Honoring Our Native Transgender Communities
Native Americans/Alaska Natives
United States• In 2000, US Census – NA/AN make up 1.5 % of
total US population – over 3 million people
• In CA, over 100 tribes – Federal & State Recognized
• 40% living in rural/reservation areas; 60% living in urban areas (Los Angeles County)
Two Spirit – Native LBGT• Two Spirit term refers to Native
American/Alaska Native Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender (LGBT) individuals
• Came from the Anishinabe language.
• Has a different meaning in different communities. Encompassing term used is “Two Spirit” adopted in 1990 at the 3rd International Native Gay & Lesbian Gathering in Winnipeg, Canada.
• It means having both feminine and masculine spirits within one person.
• The term is used in rural and urban communities to describe the re-claiming of their traditional identity and roles.
• The term refers to culturally prescribed spiritual and social roles; however, the term is not applicable to all tribes and some transgender individuals • We’wha
Tribal Language &Two Spirit Terminology
Tribe Term Gender
Crow boté male
Navajo nádleehí male and female
Lakota winkte male
Zuni lhamana male
Omaha mexoga male
LGBT/Two Spirit Umbrella
Gay BisexualLesbian Transgender
Two Spirit
A term for people whose gender identity and/or
gender expression differs from the sex they were
assigned at birth.
An individual who is physically, romantically,
emotionally and/or spiritually attracted to men
and women
A man whose enduring physical, romantic,
emotional and/or spiritual attraction is to other men
A woman whose enduring physical, romantic, emotional and/or spiritual attraction is to
other women.
A contemporary term used to identify Native American Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender
individuals with traditional and cultural understandings of gender roles and identity.
Spirituality and Culture
• “Alternative gender roles were respected and honored and believed to part of the sacred web of life and society.”
• Lakota view: Winktes are sacred people whose androgynous nature is an inborn character trait or the result of a vision.
• Example: Lakota Naming Ceremony
• For many tribes, myths revealed that two-spirit individuals were decreed to exist by deities or were among the pantheon of gods.”
• Example: Navajo Creation Story – The Separation of Sexes
Prominent figures• We’wha (Zuni) circa 1849-1896• Hastiin Klah (Diné) 1867-1937• Osh Tisch (Crow) 1854-1929• Woman Chief (Crow) circa early 19th
century -1854• Lozen (Chiricahua Apache) 1840 –
1890
We’wha (Zuni) circa 1849-1896
• Zuni spiritual leader • Performed sacred roles in ceremonial dances
Hastiin Klah (Diné) 1867 - 1937
• celebrated weaver and a sand painter
Osh-Tisch (Crow) 1854 - 1929
• “Finds Them and Kills Them”
Woman Chief (Crow) 1854 - ?
• Gros Ventre Indian• “Married” a woman
Lozen (Apache) 1840 - 1890
• Skilled warrior• Fought beside Geronimo
European Colonization
Spanish invader Vasco Nuñez de Balboa (1475-1519) presiding over the massacre of "sodomites" in Central America, Engraving by Theodore De Bry.
Boarding Schools – 1870s
Boarding Schools• Army officer, Richard Pratt, founded the first of these
schools. He based it on an education program he had developed in an Indian prison.
• "A great general has said that the only good Indian is a dead one, in a sense, I agree with the sentiment, but only in this: that all the Indian there is in the race should be dead. Kill the Indian in him, and save the man."
• Students at federal boarding schools were forbidden to express their culture — everything from wearing long hair to speaking even a single Indian word.
"I remember coming home and my grandma asked me to talk Indian to
her and I said, ‘Grandma, I don't understand you’. She said, 'Then
who are you?' “ 1945 - Bill Wright, a Pattwin Indian
Relocation Program – 1950s
• 1952, the federal government initiated the Urban Indian Relocation Program
• Jobs, education, housing, vocational training
Historical Trauma• Cumulative emotional and psychological
wounding over the lifespan and across generations
• Confront the historical trauma• Understanding the trauma• Release the pain of historical trauma• Transcend the trauma
Complete Wellness forNative Americans/Alaskan
Natives• Spirituality is important aspect of Native way of life –
everything is connected – body, mind and spirit.
