-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
1/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 1
Running Head: YOGA, MINDFULNESS AND WELL-BEING
Yoga, Mindfulness, and Self- Reported Well-being: Do Yogis Report Better Well-being
Than Those Practicing Other Types of Fitness?
Dianna Defrenza
York University
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
2/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 2
Abstract
Mindfulness, or the practice of focused awareness on the present as it unfolds, has been
found to have enormous psychological and physical health benefits (resulting in greater
objective and subjective well-being) in the context of treatment and intervention strategies.
Currently, yoga practice in western society encourages the cultivation of mindfulness, as
well as physical strength and flexibility. The present study examines whether mindfulness
cultivated through regular yoga practice is related to greater subjective well-being, and
whether individuals that practice yoga differ significantly from those that practice other
types of physical fitness (non-yoga practitioners). Also of interest is whether mindfulness
and well-being are correlated in non-intervention populations. Yoga practitioners (N= 31)
and non-yoga practitioners (N= 31) were compared on measures of mindfulness and
subjective well-being using the Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS) and the
Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS). There were no differences found between yoga and
non-yoga practitioners on either scale. Mindfulness was positively correlated with well-
being in the non-yoga population only. Limitations to the current study and suggestions for
future research are discussed.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
3/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 3
Yoga, Mindfulness, and Self- Reported Well-being: Do Yogis Report Better Well-being
Than Those Practicing Other Types of Fitness?
Mindfulness has repeatedly been linked with subjective and objective well-being in
psychological research (Mackenzie, Poulin, & Seidman-Carlson, 2006; Miller, Fletcher &
Kabat-Zinn, 1995; Wall, 2005; Brown & Kasser, 2005). In contemporary yoga practice,
mindfulness, strength and flexibility are fundamental to the yogi. Yogic mindfulness is
facilitated through the instruction of breathing and relaxation techniques. A reasonable
assumption is that the yoga studio is a place for the average person to become more
mindful while engaging in physical fitness. The present study was designed to assess
whether those who practice yoga for fitness are more mindful than those that participate in
other forms of fitness. In addition to examining potential differences in mindfulness
between yoga and non- yoga practicing populations, an inquiry into the differences in
subjective well-being of the two groups will be made.
The concept of mindfulness can be traced back to the genesis of Buddhist
meditative practices (Kabat-Zinn, 2003). Generally, mindfulness is a focused, non-reactive
awareness of the present moment, as it unfolds, without contemplation or elaboration into
the past or future. According to Kabat-Zinn (2003), An operational working definition of
mindfulness is: the awareness that emerges through paying attention on purpose, in the
present moment, and nonjudgementally to the unfolding of experience moment by
moment (p. 145).
The benefits of mindful cognition have led to the development of several
procedures which utilize mindfulness in the field of clinical psychology. These procedures
include Dialectical Behaviour Therapy, Acceptance and Commitment Therapy,
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
4/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 4
Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy (Hayes & Shenk, 2004) and Mindfulness Based
Stress Reduction (MBSR: Kabat-Zinn, 2003). These procedures foster mindfulness in
patients and clients using various techniques.
In a review of research, it is apparent that mindfulness is correlated with well-
being. There are many examples of mindfulness interventions that result in significant
improvement in subjective well-being. In a study conducted by Carlson and Brown (2005),
cancer patients participated in a mindfulness meditation intervention. Those who rated
higher in mindfulness reported lower mood disturbance and stress. Mackenzie et al. (2006)
used an abbreviated version of the Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) technique
(which teaches individuals how to self-regulate feelings and triggers that cause stress and
anxiety to escalate) in the nursing population. They found a significant reduction in the
nurses reported symptoms of stress and burnout following the intervention. Miller et al.
(1995) found significant improvements in subjective and objective symptoms of anxiety
and panic following an 8-week outpatientgroup stress reduction intervention based on
mindfulness meditation (p. 192). The three year follow-up was even more encouraging
because the subjects that continued compliance with meditation practice showed
maintenance of positive gains (Miller et al., 1995).
Beyond the context of therapy, some interesting findings further support the
connection between mindfulness and well-being. In 2005, Wall introduced middle school
students to Tai Chi (a type of martial art) and MBSR techniques through a five week
educational program, and found that the students reported increased well-being. Brown and
Kasser (2005) found a positive correlation between mindfulness, ecologically responsible
behaviour, and subjective well-being in samples of adolescents and adults. The
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
5/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 5
directionality of the relationship between these variables is unknown, however it is
apparent that a positive correlation between mindfulness and well-being exists.
Yoga is an ancient system of beliefs which include the practice of mindfulness
within the general philosophy of working towards a well balanced, enlightened life.
Western culture has adopted aspects of yoga as a form of physical fitness, and the
importance of cultivating mindfulness has been maintained in most contemporary practice.
