Download - LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
1/45
121
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
2/45
--------------------------------------------------122 Alabang Country Club, Inc. v. NLRCGR NO./ SCRA NO. 170287at!" #!bruary 1$, 2008%g!&t by" Anna '!atr%c! S. (arro&a--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" ALA'ANG CO*N(R+ CL*', INC.
R!&on!nt" *IS*'ING, J., Ca%r!r&on,CAR)IO ORALS,NA(IONAL LA'OR RLA(IONS AC*NA,3
COISSION, ALA'ANG (INGA, anCO*N(R+ CL*' IN)NN( 4LASCO, 5R., JJ.)LO+S *NION,C6RIS(O)6R )IARRO,IC6AL 'RAA, an )roulgat!"NOLASCO CAS(*RAS,R!&on!nt&.)on!nt!" 4LASCO, 5R., J
(o%c" a. 4al% %&cr%%nat%on" un%on &!cur%ty clau&! r!9u%&%t!&
#AC(S"
1. !t%t%on!r Alabang Country Club, Inc. :Club; %& a o!&t%c non-rola%n t!
%&cr!anc%!& %n =r%t%ng. *n%on ul&%on ul&%on
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
3/45
R*LING" No. *n!r t! Labor Co!, an !loy!! ay b! val%ly
t!r%nat! on t!
:1; t! un%on &!cur%ty clau&! %& al%cabl! :2; t! un%on %& r!9u!&t%ng
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
4/45
12D
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
5/45
12$
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
6/45
12E 6.G. 6!nar!& Son& v. Nat%onal Labor *n%on,
Gr No. L-17535
December 28, 1961
Digest by: Jen B!meo
"etitioner: #.G #enres $ %ons
&es'on(ent: Ntion! Lbor )nion
"onente: J. J.B.L &eyes
(o%c" R!tal%at%on" (!&t%ony aga%n&t loy!r/In%r!ct %&cr%%nat%on
#AC(S"
1.
"b!o *ernn(e+ s em'!oye( by #. G. #enres $ %ons s !bortoryssistnt in te /!ity contro! section ose 0ob s to con(/ct tests on te
'ercentge o so!i(ity o in n( oter 'ro(/cts o te com'ny.
2. #is reg/!r oring o/rs ere rom 7:44 .m. to :44 '.m. (i!y. ne (y,
e ''roce( *rncisco *rio, noter !bortory ssistnt oring on te
nigt sit, n( rrnge( to te oer te !tters sit rom mi(nigt to 8:44
.m., o te net (y.
3. *rncisco *rio, on te oter n(, s to or on *ernn(e+ sit rom
7:44 .m. to :44 '.m e rrngement s ito/t te com'nys 'rior
''ro!, oeer it enb!e( im to testiy in te ering o te cse i!e(it ;
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
7/45
12
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
8/45
127
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
9/45
128
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
10/45
--------------------------------------------------
CAS 12@ SAN IG*L COR)ORA(ION v. 'RSAIRA
G.&. No. 87744 C 186 %;& 96J/ne 13, 1994Digest by: e Deni!!--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" %n =ig/e! ;or'ortion ?m'!oyees )nion-"G>, Dnie! %.L.
Borbon eter or not tere is /nir !bor 'rctice
R*LING" 1. Aes tere is /nir !bor 'rcticeAes, bec/se te )nion sees is to reg/!ri+e te stt/s o te em'!oyees
contrcte( by Li'ercon n( DE&ite in eect, tt tey be bsorbe( into te
oring /nit o %n=ig.
is mtter (einite!y (e!!s on te oring re!tionsi' beteen si(
em'!oyees is--is %n=ig. erms, ten/re n( con(itions o teir
em'!oyment n( te rrngement o tose terms re t/s ino!e( bringing
te mtter itin te '/rie o !bor (is'/te.
*/rter, te )nion !so sees to re'resent tose orers, o e signe(
/' or )nion membersi', or te '/r'ose o co!!ectie brgining. %n=ig,
or its 'rt, resists tt )nion (emn( on te gro/n( tt tere is no
em'!oyer-em'!oyee re!tionsi' beteen it n( tose orers n( bec/se
te (emn( io!tes te terms o teir ;B. bio/s ten is tt
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
11/45
re'resenttion n( ssocition, or te '/r'ose o negotiting te con(itions
o em'!oyment re !so ino!e(.
