![Page 1: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
CLICK ON EACH FILE IN THE LEFT HAND COLUMN TO SEE INDIVIDUAL PRESENTATIONS.
If no column is present: click Bookmarks or Pages on the left side of the window.
If no icons are present: Click View, select Navigational Panels, and chose either Bookmarks or Pages.
If you need assistance or to register for the audio portion, please call Strafford customer service at 800-926-7926 ext. 10
Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle
Strategies for Valuing and Contesting NRD Injury and Damagespresents
Today's panel features:Valerie A. Lee, President, Environment International Ltd., Seattle
Michael R. Thorp, Summit Law Group, Seattle
Thursday, October 15, 2009
The conference begins at:1 pm Eastern12 pm Central
11 am Mountain10 am Pacific
The audio portion of this conference will be accessible by telephone only. Please refer to the dial in instructions emailed to registrants to access the audio portion of the conference.
A Live 90-Minute Teleconference/Webinar with Interactive Q&A
![Page 2: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
1 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Natural Resource Damage Assessment (NRDA)
Valerie Ann Lee, J.D., M.S. Civ. Eng.Environment International Ltd.Seattle, WAwww.eiltd.net
206-525-3362
Injury Assessment∑
Interdisciplinary Creativity of Law and Science
![Page 3: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
2
Topics of FocusNRDA
I. Overarching Legal Principlesand Technical Concepts
II. Federal Regulations III. Injury Determination and Quantification
Environnent International Ltd.© 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 4: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
3
I: Legal Principles & Technical Concepts of NRDA
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 5: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
4
NRDA Claims Five federal statutes – CERCLA, OPA, CWA, MPRSA, 19jj
State statutes mostly of sparse direction – WA, Maine, NJ, TX,
Right of action held only by governments (trustees)
- Federal, State & Tribal
Purpose is compensation, not punishment
Common body of law and science
The nature of the endeavor
interdisciplinary
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 6: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5
Trustees Damage assessments performed by
federal, state or tribal governments designated as natural resource “trustees”
Trustees bring claims for injuries to resources under their respective management or control
Damage assessments are most frequently conducted by inter-governmental teams (trustee councils)
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 7: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
6
Federal Agencies: Trustees/PRPs
• Dept of Interior• NOAA• Dept. of Energy (Hanford, most visible)• DoD units, Navy and other
branches
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 8: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
7
Tribal Trustees & Cases• Commencement Bay• Coeur D’Alene• Tulalip• Hanford• Clark Fork• Suquamish and Cultural Resources• St. Lawrence River• Saginaw Chippewa
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 9: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
8
MA, ME, NJ, TX, CA, WA, OR, etc.
States Active in NRDA
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 10: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
9 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Types of Cases
![Page 11: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
10 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 12: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
11 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 13: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
12 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 14: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
13
Objectives and Liability
costs of restoration, replacement or acquisition of like-kind resources to restore natural resources and their associated services to “baseline”
interim loss for the period it takes to restore or replace assessment costs monitoring costs interest from time of demand (federal law makes
explicit)
Objective of the AssessmentTranslate injuries to money or activities to make the public or environment whole
Responsible Parties liable for
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 15: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
14
Nature of Liability Under All Statutes
Strict, joint and several
– where the harm is indivisible
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 16: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
15
Limited Defenses
Statutes have similar limited defenseso Act of God or waro Act of omission of a third party (no RP fault,
due care) o Activity authorized by federal or state law
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 17: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
16
Injury and Damage
Injury – a scientific conceptadverse impact on resources or services resulting from an incident like an oil spill or release of hazardous substances
Damage – a legal term of arttranslation of injuries into what a liable party must do or pay to make the public and environment “whole”
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 18: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
17
Natural/Public Resources
Natural Resources -- Land, fish, wildlife, biota, air, water, groundwater, drinking water supplies and other such resources belonging to, or otherwise controlled by, the U.S. … any state or local government, any foreign government, any Indian tribe, or, if such resources are subject to a trust restriction on alienation, any member of an Indian Tribe. CERCLA § 101(16)
OPA has nearly identical language.
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 19: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
18
Other Covered Resources/Uses
Under CERCLA and OPA, cultural and spiritual resources if linked to a use or service provided by a natural resource.
