-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
1 OF 51
DATE REV. PREPARED BY CHECKED BY APPROVED BY 09-04-2014 01 FZL YLZ MHL
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
2 OF 51
TABLE OF CONTENT 1.0 GENERAL ............................................................................................................................ 3 1.1 Scope ................................................................................................................................... 3 1.2 Code, Standards and References......................................................................................... 3 1.3 Modelling Of Structures ........................................................................................................ 3 1.3 Strength of Materials ............................................................................................................ 4 2.0 FEA ANALYSIS ................................................................................................................... 6 2.1 Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 6 2.2 Design Data ......................................................................................................................... 6 2.2.1 Operating Condition .................................................................................................................... 7 2.2.2 Survival Condition ..................................................................................................................... 18 2.2.3 Extreme Condition .................................................................................................................... 29 3.0 FEA RESULTS .................................................................................................................. 40 3.1 Plate Centre Stresses Summary .................................................................................................. 40 3.2 Deflection Plot ............................................................................................................................... 43
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
3 OF 51
1.0 GENERAL 1.1 SCOPE
This document represents the FEA Analysis for Hull MEG Storage Tank of Malikai EPC TLP Project.
1.2 CODE, STANDARDS AND REFERENCES
1 Roarks Formula of Stresses and Strain, 8th Edition 2011. 2 AISC-ASD 9th Edition 1989, Manual of Steel Construction Allowable Stress Design. 3 API RP 2A, Recommended Practice for Planning, Designing and Construction Fixed Offshore Platform - WSD 4 DEP 37.81.10.31-Gen, Structural Steel Design of Small Deepwater Offshore Skids, Facility Packages, and Subsea Sleds Manifolds. 5 Topsides General Design Condition, Environmental and Utility Data, MLK-011-300-CS-1980-0001 6 Topsides Structural Design Basis, MLK-011-300-CS-7880-0001 7 Hull Storage Tanks Technical Specification, MLK-011-200-CX-7771-0001 8 Datasheet for MEG Hull Storage Tank, MLK-011-200-CX-2180-0002
1.3 MODELLING OF STRUCTURES
The analysis is based on a three dimensional (3D) model generated by ANSYS. The model is further analysed by general packages FEA program ANSYS. The modelling procedures, boundary conditions and loading are described in this section together with detail results obtained from the FEA analysis.
The completed Tank Structure T-5601A/B arrangement and dimension based on the sketch drawing attached are used to generate the detailed FEA model.
The element type used is 3D tetrahedral with mid side node. The complete model is meshed with local refinement to achieve results with minimum error. The aspect ratio is maintained below 0.272. The generated of the meshing is shown in Figure 2.2.
The bottom beam support level of tank are considered fully restraint (fixed support). For the support oval collar are considered displacement support on the support at top of the deck structure. ANSYS automatically calculates the self-weight of the modelled structure.
The complete plots of loading and boundary condition are presented in Section 2.3.
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
4 OF 51
1.3 STRENGTH OF MATERIALS
Structural Materials: a) ASTM A36 or equivalent
1. Yield Strength, Fy = 250 MPa
2. Tensile Strength, Fu = 400 MPa.
3. Modulus of Elastic, E = 205 kN/m2
4. Poissons Ratio = 0.3
5. Density = 7850kg/m3
(Tank bottom beam W24x62)
b) SA 240 or equivalent
1. Yield Strength, Fy = 170 MPa
2. Tensile Strength, Fu = 485 MPa.
3. Modulus of Elastic, E = 197 kN/m2
4. Poissons Ratio = 0.3
5. Density = 8030kg/m3
Following are the material using
Table 1.3: Material for Structure Beam/Plate
Item Description Material
1 W24X62 ASTM A36
2 WALL PLATE 12MM THK SA 240 SS 316L
3 TOP OVAL PLATE 30MM THK SA 240 SS 316L
4 WALL OVAL PLATE 24MM THK SA 240 SS 316L
5 OVAL SUPPORT PLATE 25MM THK SA 240 SS 316L
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
5 OF 51
Figure 1.3: Modelling for Tank T-5601 Structural Tank
1
2
3
4
5
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
6 OF 51
2.0 FEA ANALYSIS 2.1 INTRODUCTION
The FEA analysis has considered the Hull MEG Storage Tank in its operational condition. The design has also accounted for the critical loading imposed onto the platform during operation in maximum and minimum loading conditions.
