© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
BIONIC JATROPHA BREEDING PLATFORM
Defining the planting material for Bionic JcL 3.0
1
All pictures of interspecific F1 hybrid courtesy of Ton Rulkens, Flickr
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
2
ABBREVIATIONS USED
PoC = proof of concept JcL = Jatropha curcas Linn Jint = Jatropha integerrima Joth = Other Jatropha species NTMA = Non-toxic Mexican accession (of JcL) PE = Phorbol ester (critical toxin in JcL) F1, F2, F3… = generations of hybrids BC1, BC2,… = generations of hybrid back crossing with the original
parent population FC1, FC2,… = generations of forward crossing with other than parental
accessions/species HX(.X) = hybrid family (exact member number) HCXXXX = hybrid clone of XXXX
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
3
BACKGROUND – GLOBAL RESEARCH
Most important citations from global research literature:“These data suggest that the chances of improvements in commercially desirable traits of J. curcas are higher through interspecific breeding rather than the intraspecific breeding approach, which is limited by the low genetic variability in globally distributed accessions of J. curcas.” (4)
“The studies (…) indicate the limitations of using intra-specific breeding for J. curcas improvement; as exemplified by the failure to obtain low PE hybrids in crosses between J. curcas toxic accessions from India and the NTMA” (4)
“…analysis of the (JcL x Jint) F1 plants revealed advantages gained through hybridisation (…) including low PE levels. A back cross with J. curcas NTMA further reduced the PE levels comparable to NTMA – a highly desirable target. Our analysis revealed higher genetic distance between J. curcas and J. integerrima than between J. curcas accessions.” (4)
“These hybrid (JcL x Jint) clones also expressed superiority in terms of early flowering and fruiting coupled with early yield, which thus lends scope for further promotion and utilization of Jatropha as a successful biofuel crop.” (6)
“For J. curcas to be a commercially viable source of biodiesel much research and development is needed and little should be expected from the present widespread planting of wild varieties.” (4)
“If the seed cake were rendered non-toxic and could be used as animal feed, the profitability of cultivating Jatropha, which was more expensive than diesel in India in 2005, would be ‘‘dramatically increased.’’ (5)
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
4
BACKGROUND – OWN STUDIES Localization is crucial for commercial planting material as the genotype x ecosystem (GxE)
interdependence is high in JcL Epigenetics play a critical role for JcL commercialization being the only available sound explanation
for many aspects of the species’ behavior JcL intraspecific hybridization usually results in very high levels of heterosis if parents exhibit
genetic diversity Non-toxic, high yielding hybrids are possible and have a series of ground breaking advantages for
the future Non-toxic seed cake is a high value animal feed adds an absolute minimum of US$ 500 per ha to
the JcL bottom line Reported barriers to hybridization within the Jatropha genus often prove untrue Proven breeding paths for JcL are available:
Heterosis breeding offers quick path to early sucesses JcL x Jint has been tried successfully at different instances and shows a high success probability in terms of superior yield
and other favorable traits Adding other Jatropha species increases possibilities even further, but very limited successes have been reported BPL’s ongoing proof of concept aims to close knowledge gaps on interspecific breeding routes Importance of adding true wild accessions from center of origin has been clarified
Outlook: There is potential to develop JcL into an annual industrial crop, a route which would resemble the development of Castor decades ago
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
5
BACKGROUND - CONCLUSIONS JcL is currently an undomesticated wild plant previously used for living hedges Genetic variance within typically (“commercially”) used JcL accessions is too limited
(literature) The germplasm base needs to be significantly expanded for successful breeding
results Introduction of high heterozygosity through interspecific crossing Is BPL’s primary route of choice
J integerima is the species we prioritize, others will follow Successful interspecific hybrid paths reported in literature
Truly wild accessions from Central America offer an alternative, intraspecific breeding approach (heterosis)
Collected by dedicated expeditions, several have been made available to this program by Geneticlab et. al. Genetic analysis shows significantly higher heterozygosis compared to the usual homozygosis found in most
“commercial” JcL Many are low/non-toxic Advantage for time to market due to significant heterosis (hybrid vigor) effects
Induced polyploidy is an advanced breeding tool we are investigating Stable inbred lines of all selected parental material need to be established
(semi) commercial and wild toxic and non-toxic selected future hybrid lines
Advanced genetic technologies need to be applied Selection of best suited parental material Marker assisted breeding Identification of clear gene-trait relationships is the next step
Breeding for horizontal resistance Significantly reduce the cost of pesticides
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
6
GENETIC MAPPING SUPPLIES GUIDANCE
Commercial varieties (cultivated in Africa and India)
Central American landraces
Outgroups (Jatropha spp.)
