Download - Rcss Rule of Law
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
1/70
yd l if nkyf U yd l ifbul ef;rd l if;(cmOf;,mrf;ok duf;)
c.ifboDbnOfckdef;qkdifjwB;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
2/70
lm];nC ];
Kp];ma}Kp];ma}Kp];ma}Kp];ma}Kp];ma} lWc]:tac];lWc]:tac];lWc]:tac];lWc]:tac];lWc]:tac]; nL:lik]: nL:lik]: nL:lik]: nL:lik]: nL:lik]:
1. kn](1) epL,lSI,eKL:AQn];Aan];KWc],SI,Aw]Ki un];si uc]:t}; 1
2. kn](2)tWn]:kan]Aup].pi Uc],PWc];cm];kUn];mi Uc];si uc]:t}; 12
3. kn](3)Apqt]:tac];Pit]; kQw],lUv]:PU:hap],Tam];kan] 16
4. kn](4)tWn]:Sun],l}:Sun],pQn]kUn]; 20
5. kn](5) tWn]:tqp];tt];JtL; 30
6. kn](6)lWc]:yL:mw];km] 36
7. kn](7)lWc]:etL,lWc]; 40
8. kn](8)lWc]:tum].ti Uw]. KUw];KWc]El:tUw]sC ] 43
9. kn](9)lWc]:Tic];Sim];him];hgm]; 48
10. kn](10) nL:kan]Pa},Aup].pi Uc],kUn];mi Uc]; 51
11. kn](11) pi Uc]kan] hgc]:kan]ma}(1)Ti uc](5) n] C;Ai Uc],/wan]: 59
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
3/70
! kCam];nam]; @
!kan]Aup].pi Uc],@An]wL:n}. tc]:Et,hi Bn];ni uc]:lc] wan]:ni uc]:luk]:etL,Ti uc] mi Uc];ni uc]:mi Uc];nn]. ti un];mI;kan]Aup].pi Uc],PWc];cm];yU,yw]."!Aup].pi Uc],@An]wL:nn]. lUw],Aup].pi Uc],kUn]; Aup].pi Uc],sWm];kUt];ma}eKL:ham]: tap]: wan]:'Ai Uc],'mi Uc];nn].yw]." hi Bn];nu ic]:lc] wan]:ni uc]:luk]:
si uc ]:m i Uc ]; ni uc ]:m i Uc ]; epL;Am],mI; pk];pi Uc ]Aup].pi Uc ],si uc ]wan]:ekL:etSuk].yuc]: Am],kt];yQn] hiBn];ekL:etAm],mUn];Am],Kiun]:yC], siuc]:miUc];ekL: etAm],Kiun]:yC],kt];yQn]eSeP;KQn]ekL:nm]nn].yw]." kWp]:n}El: kan]Aup].pi Uc],An]wL:nn].lm],lWc]:Et.Et." pi Uc]Aup].pi Uc],n}. mI; (4)mQw];"
(1) Aup].pi Uc],sWm]; fic]:Tuc];kw],ek,"(2) Aup].pi Uc],sWm]; pk];pi Uc]si uc]:mi Uc];"(3) Aup].pi Uc],sWm]; eKL:ham]:tap]: Ai Uc],'wan]:"(4) Aup].pi Uc],sWm]; eKL:siSc],"
Aic]ni Uw] pi Uc]Aup].pi Uc], An]mI;w}.El: An] hQt];AWk],mL;n}.
hG ]:l}:lQp]:hQn];hB.eS hQt];Sac]:yU,Sw];sWm];pk];pi Uc]kU:ekL.kWn], wan]:'Ai Uc],'mi Uc];hw]; sc],etsac]: Ki un]:yC ], kt];yQn]yw]."
(yWt]:Si uk];)
hBw]pw]:lUc]
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
4/70
4
kn] (1)epL,lSI, eKL:AQn];Aan]; KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};(PWc];yam];Su ik];)
[1{[1{[1{[1{[1{ eKL:yum],ym]El:hp].Kam],"eKL:yum],ym]El:hp].Kam],"eKL:yum],ym]El:hp].Kam],"eKL:yum],ym]El:hp].Kam],"eKL:yum],ym]El:hp].Kam],"
1. wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};hw];n}. epL;wL:hw];Am],mI;AKCac].AL,nL,tQm]TUn]:El:pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];hc];eKLnn]. tL,sU iw].sat]:'saw];KU iw];An]yU,Sw];nC ];wan]:mU ic]; su ic]:t};hw]; etKu in]:yC ],mC ],Suc] Ku it];PQc],pQc];pU in]:nC ];lUk]:'nC ];km],PL,tu in];etAm],mI;tac];eSAm],kL; sU iw].sat]:'wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};hw]; tu in];etsUm] ha}kC L, nC ];Ek:kac]sum];yip];km]AL,nL, An]Am],JtL;nn].Am],hac].yum],ym]nc],n}"
2. kQp],kp];lUv]:kan]pa};mU ic]; nC ];km],PL,El:Sc] nC ];AL,SYL.El:Sc] nC ];mU ic];man]:'mU ic];t};hw];El:Sc] lqk]:la}:mL;nc],hu iw]ekL:yw]. muk].sum];KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};hw]; etp},sac]:lqk]:la}:Sc] etSu ip],hQt];Sac]:kan]can];
tL,pUt];pW },sU iw].sat]: wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t}; etL,epL;Tu ic]tI:AQn];Aan];nn].yU,yw]."
3. tWn]:tL,Kw]:pL;sW }:Tqm] kan]nC ];muk].sum];kC L,nn]. yic];/sa};Am],lU ik]:sU iw].KU iw];Am],lU ik]: PL,SL,Am],lU ik]: epL;wL:hp].Kam],hn]lInU iw] eKL:yum],ym]El: lk];nm];(6)eKL:su ic] muk].sum];KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];t}; ethp].Kam],
Aw]Kw]:hQt]:Sac]:kan] nC ];muk].sum];yU,yw]."
4. tWn]:tL,pUt];pW },Aw]sU iw].sat]: saw];KU iw]; wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t}; hC ]:epL;mI;AL,nL,pUk];pWc]l}:nn]. muk].sum];KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};hw]; tu in];yum],ym]Aw]lk];nm]; (6) eKL: An]tm];wac];w}.n}.kUv];yU,yw]."
5. muk].sum];KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};n}. hp].Kam],yum],ym]Aw] nm].sC ] hUm]:hWm];
pQn]yC ],El: Aw]la};hUm]:hWm];kn]AWn] hUw]nm];nL: kL:Am],hWt]:Tu ic]Sw]mWk],lgc]:yU ic];Aan];nn].yU,yw]."
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
5/70
5
[2{[2{[2{[2{[2{ TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:"TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:"TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:"TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:"TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:"
tUn]:KU iw];tUn]:kan];Kw]n}. mI;Sc].mI;lk]; sc],sac]:Ku in]:yC ],tUw];tWn];l}:"kUn];n}.ekL: epL;mI;Sc].lk];TWt]:mYat]:lUc] (4) yU ic]:n}. sc],sac]:l}:sam],pUv]:Sun],l}:lWc]:Ku in]:yC ], lWc]:kt];yQn]El: lWc]:Tac],hac]:yw]." TWt]:mYat]:(4)yi Uc]:nn].si uc]
1. sU iw].sat]:"2. wan]:mU ic];"
3. PL,SL,"
4. SL,SnL,"
si Uw].sat]:"si Uw].sat]:"si Uw].sat]:"si Uw].sat]:"si Uw].sat]:"
sU iw].sat]:An]wL:n}. pQn]kUn];mU ic];kU:saw];KU iw]; An]kU it],ku ik];nm].lin]
hin]PLlQw]kn]eS sL.hUm]:KI'lI hUm]:sam],mL; sQm]kWn],nn].yw]."
k.k.k.k.k. sU iw].sat]:nC ];Pqn],lin]su ic]:t};n}. An]pQn]saw];KU iw];t}; mI;hUw]kUn];nm]
lU iw]pU in]: hUw]kUn];nu ic]:pak],n}. mI;hUk];Sip];pqt],ekL. 68% kUn];KU iw];t};n}.
yU,sWm];Tuc].pQc];km].nm]"
K.K.K.K.K. saw];KU iw];plWc]: hWc]. !tAac];@ nC ];mU ic];t};n}. hUw]kUn];nu ic]:pak],mI;sQt];ekL.
7% plWc]:n}.yU,sWm];Sn]lW }km]:nm]" An]yU,mI;nm] pQn]Sn]lW }nm].Sn],
mU ic];t};pWt];hgc], SUc]yU,tI:Suc]tI:kt]; hQt];SUn]nQc]:kin]km]:nm]"
c.c.c.c.c. saw];KU iw];pAUw]; nC ];mU ic];t};n}. hUw]kUn];mI;7% yU,sWm];Sn]lW }km]:nm]nc],kw],"
hQt];kin]SUn]tWc]El:h}:nL; AL,lU; Pk];mI, km]:nm]"
s.s.s.s.s. saw];KU iw];wL. nC ];mU ic];t};n}. hUw]kUn];mI; 5% yU,tac];AWk],KUc]; hQt];kin]kan]
h}:nL;km]:nm]"
S.S.S.S.S. saw];KU iw];Kac] yU,mU ic];t};pWt];hWc], yU,sWm];Sn]lW }nu ic]:Ait];nu ic]:AI:eS
hQt];kin] h}:km]:nm]"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
6/70
6
v.v.v.v.v. saw];KU iw];TnU. yU,mU ic];t};pWt];tUk]; yU,sWm];tI:pac],pQc];km]:nm] hQt];kin]
h}:nL;"
t.t.t.t.t. saw];KU iw];Aac];SL; yU,nC ];nWc] h}a;yL:(Aac];el;) hQt];nL; hQt];SUn]
Pk];kat], emLtin] emLmu iw]; etL;PL:etL;Pqn], hQt];PL.mit]:"
T.T.T.T.T. saw];KU iw];lL;hU, yU,mU ic];t};pWt];AWk],KUc]; yU,sWm];Sn]lW }km]:nm] hQt];h}:
hQt];SUn]kin]"
n.n.n.n.n. saw];KU iw];AL;KL,(ekL:) yU,tac];mU ic];t};pWt];AWk],KUc]; sWm];lqn]lin]law];"
yU,nU iw]Sn]lW }km]:nm] hQt];h}:nL;kin]"p.p.p.p.p. saw];KU iw];kUw];kac]. yU,mU ic];t};pWt];hWc]," hQt];nL; hQt];SUn] lQc].St];El:
kL.Ka}kin]"
P.P.P.P.P. saw];KU iw];ptWc], hWc]. kyac]; yU,pWt];mU ic];pa}; mU ic];t};pWt];san];" hQt];
h}:nL;kin]"
m.m.m.m.m. saw];KU iw];lI.eSL; yU,mU ic];t};pWt];san];km]:PWc]: yU,mU ic];t};pWt];hWc],km]:PWc]:"Am],yU,pQn]muk].yC ],muk].lUc] yU,sWm];Sn]lW } hQt];h}:nL;kin]"
y.y.y.y.y. saw];KU iw];yac];lm]' yac];lqc]' yac];la}; nC ];mU ic];t};n}. mI;pWt];san];
pWt];kac]" sWm];nm].sac] ek;SI; mU ic];SU:sU iw];n}.eS hQt];h}:nL;kin]"
r.r.r.r.r. saw];KU iw];tWc],lU iw]; yU,mU ic];t};pWt];san];km]:nm]" hQt];h}:nL;kin]"
l.l.l.l.l. saw];KU iw];EK, nC ];mU ic];t};yU,sWm],sim]kU:tI:" km].nm] hQt];kan] kL.Ka}El:lQc].St];kin]"
w.w.w.w.w. saw];KU iw];klL;(pL;sQm]ekL,rKL;) yU,nC ];mU ic];t};pWt];hWc]," luk].mU ic];Ain];tI;yL;
mL;yU,nC ];mU ic];t}; mU iw]:pan]Aic];klQt]: hQt];kan]lQc].St];El:h}:nL;kin]"
h. h. h. h. h. saw];KU iw];AWn], An]Am],epL;mI;hUw]kUn];nm] mU in]nc],Aqn],' KmU.' TenL.'
pEl; sU iw];n}.ekL:mI; km]:nm] hQt];h}:nL;kin]"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
7/70
7
saw];KU iw];kUn];mU ic];t}; An]lat]:mL;sU iw];n}. pQn]kUn];mU ic]; sU iw].sat]:
lQw]kn] kU it],ku ik];nm].lin] hin]PL hUm]:kn]mL;pan]Su ip],pan]yw]. pQn]Sc]mL;ekL:
sL.hUm]:KI'lI hUm]:sam],mL;sgm];kn] Aan],hUw] hQc]pIyw]. sc],hWc].wL:pQn]sU iw].sat]:
(Nation)"
wan]:mU ic];"wan]:mU ic];"wan]:mU ic];"wan]:mU ic];"wan]:mU ic];"
mI;sU iw].sat]:yw]. epL;Am],mI;Pqn],lin]wan]:mU ic]; tI:pu ic]:Aic]yU,Sw];ekL:
pQn]tI:pU in]:Am],np].Am],ym] sac]:tQk];yQp],ym]:pUn].pqn]tQk];tQc]kn]El:Pqn],lin]wan]:mU ic];n}nn].ekL: pQn]Sc].lk];TWt]:mYat]:lUc]An]nu ic]: pun]:tL,
kUn];kU:ekL.yw]."
k.k.k.k.k. Pqn],lin]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};n}. mI;ku ik];pu in];lum]:fL.mL;pan]Su ip],pan]" tu in];mI;
Kun]Aup].pU ic],mU ic]; mL;hc];eKL" tu in];mI;Su ik];kqt],EKwan]:mU ic];mL;yU, pan]
Su ip],pan]yw]." Pqn],lin]su ic]:t}; An]Aic];klQt]:'EK,El:T}; Kw]mL;tqp];tt];lqn]lin]pn]mU iw]: 1894 nn]. tac];kCac]:yC ],mn];mI;yU, 62,500
KCa},lk];yU,yw]."
K.K.K.K.K. Pqn],lin]su ic]:t};n}. mI;nm].lIlin]lI tI:Puk],SWm]:yC ],kCac]:El: pun]:tL,
kUn];mU ic];t};hw]; hLhQt];kin]lQc].tWc].nn]. Am],mI;tac];yap],Pu it],kL:hu iw]"
pQn]An]kum],lUm]:pQc];epL;lIyU,yw]." kan]can];Puk],SWm]:nC ];mU ic];t}; sQm]pan]pU,mWn],nn]. sC ].hqc];kUn];'hqc];St];eShQt];mL;" etL,Tu ic]yam];lQw]ekL:
tu ik].l}:sC ].hqc];kUn]; hqc];St];km].pL:nm]" mak],Kw]:tw]:nm].El: KUw];KWc]
AWk],nC ];mU ic];t}; An]su iw]:yC ],n}. Kw]:San]' Kw]:kap],' cL;' TUw],lin]'
TUw],nw]:' mWk],wn];wa},' AL,lU;' Pk];mI,' nQc]:' kL,PI,' tWc]lqn];yL:'
yL:lut],pL,kYI;nI;yU iw];' mak],sWk];' mak],ekL:' mak],kQc]' yL:fin],' mak],mU.'mak].paw].(mak],Aun]) sU iw];n}.yw]."
