Download - Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
1/125
Noriel Christopher C. TiglaoAssociate Professor, UP-NCPAG
Director, CPED
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
2/125
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Transport infrastructure investment of the nationalgovernment and government owned and/or controlled
corporations (GOCCs) was highest in 1999 at 1.3% ofGDP; the ratio fell to 0.4% in 2000, before reaching 0.8%in 2008 (against a government target of 5%).
Investment in Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
3/125
Source:DraftSituationalAnalysisReport,April2009
Public Investments in theTransport Sector, by Annual
Expenditures, Percentage ofGDP and Percentage ofInfrastructureProgram, 1997-2007
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
4/125
REGION 1
P4.1 Bill ion
REGION 2
P4.1 Bill ion
CAR
P5.5 Bill ion
REGION 3P9.1 Bill ion
REGION 4-A
P6.9 Bill ion
REGION 4-B
P2.8 Bill ion
REGION 9
P6.2 Bill ion
REGION 10
P6.8 Bill ion
NCR
P3.7 Bill ion
REGION 11
P4.7 Bill ionREGION 12
P1.8 Bill ion
REGION 13
P5.2 Bill ion
REGION 8
P8.7 Bill ion
REGION 7
P3.9 Bill ion
REGION 6
P5.2 Bill ion
REGION 5
P7.6 Bill ion
2009 InfrastructureTowards Development
Roads, Bridges, Farm to MarketRoads, School Buildings, Classrooms, Flood Control, ports andAirports
Metro Manila
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
5/125
Appropriate spatialframework for sectoraldevelopment
2005-2010 North Luzon
Metro Luzon
Urban Beltway
Central
Philippines
Mindanao
Cyber Super
Region
Super RegionStrategy
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
6/125
ILOCOS
NORTE APAYAO
CAGAYAN
ABRA
KALINGA
ILOCOS
SUR ISABELAMOUNTAINPROVINCE
LA UNION
BENGUETNUEVA
VIZCAYA QUIRINO NORTH
AURORA
PANGASINAN
NORTH
ZAMBALESNORTH
TARLAC
NORTH
NUEVA
ECIJA
IFUGAO
BATANES
Salomague Seaport
Port Irene
Northern CagayanAirport
Basco, Batanes
Bagabag, NuevaVizcaya
San Fernando (PoroPoint Intl.) Airport
NORTH LUZON AGRI-BUSINESS QUADRANGLE
Casiguran, Aurora
Itbayat, Batanes
Dingalan Port, Aurora
Alaminos Airport
Airports Total (Components) = 21Ports Total (Components) = 6
Being the food basket of Luzon and MetroManila, with its agriculture and mariculturedevelopment, the region can further boost itsinvestment climate. This can be done byreducing the cost of transporting goods and
addressing social development concerns bymobilizing local resources and networks tofacilitate the implementation of NationalGovernments projects.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
7/125
South
Zambales
South
TarlacSouth
Nueva Ecija
South
Aurora
PampangaBulacan
Quezon
BataanNCR Rizal
LagunaCavite
Batangas
MarinduqueOr.
Mindoro
Occ.
Mindoro
Polillo Is.
Subic Bay
Seaport
NAIA Terminal 3
LUZON URBANBELTWAY
DMIA, Clark
Lucena Port
Cawit Port
BatangasPort
RAIL PROJECTS:
EDSA North Transit (Closing the Loop)
LRT Line 1 South Ext. (Baclaran to Cavite)LRT Line 2, Phase 2 (East Ext. to Masinag)Northrail-Southrail Linkage, Phase I
(Caloocan to Alabang)Northrail-Southrail Linkage, Phase 2
(Alabang to Calamba)Northrail Project Phase 1, Sections 1 & 2
(Caloocan to Malolos to Clark)MRT 7MRT 3 CAPEX
Airports Total (Components) = 5Ports Total (Components) = 8Railways Total (Components) = 9
One of the primary thrusts of the region isto decongest Metro by expanding the publictransport system. The efficient movementand seamless access of goods and people
will lead to a globally competitive UrbanBeltway. To achieve this goal, the NationalGovernment is continuously developing theClark-Subic Corridor, Southern LuzonCorridor, and Metro Manila, and is
addressing critical infrastructure bottlenecksalong national roads and bridges to speedtraffic out of Metro Manila.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
8/125
Central Philippines
Camarines
Norte
CatanduanesCamarines
Sur
Albay
Sorsogon
North Samar
Samar Eastern
Samar
Masbate
Leyte
BiliranAklan
Capiz
Antique Iloilo
Guimaras
Negros
Occ.Negros
Or.
Cebu
Bohol
Siquijor
Southern
Leyte
SiargaoCamiguin
Dapitan
Palawan
Kalibo Airport
Balabac Airport
Puerto Princesa Airport
San Vicente Airport
Iloilo Airport
Bacolod (Silay) Airport
Dumaguete Airport
Panglao Airport
Siargao Airport
Southern Luzon Intl.Airport
Guiuan Airport
Kabankalan Airport
Busuanga Airport
San Jose (Carabao Is.)Airport
Tacloban Airport
Cawayan Port
San Pascual Port
Aroroy Port
Claveria Port
Pantao Port
Sibunag Port
Jagna Port
Maasin Port
Limasawa Port
Naval Port
Maripipi Port
Guinsiliban Port
Southrail Project Ph1B & Ph II
Bulan Airport
Ubay Port
Siquijor Port
Balbagon Port
Bogo, Santander &
Daannbantayn Ports
Airports Total (Components) = 85Ports Total (Components) = 22Railways Total (Components) = 2
Through efficient transportation facilities likeroad links, RORO/boat links, feederairports, airstrips and ports for hard-to-reachareas, the region opens and promotes itself asthe countrys tourism center. The cost of doingbusiness in the region can be reduced byimproving ports and airport facilities toaccommodate increasing passenger and cargotraffic. Consequently, the region will be able todevelop its agribusiness, small and mediumenterprises (SMEs), and export potentials.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
9/125
9
Sarangani
Zamboanga
del Norte
Zamboanga
Sibugay
Lanao
del Norte
Misamis
OrientalMisamis
Occidental
Camiguin
Davao
Oriental
Davao
del Sur
Surigao
del Sur
Surigao
del Norte
Basilan
Sulu
Tawi-Tawi
South
Cotabato
Zamboanga
City
Cotabato
City
Davao
del Norte
Cagayan de
Oro City
North
CotabatoZamboanga
del Sur
Compostela
Valley
Agusan
del Norte
Agusan del Sur
Ipil
Pagadian
City
Dipolog
City
Ozamis
City
Iligan
City
Butuan City
Surigao City
Maramag
Kabacan
Gen. Santos
City
Tacurong Koronadal
Palimbang
Maitum
Mati
Lanao
del Sur
Tagum
City
Davao
City
SourceofBasicData:DPWH,CAAP,PPA
DIPOLOG
DUMAGUETERORO
MAMBAJAO
JAGNA
RORO
SURIGAOCITYLILOANRORO
ZamboangaLamitanRORO
ZamboangaSiasiRORO
ZamboangaBongaoRORO
ZamboangaSta.MariaRORO
WesternNauticalHighway
EasternNautical
Highway
CentralNauticalHighway
Bukidnon
Sultan
Kudarat
Mindanao Infrastructure Development
CORTESTANDAGMARIHATAG
MARIHATAG
HINATUAN
BISLIGSECTION
Airports Total (Components) = 67Ports Total (Components) = 4
Aims to establish an efficient food logisticssystem that links Mindanao to Manila. Farm-
to-market roads will link food productionareas with major roads leading to themarket, while regional and municipal portswith improved facilities will boost fisherydevelopment
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
10/125
WESTERN NAUTICALHIGHWAY
PAN PHILIPPINEHIGHWAY
CENTRAL NAUTICALHIGHWAY
EASTERN NAUTICALHIGHWAY
STRONG REPUBLIC NAUTICAL HIGHWAY
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
11/125
Sub-Sector Performance
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
12/125
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
13/125
Source: LTO
-
10,000
20,000
30,000
40,000
50,000
60,000
70,000
80,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Cars PUJ/UV Trucks PUB MC/TC Trailers
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Cars 54,054 36,181 44,119 37,542 37,369 31,666 27,546 25,266
PUJ/UV 56,484 39,401 58,964 54,580 66,843 64,412 62,444 65,952
Trucks 6,657 5,599 7,072 5,587 6,624 6,270 5,467 5,138
PUB 11,287 8,232 11,251 8,413 10,754 9,285 7,623 7,341
MC/TC 54,058 51,968 54,306 55,471 61,173 67,098 65,971 62,171
Trailers 1,141 853 1,182 1,005 985 1,514 995 2,922
Total 183,681 142,234 176,894 162,598 183,748 180,245 170,046 168,790
Trends in Motorization - Metro Manila (for hire)
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
14/125
Source: LTO
-
50,000
100,000
150,000
200,000
250,000300,000
350,000
400,000
450,000
500,000
550,000
600,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Cars PUJ/UV Trucks PUB MC/TC Trailers
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
Cars 69,464 40,908 45,161 43,128 51,889 44,585 41,061 37,648
PUJ/UV 183,055 188,897 216,717 212,968 228,260 222,094 212,620 215,529
Trucks 17,991 17,032 18,306 16,872 18,229 17,325 18,144 16,919
PUB 29,833 27,632 30,069 26,987 28,644 25,992 24,118 23,142
MC/TC 491,113 517,087 537,811 527,561 555,340 584,698 588,695 591,254
Trailers 2,843 2,467 2,798 3,144 2,564 3,183 2,312 2,475Total 794,299 794,023 850,862 830,660 884,926 897,877 886,950 886,967
Trends in Motorization - Nationw ide (for hire)
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
15/125
Source: Land Transportation Office (LTO)
0
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
4,000,000
5,000,000
6,000,000
7,000,000
2006 2007 2008
NumberofUnits
Year
Cars UV SUV Truck Buses MC/TC Trailer
Nationw ide Motor Vehicle Registration,2006-2008
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
16/125
In 2006, approx imately 1.7 b il lion passengers and 25.9million tons of freight were conveyed by roads - representinga 98% share in passenger traffic and a 58% share in cargo
traffic.
