Download - Intro To University Debating
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Outline
1. Why debate?2. What is debate?3. Matter/Manner/Method4. How to prepare a case
• Speaker roles• Team Case• Definitions• Models
5. Hot tips
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Why Debate?
Improve yourselfMake friends at uni
Travel the world funded by Monash!
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
TournamentsSEMESTER 1 (3-on-3)• Freshers (MAD)
– For virgin IV debaters• Easters (Melbourne UNI)
– The National novice comp• President’s Cup (Melbourne)
– Debate with fun people• Sorensen (MAD)
– Major 3-on-3 comp, novice rule
• ADAM (Melbourne)– Pre-Australs and great
practice• AUSTRALS @ Auckland
– MAD’s favourite IV
SEMESTER 2 (British Parliamentary)
• Pro-Am Comp• Open BP Comp• Freehills• Women’s (Sydney)• ANU Mini (Canberra)• Sydney Mini (Sydney)• Vic Mini (New Zealand)• Melbourne Mini (Melbourne)• WUPID (Malaysia)• WORLDS (Botswana)
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Why do we do it?
“Dutch troops pull out of Afghanistan”
“US to sell Uranium to India”
“Gay marriage bill vetoed”
“Cap on CEO pay strives to end era of excess”
“GLOBAL WARMING IS OVERRATED”
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
What is Debate?
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Debate is structured argument
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Debate - an overview
• Assigned topic and side• Understand context• Identify problem• Propose solution• Convince everyone whyit’s right!
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
3-on-3 Debate: the
format
1st Aff
3rd Neg
2nd Neg
1st Neg
3rd Aff
2nd Aff
AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE30 minute
prep
6-8 minutespeeches
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
MATTER, MANNER and METHOD
The elements that contribute to
persuasiveness in debates
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
What you say“Arguments”
How to make it good:• Analysis = first principles, examples, statistics etc
MATTER
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Elements of an argument
1. IDEA2. ANALYSIS
• Step through your analysis - keep asking “why?”
3. EVIDENCE• LINK
– How does it help you prove your team’s case?
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Example of an argument
Giving arms to Afghani Tribal Militias will undermine Al Qaeda's power in the hills
o Pashtun tribes have self-interest at heart (concerned with protection) -> will follow whoever presents the most benefit. By providing weapons, we become the ally of choice.
1. E.g. Under Soviet Union, Mujahaddin fighters were happy to engage with the most powerful ally
o Without weapons to defend themselves they are blackmailed by Al Qaeda
1. E.g. Al Qaeda has taken sons of tribal leaders hostage2. E.g. One tribe that resisted Al Qaeda initially was made an
example of - Suicide bombers exploded in a family wedding killing dozens
o By providing weapons, Militias will be both able to defend themselves and will be motivated to align with west
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Keep it logical and relevant
• Why is it true? • Who Cares?
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Rebuttal
• Same elements are true for building arguments and destroying them.
• Targeting the Idea > Analaysis > Evidence
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Viv’s Rebuttal
TipsWays to rebut:• Establish that the opp argument is based on an error of fact / an erroneous interpretation of fact
• Establish that the opp argument is illogical (the conclusion does not logically flow from the premise)– Problem/solution gap
• Establish that the opp argument, while itself correct, involves unacceptable implications.
The best rebuttal works together these approaches into an “Even if..”
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
MANNERYour presentation. How engaging are you as a speaker?
First things first:• There’s no hard fast rule as to what makes
good manner• Everyone’s style is different - keep it natural
• Everyone can improve their manner
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Consensus on what makes good manner:• Eye contact• Body language - gestures, posture• TONE• In control - you have the floor
Viv’s Hot tips:• Watch your language - no flippant comments
• Vary your manner• Be conscious of your own flaws
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
METHOD
How you present your caseCan you audience understand and follow what you are saying?
Matter impact:– Adjudicator can digest what you are saying
Manner impact:– You appear logical and in control.
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
How to keep your speech structured: • Team split
• Individual speaker: Introduce, Analyse, ConcludeSay what you’re going to say, say it then say what you said.
• Watch the clock
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Speaker Roles
1st Affirmative• SET UP:
– Context– Definition – Team Position/Model
– Team Split
• Arguments (5 - 6 minutes)
1st Negative• Definition Issues
• Rebut (3 mins)• SET UP:
– Team Position/Counter Model
– Team Split
• Arguments (4 mins)
ROLE: Establish the grounds on which the debate will be fought
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Definitions
• Define the meaning, not the words• Don’t need to spell it out (no “according to the Oxford dictionary…”
• In 3-on-3, definitions are usually clearly stated by the topic
• Context is the best way to go• Stress less and have fun!
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
The definition must be reasonableThere must be a debate to be had.
Unfair definitions:–Time set–Truistic - debate the should not the will
If you’re on the NEG to an unreasonable definition:–Don’t challenge. Ever.–Point out to your Adjudicator why the definition is unreasonable but debate the definition regardless.
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Team Position
AFF: • Identify problem• Propose a
Solution (Model)
NEG: (3 Options)1/ Accept the problem• Propose an
alternative solution = counter model
2/ Accept the problem• Show that the AFF
solution exacerbates the problem
3/ Negate the problem
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Speaker Roles
….continued2nd Affirmative• Rebut (3 mins)• Personal Split• Arguments (4 mins)
2nd Negative• Rebut (3 mins)• Personal Split• Arguments (4 mins)
ROLE: Move the debate forward by developing analysis of existing arguments and introducing new lines of argument
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
3rd Affirmative• Intro - biggest point Rebut (7 mins)
• Summarise and Conclude (30secs)
3rd Negative• Intro - biggest point
• Rebut (7 mins)• Summarise and Conclude (30secs)
ROLE: Organise the debate into clear questions/themes to make understanding it easier - then show why you won all of them! “Thematic Rebuttal”
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
How it all happens…..
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Secret Topic, 30 minutes ARGHH! NO 1 Rule - DON’T
PANIC! You know more than you think
Key is to structure the time you have
Choice of 3 topics Mutual Preference System
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Choice of Topics: Example
That all you need is loveThat China should float the
YuanThat trees should have the same legal rights as animals
1
3
2
3
2
1
Team of Arts students Team of Eco. students
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Timeline for Prep
Activity Time Who
Brainstorm arguments
10 minutes Individually, then together
Prioritise arguments, build case and split
10 minutes together
Flesh out arguments
10 minutes Individually, with 3rd speaker help
Brainstorm opposition case
Walking to the debate!
together
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Adjudication
• There are no draws• Scoring range 70-80• No automatic wins or losses• Adjudicator’s must provide reasons for there decisions
www.monashdebaters.com | [email protected]
Viv’s Final Tips
• Don’t introduce yourself!!!!• Make the most of your introduction• Don’t write out speeches word for word!• Get clear feedback from your adjudicators
• READ shit• PARTICIPATE in Comps and practice debates.
• Stress less and have fun!