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
8/70
8
PL,SL,"PL,SL,"PL,SL,"PL,SL,"PL,SL,"
PL,SL,An]wL:n}. pQn]kCam];lat]:'lik]:la};'fic]:Ec:" sU iw].sat]:t};hw];n}.
mI;pu in];ku ik];mU ic]; mU in]pU in]:yU," nC ];mU ic];t};n}. kCam];t};pQn]kCam];kac]" tI:nC ];saw];KU iw];
PC ]mn];nn]. lat]:kCam];sU iw].KU iw];sw]:kw],eS km]:nm]emLlat]:kCam];t};El:
Aw]kCam];t};hC ]:pQn]kCam];Ek:K} hC ]:pWc],kn]nn].yU,yw]."
lik]:An]sC ].yU,nC ];mU ic];t};n}. lik]:t};' lik]:EK,' lik]:man]:' lik]:t};Ku in]'
lik]:plWc]:' lik]:pAUw];' lik]:wL.' lik]:lL;hU,' lik]:Aic];klQt]:sU iw];n}.yw]."
yWn].t};Am],mI; lWc]:Tac],hac]:lWt]:lqw];El: lik]:t};n}. ku ik];pu in];sU iw].KU iw];mL;yU,eStL.ekL: lik]:t};hw];n}. Am],sac]:SWn]Ku in]:pQn]sn]. mU in]tac],mU ic];l}:"
pu in];lik]:t};n}. mI;ku ik];sU iw].KU iw];pan]Su ip],pan]mL;yU,"
fic]:Ec:KWc]t};n}. KUw];nuc]:kUn];sa}; pQn]kUn]KLyaw]; SU iw]:tqk]:puc],
(SU iw]:tqk],pum]) KQn];KQn];hUw]km]:nm]" mI;KUw];nac];yic];kUv]; An]l}:hn]pqk],pU ic]:kn]"
saw];KU iw];PC ]mn]; mI;l}a;kL:wqn]KWc]PC ]mn];yU," la};kL:wqn]KWc]t};n}. sat]:Sqc];'la};kL:nUk].' kL:tUw];' la};KWn].' l}a;lqw];sU iw];n}.yw]."
SL,SnL,"SL,SnL,"SL,SnL,"SL,SnL,"SL,SnL,"
SL,SnL,An]wL:n}. pQn]tI:kUn];pu ic]:Aic] yum]ym]np].Tu iw]" sU iw].sat]:
saw];KU iw];mU ic];t};n}. km].nm]yum],ym] pu ic]:Aic]SL,SnL,put].TJPL;pQn]sw]:"nC ];hUw]kUn];mU ic];t};nu ic]:hUw]pak],n}. yum]ym]put].TJPL;pQn]sw]:85%" lU iw]nn].
yum],ym]ey,SU.El:yum],ym]PI" yum],ym] hin],tU,El:Ait].Slam],sU iw];n}.
ekL:mI;yU," put].TJPL;pQn]sw]:n}. kuc],mun]mn];sw]:Tgt]:mYat]:nL, kCam];Sc],
SWn]mn];sw]:n}. Am],mI;tI:tqk]:ni Uc];"
- SWn] hC ]:kUn];kU:ekL. mI;pk];pU ic]" tu iw];km]pk];pU ic](SI,l)" mI;sC ]mn]:sC ]nim](SmL,Ti)El: mI;nm].kt].(pvL,)"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
9/70
9
- SWn] hC ]:kUn];kU:ekL. tu iw];km]sriySam]pU ic] (pun]:tL,tUw]kw],lI' sU iw].sat]:
lIEl: St];twL,tc];la}lI)"- SWn] hC ]:Aw]lWc]:PWm].SQc]pQc];pak],kn] nC ];kU:KWp],wU ic];kUn];"
PC ]PU:lC ] hQt];sWm]; kYac].km]sWm];l}:ekL: l}:yU,tUw]sC ]Ku in]:yC ], kt];yQn]Tac],hac]:Et.Et." JPL;pQn]sw]:n}. mn];sw]:wUn].hn]Pa},nL:Pa},lc]Et.Et."pu ic]:Aic]JPL;pQn]sw]:n}. mU in] hw];l}:yU,hUm]:KL; hUm]:hU in]; hUm]:huc]; hUm]:h};eSvL;mU iw]:PUn]tUk];lqt],m}:ekL: tu in];Am],kUw]Sc] l}:yU,kt];kt];yQn]yQn]yU,nn].yw]."
3.3.3.3.3. lk];nm]; (6) eKL:"lk];nm]; (6) eKL:"lk];nm]; (6) eKL:"lk];nm]; (6) eKL:"lk];nm]; (6) eKL:"
tL,etkqt],EKpUk];pWc] TWt]:mYat]:SI,yU ic]:kC L,nn]. mI;w}.lk];nm];hUk];eKL:
nc],pL:tC ]:n}.yU,yw]."
1. lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"
2. lWt]:lqw];kWn];eKL"3. tI,mUw],Ker,SI,"
4. pUk];pWc]fwkUn];mU ic];"
5. San]Kt];yL:mw];km]"
6. lWc]:kt];yQn]"
eKL:Sac];lac]; lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"eKL:Sac];lac]; lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"eKL:Sac];lac]; lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"eKL:Sac];lac]; lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"eKL:Sac];lac]; lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"
k.k.k.k.k. lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:An]wL:n}. An]kUn];saw];KU iw];mU ic];t};hw]; muc]:mWc];
lWc]:mak]:mI; lWc]:Ku in]:yC ], lWc]:kt];yQn]yU,nn]. epL;wL:hw];kU:saw];KU iw];
nC ];mU ic];t}; Am],PWm].kn]su ic] ] lWc]:muc]:mWc];lUc]Sam]pU ic]nn]. Am],Pqw]nC ];AUk];
hUw]sC ] hw];El: Am],Tu ic]yU ic];ma}kt];yQn]l}:" epL;hw];KL:KC ]:l}: eKL:muc]:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
10/70
10
mWc];lUc]Sam]pU ic]nn]. hw];KL:lUw],Aw]tUw] hQt]; SUp];wL: sC ]kYam], tc];Sam]pU ic]
eS lat]:Sc] hQt];Sc] wUn].Sc]ekL: hC ]:yum],ym]np].Tu iw]TWt]:mYat]:
4 yU ic]:' hC ]:hk].hWm]lWc]:PWm].hUm]: pun]:tL,etKWt],lU it]:kn] pUk];pWc]l}:Ku in];
lWc]:Ku in]:yC ], PwkUn];mU ic];t};hw]; nn].yw]."
K.K.K.K.K. nC ];lum]:fL.n}. mU ic];lC ]ekL: pU in]:hk].TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]: KWc]PC ]mn];kU:mU ic];"
yWn].pU iw]:PWm].kn]El: TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]:KWc]pU in]:ekL: Ku i in]:yC ],mC ],Suc]
nn].yw]."
c.c.c.c.c. sU iw].sat]:saw];KU iw];mU ic];t};hw];KL:ekL: mI;TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]:yU,El:TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]:KWc] hw];n}. Suk].yuc]:lU it],m}: lUm].sUm]yU,nC ];mu iw];
man]:PU:KCak]:mU ic];" epL;hw];KL: Am],KWt],lU it]:PWm].hUm]:kn]su ic] Am],sac]:
pUk];luk].Ku in];TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]:hw];eSAm],kL; TWt]:mYat]: 4 yU ic]:hw];
n}.ekL: sac]:etlU.ha}lUm].sUm]Am],hac]." kWp]:n}El: lk];nm];eKL:Tinu ic]:
n}. yU ic];ma}tL,TWt]:mYat]:4yU ic]:hw]; Ku in]:yC ],hU iw]:hU ic];nn].yw]." epL;wL: hw];kU:saw];KU iw]; KWt],lU it]:PWm].hUm]:kn]su ic] hw];etEk:lit]:l}: pYSnL,
mU ic];t};nc],n} -
1. hw];etpUk];pWc]l}: lWc]:Sun],l}:tqp];tt];hc];eKL"
2. hw];KC ]:hQt];Ku in]; mU ic];hUm]:tum]sqt]:sac], n}ekL:l}:"
3. Sc]wL:pUk];tc]: lWc]:Aup].pU ic],tI,mUw],Ker,SI, Sun],l}:Sun]pQn]lWc]:Tac],hac]:pQc];pU in]:nC ];km],PL, n}ekL:l}:"
4. hw];KC ]:pUk];pWc]pn] fwkUn];mU ic];hw]; hC ]:Ku in]:yC ],mak]:mI; n}ekL:l}:"
5. hw];KC ]:hC ]:yL:fin],nC ];Pqn],lin]su ic]:t}; mWt],ha}TUv]:hak]:mn];ekL:l}:"6. KC ]:hC ]:su ic]:t};kt];yQn] sW }:hC ]:lum]:fL.kt];yQn] n}ekL:hQt];l}:"
s.s.s.s.s. lWc]:PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:hw];An]wL:n}. lat]:ca}: hQt];yap]," kWp]:n}El:lWc]:PWm].hUm]: An]wL:n}. lUw],PWm].kn] hQt]; lUw],PWm].kn]sWm]; nc],kan]
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
11/70
11
Pa},tC ]:sU iw];n}. -
1. PWm].kn] Ek:lit]:pYSnL,kU:lWc]:lWc]:"
2. PWm].kn] sWm];pk];pU ic]ma}mI:An]lQw]kn]"
3. PWm].kn] hLcu in];mL;SC ],TUc]lQw]kn]"
4. PWm].kn] tu ik];PU:KQn]KCak]:mU ic];"
5. PWm].kn] tu it].ma}mI:Aup].pU ic],PWc];cm];su ic]:mU ic];"6. PWm].kn] hk].kn] sW }:kn] mUn].Em;kn] pUk];pWc]kn] tL,hC ]:kUn]; hQt];kan] hw]; hC ]:epL;Ku in]:yC ],mI;nm].kt].nn].yw]."
4.4.4.4.4. epL,lSI, nU iw]kan]PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"epL,lSI, nU iw]kan]PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"epL,lSI, nU iw]kan]PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"epL,lSI, nU iw]kan]PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"epL,lSI, nU iw]kan]PWm].hUm]:sU iw].sat]:"
1. PWm].hUm]:kn]San]Kt]; !man]:@ An]pQn]PU:KCak]:mU ic];"
2. PWm].hUm]:kn]San]Kt]; PU:hk];lc]El: yL.lU.St].sL,wan]:mU ic];"3. PWm].hUm]:kn] Kt];sC ]SUn];tum] saw];KU iw];nC ];mU ic];su ic]:t}; hC ]:l}:PWm].
SQc]pQc];pak],kn]"
5.5.5.5.5. epL,lSI, pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, pUk];pWc]wan]:mU ic];su ic]:t};"1. pUk];pWc] hC ]:kUn];su ic]:t}; PWm].SQc]pQc];pak],kn] hC ]:sac]:hUm]:kn] Kt];sC ]
Aw]Ku in]; Pqn],lin]su ic]:t};"
2. pUk];pWc] hC ]:hU.pWc],lWc]: Pqn]lin]su ic]:t}; pQn]Pqn],lin]kUn];mU ic];su ic]:t};kU:ekL."
3. wa};eSPqn],lin]su ic]:t};pUt];pW },yw]. etpUk];pWc]pQn]mL; !su ic]:mU ic];
tI,mUw],Ker,SI,@An]mI;Sun],l}: Tac],hac]:PQc],pQc];kn]"
6.6.6.6.6. epL,lSI, saw];KU iw];sL,tikUn];ku ik];mU ic];"epL,lSI, saw];KU iw];sL,tikUn];ku ik];mU ic];"epL,lSI, saw];KU iw];sL,tikUn];ku ik];mU ic];"epL,lSI, saw];KU iw];sL,tikUn];ku ik];mU ic];"epL,lSI, saw];KU iw];sL,tikUn];ku ik];mU ic];"1. kU:saw];KU iw]; mI;lWc]:PQc],pQc];kn]"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
12/70
12
2. kU:saw];KU iw]; mI;lWc]:Sun],l}:tI,mUw],Ker,SI,mU in]kn]"3. kU:saw];KU iw]; mI;lWc]:KWn]:lU it]:PWm].hUm]:kn]"4. kU:saw];KU iw]; mI;lWc]:Tac],hac]: Tic];Sim];' yuk].yWc]:' sC ].tu iw];'
fic]:Tuc];PC ]mn];"
7.7.7.7.7. epL,lSI, nU iw]PU:KQn]"epL,lSI, nU iw]PU:KQn]"epL,lSI, nU iw]PU:KQn]"epL,lSI, nU iw]PU:KQn]"epL,lSI, nU iw]PU:KQn]"1. PU:yip];km]lWk];pU ic]KCak]:mU ic];"2. PU:hk];lc]El: yL.lU.St].sL, nU iw]sU iw].sat]:wan]:mU ic];"
3. PU:kit],KCac]yL.kw]; SQn]:tac];nL:kan] sU iw].sat]:wan]:mU ic];"
8.8.8.8.8. epL,lSI, ni Uw]AUv];lI"epL,lSI, ni Uw]AUv];lI"epL,lSI, ni Uw]AUv];lI"epL,lSI, ni Uw]AUv];lI"epL,lSI, ni Uw]AUv];lI"
1. PU:hn]lIkm].sW }: SQn]:tac];nL:kan] tL,sU iw].sat]:wan]:mU ic]; hC ]:pUt];pW },
lWt]:lqw]; Tac],hac]:"
2. PU:mk];mn]: PU:KQn]An]lQw]kn]tc];RCSS
"
9.9.9.9.9. epL,lSI, !lik]:la};@ su ic]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, !lik]:la};@ su ic]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, !lik]:la};@ su ic]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, !lik]:la};@ su ic]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, !lik]:la};@ su ic]:mU ic];"
1. !lik]:t};@ pQn]lik]:An]etyip];tu iw]; lum];'hUc];hQn]; mU ic];su ic]:t};
tc];mU ic];"
2. lik]:kU:saw];KU iw];nn]. mI;Sun],Tic];Sim];' yuk].yWc]:' sC ].tu iw];' hQn];SWn]l}:"
3. lik]:la}; kCam];lat]: kU:saw];KU iw];mU ic];su ic]:t};nn]. mI;Sun],sC ].tu iw];sWm];
lik]:'kCam];lat]: t};'Aic];klQt]: tI:lum];nC ];nL:tI:Kw]yU,Sw];w}.
nC ];mU ic];su ic]:t};"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
13/70
13
10.10.10.10.10. epL,lSI, yL:mw];km]"epL,lSI, yL:mw];km]"epL,lSI, yL:mw];km]"epL,lSI, yL:mw];km]"epL,lSI, yL:mw];km]"
pYt].SnL,yL:mw];km] l}:yC ],kCac]:mL; nC ];su ic]:t};n}. yWn].wL: ....
1. lWk];pU ic]wL,tman]:KCak]:mU ic]; yL.lU.pqt]:kan] hLlQc].tWc]. kUn];mU ic];
su ic]:t};"2. lWk];pU ic]wL,tman]:KCak]:mU ic]; KC ]:pQn]!saw];KU iw];lUc]@eS KI,nQk];tQk];tQc]
AUm]Au in] hG ]:kUn];mU ic];su ic]:t};epL;ha}la}"
3. lWk];pU ic]wL,tman]:KCak]:mU ic]; Aw]pQn]KU ic]:mu iw];kan]mU ic];eS Pqn] hQt];hC ]:
yL:mw];km] Su ip],EP:tU in];yu in];yaw];w}." yWn].sU iw];nn].eSEl:
!KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};@ mI;epL,lSI, kQw],lUv]:yL:mw];km]w}. ....
(1) Ek:lit]:kan]mU ic]; hC ]:kUn];mU ic];El:wan]:mU ic]; kt];yQn]lWt]:KQn]"
(2) pn]tac];hU.hn]sU;kUn];mU ic]; hC ]:hU.lWc]:pYt].SnL, yL:mw];km]
nC ];lum]:fL."