• Living in balance is essential – harmony and balance through traditional prayer, songs, ceremonies.
• Traditional medicine is used to cure illness and disease – with herbs in ceremonial settings – often on the reservation or rural communities.
• Traditional medicine can be used with Western medicine to develop a holistic wellness of their body, mind, and spirit.
Transgender Data
• There are no concrete statistics on the number of transgender people in the United States.
• Estimates on the number of transsexual people, which ignore the broader transgender population, range anywhere from 0.25 to 1 percent of the U.S. population.
• Additional research on Native Transgender population is needed with accurate and inclusive HIV/AIDS statistics.
• Inclusion of Native Transgender in research and data is imperative! (even if the population is considered small).
Epidemiology of HIV among Transgender
Individuals• An Epidemiological Profile of HIV & AIDS 2009 Los Angeles
County: Transgender individuals are estimated to have the highest HIV seroprevalence rate with 21% of the priority populations in LA County in 2005. Specifically, Native Transgenders represent 2.9% of the cases which is higher within the populations.
• San Francisco Department of Public Health Study – A Snapshot of Discrimination: In 1997, the San Francisco Department of Public Health surveyed 392 MTF and 123 FTM transgender people that included specifically Native Americans with 6% being Native MTF and 3% being Native FTM.
AIDS Project Los Angeles (APLA)
Funded by Office of AIDS Programs and Policy, Los Angeles County Funded by the Department of Disability, City of Los Angeles, AIDS Coordinator’s Office
An Overview• Red Circle Project (RCP) was created in August 2003 at
APLA by an initial a grant from the U.S. Conference of Mayors.
• RCP is the only HIV Prevention Program in Los Angeles County that specifically targets Native American /Alaska Native Community.
• Goal of the project is to increase positive social norms around safer sex and emphasize its benefits as well as the importance of early screening for HIV – referrals for testing.
• Project provides education and prevention information to Native community at outreach events such as Powwows, etc.
Developing and Implementing Support
Group Workshops • Currently, adapting Community PROMISE intervention for
urban Native Two Spirit/Gay Men and Native Transgenders.
• The “Strengthening the Circle” Curriculum has four (4) workshops that address behavioral and cultural issues. The workshops are designed with the concept of Native American/Alaska Native’s understanding of the “Medicine Wheel.” The Medicine Wheel is a symbol of knowledge that enables individuals to live in balance with all aspects of life – physical, mental, emotion, and spiritual.
• The workshops will also encourage participants to make informed decisions that will guide their subsequent behavior.
www.redcircleproject.org
• The RCP website provides pertinent information about HIV/AIDS for individuals and service providers in Los Angeles.
• It also lists local organizations and agencies that provide services for Native organizations locally and nationally.
Challenges of Programs
• Stigma about HIV in the community still exists, however more education and outreach efforts are providing valuable information.
• Continued collaboration is needed between agencies – Native and non-Native.
• No specific geographical areas of Urban NA/AN exists (ie. neighborhoods, bars, etc.) and providing services is a challenge.
• Misclassification of clients is an issue among providers.• Additional research and accurate information on
HIV/AIDS statistics is needed.• Additional funding is still needed for additional
services and resources.
Questions & Answers
Please feel free to ask questions and/or comments . . .
