-
Navy Altimetry & NOWCAST/FORECAST Sensitivity in Undersea Warfare SystemsGuillermo Amezaga LT, USNRAdvisor: Prof. Peter ChuSecond Readers: Eric Gottshall, CDR USNPast Thesis: Michael Perry ENS, USNRSteve Mancini LCDR, USNCollaborator: David CwalinaTodd Drury
-
Past ThesisMichael Perry, June 2003GDEM vs MODAS with 3 altimetersMarch 15, 2001117 vs 1633 profiles35.0-40.0N70.0-75.0WArea coverage is an effective metric for comparing weapon presets
-
Past Thesis Process Flowchart (Mancini,2004)RelativeDifference
-
Thesis Process Flowchartfor NOWCAST/FORECASTRelativeDifferencePOMOBSMODAS
-
Thesis Process FlowchartNavy Altimetry RelativeDifference
-
Area of Interest (AOI)Taiwan High Oceanographic variabilityNE/SW MonsoonMeso-scale (Eddies)TyphoonsTactical Significance SCSMEX data availability MODAS validationPOM validationHydrographic data availability
-
Taiwan (AOI)(From Laing et. al., 2001)
-
Snapshotof Variability30m depth100m depth(From Laing et. al., 2002)
-
Satellite orbitology
GEOSAT Follow On (GFO)TOPEX (TPX)JAN 2001
-
GFO launched FEB 1998Exact overhead repeat 17 daysOrbit 800 km108 degree inclination0.001 eccentricityTPX launched AUG 1992Exact overhead repeat 10 daysOrbit 1336 km66 degree inclinationCircular
-
Satellite orbitology
GEOSAT Follow On (GFO)TOPEX (TPX)JUL 2001
-
NOWCAST/FORECASTVALIDATION South China Sea Experiment (SCSMEX) validation of MODAS and POM
-
SCSMEXSCSMEX was large scale multi-national experiment in the SCSMain goal of gaining insight into the water and energy cycle of the Asian monsoon cycle (Chu et al, 2001) SCSMEX provided a unique opportunity to evaluate both the POM and MODAS. SCSMEX was conducted in the SCS from April through June 1998. During SCSMEX, the oceanographic data set included 1742 CTD and mooring stations (Chu et al, 2001).
-
SCSMEX ObservationSCSMEX provided a unique opportunity to evaluate both the POM and MODASSCSMEX was conducted in the SCS from April through June 1998Oceanographic data set included 1742 CTD and mooring stations (Chu et al, 2001).
(From Chu et. al., 2001)
-
Methodology of SCSMEX evaluation of MODAS
Both observational and climatology where used in the verification of the value added of MODAS (Chu et al, 2004) The observational data was used as the benchmark to determine the error statistics for MODAS and climatology data. MODAS has added value if the difference between MODAS and observational data is smaller than the difference between climatological and observational data. (Chu et al, 2004).
-
Methodology of SCSMEX evaluation of MODAS (POM)
MODAS, climatology , and observational data are represented by (temperature, salinity). The difference in between MODAS and observational data is:
And, the difference in between climatology and observational data is.
-
Methodology of SCSMEX evaluation of MODAS (POM)
The bias , mean-squareerror (MSE), and root-mean-square-error (RMSE) for MODAS ,
Where, N is the total number of horizontal points (Chu et al, 2004)
-
Results of SCSMEX evaluation of MODASMODAS provides reasonably good temperature and salinity NOWCAST. (Chu et. al., 2004)Gaussian-type distribution of errorsMean Temperature error nearly zero (deg C)Mean Salinity error of -0.2 pptMODAS temperature NOWCAST better than salinity NOWCAST
-
Results of SCSMEX evaluation of MODAS(From Chu et. al., 2004)
-
Results of SCSMEX evaluation of POMPOM without data assimilation has capability to predict circulation patterns, temperature fields reasonably well, but has no capability to predict salinity fields. (Chu et. al., 2001)POM errors for temperature have a Gaussian-type distributionPOM errors for salinity have a non-Gaussian type distributionData assimilation enhances POM HINDCAST performancePOM errors for BOTH temperature and salinity have Gaussian type distribution
-
MODAS vs POMMODAS is the US Navys premier dynamic climatology tool. MODAS provides the capability of modifying the historical climatology with remotely sensed SSH and SSTDynamic MODAS assimilates in situ measurements of the temperature and salinity by method known as Optimum Interpolation techniques (Fox et al 2002). The surface structure projected downward using empirical relationships of the historical data which relates both SST and SSH to the subsurface temperature (Fox et. al., 2002).POM is a general three dimensional gridded model that is time-dependent and utilizes primitive equations to model general circulation with realistic topography and a free surface (Chu et al, 2001). POM was specifically developed to model nonlinear processes and mesocale eddy phenomena.
-
Navy Altimetry requirements for MODAS and numerical modelsA minimum of one instrument is required. With only one instrument, this data must be used in conjunction with systems such as MODAS and NRL Layered Ocean Model (NLOM). (NRL/FR/7320 99-9696)
-
Process FlowchartRelativeDifferencePOMOBSMODAS
-
Weapons Acoustic Preset Program (WAPP) ObjectivesTo Provide the Fleet with an On-Board Automated Interactive Means for Generating Mk 48 & Mk 48 ADCAP Acoustic Presets and Visualizing Torpedo PerformanceBase Computations on In Situ Environmental, Tactical, Target, and Weapon ParametersTrack the Evolution of Weapon, Tactical, Target, and Environmental ModelsProvide Interfaces to Support Fleet Exercises, Training, and Program Deliveries
-
Data SourcesProjected Environment (NUWC, NPT, RI, 2005)Latitude/LongitudeDate-Time GroupDBDB-V v4.2Level 2GDEM-V v3.0HIE (SN v5.3)SMGC v2.0BST v1.0Bottom DepthSound Speed ProfileOpen Water/MIZ/Ice CoverHistoric Wind SpeedBottom Sediment TypeShallow/Deep WaterSound Speed ProfileUnder IceSea StateBottom TypeVSS v6.3Volume Scattering StrengthProfile
-
Generated OutputPercentage Area CoverageASUW and ASW ScenariosShallow, Mid, and Deep Search BandsHigh and Low Doppler TargetsValues Normalized Over Acoustic Modes
-
Acoustic Preset ModuleRanked ListsetList Set of Search Depth/Pitch Angle/Laminar Distance/Effectiveness Values List Set Ranked Based on Acoustic Coverage Effectiveness and Recommendation Made Accounting for Cavitations and Depth SeparationLaminar Distance Utilized in Weapon Order Generation for Gyro/RTE
-
Acoustic Preset Module Signal Excess Display
Signal Excess Selectable from Pull-Down Menu Provide a Visual Interpretation of Mk 48 Acoustic Performance Over Depth Band of Target
-
5 Tactical Scenarios EvaluatedHD Deep ASWLD Deep ASWLD Shallow ASWHD ASUWLD ASUW
-
WAPP output for MODAS and POM
Here, the subscripts m denotes MODAS and p denotes. (Manicini, 2004) The relative difference was calculated using statistical package, which produced absolute values of the relative differences (RD) in area coverage (AC) for the identical SD/SA combination generated by WAPP,
-
WAPP output for MODAS and POMMeanMEAN= 12.08STD= 5.51MEAN= 18.04STD= 7.76
LZ DATA
scenario# different SA/SD combos# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.1)Prob (RD > 0.1)# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.2)Prob (RD > 0.2)
OBS MOD1 HD Deep ASW76326734.99253.28
OBS MOD2 HD Deep ASW76336147.3140.52
OBS MOD1 LD Deep ASW76331841.68222.88
OBS MOD2 LD Deep ASW76329038.0150.66
OBS MOD1 Shallow ASW76329939.19233.01
OBS MOD2 Shallow ASW76328337.0970.92
OBS MOD1 HD ASUW76314719.2716521.63
OBS MOD2 HD ASUW76316721.899812.84
OBS MOD1 LD ASUW76315520.3111414.94
OBS MOD2 LD ASUW76316020.97678.78
LZ PROB
34.99344692013.2765399738
47.31323722150.5242463958
41.67758846662.8833551769
38.00786369590.6553079948
39.18741808653.0144167759
37.09043250330.9174311927
19.266055045921.625163827
21.887287024912.8440366972
20.314547837514.9410222805
20.96985583228.7811271298
Prob (RD > 0.1)
Prob (RD > 0.2)
MODAS Shallow ASW
4
39
50
204
91
6
5
0
1
0
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS Shallow ASW
POM shallow ASW
3
64
102
218
9
4
0
0
0
0
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA
OBS vs POM Shallow ASW
MODAS HD ASUW
2
6
29
39
40
128
109
41
3
3
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
MODAS vs OBS HD ASUW
POM HD ASUW
4
19
54
107
131
80
2
2
1
0
OBS POM HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs POM HD ASUW
MODAS LD ASUW
3
11
45
47
33
129
107
25
0
0
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD ASUW
POM LD ASUW
3
26
65
86
166
51
1
2
0
0
OBS POM LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/ SA .
