No Sweat Radiant Cooling Case Studies
Ryan Westlund – REHAUDevin Abellon – Uponor
Barry Stephens – Ventacity
Definition:
A radiant system is a sensible cooling and heating system that provides more than 50% of the total heat flux by thermal radiation.
Note: Active chilled beams do not fit this definition due to added forced convection portion.
Basic Physical Phenomena
Heat emission from the human body occurs through four modes of transfer:
– Conduction (~5%)– Evaporation (~20%)– Convection (~30%)– Radiation (~45%)
Humans feel most comfortable when they can regulate at least 45% of their heat emission through radiation
Image courtesy of RPA
Hydronic Radiant Cooling Types
1. Embedded Thermal Masses
2. Ceiling Panels
3. Capillary Tube Mats
Hydronic Radiant Cooling Types
1. Embedded Thermal Masses
2. Ceiling Panels
3. Capillary Tube Mats
Hydronic Radiant Cooling Types
1. Embedded Thermal Masses
2. Ceiling Panels
3. Capillary Tube Mats
Hydronic Radiant Cooling Types
1. Embedded Thermal Masses Requires High Mass Control Strategy
2. Ceiling Panel Requires Low Mass Control Strategy
3. Capillary Tube Mats
Basic Components:• Cross-linked polyethylene (PEX) pipes• Distribution manifolds
Common Hydronic Applications:- Radiant Heating and Cooling- Snow and Ice Melting Systems (SIM)- Turf Conditioning- Anti-Frost Heave Systems
(Below commercial freezers)
Radiant Systems: “Embedded Thermal Masses”
In a radiant heating system, warm fluid circulates through PEX pipes which are integrated in the floor structure- Heat radiates outward from the warmed floor- Additional natural convection
A radiant cooling system works with the reverse energy transfer process by absorbing heat from the space- Heat transferred through the floor is removed
from the space via the circulating fluid- In cooling mode, the same network of pipes is
used as in heating mode- In some applications pipes can be embedded
into the ceiling or even the wall
WARMED CONCRETE SLAB
Floor Covering
PEX Pipe
COOLED CONCRETE SLAB
COOLED CONCRETE SLAB
Radiant Systems: Heat Transfer
• 74°F ≤ TAIR ≤ 78°F
• TSURFACE ≥ 66°F
• 55°F ≤ TSUPPLY ≤ 60°F • Minimum allowable supply temperature
based on max dew point
• 5°F ≤ ΔT ≤ 8°F
• 0-30% PG in fluid
• PEX diameter (usually 5/8” for cooling applications)
• PEX spacing (usually 6” OC for cooling applications)
Typical Radiant Cooling Parameters
From years of adjusting thermostats, we have been conditioned to believe that air temperature alone translates to comfort, but this is not necessarily true.
We have to consider:1. Air temperature
Space’s air temperature, monitored by thermostat as “set point temperature”
2. Mean radiant temperature (MRT)Average temperature of surrounding surfaces
3. Operative room temperatureWeighted average of mean radiant temperature and the conditioned space’s air temperature
The operative temperature is what we perceive on our skin in a room and what is most important to consider when specifying a radiant system.
Higher air temperature set points during the cooling season and lower set points during the heating season are possible with radiant systems.
Temperature… Which Temperature?
Pink area = approximate comfort zoneRadiant coolingForced air
MRT comfort graph originally published in Architectural Forum, January 1939
Temperature… Which Temperature?
Why Radiant Cooling is Relevant?
Energy savings through “decoupling and optimizing”
Radiant Floor Heating & Cooling• With insulation underneath to
condition the space above • Heated/cooled floor surface• Uni-directional radiant exchange
Thermally Activated Building System (TABS)- No insulation- Upper and lower surfaces of slab
heated/cooled- Bi-directional radiant exchange
Types of In-Slab Radiant Systems
Earth Rangers: Woodbridge, Ontario
Pond Road Residence, York University:Toronto, Ontario
Campus North Residential Commons, University of Chicago
Campus North Residential Commons, University of Chicago
Richard J. Klarchek Information Commons, Loyola University:Chicago, Illinois
VAV Cooling Radiant Cooling
Infosys SDB 1: Hyderabad, India
Infosys SDB 1: ASHRAE Journal
Infosys SDB 1: HVAC Energy
CBE post-occupancy survey results
Infosys SDB 1: Thermal Comfort
Colorado Army National Guard High Altitude Aviation Training Site (HAATS), Gypsum, Colorado
Modeled Cost Savings for Radiant Heating Hangar
Devin Abellon – Uponor
Introductions
• Devin Abellon, PE is an ASHRAE Distinguished Lecturer and a registered professional engineer with 23 years of experience in the HVAC industry
• Devin earned his B.S. degree in mechanical engineering from the University of California at Santa Barbara in 1993
• As a business development manager for Uponor North America, Devin works closely with engineers, contractors, and building owners throughout the country to incorporate energy-efficient and cost-effective building solutions
• Email: [email protected]• Website: www.uponorengineering.com
Acknowledgements
• Peter Simmonds, B&S Analytics• Robert Bean, RET P.Eng• Michelle Dionello, Genentech• Michael Talbot, Talbot & Associates Consulting Engineers
“No Sweat Radiant Cooling Case Studies”
Learning Objectives:
1. Discuss three radiant cooling case studies in different climate zones
2. Understand different control strategies for ensuring that surface condensation does not occur
• 18 million square feet under roof and a total of 67 acres,
• $8.5 billion. • Six of its properties (ARIA, Vdara,
Crystals, Mandarin Oriental, Las Vegas and Veer Towers) have achieved LEED Gold certification from the U.S. Green Building Council.
