![Page 1: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
HOW PROCESS VARIABLES IMPACT
CERAMIC SHELL PROPERTIES AND
PERFORMANCE
Dave Berta, Casey Wolfe and Mike Hendricks
Ransom & Randolph
Maumee, Ohio, USA
![Page 2: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
AGENDA
• Background
– Shell system evolution
– Shell building equipment evolution
• Purpose of Paper
• Design of Experiment (DOE)
– Overview
– Input Variables
– Output Variables
– DOE Setup
• Results and Discussion
• Conclusions
• Acknowledgements
2
![Page 3: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
BACKGROUND
• Shell System Evolution
– Alcohol based gave way to water
based binder systems
– Binders and systems specifically
for primary and backup
applications
– Polymers
• Speed up shell drying
• Increase adhesion
• Increase green strength
– Fibers
• Increase build rate
• Improve slurry retention on edges
• Strengthen shells
• Reduce number of coats required
3
![Page 4: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
BACKGROUND
• Robot System Evolution
- Robot systems have been part of
the process from early days
- Hardware technology of robotic
systems has had little evolution –
state of the art for some time
- Evolution has been in the
programming of the robots
- Unique dipping and draining
techniques
- Can be unique per each dip
- Shell building is a function of the
program vs the actual robot.
4
![Page 5: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
PURPOSE OF PAPER
The purpose of this paper is to utilize a Design of
Experiment (DOE) approach to determine what
the effects of certain controllable shell building
process variables have on the shell properties.
5
![Page 6: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTOVERVIEW
• DOE Definition – An effort to explain the variation of information under conditions that are hypothesized to reflect the variation of observations.
• Input Variables – (conditions)
– Viscosity
– Dwell Time
– Draining Technique
• Output Variables – (observations)
– Shell Strength
– Edge Thickness
– Hot Permeability
– Round Thickness
– Spalling Load
6
![Page 7: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTINPUT VARIABLES - VISCOSITY
• Measure of a fluid’s resistance to flow
• Quantifies the thickness or thinness of a fluid
• Universally standard test in the industry and
well documented
• Viscosity targets are unique for each foundry
depending on process, part geometry and
experience
7
![Page 8: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTINPUT VARIABLES – DWELL TIME
• Defined as the time the shell is in the slurry before removal for
draining
• Shells will absorb some liquid when dipped (ceramic sponge)
– Longer dwell
• More liquid absorbed from slurry
• Draining slurry is more uniform in rheology
– Shorter dwell
• More liquid is absorbed from the slurry layer being drained
• Draining slurry can change in rheology as liquid is absorbed by shell
• Dwell time has a greater impact on backup coats (thicker sponge)
than primary coats
8
![Page 9: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTINPUT VARIABLES – DRAINING TECHNIQUE
• Purpose of draining is to remove excess slurry from the part,
ensure cluster is evenly coated to accept a consistent layer of
stucco
• Draining is a combination of manipulation of the cluster and time
• Estimated that over 50% of the slurry that is on a cluster when it
exits the slurry tank has to drain off back into the tank
• It will take longer for slurry to drain off of a part in motion than a
stagnant part
• Consider a stagnant drain – a “GUSH” – before manipulation of
the cluster
9
![Page 10: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTOUTPUT VARIABLES
• These are all well defined, documented and discussed in previous ICI technical
papers and not discussed in great detail in presentation
– Shell Strength
• MOR
• AFL (Load Bearing Capacity)
• Thickness
– Edge Thickness
– Hot Permeability
– Round Thickness – Permeability ball thickness
• Better represent production parts
• 3D vs 2D
– Spalling Load – Intercoat adhesion measurement
Figure 1 – Wax Figure 2 – Cut Sample Figure 3 – Edge Measurement
10
![Page 11: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTDOE SETUP
• Three controlled input variables
– Viscosity – 2 levels
– Dwell time – 3 levels
– Draining technique – 3 levels
• Systems tested
Slurry ID Binder Component Refractory
P1 Polymer 1 140 mesh fused silica
P1F1 Polymer 1 with Fiber 1 140 mesh fused silica
P2F2 Polymer 2 with Fiber 2 140 mesh fused silica
11
![Page 12: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTDOE SETUP
• Used DOE Software to set up testing combinations
• Samples were built using a total of 54 separate combinations of
parameters
• The actual 54 combinations are listed in Appendix 1
12
![Page 13: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
DESIGN OF EXPERIMENTDRAINING TECHNIQUE VIDEOS
• Three videos
– Permeability balls being dipped
– 10 Second Dwell Time
• Drain Techniques
– Video 1
– Video 2
– Video 3
13
![Page 14: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
Drain 1
(0/10)
![Page 15: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
Drain 2 (0/20)
![Page 16: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
Gush + Drain 1 (10/10)
![Page 17: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSSIGNIFICANT FACTORS AFFECTING DESIGN OUTPUTS
Factor
MOR
(green)
AFL
(green)
Thickness
(flat)
Thickness
(round)
Permeability
(hot)
Spalling
Load
Edge
build
(top)
Edge
build
(bottom)
Backup
SystemX X X X X X
Viscosity
Dwell
TimeX X X X
Draining
TechniqueX X
X denotes that the Factor has an impact on Output Variable
17
![Page 18: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSBACKUP SYSTEM
Factor
MOR
(green)
AFL
(green)
Thickness
(flat)
Thickness
(round)
Permeability
(hot)
Spalling
Load
Edge build
(top)
