Download - Mp Draft Ppp Policy
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
1/117
Final Report
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP inMadhya Pradesh
Government of Madhya Pradesh and
Department for International Development, UK
May, 2011
Submitted by
Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Private Limited
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
2/117
This page has been left blank intentionally.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
3/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 1 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF CONTENTS ......................................................................................................................................................... 1
1. INTRODUCTION ......................................................................................................................................................... 6
1.1 BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................................................................. 6
1.2 OBJECTIVES OF THE ASSIGNMENT ..................................................................................................................................... 7
2. PPP IN MADHYA PRADESH ........................................................................................................................................ 8
2.1 EXISTING SCENARIO IN MP ............................................................................................................................................. 8
2.2 PPP IN MP ................................................................................................................................................................ 11
3. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS FOR GOVT. OF INDIA FOR PPP ............................................................................ 19
3.1 PPPFRAMEWORK AT CENTRAL LEVEL.............................................................................................................................. 19
3.2 POLICY FRAMEWORK FOR PPP AT CENTRAL LEVEL ............................................................................................................. 22
3.3 ISSUES WITH PPPPROJECTS AND PROCESSES AT CENTRAL LEVEL .......................................................................................... 22
4. PPP IN OTHER INDIAN STATES ................................................................................................................................. 24
4.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................... 24
4.2 GUJARAT ................................................................................................................................................................... 24
4.3 TAMIL NADU.............................................................................................................................................................. 26
4.4 MAHARASHTRA .......................................................................................................................................................... 28
4.5 ANDHRA PRADESH....................................................................................................................................................... 30
4.6 ORISSA...................................................................................................................................................................... 324.7 CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................................................................. 34
5. INTERNATIONAL PRACTICES IN PPP ......................................................................................................................... 38
5.1 INTERNATIONAL PPPEXPERIENCES ................................................................................................................................. 38
5.2 PPPFRAMEWORK FOLLOWED IN SOUTH AFRICA ............................................................................................................... 39
5.3 PPPFRAMEWORK FOLLOWED IN SOUTH KOREA................................................................................................................ 41
5.4 LEARNING FROM INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCES................................................................................................................. 43
6. PROPOSED PPP POLICY FOR MADHYA PRADESH ..................................................................................................... 44
6.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................... 44
6.2 DRAFTPPPPOLICY .................................................................................................................................................. 457. PROPOSED INSTITUTIONAL ROADMAP FOR PPP IN MP ........................................................................................... 61
7.1 INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................... 61
7.2 INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS FOR PPP ........................................................................................................................ 65
7.3 POSSIBLE OPTIONS FOR PPPFACILITATION AGENCY........................................................................................................... 72
8. WAY FORWARD....................................................................................................................................................... 83
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
4/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 2 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
9. ANNEXURES ............................................................................................................................................................ 84
9.1 ANNEXURE 1:LIST OF STAKEHOLDER INTERACTIONS ........................................................................................................... 85
9.2 ANNEXURE 2:DETAILS OF EXPERIENCE OF GOI IN PPP....................................................................................................... 86
9.3 ANNEXURE 3:DETAILS OF PPP IN OTHER INDIAN STATES.................................................................................................... 87
9.4 ANNEXURE 4:DETAILS OF INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE IN PPP............................................................................................ 999.5 ANNEXURE 5:VALUE FOR MONEY................................................................................................................................ 104
9.6 ANNEXURE 6:TYPICAL PPPMODELS ............................................................................................................................ 105
9.7 ANNEXURE 7:PROCESS OF APPOINTMENT OF TRANSACTION ADVISORS ............................................................................... 109
9.8 ANNEXURE 8:TERMS OF REFERENCE FOR THE STUDY ....................................................................................................... 111
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
5/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 3 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
List of Tables
Table 1: Department wise targets for PPP given by Govt. of Madhya Pradesh ....................................................................... 15
Table 2: Mapping of PPP projects in pipeline on the PPP process map................................................................................... 17
Table 3: Institutional Framework for PPP at central level ....................................................................................................... 20Table 4: Comparison of Institutional Framework for PPP in 5 states ...................................................................................... 35
Table 5: Comparison of the previous and the new regulatory framework in South Korea ..................................................... 41
Table 6: Inter-se responsibilities of various institutions in a PPP project cycle in Madhya Pradesh ....................................... 69
Table 7: Sector wise details of PPP projects in Maharashtra ................................................................................................... 93
Table 8: No. of PPP projects at various stages of PPP cycle in Maharashtra ........................................................................... 93
List of Figures
Figure 1: Sector wise status of PPP projects in Madhya Pradesh (number & value) ............................................................... 12
Figure 2: Status of PPP projects in Madhya Pradesh ............................................................................................................... 12
Figure 3: Status of PPP projects in road sector in Madhya Pradesh ........................................................................................ 13
Figure 4: Status of PPP projects in urban sector in Madhya Pradesh ...................................................................................... 14
Figure 5: Status of PPP projects in water sector in Madhya Pradesh ...................................................................................... 14
Figure 6: PPP process map for Madhya Pradesh ..................................................................................................................... 16
Figure 7: Institutional Framework for PPP at central level ...................................................................................................... 22
Figure 8: Institutional Framework for PPP in Gujarat .............................................................................................................. 25
Figure 9: Institutional Framework for PPP in Tamil Nadu ........................................................................................................ 27
Figure 10: Institutional Framework for PPP in Andhra Pradesh .............................................................................................. 30
Figure 11: Institutional Framework for PPP in Orissa .............................................................................................................. 32
Figure 12: Existing Institutional Framework for PPP in Madhya Pradesh ................................................................................ 61
Figure 13: Existing PPP process and approval mechanism in Madhya Pradesh ...................................................................... 63
Figure 14: Issues / gaps identified in existing PPP arrangement in Madhya Pradesh ............................................................. 64
Figure 15: Roles and responsibilities of the proposed institutional framework for PPP in Madhya Pradesh ......................... 66
Figure 16: Key features of the proposed institutional framework in Madhya Pradesh .......................................................... 72
Figure 17: Proposed Institutional Framework Option 1: DIF becomes PPP Facilitation Agency .......................................... 74
Figure 18: Proposed Institutional Framework Option 2: A separate agency under Finance becomes Facilitation Agency for
PPP ........................................................................................................................................................................................... 76
Figure 19: Proposed Institutional Framework Option 3: A separate agency outside Finance becomes Facilitation Agency
for PPP ..................................................................................................................................................................................... 78
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
6/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 4 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Abbreviations
List of Abbreviations
ADB Asian Development Bank MPPDF
Madhya Pradesh Project Development
Fund
APIICAndhra Pradesh Industrial InfrastructureCorporation
MPRDCMadhya Pradesh Road DevelopmentCorporation
BEE Black Economic Empowerment MPSIDCMadhya Pradesh State IndustrialDevelopment Corporation Ltd
BOO Build Own Operate MSRDCMaharashtra State Road DevelopmentCorporation Limited
BOOT Build Own Operate Transfer MUIF Maharashtra Urban Infrastructure Fund
BOT Build Operate Transfer MUINFRAMaharashtra Urban InfrastructureDevelopment Authority
BTL Build Transfer Lease NRI Non-resident individuals
BTO Build Transfer Operate O&M Operations and Maintenance
CA Concession Agreement PDF Project Development Fund
CIDCOCity and Industrial DevelopmentCorporation of Maharashtra Ltd
PFI Project Finance Initiative
CoI Committee on Infrastructure PFMA Public Finance Management Act
DCA Draft Concession Agreement PICKOPrivate Infrastructure Investment Center ofKorea
DEA Department of Economic Affairs PIMACPublic and Private InfrastructureInvestment Management Center
DIF Directorate of Institutional Finance PMC Project Management Consultant
DLECDepartment Level EmpoweredCommittee
PPA Project preparatory assistance
DPI Directorate of Public Instruction PPP Public private partnership
DPR Detailed Project Report PPPAC PPP Appraisal Committee
ECIEmpowered Committee onInfrastructure (Orissa)
PPPAU PPP Appraisal Unit
FDI Foreign Direct Investment PSC Public Sector Comparator
FOB Foot over-bridges PWD Public Works Department
GID Act Gujarat Infrastructure Development Act RFP Request for Proposal
GIDBGujarat Infrastructure DevelopmentBoard
RFQ Request for Qualification
GOAP Government of Andhra Pradesh SA Sponsoring Agency
GoI Government of India SLEC State Level Empowered Committee
GoMP Government of Madhya Pradesh TA Transaction Advisor
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
7/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 5 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
List of Abbreviations
HLCAHigh Level Empowered Committee(Orissa)
TC Technical Consultant
IA Andhra Pradesh Infrastructure Authority TNRDC Tamil Nadu Road Development Company
IDEAAndhra Pradesh InfrastructureDevelopment Enabling Act
TNUDF Tamil Nadu Urban Development Fund
IDFCInfrastructure Development FinanceCompany
TNUDP Tamil Nadu Urban Development Project
IIFCLIndia Infrastructure Finance CompanyLimited
TNUIFSLTamil Nadu Urban Infrastructure FinancialServices Limited
IIPDFIndia Infrastructure ProjectDevelopment Fund
TPC Total Project Cost
IL&FSInfrastructure Leasing & FinancialServices Ltd
UADDUrban Administration & DevelopmentDepartment
INCAP Infrastructure Corporation of AndhraPradesh
UK United Kingdom
JnNURMJawaharlal Nehru National UrbanMission
ULB Urban Local Body
MCA Model Concession Agreement USD US Dollars
MFMA Municipal Finance Management Act VFM Value for Money
MMRDAMumbai Metropolitan RegionDevelopment Authority
VGF Viability Gap Funding
MoF Ministry of Finance
MP Madhya Pradesh
MPIIFBMadhya Pradesh InfrastructureInvestment Fund Board
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
8/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 6 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background
Madhya Pradesh has undertaken several measures in terms of investments in physical and social
infrastructure and many policy changes to strengthen the enabling environment for infrastructure
development in the last few years. However, there are enough indications that capital expenditure by
government is not enough to meet the infrastructure deficit in the state. Investments and
development in physical and social infrastructure therefore remains the key to economic growth in the
state, which the GoMP also recognizes the urgency and need for. Even where investments have been
made, adequate provisions have not been made for maintenance of these assets and the quality of
services to the ultimate users also needs substantial improvements.
