5/8/2012
1
Friending Your Program and Challenges
Joel S. Mayer, Esq., CCEPChief Compliance OfficerNJ Higher Education Student Assistance Authority
Strengthen compliance programs by ‘listening out of the box’
Trick or Tweet! Finding hidden treasure in the tools and mentality of social media
Promote positive interaction with regulators, prosecutors, investigators and monitors to reduce the likelihood or severity of findings
2
5/8/2012
2
You have the right to an honest answer
“I have no … I don’t know” (but I’ll find out)
You have the right to interrupt, heckle, protest (non-violently), and disagree
You have the absolute right to pester me for additional or more complete information after the session and after the conference
3
INCREASED PRESSURES OR INCENTIVES TO INCREASE BUSINESS (ENROLMENT)
+AGGRESSIVE REGULATORY, INVESTIGATIVE,
PROSECUTORIAL, CONGRESSIONAL AND PUBLIC SCRUTINY
=COMLPLIANCE CHALLENGES
4
5/8/2012
3
What you do know may hurt you but what you don’t know may kill you
Your most valuable information is:AccurateTimelyVoluntaryAttributableActionable
5
Some Key Questions:
1. What did you know and when did you know it?2. Who knew what and when did they know it?3. What did you do with the information?4. What did they do with the information?5. Why did you take/not take specific actions
6. Why didn’t you know?
6
5/8/2012
4
Traditional or Standard tools:
Anonymous Hotlineso Often Mandatoryo Effective but with limitations
Auditing & Monitoring System ReportsComplaint Review/Management
All useful and necessary but not necessarily effective at supplying complete and timely information
7
Increasingly aggressive and hostile regulatory environment requires a fresh look at compliance programs, structures and
methods for acquiring actionable information
Standard methods no longer practical (increasing staff) or as effective as they need to be (additional policies & procedures)
Today’s managers/supervisors were in the trenches during compliance’s Medieval Age resulting in “tone at the middle”
challenges.
8
5/8/2012
5
9
Medieval Compliance Program
Today’s hostile regulatory environment in the social media vortex of instant, ongoing, abundant and often ill-informed public
commentary and criticism demands compliance programs and information gathering methods that are:
DYNAMIC FLEXIBLE AGILE PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY SOCIAL (MEDIA SAVVY)
10
5/8/2012
6
11
Ps (pre script): Does your institution have social media policies. If so, how are they enforced?
Benefits of Social Media:
◦ Real time information◦ Unfiltered information◦ Diverse contributors◦ Feedback from internal & external participants◦ Wiretap Orders or Search Warrants not required
Take advantage of this free, unfiltered and potentially abundant river of information (confessions, observations, criticisms & compliments)
12
5/8/2012
7
Twitter◦ Anonymous viewing/monitoring (you can follow anyone –
usually)◦ Most users aren’t anonymous ◦ You can engage if you choose or remain in ‘surveillance
mode’◦ “Tickling The Wire”◦ Free
Facebook◦ Greater wealth of information◦ Less anonymity◦ Following (“friending”) requires permission Some info available on public wall
13
14
Opening in Google Chrome provides additional search options
5/8/2012
8
a.k.a. “Compliance’s Alliances”
A compliance program is most effective when it has access to an abundance of actionable information and a structure
capable of processing and responding to it swiftly, consistently and transparently.