(3) pUk];pWc]fwkUn];mU ic];nc], -
k. hC ]:l}:mI;kan] hLlQc].tWc].lIlI"
K. hC ]:mI;!tUn]:An]mL;Puk],tqn];tac]yL:@pn]"
c. hC ]:mI;SQn]:tL:Sa}tac]; etL.SUc],kL.Ka}lIlI"
s. hC ]:mI;!lWk];kat],kL.Ka}@ tL,kun],kL.tac];Ka} An]
Am],su iw]:yL:mw]:km]"
(4) !KWc],SI,Aw]Ku in];su ic]:t};@ hUm]:hWm];lum]:fL.eS etPQw]:mUv].
yL:mw];km]kC L,"
11.11.11.11.11. epL,lSI, kan]nWk]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, kan]nWk]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, kan]nWk]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, kan]nWk]:mU ic];"epL,lSI, kan]nWk]:mU ic];"
1. AL,nL,su ic]:mU ic]; PQc],pQc];kn]"2. mI;lWc]: Tac],hac]: lWt]:lqw]; (Freedom)"
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
14/70
14
3. Sun],l}:Sun],pQn] PQc],pQc];kn]"
4. pin],pa}, pu ic]:Aic] sW }:Tqm]kn]"
5. yU,hUm]:kn] kt];yQn] SU iw];SL,"
12.12.12.12.12. epL,lSI, kUn];tac],mU ic]; mL;pu ic]:Aic],nC ];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, kUn];tac],mU ic]; mL;pu ic]:Aic],nC ];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, kUn];tac],mU ic]; mL;pu ic]:Aic],nC ];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, kUn];tac],mU ic]; mL;pu ic]:Aic],nC ];su ic]:t};"epL,lSI, kUn];tac],mU ic]; mL;pu ic]:Aic],nC ];su ic]:t};"1. Sc]sU iw].wL: Am],tum].tU iw].SQn]:tac]; TWt]:mYat]: (4) yU ic]:El:
lk];nm]; (6) eKL:n}su ic] sWm];nc],kac]sC ]PC ]mn];mI;nn]. hp].pQn]kUn];Tc]yU,nC ];su ic]:t};l}: (hp].pQn]kUn];nWk]:mU ic];An]l}:Sun], pn]
yU,Tc]Sw];w}.nC ];su ic]:t};)"2. kUn];nWk]:mU ic];sU iw];sW }:Tqm] kqt],EKtu ik];etL;Aw] mU ic];kWn];eKLsu ic]:t};
nn].ekL: nc],An]kac]sC ]PC ]mn];mI;nn]. hp].pQn]kUn];mU ic];su ic]:t};sUw]:Kaw]; Am],nn] kUn];nWk]:mU ic];An]l}:Sun],pn]yU,Sw];nC ];su ic]:t};"
wa};l}:mU ic];kgn];eKLyw]. etmI;Sun],!kU:saw];KU iw]; mI;lWc]:Sun],l}:
tI,mUw],Ker,SI,mU in]kn]@ nc],pU in]:"
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
15/70
15
kn] (2)tWn]:kan]Aup].pi Uc],PWc];cm];kUn];mi Uc];si uc]:t};(PWc];yam];Si uk];)
1.1.1.1.1. nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:El; sunr,hqdr:s/cr; pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,>nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:El; sunr,hqdr:s/cr; pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,>nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:El; sunr,hqdr:s/cr; pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,>nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:El; sunr,hqdr:s/cr; pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,>nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:El; sunr,hqdr:s/cr; pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) edlo;hbr xawrekv;jI xscr, hUwr;bwr;lUcrRCSS kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:ji ucr;
do:es hqdr:s/cr;g/nrc/nr:gfv,>(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) mI:sunr,jiscr, pU;h/br,g/nrnT:Wcr;g/nrjwr;gwr,nnr xgmr:sJwr;
eshqdr:s/cr; g/nrc/nr:gfv,>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) ebv:lo;ekv;dUgr:lUcr:lo;jTgnrdcr: dI;hUwrbwr;lUcr RCSS ywr.jJcr mI:sunr,dv,dJdr xjnrpQnrg/nr bgr:bU icrlgr:m/o Wcr;g/nrdUwr
gwr,lo;yU,>(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) edlo;aznrhUwr pQnrAjdr:Atdr:AEm: gumr:ticr:g/nrc/nr:nT:
Wcr;g/nr anrjwr;gwr,awrbunr;pznr:nnr xwo xyU,dv,es,>
(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) gqwr,lUYr;g/nrc/nr:kJgr xkgr x jmrbqnrmI:mv:nnr x edlo;l/o:c/nr:d/cr,tJcrhUwrbwr;lUcr RCSS kJdr:kJdr:jmrjmr>(6)(6)(6)(6)(6) gqwr,gbr:lUYr;nv;g/nr anrjwr;gwr,awrbunr;pznr:wo xnnr x mI:
sunr,bnrd/cr:hnrtJcr dI;hUwrbwr;lUcr RCSS lo;>(7)(7)(7)(7)(7) ebv:lo;ekv;scr,dI;hUwrbwr;lUcr R.C.S.S ywr xnojJcr dznr;dv,tQmrA
tznrAk/o xnv;dI;Abnrd/mr,Aamr,nnr yugr xyzcr;pU;h/br,g/nr nT:
Wcr;g/nrgmr:sJwr;lo;>
2.2.2.2.2. pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nr bzgr x A w/nr; A aU icr, >pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nr bzgr x A w/nr; A aU icr, >pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nr bzgr x A w/nr; A aU icr, >pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nr bzgr x A w/nr; A aU icr, >pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nr bzgr x A w/nr; A aU icr, >(1) edlo;mI:lzcr;aznrhUwrhqdr:s/cr; tdr:s/crnU iwrnv;g/nr anr
jwr;gwr, awrbunr;pznr:wo xnnr x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) dznr;dv,edgqbr:lo;s/om/ogUnr: lcrhU inr:gUnr: jv.gfv,jU iwr:no x edlo;awrbunr;pznr: hqdr:s/cr;gfv,>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
16/70
16
3.3.3.3.3. bU icrkzdr,pzdr; aubr x bU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr:>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; aubr x bU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr:>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; aubr x bU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr:>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; aubr x bU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr:>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; aubr x bU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr:>bU icrkzdr,pzdr;Wcr;g/nraubr xbU icr,gU;jnr xjnr x>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) bzgr x A w/nr;<
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) aU icr,<
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) cwr;cunr: hzcr;g/nraubr.bU icr,nT:mU icr:>
ekv;s /cr:l /cr:>ekv;s /cr:l /cr:>ekv;s /cr:l /cr:>ekv;s /cr:l /cr:>ekv;s /cr:l /cr:>
aicrnU iwrcwr:l/o:esanranr ebv:pU;gznr:Wcr;g/nramr,h/br,t/mr:lo;
nv;g/nrjJcr gQmrpU;gznr:Wcr;g/nredlo;awrbunr;pznr: sJbr,h/br,t/mr:g/nrgfv, ncr,hJwrg/nrc/nr:edamr,lo;yUbr;yzmr:>
Wcr;g/nr aubr xbU icr,nf r:mU icr:amr,nnrcwr;cunr:
aU icr,
mU,w/nr;
jumr:n/cr:yicr: jumr:pU;j/o:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
17/70
17
4.4.4.4.4. ekv;sbr:lQcr: bU icrkzdr,pzdr;>ekv;sbr:lQcr: bU icrkzdr,pzdr;>ekv;sbr:lQcr: bU icrkzdr,pzdr;>ekv;sbr:lQcr: bU icrkzdr,pzdr;>ekv;sbr:lQcr: bU icrkzdr,pzdr;>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) nJcr;w/nr; edlo;mI: (10) lcrhU inr:kJnr;nU iwr>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) nJcr;aU icr, edlo;mI: (5) w/nr; tJcr (10) w/nr;>(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) p/o,aubr xbU icr,cwr;jJcr;
5.5.5.5.5. bU icrkzdr,pzdr;mU,w/nr;>bUicrkzdr,pzdr;mU,w/nr;>bU icrkzdr,pzdr;mU,w/nr;>bUicrkzdr,pzdr;mU,w/nr;>bUicrkzdr,pzdr;mU,w/nr;>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) jumr:bzcrg/nrmU,w/nr;>g. hUwrbwr;w/nr; (1) egv.>k. gQmrhUwrbwr;w/nr; (1) egv.>c. pU;nmr:nT: (1) egv.>
6.6.6.6.6. bgr:biUcr>bgr:bi Ucr>bgr:biUcr>bgr:bi Ucr>bgr:bi Ucr>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) p/o,aubr xbU icr,pzcr:cmr:w/nr; edlo;mI:b/crgumr< nJcr;lU inrnJcr;bzgr; nT:
b/crgumrnnr x
----- edlo;bnrgf/mr:hU.gnr
----- aubr,gumrcUbr xcignr
----- scr,sznrgnr>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;sJgr:gJdr:ebv:mI:mv:nnr x edlo;tdr:s/cr dUYr:wT
gJdr:ebv: scrwv;amr,mI:wTakf/cr xjJcr edlo;d/cr,l/dr; bzcr,lQcr:
bnr pU;mI:bunr;pznr: H;kJdr:dnr:>(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) edlo;mI: pQnr A jdr: A tdr: A Em: gqwr,lUYr;nT:nv;g/nr
El; nT:w/nr;AnT:nv:>
7.7.7.7.7. la};li Uk]:hL PU:AWn] hBw] wan]:/Ai Uc],"la};li Uk]:hL PU:AWn] hBw] wan]:/Ai Uc],"la};li Uk]:hL PU:AWn] hBw] wan]:/Ai Uc],"la};li Uk]:hL PU:AWn] hBw] wan]:/Ai Uc],"la};li Uk]:hL PU:AWn] hBw] wan]:/Ai Uc],"dznr;dv,edaznrhUwr aubr xbU icr,pzcr:cmr:gfv,nU iwrgUnr:mU icr: H;ebv:mI:d/cr:kJnr;scr xkJnr;sucrkJdr:bU inr;lo;El; H;ebv:lo;gdr:yqnrsU iwr:sv,nnr x
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
18/70
18
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) l/o:lU igr;awr dI;gUnr:mU icr: H;bqnrpU;nmr:>
g. edlo;bqnregv. mI:d/cr:hU.El; jJwr;sqcrlI>
k. edlo;bqnregv. gUnr:w/nr;c. edlo;bqnregv. mI:eav:jv, l/dr;lo;ko;j/cr;>j. edlo;bqnregv. mI:agL/cr xd/cr:gmrlI>s. edamr,lo;bqnrgUnr: gqwrkzcr x< jT.dJwr: yv;mwr:gmr>Y. edamr,lo;jU:c/o;es lU igr;>
d. edlo;wUnr xsznr,lIlIes lU igr;hvH;tugr,mQnr;jzmr: lzcr;l/o:aznrhUwr>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) av,yupU;nmr: gUnr:mU icr:>
g. bU,g/cr.w/nr; (1)bIlU igr; 1bzgr; (edlo;bqnrgUnr:gU idr,gJgr:mU icr:)>
k. bU,hqcraU icr, (2)bI lU igr; 1bzgr; (edlo;bqnrgUnr:gU idr,gJgr:mU icr:)>
8.8.8.8.8. cwr;cunr: hzcr;g/nraubr.bU icr,nT:mU icr:>dznr;dv,aubr.bU icr,pzcr:cmr:El; gumr:ticr:aznrhUwrgfv,nU iwr gUnr:mU icr:nnr x
bqnrbunr;pznr: hzcr;g/nraubrxbUicr,nT:miUcr: lUwr,lo;pQnrg/nr jdr:g/nrEnxnmr:lUcr:bnrgU;lzcr;lzcr; ncr,hu iwrnf r:gUnr:mU icr: ebv:edhU.bzcr, kwr;jf reshqdr:s/cr;gfv,jzmr:lo;nnr xywr x> jzmr:ncr, bU icraubr xbU icr,nT:gUnr:mU icr: jU iwr:mI:wo xgwr,gwr, anrtugr,mQnr;jzmr: gv,led,snnr xegv; tugr,lIlo;lqbr;hqnr:hU.tuicres awrmv:bqnrd/cr:hU.bunr;dv, kwr;bv:nfr:pQnrg/nrEl;bgr:bUicrhwr:lTywr x> gzbr;nnrpU;mI:bunr;pznr: p/o,aubr xbU icr,nT:mU icr:hwr: gU:jnr xjnr xno xtugr,lo;gbr:s/nrdcr: pU;mI:bunr;pznr: nT:gUnr:mU icr:kwres hqdr:s/cr;g/nrc/nr:EdxEdxywr x>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
19/70
19
kn] (3)
Apqt]:tac];Pit]; kQw],lUv]:PU:hap],Tam];kan]
pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nranrwv;no x bqnrpU;awrbunr;pznr:h/br,t/mr:g/nrc/nr:gU;Wcr;g/nraigr,bv:gUnr:sJgr: pU;mI:jnr x nT:dbr xsJgr:dcr:sqcr;kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr xpU;kwr;bv:nT:jumr: aubr xbU icr,gU;jnr xjnr x pU;kwr;bv:nT: jumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:gU;jnr xjnrx bU,Eg, scrwv;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrnnr x dcr;jT amr,sJwr;yUwr:es
hqdr:s/cr;essmr,esbU icrEl;scr gUnr:anramr,jT;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrnnr xbUnr xbQnrbgr:bU icresywr x dumr xdU iwr xnv;g/nrpU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr esanranrjJcredlo;tugr,awraey: bnrabQdr;d/mr, jzmr:ncr,bv;dT;no xyU,ywr x>
1.1.1.1.1. pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresegv.egv.nnr x lU iwrescJnr:jT.j/o,anrdmr:
w/cr:wo x jzmr:ncr,bgr:bU icrlgr:m/onnr x edamr,lo;hbr xawrkUwr:kzcrcJnr:dzcr:scr
dI;pTlv:lv:> scrwv;hbrxawrywrxnojJcr bzcr,wv;ginrsU:ginrl/br;noEl;
edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:edv,tJcr (3)bI amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:
amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:(2)mqwr:yU,ywr.>
2.2.2.2.2. pU;mI:bunr;pznr:esegv.egv.nnr x awrcJnr:sU:l/br;es dJwr:
av,nv,eav:jv, hUmr,cmr:nU iwrpU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,g/nrkYam];
bv:kcrkzgr; edv,tJcr(3) bI amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr: amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:(2)mqwr:yU,ywr x>
3.3.3.3.3. scrwv;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresegv.egv.nnrx amr,bnrgv;knrscr
es hbr xawrkUwr:kzcranrtU igr;gv;dI;egv.anr hwr:lo;hqdr:s/cr;g/nrc/nr:bnr
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
20/70
20
esbU icrbU icrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;amr,bv:g/nrgL/mr:edv,tJcr(2)bI amr,nnr
d/mr,cJnr: amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:(2)mqwr:yU,ywr x>
4.4.4.4.4. pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrnnr x s/nrkdr:bgr:bU icrlgr:m/oes aqnr:a/nr:
hqdr:s/cr;eslzcr;lzcr; H;dumr xdU iwrxesegv.egv.jJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;
amr,bv:g/nrgL/mr: tJcr (1) bIyU,ywr x>
5.5.5.5.5. pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresegv.egv.nnr x hqdr:s/cr;g/nrm/gr;mI:sunr,dUwranr amr,tugr,mQnr;gnrdcr:bgr:bU icrlgr:m/onojJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;
amr,bv:g/nrgL/mr: edv,tJcr (2) bIyU,ywr x>
6.6.6.6.6. scrwv;esegv.egv. bzmrdUwres hqdr:s/cr;mU inrncr,pU;h/br,t/mr:
g/nrnojJcr edlo;k/mr, d/mr,kzgr;bv:g/nrgL/mr: edv,tJcr (1)bI amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr: amr,nnr d/mr,dcr: (2)mqwr:yU,ywr x>
7.7.7.7.7. scrwv;esegv.egv. aqnr:a/nr:bQdr xlQnres jT.dJwr:nucr;wokUwr:
nucr; kU icr;m/opU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrnojJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr; amr,bv:g/nrgL/mr:
(3)lU inr< amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:(100,000)bLv: amr,nnr d/mr,dcr: (2)mqwr: yU,ywr x>
8.8.8.8.8. pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nrnnr x jzmr:ncr,ekv;jI xscr,dI;nU iwr r (sUbr:gf/mr:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
21/70
21
9.9.9.9.9. ekv;jI xscr,dI;nU iwr (sUbr:gf/mr:< s/olUmr:< ligr;l/o:) bnrmv:jU:dI;jwr;gwr,El;scr bnrtJcresegv.egv.El;scr anrpU;mI:bunr;pznr:awrmv:sUcr,yJnr; mzgr,l/dr;bnrnnr x ncr,hJwrebv:edamr,j/cr;hqdr:s/cr;g/nr
can];tJcrdI;nnr x jT.l/o:esanranr h/mr;d/br;jJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;lzdr;g/nrgL/mr:tJcr (1) lUinr amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:tJcr(100,000)bLv:amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:(2) mqwr:yU,ywr x>
10.10.10.10.10. jzmr:ncr,ekv;jI xscr,dI;nU iwr (sUbr:gf/mr:< s/olUmr:< ligr;l/o:)scr,
Wcr xmv:dI;jwr;gwr,esywrx amr,hqdr:s/cr;jzmr: amr,nnrcU icr xEw;dv,edgfv,jU: dI;nU iwr anrscr,Wcr xmv:nnr xjJcr edlo;tugr,Yv:d/mr,kzgr;lzdr;g/nrgL/mr: (5) lU inr amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:(500,000)bLv:amr, nnr dcr:(2) mqwr:yU,ywr x>
11.11.11.11.11. jzmr:ncr,bunr;pznr:mI:mv:nnr xes pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr anrmI:bunr;
pznr:nnr x lUwr,lo;l/o:c/nr:dI;nU iwr pJnrligr;l/o:El;scr lUwr,lo;a/br;mzbr;bnrkU icr;m/oesanranrEl;scr kUwr:kzcresanranrEl;scr ebv:amr,yJnr;amr,mzbr;bnrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;lzdr; g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(5)lU inr amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:tJcr(500,000)bLv: yU,ywr x>
12.12.12.12.12. pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr egv.anrhbr xawrbunr;pznr: dznr;dv,dU icr,lat]:amr,nnr bnrk/wr,tJcrdI;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr egv.anrgqwr,kzcr;jzmr:nv;g/nrnnrxes amr,hqdr:jzmr:nojJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr; lzdr;g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(1)lU inr amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:(100,000)bLv:yU,ywr x>
13.13.13.13.13. yU,dI;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr anrawrbunr;pznr: dv,edbzcr,k/wr,bnr
pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresegv.egv.nnr x hU.bzcr,wv;k/wr,nnr xamr,m/nr,mQnr; amr,
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
22/70
22
nnryumr,ymrwv; bqnrk/wr,gQgr:p/cr:yU,esdv.egv; p/mr:hqdr:bqnrk/wr,jJwr;jT;
m/nr,mQnr;es sUcr,bnrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;lzdr;g/nrgL/mr: tJcr(1)bI
amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:tJcr(1,000,000)bLv: amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:(2)mqwr:yU,ywr x>
14.14.14.14.14. pU;lTpTesamr,wv; pzcr:y/mr:mU iwr;pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nr dJgr xhqdr:Sac]:g/nrc/nr:yU,nnr x awrl/o:esanranresmv:h/mr;d/br;jJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr; lzdr;g/nrgL/mr: edv,tJcr (3)lU inr amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr: (300,000)bLv: yU,ywr x>
15.15.15.15.15. pU;mI:bunr;pznr:dv,edjz o;tQmrg/nrc/nr: bnrpU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresywr x amr,jz o;tQmr amr, Wmr:mJwr:hqdr:s/cr;jzmr:jJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;lzdr;g/nrgL/mr:edv,tJcr (1)lU inr amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:tJcr (100,000)bLv:yU,ywr x>
16.16.16.16.16. mi Uwr;pzcr:y/mr:pU;h/br,t/mr:g/nresegv.egv. hqdr:s/cr;g/nrc/nr:jzmr:ncr,bgr:bU icrmI:mv:yU,nnr x mv:lzgr,cJdr;wv; edhqdr:H;dumr xdU iwr xdUwrkicr:jqbr:sQbr, essmr,esbU icrwv;nojJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr; bv:g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(2)bI amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:(2,000,000)amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:(2)mqwr:yU,ywr x>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
23/70
23
kn] (4)
tWn]:Sun],l}:Sun],pQn]kUn]; (Human Rights)
1.1.1.1.1. gqwr,lUYr;lzcr; sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:no x R.C.S.S hwr: edawr
jzmr:ncr, bgr:bU icrjumr:gmr,pv,(U.N)dQbr:ddr:wo x mU inrncr,Enbv;dT;no.
