Arab Republic of Egypt Ministry of Electricity and Energy
Egyptian Electricity Holding Company Cairo Electricity Production Company
GIZA NORTH 2 X 750 MWe GAS-FIRED COMBINED CYCLE POWER PROJECT
Environmental and Social Impact Assessment
ANNEXES Consultation Activities &
Other Annexes
(Volume- III)
January 2010
fJLE.COP-Y. Prepared by:
Engineering Consultants Group (ECG) Bldg. 2, Block 10, EI-Safarat District
Nasr City 11765, Cairo, Egypt. P.O.Box: 1167. Cairo 11511, Egypt.
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
Pub
lic D
iscl
osur
e A
utho
rized
ENGI;'<!lEERIl\G CONSULTANTS GROUP
Annex A
RECORDS OF CONSULTATIONS UNDERTAKEN BY ECG AND CEPC I EEHC
-----""-"-""-""-"-""-""-
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- A - Page I of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
RECORDS OF CONSULTATIONS
The following Table provides a record of consultations undertaken during September - November 2009, in conjunction with project preparation and completion of environmental documentation for preparing the EIA study report and local permitting.
Organization
Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
• Chairman
• Executive Board Member, Planning, Studies and Engineering
• Sector Head, Steam Power Plant Projects
• Sector Head, Gas Power Plant Projects
• Counsellor for Environmental Management and Studies
• Sector Head, Design & Research
• Consultant, Power System Design
• Sector Head, Network Studies
• General Director, Power Plant Studies
Cairo Electricity Production Company (CEPC)
• Chairman
• Head of Cairo Power Generating Sectors
• Sector Chief of Cairo West Power Plant Project
• Head of Sector for Power Plants Technical Affairs
• Head of Sector, EI-Tebbin Power Plant Project
• Head of Chemistry Sector
• General Director for Technical Affairs
• Head of Sector, Shoubrah EI-Kheima Power Plant
• General Director for Industrial Safety
• General Director for Health & Safety
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Name
- Dr. Mohamed M. Awad - Dr. Kamel Yassin
- Eng. Ahmed Salah - Eng. Mohamed Abdel Bary - Eng. Maher Aziz
- Dr. Eng. Fathi Tahoun - Dr. Eng. Ms. Nahed Haggi - Eng. Abdel Rahim Ahmed Helmi - Eng. Mohamed EI-Tablawi
- Eng. Ahmed Imam
- Eng. Soliman Mohamed Soliman
- Eng. Mohamed Esh-Sheikh
- Eng. Mohamed Ez-Zaidy
- Eng. Mohamed Habib
- Eng. Ahmed En-Nemr
- Eng. Youssef Esh-Shafiee
- Eng. Es-Sayyed Mohamed Osman
- Eng. Maher Et-Tohami
- Chemist. Afifi Afifi Ibrahim
Annex- A Page 2 01'6
ENGINEERI"G CONSULTANTS GROUP
Organization Name
Cairo North Electricity Distribution Company (CNEDC)
• Chairman - Eng. Mohamed Ashour
• Deputy Chairman for Networks - Eng. Medhat Ramadan
• Executive Assistant for - Eng. Mohamed Abu Es-Saoud Technical Affairs
Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency EEAA)
• Central Directorate for - Dr. Ms. Fatma Abu-Shouk environmental Impact - Dr. Hisham EI-Agamawi Assessment - Eng. Mahmoud Shawki
Eng. Ms. Amany Salah - Dr. Ms. Amira Abdel-Hakim
Mohamed
• EEAA- Cairo & Giza Regional Branch - Dr. Atwa Mohamed Ali
6 of October Governorate
• Governor of 6 of October - Dr. Fathi Saad
• Secretary General of 6 of - Mr. Moussa Hussein October Gov.
• President of Local People's - Dr. Eng. Adel Helal Council of 6 of October
• Governor's Assistant for Civil - Mr. EI-Sayyed EI-Bouraaie
Defence
• General Director for - Eng. Anwar Abdel-Khalek Occupational Health & Safety
• Director for Environmental - Eng. Mohamed Abdel-Gawad Affairs Ghalloush
• Head of Environmental - Dr. Ms. Hanaa Mahmoud Abdel-
Commission of 6 of October Aziz
Gov.
• Director of Environmental Health - Dr. Said Ahmed Ali
• Information Center - Ms. Soaad Sayyed Guweilly
- Mr. Walid Ibrahim
- Mr. Mohamed Nabil
Egyptian General Authoritv for Shore Protection
• Chairman • Head of General Department
for Shore Protection • Executive Director
• Executive Director
• Supporting Engineering
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
- Eng. Yahya Halaby - Eng. Naguib Adly
- Ms. Waffa Mohamed Hindawi - Ms. Rahab Abdel-Aati Allaam
- Eng. Mahmoud M. Rizk - Eng. Ahmed M. Ibrahim - Eng. EI-Sayyed Abdel Halim
EI-Tohamy
Annex- A - Page 3 of 6
ENGINEERll'OG CONSULTANTS GROUP
Organization
Egyptian General Petroleum Corporation • Director for Operations • Assistant Director for Refining
& Industrialization • Chief Assistant Engineer for
Quality Control
Name
Chem. Medhat Yousef Chem. Ahmed Abdallah
Chem. Mohamed Abdel Moneim
Egyptian Natural Gas Holding Company (EGAS)
• Head of Division, Planning and Projects
• Head of Division, Operations
~. Gas Company • Planning and Assessment • Supply Stations • Operations Affairs
General Organization for Physical Planning
• Sector Head for Suez Region
• General Manager for Planning
HydrauliCS Research Institute (HRI) • Chairman • Hydrothermal Modeling • Director, Hydrographic Survey
- Eng. Ibrahim Ahmed
- Eng. Abdel-Hamid EIMokaddem
Eng. Gamal Amer Eng. Alaa Abdel Latif Eng. Mahmoud Sallam
Eng. Ms. Somayyah Abdel-Salam Eng. Mohamed EIHusseiny
Eng. Ibrahim EI-Desouky Dr. Yasser Shawky Eng. Ahmed EI-Sayyed Dr. Fathi EI-Gamal Dr. Khaled Abdel-Hai
I - Dr. Mohamed Rushdy
AI-Azhar University, Faculty of Engineering
• Professor of Traffic & Transport
Egypt National Institute of Transport (ENIT) • Executive Director
• Senior Transport Expert • Technical Assistants
National Research Center (NRC) • Air Pollution Preclusion Unit
- Prof. Dr. Mohamed Youssry
Prof. Dr. Abdallah Wah dan
Dr. Ms. Enas Bushra Nashed Eng. Mohamed Hussein Eng. Nasser Mohamed
- Prof. Dr.Kamal Tamer Hindy
- Eng. Adel Hassan Amer
Prof. Dr. Osama Ahmed Ali • Water Quality Unit
I ~ Prof. Dr. Mohamed Ismail Badawi Dr. Mohamed Bakr M. Ibrahim
ESIA for Gml North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- A - Page 4 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Organization Name
Ain Shams University, Faculty of Engineering
• Noise and Vibration Engineering - Prof. Dr. Mansour M. EI-Bardisi
Institute of Environmental Studies and Research, Ain-Shams University
• Ecological Studies Department - Dr. Aly Nasser Hassan
National Authority for Remote Sensing and Space Sciences
• Head of Marine Studies
6 of October Local Population
• Local People's Council of 6 of October Governorate
• Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
• NGOs Representatives
• Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
- Dr. Mahmoud Hussein
- Dr. Eng. Adel Helal - Mr. Shehata Saad Ali
- Mr. Gamal Mahmoud Fahmi - Mr. Asian Abdel-Ghany - Mr. Nageh Afifi Abdel Rahman - Mr. Shaaban Abdel-Hamid
- Mr. Mohamed Shaban - Mr. Rashed Abdel-Bary - Mr. Ramadan Bendary - Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany - Mr. Mahmoud IVI. Gharib
- Mr. Nageh Atiti - Mr. Mohamed Ali Fahmi
- Mr. Hamada Sayyed Ahmed
- Journalist. Karam Asian
- Mr. Ragab Moawad
- Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany - Fellah! Hanafi Mabrouk - Fellah! Abdel Razik Ahmed
- Fellah! Motawea Abdel-Mawgoud
- Fellah! Mortada Mosbah
- Fellah! Atwa Mohamedein - Fellah! Abu-Ghali Saadoun
- Fellah! Eleiwa EI-Mohammadi
- Fellahl Bashar Kotb - Fellah! Zein Ed-Din Hassan
- Fellah! Younes Abdel-Ghaffar Ali
- Fellah! Zohdi Naaoum Badawi
- Fellah! Gaber EI-Gaafarawi
.... __ . __ .. __ .. _-_ .. _---
Annex- A - Page 5 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Organization
• AI-Watany Political Party
• Fishermen
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Name
- Mr. Abdel-Hamid Omar
- Salama Hassouna - Boltayyah abu-Eisha - Hammouda EI-Maasarany - Mohammady EI-Sharkawi - Eid Bastawi - Omran Khalil
Annex- A - Page 6 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Annex B
SeOPING SESSION
ES1A for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B Page I of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1.
SeOPING SESSION
A scoping session was held in the EI-Manashi Kasr EI-Nile Cafeteria, very close to the EI-Kata power project site in EI-Manashi area, around 10 minutes driving from the Giza North Site area, 6 of October Governorate. The main goal of conducting a scoping session is to assist the Cairo Electricity Production Company/Egyptian Electricity Holding Company in obtaining the views of concerned parties, local NGOs and affected groups, and keeping records of meetings and other activities, communications, and comments.
The scoping session is a TOR requisite. This is the first public consultation meeting according to the WB requirements. A second public consultation will be conducted by the end of the stage of producing the Draft Final Report to present to the same stakeholders the results of the EIA report seeking their comments - if any - to include in the final report.
Records of meetings and other activities, communications and comments will be incorporated in the final report.
Appreciating the importance of the public consultation task, the Consultant moved fast and announced about the meeting in the media (see Appendix I) and held extensive meetings with all the interested and affected parties to explain the event and its importance. Some 220 of the stakeholders attended the session (only some 116 persons registered their names in the attendees list) and actively participated in the Questions and Answers session following the project description presentation delivered by ECG's Project Manager, Eng. Hassan EIBanna (EIA Project Consultant) and project scope presentation delivered also by the ECG's Project Manager, Eng. Hassan EI-Banna in cooperation with the CEPC Power Plant Sector's Manager, Eng. Magdy Anwar and the EEHC's Environmental Manager.
Accompanied by the Agenda of the meeting, a concised leaflet was delivered to the attendees on the registration desk. This leaflet and an Invitation Card were distributed also by ECG, CEPC and EEHC to their members and many other concerned parties in 6 of October Governorate for inviting them to the meeting. Appendix II presents the invitation card and Appendix III provides with the Agenda and leaflet.
The Targets of the Scoping Session
The Consultant - was assigned to do the Environmental Assessment as an independent party, not biased to any preset ideas of the owner or the designer. The scoping session is a direct consultation of the public, collecting first hand information and reactions from those who might be affected by the construction of the project. Consequently, the session was organized to include the following activities:
Presentation of the ESIA scope as per the TOR; Breakdown of the activities to highlight the issues that the attendees might comment on; Explain the environmental issues and invite the participants to raise their
~-.....•.. -~ ~-- ----~ ........ ----....... ----ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Page 2 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
2.
3.
3.1.
concerns about possible negative impacts; Conduct the discussions and invite the owner, local authorities and agencies to participate in the discussions; Clearly identify the comments and recommendations of the attendees and write all the minutes of the meeting to be attached to the Interim Report.
Attendees
A wide selection of personnel from different orientations attended the scoping session as described hereinafter. A list of names and occupations is attached in Appendix IV.
Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC); Cairo Electricity Production Company (CEPC); Giza North Power Project; Cairo West Power Plant; Cairo North Power Plant; Shoubrah EI-Kheima Power Plant; National Institute for Transport; Many Interesting Companies (EI-Masria Company for Trade, Saida Co., Water & Wastewater Co., .. etc.); Petroleum Sector; NGOs (EI-Hesanin Club, Youth and Environmental Friends Society, Health & Environment, Environmental Conservation in Aziziya, ... etc.); Hydraulics Research Institute; Institute of Oceanography Sciences; National Research Center; Ministry of State for Scientific Research; EI-Kata Farmers Population; Representatives of Imbaba and Menshat EI-Qanater Community; Consultant team; Project Engineer (PGESCo) team; and Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency (EEAA).
Meeting Procedure
Introduction
The scoping session started 11.00am in the EI-Manashy Kasr EI-Nile Cafeteria adequately equipped to accommodate the attendees, the representatives of the main authorities and the ECG staff in charge of the presentation.
CEPC Deputy Chairman, Eng. Mohamed EI-Zaidy inaugurated the session, welcoming all attendees and giving a short speech on the EEHC/CEPC message and the significance of the Giza North power project.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 10
Annex- B Page 3 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
3.2.
3.3.
President of Kafr Hegazy Local Council, Mr. Fathy Abdel Samad abdelWahed gave a warm speech considering Giza North power project a landmark infrastructure urgently needed in the Imbaba area.
ECG Project Manager, Eng. Hassan EI-Sanna opened the session, welcoming and thanking the attendees and briefing them about the role of the scoping session in the EIA study. He also emphasized the importance of their input of commenting, proposing and highlighting new ideas to enrich the study output.
Project Descrjption
ECG Project Manager, Eng, Hassan EI-Sanna invited the Managing Director of the Project Company - CEPC, Eng. Magdy Anwar to highlight the Giza North Power Project. Eng. Anwar started with warm welcome giving thanks for the attendees. He explained the purpose of the project and provided them with basic idea about main components of the proposed power plant at the Giza North site.
Project Scope
The Deputy Chairman of CEPC, Eng. Mohmed EI-Zaidy invited the ECG's Project Manager, Eng. Hassan EI-Sanna to present the TOR of the EIA study emphasizing the components of the study as briefed herein after.
Project Objectives
The study goals are to identify the environmental and social impacts of construction and operation of the project. A team of experts in various environmental disciplines will investigate the project area and study the possible impacts.
Study area
The study area will include all aspects that might be affected by construction and operation of the project including the entire infrastructure serving the Power Plant.
Environmental Scope
The study will address all positive and negative as well as direct and indirect impacts and will conduct field measurements of baseline conditions and the contributing effects and compare with the International norms and limits as indicated hereinafter:
No;se
ESfA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Jan uary 20 I 0
Annex· B - Page 4 of9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Noise level will be measured in many locations within the possible affected areas. Using special software, anticipated values for the operational mode of the proposed project would be computed.
Air Pol/ution
Data will be collected to build a database followed by measuring the background air quality levels. The results will be analyzed and compared with the local and international limits. Additionally, a dispersion modeling exercise will be conducted for predicting maximum concentrations of pollutants and their locations during operation of the power project.
Water Quality
All available information on the available water sources will be collected in terms of quantities and quality. This database will be used for future water use.
Intake and Discharge Structures
A numerical and physical hydraulic modeling studies will be conducted for predicting thermal behaviour of cooling water after discharging to the EIRayyah EI-Beheiry Canal. In addition, the modeling studies will investigate best engineering design for intake and discharge structures.
Biological Life
Will study previous reports about all species living in the project area and will try to locate it on the area maps. Will also study the suitability of the environment to the seasonal species coming to the area. Study will cover terrestrial life and birds.
Solid and Hazardous Wastes
Will survey location of solid and hazardous wastes generation that might adversely affect the environment. Will propose the safe ways of its handling and locations of final disposal.
Traffic and Local Roads
Will study the road network, parking areas and pedestrian crossings in the Power Project area as well as the buses network serving the Power Plant. Will also study the capacity of these roads to accommodate the future projected expansions as well as the project peak traffic during construction phase.
Socio-economics
For studying the impact of the project on the Socio-economic sectors, the
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Annex- B - Page 5 01'9 January 20 I 0
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
4.
Consultant will investigate the following:
Disturbance in social structure and development plans; Impact on social health; The infrastructure; Increase in job opportunities and increase in the labor force; Study land uses and project landscape.
All environmental alternatives will be studied to select the optimum solutions. Mitigation measures will be proposed to reduce the impact of the new activities on the environment.
Plan for Mitigating Project Negative Impacts
Studying negative and positive impacts will lead to establishing a comprehensive management plan which will identify the mitigation measures to be implemented as part of the envisaged construction contracts and continuous operational conditions.
Institutional Support Requirements
The organization charts will be reviewed and modifications will be recommended. This will enable the electricity authorities to implement the environmental plan.
Develop the Environmental Monitoring Plan
Prepare a detailed Monitoring Plan for both construction and operation phases, and continue measurements of air and water pollution during the operation phase.
The Final Public Consultation
After completing the EIA Draft Final Report, a public consultation session will be held in 6 of October Governorate area to present the findings of the study. Comments of the attending stakeholders will be incorporated in the Final Report.
Appendix V provides with "Presentation Slides".
Scoping Session Open Discussions
The items discussed covered most of the environmental impacts and demonstrated main concerns. The following are the main issues raised during the discussions.
Giza North Power Project
A landscape area is proposed to be kept inside the Power Plant fence for improving the scenic impact.
_ .... _---_ ..... __ .... _- . __ .... _---_ .. _-_ .... _-_ .... __ ... __ ... __ ... -ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Januaty 20 I 0
Annex- B - Page 6 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
The EI-Kata Local Council should review the current capacities of services as the number of workers will be increased during the construction of the new project.
For model Predication, the condition of the worst case, not the average, should be adopted. If the noise level is above the international standards, recommendations such as monitoring the noise level, any other mitigation measures should be adopted. With respect to noise generated from ground traffic and equipment, the prediction should be superimposed to all noise sources.
Traffic
The road network will be carefully studied. Recommendations for mitigating the direct and peak construction impacts will be prepared. The traffic count points shall be selected very efficiently.
Power Supply
Electric power is available with ample capacity to meet the project requirements; The Contractors assigned to build the Power Plant will provide emergency generating sets; The generator's fuel will be recommended to be environment friendly.
Solid Waste
The Power Plan should adopt practices (separation, reuse, ... etc.) of solid and hazardous wastes as per the solid waste integrated management philosophy. Coordination between the EI-Kata Local Council and the contractors for collection and disposal of solid wastes in anticipated sanitary landfill is recommended. The ESIA study should adopt mitigation measures for hazardous wastes generated from the construction and operation of the Power Project.
Water Supply
Practices of water disinfection and tank cleaning should be adopted in order to improve drinking water quality.
Wastewater Services
Wastewater from the new Giza North Power Plant will be disposed of through the plant sewer and the EI-Kata sanitary network in the near future.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Jan uary 2010
Annex- B - Page 7 of9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
5.
The new Power Project should adopt Pre-treatment for industrial wastewaters produced from the Power Plant before discharging to the discharge facility.
Questions and Answers
The following is a paraphrasing of the questions with the questioner identified and the answer by a member of the presenters.
Mr. Karam Asian, Senior Journalist of EI-Dostour Newspaper and Member of Youth Club Council of Menshat EI-Qanater Area.
Comment: Results from the Giza North air quality data has shown that background suspended particulate matters concentrations are higher than expected contribution of the proposed power plant emissions. Therefore, major air quality problems in the area are probably due to background concentrations rather than from the proposed power plant.
Question: What environmental limitations are there at Giza North which could prevent building 1500 MWe?
Answer: Assessment of any limitations to future power plant addition at Giza North cannot be determined until the environmental impact evaluation is completed.
Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany Abd Allah Omar. Lawyer of Abu Ghaleb area
Comment: Gaseous pollution presently in the area should be included in the air quality analysis.
Question: What criteria will be used for atmospheric considerations when selecting Giza North as the site?
Answer: Previous predicting studies for Similar units were used to evaluate potential pollutant levels. If additional information is needed about model used in these predictions, it can be provided.
Mr. Motawea Abdel-Mawgoud Abdel-Latif Haddad, Farmer, Ezbet Um Dinar
Question: Will this project interfere with the existing environment?
Can cooling water used for the plant affect negatively the EI-Rayyah EI-
---------_ ..... __ . __ ....... _--_ ...... _--_ ..... -ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B Page 8 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
8eheiry?
Answer: The project will not have significant effect on the existing environment.
Utilization of canal water for power plant cooling is non-consumptive. Nevertheless, it is recognized that the power plant project will play an integral part in development of the east bank area and this effect will be addressed in the Environmental Assessment.
Mr. Osama Rabea Mabrouk, Local Council Member, Nekla Community
Question: Did you study the effect of the power plant on shoreline and canalbed in terms of erosion and sedimentation?
Answer: Complete modeling studies, numerically and physically. will be carried out by the Hydraulics Research Institute and their outcomes will be presented to you in the next public consultation meeting,
Mr. Moussa Saad Abdallah, Senior Teacher, Menshat EI-Qanater Educational Administration
Question: It is not usual that the Giza North area be a subject to flash flooding, but with extreme events resulting from recent effects of climate change there might be a possibility of flash flooding during specific times along the year. Did you take this into the design considerations and site selection studies?
Answer: Yes, there is a comprehensive study on meteorology as well as geology, geomorphology and hydrogeology, including flash floods, under implementation today, which will address the risk types associated with the project, including flash floods.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 10
Annex- B - Page 9 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix I
Newspaper Advertisement for Scoping Session
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B Appendix I - Page I of2
ENCINEERIl\C CONSULTANTS CROUP
t.iJ I ,.; .•• ~i
--4J ,5:" tsL..:U~ :&,.)AliJ' .t...s:~
~~~~\J.j ;;~tJW.YHn':"-tJ.....:.r~I~'iIf'i';_"J"-j).l';)~!
\.Si>11 ~ t~!J 4S)~ 4...,! w.1 ~~ t ;; ~~ e.:.~~I.:::t,&t;.nr.!J:;i~1b...w.~).t!~~itL..:...,/!<L.4-~ ':"IJ~VO· x 'f~J.Jl~.>lI;;jJ.JJIi"~;;~lJt...:.~4>tS~
J .. *.,; .. tI~~~'f.·l\ ~;Zl n J.~,,;tI¢,~)Y'i"i:i,,;u~j H~.'\;.\.:.: .. :M'~'4:*~~~· ~LaI;;,i~I,f~~~t$i"l..i ~! ...IA;I ~"\'>'Ij1j ~1 ..... tI~!;I# ~~\.::!IJ' A.c:W'1 ~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix I Page 2 of 2
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix II
Invitation Card to Scoping Session
ESIA for Gi?.a North Combined Cycle Power Project Janu31Y 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix II - Page I 01'2
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
--
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Janu,uy 20 J 0
\ "1, ~ [~ ~ ,.,.