As Butera (2006) explains; the psychophysical yoga health practices in classical yoga
bring relaxation to the body and concentration to the mind. The yoga practices of posture,
breathing, and relaxation serve to quiet the mind for contemplation of deeper issues (p.
203). Yoga includes the main steps of asanas (postures) and pranayama (breath control).
The postures combined with breathing techniques aim to bring the mind to a deeper state of
concentration (Butera, 2006), which is essentially the cultivation of mindfulness.
The potential benefits of mindfulness cultivated through yoga practice have largely
been unexamined. Recent studies have revealed that yoga practitioners report lower
prevalence and intensity of psychological distress than non- practitioners (Sudha, Jyotsna,
Sumita & Nalini, 2006), and it may be argued that this sense of well-being is related to
mindfulness fostered through their chosen exercise. Impett, Daubenmier and Hirshman
(2006) found that more frequent yoga practice was associated with increased body
awareness, positive affect, and satisfaction with life. Testing the effects of yoga practice on
the general population, Sharma, Yadava and Hooda (2005) found that graduate students
who completed a 10 day yoga workshop reported reduced anxiety, enhanced concentration
and increased stamina. In spite of the clear psychological and physical health benefits of
practicing yoga, there is relatively little empirical insight into the causes of these benefits.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
6/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 6
The preceding studies suggest that yoga practice increases mindfulness and in
doing so, will also be related to increased subjective well-being. It was hypothesized that
the current study would find yoga practitioners to be more mindful than those who practice
other types of organized physical fitness. In addition, it was expected that the yoga
practitioners would also report greater subjective well-being than those who practice other
forms of fitness. Mindfulness was expected to be positively correlated with subjective well-
being and it was expected that the yoga practitioner sample would rate higher on both
measures when compared with the non- yoga practitioners. It was anticipated that the
results of this study would provide additional insight into the overall health benefits of
regular yoga practice for physical fitness.
Method
Participants
A total of 62 individuals (male and female) were recruited for the study (31 recruits
for each condition: yoga and non-yoga). Participants were approached at a Moksha Yoga
Studio in Toronto, on campus at York University outside of gymnasium and athletic areas,
and at a Peel Police staff fitness area. Those in the yoga group were required to practice
yoga at least two times per week to be included in the study. Individuals in the non- yoga
group were included if they participated in any other type of organized group or individual
fitness or sport two times per week or more. Non-yoga fitness was defined as any
deliberate solitary or group activity that raised the individuals heart rate and required
physical exertion which was greater than that achieved during normal daily activities,
including walking, sitting, bending, reaching, etc.
Materials
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
7/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 7
Participants in both groups will complete the following questionnaires:
The Mindful Attention Awareness Scale (MAAS; Brown & Ryan, 2003). The
MAAS is a 15-item questionnaire which measures everyday mindfulness on a 6-point
Likert scale. A higher score on the MAAS indicates greater mindfulness. The MAAS has
been validated in populations that do not practice meditation or yoga, as well as those that
do practice mindfulness meditation, and is therefore an appropriate measure for this study
(Brown & Ryan, 2003). (see Appendix)
The Satisfaction With Life Scale (SWLS: Diener et al., 1985). The SWLS is a 5-
item questionnaire that measures subjective cognitive well- being. The SWLS requires
subjects to indicate on a 7-point Likert scale whether they agree or disagree with
statements. A higher score on the SWLS indicates greater satisfaction with life and will be
used to determine individuals subjective well- being. (see Appendix)
Procedure
Upon confirmation that the recruit qualified for either group, they were asked to
read the informed consent form and provide demographic information (age and gender). In
total there were 31 individuals in each group (N= 62). They each completed the MAAS
and SWLS and returned the questionnaires to the researcher. The subjects were not
debriefed, however the researcher was available for any questions or concerns that may
have arisen during or after they participated.
Results
Formal testing of the hypotheses in this study had largely insignificant findings.
The yoga and non-yoga groups were not found to differ significantly on either the
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
8/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 8
mindfulness (MAAS) or well-being (SWLS) measures used, as shown in Table 1. A ttest
of the differences between the MAAS scores failed to detect significance between the two
populationst(60) = -.292,p = .772. Similarly, a ttest conducted for the SWLS scores did
not reveal a significant difference between the two groups t(60) = -.754,p = .454 (see
Table 2). The yoga group had a mean mindfulness score of 61 (SD = 11), and a mean well-
being score of 25 (SD = 8); the non-yoga group had a mean score of 62 (SD = 12) and a
mean well-being score of 26 (SD = 5). These findings are contradictory to anticipated
results which expected to find that yoga practitioners would be more mindful and report
greater subjective well-being that those who practiced others forms of physical fitness.
