Medicare’s New Alphabet SoupMm’m Good? The Beneficiary’s
Perspective
-- Families USA Conference --
January 26, 2007
Presenter: David Lipschutz
California Health Advocates
California Health Advocates 2
Outline
I. Benefits & Drawbacks of Medicare Health Plans (Overview)
II. Medicare Modernization Act (MMA)
III. Types of Medicare Advantage Plans
IV. Marketing of Medicare Advantage Plans
California Health Advocates 3
I. Benefits & Drawbacks of Medicare Health Plans (Overview)
California Health Advocates 4
Benefits of Medicare Health Plans
Medicare HMOs, until recently, were only real option for most Medicare beneficiaries
Beneficiaries drawn to plans because generally lower out-of-pocket costs than original Medicare, and often additional benefitsE.g. limited prescription drug coverage prior
to Part D
California Health Advocates 5
Drawbacks of Medicare Health Plans
Choice of providers often limited – health plans generally have networks of contracting providers members “locked-in” to plan network
In HMOs, often a primary care physician acts as a “gatekeeper” to specialists and other services
California Health Advocates 6
II. Medicare Modernization Act (MMA)
California Health Advocates 7
Medicare Modernization Act
The Medicare Modernization Act (MMA) increased incentives for insurance companies to offer plans
As a result, the types of plans and numbers of plans increased greatly
At the same time, rules restricting individuals’ rights to enroll in, switch, or disenroll from plans went into effect
California Health Advocates 8
Basics – PDP v. MA-PD
Stand alone prescription drug plans (PDP) Coordinate with Original Medicare, and some
Medicare Advantage plans (see below)
Medicare Advantage (MA) Enrollees generally obtain all Medicare-
covered care through private plan MA plan that does not offer Part D coverage
(MA or MA-only)MA plan that offers Part D coverage (MA-PD)
California Health Advocates 9
III. Types of Medicare Advantage Plans
California Health Advocates 10
Medicare Advantage Plans
3 Types of MA plans:Coordinated Care Plans (HMOs, PPOs,
SNPs)Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS) PlansMedicare Medical Savings Accounts
(MSAs)
California Health Advocates 11
MA Plans and Other Part D Coverage
Individuals enrolled in an MA coordinated care plan (HMO, PPO, SNP) cannot also be enrolled in a PDP, even if MA plan does not provide Part D coverage
PFFS enrollees – if plan does not offer Part D coverage, can enroll in a PDP
MSAs cannot offer Part D coverage, so enrollees can also enroll in a PDP
California Health Advocates 12
Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs)
For many years, the only real option through Medicare Advantage (formerly Medicare+Choice)
Well entrenched in certain parts of CANetwork of contracting providers,
generally lower cost-sharing than Original Medicare, some additional benefits
California Health Advocates 13
Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs)
Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) is a plan that has a network of providers who have agreed to a specific payment rate for covered benefits with the plan
Plan provides for all covered benefits regardless of whether the benefits are provided within the network of providers
CA – limited enrollment, experience with these plansProblems primarily with people who were not aware
of high deductible and those who sought a different type of plan (e.g. Medigap) from same sponsor
California Health Advocates 14
Special Needs Plans (SNPs)
A coordinated care plan that exclusively enrolls (or enrolls a disproportionate %) of special needs individuals:Dual eligibles (Medicare and Medi-Cal, possibly MSP)Institutionalized – individual who continuously
resides, or who is expected to reside, for 90 days of longer in a long-term care facility (skilled nursing facility (SNF); nursing facility (NF); intermediate care facility for mentally retarded (ICF/MR); or inpatient psychiatric facility; (may also includes those in community but requiring a nursing home level of care)
Individuals with chronic or disabling conditions
California Health Advocates 15
Special Needs Plans (SNPs)
Potential to use specialists, case management, other tailored services to provide better coordinated care
Potential to coordinate with state Medicaid coveragenot currently required to require their network
providers to participate in Medicaid and their network pharmacies to attempt to bill Medicaid when Medicare drug coverage is denied
Some of the same restrictions as most other MA plans (e.g. limited networks, referrals, etc.)