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
7
APPROACH GREATLY DIFFERS FROM OTHERS
Nobody can effectively analyze hundreds or even thousands of accessions phenotypically and genetically (as widely claimed)
Most accessions are genetically identical or very closely clustered In JcL high phenotypic differences don’t necessarily correlate with high genetic differences
A wide spread misconception by current JcL breeders Reasons not clear yet, but epigenetic effects are the most assumed explanation available
Effective selectiveness guarantees execution of successful breeding paths A small core collection of proven genetically divers material has been established at BPL Collection will be expanded by new hybrids and additional wild accessions over time Guidance from literature and scientific reports is integrated Active investigations for sought after properties will be initiated when required A global network with like minded JcL growers/breeders is maintained
Cooperation with scientific researchers Genetic marker analysis and development Biochemical analysis Integration of latest scientific research findings Program accompanied by long term scientific research
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
8
PROGRAM OBJECTIVES Stringent commercial approach to scientifically based JcL hybrid breeding A clear proof-of-concept on the most promising approaches by mid 2012
Reduced risk Reliable planning base
A fast track success by mid 2013 (first generation non-toxic hybrids ready for field trials) Marketable success stories by mid 2012 to support critical funding initiative
Funding initiative based on proof-of-concept results Promising crosses in the early generations have to exhibit genetic improvements for important traits Only reproducible improvements backed by genetic analysis are relevant Public news flow to be established before the end of the PoC
Mandatory traits Non-toxic
Further heat treatment for anti nutritional factors will be always required (similar to soya) High yielding material for West African ecological environments
Further preferential traits Horizontal pest resistance (mealy bug!) Oil content & composition Biomass production Uniformity in size and shape (mechanical harvesting) Synchronous flowering and fruiting cycles (mechanical harvesting)
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
9
INTERSPECIFIC JCL HYBRIDS REPORTED
J curcas x J integerrima Many detailed reports Verified by BPL
J gossypifolia x J curcas Reciprocal is J tanjorensis (sterile) Patented by Nandan Verified by BPL J gossypiifolia is extremely diverse with many taxonomically close
relatives J curcas x J scaposa
Under testing (Mozambique) J curcas x J macrocarpa
Under testing (Argentina)
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
10
SYSTEMATIC BREEDING PATH
F1 Hybrid
XXXJcL
starter
Fx
F2
BC1
BC2
BC3
Inbred hybrid lines F2, F3, F4….
Genetic variance has to be taken into account via permanent selection supported by genetic markers
Variations for XXXIntraspecific:• Genetically remote JcL
accessions• Non-toxic JcL accessions• Wild accessions from center of
originInterspecific:• J integerrima• Other Jatropha species• hybrids• ….
Female parent Pollen donor
Strictly confidential
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
11
UPDATE 1: ACTUAL F1 BREEDING PATH
F2/FCF1/BCF1
Hybrid
XXXF1 as
female parent
Variations for XXXPollen donor
Strictly confidential
Female parent
Tested F1 are GHLT x Jint and GHOLD x Jint
Currently performed:• J integerrima• Other Jatropha• MXZA• MXHU• Self cross
future• GHLT• MXCLO• ….
F2/FCF1/BCF1
Hybrid
F1 as pollen donor
XXXcurrent• MXCLO8.5/7.10• MXZA• MXHU• GUA1A1• Other Jatropha• J integerrima
future• Self cross• GHLT• More NTMA• ….
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
12
POSITIVE AND PROVENParental genotypesJcLJint Joth
1st hybrid generations
2nd hybrid generations
H1=JcLxJintinterspecific
H4=JothxJoth
intraspecific
H1BC1 (GAL, GHLT, CLO7.10)
H1F2 (H1.2xH1.2) H1FC1 (H2, GUA, CLO, HU, ZA, ....)
Building up large hybrid populations to enable full exploitation of genetic variabilitythrough selection and cross breeding
H0=JcLxJcLintraspecific
H4=JothxJcL
H6=JothxJint
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
13
UPDATE 2: ACTUAL JOTH RESULTSStrictly confidential
Current results Joth (green) x Joth (red) intraspecific Joth x JcL (H2) interspecific
Jgos x GHLT (H2.1) Jgos x MXHU (H2.2)
Joth x Jint interspecificObservations Very strong maternal effect
Hybrids usually difficult to recognize Seed texture is a reliable phenotypic indicator in most cases
Intraspecific hybrids usually express some hybrid vigor (heterosis) Leave size, plant height Seed size, fruit size
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
14
PARENTAL MATERIAL FOR CORE APPROACH JcL Starter:
Selection from best Asian, Indian, African, South American semi commercial cultivars
Selection from non-toxic and wild Central American accessions In-crossed accessions:
Selected non-toxic Selected wild (natural heterozygosity) Jatropha integerima (heterozygosity)
Presumed natural hybrid from Cuba (Dehgan) Proven good results from a chain of well documented Indian breeding
experiments Improved growth
>>> We successfully produced 45 different JcLxJint hybrids during the PoC
Jatropha gossypifolia (heterozygosity) Three distinctively different wild accessions identified in Ghana Reported success of a fertile JcL hybrid (US patent application) Enormous vegetative growth rate (banned as invasive in NSW, Australia) Very strong pest resistance Favorably shaped for mechanical harvesting
Strictly confidential
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
15
VARIATIONS OF CORE APPROACH Alternative Starters:
Jatropha other (reported success) Jatropha integerrima Non-toxic JcL Wild JcL
Incrossed accessions: Selected JcL (non-toxic, wild, commercial) Jatropha integerima (heterozygosity) Jatropha other (heterozygosity)