Edge build
(bottom)
Backup
SystemX X X X X X
• A change in the backup system produced significant effect on
most output variables
• Confirms previous studies that showed that shell systems are
designed to maximize shell properties
• This paper is more focused on process variables effects so will not
discuss in detail here
18
![Page 19: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSVISCOSITY
Factor
MOR
(green)
AFL
(green)
Thickness
(flat)
Thickness
(round)
Permeability
(hot)
Spalling
Load
Edge
build
(top)
Edge
build
(bottom)
Viscosity
• The 4 second change in viscosities chosen (10 & 14/Zahn 5) did
not significantly impact the output variables
• Somewhat surprising result as viscosity is such a key control
parameter in the industry
• Could be due to forgiveness of the shell system
• More work could be done to see how large of a viscosity change
would make an impact on shell properties
19
![Page 20: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSDWELL TIME & DRAINING TECHNIQUES
Factor
MOR
(green)
AFL
(green)
Thickness
(flat)
Thickness
(round)
Permeability
(hot)
Spalling
Load
Edge
build
(top)
Edge
build
(bottom)
Dwell Time X X X X
Draining
TechniqueX X
• These input factors do impact the output variables
• Purpose of paper was to look at the effects that controllable
process variables had on the shell
• Explore these in more detail
20
![Page 21: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSDWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS AND AFL
• As dwell time increases, thickness decreases
– Confirms the ceramic sponge concept
• Decrease in thickness, decreases AFL
• Practical Application
– Increase dwell time on parts prone to bridging
– Increase in dwell time could eliminate the need for prewet on some
parts21
3.00 6.40 9.80 13.20 16.60 20.00
C: Dwell Time (secs)
Th
ickn
ess (
mm
)
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
One Factor
TH
ICK
NE
SS
(m
m)
3.00 6.40 9.80 13.20 16.60 20.00
C: Dwell Time (secs)
AF
L (
lbs)
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
One Factor
AF
L (
po
un
ds)
DWELL TIME (seconds) DWELL TIME (seconds)
![Page 22: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSDRAIN TECHNIQUE EFFECT ON ROUND THICKNESS
• Drain technique did not impact flat bar thickness
• Round part simulates actual production parts better (3D).
• Shorter drain – thicker
• Gush plus drain – thinner than just drain
• Practical Application
– Adding a gush speeds cycle especially considering part complexity and multi tree clusters
22
10 sec gush + drain 1 drain 1 drain 2
D: Drain
Ro
un
d t
hic
kn
ess (
mm
)
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
9
One Factor
Ro
un
d T
hic
kn
ess
(mm
)
10 sec gush
+ drain 1drain 1 drain 2
![Page 23: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTSDRAIN TECHNIQUE EFFECT ON EDGE BUILD
• Impact seen only on bottom edge
• Top thickness behaves similarly to the overall shell thickness
• Bottom thickness behaves similarly to the round part thickness
• Stagnant drain results in a thinner shell
23
10 sec gush + drain 1 drain 1 drain 2
D: Drain
ed
ge
bu
ild b
ott
om
(m
m)
4.2
4.4
4.6
4.8
5
One Factor
Ed
ge
bu
ild
bo
tto
m
(mm
)
10 sec gush
+ drain 1drain 1 drain 2
![Page 24: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
RESULTS
• Foundries can develop individual dipping techniques to optimize
shell build and properties
• Where bridging is a concern, implementing a longer dwell and a
gush can impact shell build by producing a thinner coat
• Where edge cracking is an issue, a reduction in drain time and
dwell time can increase the thickness
• Consider adding extended “gush” when dipping sealcoats to
speed time and reduce slurry dripping as unstuccoed parts travel
down the conveyor
• Overall dipping and draining cycle can be manipulated to impact
throughput
• A longer dwell time and addition of a gush could save production
time
24
![Page 25: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
CONCLUSIONS
• Foundries can make a real impact on shell build by making simple
changes to their dipping and draining techniques
• Different parts will require some experimentation to discover what
works best for the foundry, parts being dipped, etc.
• Today’s robots allow the user to program multiple configurations
• Investing in personnel training and establishing robot cycles
specific to different part configurations would allow the foundry to
optimize dip, drain & dwell patterns; allowing for more efficient
production and improving shell casting performance
25
![Page 26: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
FUTURE WORK OPPORTUNITIES
• Results of this investigation were not groundbreaking
– Simple test pieces and limited manipulation capabilities
• Results do indicate that more work could be done to truly understand the overall impact the process variables have on shell properties and performance
• Future work with a foundry could look at impact on actual production parts
– Shell build time
– Dewax cracking
– Shell weight
– Knockout
– Etc.
• Could be an opportunity for future collaboration with an interested foundry
26
![Page 27: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
• We would like to thank the following
– Sam Jeffrey, R&R Product and Application Technician, for all of his
work on setting up and testing samples
– Alisa Rawski and Marti Hunyor in the R&R Marketing Group for their
work on completion of the written paper and presentation
27
![Page 28: HOW PROCESS VARIABLES MPACT CERAMIC SHELL ......process variables had on the shell • Explore these in more detail 20 Investing with InnovationTM RESULTS DWELL TIME IMPACT ON THICKNESS](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022053122/60aac67d48a0cf11411a0f37/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Investing with InnovationTM
QUESTIONS?
Thank You!