#?&?*&?, te >rit o certiorari is G&N?D n( te r(ers o
res'on(ent J/(ge o 25 =rc 1989 n( 29 =rc 1989 re %? %rit o "roibition is G&N?D n( res'on(ent J/(ge is en0oine( rom
ting ny /rter ction in ;ii! ;se No. 57455 ece't or te '/r'ose o
(ismissing it. e status quo nte (ec!rtion o strie or(ere( by te ;o/rt
on 2 =y 1989 s!! be obsere( 'en(ing te 'rocee(ings in te Ntion!
;onci!ition =e(ition Bor(-De'rtment o Lbor n( ?m'!oyment,
(ocete( s N;=B-N;&-N%-41-42189 n( N;=B-N;&-N%-41-493-83. No
costs.
OC(RIN" >e recogni+e te 'ro'rietry rigt o %n=ig to eercise ninerent mngement 'rerogtie n( its best b/siness 0/(gment to(etermine eter it so/!( contrct o/t te 'erormnce o some o its orto in(e'en(ent contrctors. #oeer, te rigts o !! orers to se!-orgni+tion, co!!ectie brgining n( negotitions, n( 'ece/! concerte(ctiities, inc!/(ing te rigt to strie in ccor(nce it ! F%ection 3,
rtic!e H
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
12/45
-------------------------------------------------------------
1D0. GNRAL ILLING COR). v. CA,
HG.R. No. 1$728. #!bruary 11, 200$
Digeste( by: !ie ;c'ero
(o%c" Iio!tion o D/ty to Brgin
-------------------------------------------------------------
#AC(S"
1 "etitioner Gener! =i!!ing ;or'ortion FG=; em'!oye( 194
orers. ey ere !! members o 'rite res'on(ent Gener! =i!!ing
;or'ortion N G=; is g/i!ty o )L" or io!ting te (/ty to brgin co!!ectie!y
n(Cor interering it te rigt o its em'!oyees to se!-orgni+tion. +S
2 Di( te ; gre!y b/se its (iscretion en it im'ose( on G=; te
(rt ;B 'ro'ose( by te /nion or to yers commencing rom te
e'irtion o te origin! ;B@ +S
R*LING"
1 +S. rtic!e 253- o te Lbor ;o(e, s men(e( by & 6715, sttes:
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
13/45
&. 253-. (!r& o< a coll!ct%v! barga%n%ng agr!!!nt. ny
;B tt te 'rties my enter into s!!, insor s te
re'resenttion s'ect is concerne(, be or term o ie F5 yers.
No 'etition /estioning te m0ority stt/s o te inc/mbent
brgining gent s!! be entertine( n( no certiiction e!ection
s!! be con(/cte( by te De'rtment o Lbor n( ?m'!oyment
o/tsi(e o te sity-(y 'erio( imme(ite!y beore te (te o e'iry
o s/c ie yer term o te ;o!!ectie Brgining greement. !!
oter 'roisions o te ;o!!ectie Brgining greement s!! be
renegotite( not !ter tn tree F3 yers ter its eec/tion....
e ! mn(tes tt te re'resenttion 'roision o ;B so/!( !st or
ie yers. e re!tion beteen !bor n( mngement so/!( be
/n(ist/rbe( /nti! te !st 64 (ys o te it yer. #ence, it is in(is'/tb!e
tt en te /nion re/este( or renegotition o te economic terms o
te ;B on Noember 29, 1991, it s sti!! te certiie( co!!ectie brgining
gent o te orers, bec/se it s seeing si( renegotition itin ieF5 yers rom te (te o eectiity o te ;B on December 1, 1988. e
/nions 'ro'os! s !so s/bmitte( itin te 'rescribe( 3-yer 'erio( rom
te (te o eectiity o te ;B, !beit 0/st beore te !st (y o si(
'erio(. t it (i( s to (eise !imsy ec/se, by /estioning te eistence
o te /nion n( te stt/s o its membersi' to 'reent ny negotition.