OBS vs POM LD ASUW
pom modas data
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500
0251015202530405050Total
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200
0251015202530405050TotalPD> 10PD> 20MeanSD02510152025304050
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040037.2540.511.3054.8879141012383.4090752251.158651868.392175253.7507252211.79005453.61815937.765125349.503025823.40302509532.79
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040070.755.758.982.952353464280.64041023.12841124.6684294.4332833.5292121.440400003477.84
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040050.522.259.66254.4184159774466.819531252348.556251260.856562523.00906252535.51265625213.7278125940.9556250007789.4375
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040055.252.257.593.5607016852172.82431968.6303677.51811283.5901494.1729462.024300005058.76
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW4395020491650104005122.7510.0454.7612654959403.60812524.1589751272.601250.41312234.234275594.612151118.2601250897.30202509045.19
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM Shallow ASW36410221894000040054.52.257.58253.6215996064172.482918751994.5156680.26923751274.0587625495.17375625616.77722500005233.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334009.751019.837.8969617583786.45781907.45346377.93813768.5271933.1563.69922913.45014240.58491220.48672730.686724882.44
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD ASUW4195410713180221040026.7532.7512.73255.7961134459648.4662252188.544568753228.7440375798.92151875673.543868754225.3245300.9831125596.3331125743.51655625013404.3775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040011.758.2518.04257.764755135976.595418752830.979868757654.806281253040.04489375305.47460625494.303006255179.528268753574.545156250024056.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD ASUW326658616651120040021.541.512.085.5144921852437.77922641.76643258.216372.07041415.38243199.0464166.9264642.25280012133.44
POM LD Deep ASW
3
63
101
221
9
3
0
0
0
0
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBSvs POM LD Deep ASW
Chart6
43.753.25
23.751.5
25.753
8171
73.565.25
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
MODAS RD for 5 Tactial Scenario
Chart7
60.25
30.75
3.251
5421.25
5513.5
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
POM RD for 5 Tactical Scenario
Chart8
11.38.98
9.667.59
10.047.58
19.8312.73
18.0412.08
MODAS Mean RD
POM Mean RD
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%)
MODAS and POM Mean RD
Sheet1
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040043.753.25
MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040023.751.5
MODAS Shallow ASW43950204916501040025.753
MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334008171
MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040073.565.25
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040060.25
POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040030.75
POM Shallow ASW3641022189400004003.251
POM HD ASUW419541071318022104005421.25
POM LD ASUW32665861665112004005513.5
MODAS Mean RDPOM Mean RD
HD Deep ASW11.38.982.32
LD Deep ASW9.667.592.07
LD Shallow ASW10.047.582.46
HD ASUW19.8312.737.1
LD ASUW18.0412.085.96
MODAS LD Deep ASW
5
40
58
202
89
2
4
0
0
0
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD Deep ASW
POM HD Deep ASW
1
21
71
283
23
1
0
0
0
0
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SA/SD .
OBS vs POM HD Deep ASW
MODAS HD deep ASW
3
26
47
149
162
6
5
1
1
0
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA k
OBS vs MODAS HD Deep ASW
Chart1
3153432433
2621406339646191126
4771581015010229544565
149283202221204218391074786
162238999194013133166
6123641288012951
50405010921071
100000412252
1000103100
0000003000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart2
315343
262140633964
47715810150102
149283202221204218
16223899919
612364
504050
100000
100010
000000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Chart3
2433
6191126
29544565
391074786
4013133166
1288012951
10921071
412252
3100
3000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart4
35423
264039611
4758502945
1492022043947
16289914033
626128129
545109107
1004125
10130
00030
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Chart5
13343
2163641926
711011025465
28322121810786
2399131166
1348051
00021
00022
00010
00000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
LZ DATA
scenario# different SA/SD combos# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.1)Prob (RD > 0.1)# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.2)Prob (RD > 0.2)
OBS MOD1 HD Deep ASW76326734.99253.28
OBS MOD2 HD Deep ASW76336147.3140.52
OBS MOD1 LD Deep ASW76331841.68222.88
OBS MOD2 LD Deep ASW76329038.0150.66
OBS MOD1 Shallow ASW76329939.19233.01
OBS MOD2 Shallow ASW76328337.0970.92
OBS MOD1 HD ASUW76314719.2716521.63
OBS MOD2 HD ASUW76316721.899812.84
OBS MOD1 LD ASUW76315520.3111414.94
OBS MOD2 LD ASUW76316020.97678.78
LZ PROB
34.99344692013.2765399738
47.31323722150.5242463958
41.67758846662.8833551769
38.00786369590.6553079948
39.18741808653.0144167759
37.09043250330.9174311927
19.266055045921.625163827
21.887287024912.8440366972
20.314547837514.9410222805
20.96985583228.7811271298
Prob (RD > 0.1)
Prob (RD > 0.2)
MODAS Shallow ASW
4
39
50
204
91
6
5
0
1
0
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS Shallow ASW
POM shallow ASW
3
64
102
218
9
4
0
0
0
0
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA
OBS vs POM Shallow ASW
MODAS HD ASUW
2
6
29
39
40
128
109
41
3
3
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS HD ASUW
POM HD ASUW
4
19
54
107
131
80
2
2
1
0
OBS POM HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
POM vs MODAS HD ASUW
MODAS LD ASUW
3
11
45
47
33
129
107
25
0
0
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD ASUW
POM LD ASUW
3
26
65
86
166
51
1
2
0
0
OBS POM LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/ SA .
OBS vs POM LD ASUW
pom modas data
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500
0251015202530405050Total
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200
0251015202530405050TotalPD> 10PD> 20MeanSD02510152025304050
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040037.2540.511.3054.8879141012383.4090752251.158651868.392175253.7507252211.79005453.61815937.765125349.503025823.40302509532.79
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040070.755.758.982.952353464280.64041023.12841124.6684294.4332833.5292121.440400003477.84
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040050.522.259.66254.4184159774466.819531252348.556251260.856562523.00906252535.51265625213.7278125940.9556250007789.4375
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040055.252.257.593.5607016852172.82431968.6303677.51811283.5901494.1729462.024300005058.76
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW4395020491650104005122.7510.0454.7612654959403.60812524.1589751272.601250.41312234.234275594.612151118.2601250897.30202509045.19
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM Shallow ASW36410221894000040054.52.257.58253.6215996064172.482918751994.5156680.26923751274.0587625495.17375625616.77722500005233.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334009.751019.837.8969617583786.45781907.45346377.93813768.5271933.1563.69922913.45014240.58491220.48672730.686724882.44
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD ASUW4195410713180221040026.7532.7512.73255.7961134459648.4662252188.544568753228.7440375798.92151875673.543868754225.3245300.9831125596.3331125743.51655625013404.3775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040011.758.2518.04257.764755135976.595418752830.979868757654.806281253040.04489375305.47460625494.303006255179.528268753574.545156250024056.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD ASUW326658616651120040021.541.512.085.5144921852437.77922641.76643258.216372.07041415.38243199.0464166.9264642.25280012133.44
POM LD Deep ASW
3
63
101
221
9
3
0
0
0
0
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBSvs POM LD Deep ASW
Chart6
43.753.25
23.751.5
25.753
8171
73.565.25
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
MODAS RD for 5 Tactial Scenario
Chart7
60.25
30.75
3.251
5421.25
5513.5
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
POM RD for 5 Tactical Scenario
Chart8
11.38.98
9.667.59
10.047.58
19.8312.73
18.0412.08
MODAS Mean RD
POM Mean RD
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%)
MODAS and POM Mean RD
Sheet1
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040043.753.25
MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040023.751.5
MODAS Shallow ASW43950204916501040025.753
MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334008171
MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040073.565.25
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040060.25
POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040030.75
POM Shallow ASW3641022189400004003.251
POM HD ASUW419541071318022104005421.25
POM LD ASUW32665861665112004005513.5
MODAS Mean RDPOM Mean RD
HD Deep ASW11.38.982.32
LD Deep ASW9.667.592.07
LD Shallow ASW10.047.582.46
HD ASUW19.8312.737.1
LD ASUW18.0412.085.96
MODAS LD Deep ASW
5
40
58
202
89
2
4
0
0
0
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD Deep ASW
POM HD Deep ASW
1
21
71
283
23
1
0
0
0
0
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SA/SD .
