Download - Insights on the shopping revolution
Slide 1 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
I’ll take it!
What we’ve learned from the shopping revolution, and what’s coming nextJuly 2012
Slide 2 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The last shopping revolution happened over 100 years ago.
1890s: Stone’s Store, in Roselle Park, NJ, becomes the first shop to be lit by Thomas Edison’s carbon filament light bulbs
1916: Clarence Saunders opens Piggly Wiggly, the first self-service
grocery store, in Memphis, TN
1900: Mass-production of clothing becomes commonplace as department stores proliferate, selling ready-to-wear items
Slide 3 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Shopping will never be the same.
The High Street is changing. Where the last 50 years have seen a transition from small local merchants to chains and megabrands, the next decade will bring a massive shift in the opposite direction.• Services will become as important as objects• Shared and Pop-up retail will become commonplace• Up to 30% of retail space will permanently disappear… and even more will
radically change
Slide 4 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
We have entered a new era
Slide 5 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Why not ‘The Retail Revolution’?Because that’s not how people think. And if businesses are to survive the revolution, they need to understand the human perspective. Humans don’t “visit retail establishments.” Humans shop.
Shopping doesn’t just happen in shops, either. And in order to identify opportunities, we need to be able to see the whole picture of what shopping is and can be.
Slide 6 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Shopping: the human perspective
Slide 7 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
It’s not a linear experience
give up
price
cool
friends
quality
service
fit
look
trends delivery
supportwait
returns
Slide 8 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Many variables = complex challenge
What I’m buyingEveryday purchases
Big ticket items Long term investments
Clothing and accessoriesGifts
Personal factorsCultural context
Age and social statusFinancial comfort and
confidence
Slide 9 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Beyond retail: the shopping ecosystem
Slide 10 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
3 keys to understanding the revolution
Online vs. offline is a
myth
People pay for what makes
them feel good
Changing infrastructure is
changing the rules
Thank you.
Slide 11 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The online/offline myth
Slide 12 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Online/offline: there is no such thing.
Online/offline has not been a meaningful distinction for some time.
Digital-ness is now ubiquitous - we carry the digital world around with us in our pockets. We can access it all the time, in shops and at home and on the street.
Slide 13 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Nearly 50% of US smartphone owners use mobiles in-store
Call/t
ext f
or a
dvice
Compa
re p
rices
Send
pict
ure
of p
rodu
ct
Find
anot
her s
tore
Check
pro
duct
revi
ews
Fill t
ime
in ch
eck
out l
ine
Check
for l
ocat
ion
deal
s
Show
item
to p
erso
nnel
Scan
pro
duct
bar
code
Check
ope
ning
tim
es
Not u
sed
mob
ile in
stor
e0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Source: GP Bullhound Research, Mobile Commerce, September 2012
Slide 14 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
…and 53% have abandoned as a result
NO47%
21% Found a better
item online
30%Found a better
price online
38%Found a better
price in another store
Source: GP Bullhound Research, Mobile Commerce, September 2012
Slide 15 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Window-shopping & QR codesGrocery shelves are displayed on screens in subway stations. People make purchases by scanning codes.This “shop” is both online and offline – it looks like the real, 3D thing; it’s located in a real, 3D place, and yet the commerce all takes place over Internet Protocol.
From 3D to 2D
Slide 16 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
eBay’s Give-a-Toy shops enabled shoppers to scan QR codes from the shop window, to donate a toy to a child in need. The window display, in this case, is the shop. Similarly, more and more retailers are including QR codes in their window displays, which enables people to make a digital ‘wish list’ from real-world items in real-world places.
The window is the shop
Slide 17 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Like the glassware at the restaurant? Buy it. Fancy that dress Florence wore at last night’s gig? Have it delivered to you today. The continued rise of semantic metadata and interconnected APIs mean that we’ll be able to buy things wherever we see them – in real life, on television, anywhere.
Shop? Who needs a shop?
Slide 18 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
In-store bar code scanningCustomers in brick-and-mortar shops use smartphones to do price checks, look up reviews, add items to gift registries, or even purchase the item from another retailer and have it delivered straight to their home.
“Online” in the real world
Slide 19 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
All Saints in-store kiosk for online orderingSome retailers, including the UK-based chain All Saints, offer an in-store kiosk (or in All Saints, iPad) where customers can order articles that aren’t in stock at that location from their online store. This takes advantage of the customer’s in-store urge to buy, and is far more immediate and effective than sending them to another location to make their purchase. It also introduces brick-and-mortar customers to the online property.
“Online” in the real world
Slide 20 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
C&A has launched a pilot in Brazil of their “Fashion Like” in-store concept. Hangers contain a small display showing how many times that garment has been ‘liked’ on facebook. Instead of scanning a code or launching an app, customers can see this data made manifest where it is most relevant.