The dead weight, content load, nozzle load and displacement loads were considered. Following are the condition load to be consideration:
1) Operating Condition 2) Survival Condition 3) Extreme Condition
2.2 DESIGN DATA
(1) Reference: Global Performance Design Data for Topside Design
MLK-011-200-CX-1380-0108/5886-200-CN-3832-108 Rev 02A
(2) Summary of Acceleration at Point TS_SW : X = -33.91 m, Y = -33.91 m, Z = -35.25 m
0 Degree Heading
Heave Horizontal
Operating 0.248 0.852
Extreme 0.181 1.130
Survival 0.247 1.502
45 Degree Heading
Heave Horizontal
Operating 0.264 0.81
Extreme 0.237 1.013
Survival 0.288 1.342
90 Degree Heading
Heave Horizontal
Operating 0.247 0.853
Extreme 0.179 1.132
Survival 0.248 1.504
Acc (ms-2
)
Condition
Condition
Acc (ms-2
)
Condition
Acc (ms-2
)
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
7 OF 51
2.2.1 OPERATING CONDITION
MEG Tank (Operating Condition)
1) Mass Calculation
Tank Liquid Mass
Volumn A
L = 7.00 m
B = 4.00 m
H = 5.00 m
N = 1.65 m
Density 1092 kg /m3
Mass = 152880 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.50 m
Volumn B (Not filled) 0 kg
Tank Structure Mass 34950 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.66 m
Pump Mass 2000 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 3.325 m
Total Mass 189830 kg
1862.232 kN
Total Mass C.O.G = 2.54 m
Volumn A
Volumn B
1.6
5 m
5.0
m
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
8 OF 51
2) TOC level Nozzle Reaction Load Calculation
Horizontal :
Fh acc = 61.8 kN or 30.9 kN per nozzle
Vertical:
Fv acc (Pump & Tank Structure)= 3.9 kN
TOC Pressure Load Contributary Area = 14.0 m2
Fv TOC Pressure Load 29.7 kPa = 70 kN (Nominal 5kPa)
Total Fv = 73.9 kN or 37.0 kN per nozzle
Bending Moment = 97.0 kN m or 48.5 kNm per nozzle
3) Relative Deflection Between TOC and Deck 3 (from FE Analysis)
Horizontal = 3.5 mm from global strength analysis
Vertical = 5 mm from local model with full
tank liquid but TOC with zero pressure load
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
9 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1a: Structural tank Self weight
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
10 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1b: Tank Liquid Mass
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
11 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1c: Horizontal Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
12 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1d: Vertical Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
13 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1e: Moment Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
14 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1f: Vertical Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
15 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1g: Horizontal Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
16 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1h: Bottom Fixed Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
17 OF 51
Figure 2.2.1j: Loading and Boundary condition
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
18 OF 51
2.2.2 SURVIVAL CONDITION
MEG Tank (Survival Condition)
1) Mass Calculation
Tank Liquid Mass
Volumn A
L = 7.00 m
B = 4.00 m
H = 5.00 m
N = 1.65 m
Density 1092 kg /m3
Mass = 152880 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.50 m
Volumn B (Not filled) 0 kg
Tank Structure Mass 34950 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.66 m
Pump Mass 2000 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 3.325 m
Total Mass 189830 kg
1862.232
Total Mass C.O.G = 2.54 m
Volumn A
Volumn B
1.6
5 m
5.0
m
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
19 OF 51
2) TOC level Nozzle Reaction Load Calculation
Horizontal :
Fh acc = 109.0 kN or 54.5 kN per nozzle
Vertical:
Fv acc (Pump & Tank Structure)= 4.6 kN
TOC Pressure Load Contributary Area = 14.0 m2
Fv TOC Pressure Load 29.7 kPa = 415.8 kN (29.7kPa is based on minimum air
gap water head above TOC in survival case)
Total Fv = 420.4 kN or 210.2 kN per nozzle
Bending Moment = 171.0 kN m or 85.5 kNm per nozzle
3) Relative Deflection Between TOC and Deck 3 (from FE Analysis)
Horizontal = 5 mm from global strength analysis
Vertical = 5 mm from local model with full tank liquid
but TOC with zero pressure load
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
20 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2a: Structural tank Self weight
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
21 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2b: Tank Liquid Mass
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
22 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2c: Horizontal Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