California Health Advocates 16
Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS)
PFFS plans do not limit enrollees to a network of doctors or hospitals; enrollees can go to any Medicare provider as long as provider is willing to accept the PFFS plan’s fees and terms
Care is generally not “coordinated” Relationship between an individual
provider and plan is key factor re: PFFS plans
California Health Advocates 17
PFFS Provider Types
When a PFFS enrollee obtains services from a provider, for those services a provider is classified into one of 3 provider types: Direct-contracting – provider has a direct,
signed contract with planDeemed-contracting – provider is “deemed”
as contracting with plan Non-contracting – provider does not have a
direct contract and is not deemed
California Health Advocates 18
PFFS Provider Types
Deemed-contracting – provider is “deemed” as contracted if:Provider is aware in advance of furnishing services
that individual is in the PFFS plan;Provider has reasonable access to the plan’s terms
and conditions of participation; If plan makes this information available
through postal service, e-mail, FAX, telephone or website
The service provided is covered by the plan
California Health Advocates 19
Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS)
Benefits – generally have cost-sharing similar to other MA plans and may have maximum out of pocket limits for Medicare covered services
But beware of certain rules … Example: Today’s Options in CA
DME – if no pre-approval sought, could pay up to 50% of costs (instead of 20%)
Disadvantage: Some providers may be unwilling to treat PFFS enrollees
California Health Advocates 20
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
MSAs have 2 parts: High Deductible Health Plan – MA plan that
covers Part A and B benefits once high deductible is met
Medical Savings Account – independent bank account owned by the member into which Medicare makes a deposit; members can use funds to pay for healthcare services
California Health Advocates 21
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
Medical Savings Account Must establish an MSA with designated bank,
which will issue debit card, checkbook Medicare will make one, annual deposit into
account in the beginning of the year Members may not make deposits into this
account Unused amounts roll over in subsequent yearsIf not enough $ in account to meet plan
deductible, enrollee must pay using own $ until deductible is met
California Health Advocates 22
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
Medical Savings Account (Cont’d)Funds not subject to federal taxes if used for
“qualified health expenses”See IRS Publication 502
Use of funds to pay Part D premiums not “qualified” but payment for Part D copays, coinsurance and deductibles is qualified (and these payments will count towards TrOOP)
California Health Advocates 23
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
Health plan/policy Medicare pays premium ($0 for enrollee)Only expenses for Medicare-covered services
will apply towards deductibleWhat Medicare + beneficiary would pay in FFS
Once deductible is met, plan pays 100% for Medicare covered services (Parts A & B)
No provider network – like PFFS plan, providers must agree to deliver services to enrollees
California Health Advocates 24
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs) (CA Example)
Plan Deductible Deposit Amount Gap/Deficit
$2,500 (SmartSaver I)
$1,000 $1,500
$3,500 (SmartSaver II)
$1,375 $2,125
$4,500 (SmartSaver III)
$1,725 $2,775
California Health Advocates 25
Medical Savings Accounts (MSAs)
Restrictions on enrollment : Medicaid EGHP, retiree coverageVA, FEHBP, MedigapAny coverage that would pay for services
before deductible is met Hospice patients ESRD (like all other MA plans)If live in U.S. less than 183 days a year
California Health Advocates 26
IV. Marketing of Medicare Advantage Plans
California Health Advocates 27
Marketing of MA Plans
Number of factors converge to make informed decision making/choice more difficult for Medicare beneficiaries
Great increase in numbers and types of plans being offered, with minimal oversight of marketingMany sponsors offering multiple products (PDP,
PFFS, Medigap, etc.)Many agents selling multiple products
Lock-in rules mean limited opportunities to change plans
California Health Advocates 28
Marketing of MA Plans
Multiple plans/variations not always understood by agents and beneficiariesSome MA rules, benefit designs not
adequately explained (e.g. PFFS rules, PPO deductibles, etc.)
Plans can pay higher commissions to agents for MA enrollments vs. PDP enrollmentsEx. “enroll and migrate” strategy
California Health Advocates 29
Marketing of MA Plans
Beware: dual eligibles being targeted for plans that may be inappropriate for them Agents aggressively selling PFFS plans Using lists of same sponsor’s PDP enrollees
Beware – new enrollment period allows PFFS plans w/ no Part D benefit to market year round