A moderately significant positive correlation (p >.01) found between the
mindfulness and well-being using Pearsons correlation coefficient (Table 3). However,
this correlation was only significant (see Table 4) in the non-yoga population r(29) = .44,p
= .05. Thus, as mindfulness increased in the non-yoga practitioners, so did subjective well
being. In summary, mindfulness was not greater in either population and was only found to
be positively related to subjective well-being in the non-yoga population. These findings
fail to support the hypotheses of this study.
Discussion
The present study failed to detect a significant advantage of practicing yoga
over other forms of physical fitness, in the cultivation of mindfulness and subjective
well-being. The results gleaned were not only contradictory to the hypotheses of this
study, but also to the body of research related to mindfulness. A significant
difference between the yoga and non-yoga groups, and the detection of a strong
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
9/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 9
positive correlation between mindfulness and well-being for the yoga group, may
have been found with the exclusion of some of the limitations in this study.
Convenience sampling may have contributed to the results found in this study
not being representative of the population. The groups were pre-existing and
selection bias may have been a factor that impacted the current inquiry. Prior to
selecting their primary fitness activity, individuals in either group may have varied in
some systematic way. Individuals in either group may have had previous exposure to
meditation and mindfulness training. Alternatively, individuals in the yoga group
may have had lower subjective well-being or mindfulness before they initiated
regular yoga practice, when compared with people that chose other types of fitness.
Thus, yoga practice may have increased these individuals mindfulness and well-
being to a level equal to those in the comparison group. In general, subjects in this
study (who voluntarily participated) may have been systematically different than
those who did not volunteer to complete the surveys.
Limitations of time and space in this study may have also caused the results
to be inconsistent with previous findings related to mindfulness and well-being. An
experimental study with an intervention of guided yoga practice would have
controlled for differences in mindfulness instruction received by the yoga students,
variations in duration of yoga practice, as well as mindfulness and subjective well-
being prior to engaging in the chosen fitness regiment. Also, the participants
completed the questionnaires in very informal settings of a fitness area or yoga studio
lobby. The time required to complete the survey was approximately 5 minutes. These
factors may have influenced the consideration and responses that participants gave
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
10/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 10
the questionnaires; causing them to be more casual about their answers than they
would be if responding in a lab setting with a greater time commitment to participate.
This study raises several questions which are related to the difference
between mainstream yoga practice and traditional yoga practice. Is yoga practice
cultivated in a non-meditative context simply another form of physical fitness, and
not any different than activities such as swimming or running? Also, is yoga practice
in a physical fitness context systematically different than health interventions found
in psychological research which incorporate yoga in treatment? Perhaps
contemporary western yoga practice does not differ significantly from other types of
fitness in the cultivation of mindfulness, and the present study was not impacted by
its limitations. Future research of mindfulness and well-being, comparing yoga and
non-yoga practitioners would benefit from controls to external and internal
confounding variables found in this study .In any case, futher exploration of
contemporary yoga practice for fitness will undoubtedly find that yogis enjoy great
mental and physical health benefits.
References
Brown, K. W., & Kasser, T. (2005). Are psychological and ecological well-being
compatible? The role of values, mindfulness, and lifestyle. Social Indicators
Research, 74, 349-368.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
11/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 11
Brown, K. W., & Ryan, R. M. (2003). The benefits of being present: Mindfulness and its
role in psychological well-being.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 84,
822-848.
Butera, R. (2006). Yoga: An Introduction. In E. R. Mackenzie & B. Rakel (Eds)
Complementary and alternative medicine for older adults. New York: Springer
Publishing Company, Inc.
Carlson, L. E., & Brown, K. W. (2005). Validation of the mindful attention awareness scale
in a cancer population.Journal of Psychosomatic Research, 58, 29-33.
Diener, E., Emmons, R. A., Larsen, R. J., & Griffin, S. (1985). The satisfaction with life
scale.Journal of Personality Assessment, 49, 71-75.
Impett, E. A., Daubenmier, J. J., & Hirshman, A. L. (2006). Minding the body: Yoga,
embodiment, and well-being. Sexuality Research & Social Policy: A Journal of the
NSRC, 3, 39-48.
Kabat-Zinn, J. (2003). Mindfulness-based interventions in context: Past, present, and
future. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 10, 144-156.
Mackenzie, C. S., Poulin, P. A., & Seidman-Carlson, R. (2006). A brief mindfulness-based
stress reduction intervention for nurses and nurse aides.Applied Nursing Research,
19, 105-109.
Miller, J. J., Fletcher, K., & Kabat-Zinn, J. (1995). Three year follow-up and clinical
implications of a mindfulness meditation-based stress reduction intervention in the
treatment of anxiety disorders. General Hospital Psychiatry, 17, 192- 200.
Sharma, N., Yadava, A., & Hooda, D. (2005). Effect of yoga on psycho-physical functions .