Traffic on the Roads
Number of motor vehicles grew by 6.0% annually from 2000to 2008 to reach 5.9 mil l ion vehicles, or 7 vehicles for every100 persons. Until 2004, util ity vehicles were
dominant, accounting for 41.8% of the total fleet of motorizedvehicles.
In 2005 onwards, the composit ion changed as motorcyclesand tr icycles increased more rapidly than the other vehicle
types, now accounting for almost half of all vehicles on roads. A total of 5.9 million motor vehicles were registered in the country in
2008, including trailers of the total vehicle population in 2008, close to2 million were motorcycles and tricycles, which recorded a substantial
annual growth at 11.6%. On the other hand, the number of buses usedfor public transport is declining at an average rate of 1.6% a year.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
17/125
The road netw ork has improved, but is stil l lagging As of the end of 2008, the Philippine road network had a total length
of 205,778 km. National Roads accounted for 29,650 km or14.4%, Provincial Roads 15.2%, City Roads 3.4%, Municipal Roads
7.7 %, and Barangay Roads 59.3%. The national roads, about 72% are paved with concrete and/or
asphalt. For local roads, only about 22% (or 44,000 km) are paved,while the rest are gravel-surfaced and earth roads.
The countrys road density is by 0.22 km of paved road persq. km. of land area and 0.73 km of paved road per 1,000population.
In 2001 to 2008, the percentage of paved National Roads increasedmarginally, from 70.7% to 73.1%. Over the same period, thepercentage of paved National Roads in good and fair condition (usingthe Visual Condition Rating) improved from 47% to 54.8%. As of the
end of 2006, the average International Roughness Index (IRI) ofNational Roads was measured at 6.8, which is in the poor category.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
18/125
Comparison of Road Indices w ith Other Countries
Sources: Compiled from CIA Factbook, DPWH, ASEAN and UNESCAP Yearbooks
Country Total km
Paved Ratio %
Km per 1,000 km 2
land area
Km per 10,000population
All Roads
Natl Roads
Japan 1,193,000 79.0 3,194.294.0
Vietnam 251,787 32.2 71 682.925.8
Indonesia 372,929 55.3 214.1 16.5
Thailand 217,708 82.0 97.2 424.338.4
Malaysia 77,695 76.3 298.936.3
Phil ippines 205,778 21.0 73.0 685.922.4
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
19/125
Reforms in Governance
LGUs assuming full responsibility for financing andmanagement of local roads, w ith the DPWHfocusing on about 28,000 km of strategic nationalroads;
Establishment of a National Highway Authority;
Shifting road investments to regions with less density andlower road quality, with Mindanao getting a larger share
Wider implementation of RIMMS in 9 business processes
of DPWH. Not much has been achieved in these fourareas.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
20/125
Road Safety
The national cost of traffic accidents for the Phil ippines wasestimated at US$1.9 bi ll ion (or roughly 2.8% of the country's
GDP).
In the first three months of 2009 alone, the Philippine National Police hasrecorded more than 9,000 vehicular accidents compared to the historical
average of less than 4,000 and a record-high of 14,794 for the whole of2008. In terms of fatalities, traffic accidents average 2 fatalities for every 10accidents (compared to an average of 6 fatalities for every 10 maritimeaccidents).
In terms of number fatalit ies per m il lion vehicles, the Phil ippinesrecorded a better result at 215, against Malaysia (373), Singapore(250), Indonesia (261), Thailand (488), and Vietnam (558).
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
21/125
Road Accident Rates in Selected Countries
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
22/125
Revenues from the Motor Vehicle Users Charge (MVUC) collections
have increased from PhP6.65 billion in 2004 to PhP8.05 billion in2006. As of November 12, 2007, the Road Board has a totalavailable fund of PhP6.82 billion. There has also been a significantincrease in the release of funds - from PhP4.92 billion in 2004 to
PhP11.55 billion in 2006. The funds were used for maintainingnational, provincial and city roads nationwide, improvingdrainage, and installing adequate traffic light, road safety andpollution monitoring devices.
Motor Vehicle Users Charge (MVUC)
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
23/125
MV Inspection and Maintenance
The development of motor vehicle inspection facilities in the Philippines started inthe early 1980s when the DOTC/LTO, in collaboration with the Japan InternationalCooperation Agency (JICA), introduced the first Motor Vehicle Inspection System
(MVIS) in the country. The plan envisaged the establishment of computerized motorvehicle inspection stations all over the country. The plan called for at least onestation to be operational in each region by 1990 to evaluate the roadworthiness ofvehicles prior to registration.
In 1985, the pilot MVIS was established at the LTO Compound in Quezon City. Withits limited capacity, it performed the inspection of taxis in Metro Manila.
In 1992, twe lve (12) MVIS lanes were donated to the LTO by theJapanese government and were installed in Luzon: Metro Manila, (North
MVIS & South MVIS w ith 4 lanes each), San Fernando, Pampanga (2lanes), and Lipa City, Batangas (2 lanes). Through time, however, theseMVIS faci l i t ies have deteriorated due to inabi l i ty of the government toprovide full resources for upkeep of the system.
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
24/125
MV Inspection and Maintenance
In 2006, revived the full utility of the existing MVIS facilities in view of thecontinuing deterioration of air quality in mega cities, using the Motor
Vehicle User Charges (MVUC).
The first phase of the plan, which is ongoing, covers the following urbancenters: Metro Manila (North and South), Lipa, Pampanga, Cebu, and
Davao Cities. There are 4 other phases which will eventually cover allregional sites in the country.