May the Creator Always Guide and Protect You as You Walk In
Beauty . . .Ahe’hee (Thank you)
The Red Circle ProjectAIDS Project Los Angeles (APLA)3550 Wilshire Blvd. Ste. # 300
Los Angeles, CA 90010
Elton Naswood, Program Coordinator P: 323.329.9905E: [email protected]
Michelle Enfield, Prevention SpecialistP: 323.329.9906E: [email protected]
Global VillageJuly 23, 2012
Washington, DC
Data among the Transgender Community: Working with Native Transgender Individuals
National Gay and Lesbian Task Force and National Center for Transgender Equality◦ Almost 6500 participants in the Survey◦ Guam, District of Columbia, US virgin Islands, and
Puerto Rico
Injustice at Every turn
Dramatic Findings◦ Discrimination
◦ Poverty – 10,000 or less than the general population
◦ Suicide – 41% have thought of attempted suicide, This not including individuals who followed through. Compared to 1.6% of the general population
Injustice at Every turn
Experienced Bullying in School◦ 51% have experienced◦ 15% left school K-12
This also including teachersBoarding Schools?/Public Schools/Rural/Urban
Lost a job due to bias◦ 55% of participants◦ Tribal employment?
Victim of physical Assault◦ 61% of participants
Victim of Sexual Assault◦ 64% of participants
Injustice at Every turn
Housing Discrimination◦ Native Americans were the highest statistics◦ 47% of participants
Respondents who have experienced homelessness were highly vulnerable to mistreatment in public settings, police
abuse and negative health outcomes.
Injustice at Every turn
Public Accomodations 53% of participants denied equal treatment by government agencies or
officials
Police Interaction22% of participantsTribal Police?
Family43% still had some sort of connection57% have experienced Rejection
Injustice at Every turn
Health CareDenied HealthCare – 19%
Indian Health ServicesReservationRuralUrban
High HIV rates: Respondents reported over four times the national average of HIV infection.
50 % had to educate their healthcare provider
Injustice at every turn
Native American Transgender Population
◦ General Historical Trauma
◦ Reservation settings/Urban settings
◦ Migration of Native Transgender Population
◦ Alaska? Hawaii? Global?
Honoring our Native TG Woman
We are still here
Working
School
Family
Acceptance
Resiliency
Sex (assigned at birth)
Sexual Orientation
Gender Identity
Gender Expression
Basic Concepts:
Electronic Medical Records – how data is being collected
Committee formed to address companies that provide EMR
Data Collection - EMR
What is your sex or current gender? (Check all that apply) Male⃤ Female⃤ TransMale/Transman⃤ TransFemale/Transwoman⃤ Genderqueer⃤ Additional Category (Please Specify): ______________⃤ Decline to State⃤
What sex were you assigned at birth? Male⃤ Female⃤ Decline to State ⃤
Center of Excellence for Transgender Health
How to be an awesome Ally & Provider!
Paperwork/documents Policies/procedures Laws Data Safety – physical, mental, emotional,
spiritual Client centered
Things to remember:
Center of Excellence for Transgender Health, UCSF, www.transhealth.edu
National Center for Transgender Equality, www.transequality.org
Injustice at Every turn Statewide Transgender Organizations
◦ TGRCNM, New Mexico Local Transgender Organizations
◦ Los Angeles, San Francisco, Chicago, New York, Phoenix, Atlanta, etc.
Services and Referrals
Thank you Mattee Jim
◦ Supervisor HIV Prevention Programs, First Nations Community HealthSource, 5608 Zuni Rd., Albuquerque, NM 87108 – (505)262-6554 [email protected]
◦ National Advisory Board Member, Center of Excellence for Transgender Health, UCSF
◦ Board Member, Transgender Resource Center of New Mexico
◦ Co-Chair, New Mexico Community Planning and Action Group Transgender Task Force
◦ Community Advisory Board Member, Share Action, AIDS Project Los Angeles
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines 44
BASIC PRINCIPLES
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
45
Developing a Transgender Culturally Competent Environment
• Creating a welcoming, culturally competent, and responsive place where patients/clients feel comfortable and safe is an important aspect of keeping clients/patients in care. Clients/patients are more likely to continue going to an agency where they not only feel their needs are being met, but also where they feel respected. A transgender culturally competent environment applies both to physical space and overall agency culture. The following standards provide strategies for ensuring that agencies establish and promote an inclusive, non-discriminatory place for both staff and clients/patients.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
46
Creating a safe and comfortable agency space
• Provide gender neutral or unisex restrooms.• Display posters and literature supportive of transgender people.• Ensure that the receptionist (or the first person with whom a
client would interact) is comfortable working with transgenderpeople and is appropriately trained.