pqnr;pqnr;yU,ywr x>
ebv:gUidr,bqnrgUnr:mv:nJcr;egv.no x lUwr,lo;yU,jzmr:elv:gbv,lCdv:lUcrs/mrbU icr anrbqnrlzcr;lzdr;lQwr:(Liberty)lzcr;pqcr,bqcr:(Equality)El; lzcr;mI:bU icrCdv:m/nr,mQnr;(Fraterity)yU,ywr x> dv,edH; yU,lo;jzmr:elv:gbv,lCdv:lUcrs/mrbUicrnoxjmrx lUwr,lo;mI:sunr,lo;gUnr:(HumanRights)dqmrtUnr;> nT:gv;sunr,lo;gUnr:no xjmr x hUwrhubr;mnr:mI:wo xs/mrbU icr>
anrbqnrsunr,lo;gUnr:gJgr:mU icr:(Civil Rights) dznr;dv,yU,swr:
H;as/gr;av,yU.mnr;gJmr:gfv,El; lzcr;lzdr;lQwr:hwr:nnr x ncr,hJwryU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr; amr,yU,jzmr:bgr:bU icrCdv:esyv.gwr:lo;nnrx edlo;gQdr,EkbnryU,> bzcr,wv; H;lo;yU,swr:ginrs/cr;t/cr,h/cr; lzcr;hUmr,lUmr;dUwrgwr,lzcr;lzdr;lQwr:swr:ekvhcr:gUYr: lzcr;t/cr,h/cr;gfv,mv:bo lzcr;mI:sunr,dQbr:ddr:lo; gqwr,lUYr;bU icrCdv: edlo;mI:lzcr;eh.gcr;bnr anrlUcrbzcrjJcr;
pqwr;mUYr x j/wr:kU iwr: jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x>tQcr;bU icrnJcr;jmr x lUwr,mI:sunr,lo;gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;b/o:mU icr:(PoliticalRights) anrbqnrsunr,gUnr:gJgr:mU icr:nJcr;egv.no x mI:sunr,kwr;bv:hqdr:s/cr;h/cr;bzcrlo;g/nrc/nr: anrlUcrbzcrjJcr;h/br,gJdr xwo xyU,nnr x> mU inrncr, mI:sunr,bnrlo;kQbr:g/crjT< sunr,k/mr,lU igr;dcr;< sunr,hU.hnrhqdr:s/cr;jzmr:lzcr;lUcrbzcrjJcr;dmr:w/cr: hqdr:s/cr;ebv,lsI,< sunr,yU,swr:gfv,mv:lzdr;lQwr:<
lzcr;t/cr,h/cr;l/dr;jv< dQmr;azgr,ligr;l/o:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
24/70
24
tQcr;anrnJcr;jmrx dznr;dv,FwgUnr:hwr:yU,swr:ginrs/cr;gfv,lo;jnrxsucrjzmr:jUiwr:anrbqnr sunr,lo;b/o:m/gr;mI: bU icrgUnr:El;Ficr;Ec;(Economic Social and Cultural Rights)nnr xlIc/mr: mU inrncr, mI:lzcr;
t/cr,h/cr; hqdr:g/nrm/gr;mI:dUwrgwr, sunr,hqnr:hvbicr,Yv, sunr,lo;yUdr:yv eRv:gv, dznr;dv,yU,lIdUwrgwr, sunr,hqdr:s/cr;g/nrc/nr:lqcr xdzcr xt/cr,h/cr;lzcr;t/cr,h/cr;ticr:simr:Ep;dJnr: gf/mr:l/dr; ligr;l/o: Ficr;tucr: pv,sv,sv,snv,dUwrgwr,lo; mI:lzcr;hUmr,lUmr;nU iwraugr xjv,kUwr:kzcr cJnr:dzcr: jwr;gwr,dqmrtUnr; jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x>
yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr;El;scr gUnr:egv.lTegv.nnr xEl;scr ebv:pidr:bU icr;sunr,lo;gUnr:lUnr xlU iwrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/cr:awraey: dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:gU;mUicr:mUicr:(International Court of Justic. ICJ)amr,nnrdI;lumr: Cdv:gU;mU icr:mU icr: gqwr,lUYr,gUnr:bUnr xbQnrm/omI; (International CriminalCourt. ICC)yU,ywrx> lzcr;pidr:bU icr;sunr,lo;gUnr: lUnrxlUnrxlUiwrlU iwranrwv;nnr x mU inrncr,awrd/ogUnr:bqnrpucrbqnrjumr: lzcr;hqdr:anrj/cr;
bqnrep:edv, jumr:j/wr:kU iwr:dcr:jumr:El; lzcr;pidr:bU icr;bgr:bU icr gqwr,lUYr;bz o:sJgr:(Rv,jwudr;sJgr:) (War Crime) jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x>
2.2.2.2.2. sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:mUicr:>sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:mUicr:>sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:mUicr:>sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:mUicr:>sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrgUnr:mU icr:>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) m/omI;sunr,lo;sunr,bqnr anrwv;no x amr,lU igr; yicr:j/o:< jU iwr xkU iwr:<
t/nr;gUnr:< nv;g/nrbunr;pznr:< pv,sv,< sv,snv, El; pU;lTesmwr,wv;mI:sunr,lo;sunr,bqnr pqcr,bqcr:gnrdcr:sqcr;ywr x>(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) mI:sunr,hqdr:hvg/nrlqcr xdzcr x anrtugr,mQnr;jzmr:Cdv:nnr xlo;>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) mI:sunr, kJnr;yUdr:yvdI;hUcr:yv< emvyvanrmugr.jumr:bJdr,puYr,
mgr:mnr;wo xnnr xlo;>(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) mI:sunr,hqdr:hvd/cr:hU.d/cr:emv anredbqnrpznr:lIdUwrgwr,El;
jU iwr xj/dr; w/nr;mU icr:nnr x t/cr,h/cr;dqmrtUnr;lo;>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
25/70
25
(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) mI:sunr,kJnr;hqnr:hvbicr,Yv, ligr;l/o:dI;hUcr:hqnr: anrmugr.jumr:bJdr,puYr,wo x>
(6)(6)(6)(6)(6) mI:sunr,t/cr,h/cr;hqdr:s/cr;lo; Ficr;tucr:< ligr;l/o:< gf/mr:l/dr;<
pv,sv,< sv,snv,pTmnr: anredamr,dumr xdU iwr x lzcr;pzmr xhUmr;gnrnnr x dqmrtUnr;lo;>
(7)(7)(7)(7)(7) mI:sunr, k/mr,lU igr;bqnr pU;d/crdUwrgUnr:mU icr: nT:aU icr,pTmnr:lo;>
(8)(8)(8)(8)(8) mI:sunr,dzdr;bnrg/crjT lU igr;d/cr,pU;d/crdUwrgUnr:mU icr: pU;mv:aubr x
bU icr,dUwrgwr, nT:aU icr,pTmnr:lo;>
(9)(9)(9)(9)(9) mU iwr;pU;h/br,g/nr nT:mugr.jumr:dbr.su igr: amr,nnr pU;aubr xbU icr,pzcr:cmr:gUnr:mU icr: hqdr:s/cr;amr,tugr,mQnr;jzmr:ncr,bgr:bU icrnnr x mI:sunr,bzcr,lQcr:d/cr,tJcr dI;pU;gznr:sJgr: amr,nnr pU;mI:bunr;pznr:jnr xsucr amr,nnr hUwrbwr;lUcrgmr:sJwr;lo;>
3.3.3.3.3. sunr,lo;n/cr:yicr:sunr,lo;n/cr:yicr:sunr,lo;n/cr:yicr:sunr,lo;n/cr:yicr:sunr,lo;n/cr:yicr: (Women Rights)ligr;mnr;gQnr, gqwr,lUYr;dv,bigr xsimr:bQdr; lzcr;awrl/ogU;smr,gU;bU icres
jQgr,epn/cr:yicr:(Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination Against Women.CEDAW)nnr x mgr:mnr;bJnrEp; mU iwr;bI 1979 lU inr December (10)wnr:es Ed,jT.dJwr:mv:mU iwr;bI 1981 lU inrSeptember (3)wnr: nnr xmv:yU,ywr x> mI:jJcr;mU icr: 186 mU icr:hUmr;gnrlUcr:l/o:
mJwr:es mU icr:m/nr;smr xlUcr:l/o:mJwr: mU iwr; bI 1997 lU inr July (22)wnr:nnr xmv:yU,ywr x>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) edamr,lo;jQgr,Epes sU igr;smr,n/cr:yicr: gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;g/nr
mU icr:lzcr;bU icrgUnr: lzcr;Ficr;Ec;Ficr;tucr: lzcr;sunr,lo; gUnr:gJgr:
mU icr: jgfv,gU;lzcr;lzcr; jU iwr:no xwv;nowo x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) mU icr:anrkwr;bv:lUcr:l/o:mJwr:jU iwr:nnr x edlo;awrbunr;pznr:El;jQdr;bnrmU inrncr,lzcr;jQgr,Epjnr xt/nr;gUnr:yicr:gUnr:j/o:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
26/70
26
lzcr;b/o:wUnr xwv;n/cr:yicr:no x jnr xt/nr;dQmr,lU iwrgUnr:j/o:jgfv,
jU iwr:no x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) edlo;hqdr:s/cr;bnr lzcr;gv.k/on/cr:yicr:El; awrn/cr:yicr:kwr
jT.bqnrEm;mzgr,yv;nnr. H;wzdr;w/o:gfv,>(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) edlo;hqdr:s/cr;bnrn/cr:yicr:kwr jnr xt/nr;pqcr,bqcr:gnrd/cr:
gUnr:j/o:es h/br,t/mr:jnr xg/nrnT:lUcrbzcrjJcr;El; jnr xt/nr;g/nrc/nr:gU;mU icr:mU icr:>
(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) edlo;hqdr:s/cr;bnr bunr;dv,n/cr:yicr:kwr yv,ebH;mI:lzcr;jQgr,
Ep gqwr,lUYr; dv,lo;g/nrc/nr: b/o:bicr,Yv, b/o:m/gr;mI: b/o:bU icrgUnr:jU iwr:no x gU;jU iwr:jU iwr:>
(6)(6)(6)(6)(6) edlo;hqdr:s/cr;bnrn/cr:yicr:kwr H;mI:sunr,lU igr;awr egv.anredgUbr xgU;gnrd/cr:jwr;gwr, lzdr;lzdr;lQwr:lQwr: lzcr;dv,awrlugr;l/cr:El;pQnrdv,nv;hU inr:nnr xegv; edlo;mI:lzcr;t/cr,
h/cr; jqmrjU iwr:no xywr x>
4.4.4.4.4. sunr,lo;lugr;aznr,sunr,lo;lugr;aznr,sunr,lo;lugr;aznr,sunr,lo;lugr;aznr,sunr,lo;lugr;aznr, (Participation)ligr;mnr;gQnr,gqwr,lUYr; sunr,lo;lugr;aznr, (Convention on the
Rights of the Child. CRC)yU,dI; b/crgumrlUcrlumr:gU;mU icr:mUicr:(United
Nations General Assembly. UNGA)es mgr:mnr;bnrsunr,lugr;aznr,
mU iwr;bI1989 lU inrOctober (20)wnr:nnr xes Ed,jT.dJwr: bI1990mv:yU,ywr x>
mi Uc];man]:Edx lUcr:l/o:mJwr:kwr;Wmr:jzmr: mU iwr;bI 1991 lU inr July (15)wnr:nnr x
mv:yU,ywrx> ligr;mnr;gQnr,no x mI:(191)jJcr;mU icr:kwr;Wmr:lUcr:l/o:mJwr:jzmr:>
nT:ligr;mnr;gQnr,nnr x mI:bv:(54)dznr;es anrgQbr;mnr;Edx jQgr,Epwo x
sI,sQnr:yU,>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) sunr,lo; dznr;dv,s/ojTmnr;gJmr:gfv, (Survial Rights).