;~ .... " ;3 ·-k.J
Annex- B - Appendix II Page 2 or2
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix III
Agenda and Leaflet
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix III Page 1 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
t "t\ :'Ull tw.1 J ~~ -J
~IJ~ 750 x 2 o-JJ! o~1 JW ~4JfoS ~ tJ~ -4s,JAl1 o-JJJJI ~~
.2009 J:1jiS\ 21 ~1a.:a}'1
tJ~IC~
tJ~ 4L=J1 (.5J..4
tJ~1 ~ 4ijWl JU'i1
11:00 -10:30
11:10 -11:00
12:00 -11:15
12:15 - 12:00
13:00 -12:15
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project
January 20 I 0 Annex- B - Appendix III - Page 2 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~~~~I
'. "'I "Ull twal J ~ ~ J
~~I oJJJ.lI f"~ oJ:AJ1 JW ,.4.A-S ~ tJ~
~IJ~ 750 x 2 oJ.Ii
ESIA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix 111- Page 3 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
9-1.J+l1 .:.a",...t 1-4
ol..;.AlI.:.a~ 2-4
o~\.i ~\~lJ' oy..J\ ~~J w~J .J~~~WI ww4-:J1 ~J ~YUI wL....4i!1 J.,.o.c ~ . ~ 0l;!.J\ w~\~'l ww4-:JJ
w.,..tll ~~ .l.:!fi.1 04-0 e::y:....oJ ~~ wi .... ::.W ~ e::~~J ~l:u e::~~.)c. ~Iy ~ ~J .~IJ ~;ilI.J:!:lt-.l1 wU:. I";':;' I ~ ~ 'f'J'" 0\1\ ~j)IJI wy......ojill u-ll J~~IJ LG)yJI
w4fi::J1J' Jj'lj..ll ~ o.J"uJ ' LGy.\.J:JI.us...;.J ~fi:i .. ~}il yfiyJl ~1.JJ.l\ o~ ~J . ~ y,oJl o~ ~1..:J1
J-lll\.J .J.J~\ 4-4
. ~.".Jl ~~.,;.J\ (..i.r1J' ~ ~I.J~ ~
~--~"---~~-~~~~--~~~--~~~-~--~~~~~--~~~~~~--~~~~--~~~~--~~~~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Projeet January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix 1Il- Page 4 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~~~\,,»!i\.:i 5-4
~l.J ~~ LI ~ 1_ L.iJ u.:...J1 ,L, >~.l.ic. ~. ,_II W .-: .11 . :~11 ~ .-:~(..6. L.:. ! - ~ ~ ,.J, .J..r-~. ~ ~ ~ ~~ ,.J..)"'-'-' .".........~~
~~y.::JI ~ 1.A.J~1 ~ ;;~.:lC..61.:ii ~ ~~y.::JI wL~ ~YJ 4..b....J\ CJC ~Ull ~~~ 1-I.L-: ~.:lCli.l\ ,~J ,
, ~ll~ I.. .. t _~.I\ ~ • A-;~A'\ 'I > 1_ t ->.11 'b 1- U __ -:11 ~l ~\ U ' f"'l.:l ~ ~J J~ . c--:- ~.J-'->'..r- J~ fil i.5"""" ...r-""" .J ~ '~"JI Lj"Jli ~I ,~ .J ..s- '
4.fJ wl~ ~ ~~ u-k y..jY:! ~J ~i ;u l.S~J ~1..r--9':11 ~ JUi,31 -
.~~1
. ~1.b.b:..J ~\ JS.4A ~ 1..:-l1~'J'\ -
A...,W\ ~\ 1_ 'bl\ _ • i.5"""" fil
4..b....JI· ;;..lllU.!1 :Lu :.:11 -:. Ll1J\ -~..!:J~ 'i -'.(.. -:1\ wI .. .:.-:11 ~\ ~ , . oc., , J ,,'?"""""..s- U ~ I.S"""' ~ .J ~
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
. 0\.S....Jl JWjI -
. ~\yJIJ wlA~1 -
~l'l ;;~l.J'-• :i ~ ,.J
. JJk..l1 ~ ;;~yj -
Annex- B - Appendix III Page 5 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSllL TANTS GROUP
~I ~I J~J .~I o~ J~ 4/';.'1\ .)L:i'il C~JJ ~lyJl4;l), oi, ~ ~b . .c.) ~ , tA~ J oy..J1 'E;~y!"J .!'-~."....;:JIJ ,!'-I-*I o~y:J (..}'lYilI u4kc .,;I~\ ~ .4..b..:....J1 tJy.W
~fi..:J1 u4-:;JIJ ~I d~1 'E;JC~ ..s) ... I.t:i....\l1 ~ UJWJy !,-yfil ~\:jj'i 'E;~\:il\ ~~ ~l! ;r....J-'" u-ar ~ ~ ~I ~~I tw......\l1 ~ .)~I f'.J-AC-J ~'1\ u~IJ ~~\J f':l.l..i:iJ ~I ~ .)~\ ~~J . ..sj'~\l1 ~ f'~ ~14 h.,'1 LI.).l1\ ..s~J tJ~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
. ~1.).l11 .)) 4-J!~1 ~ ~I uk.. j3i.J1
Annex- B - Appendix III - Page 6 of 6
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix IV
List of Invitees and List of Attendees
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix IV Page I of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1 . List of Invitees
ESIA fOl Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix IV Page 2 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) For the Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project ( 2X750 MW)
PUBLIC SCOPING SESSION
Ser. Name
I. Dr. Ms. Mawaheb Abu EI-Azm
2. Dr. Ms. Fatma Abu Shouk
3. Dr. Hisham EI-Agamawi
I 4. Eng. Mahmoud Shawki
rs.--r Amany Salah
9. ! Eng. Hassan Nagm
i 10. Dr. Eng. Mohamed Awad
II. I Dr. Eng. Kamel Yassin
12. I Eng. Ms. Fawziyya Abu-Neima
13. Ace. Salah Awad
14. Dr. Hassan Mahmoud
i 15. I Dr. Ms. Nahed Haggi
I 16. I Eng. Maher Aziz Bedrous i
I 17. Eng. Ahmed Salah
I 18. Eng. Mohamed Abdel Bary
! 19. Eng. Ahmed Hassan
I 20. Eng. Ms. Fatma Maayouf
121. Eng. Mohamed Et-Tablawi
22. Eng. Ms. Dalia Nour Ed-Din - ----
23. Eng. Anob Condo
i 24. i Eng. SherifShetta
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Invitees List
Occupation Chief Executive Officer, EEAA
Head of EIA Division (EEAA)
General Director of Power Projects, EIA Department, EEAA
· General Director for Industrial Projects, EIA I Department, EEAA
I Director for Energy Projects, EIA Department, i EEAA
I Director for Industrial Projects, EIA Department, EEAA
I • General Director for EEAA Greater Cairo Regional ! Branch
• Managing Director, Egyptian Electrical Utility and I
I Consumer Protection Regulatory Agency
: Chairman of Egyptian Electricity Transmission · Company (EETC)
: Chairman, EEHC
Executive Board Member for Planning, Research and Service Com2anies Affairs, EEHC Executive Board Member for Affiliate Companies, EEHC
I Executive Board Member for Economic, Financial I & Administrative Affairs, EEHC
Sector Head, Information Department, EEHC
Consultant, Research & Testing, EEHC
i Head of Sector for Environmental Management • Studies
Sector Head for Steam Power Projects, EEHC
Sector Head for Gas Power Projects, EEHC
General Director for Civil Works, EEHC
General Director for Generation Planning, EEHC
General Director for Power Plant Studies, EEHC
Environmentalist, PGESCo
Director of Structures, PGESCo
Assistant Eng., PGESCo
Annex- B Appendix IV - Page 3 of27
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
ENGINEE:RING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Ser. i Name
25. Eng. Gasser Saber
i 26. • Eng. Ashraf EI-Far
27. Mr. Gobal
! 28. I Eng. Ashraf Nassar
29. i Mr. Serage Eddin EI-Sayyed
30. Ms. Amani Selim
i 31. • Eng. Abdel Rehim Salah
~ Chern. Hassan Akl
. 33. • Dr. Hamed Korkor
34. i Eng. Sherif Ismail
35. Eng. Ibrahim Ahmed
i Eng. Abdel-Hamid EI-Mokaddem
37. Mr. Hemdan Abdel-Sattar
38. I-----
Dr. A I-Sayed Tawfik Moustafa
39. Dr. Magdi Abbass Saleh
40. • Eng. Farag Mahmoud Yamani
41. Eng. Attia Ibrahim Omar
1
42.
Dr. Ali Abdel-Azim Toailab
i 43. Dr. Salah El-Hadidi Ali
144. Dr. Ahmed Badawi
45. Dr. Fathi EI-Gamal
.46. Eng. Ibrahim A. EI Desouky
47. Prof. Dr. Kamal Tamer Hindi
48. Prof Dr. Aleyya Abdel Shakour
49. Chern. Vasser Hassan Ibrahim
50. Eng. Adel Hassan Amer
5l. Prof Dr. Ahmed Sayed Morsi
r;2. I Prof Dr. Mohamed Anwar EI-Dib
53. i Prof Dr. Mohamed M. Al Abdi
54. Prof Dr. Osama Ahmed Ali i----
55. Prof Dr. Mohamed Ismail Badawi
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20' 0
· Occupation i Project Eng., PGESCo
Executive Assistant, PGESCo
Talkha Project Manager, PGESCo I
General Director of Power Projects, PGESCo I
Environmental Quality Sector, EGPC
Environmental Quality Sector, EGPC
Egyptian General Petroleum Corporation i
Egyptian General Petroleum Corporation I
Technical Expert, EGAS I
• Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, General Authority for I
Fishery Development (GAFD)
• Department of Fish Resources (GAFD) i
Aqua-culture Specialist (GAFD) !
Chairman, Egyptian General Authority for Shore Protection Sector Head, Studies & Research, Egyptian General Authority for Shore Protection Chairman, National Research Institute of Astronomy & GeoEh~sics (NRlAG) I Associate Professor, NRIAG
I
Associate Professor, NRIAG i
Director, Hydraulics Research Institute !
Deputy Director, Hydraulics Research Institute !
Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National I Research Center Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National !
Research Center Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center ,
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center !
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center I
Annex- B Appendix IV· Page 4 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
I Ser. Name
56. i Dr. Mohamed Bakr M. Ibrahim
57. Prof Dr. Mansour M. EI Bardisi
58. Dr. M. Mahmoud Bassyoni
59. Dr. Khaled Nabil Helaly
160. Prof. Dr. Mohamed Yousry
i 61. Dr. Aly Nasser Hassan
162. I Dr. Fathi Bekhit Shenodah
! 63. I Dr. Fathi Saad
64. Mr. Moussa Hussein
I 65. Dr. Eng. Adel Helal
66. Mr. EI-Sayyed EI-Bouraaie
I 67. Eng. Anwar Abdel-Khalek
• 68. Eng. Mohamed Abdel-Gawad Ghalloush
69. ! Dr. Ms. Hanaa Mahmoud Abdel-Aziz
I 70. Dr. Said Ahmed Ali
I 71. Ms. Soaad Sayyed Guweil\y
172. Mr. Walid Ibrahim
i 73. Mr. Mohamed Nabil
,74. Dr. Eng. Adel Helal
75. i Mr. Shehata Saad Ali
I i 76. I Mr. Gamal Mahmoud Fahmi
77. i Mr. Asian Abdel-Ghany
78. I Mr. Nageh Afifi Abdel Rahman
~ M,. Shaaban Abdel-Hamid
80. 'Mr. Mohamed Shaban
• 81. i Mr. Rashed Abdel-Bary
82. I Mr. Ramadan Bendary
83. Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany
84. Mr. Mahmoud M. Gharib
! 85. Mr. Nageh Afifi
86. I Mr. Mohamed Ali Fahmi
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 10
Occupation I
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center - I
Noise Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Ain I Shams University
Senior Transport Expert, ENIT I
Transportation & Traffic Planning, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University Transportation & Traffic Planning, Faculty of Engineering, AI-Azhar Univer~itl' Ecological Studies Department, Ain Shams University Head of Acoustics Department, National Institute for Standards
Governor of 6 of October
Secretary General of 6 of October Gov.
President of Local People's Council of 6 of October i
Governor's Assistant for Civil Defence
General Director for Occupational Health & Safety
Director for Environmental Affairs I
. ... -.~---,
Head of Environmental Commission of 6 of i
October Gov.
I Director of Environmental Health
Information Center
I Information Center
Information Center
I Local People's Council of 6 of October I I Governorate
Local People's Council of 6 of October I
Governorate
, Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
Local Council ofImbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat E1-Qanater
• Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
I NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives i
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
I Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Annex- B Appendix IV - Page 5 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
, Ser. Name
87. Mr. Hamada Sayyed Ahmed
88. i Journalist. Karam AsIan
89. Mr. Ragab Moawad
90. Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany
91. , Fellah! Hanafi Mabrouk :
Fellah! Abdel Razik Ahmed 92.
i 93. Fellah! Motawea Abdel-Mawgoud
94. ! Fellah! Gaber EI-Gaafarawi
95. i Mr. Abdel-Hamid Omar
96. Mie Salama
97. I Ashraf Abd EI-Zaher
98.
I
Nabil Sedeek
: 99. Ali Elshafe
100. i Bothina Abd EI Monoum Moustfa
101. Ashraf Moustafa Elfar
102. Mohamed Abd EI-Aziz _ ... -103. ! Eng. Saied Mohamed Badawy
104. Ayman Abu-Laid :
Eng. Ahmed Imam 105.
106. Eng. Soliman Mohamed Soliman
107. • Eng. Mohamed Esh-Sheikh
108. Eng. Mohamed Ez-Zaidy
109. Eng. Mohamed Habib
110. Eng. Ahmed En-Nemr
111. I Eng. Youssef Esh-Shafiee
112. i Eng. Es-Sayyed Mohamed Osman
113. I Eng. Maher Et-Tohami
114. Chemist. Afifi Afifi Ibrahim
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Occupation Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens I
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
AI-Watany Political Party
Broad cast
Algomhurya Newspaper
Alahram Elmasae
Akhbar - Elyom
Egyptian Electricity Holding Company
PGESCo Company I
Egyptian Electricity Transmission Company
General Manager of South Sinai Zone (GASCo) !
Journalist, Elmasry Elyom
Chairman
Head of Cairo Power Generating Sectors ...._,
Sector Chief of Cairo West Power Plant Project :
i Head of Sector for Power Plants Technical Affairs
Head of Sector, EI-Tebbin Power Plant Project
Head of Chemistry Sector
General Director for Technical Affairs :
Head of Sector, Shoubrah EI-Kheima Power Plant
General Director for Industrial Safety
General Director for Health & Safety
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 6 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
2. List of Attendees
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January '2010
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 7 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) For the Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project ( 2X750 MW)
PUBLIC SCOPING SESSION
Attendees List
Date Wednesday Oct. 21 ,2009 Place 6th of October Governorate, EL Manashy Kasr El Nile ( cafeteria)
• No. NAME JOB
• I Hamada Shamekh SECURITY Khalifa GUARD
2 Shahat Saad Ali ACCOUNTANT
3 Asian Abd EI Ghany Business Man, Abo Yousef
4 Ragab Abd AI Rasool WORKER, Mosa
5 Ibrahim Ragab Abd EI I FARMER, Gelil
6 Ibrahim Magdy ENGINEER-Mohamed Labib BUISNESSMAN,
7 Mohamed Fakhry OPERATION Maghawry GENERAL
MANAGER 8 Mohamed Said Abd El Facilities
Azeez Manager 9 Magdy Ahmed Abd El Chemistry
•
Aleem. Department Manager
10 Emad Abd Elmageed --------II Fatouh Mahmoud Abd -....... ---... -... -
EI Hameed 12 Nashaat Mahdy Gabryal Maintenance
General Manager 13 Gamal Mahmoud Senior Teacher-
Fahmy Mohamed Abd Azhar EI Samad
14 Osama Rabea Mabrouk Real Estate Officer
15 Bekhatroh Nagah Facilities • Farahat Torky Manager
16 • Abd EI Hady Farag Engineer 17 Hanafy Mabrouk Farmer 18 lbd EI Razik Ahmed Farmer
i Abd EI Aty 19 I Mohamed Shaban Abd Human Resource
L-...... I EI Bary Mohamed Manager
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
LOCATION PHONE KATAFARM 0104570535
MEMBER OF MARKAZ 0106567292 IMBABA COUNCIL NEKLA 0101693150
NEKLA-IMBABA 0108178842
NEKLA -IMBABA 0105438858
ELMASRIA COMPANY 0111991120 FOR TRADE AND CONTRACTING WEST CAIRO PLANT 0167621136
WEST CAIRO PLA
WEST CAIRO Project 0129030213
------------- 0123953124
--------- 0103474489
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0184177430
Shekh Salah Abu Ismael 0182112020
Munshaat Al Kanater Not Valid
WEST CAIRO Project Not Valid
WEST CAIRO Project Not Valid Abu Ghaleb 0193740541 Abu Ghaleb 'i
Abu Ghaleb 0166658224
Annex- B - Appendix IV Page 80f27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
20 Rashad Abdelbary Retired Mohamed
21 i Amira Abd EI Hakim Department Of · Mohamed Petroleum
Projects Manager 22 Amany Salah EI Said Department Of
Electricity • Projects Manager
23 Mohamed Deya' El Project Manager Dein Mohamed
24 Moustafa Mohamed I Boilers • Tawfik Abd EI Halim Department
Manager 25 Salah Saber Ahmed --------26 Fares Ali Abd EI Fatah Driver 27 Salah Farrag Ahmed Driver
! 28 · Saied Nasr Saied Hasan Technical Manager
29 Ali Abd EI Hamid Ali Senior Saad • Researcher
30 Osama Mohamed Abo Turbines Elela Department
Manager 31 Moawad Mohamed Ali Worker
Abd Elaty
i 32 ! Naser Fathy Abd EI Worker Aziz
i 33 Ramadan Bendary Abd Worker Allah
34 Abd EI Fatah Abd EI Lawyer Ghany Abd Allah Omar
I 35 Abd EI Lati f Abd EI Principal(Head Wanes Abd Allah Master)
• 36 Saeed Elmasry -------Mohamed
37 Nageh Afify Abd EI Worker · Rahman
38 I Fouad Abdelmaksoud Worker 39 · Mohamed .... Lawyer
Mahmoud Ghareeb
• 40 · Abdo Ali EI Gendy Manager------41 E1 Sayed Abd Elaziz EI Manager------
Sayed 42 Khaled Gamal Hasan Syndicate
committee -------43 Maher Ahmed Tohamy General manager 44 Gamal Fouad Nour EI General manager
Dein
ES1A for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January ~OIO
Abu Ghaleb Not Valid
Ministry Of Environment 0123874929
I
Ministry Of Environment 0101948860
I
• Electricity Company 0103784003
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0160465455
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0102949869 ----------- 0126982281 WEST CAIRO PLANT 0161079125 WEST CAIRO PLANT 0106477342
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0105528426
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0105125217 I
I Abu Ghaleb 0167745310
Abu Ghaleb • 0167869548
Abu Ghaleb 0103793459
Abu Ghaleb 0105893845
Abu Ghaleb 0103922725
----------- 01066932385
Gzayah 0105412445
Gzayah 0104174790 ! Abu Ghaleb 0168679199
I -------- 0128909493 I WEST CAIRO PLANT Not Valid
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0123186272
WEST CAIRO PLANT 0121654812 WEST CAIRO PLANT 0101292271
Annex. B Appendix [V· Page 9 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
45 Momen Mohamed Driver Elsabtya 0129673123 Mohamed Ahmed
46 • Nageh Afify Abd EI Local Council Munshaat al kanater 0105412445 · Rahman Member
47 Shaban Abd EI Hameed Local Council M unshaat al kanater • 0189144727 Mahmoud Hanafy Member
48 Motaz Y ousef Ahmed Chemist Egyptian Holding company 0107652151 for electricity
49 Mohamed Ahmed Contractor Saida 0106569038 Etman
1
50 Salama Hamed Contractor • Saida 0103384048 Mahmoud
151 Tamer Ali ....... Administrator -----...... - 0145202250
I 52 Ibrahim Abd Allah Lawyer Elsabtya 0119895210 I
Ibrahim i 53 Nagy Abd ..... farmer ------- Not Valid I • 54 Hasan Hosney Ahmed Security ------ 3732126
.-
55 Anwar Hassan I ~cecurity ! 0119799010
Mohamed epartment 56 • Mohamed Abd EI Driver Health and safety 0184410746
Monem Shaban department i
57 Ragaa Khamees • The central Egyptian company for 0101071816 I
I
Moawad labours divisions electricity transmission head
158 Ahmed Fathy Abd EI Jobless Almanashi Not Valid
Aziz I 59 • Hassan Abd El Megeed Stationary shop Almanashi ! 0 I 23522549
HendaVvY owner 60 Mohamed Ali Fahmy Youth club ---_ ... --------- 0100729201
: Gobran member ! 61 Hamada Rabag Jobless ! 6 th October 0181087508 !
Mohamed Sayed
I ~h~~e~d ____________ _r __ -----------+--------------------~--------~ ~~a maximos monir 4003738 . 63 Mahmoud Ali Abd EI 0182424700
Me 'eed Hamad 64
• 65
Mosbah murtada Mosbah Galal Abd EI Naby Abd EI Hameed El Sharka
66 • Sayed Abd EI Fatah ! Mahmoud
~r-rh"lned Ibrahim Hassan · Saleh
68
69
Samir yosri Saadan
Araby Badawy Ali Abd • Jobless EI Khalik
Mashash el balad
.... -~- ... - .... --------------------~ ...... --.... ---
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
0106852445
I 0101241822
0128090028
• 0119740625
018756364
0108840469
Annex- B - Appendix IV· Page 10 of
ENGINEERrNG CONSULTANTS GROUP
170 i Saber Ghareeb Technical
I • Mohamed authority
• 71 Mortada Mosbah Farmer !72 i Mohamed Ah~ed EI The plant sector I ! Shabah head
73 I Sanad Abd EI Azeem Retired Hasan
74 I Motawea Abd EI Farmer i Mawgoud Abd EI Latif
EI Hadad 75 ShriefMoustafa Ali Lawyer
176 i Fathy Abd EI Samad Local Council
Abd EI Wahed president 77 I Y ousef Ahmed EI Manager
• Shafey 78 Osama Rabea Mabrouk Local Council
Member
1
79 Islam Abd EI Khalik EI commercial Nagar ! researcher
! 80 • Mohamed Abd EI Ex- division chief i i Rahman Salem
~ Ismaeel l.aky Security manager 82 . Mosa Saad Abd Allah Senior teacher
! 83 Hamada Abo EI Fotoh Soliman
1
84 Abd EJ Shafy Abd EI Instructor Wadood Mohamed
·85 Abd EI Kader Chemist
i Abdelsattar Hashem 86 Nahed shalabi Abd .... Chemist
.87 I Kotb Kamel Mohamed retired .. ~ ~.
88 Ragab Abd EI Ghany EI Financial Shora counselor
89 Eman Fouad General manager 90 Ali Abd EI Fatah retired 91 Gamal Mohamad Abd
EI ..... 92 Said Gameel Ahmed
! 93 Gamal Saad Ahmed accountant _..-.?lsabbagh . 94 Saber abdelhalim Retired
Mohamed Omar 95 Mohamed Abd EI
I Hafeez elzedi 96 Y ousef Said EI GebaJey Researches
~\eneral manager
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
• Sabteya electricity I 0104689638 I administration A~u ghalib 3877291 i
! West cairo 13891414 1
i
EI manashi Not Valid i
Om dinar 0109908302
I EI manashi el balad Not Valid •
I Kafr hegazy Not Valid
West cairo plant Not Valid
Nekla Not Valid
Ministry ofpetroJeum Not Valid
Al ekhsas Not Valid
Elsabtya 0102260998 Munsaat Alkanater 0116015375 educational administration
0101779725
0186562448
Sabteya electricity project 0105292213
Chemical labs 0124678341 Ministry of health 0123249451
Cairo company for 0122378582 e1ectrici~ ~roduction
West cairo plant 0127018827 AI ekhsas 38942966 AI ekhsas i 0125137937 I
0168053875 Abu Ghaleb ! 0161218566
AI ekhsas 0110187313
10122378616
Cairo company for ! 0101503894 electricity production i ...
Annex" B - Appendix IV Page II of
ENGINEE.RING CONSULTANTS GROUP
97 Afef)t Afef)t Ibrahim Health and safety Cairo company for 0106754538 ! general manager electricity production i
98 I Nady Ahmed Me<aed Researches and Cairo company for ,0122378515 Khaleefa studies chief electricity production i
manager 99 I Kotb Mohamed Kotb Student EI hesanin youth club 0127994924
Mohamed 100 · Ra'fat Abd EI Aziz 0101142099
, Mohamed i
I 101 Hasan Sayed Mahamed i I 0102887749 Nasr
102 Alsayed Mohamed Boilers manager Cairo company . 0 103686948 Ahmed tir el barr
103 Said Kamal Fouad Driver Cairo comQany 0119105262 I 104 Mohamed Anwar West Cairo company 0105046993
,
Gha~ i
105 Salah Ahmed Abd I Security Cairo company 0128225993 Allah i
106 • Mohamed Ali I Student , hesanin youth club 0189788782 Mohamed Mohamed Awad I
~ Nevien Abd EI Monem Environmental ' Egyptian Holding company Not valid i
· Moustafa studies manager for electricity
U o~~ Ahmed al nimr General milnager West Cairo comj)any 106791581 i 109 Ragab moawad hegazi Engineer , Peoples council member 0129001394
110 Abd elmobdee Clerk Researches division 0127536822 I mahmoud ismaeel
I III Mohamed Hassan zalat Clerk i Researches division 0104387200 112 Sheriff Mohamed Security 0101322592
abdelrahman researcher i
113 Essam ahmed eladawi Security manager Cairo company for 0114161262 electricity production
114 Karam asian Journalist Dostour news paper 0197777093 115 Karam abdelnabi ahmed ----- Water and wastewater I 0 I 07722600
co~any
116 i Magdi anwar hussain Chief of projects i Cairo company 0109483573 division
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 12 of 27 January 2010
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ ~ ~ -)
,~ .1I .