• Attempt to locate agency in close proximity to where clients live.• Monitor waiting room areas to ensure that spaces are free from
violence and harassment, and ensuring there is a plan of actionshould these occur.
• Offer transgender sensitivity training to clients/patients.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
47
Using AppropriateCommunication and Language
• Communication is a key component to achieving and improving health literacy. Communication and language barriers affect consumers’ abilities to communicate with providers and their understanding of health concepts and procedures. Barriers to effective communication can also limit consumers’ ability to adequately advocate for their health. The following standards specifically address communication and language barriers that transgender clients/patients encounter. These standards ensure that providers utilize gender neutral language and that agencies as a whole are inclusive of transgender clients/patients.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
48
Using Gender Neutral Language• Address clients/patients with respect and courtesy.• Address clients according to their presenting gender and when in
doubt, politely ask.• Ask clients what name they prefer to be called and address
clients accordingly.• Do not make assumptions about a patient’s/client’s anatomy or about
names for the patient’s anatomy.• Use pronouns that are appropriate to the client’s gender identity.• As part of being respectful of patients, do not ask questions
that are not related to the patient’s health. Do not ask personalquestions for the sake of curiosity.
• Acknowledge that some questions may touch on sensitive orpersonal subjects.
• Ask questions in a non-judgmental manner.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
49
Using Gender Neutral Language• Use pronouns that are appropriate to the client’s gender
identity.
• As part of being respectful of patients, do not ask questionsthat are not related to the patient’s health. Do not ask personalquestions for the sake of curiosity.
• Acknowledge that some questions may touch on sensitive orpersonal subjects.
• Ask questions in a non-judgmental manner.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
50
Using Gender Neutral Language
• Attempt to use words that the patient/client uses, prefers, and understands, particularly for anatomy, sexual activities or other sensitive matters.
• If you don’t understand a word or reference, politely ask him or her to explain.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
51
Gender Neutral Agency Forms
• Develop agency forms that are inclusive; for example, intake and assessment forms should provide for optional self-identification in all categories of gender identity, sexual orientation, marital, partnership and family status.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
52
Gender Neutral Agency Forms
• Allow patients/clients the option to identify their biological gender separate from their gender identity.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
53
Building a TrustingRelationship with Trans Patients• Be aware that clients/patients may be dealing with
issues of low self esteem or depression. Make an attempt to check in with the client/patient about how he or she is doing. Speak in an encouraging manner and take an interest in the individual as a whole.
• Remind clients/patients of the available resources and referrals.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
54
Building a TrustingRelationship with Trans Patients
• Approach the client/patient in a way that allows the client/patient to feel acknowledged as a person, while recognizing the limitations of the interaction.
• Be sympathetic to the challenges that living as a transgender person brings; therefore, be open with the patient and explore what those challenges are. Give patients an opportunity to talk and share. Try to provide emotional support.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
55
Non-discrimination Policies and Procedures
• Post written non-discrimination policies and complaint procedures, in the primary languages of clients/patients, in conspicuous and accessible places throughout agency.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
56
Trans Sensitive Staff Trainings
• Transgender-specific services—Both clinical and direct staff members should be aware of transgender-specific services provided at their agency as well as at other agencies in the community.
• Communication training—Train staff in the use of culturally appropriate language. Staff members should be comfortable asking a transgender patient questions such as “What gender do you identify with?”, “What term do you use for this part of your anatomy?”
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
57
Trans Sensitive Staff Trainings
• Ongoing training on sexual orientation and gender identity issues, transgender culture and its diversity, and health issues faced by transgender people.
• Training on sexual and other forms of harassment, as well as domestic violence and anti-discrimination laws.
Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines
58
For more information:
• Transgender HIV Health Services Best Practices Guidelines.
• http://www.careacttarget.org/library/tgguidelines.pdf
Thank You.