The current facilities in North & South Metro Manila, Davao, Cebu andLipa, are being operated by the LTO Regional Offices, as part of theirregular regional operations. Once
improved/expanded/rehabilitated, these MVIS facilities are planned bythe DOTC and LTO to be continuously managed, operated, and maintainedby the Philippine government through the Regional LTOs.
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
25/125
MV Inspection and Maintenance
The preference by DOTC for a business-as-usual scenario of theimproved MVIS facilities may be rooted in the need for a painless
transition. Perceived disadvantages of the current setup are the difficulty ineffecting new and improved procedures and performance standards. Aprivatization option is not being ruled out. In 2005-2006, the DOTCevaluated a couple of privatization schemes, which are cited in studiesdone by the USTDA (2004) and ADB (2005).
Vehicle testing for both emissions compliance and roadworthiness isconducted in the MVIS centers/facilities or the private emission testingcenters (PETCs), as part of the overall motor vehicle registration process
under the current LTO setup.
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
26/125
Functions Progress Lead Agency
MV & Fuel StandardsDevelopment
Ongoing; DTI has organized TWGsfor standards formulation
DTI
MV Emissions Testing Ongoing, through MVIS & PETCs DOTC-LTO
MV Roadworthiness Testing Ongoing, through the MVIS LTO
Roadside Inspection toenforce emission standards e.g Anti-Smoke belch ing
Ongoing, through LTO, deputizedunits (DENR & LGUs); LGUs withordinances
LTO
MV Maintenance & RepairProgram
Voluntary basis by MV owners/PUVoperators
None yet
Accreditation of MV repairshops and private emissiontesting centers
Ongoing DTI
Authorization andperformance monitoring ofprivate emission testing
centers
Ongoing DOTC
Government Agencies Involved in Implementation of a nationalMotor Vehicle Inspection and Maintenance program
Road Transport
d
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
27/125
Road Transport
R d T
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
28/125
28
TSP Concentration Road Traffic-Related Monitoring Stations
Sources: Department of Environment and Natural Resources Environmental Management Bureau, Philippines (DENR-EMB), DENR National CapitalRegion, Philippines (DENR-NCR) and Partnership for Clean Air (PCA)
70% of the air pollution in
Metro Manila is attributedto transport
AirQuality
in
Metro
Manila
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
29/125
29
R d T t
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
30/125
30
Cost of pollution as a percentage of income ranges from2.5% to 6.1%
About 2,000 people die each year as a result of exposureto PM10. The model estimates an economic loss of aboutUS$140 million
About 9,000 people in these places suffer from chronic
bronchitis. The model estimates an economic loss ofabout US$120 million
Number of people suffering from PM10 relatedrespiratory symptoms is quite high. The model estimatesan economic loss of about US$170 million
Modeling by the World Bank on the effects of PM10 in Metro Manila, Davao, Cebu and Baguio
Source: http://www.adb.org/Vehicle-Emissions/phi/health.asp
Total economic cost of PM10 exposure in thesefour places: US$430 million
EconomicCosts
of
Air
Pollution
in
Key
Cities
Road Transport
R d T t
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
31/125
Energy Consumption in Road Transport
The current estimate of the countrys on-road fuel economy is 14l i ters/100 ki lometers, way below Chinas rate of 9.5 l i ters/100
kilometers.
The transport energy use in the Philippines has increased significantly from1.9 MTOE in 1980 to 10.9 MTOE in 2008, about 6.4% per year. Over thatsame period, vehicle population expanded at 6%; while the global averageenergy use in transport grew by only 2.7%. With all the energy derivedfrom petroleum (where the transport sector accounts for 65.6% of total oilconsumption), increases in future transport energy use will translate intobigger emissions of carbon.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Road Transport
R d T t
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
32/125
Road Transport
Source:DepartmentofEnergy(DOE)
R d T t
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
33/125
The Road Users Viewpoint A survey conducted by Bantay Lansangan (560 random samples of road
users) showed a 25% satisfaction rating.
CriteriaSatisfied
%
Dissatisfied
%
Net Satisfaction
Rating
1. Overall rating of road services 59.5 34.9 +25
2. Road safety 41.8 32.9 +9
3. Flow of traffic 69.2 26.2 +43
4. Road surface 65.4 31.0 +34
5. Overall bridge condition 68.4 31.6 +376. Maintenance 35.0 33.0 +2
7. Overall performance of DPWH 48.0 38.3 +10
8. Integrity level of DPWH 91.4 8.6 -83
9. Sincerity in fighting corruption 38.2 42.3 -4
10. DPWH meets concerns of the community 88.9 11.1 +78
11. DPWH practices transparency 66.7 33.3 +33
Source: Roadwatch Survey, 2008
Road Users Perception
According to the first Road Sector Status Report Card (RSSRC), datedSeptember 2009, prepared by Bantay Lansangan, the average road user
cost in 2007 was PhP 21.17 per vehicle-km, which is 41% morethan the optimal road user cost of PhP 15.17. The road user cost in2007 was slightly higher than the PhP 21.13 in 2006.
Road Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
34/125
Maritime Transport
Ma itime T anspo t
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
35/125
Sea Traffic
Cargo throughput for the period 1999-2008 hoveredaround 140 to 160 million tons per year. I t registereda high of almost 157.5 million tons in 2007, and thendropped again to below 150 mil l ion tons in 2008 .Attributing the fall to the global financial crisis of 2008 may
not be the only explanation, given the countrys relatively lowintegration with global trade.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
36/125
Domestic cargo traffic showed a moredramatic decline during the same period.
The volume of domestic cargo handled in2008 was even less than the volume in1999. This could be due to a change inrecording, since RORO traffic is notcaptured by the PPA data.
Cargo Traffic, 1999-2008
Foreign cargo continued to grow, withan 8-year average of 4.8% per year
punctuated by a drop in 2008. Thedecline was felt more in private ports,which posted an 18% drop. The privateports in Cagayan de Oro suffered themost as its foreign cargo throughput in
2008 was just a little over one milliontons compared to more than twelvemillion tons in 2006.Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
37/125
A declining trend isapparent. From a peak of24.6 million passengersin 2003, traffic droppedto 21.4 m illion in
2008, or 4% lower than2007 . While the figures arefor PPA ports only and donot capture the morenumerous small and feeder
ports, they are reflective ofthe overall situation in thetraditional port system of thecountry.
Passenger Traffic, 1999-2008
The drop in passenger traffic is more dramatic in the Port of Mani la from3.4 mil lion in 2001 to 2.3 mi llion in 2008.
Foreign container traffic has continued to grow from 1.75 m illion to 2.52mil l ion TEUs, or 6% p.a. over the last six years. In contrast, usage of
containers on the domestic trade declined by 3% during the same period.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
38/125
Sea Port System
There are more than 1,490 seaports in the Philippines, classified ascommercial , fishing, and feeder ports.
The public common-user ports totalled 331 (or 40% of the commercialcategory) as of 1997, the ports of importance in the domestic andinternational trade are those owned and operated by PPA and CPA.
In the last eight years, new port capacit ies and faci li ties wereprovided in Batangas Port (which was intended to provide relief toManila Port), Subic Container Terminal Port (an alternative to
Manila), and in Phiv idecs MICT (an alternative to Cagayan de Oro).
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
39/125
Aids to Sea Navigation
There are 561 lighthouses distributed
throughout the coastline of thecountry. Out of this number, two areoperated by private owners. Many ofthese facilities have been built in thelast 8 years through financial and
technical assistance from Japan (MSIP I and MSIP B), the United Kingdom(MSIP II) and Spain (MSIP III).
Maritime Trunk RoutesSource:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
40/125
Level of Investments
The cumulative investments of PPA in the last 10 yearsreached about Php24 Bill ion, or an average of Php2.4billion annually. PPAs single biggest project is the Portof Batangas Development Project already in Phase IIand ODA-funded by JBIC (now JICA). The total
investment for this project amounted to almost Php8bill ion.