GOAL: Improve Communication
SOLUTION: Improve Communication
15
The best way to respond to an enforcement inquiry/action is to prevent them by getting there first and the best way to get there first is through access to actionable information gained through
internal and external partnerships
CAVEAT: Reporting structures need to compliment the information network
Inherent conflicts are presented where the CCO reports to GC or University Counsel
16
5/8/2012
9
All successful partnerships on built on trust
Partnerships built on necessity will be dysfunctional at best and ineffective at worst
without a fundamentally trusting basis
NOBEL Laureate Conundrum:The smartest people in your institution are probably your most
stubborn 5 year olds
17
We spend so much time auditing, monitoring, analyzing, and training that we’ve forgotten
how to listen
More importantly, we’ve forgotten WHY we listen
The best listeners build the strongest trust and get the best information
18
5/8/2012
10
1. Listen
2. Empathize
3. Accommodate
4. Respect
5. Articulate
19
1. Listen◦ Verbal and non-verbal communication◦ Comfortable environment (off site?)◦ Individual but occasional larger groups
2. Empathize◦ “I get that” = “I don’t care” or “not my problem”
3. Accommodate◦ Drill down to underlying issue◦ Identify common ground through creativity
4. Respect◦ Silence the cell phone◦ Title neutral
5. Articulate◦ Clear explanation of issue/project/concern/solution◦ Mind your ‘x’, ‘WHY’s & ‘z’s
20
5/8/2012
11
Effective use of the LEARA Model will add credibility to the CCO and compliance staff
Credibility leads to trust which leads to:
Stronger partnerships Better actionable information Multi-level buy-in More dynamic, proactive compliance program
21
Compliance Calculus dictates that regulatory/congressional scrutiny,
investigations and enforcement actions will increase…
TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THE OPPORTUNITY
22
5/8/2012
12
Where’s the Devil?
Not necessarily in the details (that’s where the angels are probably hiding)
Because the initial focus of any complaint, inquiry or investigation leading to an enforcement action will be directed at the appearance of impropriety (conflict of
interest/data privacy breach), details which might otherwise prove the absence of impropriety may become irrelevant or
may be too costly to prove
23
Calculus for Regulators & Prosecutors 101:o Delay = Suspiciono Suspicion = Negative Perception
Negative perception generates additional attention and the prospect of a wider inquiry
Avoid negative perception by encouraging transparency and showing that you and the institution have nothing to hideo What they see through is less likely to hurt you
24
5/8/2012
13
Don’t confuse respect with intimidationWelcome them with open arm (and open
books) Learn how they take their coffeeMake yourself indispensible Show pride in your work, your integrity, your
program and the work of your staff Beware of lawyers – be very aware of
perception
25
Consumer Finance Protection Bureau (CFPB)
Director, Richard Cordray, Esq.◦ Made his mark as a career prosecutor investigating and prosecuting financial
institutions for unfair/deceptive practices on behalf of borrowers Created by Dodd-Frank Objectives◦ Conduct rule-making, supervision, and enforcement for Federal consumer
financial protection laws◦ Restrict unfair, deceptive, or abusive acts or practices◦ Take consumer complaints◦ Promote financial education◦ Research consumer behavior◦ Monitor financial markets for new risks to consumers◦ Enforce laws that outlaw discrimination and other unfair treatment in
consumer finance
26
5/8/2012
14
Why should we care?
◦ Student Loan Debt just topped $1 Billion◦ Largest consumer debt category◦ Tremendous public scrutiny on Higher Ed◦ Congressional & State AG Investigations For-Profit Schools Recruiting/Lending Practices (Title IV Compliance)
◦ Newest kids on the block Turf (justify agency, make a big splash) Aggressive/Subjective/Unpredictable
27
Developing a strong focus upon the Higher Education space◦ www.consumerfinance.gov◦ www.consumerfinance.gov/students/knowbeforeyouowe
(student loan cost calculator)◦ Encourages whistleblower complaints◦ Beta testing additional student-facing applications to
facilitate direct cost comparisons between institutions and to solicit student complaints Enforcement activity Inform future rulemaking and regulations
◦ CFPB Ombuds Office
28
5/8/2012
15
BENEFITS OF AN INQUIRY OR INVESTIGATION
Presence of regulators, investigators and prosecutors reminds everyone of the importance of compliance efforts
Permits compliance professionals to focus on compliance and improve programs
Encourages investment in compliance related systems, consulting services and third party solutions
Enhances the value of dedicated compliance professionals in the eyes of institutional leadership
Encourages the development of valuable contacts Can provide a reputational boost to your institution
29
30