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
27/70
27
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) sunr,lo; dznr;dv,yT,mv;gv;sucrmv: (Development Rights).(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) sunr,lo; dznr;dv,gQdr,EkEhxgcr;bnr (Protection Rights).(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) sunr,lo; dznr;dv,kwr;Wmr:hqdr:s/cr;jzmr: (Perticipation
Rights) jU iwr:no xyU,ywr x>sunr,lo; dznr;dv,s/ojTmnr;gJmr:gfv, anrwv;nnrx bqnrsunr,H;
lugr;aznr, sJbr,s/ojTgfv,lo; cwr;k/mr,bJnr xanrlUwr,mU inrncr, jnr xt/nr;yU,swr:ginrs/cr; hU inr:ey:lzcr;ginrymr x(ahv,R) sunr,lo;yUdr:yvdUwrjT jqmrjU iwr:no xywr x>
sunr,lo; dznr;dv,yT,gv;mv;sucrmv:anrwv;nnr xjmr x bzcr,wv;H;yT,mv;gv;sucrmv:jzmr:ncr,dUwrkwrbzcrbqnrlo;nnr xywr x> mU inrncr,sunr,lo;hqnr: awrbi rcr,Yv,d/cr:emv< sunr,lo;lzcr;lqnr;aqnrhQcr:El; lJwr;swr:< lzcr;dUcr xdqnr;jzmr:Ficr;Ec; Ficr;tucr:< sunr,lo;awrk/wr,< sunr,lo;wUnrxsznr, lzzdr;lzdr;lQwr:lQwr:El; gU iwr:lIpTmnr:nnr xywr x>
sunr,lo; dznr;dv,gQdr,EkEhxgcr;bnranrwv;nnrxjmr x lUwr,lo;gQdr,
Ekbnrlzcr;hqdr:amr,Cdv:nUiwrkwr< lzcr;bzo,bJnrxbzo,bQdr;kwrEl; Ebxginresawrnmr xdznr:nU iwrkwrjqmrjU iwr:no xywr x> mU inrncr,gQdr,EkEhxgcr;bnr lugr;aznr,b/o;ep:< gQdr,Ekbnrlzcr;cQnr:es:kwr< lzcr;gQdr,Ekbnrlugr;aznr,anrtUbr:ep: nT:b/crbz o:dJgr:< gQdr,Ekbnrlzcr;jT.ginrhQcr:lugr;aznr,< gQdr,Ekbnrlzcr;awrlugr;aznr,es lUl/og/nrgv,mv.jqmrjU i rwr:no xywr x>
sunr,lo; dznr;dv,kwr;Wmr:hqdr:s/cr;jzmr:anrwv;nnr xjmr x mI:sunr,lo;kwr;Wmr:jzmr:g/nrFicr;Ec;< Ficr;tucr:El; bUicrgUnr:jzmr:ebv;Em;bI;nzcrxhwr:
sunr,lo;d/cr,l/dr;Eng/crjTjwr;gwr, lzdr;lzdr;lQwr:lQwr:< sunr,lo;hUmr;
dumrgnrgdr:gdr:yqnryqnr< sunr,lo;kwr;bv:jzmr:nT:dUcr,wi Ucr:gUnr: jqmrjU iwr:
no xywr x>
nT:ligr;ginrgQnr, sunr,lo;lugr;aznr,nnr xjmr x hUwrhubr;mnr:mU inrncr,dI;dT;no xywr x>g.g.g.g.g. mgr:mnr;av,yU. 18 lUcr:dT;>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
28/70
28
k.k.k.k.k. yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr;es edlo;awrbunr;pznr: dznr;dv,gQdr,Ekbnrsunr,lo;lugr;aznr, dqmrdqmrtUnr;tUnr;>
c.c.c.c.c. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;bQdr xlQnrhUYr:gwr: awrlugr;aznr,azgr,gfv,
nzgr;mU icr:edv,jUwr;>j.j.j.j.j. sunr,lo; dznr;dv,lugr;aznr,t/cr,h/cr;l/dr;jv awrk/wr,c/wr:>
s.s.s.s.s. sunr,lo; dznr;dv,lugr;aznr,wUnr xsznr,t/cr,h/cr; lzcr;yumr,ymr
gU iwr:lI>
Y.Y.Y.Y.Y. sunr,lo;dznr;dv,lugr;aznr,kwr hUmr;dumrgnrkzdr,pzdr;mugr xjumr:
lzdr;lzdr;lQwr:lQwr:>d.d.d.d.d. H;lo;lzdr;g/cr: lzcr;lUl/o bU icrlzdr;lQwr:dUwrgwr,>
t.t.t.t.t. bU icrg/nrbnrbicr,Yv, gqwr,lUYr;bU icrgUnr: Ficr;Ec;El; jv,Ridr xdlugr;aznr,kJnr;yT,mv:nnr x edlo;hqdr:s/cr;bnr>
n.n.n.n.n. yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr;es edlo;lUlzmrgQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;lugr;aznr,
b/o;ep:kwr t/cr,h/cr;yU,swr:>b.b.b.b.b. yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr;es edlo;awrbunr;pznr:hqdr:s/cr;bnr b/o:yU,
lIlugr;aznr,dqmrtUnr;kJdr:jnr x>p.p.p.p.p. H;lugr;aznr,kwr mI:sunr,lo; dznr,dv,gumr,tUnr;bU icrgUnr:>F.F.F.F.F. edlo;mI:sunr, hqnr:awrbicr,Yv,pqcr,bqcr:gnr nT:g/nrhqnr:bicr,Yv,
jnr xcwr;>m.m.m.m.m. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr gf/mr:l/dr;El;Ficr;Ec;lugr;aznr,j/wr:kU iwr:kwr>y.y.y.y.y. edlo;mI:sunr, lJwr;hU i rwr xlJwr;jT>
R.R.R.R.R. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;ginrjigr:esjT.sz o gqwr,lUYr;g/nrm/gr;mI:>l.l.l.l.l. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;awrlugr;aznr,kwr;bv:hqdr:s/cr; nT:g/nr
c/nr: yv;mwr:gmr>
w.w.w.w.w. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;awrlugr;aznr,jT.du iwr:dI;nT:g/nrgv,mv.es ginrjigr:kwr>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
29/70
29
h.h.h.h.h. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;gv.k/olugr;aznr,gU;lzcr;lzcr;>a.a.a.a.a. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;amr,jzmr:Cdv:es bnrd/cr:pidr: d/mr,
d/onU iwrlugr;aznr,>
gg.gg.gg.gg.gg. edlo;gQdr,Ekbnr lzcr;awrlugr;aznr,anrav,yU.(15)bI lUcr:dT;hqdr:sJgr:>
gk.gk.gk.gk.gk. scrwv;lugr;aznr,esegv.egv. pidr:bU icr;m/omI;nojJcr edlo;awr aey: jzmr:ncr,m/omI;lugr;aznr,mI:mv:nnr xgUYr: jqmrjU iwr:no xywr x>
5.5.5.5.5. lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:>lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:>lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:>lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:>lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:> (The Trafficing in Persons)pU;lTpTesamr,wv; edamr,lo;awrgUnr: hqdr:mU inrncr,gunr,esywr x kL.Ka}
lzcr;wv;awrgUnr:gv.k/ono x hqdr:s/cr;nT:mU icr:El;scr k/oazgr,nzgr;mU icr: El;scredamr,lo;hqdr:mUinrncr, sJwrxawrn/cr:yicr:es k/oedv,esegv.egv.dv,awrhqdr:n/cr:yicr:k/odUwr amr,nnrk/obnrH;awrhqdr:ncr,kv;libr:El;scrawrlugr; aznr,yicr:av,yU. 13bIlUcr:dT; k/obnrdv,hqdr:g/nrgv,mv.El;scrdiYzbr: amr,nnr sJwrxawrlugr;aznr, j/o:av,yU. 15 bIlUcr:dT;esk/obnrdv,hqdr:kv;libr: amr,nnr sUcr,azgr,nzgr;mUicr: anramr,mI:d/cr:mv:kJnr:lo;edv,jUwr;El;scr bzcr,wv;lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:ywr x>
(ekv;lUbr:)(ekv;lUbr:)(ekv;lUbr:)(ekv;lUbr:)(ekv;lUbr:)> >ligr;ginrgQnr, dznr;dv,h/mr;d/br; gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:
(Convention of the Suppression of Traffic in Persons)nnr x lUcr:l/o:mJwr: mU iwr;bI 1949es ligr;ginrgQnr, dznr;dv,gU;smr, lzcr;awrgnrhqdr:kv;libr:(Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery)nnr x lUcr:l/o: mJwr: mU iwr;bI 1956nnr xywr x> lU iwresgv.k/ogzcr;g/cr,El;yv;mwr:gmrnnr x g/nrgv.k/ogUnr:no x nmr xdznr:mnr: lo;nmrlU iwrbU inr;wv;noywr x> lU iwresno xamr,gv:gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;awrd/ogUnr: bqnrpucrbqnrjumr:nnrxegv; mI:wo xligr; ginrgQnr,gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;dv,edgQdr,Ekbnres bnrd/mr,nU iwrgUnr:jU iwr:anr bUnr xbQnr
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
30/70
30
lzcr;awrawrd/ogUnr: bqnrpucrbqnrjumr: (Convention on the Preventionand Purnishment of the Crime of Genocide ) nnr x lUcr:l/o:mJwr: mU iwr;bI1948nnr xywr x>
ligr;ginrgQnr,gU;mUicr:mUicr: gqwr,lUYr;lzcr;jQgr,Epdqgr:dqcrgU;lzcr;lzcr;pqwr;mUYr xj/wr:kU iwr:(International Convention on the Elemination of AllForms of Racial Discrimination)nnr xnoegv; lUcr:l/o:mJwr: wo xmU iwr;bI 1965nnr xyU,ywr x>
6.6.6.6.6. sunr,lo; jwr;ho;< jwr;nv:>sunr,lo; jwr;ho;< jwr;nv:>sunr,lo; jwr;ho;< jwr;nv:>sunr,lo; jwr;ho;< jwr;nv:>sunr,lo; jwr;ho;< jwr;nv:>gUnr:gJgr:mU icr:jJcr;do:hwr:kv;no x mzgr;hUwrb/gr,80%nnr x bqnrjwr;ho;jwr;nv:
lznr xlznr x> hqdr:ginrho; so xginrnv:es yU,mv:gdr:gdr:yqnryqnr jqmrmU iwr;gznr,
mUiwr;mJnrx> w/o:eslUcrbzcrjJcr;jwr;av,nv,sJgr:m/nr;kwr w/cr:pQnrg/nrlzcr;
pqwr;mUYrxj/wr:kUiwr:mv:nox anrbqnrjwr;ho;jwr;nv:kwregv; p/nrgzdr:mv:
esywr xamr,gv: lo;yU,swr:ginrs/cr;y/br,y/br,pJdr,pJdr, lo;yU,gUwrgUwrEhEhyU,dv,es,ywrx> gUnr:anrbqnrebv;m/o;Em;m/o; lugr;aznr,amr,mI:ebv;Em;egv;
mI:nmrmv:digr:digr:ywr x>scrwv;lo;k/mr,d/cr:lUcrbzcrjJcr;m/nr; amr,nnr sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mUicr:
mv:kI,nqgr:dqgr:dqcrgU;bU icrbU icrnojJcr pU;anrludr;h/mr:sunr,lo;dUwrgwr,nnr xlUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/odQdr;nQdr;ywrx lUcr:l/omJwr:es d/cr,kJnr;dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:gUnr:mUicr: ( International Courtof Justic. ICI ) amr,nnrlumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: Rv,jwudr;gU;mU icr:mU icr: (InternationalCriminal Court.ICC)nnr xyU,ywr x>
lzcr;jwr;ho;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
31/70
31
anrjwr;gwr,lqcr xlUwo x jqmrjU iwr:nnr x lUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/odQdr;dQdr;nQdr; nQdr;lUcr:l/o:mJwr:ywr.es d/cr,yznr: dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: Rv,jwudr; gU;mU icr:mU icr:(ICC) nnr xyU,ywr x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) lzcr;sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwrmv:simr:awr sUnr< ho;< nv: hwr:l/ol/oesjT.pugr,szmr;bnr dv,dbr xkwrkJnr:nnrxegv; pU;lU.sumr:sunr,lo;jU iwr:nnr xlUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/odQdr;dQdr;nQdr;nQdr;es lUcr:l/o:mJwr:ywr x d/cr,yznr:awrdI;lumr:Cdv:Rv,jwudr;gU;mU icr:mU icr: (ICC) nnr xywr x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr;El;scr dbr xm/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:El;scr hqdr:d/cr:
lUdrxd/cr:gv: amr,nnr d/cr;lUdr xFo: amr,nnr w/cr:hU iwr:winr amr,nnrdqcrp/oesEl; awrnmr xtUmr;gfv, amr,nnr Ed,dcr;dbr xmT,kwrmv: jqmrjU iwr:nnrxes lo;lU.sumr:gfv,egv; mI:gUnr:anrdI;lo;lU.sumr:gfv,sunr,lo;jUiwr:nnrxegv; lUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/o anrhwr:lo;lU.sumr:gfv,jU iwr:nnrxdQdr;dQdr;nQdr;nQdr;es d/cr,yznr:dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:Rv,jwudr; (ICC)nnr xncr,gwr,>
(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) yU,dI;lUcrbzcrjJcr; amr,nnrdbrxsJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr atmr,mlJbr;ehv;bQdr;es awrj/wr:kU iwr:d/cr,anrmv:dQnr:yU,kJnr:dI;hwr:jU iwr:nnr x
egv; bqnrlzcr;lU. sumr:sunr,lo;hwr:EdxEdxywr x pU;anrlo;lU.sumr: sunr,lo;
hwr:gfv,jUiwr:nnrxegv; lUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/olIc/mr:ywrx lUcr:l/o:mJwr:es d/cr,
yznr:dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: Rv,jwudr;gU;mU icr:mU icr: (ICC)nnr xywr x>
[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:> >>>>>mU inrncr,lJbr;ehv;bQdr;j/wr:kUiw r:do: lJbr;ehv;bQdr;j/wr:kU iwr:do:]]]]]
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
32/70
32
(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) lzcr;lUcrbzcrjJcr; amr,nnr dbr xsJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr jT.ginrhQcr:l/ohwr:nnrxegv; bzcr,wv;jwr;ho;jwr;nv: hwr:lo;lU.sumr:sunr,lo;hwr:ywrx>
mUinrncr, lo;hqdr:d/cr:lUdrxekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:> >>>>>lo;k/mr,d/cr:ludr;h/mr: g/nrc/nr: sunr,dUwrjwr;gwr,es gfv,hqdr:bnrsJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwrnnrx lo;lU.sumr:sunr,lo;sunr,bqnrhwr:EdxEdxywr x gzbr;scrEl;nojJcr lo;awrkU icr;jT.kU icr;mJwr:jwr;gwr,< lo;awrkwr;nmr xd/cr:ginrjwr;gwr,< lo;awrmo xawrkv:kzcrjwr;gwr,es awrelv. yU,dI;sJgr:m/nr;kwrbqnrmU,bqnrjumr:es gnrxjnrlUl/oywrx awrd/obQdr;egv;mI:mv:>amr,mI:lzcr;d/cr:scres dI xYzbr:kcrkzgr;ebv.tubrxl/oegv; mI:mv:dcr:nmrywrx>gUnr:anrlo;lU.sumr:sunr,lo;nnr xEl;scr bI;nzcr xbzcr;b/ogUnr:anrlo;lU. ha}d/ogfv,nnrxEl;scr lUwr,lo;hqdr:s/om/odQdr;dQdr;nQdr;nQdr;es d/cr,kJnr;dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:gU;mU icr:mU icr: (ICC) yU,ywr x>