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 20: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
19
Services
Ecological and HumanFunctions performed by a natural resource for the benefit of another natural resource and/or the public. 15 CFR §990.30
The physical and biological functions performed by the resource including the human uses of those functions. 43 CFR §11.14 (nn)
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 21: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
20
Restoration and Baseline
Return the injured resource (or services) to the condition they would have been in but for the incident – return to the pre-incident “baseline”
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 22: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
21
NRDA Elements
Pre-assessment
Injury assessment
Damage assessment
Restoration implementation
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 23: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
22 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
II. Federal NRDA RegulationsA Federal Framework for Assessments
![Page 24: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
23 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Federal Regulations
40 CFR Part 11 – Promulgated by DOI under CERCLA to address NRDAs hazardous substances releases and discharges under CERCLA and the CWA
15 CFR Part 990 – Promulgated by NOAA under OPA to address NRDAs discharges of oil under OPA and the CWA
![Page 25: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
24 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
The Regulations
Regulations under CERCLA and OPA Both sets of regulations involved long
history and legal challenges NOAA’s OPA regulations are brief DOI’s CERCLA regulations are lengthy
and more prescriptive regarding tools and techniques
OPA regulations previously focus more on projects as the metric for assigning damage for interim losses; however, DOI recent modifications emphasize efficient resolution and “restoration over economic damages.”
![Page 26: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
25 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Rebuttable Presumption
Regulations are voluntary, Trustees obtain a “rebuttablepresumption” for any determination or assessment of damages
“Burden-shifting exercise;” not clear it gives the trustees a “powerful advantage” – D.C. Circuit
![Page 27: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
26 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Injuries as Defined by DOI Regulations Violations of standards (e.g., drinking water, water
quality criteria ,etc.) Bioassays showing elevated toxicity Death, disease, behavioral abnormalities, cancer, genetic
mutations, physiological malfunctions or physical deformities (e.g., fin erosion, lesions)
Egg shell thinning Habitat avoidance behavior Exceedances of action or
tolerance levels in food consumed by humans
![Page 28: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
27 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
CERCLA Regulations Injury both “direct and indirect” Monetary value as basis of recovery
for interim losses (contrast with OPA regulations)
Type A Assessment Procedures (Limited applicability)
Type B Assessments Procedures (Extensive literature review, sampling, and field observation)
Public involved in Assessment Plan and Restoration Plan
![Page 29: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
28 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Type B Assessment Procedures(1) Injury determination
Resources (Surface water, groundwater, air, geologic and biologic)“Definitions” for injury“Acceptance criteria”Exposure pathway
(2) Injury quantification(3) Damage determination(4) Report of Assessment (60 days for PRPs to
respond)
![Page 30: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
29
III. Injury Assessment –
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Determination and Quantification
![Page 31: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
30
What is an Injury?No statute defines “injury”Under CERCLA regulations: “measurable, adverse
change”OPA regulations include “observable” change Injuries: direct and indirect adverse consequences There are some states with similar approaches, e.g.,
WA.
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 32: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
31
“Scale” of the Injury
Individual Population – what’s a population?WatershedEcosystemGlobal
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 33: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
32
Scale of Injury Amount of Data and Difficulty of
Proof
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Global
Amount of Data
Individual/cellular
HeapsNot Much
Injury
![Page 34: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
33
What’s Proof?
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Amount ofEvidence
$250,000 $50,000,000
ExpectedLiability
![Page 35: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
34
Injury Determination and Quantification
Injury determination considers whether an activity has resulted in injury
Injury quantification determines the magnitude of injury to natural resources
In many assessments, no clear division between determination and quantification
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 36: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
35
Injury Assessment Framework
• Review readily available information• Identify possible injuries• Identify data gaps and develop a
focus for the injury assessment
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 37: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
36
Integration of NRDA with RI/FS
Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study
(RI/FS)
Nature and extent of contamination
Human Health Risk Assessment Ecological Risk Assessment
Results to NRDA
![Page 38: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
37 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Possible InjuriesDetermination requires:• A pathway between discharge and
natural resource of concern• The resource was exposed to the
discharge• Exposure has caused adverse effect
on the resource
Quantification requires:• Measurement of injury scope and
extent• Identification of baseline conditions
![Page 39: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
38 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 40: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
39 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
![Page 41: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
40 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Are assessment procedures available and what are their costs?
What is the natural recovery period for the resource?
How important is the resource to the environment and the public?
Is the resource endangered/ threatened or of tribal/cultural significance?