A strong public private partnership (PPP) framework has been identified as critical to providing a thrust
in the development of infrastructure and provision of infrastructure services in the state. TheGovernment of Madhya Pradesh (GoMP) has taken several initiatives in the last few years to develop
infrastructure through PPP mode and develop enabling environment for encouraging PPP in the state.
For example:
Directorate of Institutional Finance (DIF) has been formed to serve as the Nodal agency for
PPP projects. A PPP Cell under DIF has been created which constitutes a state level
committee for PPP. The Committee is chaired by Chief Secretary, GoMP. The PPP Cell offers
hand-holding assistance in planning and bidding out PPP projects. Apart from being the nodal
agency for PPP projects in the state, it is also responsible for strengthening performance
management in government.
Madhya Pradesh Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (MPIIFB) has been constituted to
mobilize resources for infrastructure projects including roads, irrigation, water supply, solid
waste management and drainage or a multipurpose project comprising two or more such
areas. MP Project Development Fund (MPPDF) for funding preparatory activities of PPP
projects is also constituted.
At the state level, Madhya Pradesh has been one of the pioneers in building roads under PPP mode.
However other transport sectors, urban sectors and social sectors need more focus on PPP in MP. It
is reported that, in the last few years PPP projects worth Rs. 8,600 crores have been awarded and
projects of Rs. 5,000 crores are in the pipeline. To accelerate the development of social and physical
infrastructure and to substantially enhance the delivery of services to the public in many sectors,GoMP has decided to give a major thrust to the PPP formats in many of these initiatives. It is with this
background that GoMP, with the assistance of DfID, UK, appointed consultants Deloitte to formulate a
PPP policy and suggest Institutional arrangements for effective PPP implementation.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
9/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 7 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
1.2 Objectives of the Assignment
The objectives of the study are to:
develop an overarching PPP policy framework focusing on both social and physical
infrastructure, encompassing all the sectors.
prepare an institutional roadmap for the implementation of the provisions of the PPP Policy
including infrastructure development fund, project development fund, appraisal authority,
approving authority etc.
This draft report presents a draft PPP policy and a roadmap for suitable institutional arrangements,
along with tracing the current situation of PPP in Madhya Pradesh and providing a backdrop of what
are good PPP practices elsewhere in the country and overseas.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
10/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 8 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
2. PPP IN MADHYA PRADESH
2.1 Existing Scenario in MP
2.1.1 Existing Infrastructure Scenario in MP
As of March 2010, a cumulative infrastructure investments of over USD 16.6 billion has been made in
Madhya Pradesh. Out of this, more than USD 14 billion worth of investments have been made in
generation and distribution of electricity. A total installed generation capacity of more than 8200 MW is
available with the state.
The adjacent diagram shows investments in six
hard infrastructure sectors in the state. It is seen
that power and roads has about 95% share of
investments in the hard infrastructure sectors.The total road length maintained by PWD in the
state is more than 72,000 kms. It has 16 national
highways. However, there is a huge potential for
further improvement. The national average for all
types of road network is 83 km/100 sq. km.,
whereas in M.P. it is only 53.68 km/100 sq. kms.
It has 5900 kms of railway network and 5 airports
(Bhopal, Jabalpur, Gwalior, Indore and
Khajuraho).
Under the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Mission (JNNURM), 22 projects (of value US$ 479 million)have been sanctioned for urban centres such as Bhopal, Indore, Jabalpur and Ujjain. The Asian
Development Bank (ADB) has also funded 16 projects worth US$ 33.8 million for Bhopal in the areas
of water supply, sewerage and sanitation, storm-water drainage and solid-waste management.
In the past 3-4 years, focus on social sectors like education, health has been growing. MP has 50
District Hospitals, 333 Community Health Centres, 1155 Primary Health Centres, 56 Urban Civil
Hospitals. There are 10872 high schools & higher secondary schools, 97800 primary schools, 39882
middle schools and 878 Ashram Shalas (elementary level to serve children and families who reside in
remote areas especially tribal population).
2.1.2 Sector policies
Almost all sector policies in MP encourage private sector participation in their respective sectors.
Some even specify PPP as preferred mode of development. For example State Road Policy has
initiated formation of Road Maintenance Fund which would participate in PPP projects in roads and
highway sector. Many policies have specified various incentives in terms of tax holidays, land
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
11/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 9 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
concessions, low entry/ exit barriers to encourage more and more private participation in their
respective sectors.
Highlights of relevant policies with respect to private sector participation are given below:
State Roads Policy
The objective of State Road Policy was to meet transportation requirements efficiently across all road
networks in the state through upgradation of state roads, urban roads and rural roads. However, due
to paucity of funds for upgradation/ maintenance of roads, State Road Policy has identified PPP for
development of road and highway sector in the state.
A Road Maintenance Fund has been created by pooling the toll revenue and assistance obtained from
CRF, Mandi Cess and Road Tax. This fund would be offered as 'equity participation' to BOT operators
under PPP contracts who would pool in their own resources and bid for a road project. This would
encourage PPP which would not only increase the available pool of funds but would enhance
maintenance/ reconstruction activities by application of modern techniques.
The policy states that viable projects will be offered to private sector under BOT scheme, especially forconstruction of (i) new bridges (ii) re-construction of distressed and narrow bridges (iii) bye-passes (iv)
widening of high density corridors and (v) strengthening and maintenance of economically viable
sections of highways. The policy also provides incentives (attractive entry/ exit clause, land
concessions and tax holidays) to the private sector to ensure commercial viability of road projects.
The State Road Policy has been supported by amendments and enactment of enabling legislative
structure:
Amendment of Indian Tolls (M.P.) Act, 1932 To facilitate private sector participation in road
projects, GoMP has amended the Indian Tolls (M.P.) Act 1932 which permits the levy of toll on
new construction as well as improvement of road and bridge projects.
