How Security Connects to Safety:HR & Workplace Violence
Gary T. Miller, P.E.
Louisiana Society for Human Resource Management
April 26, 2012
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Disclaimer The speaker doesn’t represent that the information
and techniques presented will prevent workplace violence, prevent loss of business or other associated costs.
This program is presented in a good faith manner to enhance the general safety and security from potential threats that are public knowledge today.
The comments presented are unclassified. Quotes and statistics are properly attributed to their
owners.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
OSHA 1970 Employers must comply with the general duty
clause [Section 5(a)(1)], which states that each employer “shall furnish…a place of employment which is free from recognized hazards that are causing or are likely to cause death or serious physical harm to his employees.”
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Without geographic boundaries
8+0/1
3+3/0
13+32/0
5+1/1
4+0/0
3+0/1
6+2/1
4+3/1
6+0/1
6+8/1
4+1/0
4+0/1
7+0/0
Fatalities
Injuries
Shooter Fatality
6+0/1
13+24/2
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Recent incidents Rural post office, Henning, TN – Oct. 2010 -
two female postal workers shot and killed: Multiple gun shots were fired; police say killings
were done with “disturbing violence.” Father & son robbery team. Son shot by police. Father arrested and confessed to crime.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Recent incidents Johns Hopkins Hospital, MD – Sept. 2009:
Shooter distraught over diagnosis by doctor about his mother’s condition
Used semiautomatic handgun concealed in his waistband
Doctor shot – injured, mother shot – killed Shooter commits suicide.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Recent incidents Kraft Foods plant, PA – Sept. 2009 - woman kills
two co-workers, wounds one: Shooter claimed harassment by co-workers Suspended after 15 years employment for
“feuding” with these co-workers Escorted from premises, returned 9 minutes later
with .357 magnum handgun, drove around security barrier while being pursued by security into building… “She’s got a gun!”
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Recent incidents Discovery Channel, MD – Sept. 2009 -
environmental protestor killed by police after holding 3 hostages at gunpoint: Had several explosive devices Restraint order expired two days earlier Made a threatening motion and was shot by
SWAT
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Recent incidents Hartford Distributors Inc., CT – Aug. 2009 -
disgruntled employee kills 8 co-workers and himself: Caught on videotape stealing beer from the
warehouse Reports that he complained of racist behavior
toward him Two 9mm handguns used were legal, so was
shotgun in the trunk of his car
Recent incidents Episcopal School, Jacksonville, FL – Mar. 2012:
Low preforming instructor counseled at an offsite meeting regarding separation
Without verbalizing any threats, terminated employee returns to campus, fatally shot School Head, the shooter commited suicide
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Local incidents Baton Rouge General – Sept. 3, 2010:
estranged husband shoots wife & her boyfriend at son’s bedside
Grady Crawford Construction Co.– Dec. 23, 2009 – former employee shot and killed two clerical workers: Complained he couldn’t get unemployment benefits He previously made threats to “get even” with supervisor
who fired him, but they didn’t make PD report Pleaded not guilty as victims were not his intended targets His PD pleaded “No Contest” to concealing cannabinoid
in his suit jacket while attempting to visit an Angola client.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
What is workplace violence? Any physical assault, threatening behavior or
verbal abuse that occurs in the work setting Acts such as psychological trauma due to
threats, obscene phone calls, an intimidating presence and harassment of any kind are included
National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH)
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Statistics Average 4000 workplace fatalities, 700
people each year are victims of workplace homicides. [Cab Drivers, C-Store Clerks, PD]
10% of all fatal work injuries annually. NIOSH
1.7MM Violent Workplace Crimes – Bureau of Justice
Workplace homicides were among the top three causes of fatalities in the workplace, second leading cause of fatalities for women.
Bureau of Labor Statistics, August 2009
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Types of workplace violence Homicide Physically aggressive behavior
Possibly resulting in injury Damaging property Domestic violence Bullying Malicious gossip, the role of social networking?
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Costs of workplace violence Loss of human life Undermines employees’ sense of safety and
security, impacting productivity 1.175 million lost work days annually Costs employers more than $36 billion
annually Injuries & death, post-incident counseling, legal
actions & fees, court awards, poor morale, turnover, negative publicity
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Typical assailants Current or former employee Someone with an outside relationship with an
employee Domestic violence spilling over
Someone with a legitimate reason for being on the premises, such as a customer or vendor
Typical assailants
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
• Used to be a white male age 35 to 45• A loner• The chronically disgruntled• The high-maintenance employee
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Risky business Any situations where workers:
exchange money with the public work alone or in small groups deliver passengers work late hours or early morning shifts
In-home services Locations in high-crime areas Positions that require employees to carry a weapon
in performance of their job
Let’s profile!
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
“…you can’t be wedded to a simple profile…you’ve got to focus on the behavior.”
Tracy L. Moon Jr., “Protecting Your Workplace from the Unimaginable: Developing a Proactive Workplace Violence Prevention and Response Strategy,” Dec. 1, 2009
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Some warning signs History of violence Threatening behavior Intimidating behavior Increase in personal stress Negative personality characteristics Marked changes in mood or behavior Socially isolated
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
“Neglected indicators” “Violence is often the result of people not reporting
incidents that could serve as warnings.” Tracy L. Moon Jr.