In addition, the development of small municipal ports, deemed
socially-important, yet mostly non-viable. The aggregateinvestment for these port projects totalled PhP 3.7billion from2000 2009.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
41/125
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
42/125
The Nautical Highw ay From 63 RORO-capab le ports in 2002 when the Strong Republ ic
Naut ica l Highway Project (SRNH) was launched, the Road-RORO-Terminal System (RRTS) development during the last five years has
brought to 100 the number of ports equipped w ith RORO ramps (18base ports, 55 term inal ports, and 27 municipa l ports) or close to 65%of the target 155 ports for RORO port improvement.
The development of RORO routes in the country expanded the coverage of bus
and truck services to inter-island connections, thereby increasing the overallaverage distance traveled by these types of vehicles. Recent studies on inter-regional passenger and freight flows indicated that vehicle kilometerstraveled for cars, provincial buses and trucks have increased by asmuch as 20% since 2000.
The RORO routes comprise 919 kilometer (land) and 137 nautical miles (sea) thatconnect Luzon to Mindanao through several islands in the Visayas. Onegovernment report claimed a travel cost reduction by 37% to 43% forpassengers and 24% to 34% for cargo, compared to both conventional
sea and air travel; and travel time savings of 10 to 12 hours comparedto ordinary sea travel.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
43/125
Domestic Shipping In an inventory of routes and vesse ls in 1999, 16 of the 53
shipping companies were formed after 1992. Of the 75 companiesoperating before 1992, only 49% remained in operation by 1999.
The qual ity of cargo services has improved as a result of morechoices of carriers, the int roduct ion of RORO vessels, andincreased containerizat ion.
Competition on tertiary routes, however, has not intensified despiteliberalized entry. In these routes, service quality is still poor due to theprevalence of old wooden-hull vessels.
The quality of passenger service has shown dramatic improvements in the
primary and secondary routes. New facilities and amenities were introducedon board while passenger accommodation and ticketing and bookingfacilities were upgraded. Fast craft ferries became popular on the secondaryroutes in the Visayas seas, due to its shorter travel time. However, theoperations could not be sustained due to oversupply and high cost ofoperations.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
44/125
Domestic Shipping In 2004 study of the domestic shipping industry concluded that
the industry is highly concentrated, in the sense that the top fiveoperators accounted for more than 90% of the passenger and
freight volumes. Those operators were also found in most of theprimary routes; in about 50% of these routes, there was only oneservice provider. Competi tion is even weaker on the secondary andtertiary routes, where 59% , or, respectively, 78% , have only one
provider.
MARINA has kept the third class passenger tariff intentionally low, at belowcost, because the users are mostly from the low-income brackets. Theyconstitute about 70% of the total traffic. As a result, passenger operations
are cross-subsidized by cargo service in cases where a shipping lineprovides both services or operated combined cargo-passenger vessels.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
45/125
Indicator Philippines Other Countries
Stevedoring rates (per 20 TCL) $62.37 in NorthHarbor, ~$40 inMICT
$26.24 in Calcutta; $36.50 in Busan
Port tariff (1,100 TEU class ship) $32,437 in Manila $48,509 in Jakarta $99,419 in Singapore;$34,163 in Bangkok; $40,818 in Saigon Port;$129,026 in Hongkong
Logistics Cost for Export ($/TEU,inclusive of trucking, customsclearance, terminal costs,
miscellaneous fees)
Manila = $384 Hongkong=470; Singapore=239; Bangkok=345; Jakarta=410
Cargo handling charges ($/TEU) Manila= $40 to $60 Calcutta= 133; Busan = 82.80; Hongkong =Hongkong =141.20; Shanghai= 74.90;Belawang (Indonesia) = 81.00
Selected Performance Indicators in Ports, Shipping and Logistics
PPA is assured of continuing increase in its share of cargo-handling revenues. Shippingcompanies do not find their longer stay in ports expensive, since wharfage anddockage remained low, while some of them have ventured into the lucrative port-sidebusiness. The cargo handlers have received periodic increases in their tariff ranging
from 35% to 90% per year. The cargo handling cost have become a significant slice oftotal sea transport cost - ranging from 29% to 46% for break-bulk cargoes, and from10% to 43% for containerized cargoes.
Source: PPA and UNESCAP
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
46/125
Route $/ TEU VoyageTime (hrs)
Manila-Cebu 399 20
Manila-Davao 654 36
Manila-Zamboanga 387 33
Cebu-General 283 10
Route toFreight$/TEU
VoyageTime
(in hours)Singapore 550 96Hong Kong 350 48Klang, Malaysia 600 144Busan, Korea 850 120
Long Beach/LA 1,985 408Tokyo 780 20Taiwan 350 48Sydney 850 288 Antwerp 950 888
Note: Ratesport-to-port, discounted for volume shipments.Source: WGA, Cebu Ferries
Ratesport-to-port, discounted for volume shipments.Source: Direct Container Line Phils
The international freight rates are higher due to theneed for transhipment, but not unreasonable
Inefficiency has been an even greater problem for inter-island shipments, where unit costs are high and transit times, including time in port
The shipping cost differential between the domestic and international routes is duemore to a difference in economic structure, than to port inefficiencies. The average
vessel size in domestic shipping is less than 1,000 GRT against the 10,000 GRT average forocean-going vessels. The one-day dockage and usage fee for a 10,000 GRT vessel in aPhilippine port is less than the 12 hours charge in most Asian ports. Given the relatively smallvessel size, it is not surprising that inter-island shipping costs are relatively high. The relativelylong turnaround times in the domestic ports and their limited capacity offset any potentialsavings in capital costs most interisland vessels being fully written off- and due to low crewcosts.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
47/125
Safety
The maritime sub-sectors record is alarming w ith an averageof more than 200 accidents per year over the last decade.
Year Number of Incidents Fatalit ies Accidents
2000 151 177
2001 168 59 ML Anahada (124 dead + 14 missing);2002 152 73 MV Carmella in April 2002 (30 dead)
2003 255 74 MV San Nicolas (43 dead + 21 missing)
2004 227 144 Superferry 14 bombed in Feb 2004 (116
dead)
2005 122 252006 114 62
2007 & later Princess of the Stars capsized in June 2008
(312dead + 461missing), MV Baleno
9, MV Catalyn B
Maritime Accidents
Source: Philippine Coast Guard
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
48/125
Maritime Incident and Lives Lost in 2008
Source: World Casualty Statistics 2008
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
49/125
Maritime safety and security measures are being implemented in thedomestic trade in compliance with the International Safety Management(ISM) and the National Safety Management (NSM) codes. Compliance with
Rule VI of RA No. 9295, An Act Promoting the Development of thePhilippine Domestic Shipping, Shipbuilding, Ship Repair and ShipBreaking, Ordaining Reforms in Government Policies Towards Shipping inthe Philippines, and for Other Purposes, is also being monitored.
The Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)-assisted ProjectEnhancement of Ship Inspection was likewise completed in 2005. Underthe project, trainings/seminars on the enhanced Ship Safety InspectionSystem (SSIS) were conducted with Maritime Industry Authority (MARINA)and Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) inspectors as participants.
The PCG has enhanced ship inspection with an annual average of 307,780Mandatory Pre-Departure Inspections (MPDI), 627 Emergency Readiness
Evaluations (ERE), 627 Port State Control Inspections (PSCI), 1,353 FlagState Control Inspections (FSCI), and 32,485 Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS)Compliance Inspections.
Safety
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
50/125
In 2005, a Study on Wooden-Hulled Ships (WHS) was completed, whichrecommended standards, rules, and regulations for the continued operationof existing WHS and the construction, safety, and operation of new WHS.Through RA 9295 and its IRR, a Mandatory Vessel Retirement Program(MVRP) shall be implemented to modernize domestic ships by retiring allunclassed ships and retiring or replacing ships that have already reachedthe maximum allowable age as stipulated under the program.