OBS vs POM HD Deep ASW
MODAS HD deep ASW
3
26
47
149
162
6
5
1
1
0
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA k
OBS vs MODAS HD Deep ASW
Chart1
3153432433
2621406339646191126
4771581015010229544565
149283202221204218391074786
162238999194013133166
6123641288012951
50405010921071
100000412252
1000103100
0000003000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart2
315343
262140633964
47715810150102
149283202221204218
16223899919
612364
504050
100000
100010
000000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Chart3
2433
6191126
29544565
391074786
4013133166
1288012951
10921071
412252
3100
3000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart4
35423
264039611
4758502945
1492022043947
16289914033
626128129
545109107
1004125
10130
00030
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Chart5
13343
2163641926
711011025465
28322121810786
2399131166
1348051
00021
00022
00010
00000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
-
WAPP output for MODAS and POM
LZ DATA
scenario# different SA/SD combos# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.1)Prob (RD > 0.1)# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.2)Prob (RD > 0.2)
OBS MOD1 HD Deep ASW76326734.99253.28
OBS MOD2 HD Deep ASW76336147.3140.52
OBS MOD1 LD Deep ASW76331841.68222.88
OBS MOD2 LD Deep ASW76329038.0150.66
OBS MOD1 Shallow ASW76329939.19233.01
OBS MOD2 Shallow ASW76328337.0970.92
OBS MOD1 HD ASUW76314719.2716521.63
OBS MOD2 HD ASUW76316721.899812.84
OBS MOD1 LD ASUW76315520.3111414.94
OBS MOD2 LD ASUW76316020.97678.78
LZ PROB
34.99344692013.2765399738
47.31323722150.5242463958
41.67758846662.8833551769
38.00786369590.6553079948
39.18741808653.0144167759
37.09043250330.9174311927
19.266055045921.625163827
21.887287024912.8440366972
20.314547837514.9410222805
20.96985583228.7811271298
Prob (RD > 0.1)
Prob (RD > 0.2)
MODAS Shallow ASW
4
39
50
204
91
6
5
0
1
0
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS Shallow ASW
POM shallow ASW
3
64
102
218
9
4
0
0
0
0
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA
OBS vs POM Shallow ASW
MODAS HD ASUW
2
6
29
39
40
128
109
41
3
3
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS HD ASUW
POM HD ASUW
4
19
54
107
131
80
2
2
1
0
OBS POM HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs POM HD ASUW
MODAS LD ASUW
3
11
45
47
33
129
107
25
0
0
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD ASUW
POM LD ASUW
3
26
65
86
166
51
1
2
0
0
OBS POM LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/ SA .
OBS vs POM LD ASUW
pom modas data
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500
0251015202530405050Total
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200
0251015202530405050TotalPD> 10PD> 20MeanSD02510152025304050
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040037.2540.511.3054.8879141012383.4090752251.158651868.392175253.7507252211.79005453.61815937.765125349.503025823.40302509532.79
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040070.755.758.982.952353464280.64041023.12841124.6684294.4332833.5292121.440400003477.84
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040050.522.259.66254.4184159774466.819531252348.556251260.856562523.00906252535.51265625213.7278125940.9556250007789.4375
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040055.252.257.593.5607016852172.82431968.6303677.51811283.5901494.1729462.024300005058.76
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW4395020491650104005122.7510.0454.7612654959403.60812524.1589751272.601250.41312234.234275594.612151118.2601250897.30202509045.19
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM Shallow ASW36410221894000040054.52.257.58253.6215996064172.482918751994.5156680.26923751274.0587625495.17375625616.77722500005233.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334009.751019.837.8969617583786.45781907.45346377.93813768.5271933.1563.69922913.45014240.58491220.48672730.686724882.44
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD ASUW4195410713180221040026.7532.7512.73255.7961134459648.4662252188.544568753228.7440375798.92151875673.543868754225.3245300.9831125596.3331125743.51655625013404.3775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040011.758.2518.04257.764755135976.595418752830.979868757654.806281253040.04489375305.47460625494.303006255179.528268753574.545156250024056.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD ASUW326658616651120040021.541.512.085.5144921852437.77922641.76643258.216372.07041415.38243199.0464166.9264642.25280012133.44
POM LD Deep ASW
3
63
101
221
9
3
0
0
0
0
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBSvs POM LD Deep ASW
Chart6
43.753.25
23.751.5
25.753
8171
73.565.25
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
MODAS RD for 5 Tactial Scenario
Chart7
60.25
30.75
3.251
5421.25
5513.5
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
POM RD for 5 Tactical Scenario
Chart8
11.38.98
9.667.59
10.047.58
19.8312.73
18.0412.08
MODAS Mean RD
POM Mean RD
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%)
MODAS and POM Mean RD
Sheet1
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040043.753.25
MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040023.751.5
MODAS Shallow ASW43950204916501040025.753
MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334008171
MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040073.565.25
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040060.25
POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040030.75
POM Shallow ASW3641022189400004003.251
POM HD ASUW419541071318022104005421.25
POM LD ASUW32665861665112004005513.5
MODAS Mean RDPOM Mean RD
HD Deep ASW11.38.982.32
LD Deep ASW9.667.592.07
LD Shallow ASW10.047.582.46
HD ASUW19.8312.737.1
LD ASUW18.0412.085.96
MODAS LD Deep ASW
5
40
58
202
89
2
4
0
0
0
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD Deep ASW
POM HD Deep ASW
1
21
71
283
23
1
0
0
0
0
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SA/SD .
OBS vs POM HD Deep ASW
MODAS HD deep ASW
3
26
47
149
162
6
5
1
1
0
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA k
OBS vs MODAS HD Deep ASW
Chart1
3153432433
2621406339646191126
4771581015010229544565
149283202221204218391074786
162238999194013133166
6123641288012951
50405010921071
100000412252
1000103100
0000003000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart2
315343
262140633964
47715810150102
149283202221204218
16223899919
612364
504050
100000
100010
000000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Chart3
2433
6191126
29544565
391074786
4013133166
1288012951
10921071
412252
3100
3000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart4
35423
264039611
4758502945
1492022043947
16289914033
626128129
545109107
1004125
10130
00030
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Chart5
13343
2163641926
711011025465
28322121810786
2399131166
1348051
00021
00022
00010
00000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
LZ DATA
scenario# different SA/SD combos# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.1)Prob (RD > 0.1)# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.2)Prob (RD > 0.2)
OBS MOD1 HD Deep ASW76326734.99253.28
OBS MOD2 HD Deep ASW76336147.3140.52
OBS MOD1 LD Deep ASW76331841.68222.88
OBS MOD2 LD Deep ASW76329038.0150.66
OBS MOD1 Shallow ASW76329939.19233.01
OBS MOD2 Shallow ASW76328337.0970.92
OBS MOD1 HD ASUW76314719.2716521.63
OBS MOD2 HD ASUW76316721.899812.84
OBS MOD1 LD ASUW76315520.3111414.94
OBS MOD2 LD ASUW76316020.97678.78
LZ PROB
34.99344692013.2765399738
47.31323722150.5242463958
41.67758846662.8833551769
38.00786369590.6553079948
39.18741808653.0144167759
37.09043250330.9174311927
19.266055045921.625163827
21.887287024912.8440366972
20.314547837514.9410222805
20.96985583228.7811271298
Prob (RD > 0.1)
Prob (RD > 0.2)
MODAS Shallow ASW
4
39
50
204
91
6
5
0
1
0
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS Shallow ASW
POM shallow ASW
3
64
102
218
9
4
0
0
0
0
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA
OBS vs POM Shallow ASW
MODAS HD ASUW
2
6
29
39
40
128
109
41
3
3
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS HD ASUW
POM HD ASUW
4
19
54
107
131
80
2
2
1
0
OBS POM HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs POM HD ASUW
MODAS LD ASUW
3
11
45
47
33
129
107
25
0
0
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD ASUW
POM LD ASUW
3
26
65
86
166
51
1
2
0
0
OBS POM LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/ SA .