Develop a Focus
![Page 42: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
41 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Assessment Techniques Selection Considerations
CostReliability and acceptance in the
scientific communityAppropriateness to study the injuryAppropriateness for the locationAppropriateness of the time frame
for the study Statistical and evidentiary power of
the information gained
![Page 43: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
42 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Methods to Determine Injury
Literature ReviewModeling Techniques Field StudiesLaboratory StudiesAnalysis of Information
on Use (human and ecological)
![Page 44: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
43 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Methods to Determine BaselineHistorical Baseline LevelsLocal Reference ApproachReference Population ApproachGradient Designs
![Page 45: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
44 Environnent International Ltd. © 2009 ▪ www.eiltd.net
Minimizes costs for PRPsAvoids duplicative studiesReduces time required for full restoration and
restitution of damages and enhance public image
Cooperative Assessment?…. Next speaker!
CoordinatingNRDA and Response Activities
![Page 46: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
DAMAGE DETERMINATIONDAMAGE DETERMINATION
COOPERATIVE NATURAL COOPERATIVE NATURAL RESOURCE DAMAGE RESOURCE DAMAGE
ASSESSMENTSASSESSMENTS
Michael R. Thorp
![Page 47: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
2
DAMAGE DETERMINATIONDAMAGE DETERMINATION
![Page 48: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
3
StatuteStatute
“The measure of damages in any action under subparagraph (C) of subsection (a) of this section shall not be limited by the sums which can be used to restore or replace such resources.” CERCLA §107(f)(1).
![Page 49: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
4
Statute Statute (cont(cont’’d)d)
“Such regulations shall identify the best available procedures to determine such damages, including both direct and indirect injury, destruction, or loss and shall take into consideration factors including, but not limited to, replacement value, use value, and ability of the ecosystem or resource to recover.”CERCLA § 301(c)(2).
![Page 50: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
5
RegulationsRegulations
Interior Department: 43 CFR §§11.80-11.84.
43 CFR §11.83 Lists Accepted Methodologies:
• Market Price • Appraisal• Factor Income • Travel Cost• Hedonic Pricing • Unit Value/Benefits• Contingent Valuation • Conjoint Analysis• Habitat Equivalency
Analysis• Resource Equivalency
Analysis• Random Utility Model
![Page 51: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
6
Case LawCase LawNRD Trustees are entitled to seek damages for both restoration
costs (the cost of restoring, rehabilitating, replacing, or acquiring the equivalent of lost or injured resources) and the lost use (including lost “passive-use”) of injured or lost resources during the interim pending the completion of restoration. State of Ohio v. Interior, 880 F.2d at 448.
The cost of restoration is the preferred measure of the damage recovery in an NRD case. However, in some cases a different method of damage calculation may be more appropriate such as where restoration is infeasible or the cost of restoration is grossly disproportionate to or excessively costly compared to the lost use value. State of Ohio v. Interior, 880 F.2d at 443.
![Page 52: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
7
Case Law Case Law (cont(cont’’d)d)
While market price may be used as one factor in determining the lost use value, these values should be derived by summing up allapplicable and reliably calculated use values, however measured.This should include, where appropriate, non-consumptive values. State of Ohio v. Interior, 880 F.2d at 462.
As a general matter, contingent valuation methodology may be used to calculate lost use values “so long as the technique produces . . . valid and reliable results for the particular incident. General Electric v. Dept. of Commerce, 128 F.2d at 773.
![Page 53: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
8
Costs of AssessmentCosts of Assessment
CERCLA §107(a)(4)(C), 42 U.S.C. §9607(a)(4)(C) provides that in addition to natural resource damages, trustees are entitled to seek “the reasonable costs of assessing such injury, destruction, or loss resulting from such a release.”
![Page 54: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
9
COEUR DCOEUR D’’ALENE EXAMPLEALENE EXAMPLE
![Page 55: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
10
![Page 56: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
11
![Page 57: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
12
![Page 58: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
13
![Page 59: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
14
![Page 60: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
15
![Page 61: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
16
COOPERATIVE NATURAL RESOURCE COOPERATIVE NATURAL RESOURCE DAMAGE ASSESSMENTSDAMAGE ASSESSMENTS
![Page 62: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
17
StatutesStatutes
• Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation and Liability Act of 1980,42 U.S.C. § 9601 et. seq. (CERCLA)• § 9607(f)(2)(A): “[Trustees] shall assess damages for
injury to, destruction of, or loss of natural resources….”
• Oil Pollution Act of 1990, 33 U.S.C. §§ 2701 et. seq. (OPA)• § 2706(c)(1): “The Federal Officials… shall assess
natural resource damages … for natural resources under their trusteeship.”
![Page 63: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
18
Statutes Statutes (cont(cont’’d)d)
• National Marine Sanctuaries Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 1431 et. seq.• § 1443(b)(2): “The Secretary shall assess damages to sanctuary
resources.”