The program will be facilitated by establishing a viable financing scheme tosupport local construction of needed vessels. Under EO588, Strengthening the Philippine Shipbuilding and Ship Repair (SBSR)
Sector and Instituting Measures to Promote Its Growth and Developmentissued on December 8, 2006, the MARINA, in coordination with theinteragency Ad-Hoc Committee and Technical Working Group, completedthe Comprehensive Development Plan for the Philippine Shipbuilding andShip Repair Industry on October 16, 2007.
Safety
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
51/125
The target to reduce maritime accidents by at least 50 percent by 2010 hasbeen exceeded as of third quarter 2007, with only 40 recorded maritimeaccidents compared with the 227 accidents recorded in 2004 despite
increased maritime traffic due to the development of the RORO system.
With respect to compliance with international safety standards, adherenceis being implemented by adopting the International Ship and Port Facility
Security (ISPS) Code. A Vessel Traffic Management System (VTMS) hasbeen installed in the Port of Manila to comply with security provisions ofthe Code. There are also plans to install the system in other major portsacross the country.
Safety
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
52/125
From 2004 to 2007, government worked to provide the needed transportinfrastructure that complements the roll-on roll-off (RORO) system and opens upnew economic opportunities, reduces transportation and transaction costs, andincreases access to social services.
The improvement of the nautical highway system maximizes the use of the Road-RORO Terminal System (RRTS) to transport produce from Mindanao through
Visayas to Luzon. It reduced travel time by 12 hours, and decreased transportcost by 37 percent to 43 percent for passengers and 24 percent to 34 percent forcargo.
The Maritime Equity Corporation of the Philippines under the NationalDevelopment Company (later renamed the NDC-Maritime Leasing Corporation orNMLC) was established in 2005 to facilitate the acquisition of maritime ROROvessels for leasing to qualified operators under a lease purchase agreement.
The government aims to complete the nautical highway by improving 837.8kilometers (km) of national roads along the Western Nautical Highway, 413.6 kmon the Central Nautical Highway and 76.4 km on the Eastern Nautical Highway.
Roll -On-Roll-Off (RORO System)
Institutional Strengthening
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
53/125
To enhance the countrys exports and private sector participation in port expansionand operation and maintenance, the modernization of the Manila North Harbor wasbid out to the private sector to finance, develop, manage, operate, and maintain thevarious facilities and services at the harbor.
The Philippine Ports Authority (PPA) issued Administrative Order (AO) No. 03-2004prescribing guidelines on developing, constructing, managing and operating ferryterminals under the RRTS. The AO also simplified the procedures in theprocessing/issuance of required Clearance to Develop/Permit to Construct, andCertificate of Registration/Permit to Operate.
In addition, to coordinate port development plans and ensure an integrated andefficient port system, AO 123 was formulated, authorizing the Secretary of theDepartment of Transportation and Communications (DOTC) to perform all necessarypowers and functions to connect the country by developing transportation networkssuch as the RORO system.
Roll -On-Roll-Off (RORO System)
Institutional Strengthening
Maritime Transport
Maritime Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
54/125
Other Outcome Key reforms that were stated in the MTDP, but which were not
achieved, include:a) separat ion of port regulation and operat ion;
b) decentralizat ion of port management in preparation to portsprivatization; and
c) discontinuat ion of levies paid by private ports to PPA.
Two major container port projects outside its umbrella have taken off, with
substantial JBIC funding. These are the Subic Port (under SBMA) and theMindanao Container Port (under the Phividec Industrial Authority). The firstone could offer an alternative to the port of Manila, while the second is athreat to PPA domination is the port of Cagayan de Oro.
An alternative port system, the RRTS, was also launched in 2002 underExecutive Order No. 170. It promises to provide a lower-cost alternative (inthe absence of cargo-handling charges) to PPA ports in the short-distancemarkets, as well as time savings.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Maritime Transport
Container Throughput and Berth Length
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
55/125
Source: 1)Lloyd's List Port of the World 2008, 2) Containerization International Yearbook 2009, 3)International Transport Handbook 2009
g p gof 47 Designated Ports in ASEAN
Container Throughput of
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
56/125
g pASEAN Countries (2000 - 2007)
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
(1,0
00T
EU)
Indonesia
Malaysia
Philippine
Singapore
Thailand
Vietnam
Source: Containerization International Yearbook
Annual Average GrowthRate of Member States
8%
Batangas Port
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
57/125
Year
Container Cargo Volume (1000 TEU's)
Import Ex port EmptyTrans-
shipment To ta lVolumeIncrease
2010 4.4 3.7 1.8 0.2 10.0
2011 17.7 14.9 7.1 0.3 40.0 300%2012 31.3 26.1 12.4 0.3 70.0 75%
2013 44.7 37.2 17.6 0.5 100.0 43%
2014 49.2 41.0 19.4 0.5 110.0 10%
2015 56.8 47.4 22.4 0.6 127.2 16%
2016 62.1 51.7 24.5 0.6 138.9 9%
2017 69.6 58.1 27.5 0.8 155.9 12%
2018 80.2 66.8 31.7 0.8 179.5 15%
2019 98.7 82.2 39.0 0.9 220.8 23%
2020 112.7 93.9 44.5 1.1 252.1 14%
2021 124.8 104.0 49.3 1.2 279.2 11%
2022 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 7%
Projected Container Volume for 2010-2034 Cargo Forecast
Year
Container Cargo Volume (1000 TEU's)
I mport Export Em ptyTrans-
sh ipment To ta lVolumeIncrease
2023 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2024 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%2025 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2026 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2027 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2028 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2029 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%2030 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2031 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2032 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2033 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
2034 134.1 111.7 52.9 1.2 300.0 0%
China-ASEAN Free Trade Agreement (from 1 Jan 2010)
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
58/125
Yunnan
45 mil Pop
Guangxi
50 mil Pop
g ( )Benefits: Increased trade, investment & market size
Strategic Geographical Location
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
59/125
BohaiEconomicZone
Yangtze River Delta
Pearl River Delta
Malacca Strait
?
Tokyo Bay
Strategic Geographical Location
China Energy Security & Alternat ive Access
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
60/125
Time and costcompetitive
Economic andlogistics potentials
Relieving
congestion inStrait of Malacca
Intermodal
infrastructuredevelopment
gy yto Indian Ocean
Land Corridor
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
61/125
Land Corridor
A corridor is only as strong as the weakest link
Land Corridor
The Case of GMS-East West Economic Corridor
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
62/125
The Case of GMS East West Economic Corridor
Road Infrastructure is not a major issue but intra-connectivity within is.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
63/125
Transport is a derived demand.Development of industrial/ economic
corridor generally dictated by the
private sector. Did w e set ourselves forfailure from very beginning???
The Case of Batangas Port
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
64/125
The Case of Batangas Port
Risks/ Challenges Response1. Low utilization of port facilities
- irregular port of call of containervessels
Logistic infrastructure development study Communication plan to achieve buy-in
support of stakeholders/locators
Convergence forum with stakeholders Explore possible assistance of dialoguepartner on the provision of vessel
Market/provide incentives to biginternational shipping companies to utilize
Batangas port as their maritime hub.2. Domestic Competition
- South harbour/ICTSI- Subic
Assist port operator with business plan- cargo consolidation/inland clearance
depot
- time/distance cost analyses- time/space analyses
3. Global/regional market competition Regional cooperation, including China,Japan, Korea and India
4. Lack of policy directions- Role of MICT, Subic and Batangas port Conduct SUMAC ports strategy study Build case with NCC
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
65/125
Civil Aviation
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
66/125
Air Traffic
Passenger traff ic has grown rapidly in the last seven years, withdomestic growth outpacing international. Cargo volume domesticand international, however, registered sluggish growth low er thanthe economys average rate of expansion.