OBS vs POM LD ASUW
pom modas data
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500
0251015202530405050Total
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200
0251015202530405050TotalPD> 10PD> 20MeanSD02510152025304050
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040037.2540.511.3054.8879141012383.4090752251.158651868.392175253.7507252211.79005453.61815937.765125349.503025823.40302509532.79
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040070.755.758.982.952353464280.64041023.12841124.6684294.4332833.5292121.440400003477.84
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040050.522.259.66254.4184159774466.819531252348.556251260.856562523.00906252535.51265625213.7278125940.9556250007789.4375
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040055.252.257.593.5607016852172.82431968.6303677.51811283.5901494.1729462.024300005058.76
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW4395020491650104005122.7510.0454.7612654959403.60812524.1589751272.601250.41312234.234275594.612151118.2601250897.30202509045.19
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM Shallow ASW36410221894000040054.52.257.58253.6215996064172.482918751994.5156680.26923751274.0587625495.17375625616.77722500005233.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334009.751019.837.8969617583786.45781907.45346377.93813768.5271933.1563.69922913.45014240.58491220.48672730.686724882.44
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD ASUW4195410713180221040026.7532.7512.73255.7961134459648.4662252188.544568753228.7440375798.92151875673.543868754225.3245300.9831125596.3331125743.51655625013404.3775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040011.758.2518.04257.764755135976.595418752830.979868757654.806281253040.04489375305.47460625494.303006255179.528268753574.545156250024056.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD ASUW326658616651120040021.541.512.085.5144921852437.77922641.76643258.216372.07041415.38243199.0464166.9264642.25280012133.44
POM LD Deep ASW
3
63
101
221
9
3
0
0
0
0
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBSvs POM LD Deep ASW
Chart6
43.753.25
23.751.5
25.753
8171
73.565.25
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
MODAS RD for 5 Tactial Scenario
Chart7
60.25
30.75
3.251
5421.25
5513.5
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
POM RD for 5 Tactical Scenario
Chart8
11.38.98
9.667.59
10.047.58
19.8312.73
18.0412.08
MODAS Mean RD
POM Mean RD
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%)
MODAS and POM Mean RD
Sheet1
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040043.753.25
MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040023.751.5
MODAS Shallow ASW43950204916501040025.753
MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334008171
MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040073.565.25
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040060.25
POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040030.75
POM Shallow ASW3641022189400004003.251
POM HD ASUW419541071318022104005421.25
POM LD ASUW32665861665112004005513.5
MODAS Mean RDPOM Mean RD
HD Deep ASW11.38.982.32
LD Deep ASW9.667.592.07
LD Shallow ASW10.047.582.46
HD ASUW19.8312.737.1
LD ASUW18.0412.085.96
MODAS LD Deep ASW
5
40
58
202
89
2
4
0
0
0
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD Deep ASW
POM HD Deep ASW
1
21
71
283
23
1
0
0
0
0
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SA/SD .
OBS vs POM HD Deep ASW
MODAS HD deep ASW
3
26
47
149
162
6
5
1
1
0
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA k
OBS vs MODAS HD Deep ASW
Chart1
3153432433
2621406339646191126
4771581015010229544565
149283202221204218391074786
162238999194013133166
6123641288012951
50405010921071
100000412252
1000103100
0000003000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart2
315343
262140633964
47715810150102
149283202221204218
16223899919
612364
504050
100000
100010
000000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Chart3
2433
6191126
29544565
391074786
4013133166
1288012951
10921071
412252
3100
3000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart4
35423
264039611
4758502945
1492022043947
16289914033
626128129
545109107
1004125
10130
00030
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Chart5
13343
2163641926
711011025465
28322121810786
2399131166
1348051
00021
00022
00010
00000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
-
WAPP output for MODAS and POM
LZ DATA
scenario# different SA/SD combos# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.1)Prob (RD > 0.1)# different SA/SD combos (RD>0.2)Prob (RD > 0.2)
OBS MOD1 HD Deep ASW76326734.99253.28
OBS MOD2 HD Deep ASW76336147.3140.52
OBS MOD1 LD Deep ASW76331841.68222.88
OBS MOD2 LD Deep ASW76329038.0150.66
OBS MOD1 Shallow ASW76329939.19233.01
OBS MOD2 Shallow ASW76328337.0970.92
OBS MOD1 HD ASUW76314719.2716521.63
OBS MOD2 HD ASUW76316721.899812.84
OBS MOD1 LD ASUW76315520.3111414.94
OBS MOD2 LD ASUW76316020.97678.78
LZ PROB
34.99344692013.2765399738
47.31323722150.5242463958
41.67758846662.8833551769
38.00786369590.6553079948
39.18741808653.0144167759
37.09043250330.9174311927
19.266055045921.625163827
21.887287024912.8440366972
20.314547837514.9410222805
20.96985583228.7811271298
Prob (RD > 0.1)
Prob (RD > 0.2)
MODAS Shallow ASW
4
39
50
204
91
6
5
0
1
0
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS Shallow ASW
POM shallow ASW
3
64
102
218
9
4
0
0
0
0
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA
OBS vs POM Shallow ASW
MODAS HD ASUW
2
6
29
39
40
128
109
41
3
3
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS HD ASUW
POM HD ASUW
4
19
54
107
131
80
2
2
1
0
OBS POM HD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs POM HD ASUW
MODAS LD ASUW
3
11
45
47
33
129
107
25
0
0
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD ASUW
POM LD ASUW
3
26
65
86
166
51
1
2
0
0
OBS POM LD ASUW
Relative Difference
# SD/ SA .
OBS vs POM LD ASUW
pom modas data
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110400
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000400
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000400
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000400
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010400
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133400
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210400
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500400
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200400
0251015202530405050Total
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW3264714916265110
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW540582028924000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW439502049165010
OBS MODAS HD ASUW262939401281094133
OBS MODAS LD ASUW3114547331291072500
0251015202530405050Total
OBS POM HD Deep ASW121712832310000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW363101221930000
OBS POM Shallow ASW364102218940000
OBS POM HD ASUW41954107131802210
OBS POM LD ASUW3266586166511200
0251015202530405050TotalPD> 10PD> 20MeanSD02510152025304050
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040037.2540.511.3054.8879141012383.4090752251.158651868.392175253.7507252211.79005453.61815937.765125349.503025823.40302509532.79
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040070.755.758.982.952353464280.64041023.12841124.6684294.4332833.5292121.440400003477.84
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040050.522.259.66254.4184159774466.819531252348.556251260.856562523.00906252535.51265625213.7278125940.9556250007789.4375
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040055.252.257.593.5607016852172.82431968.6303677.51811283.5901494.1729462.024300005058.76
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW4395020491650104005122.7510.0454.7612654959403.60812524.1589751272.601250.41312234.234275594.612151118.2601250897.30202509045.19
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM Shallow ASW36410221894000040054.52.257.58253.6215996064172.482918751994.5156680.26923751274.0587625495.17375625616.77722500005233.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334009.751019.837.8969617583786.45781907.45346377.93813768.5271933.1563.69922913.45014240.58491220.48672730.686724882.44
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM HD ASUW4195410713180221040026.7532.7512.73255.7961134459648.4662252188.544568753228.7440375798.92151875673.543868754225.3245300.9831125596.3331125743.51655625013404.3775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040011.758.2518.04257.764755135976.595418752830.979868757654.806281253040.04489375305.47460625494.303006255179.528268753574.545156250024056.2775
00000000000
00000000000
0251015202530405050Total00000000000
OBS POM LD ASUW326658616651120040021.541.512.085.5144921852437.77922641.76643258.216372.07041415.38243199.0464166.9264642.25280012133.44
POM LD Deep ASW
3
63
101
221
9
3
0
0
0
0
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBSvs POM LD Deep ASW
Chart6
43.753.25
23.751.5
25.753
8171
73.565.25
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
MODAS RD for 5 Tactial Scenario
Chart7
60.25
30.75
3.251
5421.25
5513.5
RD> 10
RD> 15
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%) .
POM RD for 5 Tactical Scenario
Chart8
11.38.98
9.667.59
10.047.58
19.8312.73
18.0412.08
MODAS Mean RD
POM Mean RD
Tactical Scenario
Prob (%)
MODAS and POM Mean RD
Sheet1
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
MODAS HD Deep ASW326471491626511040043.753.25
MODAS LD Deep ASW54058202892400040023.751.5
MODAS Shallow ASW43950204916501040025.753
MODAS HD ASUW2629394012810941334008171
MODAS LD ASUW311454733129107250040073.565.25
0251015202530405050TotalRD> 10RD> 15
POM HD Deep ASW12171283231000040060.25
POM LD Deep ASW36310122193000040030.75
POM Shallow ASW3641022189400004003.251
POM HD ASUW419541071318022104005421.25
POM LD ASUW32665861665112004005513.5
MODAS Mean RDPOM Mean RD
HD Deep ASW11.38.982.32
LD Deep ASW9.667.592.07
LD Shallow ASW10.047.582.46
HD ASUW19.8312.737.1
LD ASUW18.0412.085.96
MODAS LD Deep ASW
5
40
58
202
89
2
4
0
0
0
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA .
OBS vs MODAS LD Deep ASW
POM HD Deep ASW
1
21
71
283
23
1
0
0
0
0
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SA/SD .
OBS vs POM HD Deep ASW
MODAS HD deep ASW
3
26
47
149
162
6
5
1
1
0
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
Relative Difference
# SD/SA k
OBS vs MODAS HD Deep ASW
Chart1
3153432433
2621406339646191126
4771581015010229544565
149283202221204218391074786
162238999194013133166
6123641288012951
50405010921071
100000412252
1000103100
0000003000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart2
315343
262140633964
47715810150102
149283202221204218
16223899919
612364
504050
100000
100010
000000
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
Chart3
2433
6191126
29544565
391074786
4013133166
1288012951
10921071
412252
3100
3000
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
Chart4
35423
264039611
4758502945
1492022043947
16289914033
626128129
545109107
1004125
10130
00030
OBS MODAS HD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS LD Deep ASW
OBS MODAS Shallow ASW
OBS MODAS HD ASUW
OBS MODAS LD ASUW
Chart5
13343
2163641926
711011025465
28322121810786
2399131166
1348051
00021
00022
00010
00000
OBS POM HD Deep ASW
OBS POM LD Deep ASW
OBS POM Shallow ASW
OBS POM HD ASUW
OBS POM LD ASUW
-
Navy Altimetry Sensitivity GFO vs TPXJAN 2001
-
TPXGFOIn January 2001, the orbital coverage by TPX for the ECS and SCS did not vary. The same orbital track was updated every ten-days. GFO orbital change every 17 days. GFO orbital track overlapped the TPX orbital track during the ten-day period of 21-31 January 2001.
-
Analysis of Input DataECSJAN 05, 2001
-
MODAS SSP delta in ECS JAN 05, 2001
-
STATS in ECSJAN 05, 2001y=x
-
STATS in ECS JAN 05, 2001
-
SSP in ECS JAN 05, 2001
-
Analysis of Input DataSCS JAN 05, 2001
-
MODAS SSP delta in SCSJAN 05, 2001
-
STATS in SCSJAN 05, 2001y=x
-
STATS in SCS JAN 05, 2001
-
SSP in SCS JAN 05, 2001
-
Process FlowchartRelativeDifference
-
WAPP output for MODAS and POM
Here, the subscripts mg denotes MODAS-GFO and mt denotes MODAS-TPX The relative difference was calculated using statistical package, which produced absolute values of the relative differences (RD) in area coverage (AC) for the identical SD/SA combination generated by WAPP,
-
Chart1
0.9363295880
5.29026217230.8895131086
5.80524344570.8426966292
5.75842696631.0767790262
17.50936329593.6048689139
RD>10
RD>15
Tactical Scenario
RD (%) .
MG vs MT RD JAN 2001 5 Tactical Scenarios
Chart2
0.9363295880
0.79588014980
0.37453183520
0.09363295880
0.14044943820
0.09363295880
RD>10
RD>15
Chart10
5.29026217230.8895131086
5.89887640450.8895131086
9.08239700372.1535580524
6.17977528092.7621722846
5.52434456932.2940074906
4.91573033712.4344569288
RD>10
RD>15
Chart11
5.80524344570.8426966292
6.50749063670.936329588
9.97191011242.1535580524
6.97565543072.808988764
6.22659176032.2940074906
5.52434456932.4344569288
RD>10
RD>15
Chart12
5.75842696631.0767790262
5.24344569290.8895131086
4.11985018730.7958801498
3.27715355810.0468164794
2.38764044940.1404494382
3.32397003750.1872659176
RD>10
RD>15
Chart3
2.72435897440
3.04487179490.0801282051
2.08333333330.0801282051
0.56089743590
0.80128205130
0.32051282050
RD>10
RD>15
Chart13
3.7660256410
3.68589743590.0801282051
2.72435897440.0801282051
1.28205128210.0801282051
1.04166666670.0801282051
0.88141025640
RD>10
RD>15
Chart14
6.00961538460.2403846154
5.84935897440.3205128205
3.7660256410.3205128205
2.16346153850.1602564103
2.88461538460.2403846154
3.36538461540.2403846154
RD>10
RD>15
Chart15
15.70512820512.7243589744
15.6254.0064102564
13.86217948722.3237179487
10.73717948720.8012820513
6.97115384620.4006410256
7.77243589740.4807692308
RD>10
RD>15
Chart16
13.38141025641.8429487179
13.06089743590.9615384615
11.21794871791.2019230769
7.45192307690.8012820513
5.20833333330.7211538462
4.48717948720.8012820513
RD>10
RD>15
Sheet4
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 HD Deep ASW0.9360.0003.3992.746
ECS 0105 LD Deep ASW5.2900.8904.3794.447
ECS 0105 LD Shallow ASW5.8050.8434.7134.675
ECS 0105 HD ASUW5.7581.0773.8954.595
ECS 0105 LD ASUW17.5093.6056.5747.725
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0110 HD Deep ASW0.7960.0003.1082.550
ECS 0110 LD Deep ASW5.8990.8904.2694.580
ECS 0110 LD Shallow ASW6.5070.9364.2824.781
ECS 0110 HD ASUW5.2430.8902.9864.587
ECS 0110 LD ASUW15.0283.8866.3197.837
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0115 HD Deep ASW0.3750.0003.0272.238
ECS 0115 LD Deep ASW9.0822.1545.0286.296
ECS 0115 LD Shallow ASW9.9722.1545.0766.473
ECS 0115 HD ASUW4.1200.7962.7654.289
ECS 0115 LD ASUW13.9043.8865.8387.183
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0120 HD Deep ASW0.0940.0002.8121.995
ECS 0120 LD Deep ASW6.1802.7624.4416.222
ECS 0120 LD Shallow ASW6.9762.8094.4206.388
ECS 0120 HD ASUW3.2770.0472.5323.760
ECS 0120 LD ASUW10.9553.0905.0256.640
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0125 HD Deep ASW0.1400.0002.6751.998
ECS 0125 LD Deep ASW5.5242.2944.1626.026
ECS 0125 LD Shallow ASW6.2272.2944.1646.176
ECS 0125 HD ASUW2.3880.1402.3083.493
ECS 0125 LD ASUW8.4741.6854.3465.795
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0130 HD Deep ASW0.0940.0002.5851.976
ECS 0130 LD Deep ASW4.9162.4343.9455.789
ECS 0130 LD Shallow ASW5.5242.4343.9475.911
ECS 0130 HD ASUW3.3240.1872.5133.868
ECS 0130 LD ASUW7.8181.2174.1565.459
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 HD Deep ASW0.9360.0003.3992.746
ECS 0110 HD Deep ASW0.7960.0003.1082.550
ECS 0115 HD Deep ASW0.3750.0003.0272.238
ECS 0120 HD Deep ASW0.0940.0002.8121.995
ECS 0125 HD Deep ASW0.1400.0002.6751.998
ECS 0130 HD Deep ASW0.0940.0002.5851.976
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 LD Deep ASW5.2900.8904.3794.447
ECS 0110 LD Deep ASW5.8990.8904.2694.580
ECS 0115 LD Deep ASW9.0822.1545.0286.296
ECS 0120 LD Deep ASW6.1802.7624.4416.222
ECS 0125 LD Deep ASW5.5242.2944.1626.026
ECS 0130 LD Deep ASW4.9162.4343.9455.789
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 LD Shallow ASW5.8050.8434.7134.675
ECS 0110 LD Shallow ASW6.5070.9364.2824.781
ECS 0115 LD Shallow ASW9.9722.1545.0766.473
ECS 0120 LD Shallow ASW6.9762.8094.4206.388
ECS 0125 LD Shallow ASW6.2272.2944.1646.176
ECS 0130 LD Shallow ASW5.5242.4343.9475.911
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 HD ASUW5.7581.0773.8954.595
ECS 0110 HD ASUW5.2430.8902.9864.587
ECS 0115 HD ASUW4.1200.7962.7654.289
ECS 0120 HD ASUW3.2770.0472.5323.760
ECS 0125 HD ASUW2.3880.1402.3083.493
ECS 0130 HD ASUW3.3240.1872.5133.868
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
ECS 0105 LD ASUW17.5093.6056.5747.725
ECS 0110 LD ASUW15.0283.8866.3197.837
ECS 0115 LD ASUW13.9043.8865.8387.183
ECS 0120 LD ASUW10.9553.0905.0256.640
ECS 0125 LD ASUW8.4741.6854.3465.795
ECS 0130 LD ASUW7.8181.2174.1565.459
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 HD Deep ASW2.7240.0004.6002.591
SCS 0105 LD Deep ASW3.7660.0004.6952.750
SCS 0105 LD Shallow ASW6.0100.2405.2333.295
SCS 0105 HD ASUW15.7052.7246.5954.875
SCS 0105 LD ASUW13.3811.8436.2354.583
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0110 HD Deep ASW3.0450.0804.8652.728
SCS 0110 LD Deep ASW3.6860.0804.8072.866
SCS 0110 LD Shallow ASW5.8490.3215.2813.211
SCS 0110 HD ASUW15.6254.0066.6825.194
SCS 0110 LD ASUW13.0610.9626.2194.181
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0115 HD Deep ASW2.0830.0804.4962.603
SCS 0115 LD Deep ASW2.7240.0804.6112.657
SCS 0115 LD Shallow ASW3.7660.3215.1083.053
SCS 0115 HD ASUW13.8622.3246.4394.825
SCS 0115 LD ASUW11.2181.2026.0234.214
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0120 HD Deep ASW0.5610.0004.1632.249
SCS 0120 LD Deep ASW1.2820.0804.4392.458
SCS 0120 LD Shallow ASW2.1630.1604.6032.714
SCS 0120 HD ASUW10.7370.8015.7904.140
SCS 0120 LD ASUW7.4520.8015.2263.669
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0125 HD Deep ASW0.8010.0003.9722.310
SCS 0125 LD Deep ASW1.0420.0804.1462.361
SCS 0125 LD Shallow ASW2.8850.2404.3672.808
SCS 0125 HD ASUW6.9710.4015.2213.603
SCS 0125 LD ASUW5.2080.7214.5903.471
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0130 HD Deep ASW0.3210.0003.8582.100
SCS 0130 LD Deep ASW0.8810.0004.1402.288
SCS 0130 LD Shallow ASW3.3650.2404.5882.873
SCS 0130 HD ASUW7.7720.4815.5073.518
SCS 0130 LD ASUW4.4870.8014.7283.469
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 HD Deep ASW2.7240.0004.6002.591
SCS 0110 HD Deep ASW3.0450.0804.8652.728
SCS 0115 HD Deep ASW2.0830.0804.4962.603
SCS 0120 HD Deep ASW0.5610.0004.1632.249
SCS 0125 HD Deep ASW0.8010.0003.9722.310
SCS 0130 HD Deep ASW0.3210.0003.8582.100
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 LD Deep ASW3.7660.0004.6952.750
SCS 0110 LD Deep ASW3.6860.0804.8072.866
SCS 0115 LD Deep ASW2.7240.0804.6112.657
SCS 0120 LD Deep ASW1.2820.0804.4392.458
SCS 0125 LD Deep ASW1.0420.0804.1462.361
SCS 0130 LD Deep ASW0.8810.0004.1402.288
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 LD Shallow ASW6.0100.2405.2333.295
SCS 0110 LD Shallow ASW5.8490.3215.2813.211
SCS 0115 LD Shallow ASW3.7660.3215.1083.053
SCS 0120 LD Shallow ASW2.1630.1604.6032.714
SCS 0125 LD Shallow ASW2.8850.2404.3672.808
SCS 0130 LD Shallow ASW3.3650.2404.5882.873
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 HD ASUW15.7052.7246.5954.875
SCS 0110 HD ASUW15.6254.0066.6825.194
SCS 0115 HD ASUW13.8622.3246.4394.825
SCS 0120 HD ASUW10.7370.8015.7904.140
SCS 0125 HD ASUW6.9710.4015.2213.603
SCS 0130 HD ASUW7.7720.4815.5073.518
RD>10RD>15MeanSD
SCS 0105 LD ASUW13.3811.8436.2354.583
SCS 0110 LD ASUW13.0610.9626.2194.181
SCS 0115 LD ASUW11.2181.2026.0234.214
SCS 0120 LD ASUW7.4520.8015.2263.669
SCS 0125 LD ASUW5.2080.7214.5903.471
SCS 0130 LD ASUW4.4870.8014.7283.469
Chart28
17.50936329593.6048689139
15.02808988763.8857677903
13.9044943823.8857677903
10.95505617983.0898876404
8.47378277151.6853932584
7.81835205991.2172284644
RD>10
RD>15
ECS HIST DATA
-50-40-30-25-20-15-10-5-20251015202530405050Total
ECS 0105 HD Deep ASW02271831421204782705633421825218702002136
ECS 0105 LD Deep ASW00139927471104222375404751924018330002136
ECS 0105 LD Shallow ASW00139929441024112515133833084919230002136
ECS 0105 HD ASUW000000625902234795275848559351750102136
ECS 0105 LD ASUW00004162773103257425322350232173812820111222136
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 HD Deep ASW1931155609159173000021362136200.00936329590.9363295880003.39887640452.7455868192229.60563691452260.16775028411561.23043176376928.39840297942287.9631675294826.7919138998000016094.1573033708
ECS 0105 LD Deep ASW237962585239672712610213621361130.05290262175.2902621723190.00889513110.88951310864.37921348314.44707405464545.07004323955445.5518400454225.4449012127550.78461526327557.67411785136588.24222793845102.6020388843938.54821045321268.8404320793042222.7584269663
ECS 0105 LD Shallow ASW251924485352782811610213621361240.05805243455.8052434457180.00842696630.84269662924.71348314614.6750120545576.44776543376803.403484408539.81457517999837.43567731358253.36946092666542.97273071584526.97042671383836.44760762531245.1382716829046662
ECS 0105 HD ASUW479750674110653517501213621361230.05758426975.7584269663230.01076779031.07677902623.89513108614.59518241127267.41011937332693.6413752472822.77560352934099.63669009248015.67738360769077.83809563897572.0633618093407.320905048502125.65893756445082.0224719101
ECS 0105 LD ASUW4255794533052009732201114213621363740.17509363317.5093632959770.03604868913.60486891396.57443820227.72476061518369.876011946112115.85573751741122.9216106713579.014457218214198.018321550317483.833829772110864.042482009810975.138910806712289.949996449326400.9118443063127399.563202247
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0110 HD Deep ASW2021279512126161000021362136170.00795880150.79588014980003.10767790262.55040375021950.84771318161569.26947968831833.41205515585985.51709064512262.8371978847285.3505458416000013887.234082397
ECS 0110 LD Deep ASW2171034569190723513240213621361260.0589887645.8988764045190.00889513110.88951310864.26872659184.58042888233954.17979719875322.1224399978304.27889383366241.02402719928291.53648529238661.55370656765587.21406265341324.19686241925106.8955974975044793.0018726592
ECS 0110 LD Shallow ASW2701041462224833614240213621361390.06507490646.5074906367200.00936329590.9363295884.28230337084.78079094184951.29298305145422.4739320319237.9708646327323.02026259319534.12874597598893.65554380766009.12135068171322.79983982455103.0154099861048797.4789325843
ECS 0110 HD ASUW79279934291454815310213621361120.05243445695.2434456929190.00889513110.88951310862.98595505624.58696947067061.4146572402776.71379087241387.28094621894476.91120912766495.17741604613894.93081681617269.2726218282189.27587268021370.0395231031044921.0168539326
ECS 0110 LD ASUW4655814453241538535201018213621363210.150280898915.0280898876830.03885767793.88576779036.31882022477.836970196518566.282400028410836.9329255302773.9826193824390.551390291611530.520990484215909.847803702212214.526722872711215.965510983511344.218710547934344.8183980874131127.64747191
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0115 HD Deep ASW1991235614807100002136213680.00374531840.37453183520003.02668539332.23842104491823.0040694831301.79237746182390.89790982833890.16932836761003.5218387041288.0934087394000010697.4789325843
ECS 0115 LD Deep ASW15710026151689058127234213621361940.090823979.0823970037460.02153558052.15355805245.02762172286.29607257853968.48588952199184.8262832450.46922013744153.72368282628950.34956523813001.98245390244786.75072854864365.337737720828130.54657428748090.059231613684632.5313670412
ECS 0115 LD Shallow ASW204102448920610463127234213621362130.09971910119.9719101124460.02153558052.15355805245.07631086146.47293561555256.86212020799690.81704049712.84761696234993.999235067810241.879036387114031.13934280714763.44066668774348.331961934928052.27345010278072.551383277989454.1418539326
ECS 0115 HD ASUW95557341910145261421021362136880.04119850194.1198501873170.00795880150.79588014982.76498127344.28861136727301.0909773948335.31750778522093.03434874245286.89509338756736.30574580237723.19263315526921.54480880641483.49249007561386.4466195696039267.3202247191
ECS 0115 LD ASUW424633556226143714618118213621362970.139044943813.904494382830.03885767793.88576779035.83848314617.183205247214453.26342949129326.5921620534390.89801634893913.918290777712002.474922279414238.947731899416889.53149460310508.020140291612837.101571376715601.9165667214110162.664325843
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0120 HD Deep ASW2001333540612000002136213620.00093632960.09363295880002.81179775281.99464654671581.2413205403878.46778342382585.64370029043151.8853443378297.1045480369000008494.3426966292
ECS 0120 LD Deep ASW21610905371614231188330213621361320.06179775286.1797752809590.02762172282.76217228464.44054307126.22174841714259.17931763676492.3130255895168.07673365634976.11737632214683.08948654427504.99769753227608.44284575815226.286707977441727.6742434404082646.1774344569
ECS 0120 LD Shallow ASW28010914391775435198330213621361490.06975655436.9756554307600.02808988762.8089887644.4204119856.38779075645471.21179284326391.5080473495147.46987526135510.32902779536044.09485860378495.32469507928046.86941446095234.522584129441774.9337494214087116.2640449438
ECS 0120 HD ASUW9995693761224722100021362136700.03277153563.277153558110.00046816480.04681647942.5318352063.76000368776403.7793207928160.94090252352290.53088134216804.36521763537306.39126653486713.0091879533504.818429210700030183.8352059925
ECS 0120 LD ASUW516667517202111573215181213621362340.109550561810.9550561798660.03089887643.08988764045.02528089896.639782098313030.77922610786104.600452910.33042702944999.06168728711043.947347241512781.806092980712767.66090140139356.048912700422018.1575716452022.72535822594125.1179775281
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0125 HD Deep ASW2341377461613000002136213630.00140449440.14044943820002.6750936331.99795152491674.5334711526627.56969606112491.79241274953272.9094504412455.709950869000008522.5149812734
ECS 0125 LD Deep ASW2121185473148402997330213621361180.05524344575.5243445693490.02294007492.29400749064.16198501876.02592840173672.28929077425538.9023771199332.17328848075044.19800039284698.50274937237274.43883786423908.0058152384673.221127207642383.9894873333077525.7209737828
ECS 0125 LD Shallow ASW2991122417165523297330213621361330.06226591766.2265917603490.02294007492.29400749064.16385767796.17615888385183.97551778685253.5182163447291.53887082865619.99193862316105.9429820878025.06891666323907.30344180034672.543750613742379.5601854774081439.4438202247
ECS 0125 HD ASUW10265953531113414300021362136510.02387640452.387640449430.00140449440.14044943822.30805243453.49313823855465.610797247856.4632999132558.04333855856567.43236596815476.90812222084382.0701212671544.773452952100026051.3014981273
ECS 0125 LD ASUW55673147119710144149130213621361810.08473782778.4737827715360.01685393261.68539325844.3455056185.794747537110499.18100618614021.5209174978201.75892406266298.741423115811465.343304191410782.7805516985972.5139344785923.37773797516526.1586052897071691.3764044944
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0130 HD Deep ASW2501416404642000002136213620.00093632960.09363295880002.58520599251.97626341881670.8225059266484.93193199512355.81695983953518.6668911052308.2542204969000008338.4925093633