Madhya Pradesh Highway Bill 2001 In order to facilitate implementation of the policy
effectively and within the prescribed time frame, a legal framework for the regulation and
development of road sector has been prepared. It has been prepared on the guidelines of a
Model Highway Act issued by Govt. of India. The bill is yet to be enacted.
Tourism Policy, 2010
Tourism Policy for Madhya Pradesh was approved by the State Cabinet in 2010 to promote balanced
and sustainable tourism, Tourism Policy particularly focuses on attracting private investment and
advocates land use for the purpose of tourism centers. One of the guiding principles of the policy is to
create institutional mechanism to promote private investment and to promote PPP in tourism.
In order to enhance tourism, guidelines and procedures to attract private investment have been madetransparent. Land bank policy is strengthened to promote tourism. For tourism projects, land for 90
years lease or development agreement for 30 years is permitted along with exemption of stamp duty.
A databank has been prepared for destination marketing. Concessions on taxes in tourism sector have
been given in many cases.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
12/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 10 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
State Water Policy (2003)
MP has formulated a State Water Policy in 2003 which has been prepared in accordance to the
guidelines and general directions in the National Water Policy, keeping in view the specific necessity
for the state of Madhya Pradesh.
The policy has specified water allocation priorities (in that order) for the state Drinking water supply,
Irrigation and afforestation, power generation/industrial and tourism. The policy identifies use of
information systems, quality control mechanisms for drinking water, management and control of water
zones, irrigation and land management etc.
The policy does not talk directly about PPP. However, the policy does encourage non-government
participation in the water sector in project planning, construction and maintenance.
Housing Policy, 2007
Housing policy of 1995 was amended in 2007 due to change in demand for urban housing due to rapid
urbanization. Considering growing need for urban housing, provision for participation of private and
corporate sectors has been made in the policy to meet the requirement of social housing in the state.Provision of providing government land at concessional rates for development of habitations to
construction agencies has also been made.
The policy encourages PPP to meet the shortages of houses. Provision has been made to grant
permission for township development in agricultural areas scrapping the existing practice of
compulsory for diversion of lands.
Health Policy
Around 75% of the total funding in health sector is a private sector funding. There is an urban rural
divide since 70% of the qualified practitioners are in urban areas. Given the numbers and spread of
private health care providers in rural areas (often the less than qualified providers) and substantialpresence of qualified and less than qualified providers in urban areas, it is obvious to explore
possibilities of the role the private sector can play for improved public health in the state.
Government puts forward specific measures for encouraging public private collaboration in the fields of
immunization, reduction of maternal mortality and control of infectious diseases. Further, measures are
suggested to use the human and financial resources of non-government organizations (NGOs) and
private sector for management of some government owned facilities.
Industrial Promotion Policy 2010 and Action Plan
In order to attract industrial investments, establish industrial houses, GoMP has taken many policy
initiatives. The industrial policy was revised recently with effect from November 2010. For ensuring
speedy approvals of investment proposals, rules and procedures have been streamlined under
Madhya Pradesh Investment Facilitation Act 2008 (single window clearance).
One of the key objectives of the Industrial Promotion Policy is to attract private sector participation in
industrial infrastructure and encourage FDIs and investments by NRIs. The policy also intends to
rationalize rates of commercial taxes to make the industry attractive.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
13/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 11 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
2.2 PPP in MP
PPP in Madhya Pradesh started with a road sector project in 1992 by MP Bridge Corporation. A road
sector project was conceptualized and developed in early 1990 (Pithampur-Indore highway project).
Primarily reason for this PPP initiative in 1990s were two fold firstly urgent need for the Pithampur-
Indore highway was felt and secondly there was dearth of funds with the government to implement the
project. Post 2000, many PPP projects were conceptualized across many other sectors also like urban
infrastructure, water supply and sanitation, social sector etc.
For example, Dewas Industrial Water Supply project was one of Indias early water supply projects
developed on a BOT basis. This green field project was awarded on a domestic tender for a contract
period of 30 years. Madhya Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd (MPSIDC) awarded
this project to MSK Projects (I) Ltd. The cost of this project was around USD 20 million, 70% of which
was provided by IDFC and 30% came from developers equity.
2.2.1 Status of PPP Projects in MP
It is understood that around 88 infrastructure projects have been taken up or initiated on PPP in the
state with a definite increasing trend in recent times. The value of these projects is estimated to be
more than Rs.13,800 crores. This section highlights key trends in terms of number and value of PPP
projects and status of these projects across various identified infrastructure sectors.
It is seen that most of the PPP projects are from in the road and highway sector. This sector accounts
for around half of the total value of PPP projects in the state. Road and highway sector has had the
advantage of standardized process/ documents/ guidelines for PPP (even at central level) and
authorities have also found it easier to establish suitability of PPP for road projects.
MPRDC (MP Road Development Corporation) is responsible for sponsoring most of the PPP projectsin the road sector. Over the years, they have acquired PPP project preparation capacities. However,
there is absence of these capacities in other departments / agencies. It may also be noted that
average size of road projects are comparatively larger than other infrastructure projects (like projects
in urban or social infrastructure).
It is seen that more than Rs.1800 crores worth of PPP projects have been completed in road sector
compared to less than Rs.5 crores worth of PPP projects in all remaining sectors. More than Rs.4600
crores worth of PPP projects are under construction and in the pipeline in road sectors, whereas more
than Rs.7300 crores worth of PPP projects are under construction and in the pipeline in other sectors.
The exhibit below describes sector wise breakup of PPP projects (completed & pipeline projects) in the
state.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
14/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 12 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Figure 1: Sector wise status of PPP projects in Madhya Pradesh (number & value)
It is seen than out of 88 projects, over 50% belongs to road sector and over 17% belong to urban
sectors. However, in terms of value, around 47% and 3% belong to these sectors. Health and sports
sectors have also seen relatively larger projects. Only 5 projects in health and sports sector comprise
of 25% of total value of PPP projects in the state. The two large projects include the 195 hectare
Medical Hub at Tigaria Badshah and Sports City in Bhopal having project cost of Rs.2000 crores and
Rs.900 crores respectively.
It is seen that only 16 projects (out of these 88 projects) have been completed having value of less
than 15%. Out of these14 projects belong to road sector. All the remaining projects are in the pipelineand construction phase. The exhibit below describes status of PPP projects in the state.
Figure 2: Status of PPP projects in Madhya Pradesh
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
15/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 13 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Projects in pipeline include all projects before bids are invited from bidders. It includes projects under
various stages like project conceptualization, DPR preparation, awaiting DLEC / SLEC / cabinet
approvals, transaction advisor selection, bid document preparation etc.
2.2.2 Status of PPP projects in Road Sector
As mentioned before, 14 out of 16 completed projects belong to road sector. It is seen that there are
14 projects in the construction phase also. The fact that 28 road sector projects have been bid out on
PPP highlights the fact that road sector has matured in the PPP learning curve. They have
standardized procedures, standardized bidding documents and institutional capacity to manage PPP
transactions.
It is seen from the experience that most projects get stuck in bidding / pipeline stage is due to its non-
viability. However in case of road sector, since most of the projects are financially viable, 28 projects
have been successfully bid out.
The diagram below describes the status of the road sector projects in terms of numbers and value.
Figure 3: Status of PPP projects in road sector in Madhya Pradesh
2.2.3 Status of PPP projects in Urban Sector
It can be seen that there are many urban PPP projects in the pipeline stage. Most of these projects are
unattractive for the private sector. Some of them have even gone for re-bid due to no response frombidders. The two completed urban projects are Bus stops for city service and public toilets in Bhopal.
The two under construction projects are multi-level parking and FOBs in Indore.
Unlike other sectors, urban sector projects can be conceptualized at departmental level as well as
local body level. In most cases local bodies do not have the capability to undertake and manage a
PPP transaction. Hence most local bodies follow conventional method of procurement for projects
sponsored by them.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
16/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 14 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
The diagram below describes the status of the urban sector projects in terms of numbers and value.