Augmented merchandise
Slide 21 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
PayPal HereSquare PayPal Here, Sail and Square take
online payment methods into the brick and mortar world (more on this later).
“Online” in the real world
Slide 22 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
Apple now allows customers to shop in stores without making any contact with staff unless they want to. The concept enables customers to explore the merchandise for as long as they like, make a decision (assisted or not), find the item and pay for it, all on their own. This gives the customer unprecedented freedom in shaping their own experience. Apple can do this because they own every piece of the system – the merchandise, the shop, the payment.
Shopping goes DIY
Slide 23 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
After
Online purchases returned in-storeMany retailers allow customers to return online purchases to brick-and-mortar locations. This combines the convenience of buying online without the inconvenience of having to go to the post office for returns.
Whenever, wherever
Slide 24 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The idea of buying in-store and getting home delivery is not new – appliance dealers have been using this system for decades. But the idea of buying something online and picking it up in-store is more recent, further blurring the lines between ‘online’ and ‘offline’
Whenever, wherever
Slide 25 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
After
Online registration & support for items purchased in brick & mortar shopsIt has become commonplace for consumer electronics, no matter where they are bought, to be registered online. Support, too, is delivered primarily through online means, with phone support often only available at a premium.
Whenever, wherever
Thank you.
Slide 26 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The feel-good factor
“Money, if it does not bring you happiness, will at least help you be miserable in comfort.” - Helen Gurley
Slide 27 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
There are some things money can’t buy
Slide 28 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
People pay for what makes them happy.Some people are happy with simply getting the best deal, but many are willing to pay a premium for better service
Recognition and recommendation
Know who I am and what I like
Loyalty
Reward me for repeat custom
Follow-through and support
Resolve my problems and address my complaints
Slide 29 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Great technology experiences are in demand
59%Would
purchase more frequently if
the experience were better
42%
Would use mobile
checkout if available
42%Are
interested in mobile wallet
services 40%Want QR &
barcode scanners
36%Find mobile purchasing frustrating,
but do it anyway
36%Want
vouchers & location based
services
Source: GP Bullhound Research, Mobile Commerce, September 2012
Slide 30 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Before
Amazon home page with recommendations
Amazon is perhaps the best-known example of recognition and recommendation – it is definitely one of the most widely cited examples in the online world.
Nice to see you again.
Slide 31 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Before
Messaging from local merchant/ brick & mortar store/ call from the lady at the DKNY counter Personal service in local stores – for
example, the shop owner who gives you a spontaneous 10% discount because you choose to buy two items when you only intended to buy one – can be quite powerful in driving loyalty. Services like Square, PayPal Here and Sail have the potential to facilitate and support this by giving merchants access to customers’ purchase histories in their shops.
Where everybody knows your name
Slide 32 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
During
Local merchants taking 10% off when you buy 2 pieces (because you came in only intending to buy 1)Local shop owners are also more likely to know their customers personally, building trust relationships that enable them to advise on purchases – this makes both parties feel better about the transactions, even though the goods may cost more.The best merchants will even call their regular customers when new and relevant merchandise arrives – this makes customers feel like VIPs and drives both store visits and loyalty.
Where everybody knows your name
Slide 33 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The Starbucks app is an excellent example of tying the full customer lifecycle together – from locating a shop to ordering to payment to loyalty, all in one well-designed package.
Slide 34 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
After
Net-a-porter delivery service (guy in the suit, black boxes with ribbons, same day in London)Net-a-porter offers same-day delivery by liveried staff – a luxurious personal touch that makes customers feel better about the price tag of their merchandise.
VIP service, VIP status
Slide 35 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
With you everywhere
Uniqlo has extended its relationship with customers through a widely-loved alarm app, and encouraged ongoing interaction by awarding discounts to customers who tweet about their products.
Slide 36 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
20-40 year olds with less income than they’d hoped to have are bridging the gap between expectation and reality by doing their everyday shopping at discounters and putting a large proportion of their disposable income toward high-end designer accessories. These are often purchased at outlet shops such as TK Maxx.
Bridging the expectation gap
Thank you.
Slide 37 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Portable infrastructure
Slide 38 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Banks take a backseatAs mobile alternatives such as Square, Sail and PayPal Here gain traction in the market, virtually anyone can become a retailer. This enables proliferation of microbusinesses and also threatens more traditional infrastructure providers (banks, credit card companies) who have begun to fade into the background as these OTT players take the spotlight with consumers and merchants alike.
This movement is reminiscent of the challenge faced by Telcos over the past half a decade, as manufacturers and OTT providers have captured customers’ hearts through high-value services.