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Pax Domestic (000) 12,233 12,288 13,031 15,094 14,531 15,712 21,110 23,668
Pax Intl (000) 7,732 8,026 7,703 9,052 9,981 10,557 12,362 12,763
CargoDomestic (000
tons)
248 309 253 265 261 232 342 257
CargoIntl (000 tons) 261 287 280 318 310 307 317 280
Air Transport Traffic Statist ics, 2001-2008
Source: Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
67/125
Growth Rates in Air Cargo and Passenger
The 8-year year-on-year average growth rates in passenger volume were9.8% for domestic and 7.7% for international. In comparison, the economygrew by an average of 4.4% . In effect , the sectors performance wasconsistent with the industry s rule-of-thumb that demand for air travelgrows tw ice as fast as GDP.That it exceeded the expected growth in domestic airtravel can be explained by consumers positive response to the airlines marketing andlow-fare offerings. For air cargo, the comparative figures were only 2.4% and1.3%, respectively.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
68/125
Domestic air traff ic was concentrated in 20 airports (out of 85). International traff iccentered on only five gateway airports (out of 10) of which 95.5% was accounted for by
Manila and Mactan (Cebu). The performance of Laoag International Airport (Ilocos Norte) surpassedthat of Davao in the south of Mindanao especially in cargo traffic. It would seem that Laoag benefitedfrom the open-skies policy, which had been adopted in the 1990s, but was limited only to Laoag.
Distribution of Air Traffic by Airports
Strong tourism traffic explains the substantial growths of the airports of
Kalibo, Caticlan, Laoag, Tagbilaran, and Puerto Princesa. Pagadian airports record, on the other hand, ispoor: In 1995, the airport recorded more than 50,000 arrivals and departures. By 2008, the traffic haddropped to zero.Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
69/125
Air Infrastructure
The Ph ilippines has 254 airports, of which only 85 are publicand provided wi th paved runways. They have varying
degrees of compliance w ith international aviation standards.Ten airports are classified as international, of which seven areconsidered class 1. About half of the 85 top airports are classified ascommunity airports, which are small with short runways and serving
only general aviation. The middle category is occupied by 34 primaryairports of which 15 are rated as Class 1. Pagadian, which recordedzero traffic in 2008, belongs to this category. Seven of 19 class 2primary airports have very little traffic (less than 20 passengers a
week).
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
70/125
To be globally competitive andaddress safety issues raised by
tourists, the government is in theprocess of implementing theCommunications NavigationSurveillance/Air Traffic Management
(CNS/ATM) System in accordance withInternational Civil AviationOrganization (ICAO) standards.Furthermore, the Nationwide AirNavigation Facilities ModernizationProject (Phase 3), which aims toreplace ageing air navigationequipment, was completed in March2004.
Communication Nav igation Satellite/ Air TrafficManagement (CNS/ ATM)
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
71/125
Airline Services Air transport services have become competitive resulting largely from
Executive Order (EO) 219 issued in 1995. New players entered the domesticscene, such as Cebu Pacific, Air Philippines, Asian Spirit, Grand
Airways, Mindanao Express, Pacific Airways, Laoag International Airlines, andSouth East Asian Airlines. Consolidation and mergers since 2000 reduced thenumber of viable operators a pattern observed in many other countries thathave deregulated their aviation industry.
A research study of ten routes covering the period 19812003, concluded that airfare per k i lometer was 10% lower, onaverage, on routes w i th at least two airlines. Twenty-threeroutes, representing more than 90% of domestic airlinepassengers, have at least two airlines by 2003, indicating that mostpassengers benefited from lower fares, more frequent services, andmore consumer choices.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
72/125
Sub-Sector Governance The proposal to corporatize the aviation administration took more
than 15 years to realize. It remains to be seen whether the newinstitu tion w ill live up to earlier expectations.
While it may be too early to evaluate the performance of the newbody, some features in its statute are contrary to good practices:
a. Board of Directors composed of five department Secretaries, who, becauseof existing prohibitions on multiple compensations, are likely to delegatetheir functions to lower-level officials;
b. The combination of regulatory and commercial powers within one agencylends itself to the risk of conflict-of-interests;
c. Failure to define the authoritys relationships with the autonomous airportbodies (over the international airports of Manila, Subic, Mactan-Cebu, andClark) and with the Civil Aeronautics Board.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
73/125
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
74/125
Safety The FAA dow ngraded CAAP from Category 1 to Category 2 status on
04 January 2008, aviation capability in providing safetycertification and oversight for international carriers, citing among
others:- inadequate and, in some cases, nonexistent regulatory legislation;- lack of advisory documentation;- shortage of experienced airworthiness staff;
- lack of control on important airworthiness related items such as issuanceand enforcement of Airworthiness Directives, Minimum Equipment Lists,investigation of Service Difficulty Reports, etc.;
- lack of adequate technical data;- absence of Air Operator Certification (AOC) systems, and non-conformance
to the requirements of the AOC System;- lack or shortage of adequately trained flight operations inspectors includinga lack of type ratings;
- lack of updated company manuals for the use by airmen;- inadequate proficiency check procedures; and- inadequately trained of cabin attendants.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
75/125
Consistent with the principle of separation of operation and regulatoryfunctions in the civil aviation industry, Republic Act (RA) No. 9497 was
enacted into law on March 4, 2008 creating the Civil Aviation Authority ofthe Philippines (CAAP). The CAAP handles technical regulation functionswithout diminishing the role of the CAB.
Institutional Strengthening
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
76/125
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
77/125
Railway Sector
Railway Sector
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
78/125
Railway Traffic
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Rail transport used to be the dominant mode in Luzon up to the1960s, when the network comprised 1,140 track ki lometers.
The 448-km Manila South Line continued to operate from Manilato Naga up to September 2006, when a major typhoon cut theline to 40 km.
The South L ine was barely attract ive with dai ly passengervolume of less than 1,000. In the last tw o decades, three majorattempts and investments were made to rehabilitate the tracksand provide better trains; al l of which yielded only temporarygains fo l lowed by decl ine in patronage. Bus service on thecorridor, where PNR operates, is more attractive, despite thelower rail fares.
Railway Sector
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
79/125
Railway Traffic
Passenger traffic on the PNR Main Line South continued todecl ine from 374 thousand in 2000 to 137 thousand in
2006. In September 2006, the line was forced to close due totyphoon-induced damage on a railw ay bridge and tracks.
I ts commuter train operations, which serve main ly the
southern part of Metro Manila, also recorded cont inuingdecline in ridership from 3.5 mi llion in 2000 to 1.9 million in2007.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Railway Sector
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
80/125
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Line 1 107.0 107.24 98.86 104.41 111.08 119.12 138.04
Line 2 2.35 20.69 41.89 47.58 52.93 58.59
Line 3 102.4 112.65 122.61 127.79 122.97 142.69 149.58
Total 209.4 222.24 242.16 274.09 281.59 314.59 346.21
Urban Rail Ridership in Metro Manila:LRT Lines
Ridership has reached almost a million passengers a dayon all three lines, which is about 5% of total daily trips inMetro Manila.
LRT Line 2006 2007 2008
Line 1 61.5 66.5 62.4
Line 2 30.9 34.1 38.8Line 3 76.8 87.7 91.8
Average Load Factors (% )
The average load factors indicate overcrowd ing on Lines 3 and 1 , w i th sufficient capacity on Line 2. In an urbansett ing, where peak loading is the usual
pattern, an average dai ly load factor ofabove 60% is an indicator of congest ion.
LRT Line 2006 2007 2008
Line 1 1.52 1.49 1.56Line 2 1.10 1.02 1.03Line 3 0.96 1.07 1.08
Fare Box Ratio of Metro Lines
Despite the higher ridership on Line 3, its fare box ratio is
lower than Line 1 due to the formers high operatingexpenses under its Build-Lease-Transfer scheme.
LRT Line 2006 2007 2008Fare Subsidy Fare Subsidy Fare Subsidy
Line 1 14.362.67
14.34-4.06
14.22n.a.