Figure 4: Status of PPP projects in urban sector in Madhya Pradesh
2.2.4 Status of PPP projects in Water Sector
The two under construction projects in water sector are augmentation of water supply network in
Shivpuri and Kandwa. The two projects under bidding stage are ADB projects for 24X7 and NRW
reduction for Indore and Bhopal. Since these projects are pilot projects, the value of these projects is
very small. Hence they represent only 3% water sector PPP project in the state.
The diagram below describes the status of the water sector projects in terms of numbers and value.
Figure 5: Status of PPP projects in water sector in Madhya Pradesh
Going forward, it is seen that PPP has been identified as a preferred mode of procurement of water
infrastructure projects. The section below highlights PPP targets identified for various departments in
GoMP.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
17/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 15 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
2.2.5 PPP targets has been identified for next 3 years
Procurement of infrastructure projects through PPP has been identified as the priority. GoMP intends
to double the investment in the State through PPP in next three years. GoMP intends to attract
Rs.25000 crores of investment in three years in projects developed through PPP. Department-wise
PPP targets have been proposed.
Department wise targets for Rs.18500 crores are given in the table below.
Table 1: Department wise targets for PPP given by Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
Sl.
No.Department
Target for 2010-12
(in Rs. crores)
1. Medical Education 200
2. Public Works Department (Road Sector) 6000
3. School Education (DPI) 900
4. Horticulture and Food Processing 500
5. School Education (Rajya Shiksha Kendra) 500
6. Urban Admin & Development Department 1000
7. Commerce, Industries & Employment 4000
8. Energy 2000
9. Biotech 200
10. Food & Civil Supplies (Warehousing) 500
11. Transport 1200
12. Health 100
13. Higher Education 100
14. Technical Education 100
15. Tourism 200
16. Housing 1000
17. Water Resources (To be indicated by the department) NA
Total 18500
Source: Govt. of Madhya Pradesh
In order to achieve these targets, GoMP has attempted many policy and regulatory initiatives and set
up an institutional mechanism. A discussion on the exiting institutional mechanism is presented in a
later section of this report.
2.2.6 PPP Process Map
The PPP process followed in Madhya Pradesh has been mapped and shown below:
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
18/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 16 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Figure 6: PPP process map for Madhya Pradesh
GoILEVEL
Empowere
dComm./
Ins
ti.
GoILEVEL
PPPCell,DEA,
GoI
LineMinistry/Implementing&Sponsoring
Agency
M
PPDF
MPIIFB
Approval
Committees
(DLEC/SLEC)
CabinetApproval
(Cabinet/Line
Ministry)
PPPCell,DIF,
GoMP
Preparatory / In-principle Approval Stage Final Approval / Tendering StageProject Conceptualization / Study
Formulation ofproject documents
like project
agreements, rightsand obligation of
each party
In-principleApproval
RfQ tenderedby the
department
Selection ofConcessionaire
In principle approvalgiven by Empowered
Comm./Insti.Depending upon
project size
Appointment oftransactionadvisor /project
development
Preparationof projectproposal
| D |
| G |
| C |
Vetting of RfQand Project
Proposal withsuggested
modifications
Project
Conceptualization
PreparationMemorandum ofConsideration
(MFC)
Screening of MFCsubmitted bySponsoring
Agency
Approval of MFCapplication and
disbursement offunds if approved
Disbursementof IIPDF funds
Approval ofapplication for MPPDF
funds after scrutiny
and analysis
Disbursementof MPPDF
funds
DPRpreparation andassessment of
feasibility
Approval fromDLEC / SLECdepending onproject value
Issue of RfPand CA toshortlisted
bidders
FinalApproval
Vetting of Projectdocuments
including RfP,CA with
suggestedmodifications
Approval fromDLEC / SLECdepending onproject value
Shortlisting of
bidders
| E |
Approval forState VGF
Verify andforward
State VGFProposal
Is VGFrequired
YES
NO
| B |
| A |
Signing ofConcessionAgreement
| H |
| F |
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
19/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 17 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Legend:
Roles performed by every institution at every stage are clearly mentioned in the diagram. The process
map shows the approval process of central VGF, state VGF, IIPDF, MPPDF and PPP approval
process in the current scenario. For approval of IIPDF and central VGF, central government level
institutions like Empowered Committee / Institution and PPP Cell, DEA are also involved.
The PPP projects of MP which are in pipeline (as on March 2011) have been mapped in the process
diagram above from A to H. The details of these projects are given in the table below.
Table 2: Mapping of PPP projects in pipeline on the PPP process map
Referenceno. Project Location
A.1 Multi-level Parking at New Mkt Bhopal
B.1 Minerals-based SEZ on 250 acres Hargarh, JabalpurB.2 Agro-based SEZ on 248 acres Umariya-Dungariya, JabalpurB.3 PPP Projects exploration at select MCs in MP 11 citiesB.4 MLP In front of Nigam Shopping Complex Daulat Ganj GwaliorB.5 MLP at Old Bus Stand Kampoo GwaliorB.6 Bus Terminals (3) Bhopal
C.1 Van Vihar Ph-II on 350 ha BhopalC.2 Sports Complex on 42.140 hect spread over 3 locations Indore
C.3 Logistics Hub at Talavali Chanda on 151.845 hect IndoreC.4 ISBT on 10 hect IndoreC.5 Convention Centre on Airport Road IndoreC.6 Medical Hub at vill Tigaria Badshah on 194.727 hect IndoreC.7 Hospital Project at Old Nigam Work Shop, Dholi Bua ka Pull Gwalior
D.1 Water Supply Improvement Pithampur PithampurD.2 Betul-Sarni-Parasiya 124.10 kmsD.3 Damoh-Bahtiyargrah-Hirapur 69.60 kmsD.4 Jhabua-Jobat-Zeerpanya-Kukshi 95.50 kmsD.5 Rau-Mhow-Mandleshwar 74.40 kmsD.6 Sarangpur-Akodia-Shujalpur 39.86 kmsD.7 Khandwa-Dehtalai-Burhanpur 127.25 kms
E.1 BioTech Park on 181 acres (Common research facilities/Residential/Commercial) Indore
E.2 Logistics Park Powerkheda (115 acres) HoshangabadE.3 Commercial Cplx construction and O&M of Bus terminal Rewa
F.1 Food Park at Karmadi 80 acres RatlamF.2 Food Park at Anjana Saraiyat 60 acres HardaF.3 Food Park at Adampur Chhawni 50 acres Bhopal
F.4Parking Cum Commercial at Gandhi Mkt, Maharaj Bada for 300cars, 252 shops relocation. (5,228 Sq. Mt.)
Gwalior
Central VGF
Process
PPP Process
IIPDF Process
State VGF
Process
MPPDF Process
A
B
|C|
D
E
|F|
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
20/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 18 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Referenceno.
Project Location
F.5 ADB Pilot - 24x7 and NRW Water reduction Gwalior
G.1 Kalpana Nagar Swimming Pool O&M BhopalG.2 Fitness Centre O & M of Prakash Swimming Pool Bhopal
G.3 Mandsaur-Pratapgarh 11.526 kmsG.4 Hata-Fatehpur-Rajpura-Solapuir-Bajna-Dargawon 64.42 kmsG.5 Sendhwa-Khetia 57.3 kmsG.6 Semaria-Manikpur 16.36 kmsG.7 Deharda-Ishagrah 32.93 kmsG.8 Tikamgarh-Maheroni 15.7 kmsG.9 Badwani-Palsod-Sendhwa 56.89 kms
G.10 Dhar-Nagda 22.50 kmsG.11 Mhow-Ghata Billod 26.88 kmsG.12 Sardarpur Badnawar 42.98 kmsG.13 Water-based Tourism activities on Indira Sagar Dam - II Vill Hanvantiya, KhandwaG.14 Water-based Tourism activities on Indira Sagar Dam - I Vill Hanvantiya, KhandwaG.15 Eco-Tourism Park (7 hectares) RewaG.16 ADB Pilot - 24x7 and NRW Water reduction Indore
G.17 ADB Pilot - 24x7 and NRW Water reduction Bhopal
H.1 Dindayal Chalit Aspatal Yojana
G
|H|
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
21/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 19 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
3. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTSFOR GOVT. OF INDIA FOR PPP
3.1 PPP Framework at Central level
The enabling environment for Infrastructure development is significantly different from the situation a
few years ago when issues such as lack of political will, varied interest groups at the centre and the
state levels, red-tapism, and lengthy tedious approval processes were considered major bottlenecks.
