Download - Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism
![Page 1: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
FreedomofExpressioninMalaysia2009
An Annual Review by
![Page 2: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
contents 4 Foreword
5 Malaysia’sMediaLandscape
6 TheCrisisinPerak
8 Policepartialityandfreedomofassembly
10 Racialisationofissuesvsethicalreporting
12 Threatsagainstonlinemediaandbloggers
14 Intoleranceofdiversity
16 Conclusion
18 TimelineofEvents
• The Perak Crisis• Right to Assembly• ISA and the release of Hindraf leaders• The “Allah” issue• Restrictions against discourse of Islam• Online censorship• Raja Petra Kamarudin• Restriction of campaigning at by-elections• Others
![Page 3: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
4
FO
RE
WO
RD Fourteendasyafterthefireworksushering2010,anumberofplacesofworshipwereattacked,onewithpaints,mostotherswith
firebombs.Noonewasinjured,butthiscameafterdaysofprotestbyMuslim-MalayoressuregroupsagainstthecourtrulingallowingtheCatholicstousetheword“Allah”intheirpublication.
Sectarianviolenceisrareinmulti-ethnicMalaysia,butwhentheStateandnon-Stateactorschampionthecauseofnarrowly-definedrightsandprivilegesforaspecificgroupovertherightsofallcitizens,thisfomentsfearandignorance,andencouragesintoleranceininteractionsbetweenandwithinethniccommunities.
Tostokethefire,thereisalsounprecendentedpartisanshipontheissueinacertainmedia-aworryingsubversionofthemedia’spotentialinpromotingpeaceandunderstandinginourmulti-ethnicsetting.
ThatisthemessagethatCentreforIndependentJournalism(CIJ)isconveyinginourfreedomofExpressioninMalaysia2009AnnualReview.TheReviewpresentedatrajectoryofhoweventswerere-interpretedtotensionlevel,withchallengersbeingremovedormarginalized,onceagain,throughlegalbutunlawfulmeans.
AswecriticallyrevisittheeventsdocumentedintheReview,CIJiscompelledtosoundawarningbellonthedangerofmessagesofpartisanshipbasedonethnicityandreligion.ThecurrentclimatemakesitallthemoreurgentforMalaysianstoreclaimtheirrighttofreedomofexpression,andtodemandtheirmediatoprovidesufficientandequalspacesformeaningfuldiscussion,notfomentcleavagesandsiegementality.
AswecommemoratetheWorldPressFreedomDayin2010,letusbeclearthatthefreedomtoexpressissynonymouswiththedesireforpeaceanddemocracy.
Masjaliza Hamzahon behalf of the Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ)
![Page 4: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
In2009,perceivedpoliticalcrisisandincreasingstrainbetweenvariousreligiousandethnicgroups,wereusedasexcusesforpoliticalleaderstoleavedemandsforpoliticalanddemocraticreforminabeyance.
Followingthe2008generalelection,thewinningbutbadlyshakenpartyaswellasotherethno-religiousgroupshaveusedforpoliticalmileagetheperceptionthatthespecialpositionofthe‘natives’enshrinedintheConstitutionhasbeenundermined.AnauthoritarianbrandofIslamhasalsobeenpropagatedbythestateandindividualsmorevocallysince2008.In2009,thesegroupshaveincreasedtheirvisibilitybyactivelycensuringandinvokingthethreatofviolenceagainstremarksdiscussingaffirmativeaction,themonarchyandIslam.TheircausewasaidedbytheMalaymediaownedbytheUnitedMalaysNationalOrganisation(UMNO)takinguptheirbattle-cry,fuelledbyroutinedepictionsoftheoppositionpactPakatanRakyat(Pakatan)asathreattothe‘Malayrace’.
Thus2009sawaggressiveethno-religiousexpressionbecomingthedominantthemeinthemedia,withintoleranceandcontemptcolouringdiscourse.ThiscontradictsthenewPrimeMinisterNajibRazak’svisionof“1Malaysia”,whichincludesasitsaimsafreermedia.SpeakingtojournalistsandeditorsthreedaysafterbecomingPrimeMinisterinApril2008,Najibsaidhewantedthemediato“holdthegovernmentandpublicofficialsaccountable”andto“reportwithoutfearandfavour”,butthetoughlawsgoverningthemediahaveremainedunchanged.Further,editorshavespokenaboutthegovernment’splantoreviveMediaCouncillegislationontopoftheexistinglaws,andattheendoflastyear,theywerebeingtoldtoimplementadditionalandstricterpublishingguidelines.
Therehavebeenafewwelcomegesturesfordemocraticrights.SomedetaineesbeingheldunderthedreadedInternalSecurityAct1960(ISA)werefreedandthe2008amendmentstotheUniversitiesandUniversityCollegesAct1971,weregazettedinearly2009toreverseabanonstudents’freedomofassociationandexpression.Butthesepaleincomparisontotheongoingpunitiveactionsagainstgovernmentopponentsandcritics,andfallfarshortofacceptablestandards.
Thecontinualdwellingonandincitingofissuesofethnicityandreligiondirectlyaffectstheprospectoffreedomofexpression.Ethnicandreligioustensionsarebeingusedbythestatetorationalisethemaintenanceoftherestrictivelaws.Morepositively,theselawsarealsobeingseenbysomeasthetoolsthatfacilitatetension,duetorestrictingdiscourseanddebate,andprivilegingvoicesthatareincendiary.
Whiletheprospectofmeaningfulreformfordemocraticspaceslooksdismal,thiscomeswithapoliticalcosttothegovernment–ofalienatingprogressivevoiceswithinMalaysiaandjeopardisingthecountry’simageabroad.TheNajibadministrationwillhavetoevaluatetheserisks,forboththeshortandthelongterms,inatworstusing,andatleasttolerating,thismovetowardsgreaterauthoritarianisminthenameofreligiousintoleranceandracial‘unity’.
Malaysia’s Media Landscape: Race, religion stoking policy
5
![Page 5: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
ThecountrywasrockedatthebeginningoftheyearwithacrisisinthestateofPerak.Thecrisisrevealedthatthegovernment
isbentonsecuringpoliticalinterestsandgettingaheadofitspoliticalrival,thePakatanoppositionalliance,regardlessofthecosttogoodgovernanceanddemocracy.
PerakwaswonbyPRinthe2008elections.However,inFebruary2009,electedmembersofPakatandefectedtobecome‘BarisanNasional(BN)-friendlyindependents’.Intheresultingpoliticalvacuum,theSultanofPerakAzlanShahactedbyappointinglawmakersfromtheBNandsackingtheexistingstategovernmentbeforeavoteofno-confidencecouldbeheldinthelegislature.Thiswasbothunpopularandlegallycontroversial.
Attheswearing-inofPerak’snewMenteriBesarinFebruary,policefiredteargasonanestimated3,000to5,000protesters,arrestingnine.Days
later,authorities,invokingthePrintingPressesandPublicationsAct1984,confiscatedthousandsofcopiesoftwooppositionnewspapers–SuaraKeadilan,byPartiKeadilanRakyat(PKR,orthePeople’sJusticeParty),andHarakah,publishedbytheIslamicpartyPAS.WebelievethisisbecauseoftheircoverageofthePerakcrisis.Thefollowingmonth,thetwonewspaperswereorderedtoshutdownforthreemonthsbythegovernment.Thiswasnotonlyshortlyafterthiscrisis,butimmediatelypriortothenewPrimeMinisterbeingsworninandthethreecrucialby-electionsinKedah,PerakandSarawak.Thebanwasliftedon3April,onNajib’sfirstdayinoffice.
However,thechairpersonoftheDemocraticActionParty(DAP)andMPforBukitGelugorKarpalSingh,waschargedundertheSeditionAct1948forquestioningthelegalityoftheSultan’sactions.Iffoundguilty,KarpalfacesuptothreeyearsinprisonorafineofuptoRM5,000(US$1,400)orboth.
Crisis in Perak
A protest by Pakatan supporters in February to demand for the dissolution of the Perak state assembly to pave way for fresh elections, after three lawmakers left the Pakatan government.
6
![Page 6: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
ActionswerealsotakenagainstmembersofthepublicinPerakwhovoiceddismayoverthecrisis.PolicearrestedsixonlinecommentatorsforcriticisingtheSultanofPerak’sroleinthepowerstruggle.TheywerechargedunderSection233(1)oftheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct1998,andSection34ofthePenalCodefor“insulting”thePerakroyaltyinvariousblogs.ThebroadlywordedSection233(1)penalisesthe“improperuseoffacilitiesornetworkservice,etc.”andprovidesforajailtermofoneyearandafineofuptoRM50,000(approximatelyUS$13,500).Twobloggers,JedYoongandAhiruddinAttan,arealsobeinginvestigatedbythepoliceforcontentandcommentsontheirblogsaboutthecrisis.
InMay,whentheassemblyinPerakresumed,policeagainimplementedacrackdown.Inthespanofthreeweeks,policearrestedatotalof146people,includingoppositionlawmakers,writers,activistsandlawyers,stirringpublicconcernthatthiswouldbeareenactmentofthe1987OperasiLallangcrackdown.However,mostofthosearrestedwereeitherreleasedthesamedayorremandedforuptofourdays.
Writer,academicandchairpersonoftheWriters’AllianceforMediaIndependence(WAMI)WongChinHuatwasremandedforfourdayssimplybecausehetriedtorallypeopletowearblackontheassemblyday,tomournthedeathofdemocracyinPerak.PoliticalcolumnistforleadingonlinenewsserviceMalaysiakiniJoshHongandtheeditorofSuaraKeadilanLawTeckHaowereamongthosearrestedwhileattending
acandlelightvigilforWonginfrontofapolicestationinKualaLumpur.PASvicepresidentMatSabuwasarrestedbecausehecalledforagatheringatamosqueinPerakonthefirstdaythattheassemblywastomeetfollowingthecrisis.PolicealsoraidedtheDAPofficeontwoseparateoccasions,seizingelectronicequipment,publicationsandDVDsaboutthecrisis.
Nationally,thePerakcrisiswasframedbysomeofthemainstreammediaasamatteroftreasonagainstthemonarchyand–stretchingthelimitsofcredulity–asbeingethnicallymotivated,withthepossibilityofleadingtointer-ethnicclashes.ThoughtheformerMenteriBesarNizarJamaluddinisaMalayMuslim,hewasaccusedofrunningapuppetgovernmentfortheChinese-majorityDAPandofcommittingtreasonagainsttheSultanbyrefusingtoresignortoacceptthelegalityoftheSultan’sactions.SomeofthosewhowerechargedforcriticisingtheSultanonlinewere,followingtheirarrests,depictedasremorseful,implyingthatthemonarchyissacrosanct.Karpal,aswellasbeinginvestigated,wasalsotargetedatpublicralliesstagedbyUMNO,andaccusedofbeingsacrilegious.
Themainstreammediaalsospunthelegallydubioustake-overasbeing“tit-for-tat”againstPakatanforitsfailedattempttotakeovertheFederalgovernmentthroughthedefectionofBNparliamentariansin2008.Insuchspins,thepublichasbeentoldbythecontrolledpressthatthePerakcrisisisaparty-politicalone,notacrisisofdemocracyinwhichtheyarethetruestakeholders.
Then PKR information chief Tian Chua (right) and Suara Keadilan editor, Zunar (left) reveal that the party organ was confiscated by the authority. Pic courtesy of Malaysiakini
Attempt by activists lead by PKR Supreme Council member, Badrul Hisham Shaharin (left) to deliver a cake to the PM on the late Altantuya’s birthday, is met with police arrest, on the same day as the arrest of PAS vice president, Mat Sabu. Pic courtesy of Amin Iskandar.
7
![Page 7: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
ThePerakcrisisisjustoneofseveralissuesthatdroveMalaysianstothestreets.Someoftheotherswere
ethnocentricintheircause,forwhichthepolicetookdelayed(ifany)actionagainstorganisersandparticipants,whileforassembliesthatweremoreethnicallydiversebutanti-BNintone,protestersweremetwithimmediaterepression.
Asmentionedintheprevioussection,thestatementbyKarpalpromptedUMNOtoorganiseapublicrallyagainsthim.Notonlyweretherenoarrestsamongthe200-strongcrowd,policealsobelatedlydeclaredthatithadnopermit.Whileapplaudingthelackofpoliceactioninthisinstance,CIJcallsfortheneedtoensurethatsimilarfreedomsareenjoyedbyall,notjustbythoseconnectedtothegovernment,orthoseopposingPakatan.
Incontrast,duringtheanti-ISArallyinearlyAugust2009attendedby5,000or15,000(dependingonwhichsource),policeusedteargas,watercannonsandroadblocks,andarrestedcloseto600people.Theanti-ISArallyalmosthadtofaceapro-ISArallyorganisedonthesamedaybyvariousNGOsundertheumbrellagroupPewaris.Attheeleventhhour–apparentlyafterrealisingtherewouldbeameagreturnout–Pewariscancelledtherallyanddecidedinsteadtohavearepresentativesubmitamemorandumtothepalace.Whiletheslewofarrestsandclampdownoperationsagainsttheanti-ISAprotesterswerehappening,thePewarisrepresentativewasallowedbypolicetosubmithismemorandum.
Oneoftheyear’smostnotoriousincidents,the‘cow-headprotest’exposesevenmoreglaringlypoliceinconsistencyincontrollingtherighttoassembly.TheprotestwassparkedwhenaHindutemplewastoberelocatedtoaMuslimpopulatedareainShahAlam,Selangor,amovelinkedtothePakatanstategovernment.On28August,someMuslimresidentsheldaprotest
rally,thehighlightofwhichwasthedisplayofarecently-decapitatedcow’shead,whichwaslaterkickedbysomeprotesters.Therewerenoarrestsatthetime,andtheHomeMinisterlatercameoutwithastatementsupportingtherally,causingpublicoutcry.On9September,thegovernmentchargedsixoftheprotestersundertheSeditionAct1948.
Therewasalsopublicoutcryasaresultofthegovernment’sharassmentofnewssiteMalaysiakini,whenvideosofthe‘cow-head’protestandtheMinister’spressconference,includinghisdefenseofthatprotest,werepostedonline.TheMalaysianCommunicationsandMultimediaCommission(MCMC)deemedthesevideosoffensiveandaskedMalaysiakinitotakethemdown,invokingtheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct1998.Malaysiakinirefused,andtheMCMCsentofficerstoquestionitsEditor-in-ChiefStevenGanandCEOPremeshChandran.
Policealsoarrested14BurmesenationalsfortakingpartinagatheringorganisedbytheSelangorstategovernmenttocelebratethe64thbirthdayofBurmeseactivistAungSanSuuKyiinJune.
OntheanniversarydayoftheformationofMalaysia,15indigenouspeoplefromtribesofPenan,Kayan,KenyahandIbanwerearrrestedinKuchingforsubmittingamemorandumofprotestagainsttheconstructionoftwodamsthatwillbeaffectingthepeopleintheareaofBaramandMurum.
Theinconsistencyofenforcementshowsthatfreedomofassemblyremainsabarelytoleratedright.AsthepoliceforceisnotobligedtobeaccountabletothepublicandisanswerableonlytotheHomeMinistry,thepublichavenotbeengivenanyexplanationfortheinconsistency.Asaconstitutionallyenshrinedright,freedomofassemblyshouldneverbesubjecttotheinterestsofthegovernmentorothergroups,butupheldforallequallyandimpartially.
Police partiality and freedom of assembly
8
![Page 8: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Police cracks down on the anti-ISA mass rally using water cannon (left) and tear gas (below). Picture courtesy of Merdeka Review.
The act of stamping on a cowhead by protesters who are against the relocation of a Hindu temple to a mostly Malay populated area, ignites public outcry and give the protest the name “cowhead”. Picture courtesy of The Malaysian Insider.
9
![Page 9: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Theroleofthemediaintheseeventswas,sadly,notthatofaneutralbystander.Someissuesweredeliberatelygiven
anethnicspinbysomemedia.Since2008,UMNO-owneddailyUtusanMalaysiahasbeenchampioning“Malayunity”,athinlydisguisedcallfor‘Malays’tobepoliticallyunitedunderUMNO.ApoliticalunityamongMalaysisarguedtobefundamentaltotheethnicgroup’scollectivesurvivalvis-a-visothercommunities,aswellastothecountry’ssecurity.Theideafollowsfromtheconceptof“KetuananMelayu”commonlyinterpretedasperpetualprivilegesforthe‘native’majorityethnicgroup.WithUMNO’selectoralsetbackandPakatan’sgain,PakatanpartnersPKRandPAShavebeenoftenportrayed–throughstatementsfromUMNOofficialsaswellastheMalay-basedgroupsmentionedearlier–asathreattothatunity,whileDAPwasrepresentedasathreatfromthesupposedlyeconomicallypowerful‘ethnicChinese’.
Theanti-ISAmassrallyinAugust,forexample,waspaintedbyUtusanasabetrayalbythoseMalayswhowereorganisingtherally(alongsideothers),aswellastheminority’sthreattothedominantrace.
EarlierinJuly,callstoinvestigatethesuspiciousdeathofoppositionpoliticalaideTeohBengHockwhilebeingheldovernightforquestioningattheMalaysianAnti-CorruptionCommission’s(MACC)officesweregivenanethnictwist–aboutthe‘Chinese’attemptingtounderminethe‘Malay’staffattheMACC.Itwas,apparently,irrelevantthatcallsforanimpartialinvestigationwerebeingmadefromabroadcross-sectionofMalaysiansociety.TheresponseofPakatan,however,wasalso
wanting.ThecoalitionbannedUtusanMalaysiaandtheBN-ownedNewStraitsTimesfromtheirevents.Theirreactionraisedthequestionofhowpressfreedomcanbepractisedwhenethicalstandardsarenotbeingupheld.PakatanstategovernmentsinSelangorandPenanghavesetuptheironlineandprintorgans,butmaintainedabanonthesetwodailiesandtheirreporters.
TheracialisationofreportingisnotlimitedtodemonisingtheFederal-levelopposition.Theunderlyingconceptof“KetuananMelayu”entailstheviewingofthe‘non-native’withsuspicion,thusthenewspapersdwellontheimmigrantoriginoftheOther.ThissuspicionofotherethnicgroupswasalsotheunderlyingissueinadvertentlyhighlightedbythemagazineAl-Islam,whichispublishedbytheUtusangroup.Themagazinesentareportertogoundercoveratachurchmassinorderto“expose”theallegedconversionofMuslims.Thereporterfoundoutthattheallegationwasnottrue,buthismethodofinvestigation–takingpartintheholycommunionunderdisguiseasaChristian,thenspittingouttheholywaferforphoto-taking–raisedprotests,particularlybyCatholics,onthereporter’lackofreligioussensitivity.
CriticsofthemagazinehavepointedoutthatthegovernmentwouldhaveunleashedthefullpowerofthelawifithadbeenanactthatviolatedthesanctityofIslam.CIJ,however,recognisesandemphasisesthattheonlywaytoencouragetoleranceisbyallowingallmediatooperateonanequalandfreefooting,andtorevokeallrepressivemedialaws.TheAl-Islamcasemerelydemonstratesthearbitrarynatureofthelawsandtheirenforcement.
Racialisation of issues vs ethical reporting
10
![Page 10: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
From left to right: Lawyer Annou Xavier, Sundhagaran Stanley and Joachim Francis Xavier, from the Diocesan Migrant Ministry at the Dang Wangi Police station to follow up on a report they lodged against Al-Islam magazine (right) for publishing an article by a reporter deemed to have desecrated the Church. Pic courtesy of Sundhagaran Stanley.
11
![Page 11: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Threats against online media and bloggers
12Reporters Without Borders (RSF) campaign logo on cyber censorship
![Page 12: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
AsearlyintheyearasMarch,duringtheannualUMNOgeneralassembly,onlinemediaMalaysiakini,TheMalaysian
Insider,Siasah,MerdekaReviewandTheNutGraphwerebarredfromtheevent,supposedlyoverquestionsofethics.
Lessthanamonthlater,aphotographerandareporterfromMerdekaReviewwerebarredfromcoveringthePrimeMinister’sannouncementofhisCabinetlineup.TheChineseportalhadbeenpublishingcommentariescriticisingpro-Najibarticlesfromotherpublications.
InAugust,thegovernmentplantofurthercontroltheInternetthroughtheuseoffilterswasexposedbytheonlineandforeignmedia,triggeringapublicoutcry.AccordingtonewssiteTheMalaysianInsider,acallfortenderhadbeenissuedtocompaniestosubmitproposalstoassistthecommunicationsregulatorMCMCevaluatethefeasibilityofanInternetfilter.TheMinistryofInformation,CommunicationsandCultureexpectedthestudytobecompletedbyDecemberandadecisiontobemadebytheNationalSecurityCouncilheadedbythePrimeMinister.
Respondingtopublicopposition,InformationMinisterRaisYatimconfirmedthereportsbutdefendedthefilterasnecessaryforcurbingpornography.Nevertheless,justtwodayslater,thePrimeMinisterscrappedtheplan,reiteratingthepromiseofnoInternetcensorshipasoutlinedintheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct1998.
RaishassignaledthatheagreedwithconservativeswantinggreatercontroloftheInternet.HavingtheMCMCunderhisministry’spurview,hemadeitknownthattheMinistrywasactivelymonitoringandinvestigatingwebsites.ThePrimeMinisterhimself,inananswertoparliamentarians’questionsinJune,saidthatcivilservantswerebarredfromvisiting39sitesdeemedseditious,offensiveorobscene,addingthatseveralofthesiteswereunderinvestigation.
InNovember,bloggerBernardKhoowasquestionedbythepoliceoverthepostingofamodifiedimageofthepoliceemblem.Nochargewasfiledagainsthim.
Althoughitmayappearthattheonlinecontentisnotbeingsubjecttoregulationsasrigorousandaseffectiveastheirprintcounterpart,twocasesdemonstratethattheMalaysiangovernmentdoesnotlackanylegalmeanstoprosecuteonlinewriters.Thefirst,mentionedearlier,istheprosecutionagainstcommentatorsofthePerakcrisisunderSection233(1)oftheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct1998,whichisfoundtobesimilartotheSeditionActintermsofscopeandwording.
ThesecondcaseisacriminaldefamationsuitagainstprominentbloggerRajaPetraKamarudin.Hewaschargedin2008foranarticleandastatutorydeclarationcontainingallegationsagainstthePrimeMinister’swifeRosmahMansorandwasscheduledtogoontrialin2009.However,RajaPetrahasgoneintohiding,claimingthathewastippedoffthathewouldbearrestedundertheISAforthethirdtime.Criticshavequestionedwhycriminaldefamationwasused,insteadofcivildefamation,asRosmahisnotagovernmentofficial.
TwoarrestwarrantshavebeenissuedagainstRajaPetraafterhefailedtoturnupincourton23Apriland23May.Asthepolicewereunabletoservethewarrantofarrestonhim,theSessionsCourtgrantedhimadischargenotamountingtoanacquittalon11November–forhisseditioncase-andanotherdischargetwodayslater-forhiscriminaldefamationcase,butthepoliceefforttotrackhimdownisongoing.
Whilehecontinuestorunhiswebsiteinhiding,thegovernmentshouldmakegooditspromiseofnoInternetcensorshipbydroppingthecaseagainsthim.
13
![Page 13: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Muslims in Kampung Baru, Kuala Lumpur protest against the High Court ruling on 31 December allowing Christians to use the word “Allah” for denoting God. Pic courtesy of The Malaysian Insider.
CriticismoftheMalaysiangovernmenthaslongbeenill-tolerated.TheMalaysianpublicmightoccasionally
findinthemainstreammediacriticismofthecivilservice,butnotdirectcriticismofthePrimeMinisteroftheday.Thisremainsunchangedunderthecurrentadministration.Havingassumedofficeatatimeofglobaleconomictrouble,weakenedsupportforUMNOand,morepersonally,whilebeinglinkedtothetrialofhisaideAbdulRazakBagindaformurder,Najibforwentthespellofopennessthathadmarkedthebeginningofhistwoimmediatepredecessors’ascenttopower.
ShortlyafterNajibassumedoffice,threeby-elections–seenastestsofhislegitimacy–wereheldsimultaneouslyinthestatesofPerak,KedahandSarawak.TherewasalsoatestforthenewPrimeMinister’sopenness,inwhichhedidnotfarewell.First,thepoliceissuedabanagainstanymentionofthecaseofamurderedMongolianwomanAltantuyaShaariibuuincampaignspeeches,asPakatanandbyvariousbloggershadconnectedthePrimeMinister
Intolerance of diversitytothecase.Thebanextendedtothemediaaswell.Malaysiakinireportedthattelevisionstationswereorderednottonameoneoftheaccused–thePrimeMinister’saideAbdulRazak–andtoignorehisbackgroundwhenreportingthejudgmentofthemurdertrialinApril.(AbdulRazakwaseventuallyacquitted.)
SuaraKeadilan,thePKRorgan,continuedtobeconfiscatedoritsdistributorsharassedalthoughNajibhadliftedthebanonthepaperwhenhebecamePrimeMinister.
InJuly,aTVhostwasdemotedtofieldreporterstatusaftersheaskedhergueststorateNajib’sperformanceontheoccasionofhis100thdayinoffice.
On25August,officialsfromthePublicationControlUnitoftheHomeMinistryseizedcopiesoftheinauguralissuesofcartoonmagazineGedungKartunfromthepublisher’sofficeinKualaLumpur.Accordingtoitseditor-in-chiefZulkifleeAnwarHaque,betterknownasZunar,morethan400copieswereseized.Authorities
14
![Page 14: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
claimedZunarhadnotsecuredapermitforthepublication,asmandatedbythePrintingPressesandPublicationsAct1984.Observerssaid,however,thatZunar’spoliticalcartoonscriticisingthePrimeMinisterandhispoliciesweretherealreasonfortheconfiscation.
TheHomeMinistryconfiscatedMalaysianMaverick:MahathirMohamadinTurbulentTimeson24December,asthebookswerebroughtintothecountrythroughaPortKlangcheckpoint,puttingagagonthecirculationofthebook.AuthoredbyAsianWallStreetJournalformereditorBarryWain,thebookcontends,amongotherthings,thatthefourthPrimeMinisterwasresponsibleforalossofRM100billion(US$28.6billion)duringhisterminoffice.BesidesreiningincriticalviewsaboutMalaysia’sPrimeMinisters,bothFederalandstateinstitutionshavebeenactivelycontrollingthediscoursesonIslam.ThepreachingofIslamotherthaninthecountry’sofficiallysanctionedSunnahWalJamaahideologyisdisallowed.
AnexampleoftheextentofthiscontrolisthatthestateIslamiccouncilpreparestheFridaysermonstobepreachedbythemosqueimamthroughouteachstate.ThepoweroftheseinstitutionswasbroughttotheforebythearrestofMuslimscholarMohdAsriZainulAbidininNovember.AformermuftiinPerlisandknownforhisoutspokenness,AsriwasarrestedbytheSelangorreligiousauthorityforpreachingunauthorisedsermonsandwasaccusedofspreading“Wahabbism”.DespitethearrestdrawingcriticismfromtheoppositionparliamentariansandthePrimeMinister,chargeswerefiledagainstAsri.Inthesamemonth,thesamereligiousauthorityalsobarredPASparliamentarianKhalidAbdulSamadfrompreaching.ThereasongivenwasthatKhalid’ssermonsweretoo“political”.
Women’sgroupSistersinIslam(SIS)alsoraisedtheireofboththerulingandoppositionpartiesforopposingthecaningofMuslimwomen.InJuly,theShari’ahcourtinPahangsentencedawoman,KartikaSariDewiShukarno,tothemaximumsentenceofsixstrokesofthecaneandafineofRM5,000(US$1,430)fordrinkingbeerinpublicin2007.Followingajoint
statementbySISandotherwomen’sgroups,andSIS’sdecisionforlegalintervention,theUMNOwomen’swinginJohorand14otherMuslimgroupscalledonthegovernmenttocanceltheNGO’sregistration.TheMuslimgroupsalsolodgedpolicereportsagainstSIS.
Meanwhile,PASYouthaskedforapublicboycottofSISfor“beinginsolent”.EarlierinJune,duringthePASgeneralassemblyormuktamar,aresolutionwaspassedcallingforSIStobebanned.However,thepartysoonclaimedthattheresolutionwasamistake,afterrunningintodisagreementwithotherPakatanpartnersanddrawingcriticismfromthepublic,especiallygiventhattheresolutionwassponsoredbythebranchheadedbyapoliticianpreviouslyknownforhiscomparativelyprogressivestand.
Acrucialincidenthighlightingtheimpactofsuchintolerancetodiversereligiousdiscoursehasbeentheso-called“Allah”controversy.ThegovernmenthasinMarchrescindeditsFebruarypermissionfortheCatholicweekly,TheHeraldtouseoffourArabicwords–“Allah”,“Kaabah”,“Baitullah”and“solat”–bynon-Muslims.TheCatholicChurchrevealedthattheHomeMinistryseizedthousandsofcopiesoftranslatedBibleswhichusetheword“Allah”fromthecustomscheckpointsinMarchandSeptember,whileapetitionforjudicialreviewfiledbythechurcheswasongoing.
InMarch,religiousauthoritiesinSelangorthreatenedtheBarCouncilwithlegalactionforholdinganonlinepollontheissueoftheusageoftheword“Allah”bynon-Muslims.ThecourteventuallyruledinfavoroftheCatholicChurchinDecember,but,followinganappealfromthegovernmentaswellasprotestsfromseveralMuslimgroups,astayorderwasissued,meaningthatthebanwastoremaininplace.TheMuslimgroupsproceededtoorganisedemonstrationsinvariouspartsofthecapitalcityairingtheirdemandfor“Allah”tobemadeexclusiveforMuslims.Althoughthepolicedeemedthedemonstrationsillegal,noarrestsweremade.Astheworldenteredinto2010,severalChristianchurcheswereattackedwithfirebombs,believedtobeconnectedtothisissue.
15
![Page 15: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Giventhegovernment’spoliticalcontroloverthemedia,itishardnottospeculateontheirroleintheprominenceofethno-religiousdiscourse,andintheresultingtension.Malaysians
havelimitedandunequalaccesstoalternativeviews,discourseandinformation,whichareavailablelargelyonlineandpredominantlyinEnglish.Suchlimitedcirculationofalternativeviewscannoteffectivelychallengetheethno-religiousdogmabeingcirculatedthroughthemainstreammedia.
Formanyyears,thepolicyofcontrollinginformationandexpressionhasbeenjustifiedexplicitlyonsecurityreason,orimplicitlyasnecessarytothesocialengineeringprojectharboureduponthehopeofnation-building:unityandprosperity.ItistimeforMalaysianstorealisethatbothreasonshaveexpired,iftheywereeverlegitimate.Rather,theinconsistentemploymentoftherepressivelawsishavingadangerousimpactontheunity,economyandsecurityofMalaysians.
Despiteprogressiverhetoric,thegovernmenthasbeentakinghalf-measurestoimprovetransparencyandthusboostthecountry’scompetitiveness.Thisisnotgoodenough,andthetensionsandviolencethatwehaveseeneruptingareadirectresultofrepressivelegislations.Through2009andinto2010,CIJcontinuestocontendthatthePrintingPressesandPublicationsAct1984,SeditionAct1948,OfficialSecretsAct1972andSection233(1)oftheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct1998formamajorimpedimenttotransparencyandgoodgovernance.Theselawsmustberepealedforanytruereformtomaterialise.
Conclusion
16
![Page 16: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
17
![Page 17: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Arrest of Demonstrators and Assemblymen6 FebTeargaswasfiredat3000-5000demonstratorswhohadgatheredtoprotesttheswearing-inofthenewChiefMinisterfromBarisanNasional.Ninewerearrested.
4 MayPolicewarnedsupportersofBNandPakatannottogatherneartheStateSecretariatbuildingwhentheStateAssemblymeetingconvened.CivilsocietyactivistWongChinHuat,alsoaspokesmanforBersih,wasdetainedbypoliceforallegedsedition.Hisarrestwaslinkedtoapressconferencehehadcalledadaybefore,whereheurgedthepublictowearblackthefollowingdaytoprotestthechangeinadministrationinPerak.
6 MayWong’sremandorderwasextendedtwomoredays.PASvice-presidentMohamadSabuwasdetainedbypolice.PolicealsoarrestedthreeotherswhoattemptedtopresentacakeandlettertothePrimeMinisteronthebirthdayofthemurderedMongolian,AltantuyaShaaribuu.
7 MayThedayoftheStateAssemblysitting
Accordingtomedia,policearrestedsixty-fiveatthePerakstateassembly,includingPakatanleaders,parliamentariansandactivists.Anypersonwearingblackwasimmediatelydetained.Laterthatnight,policearrestedthirtytwoprotesterswhogatheredforcandlelightvigilsinprotestofWong’sarrestandtheeventsinPerak.TheprotesterswerearrestedinKualaLumpur,PenangandSarawak.Amongthosearrestedwerefivelawyerswhowerethereascounselforthosewhohadbeendetainedearlier.HomeMinisterDatukSeriHishammuddinTunHusseinpraisedthepolicecrackdown.
9 MayPoliceonSaturdaystoppedaDAPdinnerataschoolandseizedaudiovisualequipmentthatwasbeingusedtoplayavideoaboutthePerakassemblysitting.Thetechnicianhandlingtheequipmentwasalsodetained.
19 MayDAPparliamentariansTeoNieChingandJeniceLeewereamong11peoplearrestedinacandlelightvigilcallingforfreshelectionsinPerak.
21 May ThethirdprotesttobythePakatansaw17peopleincludingJeniceLeebeingdetainedbypoliceinAmpang.JeniceLeewasremandedfortwodays.
23 MayPoliceraidedtheDAPheadquartersinSelangorandconfiscatedcomputersandflyersaboutthePerakpoliticalcrisis.
26 MayPolicearrested21peopleincludingeightelectedrepresentativesfortakingpartinahungerstrikecallingforfreshelection,beingheldattheDAPheadquarters.AmongthosearrestedwereassemblymenChangLihKang(Teja),ChanMingKai(SimpangPulai),ThomasSu(PasirPinji),LimPekHar(Menglembu),LeongMeeMeng(Jalong),KeshvinderSingh(MalimNawar),formerSpeakerV.Sivakumar,IpohBaratMemberofParliamentM.Kulasegaranandsixsupporters.
Karpal Singh tried for sedition11 FebDAPChairman,KarpalSinghgaveastatementtothepoliceregardingpolicereportsmadeagainsthimbecausehesaidinapressconferencethattheSultancanbesuedforhisdecisiontoremoveNizarJamaluddinasPerakChiefMinister.Accordingtothepolice,89policereportswerelodgedagainstKarpal,includingfromUMNOmembers.Onthesameday,SelangorUmnoYouthchiefAbdulShukurIdrusled600peoplefromUmnoYouth,PuteriUmnoandotherNGOsinaprotestmarchfromthestateUmnobuildingtotheShahAlampolicestationtolodgeareportSingh.
16 MarchSinghischargedwithsedition.
29 April TheHighCourtrejectedSingh’sapplicationtogethimselfdischargedfrom
Timeline of Events
Chronology of the crisis in Perak
18
![Page 18: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
hisseditioncase.TheCourtheldthathisspeechinthepressconferencecanbetakenintotalityasthebasisforthechargewithouthavingtospecifythewordsorpartsthatareseditious.
12 AugustAnUtusanjournalist,thefirstprosecutionwitness,toldtheHighCourtthathewroteanarticleforhisnewspaperbasedonapartialunderstandingofthepressstatementandmistakenthemeaningofthewords“ultravires”inthestatementtomean“toinsult”.
9 DecemberAnotherprosecutionwitness,anRTMdeputynewsdirector,saidthetelevisionstationhadlabeledSinghashavingcommittedtreasoninthestation’sreportingofthepressconference.
14 DecemberAprosecutionwitnessfromastudentNGO,GabunganPelajarMelayuSemenanjungPerak,saidhelodgedapolicereportbecausehewasnot‘satisfied’thatSinghhadquestionedthelegalityoftheBNstategovernmentinPerak.
Media control12 Feb10000to20000copiesofpoliticalpartyorgansSuaraKeadilanandHarakahwerereportedconfiscatedinvariouspartsofthecountrysinceJanuary.
23 MarchTheHomeMinistrysuspendedHarakahandSuaraKeadilanforthreemonths.ThebanwasliftedbyNajibRazakonApril3whenhesworninasPrimeMinisterbutPKRcomplainedthatgovernmentofficialscontinuedtoharassdistributorsandconfiscatethepaper.
3 MayBNPerakStateSecretaryDrAbdulRahmanHashimbarredanumberofmediaorganizations,includingonlinenewssites,fromcoveringthestateassemblysitting,duetobeginon7May.However,thePakatanassemblySpeakerV.Sivakumarliftedtheban.BNappointedChiefMinisterZambryAbdulKadirdeniedthathehadissuedtheban.
13 MayMalaysiakinireportedthatmediaconglomerate,MediaPrima,hadbannedtheairingoffootageshowingthePakatanassemblySpeakerSivakumarbeingdraggedoutofthesittingon7May.MediaPrimaownsfourfree-to-airtelevisionstationsandisaffiliatedwithUMNO.
Police action and intimidation against bloggers23 FebPoliceinvestigatedblogger,JedYoongYuiFoongforpostingatranslationofanotherblogger’spostingcriticizingthePerakSultan.
24 FebPolicequestionedbloggerAhiruddinAttan(RockyBru)overcommentsleftonhisblogabouttheroleofthemonarchybyknownandannoymouscommentators.
13 MarchInanunprecedentedmove,sixpeoplewerechargedforhaving“insulted”SultanofPerakthroughawebsite.AlabassistantwasfinedRM10000indefault5months’jailforthesameoffence.
16 MarchAhusbandandwifewerechargedintheSessionsCourtforpostingcommentsontheSultanofPerak’swebsite,disagreeingwiththeRoyals’roleinthePerakcrisis.
15 AprilAhousewifewaschargedinaSessionsCourtwithforwardingcommentsagainsttheSultanofPerak.Herhusbandwasamongthesixchargedon13March.Bothofthemlaterclaimedtohavereceiveddeaththreatsviaemail.
22 AprilGagasanMelayuPerak(GMP)lodgedapolicereportagainstMalaysiakiniforanarticleallegedlyinsultingSultanAzlanShahofPerakandtheRajaMudaofPerak,RajaNazrinShah.
21 OctoberAtotalof11peoplewerechargedunderSection211and233oftheCommunicationandMultimediaActwhichinvolveafineofuptoRM24,500,forinsultingtheSultanofPerak,revealedtheMinisterofInformation.
19
![Page 19: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Right to Assembly
7 MarchRiotpolicefiredteargasatthousandsofpeoplewhotriedtomarchtowardstheIstanaNegara(NationalPalace),toprotestagainstthepolicyofusingEnglishtoteachScienceandMathematics.124werearrested.
17 AprilSevenpeople,includingfourlawyers,wereacquittedanddischargedfortakingpartinawalktomarkWorldHumanRightsDayin2007.
19 MayBatuMPTianChuawasorderedbyamagistrate’scourttoenterhisdefenceagainstachargeofinjuringapolicemaninDecember2007,duringaBersihrally.
24 May1000supportersoftheSriLankanseparatistgroupTamilTigersassembledatSriSubramaniartempleinJalanBesar,BatuCaves,Gombak.Despitenothavingapolicepermit,itwasattendedbyDeputyMinisterM.Saravananandtwooppositionparliamentarians.Noarrestsweremade.
15 JunePolicefiredteargastodisperse700Iranians,mostlyuniversitystudents,outsideWismaUNinJalanSemantan.TheywereprotestingtheresultsoftheIranianpresidentialelections.
18 JuneFivepeoplewhowerestudentsatthetimeoftheirarrestwerefinedRM3,900orthreemonths’jailbythemagistrate’scourtforattendingananti-ISAassemblyin2001.Theyhadbeensuspendedfromtheirundergraduatestudieswhenchargedin2001.
19 JunePolicearrested14BurmesenationalsfortakingpartinagatheringorganizedbytheSelangorstategovernmenttocelebratethe64thbirthdayofactivistAungSanSuuKyi.
17 JulySevenwerearrestedattheformerMACCSelangorheadquartersatPlazaMasalamforgatheringtodemandaninvestigationintothedeathofpoliticalaide,
TeohBengHock.PakatanparliamentariansS.ManikavasagamandXavierJayakumarwereamongthosearrested,whileMPGanPeiNeiandastateassemblyaide,LooChuanBoonwereinjuredduringascufflewiththeriotpolice.
17 July ThreewerearrestedforsubmittingamemorandumofagainstthekillingsofMuslimsinsouthernThailandtotheThaiembassy.
23 JulyPolicedetained10people,includingMICYouthcoordinatorT.Mohan,whenabout50peopleweretomarchtowardsKomtartohandoveramemorandumtotheChiefMinister’sofficeonanevictionissue.
28 JulyPolicewarnedthattheywilltakesternactionagainstanypartythatparticipatesinanyassemblyinthecapitalon1August.Thewarningcameastworallieshadbeenplannedforthatday,bygroupswithopposingstandsontheISA.
1 AugustPolicearrested589people,firedteargasandwatercannonsatnumerouslocationsinthecityafterthousandsofpeopletooktothestreetscallingforarepealoftheISA.Thousandswereblockedfromreachingthevenue,asthecapitalcitywaspracticallysealedoff.Mediareportedthatthecrowdconsistedofbetween5,000and15,000protesters.
2 AugustNajibRazaksaidthegovernmentwillallowfuturemassrallyinstadiumsandurgedthepeoplenottotaketothestreets.
2 AugustPolicereleased560outof589peopledetainedthepreviousday.Thosereleasedincludeda13yearold.
3 August29peopleclaimedtrialtothechargeofillegalassembly,havingbeenarrestedduringprotestscallingfortheabolitionoftheISA.
13 AugustThePublicServicedirector-generalIsmailAdamissuedacircularwarningthatcivilservantsfoundparticipatinginillegalgatheringsor“causes”wouldbedemotedorsacked.
Timeline of Events
20
![Page 20: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19 August TheHomeMinistersaidthegovernmentistoamendthePoliceActtoallowpublicassembliesincertainlocations,withouttheneedforapolicepermit.
16 September15indigenouspeople,includingtwoindigenousrightsleaderswerearrestedforsubmittingamemorandumtotheSarawakchiefminister,TaibMahmud,protestingtheconstructionoftheMurumDam.Theywerereleasedonthesameday.
October 11AllthosechargedwithillegalassemblyattheKesasHighwayin2000,wherepoliceactionwascondemnedbytheMalaysianhumanrightscommissionasbeingexcessive,wereacquitted.Nopoliceinvestigationhastakenplaceintotheincident.
ISA and the release of Hindraf leaders
5 April13peopleincludingHindrafleadersV.Ganabatirau,andR.KengadharanwerereleasedfromtheISAdetentioncentreinKamunting,Taiping.Ganabatiraulaterclaimedhewaspreventedfromspeakingtothemediaforayearasoneoftheconditionsforhisrelease.
17 AprilInspectorGeneralPolice,MusaHassanconfirmedthearrestofthreemeninJohorundertheISA.
20 AprilMalaysiakinireportedthatthepolicehasbeenpressuringthefamilymembersofISAdetaineeAgusSalimtostopthemfromseekinghelporgettingtheirplightheard.Aguswasdetainedon5MarchallegedlyduetosuspectedlinkswithIslamicfundamentalists.
8 MayThethreeremainingHindrafleaders,P.Uthayakumar,M.ManoharanandVasanthaKumarwerereleasedfromtheKamuntingdetentioncentre,after514daysofincarcerationundertheISA.On16April,thetriohadfailedintheirhabeascorpusappeal.P.Uthayakumar
stillhasaseditioncasepending,ashefailedtogettheSessionsCourttostrikeoutthecharge.SevenforeignersdetainedundertheISAwerealsoreleased.
19 MayFormerISAdetaineeP.UthayakumarfailedtoappearbeforeanadvisorypanelmeetingattheKamuntingdetentioncampnearhere,forwhichtheHomeMinisterDatukSeriHishammuddinHusseinsaidnoactionwillbetakenagainsthim.
27 MayAllegedJImilitantMasSelamatKastariisdetainedundertheISA.
16 JuneTheHomeMinistersaidtheISAmaybeusedtocrushthe‘FederalSpecialForcesofMalaysia(FSFM)’,believedtobeafraudorganizationmodeledasacivilianarmy.
25 JuneHomeMinisterHishammuddinHusseinsaidinreplytoquestioninparliamentthattherewereonly12ISAdetaineesleftinKamunting,comprising6Malaysiansand6foreigners.Hesaidtheywereunderdetentionforeitherinvolvementinmilitantactivitiesorforforgingdocuments.
25 JuneHusseinsaidtheGovernmentislookingintoaproposaltoreducethedetentionperiodunderISAfrom60to28days.
19 OctoberThegovernmentmaintaineditsstancethatitwillnotscraptheISA.
22 October TheHomeMinistryannouncedthatthereviewofISAwillbeonfiveareas:thetreatmentaccordedtoISAdetainees:theirlivingconditions,mealsandotherbasicneeds;thedurationoftheirsentence,thatistheinitial60days’detentionforinvestigationsandthetwo-yeardetentionorder;thepowersoftheHomeMinisterininvokingtheactandtheabuseofsuchpowersheholds;theperceptionthattheISAisormaybeexploitedforpoliticalreasons;andtheprovisionsintheISAwhichallowfordetentionwithouttrial.
21
![Page 21: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Timeline of Events
22
The “Allah” issue
26 Feb HomeMinistryliftedabanontheword“Allah”,whichhadbeenrestrictedtoMuslimpublications,providednon-Muslimreligiouspublicationsusingthewordstateprominentlythatthepublicationisfornon-Muslimsonly.CatholicweeklyHeraldhadappliedforajudicialreviewofthebanin2008.TheapplicationwasdeemedacademicwhentheHerald’spublicationpermitexpiredinDec2008,sotheHeraldreappliedforajudicialreviewon16Feb.
2 MarchThegovernmentrescindeditsearlierdecisiontoliftthebanontheuseoftheword“Allah”.
5 MarchReligiousadviserinthePMdepartment,AbdullahMdZinsaid10stateswithSultanshavegazettedthebanontheusageof“Allah”,“Kaabah”,“Solat”and“Baitullah”bynonMuslims,whileafatwaonasimilarbanhadbeenissuedtotheremainingfourstates,noneofwhichhaveaSultan.
12 MarchTheSelangorIslamicReligiousCouncil(Mais)threatenedlegalactionagainsttheBarCounciloveritspollontheuseofthewordAllahbynon-Muslims.
13 MarchThesongAllahPedulibyIndonesianartistAgnesMonicahasbeenbannedinSelangor,asAllahinthelyricspertainstoJesusChrist.
5 September Catholic weekyly TheHeraldreceivedaletterfromtheHomeMinistrystatingthatithasnotapprovedthepublishingpermitfor2010,althoughinAugustithadapprovedittoprintinfouroutofthefivelanguagestheyhadrequested,excludingtheKadazanDusunlanguage.
4 November TheCouncilofChurchesrevealedthat15,000BahasaMalaysiaBibleswerepreventedfrombeingdistributedbytheHomeMinistryinMarchandinSeptemberforcontaining‘banned’terminology.TheChristianFederationofMalaysia(CFM)calledfortheimmediatereleaseof theBibles.
14 November The HomeMinisterheldameetingwith representativesoftheCatholicChurch explainingthattheAugustpermitwas validandthattheyaretoignorethe Septemberletter.
31 December The HighCourtallowedTheHeraldtouse theword“Allah”forChristians.
![Page 22: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
23
Restrictions against discourse of Islam
Call to ban SIS
7 JunePASpassedaresolutionurgingthatwomenrightsgroupSistersinIslam(SIS)bebannedandcalledfortheNationalFatwaCounciltoinvestigateSIS.Onthesameday,PAS’spartnerinPakatan,PKRissuedastatementdisagreeingwiththeresolution.
9 JuneMPTeresaKokofDAPandtheMinisterforWomen,FamilyandtheCommunityShahrizatAbdulJalilcriticizedPAS’sresolution.
10 JuneFormerPMTunDrMahathirMohamadcriticizedPASforitscalltobanSIS.
11 JunePKRMPZulkifliNoordinwantstheCompaniesCommission(CCM)tostopSISfromusingtheword“Islam”initstitle.TheCCMsaiditisunabletodoso.
14 JunePASsaiditsresolutioncallingforthebanningofwomen’sgroup,SIS,wasamistakeandthatthe‘correct’resolutioncalledforengagementwiththewomen’sgroup.
16 JuneWanitaGerakanurgedPAStowithdrawitsresolution.
2 OctoberFourteenMuslimNGOslodgedpolicereportsagainstSISforquestioningthe
caningofwomenundertheIslamiclaw.TheNGOsdemandedSIS“apologizeforhavinginsultedIslamiclawandtheShar’iahcourt”.
6 OctoberUMNOWanitaJohorcalledonthegovernmenttocanceltheregistrationofSIS,theJointActionGroupforGenderEquality(JAG)andtheWomens’AidOrganization(WAO),inthelightofthegroup’sstatementagainstthewhippingofaformermodel.
The Former Perlis mufti
2 November Whileconductingareligiousclassinaprivatehome,formerPerlismuftiDrMohdAsriZainulAbidinwasarrestedbytheSelangorReligiousAffairsDepartment(JAIS),onthegroundsofpreachingwithoutcertification.Hisarrestwasquestionedbyparliamentarians,includingthePrimeMinister,butJAISdefendeditsactions,andrevealedthatithadbeenmonitoringAsri’spreachingforthreeyears.
18 November AbidinwaschargedforpreachingwithoutcertificationattheShari’ahCourtunderSection119oftheIslamicAdministrationofSelangor.Ifconvicted,AsricanbefineduptoRM3,000andfacesimprisonmentofuptotwoyears.
25 NovemberOppositionMPKhalidAbdulSamad’sauthorizationtopreachIslamwasrevokedbyJAIS,onthegroundthathispreachingistoopolitical.
![Page 23: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Online censorship
16 JuneThePrimeMinistertoldParliamentthatcivilservantsarebannedfromvisiting39websitesandblogscontaining“offensive,obsceneorseditiouselements”.
7 July TheInformationMinister,RaisYatimrevealedthatspecialunitshavebeensetupunderboththeHomeandInformationMinistriestomonitorblogs,addingthattheregulationofbloggerscomesunderboththePrintingPressesandPublicationsActandtheCommunicationsandMultimediaAct.
8 JulyTheDeputyMinisterofScienceandTechnologyrevealedthattheMalaysianCommunicationsandMultimediaCommission(MCMC)hadshutdown33websitessaidtocontainpornographicmaterials,andthatafurther15similarwebsiteshadbeenaskedtoshutdown.
6 AugustAFP,quotingananonymoussource,reportedthatthegovernmentwasconsideringimposinganinternetfiltertoblock“undesirable”websites,onthegroundsofmaintainingracialharmony.LocalportalTheMalaysianInsiderreportedthatthegovernmenthadcalledforproposalsfromcompaniesforinternetcontentfilteringsystems.
7 AugustYatimconfirmedthataninternetfilteringsystemwouldbesetuptofilterpornography.Civilsocieties,oppositionmembersandbloggerscriedfoul.
8 August,ThePrimeMinisterrefutedtheInformationMinister’sstatementsabouttheinternetfilterandsaidthattheGovernmentwillnotimposeanycensorshipontheinternet.
4September TheMCMCorderedMalaysiakinitoremovefromitswebsitetwovideos.Thefirstvideodepictedprotestersstompingacowhead,asymboloftheHindureligion,whileagitatingagainsttherelocationofaHindu
temple.ThesecondvideowastheHomeMinister’spressconferenceindefenceoftheprotesters.
4 NovemberBloggerBernardKhooTengSwee,whowriteszorro-unmasked.blogspot.com,wasquestionedbypoliceoverapostingin2008ofaphotowhichcarriedtheemblemoftheRoyalMalaysianPolice,onwhichwassuperimposedtheimageofadog.
19 NovemberTheInformationMinistertoldtheParliamentthattheMCMChadchargedeightwebsiteoperatorsundertheCMA.SevenofthewebsitesweresaidtohaveinsultedIslam.Atotalofseventy-oneinvestigationshadbeencarriedoutbytheMCMC.
Raja Petra Kamarudin
23 April TheSessionsCourtissuedawarrantofarrestagainstPetraKamarudinandashow-causenoticetohiswife,Marina,becausetheformerfailedtoshowupathiscriminaldefamationtrial.Thebloggerclaimedonhiswebsite,MalaysiaToday,thatheisinself-exileandfearsanotherarrestundertheISA.
26 JuneSecondarrestwarrantoutforKamarudinafterhefailedtoattendhiscriminaldefamationtrialattheSessionsCourt.
11 NovemberKamaruddin’sSeditioncasewassuspendedbecausethepolicewereunabletotrackhimdown.
13 NovemberKamarudin’scriminaldefamationcasewassuspendedbecausethepolicewasunabletotrackhimdown.
On the media
16 JanTwojournalistsfromMerdekaReviewlodgedapolicereportforhavebeengivencashattheBarisanNasionalcommonmediacentreduringtheKualaTerengganuby-election.OppositionparliamentarianTeoNieChing’s
Timeline of Events
24
![Page 24: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
questiontothePrimeMinisterontheissueduringthenextday’sParliamentsittingwasrejected.Theanti-corruptioncommissionalsodecidedtodropthecaseon20Jandespiteinformingthereportersthatitwouldlaunchaninvestigation.
24 MarchSixonlinemediaorganizations-Malaysiakini,TheMalaysianInsider,Siasah,MerdekaReviewandTheNutGraph-werebarredfromcoveringproceedingsoftheUMNOgeneralassembly.ThereasongivenbytheUMNOsec-generalTengkuAdnanwasthatthemediawerenot“ethical”.
31 MarchInhisblog,thePenangChiefMinisterLimGuanEngsaidthestatehasbannedtheNewStraitsTimesfromthestate’sfunctionsuntilthepaperprovidestheadministrationwiththerightofreply.Limsaidthatthepaperhascarriedinaccuratereportsabouthisadministration.
18 AprilMalaysiakinireportedthatMediaPrimaBerhad–theownerofthefourTVstationsTV3,ntv7,8TVandtv9-hadorderedthestationsnottonamepoliticalanalystanddefendantAbdulRazakBagindawhenreportingthejudgementoftheAltantuyaShaariibuumurdercase.
8 MayMCAPresidentOngTeeKeatlodgedapolicereportagainstChineselanguagemagazineHaoWai(SpecialWeekly)fordefamationunderthePrintingPressesandPublicationActandcriminaldefamation.Themagazineeditorandtwostaffwerequestionedbypolice.
3 JuneTheMICurgedtheGovernmenttotakeactionagainstcolumnist“AwangSelamat”forreferringtotheChineseandIndiansMalaysiansinMalaysiaasimmigrants.
5 JuneAreporterfromUtusanMalaysia,HasnurulMohamdwasbarredfromcoveringtheswearinginoftheSeberangPeraiMunicipalCouncilPresidentinPenang.
24 JuneHomeMinisterHishammuddinHusseinsaidthegovernmenthasnoplantoabolishthePrintingPressesandPublicationsActortheISA.
13 JulyPolicehavestartedinvestigatingapolicereportonanarticlepublishedbymagazineAl-Islam.Thearticle,writtenbyaMuslimreporterwhowentundercovertoparticipateinachurchmasswasdeemedoffensivetoChristians.
15 JulyAjournalistwithprivatetelevisionchannelntv7,FlorenceLooi,wasissuedamemoandhertalkshowprogramshelvedaftersheaskedherpanelgueststoratetheperformanceofthePrimeMinisterinhisfirst100days.
25 AugustThenewspapervendorsassociationandMICmemberslodgedapolicereportagainsttheMalayMailforpublishinganarticlediscussingtheparty’sinternalpolitics,picturesofMICleaderslabelledasbelongingtolowercastes.TheMalayMailrespondedwithaclarificationandtookdownthepicturesfromitswebedition.
25 NovemberAreporterfromUtusanMalaysia,YazidAliazwasaskedtoleaveapressconferenceorganizedbyPakatanRakyatinSelangor.
14 DecemberViceChairmanofDAPM.Kulasegaranmadeapolicereportagainst“AwangSelamat”forsuggestingthattheDAPwouldabolishthemonarchyifitcametopower.
17 DecemberMalaysiakinireportedthatameetingwascalledbytheHomeMinistrywithnewspapereditorstodiscusstheadoptionofanewsetofpublishingguidelines.Theelaboratebutambiguouslywordedguidelineswereframedas“self-regulation”.Amongothers,theywerenottogivedetaileddescriptionsofcriminaloffencessuchasrape,murder,robbery;nothingaboutcohabitation,adultery,homosexuality,counter-culture;andnographicsofhumangenitaliaandG-strings.
25
![Page 25: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Restriction of campaigning at by-elections
6 JanuaryPolicearrestedsixPKRmembersforputtinguppostersofthemurderedMongolian,AltantuyaShaariibuu,atKualaTerengganu,duringaby-electioncampaigningperiod.
23 MarchThirty-onewerearrestedataPKRceramahinSungaiPetani.Thecrowd,reportedtobearound1,000strong,hadassembledtolistentoAnwarIbrahim’scampaignspeechfortheBukitSelambauby-election.Theyweremetwithteargasandwatercannonfromthepolice.
27 MarchPolicebannedallpoliticalpartiesfromgivingtalksinopenareasthroughouttheBukitSelambauby-election.Electionwatchdog‘MalaysiansforFreeandFairElections’(Mafrel)saidtherewasheavy,unjustifiedpolicepresenceduringthreeby-electionsinBukitGantang,BukitSelambauandBatangAi.
31 MarchTopicssuchastheShaariibuumurderandthePerakpoliticalcrisis,aswellasraceandreligion,werebannedfromcampaignspeechesinthetripleby-electionsofBukitGantang,BukitSelambauandBatangAi.Thetopicrestrictionsweremadespecificasconditionsofobtainingapolicepermitforpublicspeeches.
30 MayThepolicesaidtheyareinvestigatingthreePakatanleadersincludingDAPadviserLimKitSiang,inrelationtheirpublicspeechesduringthePenantiby-election.
Others
9 MarchTwostudents,ChooKokWeiandMedecciLineilRepongfromUniversitiUtaraMalaysiainSintok,Kedah,werechargedbytheuniversitywithbreachingtheUniversitiesandUniversityCollegesAct(UUCA).Theyhadissuedstatementstothemediacondemninganincreaseinbusfaresandstartedanonlinepetition.Thestudentsandotherspresentedamemorandumtotheofficeofthevicechancellorforstudentaffairs,AhmadFaizHamid,onJan19.
21 JulyTheHomeMinistryissuedaprohibitionorderon13publicationswith“immoralcontent”anddeemedunsuitableforthereadingpublic.
8 AugustTheHomeMinistrybanned22booksinthesevenmonthstoJulythisyearsaidthePublicationsControlDivisionandAl-QuranTextDivisionprincipalassistantsecretaryAbdulRazakAbdulLatif
9 SeptemberSixmenwerechargedwithseditionintheSessionsCourtfortheirinvolvementinthe“cowhead”protest.
14 SeptemberAprotestwasheldagainsttheMalaysianCommunicationandMultimediaCommission(MCMC)’sinvestigationofonlinenewswebsiteMalaysiakini,whichhadbeenaccusedoffanningracialtension.
28 SeptemberBrunowasbannedbytheNationalFilmCensorshipBoard
13 October 8studentsfromUniversityMalayawerechargedundertheUUCAforinvitinganoppositionpolitician,ExcoofSelangorstateTeresaKoktobepartoftheirpaneljudgesforanon-campusdebatecompetition,despiteamendmentstothelawwhichallowsstudentsinteractionwithpoliticiansonacademicoccasion.24 DecCopiesofMalaysianMaverick:MahathirMohamadinTurbulentTimeswereconfiscatedfromthePortKlangcheckpointfor“contentstudy”bytheHomeMinistry.
Timeline of Events
26
![Page 26: Malaysia: Freedom of Expression in 2009- Annual Review by Centre for Independent Journalism](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022052618/54c94fcf4a7959dd228b46c9/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
4
The Centre for Indepedent Journalism (CIJ)would like to thank Malaysiakini.com, The Malaysian Insider, Merdeka Review, Amin Iskandar, and Sundhagran Stanley for providing and allowing us to use the photographs in this report. Individual credits are in the photograph captions.
Cover picture by Amin IskandarPublished by Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ) 2010ISBN: 983 44026
Writer/ Researcher: Yip Wai FongEditor: Sonia Randhawa, Chuah Siew Eng
About CIJTheCentreforIndependentJournalism(CIJ)isanon-profitorganizationwhichaspirestocreateasocietythatisdemocratic,justandfree,whereallpeoplewillenjoyfreemediaandthefreedomtoexpress,seekandimpartinformation.
CIJwasstartedinresponsetothepoliticalcrisisof1998asSaksi.com,awebsitethatattemptedtogivebroadanalysistocurrentevents.Todaywehaveexpandedourefforttoadvocacyoffreedomofexpression(FOE)andinformation(FOI)andtoencourageproffesionaljournalismpracticesandmediafreedominMalaysia.
Our objectives;• PromoteanddefendtheexerciseofFOE• RaisepublicawarenessonFOE/FOItomobilizesupportfor mediafreedom,expressionandaccesstoinformation.• Ensuregoodpoliciesandadvocatinglegislativechange• Facilitatingmarginalizedvoicethroughcommunityradio
Contact Us27CJalanSarikei,offJalanPahang53000KualaLumpurTel:0340230772Fax:0340230769www.cijmalaysia.org