] i~ v- I
~ ~ .1-j :lj'!l
-8 ... ,~ . " . 10-
~ ~ .., 'l Qj
,J '} ~) j #)
? i i: 7i
j '1 ... 1- {' ,4
:l' ''I "') . .,.
M .. Q V', r-
"" J: ..,
::.J ~ 0 :x: :.:.:;J
VJ ~ <: ~ ;::l rn Z 0 V (J Z ;;;: tIl ::u Z 5 Gj
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 20 I 0
~ ~ -!--.-!...ff -II
Annex- B - Appendix IV Page 13 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
i ] .....
ESIA for GIza North Combll1ed Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
I I~
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 14 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ ,~
~~ ·iU .:)
~ ~{ j . ...
I
~ ~J j ~'.!l
~ .... ,~
~ ")
.u
J , i ~ J' .,
?i .3' J.
;;
J ;1 -1- t-... :1' "
.,. N ... <:> ..., r--.
c... 1-")
;:J 0 0 ~ 0 Vl
~ <: !3 ;:> Vl Z 0 u a 25 ~ u.: ~
25 0 ~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 17 January 2010
··--i
Annex- B - AppendIx IV Page 15 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
:> ,~
~ ~ ~ -8
~ "'I UJ
J ':1;
i '1., ..J'
.J :i 1 ~
~1 .... 1· t ,0
:1' . ., , .. .... ... c '" .....
e:: ~ 5 ~
'" c.?
~ z < f:-: ~ V.1 Z 0 U c if e1 t.ll if c.? z ~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 16 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
, '\
g ~ .l'
~ ~ 1 > ~~ ~'
'" I
~ ~ .1' J :Ij '!J ./) ... ,~ ~ . " . .....
1, ~ ")
'.:t oJ
,J !1
} ~)
1" ...
,J i i ;;
j ~1 ... 1- :t~ :J'
,0
N .. eo l(}
r-
""' t ;::) ';j 0 p! Ci Vi f-< Z .0(
tl ;:;l Vi Z 0 U Ci z r:2 w.l w.l
2S 0 z c;;;
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
"l ;c
~
~I 'i [
~ ~ 6 ,.
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 17 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1 ] ....
ESIA lor Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January :CO 10
j
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 18 of
ENGINEERII\G CONSULTANTS GROUP
i 1 ....
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January ~O I 0
Annex- B - Append ix IV - Page 19 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP <i.t:v~~ ~.;.srv
~ ~~ \)<J
'\ .l; 'J
~ ;i; 1 i .~ ...
I
~ ~ .1' J ~ ':!l
~ .... ,~ . . , . ....
~ ~ '"l
'=1 IlJ
.J ., I !
1; J' I I
t -; ..3' .., I
? i i: I
~ I· N r ~l
, j j
i, I -1, 1 :~ :1' H' M ... <:> \()
"" I!...
j: '"l
::::> ~ a ~ (;) <n
~ <:: ~ ::::> t;;)
:z; a u
~ (;) 7-t:2 ~
.J. \.U 6 (;) Z !:lJ
~~ ~--~~-~~~ .. ---~--- ---~-
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 20 I 0
Annex- B Appendix rv Page 20 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
, ,~
~~ .;!j .
1 ~1 "'") . j- . II< I ,..::)
~ ~ ,1-J :I) '!i
~5 ... ,~ . " . ....
1 !% oj ':t ,J ~
.~
~} ..1'
I .,
J 4<1-J' ]-
;; ~ ~ j ~1 ... 1· 1: 14
:1' . " " . .". ><
Q
'" ....
:>.. l ;:::, \j 0 ~ 0
~ z :( t--d c;5 z c v '.) z 2 ~ ;x.; ~
" ~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
Annex- B Appendix IV Page 21 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
J ] ...
J. ).
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
Annex- B Appendix rv Page 22 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 201 0
Annex- B - Appendix IV Page 23 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ ,~
~-~iJj ~ ~ .~ ]
;; ~ i 4b ... j
~
J ~
~.1" :J.; '!J
". ,~ . " ...
1 "'"
~ ..u
J -t-"
1 'l,} J ~
;iii ~~ j ... :t j 1-
:1' ''I ,
..:r ... i:
,0
'" .. <::> .... f-
A. J ..,
::J ~ 0 c:; 0 V> f-;;>; <: f-:: ..-i ::::J CIl :z. 0 C,)
0 ;?;; c:; u:l u:l 2; 0
ffi
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
~
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 24 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1 ] ....
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
I i('() I-I I
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 25 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ '\
~~ .j!) 'J
~ ~~ '") . ~ j' ...
I
~ ~ .1' j :.t;'!J
,$ ... ,~
.: "
~ ~ .u .:t ,J "
~~ ..l'
i f. J ...
] ~~ ...
:t J 1-:1' . "
, .. .... ~
<:> .... l-
"'"" ~
;:J ";:i 0 ~ u Vi
~ < s ;:J III Z 0 v
ill 0 , 6 ;:.: ~ j.!J
I I z G Z w I I
<--~--........... ~ .. --......... ------ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January :~o 10
t -¥ P ~ ~
i}-t :F ' '1' 1 \ ~
Annex- B - Appendix IV - Page 26 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
l' ] ....
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 27 January 2010
Annex- B Appendix IV Page 27 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix V
Presentation Slides
Project Description and
ESIA Scoping Slides
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix V - Page I of37
1
-,
4...l.il..;-}JJSJ~""'J~l , ........... ..;";1, .1.rJl...u~,-..: ~j'::iJ~Wj J> ~4~1 CW'j '~\i.ijlSrO .I'~.".sJI~
~I tt..:.w':il :a.....J.:. ~4JfS ~ e.J~ YI .A'll ~ ~Ijl
":'IJ~ 150)(2 .,;.Ii iJR.l1 J,...:. ~yJl f.).J.>l1 ~uu,
~:t....IJJ~
et...l...I~~ (2009 ,;;jo1,S\ 21) ~4 a
(2010 ,;;lJ,j 4 lA.l\.W1 ~"""') 4414 IJ
wL....b.Wlj .)\.4.'.11 ,.!\ljWlJ ..;.y..'J1 u~1 C" ~I •
,4-fo=JI ...iP
~------------------. • ,;;,,:;si .;;. (j"JI.wJI ~ ~ JW ~ 32 ; ~.Jo&lIU
,UollI V";' .,;;,,:;s\ .;;. (j".>I.wJ1 Wt..:..J ~IJ'i1 .l~1 ~IJU
J,I.;WI';" 'foWI.b...; J~ JW ~ 35 ~\J"'.lA.J';"0 .JJ~411 (.$\.:o;! ~I • ...,.WI .;;. ";""'.Jo&ll
-
2
3
.. ~.;ll ~i..A.l1 ":'1",4+-1500 • .)<Ii .l.p.;oll '.,JJJ)I ri.ll.:: '~I JI,...:. ~I.t-*.u..... t,Jy.:..o
1;''''''\ "L.....~ J"""1!:w1 ~,., .::.1 ..... 250 '""" Jl' 'J..i "I:;j~ ~""'; '""" ~ • ~--l.L--..;.ttf .~ _____ J"'J ~)"'-f" ·*.Y' :J .a.J.e ,,",,1-'&11, ' ....... ', ~1,~ 250
.""6().""57'~I.~
.,.". jU, ,,;,n, ,\~)'I .,a.IJf,) ,,; ~~ ~: ~~ fU:..i
Once -through System . ~\,..,. ... ",u.-, .1,J1, ,\ .... ~\.-lW
.... .,.-1IJ,i ...... "'u.-'wloll.I,..I1""..,olOo:Jl"JiU .1-..,n~..p:nas:,.:.n,..,}I'.."..,nw.n~I .....
Combine;! Cycle Power Plants Principle of Plant Operation
SC iftk;uncy
up to 40 %
CC Effleiency
0\_1060%
g-llWa
G.u TUft)in. and CombfnW·Cycle Power Pla!"!t. ~ __ '_,,,,,,·n"",, __ ... t _",,'"
16
J.;.l.t.JI ..... ..l.i+l1 ~\ ·2 ..);Iw'1.,.JIJ ,...,,":!....JI J$4f.lIJ ,,,,,,4J1J ,.:..t...t...~IJ ,~jI~1
.~..,...n ~..-,..JI ~.,.lJIJ ,.:..y.:...J~1 u.i ~.."i..W1
~ .l..o.;lIJ ~1.)4l1 -3 c:..1......JIJ .JH.~1 JS.;~I ...... )IJt,.ilyJl ~
} .... j:ill W~I.J ~~.J ~.J.J£l'l1
18
Combined Cycle Design Concept
Jl-.c.';.U .... p (20) .>.lC. .)1 t.J~ ""'.Jw::...'J1 l..ilS:ll! ~ :.)l.:il\~\.,.l..':"I...",; .. l1.Jc:..I......JI.J~1
I... ~ <-"!.J )-#-!.J Y!>.h ":!.J.i'.J~.J~.J ~ :.);
~.,..J1~·1 ,\.. \" •• 11' ""1 \ .. ell l. " ", ·.,11 ;;..,.;.,\ .l;.. ......... ~W.J'~"-.J.;<J ""!.Jt-"' ~.J'.J'_ .:
')1'»''11..1 ,~I Jt...c~ Y'"L......J1..r-l1 ....0..-11...1 ..,..y:.ll . .~I ~\ Jt..c. ~ ~..,...n j..WI
13
17
4
-'+i" (.~.ri....l.~ 8) 4>,j...l.~ 4 J:::u.. U<> M u-..l1.1.,.J ...... ~220
-'+i" .l.a.; ;i""b.J1 u~.>:!,..s 11 ~\..,... J~ U4l }:il uLhiJI c . <.::.>1;,L..J1/500 • -"till ...... ~ 220
.loa....; ~\ ().....l.;.>:! r-S 1 ~I.,..... J~ ul~':I1 uLl..;.,l\ 0
.U"~/""Jl. ...... ~ 220 ~
%80 ,-",.1I..,... ..)"> 69 ~IJ"'-I JJ"JI.l.oJ1 "" ~I.>:!"JI ~ .J.li:i C'
4-l- J.i.t:..t...... =1) 4lJ , ...... J.Jj.. .>F ~ ,-,""""I).,...i 4-l.4-JJ"'.J~ ~I ~I) ~ W:!..!-''\:WI FJ t...Y' ifo 20)(20
J~ ~.,.. (2) .l.l.c. ...-Jc. ~ l...f.l.. JS J~.,.. (2) ~ -l
ul.t.........:.J ,.4011 .J;!-"'1.,..J.l..i\J-"")loLJi ... A;-:JI • ..\L.;i.....,4 . .:t;....L.......llul.Jji."...lIJ ul> ........ lIJ .ul.'Jl
. ,"""",\.l~IJ\..I:c.IJ~IJ\..I:c.~1 ..J
.~IJ W"\.,iilIJ ~~1 J\..I:c.~1 ~
.Demineralized (J..,I......,u }G~I.is. ",jlo ~y...ll .:..~~
(Desalinated) ('~I) i:~'J1 .is. Jjlo .y...ll ~.~..!1.iU 0
.J'.iJ-l1 w"fo..!1.iU C'
20
22
24
Gas \!jl.C "-lJy.... ....... .A 220 ~"U.. (bays) <.::.>I.>.:o.J .(indoor) (...-i+- J.;.IJ) ,I..l..o.. Insulated (GIS)
....... .A 220 ~LWI Ji.Y"'! ~)I <.::.>'(,....J\.1.,J
.<.::.>'J~'JIJ ~..;+SJI ~\j)1 'jH.l :J
.~LWI Ji.Y"'! ~I ~
.tb,:i.;..ll ~..;+SJIJ w\S,IJIJ ~I J...c"J1 ~
19
;.J-lS~jl.C ~Ji (2) ~.):. 4.l.. J!; ... ;.....: JJ;flY' (2) ~ D
.61}",,~ 250 4.l.. J!;
.... ;,Wl ~I "" ~jWl ~Jil1.i J).,.,J! ~I jWI ~ ;,
jW4 ;,1.>..';11 t\..l.i;1 .l..ic ... )y....;..'J1 ~I "" J'J.".,JI ~ .• . .l..ii -Y+'" ... "J-
.c:.L"t..,.i)\l ~I .l..o.h A.;!1.;..l1 rU;,.)
.JJ;flY' J$J '.>.:o.IJ ~J~ ~Ji (2) ~
J$J (once through») .• .....!1 ... ,,6.1 <...1iS...~) IZ...P-i J\..;..;ll ~l>..>~.• J ... ..!-'
.U:!-l'J~;'~...-IJtS.;I.".., u.....:.. ~J~ ~Ji J$,
.tb,:i.;..ll ~IJ U"\,!ilIJ ~..;+SJIJ ~I J...c )II,] Y1:!U)l1
21
5
.(~I...,.ll .L,..o~) UJla.Jl ~ ~ ~I ol,i.. f>!.Ai
.~11"!.Ai
• ..:..;,;"lSJH+!1 ro!.Ai
.ot.;..Jl <.::.I.,iJI...t.,!S .... .i.i.:l !,!.Ai
. .t.JWl .t,...J1 ~ ",!.Ai
~IJ ...,..\;ill) ""*.;+SJl :.1.,..:..t.........l1 J1.,.s:."i1 &"'I' .(<.::.L..~\S '":':!il.l'.ll) ~t.s,;.lIJ (...,4iL.. . .,:;':i1
. ..,-:J.) J.,.,..,+S .;;i J.,.... (2) J~ Jj;JJ-4 JSJ i~
.(.)oL,>:i..>.I) .l.iL...... J.,.... (2) J~J
26
~1.J V"~I oJf+I-13
~.;tSJ1 oj...f.;o.'.iI -14
'::'l.I:.JJ ... ,Il.J ~1.J ~li.jll oJf+l.J ~I.)~I'::'I .... •
.CJl .. ..::D4\.SJI.J
28
~------------------• .;~l eli)1 ~ ~I .t.,r. [.;a..J ~t...::.w..;.. ,
iJI&.!J ~I ~ .)L>.,JI ~ .;~1 e\.j)1 .:".. .I;.JI ......... .i$~l eLi)1 .,I! (.::.u.....\.Jo4l1 ...,....Li I~I ...,....Li) If'l~ .I;.JI
&J..J;'" \+.Ill \.i"""", .;~I eltJ.l &.I.l\al\ .I;.JI OJ.>", JJl:j..:i:i 'J u ~ 48 rSJ ~W\ ......-.. ~ ~JJ 35 ~l .I;.J\
• .!.ofoll .:".. ..... .;.)J J..+.i.\1 -*' ~ ..,...wI 1982
i';"'150J 100 VJi eJlfoJ.J.i. 3.ll..i.. Ja.t oJi..)Oo.l1 ~.)J.lo,...:; n
.~ .::.I..).JJ 3.:".. Jil.,l!
. !.~<'~tl ~ ~!.~tl 1 .. ,~~,'"-:!~ ~"~.J~~~O
J:!~I O.)J.l~ ,~'L4~1 ~y.o.J ,,,~\ ~.J~~
.IA.~.J ,~I
25
~------------------L~I i""1.J..l..lI.J ,4~1 ;':'L..~I.J J:!-'o"I.,..,Ji
~ ;.:.UiJ.:il1 ..J-"'I1Jl:;,J ,a..u\~\ ;':'~I.JJj'il.J '4J
~~ -~)\ .;L..¥I) 4~\ ~I~\
(t;Jl .. ~~\
27
~~~~~~~~--.~ .<M~I >;l":'~J ~ .:..l.J-lIJ .jj!,'il ~J ~I_I","I ~
•• I.,.ll J.t1""'J 4,1...,.JI '::''i.x,...J1
..::.u".Jl:a.\ ~J ~IJ '-+...-Jl ~ _1","1
~IJ C:;"''j1 ';'.JJ
;U.):WlJ ~I ~I '::'1.>z..lIJ iJfl.11
~IJ J.......jwll Jf+ll ~I.i... -16
.~ Jf+lIJ .u . .!l6,3 "f+ll ,;.:.. ;;;'1»","1 .) ~I iJfl.IJ 1.!::I'iJ..
29
O'l
I'V o o 00
t.. :e. c-
~
~ . r.,
& Cf;. t t= t 1 "' :;: ., ...
. ~. t 1: "'!i;: I _
€. ': f. ;;;\; t . $'~ . \.. ",-. rt ~ £~: ~ ~ {' ~I;:.t[ t 't.
ri- i ~~ {: \ r' ~\ ~ r ~ c t~ fr.!o !:, ;i ~l. "!. ii \. iittt,_!={ "'D'DD ;;-
t $'
r , t
'" f. f
i' ~~,~, f li~ I{ lr:<t ~. I. ~ _ 1:. ~.r-1 -t'-" . ill' .. l' i' ~ ~it.'';- " " i~< t1' .... 'tr{·!.
~ ['t t ~ .;- t f f ~ t t ~ '!f. ·il~'r..·<;:"{;· ______ ~$t't ...
~
" 1 '.:
l
t ·r 'to
I I~ I ':l
'E ~
! • t :-;:
t' 1 ~
, I
l;-(0 ooG
f l..
....... 0
c·
"'- [, .!!. [f ...
fi ~ [ . L
'f; r.tf ... ~ ~ [. - '" ,., * [, .
~. r '[ '. 6'-t' 't; 'f, - f ~ f I;:. ,. t '-
t r . -~. [. 1 "' .. , f , "' L
\; £: ~ i:·~.r <i'
~li~f~f f,-(. , - I> '-_ ~ f '- 1. \' ~ {' ~,
Ie. 'to.. .' ~ .~ • "'.J.: "' C" - "". r E c. 1, l;O f i: ;: ~ l:."'£'t,~ 'f,
-DDDD~';;- ...
~
n ~ § );. +~ I'V
.\
;E ~ ;E i. 1: .; Ir [ ~ } \ i I t i. 1 t \.. ,t 11. 1 I ,.t~ 'L.
.. ~. f' \ "[ [ . .g1"t' e--'''f'''- 1\..
t~!if :!<t~ 'E t.'i.5~·~t· ! •
-~~E'~'i;l 1:'f:r.~ii, ~
(0
l:l:l~{t·~~ 0:-
'1: ~ ...... -: : ~
I ~
~f: <i' ,-v ~ t
. .t f"t..
t f~· t ' -, -b'
H~t~h ;E '- i-Er~ -. c ~ t:,'" , ~fi.~-E{ t 'Lirf.([.c t f.t'" ·"'fr. t'
"- -' t. H 'f, t !,; 'i: t r.. _' D CDC ,.-: ~
~
lil
~ ~lfl '- 'El
t~[i " ~. i!;-.~~ ~ IE ~nJ t!t 'i:
\ f<'d~';'l 1 , . l,,{£-.&: 1 c· ~ ~ 'El t £ t' . f [t fl ~ ~ [I.r t· \: E
- v -t'" .... ~ ~. i; \ ~1UH 1 ~ " f1-' i ~ ... t~· ~~~i'~ 11 ). E t'~ 1;; ... " ~ , \ - ..l~i" ~ ~
I - f'~---N -'- ~ (;" I -~ • 0 ......:... .co CII)
7
~--------------------. • u;.l~l VO ~11'.lb.lll!:" ~~I ~I ~l (J
.~\~\.SI":;'~I
..:;,~IJ jl.oJJS+. 10 vo Ji\ UJ\aJ\ ":;'~I ":;'~l .UJ\aJ1 4lsJ1
.Ji."ll ~.JA vo u.",..;SJI ~\ J,,\ .:.L.'Ut.;.l1 [1
jl.Lll) .l."i,!1 ..;.;a. c.F- 4->uJ1 UJ,I.;SJ1 ~i ..,..~ .:.L.'Ut.;.l1 .(Ji.,....tl/~1
J,..lI~4M • 'I"'WI.)",U"LJ1",~~~",~.l
, u,.I..Il.>:ilaJl. ""I,m .2 .":WI..,.,.n">"J;II"'\;\,!.3
. 'L:!<i:llll"lll,~ ~ t.'" J"lol.4 Industrial Source Complex-Short Term (ISC-STI Model
1,.;.0 # 2 5 I.;'; ""'" _;1 • .) ~}I ",U,ul -"I;,S';< ",\oI1'} ",I;,:; J- J,-II.5 . .::.I..","~I ~.), .""~I ~ J
~>w, J.,-.J1,1,.lI, ' .... ,.11 ",1;,S'.rJ1\.,J!u.t.:...::.U,l.U W;:.)I ",1;,S'.rJ1 e:-"".6 , u,.I..Il-",l..,I~
, "'~.rJIe",.7
40
.------------------~ J-II~~ • . e'tJ1.)I-1.I. .1..;:.1 J- tl.lll, ~ .!,..II v- "'Y e:-"".1
";}I- .),..,1 'v) e'..n.).1,.» ~ ..,.1...,u:l.piJI ",I...I,,1lI, J:I1..o;!I.""J.2 (~ .. ",,,.sJ1 J,....rJI. ,>lS.1I- ...,..,,,,.,':11
. .,.'l,.,SJI",I...I,,1lI.J:I1..o;!I·""1·3
. .,.,,1,,,,1 ",I...I"1lI,J:I1..o;!I.",,,.5
. tlill.,....l,) J,JW .",,).6
42
• .!..jtll [.I.,..., ~I~j ;;M.jlo...I1 ~ u...1.".1f.a1..u.......1 f';lla.ll~1 ~
.~I.HJl y.,,:; ~ ~t.:..'il Jii W)I ~.,wl tA
:.;<- J,...wl .... ,1 .... 1I :w.wl ,) ~1 J...jil ..::u.... .,.
.~le~~I~I.,. .4-; ~I :w.wl .;<-~I ..»J;.. ~~ [.I.,.. J.ooo .,.
J"i...!.l '-"" ~I~::.o W.Jl.olI":'I.;r'i:ill~""',) ~1.HJl y.J<l ~.,. .;<- e.....,...:..Jl..,J,Hl1 ,)'''il ~ '-"" V .1""1., e~1 FI .>at ~I
.... HJly.J<l
37
.!I,.J.:JI( ~~,...; J..:)
~I----------------~ ..:.~I.$)U.lI, Uu../l ~ V"1!:'"WI.l.wI.:..,t oS"" ~ L..\, .. : .,j~1 •
. .&..-II ,I.wl J! .:.>-'...,1 V" ..:.",wl
~1S1)~}I..:.c,1.U~~.'.wI.:.,t:lw.t:.llJI,....'iI: ~I \!WMJi •
r.oIt..II~,..... oS ..... , (un.ll ys:J1..:.1:t~"~' ~1S1, u.orJH'
..:.1j,,5) oS,:-., e,.J1 ft.loS~1 c.VI.~..:>.,t oS"": ~ I ~WMJI •
,..:.",w'
39
41
2008 ~'!J J,i
.)...0.11 ~4:.. •
.(t.!Vlt1iJP:l..;")e,I,.n~l~t.V.)",,~..y;.o.~·l
.""'!.t. b,N~"""'llI\,. J,t.i,(.J.I-.)"';' ;T, .... \ut,;JOI.~·2 •• 1".11 ",1oJ""" ........,1.\,0 oa".s',. ",,1.II.>J;IJ ~I """'J01l".J1 ~ ..... J.
.~.\,o IJt.--""IorJ·' JilJl .... ~ JLIi ",.... ,J.:.Ji 11ft """",,,,I t"" • 3
• .:Jf..,A ....