Induced polyploidy First line experiments ongoing with several natural polyploid JcL plants
available Targets:
New hybrids as parental material with favorable traits Non-toxic hybrids with high heterozygosity (primarily as further breeding
base) Inter- and intraspecific
Jint/Joth hybrids as new established breeding base (patent applications pending)
Strictly confidential
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
16
TRANSGENIC APPROACH Interspecific breeding is a necessity
Limited genetic variance with globally accessible material J integerrima has ideal genetic properties
A natural hybrid from Cuba with high heterozygosity (Dehgan and others) see variability in leaves see variable flower colors 100% heterozygosis reported - to be verified within the program
Seeds contain high levels of linoleic acid Fast growth and permanent flowering (3 months to first flowering reported)
J other easy intraspecific crossing but difficult for interspecific hybridization Enormously vegetative Very high horizontal resistance Potential for an annual crop similar to Castor development Direct crossing with JcL (Dehgan says “impossible”)
>>> we produced a limited number of healthy seeds and seedlings in 2011 for all combinations listed above, further PoC trials ongoing in 2012 establishing a sound base for future mainstream breeding
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
17
NON TOXIC
Why not? Toxicity does not increase pest resistance Some wild non-toxic accessions exhibit superior expressions of
important traits A must for acceptable labor conditions
Modern crop commercialization requires strict health protection for workers at all times
Co-carcinogenic effect of PE becomes evident only after years of exposure Any kind of detoxification process cannot eliminate that issue
Fundamental turn around for weak JcL business models Press cake forms a high quality animal feed without the need of chemical
detoxification Poultry feed Fish feed
Potentially adds 1000 USD and more to a farms revenue stream per ha
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
18
TOOLS BEYOND HYBRIDIZATION Artificial/natural polyploidy
Checking farm for more natural occurrences Improve experimental procedures
Use of growth regulators GA3 – coconut water BA - Benzyladenine
Number of flowers female/male ratio of flowers
PBZ Induce early flowering/fruiting Reduction of vegetative growth Synchronous plantation cycle
Other plant enzymes Vitamin B1- Thiamin
In vitro propagation possible for important hybrids
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
19
TOOLS BEYOND HYBRIDIZATION (2) Dedicated crop cycle management
Water management Abundant for vegetative phase (drip irrigation from reservoirs) Mild water stress for flowering/fruiting
Synchronized pruning PBZ as additional control instrument
Soil amendments & nutrient applications Mycorrhiza and other micro organisms show very positive results if applied correctly Biochar additions show strong effect on vegetative growth Enzyme treatment for faster propagation are under investigation
Manipulation of day light Research required Extend to 16 hours for breeding nursery Find plausible background first
Verify assumption: Best areas today are 15 - 20 degrees away from the equator Try domestication for 0-15 degrees Replication of Mexican daylight times
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
20
THE BIONIC JCL BREEDING TRIANGLE
Jatrophacurcas Linn
Jatrophaintegerrima
Other Jatropha
oil quality > highseeds > medium-largesoil requirement > lowdrought resistance > highpest resistance > moderatenon-toxic accessions > yesmarket acceptance > high
domestication > limitedgenetic variability > low uniformity > lowyield > insufficientflowering > asynchronous toxicity > medium - low
oil quality > very highseeds > smallsoil requirement > mediumdrought resistance > mediumpest resistance > lownon-toxic accessions > nomarket acceptance > none
oil quality > mediumseeds > very smallsoil requirement > lowdrought resistance > highpest resistance > very highnon-toxic accessions > nomarket acceptance > low
domestication > nonegenetic variability > highuniformity > noyield > highflowering > permanent toxicity > high
domestication > nonegenetic variability > high uniformity > highyield > very highflowering > permanenttoxicity > very high
+ _
+ +
__
Strictly confidential
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
21
TRAITS TARGETED FOR OPTIMIZATION Crop yield
Seed weight Number of flowers & female/male ratio Branching
Natural or pruning induced “Willingness to flower” of new branches
Oil content & quality Crop cycles per year
Quality of crop Toxicity Oil composition
Agronomic suitability Uniformity
Canopy shape and size Synchronous flowering
Drought resistance Pest resistance
Horizontal resistance
Strictly confidential
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
22
AN ELITE WILD ACCESSION FROM THE BIONIC COLLECTION
A member of a family of wild germplasm collected from the center of origin
Non-toxic Male sterile High yielding based on several distinct traits
• 12-20 fruits per cluster• 100-seed weight 85+ gram• Strong, permanent flowering• Strong branching
Cuttings develop flowers before leaves
Similarly new branch shoots from pruning often start flowers before leaves
© 2011, 2012 Bionic Fuel Knowledge Partners Inc., Oswego, NY, USA
23
OPEN INFORMATION EXCHANGE POLICY Bionic is promoting an open exchange policy in Jatropha plant
development Looking for collaborative partnerships Mutually beneficial relationships Balanced give and take Open source approach where ever possible Protected intellectual property only where necessary and useful
We wish to talk with anyone in the industry Open dialog without predjudice Explore common industry Alignment of objectives
Talk to us.... [email protected]