Fermilab Proton Driver Project
Weiren Chou for Bill FosterFermilab, U.S.A.
October 20, 2004
Presentation at the Proton Driver SessionICFA-HB2004, Bensheim, Germany, Oct 18-22, 2004
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 2
Introduction
Neutrino Superbeam/Proton Driver is one of 28 new facilities on the DOE’s 20-year strategic plan.
Fermilab Long Range Planning Committee has recommended the proton driver as one of two candidates for a future construction project at Fermilab. (LC is the other one.)
Early this year Fermilab director issued a charge to Bill Foster and Steve Geer to prepare a CD0 document for establishing mission needs for a proton driver.
There were two options considered: 8 GeV RCS or 8 GeV sc rf linac. The ICFA decision to choose sc rf technology for a future ILC gave a big
boost to the linac option. Fermilab director recent announced to go for the linac option. R&D for LC and proton driver will go in parallel. The core part of this R&D is to establish a Superconducting rf Module
Test Facility (SMTF) at Fermilab. This will be a multi-institution collaboration project. A LOI is being circulated. A number of instituion have signed up.
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 3
Introduction (cont…)
The Proton Driver project is defined as:
“a complete replacement of our current 400 MeV linac and 8 GeV Booster, accompanied by Main Injector upgrades.”
Beam power spec: 8 GeV Proton Driver: 0.5 MW
8–120 GeV upgraded Main Injector: 2 MW
Total beam power: 2.5 MW
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 4
Proton Driver Study II (Fermilab-TM-2169)
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 5
8 GeV Linac Parameters
Energy GeV 8
Particle Type H, e
Rep. Rate Hz 10
Active Length m 671
Beam Current mA 25
Pulse Length ms 1
Beam Intensity P / pulse 1.5E+14
P/hour 5.4E+18
Linac Beam Power MW avg. 2
MW peak 200
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 6
Wide Range of Applications
~ 700m Active Length8 GeV Linac
X-RAY FEL LAB
Long-Pulse Spallation Source
8 GeVneutrino
MainInjector@2 MW
Anti-Proton
SY-120Fixed-Target
Neutrino“Super- Beams”
NUMI
Off- Axis
& Neutrino Target
Neutrinosto “Homestake”
Short Baseline Detector Array
Target and Muon Cooling Channel
Bunching Ring
RecirculatingLinac for Neutrino Factory
VLHC at Fermilab
Damping Ringsfor TESLA @ FNALWith 8 GeV e+ Preacc.
1% LC Systems Test
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 7
Wide Range Choice of MI Beam Energy
Main Injector: 120 GeV, 0.67 Hz Cycle, 2.0 MW Beam PowerLinac Protons: 8 GeV, 4.67 Hz Cycle, 0.93 MW Beam Power Linac Electrons: 8 GeV, 4.67 Hz Cycle, 0.93 MW Beam Power
8 GeV Linac Cycles 1.5E14 per Pulse at 10Hz
Main Injector Energy
H-Injection
8 GeVProtons
8 GeVElectrons
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (sec)
MI Energy
H- Injection
8 GeV Protons
Electrons
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 8
Wide Range Choice of MI Beam Energy (cont…)
Main Injector: 40 GeV, 2.0 Hz Cycle, 2.0 MW Beam PowerLinac Protons: 8 GeV, 4.0 Hz Cycle, 0.8 MW Beam Power Linac Electrons: 8 GeV, 4.0 Hz Cycle, 0.8 MW Beam Power
8 GeV Linac Cycles 1.5E14 per Pulse at 10Hz
Main Injector Energy
H-Injection
8 GeVProtons
8 GeVElectrons
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (sec)
MI Energy
H- Injection
8 GeV Protons
Electrons
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 9
8 GeV Linac Baseline 2 MW
D T L 1D T L 2D T L 3D T L 4D T L 5D T L 6R F QR F Q
Modulator Modulator
(7 total) 402.5 MHzSNS Klystrons 2.5 MW
H -
B=0.47 B=0.47 B=0.61 B=0.61 B=0.61 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81
Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator
12 cavites/ Klystron 8 cavites/ Klystron
805 MHz SNS Klystrons 5 MW
Warm CopperDrift Tube Linac402.5 MHz0 - 87 MeV
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator Modulator Modulator
12 cavites/ Klystron
1207 MHz Beta=1
41 Klystrons (3 types) 31 Modulators 20 MW ea. 7 Warm Linac Loads 48 Cryomodules384 Superconducting Cavities
8 GeV 2 MW LINAC
Superconducting "SNS" Linac805 MHz0.087 - 1.2 GeV
"TESLA" LINAC 24 Klystrons288 cavites in 36 Cryomodules
10 Klystrons96 cavites in 12 Cryomodules
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 10
0.5 MW with TESLA Frequencies & SCRF F.E.
R F QR F Q
Modulator
H -
B=0.47 B=0.47 B=0.61 B=0.61 B=0.61 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81 B=0.81
Modulator
"Pulsed RIA" SCRF Linac 325 MHz 0 - 120 MeV
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator
12 Klystrons (2 types) 11 Modulators 20 MW ea. 1 Warm Linac Load 54 Cryomodules~550 Superconducting Cavities
8 GeV 0.5 MW LINAC
8 Klystrons288 cavites in 36 Cryomodules
2 Klystrons96 cavites in 12 Cryomodules
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator
B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1B e t a = 1
Modulator Modulator
Modulator
48 cavites/ Klystron
36 cavites/ Klystron
TESLA Klystrons1300 MHz 10 MW
"Squeezed TESLA" Superconducting Linac1300 MHz 0.087 - 1.2 GeV
"TESLA" LINAC 1300 MHz Beta=1
S S RS S RS S RD S RD S RD S R
Multi-Cavity Fanout at 10-20kW/cavityPhase & Amplitude Adjust via Fast Ferrite Tuners
TESLA Klystrons1300 MHz 10 MW
325 MHz Klystrons1.5 MW
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 11
RF Fanout
CIRCULATOR/ ISOLATOR
Magic Tee
FerriteLoaded Stub
CAVITYBEAM
1/8 Power Split (9.03 dB)
DIRECTIONAL COUPLER
1/7 Power Split (8.45 dB)
1/6 Power Split (7.78 dB)
1/5 Power Split (6.99 dB)
1/4 Power Split (6.02 dB)
1/3 Power Split (4.77 dB)
1/2 Power Split (3.01 dB)
E-H TUNER
KLYSTRON
35 footwaveguidefrom galleryto tunnel
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 12
RF Fanout at Each Cavity
CIRCULATOR/ ISOLATOR
Magic Tee
FerriteLoaded Stub
CAVITYBEAM
DIRECTIONAL COUPLER
E-H TUNER
KLYSTRON
35 footwaveguidefrom galleryto tunnel
CIRCULATOR / ISOLATOR - Passes RF power forward towards cavity - Diverts reflected power to water cooled load
KLYSTRON - RF Power Source - Located in Gallery above tunnel - Each Klystron Feeds 8-16 Cavities
DIRECTIONAL COUPLER - Picks of a fixed amount of RF power at each station - Passes remaining power downstream to other cavities
E-H TUNER - Provides Phase and Amplitude Control for Cavities - Biased Ferrite Provides Electronic Control
SUPERCONDUCTING RF CAVITY - Couples RF Power to Beam
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 13
ELECTRONICALLY ADJUSTABLEE-H TUNER
Magic Tee
MICROWAVE INPUT POWER from Klystron and Circulator
E-HTUNER
Reflected Power(absorbed by circulator)
ATTENUATED OUTPUT TO CAVITY
ELECTRONIC TUNINGWITH BIASED FERRITE
Bias Coil
FerriteLoadedStub
FERRITE LOADED SHORTED STUBSCHANGE ELECTRICAL LENGTH DEPENDING ON DC MAGNETIC BIAS.
TWO COILS PROVIDE INDEPENDENTPHASE AND AMPLITUDE CONTROL OF CAVITIES
Attractive Price Quote from AFT
(<< Klystron)
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 14
Ferrite Phase Shifter High-Power Test
Stand
805 MHz Klystron 12 MW x 100usec
(need: 0.5 MW x 1 msec)
First goal: See if existing YIG tuner
functions at 500kW. (yes!)