Apart from the above there were limited incentives for the private sector due to constraints in
Government regulations with only select areas open to private participation, the reluctance of users to
pay for the infrastructure facilities and project returns not meeting investor expectations.
The 11th Plan approach paper and various working groups identified an ambitious program for
infrastructure development in the Road, Rail, Air, Water Transport, Power, Telecommunication, WaterSupply, Irrigation and Storage. Out of the total investments in infrastructure, 30% is envisaged to come
through private investments. It has been recognized that for creating world class infrastructure, it is
necessary to explore PPP in all sectors of infrastructure. To facilitate this process, the government is
pushing for reforms that encourage private sector participation and has recently made various legal
and regulatory changes to enable PPPs in infrastructure.
GoI has actively promoted PPPs across sectors through various initiatives. A three-tier approval
system has been instituted. Initiatives for facilitating PPP including model documents, financing
mechanisms and provision of technical assistance have been established. The institutional framework
for PPP projects can be categorized into the following:
PPP Advisory: These include the Committee on Infrastructure (CoI), Planning Commission
including PPP Appraisal Unit (PPPAU)
PPP Approval Mechanism: These include PPP Appraisal Committee (PPPAC) for approving
PPP projects and Empowered Committee / Institution for approving VGF.
PPP Financing Mechanism: These include 1) Viability Gap Funding (VGF), 2) India
Infrastructure Finance Company Limited (IIFCL), 3) India Infrastructure Project Development
Fund, and 4) other institutions like IDFC, IL&FS, and other financial institutions including
commercial banks
Government Ministries / Sponsoring Agencies: These include Ministry of Finance (MoF),
Department of Economic Affairs (DEA) including PPP cell in DEA and, PPP coordinators in line
ministries.
The table below summarizes the Institutional Framework for PPP at central level:
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
22/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 20 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Table 3: Institutional Framework for PPP at central level
Name Role
PPP Advisory
Committee onInfrastructure
(CoI)
It was instituted under the Chairmanship of thePrime Ministerin2004 with anobjective to initiate policies that enable creation and management of infrastructure,
facilitate mechanisms for PPPs, and monitor the progress of key infrastructure
projects.
The committee has since issued guidelines for implementation of PPP projects
including bidder selection guidelines, specifications and standards for projects,
model concession agreements, and financing plans.
Planning
Commission
It is the apex planning body of government. It plays a pivotal role directly and
through PPP Approval Committee (PPPAC) and PPP Appraisal Unit (PPPAU) as a
member, a unit created to appraise PPP projects and suggest suitable
modifications.
PPP Approval Mechanism
PPP Appraisal
Committee
(PPPAC)
It is an important institution for approval of PPP projects which was established in
2005. PPPAC first gives in-principle approval to a project put forth by a central
government ministry / autonomous undertaking and sends it to DEA, Planning
Commission and concerned line ministries for approval. Subsequent to their
approval, PPPAC gives final approval to the project.
Empowered
Committee /
Institution
An Empowered Committee and an Empowered Institution have been established
for approving Viability Gap Funding up to USD 50 million and USD 25 million
respectively, for projects which satisfy the eligibility criteria of the VGF scheme.1
PPP financing mechanisms
Viability Gap
Funding (VGF)
This scheme of government support is envisaged to bridge the viability gap of
infrastructure PPP projects up to a maximum of 20% of project in cases where the
project is awarded on competitive bidding and the private party has 51% or more
equity stake.2 This scheme is funded by MoF through budgetary allocations and
the assistance is provided in the form of capital grant to fund a part of the project
cost. Eligible sectors for VGF include Roads and bridges, railways, seaports,
airports, power and urban transport.
India It was established in 2006 with a mandate to provide long term debt for
1Empowered Institution (an institution, company or inter-ministerial group designated by the Government for
VGF scheme) will release the Grant to the Lead Financial Institution (the financial institution (FI) that is fundingthe PPP project) and will obtain reimbursement from the Finance Ministry. The Empowered Institution, the LeadFinancial Institution and the Private Sector Company shall enter into a Tripartite Agreement for the purposes ofthis scheme.2
The sponsoring ministry, state government or statutory entity can provide support over and above VGF subjectto a maximum of 20% of project cost
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
23/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 21 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Name Role
Infrastructure
Finance
Company
Limited (IIFCL)
infrastructure projects either by way of refinance or by direct lending, up to 20% of
capital cost, to project companies with a preference for infrastructure PPP projects.
Role of IIFCL is complimentary to that of existing infrastructure financing
institutions. In addition IIFCL enjoys Government guarantee for the funds it raisesfrom domestic and international markets (limits to be set at the beginning of each
year) whereas other institutions do not have such guarantee. IIFCL is expected to
fill in the gap in long-term debt financing for infrastructure projects and complement
the efforts of commercial banks and other financial institutions. It also provides
refinance to banks and FI for loans with tenor of five years or more. The
commercial banks in India participate in the infrastructure project funding and
typically provide three-fourth of the total funds.
IIFCL has also been identified as the channeling agency for using part of foreign
exchange reserves to finance import of capital goods for infrastructure projects.
India
Infrastructure
Project
Development
Fund
IIPDF was announced in the Budget Speech for 2007-08 and was subsequently
created with a corpus of USD 25 million to quicken the pace of preparation of a
shelf of bankable projects which can be offered for competitive bidding.
Upto 75% of the feasibility level project development cost may be financed from
this fund as interest free loan and is envisaged to be recovered from the successful
bidder. If the project does not take off, then the same is converted to a grant. Any
state government & local body can avail of this facility for developing PPP projects.
Government ministries/ Sponsoring Agencies
Ministry of
Finance(MoF)
The Ministry of Finance is the nodal ministry responsible for examining concession
agreements from the financial angle, deciding on guarantees to be extended, andgenerally assess risk allocation from the investment and banking perspectives.
There is no generic policy in India which governs the provision of guarantee by the
MoF for PPP projects. The projects undertaken by government and its bodies have
implicit sovereign guarantee. There have been instances of explicit sovereign
guarantee in case of projects funded by multilateral institutions
Department of
Economic
Affairs (DEA)-
Ministry of
Finance
DEA is the nodal agency of the Union Government to formulate and monitor
country's economic policies and programmes having a bearing on internal and
external aspects of economic management. DEA services the Public Private
Partnership Approval Committee (PPPAC).
The PPP cell in DEA coordinates the PPP related activities at central level,including VGF (detailed later) and appraisal of PPP projects at the centre
Line Ministries
(Roads, Ports,
Civil Aviation,
etc.)
These play an important role in identification of PPP projects within their respective
areas. They are also part of the PPPAC as project sponsor to suggest necessary
modifications before approval of project. Nodal officers have been nominated in
key line ministries such as Urban Development, Civil Aviation, Road Transport,
Railways etc. for coordination of PPP projects.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
24/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 22 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
The institutional framework at the central level can be described by the diagram below.
Figure 7: Institutional Framework for PPP at central level
Details of the PPP projects (quantum and value) are attached as Annexure 2.
3.2 Policy Framework for PPP at Central level
As on date, India does not have an overall Infrastructure PPP Policy. However, talks are going on in
Planning Commission and DEA to formulate an overarching policy guideline at the Central level soon.
However, at various times, the GoI has made various policy statements outlining the need to provide a
strategic thrust towards PPP especially in infrastructure.