Line 2 13.51 14.15 13.93Line 3 13.42 16.92 12.05 18.01 12.34 15.56
Average Fare and Subsidy Per Passenger
The average fare as well as the implicit subsidy per passenger
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Railway Sector
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
81/125
Urban Rail Network
The urban rail network totals 45.8 km in length, consisting of 15 km elevated
Line 1 on a north-south axis, a 13.8 km Line 2 on an east-west axis, and17km Line 3 on a circumferential route. An additional 4km northernextension to Line 1 is under construction.
Ridership on the three Metro l ines continues to expand at 8.8%
yearly average w ith fares stagnant at its 2003 level while thoseof competing buses have increased several times.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Railway Sector
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
82/125
Governance of Rail Subsector There are several issues in the way the rail sub-sector is
managed, including:
- MRT 3 is operated by DOTC, employing casual employees since 2002,instead of consol idat ing the same with LRTA and al lowing a morepermanent tenure.
- The Northrai l Project is being implemented by an agency with no
business or franchise to engage in rail services.- The long-delayed extension to Line 3 is being built as an extension to
Line 1, w ith long-term consequences on future operations and networkefficiency.
- Line 3 was completed at a cost of $675.5 mil l ion. After eight years oflease payments, the balance on outstanding loan principals should beless than $500m. However, in 2009, the government bought out about75% of the interest of the original investors at about $800m , whichwould be equiva lent to an outstanding balance of $1,060 million.
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Global Competitiveness
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
83/125
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
The Decline of the Philippines GlobalCompetitiveness Ranking (GCR) from 48 th in 2002
to 87 th in 2009. The fall was mirrored in the declineof the global index for Ease of Doing Business from136 th in 2007 to 144 th in 2009. In contrast, Thailand
which used to be at par with the Philippines in the 1970s -has advanced to the 36th position on the GCR scale.
p
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
84/125
Transport Infrastructure Rank ings in the GlobalCompetitiveness Report 2008-09
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
85/125
Source: World Economic Forum, The Global Competitiveness Report, 20082009.
Competitiveness Report, 2008-09
Logistics
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
86/125
Singapore topped the ranking with and LPI of 4.19. It is perhaps surprising that thePhilippines fared worse than Vietnam and Indonesia, despite the countrys acknowledgedadvantage in IT know-how.
Comparative LPI of Selected Countries
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
g
Logistics
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
87/125
The Philippines Logistic Performance Index (LPI) stood at 2.69, good enough for a65th position against other countries, in 2007.
CriteriaVietnam Thailand Malaysia Singapore Indonesia Philippines
Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank Score Rank
Customs 2.89 37 3.03 32 2.99 35 3.90 3 2.73 44 2.64 53Infrastructure 2.50 60 3.16 31 3.20 30 4.27 2 2.83 45 2.26 86
International Shipments 3.00 47 3.24 32 3.31 28 4.04 2 3.05 44 2.77 63
Logistics Competence 2.80 56 3.31 29 3.40 27 4.21 2 2.90 50 2.65 70
Tracking and Tracing 2.90 53 3.25 36 3.37 31 4.25 1 3.30 33 2.65 69
Domestic Logistics Cost 3.30 17 3.21 28 2.97 72 2.70 113 2.84 92 3.27 19
Timeliness 3.22 65 3.91 28 3.68 36 4.53 1 3.28 58 3.14 70
Overall LPI 2.89 53 3.31 31 3.32 30 4.19 1 3.01 43 2.69 65
LPI Score of Selected Countries, 2007
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Energy in Transport
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
88/125
Source:DraftNationalTransportPlan,14Dec.2009
Energy use in transport is grow ing at 6.4 % ayear, which exceeds the global average of 2 .7% , toreach 10.9 MTOE in 2008.
The estimated greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions in 2007is 29.3 MtCO2 of which road transport contributed about
24 MtCO2.
Maritime and aviation emitted a total of 5.3 MtCO2.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
89/125
Civil Aviation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
90/125
The FAA downgraded CAAP from Category 1to Category 2 status on 04 January 2008.The Consequences of downgrading intoCategory 2 includes no expansion/increaseof existing number of flights and routes for
Philippine carriers operating into USterritories and heightened operation andairworthiness surveillance by the FAA on
Philippine carriers operating in the USterritories.
Civil Aviation
http://images.google.com.ph/imgres?imgurl=http://www.af.mil/shared/media/photodb/photos/061113-F-9062T-001.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.af.mil/photos/media_search.asp%3Fq%3Dconvoys%26page%3D3&usg=__bonIRHMRHE2wN32Fg7F7QMcEGu8=&h=1375&w=2182&sz=914&hl=en&start=14&tbnid=vT7i796_7ituRM:&tbnh=95&tbnw=150&prev=/images%3Fq%3DAir%2BCargo%26gbv%3D2%26hl%3Denhttp://images.google.com.ph/imgres?imgurl=http://www.trans-logistic.com/images/globeplane.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.trans-logistic.com/air%2520freight.htm&usg=__fHesquJTPRQ2OWl9p66Y75LM144=&h=301&w=300&sz=21&hl=en&start=9&tbnid=maPmeay17oY86M:&tbnh=116&tbnw=116&prev=/images%3Fq%3DAir%2BCargo%26gbv%3D2%26hl%3Den -
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
91/125
Filipino Airlines Suffering from Poor Aviat ionRating
Korean civil aviation officials had nixedPhilippine Airlines bid for a Cebu-Seoul route.
Saudi Arabia too may delay resumption of the
flag carriers Manila-Riyadh flights.
Authorities in Japan, HongKong, Singapore, and Australia have begun
inquiring about RPs aviation record andpolicies.
Revenues would be lost from the traditional
high-profit routes.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
92/125
Magnitude of theEnvironmental problem
Based on the 2007 NationalEmission Inventory mobile
sources contribute 65%of
the air pollution loadnationwide
Scientif ic evidence suggests that a 450ppm CO2e pathway with over-shoot gives a 40-60% probability to limit global warming to 2 degrees
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
93/125
Global GHG emissions and pathways for GHG stabil ity
Probabil ity oftemperature
increaseunder 2oC
Expectedtemperature
increase
Source: IPCC WG3 AR4,, den Eizen, van Vuuren; Meinshausen; Global GHG Abatement Cost Curve v2.0, Catalyst analysis
* Climate impact estimates for current proposals calculated using C-ROADS model
17 Gt of reduct ions below BAU in 2020 are required for 450ppm:Current proposals put us on a 700-750 ppm path and 4 degree future
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
94/125
Global GHG emissions, Gt, CO2e per year
Source: McKinsey Global GHG Abatement Cost Curve v2.0; Houghton; IEA; US EPA; den Eizen, van Vuuren; Project Catalyst analysis
ITS IMPACTS WILL INCREASE,
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
95/125
ITS IMPACTS WILL INCREASE,BOTH IN STRENGTH & IN FREQUENCY.
It w il l get worse,before it gets better.
Non OPEC Oil Production Forecast
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
96/125
This is the 2004 CIA predictions of oil production of non OPECmembers and former Soviet Union.
The Road Users in the Future ??
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
97/125
Developments in the Regional Arena
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
98/125
Developments in the Regional Arena
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
99/125
ASEAN-China North-South Corridor-1 (ACNS-1)- China-Myanmar-Andaman Sea Corridor
ASEAN-China North-South Corridor-2 (ACNS-2)- China--Lao PDR/Myanmar-Thailand-Malaysia-
Singapore Corridor
ASEAN-China North-South Corridor-3 (ACNS-3)- China-Vietnam-Lao PDR-Cambodia Corridor
ASEAN-China North-South Corridor-4 (ACNS-4)- China-ASEAN Ocean Corridor
ASEAN-China East-West Corridor-1 (ACEW-1)
- The Straits of Malacca Corridor
ASEAN-China East-West Corridor-2 (ACEW-2)- Vietnam-Cambodia-Thailand-Myanmar
ASEAN-China East-West Corridor-3 (ACEW-3)- Vietnam-China-Myanmar-Bengal-India Corridor
List of Priority Projects of theASEAN-China Increased globalization and
competition for markets and
investment; Emergence of China as a global
economic player;
Increased collaboration ofASEAN withChina, Japan, Korea, and India;
China-ASEAN Free Trade Agreement (from 1 Jan 2010)Benefits: Increased trade, investment & market size
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
100/125
Yunnan
45 mil Pop
Guangxi
50 mil Pop
,
Strategic Geographical Location
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
101/125
BohaiEconomicZone
Yangtze River Delta
Pearl River Delta
Malacca Strait
?
