Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Analysis of Royal Theater’sPractice of Showing
Commercials
Presenters: Dr. Rymsza and Dr. Gunther
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Agenda
Background: Rymsza The Case for Fraud: Rymsza Survey Goals: Gunther Survey Results: Gunther Ethical Issues: Gunther Strategic Issue: Gunther Conclusions: Rymsza Recommendations: Rymsza
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Background
A Patron (Tommy) is dissatisfied with his recent experience in a Royal Theater.
– Having to sit through 20 minutes of commercials before the movie actually started
Allegation of fraud on Royal Theater’s part
Threatens to file class action lawsuit.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Misrepresentation vs. Fraud
Fraud distinguished from misrepresentation
Prima facie case for fraud
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Prima Facie Case for Fraud
A plaintiff alleging fraud must prove:
• A representation was made• The representation was false• When made, the representation was known to be false• The plaintiff relied on the representation• The plaintiff REASONABLY relied on the representation• The plaintiff suffered damage (economic loss) as a result
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
False Assertion of Fact
Assertion – “Movie begins at 1:00 pm”
Assertion is false
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Knowledge & Intent
Knowledge of the falsity– Theater sets starting times
Intent to deceive– Want Tommy to act on the given information
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Actual Reliance
Complaining party acts on the assertion
– Tommy made sure he was seated by 1:00pm
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Justifiable (Reasonable) Reliance
Reliance must be reasonable– Starting time specified in:
Newspaper ad Marquee Employee Movie ticket
– General public knowledge
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Damage – Economic Loss
Damage resulting from reliance
– Opportunity cost - 20 minutes of lost time• Nominal• Punitive Damages
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
The Case for Fraud
Conclusion:– First four elements easy to establish
– Difficulty establishing reasonable reliance and damage
– Tommy HAS A WEAK case for fraud.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
How Widespread is Discontent with Commercials?
Your theater’s reputation and financial viability depend on your patron’s opinions of this behavior.
Objective – estimate the percentage of all theater patrons resenting commercials.
– If less than 5% resent the commercials, Royal Theater should consider going to trial and defending any lawsuit.
– If between 5% and 20% resent them, cut showing time of ads by 50% provided Tommy files lawsuit.
– If more than 20% resent the commercials, Royal Theater should consider settling with Tommy and discontinue ads.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Interpretation of 1st Survey Results
A survey is a sampling of the population. Out of 100 responses: 12 patrons or 12%
resent the commercials.– We can be 95% confident percentage of
moviegoers who resent commercials is between 5.6% and 18.4%
– Results indicate that Royal Theater should cut showing time of ads by 50% if Tommy files lawsuit.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Interpretation of 2nd Survey Results
Out of 300 responses: 60 patrons or 20% resent the commercials.– We can be 95% confident percentage of
moviegoers who resent commercials is between 15.5% and 24.5%
– This answer extends across two of the decision rules: either cut the ads by 50% or discontinue ads entirely and settle with Tommy.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Ethical Issues
Decision to state movie starting time as 1 p.m.
Traditional View - Costs vs. Benefits
Impact of decision on STAKEHOLDERS: patrons, owners of theaters, employees
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Costs
Potentially agitated customers
Potential legal liabilities
Perception of “tricking” a captive audience to increase revenues
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Benefits
Increased revenues
Public service announcements
Buffer grace period
Entertainment
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Conclusions
Survey a larger population before making any decision regarding Tommy’s lawsuit.
– Estimates of percentages will be more precise (smaller interval) making it clearer whether to reduce ads 50% or settle.
Tommy’s case for fraud is weak, but Royal Theater should be prepared to respond.
Royal Theater is behaving in an ethical manner, but opinions of patrons must be considered for longer term viability.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Conclusions: Royal Theatre Should Apply Strategic Thinking
The Whole Picture: Long term changes in business environment that could affect Royal’s profitability:
– Consumer attitudes about commercials prior to films– Economy– Competing forms of entertainment– Competing theatres– Changing demographics– Changes in government regulations
A Sense of Direction: All of these could impact future decisions to show commercials.
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Long Term Recommendations
Consider changing theater operations to avoid future lawsuits and attract more patrons– Advertise movie starting times more clearly.– Reconsider the number of commercials shown
before each movie.– Treat consumer complaints courteously– Consider innovations to bring in more
customers – “continuous improvement”
Looney Consulting Group, Inc. Providing Complex Solutions to Simple Problems
Looney Consulting GroupWhere We
Expect Our
ClTelephone: 1-800-CaRP-
CON email -