• Park System Resources Protection Act, 16 U.S.C. §§ 19jj• § 19jj-2(b)(2): “The Secretary shall assess and monitor
damages to park system resources.”
![Page 64: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
19
RegulationsRegulations
“The authorized official shall send a Notice of Intent to Perform an Assessment to all identified potentially responsible parties. The Notice shall invite the participation of the potentially responsible parties . . . in the development of the type and scope of the assessment and in the performance of the assessment.”43 CFR §11.32(a)(2)(iii)(A).
“Trustees must invite the responsible parties to participate in the natural resource damage assessment.” 15 CFR §990.14c
![Page 65: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
20
What Is A Natural Resource Damage What Is A Natural Resource Damage Assessment?Assessment?
“The process of collecting, compiling, and analyzing information, statistics, or data through prescribed methodologies to determine damages for injuries to natural resources.” 43 CFR §11.14(aa).
NRDA Process: (1) Screening and Assessment Plan;(2) Injury Determination; (3) Injury Quantification; (4) Identification of Reduction in Services;(5) Determine Damages.
![Page 66: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
21
What Is A Cooperative Assessment?What Is A Cooperative Assessment?
• No standard definition
• The degree of “cooperation” is very broad and specific to trustees
• Significant advantages and disadvantages
• No industry consensus on advisability or approach
![Page 67: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
22
AdvantagesAdvantages• The opportunity for the PRPs to influence the scope,
direction and outcome of the NRDA• Some degree of NRDA cost control• The process serves as a pathway to settlement• The development of a common database• The opportunity for the PRPs to focus the assessment
on PRP issues such as baseline and causation• Focus on restoration• For the trustees-an opportunity to get up front funding
for the NRDA from the PRPs
![Page 68: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
23
DisadvantagesDisadvantages
• By providing funding, PRPs may actually accelerate or increase the scope of the NRDA
• The NRDA may not be truly “cooperative” as the trustees may take the PRP’s money and then simply go through the motions of considering PRP input into the process
• A cooperative NRDA may compromise the PRP’sability to challenge the NRDA results
• Involvement by the PRPs may improve the quality of the NRDA making it harder to challenge
![Page 69: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
24
Disadvantages Disadvantages (cont(cont’’d)d)
• Cooperation is a two-way street. The PRPs may have to give up positions they would otherwise maintain
• Science may be compromised in order to expedite the process: non-scientific, simplifying assumptions, absence of rigorous analysis of baseline or causation, little or no connection between restoration projects and injury
![Page 70: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
25
Common CooperativeCommon CooperativeAssessment IssuesAssessment Issues
• Is there a standard process?
• Is there a standard written agreement?
• Is there flexibility?
![Page 71: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
26
Keys to SuccessKeys to Success
1. The parties should be realistic about the chances of success. Four factors seem to be critical: (1) How big is the “incident” and potential claim?; (2) Is it a historical incident or recent?; (3) What is the historical relationship between the trustees and thePRPs?; and (4) How enthusiastic are the primary players to engage in the process?
2. There must be effective leadership for both the trustees and the PRPs. These people should be problem solvers with good consensus building skills.
![Page 72: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
27
Keys to Success Keys to Success (cont(cont’’d)d)
3. The cooperative assessment process must be initiated before positions are carved in stone. Most importantly, the trustee must not have taken a public position on the dollar amount of the damage claim.
4. There must be some provision for public involvement. This does not mean that the public must be at the negotiating table but there should be regular briefings and a mechanism for public input at important points, particularly regarding possible restoration projects. It is important to keep local government informed.
5. There should be an early focus on restoration. Restoration should be the constant theme of discussions
![Page 73: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
28
Keys to Success Keys to Success (cont(cont’’d)d)
6. The parties should create a process which attempts to avoid “hot button” words.
7. The process should allow for the issues of both sides to be addressed.
8. There should be a realistic approach to restoration. Restoration should be linked to injury. Re-openers and performance standards can be problems.
9. The process works best if it is funded in part by both sides.
10. Individuals with authority should be personally involved in the process.
![Page 74: Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battlemedia.straffordpub.com/products/natural-resource-damages-the... · Natural Resource Damages: The Assessment Battle ... Natural Resources](https://reader030.vdocument.in/reader030/viewer/2022032613/5ada7e407f8b9a6d318cd0a2/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
29
Keys to Success Keys to Success (cont(cont’’d)d)
11. The parties should establish a definite schedule and stick to it.
12. Consideration should be given to use of a third party mediator.
13. The collection of new data should be limited to critical items, not trustee research projects.