23 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2d: Vertical Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
24 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2e: Moment Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
25 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2f: Vertical Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
26 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2g: Horizontal Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
27 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2h: Bottom Fixed Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
28 OF 51
Figure 2.2.2j: Loading and Boundary condition
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
29 OF 51
2.2.3 EXTREME CONDITION
MEG Tank (Extreme Condition)
1) Mass Calculation
Tank Liquid Mass
Volumn A
L = 7.00 m
B = 4.00 m
H = 5.00 m
N = 1.65 m
Density 1092 kg /m3
Mass = 152880 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.50 m
Volumn B (Not filled) 0 kg
Tank Structure Mass 34950 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 2.66 m
Pump Mass 2000 kg
Vertical C.O.G from tank bottom = 3.325 m
Total Mass 189830 kg
1862.232 kN
Total Mass C.O.G = 2.54 m
Volumn A
Volumn B
1.6
5 m
5.0
m
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
30 OF 51
2) TOC level Nozzle Reaction Load Calculation
Horizontal :
Fh acc = 82.0 kN or 41.0 kN per nozzle
Vertical:
Fv acc (Pump & Tank Structure)= 2.9 kN
TOC Pressure Load Contributary Area = 14.0 m2
Fv TOC Pressure Load 29.7 kPa = 70 kN (Nominal 5 kPa)
Total Fv = 72.9 kN or 36.4 kN per nozzle
Bending Moment = 128.7 kN m or 64.4 kNm per nozzle
3) Relative Deflection Between TOC and Deck 3 (from FE Analysis)
Horizontal = 4 mm from global strength analysis
Vertical = 5 mm from local model with full tank liquid
but TOC with zero pressure load
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
31 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3a: Structural tank Self weight
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
32 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3b: Tank Liquid Mass
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
33 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3c: Horizontal Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
34 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3d: Vertical Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
35 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3e: Moment Nozzle Reaction
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
36 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3f: Vertical Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
37 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3g: Horizontal Displacement at Oval Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
38 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3h: Bottom Fixed Support
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
39 OF 51
Figure 2.2.3j: Loading and Boundary condition
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
40 OF 51
3.0 FEA RESULTS 3.1 PLATE CENTRE STRESSES SUMMARY
For detailed FE analysis the allowable stress based on the Von Misses criteria [1].
Figure 3.1a: Von Misses Plot for Operating Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
41 OF 51
Figure 3.1b: Von Misses Plot for Survival Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
42 OF 51
Figure 3.1c: Von Misses Plot for Extreme Cases
Allowable Strength for SA240 SS316L (Table 2A: ASME Stress Table) at Temperature 70C = 113 MPa----OK Allowable Strength for ASTM A36 (Table 2A: ASME Stress Table) at Temperature 70C = 134.03 MPa----OK
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
43 OF 51
3.2 DEFLECTION PLOT
Figure 3.2a: Deflection Plot Dir-X for Operating Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
44 OF 51
Figure 3.2b: Deflection Plot Dir-Y for Operating Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
45 OF 51
Figure 3.2c: Deflection Plot Dir-Z for Operating Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
46 OF 51
Figure 3.2d: Deflection Plot Dir-X for Survival Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
47 OF 51
Figure 3.2e: Deflection Plot Dir-Y for Survival Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
48 OF 51
Figure 3.2f: Deflection Plot Dir-Z for Survival Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
49 OF 51
Figure 3.2g: Deflection Plot Dir-X for Extreme Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
50 OF 51
Figure 3.2h: Deflection Plot Dir-Y for Extreme Cases
-
FEA ANALYSIS FOR HULL MEG STORAGE TANK T-5601A/B REV 01
51 OF 51
Figure 3.2j: Deflection Plot Dir-Z for Extreme Cases