G=;s i!/re to me time!y re'!y to te 'ro'os!s 'resente( by te /nion
is in(ictie o its /tter !c o interest in brgining it te /nion.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
14/45
G!n!ral rul!" is tt en ;B !re(y eists, its 'roision s!! contin/e
to goern te re!tionsi' beteen te 'rties, /nti! ne one is gree(
/'on. e r/!e necessri!y 'res/''oses tt !! oter tings re e/!. t
is, tt neiter 'rty is g/i!ty o b( it.
>c!t%on" #oeer, en one o te 'rties b/ses tis grce 'erio( by
'/r'ose!y (e!ying te brgining 'rocess, (e'rt/re rom te gener! r/!e
is rrnte(.
e re not
inc!ine( to grtiy G=; it n eten(e( term o te o!( ;B ter it resorte(
to (e!ying tctics to 'reent negotitions. %ince it s G=; ic io!te(
te (/ty to brgin co!!ectie!y, it ( !ost its stt/tory rigt to negotite or
renegotite te terms n( con(itions o te (rt ;B 'ro'ose( by te /nion.
)n(er or(inry circ/mstnces, it is not ob!igtory /'on eiter si(e o !bor
controersy to 'reci'itte!y cce't or gree to te 'ro'os!s o te oter. B/t
n erring 'rty so/!( not be !!oe( to resort it im'/nity to scemes
eigning negotitions by going tro/g em'ty gest/res. /s, by im'osing onG=; te 'roisions o te (rt ;B 'ro'ose( by te /nion, in o/r ie, te
interests o e/ity n( ir '!y ere 'ro'er!y sere( n( bot 'rties
regine( e/! ooting, ic s !ost en G=; trte( te negotitions
or ne economic terms o te ;B.
%&o&%t%v!" G=; !ost.
octr%n!" *i!ing to com'!y it te mn(tory ob!igtion to s/bmit re'!y to
te /nions 'ro'os!s, G=; io!te( its (/ty to brgin co!!ectie!y, ming it
!ib!e or )L".
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
15/45
1D1
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
16/45
--------------------------------------------------
1D2 St. 5on Coll!g!&, Inc. v. St. 5on Aca!y #aculty an loy!!&
*n%on
G& N.C %;& N. 167892
Dte ctober 27, 2446
Digest by: nn Betrice %. rros
--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" %t. Jon ;o!!eges,
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
17/45
by ten, te em'!oyer-em'!oyee re!tionsi' ( !re(y been terminte(
(/e to te c!os/re o te ig scoo!.
6. ;: irme( te Decision o te NL&;
ISS*/S"
1. >N te 'etitioner is g/i!ty o )L" n( i!!eg! (ismiss!
R*LING" Aes, te 'etitioner is g/i!ty o )"L n( i!!eg! (ismiss!.
e to (ecisie ctors in (etermining eter %J;< cte( in b( it re
F1 te timing o, n( resons or te c!os/re o te ig scoo!, n( F2 te
timing o, n( te resons or te s/bse/ent o'ening o co!!ege n(
e!ementry (e'rtment, n(, /!timte!y, te reo'ening o te ig scoo!
(e'rtment by %J;< ter on!y one yer rom its c!os/re.
"rior to te c!os/re o te ig scoo! by %J;
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
18/45
1DD
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
19/45
1D$
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
20/45
1DE San %gu!l #oo&, Inc. v. SC loy!!& *n%on-)(GJO
Gr No. 168569
ctober 5, 2447
Digest by: Jen B!meo
"etitioner: %n =ig/e! *oo(s
&es'on(ent: %=; )nionF"G>
"onente: J.;r'io =or!es
(o%c" Gro&& 4%olat%on o< C'A
#AC(S"
t te time mteri! to te cse, %n =ig/e! ;or'ortion ?m'!oyees )nion
">G Fte )nion, s te so!e brgining gent o !! te mont!y 'i(
em'!oyees o 'etitioner %n =ig/e! *oo(s,
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
21/45
rtic!e o te Lbor ;o(e 'roi(es tt !! (o/bts in te im'!ementtion
n( inter'rettion o te 'roisions o tis ;o(e, inc!/(ing im'!ementing r/!es
n( reg/!tions, s!! be reso!e( in or o !bor. %ince te seniority r/!e in
te 'romotion o em'!oyees s bering on s!ry n( beneits, it my,
o!!oing !iber! constr/ction o rtic!e 261 o te Lbor ;o(e, be
consi(ere( n economic 'roision o te ;B.