ECS 0130 LD Deep ASW24412234301343122179251213621361050.04915730344.9157303371520.02434456932.43445692883.94475655435.78867339393796.90944255074625.4814619016478.82165376144913.24040700533788.77063694965670.95852621027536.49570147576109.881399128932499.51449820452121.08544884271541.1591760299
ECS 0130 LD Shallow ASW32311454121384125179251213621361180.05524344575.5243445693520.02434456932.43445692883.94662921355.91101042185031.00993403614338.82326253457.15108572155056.77510730975009.25723551326442.76784023487535.15516506756109.003164057632496.13862675172120.912960800474596.9943820225
ECS 0130 HD ASUW9915843871034621300121362136710.03323970043.323970037540.00187265920.18726591762.51310861423.8681811936258.8734727658153.75578279962393.45133190255773.51489009527172.43299807826421.61877709041516.980852586002255.004853483731945.6329588015
ECS 0130 LD ASUW568764438199865514561213621361670.07818352067.8183520599260.01217228461.21722846444.15636704125.45892244169812.41980529963552.5379757045311.73185729926795.46118528110112.256314087713806.13879332726082.39848889733339.46682254637708.59614211172101.638682861363622.6460674157
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 HD Deep ASW1931155609159173000021362136200.00936329590.9363295880003.39887640452.7455868192229.60563691452260.16775028411561.23043176376928.39840297942287.9631675294826.7919138998000016094.1573033708
ECS 0110 HD Deep ASW2021279512126161000021362136170.00795880150.79588014980003.10767790262.55040375021950.84771318161569.26947968831833.41205515585985.51709064512262.8371978847285.3505458416000013887.234082397
ECS 0115 HD Deep ASW1991235614807100002136213680.00374531840.37453183520003.02668539332.23842104491823.0040694831301.79237746182390.89790982833890.16932836761003.5218387041288.0934087394000010697.4789325843
ECS 0120 HD Deep ASW2001333540612000002136213620.00093632960.09363295880002.81179775281.99464654671581.2413205403878.46778342382585.64370029043151.8853443378297.1045480369000008494.3426966292
ECS 0125 HD Deep ASW2341377461613000002136213630.00140449440.14044943820002.6750936331.99795152491674.5334711526627.56969606112491.79241274953272.9094504412455.709950869000008522.5149812734
ECS 0130 HD Deep ASW2501416404642000002136213620.00093632960.09363295880002.58520599251.97626341881670.8225059266484.93193199512355.81695983953518.6668911052308.2542204969000008338.4925093633
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 LD Deep ASW237962585239672712610213621361130.05290262175.2902621723190.00889513110.88951310864.37921348314.44707405464545.07004323955445.5518400454225.4449012127550.78461526327557.67411785136588.24222793845102.6020388843938.54821045321268.8404320793042222.7584269663
ECS 0110 LD Deep ASW2171034569190723513240213621361260.0589887645.8988764045190.00889513110.88951310864.26872659184.58042888233954.17979719875322.1224399978304.27889383366241.02402719928291.53648529238661.55370656765587.21406265341324.19686241925106.8955974975044793.0018726592
ECS 0115 LD Deep ASW15710026151689058127234213621361940.090823979.0823970037460.02153558052.15355805245.02762172286.29607257853968.48588952199184.8262832450.46922013744153.72368282628950.34956523813001.98245390244786.75072854864365.337737720828130.54657428748090.059231613684632.5313670412
ECS 0120 LD Deep ASW21610905371614231188330213621361320.06179775286.1797752809590.02762172282.76217228464.44054307126.22174841714259.17931763676492.3130255895168.07673365634976.11737632214683.08948654427504.99769753227608.44284575815226.286707977441727.6742434404082646.1774344569
ECS 0125 LD Deep ASW2121185473148402997330213621361180.05524344575.5243445693490.02294007492.29400749064.16198501876.02592840173672.28929077425538.9023771199332.17328848075044.19800039284698.50274937237274.43883786423908.0058152384673.221127207642383.9894873333077525.7209737828
ECS 0130 LD Deep ASW24412234301343122179251213621361050.04915730344.9157303371520.02434456932.43445692883.94475655435.78867339393796.90944255074625.4814619016478.82165376144913.24040700533788.77063694965670.95852621027536.49570147576109.881399128932499.51449820452121.08544884271541.1591760299
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 LD Shallow ASW251924485352782811610213621361240.05805243455.8052434457180.00842696630.84269662924.71348314614.6750120545576.44776543376803.403484408539.81457517999837.43567731358253.36946092666542.97273071584526.97042671383836.44760762531245.1382716829046662
ECS 0110 LD Shallow ASW2701041462224833614240213621361390.06507490646.5074906367200.00936329590.9363295884.28230337084.78079094184951.29298305145422.4739320319237.9708646327323.02026259319534.12874597598893.65554380766009.12135068171322.79983982455103.0154099861048797.4789325843
ECS 0115 LD Shallow ASW204102448920610463127234213621362130.09971910119.9719101124460.02153558052.15355805245.07631086146.47293561555256.86212020799690.81704049712.84761696234993.999235067810241.879036387114031.13934280714763.44066668774348.331961934928052.27345010278072.551383277989454.1418539326
ECS 0120 LD Shallow ASW28010914391775435198330213621361490.06975655436.9756554307600.02808988762.8089887644.4204119856.38779075645471.21179284326391.5080473495147.46987526135510.32902779536044.09485860378495.32469507928046.86941446095234.522584129441774.9337494214087116.2640449438
ECS 0125 LD Shallow ASW2991122417165523297330213621361330.06226591766.2265917603490.02294007492.29400749064.16385767796.17615888385183.97551778685253.5182163447291.53887082865619.99193862316105.9429820878025.06891666323907.30344180034672.543750613742379.5601854774081439.4438202247
ECS 0130 LD Shallow ASW32311454121384125179251213621361180.05524344575.5243445693520.02434456932.43445692883.94662921355.91101042185031.00993403614338.82326253457.15108572155056.77510730975009.25723551326442.76784023487535.15516506756109.003164057632496.13862675172120.912960800474596.9943820225
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 HD ASUW479750674110653517501213621361230.05758426975.7584269663230.01076779031.07677902623.89513108614.59518241127267.41011937332693.6413752472822.77560352934099.63669009248015.67738360769077.83809563897572.0633618093407.320905048502125.65893756445082.0224719101
ECS 0110 HD ASUW79279934291454815310213621361120.05243445695.2434456929190.00889513110.88951310862.98595505624.58696947067061.4146572402776.71379087241387.28094621894476.91120912766495.17741604613894.93081681617269.2726218282189.27587268021370.0395231031044921.0168539326
ECS 0115 HD ASUW95557341910145261421021362136880.04119850194.1198501873170.00795880150.79588014982.76498127344.28861136727301.0909773948335.31750778522093.03434874245286.89509338756736.30574580237723.19263315526921.54480880641483.49249007561386.4466195696039267.3202247191
ECS 0120 HD ASUW9995693761224722100021362136700.03277153563.277153558110.00046816480.04681647942.5318352063.76000368776403.7793207928160.94090252352290.53088134216804.36521763537306.39126653486713.0091879533504.818429210700030183.8352059925
ECS 0125 HD ASUW10265953531113414300021362136510.02387640452.387640449430.00140449440.14044943822.30805243453.49313823855465.610797247856.4632999132558.04333855856567.43236596815476.90812222084382.0701212671544.773452952100026051.3014981273
ECS 0130 HD ASUW9915843871034621300121362136710.03323970043.323970037540.00187265920.18726591762.51310861423.8681811936258.8734727658153.75578279962393.45133190255773.51489009527172.43299807826421.61877709041516.980852586002255.004853483731945.6329588015
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
ECS 0105 LD ASUW4255794533052009732201114213621363740.17509363317.5093632959770.03604868913.60486891396.57443820227.72476061518369.876011946112115.85573751741122.9216106713579.014457218214198.018321550317483.833829772110864.042482009810975.138910806712289.949996449326400.9118443063127399.563202247
ECS 0110 LD ASUW4655814453241538535201018213621363210.150280898915.0280898876830.03885767793.88576779036.31882022477.836970196518566.282400028410836.9329255302773.9826193824390.551390291611530.520990484215909.847803702212214.526722872711215.965510983511344.218710547934344.8183980874131127.64747191
ECS 0115 LD ASUW424633556226143714618118213621362970.139044943813.904494382830.03885767793.88576779035.83848314617.183205247214453.26342949129326.5921620534390.89801634893913.918290777712002.474922279414238.947731899416889.53149460310508.020140291612837.101571376715601.9165667214110162.664325843
ECS 0120 LD ASUW516667517202111573215181213621362340.109550561810.9550561798660.03089887643.08988764045.02528089896.639782098313030.77922610786104.600452910.33042702944999.06168728711043.947347241512781.806092980712767.66090140139356.048912700422018.1575716452022.72535822594125.1179775281
ECS 0125 LD ASUW55673147119710144149130213621361810.08473782778.4737827715360.01685393261.68539325844.3455056185.794747537110499.18100618614021.5209174978201.75892406266298.741423115811465.343304191410782.7805516985972.5139344785923.37773797516526.1586052897071691.3764044944
ECS 0130 LD ASUW568764438199865514561213621361670.07818352067.8183520599260.01217228461.21722846444.15636704125.45892244169812.41980529963552.5379757045311.73185729926795.46118528110112.256314087713806.13879332726082.39848889733339.46682254637708.59614211172101.638682861363622.6460674157
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
SCS 0105 HD Deep ASW51528436199331000012481248340.02724358972.72435897440004.60016025642.59051412871079.23519361753569.720013560269.70411376155802.49558203383569.1700008475237.1550641282000014327.4799679487
SCS 0105 LD Deep ASW51532423195425000012481248470.03766025643.7660256410004.69471153852.75006366511124.05613789763863.102186575439.42404192865488.4867037264460.35675157181171.2592744545000016146.6850961538
SCS 0105 LD Shallow ASW754584152254824210012481248750.06009615386.009615384630.00240384620.24038461545.23317307693.29528867412053.95753397744787.660930565822.56341877775112.59375577854578.76359097635233.4202570266781.4548932138613.39571583760023183.8100961538
SCS 0105 HD ASUW141293449169976527322124812481960.157051282115.7051282051340.02724358972.72435897446.59535256414.87514174886133.31323771886187.35870020241142.77226190111958.98448350696851.895556608511679.49723724639145.73827547151643.3325647962231.74094063323767.926838069150742.5600961538
SCS 0105 LD ASUW1343134342001063815071124812481670.133814102613.3814102564230.01842948721.84294871796.2347756414.58289979835208.90525738625613.130640435661.70716351292835.38289468288143.89075469477200.29326281025282.004678639707980.63263208311915.394863191444841.3421474359
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
SCS 0110 HD Deep ASW35521423231352010012481248380.03044871793.044871794910.00080128210.08012820514.86538461542.7280048476828.51886094674277.63350591727.66531065096090.14755917163594.8650147929458.11316568050631.74889053250015888.6923076923
SCS 0110 LD Deep ASW575124222113411100012481248460.03685897443.685897435910.00080128210.08012820514.80689102562.86597259931317.05347594614033.8622616715.73683406275690.32835292883532.58199914742539.1361633742407.761650050300017536.4607371795
SCS 0110 LD Shallow ASW724384302355316400012481248730.05849358975.849358974440.00320512820.32051282055.281253.21138790792008.19531254715.77148437534.0136718755232.65136718755006.06738281253466.2656251555.3164062500022018.28125
SCS 0110 HD ASUW121347423162846138633124812481950.1562515.625500.04006410264.00641025646.68189102565.19383638495402.36778910367606.27594086441196.56438956181783.59524084695812.038700382210819.69362582712751.01842306673262.40523684053330.28915688185629.375695343357593.6241987179
SCS 0110 LD ASUW116333418218111408211124812481630.130608974413.0608974359120.00961538460.96153846156.218754.1807889094486.050781255926.6845703125620.8769531253116.9316406258559.24902343757596.91406252821.88281251131.0957031251141.17285156251916.797851562537317.65625
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
SCS 0115 HD Deep ASW51558413200223010012481248260.02083333332.083333333310.00080128210.08012820514.49599358972.60335757261030.91187630983476.3310720229104.91127663246058.81731282872427.3513146676721.12264430780650.45434297440014469.8998397436
SCS 0115 LD Deep ASW53527438196303010012481248340.02724358972.724358974410.00080128210.08012820514.61057692312.65687671431126.64323687133591.56395617666.4228457845692.99269600593238.203356139710.50302792160644.6228041790015070.9519230769
SCS 0115 LD Shallow ASW89435415262367220012481248470.03766025643.76602564140.00320512820.32051282055.10817307693.05336789962322.31546435844202.42184610764.8560870476269.65230907913522.53663553991552.3655637482791.36955667531239.20609513680019904.7235576923
SCS 0115 HD ASUW127333415200964819424124812481730.138621794913.8621794872290.02323717952.32371794876.43910256414.82455351095265.67931254116561.9753143491859.47171885272535.99810979627035.74063116378827.10108481266545.63135889222220.46355193952252.66767340567590.207141683149694.9358974359
SCS 0115 LD ASUW12734141422684419240124812481400.112179487211.2179487179150.01201923081.20192307696.02323717954.21447247984607.48203728535519.5751542211433.46393075073574.10921191866768.91074180238009.34585657563241.0577443141149.77031070224617.6816470455037921.3966346154
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
SCS 0120 HD Deep ASW655504551716100001248124870.00560897440.56089743590004.16266025642.24911952251126.30312666932572.4046615611319.01772001875826.7455332378704.6875963079250.8213301539000010799.9799679487
SCS 0120 LD Deep ASW54535444199132100012481248160.01282051281.282051282110.00080128210.08012820514.43910256412.45782903341064.10410502963182.8334052433139.68503451686153.79247822161449.9232104701484.283058021422.750503369500012897.3717948718
SCS 0120 LD Shallow ASW80502420219205200012481248270.02163461542.163461538520.00160256410.16025641034.60256410262.71355965351694.68770545693400.216633793666.34122287976379.97682445762162.13346482581185.4051610782832.1107823800015720.8717948718
SCS 0120 HD ASUW135373371235111134123124812481340.107371794910.7371794872100.00801282050.80128205135.79006410264.13966903574525.85371209325357.9905412763231.57867716554165.03666122219415.34403507152624.98961672011476.0865487344586.1209961582340.63942821345863.555296166236587.1955128205
SCS 0120 LD ASUW1483914082086914532012481248930.07451923087.4519230769100.00801282050.80128205135.22596153853.66864032254041.97975221894069.069688424620.83191568054740.62019230776591.69612148673055.81097448221955.0629853921841.25894508142418.4675018491028734.7980769231
02510152025304050TotalRD>10RD>15MeanSD02510152025304050
SCS 0125 HD Deep ASW84601385168100000012481248100.00801282050.80128205130003.97195512822.30974094771325.21991339992337.0528236204406.89735949316104.67059603061216.17773694320000011390.0184294872
SCS 0125 LD Deep ASW63587411174120100012481248130.01041666671.041666666710.00080128210.08012820514.14583333332.36063127481082.839843752702.9006076389299.86588541675963.20052083331413.75520833330434.896267361100011897.4583333333
SCS 0125 LD Shallow ASW865603901762310300012481248360.02884615382.884615384630.00240384620.24038461544.36698717952.80847828751640.06962421933137.4718523997156.27504006415584.62668474692600.40211774742443.91089846321277.163654154300016839.9198717949
SCS 0125 HD ASUW1613234772006319202112481248870.06971153856.971153846250.00400641030.40064102565.22115384623.60276470634388.93204511833351.393768491123.32960428994567.4741124266024.42742233734149.871579142782.40551035502419.13627958582005.145062869827712.1153846154
SCS 0125 LD ASUW19037947014446104