J..all [,4:-< • ,.,.l;..JIJ1.,,'i1 J""'.I.l1,OJl; 1,.. ... e',.,J1¥1".",. ....... 1
• '11 ... 1.111 'llJi-li -"'s!rJI. e',.,JI 1,0:,1"", ....... 2 .Io-It....;.. 'ltrll .,.,:) .),,-ii ....... 3
.(~.- .;.!.I,.l1. ¥,.,tl .\,.11 .,. ... , l,.S') e'''» ..,.,1..,.".r1 ~1.4 ,a,;.\;.J1 J.oI,..u ...... .s
,~JI;J;JI j,~1 e,ou.6 , e,Jl,,,,...,..u!~,..;JI,oII .... .,,...7
.)...o.I1~4:.. •
. e,I,.JIt .t.:.,..,IIS,:-I "" .. ". Jo- .1
. ",,""\,III.loII e,I,.JIt ~ .... vliJ1.lt:-i·2
.;u.....JI..J.U.:I""W,..,I·~..,...:It.lJOl~I ....... I.3
.~.w.,.:.u~~""J.4
.~.,.J.A:tII, ~\0.011 J/il "" -U """"JIll, "'l..p.II f."'.t .5
44
46
48
~V}1";' o>,Ir,:!l.\:-o V"', .... 1.. 01:.:. 0~'I:; Jj,>J:I"'~. ~I •
JU"i1 .:.-~ ol...~ ,=-",::J1 , ISJI,oJI .!I,J.;:lI }. ~, I$~I
.y...J1
,1"...,1 .:.- ~"'I ~W IS~I ~V1 ~t...;.. ..;. Ji,lioJI : ~11t1..l.Jt1 •
. .!I,l:I1 ,I ,u-loll .:.- ~1.,=,"':i1, ~ ..;. JolioJl,. J~I
~ m.; .• II, ~ ";-J'i .;I""~I....IyJJ ~I..I ... ~.: ~ •
~,Jlt Jj'tj1 Jot... ~, Jljjl .l.U;JI ~J'
<l.o.i ')"iJ" 1S"..1lil1 ~,~!PJ .. ';-J':i1....1?1 : ~Iltw..all •
. ¥~ .I;:.U u.1oJI.:.t.;",p.:l1, .. Jj~
: .... ~I·
. <lJ'"' e,I,.JIt .w.,..u JI.oII",:-.i1 ~ I:)
.~"",!......,I "" !!iWI.W.,..,I",:-I<.,...Ii) t.lJOl Jo- I:)
,"'~'~)III1aJ1"'.IJ.lI\,..).W.""I",,""'I""I.""').lt:-i I:)
';"'':I~I.:.:lI'''''~""~"\:JI.~",~~::a,,:,,,J1 \!1..l.Jt1 •
• ......,~ 0.10" ••• 11, ..... Wl_. ~
43
45
9
_1 __________________ _
J..,aJ1 ~4.:.. • • u....n~~~'-"JoI!JlooII,:..,....:;.l
.;10..- ,fi-.- .;lIll ~I~,. J\l.J J.i-I. WIJ!1 ..... ~~ "'~ ~.2 .(c!'l ..
. :L.1;Jl UIw J.II .... .::..w.J;u."" ",u\:1 ""'Ii ,J../.JIWI OIS:,:. .:.01".,.,.".....3
,;.. Jv.III "'~ .IIJ!, ~,.n .wJI ,...1 ".... .4 .!l.1..24L1.J~~~~"'I.loIl::l1,..i)IoIIOIS:,:.
_1-------------------J.i-1.1t6\o1, "'~I".JI)IO>l1 ",,,,,,,,,,,I joIo>oii,. ~ WioII.s,.... ~.8
. ,~I.;,$\ol, ~t.JI ~I J.".\Uol, :11 •••• 11 ",UI,t .,...; .:.\Il,. u....n
. :L.1;Jl ~.wJI:tS",,;.....,u...,MI ""....u ~ Jl,.o'iI~.9
~------------------J.,..ollli:~·
t~1 UI.;.." ~l.:J1 J .,.1>11, l,ttJl ~J ",.1,,-11, .,,'Y/I ~'lI V" .::.Ill" ~, I
u~ J ,;j:.,. ~,."t.,.. r), .;:JI ,>.WI l,ttJlli,oJlj .::..I,>l,,-llj .::..1,0"\,;11 ~,;l.-;; .3 '0-~J,)~Jl a.J.1...a.oi1,1 ~ iA\i~l')
~lJIj"..,J1 ;,:"I11i,oJ1 ,;..(~, .\'\')~I ,;tJ..".t;;I) ~I ~1r.'t, .... ...,;.4 'U~IUI.;.."
~Ij .'::'...,j uJ ur-u ;,.J-JI ",1,,>'1::11 U" ~ ... \;,;I/,ilU1 ",I.","~I ,..1 .... ...,;.5 , ,,'lI/.;I !;! """,Jp.,'jl .... "u /!:,u)/
.. I : ";"",,1 •
, e,JJ .",;..JI ,,)JI as..,.:.,. C;At,J1 ~"I ~ CI
ul....,.JI Jl' ..... .ji)JI .;,t...13 ,,;-WI ..,1< fL.-,j'.il ~: ~11.tL..<..iJ1 •
.~I,l:)I~1
49
_I------------------~ (ell:i)J.,..olI~~ •
t.I>"'- ...... ..,.."., • J>l.II ",:...,,;.. ~ >5"...) ..... ,.11 r:n "'I.\! ~.5 . ~; ........ ,.. .,01 ",1.....,1, • <Jo..J1
,;.. ",...II .. }"' ",u...r-"""";, rn'1 of ... ,;.. ... ~ ~I / ..... 1 ~,J,W.6 . ~ u,.... ......... JI .. W.~~ • J,.IoII "':...,
Uo,l".JI<>,.J1 tY';" ";p1, ... s..I...-J1 .::.~}l"......::J ~ ",u!IM,J,W. 7 . ~.IIJ! J,..,JI "'Y.- ......... ,. '~1¥
• It,lo ~I }I,. <I,.., e,.Jli ;..>I,..JI, .... "1.,.:JI tI,..~ a...~. : ";"",,1 •
..... '1.l1 a;,.u ~ J!.JI &.is, ~1.,... ..... "....1,
I.).t;/I.:;;UI,..JI, ~1.:;;ct,.:JI V" I;OWI tI,."i1;. Jiu.JI : ~ll.t\.aill •
, .;.."...'J1 trJl, ~I .:;;l:-J!, ~1.l1 • .."...'J1.;. Wt...J1 ,
51
53
10
J-JI t4;.o • "=",,,,1 JlIP .;.;.n, l,l.oJ1 "1iIO..I1 <J,\;".,..,JI.-l "",".1
.J,>.:..:II J;,ll.. .;.;.n, l,l.oJ1 "w,.n <J,\;"..."...1 "",".2
,J,Jw, ':'\!J" J\ I;'" jl"-t.. .>I...,.P 1J,:::N..;n..:.t-w.....u 1J"',...uJ! olat'J.P ,:JJ';J
'JlIP.;,o>.o,J;.;""~-3
,.J-.J1.,..u.:;1. J.I"I- ..,..",.,...,J ..... JI,lJ'Il,~1 ,,1lI,o!1';', V"''''' .1,.111.,." .'W1 ..... ,.....n.;. .... tJl ",;.,"\~I.,...,.. '#J J:lN
.~I"";I,
. ¢!~IIJ&~I':"I.~l~~~!i)!¥I4JU. e-"'J,4
. <,;l.,.>I,-}I"""e",.5
(eft) ~.),-","'Jl- ~~'il""";l~l
a.t.t..:."iI-~I.:o,.~II.!L:.i)I •
( ..... , ... Q u,.lo,:lII·1..1 u
.I;)I, ~I",I,,"\",I L:l
"'1.i:II,~WIv"''1...;J1 LI
~,'1I..;,.-;:!1 U
u....n ",1,.,1-.11 U
.."....,1 J;,ll.. 1>,1,11 m..J1",uo..:; U
>,It....11 '-0/1 u
uLo~,,,,'11 U
..
(eft) ~.),-","'Jl- ~~'i1""";1~1
J-li~ • ",J.!~,n""",) .... "",,,..l.JII- ........ YI~,....,.;J1~I"'.'-!J"'''''/;.<'t' .J
,(~.....,..."W',
.\tt.~""";cIiiJ..:aJIJ~4;.Mlm~lliU~~~~.!r.l :..J
,,;..JI~,,1~1 :.J
... l,ll ~I, ",YI"',JI ",10,;.., "'-" """"" -="'.JPI, .,.sJ1...,..n "''''' , ........ , :J (l,I,.J,\,l..) ........ ,~Ic:'.,...;.~llJ,JN.;,.,.,
,,...,..".""'!Jo\U1J1Jt:1 .... ~"""'Jo.
.~I""' ..... I}w.~.;..,.,""Jo. ,;..JI~.,. ... JIe'\ooII
"...,~...".,-
..
_, .) ~ \.)I' q.,1.;J1;;.;.n, ~ .:.Wo.JJ u.~ ;~I.;tl: ... """, •
uw..n.u..!r (J~.t.""J .1.:.>11>
:~ . . ~\..a:o~I"'I-.'iI '<f1Jl1 "" ~ J\-.'1',--Jrl1 Q
t,.,.:.J! Ub.:.l.s.t..:."il-..,.1.:0,.'11 ..,1,,-11 •
~.,; ...... ..4.;J1 -I
~IW' ..J
i:rl:-Jl.t~~.nJ~l.:..ilu...:.."':l1 -I
,J....JIJ,..,V\..IJ1 .:..J
.s"t...o.~I~."I.,:'.r'ilJ'''"I',Jio-.J!~; .J
, Ji!,.lI,..w1 ",t..;,Il ..J
."1I1-,.,.."I-'"'WI'-'I-J.I;iI,"YI..u"lI-.1,,.<SI-.,-J .... ,...,,-.,..r"' .... ,.\.;.iII,
"",;lI",t..;,Il ..J
",,': ... 11 "'[,.aI' ..... 1 ..J
~'0....""'-",,,,,....,~, :.J
55
57
..
11
<et) a..t..ll a.-Jl
J-l'1'r~ • • ~1.J1j l,o~I.::.U1..,l'iI iJO ~,!.i\.sl ~ ~.:.1.,II:I1 ~ J:,Io.i.1
.• w.,.,.n iJO ~"\.sl ~ ~ .:..1.,11:11 J:,Io.i.2
. JoaII UoI .)0.1. :a.-lI.:..I .... 1::I1 J:,Io.i.3
Ito> I.t ~W)'I a..../I.)o ~~".JI .,..ll,..u ~ 1,1.;tI..wJ .;.~ ..... ,.4 • ",!,,>1::I1...;.,MJ.:..1.!.-.-!
(et)..,.:..)~I~1
J-l11'r~ •
.... wlAJl :I:-ot....ll ",I. )"'1.: .. 11, e,.n J,.. ":'J~ ~I J:,Io.i .1
. e,.n J,.....,a..JI.).;.j;J ~1oJI "'\ol ........ '¥! J:,Io.i.2
. e,J1 J,.. u&..:..I1t ~I,.n...n .,.st....o. J:,Io.i.3
. ",t",II;:II iJO~ .:.I.!.-.-J Ito> I.t ~ .,~;tl u... e",.4
.1,iI".JI,.o-jl u... e",.5
(et)~I"""';I~1
J...aII[~ •
. '~*"1!:.I:I)II ... liIllf"",J"M ,~".s:J ~liIllI$).tJJ ~ ~I J:,Io.i.1
.J.A..Ior.n,...,....",p..y..) ~ ~ JY1 J:,Io.i.2
. ~, uj- a.j)Ul ",I".-pl e",.3
.:..1....,l1:lI iJO ~I.:..I.!'-'-J Ito> I.t ¥",II 'J,.;tI u... e"" .4
. ~;".n, .... j1 u... e",.5
..
..
""';1, .. 11, )La.".J1 V" ... WI <-,,)1 "l.>- . "'~I •
.~I
.,jdl, .1,.I1,,~..:.,.Ii 0
J.allUoi 0
.:.e1-1.I1 ...... 0
.~I.JI.I.lJl.).:.ts:..JI ...... O
61
_,----------------~ Jt>J':i1 .::A.I~I, ""'--';-J'iI ~I J..-.-..:1o.:i. "'~' •
.~~t;lJ
'---i01~ ;".....--.", L..."l~I..---..lI,.JI: ~1l,tL.....:.il1 •
. u,Jla:.~, y~,
63
~1"""';1~1 ., -.Jia;.:ll ~I .} ~I iJ"~ ~ .i~1 •
·U.,..:..niJI.,..
~ "";1",," VI' ll.ts:ll ~,:-JI ~1 \e1.,,;iI! •
. "'''.;.' J.ts:ll t;:",
65
12
. JOl<II ",,~I ~I,. ..}u.-n,w,..n ",,,,,'I.i1 UlS' ....... i, ..... ~1.3
cl) • ..} lot .:.\;ooi;;u a,.~~, a;..,.n iJI>)Il aw. ..-III'!' UlS' ....... '" ..... ~1.4 • ~l.,o.Jl, ~...,.,)I...'t .;.,II, .,:J:I1..w,tl1
• .::.I"l1::lIa;..,.n.,."\,J1 ~""IIo.II...,.,)I...'tI ....... ,.,e-:-,.S . 1t11o,PIIU ..... '.n.,.,n..,....;.6
..
.Jts::.'tI, J,l"""I,.::.~, "'JItOII, ..ilW1.:. ..... •
. ,,~.,u.I.J1 •
. ~I;>II ~}I J,...aII •
. ~I..'tI ..... ~.JI •
..}a,....I.iII.::.I..I;.JI,J.n •• '",.:.1..1,.lII ~lf'w,.::.I-:lI.;.,"'~JOl<I1~.2 .... ~fJ\l .,dl.\lot-'tl,} u..-~;,,1cl)'..} lot JOl<II "" ~I~I,.
.It:"~
"
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix VI
SELECTED PHOTOS
-~ ... -.-... --------------------- ... -----~--
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B Appendix VI- Page I of38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 2 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 3 of38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 4 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI Page 50f38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Gi74 North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B Appendix VI Page 6 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 \0
Annex- B - AppendiX VI - Page 7 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 21) 10
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 8 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 9 of 38
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for GIza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 J 0
Annex- B Appendix VI Page 10 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
-----..... "'*'.~
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page II of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project
38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B Appendix VI Page 12 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Gml North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI Page 13 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2') 10
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 14 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2(11)
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 15 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
.-.--.-----~---.-----------.------... -------ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2J 1 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 16 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ES1A for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project
38 January 2(110
Annex- B - Appendix VI Page 17 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page! 8 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 19 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20) 0
.. ~~~----.~~~-
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 20 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 21 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
-----.. ---------------------.--.--~ .. ---
ESIA for Giz.a North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2C I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 22 of
ENGfNEERfNG CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20' 0
Annex· B· Appendix VI· Page 23 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
------------ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 24 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ES[A for GIza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI: Page 25 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
--~--------~--- ------------------------------ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2C 10
Annex- B - Appendix VI Page 26 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 i 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 27 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~--... ---... --.. --.------... --.. -~ ... -----ESIA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2(110
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 28 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ ... ---... --... --~ .. -----------------ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 29 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North C()mbined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 30 of
ENGINEERII\G CONSULTANTS GROUP
~~ .... ~---.~--~ .... --~ .... --~ .. --~ .... ---ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2(1 I 0
----------... ---.. ----Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 31 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January =010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 32 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January ;010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 33 of
EI'iGII'iEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January :?O 10
Annex- B - Appendix VI- Page 34 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 2010
Annex· B . Appendix VI· Page 35 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
--.----... --.. ---.. ---... --.. ~ ... ----ESIA lor Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
---- .. -~---
Annex~ B - Appendix VI - Page 36 of
ENGINEl:RING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESLA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project 38 January 20 I 0
Annex- B Appendix VI - Page 37 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project
38 January 2010
Annex- B - Appendix VI - Page 38 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Annex C
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDER INVOLVEMENT
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- C - Page J of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1.
2.
.. _ .. _ .. _--
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERE INVOLVEMENT
Consultation with Affected Stakeholders
Given it's broad scope, an EIA study potentially involves a large number of stakeholders. The concerns and viewpoints of all parties interested in and affected by the project should be taken into account in reaching a decision on the project. Informed views of farmers segment of the affected population are critically important to the EA process because different groups use, and are familiar with, different parts of the environment and will be affected to different degrees by the project.
Public and stakeholder involvement is particularly important to developing an understanding of the nature and extent of potential sociocultural impacts, and to assessing the suitability and acceptability of various measures that might be employed to prevent or mitigate impacts, or to compensate affected groups for unavoidable residual effects.
Classification of Stakeholders
Each stakeholder group will have a different interest in being involved in the EA process:
• The developer or proponent needs to know where to site a project and how to minimize adverse environmental impacts; and what issues are likely to be of concern to regulators and the affected community.
• An investor needs to know how the impacts will affect the viability of the project and what liabilities are incurred.
• Regulatory authorities need to know the extent of impacts and whether they are acceptable; and they will use EA study results to decide on their response to specific permit applications.
• Government policy makers will want to know the implications of the project for other projects/plans/programs they may wish to promote.
• Regional planners need to know how the project might affect or interfere with adjacent developments and land uses.
• The local community and its representatives will need to know how the project's impacts will affect their quality of life.
• Public interest groups (I.e., Non-government organizations or NGO's) may be interested in whether the project is consistent with sound environmental management practices.
--_._ .. _ .. --_.------- ---_._ .. _ .. -
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- C - Page 2 of9
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
3.
• Politicians need to know who is affected and in what way, and what issues should be of concern.
Purpose of Stakeholders Consultation
The purpose of taking these viewpoints into account is to improve project viability. The World Bank (1991) has found that where such views are seriously considered and incorporated in the EA process, projects are likely to be more successful. The Bank provides some useful guidance regarding the extent and level of stakeholder involvement in the EA process in its Sourcebooks (World Bank, 1991-Chapter 7).
The purpose of the consultation effort should be:
• to inform interested groups and individuals about the proposed development, its potential impacts, and measures which will lessen impacts and protect the environment;
• to provide opportunities for timely feedback, (i.e. for the public to voice concerns, comment on proposals and evaluate alternatives);
• to identify problems, needs and values; .
• to minimize misunderstandings about the scope and impacts of the project and increase public confidence in the proposed development;
• to ensure decisions have adequately considered the concerns and values of the stakeholders -- particularly the affected community{ies);
• to seek approaches to problem solving and hopefully resolve conflicts; and
• to contribute to an increased awareness and understanding of project plans and activities.
ESIA for Giza l\onh Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- C - Page 3 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVEMENT
Memorandum-1
To : File From : Assistant Project Manager Place Fishing Activity Area, around 5 km northward direction from the proposed site Date Tuesday, 2ih October 2009 Attended by Present for the Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
Eng. Maher Aziz Bedrous
Present for ECG Eng. Hassan Atta
Present for Fishermen 1. Salama Hassouna 2. Boltyyah Abu-Eisha 3. Hammouda EI-Maasarany 4. Mohammady EI-Sharkawi 5. Eid Bastawi 6. Omran Khalil
Subject Minutes of meeting with group of fishermen.
The principal points discussed in this meeting consisted the following:
1. Where are they fishing? 2. What are the areas of good fishing activity? 3. What about fishing at EI-Kata area?
• EI-Kata segment of EI-Rayyah EI-Beheiry canal and the power plant site is not an area for commercial fishing activity.
• No commercial or art is anal fishing is found in this area.
• Only around 7-13 fishermen fishing daily on the spot located 5km northward direction of the Giza North site.
• Fishing has long historic traditions in the Nile River and its branches. It represents one of the important features of the life customs of delta people, irrespective of its economic value.
• General Authority for Fishery Development is the main body responsible of fishing activities in Egypt. West Delta for Fish Wealth -
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- C - Page 4 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
a zonal division of the General Authority - is responsible of fishery works in West Delta, which includes water surfaces extend along about the Rosetta Branch and its sub-branches.
• There are many fishing farms in north delta area.
• The number of fishermen utilizing the area in question is estimated to about very few or engaged in fishing part time.
• Traditional practice has shown that the impacts of the warm water from a power plant are highly localized. At the point of discharge the water temperature is about 8 degrees above ambient. 50-70 meters from the discharge point the temperature is 5 degrees above ambient and at 90-100 meters 3 degrees higher. 300 meters downstream there is no longer any difference in temperature. The fishermen generally utilize a 1 km stretch, roughly 500m in each direction from the pOint of discharge.
• Most of the fisheries activities in West Delta are concentrated at the northern part of the Rosetta Branch. The effects on the fisheries of warmer water returned to the water body from similar power plants along the bankal zones of Nile River and its branches are well known. Experience from about ten other power plants - located on bankal areas of the Nile River and its branches- that have operated for a number of years- indicate that the overall impacts on fisheries of slightly warmer water actually are positive, and consultations with the fishermen indicate that the catches in these areas have increased rather than decreased. Since this is part-time, small-scale fisheries no statistics are available, but after many years the warmer water around the various points of discharge, is clearly perceived by the fishermen to have positive effects.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Junuary 2010
Annex- C Page 5 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVEMENT
To : File From : Project Manager Place
Memorandum-2
Egyptian Environmental Affairs Agency, Central Directorate for Environmental Assessment, Maadi Headquarter Date Wednesday, 11th November 2009 Attended by Present for the Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
Eng. Maher Aziz Bedrous
Present for EEAA Headquarter Office Ms. Amany Salah Es-Said Ms. Amira Kamel Mohamed
Present for ECG Eng. Hassan EI-Banna
Subject Minutes of meeting with EEAA Environmentalists on the project effect and the area proposed for the power project.
The principal points discussed in this meeting consisted of the following:
1. NOx emissions of the power plant, under all operational regimes, should be kept within the standards.
2. Combined effect of the Giza North power project and the surrounding background facilities in the area must not exceed the upper background air quality limit for the EI-Kata area.
3. Type of pollutants emitted to the atmosphere by the power plant shouldn't exceed, when superimposed to existing pollution loads, stipulated regulations.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- C - Page 6 of9
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVEMENT
To : File From : Project Manager Place
Memorandum-3
Local People's Council Premises in Imbaba and Menshat EI-Qanater Date Saturday, 21 st November 2009 Attended by Present for the Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
Eng. Maher Aziz
Present for Local People's Council Mr. Nageh Afifi Abdel-Rahman
(Member) Mr. Shaaban Abdel-Hamied Mahmoud Hanafi
(Member) Mr. Fathy Abdel Samad Abdel-Wahed
(President. Kafr Hegazy) . Mr. Osama Rabea Mabrouk
(Member, Nekla) Mr. Mahmoud Ali Abdel-Majeed
(Member, AI-Hager)
Present for ECG Eng. Hassan EI-Banna Eng. Hassan Atta Ms. Iman Ismail
Subject Minutes of meeting with Local People's Council representatives.
The principal points discussed in this meeting consisted of the following:
1. Giza North Power Project is a big zonal, as well as national, project and real benefit shall be earned to the local society as well as the whole nation.
2. Benefit from the project to the Local Community mainly includes new job opportunities for graduate youth. Giza North society is an rurallabour featured. The problem is that the second generation seeks job opportunities and the power project will provide only some of them.
3. Necessary data on socio-economic setting in the project area, including NGOs information and data sheet, will be provided to EIA preparers within few days.
ESIA for Giza North Combmed Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- C - Page 7 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVEMENT
To : File From : Project Manager Place
Memorandum-4
The sit of the Proposed Giza North Power Project and surrounding area Date Thursday, 26th November 2009 Attended by Present for the Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
Eng. Maher Aziz
Present for Local Farmers Fellahl Atwa Mohamedein Fellahl Abu-Ghali Saadoun Fellahl Eleiwa EI-Mohammadi Fellahl Bashar Kotb Fellahl Zein Ed-Din Hassan Fellahl Younes Abdel-Ghaffar Ali Fellahl Zohdi Naaoum Badawi Fellahl Gaber EI-Gaafarawi
Present for ECG Eng. Hassan Atta Ms. Iman Ismail
Subject
This was the first visit to the site by ECG during this study and represents the ninth visit, considering previous eight visits made by baseline studies teams of experts. The major purpose was to investigate present condition of the site and meet with some farmers around it. The study team walked the perimeter of the site. The team also discussed the project with local farmers, approximately five of which presently farm the land along the proposed routing of the transmission lines.
Discussions with the local farmers indicate that they are well aware of the project. They expressed a variety of views, with some being accepting of the project and its associated development of the area, others expressed objection. Those expressing objection saw the project from a personal basis and were concerned with the compensation level that they would receive.
When compensation policy was explained to the farmers, they changed their opposition expressing acceptance under fair, unbiased compensation.
ESIA for GIza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- C - Page 8 of 9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
PUBLIC & STAKEHOLDERS INVOLVEMENT
Memorandum-5
To : File From : Project Manager Place The Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation Date Wednesday, 2nd October 2009 Attended by Present for the Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC)
Eng. Maher Aziz
Present for the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation Eng. Ibrahim EI-Dessouki Dr. Fathi EI-Gamal Dr. Mohamed Rushdy Dr. Ms. Dalal Abd EI-Hamid Eng. Tarek Samir Gamil
Present for ECG Eng. Hassan EI-Banna Ms. Iman Ismail
Subject Meeting with the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation to discuss the water requirements for the proposed 1500 MW electrical generating project to be constructed near the village of EI-Kata.
The principal points discussed in this meeting consisted of the following:
1. General overview of the history of the project.
2. Brief description of the project as related to the water requirements: Water requirements- 27 m3/sec. More than 99% of the water will be returned to the river. Temperature rise across the condenser is 8 cC.
