Microinsurance
Core concepts to structure microinsurance products
Brandon Mathews
World Bank Workshop Uganda2 March 2009
Microinsurance2
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Agenda of core product issues
IncentivesUtility for customers (demand)Utility for providers (supply)
TechnicalInsurance & operational risksPartners and intermediariesCustomer needs
Microinsurance3
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Agenda of core product issues
IncentivesUtility for customers (demand)Utility for providers (supply)
TechnicalInsurance & operational risksPartners and intermediariesCustomer needs
Microinsurance4
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Utility… insurance must be useful for those that use it (that have a claim).
Ten people know there’s a risk event that they believe costs $30 and it will happen to one of them so ten buy insurance.
For the one that claims, insurance must Correctly pay incurred losses.Pay in time to be useful.Pay in a way that is useful.Be in a useful amount.
Make certain that the claims benefit suits customer requirements
Microinsurance5
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
… should be useful for those that don’t use it (don’t claim).
Nine people bought the insurance but didn’t have a claim… but also no longer saved toward the $30 event.
Insurance should allow:Release of savingsAcceptance of ordinary risk.
Good insurance changes the behavior of the insured.
Microinsurance6
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
… perhaps will be useful for those that don’t even buy it.
Ten insurance buyers live in a community of twenty people.The $30 claim pays for services that otherwise aren’t available.
Insurance allows services to form that eventually can also serve the uninsured.
Microinsurance7
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Customer utility affects product design…
Products that benefit the claimant directly and sufficiently are more valued and will drive sales over the medium term.
Products that benefit non-claimants are more valued.Voluntary purchases are more likely to have proven their use
Products that deliver services directly add utility.Funeral / burial insuranceMedical services instead of reimbursement.
Microinsurance8
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Agenda of core product issues
IncentivesUtility for customers (demand)Utility for providers (supply)
TechnicalInsurance & operational risksPartners and intermediariesCustomer needs
Microinsurance9
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Providers should supply microinsurance out of self-interest.
Insurance capital, opportunity, & other costs exist.
Demand is marginally affected, at best, by profitability. Whether the premium in my example was $3.00, $2.90, or $3.10:
Person whose claim was paid is better offPeople that didn’t claim assessed experience based on total priceFormation of services for non-buyers is not affected
Possible to justify with some other benefits:Employee moral – good to work for a company that is good.Innovation – disaggregating value-chain improves performance.Alignment with other market actors.
Microinsurance10
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Provider utility impacts product design…
Corporate responsibility is to try to make a profit in this space… not just CR on its own.
To continuously lower the median income of customers requires profit.
Microinsurance11
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Agenda of core product issues
IncentivesUtility for customers (demand)Utility for providers (supply)
TechnicalInsurance & operational risksPartners and intermediariesCustomer needs
Microinsurance12
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Microinsurance products require that we modify in 3 basic dimensions
Insurance Risk Operational Risk
New partners
Existing partnersNew Customers
Existing Customers
Microinsurance13
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Agenda of core product issues
IncentivesUtility for customers (demand)Utility for providers (supply)
TechnicalInsurance & operational risksPartners and intermediariesCustomer needs and situations
Microinsurance14
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Direct expenses (operational risk) and commissions are knowable factors.
Mostcustomers
Wealthycustomers
Microcustomers
Claims
DirectCapitalComms
Microinsurance15
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Innovate over time to gain profit and then to improve market position.
Immediate Mid term Over time
Higher ERLower LR
Acceptable CR
Lower ERHigher LR
Attractive CRthrough innovation
Lower RateSame ERSame LR
Acceptable CRand increasemarket share
Same RateSame ERHigher LR
Acceptable CRand increasepenetration
Microinsurance16
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Product design must reduce or anticipate operational requirements.
Pre-underwritten one-price-fits-all
Make obvious who the product targetsFemale health insuranceSpecific item property
Timing of cashflows should be pricedCash maybe collected any time during a monthMore frequent cancel/rewrite possible
In-kind claims benefits reduces moral hazardWarrantyProsthesis vs payment
Reducing operationalrisks often systemicallybenefits insurance risk.
Microinsurance17
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Control and anticipate operational risk in each step of product rollout.
Start with products that require the fewest changes from present:
Sell through a known intermediary typeSell products with a low operational risk
Progress to products that require organizational adaptation.
Microinsurance18
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Do we need to reinvent the wheel?
Credit: Q-Drum
Microinsurance19
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Zurich programs have grown more ambitious over the years.
BoliviaCredit Life -> Savings Linked -> Health -> Retail PABank -> Bank -> Bank -> Multiple channels
VenezuelaCredit Life -> Credit Auto -> Voluntary Pick FourBank -> Bank -> Bank / Multiple
BrazilPersonal Accident -> Unemployment -> Small propertyRetailers -> Utilities
Microinsurance20
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Zurich programs have grown more ambitious over the years. (2)
ChinaPersonal Accident -> Critical IllnessAgent -> Agent to group
IndonesiaCredit PA/Property -> CattleBank -> Bank
South AfricaFuneral/Property -> Credit lifeAgent -> Bank
Microinsurance21
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Sequence products realistically for value and operational achievement.
Customers value products whichThey know aboutThey choose to purchaseThat deliver when it matters
Insurance companies value products whichLimit operational risk in implementationCreate innovation value for other lines/segmentsDeliver profit
Microinsurance22
© Z
urich
Fin
ancia
l Ser
vice
s
3/1/2009
Thank you
Brandon MathewsZurich Financial Services
[email protected]: +41 (0)44 639 2000
www.zurich.com