3.3 Issues with PPP Projects and Processes at Central level
GoI has made extensive effort in institutionalizing PPP with special focus on defining PPP, preparing
policy, guidelines and model documents, establishing an approval mechanism, setting procurement
Sponsoring Agency
Policy and Legislation
PPP Cell, DEA
under MoF
Line Ministries /
Departments at
state level
Planning
Commission
Committee on
Infrastructure
Financing
Mechanism
No PPP policy oroverall infrastructurepolicy
Various sectorspecific policies
Various initiatives toencourage PPP likestandardization ofbid documents,project preparatoryassistance, andviability gap funding
PPPAC
VGF IIFCL IIPDF
PPP
Coordinators in
every Line
Ministries at
Central level
Viability gap
assistance
Financial
assistance
through long
term debt
Project
preparatory
assistance
State Nodal
Agency
Advisory
Empowered
Committee/
Approval
Committees
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
25/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 23 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
methods and processes. But there are some gaps and issues identified in the PPP mechanism at the
central level which should be addressed.
There is an absence of a comprehensive PPP Policy at the Central level. Planning Commission
is considering developing such policy which will be applicable to all infrastructure sectors.
There is no overarching legislation for PPP at the central level. Social sector needs more encouragement in undertaking PPP including through additional and
innovative financial incentives in addition to VGF.
There are constant changes in the processes and guidelines which sometimes hinder the
growth for PPP e.g. evaluation criteria changes, timeline changes for bidding, changes in tax
applicability, interpretations etc.
In addition, the time taken to obtain clearances by private parties after getting selected also
varies hugely depending on quality of ground work done by bidding authorities in advance. This
also acts as a deterrent. Absence of capacity in bidding agencies also sometimes comes in the
way of getting serious private parties.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
26/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 24 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
4. PPP IN OTHER INDIAN STATES
4.1 Introduction
There are a number of states in the country which have adopted PPP models successfully to provide
efficient infrastructure services to people while others are still in the process of coming to terms with
PPP. Realizing the importance of speedy development of infrastructure through PPP, some states like
Andhra Pradesh and Gujarat institutionalized PPP even before a formal mechanism was established
at the central level.
Studying the PPP framework adopted by various states has given important insights into various
policies, institutional, financial and regulatory options that have been used to operationalize PPP.
There are different frameworks adopted by different states and it is possible to use specific examples
for Madhya Pradesh given the local context. The states chosen for the purpose of analysis here
included Gujarat and Andhra Pradesh - both of which operationalized PPPs through an over-archinginstitutional and legal framework for PPPs including the creation of a specialised institution. Tamil
Nadu and Maharashtra have also achieved some success in undertaking PPP projects by creating
specialised sector specific agencies with private sector participation and also by leveraging public
funds to undertake PPP projects. Another state added to the comparison list was Orissa as it has
implemented a PPP policy and has a formal three-tier hierarchical mechanism for approving PPP
projects. The key lessons that emerge from the comparative analysis are presented at the end.
4.2 Gujarat
4.2.1 PPP in Gujarat
Gujarat has been one of the leading states in implementing PPP projects and has been one of the few
states that have enacted special legislations for infrastructure development through PPP that cuts
across sectors and have created institutions for undertaking these initiatives.
The Gujarat Infrastructure Development Board (GIDB) is the nodal agency to promote private sector
participation in all infrastructure sectors in Gujarat. Presently the major infrastructure sectors where
PPP projects have been successful are Roads and Ports. The Gujarat Infrastructure Development Act,
1999 (BOT Law) provides the legal framework for private sector participation in financing, construction,
operation and maintenance of the project.
GIDB was established under the Gujarat Infrastructure Development Act, 1999 (GID Act) to promote
private sector participation in Infrastructure Projects. GIDB focuses on overall planning, coordination
between various sector specific departments, concession agreements, selection of developers etc.
rather than developing infrastructure facilities on their own. GIDB is an over-arching body for
infrastructure development in Gujarat (hard as well as soft infrastructure sectors). GIDB itself does not
develop infrastructure but acts as a catalyst for their development.
GIDB is mandated with the following functions:
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
27/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 25 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
To promote private sector participation in financing, construction, operation and maintenance of
the Infrastructure projects.
To develop the projects through pre-feasibility/ feasibility studies of the project.
To advise the state government and its agencies on the matter of Policy.
To lay down priority of the projects. To consider proposal and proposed concession agreement to be entered into between the
state government/agency and the private sector developer.
To monitor the projects undertaken in the state.
Figure 8: Institutional Framework for PPP in Gujarat
Details of GIDB and other agencies, policies and legislative framework pertaining to PPP in Gujarat
are attached in Annexure 3.
PPP Initiatives
Formulated a State VGF
Scheme and guidelines
for its operation
Model documents
Vision documents ( BIG
2020)
Sector Policies
GIDB
Nodal agency for PPP headed by Chief Minister
Overall planning & framework studies
Advise on Policy matters
Prioritization of projects
Provide state VGF (20% oTPC)
Nodal agency for preparing VGF proposals for
Centre
Line Departments /Sponsoring agency
Project preparation
Bidding
Approval
Selection of developer
Project execution
Monitoring
Empowered Committee (Executive Committee)
Approval of feasibility study less than Rs. 1.5 crore
Appraise all proposals requiring VGF and puts it
up to the state Government for approval
GID Board (Steering Committee)
Approval of feasibility studies costing more than
Rs. 1.5 crore
Approval of all PPP projects
PPP Cell / Project preparation
develops shelf of projects
conducting feasibility studies
drafting of model documents
bid process management
appraisal of projects for approval and VGF
Conceptual diagram of PPP Institutional framework in Gujarat
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
28/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 26 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
4.2.2 Key Learning from Gujarat
Gujarat is a progressive state and has undertaken many PPP projects in various sectors. The state
has institutionalized the PPP mechanism so well that process of doing PPP projects is clearly
understood and followed by line departments. Some of the important lessons to be drawn from Gujarat
are given below.
A nodal agency for PPP projects, headed by the Chief Minister/ Chief Secretary should be
created at the state level.
Such agency should be a one point of contact for all departments for project preparation and
approval of PPP projects which also helps in expediting the project development and
implementation.
Nodal agency should also be mandated to build capacities of other line departments.
Political consent at various stages of project development helps in faster movement of the PPP
project in the project cycle.
Swiss challenge must be encouraged as a procurement method for PPP as it allows for
innovation.
4.3 Tamil Nadu
4.3.1 PPP in Tamil Nadu
Tamil Nadu has made some success in promoting public-private-partnership (PPP) in some
infrastructure sectors, including power, roads, ports and urban. The State Government has
encouraged private sector participation in the process of infrastructure development. Tamil Nadu was
the first state in the country to setup a genuine public - private partnership venture for infrastructure
development in the year 1998.
The Tamil Nadu government has agencies in different sectors promoting PPP but not an overall
coordinating agency as in case of Gujarat or Andhra Pradesh. Some of the Joint venture companies
established at the state level for specific PPP projects are shown below.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
29/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 27 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Figure 9: Institutional Framework for PPP in Tamil Nadu
Details of the projects and PPP agencies in Tamil Nadu are attached as Annexure 3.
4.3.2 Key Learning from Tamil Nadu
Tamil Nadu has achieved success in PPP using JV model for project preparation and execution. It
does not have a nodal agency or an umbrella legislation to support PPP but there are some merits inadopting such model. Key learning from PPP mechanism in Tamil Nadu is listed below.
Involvement of private player from project conceptualization stage itself helps in
accomplishment of PPP projects as suitability of PPP is established at the onset.
PPP projects can also be funded through schemes like capital subsidy as given in Tamil Nadu
apart from viability given funding. This can give additional incentive to the private players to
undertake a PPP project.
TNRDC was formed to encourage PPP in road sector. TNRDC is a 50:50joint venture between TIDCO and IL&FS. It was set up with the objective to
catalyze private sector participation and investment in Road sector and ismandated to initiate commercialization of operations and maintenance ofRoad assets.