3. Requested river flow, level, cross-sections and water quality records for the EI-Rayyah EI-Beheiry Canal at or near the Giza North site.
Dr. Fathi EI-Gamal stated that there is a surface level recording stations upstream and downstream the Giza North site and water levels are recorded daily at these locations, discharge of flow volume is not measured and no water quality records are available. Dr. Mohamed Rushdy stated that it would be safe to assume that the discharge measured at these stations could be used at the Giza North site.
Eng. Ibrahim EI-Dessouki suggested that the Hydrualics Research Institute and the National Research Center· would provide measurements relative to water quality.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I ()
Annex- C Page 9 of9
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix E
Non-Technical Summary
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2(110
Annex- 0 - Appendlx- E - Page 1 of I
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix C
Leaflet I Agenda
ESIA for Giza :Jorth Combined Cycle Power Project .f anuary :,010
Annex- D - Appendlx- C - Page 1 of 1
r-W\ t~~l
~\ ~\ ~I :OWl ~t.:i.AJ ; ~ .• t .. .... ~ t,..;-...r-
~ I j I;, i t..9~
J ~ ., ~ J-4-S' o~1 -. ~J-O oJ.9~ ~ 750 x 2 0 J .J...j
wl.9~ . -
I" 1 -~ ...>JA J:H (.j
u~~~I~t1
o J:AJI -~JlI
2010.>.!~ 11 h~ ~IJ oy!.WI
~1.:J-+Sll [Llj~ &~W, ~~
'4~l ~~~ i.)A\l.$Jl ib)ih
~WI ~~ 4.a..:\.:i.ll wtS~I i,$.l::I.) ~ ,s:-4JfSll [I.lt~ oJlllill ~y!. ~1 i.~l.t'! U""',.,.ill e-"wyll ) .. ..b) ~ ~ ~ w.........li ~J'~ ,,~~ 0-"> ~j.o ~'l4..sl..blIJ ,,~~I i.)jJ lAU:W..,.:;ll 4l\..b11 tLbi J:l~ ~y...,J ~ "l:i.J" 4..1 < ~ .. ·'1 .... <~.. ,~I i.,,\....iSJ1 ~~I.......:.:i§'il :tJc.U1\ ~ J ...y::. .,.,......... ..J-"""" W..,............ J, J, < ~
.. ~yJl i..)J.l11 r~ WI-" .. ~ 750x 2 o.J~ i.~\ JW "~...>P 4...b.:......
~. l...J .• <\ ~WI ~ . ·11 PGESC " -< ._.11 ~ .,.c.,lj ...>--' J ~" .. J(i:-W .. ->-""'" 0 ~ ...>--' \ J
~J ~J ('JA .. • .. ;\Lj)UI ~\ wl~ ,,~~I '(1...:"Jj'! o.)ALilI
.. ,: ... 11:Lc.~ If ~ • ~ ~ 4..J ~ ~ k... I_'ll.i! ~I 1...B-'-'4!"""" • ->--" ~ J ~ J, J ~ .. ~ ~ J
wl...>-PJ~ ~~I Engineering Consultants Group (ECG) " .. ».uL:.J....'i1
tJy.:;..JI \~ ~t....:i.:;..'iIJ 4;\))\1 wl.):!J4.:.il1 I'JJO' wLI.J~ "I..,}?-'i 4....j)UI ~\
4.s~1 ClI~
,,~~I '(!.ti..i'! 0 .)AWl ~ y:;. 4..J:U..J I -" .. ." L.;, _.. ~ \,.,..J
(202) 2574 -0550 : 0# (202) 2579 -3054 : ~\j
• • ••••••
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix F
Presentation Slides:
ESIA for GIza l'.orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Project Description and ESIA Scoping Slides
Annex- 0 - Appendlx- F - Page I of 1
ENGINEEruNG CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix A
Advert
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2C 10
Annex- D - Appendix- A - Page 1 of 2
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- A - Page 2 of2
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix B
Invitation Card
ESIA lor Giza l\orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- B - Page I of2
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
;/').'11 ~l...I~ .lI.:l.c.?l! ~I ~1~1y?-)l1 J~J ~
o~1 oJRJI J...J, .~Jf5 J;l~ ~ e~ d J~;." V" • x" ;; .)lP .. ~ yJl ;; Jylll f'~
. .. .. uJ ''IJ:f
~L.......! .i. A ,,1 I (.)M~I 0I-4~\ r,Ijj)l oJAtill ~~ OJ.l) ~:AJ
~ ,,,,,WI (, "'-'\ ~~ - ' __ I -<-:~~ (, .l.l -.,;.;-. JY""""'... . J.,........... r-- . y;..
i~4~.\l41~I~J~ ~\.S~l
y • ,. JA " J.i1.,J1 ~~\ f' ~ . 6..4- ~IJ ;; ~I ~L..JI fLA:i ~
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 - Appendlx- B - Page 2 of2
ENGINEERlNG CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix D
List of Invitees and List of Attendees
ESIA for Giza j\.orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page I of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
1 . List of Invitees
ES1A for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project Annex- 0 Appendix- 0 - Page 2 of27 January 20 I 0
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
List of the Invitees Invited to the Public Consultation Meeting
Held on Monday 11th January 2010,11:00 am at Pyramisa Hotel of the Giza Area
Ser. Name Occupation
_~k Ms. Mawaheb Abu EI-Azm Chief Executive Officer, EEAA
2. Dr. Ms. Fatma Abu Shouk Head of EIA Division (EEAA) -. .
i General Direct~r of Power Projects, EIA 3. i Dr. Hisham El-Agamawi • Department, EEAA
4. Eng. Mahmoud Shawki General Director for Industrial Projects, EIA Department, EEAA
5. Eng. Amany Salah Director for Energy Projects, EIA Department,
I EEAA
6. Eng. Amira Abdel-Hakim Director for Industrial Projects, EIA Department, !
EEAA I
7, Dr. Atwa Mohamed Ali General Director for EEAA Greater Cairo Regional Branch
8. Dr. Eng. Hafez Salmawi , Managing Director, Egyptian Electrical Utility and I i Consumer Protection Regulatory Agency
9. Eng. Hassan Nagm I Chairman of Egyptian Electricity Transmission i Company (EETC)
10. • Dr. Eng. Mohamed Awad Chairman, EEHC
I. Dr. Eng. Kamel Yassin Executive Board Member for Planning, Research and Service Companies Affairs, EEHC
Eng. Ms. Fawziyya Abu-Neima Executive Board Member for Affiliate Companies, EEHC
\3. Acc. Salah Awad Executive Board Member for Economic, Financial
I & Administrative Affairs, EEHC 14. i Dr. Hassan Mahmoud Sector Head, Information Department, EEHC
15. Dr. Ms. Nahed Haggi Consultant, Research & Testing, EEHC
16. I Eng. Maher Aziz Bedrous Head of Sector for Environmental Management Studies
17. Eng. Ahmed Salah Sector Head for Steam Power Projects, EEHC
18. I Eng. Mohamed Abdel Bary Sector Head for Gas Power Projects, EEHC
19. Eng. Ahmed Hassan General Director for Civil Works, EEHC
20. ! Eng. Ms. Fatma Maayouf General Director for Generation Planning, EEHC I
21. Eng. Mohamed Et-Tablawi General Director for Power Plant Studies, EEHC
. 22. Eng. Ms. Dalia Nour Ed-Din Environmentalist, PGESCo 1----
Director of Structures, PGESCo 23. Erig. Anob Condo
24. I Eng. SherifShetta Assistant Eng., PGESCo
- .. -~- .... --~ .... -~-~ .... -----------------.... ~---
ESIA for G iza ~orth Combined Cycle Power Project January ;010
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 3 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Ser. · Name 25. Eng. Gasser Saber
I 26. Eng. Ashraf EI-Far
27. Mr. Gobal
• 28. Eng. Ashraf Nassar
29. Mr. Serage Eddin EI-Sayyed
i 30. Ms. Amani Selim
l~31. Eng. Abdel Rehim Salah
32. • Chem. Hassan Akl I 33. Dr. Hamed Korkor
I 34. • Eng. Sherif Ismail
35. Eng. Ibrahim Ahmed
36. i Eng. Abdel-Hamid EI-Mokaddem
• 37. · Mr. Hemdan Abdel-Sattar
~. I i Dr. A I-Sayed Tawfik Moustafa
I 39. • Dr. Magdi Abbass Saleh
40. Eng. Farag Mahmoud Yamani
• 41. I Eng. Attia Ibrahim Omar I
I 42. I Dr. Ali Abdel-Azim Toailab
• 43. • Dr. Salah EI-Hadidi Ali
44. Dr. Ahmed Badawi
45. Dr. Fathi El-Gamal
46. Eng. Ibrahim A. EI Desouky
I 47. Prof. Dr. Kamal Tamer Hindi
1 48. I Prof Dr. Aleyya Abdel Shakour i
49. I Chem. Vasser Hassan Ibrahim
50. • Eng. Adel Hassan Amer
• 51. Prof Dr. Ahmed Sayed Morsi
52. • Prof Dr. Mohamed Anwar EI-Dib
53. Prof Dr. Mohamed M. AI Abdi
54. • Prof Dr. Osama Ahmed Ali
55. Prof Dr. Mohamed Ismail Badawi
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Occupation Project Eng., PGESCo
Executive Assistant, PGESCo
Talkha Project Manager, PGESCo
General Director of Power Projects, PGESCo
Environmental Quality Sector, EGPC
Environmental Quality Sector, EGPC
Egyptian General Petroleum Corporation
Egyptian General Petroleum Corporation
Technical Expert, EGAS
Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, EGAS
Deputy Chairman, General Authority for Fishery Development (GAFD)
Department of Fish Resources (GAFD)
Aqua-culture Specialist (GAFD)
Chairman, Egyptian General Authority for Shore Protection Sector Head, Studies & Research, Egyptian General Authority for Shore Protection Chairman, National Research Institute of Astronomy & Geophysics (NRIAG) Associate Professor, NRIAG
Associate Professor, NRIAG
I Director, Hydraulics Research Institute
Deputy Director, Hydraulics Research Institute
Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center
• Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center Air Protection from Pollution Unit, National Research Center Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
i
I
!
i i
I 1
I
I
I
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 4 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Ser. Name I
56. · Dr. Mohamed Bakr M. Ibrahim
57. Prof Dr. Mansour M. EI Bardisi
58. Dr. M. Mahmoud Bassyoni
59. Dr. Khaled Nabil Helaly
60. Prof. Dr. Mohamed Yousry
61. • Dr. Aly Nasser Hassan
16z.- Dr. Fathi Bekhit Shenodah
63. Dr. Fathi Saad
64. Mr. Moussa Hussein
65. · Dr. Eng. Adel Helal
66. Mr. EI-Sayyed EI-Bou.raaie
67. Eng. Anwar Abdel-Khalek
68. Eng. Mohamed Abdel-Gawad Ghalloush c---_._-
69. Dr. Ms. Hanaa Mahmoud Abdel-Aziz
. _-70. Dr. Said Ahmed Ali
• 71. Ms. Soaad Sayyed Guwei\ly
~~. Walid Ibrahim 73. r. ~lohamed Nabil
~ Dr. Eng. Ad,] Heia]
Mr. Shehata Saad Ali
. Mr. Gamal Mahmoud Fahmi
77. Mr. AsIan Abdel-Ghany
78. Mr. Nageh Afifi Abdel Rahman
• 79. Mr. Shaaban Abdel-Hamid
i 80. Mr. Mohamed Shaban
!81. Mr. Rashed Abdel-Bary
82. Mr. Ramadan Bendary
83. Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany
84. Mr. Mahmoud M. Gharib
85. Mr. Nageh Afifi
i 86. Mr. Mohamed Ali Fahmi
87. Mr. Hamada Sayyed Ahmed
-_._.-----
ESIA for ::Jizal'.onh Combined Cycle Power Project January 2)10
Occupation Water Quality Unit, National Research Center
Noise Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Ain Shams University Senior Transport Expert, ENIT
Transportation & Traffic Planning, Faculty of Engineering, Cairo University Transportation & Traffic Planning, Faculty of Engineering, AI-Azhar University Ecological Studies Department, Ain Shams University Head of Acoustics Department, National Institute for Standards
Governor of 6 of October
Secretary General of 6 of October Gov.
President of Local People's Council of 6 of October
Governor's Assistant for Civil Defence
neral Director for Occupational Health & Safety
Director for Environmental Affairs
Head of Environmental Commission of 6 of I October Gov .
Director of Environmental Health
Information Center
Information Center
Information Center
Local People's Counci I of 6 of October Governorate
Local People's Council of 6 of October Governorate
Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater
Local Council of Imbaba & Menshat E1-Qanater
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
NGOs Representatives
1mbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
1mbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens i
Annex- D - Appendlx- D - Page 5 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Ser. Name 88. Journalist. Karam Asian
89. Mr. Ragab Moawad
90, I Mr. Abdel-Fattah Abdel-Ghany
I 91. Fellah! Hanafi Mabrouk
i 92. Fellah! Abdel Razik Ahmed
93. I Fellah! Motawea Abdel-Mawgoud
I 94. Fellah! Mortada Mosbah
95. Fellah/ Atwa Mohamedein
96. Fellah! Abu-Ghali Saadoun
.97. I Fellah! Eleiwa El-Mohammadi
: 98. Fellah! Bashar Kotb
199. Fellah! Zein Ed-Din Hassan
100. Fellah! Younes Abdel-Ghaffar Ali
101. Fellah! Zohdi Naaoum Badawi
102. Fellah! Gaber El-Gaafarawi
103. Mr. Abdel-Hamid Omar
104, : Salama Hassouna
105, Boltayyah abu-Eisha
106. Hammouda El-Maasarany
107. Mohammady El-Sharkawi
108. Eid Bastawi
109. Omran Khalil
110. Mie Salama
III. : Ashraf Abd EI-Zaher
112 .. Nabil Sedeek
I 113. Ali Elshafe
i
114. Bothina Abd EI Monoum Moustfa
115. I Ashraf Moustafa Elfar
116. Mohamed Abd EI-Aziz
117, Eng. Saied Mohamed Badawy
118. Ayman Abu-Laid
119. Eng. Ahmed Imam
120. Eng. Soliman Mohamed Soliman
121. Eng. Mohamed Esh-Sheikh
122, Eng. Mohamed Ez-Zaidy
123. Eng. Mohamed Habib
ESIA for GIza North Combined Cycle Power Project .I anuary 20 10
Occupation Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens' I Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
~baba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
mbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
1mbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
Imbaba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
~baba & Menshat EI-Qanat .. Citizens
baba & Menshat EI-Qanater Citizens
AI-Watany Political Party
Fishermen
Fishermen
Fishermen
Fishermen
Fishermen
Fishermen
Broad cast
Algomhurya Newspaper
Alahram Elmasae
Akhbar - Elyom
Egyptian Electricity Holding Company I
PGESCo Company
Egyptian Electricity Transmission Company I General Manager of South Sinai Zone (GASCo)
Journalist, Elmasry Elyom i
Chairman
I Head of Cairo Power Generating Sectors
Sector Chief of Cairo West Power Plant Project
Head of Sector for Power Plants Technical Affairs
Head of Sector, El-Tebbin Power Plant Project
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 6 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Ser. Name 1--'
Eng. Ahmed En-Nemr 124.
125. Eng. Youssef Esh-Shafiee
126. Eng. Es-Sayyed Mohamed Osman
127. Eng. Maher Et-Tohami
~28. I Chemist. Afifi Afifi Ibrahim
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2,) 1 0
Occupation Head of Chemistry Sector
General Director for Technical Affairs
~ of Sector, Shoubrah El-Kheima Power Plant
General Director for Industrial Safety
General Director for Health & Safety
Annex- D - Appendix- D Page 7 0[27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
2. List of Attendees
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- D • Page 8 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Plant Project (2 X 750 MW)
Date: 11 January, 2010 Place: Pyramis a Hotel, EI Giza ,El Lotus
List of Attendances
Serial ' Name Position Work of Place Telephone
l. Eng. Hasan EI Sana Consultant of the project ECG 0101716679
2. Dr. Hamdy Hashem Expert of EIA ECG 0106508810
3. Dr. Nabil Mahmud Abu I Technical Expert ECG 022744740 Zeid --
4. Eng. Samar Yousif Refaai Civil Engineer ECG 0100950021
5. Eng. Radwa Mohamed Civil Engineer ECG 0102427330 Sakr
6. Ragab Moawad Hegazy Member People's Assembly 0129001394
7. Hany Ragab Journalist EI Sayan
8. Hany Abd Computer Science Wardan ,Embaba 0189677818 Teacher Sq.
9. Amira A bd EI Hakim EEAA Ministry of 0123874929 Mohamed Environment
-~~I---
10. I Prof.Dr. Kamal Wadea Research Center Ministry of 30615 i Khalil Scientific Research i
-.-~--
II. i Ahmed Abd EI Samea Security Manger Cairo Company For 0101804264 Ahmed Electricity
Production
12. Saber Ghareb Mohamed Driver Cairo Company For 0104689638 Electricity Production
13. Atef Sales Deputy Cairo Company For 0101437075 Electricity Production
14. Saeed Kamal F oad Driver Cairo Company For 0119105262 Electricity Production
15. Maher Labeb Diver Cairo Company For 0182328894 Electricity Production
16. Amr Mustafa Fathy Journaling Photographer EI Doustor Journal 0126819400
17. Eng. Mahmud Shawky Manger of Industrial Ministry of 0103066922 Production Environment
18. Eng. Ali Hussin Ali Manger of Purchases Cairo Company For 01200358898 Dep. Electricity
! Production
ESIA for Giza l\onh Combined Cycle Power Project January 2:J I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 9 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Serial Name Position
19. Eng. E! Sayed Mohamed Manger of Shobra EI Osmn Khema Station
20. Sayed Esawy Gad Manger of Contracts Oep.
21. Mohamed Abd El Gawad Manger of 6th October Gholosh Environmental Affairs
22. i Mohamed Abd EI Hafez Manger of Production El Zen Oep.
23. Eng. Magdy Anwar Manger of Projects Oep. Hussin
24. i Eng. Enaam El Shazly
25. Eng. Amgad Samir Start Up And Contractor Chief
26. Eng. Mohamed Oeyaa Project Manger Hasan
27. Ashraf Nasar Technical Manger
28. Mohamed Helmy Habib Manger of Teben Station
29. El Sayed Ahmed Badawy Manger of Finance Oep.
30. Ragya Khalil Manger of Municipal Union
31. Samya Mohamed EI Manger Of Human Sayed Naga Resources
32. Emad Hasan Orf Executive Secretary of Company Manger
33. Yasser Mohamed Ahmed Manger
34. Ata Mohamed Ahmed Manger of Information Oep.
35. i Naser Mahmud Soliman i Chemist Expert
i 36. ! Ahmed Mustafa Emam i Manger
i i
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Work of Place Telephone
Cairo Company For 0120035771 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0105531672 Electricity Production Governorate of 6th 0129519428 October Cairo Company For I 0122378616 Electricity Production Cairo ~?mpany For I 0109483573 ElectrICIty ! Production P Gasco 0105040030
P Gasco 0101688445
Projects Oep. 0103784003
P Gasco 0122180419
Cairo Company For 0122378179 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0109483963 Electricity Production Municipals 0160489950
Cairo Company For 0122330350 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0225740550 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0225740550 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0121034012 Electricity Production
• Cairo Company For 0121809496 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0224054052 Electricity Production
Annex- D· Appendix- D - Page 10 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Serial Name Position
37. Moamed Sultan Abd El Manger of Projects Oep. Hamid
38. Eng. Rehab Yousry E\ Mechanical Engineer Saved
39. Eng. Mona Mohamed Abd Manger of Chemicals EI Aal Oep.
40. Eng. Adel EI Sayed Manger of execution Oep.
41. Soliman Abd El Hamed Mechanical Engineer Soliman
42. Eng. Mohamed Mokhtar Manger of Stations Rafat Affairs Oep.
43. Khairy Mohamed HanafY Manger of Finance Oep.
44. Nady Ahmed Mosaed Manger of Studies Oep.
45. Esam Ahmed El Adawy Manger of Security
46. Amer Abd El Karem Manger of Security Mohamed
47. Ahmed Mohamed Ahmed Manger of Labs, Researches and Tests Oep.
48. Afefy Afefy Ibrahim HSE manager
49. Amany Salah EI Saeed Manger of Electrical projects
50. Eng. Yousif Saeed El Manger Of researches Gebaly and studies
51. Amera Sayed Mohamed Chemistry laboratory Saber manager
52. Eng. Ibrahim Syed Mechanical maintenance Mohamed senior
53. Badr Mohamed abu el Contracting and soud purchasing manager
54. Eng. Mohamed alsayed IT manager ahmed
ESIA for Giza l\orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Work of Place Telephone
Cairo Company For 0225771577 Electricity Production Outch Land 0107164022 Technology Cairo Company For 0120600761 Electricity Production Power Station of 0102756488 Shoubra El Khema P Gasco 0101636448
Cairo Company For 0129002977 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0225794862 Electricity Production C.E.P.C. 0122378515
C.E.P.C. 0114161262
C.E.P.C. 10127931670
The Egyptian 0105024811 Holding company electricity Cairo Company For 0106754538 Electricity Production Ministry Of 0101948860 Environment Cairo Company For 0105038940 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0118571158 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0104672357 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0123530428 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 006890697 Electricity Production
Annex- D Appendix- D - Page 11 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Serial Name Position
55. Bothayna abd el monem Environmental studies manager
56. Saad i Accountant- projects dep.
57. Mohamed mostafa Accountant- projects dep.
58. D\ kotb kamel Mohamed ------
59. Said ahmed mahmoud Chemical lab manager
60. Magdi al aaydi Plant design CE
61. Hazem hegab 1ST
62. Ali basyouni Engineer
63. Badawi asaker Chief of local council
64. Abd el kadir hashim Chemist- Sabteya plant
65. Mohamed Mohamed abdin Engineer- Sabteya plant
66. ahmed kamel Captain
67. Tarek al azori Engineer
68. Amro swidan Engineer
69. magdi mohammed Engineer amahmoud
70. Sara salah ateia sonbol Chemist
71. Noha mohammed Engineer
72. Shedrif mohammed Security researcher A. Rahman
73. Khaled al sayed A. Aziz Security researcher
74. -_ ... _ .. _------ Environmental affairs managers
75. Eid irahim asran General manager
76. Ashraf el Far Engineer
77. • Gomaa ibrahim gomaa Operation manager
•
78. Ibrahim ali HSE manager
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Wor:-k of Place Telephone
The Egyptian 0222616531 Holding company electricity Cairo Company For 0121031283 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0121778375 Electricity Production Ministry of health 012349451
Cairo Company For 0124166819 Electricity Production PGESCO 0103996164
PGESCO I 0105142568
PGESCO 0103429889
Imbaba 0106760444
Cairo Company For 0105292213 Electricity Production Cairo Company For 0103385260 Electricity Production Giza police 012583491
PGESCO 0122231617
PGESCO 0102581306 PGESCO 0106959907
EEHC 010770606272 EEHC 0123801984
CEP 0101322592
CEP 0121372675
Cairo Company For 0122657069 Electricity Production 6 tl1 October 0119738881 governorate PGESCO 0101831234
Cairo Company For 0129572259 Electricity Production Cairo governorate I --
Annex- D • Appendix- D - Page 12 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
~Name Position
79. Mohammed ahmed el Chief department sheikh
80. Tarik abd el Shafi Monshaat al kanater mayor
81. Ahmed el nemr Chemist-west Cairo project chief
82. Alsayed mohammed Chief manager ahmed
83. Ali mohsen ahmed Chief manager
84. Mohammed anwar ghazi Chief manager
85. Seham al nadi hasan Chemist
86. Maryan magdi foad Chemist
87. Mohammed said Instrumentation department manager
88. Abd el Kader mohammed Chief manager
89. Mohammed nader ibrahim Engineer
90. Sahar ahmed taha Environmental affairs department chief
91. Fayez nagy abu seif Farmer
92. Ibrahim mahdi abu seif Farmer
93. Mohammed ali A.magid Farmer
94. Eid nafea Farmer
95. I Mohammed mahmoud Farmer katoush
96. Hanafi A.Hamid Farmer
97. Hamada AbueIfotouh Environmental affairs soliman department chief-tebbin
98. Sayed mohammed Instrumentation department manager
99. Walid al sayed ibrahim Vice Parliament member gebreel
100. Mostafa sammaa Pari iament member
~MOhab Energy consultant
102. karam asIan Jornalist
ESIA for Giza i"orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Work of Place Telephone
West Cairo 0123264430 company 6th October 0121168070 governorate West Cairo 981 company West Cairo plant 948
West Cairo plant 0106598136
West Cairo plant 0105046993
The Egyptian 0101130196 Holding company electricity The Egyptian 0192053116 Holding company electricity West Cairo I v vv';u 7401
Cairo Company For 0122371701 Electricity I Production
Theeng~~e~~~;e 10124648403 consultin Cairo Company For 0101314221 Electricity Production Abu ghalib- imbaba 0102450665
Abu ghalib- imbaba 0169892182
Abu ghalib- imbaba 0171195746
Abu ghalib- imbaba
Abu ghalib- imbaba 0166112304
Abu ghalib- imbaba
Tebbin plant 0101779725
South Cairo plant 0166151869
Peoples assembly 0103418866
Peoples assembly - 0101643715 monshaat al kanater World bank
Dostour 0197777093-
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 13 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Serial Name Position
103. Adel Ibrahim Mohamed Accountant
104. Sohair mohammed Chemist abdelmoaty
105. Adel mostafa has san Chemistry department chief manager
106. Omayma saleh saleh HR manager
107. Manal 1. abd el maksoud Chief engineer
108. Mohamed Fawzy General Manger
109. Osama Mohamed abu EI Department manger elaa
110. Gamal foaad nor rl din General manger
III. i Ibrahim el sayed mohsen
112. Mohamed alam
113. Tareq Ibrahim Abd El Manger of boilers dayem maintenance dep.
114. Maher Mohamed M.E.D.
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Work of Place Telephone
Cairo Company For • 0122300062 Electricity Production North Cairo plant 68529
North Cairo plant 0103066134
Cairo Company For 0122378700 Electricity Production The Egyptian 0127372900 Holding company electricity West Cairo plant 0166721136
plant 0105125211
West Cairo plant 0101292271
Cairo Company For Electricity Production Cairo Company For Electricity Production (shobra el khema) South Cairo 0188774542 electricity . production plant
0118513750
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 14 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
i~ m-l'-l~-T · .~ ~~; r- j
"" , ~ I ",I" 1 ' .... 1 3j ,I ,I" 1\ .... "-,
~ 3 i_ I nfil~'~; ~' ~
t~ .,. \J 1 I '\ j ,. I. 2t 1 J) 'tU,'1 , .. . y ! II}-~ . , ... \ \, ,
~ -, _: i , , I '\ I .
