![Page 1: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Jorge Peñarrubia
Santiago de Chile 13 April 2015
Mass modelling of dwarf spheroidals
![Page 2: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Universe Composition
WMAP7
Assumption: GR is correct
![Page 3: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
63 orders
51 orders
DM particle models: Constraints
![Page 4: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
63 orders
51 orders
DM particle models: Constraints
CDM N-body
collision-less simulations
![Page 5: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section
1- Counting number of structures in the Universe
2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes
3- Seeking DM-annihilation signals in galaxies
4- Detecting DM particles on Earth
5- Manufacturing DM in particle accelerators
![Page 6: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Substructure abundance
![Page 7: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
λFS
HOT<102 ev
WARM103 __ 105 ev
COLD109 __ 1012 ev
λFS ~ 20 Mpc (30 ev / mν)λFS ~ 100 kpc (1 kev / mν) λFS ~ 3.7 pc (100 Gev / mν)1/2
λFS ≡ “average distance travelled by a DM
particle before it falls in a potential well”
Substructure abundance
![Page 8: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
The inner structure of DM haloes
CDM haloes follow a centrally-divergent density profile
Dubinsky & Carlberg 91, NFW97, Moore+98, Diemand+ 05)
dark matter “cusp”
![Page 9: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
The inner structure of DM haloes
•Relic thermal energy (low particle mass)•Scattering (large cross section) dark matter “cores”
![Page 10: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
The inner structure of DM haloes
•Relic thermal energy (low particle mass)•Scattering (large cross section) dark matter “cores”
![Page 11: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
The extreme properties of dSphs★ Faintest galaxies in the known Universe: 103 < L/Lsol < 107
★Smallest 30 < rhalf/pc < 2000
★Most numerous satellites
★Old, metal poor stellar populations0.1 < age/Gyr < 12
★High mass-to-light ratios: 10 < M/L <1000(Potential dominated by DM)
★No gas
★No rotation
★DM particle mass & cross section
★Gravity tests
★Star formation/feedback in low mass haloes
★Hierarchical galaxy formation
![Page 12: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
( King models)
Illingworth (1976) mass estimate for Globular Clusters
Walker+09Hidalgo+13
M = 167rcµ < v2r >
M/L = 0.72 < v2r/(km/s)2 >⇡ 31from 3 carbon stars:
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity
µ ⇡ 4
Text
![Page 13: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Walker+09Hidalgo+13
Simon & Geha (2007)
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity
Kleyna+02: 165 members
The era of multi-fibre spectrographs
![Page 14: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Walker+09
Simon & Geha (2007)
The era of multi-fibre spectrographs
Kleyna+02: 165 members
Wilkinson+02
� =�0
(1 + r2)↵/2
Wilkinson+02: stars mass-loss tracers of the underlying potential
⇢? =⇢0
[1 + (r/rc)2]5/2} f(E,L)
Anisotropic DF
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity • known form of the (DM) potential• constant anisotropy
![Page 15: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Walker+09
Simon & Geha (2007)
Schwarzschild modelling: orbits
Walker 12
Construction of orbital libraries in a given potential. Subset chosen in order to match v_los(R)
⇢DM = ⇢0(r/rs)↵(1 + r/rs)
�(3+↵)
Breddles+13
Using mock data Breddels+13 conclude that current current kinematic samples are too small to break degeneracies in the (spherical) halo profile
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity • known form of the (DM) potential• arbitrary anisotropy
![Page 16: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity • known form of the (DM) potential• arbitrary anisotropy
Walker+09
Simon & Geha (2007)
Jeans modelling: fast and easy
@
@r(⇢�2
r) +@�
@r⇢+
2�
r(⇢�2
r) = 0. spherical Jeans eqs.
�2r(r) =
1
r2�⇢(r)
Z 1
rdr0r02�⇢(r0)
@�
@r.
�2
los
(R) =2
⌃(R)
Z+1
Rdr
✓1� �(r)
R2
r2
◆⇢(r)�2
rrpr2 �R2
.
Working with the moments of a DF is considerably simpler than constructing DF for a potential/luminous profile pair
![Page 17: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Walker+09
Simon & Geha (2007)
Wilkinson+02
mass-anisotropy degeneracy
Unknown β(r)
Unknown M(r)
Walker 12
Working with the moments of a DF is considerably simpler than constructing DF for a potential/luminous profile pair@
@r(⇢�2
r) +@�
@r⇢+
2�
r(⇢�2
r) = 0. spherical Jeans eqs.
�2r(r) =
1
r2�⇢(r)
Z 1
rdr0r02�⇢(r0)
@�
@r.
�2
los
(R) =2
⌃(R)
Z+1
Rdr
✓1� �(r)
R2
r2
◆⇢(r)�2
rrpr2 �R2
.
