminated land SCP PDCR Capital
Site service infrastructure difficulties SCP PDCR Capital
Flora and fauna issues Trust PDCR Capital
Archeological issues Trust PDCR Capital
Environmental Impact Assessment difficulties Trust PDCR Capital
Traffic Impact Assessment difficulties Trust PDCR Capital
Failure to achieve Outline Planning Permission Trust PDCR Capital
Delay in achieving Outline Planning Permission Trust PDCR Capital
Poor Trust organisational Trust PDCR Capital
- 20 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Classification Risk Implications
Risk No.
Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Time Cost Quality Operational
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
structure
Limited Trust project resources Trust PDCR Capital
Poor Trust brief Trust PDCR Capital
Trust changing service requirements Trust PDCR Capital
Trust design changes Trust PDCR Capital
Failure to achieve Full Planning Permission Trust PDCR Capital
Onerous Planning Conditions Trust PDCR Capital
Failure to achieve Building Control approval SCP PDCR Capital
Breach of CDM Regulations SCP PDCR Capital
SCP bankruptcy Trust PDCR Capital
Availability of materials SCP PDCR Capital
Availability of labour SCP PDCR Capital
Poor SCP co-ordination SCP PDCR Capital
Poor SCP site supervision SCP PDCR Capital
Poor workmanship SCP PDCR Capital
SCP design changes SCP PDCR Capital
SCM bankruptcy SCP PDCR Capital
Poor SCM performance SCP PDCR Capital
Fire prior to completion SCP PDCR Capital
Changes in VAT rate Trust ER Capital
Failure to achieve anticipated VAT recovery Trust PDCR Capital
- 21 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Classification Risk Implications
Risk No.
Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Time Cost Quality Operational
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
Changes in Building Regulations Trust ER Capital
Rise in tender market above anticipated allowance Trust ER Capital
Adjudication Trust PDCR Capital
Arbitration Trust PDCR Capital
Litigation Trust PDCR Capital
Latent defects Trust OR Capital
Force Majeure Trust ER Capital
Adverse weather conditions SCP PDCR Capital
Engineering commissioning difficulties SCP PDCR Capital
Key Trust personnel changes Trust PDCR Capital
Key SCP personnel changes SCP PDCR Capital
Key SCM personnel changes SCP PDCR Capital
Civil commotion Trust ER Capital
Industrial action affecting SCP SCP ER Capital
Operational commissioning difficulties Trust OR Capital
Problems with site disposal(s) Trust OR Capital
Construction Noise SCP PDCR Capital
Construction Vibration SCP PDCR Capital
Construction Dust SCP PDCR Capital
Presence of asbestos SCP PDCR Capital
Legislative change: NHS specific Trust ER Revenue
- 22 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Classification Risk Implications
Risk No.
Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Time Cost Quality Operational
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
Legislative change: Non-NHS specific Trust ER Capital
Poor Trust Project Management Trust PDCR Capital
Poor Trust Cost Control Trust PDCR Capital
Accidental loss of engineering services to existing facilities SCP PDCR Capital
Delayed support from commissioners Trust PDCR Capital
Delayed approval by WAG Trust PDCR Capital
Failure to agree Target Cost Trust PDCR Capital
Construction buildability issues SCP PDCR Capital
Serious accident on site SCP PDCR Capital
Phasing interface difficulties SCP PDCR Capital
Programme over-run Trust PDCR Capital
Capital Cost over-run Trust PDCR Capital
Incorrect assessment of maintenance costs Trust OR Revenue
Incorrect assessment of projected energy use Trust OR Revenue
Capital Charge calculations inadequate Trust OR Revenue
Revenue cost assumptions underestimated Trust OR Revenue
Site sale receipts not realised Trust OR Capital
Technological change resulting in asset obsolescence Trust OR Revenue
- 23 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Classification Risk Implications
Risk No.