Excessive absenteeism or tardiness Excessive work breaks Missed deadlines Poor work quality Sudden or significant job performance deterioration Difficulty with co-workers or social withdrawal
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Situations that lead to violence Stress caused by layoffs Reorganization or increased workloads Growing prevalence of substance abuse at work Mistrust and hostility among ethnic, social and racial
groups Critical performance reviews Low morale caused by employees believing they’re
not treated with respect
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Escalation Speaking loudly, frantically or quickly Gesturing wildly Aggressive stances and gestures such as
pointing, getting close, clinching fists Making threats and personal insults Physically closer than comfortable
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Threats What’s in a threat?
When does it become a crime?
Can HIPAA hide the concerns?
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Report troubling behavior People often don’t report because they don’t
want to become involved.
Supervisors might hesitate to report: want to be a buddy fear hurting someone’s career or feelings want to avoid angering employee they depend
upon
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Better safe than sorry “Where there are critical indicators of a troubled
employee who needs immediate assistance—• the person talks of suicide, • makes delusional statements, • is paranoid, • has unfounded concerns about his or her safety—
the supervisor should notify HR, security, medical personnel or the EAP immediately.”
Tracy L. Moon, Jr.
If you know, you got’ta tell!
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
• Once the company is aware of an employee threat, they have an affirmative obligation to protect that employee and provide a safe and secure workplace.
• Liability could result if such actions are not taken and litigation could result in various tort claims.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Defusing violence Assess the situation - recognize the potential
for violence. Project calmness, empathy, patience. Encourage the person to talk, focus
your attention on him/her. Position yourself so that your exit
is not blocked –
always assess safety.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Actions to avoid Using a confrontational approach Trying to be the hero – keep others safe
without putting yourself in harm’s way Making promises you cannot keep Engaging in physical contact with the
individual
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
12-point action plan1. Publicize zero-tolerance policy regarding
threats, harassment and violence in the workplace.
“Not disciplining people for bad behavior encourages it and sends the message that the organization doesn’t care about enforcing its rules and protecting workers’ safety.”
Tracy L. Moon Jr.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
12-point action plan2. Review hiring practices, background checks,
drug and alcohol testing.
3. Implement release forms for background checks.
4. Update personnel policies.
5. Screen temporary employees.
6. Conduct security audits and risk assessments.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
12-point action plan7. Develop a crisis management plan.
8. Train supervisors on conflict resolution and non-violent techniques for handling situations.
9. Train supervisors to identify and take action on early warning signs of potential problems.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
12-point action plan10. Publicize EAPs, etc.
11. Investigate all threats and complaints of harassment and violence immediately.
12. Publicize company procedures for handling employee problems.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Physical security measures Limited public access Screen visitors Adequate lighting Access-card entry systems ID cards for employees and visitors Situational awareness
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Physical security measures Video surveillance inside and outside Security officers where appropriate Escort to parking area after hours Cabs for employees working late Metal detectors
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Victimization of women More than 25% of female victims were assaulted by
people they knew.
Domestic violence that spills into the workplace accounts for 16% of female victims.
Women are 5 times more likely to be attacked at work by an intimate partner.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Domestic violence victims Grant leave requests. Change work location, phone extensions or hours of
work. Make a list of support groups and shelters available
to all employees. Take into consideration performance issues related to
domestic violence. Request picture of potential perpetrator for reception
desk and/or security.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Restraining orders Legal order by a state court which requires
one person to stop harassing/harming another
Some states (not LA) have enacted laws which allow employers to seek a temporary restraining order to protect employees, co-workers and workplace property from threats of acts of violence.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
“Guns-at-Work” laws 13 states (AK, AZ, FL, GA, IN, KS, KY, LA, MN,
MS, NB, OK, UT) permit employees to store their firearms in vehicles located in company parking lots: Employee must be legally allowed to possess a firearm. Vehicle storing the gun must belong to employee (and be
privately owned). Firearm must be hidden. Vehicle must be locked.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
How to fire like a pro Work your plan every time:
Establish roles and termination procedures. Employee’s personal items
Minimize opportunity to reenter.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Active shooter: Preplanning Procedures for calling for help Who will provide medical assistance? Emergency notification & escape procedures or
routes Identify “safe havens” within and outside the facility Procedures for accounting for all employees after the
event Procedures to secure the work area after the event
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Active shooter: Scenario Contact local law enforcement (911) and
follow their instructions. Notify your company/building security force. Get people away from the scene as quickly as
possible. Stay calm Escape, hide/barricade or neutralize??
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Active shooter: Aftermath Secure the premises. Safeguard evidence. Cooperate with authorities, hands raised and
visible, do not hug police, speak in controlled voice.
Prepare an incident report. Designate a spokesperson who has media
training.
Copyright 2012 by HR a la carte, LLC
Active shooter: Aftermath Consult legal counsel. Arrange for counseling/EAPs when
appropriate. Review policies and procedures. Address risk factors.