Tamil Nadu Road
DevelopmentCompany (TNRDC)
In order to attract private capital into urban infrastructure developmentTNUDF was established in 1996. TNUDF is the first public privatepartnership between Government of Tamil Nadu and three FinancialInstitutions (viz., ICICI, HDFC, and IL&FS) for providing long term financefor civic infrastructure on a non-guarantee mode. The TNUDF aims to raiseresources and long-term finance for infrastructure in Urban local bodies ona sustainable basis, support and strengthen Urban reforms, and institutionalstrengthening and capacity building. It also promotes PPP arrangement tochannel private capital in municipal infrastructure. The Fund is managed byTamil Nadu Urban Infrastructure Financial Services Limited.
Tamil Nadu UrbanDevelopment Fund
(TNUDF)
TNUIFSL is a Public Limited Company and is a partnership in the Urbansector, between Government of Tamil Nadu and three all India-Financial-Institutions namely, ICICI Bank Limited, Housing Development FinanceCorporation Limited (HDFC) and Infrastructure Leasing and FinancialServices Limited (IL&FS). TNUIFSL undertakes fund management (includingthe TNUDF) on the basis of management contracts
Tamil Nadu UrbanInfrastructure
Financial ServicesLimited (TNUIFSL)
TNUDP is a state government project with assistance from the World Bank.A part of the project is to enhance the institutional capacity andstrengthening the financial and managerial capacities in ULBs. Under thisproject, the TNUDF, the first private institutional arrangement in the country,has been established to assist municipalities in raising funds from markets tofinance specific infrastructure projects. It also helps local authorities tostructure and develop infrastructure projects.
Tamil Nadu UrbanDevelopment
Project (TNUDP)
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
30/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 28 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
4.4 Maharashtra
4.4.1 PPP in Maharashtra
Maharashtra does not have any specific institutional or regulatory framework for PPP across sectors.
Presently, individual organisations / agencies are responsible for carrying out the PPP projects
according to their own policies and guidelines and the thrust of PPPs in the state have been in ports
and roads sectors. Currently, PPP cell acts as the nodal agency and there is now a nodal officer in the
state who is responsible for overseeing all PPP projects in the state. A PPP Policy has been
formulated at the state level and is under the process of approval from the Cabinet.
The Maharashtra government has several infrastructure departments such as the Public Works
Department, Urban Development Department, and Water Supply and Sanitation Department which
have organizations (authorities and corporations) working under them to coordinate the PPP projects
in their respective sectors.The key agency responsible for PPP in ports is the Maharashtra Maritime Board (which is the nodal
agency for development of minor Ports in Maharashtra). The PPP projects in the road sector are under
the purview of the Public Works Department (PWD) and the Maharashtra State Road Development
Corporation Limited (MSRDC). Planning authorities such as MMRDA, CIDCO, Nagpur Improvement
Trust and Pimpri Chinchwad Development Authority under the Urban Development Department have
implemented PPP projects such as the Mumbai Metro and other Urban Infrastructure Projects.
In order to undertake road sector development through private sector participation, the Government of
Maharashtra had come out with a Policy on implementation of Road & Bridge Projects through
private sector participationin 1996. The key provisions of the policy include the following:
Certain concessions been granted to the private sector developer to make the project
financially attractive.
The entrepreneur is envisaged to meet the project cost and recover the same through tolls. In
some cases, based on the financial feasibility of the project, the government may decide to
contribute towards the project upto 40% of the project cost.
The Power to decide whether the project can be taken up through private sector participation
are as follows:
o For works/projects with estimated cost less than Rs. 50 crores, the Public Works
Department may take decision and the tender should be approved by the Public Works
Department on consultation with the Finance Department and after approval of the Minister
for Public Works Department.
o For works with estimated cost more than Rs. 50 crores, the proposal should be placed
before the Cabinet for approval. The tender for such works should also be placed before
the Cabinet for approval.
Maharashtra has also developed a Toll Policy, which provides for the tolls to be levied depending upon
the project cost for different categories of vehicles. Although the government does not give any traffic
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
31/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 29 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
guarantee, in cases where tolls cannot be charged for 15 days or more, there is a provision that the
government would compensate the concessionaire.
Salient features of Proposed PPP Policy
An Infrastructure Authority is proposed to be created for facilitating PPP projects in the state.
Decentralized approach
o It is proposed that no approvals will be required from Infrastructure Authority.
o Such authority will only be facilitated from PPP cell on technical matters.
As per existing rules, all the projects costing more than Rs 25 Cr necessarily be sent to Cabinet
Sub-committee on Infrastructure chaired by CM
VGF Approval
o Departments may approach GoI for VGF directly in case no State Support is required
o Departments have to approach GoI through State Government, in case State share of
20% is required or
o Departments have to take approval from State Government if entire 40% of total VGF
is required from State Government.
VGF to be housed in Planning Department
o Principal Secretary (Planning) is Member Secretary of Infrastructure Sub Committee
PDF to be created and housed in PPP Cell
Risks Disclosures in all the PPP Projects
VfM analyses for PPP projects need to be done
PPP Regulator to be established with sunset clause
Panel of States own Transactional Advisors in addition to GoI TAs must be established.
4.4.2 Key Learning from Maharashtra
Maharashtra does not have an overarching legislation or organization for doing PPP projects but still
the state has executed many PPP projects successfully. Some of the factors facilitating PPP in
Maharashtra are given below.
PPP facilitators like model documents and toolkits (PPP and Sector toolkits) enhance the
amenability of PPP.
A dedicated fund for supporting PPP projects at Urban Local Bodies, like MUIF, assists in
developing PPP projects at grass root level.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
32/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 30 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
4.5 Andhra Pradesh
4.5.1 PPP in Andhra Pradesh
Andhra Pradesh is one of the leading states in India with a successful track record of implementing
infrastructure projects under PPP framework. The state is amongst the first ones to have acomprehensive legislation relating to development of Infrastructure (AP Infrastructure Development
Enabling Act). In addition, AP has also constituted an Infrastructure Authority (IA) to co-ordinate and
develop various infrastructure initiatives under Public Private Partnerships. The following diagram
shows a broad level institutional framework for PPP in Andhra Pradesh.
Figure 10: Institutional Framework for PPP in Andhra Pradesh
In May 2005 the Government of Andhra Pradesh (GoAP) established anew department called the Infrastructure and Investment Department forachieving the infrastructure goals in select sectors `through a holisticapproach'. It was envisaged to create an environment for the upcoming
projects through single window facility. The Government of AndhraPradesh enacted the Andhra Pradesh Infrastructure DevelopmentEnabling Act (IDEA-2001) and two organizations have been set up - theInfrastructure Authority and Infrastructure Corporation of Andhra Pradesh.
Infrastructure andInvestmentDepartment
IDEA provided for the establishment of the Infrastructure authority (IA)under the Infrastructure and Investment department of the GoAP. TheAuthority has the Chief Secretary as the Chairman, and other membersinclude the Managing Director of APIIC, Director of National Academy ofConstruction and Secretaries of Departments of Finance & Planning,Transport, Roads & Bridges, IT, Municipal Administration & Urban
Development of GoAP.
InfrastructureAuthority (IA)
The GoAP created the Infrastructure Corporation of Andhra Pradesh(INCAP) on 31st May, 2005 as a part of the Department of Infrastructureand Investment working directly under the supervision of the HonbleChief Minister. INCAP was envisaged to facilitate infrastructuredevelopment by assisting the setting up and development of PPPprojects in the state. INCAP is also envisaged to enable the creation ofSpecial Purpose Vehicles that will provide impetus to infrastructureinvestment in the State.
The Infrastructure Corporation aims to facilitate project preparation,
project financing mechanism, the government role as sponsor /developer , access to long term funds and enhanced administrativesupport for Investors, including mobilizing and leveraging finances fromgovernment, public, private bilateral and multilateral entities includingViability Gap Funding from the Government of India where needed.
InfrastructureCorporation of
Andhra Pradesh(INCAP)
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
33/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 31 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Facilitators
Andhra Pradesh Infrastructure Policy
The Andhra Pradesh Infrastructure Policy provides guidelines for attracting and facilitating private
investments in infrastructure. It provides for a transparent selection mechanism, administrative support
for reduction in procedural delays and a risk sharing mechanism.
The Policy applies to all infrastructure projects implemented with Private Public Partnership (PPP) and
requiring Government support. The Infrastructure Development Enabling Act (IDEA) was enacted as a
result of this policy.