Risk Description
Likelihood of occurrence
Potential impact
Risk exposure score
Risk Owner
Risk Type
Time Cost Quality Operational
Risk Cost
Funding Implication
Risk Counter- measures
Actioned By
Risk Status
Comments
Change arising from technological advancement Trust OR Revenue
Unexpected change in allocation of healthcare resources Trust OR Revenue
Unexpected change in medical technology Trust OR Revenue
Changes in service demand Trust OR Revenue
Inability to deliver service targets Trust OR Revenue
Non-realisation of equipment transfers Trust PDCR Capital
Equipment costs exceed equipment budget Trust PDCR Capital
Poor Gateway Review performance Trust PDCR Capital
Use of innovative design/construction systems SCP PDCR Capital
Changes to catchment population Trust OR Revenue
Determination of Contract by either Party Trust PDCR Capital
- 24 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
ANNEXURE D Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Typical Project Durations (months) - New Build
Construction Value (£m)
Appoint SCs
SOC
RO Approval
Appoint SCs + SCP
OBC
WAG Approval
FBC
WAG Approval
DC & C
Sub- total
OC
Duration to Opening
Project Closure
Total Duration
5 -10 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 24 48.5 1 49.5 9 58.5
10-15 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 24 48.5 1 49.5 9 58.5
15-20 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 27 51.5 2 53.5 9 62.5
20-25 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 27 51.5 2 53.5 9 62.5
25-30 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 27 55.5 3 58.5 9 67.5
30-35 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 30 58.5 3 61.5 9 70.5
35-40 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 30 58.5 4 62.5 9 71.5
40-45 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 12 2 33 62.5 4 66.5 9 75.5
45-50 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 33 64.5 5 69.5 9 78.5
50-55 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 36 67.5 5 72.5 9 81.5
55-60 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 36 67.5 6 73.5 9 82.5
Schemes over £60m to be separately assessed.
Legend: SOC Strategic Outline Case OBC Outline Business Case FBC Full Business Case DC & C Design Completion and Construction OC Operational Commissioning Assumptions: SCs Support Consultants SOC, OBC and FBC periods include Trust obtaining commissioner support. RO Regional Office FBC assumes 70-80% of design completed and market tested. SCP Supply Chain Partner Trust has prepared appropriate briefs prior to commencement of SOC, OBC and FBC stage. WAG Welsh Assembly Government
- 25 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Designed for Life: Building for Wales Typical Project Durations (months) - Refurbishment
Construction Assumed No. Appoint SOC RO Appoint OBC WAG FBC WAG Demolitions/ Fit- out
Sub- total OC Duration to Project Total
Value (£m) of phases SCs Approval SCs + SCP Approval Approval gutting Opening Closure Duration
5 -10 1 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 2 10 36.5 1.5 38 9 47 10-15 1 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 2 13 39.5 1.5 41 9 50 15-20 2 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 4 16 44.5 3 47.5 9 56.5 20-25 2 1 3 2 1.5 4 2 9 2 4 20 48.5 3 51.5 9 60.5 25-30 2 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 4 24 56.5 3 59.5 9 68.5 30-35 3 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 6 27 61.5 4.5 66 9 75 35-40 3 1 3 2 1.5 5 2 12 2 6 30 64.5 4.5 69 9 78 40-45 3 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 12 2 6 34 69.5 4.5 74 9 83 45-50 4 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 8 38 77.5 6 83.5 9 92.5 50-55 4 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 8 40 79.5 6 85.5 9 94.5 55-60 4 1 3 2 1.5 6 2 14 2 8 42 81.5 6 87.5 9 96.5
Schemes over £60m to be separately assessed.
Legend: SOC Strategic Outline Case OBC Outline Business Case FBC Full Business Case DC & C Design Completion and Construction OC Operational Commissioning
Assumptions: SCs Support Consutants SOC, OBC and FBC periods include Trust obtaining commissioner support. RO Regional Office FBC assumes 70-80% of design completed and market tested. SCP Supply Chain Partner Trust has prepared appropriate briefs prior to commencement of SOC, OBC and FBC stage. WAG Welsh Assembly Government Excludes asbestos removal