I)J \J. J ..... L.-
.-i t \. h ...
1 ".\ ~ I J I'~~ ~~I" ,~ ~ '"
J ": ~\ \ ! ~i \ rl .J ~
j • t i""r"'! I 1 ''). \~ ! ':) j- l .", !
\ ~ '.'i - i , ) ... 31 - \' ~r~I'ld )- -\ ~'l"'> '! \
1 - I
'\ 1;'0 1,/ 1.1
,J' "!I .. j ~ -,
.4
N .. ~ t, i ,
<::> \ or. r-
i I.!J i- ....
iJ \ (tl ':S \ ..)
-U vi--- ~ ;'j tLl ~!) I .
i ! I- ,~ t
.. __ ._._--------------------------
FSIA for Giza I\orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 10
Annex- 0 Appendix- 0 - Page 15 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- 0 - Appendix- 0 - Page 16 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
;5 ~~ - I I C- cY) ClI~~ I( .\
~ ?;; I -.~--l--
~i,\-] .~ ~ J . 1>1
- ~ :p 11'} L"\ ~ .-
j tll~11~ j t I
1 1i J v~· ~ ... .
.-. 1 'J ...
=t ··1 "') <U
,J ..>
j ... ~ ") ...
1 .J ~ ... ~1 . Q
]. 1 1,:, .~. ,.,
N
'" '" or, ) t'-
:::.. t ij 1ft U ,,) ..> ;'j
\yJ -0 -'"' ::t: 0.. ~ Lv 0 '""- '" vl it W I..u ""' ~ V ;? < ~ ""' -l
~ !f.",
:J ;,):1: Ul ~, ~
;.-: "i:J 0 ,,-U be
V ~ L.
7. 1>5 [ c;: r~ Ii ;: w 1e'" WJ .- .. ;7 H G /" ~8 ;.I.j
L~._.~ ...
-.--'--~-""""""""""""""" .~.""""""""""""""""""""""-~~~~------------
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 JO
Annex- D - Appendix- D· Page 17 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
._-_ ... _ ..... -~~ ..... -- ... ----..... ---------
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 Appendix- 0 - Page 18 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
::> '\ i~
~ ~ ~ ~
~ ~ ~ ~ -
J t' .~ '\~ ... .
~ . ~ ..
~ .~
'")
OJ
.J , i ,., .::I'
-) ...
1 .J~ .0' 31 1 li ~; .J ,;(
.... ><
0 VI t-
~ "-:;; ~ :::> :..:
:,; :r.
2'. ~
:i :;) /J z.. :::> f..)
'::i 7-;;: "-l "-l
~ 0 :z W
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
!
I '-
1 - \
II ,; f :t
,~
~J \1 - i - .
I - ..,
I
~r I I · ' , -\ .- , r:J:)' -r i~~' I''f '~ " Ji;t 1 Iv f '5 t i..<l . , '" r\ .). '"
-'-,·,1,---]--, -~
1 ~ I • J
t,; . i E' ;- 1..Y Ii.
~JL " ~I
~ .' ~~ ;.l;rl
Annex- D Appendix- D Page 19 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
~ ~ "-
.J ~
~1 1.:,
... '" .. <::> .,., r-
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
'" ~~~+-~~~+-~~~
~
:t I
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 20 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
-~~~- •..... ----------~.
ESIA for Giza },orth Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D Appendix- D - Page 21 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
:;s ,~
fj ~ .~ .
~ ~.~ .' ~
~:; - ~ (g -j ti -5 ... .
I - I' . ~ ... j
~ "') uJ
.J l'
1; ., .1' . ~ ...
i .J ~ ,;;- 11 ]-1 1:~ ,J' ~
'" ,... .. <:;> or, ,.,.
"'- ~ :.:l ;'j 0 '" \;J </l I-Z «. tl '" :::J :i: C/l
is ~ u ,7. \;J .~ ~ ' .. ' z.: " w ~ w ~ ~ 0 z w ;:
--_........ _ ........ ----------------
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- D Page 22 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
;> '\ ~~
~ - ':;J fl .~
,~ :Ii --8 - 3 G -3 li ~ '" .
I -. 1 ...
~ .. 0.)
,J
i' ~ ~ '"
1 ,J ~ .~ 11 ]-1 1:~ .'1' ....
N ... <:> t()
""
"" {
:::J ;'j ..., i :::J :n
L. <>: ::::i :il § ".)
" z Q2 "-l u.r /. V /. ;.l.:
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- D - Page 23 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULT ANTS GROUP
!S '\
~ ~ j ,3 - I
, ~ ....
~ .~
"') <IJ
J l
, "\
..1' ...
1 J ~
11 ,Q
1 1; \ ~ ..
''I ,J "' '" N ... ~ r-.
j: 0... "') :;; :] 0 0:: 0 </)
1-Z « t; :;; :/l Z 0 u 0 z i ~ w ~ 0 z u..
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Q.
"
i ! I
I r il I I',11J 3 !"3:> i d"" .;;.
l ' I i '~ I' , I'Y , r·
I: m II "I ___ ~ __ ~_,J.......~_
i i ! i \ I '. i( \' I 1,"\ I' ( I 11 '~).~
Ijr~ I . ~,~ ~ " i"<:!' 'J! )...,- i
':l,I~ i h <:' I \,., d{ I ! -1-. I i ·1"::>... I : ... ~ \ ,," : l ,I '" '"
" I (!Y .
, , ", r" ' !j.~ ! .".1 d" ' 3'-
1'1,1<,;- '" ~ I ,L' r' '
i', I ~I", 17 ,. ;;;> ! l.J ~I ~I~ 1 6
.1 "
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 24 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
, '\
!l ~ -l- ~
1 1 --~ ~
Ji , ~ ~ -
J ti 1 -8 , .. - I . l ....
~ "") \U
J i ... J .., ..
~
1 ,J ~ ,J .0' 11 ]- "
~ , ; ..
.:J " ". '" '" I c
I on ""' .~
;)..
1.11 ;:) \) :> 0:: '.:J :fl ,... 7..
I I ' « ...J rl-i- '" .:;, =: '/l z ~
:3 ~
~ ~
1%1 1 ;z.
;: ~
I- I ~
g ~
I.J ! z 0
"-l LJ ..... '"
.... -.---.. -.-..... -~ .... - .... --------------------
ESIA for GIza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- D - Page 25 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
;;; i~ "
] ~ ~ ',",
1; - ~ ~ -
J ti ,3 " . . I
~ . ~ ...
~ '~
")
u.J
.J
1" J ~ ....
1 :J:! 3 . '.0 ~~ J ]-! '.~ ,J ~
'" M .., Co
'" t-
o... J ")
;:) ;"j 0
'" " ~ z < :3 :::J Vl Z 0 U
" Z ;;;: t;W w Z 0 Z w
. ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
~
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 26 of 27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
, ,~ i~
~ ~«;
< ~
- ~ ~ -~ ti ~
... . I -. l ....
l .., ilJ
.J
l' , ..:1<
~ .a.
i :J :! .0' i1 1 ,.:~ .J' ...
.... .. eo
'" ....
t :>. :::J -;'J '::l x
"' Jl
Z. ~
j /., . :> ~ v z. i :..w -..w z. ~
7 u.;
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
~
J ,:,
~ .. -::r i
i~ .. r'"
"" 1
Annex- D - Appendix- D - Page 27 of27
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
Appendix G
SELECTED PHOTOS
----------------------------------
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 1 of 28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESLA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 2 of28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for (}iza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 3 of 28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for G,za North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 - Appendlx- G Page 4 of28
ENGINE1:RING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- 0 - Appendix- G Page 50f28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESLA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 6 of 28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project January 20) 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 7 of28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D· Appendix- G· Page 8 of28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESLA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 9 of28
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 Appendix- G - Page 10 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page I I of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- G Page 12 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 13 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESlA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- G - Page 14 of
ENGINEF:RING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- G - Page 15 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D Appendix- G - Page t 6 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza l'iorth Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 17 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendlx- G Page 18 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza Nonh Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- D Appendix- G Page 19 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G Page 20 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
------.----.-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 21 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 - Appendix- G - Page 22 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza r-;orth Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 23 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- 0 - Appendix- G - Page 24 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- D - Appendix- G· Page 25 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D • Appendix- G - Page 26 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 2010
Annex- D - Appendix- G - Page 27 of
ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS GROUP
ESIA for Giza North Combined Cycle Power Project 28 January 20 I 0
Annex- D Appendix- G Page 28 of
Water Surface Profile for EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Model Calibration
HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE Delta Barrage - Egypt
..
North Giza power plant Project
Figure (3)
= = = = = = = '=! = = = = '=! '=! I:- ...c .n ...,;. M ~ -- - ....... ....... - ....... -lWJI~A\)lHl8 Ai
Designed Water Levels for EI-Rayah EI-Behery
HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE Delta Barrage - Egypt
= = = = 0 ~ -
= = 0 '-C>
= = 0 on
= '=! = ~
= = 0 ~
= = o -
= = 0
~ -.... <:> .-1;'1;
:; t>J)
2:: -= 1;'1; ~ -= e ~ B = 1;'1; .-"" Q
North Giza power plant Project
Figure (2)
,-----.... -~ ----....
:::-. co
""0 -(""'") <: E ~ ~ r-("'.J
II :::-. c:: CO 0)
'00 ""0 -Q) (""'")
""0 <:
CJ E ~
--i ~
~ r-("'.J
(f) II Q) CO Cl ::::l ->< u
CO CO ~ CJ
• I
c:::::> c:::::> c:::::> c:::::> c:::::> c:::::> c:::::> ~ c:::::> c:::::> ~ c:::::> r-: c:o ..n -.i <""> N ,..- ,..- ,..-
( IN) I a A a 1 J aJ e M
Water Surface Profile for EI-Rayah EI-Behery at Maximum Discharge
HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE Delta Barrage - Egypt
c:::::> c:::::> c::> J.t")
c:::::> ~ J.t")
.......
c:::::> ~ c:::::> .......
c:::::> ~ J.t")
<"">
~ c:::::> c:::::> -.... c::> .s <""> S
::::J CD Q) ....
c:::::> "'C ~ ca J.t") Q) C"J .c
E 0 .:::
c:::::> Q)
~ (..) s:::: c:::::> J9 C"J U)
i5
c:::::> ~ J.t") ,..-
c:::::> ~ c:::::> ,..-
c:::::> ~ J.t")
c:::::> ~
c:::::> c:::::>
~ ,..-,..-
North Giza power plant Project
Figure (6)
:: -< = ~
=~ to ... =*('1 ~ 00-
f~ ~ 00-~ M ~ > ,;:c M('1 ~ :: "'0 ... _2:
00-~
~ ~ ~ M
"'!"j liQo
= ~
"Z:: -
~ ctr .... CJ) s:::: ~
I» I» ..... n :s:CD _. 1J :::J .... _. 0 3 ~ s:::: CD 30' c .... _. m o_ n I
:::J"::;O I» I» .... ~ CQI» CD:::J"
m I
OJ CD :::J" CD ~
z o 9: Q
"tJ N' o At (j)'-o (") 0 -~ (I)
""'II
-0 Dr ::J -
I . 17.001 I •••• Max. Des. W.L., Q design = 27.0
16.00 +. ____ c_.'-
15.00
:::E14.00 r .hm:--·········C" I
CIJ
> ClJ13.00
--I .... CIJ
::12.00 3:
11.00
10.00
MmAJ/day -Q = 10.0 MmA3/day
9.00 -I .' ',1
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00 45.00 50.00
Distance from head regulator (KM)
~ -CD ...,
== (J)
~ s:::
~ m;r ~ -(")
~~ OCD 0"'0
~ - 3 ..., =(j _. 0 ~ 7J). :::s :::!! ~ ~. m -:::s CD =i 7J). -~ ~ ~ OQ ~ >
I = fir m ~(j (") 'I
== ::r:;tl - m m
..... z ca'< 7J). CD m -3 ::r --3 m Cj -I -3 m ~ CD
::r CD ~
Z 0 ~ ::::T
~ (j) .... "D ji;j' ~ = .... II)
~ .2. (1)"0 -til (') 0
'-' -=e (I) .... '2. II)
:::J -
17.00 ,i --:------; __ ~------l • • • • Max. Des. W.L., Q design = 27.0 Mm"3/day
16.00
15.00
::!E 14.00 Q)
> ~13.00 .... Q)
:; 12.00 s:
11.00 -l,\f· •• '.'e"""
10.00
9.00 +-! -'"""--+-'--~------+-----+---I---"""""-----t-'---+---"""""""'---;
0.00 5.00 10.00 15.00 20.00 25.00 30.00 35.00 40.00 45.00 50.00
Distance from head regulator (KM)
Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation National Water Research Center
Hydraulics Research Institute
Report No 192 12009
NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT (l-D Mathematical model)
By: Dr. Ahmed EI-Belasy
Eng. Randa farag
Director of HRI Fathy El Gamal
Dec. 2009
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Final Report
Table of Contents
1. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................... 1
2. SCOPE OF THE STUDy ............................................................................................... 1
3 OBJECTIVE OF THE ID MODEL STUDY .................................................................. 2
4. FIELD MEASUREMENTS ............................................................................................ 2
4.1 Horizontal Control ..................................................................................................... 2
4.2 Vertical Control ......................................................................................................... 3
4.3 Bathymetric Survey ................................................................................................... 3
4.4 Flow Measurements ................................................................................................... 3
4.5 Water Surface Current ............................................................................................... 3
4.6 Bed Sampling ............................................................................................................ 3
5. HYDRAULIC CHARACTARISTICS FOR EL-RA Y AH EL-BEHERY ..................... .4
6. THE MATHEMATICAL MODEL ................................................................................. 6
6.1 The Mathematical Model Sobek 1 D .......................................................................... 6
6-2 Model Setup .............................................................................................................. 8
6-3 Model calibration ...................................................................................................... 8
7. MODEL RESULTS ......................................................................................................... 9
7.1 Scenario 1 .................................................................................................................. 9
7.2 Scenario 2 .................................................................................................................. 9
7.3 Scenario 3 .................................................................................................................. 9
8. CONCLUSIONS ........................................................................................................... 11
9. RECOMMENDATIONS ............................................................................................... 12
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
List of figures
Figure (l); Layout of EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Figure (2); Designed Water Levels for EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Figure (3); Model Calibration
Figure (4): Water Surface Profile for El-Rayah El-Behery at Minimum
Discharge.
Figure (5): Water Surface Profile for EI-Rayah El-Behery at Dominant
Discharge.
Figure (6): Water Surface Profile for EI-Rayah EI-Behery at Maximum
Discharge.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
1. INTRODUCTION The Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC) is planning to build a new plant in Giza
Governorate which is North Giza Power Plant. The plant capacity is 2* 750 MW and will be
Combined Cycle. It is proposed to build the plant at km 22 on the right hand side of the main
road located at the right bank of EI-Rayah EI-Behery. The plant will abstract the water from EI
Rayah EI-Behery through its intake for the cooling process of its condensers. The hot brine will
be discharged back to EI-Rayah El-Behery through a discharge pipe to the discharge outfall
structure.
The EEHC commissioned the Hydraulics Research Institute (HRJ) to carry out the
hydrodynamic and environmental studies for the North Giza Plant. The study comprised field
survey, hydrodynamic numerical models and physical models. The numerical models consist of
one dimensional model (lD) to provide the relevant and necessary water levels to the two
dimensional model and the physical model. The ID model was carried out by the SOBEK
software package of Delft Hydraulics. The two dimensional numerical model was done using
the Delft3D Software Package of Delft Hydraulics. The 2D numerical model and the physical
model was used to investigate the reciculation of the hot brine from the outfall to the intake of
the plant and to investigate the transport and diffusion of the plume in the plant vicinity. The
effect of the plant discharge on the current speed which may affect the navigation in EI Rayah
EI-Behaery was also investigated in the models.
The report presents the study which was carried out by the ID model to investigate the
necessary water levels which will be used in the other models.
2. SCOPE OF THE STUDY
The investigation of the recirculation of the hot brine and the distribution of the temperature in
the plant vicinity will be carried out under the minimum, dominant, maximum and the expected
discharge in the future. The investigation will include also the effect of the plant discharge on
the navigation. In order to do the study under the mentioned flow discharges in EI Rayah EI
Behery using the 2D numerical model and the physical model it is necessary to determine the
water levels relevant to these discharges. The ID numerical model was used in this study to
obtain the required water levels.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
The numerical model Sobek-ID was used to simulate the first reach for El-Rayah El-Behery
from the head regulator to AI-Khatatba Regulator where the plant will be located. All structures
such as bridges, regulators and siphon along EI-Rayah in this reach were simulated in the
model in addition to all offtakes. The outflows of irrigation channels and other sources must be
specified as function of time/discharge. The lateral discharges were simulated in the model as
point discharge (m3/s). Three scenarios were simulated in the model to obtain the required
water levels which are related to the minimum, dominant, maximum and expected discharge in
the future in El-Rayah EI-Behery.
3 OBJECTIVE OF THE ID MODEL STUDY The objective of the 1-0 mathematical model study is to define the water levels at the location
of the power plant for the following discharges flowing in El-Rayah EI-Behery :
• Minimum discharge: 10 Mm3/day
• Dominant discharge: 20 Mm3/day
• Maximum discharge: 27 Mm3/day
The computed water levels at the location of plant will be used in the boundary conditions of
the 2D numerical flow model and the physical scale model.
4. FIELD MEASUREMENTS Field measurement was carried by HRI in the period from 08108/2009 till 16/08/2009. The
survey includes bathymetric survey, flow measurement, water surface current measurements
and bed sampling, The survey covered a length of 6km along EI Rayah EI Behyri, 3 km
upstream and 3 km downstream the power plant. The following sections describe, in brief,
the survey activities. For more details, reference is made to the HRI survey report
No.24/2009.
4.1 Horizontal Control In order to determine the horizontal control, the Differential Geographical Positioning
System (DGPS) was used to measure the global coordinate of the site. All horizontal
coordinates in the study area were obtained using WGS 84 Universal System.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
2
Final Report
4.2 Vertical Control The water and bed levels were determined according the Bench Marks which were
positioned in front of the proposed location of the power plant. The Bench Marks were fixed by
HRI during the hydrographic survey and referenced to the Datum of the Egyptian Survey
Authority.
4.3 Bathymetric Survey
The bathymetric survey covers 6 km along EI Rayah El Behery, 3 km upstream and 3 km
downstream the plant. A rubber boat equipped by both Echo Sounder and DGPS unit was used
for conducting the bathymetric survey. The bathymetric survey was carried out in cross
sections, with an average distance of 50.0 m between each two cross-sections. All levels were
related to the mean sea level (MSL). The bathymetric data was transformed into a contour map.
For more details, reference is made to the HRI survey report no 124/2009.
4.4 Flow Measurements
Propeller current meters were used for measuring the flow velocity profiles at 5 selected cross
sections representing the surveyed area. Measurements were carried out at eleven verticals
distributed along the width of each cross-section depending on the shape of the cross section.
The velocity in each vertical was measured .20, 0.50 and 0.80 from the water surface.
4.5 Water Surface Current
The water surface current was measured using six calibrating floats with draft of 1.0 m
and equipped by a prism to be able to follow using a Total Station system. The start
locations of the mentioned floats were 500 m upstream the centerline of the power plant.
4.6 Bed Sampling A Van Veen grab sampler was used to collect the bed material samples. The bed
samples were collected at the same locations of the velocity measurements (three
samples per cross-section). The Analysis of bed samples was carried out to obtain the
grain size distribution of bed material for the design purposes of the physical model.
The analyses of samples are shown in HRI survey report no 124/2009.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
3
Final Report
5. HYDRAULIC CHARACTARISTICS FOR EL-RAYAH EL-BEHERY
The length of EI-Rayah EI-Behery is about 94.85 km starts from EI-Kanater EI-Khairia
Barrage. The Head Regulator is located at Kilometer Zero on Rosetta Branch and ends at KM
94.85 The width of the designed cross section from the beginning of the El-Rayah El-Behery
to Km 85.10 is about 59.00 meters, while the bed width is about 44.00 meter between Km
85.10 and Km 94.85. The EI-Rayah El_Behery is not lined. The hydraulic characteristics of
EI-Rayah EI-Behery are shown Table (1).
There are many intakes on EI-Rayah EI-Behery as shown in Figure (1). There is also two
drains discharge their water in El-Rayah EI-Behery. Table (2) shows the area served by the
intakes and the drains along EI-Rayah El-Behery. Table (3) shows the main barrages on El
Rayah EI-Behery. Figure (2) the shows designed water surface profile for El-Rayah E1-
Behery.
