Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Robert P. Esgro, R.Ph., Esq.Attorney & PharmacistVillanova, Pennsylvania
1
EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVESAt the conclusion of this program, participants will be
able to:1. Describe the requirements to bring a negligence
case2. Apply the principles of negligence to pharmacy
practice.3. Identify problem areas in pharmacy practice that
can effect the rise of professional liability.4. Recognize how to reduce problem areas.5. Discuss the current topics in pharmacy litigation.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
2
Specific Topics that will be covered
1. Negligence - generally defined then specifically applied to pharmacy.
2. “Standard of Care” - Define what is meant by pharmacy
3. “Duty to Warn” - Address what is meant by the duty to warn
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
3
Terms in Civil Cases
1. Civil Liability – Legally enforceable debt
2. Tort – wrongs committed by a breach of legal duty
3. Negligence – Lack of diligence or careFailure to use reasonable care
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
4
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
4. Implied Warranty or Warranty of Merchantability - unwritten or
assumed that the product will do what is supposed to.
5. Warranty of Fitness for a Particular Purpose – Exists when a buyer is
relying on seller’s expertise
5
6. Respondeat Superior(rehs-pond-dee-at superior) Latin for "let the master answer" This doctrine which makes the principal (employer) responsible for the actions of his/her agent (employee) in the "course of employment."
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
6
7. Learned Intermediary RuleA legal term used to describe the physician’s relationship with the patient.
Some state courts have held that the physician is in the best position to warn patients. Therefore, removing claims against the manufacturer and the pharmacists.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
7
Types of Negligence
Ordinary Negligence – It is a level of care or skill, which is acceptable and appropriate by reasonably prudent pharmacist under similar circumstances.
Gross Negligence - Reckless disregard or acting so reckless that there’s a lack of concern whether an injury will occur. Wanton or reckless conduct is more than ordinary negligence and is a higher degree of carelessness. This includes willful misconduct or intent to harm.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
8
NEGLIGENCE Plaintiff must prove these 4 elements to succeed or no recovery
1. Duty 2. Breach of Duty 3. Causation 4. Damages
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
9
Pharmacist Duty1. Maintaining professional competence2. Using such skill and precaution in
preparation, compounding, dispensing, labeling, and sale of drugs – so as to prevent injury or death to all who are exposed to his professional services.*
3. Pharmacy Owners have additional duty to employ only qualified persons.
*Pharmacy Law Digest 36th Edition 2002
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
10
Standard of CareReally a test of what the Ordinary
Reasonable Pharmacist would do in that particular situation.
State Regulations and Law may help define. Probably going to be the most basic or minimal standard of ORP.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
11
Duty to WarnState and federal laws required pharmacist
to counsel. The duty to warn has really stemmed from those laws.
State Courts still seem to take the approach that the physician should provide drug warnings – Learned Intermediary.
However, when a pharmacist warns, they must provide accurate information. The pharmacist does not have to provide every risk.*
*Kasin v. Osco Drugs, Slip Op No 2-99-0356 (April 12, 2000), 2000 Ill App Lexis 242
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
12
Morgan v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., (Tex.App. Dist.3 08/10/2000)
Texas appeals court held that there was a law requiring pharmacists to counsel, but it was not specific. The court held “…pharmacists have no generalized duty to warn patients of potential adverse reactions to prescription drugs absent some special circumstances not present here."
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
13
Happel v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., (Illinois, 2000 - 2004)
Facts: Patient known allergy to NSAIDs and was dispensed Toradol.
Damages: Long term medical problemClaim Asserted: breach of “Duty to Warn”Defense Asserted: Learned intermediaryHolding: Pharmacy had specific knowledge of
potential allergic reaction and should have warned.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
14
Causation
It may seem clear at first that the pharmacist’s breach of duty “caused” a recoverable loss.
However, the pharmacist’s breach of duty may not have been the actual cause of harm.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
15
Two Types of Damages
1. Actual DamagesMoney paid from the actual lossCalculated
2. Punitive DamagesMoney paid as a form of punishmentJury determines amount
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
16
Damages • May seem obvious there were or were not
damages, but this can be deceiving.• There must be an injury or loss of
property1. Patient2. Family member(s)
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
17
Attempt by States to Reduce Malpractice1. Requiring a Certificate of Merit2. Expert Witness Report may be required
to validate the cause of action and breach.3. Expert Witness Testimony which
increases costsDepositionTrial
4. Cap to non-economic damage awards
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
18
5. Prior bad acts Some states have laws that prohibit prior reports prescription errors reports, certain Board of Pharmacy complaints, and evidence of other lawsuits filed against the pharmacy.
A national chain in one state had 2,900 misfilled prescription in one year. This was allowed to be introduced to a jury.* This lead to an enormous jury verdict against the pharmacy.
An attempt to reduce punitive damages.
*Hundley v. Rite Aid of South Carolina, Inc., 339 S.C. 285, 529 S.E.2d 45 (S.C. App. Ct. 2000)
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
19
Pharmacist Malpractice Cases
Pharmacy has had relatively few malpractice claims as compared to other professions.
However, this will likely change.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
20
Progression of a Civil Trial1. Plaintiff files a claim and defendant
answers.
2. Discovery – parties collect evidence
3. Deposition – statements are taken
4. Trial or Settle
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
21
Case 1 – Misfill Prescription1. Prescription was mistyped
- wrong strength, directions, or drug
2. Refilled with wrong drug
Prevention – Go back to original on 1st refill and review what was typed
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
22
Case 1 – Plaintiff Claims 1. Pharmacist
Negligent filling practice2. Employer
Negligent Hiring PracticeNegligent Employee
RetentionNegligent Training and PolicyNegligent Work Conditions
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
23
Case 1 – Damages and OutcomeActual Damages would need to be calculatedAre there enough damages to bring an action or enough to cause you grief
Settlement or trial
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
24
Case 2 – Patient DiesNo apparent pharmacy errorPrescriptions for
Oxycodone SR Oxycodone/APAPCyclobenzaprine Zolpidem
Patient on meds for years and tolerant
Patient dies
Pharmacy sued even though no apparent mistake by pharmacy
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
25
Case 2 – Plaintiff ClaimsNegligence on behalf of the Pharmacy/Pharmacist
Negligence on behalf of the Physician
Negligence on behalf of the State
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
26
Case 2 – Why the PharmacistPhysician has insufficient insurance and can not be found
Pharmacist is the next in line
Lack of documentation for drug interactions
Pharmacist will likely pay some amount
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
27
Case 3 – Failure to MonitorLawyers have little or no knowledge of what you do.
Lawyer wanted to bring an action against a retail pharmacist for not monitoring, suggest to monitor, or knowing lab values before dispensing.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
28
How can you reduce you liability risk?
1. Fill prescriptions (retail/hospital) at your own pace.
2. Get to know your patients
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
29
3. Follow your company’s/hospital’s filling policy
4. Follow your company’s error reporting procedure
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
30
5. Document anything unusual on the prescription.
•Why did you do what you did•Staple a cut out of the package
insert to back of the prescription – write what you did “discussed with pt” or “gave copy to pt”
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
31
6. Never put anything in writing on your own!!!
It will likely be used against you or at least embarrass you.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
32
7. When an error is made:The pharmacist must promptly rectify it.You should inform the patient and physician.
i.e. – Alprazolam was misfilled for another drug.
Patient’s physician was not notified by the pharmacist. Therefore, the patient was abruptly discontinued instead of being tapered as was later done. The situation became even worse due to lack of action the part of the pharmacist.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
33
Malpractice InsuranceYour employer will likely have coverage that insures you as well as the pharmacy
Because pharmacy coverage is relatively inexpensive it is wise to have your additional coverage.
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
Present Issues in Pharmacy Litigation
34
Contact Information
Robert P. Esgro, R.Ph., Esq.Pharmacist-Lawyer80 Ithan Avenue
Villanova, PA 19085Phone: (610) 308-6666
35