Slide 39 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The great equaliserA street market vendor can suddenly be equal to a high street brand like Topshop – access to affordable payment infrastructure enables the quality conversation to dominate, rather than the power lent by superior infrastructure and presence.
Slide 40 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Geofencing allows payment without taking anything out of your pocket.
Slide 41 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Customer or merchant?The distinction between customer and merchant is also blurred by this new infrastructure – anyone can be a consumer by day and a merchant by night, or vice versa.
Slide 42 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Reach out and touch someoneTraditional traffic drivers like vouchers and coupons have also moved into the mobile domain, with location based services like Groupon and Foursquare, and social curation tools such as Pinterest.
Slide 43 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
More choice, more pressure
There is now a far greater range of payment choices for retailers as well as individuals. This puts further pressure on traditional service providers to innovate to drive value.
Thank you.
Slide 44 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
What do we do now?
Slide 45 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Beautiful seams, not “seamlessness”Some new shopping experiences are unnerving for customers – the absence of the “the altar of commerce” that is the till is confusing, leaving people wondering whether they’ve actually paid for their purchases or not.
This new behaviour could also cause other problems, as customers grow so accustomed to skipping the till that they do it even when there is no other technology in place.
We must mitigate this by ensuring that customers are aware of the transitions as they take place. Total “seamlessness” is not ideal here – while the transitions should be smooth and not jarring, it is critical that customer/users always know what’s happening and where they stand.
Slide 46 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Beware the uncanny valley
This is a well-known concept in the robotics world, but it also applies to “smart” services.
The myth is that the better a service knows me, the more conclusions it draws, the better my experience will be. But that’s not true – beyond a certain point, the service stops being cool and starts to be creepy.
It takes a huge effort to pull the service back out of the valley – and you may never regain the trust you’ve lost.
Slide 47 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Where people are concerned, why is more important than what.
It’s not enough to know what your customers are doing – in order to know how best to respond, you need to understand why.
Slide 48 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Why isn’t everyone more engaged?Less than 20% of mobile users engage with online retail. Why not more?
48%Awkward shopping
experience
23%Not easy to
view product
information
31%Slow
connection
36%Credit card info
security concerns
20%Takes too
long
18%Product
information too limited
Slide 49 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
It’s a balancing act
Know ‘what’ but not ‘why’ Confusion
Single point of focus Focus on many areas at once
The trick is to choose a framework of KPIs that work together to show you not just what your customers are doing, but why they might be doing it; not just how your business is performing, but where the opportunities lie to improve.
Slide 50 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Look at the system (not just at one part)
For customers, the whole ecosystem works together to create the experience they think of as shopping.
Slide 51 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Look at the system (not just at one part)
Understanding how the pieces of your ecosystem work together is the key to creating the best experience possible.
Slide 52 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
When you put people first, great things can happen for business.
Thank you.
Slide 53 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Opportunity Spaces
“Entrepreneurs are simply those who understand that there is little difference between obstacle and opportunity and are able to turn both to their advantage” - Niccolo Machiavelli
Slide 54 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
From Shop to ShowroomWhile Apple’s new ultra-DIY shops have troubled some customers, they are indicative of an interesting shift – from ‘shop’ environment to ‘showroom’. The focus is no longer only on selecting product and paying for it; the focus is on experiencing the products, with or without assistance.
Technology has opened the door to radical change in physical retail spaces. Without the constraints of the counter, the till, maybe even the merchandise, we are free to invent whatever kinds of space are best suited to connecting people to things they will love.
Slide 55 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
My data earns me money
As customers become more savvy about their data, new opportunities open for merchants to barter discounts or merchandise to access improved information. This means opportunity for deeper, more meaningful relationships with customers.
Slide 56 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Let me take my community with me
Location based technology, social graphs and other metadata can be combined to give customers more control over who influences their buying decisions – leaving recommendations and reviews for friends in specific locations, attached to specific merchandise.
Or, customers could choose to follow in the fashion footsteps of the stars they want to emulate - literally, in the physical world.
Slide 57 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Make it feel better to buyMany medium- and big-ticket items, from car seats to washing machines, are necessary but uninspiring purchases. Anyone who can make a more satisfying experience of these purchases will win a good deal of trust and affection from customers.
Slide 58 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Help me to aspire
There are collections of items – such as home theatre or hi-fi equipment – that many customers continually and incrementally upgrade over longer periods of time. For those who are less technology-savvy, this can be a challenging process of reading reviews and specifications and asking friends and acquaintances for advice. Anyone who can help customers remember what they have and what it will work best with will certainly gain trust and goodwill.
Slide 59 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
Remember:It’s the system, not the part.
Slide 60 © Fjord 2012 | Confidential
The end.