s boe-stte(, te )nion crges %=*< to e 'romote( !ess senior
em'!oyees, t/s by'ssing oters o ere more senior n( e/!!y or more /!iie(.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
22/45
1D
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
23/45
1D7
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
24/45
1D8
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
25/45
--------------------------------------------------
CAS 1D@ NA(IONAL LA'OR *NION v. CIR
G.&. No. L-31276 C 116 %;& 17%e'tember 9, 1982Digest by: e Deni!!--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" Ntion! Lbor )nion
R!&on!nt" ;o/rt o o Long n( Benito %. ?stnis!o
)on!nt!" G/tierre+, Jr., J.
(o%c" ?norcement, &eme(ies n( %nctions 2. "rties Lib!e or cts b.
Lbor rgni+tion
#AC(S"
1 e cting "rosec/tor o tis ;o/rt i!e( orm! com'!int it tis;o/rt crging res'on(ent ?er!sting =n/ct/ring o /nir !bor 'rctice itin te mening o %ection F, s/b-'rgr's 1, n( 6 inre!tion to %ections 13, 1 n( 15 o &e'/b!ic ct 875 Fn ct to"romote
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
26/45
ISS*S"
1 >eter or not te res'on(ent co/rt s 0/stiie( in com'!ete!y oer-t/rning its =rc 22, 1966 r/!ing on te !ibi!ity o ng >o Long Fin(ingg/i!ty o /nir !bor 'rctice /n(er te =y 3, 1963 co!!ectiebrgining contrct.
R*LING" 1. No, te res'on(ent co/rt s not 0/stiie( in com'!ete!y oer-t/rning te si( r/!ing.
No, bec/se it m/st be note( tt te res'on(ent co/rt mo(iie( its (ecisionn( bso!e( ng >o Long o res'onsibi!ity or n( !ibi!ity /n(er te =y 3,
1963 co!!ectie brgining contrct bec/se o its in(ing tt tere s
!c o ei(ence ic o/!( so no!e(ge not on!y o te ;B b/t o te
eistence o te /nion itse! on te 'rt o =r. ng >o Long.
Ono!e(ge or reness o t is going on reers to ment! n( inner
stte o conscio/sness, cogni+nce, n( inormtion. >eter or not =r. ng
>o Long ne te !bor 'rob!ems o te irm e '/rcse(, te eistence o
/nion, te on-going P ;B negotitions, n( te eorts o te em'!oyees
e !ter (ismisse( to rec n greement it mngement on te termsn( con(itions o teir em'!oyment cn be (etermine( on!y rom n
(mission o =r. ng imse! or rom te s/rro/n(ing cts n(
circ/mstnces in(ictie o no!e(ge. or reness.
)n(er te cts re circ/mstnces o tis cse, it is irrtion! i not s'ecio/s
to ss/me tt =r. ng bo/gt b/siness !oc, stoc, n( brre! ito/t
in/iring into its !bor-mngement sit/tion n( tt is (ismiss! o !! te
/nion members ito/t retining e e'erience( orers n( teir
re'!cement it com'!ete!y ne set o em'!oyees o ere strngers to
te com'ny s nyting oter tn n ttem't to ri( te irm o /nnte(
/nion ctiity.
(!r! %& &ub&tant%al !v%!nc! to &u&ta%n a o Long P is i!ing n
''!iction or registrtion it te B/re/ o ;ommerce on 'ri! 21, 1963,
is sec/ring te myorEs 'ermit, n( is oter cts o mngement P ere
on!y cts 're'rtory to ting oer te irm n( not cts in(icting
no!e(ge o /nion ctiity n( te ;B negotitions. >e r/!e oterise.