********************
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
33/70
33
kn] (5)
tWn]:tqp];tt];JtL;
1.1.1.1.1. bunr;pznr:El;nv;g/nr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bunr;pznr:El;nv;g/nr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bunr;pznr:El;nv;g/nr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bunr;pznr:El;nv;g/nr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bunr;pznr:El;nv;g/nr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnrxjnrx>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) scrwv;ebv,mI:mv: (sicr) (amU.)esbU icrbU icres pU;d/cr,(sicr)(pU;En:
- w&m;vd k)nnr x d/cr,kJnr;mv:ekv;En:(cG Jcsuf)jJcr edlo;hbr xwo xes hqdr:nQbr,(sicr) nQbr,(amU. - tr_wG J)esywr x edlUwr,lo;Wcr xawr pU;Eg;(pU;k/mr,En:-w&m;cH)mv:pQwrnv;lumr:Cdv:es sbr:lQcr:Enlzcr;d/cr: anrmnr:lo;
pidr:bU icr;bgr:bU icrlgr:m/onnr xlIc/mr: w/o:esnnr xlUwr,lo;awr ekv;jQbr:jznrx(ekv;azgr,l/dr;) ekv;jQdr:kL/gr;(ppfcsuf) dI;pU;d/cr,sicr(pU;En: - w&m;lu i)aigr,bv:pU;hU.hnrjzmr:(s/gr;es, - oufao) anrpU;d/cr,sicr(pU;En: -w&m;vk d)d/cr,mv:nnrdcr:sqcr; w/o:esnnr xlUwr,lo;jQdr;t/mr pU;Eg;sicr(pU;k/mr,En:-w&m;cH)El;pU;hU.hnrjzmr:pU;Eg;sicr(s/gr;es,p/opU;k/mr,
En: -w&m;cH oufao)jU iwr:nnr xdcr:sqcr; ebv:lo;ekv;jQbr:jznr x (ekv;azgr,l/dr; ppfcsuf)dcr:sqcr;ywr xjJcr lUwr,lo;tzmr,cinr: lzcr;ekv;hnrtJcr (av#mufvJcsuf Argument )d/cr:szcr,p/o,szcrbv;esywr x jcr,tdr:s/crdUYr:lIlIesdQbr:ddr:jzmr:ncr, bgr:bU icrdmr:w/cr:mv:wo xnnr x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) ekv;jQbr:jznr x(ekv;azgr,l/dr;)jU iwr:nnr xegv; edlo;dQmr;m/ojzmr:wo xnQbr,gJgr:wo xbv:nT: nQbr,sicr(nQbr,amU. - tr_wG J)nnr xdcr:sqcr;>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) scrwv;pU;d/cr,sicr (pU;En: - w&m;vd k)El;scr pU;Eg;(pU;k/mr,En: - w&m;cH)El;scr amr,bqcr:ebv:jTnU iwrekv;dQbr:ddr:nnr xes d/cr,yznr:mv: dznr;dv,kJnr:pJnr xEg;dUwr (t,lcHr_ Appeal) amr,nnr pJnrmUnr xEm:lzcr;ddr:sinr(jyifqifrS l - Revision)amr,nnr pJnrd/cr,Ea:lU(toem;cHv$m - Bill of rights)nojJcr edlo;awr pJnrligr;anrd/cr,
yznr:mv:nnr x nQbr,gJgr:bv:nT:nQbr,sicr (nQbr,amU.)nnr xes d/cr,kJnr;bnrdI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: dI;nU iwranrgqwr,kzcr;nnr xyU,ywr x>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
34/70
34
(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) scrwv;sicr (amU.) anrd/cr,tJcrmv:dI;lumr:Cdv:jwr;gwr,nnrx
sucrlU iwrsunr,dQbr:ddr: Cdv:jwr;gwr,jJcr edlo;dQmr;m/oekv;m/odzcr:(Remark )
gJgr:bv:nQbr,sicr(nQbr,amU.)nnrxes d/cr,kJnr;jU: lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:
jnr xnU iwr anrmI:sunr,dQbr:ddr:Cdv:lo; anrgqwr,kzcr;sicr(amU.)nnr x>(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) bU icrdQbr:ddr:Cdv:no x edlo;mI:lzcr;t/cr,h/cr;lzdr;lQwr: (Indepen
dent Judiciary) esywrx edamr,lo;mI:pU;lTAgUnr:lTAjumr:lT mv:bnreav:jv,scr edamr,lo;mI:dT;hUmr;cmr:pT lzcr;dQbr:ddr:Cdv:nnrxegv;edlo;bJdr,puYr,wo xes tdr:s/crdQbr:ddr:b/gr,nv;gUnr:d/cr:nmr edamr,
lo; sU icr,wo xAsimr:wo xAlbr xwo x bzcr,wv;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:bJdr,puYr, (Open Court)nnr xyU,ywr x>
(6)(6)(6)(6)(6) sunr,lo;pU;d/cr,sicr(pU;En: - w&m;vdk) scrwv;esegv.egv.amr,nnr esjumr:jumr: hqdr:amr,Cdv:nU iwrjwr;gwr, gqwr,lUYr;bgr:bU icrlgr:m/oesanranrjJcr mI:sunr,d/cr,tJcrH;tdr:s/crmUnrxEm: Eg;lidr;bnr
lzcr;amr,Cdv:nnrxdI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: mUiwr;d/cr,pJnrligr; nQbr,sicr(tr_wG J)nnr x edlo;dQmr;d/cr,Enlzcr;sicr(amU.)nnr x ebv,bqnrmv:jU icr xhJwrAdUwrjwr;gwr,lo;lU.sumr: sunr,lo;sunr,bqnr jU icr xhJwr A gzbr;scrEl; pU;Eg;(pU;k/mr,En: - w&m;cH) nnr x bUnr xbQnrjU icr xhJwr jgfv,jU iwr:nnr x edlo;dQmr;d/cr,bv:H;dqmrtUnr; nT:pJnrligr;nnr x edlo;bnrbv:s/om/o pU;hU.hnrjzmr: (s/gr;es,)dcr:mUdr:>
(7)(7)(7)(7)(7) mI:sunr,lo;dv,edj/cr;awr pU;sgr:(w&m;vdka&Shae)esl/dr;dQnr:dUwrgwr,lo; scrwv; lzcr;tdr:s/cresanranr amr,tugr,mQnrjzmr:bgr:bU icrlgr:m/oegv; d/cr,lo;pJnrmUnr xEm:tdr:s/crsinr (jyifqifr_-Revision)dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:jnrxnUiwrlo; lUiwresnnrxamr,gv: ebv:hnrtJcrwv;ekv;dQbr:ddr:Cdv:lumr:dT;nnr x amr,tugr,mQnr;noegv; mI:sunr,dv,edd/cr,
pJnrEg;dUwr(Appeal
-t,lcHr_
) dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:d/cr:nUiwrlo; gmr:lJnr:sudr: scrwv;ekv;dQbr:ddr:lumr:Cdv:anrsucrsudr: (lumr:dQbr:ddr:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
35/70
35
Cdv:cwr;cunr:)nnrx amr,bo,bqcr:ebv:jTnojJcr d/cr,lo;pJnrd/cr,Ea:lU(toem;cHv$m- Bill of Rights)dI; hUwrbwr;lUcr R.C.S.S kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:jJcr;do:lo;yU,>
(8)(8)(8)(8)(8) sunr,lo;pU;Eg;(pU;k/mr,En:) scrwv;dUwrgwr,pidr:bU icr; bgr:bU icr lgr:m/oesanranrEl;scr esegv.jIxEn:mv:wv; dUwrgwr,bUnrxbQnrnUiwrsunr,lo;mnr: esanranrEl;scr ebv:lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:mgr:mnr;dUwrgwr,bqnrpU;Eg;(pU;k/mr,En:)mv:nojJcr mI:sunr,lo;dzbr,tqcr Eg;lidr;kJnr:ekv;En:nnrxlo; lUiwresnnrx mI:sunr,hbrxj/cr; awrpU;Eg;(sgr:)
(w&m;cHa&S hae) l/dr;dQnr:dUwrgwr,lo;>(9)(9)(9)(9)(9) pzcr:y/mr:jQdr;t/mrtdr:s/crsicr(amU.)nnrx scrwv;hnrtJcrlzcr;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: tdr:s/cramr,tugr,mQnr;jzmr:bgr:bU icrnojJcr d/cr,lo;pJnrmUnrxEm: (jyifqifr_ Revision) dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr: Cdv:p/o,nUiwrlo;scrwv;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: tdr:s/crywrxdUwr;es dQbr:ddr:bnrekv;bUcrywr xdUwr;lIc/mr:ywr xesEl; amr,bqcr:ebv:nU iwrekv;bUcrnnr xegv; mI;sunr,d/cr,
lo;pJnrEg;dUwr(t,lcHr_-Appeal) dI;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:p/o,nU iwrtQcr; lo;yU,>scrwv;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:sucrsudr: (lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:cwr;cunr:)dQbr:ddr:bnrekv;bUcrnnr x amr,bo,bqcr:ebv:jTtQcr;nojJcr d/cr,lo;pJnrd/cr,Ea:lU (toem;cHv$m -Bill of Rights) dI;hUwrbwr;lUcr R.C.S.S kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:jJcr;do: tQcr;lo;yU,>
2.2.2.2.2. bU icrkzdr,pzdr; dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>bU icrkzdr,pzdr; dQbr:ddr:Cdv: gU;jnr xjnr x>@@dQbr:ddr:Cdv:nnr x## hqdr:bnrH;pqcr,bqcr:< dQbr:ddr:ncr,gUnr: mI:sinr<
dQbr:ddr:jzmr:bUicrsinr H;tugr,mQnr;El;@@ddr:sinr##noegv;wv;ywrx>
dv,edddr:sinrnnrx dcr;Ed,awr mU,w/nr;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
36/70
36
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:mU,w/nr;>dv,eddQbr:ddr: g/nrpidr:tugr,gnr nT:w/nr;lo;nnr x edlo;
mI:jumr:ddr:sinryU,ywr x> jumr:ddr:sinrmU,w/nr;nnr x edlo;kzdr,pzdr;
ncr,dT;no xywr x>g.g.g.g.g. bU,g/cr xw/nr; (1) egv.>k.k.k.k.k. pU;n/mr:nT:w/nr; (1) egv.>c.c.c.c.c. mU,jumr:j/o:yicr: (2) egv.>j.j.j.j.j. twr;w/nr;twr;nv: (3) egv.>
s.s.s.s.s. sunr,lo;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv: ^mU,w/nr;& >1. dQbr:ddr:bnr d/mr,gL/mr: amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:lo;>
2. scrbnrd/mr,cJnr: edamr,lo;lU iwr(200,000)bLv:>
nT:nnr x (10%)bLv: bqnrjRibr;ddr:sinr dv,(90%)
bLv: bqnrcJnr:gzcrg/crw/nr;>
3. dQbr:ddr:bnrlo; d/mr,kzgr; gJgr:g/nrgL/mr: edv,tJcr(6)lU inr>
4. scr,wv;w/nr; amr,dQbr:ddr:lo;nojJcr edlo;d/cr,tJcrdI;^aU icr,&>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:aU icr,>dv,eddQbr:ddr:g/nrpidr:Atugr, nT:aU icr,El; anrw/nr;amr,dQbr:ddr:lo;nnrx edlo;mI: jumr:ddr:sinraUicr,yU,ywrx> jumr:ddr:sinr̂ aU icr,&nnr x edlo;kzdr,pzdr;ncr,bv;dT;no xywr x>
g.g.g.g.g. bU,hqcraU icr, (1) egv.>
k.k.k.k.k. pU;n/mr:nT:aU icr, (1) egv.>
c.c.c.c.c. mU,jumr:j/o:Ayicr: (2) egv.>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
37/70
37
j.j.j.j.j. twr;w/nr;twr;nv: (5) egv.>
s.s.s.s.s. sunr,lo;lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:^aU icr,&
1. dQbr:ddr:bnrd/mr,gL/mr: amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:>
2. scrbnrd/mr,cJnr: edamr,lo;lU iwr (500,000)bLv:
nT:nnr x (10%)bLv: bqnrjRibr;ddr:sinr dv,
(90%)bLv: bqnrcJnr:gzcrg/craU icr,>
3. d/mr,gL/mr:gJgr:bv:d/mr,kzgr;tJcr (2) bI>
4. scrwv;aU icr,amr,dQbr:ddr:lo;nojJcr edlo;dQmr;ligr;
gJgr:Wmr:jzmr:es sJbr,d/cr,tJcrdI; ^sw]:nL:tI:Pa},
Aup].pi Uc],&yU,ywr x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:cwr;cunr:>dv,eddQbr:ddr:g/nrpidr:Atugr,gnr anrai Ucr, amr,dQbr:
ddr:lo;nnrx edlo;mI: jumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:cwr;cunr:yU,ywrx> jumr:dQbr:
ddr:Cdv:cwr;cunr:nnr x edlo;kzdr,pzdr;ncr,bv; dT;no xywr x>g.g.g.g.g. pU;gdr xkQnr, p/o,m/omI; (1) egv.>k.k.k.k.k. pU;mI: smr,mv,ti (2) egv.>c.c.c.c.c. pU;kwr;bv: (2) egv.>
j.j.j.j.j. sunr,anrcwr;cunr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:ddr:sinrlo;>1. edlo;dQbr:ddr:g/nrpidr:Atugr,gnr anrai Ucr,amr,
j/cr;ddr:lo;ywr xEl; bv:nQbr,ligr;bJnr:d/cr:pidr:<
ekv;jQdr;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
38/70
38
2. scrbnrd/mr,cJnr: edamr,lo;lU iwr (5,000,000)bLv:
nT:nnr x dv, (10%)bLv: bqnrjRibr;dQbr:ddr:Cdv:>
(90%)bLv: bqnrcJnr:gzcrg/cr Wmr:pznr:mugr xjumr:>
3. dQbr:ddr:bnrlo;d/mr,d/o gUYr:nv,lUwr,ekv;lo;jTdI;
hUwrbwr;lUcr R.C.S.S kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:jJcr;do: jcr,ed
lo;bnrd/mr,d/ono xlo;>
4. hbr xawrdQbr:ddr: tdr:s/crlo;pJnrmUnr xEm:(Revi
sion)amr,nnr pJnrEg;dUwr
(Appeal)anrlumr:bv;dT; d/cr,kJnr;mv:jU iwr:nnr x>
5. lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:cwr;cunr:no x mI:av,nv,dQbr:ddr:
Cdv:sucrsudr:es ekv;dQbr:ddr:nnr x bqnrdI;yzdr;
Wdr;dI;b/oywr x> (nzgr;lU iwresbnrd/mr,d/o)>
6. gUYr:nv, scrwv; pU;k/mr,En:nnr x kT;d/cr,yznr:pJnrd/cr,Ea:lU (Bill of Rights) nU iwrekv;dQbr:ddr:Cdv:nnr x edlo;hbr xawres sJbr,d/cr,tJcrdI; hUwrbwr;lUcr R.C.S.S kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:jJcr;do: k/wr:d/cr:nT:(90)wnr:>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
39/70
39
kn] (6)lWc]:yL:mw];km]
1.1.1.1.1. yv;mwr:gmryv;mwr:gmryv;mwr:gmryv;mwr:gmryv;mwr:gmranrwv;nnrx bzcr,wv;bqnryv;yvanr sU,< smr:< ginr< dv:esywr x awrgUnr:hwr: cmr:cwr:mwr:lJmr:gfv, gU;smr,gU;bU icrnnr xywr x>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) nT:gv; yv;mwr:gmrnnr x edkwr;bv: anrbqnrjU iwr:yv;Finr, mU inrncr,yv;lmr< mnr:yv;lmr< pzcrhQcr;yv;lmr< yv;Finr,pU igr, jgfv,jU iwr:no x kwr;bv:mUdr:>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) jU iwr:anrbqnr b/cr:(hi) mU inrncr, dUnr;b/cr:< wTb/cr:< pzcrmnr: anrawrdI;b/cr:hqdr:azgr,mv: kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) jU iwr:anrbqnr gUwr,gqnr: (Cocaine) mU inrncr, pzcr< nmr x< mnr:anrawrdI;dUnr;dI;wT gUwr,gv,(Coca)hqdr:azgr,mv: kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr x>
(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) jU iwr:anrbqnryv;yv awrkUwr:kzcrdv,dU.eb,dv.(Chemical) mU inrncr, yv;mv.< yv;aI: jgfv,jU iwr:nnrP kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr x>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:pugr,szmr;< hucrdUmr;< hqdr:azgr,< simr:es:kUwr:
kzcr< gumr:ticr:gQdr,Ekbnr< edv.sUcr,bnr< gv.k/o< sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr
nojJcr edlo;wv;bqnrgUnr:mI:d/cr:pidr:yU,ywr x>
2.2.2.2.2. lzcr;pugr,szlzcr;pugr,szlzcr;pugr,szlzcr;pugr,szlzcr;pugr,szmr; yv;mwr:gmr>mr; yv;mwr:gmr>mr; yv;mwr:gmr>mr; yv;mwr:gmr>mr; yv;mwr:gmr>
pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:pugr,szmr;yv;mwr:gmresanranr yv;Finr,<b/cr:< gUwr,gqnr:< jgfv, nojJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:> sUnr yv;mwr:gmrnnr x edlo;tugr,yv.lQwr dI,pqwr;bQdr;sqcr;>
3.3.3.3.3. lzcr;hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr, yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr, yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr, yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr, yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr, yv;mwr:gmr>
pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:awrgunr,lU icr:gunr,gL/mr: yv;mwr:gmresanranr
mv:hucrdUmr;esywr x hqdr:azgr,mv:yv;mwr:gmranrtU igr;gv;nnr xjJcr edlo;k/mr,
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
40/70
40
d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,d/cr:szcrmqwr:
yU,ywr x> kUwr:kzcrkU icr;anrhucrdUmr;jU iwr:nnr xegv; edlo;k/mr,yv.lQwrbQ rdr;mUdr:<
yv;mwr:gmr anrhqdr:azgr,mv:nnr xegv; edlok/mr, pqwr;mUYr x< yv.lQwr< Fo:pwr
bQdr;mUdr:>
4.4.4.4.4. lzcr;simr:es: kUwr:kzcryv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;simr:es: kUwr:kzcryv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;simr:es: kUwr:kzcryv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;simr:es: kUwr:kzcryv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;simr:es: kUwr:kzcryv;mwr:gmr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:simr:es:wox yv;mwr:gmranrbqnrgunr,gL/mr:<
amr,nnr yv;mwr:gmr anrbqnrgunr,ekLv:< amr,nnrkUwr:kzcrhucrdUmr; yv;mwr:gmr
esanranr kUwr:kzcranr sU icr,simr:wo xjU iwr:nnr xegv; edlo;k/mr,yv.lQwr< pqwr;pwrbQdr; amr,nnr simr:awrbqnr p/nr,dv, mugr xjumr:yU,ywr x>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>kUwr:kzcranrsU icr,simr:wo xnnr x mI:dI;nT:hU inr:< amr,nnr si ucr,< tqcr< sUnr<
nv: anrbqnrkzcrjwr;gwr, amr,nnr lUdr x gU;mqwr:< elv.< lv:< mv. jgfv,jU iwr:nnr xkwr;bv:mUdr:>]]]]]
5.5.5.5.5. lzcr;gumr:ticr:>lzcr;gumr:ticr:>lzcr;gumr:ticr:>lzcr;gumr:ticr:>lzcr;gumr:ticr:>
pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:lUlzmrgumr:ticr:bnr sUnr< ho;< nv:< anrdI;pugr,szmr; yv;mwr:gmr amr,nnr hUcr:hucrdUmr; hqdr:azgr,yv;mwr:gmr< amr,nnrkUwr:kzcranrhqdr:azgr,yv;mwr:gmrgU;lzcr;lzcr;< amr,nnryv;mwr:gmrgU;mqwr:mqwr:<amr,nnrhU inr:ey:
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
41/70
41
6.6.6.6.6. lzcredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmr>lzcredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmr>lzcredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmr>lzcredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmr>lzcredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:awrkUicr;edv.sUcr,esanranr mUinrncr,
lUdr xgU;mqwr:mqwr:< elv.< mv.< lv:< gUnr:h/br, edv.awryv;mwr:gmr anrk/o xlQgr;
la}:tI:lo;(Movable Property)lugrxdI;nJcr;k/o xsUcr,tJcrdI;nJcr;jJcr bzcr,wv;lzcr;edv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmrywr x> pU;anredv.sUcr,yv;mwr:gmrnnr x edlo;k/mr,d/mr, kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,d/cr:szcrmqwr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>
kUwr:kzcranrk/o xlQgr;l/odI;lo; (Movable Property) anrwv;nnr x lU iwres
kUwr:kzcrhU inr:ey: anrgJdr:jbr:pcrwo xnT:linr amr,nnr kUwr:kzcranrmv:jbr:gJgr:woxdI;kUwr:kzcr anramr,k/oxl/o;lo;d/cr,dI; (UnmovetableProperty) nnr x kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr x>]]]]]
7.7.7.7.7. lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; anrlo;nmrxdznr:pznr:lIes awryv;mwr:gmr
esanranr sJwrx k/oes lo;j/mr,bUYr;jzmr:mnr:nojJcr bzcr,wv;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmrywrx> lzcr;gv.k/onox sJwrxawrdI;nJcr;essUcr,k/od/cr,dI;nnrxbv:mUdr:ywrx> amr,jT;wv; gv.yT,< gv.lUcr< gv.yz o;< gv.yQmr:< ebv:sJwr.awryv;mwr:gmres k/okJnr:nnrxegv;bzcr,wv; gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmrywrx> pU;anrgv.k/oyv;mwr:gmrnnrx edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:<
amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:yU,ywrx> yv;mwr:gmr amr,nnr cJnr:dzcr:anrgqwr,gbr: lzcr;gv.k/oyv;mwr:gmrnnr xegv; edlo;k/mr,pqwr;simr: awrkwr;bqnrp/nr,dv,mugr xjumr:yU,ywr x>
8.8.8.8.8. lzcr; sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr; sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr; sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr; sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr; sU,< smr:< ginr< dv: yv;mwr:gmr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; jT.dJwr:yv;mwr:gmresanranresywr x sU,< smr:<
ginr< dv: H;ebv: cmr:cwr:lJmr:gfv,gU;bU icrjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:<amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr: yU,ywr x>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
42/70
42
9.9.9.9.9. lzcr;amrlbrxgqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;amrlbrxgqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;amrlbrxgqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;amrlbrxgqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmr>lzcr;amrlbrxgqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; hU.hnrjzmr:lzcr;pugr,szmr;< hUcr:dUmr;hqdr:azgr,<
simr:es:kUwr:kzcr< gumr:ticr: wo xgU;lzcr;lzcr;< lzcr;edv.sUcr,< lzcr;gv.k/o< lzcr;sU,
smr:ginrdv: yv;mwr:gmryU,esdv.egv; yznrxbU iwr;hbrxlo; cJnr:sU:cJnr:l/br;amr,nnr bqnregv.Es;bI;nzcr xesywr x amr,bzcr,k/wr,bnrdI;p/o,aubr xbU icr,< p/o,lumr:Cdv:< jwr;nv;dI; jgfv,jU iwr:no xjJcr bzcr,wv;lzcr;amrlbr x gqwr,lUYr; yv;mwr:gmrywr x> pU;anramrlbr x gqwr,lUYr;yv;mwr:gmrnnr x edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:yU,ywr x>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
43/70
43
kn] (7)
lWc]:etL,lWc];
lzcr;edv,lzcr;anrwv;nox mnr:kwr;bv:lzcr;edv,lzcr:jzmr: m/gr,bnr,sI,dUwr< tI, (36) dUwr< edv,p/o x< edv,m/gr,jQcr< edv,m/gr,gicr;lz o< edv,m/gr,kUgr xkUgr x<lzcr:mv.< edv,go, jgfv,jU iwr:noxbv:sqcr;ywrx> scrwv;egv.nJcr;El; egv.nJcr;mcr,kT;lo;cJnr;gnres awrl/o:esanranr mv:EkxkQcr,gnrjJcr bzcr,wv;g/nredv,lzcr:yU,ywr x>
lzcr;g/nredv,lzcr:no x yU,dI;m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr dmr:w/cr:pQnrg/nreshqdr:s/cr;H;gUnr:mU icr:hwr:p/nrgzdr:< hqdr:H;jv,Rigr xdgUnr:mUicr:hwr:dQmr,eyv;gfv,es gmr:lJnr:sudr:mv: hqdr:H;jU iwr xj/dr;w/nr;mU i rcr:hwr:jUmr h/ogfv, kwrmI:pQnrg/nres hqdr:s/cr;mv:nU iwrhwr:yU,ywr x> gzbr;bU iwr;nnrEl; yU,dI;kzcr,sI,awrkJnr:jJcr;do:es d/mr:w/cr:woxebv,lsI, dznr;dv,h/mr;d/br;bnrd/mr, gqwr,lUYr;
lzcr;edv,lzcr: gU;bU icrbU icryU,ywr x>g.g.g.g.g. d/mr:w/cr:bgr:bU U icrlgr:m/o lzcr;h/mr;d/br;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr: gU;bU icrbU i rcr>k.k.k.k.k. d/mr:w/cr:lzcr;awraey:bnrd/mr, pU;anrgqwr,kzcr; lzcr;g/nredv,
g/nrlzcr:>c.c.c.c.c. sUnr:dumrgUnr:mU icr: H;s/nrkdr: lzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:>jjjjj. edbnrd/cr:hU. lzcr;pznr:jv. g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:gfv, nU iwrgUnr:mU icr:
jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x>
1.1.1.1.1. g/nrhqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr:>g/nrhqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr:>g/nrhqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr:>g/nrhqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr:>g/nrhqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr:>
pU;lTpTesamr,wv; hqdr:jwr;dQcr,es awrlzcr;edv,lzcr:esanranr
mv:kLv.bnrH;gUnr:dcr:nmr mv:edv,lzcr:gnr lzcr;m/cr,lo;cJnr:dzcr:nU iwrgnr
nnr x bzcr,wv;pU;hqdr:dQcr,edv,lzcr: amr,nnr jwr;dQcr, yU,ywr x> jwr;dQcr,
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
44/70
44
nnr x edlo;k/mr, d/mr,kzgr; gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnr
d/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr: cJnr:dzcr:anredv,lzcr:nnr xegv; edlo;k/mr,simr:awrbqnr
p/nr,dv,mugr xjumr:yU,ywr x>
2.2.2.2.2. g/nrgUnr:edv,lzcr:g/nrgUnr:edv,lzcr:g/nrgUnr:edv,lzcr:g/nrgUnr:edv,lzcr:g/nrgUnr:edv,lzcr:pU;lTpTesamr,wv; awrcJnr:dzcr:es mv:edv,lzcr:dI;b/crlzcr:nojJcr
bzcr,wv;gUnr:edv,lzcr:ywr x> gUnr:edv,lzcr:nnr x edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nr
gL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr: yU,ywrx> kUwr:kzcr
cJnr:dzcr: anrgqwr,gbr:lUYr;g/nredv,lzcr:nnr xegv; edlo;tugr,simr:awr
hqdr:p/nr,dv, mugr xjumr:yU,ywr x>
3.3.3.3.3. pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:
pU;lTpTesamr,wv; ebv:awrgv;knrcJnr:dzcr:esbnrdI;yU, dznr;dv,
ededv,lzcr:esbU icrbU icrnnr xjJcr bzcr,wv;pU;hbr xbnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:yU,ywr x>pU;hbrxbnrdI;yU, dv,edv,lzcr:nnrx edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:<amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:yU,ywr x> kUwr:kzcrcJnr:dzcr:anrgqwr,gbr:lo;lzcr;bnrdI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:nnr xegv; edlo;k/mr,hubr;simr:awrhq qdr:p/nr,dv,mugr xjumr: yU,ywr x>
[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>
dI;yU,dv,edv,lzcr:anrwv;nnrx bqnrhUinr:< sumrx< tqcr< dI;linr<
dI;yU,swr:esdI;dI;esanr anr dznr;dv,edhqdr:b/credv,b/crlzcr:lo;
nnr x kwr;bv:mUdr:ywr x>]]]]]
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
45/70
45
4.4.4.4.4. pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:pU;mI:av,nv,esegv.egv. amr,nnr pU;mI:bunr;pznr:esegv.egv.