Table (1) The Designed Hydraulic Characteristics For EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Water surface Water Kilometer Bed width
Side slope slope depth
(m) CmlKm (m)
i
0.00 - 85.10 59 I 3:2 7 5.8
85.1 - 94.85 44 3:2 7 5.7
I
Table (2) The Intakes And The Drains On EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Nol Name Km Discharge(m3/sec) Area served
It Ganabyat wardan 23.000 2 Wardan canal 25.720 3 Ganabyat bany salama 32.375
4 Fom EI-fatraEL- 40.25
~.
baharya 5 Fom Tawaty 41.500 6 Ganabyat EI-Khatatba 41.935
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
.. ~~dl 0.202 700 1.157 4000 0.289 1000 0.11 380
jli 0.47 1625 0.208 720
4
~ Name Km -
7 Fom EI-Fatra basin 44.000
8 Ganabyat 46.720 EL Khatatba outfllow
9 fom Ganabyat kafr 46.720 dawood
10 Ganabyat EI-brygat EI- 54.000 kiblia ~. Ganabyat EI-~rygat EI- 54.000 bahana 12· Fom EI-tahreer EI- 56.700 -ii- eanobia
Ganabyat Dashany 57.700
14 Ganabyat Abo-EI- 63.800 Khawy
15 Fom canal no.6 71.250 moderiat EI-tahreer 16 Ganabyat Kom shreek 72.570
17 Ganabyat EI-tabaria 74.900 El-keblia 18 Ganabyat EI-tabaria 74.900 ii-I;t EI-Baharia Ganabyat Zawet EI- 77.500 Bar
HI Fom Ray EI-Negela 85.600 FomGanabyatVVaked 78.500
22 I Fom EI-nubaria canal 81.650 23 Fom EI-negila canal 82.000 _ ..
Fom Abo diab Alaala 24 82.030 canal
25 Ganabyat meleha EI- 82.050 Kiblia
26 Ganabyat Meleha 1- 85.250 wosta
Ir;- Zepeda canal 88.270 Ganabyat Melha EI- 88.270 Baharia
29 Ganabyat Shapor 89.000 30 Fom Shapor canal 90.950 31 Fom Serseka canal 91.550
Kafr Salamoon canal 91.350 EI-Khndak EI-gharby 92.370 canal
34 Shaker canal 92.370 35 EI-Ganabia EI-Sharkia 94.345 36 Sahel Morkos canal 94.350
37 EI-ganabia I-Gharbia 94.355 EI-Kiblia 38 Satat canal 94.355
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Discharge(m3 /sec) Area served· (Fed)
0.380 1315 In Ganabyat Kafr EI- NA
dawar 0.409 1413
0.116 400 i
0.221 765
NA I
NA
0.541 1870 0.143 495
I
1.013 3500 I
0.473 1636 0.407 1408
0.318 1100
0.462 I
1597
0.09 304 0.884 ! 3056
NA 0.93 3215 17.36 49775
0.155 535
0.253 875
0.926 3200 0.347 1200
0.181 642 i
0.578 2000 I 0.570 1970
0.200 690 I
1.071 3700
0.245 847 1.716 5930 34.72 102046
0.579 2000
1.186 4100
5
Final Report
No Name Km Discharge(mJ Isec
39 Fom EI-Khandak EI- 94.850 34.76 Shark
40 End ofEI- 1.910 6600 Ra ah
Table (3) The Main Regulators On EI-Rayah EI-Behery
Regulator Name Kilometer No. of vents Vent width Sill crest level
(m) under gate
Head regulator 0 6 8 10.5
EI-Khatatba 41.5 9 5 8.2
regulator
~-
Polyn regulatot 82.1 5 5 5.21
6. THE MATHEMATICAL MODEL The SOBEK-Channel Flow Software is a one-dimensional modeling that can simulates the
flow and water quality in river and estuary systems. It has been developed by WL I Delft
Hydraulics. It is a tool based on knowledge and experience gained from many rivers and
estuaries in the world. SOBEK-Overland Flow is a two-dimensional modeling system, which
supports the work of engineers related to river studies. In a typical application the two'
dimensional model is used to simulate the progression of flood waters and the depth of
flooding in an area along a river or a canal. It calculates the water depths and flow velocities. In
this study the SOBEK 1 D Software was used.
6.1 The Mathematical Model Sobek ID The numerical model SOBEK I D was used to simulate the first reach for EI-Rayah EI-
Behery from the Head Regulator to AI-Khatatba regulator at Km 42.00. The proposed
plant is located in this reach. All structures were simulated such as Bridges, regulators
and siphons, along EI-Rayah EI-Behery. All lateral off takes were introduced in the
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
6
Final Report
model. The outflows of irrigation channels and other sources were specified as function
oftime/discharge. The lateral discharges were specified as point discharges (m3/s).
Basic equations used for ID computation
In the flow module, the flow is described by the full Saint- Venant equations for unsteady
open-channel flow, which read for a regular river application:
• Continuity equation (representing the conservation of mass):
• Momentum equation (representing the conservation of momentum):
With:
Af = conveying cross-section [m2]
AI = total cross-sectional area [m2]
C Chezy coefficient [mll2ls]
g = gravitation constant [m/s2]
h = water level relative to reference level [m]
qlal lateral inflow per unit length [m3/m/s]
Q = discharge [m3 Is]
R hydraulic radius (roughly equal to the water depth) [m]
= time [s]
Wf = width of conveying cross-section at water surface [m]
x distance along the channel [m]
aB = Boussinesq coefficient (see equation 3) [-]
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
7
2
Final Report
The Boussinesq coefficient is a correction factor in the convective acceleration term (in
Equation 2), to account for non-uniform velocity distribution in the cross-section. It is
computed from:
..................................... (3)
== index ind icating type of sub-section in conveying cross-section (i ::; 3)
The last expression in Equation (3), computing a representative C2 R, is also used in the bed
friction term in equation 2. The Chezy coefficient C is in this model computed as a function
of Manning's roughness coefficient nm:
6-2 Model Setup The reach where the plant will be located was simulated using the available bathymetric survey which was carried out by HRI. In this reach the main regulators on EI-Rayah ElBehery that presented Table (3) were simulated in the mathematical model SOBEK I-D. All the intakes and the drains on EI-Rayah EI-Behery which are presented Table (2) were simulated in the mathematical model SOBEK I-D.
6-3 Model calibration
The Calibration ofEI-Rayah EI-Behery was done based on the available measured data (water
levels and discharges). The data used in the model calibration is as follows:
• Discharge of the Head Regulator is 286.6m3/s.
• Water Level at Km 0.00 during the survey campaign is 15.98 m.
• Water Level at Km 42.50 during the survey campaign is 12.95 m.
The roughness coefficient which was used in the model was based on the field measurement
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
8
Final Report
and the calibration results. It was found that Manning roughness coefficient of 0.0268 gave a
good agreement between the measured and computed water levels. It was found that the
difference between measured and computed water levels is less than 0.02m. The result of the
model calibration is shown in Figure (3).
7. MODEL RESULTS After calibrating the model, it was run for Four scenarios to calculate the water levels for
minimum, dominant, maximum and the expected discharge in the future in EI Rayah EJ-
Behery. These scenarios are as follows:
7.1 Scenario 1
This scenario aims at computing the water level at the minimum discharge at km 22 where
the plant will be located. The minimum discharge in EI-Rayah EI-Behery which is
10Mm3/day at EJ-fom regulator was used in the simulation. The results of the scenario show
that the computed water level at the plant location will be 13.00 m above MSL. Figure (4)
shows the results of Scenario 1.
7.2 Scenario 2
Scenario 2 aims at computing the water level at the plant location under the dominant
discharge. The dominant discharge in El-rayah EI-Behery which was used in the model is
20Mm3/dayat El-fom regulator. The model results are shown in Figure (5). The computed
water level for the dominant discharge at the location of the proposed plant was found to be
14.17 m above the MSL.
7.3 Scenario 3 Scenario 3 aims at determ ining the water level at the location of the proposed plant under the
maximum discharge condition. The model was run under a maximum discharge in EI_Rayah
El-Behery of 27.000Mm3/day at El-fom regulator. computing water levels along El-Rayah EI-
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
9
Final Report
Behery at maximum discharge to define water level at Km 22. Figure (6) shows the model
results for Scenario 3. The computed water level at Km 22 where the plant will be located
was found to be 14.92 m above MSL based on the model computation.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
10
I
i
I
i
I
Final Report
Table no (4) Water Levels for All Discharges at the Location of Plant.
Scenario Discharge Water Levels
(Mm3/day) (m) MSL
Minimum discharge 10.00 13.00
Dominant discharge 20.00 14.17
Maximum discharge 27.00
I 14.92
8. CONCLUSIONS The numerical model SOBEK 1 D was used to simulate the first reach of EI-Rayah EI-Behery
starting from the Head regulator to AI-Khatatba regulator at Km 42.000. The model was used
to calculate the water levels along the first resch of EI-Rayah El-Behery. From these water
levels the computed water level at the location of the power plant at Km 22.000 for different
discharges was obtained. The computed water level at the location of the proposed plant is as
follows::
1. At minimum discharge of 1 OMm3/day, water level is 13.00 m above MSL.
2. At dominant discharge of20Mm3/day, water level is 14.17 m above MSL.
3. At maximum discharge of 27.000Mm3/day, water level is 14.92 m above MSL.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
11
i
Final Report
9. RECOMMENDATIONS
It is advised to use the computed water levels by the 10 Model with their relevant discharges
in tht~ 20 numerical model and physical model studies. These models will be used to
investigate the recirculation of the hot brine from the plant outfall to its intake and the study
the transport and advection of the thermal plume in the plant vicinity. The models can be
used to investigate the effect of the plant discharge on the cross flow which may affect the
navigation in the EI-Rayah EI-Behery. numerical model Delft 3D to study the different
alternatives for the location of the intake and outfall structures with max number two
proposed layout to ensure preventing warm water recirculation.
The physical model to obtain the local dilution and dispersion behavior of the hot water at the
near field for different configurations of the outfall structures and different hydrodynamic
conditions, as well as effect of the plant operation on the safety of navigation.
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
12
Figure
NEW COMBINED CYCLE AT NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Rosetta Branch
EL-Ra)ah EL-Behery head regulator rri
(Km 00.000)
Werdan Canal regulator ] (Km 25.720)
GanabYIl Werdan regulator ] (Km 28.000)
GanabYll bany salama ] (Km 32.375)
Fum al-fatrah al-baharya [ (Km 40.25)
Fum twaty ] (Km 41.500)
Fum Ganabya al-khatatba ~ (Km 41.935)
AI-khatatba regulator H (Km 42.250)
] Fum hode al-fatrah (Km 44.000)
Ganabya Kafr Dawood ] (Km 46.720)
Ganabya al-bryhat al-keblya wa al-baharya [ (Km 54.000)
Fum al-tahrir al-ganobya [ (Km 56.700)
Fum GlInabya dshany ] (Km 57.700)
Fum ganabya abou al-khawy ] (Km 63.800)
Fum channel No.6 [ (Km 71.250)
Fum Ganabya kom sheriek ] (Km 72.570)
Ganabya al-tabarya al-keblya wa al-baharya [ (Km 74.900)
Ganabya zawyt al-bahr ] (Km 77.500)
Ganabya waked [ (Km 78.500)
fum AI-nobarya canal [ (Km 81.650)
Fum al-negela canal ] (Km 82.000)
Fum abou Diab canal [ (Km 82.030)
Ganabya meleha al-keblya [ (Km 82.050)
Layout of EL-Rayah EI-Behery North Giza Power Plant
Project
HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE Figure (1 )
Delta Barrage - Egypt
Name of Power Plant
Elkurimat Power Plant 2006-2007
N arne of Power Plant
Tebeen 2005
Name of Power Plant
Nubaria Power Plant
2005-2006
Name of Power Plant
AI-Atf Power Plant
2007
River Water
At(C
Temp. (C)
8 15
8 25
8 28
River Water Temp. (C)
15
25
10.0 9.3 10.0 9.3 28
Power Plant Operational Conditions
750 MW 750 MW 750 MW River Combined
Unit I Combined Unit
III
At(C
10 10.79 10
14.8 10.79 10
10 10.79 10
Flow Conditions
115 II Winter Flow,
Water Temp. (C)
15
Flow Conditions
Winter Flow,
Dominant Flow
Maximum Flow
Flow Conditions
Winter Flow,
Dominant Flow
Maximum Flow
Flow Conditions
Winter Flow,
~, Ii' ~2 C "!IJ2 1 1lJI1 2 !KlZ l 'ltrZ..... .D:!!.~. lD:!.1> lD:!'.7
P!alll.f:n, (krn)
Co-mcl1led Flow Pattern, case of mInimum cll"9charQi!'
iJpper flr.:;jure: flOW pall ern II'l the lop loyer
Lo~r fi9ur~; fltlW poll ~rn in \ h~ bolt ... m loy~r
HydraulIcs Research Ins1Huie
'ScenarIO- 1
- 1lI200m/~
FIgure 7
;A-
li! ~ II Ii! .E! 't: it z
a C :til .fl ;::!
Ii II!.
'J~e
'J~8
'J~8
J34B
J34B
J34B
J34B
J34B
J3d8
3ld7
Jld7
::13<17
'l'5d7
301 • .4 J01.l~ JOU:l 30' 0 :!KI:<':<' :!KI::1 ~ 302 a ~ a JD.3J1 :c.StJlll f);m l
'J~g
J34B J3d8 ::13<111
'J~8
J34B J34B 33d8 'J~a
J34B J34B J3d7 'l'5d7
301 Q JOU~ 301 , JOU~ ~1 Ii 300..0 30~ ~ ~.t Jo~.e; 3<t.' €I 0303..0 ~3 ~ 30.:5...d Ilelblll (]em l
lemPfJ'rol.ure di!S'lribulion. CDse of miniMUM dl!lcharge
Upper rlqu,J!!.· tJ!!.MpJ!!.roiure dr~irfbuilor. 1ro the i.:lp loyer
LJ"p~r rjglJr~. ~~mp~roi!)r~ di~hib!)ljon in the bQllom I~r Scl!'nariO 1
Hydraulics Research Institute
.<15.00
.<16.00 0<17.00 0<18.00 0<19.00 0<20.00 .<21.00 .<21.50 .<22.00 .<22.50 .<23.00 0">23.00
·<15,00 .<16.00 0<17.00 0<18.00 0<19.00 0<20.00 .<21.00 • <21 .50 .<22.00 .<22.50 .<23.00 0">23.00
le<TIpeoro:nurl!!! dlstnblJllO'" ortlu ... d lheo OlJlfDII, C'Q1!IlI! of mi ... i .... u ..... c"schDrgeo
Ur:lIler nqur~' t~mp~rolure dr91rrbullor. 1 ... the lor:> 10Y!'Y
LJpPll'r figlJrll:!'. ~lI:!'m~lI:!'rQlurt' di1!iribUlitm In th;::, oo~l"m I~r
Hydraulics Research Institute
Sc-E'nori~ 1
·<15.00 .<17.00 0<19.00 0<20.00 0<!:l1.00 0<21,50 l1li <:22.00 • <!12 • .20 .<22.40 • <!:l7.60 .<22,80 0<:23.00 0'>23.00
.<15,00
.<17.00 0<19.00 0<:20,00 o <!:l 1.00 0<!11,50 I!!IlI <:22.00 • <!:l7.20 .<:22,40 • <!:l7.60 • <!12,80 0<:23.00 0'>23.00
::101,# ::1070 'm7 1 ~ 7 ~ J -:l1l'Z'" jll2.~ lll2.1!. llll!'.7
EllllUn8 (11m)
J341!1
30.:1.0 3IJ:? 1 JD::I.!I ](I:!' 3 :;:)2 -4
BaI1llJl,Q !1m1)
Computed Flow Poltern, cO:!le of dominonl discharge
IJppe. rI<;jure: flow p.,llerl'l In the lop loye.
LO~f r'qur!i:'; flCM' pgli!i:'rn in H'I!i:' boi{tom IOY!i:'f
Hydraulics Research IlisiHu1e
Scenario 2
,.. III <':i • iI2 ,Il! 1: 11' :z.
'i 0 'III Jl ;:!
i II!.
)}<IS
]}<IS
)}<I8
::534B
J34B
::534B
J34B
::5341i1
J3it8
J347
:13.<17
J:s.a"
'1""" ::5D1.4 3D1.I~ 301.6
::534B ::53it8 ::s:s.all ]}<IS
334B ::5341i1 :5348 ]}<IS
::5348 ::534B ::53it7
'1""" .,"", 3347 3347
301 0 .lOU' 301 .t 301.6, ~1 B ::500.0 :502' 2' ~" 302'.8 300 III 301.0 ~:!i , Jill ... !llllb",. f'.km l
Temperolure disiributi.on, t"Dge .of d.ominan1. cli'!lcha~qe
Upper rlgure' temperolure dr'!lwoulior. In th~ jop IOjll'r
i.)PI'l!'r figvn:. \~ml1~rl;lfurl!' rji,fribuiir;;>n in th,: oolillm lQ't':'r
Hyd ra U lies Resea rch Institute
.<25.00
.<26.00 0~7.00 0<:28.00 0<29.00 0<30.00 III <31.00 .<31.50 • ..c2.00 .<32.50 .<33.00 0>:5:3.00
·~5.00 .<26.00 0<27.00 1I:'J<28.00 0<29.00 0<30.00 l1li <31.00 .<31.50 .<32.00 .<32.50 .<33.00 0>:5:3.00
, emllil'rCllur@ dis! rltJullol"l aroond lh@ oulJali. NU Of ';01'(lIn.:]1'11 .d1sth.:]YQI!'
lJt:)p@Y rlqur~' leMr;.erotur@ dr9'lrlbullol"l In lhe tOt:) loy~r
IJppc-r rigure. ~empert;JI.'Jrc- di-:;lribul;l;In ;n ~hl!:' boitom loyc-r
Hydraulics Research Instituie
ScenariO 2:
.<25.00
.<27.00 0<29.00 IE'J <l0.00 0<31.00 IE'J <31.50 III <32.00 .<32.20 .<:;;2.40 .<32.60 .<32.80 IE'J <3::>.00 0>33.00
FlgurO!' lab
lIl' ... 1Il:<' [] '!IJ:<' 1 ~ :<' ~ 3 ~m A- 'l1l2.!3< 31l2.1S. lll2'.7
EslII.!:ne (11m)
CompLJI.ed FlDW Pa11ern. case af mD'c'lmum d'sch{;)rqe
Ul>per rlgure: flow po11ey l't ,,, the iop loyer
L!:IM:t fit;lurco; flC'iW po1i corn in ~ hco b!:lit\;>m l!:Iycor
Hydraulics Research Insti'iuie
Scerll;1rIO :;
- D.200m/~
Flgure 11
i e ~
.A Q
i jr,
.-
.§ 'iii
'" .i! i z:.
3;.48
J34B
J34B
J34B
J34B
J3d8
J3d8
J3d8
'l~1!I
3;.47
3;.47
J347
J347
J
)~e
J34B J34B J3d8 'l~1!I
J34B J34B J3d8 J~I!I
3;.48 J347 J3d7 l:547
3;.47
l[ll.;d :!Ol.!i :!O' I!I 'lI:Y.!' [I ~::" J[J:.l.;d :l1l2.1> ][l7.1!1 :!OJ [I
2allij:ne [1m1)
T-emDl?rol.ur~ dilrlrlbulion. co !IE! Of mO'<'lmum dl9chorgE!
Upper rlqure' teMperature dr~rlbullol'\ 11'1 the iop I"yer
I.)ppc-r Fig\,lr~. \emperr:ll.vrc- di'!';lr'bvliQn in \n!:' bljl~t>m Iljyc-r
Hyd rau Ii C5 Research I list it u1e
.<28,00
.-<29.00 0<30.00 ['] ..::31 .00 0<32.00 [']<33,00 1iiil-<:34.00 • <3.4.50 .<35,00 .<35.50 .<35,00 0>36.00
• <2a.oo .<29.00 ['] ..::30.00 0<31,00 ['] <3.2.00 o <:3}.OO Ell!J<3.4.00 • ..::34.:50 .<35.00 .<35.50 .<:36.00 ['] >36.00
, em!:)erCJlure dlS1 rlbUllon orOl.md the out rail, C'<I"~ Of I"II(I'<'lmul'I1 disc-I'<I rge- NGr "'odeol
Upper Flqure' teMperature df'9'1rlbullon In the iop loyer
IJpPl!'r figure:. t~mp<:rot.vrl!' di~rlbvlkm in thl!' bt1i~t>m 1t1:,'l!'r ScenariO :5
.<28,00
.~O.OO 0<32.00 0<:33.00 0<34.00 0<34,50 1II~5.00 .<35.20 • <J5,40 .<35.60 .<35,60 0~6.00 0>36.00
.-<:C8.00
.<30.00 0<:32.00 0<33.00 o <J4,00 0<:34.50 III <35.00 .<:35.20 .<35.40 • <J5,60 .<:35.130 0<36.00 0>36.00
Hyd rau lies Research I nst it ute F1i;Jureo t2b
lllll
, !!I II
156 ..... ..g 15 ~
.... 15~ ]
i 150
1~ B
J 1~ a U~
U,:1
U,O 00,00,00
0"-2000
26,0
2'-',1!I .:I'!lll
8 .:I!!I J
~ :25~
i :250
~ .;lHI
':14 a I!-o
.:I~ ~
.:I~ :1
.:I.e 0 000000 08-200ll
29,0
29,9
213,(; § 21!1,~
~ .:III=<'
i !lID
~ .II' iii ,l!7 fI
e-.;l7 ~
.:17 :1
.:170 00 0000 OB-200!l
- Scel"lQrlo 1
1 1 3 4 !> i 7 a 9 1011 1.:1 1:) 14 15 141 17 11'1 19 '0 11 1'1 :?3 OOIC(l,OO
I' - 0"-200'1
- 5(:~l'I(]tl0 2
1 , :; 4 50 i 7 a 9 1011 1.:1 1.30 14 15 11 17 11'1 19 '0 21 2'2 :13 [)OojJQ OD
?1-01J-201)'J
- 'X~l'I(]t10 3
1 , 3 4 50 i 7 ill '3 10 11 1.:1 1.1 14 15 11 17 1 B 19 '0 21 2'2 :13 [)OojJQ OD
?1-0B-200!l
T .£'mpil'r alur i' 01 1 he Into k-i' of 1 he power plo nt. 5tetlorlo1 ~ minIMUM dr'!lPehoyqe. 5e-i!'P'lcJrlo 2' dOl'!'irno~ dlsckayqe
5~C'nQriQ ::!\, mQyiml,lm di~hl;!rg~
Hydraulics Research Insiitute
ScenariO'S 1, 2 end j
FIgure 13
Figure 14: Layout of the cross sectious for measuriug the cross flow
20-Aug-200900 00.00
x 000'''""1,, (m) ->
Figure 15: Cross current upstream the outfall, Scenario 1
20-Aug-2009 00:00 00 0.2
01
01---_ .......
x ooordinale (m) ->
Figure 26: Cross current at the center of the outfall, Scenario 1
:if {J 02 -
"s.
o
"' t ~ {Joe
.c ·li
l'!
.01
2O-Aug-2009 00:00-00
20 8J 100 120 < coorclnate (m) -'>
Figure 17: Cross current at downstream the outfall, Scenario 1
2O-Aug-2009 00:00-00
{)12L----------~----------~--------~L---------~~---------10LO----------~120
x coordinate (m) .....
Figure 18: Cross current at upstream the outfall, Scenario 2
2D-Aug-2OQ9 00:00:00
-0.02
l'
c ru c 8-E 8
.ll !I '" f'j, !l
~ -"
~
-0.1
-o12~--------------------~---------L----------~---------L--------~ o
x coord nate (m) ...,.
Figure 19: Cross current at the center of the outfall, Scenario 2
2O-Aug-2009 00.00 00
-001
x coordinate (m) ...,.
Figure 30: Cross current at the downstream of the outfall, Scenario 2
" S .(104
~ 8. E o (J
" ~ .().06
~ 9i " Q)
~ ~ .(lOB
" " ~
20-Aug-2D0900 00 00
.(I12L---------~2D~--------~~~I-----------ro='-----------ro='-----------l~O~0----------~120
X ooor(jnate (m) ~
Figure 21: Cross current at the upstream of the outfall, Scenario 3
20-Aug-2D0900·00:00 0.3
0.2
t ~ 0.1
S E Q)
" ~ E 8 " '" E 9i .(II u ~ e ~ a ~2 19
.(13
.(1.4 0 20 40 ro ro toO 120
Figure 22: Cross current at the center of the outfall, Scenario 3
2O-Aug-2Ul9oo.oo.oo 0.01
t
120 x coortlrale (m) ~
Figure 23: Cross current at the downstream of the plant, Scenario 3
Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation National Water Research Center Hydraulics Research Institute
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY
Final Report
NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT (2x750 MW) USING DELFT-3D NUMERICAL MODEL
No. 193/2009
By Eng. Mohamed Bahgat Eng. Ahmed Medhat
Supervised by Prof. Dr. Khaled Abdel Hai Ramadan
Director of HRI Prof. Dr. Fathy EI-Gamal
Dec. 2009
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Table of Contents
I. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................... 1 2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION ............................................................................................ I 3. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDy .................................................................................... 2 4. SCOPE OF THE STUDy .............................................................................................. 2 5. FIELD MEASUREMENTS AND DATA COLLECTION .................................. 3
5.1 Bathymetric Survey ...................................................................................... 3 5.2 Flow measurements ..................................................................................... 4
6. HYDRODYNAMIC MODELING ....................................................................... 6 6.1 Description of Delft3D Numerical Software Package ................................... 6 6.2 Setup of North Giza Hydrodynamic Model .................................................. 6
6.2.1 Model schematization ........................................................................... 6 6.2.2 Grid generation ..................................................................................... 7 6.2.3 Depth schematization ........................................................................................ 9 6.2.4 Boundary conditions .......................................................................................... 9 6.2.5 Parameter settings ............................................................................................. 9 6.2.6 Time step ........................................................................................................... 9
6.3 Model Calibration ...................................................................................... 10 7. PLANT CHARACTERISTICS .......................................................................... 11 8. MODEL SCENARIOS ...................................................................................... 12 9. MODEL RESULTS ........................................................................................... 13
9.1 Scenario I .................................................................................................. 13 9.2 Scenario 2 .................................................................................................. 13 9.3 Scenario 3 .................................................................................................. 13
10. VELOCITY DISTRIBUTION RESULTS .......................................................... 14 II. CONCLUSIONS ....................................................................................................... 14 12.RECOMMENDATIONS ................................................................................... 15
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
1. INTRODUCTION The Egyptian Electricity Holding Company (EEHC), Ministry of Electricity and Energy would like to build a new plant in Giza Governorate, which is North Giza Power Plant. The plant will be a combined cycle module with a capacity of2x750 MW power. The plant will
be built at the right bank of El-Rayah EI Behary in North Giza. The cooling system of the plant consists of an intake to abstract the water for cooling the condensers and outfall structure to discharge the effluent discharge back to EI-Rayah EI-Behary. The inflow and outflow discharges of the plant are 27.50 m3/s.
The Egyptian Electricity Holding Company commissioned the Hydraulics Research Institute (HRI) to carry out the hydrodynamiC and environmental studies for the proposed plant. The study comprised hydrographic survey, numerical flow modeling and physical scale modeling.
The report presents the part of the study which concerning the two and three dimension numerical flow modeling. This part investigates the recirculation of effluents from the plant outfall to its intake. It simulates the transport and advection of the plume in the plant vicinity. The effect of the outfall discharge on the cross current which may affect the navigation will
be studied.
2. PROJECT DESCRIPTION The proposed North Giza Plant will be 2* 750 MW Combined Cycle Project. It will be located at krn 22 on the right hand side of the main road located at the right bank of EI-Rayah
El Behary as shown in Figure I. The plant will use the water from El-Rayah El Behary for cooling its condensers and the effluent discharge will be discharged back to EI-Rayah EIBehery through the plant outfall. The maximum design flow for the intake and outfall
structures is about 27.5 m3 Is.
The effluent discharged to El-Rayah El-Behery through the plant outfall can recirculate to the
p.ant intake which may affect the plant efficiency. The thermal plume will increase the temperature of the ambient water in the plant vicinity which may affect the water quality and the aquatic life. The discharge of the plant outfall/intake may produce a cross current which can affect the navigation in front of the plant. The layout and the hydraulic design of the intake and outfall structures are the main factors governing the recirculation, environmental issues and the cross current in the plant vicinity. The study investigates the feasibility of the layout and the hydraulic design of the intake and outfall structures. Field measurements and numerical and physical scale models will be used in the study.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Figure 1: general layout of the location of North Giza Plant
3. OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY The main objectives of the study can be summarized as follows:
• Investigate the transport and advection of the thermal plume in the plant vicinity due to the proposed intake-outfall layout
• Ensure that there is no recirculation of the effluent discharge at the plant intake to maintain the plant efficiency to its maximum value.
• Study the impact of the effluent discharge on the water temperature of EI-Rayah EIBehary and check that the water quality in the plant vicinity complies with the Egyptian water quality standards. According to the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation Law No. 48, 1982, and the Ministry of Environment Law No.9, 1994, the area of the mixing zone should be minimum and the maximum absolute water temperature in the plant vicinity should not exceed 35 "c. The water outside the mixing zone should not exceed 5 Cc above the ambient water temperature.
• Ensure the navigation safety in the plant vicinity. According to the Egyptian standards, the cross flow in front of the plant due to the intake and outfall discharges should not exceed 0.3 m/s in the navigation path.
4. SCOPE OF THE STUDY To achieve the aim of the study field measurements, numerical and physical models should be carried out. Field measurements should be carried out to provide the necessary data for the setup, calibration and operation of the numerical and physical
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
2
Final Report
scale models. The field measurements comprised bathymetric survey, flow measurements and bed sampling.
The two and three dimension numerical flow model (2D & 3D model) was developed by Delft3D Software Package of Delft Hydraulics to simulate the flow pattern in the plant vicinity. The proposed layout of the intake and outfall of the plant was simulated in the model. The 3D model aims at studying the followings:
• The impact of the plant on the recirculation of effluents at its intake • The impact of the plant on the water quality in its vicinity • The impact of the plant on the navigation.
The 3D model was run under different flow regime. Three flow discharges in EI-Rayah EIBehary were simulated in the model. These are the minimum, dominant and maximum dis.charges which cover the flow regime during the full year. The relevant water levels associated to these discharges were obtained from the computation results of the one dimensional numerical flow model (SOBEK 1 D model).
In the 1 D model a reach along EI-Rayah EI -Behery starting from Km 0.0 at the Head Regulator to Km 85.1 was simulated. The location of the proposed plant is at Km 22 in this reach. The simulation was carried out under the three discharges and all structures, intakes and drains along this reach were simulated. The 1 D model gave the water levels associated with the three discharges. For more details reference is made to the HRI Report No. 192/2009.
Within the frame work of the study, a physical scale model simulates the flow pattern in the plant vicinity should be carried out. The model will confirm the feasibility of the intakeoutfall layout configuration which is recommended from the 2D and 3D numerical flow model study.
This report will focus on the 2D & 3D numerical flow model study. The following sections will present the setup, calibration and the production runs for the 2D & 3D numerical flow model. The model results and conclusion of the study will be presented.
5. FIELD MEASUREMENTS AND DATA COLLECTION
Field measurements were carried out by HRI in August 2009 to collect the data required for the numerical and physical scale models. The data consists of:
Bathymetric survey Flow measurement
5.1 Bathymetric Survey The bathymetric survey in the plant vicinity covered a reach of 6km, 3 km upstream the ct:nterline of the power plant and 3 km downstream the plant. The bathymetric data was used to obtain the contour Map as shown in Figure 2. The contour map was used to build the numerical and physical scale models. For more details reference is made to HRl Survey Report No. 124/2009 which includes the survey Album.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
3
Final Report
Figure 2: General layout of the contour map ofthe study area
5.2 Flow measurements The flow measurements were carried out at five cross-sections covering the surveyed reach. Two cross sections are located upstream the power plant, one section in the vicinity of the plant and the other two are in the downstream of the plant. The layout of the location of the cross sections is shown in Figure 3. The measured discharges and water levels at the measuring cross sections are shown in Table 1.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
4
Figure 3: Location of the velocity cross sections
Tablel: Flow distribution at measured cross sections
Table 1: Flow discharges and water levels at the cross sections
Cross section Q(m3/s)
veil 290.82
vel2 288.09
vel3 286.33
vel4 280.41
vel5 279.26
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
5
WL(m)MSL
14.81
14.71
14.65
14.57
14.46
Final Report
Final Repe.rt
6. HYDRODYNAMIC MODELING
6.1 Description of Delft3D Numerical Software Package Delft3D Software Package of Delft Hydraulics, the Netherlands was used to develop the hydrodynamic numerical flow model which simulates the flow pattern in the vicinity of the proposed plant. The model will enable the study of recirculation, transport and advection of the thermal plume and the cross flow. Delft3D is integrated, powerful and flexible software. It can carry out simulations of two- (either in the horizontal or a vertical plane) and three-dimensional flows, sediment transports, waves, water quality, morphological developments and ecology. The Delft3D package is used for the modeling of coastal, river and estuarine areas. It encompasses a number of well-tested and validated modules, which are linked to and integrated with one-another. These modules are flow, waves, water quality, ecology, particle tracking and sediment transport. Since this study focuses on hydrodynamic simulations and the transport and advection of the thermal plume, the hydrodynamic module (flow module) of Delft 3D was used. The flow module of Delft 3D is used for far field modeling in which the simulations are accurate enough. For more details on the Delft3D -Flow Module, reference is made to Delft3D Manual.
The Delft 3D Software Package is supported by two other modules to enable the computational grid generation (Delft-RGFGRID) and bathymetric schematization at the grid points (Delft-QUICKIN).
6.2 Setup of North Giza Hydrodynamic Model Delft3D Software Package of Delft Hydraulics was used to develop the North Giza hydrodynamic numerical flow model (NGF). The model simulates the flow pattern in the plant vicinity. All parameters and variables in the model have units according to the SI conventions. The coordinate system used for the model is in WGS-84 UTM system zone 36. All metric co-ordinates in this report are given in this co-ordinate system. The depths and water level information in the flow model are defined relative to a leveling datum, which is equal to Mean Sea Level (MSL). The following sections present the development ofNGF Model.
6.2.1 Model schematization
The development of a numerical flow model starts with the selection of the model limits, which gives the location of the open and closed boundaries and the overall size of the model. The model should be large enough to provide adequate precession at the area of interest based on the information of the study area and location of the plant. The NGF Model is a 20 model and was extended to 3D model with 6 layers along the water column. The 2 dimension mode was used in the calibration phase and the 3 dimension mode was used in the production run to account for the stratification which may occur due to the plant operation. The model covers the wider area around the plant. The model has two open boundaries. One boundary is the discharge open boundary which is located at 3km upstream the plant and the other one is a water level boundary located at 3km downstream
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
6
Final Report
the plant. The intake and outfall of the plant is schematized in the model as discharge sources.
6.2.2 Grid generation
The next step in the schematization process is the design and generation of the computational grid. The computational grid is a curvilinear grid to avoid the stair case problem which affects the numerical accuracy. In the design of a curvilinear grid it is important to follow the land boundaries as good as possible. For the generation of a computational grid, the following items are important:
• The areas which require the highest resolution. • The orthogonality of individual cells; • The spatial variation of the dimensions of the cells; • The total number of computational points.
The resulting computational grid is a compromise between the above items, the selected dimensions of the model and the position of the boundaries. The general layout of the computational grid of the NOF model is given in Figure 4.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
7
Final Report
"lO' 3349,
I 3348
t
3346
30t 301S 302 3m~ 303 3035 304 ;.; COOtdmale (m) -+ x 10~
Figure 4: General layout ofthe computational grid
The model covers an area of about 6.3 km along EI·Rayah EI·Behary and about 0.16 km representing the width of the river in this area. The grid has been developed to match the layout of the land contours as good as possible
For each of the items mentioned above the quality of the computational grid will be described in relation to the relevant requirements.
Resolution The dimensions of the individual cells in the area of interest are about 50 m2
• This resolution, defined as the square root ofthe area of a grid cell.
Orthogonality The deviation from a perfectly orthogonal grid should be smaller than 3° in order to limit errors in the cross advection terms. The parameter describing the orthogonality is defined as cos(90·aO) ::s 0.05, which is equivalent to a::S 3°. In grid cells with negligible cross flow, such as on shallow waters, this requirement can be relaxed. the orthogonality of the model grid was considered in the model and it complies with the grid requirements.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
8
Final Report
Variation of cell dimension The variation of grid cell dimensions should be relatively small. The size difference between two neighboring ceIls is smaller than 20%, as required. This smoothness of the computational grid in the model fulfill the smoothness requirements.
Number of computational points The total number of computational ceIls should be minimized, in order to have an acceptable computation time. The generated computational grid of the depth~averaged model comprises 149 x 158 = 23, 542 points.
6.2.3 Depth schematization
The schematization of the land boundaries have been derived from the hydrographic survey which was carried out by HRI. The water depths have been derived from the contour map obtained from the bathymetric survey conducted by HRI. The bathymetric data has been mapped through an interpolation procedure on the computational grid of the NGF model. In this way each co-ordinate of the computational grid of the model is given a depth value. The transition between the regions covered by different bathymetric data sources have been checked and smoothed where necessary. The resulting bathymetry is presented in Figure 5.
6.2.4 Boundary conditions
In the flow simulations of a specific reach in a river with two open boundaries it is preferable to setup one boundary as a discharge boundary and the other one as a water level boundary. In NGF model the open boundary upstream the plant was selected as a discharge boundary. The boundary downstream the plant was selected as water level boundary. During the calibration phase the discharge and water level measurements at the location of the open boundaries were used in the model. In the model scenarios (production simulations) the discharge data imposed in the upstream boundary is based on the available Icng~term data. The minimum, dominant and maximum discharges were used in the model scenarios. The water levels associated with these discharges were used in the downstream boundary. These water levels were obtained from the results of the I D flow model (SOBEK~ 1 D). For more details on the water level computations, reference is made to the Report No. 192/2009.
6.2.5 Parameter settings
A uniform water density of 1000 kg/m3 was used, representing the fresh water density. The acceleration of gravity was set to 9.80 m2/s. The value for the horizontal eddy viscosity is set to 1.0 m2/s.
6.2.6 Time step
The time step was selected for the model simulations based on the grid size and the Courant Number. A time step of 0.05 minute (3 seconds) was used in the simulations. This time step fulfill the numerical criteria and the Courant Number requirements.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
9
Final Report
6.3 Model Calibration In the calibration phase, various parameters may be adjusted within the limits of their uncertainty to achieve the best model results compared with the measurements data. In the calibration the model open boundaries (discharge and water level boundaries) were obtained from the measurements which were carried out by HRI in the framework of the study. The upstream discharge boundary was 290 m3/s and downstream water level boundary was 14.41 m MSL. In the calibration phase the model was run in its 20 mode (Depth-averaged mode). The model was calibrated against 5 measuring cross sections. During the model calibration the measured depth averaged flow velocities along the measuring cross sections were compared with the model results. The measured and computed water surface slope was also carried out. Tuning of the roughness parameter in the model was carried out to obtain the best matching between the model and the field measurements. Manning Roughness Coefficient of 0.022 to 0.028 m along the model area was found to give the best matching between the measurements and model computations. The calibration results are shown in Figures 6 and 7. Figure 6 shows the comparison between the measured and computed water level. Figure 7 shows the measured and computed flow velocities. The figures show that there is a good agreement between the model and the measurements which confirms that the model simulates the flow pattern in the plant vicinity in the right way.
Water Level Comparison
14.9 -,--.~--~-----------------------,
14.75
14.6
.......
.§. iii 14.45 ~
...J
14.3
14.15
14~--~~---_~--~~~--~~~-~-T~~~~~~~~
o 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 Distances (m)
Figure 5: Measured and computed water surface slope in the study area
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
10
0,11
0.'
";' 0.. E
Velocity COmparbOll at CS-J
Velo<ity ComparisoR .1 CS·J
i 0.5 I .. :> '" 0 •• 'g ~ 0,3
D.2
01
0.0 '0,0 20,0 30,0
Final Report
Velotity Comparisoo at CS-2
(hunc •• (m}
Velodty Comparison at CS-4
VelD<ity Comparison.1 CS-S
Figure 6: Measured and computed flow velocities at the measuring cross sections
7. PLANT CHARACTERISTICS The proposed plant consists of two units of 750 MW power each. The plant will be a combined cycle. The intake and outfall layout and discharges and the design excess temperature at the outfall above the ambient water temperature are essential information to simulate the plant in the model. This information should be received by the client (EEHC). The client has not yet submitted this information to HRI and has requested HRI through a phone call to HRI director to get this information based on HRI experience in similar
HVDROTHER~:'~~U:L:~~ NORTH GIZA 11 !8) <':" ~-~~,,.
Final Report
projects. Based on HRI experience in similar studies, the intake and outfall discharges and the excess water temperature at the outfall above the ambient water were investigated. Tables I to 4 in Appendix I present the plant characteristics of four power plants which were studied in HRI. For 2 units of 750 MW power with a combined cycle the intake and outfall discharges are taken 27.5 m3/s. The excess temperature at the outfall above the ambient water is taken 8 0 C.
HRI setup the model scenarios based on the above information and assuming that the plant is running for its full capacity (the two units are in operation).
8. MODEL SCENARIOS After the hydrodynamic simulation was confirmed from the calibration phase the model was used to investigate the impact of the proposed plant on the recirculation, temperature distribution around the plant and the cross flow induced by the plant. In the model scenarios the depth-averaged model was extended to a three dimensional model. Six layers along the water depth was setup. The depth of the first two surface layers is 10% of the water depth while the other four layers are 20% of the water depth. The three dimension model accounts for the stratification which would occur due to the density difference along the water column. The stratification may occur in the plant vicinity due to the high water temperature discharged from the plant outfall.
To achieve the aim of the study a test program consists of three scenarios was setup. The scenarios consider the seasonal variations of the discharges flowing in AI-Rayah EI_Behery
The EEHC did not provide HRI with the discharges flowing in EI-Rayah EI_Behery in which the model should be conducted. The discharges used in the model scenarios are based on the available data in HRI. From the data the minimum, dominant and maximum discharges were obtained. The associated water levels for each discharge was obtained from the 1 D model (SOBEK I D). The minimum discharge occurs in the winter season when the ambient water temperature is about 15 0 C. The dominant discharge occurs most of the year when the ambient water temperature is about 25°C. The maximum discharge occurs in the summer where the ambient water temperature is 28°C. Table 2 presents a summery of test program. In the table At is the excess temperature above the ambient water at the outfall.
Table 2: Test Program
I Scenario Flow Q river Water Ambient water i Plant Characterristics .-
condition level temperature f-Q .. -(m3/s) I ,11
(C) i (m3/s) (C)
I (m) MSL
1 Minimum 113.5 12.84
2 I Dominant 231.5 I i 14.08
3 I maximum 312.5 ! 14.79
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
15 27.5 8
25 27.5 8
28 1
27.5 8
12 da ;;;"_:." : /),~ . , '"-"---.,,,,,,'"
Final Report
9. MODEL RESULTS The 3 dimension model results are presented in this chapter. The following sections discuss the results of the model scenarios. The figures of the model results are presented in Appendix 2 in the report.
9.1 Scenario 1 Scenario 1 simulates the flow condition in EI-Rayah EI-Behery in the winter where the flow discharge is the minimum. In this scenario the total inflow of water to the plant is 27.5 m: Is whereas the river flow is r I 4 m3/s, i.e. the water abstraction by the plant is about 24.2 % of the main river flow. The flow pattern around the plant in the top and bottom layers is presented in Figure 7. The figures showed that the flow velocities in the top layer are higher than in the bottom layer. The effect of the flow discharge from the plant on the flow velocity in front of the outfall is clearly seen. The distribution of the water temperature in th\~ plant vicinity for this flow condition in the top and bottom layers is shown in Figure 8a. Figure 8b shows the plume around the plant outfall. The figures show that the plume is concentrated near the water surface (top layer). The effect of the plume on the water temperature close to the bed is relatively small. The figures show that there is no redrculation of the effluent discharge from the plant outfall to its intake. The excess temperature above the ambient water outside the mixing zone does not exceed 5 degrees which complies with the water quality standards.
9.2 Scenario 2 This scenario simulates the flow condition in EI-Rayah EI-Behary in most of the year where the flow discharge is dominant. The plant inflow is 27.5 m3/s whereas the river flow is 231.5 m3/s, i.e. the plant inflow is about 11.9 % of the main river flow. The flow pattern in the top and bottom layer under this flow condition is presented in Figure 9. The figure shows that the flow velocity in the top layer is higher than in the bottom layer. It can be seen that the flow velocity in this scenario is higher than the flow velocity in scenario I "'ith minimum discharge. The distribution of the water temperature in the plant vicinity and at the plant outfall in top and bottom layers is shown in figures lOa and lOb. The figures show that there is no recirculation of the effluent discharge at the plant intake. It can be st:en from the figures that the area of the plume in case of the dominant discharge is smaller than the area of the plume in case of the minimum discharge. This can be explained by that fact that the dominant discharge causes a larger water mixing in front of the outfall than the minimum discharge which increase the dilution process. The figures show that the plume etfect in the top layer is larger than in the bottom layer. The excess water temperature above the ambient water outside the mixing zone is less than 5 degrees which complies with the Egyptian water quality standards.
9.3 Scenario 3 This scenario simulates the flow condition in EI-Rayah EI-Behery in the summer where the flow discharge is the maximum. The plant inflow is 27.5 m3/s whereas the river flow is 3 I 3 m3/s, i.e. the plant inflow is about 8.8 % of the main river flow. Figure 11 shows that flow pattern in top and bottom layers under this flow condition. The figure shows that the flow -velocities are higher than the other scenarios because of the higher discharge. Figures 12a and 12b show the water distribution in the vicinity and in front of the
HY DROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
13
Final Report
outfall. The figures show that there is no recirculation of the effluent discharge to the intake. The size of the plume is small compared to the size of the plume in case of minimum and dominant discharges because of the higher flow velocities which cause more dilution of the effluent discharge and better mixing of the effluents with the fresh water. The figures show that the water temperature outside the mixing zone is less than 5 degrees which is in a good agreement with the Egyptian water quality standards ..
Figure 13 shows the water temperature at the intake for Scenarios 1,2 and 3. It can be seen that there is no recirculation at the intake for the three scenarios.
10. VELOCITY DISTRIBUTION RESULTS The flow pattern was simulated in the three scenarios. The flow velocity in the direction of the river flow and the cross velocity perpendicular to the main flow in the river were obtained at three cross sections, see Figure 14. The first cross section is upstream the outfall structure at a distance of 10m. The second cross section is in the center line of the outfall structure. The third cross section is downstream the outfall structure at a distance of 10m. At each cross section the flow velocity was obtained starting from the left bank to the right bank. The computed velocities show that the cross flow velocity exceeds the allowable velocity, which is 0.30 m3/s slightly only in the area surrounding outfall structures and is confined to less than 20% of the total river width. More than 80% of the river width the cross velocity is less than 0.3 m/s which is suitable for navigation. The computed cross flow velocities for the three scenarios at the three cross sections are shown in Figures 15 to 23. The figures show that the safety zone width is about 65 m from the discharging point of the outfall structures.
11. CONCLUSIONS
The EEHC commissioned HRI to conduct hydrodynamic and circulation study to investigate the impact of the proposed North Giza Plant on the recirculation, environment and navigation. The study comprised hydrographic survey, numerical hydrodynamic modeling and physical scale modeling. The data from the hydrographic survey was used to develop, calibrate and operate the numerical and physical scale models.
The report presents the hydrodynamic two and three dimension modeling study. The study aims at investigating the impact of the plant on the recirculation of the hot brine at its intake and the increased water temperature in the plant vicinity. The study on the impact of the plant on the cross current induced by the plant intake/outfall on the navigation was conducted within the framework of the study.
The depth averaged numerical hydrodynamic flow model was developed and calibrated with the data from the field measurements. This model was extended to a three dimension model with six layers along the water column to account for the stratification which ma)' occur in front of the plant due to the density difference induced by the temperature variation. Three scenarios were setup to account for the different flow regime in the river, minimum, dominant and maximum discharges. The water levels associated to theses discharges were obtained from the 1 dimensional model (10 SOBEK).
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
14
Final Report
To do the plant simulation the layout of the intake/outfall structure, the design inflow and outflow of the plant and the excess temperature at the outfall above the ambient water should be provided by the client. The client did not provide these information and HRI was requested to obtain this information from HRI experience in similar projects. HRI did investigate this information from the similar previous studies and use it in the present study.
The results of the model simulations show the followings: ~o recirculation of the effluent discharge at the plant intake for all scenarios. The excess of the water temperature above the ambient water outside the mixing lOne and in the plant vicinity under the different river flow regime is less than 5 degrees. This values are in accordance with the Egyptian water quality standards. The flow pattern obtained from the model scenarios show that the cross flow velocities in the plant vicinity for all scenarios are within the accepted limits in the navigation path. The flow velocities hardly exceeds the 0.3 m/s in the navigation path. The model results show that the dilution of the plume is better for the dominant and maximum discharges than the minimum discharge because of the good mixing of the effluents with the fresh water under relatively high discharges. The results show that the plume is concentrated near the water surface and its impact is reduced near the river bed.
12. RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the study and the model results the following is recommended:
The layout and the plant characteristics as simulated in the model is recommended with a condition of confirming the design with the physical scale model. fhe layout of the intake/outfall structures and the plant characteristics as simulated in the numerical model should be tested in the physical scale model. The aim of the physical scale model is to confirm the results of the numerical model. Warning signs are to be placed upstream and downstream the plant. All fishermen boats are to be kept 30 m away from the outfall structures to avoid the effect of relatively high cross currents caused by the effluent discharge into the river.
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
15
Appendix 1
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Appendix 2
HYDROTHERMAL STUDY TO NORTH GIZA POWER PLANT
Final Report
Annex E
THERMAL PLUME MODELING