"recise!y bec/se =r. ng 'erorme( cts in(ictie o norm! cre n(
c/tion on te 'rt o mn b/ying mn/ct/ring irm, >e r/!e tt te
sme cre n( c/tion s !so eten(e( to more sensitie s'ect o te
b/siness, one ttrcting te gretest (egree o concern n( ttention o ny
ne oner, ic s te re!tionsi' o te orers to mngement, teir
i!!ingness to coo'erte it te oner, n( teir 'ro(/ctiity rising rom
rmonio/s re!tions. Benito ?stnis!o signe( te ;B no !onger s oner
b/t s gener! mnger. e ne oner /se( te sme 'remises, te
sme b/siness nme, mcineries, too!s n( im'!ements n( te sme
oici!s n( s/'erisors inc!/(ing te ssistnt mnger, =r. n #oc e
on!y cnge s te re'!cement o te 21 /nion member it com'!ete!y
ne set o em'!oyees ire( rom o/tsi(e te irm. s stte( by J/(ge
mn(o ;. B/gyong in te co/rtEs =rc 22,1966 (ecision, te res'on(ent
ng >o Long (i( not so ny 0/st c/se or (is'ensing it te serices o !! te 21 /nion members. >e gree it J/(ge B/gyong tt te
conc!/sion becomes inesc'b!e tt e F=r. ng (ismisse( te
com'!innts in or(er to bre te /nion n( (o y it te eisting
co!!ectie brgining greement ic it s obtine( on!y ter strie n(
brgining negotitions.
noter mystiying s'ect o te /estione( or(er n( reso!/tion s te
'!cing o /!! res'onsibi!ity on te so/!(ers o =r. Benito ?stnis!o om
te co/rt /nny ne ( !re(y conenient!y (is''ere( een s it
bso!e( te on!y 'erson o co/!( grnt irmtie re!ie n( ose !ibi!ity
( er!ier been (etermine( to be o/n(e( on s/bstnti! ei(ence. e
s/mmons iss/e( to Benito ?stnis!o s ret/rne( by ng >o LongEs
co/nse! o stte( tt Benito ?stnis!o s no !onger t is ormer
((ress. %/mmons ( to be eecte( tro/g '/b!iction. e 'erson o/n(
g/i!ty o /nir !bor 'rctice (i( not so /' t te reo'ene( erings n(
s r s te recor(s beore )% so, ( (is''ere(. e conctention
o circ/mstnces c!er!y in(ictes te 'rtici'tion o bot =r. ?stnis!o n(
=r. ng in te /nir !bor 'rctice. #ence, ng >o Long so/!( be 0oint!y
n( seer!!y !ib!e it Benito %. ?stnis!o or te 'yment o bcges
to te com'!ining em'!oyees.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
27/45
#ence, te ;o/rt e!( tt tey grnt tree F3 yers bcges ito/t
(e(/ction or /!iiction to te (ismisse( em'!oyees. *o!!oing te sme
consi(ertions n( in irness to ng >o Long, reinsttement o te
com'!ining em'!oyees so/!( be m(e on te bsis o te !tterEs 'ysic!
itness or te res'ectie 0obs rom ic tey ere i!!eg!!y o/ste(.
IS)OSI(I4" >#?&?*&?, te 'etition is ereby G&N?D.
1 ng >o Long n( Benito %. ?stnis!o re ereby &D?&?D 0oint!y n(
seer!!y to 'y te com'!ining em'!oyees tree F3 yers bcges
ito/t (e(/ction or /!iiction.
2 ng >o Long is ereby or(ere( to reinstte te com'!ining em'!oyees
n( e my re/ire certiictions o teir 'ysic! itness by goernment
'ysicin n(
3 ng >o Long n( Benito %. ?stnis!o s!! 'y te costs.
OC(RIN" ''recition o cts n( conc!/sions (rn rom cts m/st bes/c s o/!( be cce'tb!e to resonb!e min(. e reconsi(ere(
conc!/sions o te res'on(ent co/rt not on!y !y ginst te (icttes o reson
n( common sense b/t re o/t o to/c it te gro/n(s o '/b!ic 'o!icy
im'!icit in te
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
28/45
-------------------------------------------------------------
1$0. CCLC .G. GOC6ANGCO JORMRS *NION v. NLRC
ay D0, 1@88
Digeste( by: !ie ;c'ero
(o%c" ?norcement, &eme(ies n( %nctions ;om'romise
------------------------------------------------------------
#AC(S"
1 )!t%t%on!r CCLC .G. Gocangco Jor?!r& *n%on is !oc! c'ter o te ;entr! L/+on Lbor ;ongress F;LL;, !egitimte !bor e(ertion(/!y registere( it te =inistry o Lbor n( ?m'!oyment F=L?, i!ete %n%v%ual !t%t%on!r& re ormer em'!oyees o 'rite res'on(ento ere oicers n( members o te 'etitioner /nion.