Tokyo Bay
Intermodal Transport Logistics Operations
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
102/125
CHINAINDIA
Kunming
Nanning
Sittwe
Yangon
Mandalay
Bangkok
Vientiane
Hanoi
Ho Chi Minh
Phnom
Penh
Bhamo
Danang
Mawlamyine
Shenzhen
Landbridge for Global Maritime Shipping
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
103/125
Economicbenefits
Logistics cost
impactsShippingroutingimplications
Infrastructuredevelopmentstrategies
Regionalcooperation
Multimodal
corridors
China Energy Security & Alternat ive Accessto Indian Ocean
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
104/125
Time and costcompetitive
Economic andlogistics potentials
Relieving
congestion inStrait of Malacca
Intermodal
infrastructuredevelopment
Strait of Malacca -- Security, Capacity, Time
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
105/125
Expected completion2014
48 pipeline of capacity
6 million barrels crude oilper day
Cut down tanker traffic in
Malacca Strait by 20%. Transport cost and time
implications
Intermodal Transport
China-ASEAN Port Cooperation
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
106/125
Three ports in BeibuGulf for cooperation withASEAN:
Beihai Port FangchengPort
Qinzhou Port
Enhancingarchipelagic
ASEAN maritime
corridors
Trans-Asian Railway route map
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
107/125
81,000 km, 28 countries
Missing links
Intergovernmental Agreement on the Trans-Asian Railway Network Adopted by the 62nd UNESCAP Commission (April 2006, Jakarta)
Signing ceremony during the Ministerial Conference on
Transport (6-11 November 2006, Busan)
Expected to enter into force in May 2009
Current Trends
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
108/125
ECONOMICS Market integration Development of industrial/economic corridors
Internal Mobility/Connectivity Liberalised context Liberalisation of logistics services
SOCIAL Safety & Security Training/Skills development
ENVIRONMENTAL Pollution Carbon emission
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
109/125
What does these developments in
Regional Arena mean for us???
What opportunities, including those interms of financial and technicalcooperation and assistance have been
opened or closed for us???
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
110/125
We cant improve something w ithoutmeasuring!!!
Develop a rigorous economic geographymodel for predicting changes in the locat ionof population and industries across region
in the process of economic integrat ion.- IDE Geographical Simulation Model
determine the dynamic of location of population and industries in East Asia in thelong term.
analyze the impact of infrastructure
development projects on the regional economyat sub-national level.
Vietnam
Myanmar
Guangzhou
PXG
Hanoi China
Nanning
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
111/125
VTE
Singapore
Kuala Lumpur
Phnom Phen
Malaysia
Bangkok
Ho Chi Minh
Laos
Danang
Cambodia
Hanoi
China
Thailand
ZVK
VTE
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
Sub-Regional RORO Prospect
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
112/125
BUKIDNON
COTABATO
DAVAO
AGUSAN DEL SUR
MAGUINDANAODAVAO ORIENTAL
SULTAN KUDARAT
ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE
SURIGAO DEL SUR
LANAO DEL SUR
DAVAO DEL SUR
SOUTH COTABATO
SARANGGANI
COMPOSTELA VALLEY
MISAMIS ORIENTAL
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR
SULU
LANAO DEL NORTE
AGUSAN DEL NORTE
BASILAN
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY
DAVAO DEL SURSARANGGANI
MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
TAWI-TAWI
DAVAO
CAMIGUIN
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
SULU
SULU
TAWI-TAWI
SULU
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
BUKIDNON
COTABATO
DAVAO
AGUSAN DEL SUR
MAGUINDANAODAVAO ORIENTAL
SULTAN KUDARAT
ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE
SURIGAO DEL SUR
LANAO DEL SUR
DAVAO DEL SUR
SOUTH COTABATO
SARANGGANI
COMPOSTELA VALLEY
MISAMIS ORIENTAL
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR
SULU
LANAO DEL NORTE
AGUSAN DEL NORTE
BASILAN
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY
DAVAO DEL SURSARANGGANI
MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL
ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
TAWI-TAWI
DAVAO
CAMIGUIN
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
SULU
SULU
TAWI-TAWI
SULU
ZAMBOANGA SIBUGAY
SURIGAO DEL NORTE
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
TAWI-TAWI
Mindanao connectivity under BIMP-EAGA
Sea Linkages
Air Linkages
Logistic Development Framework
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
113/125
Liberalization of Logistics Services Maritime Transport Services Air Freight Services Rail Freight Transport Services Road Freight Transport Services
Enhancing Competitiveness of Logistic Services
Providers through Trade and Logistics Facilitation Trade and Customs Facilitation Logistics Facilitation
Expanding Capability of Logistics Service Providers Human Resource Development
Enhance Multi-Modal Transport Infrastructure andInvestment
Governance
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
114/125
The Philippine Economic Boat andThe Global Recession
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
115/125
The Philippines is notbadly affected because wesaw the global storm andour boat stayed in port.
Dr. Josef T.Yap, president, Philippine Institutefor Development Studies at conference on the global recession.February 17, 2009
The Philippines is not badlyaffected because our boat
did not leave the port.
Attributed to Dr. Felipe M. Medalla, UPeconomist & former NEDA DirectorGeneral
The Philippines is not badlyaffected because our boat
has not been built.
Manuel V. Pangalinan, chairman PLDT, MAP speech, February 11, 2009
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
116/125
The World Is ChangingAre we on board?
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
117/125
THE WAY FORWARD ??
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
118/125
Transport Issues
Early Realizations
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
119/125
119
Early Realizations The country did not have a truly integrated
strategy for the transport sector
Although we may have the best and technically-exceptional plans and projects, we areconstrained with the absence of capable
institutions who will implement the plans
Philippine Transport StrategyStudy (PTSS)
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
120/125
120
Study (PTSS) Commissioned to develop the Transport Agenda
for the next 6 years (1999-2004) in line with the
Medium-Term Philippine Development Plan(MTPDP)
Issues identified by PTSS
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
121/125
121
Issues identified by PTSS
Politics intrudes extensively in the sector toointrusively. The results is that just abouteverywhere is a development priority, and littleattention is paid to economic efficiency;
The institutions of Government are now ill-suitedto the task ahead change is needed;
There is inadequate funding to meet the sectors
needs; The private sector is, incorrectly, seen as the
(easy) answer to this funding problem;
Issues identified by PTSS (2)
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
122/125
122
Issues identified by PTSS (2)
There is no transport policy and strategy that isowned by the agencies of government;
In many areas, there is inadequate understandingof the potential of transport strategy;
Attention focuses on projects, not institutions or
policies which are now more important; There are few prepared good projects that are
implementable surprisingly few;
Many projects are simply unrealistic, orunaffordable.
Key Characteristics of FutureAgenda
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
123/125
123
Agenda
Much reduced government and a much increase role
for the private sector; Sustainability of policy in the medium and long-term;
Transport policy that is responsive to demands for
quality service, driven by increased incomes and therequirements of global competitiveness, improvedefficiency and innovation.
PTSS Recommendations
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
124/125
124
PTSS Recommendations PTSS has underscored the urgent need to
improve existing Government processes in
relation to the transport sector PTSS recognizes that there is little need for
new infrastructure. There is a large road
network, an extensive railway, that is under-used, probably too many ports and manyairports. The primary need therefore is tomaintain, rehabilitate and upgrade theinfrastructure that exists.
-
8/3/2019 Publicus Js Ncpag Transport Issues
125/125