- 26 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
ANNEXURE E
Suggested Whole Life Cost Process at FBC stage
1. Approval to Outline Business Case.
2. Determine Project Base Construction Cost
3. Confirm buildable area
4. Prepare Notional Cost Plan
5. Carry out Whole Life Cost elemental specification selection
6. Agree Target Cost Plan
7. Cost checking/value engineering
8. Utilise Whole Life Cost principles in component selection
9. Complete Full Business Case
10. Finalise Target Cost
- 27 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Life Costing Exercise
Project :
Element:
Summary of Options
Option Option Capital Costs Revenue Costs Discounted cashflow calculations Comments:
No. Description Maintenance Operational Energy Present Equivalent
Initial Replacement Disposal Costs Costs Costs Value Annual Cost
Cost Cost Cost Annual Recurring Annual Annual
1
2
3
4
5
Notes:
- 28 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Designed for Life: Building for Wales
Whole Life Costing Exercise
Project : Another Hospital Element: 2C Roof Option: 35°Degree Pitched roof comprising Natural Welsh slates on underfelt on battens on counterbattens on sarking felt on marine plywood
boarding on rafters on purlins fixed to steel structural frame with 300mm thick insulation quilt and polyster powder coated steel gutters
Capital Costs Revenue Costs Present Value Calculation Comments:
Year Maintenance Operational Energy Net Discount Present Cumulative
Initial Replacement Disposal Costs Costs Costs Cashflow Factor Value PV
Cost Cost Cost Annual Recurring Annual Annual
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1.0000 0 0
1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.9662 0 0
2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.9335 0 0
3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.9019 0 0
4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.8714 0 0
5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.8420 0 0
6 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.8135 0 0
7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.7860 0 0
8 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.7594 0 0
9 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.7337 0 0
10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.7089 0 0
11 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.6849 0 0
12 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.6618 0 0
13 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.6394 0 0
- 29 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Capital Costs Revenue Costs Present Value Calculation Comments:
Year Maintenance Operational Energy Net Discount Present Cumulative
Initial Replacement Disposal Costs Costs Costs Cashflow Factor Value PV
Cost Cost Cost Annual Recurring Annual Annual
14 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.6178 0 0
15 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5969 0 0
16 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5767 0 0
17 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5572 0 0
18 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5384 0 0
19 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5202 0 0
20 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.5026 0 0
21 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4856 0 0
22 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4692 0 0
23 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4533 0 0
24 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4380 0 0
25 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4231 0 0
26 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4088 0 0
27 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3950 0 0
28 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3817 0 0
29 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3687 0 0
30 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3563 0 0
31 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.4000 0 0
32 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3883 0 0
33 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3770 0 0
34 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3660 0 0
- 30 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Capital Costs Revenue Costs Present Value Calculation Comments:
Year Maintenance Operational Energy Net Discount Present Cumulative
Initial Replacement Disposal Costs Costs Costs Cashflow Factor Value PV
Cost Cost Cost Annual Recurring Annual Annual
35 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3554 0 0
36 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3450 0 0
37 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3350 0 0
38 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3252 0 0
39 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3158 0 0
40 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.3066 0 0
41 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2976 0 0
42 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2890 0 0
43 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2805 0 0
44 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2724 0 0
45 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2644 0 0
46 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2567 0 0
47 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2493 0 0
48 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2420 0 0
49 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2350 0 0
50 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2281 0 0
51 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2215 0 0
52 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2150 0 0
53 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2088 0 0
54 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.2027 0 0
55 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.1968 0 0
- 31 - K:\FPMI\Information Services\PDF\DesignedforLife\BusinessCases\EstatesContentofBusinessCasesV3.doc
Capital Costs Revenue Costs Present Value Calculation Comments:
Year Maintenance Operational Energy Net Discount Present Cumulative
Initial Replacement Disposal Costs Costs Costs Cashflow Factor Value PV
Cost Cost Cost Annual Recurring Annual Annual
56 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.1910 0 0
57 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.1855 0 0
58 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.1801 0 0
59 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0.1748 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
EAC factor (60 years) 27.2975
Equivalent Annual Cost 0
Note: Costs exclude inflation and VAT Red=3.5% Blue=3%
Notes: