ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
SOX In The City
Purchasing Management Association of Philadelphia
November, 2009
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Sarbanes-Oxley Background
Who are -Sarbanes and
Oxley?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Officially
Paul Sarbanes (D) was a senator from the State of Maryland and has served in politics for almost four decades, first as a member of the Maryland House of Delegates and then serving as a Congressman from the Third Congressional District for three terms. Since 1977, he has served in the United States Senate.
Michael G. Oxley (R-Ohio) was serving in his eleventh term in the House of Representatives and is Chairman of the House Financial Services Committee. This Committee oversees Wall Street, banking and the insurance industry.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
But To The People Who Have To Adhere To The Sarbanes Oxley Act
Nothing But Trouble
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002
Establishes the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board to oversee the audit of public companies that are subject to securities laws; establish the rules of
conduct surrounding audits, auditors, and companies that trade securities on the
public market.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
In Its Simplest terms, What Is the Sarbanes Oxley Act of
2002?
REGULATED COMMON SENSE
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
What Venue Will Cause The Most Damage To Your Career?
Jail
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
What Are the 3 Most Important Letters In The Corporate World?
CYA
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Pre-SOX, What Did Every CFO Have Embroidered On His or Her Pillow?
IGNORANCE IS BLISS
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Is SOX Compliance A Pain.
Oh Yeah!
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
But Is SOX Extra Work?
It Depends On What You Have Been Doing All
Along.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
WARNING!! THE ANSWER TO THE NEXT SLIDE IS VERY SCARY
SO HOLD ON TO SOMETHING SECURE & TAKE A DEEP
BREATH
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Why Was SOX Created?
To Make EVERYONE Accountable.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Sox Amended Federal Law Making The Following CRIMINAL Offenses
Knowingly destroying, altering, concealing, or falsifying records with intent to obstruct or influence either a
Federal investigation or a matter of bankruptcy…
Fines up to $5 million and imprisonment up to 20 years now
apply.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
What Most People (including Auditors) Think
People involved in Corporate Travel and Meetings & Events have a great life. They
have never seen the back of a plane. They stay in suites, have massages, play golf, go to exotic destinations and do it all
on Company time.
Why Are You Likely Targets?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Are you sitting here & thinking:
Not me or my staff. We are proud of our ethical
practices.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Site Inspections: The Invitation
Take a Tour & Have Lunch
Or
Stay Over & Have A Mini Vacation
In choosing a venue, has this ever happened? Does it serve a legitimate purpose?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Sequence of Events
(What The Hotels Want)
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
See Room
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Say “Very Nice”
Have a Nice Lunch / Stay
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Feel Appreciative (Guilty)
Give Them Business
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
What Differentiates A “Bribe” from A Site Inspection?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Drilling Down :What Should Be Taking Place
DO YOU DO THESE THINGS? ARE THEY DOCUMENTED & PUT TO USE?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Doorman
• Open The Door
• Take Your Bags
• Polite
• Well-Groomed
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Reception
• Polite
• Helpful
• Quick
• Uses Your Last Name
• Remembers You During Your Stay
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Bell Staff
• Polite• Helpful• Neat• Speaks & Understands
Your Primary Traveler’s Language
• Quick• Verbal Tour of Room &
Property
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Elevator
• Safety
• Lighting
• Cleanliness
• Ratio To Rooms
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Hallway
• Lighting
• Safety
• Signage
• Maintenance
• Carts
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Room• Décor• Cleanliness• Bed Comfort• “Real” Pillows• Safe• Minibar• Unoccupied Outlets• Safety• Noise From Outside The
Room
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Workspace
• Lighting
• Empty Outlets
• PC Connections
• Deskspace
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Bathroom
• Lighting
• Amenities
• Cleanliness
• Water Pressure
• Hot Water
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Business Center
• Hours of Operation
• Equipment Available
• Laptop Support
• Fees
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Checkout
• PM Folio Delivery
• Bell Staff
• Reception
• Correct Billing
• Valet Parking
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Things You Might Want To Do When Staying Overnight To Test A Property
• Have someone send you a fax during the day and again at night (How long until delivery or notification took place?)
• Call housekeeping for an iron• Call the front desk at night and ask for
directions to the nearest hospital• See how soundproof the room is from
noise in the next room or hallway
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
• Lose your room key & ask for a replacement (Did they ask for an ID before giving you another key?)
• Valet park your car & time how long it takes to retrieve it at 8 AM & again at night
• Use something from the minibar & see if the item is replaced (& that the charge is correct when checking out)
See handout for additional details
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
CYA
File A Report of Findings
Make Others Aware Of Your Actions
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
What Questions Should You Have Been Asking All Along?
• Is the person authorizing financial commitments authorized to do so?
• Is the person signing the agreements authorized to do so?
• Will charges be applied to the correct GL category or be buried elsewhere?
• Is there a paper trail on every commitment? Was someone willing to sign their approval?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
• Did you know when someone was doing something improper but looked the other way?
• Was someone given a “freebie” in order to close the deal? • Have you protected yourself from an executive who suffers
from Corporate Amnesia?• Will all expenses pass an auditor’s scrutiny?• Do you apply the same care to all details that you do to your
accounting for petty cash?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
So What Is The Story SOX Wants You To Tell?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Like Any Good Story (or Recipe), It Must Have:
• A Beginning
• A Middle
• An End
Ever leave out an ingredient or skip a few pages?
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Beginning…
• Written Procedures & Compliance Standards Including A Code of Conduct
• Senior Management knowledge, Involvement & Endorsement
• Creation Of A Hotline For Anonymous Calls & Questions
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
The Middle…
• Communicate The Policies, Procedures, & Expectations To All Involved
• Train All Employees To Adhere To Ethical Standards
• Perform Reasonable Testing Throughout The Process
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
• If Problems Arise, Apply Disciplinary Action Uniformly & Fairly To All Involved
• As Problems Arise, Modify The Program To Avoid The Problems From Repeating Themselves
The End…
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Were The Authors Sneaky?
What does this statement mean?
Only “reporting” companies were required to comply by December 31, 2004, but all
other companies may be legally required to live by the same standards.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Protecting Yourself From Getting Burned
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Example: Are Any Of These Things On File?
• A Meeting Request Form (approved & with the purpose outlined)• A Properly Approved Budget• Expenses Properly Supported (can be audited)• A Final Project Reconciliation• Properly Approved Contracts• Properly Approved Invoices• Site Inspection Notes / Form• A Meeting Agenda• A Properly Approved & Thorough Attendee List• A Paper Trail of Alternative Sites or Suppliers• A Statement As To The Training of Staff Handling The Event
(policies, procedures, penalties)• A “Sign-off” Sheet That All Details Have been Examined &
Approved
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Site Inspection: Ensuring Its Value
Overall Rating out of 5: (Considering price, location, and all listed below)
Hotel: Number of Rooms:
Address: Number of Floors:
City State Zip: Year Built:
Cards Accepted: Recent Renovations:
Check-in Times/Locations:
Room Type Dimensions Low Price High Price
Nearest Company Office:
Distance to Office:
Nearest Airport:
Distance to Airport:
Amenities: Included Extra Cost Not Available Facilities Included Extra Cost Not Available
Newspaper Fitness Center: In-room hair dryer Spa/Beauty Center: Iron/Ironing Board Pool/Jacuzzi: In-room Safe Golf on-site/Privileges: Coffee Maker Restaurants/Room Service: Bathrobe Babysitting Service: Minibar/Refrigerator On-site Shopping:
Lan Connection Laundry:
Wireless Connection Club Level/Preferred Floors:
Fax Machine Parking: Voicemail ATM: Breakfast Wake-up Service
Facility Ratings 5 4 3 2 1 n/a CommentsBreakfast Hotel Restaurant Hotel Bar Lighting
Interior Design Landscaping Fitness Center Parking Vending Machines Community/Neighborhood Security
Room Ratings 5 4 3 2 1 n/a CommentsCleanliness Lighting Bed/Matress Heating/Cooling Unit Bathroom Room Size/Use of space Furniture
TV/Entertainment System Hotel/Community guides Wake-up Service
Hotel Staff 5 4 3 2 1 n/a CommentsProfessionalism Friendliness
Knowledge Communication Skills Check-in (efficiency) Check-out (efficiency)
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Did The Authors Have A Sense Of Humor?
Don’t give authority to “individuals with a propensity to
illegal activities”.
ICG Commerce – Confidential and Proprietary Information
Questions?
Howard Z Brooks: [email protected]