Infrastructure Development Enabling Act.(IDEA) 2001
It is applicable to all Infrastructure Projects implemented through PPP in the specified sectors of the
Act. The Act provides for the establishment of the Infrastructure authority (IA) with the Chief Secretary
as the Chairman, and members including Managing Director of APIIC, Director of National Academy of
Construction and Secretaries of Departments of Finance & Planning, Transport, Roads & Bridges, IT,Municipal Administration & Urban Development of GoAP.
The act formalizes the project delivery process by defining the procedures for the following:
Project identification
Project prioritization
Method of Selection of the developer
Selection criteria
Development of Model Concession Contract
The Act provides for the establishment of a Rs.10 million Infrastructure Projects Fund. It also entrusts
the IA to administer this fund.
Details about PPP agencies or organizations, projects, regulatory and policy framework in Andhra
Pradesh are given in Annexure 3.
4.5.2 Key Learning from Andhra Pradesh
Having gone through the PPP project cycle many times for projects in different sector, AP has some
experiences and recommendations for successful PPP. Given below are some key learning after
studying PPP projects and processes in AP and based on interactions with official from PPP Cell, AP.
For successful implementation of PPP, approval processes and committees for approving
projects with different project cost should be established.
Arbitration mechanism must be clearly spelt out in the PPP document (Guidelines / Policy/ Act).
Standardization of processes including appointment of Consultants and Transaction advisors
also contributes towards success of PPP.
Legal support for implementing any process or mechanism in PPP is required as it then
becomes binding on the departments and agencies to follow.
A dedicated Project Development fund aids preparation of projects in PPP format which
otherwise may not get developed through Department budget.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
34/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 32 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
4.6 Orissa
4.6.1 PPP in Orissa
Orissa has institutionalized PPP and established a state level PPP Policy in 2007. The Policy
document clearly spells out the mechanism for undertaking PPP projects. It has also put in place an
effective and efficient institutional mechanism for speedy clearance of the projects. Though the
success stories of PPP projects in the state are few but Orissa has well established institutional and
framework for PPP which is worth emulating. The three-tier hierarchical approval mechanism adopted
by Orissa is a national practice and is an effective mechanism.
The approval mechanism of PPP projects is as shown in diagram below.
Figure 11: Institutional Framework for PPP in Orissa
Role of ECI
The ECI shall be the nodal agency to co-ordinate all efforts of the State Government regarding
development of infrastructure sectors, involving private participation and funding from various sources.
The Powers and Functions of the ECI would include:
To prioritize, approve shelf of projects, sanction, authorize expenditure for PPP projects
Adopt, adapt and develop Model Concession Agreements for various sectors
Recommend projects for Viability Gap Funding
High Level Empowered Committee (HLCA)
Approve project costing greater than Rs. 500 crore
or involving any grant or other financial support
from GoO
Empowered Committee on Infrastructure (ECI)
Approve project costing lesser than Rs. 500 crore
or not involving any grant or other financial supportfrom GoO
Line
Departments
ECI deliberates a
recommends PPP
projects to HLCA
PPP cell housed in P&C department
assists ECI in approving PPP projects
Technical Secretariat
housed in IDCO
assists PPP cell.
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
35/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 33 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Manage the Infrastructure Development Fund proposed to be created to facilitate infrastructure
development, to recommend projects along with amount required from the Fund to meet the
objectives of this Policy
Deliberate and recommend to HLCA the final bids for approval of the projects above Rs. 500
crores.
Deliberate and recommend to HLCA any special grants and concessions
Coordinate the efforts of other departments for the furtherance of the objectives of this Policy.
Shall have power to inspect visit, review and monitor any PPP Projects regarding its
implementation, execution, operation and management.
To recommend enacting a special legislation for formation of appropriate regulatory
mechanism robust grievance redressal mechanism as may be required for the project.
To sanction PPP Projects and approval of concession agreements for projects upto Rs. 500
Crores.
Functions of the PPP Cell and Technical Secretariat (TS)
The Functions of the PPP Cell and its Technical Secretariat would include:
To identify, conceptualize and create a shelf of projects in consultation with the owner
department and recommend approval of such projects for PPP from time to time to the ECI.
To assist different government departments in preparing pre-feasibility reports by itself or
through consultants.
To assist the respective departments for preparing Detailed Project Reports
Shall have the powers to appoint / select consultants to take the projects upto selection of
developer stage in consultation with the concerned department.
To help respective departments to conduct the bidding process for appointment of developers.
To interact with the Planning Commission, GOI and other funding agencies like World Bank for
obtaining approval under VGF and any other fund created for such purpose.
To recommend the requirement of multilateral/bilateral funding for furthering the objectives of
the Policy.
To act as the nodal agency for capacity building for PPP in the state. To further this function itshall conduct/recommend exposure visits and training programs on PPP.
Recommend appropriate regulatory mechanism / robust grievance redressal mechanism as
per requirement of the project.
Recommend requirements from the PPP Fund for development of projects, gap funding and for
any other requirement for furthering the object of the Policy. It also assists in formulation and
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
36/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 34 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
recommendation of any legislation if required for creation, administration and monitoring of the
Fund.
The PPP cell shall develop internal evaluation guideline in consultation with the respective
departments to evaluate and assess the projects whether the projects are to be funded by the
State Government, through multilateral/bilateral funding and/or implemented with Private sectorparticipation.
4.6.2 Key Learning from Orissa
Institutional mechanism for PPP in Orissa is stronger and well established than many other Indian
states. Therefore, there are many lessons which are worth emulating from Orissa.
PPP Policy document enunciating institutional, legal and approval mechanism for PPP
facilitates departments to undertake PPP projects.
A structured hierarchical approval process adds to faster movement of PPP project in the
project cycle. PPP cell can be the technical secretariat to such approval committees.
4.7 Conclusion
4.7.1 Conclusion based on State wise PPP study
After studying the PPP scenario in the selected states, a comparative table highlighting the policy,
legislative and institutional framework has been prepared. The table is as shown below
-
7/31/2019 Mp Draft Ppp Policy
37/117
Policy Framework and Institutional Roadmap for PPP in Madhya Pradesh
Page | 35 2011 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu India Pvt. Ltd.
Table 4: Comparison of Institutional Framework for PPP in 5 states
StateLegislation/Policy
Agency/ Institution Facilitators Role of agency
GujaratGIDBAct,1999(BOT law)
GIDB nodal agency forPPP/ PPP Cell
Sector policies,
VGF fund (proposed),
MCAs
Overall planning, policy support,coordination between departments,monitoring the progress of PPP, projectpreparation, capacity building and approval(Executive Committee as the Secretariat to
Board)
MaharashtraNooverarchinglegislation
PPP Cell/ MSRDC/MUINFRA
PPP Toolkits (water and urbantransport)
Maharashtra UrbanInfrastructure Fund (MUIF)
PPP cell provides state support for PPPthrough line departments;
MUIF meant to facilitate access toinstitutional finance and capital markets andMUINFRA assists urban local authorities indeveloping projects.
AndhraPradesh
InfrastructureDevelopmentEnablingAct(IDEA),2001
Infrastructure authority /PPP Cell/ INCAP
Sector Policies,
Infrastructure Fund / ProjectDevelopment Fund
Coordination with line departments,monitoring of progress, status of clearances,management of infrastructure fund, projectpreparation, seeking GoI assistance
OrissaPPP Policy,
2007
PPP Cell
HLCA & ECoI for approval
Various forms of governmentsupport;
VGF fund proposed
PPP Cell promotes PPP in infrastructureand helps in project development andprioritization. It also guides and approvesthe project and assists in procuring VGFfunding for the projects
Tamil Nadu
Nooverarchinglegislation /Nodal agency
JVs with private sector forend to end PPP-projectpreparation toimplementation in road,water and urbaninfrastructure / PPP Cell
Sector policies /
To attract private investments,government sometimes givescapital subsidy of 25% up to Rs.2.5 million.
JVs are run as joint management bygovernment and private sector. Themanagin