• And two properties — Crystals and Veer Towers — feature radiant heating and cooling.
• Goal 30% more efficient
CityCenter
Crystals at CityCenter
• 6" on-center tube spacing for exterior zones
• 9" on-center tube spacing for interior zones
• Cooling only for interior zones• Heating and cooling for exterior
zones• 25 total zones on three levels• LEED® Gold
34
35
Radiant cooling design parameters
• Minimum surface temperature: 66°F
• Average water temperature:
55°F to 58°F
• Spacing: 6" on center
(maximum 9" on center)
• Loop lengths: 300 to 500 feet
• Size of pipe: ½", ⅝", ¾" typical
• Design differential temperatures: 5°F to 8°F for
cooling36
Human comfort
ASHRAE Standard 55
Six Factors:
AIR MOVEMENT
AIR TEMP
HUMIDITY
CLOTHING
RADIANT TEMP
METABOLISM
Four Factors:
Human comfort
Direct solar heat gain
Akron Art MuseumAkron, OhioRadiant Heating and Cooling45,000 square feet
Energy Efficiency
7.5%
9.4%
1.9%
34.4%
Fan andmotor
Load from lights
Air transport load
Other loads
ConventionalHVAC system
Radiant coolingHVAC system
37.5%
18.8%
9.3%
34.4%
Chiller62.5%
100% peak power
57.7%
7.5%
9.4%
1.9%
34.4%
Fan andmotor
Load from lights
Air transport load
Other loads
ConventionalHVAC system
Radiant coolingHVAC system
37.5%
18.8%
9.3%
34.4%
Chiller62.5%
100% peak power
Source: LBNL
1.5% - Pumps
Depending on the climate, a radiant cooling system in conjunction with a dedicated outside air system (DOAS) could save between 17% to 42% over the baseline VAV system.
Lawrence Berkley National Laboratory Report:
Commercial radiant heating and cooling case studies
NREL Research Support Facility, Golden, ColoradoLEED Platinum / Net Zero
David Brower Center, Berkeley, CaliforniaLEED Platinum
41
Commercial radiant heating and cooling case studies
Western Science Center, Hemet, CaliforniaLEED Platinum
Cooper Union, New York, New YorkLEED Platinum
42
Commercial radiant heating and cooling case studies
The Chartwell School, Seaside, CaliforniaLEED Platinum
Manitoba Hydro Place, Winnipeg, ManitobaLEED Platinum
43
Commercial radiant heating and cooling case studiesSuvarnabhumi Bangkok Airport, Bangkok, Thailand30.5% Energy Savings
44
Suvarnabhumi Bangkok AirportBangkok, Thailand
48
• Completed in 2006• 2,150,000 SF• Radiant Area – Approx.
1,615,000 SF• Challenges
– Outdoor Conditions– Internal Gains
• Design Temperatures:– 99 deg. F dry bulb– 85% relative humidity– Average dew point – 77.1
deg. F
Suvarnabhumi Bangkok AirportBangkok, Thailand
49
• Nearly 2M feet of tubing (approx. 370 miles)
• 7500 circuits• Combined with
displacement ventilation diffusers
• System Temperatures:– Setpoint 75 deg F / 50-
60% RH– Dew Point – 60 deg F– Surface Temperature –
69deg F.
Suvarnabhumi Bangkok AirportBangkok, Thailand
54
• Condensation Control Strategy:– Minimize loads with high
performance envelope– Maintain airport’s
required indoor conditions of 75 deg F and 50-60% RH with displacement ventilation system
– Operate radiant slab to provide sensible cooling per ASHRAE Standard 55
Clemson University Lee HallSchool of Architecture – Clemson, South Carolina
55
Clemson University Lee HallSchool of Architecture – Clemson, South Carolina
58
• Completed in 2011• 53,000 SF• Challenges
– Outdoor Conditions– Internal Gains– Natural Ventilation
• Design Temperatures:– 90 deg. F dry bulb– 90% relative humidity
Clemson University Lee HallSchool of Architecture – Clemson, South Carolina
59
• Concrete slabs combined with radiant heating & cooling, and night time free cooling
• Natural ventilation interlocked with the HVAC system thru building automation
• Dedicated outdoor air systems allow for dry air to be introduced to the space either at a neutral temperature or a low temperature to provide supplemental cooling
• Lowest energy use building on Clemson’s campus-exceeds ASHRAE 90.1-2007 by 50 percent
• Geothermal water to water heat pump system• Radiant cooling/heating system integrated with geothermal• Natural ventilation system• Dedicated outside air system• Net zero energy building• Green roof• Daylighting/controls• Building dashboard with web-interface
HEB Austin Mueller Grocery StoreAustin, Texas
HEB Austin Mueller Grocery StoreAustin, Texas
66
• Completed in 2013• 75,000 SF• Radiant Area – Approx.
22,000 SF• Challenges
– Outdoor Conditions– Internal Gains
• Design Temperatures:– 100 deg. F dry bulb– 88% relative humidity
• Solutions provided to optimize the radiant design or installation – Used dessicant wheel 100% OA units with radiant floor;
needed to add an additional cooling coil in the unit to supplement the radiant floor for peak cooling
– Installation of perimeter insulation– Used heat recovery from cooling tower condenser for
heating
Design Challenges and Solutions
• Goal: Use 50% less energy than a typical HEB store
• Goal using radiant was to have a low-energy design and be committed to occupant comfort in the space.
Radiant Advantages
99198
192
80
0 100 200 300
Austin Mueller Target
Typical HEB Store
CBECS 2003- 28 stores
ASHRAE Target (CZ2)
kBtu/SF
Committed to 50% energy reduction
Condensation control
69
• “Although radiant cooling has been in successful use in Switzerland for about 15 years, very little, if any progress has been made in its use in America. The reason seems to be that many engineers believe that a radiant cooling system will necessarily carry with it objectionable and injurious condensation of water vapor on the cooling panels…”
— F.E. Giesecke, Ph.D.Founder of the Texas A&M University Architecture ProgramHot Water Heating and Radiant Heating and Radiant Cooling, 1946
Piping and controls
70
Combination heating/cooling piping diagramMixing with heating/cooling switchover
71
Combination heating/cooling piping diagram
Local secondary injection system
72
Control scenariosScenario: High-humidity infiltration
• Radiant system is in cooling mode• Airside system is in operation for
latent load / ventilation• Main doors constantly open and
close, allowing warmer humid air to enter atrium space
73
Contact Information
For a copy of this presentation, please contact:
Devin Abellon, Uponor• Email: [email protected]• Website: www.uponorengineering.com
Thank You!
Barry Stephens – Ventacity
The Project
The Parts & Pieces
Factory• Heat Recovery From Powder Coat Oven• Radiant Panels • Backup Boilers
Offices• Tight, well insulated envelope• Low-E Windows & External Blinds• Geothermal WSHPs• Very High Efficiency HRV• Advanced Control System
The Factory
Air-to-Water Heat Recovery
• 400 F Powder Coat Oven Waste Heat
• 135 F AWT
• Two Boilers ProvideBackup and Heat During Oven Shutdown
Radiant Panels• Radiant design optimizes comfort at floor level
• AWT 130F
• 150,000 SF Factory
The Office
Build It Tight…..
• Tight, well insulated envelope
• External blinds, automatic operationwith minimum tempand max wind controls
Low-E, low U-valuewindows
The Loop Field
20,00 Feet of Pipe
• Buried at 10 Ft Depth
• Connected to 3 WSHPs
• Allows for “FreeCooling” and Pre-Heating of HRV Supply Air
Ventilate Right
• Provides fresh air
• Allows for controlof humidity
• Significant energysavings
• Leverage groundloop for maximumefficiency
DO AS I SAY!
Ground-Source Pre-Heat/Pre-Cooling
• Up to 99% ASE
• Up to 90+% SRE
• Pre-Cooling =Dehumidification
• Frost Free Operation
• COP up to 30+ at-15F
Post-Heating
• Tempering
• Re-Heat forDry Mode
Post-Cooling/Dehumidification
• Tempering raises Dew Point
Advanced Controls
Advanced Dehumidification
• DEHUMIDIFIER 300/850 CFM• CONDENSATION* 25 gal/day• POWER ABSORBED 1.15 KW• COOLED WATER SUPPLY 210 gal/h• WEIGHT 155 Lb• DIMENSIONS 54” x 28” x 14”
*At 78 ºF and 65% HR
DRS 1000
Dehumidification Neutral Air1. Pre-treatment2. Air condenser3. Evaporator4. Water condenser5. capillary6. C= Compressor7. Modulating valve8. A= Inlet chilled water9. B=Outlet chilled water
Dehumidification & Cooling1. Pre-treatment2. Air condenser3. Evaporator4. Water condenser5. capillary6. C= Compressor7. Modulating valve8. A= Inlet chilled water9. B=Outlet chilled water
Advanced Dehumidification