Journal of Indian Psychology, 23, 37-42.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
12/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 12
Sudha, P., Jyotsna, G. N., Sumita, K., & Nalini, B. (2006). Comparative study of
psychological distress among practitioners and non-practitioners of yoga.Journal
of Indian Psychology, 24, 7-13.
Wall, R. B. (2005) Tai chi and mindfulness-based stress reduction in a Boston public
middle school.Journal of Paediatric Health Care, 19, 230- 237.
Appendix
The Satisfaction with Life Scale (SWLS)
Instructions: Please use one of the following numbers from 1 to 7 to indicate
how much you agree or disagree with the following statements.
7 Strongly agree
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
13/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 13
6 Agree
5 Slightly agree
4 Neither agree nor disagree3 Slightly disagree
2 Disagree
1 Strongly disagree
1. ____In most ways my life is close to my ideal.
2. ____The conditions of my life are excellent.3. ____I am satisfied with my life.
4. ____So far I have gotten the important things I want in my life.
5. ____If I could live my life over, I would change almost nothing.
Note. Scores for all items are summed to calculate a total score.
The Mindful Awareness Attention Scale (MAAS)
Instructions: Below is a collection of statements about your everyday experience. Using the16 scale below, please indicate how frequently or infrequently you currently have each
experience. Please answer according to what really reflects your experience rather than
what you think your experience should be.
1 Almost always,
2 Very frequently
3 Somewhat frequently4 Somewhat infrequently
5 Very infrequently6 Almost never
1. ____ I could be experiencing some emotion and not be conscious of it until some timelater.
2. ____ I break or spill things because of carelessness, not paying attention, or thinking of
something else.
3. ____ I find it difficult to stay focused on whats happening in the present.4. ____ I tend to walk quickly to get where Im going without paying attention to what I
experience along the way.
5. ____ I tend not to notice feelings of physical tension or discomfort until they really grabmy attention.
6. ____ I forget a persons name almost as soon as Ive been told it for the first time.
7. ____ It seems I am running on automatic without much awareness of what Im doing.8. ____ I rush through activities without being really attentive to them.
9. ____ I get so focused on the goal I want to achieve that I lose touch with what I am
doing right now to get there.10. ____ I do jobs or tasks automatically, without being aware of what Im doing.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
14/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 14
11. ____ I find myself listening to someone with one ear, doing something else at the same
time.
12. ____ I drive places on automatic pilot and then wonder why I went there.13. ____ I find myself preoccupied with the future or the past.
14. ____ I find myself doing things without paying attention.
15. ____ I snack without being aware that Im eating.
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
15/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 15
Table 1
Group Statistics for Yoga and Non-Yoga on Mindfulness and Well-being Measures
Exercise N Mean Std. Deviation
Mindfulness Yoga 31 61.06 11.20Non Yoga 31 61.93 12.27
Well-being Yoga 31 25.25 7.76
Non Yoga 31 26.48 4.63
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
16/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 16
Table 2
Equality of Variances and Equality of Means for Mindfulness and Well-being Results
F Sig. t df
Sig. (2-
tailed)
Mean
Difference
Std. Error
Difference
95% ConfidenceInterval of the
Difference
Mindfulness Equalvariances
assumed
.087 .769 -.292 60 .772 -.87097 2.98558 -6.84302 5.10109
Equal
variancesnot assumed
-.292 59.503 .772 -.87097 2.98558 -6.84405 5.10211
Well-being Equal
variancesassumed
6.853 .011 -.754 60 .454 -1.22581 1.62497 -4.47622 2.02461
Equalvariances
not assumed
-.754 48.989 .454 -1.22581 1.62497 -4.49132 2.03970
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
17/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 17
Table 3
Correlation between Mindfulness and Well-being
Mindfulness Well-being
Mindfulness Pearson Correlation 1 .364**Sig. (2-tailed) .004
N 62 62
Well-being Pearson Correlation .364** 1Sig. (2-tailed) .004
N 62 62
**p < .01 (2-tailed)
-
8/2/2019 Mindfulness and Self Reports of Well Being- Final
18/18
Yoga, Mindfulness and Subjective Well-being 18
Table 4
Correlation between Mindfulness and Well-being In Yoga and Non-Yoga Groups
Exercise Mindfulness Wellbeing
Non Yoga Mindfulness Pearson Correlation 1 .442*Sig. (2-tailed) .013
N 31 31
Wellbeing Pearson Correlation .442* 1
Sig. (2-tailed) .013
N 31 31
Yoga Mindfulness Pearson Correlation 1 .336Sig. (2-tailed) .065
N 31 31
Wellbeing Pearson Correlation .336 1
Sig. (2-tailed) .065N 31 31
p < .05 level (2-tailed)