Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances
Rafael Doménech
An Independent Fiscal Responsibility Authority For Spain
IEF, Madrid, May 13!14, 2013
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 2
Objectives of an independent "iscal authority
Many academic contributions, starting in the mid-1990s (e.g., Calmfors and Wren-Lewis, 2011, Debrun et al., 2009, and others), have proposed
independent fiscal authorities to prevent the deficit bias of fiscal policy
(2) Proposal of a methodology for the estimation of trend forecasts of public revenues and expenditures
(1) Assessment of economic forecasts, budget stability along the business cycle and the sustainability of public debt
(3) Evaluation of the Stability Programme (including the pension system), assessment of regional governments’ budgets and financial rebalancing
plans
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 3
Why now?
(1) Despite previous stability laws, evidence of persistent structural deficits and the current situation of public accounts, with debt on an unsustainable
path that should be curbed
(3) Demographic challenges with significant implications upon the sustainability of public accounts, particularly for the pension system
(2) A Constitutional reform in 2011 and an new Budget Stability Law in 2012
-> Independent ex ante evaluation of fiscal plans to avoid potential deficit bias
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 4
Why now?
EU15 and the USA: structural budget balance (% GDP) Source: Doménech and García (2013)
Deficit bias over last three decades, not only in Spain
Spain had an structural deficit similar to other countries, but with higher volatility
High dispersion across countries
High persistence
-‐15
-‐10
-‐5
0
5
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Media
España
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 5
Why now?
EU15 and the USA: public debt (% GDP) Source: Doménech and García (2013)
A higher structural deficit in the past leads to a higher level of public debt in the present ...
… with the consequent distortionary and negative effects on investment and growth
Given a level of public spending over GDP, a higher level of debt requires higher tax rates ...
… forcing to maintain a higher primary surplus in the future (modified golden rule)
10
30
50
70
90
110
130
150
170
1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Media
España
d = 1+ g
r − g(t − g)
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 6
Why now?
Density function of the effect of 1pp of public debt on growth Source: Doménech and García (2013) from Kumar and Woo (2010) and Reinhart and Rogoff (2010)
A 10 PP increase in the debt to GDP ratio implies 2 decimal points of ess growth
Causality problem: To what extent a lower potential growth leads to more public debt?
There is some evidence of non-linearities. The effects are quantitatively more important from debt levels
above 60%-90%
In 92% cases the estimated coe#icient is negative. A 10pp reduction in the debt ratio leads to an increase in
long-term GDP by 0.8%
Solo en un 8% de los casos el coeficiente es positivo
Reinhart y Rogoff (2010) 0.043
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 7
Why now?
Effects of public debt reduction from 95% to 35% of GDP Source: Doménech and García (2013)
According to current forecasts, public debt will stabilise around levels close to 100%
For each 10 pp of debt reduction GDP increases by 0.87% (0.8% Kumar and Woo, 0.7% Elmendorf and
Mankiw)
Tax rates vary to ensure debt sustainability
Steady state change: debt 95% (2014) to 35% (minimum level before the crisis)
GDP Private Consumption Investment Employment Capital stock Tax rates
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 8
Needed (1): macroeconomic and "iscal forecasts
In order to asses the current and future fiscal stance, independent macroeconomic and fiscal forecasts are needed
… and their effects on tax bases, public revenues, expenditures and the budget balance
Not only about basic macroeconomic and fiscal variables, but also with an assessment of potential macroeconomic imbalances …
For different reasons (CAB decomposition, sustainability of the pension system), the forecasting period should be longer than for the Stability
Programme
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 9
Needed (2): methodology to compute trend components
(1) Decomposition of GDP and unemployment rates into structural and cyclical components
(1) and (2) -> decomposition of taxes bases, revenues, expenditures and the budget balance into structural and cyclical components
(2) Estimates of revenues and expenditures elasticities
(1) and (2) are subject to many problems and shortcomings
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 10
Problem (1): bias in government forecasts Forecasted versus actual output gap Source: Jonung and Larch (2006)
Evidence (e.g., Jonung and Larch, 2006, Frankel and Schreger 2013, and others) that EMU governments
produce biased forecasts of economic activity ...
Would an independent forecasting authority make a difference? Yes, according to the evidence (e.g., Jonung
and Larch, 2006, Frankel and Schreger, 2013)
Frankel and Schreger (2013): forecasting bias can defeat fiscal rules
… that have played a role in generating excessive deficits
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
-4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5
One
-yea
r ah
ead
fore
cast
Actual output gap
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 11
Problem (2): procyclicality of trend components Unemployment rate and its structural component, Spain 1980-2012 Source: European Commission
Many ex-post estimates of structural unemployment are very procyclical …
This procyclicality of structural unemployment is the main cause of the procyclicality of potential growth
Real time estimates are even more procyclical
… even those estimated by independent authorities, such as the European Commsission
7%
9%
11%
13%
15%
17%
19%
21%
23%
25%
27%
1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008 2012
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 12
Problem (2): procyclicality of trend components Growth of GDP and potential growth, Spain 1981-2012 Source: European Commission
Ex-post estimates of potential GDP growth are usually very procyclical …
Other factors (e.g., working-age population growth) also contribute to this procyclicality
As in the case of unemployment, real time estimates are even more procyclical
The procyclicality of potential growth is not only the consequence of the procyclicality of structural
unemployment
-4%
-3%
-2%
-1%
0%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 13
Problem (2): procyclicality of trend components Growth of working-age population, Spain, EMU and USA 1981-2012 Source: BBVA Research
Spain: short-run population forecasts (thousands), resident population, 1st of January each year Source: BBVA Research based on INE
-1.5%
-1.0%
-0.5%
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
2.5%
1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005 2009
USA$
EMU$
Spain$
44000
45000
46000
47000
48000
49000
50000
2007 2009 2011 2013 2015 2017 2019 2021
2007-15 2008-18 2009-19 2010-20 2011-21 2012-22
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 14
Problem (3): changes in tax bases and elasticities Unemployment rat and total public revenues over GDP, Spain 1987-2012 Source: BBVA Research
Large movements in tax bases and public revenues that are related to changes in asset prices or in demand
and/or sectorial composition
Discretionary vs. cyclical changes, transitory vs. permanent, composition and price effects, etc.
Example, boom from 2003 to 2007 and crisis from 2007 to 2009: public revenues from 41% to 35%
The procyclicality of potential growth is not only the consequence of the procyclicality of structural
unemployment
87 88
89
90
91
92 93
94
95
96 97
98
99
00 01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27
Publ
ic re
venu
es (%
GD
P)
Unemployment rate (%)
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 15
80
81
82 83
84
85 86
87 88 89
90 91 92
93 94
95
96
97 98
99 00 01 02 03 04
05 06 07
08
09
10 11
12(f)
12e
6e
-12
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27
Budg
et b
alan
ce (%
GD
P)
Unemployment rate (%)
1.7%%
&5.9%%
21.67%%(2012)%
10.96%%(2006)%
18%%(2012)%
&3%%
Problem (4): implications for "iscal policy evaluation Unemployment and budget balance, Spain 1980-2012 Source: BBVA Research
The structural budget deficit estimated by the EC is also procyclical
It is crucial that an independent fiscal authority could asses the fiscal stance properly
Larger structural deficits in the boom and smaller in the crisis than the ones estimated by the EC
Alternative estimates of the structural unemployment rate produce less procyclical structural budget
balances
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances May, 2013
Page 16
Main messages
1
2
3
In order to asses the current and future fiscal stance, an independent assessment of forecasts is needed to avoid the deficit bias of government forecasts
Forecasts of macroeconomic and fiscal variables, but also with an assessment of potential macroeconomic imbalances, and their effects on the budget balance
Also needed a methodology to compute structural components of public accounts (cyclical position and elasticities)
Many forecasting and measurement problems: some are well-known, others are less well-known (real time analysis, asset prices and bubbles, changes in demand and sectorial composition, etc.)
Fiscal policy in practice is as much art as science … but science is quite useful! (as Blinder, 1997, on the dark art of monetary policy)
4
5
Macroeconomic Forecasting and the Sustainability of Public Finances
Rafael Doménech
An Independent Fiscal Responsibility Authority For Spain
IEF, Madrid, May 13!14, 2013