2 =0ority o te rn n( i!e em'!oyees o res'on(ent irm orgni+e( te
e.g. Gocngco >orers )nion s n i!ite o te ;LL;.3 )nion i!e( 'etition or certiiction ;LL; ntion! 'resi(ent rote te gener! mnger o res'on(ent irm
inorming im o te orgni+tion o te /nion n( re/esting or !bor mngement conerence to norm!i+e em'!oyer-em'!oyee re!tions
5 )nion sent ritten notice to res'on(ent irm re/esting 'ermission or certin member oicers n( members o te /nion to tten( te eringo te 'etition or certiiction e!ection. e mngement re/se( tocno!e(ge recei't o si( notice
6 "rite res'on(ent 'reentie!y s/s'en(e( te /nion oicers n(members o tten(e( te ering. e common gro/n( !!ege( by'rite res'on(ent or its ction s bn(onment o or on *ebr/ry
27, 1984. n te sme (te, !! te gte 'sses o !! te boe-mentione( em'!oyees to ;!r ir Bse ere coniscte( by Bseg/r(.
7 ;!iming tt 'rite res'on(ent instigte( te conisction o teir gte'sses to 'reent tem rom 'erorming teir (/ties n( tt res'on(entirm (i( not 'y tem teir oertime 'y, 13t mont 'y n( oter beneits, 'etitioner /nion n( its members i!e( com'!int or constr/ctie !oco/t n( /nir !bor 'rctice ginst 'rite res'on(ent.
8 'rite res'on(ent i!e( n ''!iction or c!ernce to (ismiss te /nionoicers n( members
9 "etitioner &icr(o Dormingo o s 'reentie!y s/s'en(e(, i!e( com'!int or )L". %erices o 9 more /nion members ere terminte(
by 'rite res'on(ent on te gro/n( tt its contrct it te ).%. ir
*orce ( e'ire(. e 9 em'!oyees i!e( com'!int or i!!eg!(ismiss! ginst 'rite res'on(ents
14 "rite res'on(ent i!e( it =L? Notice o ermintion o ;ontrcttogeter it !ist o em'!oyees ecte( by te e'irtion o tecontrct, mong tem, te 39 in(ii(/! 'etitioners erein.
11 LA or(ere(: o reinstte !! te s/s'en(e(C(ismisse( em'!oyees to teir ormer 'ositions ito/t !oss o seniority rigts n( oter 'rii!eges, it/!! bcges inc!/(ing cost o emergency !iing !!once rom te(te o teir s/s'ensionC(ismiss! /' to te s/''ose( (te o ct/!
reinsttement12 NLRC" set si(e te (ecision o te L grnte( te ''!iction or
c!ernce to terminte te serices o in(ii(/! com'!innts-''e!!eesi!e( by res'on(ent-''e!!nt.
ISS*" >N 'etitioners ie( teir teir economic (emn(s, s !!ege( by
'rite res'on(ent, by y o com'romise.
R*LING
NO.
>e re conince( tt te res'on(ent com'ny is in(ee( g/i!ty o n )L".
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
29/45
e ;o/rt re0ects te c!ims o n !!ege( ier by te 'etitioners o teir
economic (emn(s, in te !igt o n !!ege( or(er iss/e( by Lbor rbiter
/ino in connection it noter cseFs ino!ing te sme 'rties. F
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
30/45
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
31/45
--------------------------------------------------
1$2 '%&%g ng anggaga=a &a Concr!t! Aggr!gat!&, Inc. v. NLRC
G& N.C %;& N. 145494
Dte: %e'tember 16, 1993
Digest by: nn Betrice %. rros
--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" Bisig Ng =nggg % ;oncrete ggregtes, ! ming 'ie!em s & ninyoSB/b/gb/gin nmin yo 'g
yo ng'i!itTe &mon Bn, )nion "resi(ent: Rsisiment/in nming ng gtes ng
;oncrete ggregte n it i'is s in(i m'soT8 )nion i!e( te instnt 'etition or certiorri
ISS*/S"
1. " >N te iss/nce o te "re!iminry
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
32/45
2 &ecor(s ree! cont%nu%ng %&u&! o< un-art! (RO %& not !r &! ro%b%t! '*( %t u&t b!
cl!arly Fu&t%tr!! n!c!&&%ty. Bec/se im'r/(ent!y iss/es &s cn bre te bc o em'!oyees
engge( in !eg! strie.
b e (e!eterio/s eects o s/c & on te rigts o striingem'!oyees cn no !onger be re'ire( or tey (ey sim'!emoneti+tion.
c s s/c it beooes oicers receiing ei(ence to s/''ort e-'rteei(ence to te more ctie stnce seeing to it tt te rigt tosoci! 0/stice is in no y io!te(.
Nor (oes te co/rt in( bse!ess te !!egtion by te /nion tt NL&;( neg!ecte( to reso!es teir in0/nction. e com'nys 'ryer or e-'rte & s er( n( grnte( on
te sme (y.b e com'nys 'etition or 're!iminry in0/nction s i!e( 'ri! 34
n( s grnte( !ess tn ee ter =y5.
c n te oter n(, te /nions 'etition s not yet been er( nor (eci(e(.
( e (is'rte tretment is ine'!icb!e consi(ering te s/b0ectmtters o teir 'etition re o simi!r im'ortnce to te 'rties n( tote '/b!ic.
IS)OSI(I4" )RLIINAR+ IN5*NC(ION :aga%n&t &tr%?%ng =or?!r&;
ANN*L S( ASI
*/rter: NL&; is or(ere( to er n( reso!e it (e!iberte s'ee(/nions 'etition or in0/nction i!e( on 34 'ri! 1992.
OC(RIN" The restoration of the right to strike is the most valuable gain of
labor after the EDSA revolution. t is the emplo!ees sole weapon. n
recognition of its importance, our #onsti has accor$e$ this right a $istinct
status while our laws have assure$ that its rightful e%ercise will not be
negate$ b! the issuance of unnecessar! in&unctions
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
33/45
1$D
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
34/45
1$$
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
35/45
1$E GS (ran&ort Cor. v. (%to S. In
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
36/45
R*LING" A?%, ccor(ing to rtic!e 212 o te Lbor ;o(e (eines strie s
ny tem'orry sto''ge o or by te concerte( ction o em'!oyees s
res/!t o n in(/stri! or !bor (is'/te.
!i( strie tereore 'res/''oses te eistence o !bor (is'/te. e
strie /n(erten by res'on(ents too te orm o sit-(on strie, or more
't!y terme( s sym'tetic strie, ere te striing em'!oyees e no
(emn(s or griences o teir on, b/t tey strie or te '/r'ose o (irect!y
or in(irect!y i(ing oters, ito/t (irect re!tion to te (ncement o teinterest o te striers.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
37/45
1$
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
38/45
1$7
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
39/45
1$8
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
40/45
--------------------------------------------------
CAS 1$@ S(A. ROSA COCA-COLA )LAN( )LO+S *NION v.
CC')
G.&. Nos. 16342-43%e'tember 9, 1982Digest by: e Deni!!--------------------------------------------------
)!t%t%on!r" %nt &os ;oc-;o! "!nt ?m'!oyees )nion, Donrico I.
%ebstin, ?/!ogio G. Btino, %m/e! . tn/e, =no!o ;. Ub!0/reg/i,
Dionisio enorio, ?(in ". &e!!ores, L/is B. Ntii((, =yrn "etingco,
*e!icino o!entino, &o(o!o . mnte, Jr., ;i'rino ;. Be!!o, &on!(o .
?s'ino, ?ren G!n n( J/n ;rme!ito %ntos
R!&on!nt" ;oc-;o! Bott!ers "i!s.,
16.Lbor rbiter: ren(ere( Decision grnting te 'etition o te ;om'ny.
#e (ec!re( tt te mss !ee s ct/!!y strie /n(er rtic!e 212o te Lbor ;o(e. e strie con(/cte( by te )nion s i!!eg! sincetere s no soing tt te )nion con(/cte( strie ote, obsere(te 'rescribe( coo!ing-o 'erio(, m/c !ess, s/bmitte( strie ote tote DL? itin te re/ire( time. ;onse/ent!y, or noing!y'rtici'ting in te i!!eg! strie, te in(ii(/! 'etitioners ereconsi(ere( to e !ost teir em'!oyment stt/s.
17. e )nion ''e!e( te (ecision to te NL&;. n J/!y 31, 2442, teNL&; irme( te (ecision o te Lbor rbiter it te mo(iiction tt)nion res/rer ;r!it =. brigo, o s on bereement !ee tte time, so/!( be ec!/(e( rom te !ist o tose o 'rtici'te( in tei!!eg! strie. %e s t/s or(ere( reinstte( to er ormer 'osition it
/!! bcges n( beneits.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
41/45
18. ; ren(ere( 0/(gment (ismissing te 'etition or !c o merit.1@. "etitioner )nion i!e( n =& b/t s (enie(.20. #ence, tis 'etition or reie on certiorri.
ISS*S"
1. >eter or not te %e'tember 21, 1999 mss ction stge( by te )nions strie
2. i, in te irmtie, eter it s !eg!3. >eter or not te in(ii(/! oicers n( so' ster(s o 'etitioner
)nion so/!( be (ismisse( rom teir em'!oyment.
R*LING" 1. Aes, e r/!ing o te ; tt 'etitioners stge( strie on%e'tember 21, 1999, n( not mere!y 'icet is correct.
Aes, bec/se e bre ct tt 'etitioners ere gien =yors 'ermit isnot conc!/sie ei(ence tt teir ctionCctiity (i( not mo/nt to strie.e =yors (escri'tion o t ctiities 'etitioners ere !!oe( to con(/ct
is inconse/enti!. o re'et, t is (einitie o eter te ction stge(by 'etitioners is strie n( not mere!y 'icet is te tot!ity o tecirc/mstnces s/rro/n(ing te sit/tion.
2. &ecor(s ree! tt te si( strie (i( not com'!y it te re/irements o rtic!e 263 F* in re!tion to rtic!e 26 o te Lbor ;o(e or !i( strie.
&. 263. %&
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
42/45
'rescribe( coo!ing-o 'erio(, con(/cte( strie ote, m/c !ess s/bmitte( strie ote re'ort to te De'rtment o Lbor itin te re/ire( time. isbeing te cse, res'on(ents strie on %e'tember 21, 1999 is i!!eg!. orers )nion s. NL&;, 2999 Fsic %;&14, te %/'reme ;o/rt ( si(:
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
43/45
e!' tem sort it o/t or, i necessry, e!' tem i!e com'!int.
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
44/45
-------------------------------------------------------------
1E0. SCARIO v. NLRC
G.&. No. 164342, %e'tember 27, 2414
Digeste( by: !ie ;c'ero
(o%c" %trie ?ect on >or &e!tionsi'
-------------------------------------------------------------
#AC(S"
1 e !t%t%on!r& ere mong te reg/!r em'!oyees o r!&on!nt)%na?aa&ara Cororat%on :)INA, cor'ortion engge( inmn/ct/ring n( se!!ing oo( sesoning. ey ere members o !t%t%on!r =!yng %mn ng mg =nggg s B!nce(*oo(s F)nion.
2 n =rc 13, 1993, !! te oicers n( some 244 members o te )nion!e( o/t o "
-
8/18/2019 LABREL Week 5 Digests INC
45/45
s/''orting i!!eg! stries, bsent ny in(ing tt s/c orers committe(
i!!eg! cts (/ring te 'erio( o te i!!eg! stries.
e 'etitioners ere terminte( or 0oining strie tt s !ter (ec!re( to
be i!!eg!. e NL&; or(ere( teir reinsttement or, in !ie/ o reinsttement,
te 'yment o teir se'rtion 'y, bec/se tey ere mere rn-n(-i!e
orers om te )nions oicers ( mis!e( into 0oining te i!!eg! strie.
ey ere not /n0/st!y (ismisse( rom or. Bse( on te tet n( intent o
te to ore/ote( 'roisions o te 'abor #o$e, tereore, it is '!in tt rtic!e 26Fa is te ''!icb!e one.
)!t%t%on!r& rg/e tt te in(ing o no bn(onment e/te( to in(ing o
i!!eg! (ismiss! in teir or. #ence, tey ere entit!e( to /!! bcges.
e 'etitioners rg/ment cnnot be s/stine(.
e 'etitioners 'rtici'tion in te i!!eg! strie s 'recise!y t 'rom'te(
"