Ultimate Goal:0.2 dB loss for360 deg. phase shiftin 100~500usec.Door-knob
Transition
YIG FerritePhase Shifter
Dry Load
FerriteBias
Supply
HybridTee
12 MW Klystron
A. Moretti, D. Wildman, N. Solyak, Y. Terechkine
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 15
Main Injector Upgrade to 2 MW
Present Upgrade
Injection kinetic energy (GeV) 8 8
Extraction kinetic energy (GeV) 120 8 - 120
Protons per MI cycle 3 1013 1.5 1014
Cycle time at 120 GeV (s) 1.867 1.533
Beam power (MW) 0.3 1.9
• Increase beam intensity by a factor of 5
• Reduce cycle time by 20%
• Increase beam power by a factor of 6
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 16
Technical Systems Upgrade
RF: major upgrade. Need a second power amplifier for each cavity and more cavities; also work on a new cavity design.
Power supply: moderate upgrade Magnet: ok Cooling capacity: ok for magnet, but need to be doubled for RF Gamma-t jump system: new Large aperture quadrupoles: new Shielding: ok Collimation system: new Passive damper and active feedback: new or moderate upgrade Kickers: moderate upgrade Abort system: moderate upgrade NuMI beamline: moderate upgrade
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 17
Dual PA for MI RF Cavity
To be replaced by a 2nd PA
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 18
New RF Design
Z0 = 20 , R= 100 k, Q = 4000, R/Q = 25 , V = 240 kV
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 19
Large Aperture Quadrupole
Lamination design 3-D calculation
Fabricating 9 magnets, 7 to be installed in the MI in 2005
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 20
Issues Concerning 8 GeV H Ions
OUTLINE 1. Introduction 2. Atomic Physics of 8 GeV H ions
2.1. General physics of H ions 2.2. Blackbody radiation stripping 2.3. Magnetic field stripping 2.4. Residual gas stripping 2.5. Lifetime of Stark states of hydrogen atoms 2.6. Population of Stark states of hydrogen atoms
3. Foil Physics 3.1. Stripping efficiency 3.2. Multiple Coulomb scattering 3.3. Large angle Coulomb scattering 3.4. Energy deposition and heating analysis (MARS) 3.5. Heating and stress analysis (ANSYS) 3.6. Radiation activation
4. Beam Physics of an 8 GeV H transport line 4.1. Collimation 4.2. Energy jitter correction 4.3. Radiation activation
5. Summary
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 21
Blackbody Radiation Stripping
• At 8 GeV, thermal photons emitted from the room temperature beam pipe would cause a loss of ~ 0.53 × 106 m1 sec1
• Or about 0.53 × 108 particles m1 sec1
• High radiation activation on the beam pipe is a serious concern
Photodetachment of H- Ions from Blackbody Radiation (@ 300 K)
1.00E-11
1.00E-10
1.00E-09
1.00E-08
1.00E-07
1.00E-06
1.00E-05
0 10 20 30 40 50
H- ion kinetic energy (GeV)
Det
ach
men
t ra
te (
1/m
)
Hill-Bryant method
8 GeV
1 GeV
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 22
Foil Stripping Efficiency Measurements
Webber & Hojvat, 1979
Fermilab linac, 200 MeV
Gulley et al., 1996
LANL linac, 800 MeV
11.2% H0
0.4% H0H0
H-
H+H+
H-
H0
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 23
Foil Stripping Efficiency Calculation
H(0) Yield at Different Energies
0.000
0.100
0.200
0.300
0.400
0.500
0.600
0 100 200 300 400 500 600
Foil Thickness (microgram/cm^2)
H(0
) Y
ield
8 GeV
800 MeV (Gulley et al.)
400 MeV
200 MeV (W&H)
200 MeV (fit to Gulley)
0.5% H0
Chou for Foster ICFA-HB2004 Workshop, October 20, 2004 24
Summary
Proton driver and ILC are two candidates for a future construction project at Fermilab
The sc linac design is chosen. This has the major advantage of a large overlap in R&D for both candidates, e.g., SMTF
A key R&D item is the fast phase shifter
A comprehensive understanding of the transport and stripping of 8 GeV H ions is another high priority item
The lab has decided to work towards the goal of getting DOE’s CD0 approval next year.
Questions?