Assumptions: • Equilibrium• mass follows light• spherical shape• isotropic velocity • known form of the (DM) potential• arbitrary anisotropy
Jeans modelling: fast and easy
(although fitting kurtosis(R) may help to break degeneracy, Richardson+Fairbairn 13,14)
![Page 18: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Breaking the degeneracyWalker & Peñarrubia (2011)
M -- β degeneracy breaks at R≃Rhalf
Peñarrubia+08; Walker+09; Wolf+10; Amorisco & Evans 2010
M(Rhalf) � µRhalf⇥�V ⇤2
µ � 480M⇥pc�1km�2s�2 (Walker+09)
mass estimator insensitive to β !!
Wolf+10
![Page 19: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Walker & Peñarrubia (2011)
M -- β degeneracy breaks at R≃Rhalf
Peñarrubia+08; Walker+09; Wolf+10; Amorisco & Evans 2010
M(Rhalf) � µRhalf⇥�V ⇤2
Some dSphs show spatially + kinematically distinct stellar components
Tolstoy + 04 (see also Battaglia+08)
Sculptor dSph
µ � 480M⇥pc�1km�2s�2 (Walker+09)
mass estimator insensitive to β !!
Breaking the degeneracy
Wolf+10
![Page 20: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Walker & Peñarrubia (2011)
log M
log R
Multi-component splitting
![Page 21: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
log M
log R
Walker & Peñarrubia (2011)
Multi-component splitting
![Page 22: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
log M
log R
Walker & Peñarrubia (2011)
M � R��
M(Rh) ⇡ µRhh�2i
Multi-component splitting
� = 1 +
log[h�22i/h�2
1i]log[Rh,2/Rh,1]
directly from observables w/o dynamical modelling!
![Page 23: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Walker & Peñarrubia (2011)
DM cusps ruled out in Sculptor and Fornax at a 93% and 97% confidence level
see also Amorisco & Evans(2012); Agnello & Evans(2012); Jardel & Gebhardt (2012)
Sculptor, Fornax
NFW
� 3� �
![Page 24: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Walker, Peñarrubia, Mateo & Olzweski + 15
Sculptor, Fornax.... & Draco
Prelimi
nary
With L~105Lsol Draco is ~300 times fainter than Fornax and 50 times fainter than Sculptor
![Page 25: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
DM profile in fainter dSphs?
Star formation histories (HST data)
Weisz+14
Faint dSphs only have one star formation episode
105 Lsol
106 Lsol
107 Lsol
L<105Lsol
multiple chemo-dynamical components??
![Page 26: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Tidal streams of dSphsErrani, Peñarrubia & Tormen (2015)
� = 1
� = 0
cusp
core
⇢? =⇢0,?
[1 + (r/rc)2]5/2
* Stars (particle tagging)* Dark Matter
Mcore
(< rh) = Mcusp
(< rh)
• N = 2x106 particles • grid size = 10 pc
Initial conditions chosen such that observables independent of halo profile
⇢ =⇢0
(r/a)�(1 + r/a)3��
Mcore
Mcusp
= 1 +a
rh> 1 Cored models more
massive!
![Page 27: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Stellar streams: surface density
![Page 28: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Tidal evolution of dSphs
dSphs acted on by tides follow well-defined tidal tracks
For same amount of mass lost cored dSphs are larger and colder than cuspy dSphs
The sensitivity to core/cusp increases for deeply segregated stellar components (r*<<a)
![Page 29: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Stellar streams: kinematics
![Page 30: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Stellar streams: radial dependence
normalized width and velocity dispersion of the stream to the half-light radius and mean velocity dispersion of the progenitor:
cored dSphs lead to systematically hotter streams
![Page 31: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
streams: core/cusp problem
Systematic offset in stream properties at t=0
PROGENITOR
rt ⇠ M1/3 (e.g. Amorisco 2015)
�z ⇡GM(< rt)
rt
�1/2
rt,core/rt,cusp ' 1.7�z,core/�z,cusp ' 1.7
* fixing the progenitor’s properties yields an offset in the associated stream!
* offset increases with stream age & stellar segregation
* offset evolves parallel to tidal tracks
![Page 32: Jorge Peñarrubia - ESO · Constraints on DM-particle mass & cross-section 1- Counting number of structures in the Universe 2- Measuring inner structure of DM haloes 3- Seeking DM-annihilation](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022041302/5e12d5654870a010ef1b5ccd/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Summary• Equilibrium models suggest that presence of DM cores extends down to L~105 Lsol
•dSphs embedded in cored haloes have streams that are systematically hotter than those embedded in cuspy haloes
•Depending on the age of the stream, the velocity dispersion of cored models can be 2-4x higher than those of cuspy models
• Difference increases with stream age and stellar segregation within the progenitor’s DM halo
•Sgr is the obvious target in the MW
•Such (large) kinematic differences can be straightforwardly measured in streams associated to dSphs in external galaxies
http://www.roe.ac.uk/~raer/tidalstreamsanimations at: