Download - McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
1/57
CONTINGENCY RESERVE FUND
STUDY
VR 1047 - CHELSEA TERRACE1040 PACIFIC STREET, VANCOUVER, BRITISH COLUMBIA
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
2/57
TABLE OF CONTENTS
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................... i
1.0 INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................... 1
2.0 METHODOLOGY.............................................................................................................. 3
2.1 HOW THIS CRF STUDY WAS CONDUCTED...................................................................... 3
2.2 MATERIAL LIFE EXPECTANCIES AND ASSOCIATED PRICING................................ 5
3.0 BUILDING COMPONENTS............................................................................................. 8
3.1 BUILDING ENVELOPE............................................................................................................. 83.2 GENERAL SITE ISSUES.......................................................................................................... 13
3.3 STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS ....................................................................................................... 14
3.4 MECHANICAL SYSTEMS ...................................................................................................... 17
3.5 SAFETY SYSTEMS................................................................................................................... 19
3.6 ELECTRICAL ............................................................................................................................ 20
4.0 FINANCIAL ANALYSIS................................................................................................. 21
4.1 BASE SCENARIO...................................................................................................................... 21
4.2 PROPOSED SCENARIOS 1 THROUGH 4 ............................................................................ 22
4.3 COMMENTS ON THE FOUR SCENARIOS......................................................................... 25
10.0 FINAL REMARKS......................................................................................................... 27
LIST OF APPENDICES
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
3/57
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
McCuaig & Associates Engineering Ltd. (MAE) was retained by Strata Corporation VR 1047 to
undertake a review of the major construction components at Chelsea Terrace, with the intent to
provide a Contingency Reserve Fund Study, henceforth referred to as a CRF. The building is
located at 1040 Pacific Street in Vancouver, British Columbia.
A CRF study provides forecasted costs for the maintenance and renewal of all significant
existing building components of the building. In addition to this, the CRF presents a financial
study as to how the Strata will have to budget for these expenditures over the next 25 years.
Maintenance costs are the expected ongoing requirements to keep components operating as
intended. Renewal costs are those costs required when the components must be replaced, even if
adequate regular on-going maintenance has been carried out. Renewal costs are not intended to
provide upgrades to any building components unless the present requirements (codes or
technology) dictate that an upgrade is necessary. Otherwise all estimates for renewals assumes
replacing like for like.
Recommendations have been developed based on our assumption that the building should
provide approximately 50 more years of service life. The design service life of the building was
not indicated on any of the documentation reviewed by MAE. Industry standards, however,
consider a 50 to 100 year service life to be a reasonable expectation for a building of this type.
Overall, Chelsea Terrace is in good condition for a building of its age. The buildings equipment
and grounds have been maintained at standards that would be considered above average for a
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
4/57
solutions for the Strata to prepare for future expenditures. Some scenarios will likely be more
agreeable than others regarding collection of funds from the strata members.
Two basic assumptions made for this study include:
Inflation rate of 2 percent; Existing maintenance fees are approximately 30 percent below industry average for
comparable Stratas.
Scenario 1 proposes a modest and constant strata fee increase of 2 percent, which we have
assumed to equal inflation. This model produces numerous special assessments for The Strata
over a 25 year period, which in not desirable and may not be feasible.
Scenario 2 proposes a 5 percent increase in strata fees for 5 years and 2 percent thereafter. This
model slowly addresses the below average strata fees at Chelsea Terrace but does not reach the
30 percent increase until the 6th year. In addition to this, there are eight special assessments in
this model totaling 2.7 million dollars, which is still undesirable.
Scenario 3 proposes a 20 percent initial increase, 10 percent for the following 3 years, and 2.5
percent thereafter. This scenario fully addresses the below average strata fees in the second
year and also significantly reduces the number of special assessments and there total value.
There are four proposed special assessments in this model with a total value of 1.0 million
dollars. This proposal is balanced between strata fee increases and special assessment and is
our recommended strategy for the Strata.
Scenario 4 proposes an initial 25 percent increase to the fees with 10 percent annual increases for
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
5/57
1.0 INTRODUCTIONMAE was retained by Strata Corporation VR 1047 to conduct a Contingency Reserve Fund
Study at Chelsea Terrace, located at 1040 Pacific Street in Vancouver, BC.
Chelsea Terrace was constructed in a high-density residential neighborhood on a sloping lot.
The development is surrounded by mid and high-rise residential buildings and is approximately
one block north of the ocean. The building consists of 112 strata units, one amenities room, a
common laundry room, and an underground parking facility.
The building is nine stories high with parking on the first floor and a portion of the second floor.
Residential units start on the second floor and extend to the top floor. All units have access to
either private patios or balconies off their suites. Each unit is heated with individual electric
baseboard heating systems.
The building structure is constructed from cast-in-place concrete and steel supports. Concretewas used to build the structural support walls and the suspended slabs in the parking areas. The
above grade floors are supported by steel joists with a concrete topping. Concrete forms a large
portion of the exterior cladding of the building. At some locations, however, the exterior walls
are comprised of infill sections made from light-gauge steel stud framing with exterior sheathing
and stucco as the exterior cladding.
The windows and sliding doors in the building have double-glazing and date back to the original
construction.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
6/57
involve a comprehensive review of all surface or components. Areas reviewed at Chelsea
Terrace included:
Building Envelope (roofs, exterior wall cladding, sealant, windows and doors, balconies,roof decks, plaza decks, exterior paint, and parking garage); General Site Issues (landscaping, exterior concrete ramps & stairs, and carpets/finishes in
common areas);
Structural System; Mechanical System (plumbing, drainage, and HVAC systems); Electrical System (fuse/breaker panels, switch/subpanels, and security lighting); Fire Safety System (fire notification systems, sprinkler system, and fire separation); and Elevator System.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
7/57
2.0 METHODOLOGY
2.1 HOW THIS CRF STUDY WAS CONDUCTED
2.1.1. The Construction Drawings and relevant documents obtained from the City of Vancouverwere reviewed in order to become familiar with the project. The drawings that were
reviewed and are relevant to this report are described below:
Table 1 List of Construction Drawings
Consultant Document
Drawing
Drawings
Provided
Latest Issue
Date
Purpose of Issue
HaleArchitects
Architectural A1 to A24 December,1979
Proposal toMunicipality
Read JonesChristoffersenLtd.
Structural S8 and S9(other structuraldrawings were
not available)
November,1979
Issued for BuildingPermit
N/A Mechanical M1 to M10 N/A Issued for BuildingPermit
N/A Plumbing P1 to P10 N/A Issued for BuildingPermit
R. J. Wong &AssociatesLtd.
Electrical E1 and E2 N/A Issued for BuildingPermit
N/A Sprinkler SP1 to SP3 N/A Issued for BuildingPermit
It should be noted that all drawings were received in a compressed (smaller size) format
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
8/57
A copy of Common Area Carpet Cleaning Service invoice dated June 3, 2011 byCarpetex.
A copy of Annual Fire & Safety Inspection Deficiencies Quote dated August 17,2011 by Voltech Fire Protection.
A copy of Roof Replacement Contract dated July 31, 1997 by IGB Contracting Ltd. The Strata Corporations operating budget and financial statement provided by the
Property Management Company.
2.1.2. A Visual non-invasive review of a representative sample of building envelopecomponents was conducted. This includes reviews of various roofs, exterior face of
walls, balconies, plaza decks, and window assemblies.
2.1.3. A Visual non-invasive review of exposed structural components was completed. Thepurpose of this review was to evaluate the condition of the exposed structural
components that must provide acceptable service levels for the remaining life of thebuilding.
2.1.4. A Visual non-invasive review of general site conditions including; landscaping, exteriorramps & stairs and carpets/finishes of common areas.
2.1.5. A Visual non-invasive review of a representative sample of the buildings mechanical,electrical, fire safety and elevator systems.
2 1 6 An interview with the building manager Nick Dotsev to identify and discuss any areas
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
9/57
2.2 MATERIAL LIFE EXPECTANCIES AND ASSOCIATED PRICING
When developing a report of this type it is necessary to define the service life of the various
building components. The estimated service life of a component or material is determined
based on several variables including: quality of materials, quality of installation, historicalperformance, exposure conditions, manufacturers recommendations, and maintenance, servicing
or upkeep of the item.
It should be understood the design service lives discussed within this report are not a finite life.
In some cases the actual service life of a product or component could be shorter or longer than
the expected service life. Considering the host of variable that influence service life, it maybetter be described as a service life range.
Table 2 shows examples of building components with their Expected Service Life, a Range of
Expected Service Life and Factors Affecting Service Life.
Table 2 Expected Service Lives of Various Building Components
Item
Expected
Service Life
Range of
Expected
Service Life Factors Affecting Service Life
Roof membranes 20 years 17-25 years Type and quality of membraneQuality of installationSlope and drainage of the roofExposure to elements (wind, precipitation,
pollution, UV, etc.)Regular maintenance
Plaza deck
membranes
20 years 15-25 years Type and quality of membraneQuality of installation
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
10/57
Item
Expected
Service Life
Range of
Expected
Service Life Factors Affecting Service Life
Metal roofing 40 years 30-50 years Type and gauge of metal roofingQuality of protection coatingQuality of installation (i.e. Exposed vs. hidden
fastener systems, etc.)
Exposure to elements (winds, precipitation,pollution, UV, etc.)
Regular maintenanceExterior wall
sealant (caulking)
10 years 8-12 years Type and quality of sealantQuality of installationExposure to elements (wind, precipitation,
pollution, UV, etc.)
Regular maintenanceWindows and patio
doors
25 years 15-30 years Quality of windows and glazingQuality of installationMaterial of the window frame (metal, wood,
vinyl, etc.)
Type of glazing (single glazed, double glazed,Low E coating, etc.)
Type of operators (casement, awing, slider,etc.)
Exposure to elements (wind, precipitation,pollution, UV, etc.)
Regular maintenance
Opinions of probable costs allocated to maintenance or renewal items should not be consideredset costs. These values are established based on current market conditions and product
availability. The cost of construction materials and labour are influenced by many variables.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
11/57
Given the volatility of construction prices, MAE assumes no responsibility for the future
accuracy of our projected estimated costs. Moreover, our opinion of remaining service life is
not guarantee that the components will not fail earlier than projected.
This study should be viewed as a dynamic process that necessitates regular review and updating
for both projected remaining service life and related costs. Items that are to be undertaken in
several years should be reviewed closer to the date of the work.
Should our services be requires, MAE is available to assist the Strata in obtaining quotations for
future maintenance or renewals work.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
12/57
3.0 BUILDING COMPONENTS
3.1 BUILDING ENVELOPE
Descriptions of the various building envelope assemblies that are the subject of this report are
provided in this section. The descriptions provided in this report are based on the Construction
Drawings, our experience with similar buildings, and our visual reviews. There has been no
attempt to verify the presence of all the components described herein. For a detailed description
of building envelope components and their performance, refer to Building Envelope Condition
Assessment (BECA) report dated September 30, 2011 prepared by MAE.
Several components are nearing the end of their reasonably expected lifespan and such will need
replacement in the near future.
Envelope Items included in this section are as following:
Roofs; Exterior Wall Cladding; Sealants; Windows and Doors; Balconies, Roof Decks, and Plaza Decks; Parking Garage.
3.1.1 Roofs
There are two types of roofs on the site: low-slope roofs protected with 2-ply SBS membranes
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
13/57
over the spa room on the northeast corner of the building. Refer to Photo 2. These roofs should
be replaced as soon as possible with new rainwater drain system where required, and the
expected cost is approximately $45,000.
Photo 1 Main roof above ninth level. Photo 2 Lower tier roofs over the spa room
(concrete topping) and racket ball court.
The existing metal roofs appear to be in fair condition with no reported leaks. MAE is aware that
one of the pitched roofs has been replaced in the past two years. A visual review for any
damages to the panels, openings at standing seams, rust on paint finish and debris in perimeter
gutters on a regular basis will ensure the longevity of the metal roofing system.
It is our recommendation that The Strata should adopt a comprehensive roof maintenance
program for all roofing systems at Chelsea Terrace. A qualified roofing tradesman should review
the roofs annually and any required maintenance should be performed during the review. The
expected cost to implement this recommendation is $2 000 per year
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
14/57
the overall building including windows, doors, exterior cladding, guardrails, decks, and
balconies.
It is our knowledge that exterior paint had been applied to the exterior walls approximately fiveyears ago. Exterior paint and water repellent coatings help to protect the substrate surfaces from
the exterior elements and premature deterioration while providing an aesthetic appearance.
Properly applied exterior paint and water repellent coatings should last ten to fifteen years
depending on various factors such as the condition of substrate, type of paint, thickness applied
and exposure. The Strata should allow a budget of $120,000 within next five years to repaint and
recoat the exterior cladding and expect to re-apply every ten to fifteen years.
3.1.3 Sealants
An integral design element in a face sealed cladding system is the sealed joints at the material
interfaces. Sealing of the interfaces is a primary defense against thermal movements and
moisture ingress. A standard sealant application should be expected to last approximately seven
to ten years depending on the quality, application, exposure and joint movement.
The existing sealant at Chelsea Terrace has reached the end of its service life. Sealant loses its
flexibility and adhesion to the substrate as it ages. The exterior sealant should be removed and
replaced at all exterior locations including all window/door interfaces, cladding interfaces, and
flashing details within the next two years. The budget required for this is $50,000. The Strata
should expect to replace sealant every ten years.
3.1.4 Windows and Doors
The original windows and patio doors installed at Chelsea Terrace are metal frame, non-
h ll b k d bl l d h bl i d i f lid d i d
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
15/57
is our recommendation to investigate the skylights on the south elevation at the time of window
upgrade.
3.1.5 Balconies, Roof Decks, and Plaza Decks
a) Balconies
The balcony membranes at Chelsea Terrace have reached the end of their service life, assuming
an age of 30 years. The upper balconies, exposed to direct precipitation and sunlight, are
considered to be high-risk and therefore these membranes should be replaced as soon as possible.
Refer to Photo 3. The existing membranes at upper balconies and balconies at Suites 608 and
813 should be removed and replaced with a new SBS system including concrete pavers overtop.The exterior wall of balcony at Suite 813 also requires structural repairs due to the corroded steel
members. An estimated total cost of membrane replacement work is $55,000 and MAE
recommends this work take place as soon as possible.
The existing drainage system for the balconies directs water to balcony below. This system is
considered undesirable due to a high risk of water ingress problems. Refer to Photo 4. MAE
recommends that a new rainwater collection system be installed that does not drain water ontoother balconies. The new rainwater collection system will have to be implemented as soon as
feasible and the expected cost is $40,000.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
16/57
deck membranes and, if warranted, replace them while other roof work is being completed. A
budget of $20,000 should be allocated to implement this recommendation.
c) Plaza Decks
The current plaza deck membranes at Chelsea Terrace appear to be nearing the end of their life
spans. Although no leaks were reported, MAE observed deterioration in membranes and signs of
repairs against the exterior walls during the review. Refer to Photos 5 and 6.
The Strata should replace the membranes and expect to allocate $225,000 for this work. In order
to minimize financial overload, The Strata may consider replacing the membranes over three
phases at approximately $75,000 per phase. It is recommended to commence this work within
three years and continue the remaining two phases one year apart.
Photo 5 Plaza deck membrane is delaminating
from the exterior wall.
Photo 6 Plaza deck drain exposed beneath paver.
The membrane is deteriorated and is no longer
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
17/57
prevent further concrete decay along with a textured no-slip surface. The application of traffic
coating will require a budget of $75,000.
Structural issues related to parkade walls and slabs are further discussed in Section 3.3 Structural Systems.
3.2 GENERAL SITE ISSUES
General site issues relate to the following items:
Landscaping; Exterior Concrete Walkway and Stairs; Carpets/Finishes in Common Areas.
3.2.1 Landscaping
A visual review of landscaping and drainage issues around the building was conducted. In
general, the shrubs and plants on all elevations have been well maintained. However, the trees onnorth elevation have grown outwards and now are touching the cladding of the building. Refer to
Photo 7. Trees that are too close to buildings restrict drying and may result in foundation cracks
and uplifts due to extending tree roots. Leaves of deciduous trees can clog gutters and drains.
We recommend the existing trees close to the north elevation be trimmed. The Strata should
allocate $5,000 annually for landscape related work.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
18/57
3.2.2 Exterior Concrete Ramps & Stairs
The surfaces of the exterior concrete ramps and stairs at Chelsea Terrace appear to be worn down
due to prolonged exposure to exterior weather conditions and pedestrian traffic. Refer to Photo 8.
The worn down concrete surfaces might pose a slip hazard in the event of precipitation and icyweather. In addition, as concrete deteriorates over time, cracks develop and create a passageway
for water ingress that would further damage the concrete slabs. The Strata should consider
applying a traffic coating with a textured no-slip surface that is similar to what was installed on
the exterior of the parking garage entrance ramp at a cost of $5,000.
3.2.3 Carpets & Finishes in Common Areas
The carpets and finishes in the common areas of
Chelsea Terrace appear to be in fair condition. It
is our understanding that the carpets have been
replaced within last two to three years and The
Strata has carried out regular maintenance, such
as vacuuming and annual cleaning. The interior
walls were painted approximately two years ago
and are in good shape, except for few dents and
scratches observed on some hallway walls. Refer
to Photo 9. With a regular touch-up of damaged
areas, the paint should last for another ten years.
The Strata should expect to spend $1,200 for
continued annual maintenance and $50,000 oncarpet replacement and re-painting of the walls
in common areas every ten years.
Photo 9 Scratches and dents on interior wall
finish at main entry corridor.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
19/57
3.3.1 Outdoor Retaining Walls
The outdoor retaining walls appear to have provided reasonable performance to date. Vertical
cracks were observed at several isolated locations. Dried efflorescence was observed at
approximately half of the vertical cracks. The efflorescence suggests that water has passedthrough the wall; however, since there was no evidence of delaminated concrete or corroded
rebar, we are of the opinion that the presence of the efflorescence is an aesthetic issue only.
Furthermore, we are of the opinion that, due to the orientation and thin width of the cracks, they
are not a cause for concern.
We did note one area on the south side of Level 2
where the bottom of the retaining wall was
inconsistent refer to Photo 10. It appears that this
section of wall was pinned back to the soil
sometime after its original construction. It appears
that the wall has provided acceptable performance
since the remedial work was completed.
The Strata should inspect the retaining walls
annually. Reviews should record excessive
movement, widening or propagation of additional
cracks, and evidence of delaminating concrete or
corroding steel. Should any of the aforementioned
occur, review by a professional should be
arranged.3.3.2 Parkade Walls
Photo 10 Inconsistent bottom of the retaining
wall.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
20/57
3.3.3 Parkade Slabs
There are two types of slab within the parkade at Chelsea Terrace:
Slabs on grade that provide the traffic surface for Level 1 and the north half of Level 2. Suspended slabs that provide the traffic surface for the south half of Level 2 and for the
entire ceiling over Level 2 (the floor of Level 3).
a) Slabs on Grade
Except as noted below, the slabs on grade appear to have provided satisfactory performance to
date and there is no indication that, for the most part, maintenance or remedial work will be
required in the future.
The supporting soil beneath one area on the Level 2 slab appears to have heaved. The heaving
soil has caused the slab to crack refer to Photo 11. The difference in elevation of each side of
the crack may cause a tripping hazard. If the strata is concerned about this and structural
drawings cannot be obtained, The Strata should consult a professional to investigate thebuildings foundation system.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
21/57
that, at most locations, the danger of partial structural collapse is minimal, given the observed
conditions at the time of our review.
Note that the exposed rebar at the underside of the access ramps appears to be main steel, thus
the structural degradation at the ramps is more serious than at other slab locations. For this
reason, it is recommended that steps be implemented to either repair the ramps or install
temporary structural support as soon as possible. The structural issue relating to the parkade
ramp is beyond the scope of this report and it will be dealt with independently.
3.4 MECHANICAL SYSTEMS
Some mechanical components have been recently upgraded. The expected life of these, however,
is such that even some of the new components will likely need replacement within 20 years.
These replacement costs have been considered in this study.
Mechanical components included in this review are as following:
Boiler; Heating; Domestic Water Pipes; Domestic Water Mains; Drainage Pipes; Elevators; DHW tanks; Valves/Pumps;
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
22/57
3.4.3 Domestic Water Pipes
The domestic water pipes in the building were replaced in 2003. The expected life of these pipes
is in the range of 20 years and as such, they should be replaced, approximately, in the year 2023.
The cost of this replacement would be in the range of $300,000.
3.4.4 Domestic Water Main
The domestic water main supply to the building is via an underground service pipe. This was not
replaced as part of the recent re-piping. Water mains have a reasonably long life, and the water
main at Chelsea Terrace will require replacement within the next 15 to 20 years at a cost of
$40,000.
3.4.5 Drainage Pipes
Given the materials, usage, and pressures involved, drainage pipes (sanitary and rain water) do
not require wholesale replacement as with domestic pipes. Ongoing maintenance, however, is
necessary, and we estimate an annual cost of $2,000 for this.
3.4.6 Elevators
The existing elevators are original equipment. It includes two cabs and uses mechanical relays
for operation. These relays have been maintained but will likely require wholesale replacement
within 20 years. Motors, ropes, and related equipment are also quite robust but will likely require
some form of overhaul within the next 20 years. Expected cost of the major work would be in the
range of $100,000. Annual service costs are in the range of $8,000.
3.4.7 Domestic Hot Water Tanks
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
23/57
3.5 SAFETY SYSTEMS
The safety systems in this building generally meet the requirements at the time it was built,
however they are likely below what would be required for a new residential building today.
It is our understanding that there are no outstanding orders from the Fire Marshals Office,
although there was a list of fire alarm repairs in the process of being carried out at the time of our
review.
During our review, the condition of the fire hoses in the hose cabinets seemed questionable, and
the ceiling installation around some of the fire gongs may interfere with their proper function.
We recommend that these items be reviewed by a qualified fire safety technician.
The Fire Marshals Office has a large degree of discretion as to what they can order and it is
difficult to predict what orders may be made in the future. It is reasonable, however, to assume
that the Strata would voluntarily undertake reasonable upgrades to life safety equipment to
mitigate the possibility of a preventable injury or loss of life, especially if so requested by the
Fire Marshalls Office. Given this, it is our opinion that it is not unreasonable to expect the Stratato upgrade some systems in the next 20 years (such as in-suite sprinklers), but there is no
requirement for this work at present.
The following areas are to be considered:
Smoke/Heat detectors; Alarm Panel Upgrade; Sprinklers;
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
24/57
3.5.3 Sprinklers
As stated above, it is unlikely that sprinklers will be mandated in the near future, but it is
possible that these could either be mandated or installed voluntarily within 20 years. The cost of
this work would be in the range of $300,000.
3.5.4 Fire Alarm Annual Reviews
Annual reviews of fire safety equipment are required by the City of Vancouver. This work will
cost in the range of $7,000 annually.
3.6 ELECTRICAL
Electrical components are in generally good condition and require little or no maintenance or
upgrades. The following areas are of note:
Switches/ Subpanels; Emergency Generator.
3.6.1 Switches/ Subpanels
The age of these is adequate to expect that replacement and repair would likely not be necessary
within the next 20 years.
3.6.2 Emergency Generator
The existing emergency generator provides adequate power for emergency lighting and (MAEassumes) the fire alarm. Monthly testing and required maintenance of the generator is
recommended, and this requires and annual cost of $7,000.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
25/57
4.0 FINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Based on our review of Chelsea Terrace and our experience with similar buildings, we haveprepared a table of fixed annual revenue and expenses along with a financial forecast table of the
annual maintenance and renewals expenditures for the next 25 years. These tables will be
considered our base scenario and can be found in Appendix A.
When completing a reserve fund study the objective is to have the closing balance of this fund
remain positive at the end of each fiscal year. Over and above a positive balance, we consider it
reasonable for a Strata of this size to maintain a balance of $100,000 for any unforeseeable
emergency repairs.
The Property Manager provided MAE with The Stratas operating budget for 2011 and the
financial statements as of September 30th, 2011. The following information was gathered and
used as the basis of the financial analysis:
Contingency Reserve Fund General $136,612.90
Contingency Reserve Fund Elevator $ 57, 218.93
Total Contingency Reserve Fund $195,831.83
Present Annual Contribution to the CRF General $ 19,943.00
Present Annual Contribution to the CRF Elevator $ 14,908.88
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
26/57
one-time lump sum contributions to the CRF made by the owners to cover the costs of a
maintenance or renewal expenses.
The result of the above study confirms that there will be insufficient funds in the CRF to be able
to meet the anticipated maintenance and expenditures for the 25-year period. In fact, the CRF
balance falls into the negative amounts by year 2014 and continues to decline, refer to the graph
in Appendix A. In 10 years time the CRF balance is negative 1.8 million dollars and at the end
the 25-year study the balance is negative 6.0 million dollars.
The results of this base model show the inevitable shortcomings of the current CRF
contributions. This base model is taken as a literal translation from the above noted
maintenance and renewal issues discussed in Items 3.0 and should not be considered a proposed
option. This model shows a worst-case scenario for the Strata. The following Scenarios 1, 2,
3 and 4 apply analytical methods on increasing strata revenue along with a more practical
maintenance and renewals schedule, which allow for spreading out the inevitable maintenance
items into more feasible timelines.
4.2 PROPOSED SCENARIOS 1 THROUGH 4
For the proposed scenarios, a more reasonable approach is taken with the renewals schedule.
As the maintenance and renewals schedule is a dynamic document, we have the ability to adjust
such high cost items that all fall within a single scheduled year. This is true for year 5 (2016)
where the base model has approximately 1 million dollars on maintenance and renewals costs
including roof and window replacement. It is unlikely that a strata would perform such items in
the same year and now we can utilize the range of expected service life discussed in Item 2.2
above to make rational adjustments.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
27/57
increase but has the highest number and value of special assessments. Scenarios 2 and 3
increase the strata fee contribution with a reduction in special assessments. Scenario 4
increases the strata fee to a level where no special assessments are required over the 25-year
term.
3.2.1 Scenario 1 2 percent Annual Increase in Strata Fees for the 25-Year Term
Scenario 1 has the smallest increase to the strata fees collected at Chelsea Terrace. We have
chosen a 2 percent fee increase to account for inflation, which is assumed to be 2 percent for the
duration of the study. The result this model creates is the need for multiple special assessments
throughout the 25-year period. Refer to Appendix C for the financial data in chart and
graphical form. A sample forecasted single unit strata fee is shown below using $175/month as
an assumed starting point.
Year Strata Fee
0 $175
1 $179
2 $182
3 $186
4 $189
5 $193
10 $213
By the 3rd year of the study the first special assessment is required. The value of this
assessment is $300,000. The second assessment comes in year 5 and is for $400,000. In total,
ten assessments are required over the study period ranging from $300,000 to $600,000. In this
case, annual revenue from the Strata is approximately 10.1 million dollars while the ten special
assessments total approximately 4 million for the 25-year term.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
28/57
By the 3rd year of the study the first special assessment is required. The value of this
assessment is $300,000. The second assessment comes in year 5 and if for $400,000. In total,
eight assessments are required over the study period ranging from $200,000 to $400,000. In this
case, annual revenue from the Strata is approximately 11.4 million dollars while the ten special
assessments total approximately 2.7 million for the 25-year term.
4.2.3 Scenario 3 20 percent Initial Fee Increase, 5 percent Increase for 3 years and 2.5
percent Thereafter
Scenario 3 proposes an initial 20 percent increase to the strata fees. This initial increase helps
the strata fees at Chelsea Terrace to be in line with current market values for similar properties.
The following 3 years will have an increase of 5 percent per year with the remainder of the years
having a 2.5 percent annual increase, which is slightly above the assumed inflation rate of 2
percent. A sample forecasted single unit strata fee is shown below using $175/month as an
assumed starting point.
Year Strata Fee
0 $175
1 $210
2 $231
3 $254
4 $280
5 $286
10 $324
This model requires four special assessments during the study period with the first being in year3 for $300,000. The assessments range from $200,000 to $300,000. MAE believes the
number of assessment and the amount of each assessment to be reasonable given the forecasted
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
29/57
schedule at the 10, 15, and 20 year intervals. A sample forecasted single unit strata fee is shown
below using $175/month as an assumed starting point.
Year Strata Fee0 $175
1 $219
2 $241
3 $265
4 $291
5 $320
10 $352
As stated above, scenario four has been configured to eliminate the need for any special
assessments, according to the model, for the entire 25-year term. The strategy is to increase the
strata fees substantially for the first 6 years to accommodate all the forecasted maintenance and
renewal expenses. As this is a model, there is no guarantee that a special assessment will not be
required in the study period but one is not expected.
In this case, annual revenue from the Strata is approximately 14.3 million dollars and the special
assessments total is $0 for the 25-year term. Refer to Appendix F for the financial data in chart
and graphical form.
4.3 COMMENTS ON THE FOUR SCENARIOSIt is our opinion that the current strata fees at Chelsea Terrace are below average for the area.
MAE conducted a brief study of comparable buildings in the area and the results were other
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
30/57
Scenario 2 proposes a 5 percent increase in strata fees for 5 years and 2 percent thereafter. This
model slowly addresses the below average strata fees at Chelsea Terrace but does not bring reach
the 30 percent increase until the 6th year. In addition, there are eight special assessments in this
model totaling 2.7 million dollars, which may be undesirable.
Scenario 3 proposes a 20 percent initial increase, 10 percent for the following 3 years, and 2.5
percent thereafter. This scenario fully addresses the below average strata fees in the second
year and also significantly reduces the number of special assessments and there total value.
There are four proposed special assessments in this model with a total value of 1.0 million
dollars. This proposal is balanced between strata fee increases and special assessment. This is
the recommended strategy for the Strata.
Scenario 4 proposes an initial 25 percent increase to the fees with 10 percent annul increases for
the following 6 years. No increases are forecasted for the remaining years. This model
addresses the below average strata fees within 2 years and eliminates the need for special
assessments throughout the 25-year study period. Although this option is financially feasible it
may be undesirable to focus all fundraising on increased monthly fees.
The CRF study uses a financial model that has countless viable solutions. MAE has attempted
to provide sample solutions representing various options. The actual Strata Corporations
annual contributions to the CRF account must be established by the Strata Council and their
members. We suggest the Strata also consider conferring with their solicitor and/or accountant
to confirm this meets the requirements of the Strata.
MAE is available to go over the dynamic financial models with the council and/or property
manager.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
31/57
5.0 FINAL REMARKS
It should be noted that reviews that are described in this report were limited to the areas andassemblies that are specifically noted in the report. Except where specifically noted, no testing or
dismantling of any assemblies was performed and reviews were made on a random basis with no
attempt to review or inspect every element or portion of the buildings. Our comments are not a
guarantee or warranty of any aspect of the condition of the buildings whatsoever.
This report was prepared by McCuaig & Associates Engineering Limited (MAE) for the account
of Strata Corporation VR 1047. MAE accepts no responsibility for damages, if any, suffered by
any third party as a result of decisions made or actions based on this report.
MAE has reviewed and assessed the contingency reserve fund requirements of the Strata
Coporation in accordance with MAEs proposal. It should be noted again that a CRF study is a
dynamic document that will change over time as maintenance and renewals are performed along
with fluctuations in market conditions and inflation. As such, regular review and updates to thisCRF study are necessary to re-assess the needs of the Strata.
We would be pleased to meet with The Strata to review this report and answer questions that
may exist. We trust this meets your requirements at this time, and should you have any questions
or concerns, please contact our office.
McCUAIG & ASSOCIATES ENGINEERING LTD.
Prepared by: Reviewed by:
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
32/57
APPENDIX A
BASE SCENARIO MAINTENANCE AND RENEWALS TABLE
AND FINANCIAL TABLE
Base Scenario of Annual Revenue and Expenses with 2% Inflation: Chelsea Terrace - 1040 Pacific Street, Vancouver, BC
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
33/57
October 2011 Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITY
REVENUE
Strata Fee
$267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735 $267,735
Laundry Income
$17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000 $17,000
Move In/Out Fee
$ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 75 0
Parking Income
$29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880 $29,880
Fobs/Keys/Remotes
$500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500 $500
Prior Years Surplus
$27,077
(E) TOTAL REVENUE $343,942 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865 $316,865
(F) ACTUAL TOTAL
EXPENSES$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Administrative Expenses$77,000 $78,540 $80,111 $81,713 $83,347 $85,014 $86,715 $88,449 $90,218 $92,022 $93,863 $95,740 $97,655 $99,608 $101,600 $103,632 $105,704 $107,819 $109,975 $112,174 $114,418 $116,706 $119,040 $121,421 $123,850
Employee Expenses$32,424 $33,073 $33,734 $34,409 $35,097 $35,799 $36,515 $37,245 $37,990 $38,750 $39,525 $40,315 $41,122 $41,944 $42,783 $43,639 $44,511 $45,402 $46,310 $47,236 $48,181 $49,144 $50,127 $51,130 $52,152
Utilities$72,850 $74,307 $75,793 $77,309 $78,855 $80,432 $82,041 $83,682 $85,355 $87,062 $88,804 $90,580 $92,391 $94,239 $96,124 $98,047 $100,007 $102,008 $104,048 $106,129 $108,251 $110,416 $112,625 $114,877 $117,175
General Repair &
Maintenance $40,000 $40,800 $41,616 $42,448 $43,297 $44,163 $45,046 $45,947 $46,866 $47,804 $48,760 $49,735 $50,730 $51,744 $52,779 $53,835 $54,911 $56,010 $57,130 $58,272 $59,438 $60,627 $61,839 $63,076 $64,337
Window Cleaning &
Maintenance $8,000 $8,160 $8,323 $8,490 $8,659 $8,833 $9,009 $9,189 $9,373 $9,561 $9,752 $9,947 $10,146 $10,349 $10,556 $10,767 $10,982 $11,202 $11,426 $11,654 $11,888 $12,125 $12,368 $12,615 $12,867
Power Washing$ 3, 50 0 $ 3, 57 0 $ 3, 64 1 $ 3, 71 4 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 4 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 0 $ 4, 10 1 $ 4, 18 3 $ 4, 26 6 $ 4, 35 2 $ 4, 43 9 $ 4, 52 8 $ 4, 61 8 $ 4, 711 $ 4, 80 5 $ 4, 90 1 $ 4, 99 9 $ 5, 09 9 $ 5, 20 1 $ 5, 30 5 $ 5, 411 $ 5, 51 9 $ 5, 63 0
Landscaping Maintenance $ 5, 20 0 $ 5, 30 4 $ 5, 41 0 $ 5, 51 8 $ 5, 62 9 $ 5, 74 1 $ 5, 85 6 $ 5, 97 3 $ 6, 09 3 $ 6, 21 4 $ 6, 33 9 $ 6, 46 6 $ 6, 59 5 $ 6, 72 7 $ 6, 86 1 $ 6, 99 9 $ 7, 13 8 $ 7, 28 1 $ 7, 42 7 $ 7, 57 5 $ 7, 72 7 $ 7, 88 1 $ 8, 03 9 $ 8, 20 0 $ 8, 36 4
Irrigation
$750 $765 $780 $796 $812 $828 $845 $862 $879 $896 $914 $933 $951 $970 $990 $1,009 $1,030 $1,050 $1,071 $1,093 $1,114 $1,137 $1,159 $1,183 $1,206
NOTESEXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
Caretaker Wage
Electricity, Gas, Water &Sewer
an enance cos ncu escleaning and replacing failedunits. Expect maintenancecost to decrease oncewindows are u raded.
EXPENSES
Statutory Review of Books,Additional Services, BankCharges, Insurance, Office
Supplies, Telephone, & Misc.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
EXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
34/57
October 2011 Page 2 of 3
EXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
Parking Lot Cleaning
$ 1, 00 0 $ 1, 02 0 $ 1, 04 0 $ 1, 06 1 $ 1, 08 2 $ 1, 10 4 $ 1, 12 6 $ 1, 14 9 $ 1, 17 2 $ 1, 19 5 $ 1, 21 9 $ 1, 24 3 $ 1, 26 8 $ 1, 29 4 $ 1, 31 9 $ 1, 34 6 $ 1, 37 3 $ 1, 40 0 $ 1, 42 8 $ 1, 45 7 $ 1, 48 6 $ 1, 51 6 $ 1, 54 6 $ 1, 57 7 $ 1, 60 8
Carpet Cleaning$ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Mechanical Repairs &
Maintenance $ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Plumbing Repairs &Maintenance $ 5, 00 0 $ 5, 10 0 $ 5, 20 2 $ 5, 30 6 $ 5, 41 2 $ 5, 52 0 $ 5, 63 1 $ 5, 74 3 $ 5, 85 8 $ 5, 97 5 $ 6, 09 5 $ 6, 21 7 $ 6, 34 1 $ 6, 46 8 $ 6, 59 7 $ 6, 72 9 $ 6, 86 4 $ 7, 00 1 $ 7, 14 1 $ 7, 28 4 $ 7, 43 0 $ 7, 57 8 $ 7, 73 0 $ 7, 88 4 $ 8, 04 2
Pool/Spa Chemicals &Maintenance $ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Elevator Inspection, Repair,
Maintenance & License $10,550 $10,761 $10,976 $11,196 $11,420 $11,648 $11,881 $12,119 $12,361 $12,608 $12,860 $13,118 $13,380 $13,648 $13,921 $14,199 $14,483 $14,773 $15,068 $15,369 $15,677 $15,990 $16,310 $16,636 $16,969
Fire Protection & Alarm
Monitoring $ 3, 96 5 $ 4, 04 4 $ 4, 12 5 $ 4, 20 8 $ 4, 29 2 $ 4, 37 8 $ 4, 46 5 $ 4, 55 5 $ 4, 64 6 $ 4, 73 9 $ 4, 83 3 $ 4, 93 0 $ 5, 02 9 $ 5, 12 9 $ 5, 23 2 $ 5, 33 6 $ 5, 44 3 $ 5, 55 2 $ 5, 66 3 $ 5, 77 6 $ 5, 89 2 $ 6, 01 0 $ 6, 13 0 $ 6, 25 2 $ 6, 37 7
Emergency GeneratorMonitoring $ 1, 20 0 $ 1, 22 4 $ 1, 24 8 $ 1, 27 3 $ 1, 29 9 $ 1, 32 5 $ 1, 35 1 $ 1, 37 8 $ 1, 40 6 $ 1, 43 4 $ 1, 46 3 $ 1, 49 2 $ 1, 52 2 $ 1, 55 2 $ 1, 58 3 $ 1, 61 5 $ 1, 64 7 $ 1, 68 0 $ 1, 71 4 $ 1, 74 8 $ 1, 78 3 $ 1, 81 9 $ 1, 85 5 $ 1, 89 2 $ 1, 93 0
Enterphone$ 97 5 $ 99 5 $ 1, 01 4 $ 1, 03 5 $ 1, 05 5 $ 1, 07 6 $ 1, 09 8 $ 1, 12 0 $ 1, 14 2 $ 1, 16 5 $ 1, 18 9 $ 1, 21 2 $ 1, 23 7 $ 1, 26 1 $ 1, 28 6 $ 1, 31 2 $ 1, 33 8 $ 1, 36 5 $ 1, 39 3 $ 1, 42 0 $ 1, 44 9 $ 1, 47 8 $ 1, 50 7 $ 1, 53 7 $ 1, 56 8
Security$ 1, 50 0 $ 1, 53 0 $ 1, 56 1 $ 1, 59 2 $ 1, 62 4 $ 1, 65 6 $ 1, 68 9 $ 1, 72 3 $ 1, 75 7 $ 1, 79 3 $ 1, 82 8 $ 1, 86 5 $ 1, 90 2 $ 1, 94 0 $ 1, 97 9 $ 2, 01 9 $ 2, 05 9 $ 2, 10 0 $ 2, 14 2 $ 2, 18 5 $ 2, 22 9 $ 2, 27 3 $ 2, 31 9 $ 2, 36 5 $ 2, 41 3
Lighting$500 $510 $520 $531 $541 $552 $563 $574 $586 $598 $609 $622 $634 $647 $660 $673 $686 $700 $714 $728 $743 $758 $773 $788 $804
Locks/Keys$ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 78 5 $ 1, 82 1 $ 1, 85 7 $ 1, 89 4 $ 1, 93 2 $ 1, 97 1 $ 2, 01 0 $ 2, 05 0 $ 2, 09 1 $ 2, 13 3 $ 2, 17 6 $ 2, 21 9 $ 2, 26 4 $ 2, 30 9 $ 2, 35 5 $ 2, 40 2 $ 2, 45 0 $ 2, 49 9 $ 2, 54 9 $ 2, 60 0 $ 2, 65 2 $ 2, 70 5 $ 2, 76 0 $ 2, 81 5
Pest Control$ 3, 50 0 $ 3, 57 0 $ 3, 64 1 $ 3, 71 4 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 4 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 0 $ 4, 10 1 $ 4, 18 3 $ 4, 26 6 $ 4, 35 2 $ 4, 43 9 $ 4, 52 8 $ 4, 61 8 $ 4, 711 $ 4, 80 5 $ 4, 90 1 $ 4, 99 9 $ 5, 09 9 $ 5, 20 1 $ 5, 30 5 $ 5, 411 $ 5, 51 9 $ 5, 63 0
Garbage Collection &
Recycling $12,950 $13,209 $13,473 $13,743 $14,017 $14,298 $14,584 $14,875 $15,173 $15,476 $15,786 $16,102 $16,424 $16,752 $17,087 $17,429 $17,778 $18,133 $18,496 $18,866 $19,243 $19,628 $20,020 $20,421 $20,829
Snow Removal$ 2, 50 0 $ 2, 55 0 $ 2, 60 1 $ 2, 65 3 $ 2, 70 6 $ 2, 76 0 $ 2, 81 5 $ 2, 87 2 $ 2, 92 9 $ 2, 98 8 $ 3, 04 7 $ 3, 10 8 $ 3, 17 1 $ 3, 23 4 $ 3, 29 9 $ 3, 36 5 $ 3, 43 2 $ 3, 50 1 $ 3, 57 1 $ 3, 64 2 $ 3, 71 5 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 5 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 1
Supplies$ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Elevator Upgrades$ 5, 00 0 $ 5, 10 0 $ 5, 20 2 $ 5, 30 6 $ 5, 41 2 $ 5, 52 0 $ 5, 63 1 $ 5, 74 3 $ 5, 85 8 $ 5, 97 5 $ 6, 09 5 $ 6, 21 7 $ 6, 34 1 $ 6, 46 8 $ 6, 59 7 $ 6, 72 9 $ 6, 86 4 $ 7, 00 1 $ 7, 14 1 $ 7, 28 4 $ 7, 43 0 $ 7, 57 8 $ 7, 73 0 $ 7, 88 4 $ 8, 04 2
Garage Door$ 3, 00 0 $ 3, 06 0 $ 3, 12 1 $ 3, 18 4 $ 3, 24 7 $ 3, 31 2 $ 3, 37 8 $ 3, 44 6 $ 3, 51 5 $ 3, 58 5 $ 3, 65 7 $ 3, 73 0 $ 3, 80 5 $ 3, 88 1 $ 3, 95 8 $ 4, 03 8 $ 4, 11 8 $ 4, 20 1 $ 4, 28 5 $ 4, 37 0 $ 4, 45 8 $ 4, 54 7 $ 4, 63 8 $ 4, 73 1 $ 4, 82 5
We understand that this workis being carried out monthly bythe building manager.
Contract
Wholesale replacementrequired within 20 years.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
EXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
35/57
October 2011 Page 3 of 3
Ground Improvement$ 1, 50 0 $ 1, 53 0 $ 1, 56 1 $ 1, 59 2 $ 1, 62 4 $ 1, 65 6 $ 1, 68 9 $ 1, 72 3 $ 1, 75 7 $ 1, 79 3 $ 1, 82 8 $ 1, 86 5 $ 1, 90 2 $ 1, 94 0 $ 1, 97 9 $ 2, 01 9 $ 2, 05 9 $ 2, 10 0 $ 2, 14 2 $ 2, 18 5 $ 2, 22 9 $ 2, 27 3 $ 2, 31 9 $ 2, 36 5 $ 2, 41 3
Mechanical$ 4, 50 0 $ 4, 59 0 $ 4, 68 2 $ 4, 77 5 $ 4, 87 1 $ 4, 96 8 $ 5, 06 8 $ 5, 16 9 $ 5, 27 2 $ 5, 37 8 $ 5, 48 5 $ 5, 59 5 $ 5, 70 7 $ 5, 82 1 $ 5, 93 8 $ 6, 05 6 $ 6, 17 8 $ 6, 30 1 $ 6, 42 7 $ 6, 55 6 $ 6, 68 7 $ 6, 82 0 $ 6, 95 7 $ 7, 09 6 $ 7, 23 8
Fire Equipment$ 2, 25 0 $ 2, 29 5 $ 2, 34 1 $ 2, 38 8 $ 2, 43 5 $ 2, 48 4 $ 2, 53 4 $ 2, 58 5 $ 2, 63 6 $ 2, 68 9 $ 2, 74 3 $ 2, 79 8 $ 2, 85 4 $ 2, 911 $ 2, 96 9 $ 3, 02 8 $ 3, 08 9 $ 3, 15 1 $ 3, 21 4 $ 3, 27 8 $ 3, 34 3 $ 3, 41 0 $ 3, 47 8 $ 3, 54 8 $ 3, 61 9
(G) TOTAL EXPENSES $309,364 $315,551 $321,863 $328,300 $334,866 $341,563 $348,394 $355,362 $362,469 $369,719 $377,113 $384,655 $392,349 $400,196 $408,199 $416,363 $424,691 $433,185 $441,848 $450,685 $459,699 $468,893 $478,271 $487,836 $497,593
(H) ACTUAL TOTALEXPENSES
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Base Scenario of Yearly Maintenance / Renewals Expenditures for:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Chelsea Terrace - 1040 Pacific Street, Vancouver, BC
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
36/57
October 2011 Page 1 of 2
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITY
$2,000 $2,060 $2,130 $2,200 $2,270 $2,340 $2,420 $2,500 $2,580 $2,660 $2,740 $2,830 $2,920 $3,010 $3,110 $3,210 $3,310 $3,410 $3,520 $3,630 $3,740 $3,860 $3,980 $4,100 $4,230
SBS Roofing MembraneReplacement of Main Roofs $275,000
SBS Roofing MembraneReplacement of Lower Tier
Roofs
$45,000
Exterior Wall SealantReplacement $50,000 $70,000 $95,000
Windows / DoorsReplacement
$400,000
Balcony MembraneReplacement $55,000 $12,240 $12,490 $12,74 0 $13,000 $13,2 60 $13,530 $13,810 $1 4,090 $14,380 $14,670 $ 14,970 $15,270 $15,580 $15,90 0 $16,220 $1 6,550 $16,890 $17,230 $ 17,580 $17,940 $18,300 $18,67 0 $19,050 $1 9,440
New Rain Water CollectionSystem $40,000
Roof Deck Condition Review$2,000
Plaza Deck MembraneReplacement $ 75 ,0 00 $ 75 ,0 00 $ 75 ,0 00
$135,000 $180,000 $120,000
$5,000 $5,100 $5,210 $5,320 $5,430 $5,540 $5,660 $5,780 $5,900 $6,020 $6,150 $6,280 $6,410 $6,540 $6,680 $6,820 $6,960 $7,100 $7,250 $7,400 $7,550 $7,710 $7,870 $8,030 $8,200
$85,000 $150,000
$65,000 $85,000
Professional BuildingEnvelope Review $13,000 $15,000 $18,000 $20,000 $25,000
(A) Total Cost for BldgExterior & General Site
Issues per year
$1 07,000 $19,400 $271,830 $95,26 0 $918,700 $21,1 40 $21,610 $22,090 $2 2,570 $103,060 $23,560 $ 24,080 $94,600 $25,130 $223,69 0 $26,250 $2 6,820 $27,400 $28,000 $1 33,610 $29,230 $29,870 $275,52 0 $31,180 $17 6,870
(B) Actual Amount Spent for
Bldg Exterior & General SiteIssues
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Roofing Maintenance(Misc. maintenance and repairs
to membranes, drains andflashing)
Exterior Painting andWaterproofing Sealer
(Exterior Cladding)
NOTES
Old sealant must be removedto facilitate proper applicationof new sealant.
Review should be carried outby an RCABC approvedcontractor.
Roofing Maintenance shouldbe carried out by an RCABCapproved contractor
To replace with 2-ply SBSroofing membrane.
To replace with 2-ply SBSroofing membrane.
New rain water collectionsystem to collect water anddirect down to the ground.
Upper balcony membranes tobe replaced as soon aspossible. The rest of themembranes to be replaced asneeded on an annual basis.
RECOMMENDED ANNUAL MAINTENANCE/RENEWALS EXPENSES
Replace existing membranewith SBS membrane in threephases.
Exterior cladding to be paintedand sealed every 10 years.
Waterproofing of concreteslabs to be done every 20years.
Waterproofing ConcreteParkade Ramp, Pedestrian
Ramp and Stairs
Carpet Replacement &Interior Painting of Common
Areas
*Numbers in bold representwholesale replacement costs.
Carpet to be cleaned annually.Replacement of carpet andrepainting interior walls tooccur every 10 years.
Intermediate review may benecessary based on findings.
Annual Cleaning(Windows, Doors, ExteriorCladding, Glass Canopies,
Guardrails, Decks, & Patios)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
RECOMMENDED ANNUAL MAINTENANCE/RENEWALS EXPENSES
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
37/57
October 2011 Page 2 of 2
Boiler Service &Replacement $20,000 $2,060 $2,110 $2,160 $2,210 $2,260 $2,310 $2,360 $2,410 $2,460 $2,510 $2,570 $2,630 $2,690 $2,750 $2,810 $2,870 $2,930 $2,990 $3,050 $3,120 $3,190 $3,260 $3,330 $3,400
Domestic Pipes Replacement$400,000
Water Mains Replacement$60,000
Drainage Pipes Maintenance$2,000 $2,040 $2,090 $2,140 $2,190 $2,240 $2,290 $2,340 $2,390 $2,440 $2,490 $2,540 $2,600 $2,660 $2,720 $2,780 $2,840 $2,900 $2,960 $3,020 $3,090 $3,160 $3,230 $3,300 $3,370
Elevator Replacement$175,000
DHW Tanks Replacement$20,000
Valves / PumpsRepair & Replacement $1,000 $1,020 $1,050 $1,080 $1,110 $1,140 $1,170 $1,200 $1,230 $1,260 $1,290 $1,320 $1,350 $1,380 $1,410 $1,440 $1,470 $1,500 $1,530 $1,570 $1,610 $1,650 $1,690 $1,730 $1,770
Alarm Panel Upgrade$85,000
Sprinklers$500,000
(C ) Total Cost forMech/Safety/Elec Systems
per year
$23,000 $5,120 $5,250 $5,380 $5,510 $5,640 $5,770 $5,900 $6,030 $6,160 $6,290 $426,430 $6,580 $6,730 $66,880 $7,030 $92,180 $7,330 $182,480 $7,640 $7,820 $508,000 $8,180 $8,360 $8,540
(D) Actual Amount Spent onMech/Safety/Elec Systems
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
PROJECTED TOTAL(A + C) per year
$ 13 0, 00 0 $ 24 ,5 20 $ 27 7, 08 0 $ 10 0,6 40 $ 92 4, 21 0 $ 26 ,7 80 $ 27 ,3 80 $ 27 ,9 90 $ 28 ,6 00 $ 10 9,2 20 $ 29 ,8 50 $ 45 0, 51 0 $ 10 1,1 80 $ 31 ,8 60 $ 29 0,5 70 $ 33 ,2 80 $ 11 9,0 00 $ 34 ,7 30 $ 21 0, 48 0 $ 14 1, 25 0 $ 37 ,0 50 $ 53 7, 87 0 $ 28 3, 70 0 $ 39 ,5 40 $ 18 5, 41 0ACTUAL TOTAL(B + D) per year
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
The preceding tables should be taken as an initial guideline only. Actual expenditure amounts should be input into the empty row provided below each item. The spreadsheet has been formatted in such a way that input data will be tallied for each year.
DHW tanks to be replacedevery 20 years.
Dependent on condition, maynot be necessary.
Dependent on condition, maynot be necessary.
The Renewals Budget information provides an estimated service life and replacement cost for exterior materials and systems. The expected service life time frames are based on available manufacturers literature, warranties, and theoretical or historical industry standards. All systems and components aresubject to a wide variety of factors that affect their life expectancy including: weather exposure, quality of installation, quality of manufacture, and the quality of the ongoing maintenance program. As a result of these factors, systems and components demonstrate variations in their predicted service life, whilesome may out live the predicted life, others may not.
Estimates for future materials and labour costs are also subject to wide variations based on inflation, materials availability, and ultimately, final design decisions. While the preceding caveats must be taken in to consideration, planning for the in evitable replacement of materials is important, and should not beignored. The expected service life of products should be updated periodically based on ongoing maintenance reviews.
* Numbers in bold represent
wholesale replacement costs.
Dollar values are calculated using an assumed inflation rate of 2% per year for the 25 ye ar period.
Wholesale replacement
required within 20 years.
Boiler to be serviced annuallyand replaced every 20 years.
Domestic pipes were replacedin 2003 and to be replacedevery 20 years.
Water main pipes to beereplaced every 20 years.
BASE SCENARIO
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
38/57
$195,617
2%
1%
[ b - c ] [b - c - d + f] [a + g + h]
2012 $195,617 $316,865 $309,364 $130,000 $7,501 $0 -$122,499 $1,956 $75,074
2013 $75,074 $316,865 $315,551 $24,520 $1,313 $0 -$23,207 $751 $52,618
2014 $52,618 $316,865 $321,863 $277,080 -$4,998 $0 -$282,078 $526 -$228,934
2015 -$228,934 $316,865 $328,300 $100,640 -$11,435 $0 -$112,075 $0 -$341,009
2016 -$341,009 $316,865 $334,866 $924,210 -$18,001 $0 -$942,211 $0 -$1,283,220
2017 -$1,283,220 $316,865 $341,563 $26,780 -$24,698 $0 -$51,478 $0 -$1,334,698
2018 -$1,334,698 $316,865 $348,394 $27,380 -$31,530 $0 -$58,910 $0 -$1,393,607
2019 -$1,393,607 $316,865 $355,362 $27,990 -$38,497 $0 -$66,487 $0 -$1,460,095
2020 -$1,460,095 $316,865 $362,469 $28,600 -$45,605 $0 -$74,205 $0 -$1,534,300
2021 -$1,534,300 $316,865 $369,719 $109,220 -$52,854 $0 -$162,074 $0 -$1,696,374
2022 -$1,696,374 $316,865 $377,113 $29,850 -$60,248 $0 -$90,098 $0 -$1,786,472
2023 -$1,786,472 $316,865 $384,655 $450,510 -$67,791 $0 -$518,301 $0 -$2,304,773
2024 -$2,304,773 $316,865 $392,349 $101,180 -$75,484 $0 -$176,664 $0 -$2,481,437
2025 -$2,481,437 $316,865 $400,196 $31,860 -$83,331 $0 -$115,191 $0 -$2,596,6272026 -$2,596,627 $316,865 $408,199 $290,570 -$91,335 $0 -$381,905 $0 -$2,978,532
2027 -$2,978,532 $316,865 $416,363 $33,280 -$99,499 $0 -$132,779 $0 -$3,111,311
2028 -$3,111,311 $316,865 $424,691 $119,000 -$107,826 $0 -$226,826 $0 -$3,338,137
2029 -$3,338,137 $316,865 $433,185 $34,730 -$116,320 $0 -$151,050 $0 -$3,489,186
2030 -$3,489,186 $316,865 $441,848 $210,480 -$124,983 $0 -$335,463 $0 -$3,824,650
2031 -$3,824,650 $316,865 $450,685 $141,250 -$133,820 $0 -$275,070 $0 -$4,099,720
2032 -$4,099,720 $316,865 $459,699 $37,050 -$142,834 $0 -$179,884 $0 -$4,279,604
2033 -$4,279,604 $316,865 $468,893 $537,870 -$152,028 $0 -$689,898 $0 -$4,969,503
2034 -$4,969,503 $316,865 $478,271 $283,700 -$161,406 $0 -$445,106 $0 -$5,414,608
2035 -$5,414,608 $316,865 $487,836 $39,540 -$170,971 $0 -$210,511 $0 -$5,625,120
2036 -$5,625,120 $316,865 $497,593 $185,410 -$180,728 $0 -$366,138 $0 -$5,991,258
Year
BASE SCENARIO
(f)
Special
Assessment
(h)
Interest
Earned
(i)
Year End
Asset
(a)
Opening
Balance
(CRF for Bldg
+ Elevator)
(b)
Annual
Revenue
(Assumes no
increase)
(c )
Current
Annual
Expenses
(Assumes
annual
increase of
inflation)
(d)
Major
Expenses
Expected
(e)
Annual CRF
Contribution
(Assumes
annual
increase of
inflation)
(g)
Surplus/
Deficit
0% increase in strata fees
Total Asset as of Sept 30, 2011
Inflation
Interest Rate
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
39/57
!"#$%&
!"#$'&
!"#$(&
!"#$)&
!"#$#&
!"#$*&
!"*$+&
!"*$,&
!"*$-&
!"*$.&
!"*$%&
!"*$'&
!"*$(&
!"*$)&
!"*$#&
"*$*&
"*$#&
"*$)&
"*$(&
"*$'&
"*$%&
"*$.&
"*$-&
"*$,&
"*$+&
"#$*&
"#$#&
"#$)&
"#$(&
"#$'&
"#$%&
)*#)& )*#(& )*#'& )*#%& )*#.& )*#-& )*#,& )*#+& )*)*& )*)#& )*))& )*)(& )*)'& )*)%& )*).& )*)-& )*),& )*)+& )*(*& )*(#& )*()& )*((& )*('& )*(%& )*(.&
!"#$&!'(
)*+,,+"-.
/+01%&2134.%
53#1%671-34+"%3$%!81,#13%/144371%9%:14"%;-7413#1%+-%6$43$3%
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
40/57
APPENDIX B
PROPOSED MAINTENANCE AND RENEWALS TABLE AND
FINANCIAL TABLE FOR THE FOUR PROPOSED SCENARIOS
Yearly Forecasted Revenues and Expenses Assuming 2% Inflation for:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Chelsea Terrace - 1040 Pacific Street, Vancouver, BC
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
41/57
October 2011 Page 1 of 3
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITY
REVENUE
Strata Fee$267,735 $273,089 $278,551 $284,122 $289,805 $295,601 $301,513 $307,543 $313,694 $319,968 $326,367 $332,895 $339,552 $346,344 $353,270 $360,336 $367,543 $374,893 $382,391 $390,039 $397,840 $405,797 $413,913 $422,191 $430,635
Laundry Income$17,000 $17,340 $17,687 $18,041 $18,401 $18,769 $19,145 $19,528 $19,918 $20,317 $20,723 $21,137 $21,560 $21,991 $22,431 $22,880 $23,337 $23,804 $24,280 $24,766 $25,261 $25,766 $26,282 $26,807 $27,343
Move In/Out Fee$ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 78 5 $ 1, 82 1 $ 1, 85 7 $ 1, 89 4 $ 1, 93 2 $ 1, 97 1 $ 2, 01 0 $ 2, 05 0 $ 2, 09 1 $ 2, 13 3 $ 2, 17 6 $ 2, 21 9 $ 2, 26 4 $ 2, 30 9 $ 2, 35 5 $ 2, 40 2 $ 2, 45 0 $ 2, 49 9 $ 2, 54 9 $ 2, 60 0 $ 2, 65 2 $ 2, 70 5 $ 2, 76 0 $ 2, 81 5
Parking Income$29,880 $30,478 $31,087 $31,709 $32,343 $32,990 $33,650 $34,323 $35,009 $35,709 $36,424 $37,152 $37,895 $38,653 $39,426 $40,215 $41,019 $41,839 $42,676 $43,530 $44,400 $45,288 $46,194 $47,118 $48,060
Fobs/Keys/Remotes$500 $510 $520 $531 $541 $552 $563 $574 $586 $598 $609 $622 $634 $647 $660 $673 $686 $700 $714 $728 $743 $758 $773 $788 $804
Prior Year's Surplus$27,077
(E) TOTAL REVENUE $343,942 $323,202 $329,666 $336,259 $342,985 $349,844 $356,841 $363,978 $371,258 $378,683 $386,256 $393,982 $401,861 $409,898 $418,096 $426,458 $434,987 $443,687 $452,561 $461,612 $470,844 $480,261 $489,867 $499,664 $509,657
(F) ACTUAL TOTALREVENUE
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Administrative Expenses$77,000 $78,540 $80,111 $81,713 $83,347 $85,014 $86,715 $88,449 $90,218 $92,022 $93,863 $95,740 $97,655 $99,608 $101,600 $103,632 $105,704 $107,819 $109,975 $112,174 $114,418 $116,706 $119,040 $121,421 $123,850
Employee Expenses$32,424 $33,073 $33,734 $34,409 $35,097 $35,799 $36,515 $37,245 $37,990 $38,750 $39,525 $40,315 $41,122 $41,944 $42,783 $43,639 $44,511 $45,402 $46,310 $47,236 $48,181 $49,144 $50,127 $51,130 $52,152
Utilities$72,850 $74,307 $75,793 $77,309 $78,855 $80,432 $82,041 $83,682 $85,355 $87,062 $88,804 $90,580 $92,391 $94,239 $96,124 $98,047 $100,007 $102,008 $104,048 $106,129 $108,251 $110,416 $112,625 $114,877 $117,175
General Repair &Maintenance $40,000 $40,800 $41,616 $42,448 $43,297 $44,163 $45,046 $45,947 $46,866 $47,804 $48,760 $49,735 $50,730 $51,744 $52,779 $53,835 $54,911 $56,010 $57,130 $58,272 $59,438 $60,627 $61,839 $63,076 $64,337
Window Cleaning &Maintenance $8,000 $8,160 $8,323 $8,490 $8,659 $8,833 $9,009 $9,189 $9,373 $9,561 $9,752 $9,947 $10,146 $10,349 $10,556 $10,767 $10,982 $11,202 $11,426 $11,654 $11,888 $12,125 $12,368 $12,615 $12,867
Power Washing$ 3, 50 0 $ 3, 57 0 $ 3, 64 1 $ 3, 71 4 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 4 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 0 $ 4, 10 1 $ 4, 18 3 $ 4, 26 6 $ 4, 35 2 $ 4, 43 9 $ 4, 52 8 $ 4, 61 8 $ 4, 711 $ 4, 80 5 $ 4, 90 1 $ 4, 99 9 $ 5, 09 9 $ 5, 20 1 $ 5, 30 5 $ 5, 411 $ 5, 51 9 $ 5, 63 0
Landscaping Maintenance $ 5, 20 0 $ 5, 30 4 $ 5, 41 0 $ 5, 51 8 $ 5, 62 9 $ 5, 74 1 $ 5, 85 6 $ 5, 97 3 $ 6, 09 3 $ 6, 21 4 $ 6, 33 9 $ 6, 46 6 $ 6, 59 5 $ 6, 72 7 $ 6, 86 1 $ 6, 99 9 $ 7, 13 8 $ 7, 28 1 $ 7, 42 7 $ 7, 57 5 $ 7, 72 7 $ 7, 88 1 $ 8, 03 9 $ 8, 20 0 $ 8, 36 4
Irrigation$750 $765 $780 $796 $812 $828 $845 $862 $879 $896 $914 $933 $951 $970 $990 $1,009 $1,030 $1,050 $1,071 $1,093 $1,114 $1,137 $1,159 $1,183 $1,206
EXPENSES
Statutory Review of Books,Additional Services, BankCharges, Insurance, OfficeSupplies, Telephone, & Misc.
NOTESEXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
Caretaker Wage
Electricity, Gas, Water &Sewer
an enance cos ncu escleaning and replacing failedunits. Expect maintenancecost to decrease oncewindows are upgraded.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
EXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
ParkingLotCleaning
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
42/57
October 2011 Page 2 of 3
Parking Lot Cleaning$ 1, 00 0 $ 1, 02 0 $ 1, 04 0 $ 1, 06 1 $ 1, 08 2 $ 1, 10 4 $ 1, 12 6 $ 1, 14 9 $ 1, 17 2 $ 1, 19 5 $ 1, 21 9 $ 1, 24 3 $ 1, 26 8 $ 1, 29 4 $ 1, 31 9 $ 1, 34 6 $ 1, 37 3 $ 1, 40 0 $ 1, 42 8 $ 1, 45 7 $ 1, 48 6 $ 1, 51 6 $ 1, 54 6 $ 1, 57 7 $ 1, 60 8
Carpet Cleaning$ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Mechanical Repairs &Maintenance $ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Plumbing Repairs &Maintenance $ 5, 00 0 $ 5, 10 0 $ 5, 20 2 $ 5, 30 6 $ 5, 41 2 $ 5, 52 0 $ 5, 63 1 $ 5, 74 3 $ 5, 85 8 $ 5, 97 5 $ 6, 09 5 $ 6, 21 7 $ 6, 34 1 $ 6, 46 8 $ 6, 59 7 $ 6, 72 9 $ 6, 86 4 $ 7, 00 1 $ 7, 14 1 $ 7, 28 4 $ 7, 43 0 $ 7, 57 8 $ 7, 73 0 $ 7, 88 4 $ 8, 04 2
Pool/Spa Chemicals &Maintenance $ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Elevator Inspection, Repair,Maintenance & License $10,550 $10,761 $10,976 $11,196 $11,420 $11,648 $11,881 $12,119 $12,361 $12,608 $12,860 $13,118 $13,380 $13,648 $13,921 $14,199 $14,483 $14,773 $15,068 $15,369 $15,677 $15,990 $16,310 $16,636 $16,969
Fire Protection & AlarmMonitoring $ 3, 96 5 $ 4, 04 4 $ 4, 12 5 $ 4, 20 8 $ 4, 29 2 $ 4, 37 8 $ 4, 46 5 $ 4, 55 5 $ 4, 64 6 $ 4, 73 9 $ 4, 83 3 $ 4, 93 0 $ 5, 02 9 $ 5, 12 9 $ 5, 23 2 $ 5, 33 6 $ 5, 44 3 $ 5, 55 2 $ 5, 66 3 $ 5, 77 6 $ 5, 89 2 $ 6, 01 0 $ 6, 13 0 $ 6, 25 2 $ 6, 37 7
Emergency GeneratorMonitoring $ 1, 20 0 $ 1, 22 4 $ 1, 24 8 $ 1, 27 3 $ 1, 29 9 $ 1, 32 5 $ 1, 35 1 $ 1, 37 8 $ 1, 40 6 $ 1, 43 4 $ 1, 46 3 $ 1, 49 2 $ 1, 52 2 $ 1, 55 2 $ 1, 58 3 $ 1, 61 5 $ 1, 64 7 $ 1, 68 0 $ 1, 71 4 $ 1, 74 8 $ 1, 78 3 $ 1, 81 9 $ 1, 85 5 $ 1, 89 2 $ 1, 93 0
Enterphone$ 97 5 $ 99 5 $ 1, 01 4 $ 1, 03 5 $ 1, 05 5 $ 1, 07 6 $ 1, 09 8 $ 1, 12 0 $ 1, 14 2 $ 1, 16 5 $ 1, 18 9 $ 1, 21 2 $ 1, 23 7 $ 1, 26 1 $ 1, 28 6 $ 1, 31 2 $ 1, 33 8 $ 1, 36 5 $ 1, 39 3 $ 1, 42 0 $ 1, 44 9 $ 1, 47 8 $ 1, 50 7 $ 1, 53 7 $ 1, 56 8
Security$ 1, 50 0 $ 1, 53 0 $ 1, 56 1 $ 1, 59 2 $ 1, 62 4 $ 1, 65 6 $ 1, 68 9 $ 1, 72 3 $ 1, 75 7 $ 1, 79 3 $ 1, 82 8 $ 1, 86 5 $ 1, 90 2 $ 1, 94 0 $ 1, 97 9 $ 2, 01 9 $ 2, 05 9 $ 2, 10 0 $ 2, 14 2 $ 2, 18 5 $ 2, 22 9 $ 2, 27 3 $ 2, 31 9 $ 2, 36 5 $ 2, 41 3
Lighting$500 $510 $520 $531 $541 $552 $563 $574 $586 $598 $609 $622 $634 $647 $660 $673 $686 $700 $714 $728 $743 $758 $773 $788 $804
Locks/Keys$ 1, 75 0 $ 1, 78 5 $ 1, 82 1 $ 1, 85 7 $ 1, 89 4 $ 1, 93 2 $ 1, 97 1 $ 2, 01 0 $ 2, 05 0 $ 2, 09 1 $ 2, 13 3 $ 2, 17 6 $ 2, 21 9 $ 2, 26 4 $ 2, 30 9 $ 2, 35 5 $ 2, 40 2 $ 2, 45 0 $ 2, 49 9 $ 2, 54 9 $ 2, 60 0 $ 2, 65 2 $ 2, 70 5 $ 2, 76 0 $ 2, 81 5
Pest Control$ 3, 50 0 $ 3, 57 0 $ 3, 64 1 $ 3, 71 4 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 4 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 0 $ 4, 10 1 $ 4, 18 3 $ 4, 26 6 $ 4, 35 2 $ 4, 43 9 $ 4, 52 8 $ 4, 61 8 $ 4, 711 $ 4, 80 5 $ 4, 90 1 $ 4, 99 9 $ 5, 09 9 $ 5, 20 1 $ 5, 30 5 $ 5, 411 $ 5, 51 9 $ 5, 63 0
Garbage Collection &Recycling $12,950 $13,209 $13,473 $13,743 $14,017 $14,298 $14,584 $14,875 $15,173 $15,476 $15,786 $16,102 $16,424 $16,752 $17,087 $17,429 $17,778 $18,133 $18,496 $18,866 $19,243 $19,628 $20,020 $20,421 $20,829
Snow Removal$ 2, 50 0 $ 2, 55 0 $ 2, 60 1 $ 2, 65 3 $ 2, 70 6 $ 2, 76 0 $ 2, 81 5 $ 2, 87 2 $ 2, 92 9 $ 2, 98 8 $ 3, 04 7 $ 3, 10 8 $ 3, 17 1 $ 3, 23 4 $ 3, 29 9 $ 3, 36 5 $ 3, 43 2 $ 3, 50 1 $ 3, 57 1 $ 3, 64 2 $ 3, 71 5 $ 3, 78 9 $ 3, 86 5 $ 3, 94 2 $ 4, 02 1
Supplies$ 2, 00 0 $ 2, 04 0 $ 2, 08 1 $ 2, 12 2 $ 2, 16 5 $ 2, 20 8 $ 2, 25 2 $ 2, 29 7 $ 2, 34 3 $ 2, 39 0 $ 2, 43 8 $ 2, 48 7 $ 2, 53 6 $ 2, 58 7 $ 2, 63 9 $ 2, 69 2 $ 2, 74 6 $ 2, 80 0 $ 2, 85 6 $ 2, 91 4 $ 2, 97 2 $ 3, 03 1 $ 3, 09 2 $ 3, 15 4 $ 3, 21 7
Elevator Upgrades$ 5, 00 0 $ 5, 10 0 $ 5, 20 2 $ 5, 30 6 $ 5, 41 2 $ 5, 52 0 $ 5, 63 1 $ 5, 74 3 $ 5, 85 8 $ 5, 97 5 $ 6, 09 5 $ 6, 21 7 $ 6, 34 1 $ 6, 46 8 $ 6, 59 7 $ 6, 72 9 $ 6, 86 4 $ 7, 00 1 $ 7, 14 1 $ 7, 28 4 $ 7, 43 0 $ 7, 57 8 $ 7, 73 0 $ 7, 88 4 $ 8, 04 2
Garage Door$ 3, 00 0 $ 3, 06 0 $ 3, 12 1 $ 3, 18 4 $ 3, 24 7 $ 3, 31 2 $ 3, 37 8 $ 3, 44 6 $ 3, 51 5 $ 3, 58 5 $ 3, 65 7 $ 3, 73 0 $ 3, 80 5 $ 3, 88 1 $ 3, 95 8 $ 4, 03 8 $ 4, 11 8 $ 4, 20 1 $ 4, 28 5 $ 4, 37 0 $ 4, 45 8 $ 4, 54 7 $ 4, 63 8 $ 4, 73 1 $ 4, 82 5
Wholesale replacementrequired within 20 years.
Contract
We understand that this workis being carried out monthly bythe building manager.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
EXISTING FIXED ANNUAL REVENUE & EXPENSES
GroundImprovement
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
43/57
October 2011 Page 3 of 3
Ground Improvement$ 1, 50 0 $ 1, 53 0 $ 1, 56 1 $ 1, 59 2 $ 1, 62 4 $ 1, 65 6 $ 1, 68 9 $ 1, 72 3 $ 1, 75 7 $ 1, 79 3 $ 1, 82 8 $ 1, 86 5 $ 1, 90 2 $ 1, 94 0 $ 1, 97 9 $ 2, 01 9 $ 2, 05 9 $ 2, 10 0 $ 2, 14 2 $ 2, 18 5 $ 2, 22 9 $ 2, 27 3 $ 2, 31 9 $ 2, 36 5 $ 2, 41 3
Mechanical$ 4, 50 0 $ 4, 59 0 $ 4, 68 2 $ 4, 77 5 $ 4, 87 1 $ 4, 96 8 $ 5, 06 8 $ 5, 16 9 $ 5, 27 2 $ 5, 37 8 $ 5, 48 5 $ 5, 59 5 $ 5, 70 7 $ 5, 82 1 $ 5, 93 8 $ 6, 05 6 $ 6, 17 8 $ 6, 30 1 $ 6, 42 7 $ 6, 55 6 $ 6, 68 7 $ 6, 82 0 $ 6, 95 7 $ 7, 09 6 $ 7, 23 8
Fire Equipment$ 2, 25 0 $ 2, 29 5 $ 2, 34 1 $ 2, 38 8 $ 2, 43 5 $ 2, 48 4 $ 2, 53 4 $ 2, 58 5 $ 2, 63 6 $ 2, 68 9 $ 2, 74 3 $ 2, 79 8 $ 2, 85 4 $ 2, 911 $ 2, 96 9 $ 3, 02 8 $ 3, 08 9 $ 3, 15 1 $ 3, 21 4 $ 3, 27 8 $ 3, 34 3 $ 3, 41 0 $ 3, 47 8 $ 3, 54 8 $ 3, 61 9
(G) TOTAL EXPENSES $309,364 $315,551 $321,863 $328,300 $334,866 $341,563 $348,394 $355,362 $362,469 $369,719 $377,113 $384,655 $392,349 $400,196 $408,199 $416,363 $424,691 $433,185 $441,848 $450,685 $459,699 $468,893 $478,271 $487,836 $497,593
(H) ACTUAL TOTALEXPENSES
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Adjusted Yearly Maintenance / Renewals Expenditures for:
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
Chelsea Terrace - 1040 Pacific Street, Vancouver, BC
NOTES
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
44/57
October 2011 Page 1 of 2
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036ITEM / ACTIVITY
$2,000 $2,060 $2,130 $2,200 $2,270 $2,340 $2,420 $2,500 $2,580 $2,660 $2,740 $2,830 $2,920 $3,010 $3,110 $3,210 $3,310 $3,410 $3,520 $3,630 $3,740 $3,860 $3,980 $4,100 $4,230
SBS Roofing MembraneReplacement of Main Roofs $300,000
SBS Roofing MembraneReplacement of Lower Tier
Roofs
$45,000
Exterior Wall SealantReplacement $53,000 $70,000 $95,000
Windows / Doors
Replacement $150,000 $150,000 $150,000
Balcony MembraneReplacement $55,000 $12,360 $12,740 $13,13 0 $13,530 $13,9 40 $14,360 $14,800 $1 5,250 $15,710 $16,190 $ 16,680 $17,190 $17,710 $18,25 0 $18,800 $1 9,370 $19,960 $20,560 $ 21,180 $21,820 $22,480 $23,16 0 $23,860 $2 4,580
New Rain Water CollectionSystem $32,000
Roof Deck Condition Review$2,000
Plaza Deck MembraneReplacement $ 80 ,0 00 $ 82 ,0 00 $ 84 ,0 00
$135,000 $180,000 $120,000
$5,000 $5,150 $5,310 $5,470 $5,640 $5,810 $5,990 $6,170 $6,360 $6,560 $6,760 $6,970 $7,180 $7,400 $7,630 $7,860 $8,100 $8,350 $8,610 $8,870 $9,140 $9,420 $9,710 $10,010 $10,320
$85,000 $150,000
$65,000 $85,000
Professional BuildingEnvelope Review $13,000 $15,000 $18,000 $20,000 $25,000
(A) Total Cost for BldgExterior & General Site
Issues per year$ 10 7,0 00 $ 19 ,5 70 $ 27 2, 18 0 $ 10 2,8 00 $ 25 3, 44 0 $ 32 2,0 90 $ 22 ,7 70 $ 17 3, 47 0 $ 17 4,1 90 $ 25 4, 93 0 $ 25 ,6 90 $ 26 ,4 80 $ 97 ,2 90 $ 28 ,1 20 $ 22 6,9 90 $ 29 ,8 70 $ 30 ,7 80 $ 31 ,7 20 $ 32 ,6 90 $ 13 8,6 80 $ 34 ,7 00 $ 35 ,7 60 $ 28 1,8 50 $ 37 ,9 70 $ 18 4,1 30
(B) Actual Amount Spent for
Bldg Exterior & General SiteIssues
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Waterproofing of concreteslabs to be done every 20years.
Waterproofing ConcreteParkade Ramp, Pedestrian
Ramp and Stairs
Carpet Replacement &Interior Painting of Common
Areas
*Numbers in bold representwholesale replacement costs.
Carpet to be cleaned annually.Replacement of carpet andrepainting interior walls tooccur every 10 years.
Intermediate review may benecessary based on findings.
Annual Cleaning(Windows, Doors, ExteriorCladding, Glass Canopies,
Guardrails, Decks, & Patios)
Roofing Maintenance(Misc. maintenance and repairs
to membranes, drains andflashing)
Exterior Painting andWaterproofing Sealer
(Exterior Cladding)
NOTES
Old sealant must be removedto facilitate proper applicationof new sealant.
Review should be carried outby an RCABC approvedcontractor.
Roofing Maintenance shouldbe carried out by an RCABCapproved contractor
To replace with 2-ply SBSroofing membrane.
To replace with 2-ply SBSroofing membrane.
New rain water collectionsystem to collect water anddirect down to the ground.
Upper balcony membranes tobe replaced as soon aspossible. The rest of themembranes to be replaced asneeded on an annual basis.
RECOMMENDED ANNUAL MAINTENANCE/RENEWALS EXPENSES
Replace existing membranewith SBS membrane in threephases.
Exterior cladding to be painted
and sealed every 10 years.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 252012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 2033 2034 2035 2036
ITEM / ACTIVITYNOTES
RECOMMENDED ANNUAL MAINTENANCE/RENEWALS EXPENSES
Boiler Service &$ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
45/57
October 2011 Page 2 of 2
Replacement $20,000 $2,060 $2,130 $2,200 $2,270 $2,340 $2,420 $2,500 $2,580 $2,660 $2,740 $2,830 $2,920 $3,010 $3,110 $3,210 $3,310 $3,410 $3,520 $35,000 $3,740 $3,860 $3,980 $4,100 $4,230
Domestic Pipes Replacement$200,000 $200,000
Water Mains Replacement$60,000
Drainage Pipes Maintenance$2,000 $2,060 $2,130 $2,200 $2,270 $2,340 $2,420 $2,500 $2,580 $2,660 $2,740 $2,830 $2,920 $3,010 $3,110 $3,210 $3,310 $3,410 $3,520 $3,630 $3,740 $3,860 $3,980 $4,100 $4,230
Elevator Replacement$175,000
DHW Tanks Replacement$20,000
Valves / PumpsRepair & Replacement $1,000 $1,030 $1,070 $1,110 $1,150 $1,190 $1,230 $1,270 $1,310 $1,350 $1,400 $1,450 $1,500 $1,550 $1,600 $1,650 $1,700 $1,760 $1,820 $1,880 $1,940 $2,000 $2,060 $2,130 $2,200
Alarm Panel Upgrade$85,000
Sprinklers$250,000 $250,000
(C ) Total Cost forMech/Safety/Elec Systems
per year
$23,000 $5,150 $5,330 $5,510 $5,690 $5,870 $6,070 $6,270 $6,470 $6,670 $6,880 $227,110 $207,340 $7,570 $67,820 $8,070 $93,320 $8,580 $183,860 $40,510 $9,420 $259,720 $10,020 $260,330 $10,660
(D) Actual Amount Spent onMech/Safety/Elec Systems
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
PROJECTED TOTAL(A + C) per year
$130, 000 $24 ,720 $277, 510 $108, 310 $259, 130 $327, 960 $28 ,840 $179, 740 $180, 660 $261, 600 $32 ,570 $253, 590 $304, 630 $35 ,690 $294, 810 $37 ,940 $124, 100 $40 ,300 $216, 550 $179, 190 $44 ,120 $295, 480 $291, 870 $298, 300 $194, 790ACTUAL TOTAL(B + D) per year
$0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0
Wholesale replacement
required within 20 years.
Boiler to be serviced annuallyand replaced every 20 years.
Domestic pipes were replacedin 2003 and to be replacedevery 20 years.
Water main pipes to beereplaced every 20 years.
The preceding tables should be taken as an initial guideline only. Actual expenditure amounts should be input into the empty row provided below each item. The spreadsheet has been formatted in such a way that input data will be tallied for each year.
DHW tanks to be replacedevery 20 years.
Dependent on condition, maynot be necessary.
Dependent on condition, maynot be necessary.
The Renewals Budget information provides an estimated service life and replacement cost for exterior materials and systems. The expected service life time frames are based on available manufacturers literature, warranties, and theoretical or historical industry standards. All systems and components aresubject to a wide variety of factors that affect their life expectancy including: weather exposure, quality of installation, quality of manufacture, and the quality of the ongoing maintenance program. As a result of these factors, systems and components demonstrate variations in their predicted service life, whilesome may out live the predicted life, others may not.
Estimates for future materials and labour costs are also subject to wide variations based on inflation, materials availability, and ultimately, final design decisions. While the preceding caveats must be taken in to consideration, planning for the in evitable replacement of materials is important, and should not beignored. The expected service life of products should be updated periodically based on ongoing maintenance reviews.
* Numbers in bold represent
wholesale replacement costs.
Dollar values are calculated using an assumed inflation rate of 2% per year for the 25 ye ar period.
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
46/57
APPENDIX C
SCENARIO 1 FINANCIAL ANALYSIS TABLE
AND GRAPH
SCENARIO 1
-
7/29/2019 McCuaig & Associates-CRF Study (Oct 2011)
47/57
$195,617 Fee Increases: 2.0%
2%
1%
[ b - c ] [b - c - d + f] [a + g + h]
2012 $195,617 $322,219 $309,364 $130,000 $12,855 $0 -$117,145 $1,956 $80,428
2013 $80,428 $327,681 $315,551 $24,720 $12,130 $0 -$12,590 $804 $68,643
2014 $68,643 $333,252 $321,863 $277,510 $11,390 $300,000 $33,880 $686 $103,209
2015 $103,209 $338,935 $328,300 $108,310 $10,635 $0 -$97,675 $1,032 $6,566
2016 $6,566 $344,731 $334,866 $259,130 $9,865 $600,000 $350,735 $66 $357,367
2017 $357,367 $350,643 $341,563 $327,960 $9,080 $0 -$318,880 $3,574 $42,060
2018 $42,060 $356,673 $348,394 $28,840 $8,279 $0 -$20,561 $421 $21,919
2019 $21,919 $362,824 $355,362 $179,740 $7,462 $350,000 $177,722 $219 $199,860
2020 $199,860 $369,098 $362,469 $180,660 $6,628 $0 -$174,032 $1,999 $27,827
2021 $27,827 $375,497 $369,719 $261,600 $5,778 $300,000 $44,178 $278 $72,284
2022 $72,284 $391,851 $377,113 $32,570 $14,737 $0 -$17,833 $723 $55,174
2023 $55,174 $398,508 $384,655 $253,590 $13,853 $550,000 $310,263 $552 $365,989
2024 $365,9