amr,nnr jwr;nv;dI;esegv.egv.nnrx hbr xawrcJnr:dzcr:dI;jwr;dQcr,b/cr
lzcr:es bnrakf/cr xhqdr:s/cr; b/crlzcr:gfv, H;ebv:bqnr bz o:edv,bz o:lzcr:gfv,nnr xbzcr,wv;pU; gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:ywr x> pU;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:no x edlo;tugr,awraey:bnrd/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:yU,ywrx> kUwr:kzcrcJnr:dzcr: anrgqwr,gbr:lUYr;lzcr;gqbr:kznr,b/crlzcr:nnrxedlo;tugr,simr: awrbqnrp/nr,dv,mugr xjumr:yU,ywr x>
5.5.5.5.5. pU;sU icr,simr:amrlbrxlzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:pU;sUicr,simr:amrlbrxlzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:pU;sU icr,simr:amrlbrxlzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:pU;sUicr,simr:amrlbrxlzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:pU;sUicr,simr:amrlbrxlzcr;g/nredv,g/nrlzcr:pU;lTpTesamr,wv; hU.hnrjzmr:lzcr;edv,lzcr:gU;bUicrbUicr amr,nnr
essmr,esbU icresywr x amr,bzcr,lQcr:bnr dI;pU;mI:bunr;pznr:< amr,nnrlumr:aubr xbU icr,< amr,nnr lumr:dQbr:ddr:Cdv:jU iwr:nnr xEl;scr awrsU: awrl/br;dI;pU;gqwr,kzcr;g/nredv,lzcr:jU iwr:nnrxEl;scr bzcr,wv;mI:d/cr:
pidr:El;edlo; k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr: amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrmqwr:yU,ywr x>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
46/70
46
kn] (8)
lWc]:tum].ti Uw]. KUw];KWc]El:tUw]sC ]
gUnr:esegv.egv.nnrx bUnrxbQnrpidr:bU icr;bgr:bUicrlgr:m/oesywrx d/cr:
hqdr:s/cr;mnr:nnrx gfv,dumrxdUiwrxesegv.egv. gqwr,lUYr;kUwr:kzcrEl;scr<
gqwr,lUYr; dUwrjTEl;scr egv.anrhqdr:s/cr;nnr x mI:d/cr:pidr:es tU igr;
d/nr,lIawraey:bnrd/mr,yU,ywrx> lzcrdumrxdUiwrxkUwr:kzcrnnrx mUinrncr,
lgr xawr< himrlibr:awr< jUnrawr jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x> lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xdUwrjTjJcrawrgUnr:d/o< jUnresywrxawrd/obv:gUnr:< gnrxjnrlUl/on/cr:yicr:
jgfv,jU iwr:no xywr x>
1.1.1.1.1. d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwrkUwr:kzcr>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwrkUwr:kzcr>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwrkUwr:kzcr>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwrkUwr:kzcr>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumrxdU iwrxnU iwrkUwr:kzcr>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) lzcr;lgr x>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; yU,dI;jwr;kzcrmnr:amr,hU.amr,hnrjzmr:eswo xjTamr,sJwr;amr,yUwr:esywr x aqnr:a/nr:awrkUwr:kzcranrk/o xlo;nnr x lQgr;l/o;dI;mnr:wo xjJcr bzcr,wv;bUnr xbQnrlzcr;lgr xywr x> pU;anrbUnr xbQnr lzcr;lgr xnnr xjJcr edlo;k/mr, d/mr,kzgr;tJcr(3)bI amr,nnr d/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrbU icryU,ywr x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) lzcr;lzgr,cJdr;esyznr:awrkUwr:kzcr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; lzgr,cJdr;hqdr:s/cr; H;gUwrymres yznr:awr
kUwr:kzcrdI;esegv.egv.jJcr bzcr,wv;lzgr,cJdr;esyznr:awrkUwr:kzcrywr x> pU;anrbUnrxbQnrlzcr;lzgr, cJdr;esyznr:awrkUwr:kzcrnnrxjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,
kzgr;esmqwr:mqwr:edv, tJcr (3) bI< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:szcrbU icryU,ywr x>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
47/70
47
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) lzcr;himrlibr:awr>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; lzgr,cJdr;esl/dr;wv; edhqdr:H;jwr;kzcr
nnrxd/o< amr,nnr hqdr:H;jqbr:sQbr,yT,nmrwv;noes yznr:awrkUwr:kzcr
tU igr;gv;dI;esegv.egv.jJcr bzcr,wv;himrlibr:awrywr x> pU;bUnr xbQnrlzcr;himrlibr:no xedlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:g/nrgL/mr:tJcr (10) bI< amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrbU icryU,ywr x>
(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) lzcr;jUnr
scrwv;pU;anrbUnrxbQnrlzcr;himrlibr:nnrx mI:gUnr:(5)egv.kJnr;nU iwrjJcr d/cr:hq rdr:kwrnnr x bzcr,wv;lzcr;jUnrywr x> pU;bUnr xbQnrlzcr;jUnrnnr xedlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;edv,jUwr; amr,nnr d/mr,kzgr;gJgr: g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(10)bIesamr,gv: d/mr,cJnr:egv;edlo;k/mr,bv:yU,ywr x>
2.2.2.2.2. d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwr dUwrjTgUnr:>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumrxdU iwr xnU iwr dUwrjTgUnr:>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwr dUwrjTgUnr:>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumrxdU iwr xnU iwr dUwrjTgUnr:>d/cr:pidr: lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xnU iwr dUwrjTgUnr:>
(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:>g.g.g.g.g. pU;lTpTesamr,wv; bQdr xlQnr amr,nnr awrcJnr:dzcr:bnr
dI;ebv;Em; amr,nnr pU;gumr:ticr:gUnr:esegv.egv.ywr xl/dr;wv; edhqdr:bnrlzcr;pznr:lIdznr;dv,gUnr:egv.nnrxnoes sUcr,azgr,nzgr;mU icr: a/br;bnresegv.egv.ywr x awrgv;knrmnr:jJcr bzcr,wv;gv.k/ogUnr:ywr x> pU;anrbUnr xbQnr
lzcr;gv.k/ogUnr:no x edlo;k/mr, d/mr,kzgr; g/nrgL/mr:tJcr (7)bI esywr xamr,gv:d/mr,cJnr:egv; edlo;k/mr,yU,ywr x>k.k.k.k.k. pU;lTpTesamr,wv; awrcJnr:bnrdI;ebv;Em; amr,nnr
gUnr:gumr:ticr:lugr;aznr,yicr: av,yU.(13)bIlUcr:dT;esywrx bQdrxlQnrwv;edsUcr,bnrdI;hqdr:g/nrlInoesywrx awrlugr;aznr,yicr:nnrx gfv,k/obnrdI;Wcr;g/nrk/odUwrnzgr;mU icr:jJcr bzcr,wv;gv.k/on/cr:yicr:gfv,nzgr;mU icr: awrhqdr:
bqnrEm;mzgr,yv;noywr x> pU;bUnr xbQnrawrn/cr:yicr: gfv,k/ohqdr:bqnrEm;mzgr,yv;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
48/70
48
no xjJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;tJcr (20) bI esywr xamr,gv: d/mr,cJnr:egv;edlo;k/mr,bv:yU,ywr x>
c.c.c.c.c. pU;lTpTesamr,wv; bQdrxlQnrawrcJnr:bnrdI;ebv;Em;
amr,nnr gUnr:gumr:ticr: lugr;aznr,j/o: anrav,yU.(15)bIlUcr:dT;essUcr,azgr,nzgr;mU icr: k/obnrH;awrjT. ncr,kv;libr:jJcr bzcr,wv;gv.k/olugr;aznr
awrbnrbU inr;hqdr:kv;ywr x> pU;bUnr xbQnrnnr x edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;edv,tJcr (20)
bIesamr,gv: d/mr,cJnr:egv;edlo;k/mr,bv:yU,ywr x>
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) lzcr;awrd/ogUnr:>pU;lTpTesamr,wv; aqnr:a/nr:dcr;jTesywrx hqdr:s/cr;es
anranr H;ebv:dumrxdUiwrx as/gr;< amr,nnrlzcr;jqbr:sQbr,tJcrdI;d/oedv,esegv.esgUnr:d/ojJcr bzcr,wv; awrd/ogUnr:ywrx> pU;bUnr xbQnr awrd/ogUnr:no x edlo;k/mr,d/mr,d/o< amr,nnrd/mr,kzgr;edv,jUwr;< amr,nnr d/mr,
kzgr;gJgr: g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(20)bI gJgr:bv:d/mr,cJnr:yU,ywr x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) lzcr;jUnres awrd/ogUnr:>scrwv;gUnr: (5) egv.kJnr;nU iwr bUnr xbQnrlzcr;jUnresywr x nT:kwres
egv.egv. awrd/omQnr; gUnr:jJcr gUnr:jUnrd/cr:sqcr;nnr x tugr,lo;k/mr,d/mr,d/o amr,nnrd/mr,kzgr;edv,jUwr; d/mr,kzgr;bv:g/nrgL/mr:tJcr(10)bIesywrx
amr,gv: d/mr,cJnr:egv;edlo; k/mr,yU,ywr x>
(4)(4)(4)(4)(4) lzcr;gnr xjnrlUl/on/cr:yicr:>g.g.g.g.g. gzbr;bUiwr;n/cr:yicr:amr,pzmrxlo;jTjzmr:< amr,nnrgUnr:anr
lUl/onnrx lzgr,cJdr;wv; edawrd/oEl;scr edhqdr:H;jqbr:sQbr,yT,nmr
El;scr bnrakf/crxpU;lUl/o< amr,nnrlo;jTgnrdcr:szcrp/oesdv.egv;gUnr:yicr:nnrxav,yU.amr,dqmr(13)bIjJcr bzcr,wv;gnrxjnrlUl/oywrx>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
49/70
49
pU;lTbUnr xbQnrlUl/on/cr:yicr:nnr x edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kz zgr;tJcr(10)bI amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:< amr,nnrd/mr,dcr:szcrbU icryU,ywr x>
k.k.k.k.k. yU,dI;gUnr:bqnrmU,bqnrpucresywrx bUnrxbQnrlzcr;gnrxjnr
lUl/on/cr:yicr:jJcr edlo;k/mr,d/mr,kzgr; tJcr (20) bI amr,nnrd/mr,cJnr:amr,nnr d/mr,dcr:szcrbU icryU,ywr x>
c.c.c.c.c. gUnr:egv.lqwrEl;scr gUnr:bqnrpucrbqnrjumr:El;scrbUnr xbQnrlzcr;gnr.jnr lUl/on/cr:yicr:nnr xesywr x awrd/obQdr;jJcr pU;bUnr xbQnrjU iwr:nnrx edlo;k/mr,d/mr,d/o amr,nnrd/mr,kzgr; edv,jUwr;esywrx
amr,gv: d/mr,cJnr:egv; edlo;k/mr,bv:yU,ywr x>
(5)(5)(5)(5)(5) lzcr;l/o:hqdr:s/cr; bUnr xbQnrbgr:bU icrgUnr:<g.g.g.g.g. yU,dI;gUnr:bqnrpucr (5)egv.kJnr;nU iwres jI xEn:wv; esegv.
egv.nnrx mI:d/cr:pidr:essmr,esbUicrwv;noes pzmrxgnrEbxginrlUl/oedv,tJcrpU;k/mr,En:nnr x tJcrdI;lo;d/ogfv,jJcr bzcr,wv;bUnr xbQnrbgr:bU icrgUnr:
ywr x> pU;kwr;bv:hqdr:s/cr; lzcr;bUnr xbQnr bgr:bU icrgUnr:d/cr:sqcr;nnr x edlo;k/mr, d/mr,d/omUdr:yU,ywr x>[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>
lzcrEbxginrlUl/o bUnr xbQnrbgr:bU icrgUnr:anrwv;nnr x mU inrncr, tznrbQdr;g/br,nqbrxdinr< nqbrxmJwr:< b/dr,bQdr;minr,hU< kU;ncr< dQcr:bzcr,bQdr;m/gr,dv<
dz o,kq rwr;hgr: jgfv,jU iwr:no xd/cr:sqcr;ywr x>]]]]]kkkkk. yU,dI;gUnr: (5)egv.kJnr;nUiwres pzmrxgnrlUl/on/cr:yicr:
egv.lqwredv,tJcr dI;ebv:lo;d/o< amr,nnr pzmr xgnrlUl/on/cr:yicr: anrmI:
snr,et,dzcr xlUcr< amr,nnrn/cr:yicr:av,yU.(13)bIlUcr:dT;nojJcr bzcr,wv;
hqdr:s/cr;bUnr xbQnrbgr:bU icrgUnr:ywr x> pU;bUnr xbQnr dcr:sqcr;nnr x edlo;k/mr,
d/mr,d/omUdr:yU,ywr x>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
50/70
50
c.c.c.c.c. yU,dI;gUnr:egv.nJcr;El;scr gUnr:nmrEl;scr lUl/olugr;aznr,yicr: av,yU. (7) kUbr,lUcr:dT;jJcr bzcr,wv;hqdr:s/cr;bUnr xbQnr bgr:bU icrgUnr:ywr xEl; edlo; k/mr,d/mr,kzgr;gJgr:bv:g/nrgL/mr: edv,jUwr;yU,ywr x>
[ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>ekv;sbr:lQcr:>scrwv;acr,gv,gUnr:j/o:nnrx lo;bUnr.bQnrgfv,dI;acr,gv,gUnr:yicr:jJcr
bzcr,wv;lzcr;lUl/onnr x tJcrdI;ywr x>]]]]]
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
51/70
51
kn] (9)
lWc]:Tic];SIm]; him];hgm]; (Environment)
Ed,awrmUiwr;sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mUicr:kwr hubr;simr:awrav,nv,jJcr;mUicr:mv:noxspv,whimr:Wmr:hwr:no xegv; lo;lU.sumr:gfv,dcr:nmrywr x> nmr xlinrhinrpvegv;gUnr,bcr:lU.lQwr< bv,tU inrbv,mo xegv; gqcr;b/cr,< dUwrsdr: ddr:jTegv; lU.h/od/o
nmr> dI;yU,dnr:swr:gJgr:bJnr:egv; lo;lU.bcr:gfv,dcr:nmr jgfv,jU iwr:no x ebv,mI:
mv:ywr xEl; lUwr,lo;aznrgnrEh.gcr; lUlzmrticr:simr:gfv,yU,EdxEdxywr x>
1.1.1.1.1. nmrxlinrhinrpv>nmrxlinrhinrpv>nmrxlinrhinrpv>nmrxlinrhinrpv>nmrxlinrhinrpv>(1)(1)(1)(1)(1) emv,sQcr< emv,cJnr:< emv,kmr:< emv,Eh; gU;mqwr:mqwr:< sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr
gfv,kudr:mv: jUcrawrgfv,Rdnv,tU igr;gv; nT:linrhwr:es awrkI;linr
(2)(2)(2)(2)(2) lzcr;hqdr:gU inr,p/onmr.>gzbr;bU iwr;wv; lUcrbzcrjJcr; lo;jT.dJwr:Fo:Fv.esywr x hqdr:gU inr,hqdr:
p/odqcrnmr xyJcr;es dumr xdU iwr x lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:hwr:mv: mI:dcr:nmrywr x>yznr xdqcrp/oes nmr xyJcr;kJnr;mv: awrho;nv:w/nr; jUmrh/ogfv,nT:nmr xEl; bv,mo xhUYr;tU inr,< mU,w/nr;hU inr:ey:< dI;yU,dnr:swr:gznr,mznr mU inrncr,Cpv:< gzcr:mU:<wdr.gGcr:< h/cr;ehv; jU iwr:no xlo;jUmrh/olU.lQwrgfv,jzmr:ywr x>
(3)(3)(3)(3)(3) lzcr;dumr xdU iwr xgqwr,lUYr;yv.lU.bU icrticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>
mUinrncr,yv.lU.bQdr; bUicrticr:simr:himr:Wmr:El; lo;dumrxdUiwrxmv:mI:yU,l/obU icrywr r r x> gzbr;bU iwr; jUcrkudr:awrkUwr:kzcrEl; lz olo;gUnr,bcr:es tUmr;bQdr;
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
52/70
52
hUYr;< Wcr;< nmr xnzcrnnr x hqdr:H;nmr xlUgr;lzmr. himr:Wmr:mUdr:< yv,sI,Fv.FUnregv; lQgr;l/o; dUwrsdr:ddr:jTanryU,jzmr:nT:nmr x
2.2.2.2.2. dUnr;tU inr,bv,mo x>dUnr;tU inr,bv,mo x>dUnr;tU inr,bv,mo x>dUnr;tU inr,bv,mo x>dUnr;tUinr,bv,mox>yznr xbU iwr;awrjTelv:pEd,cwr;esywr x dQbr:pnr:awrbv,mo xk/oEl;tJcrdI;
ebv:gqcr;lU imr;gfv,nnr xegv; dumr xdU iwr xlzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:EdxEdxywr x> gzbr;bU iwr;
wv; amr,pugr,dQnr:kJnr:bv,moxEl; dUwrsdr:ddr:jT anraicrbU icr;yU,jzmr:tU inr,bv,nnr xegv; lo;lU.h/od/ojzmr:yU,ywr x>yznr xbU iwr;dQbr:pqwr;bv,tU inr, gqcr;lU imr;bQdr;mUdr:El; dUnr;anraicrbJcr;
tU inr,mo xesazgr,jzmr:jU iwr:nnr xegv; lU.h/od/ojzmr:gfv,yU,ywr x> mU inr,ncr, anrbqnrdUnr;mzgr,< m/gr,< hUwrmo.< hUwrdzgr, mqwr:anrkwr;bqnryv;yv anrazgr,gUYr:nT:tU inr,nnrxegv; lo;jUmrh/ojzmr:gfv,yU,ywrx> anrbqnrkzcr spv,wtU igr;gv;
mU inrncr, mzgr, kmr:< mzgr,b/nr:es:b/nr:edv jgfv,jU iwr:no xegv; lo;lU.sumr:jzmr:yU,ywr x> kUwr:kzcranrazgr,jzmr:dUnr;tU inr,bv, mU inrncr, w/gr,bwr:dUwrsdr:ddr:jT>dUwrsdr:ddr:jT>dUwrsdr:ddr:jT>
gzbr;bUiwr;wv; amr,mI:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:El; dUwrsdr:ddr:jTanrlo;aicrbJcr;tU inr,mo x< nmr xnzcrjU iwr:nnrxegv; lo;lU.h/od/ojzmr:dcr:nmryU,ywr x> jU iwr:anramr,lU.amr,d/oegv; gzbr;bU iwr;amr,mI:dI;yU,dI;swr:ywr xEl;lo;y/o xk/o xhvaicrbJcr;hUmr;pUYr: d/cr,dI;d/cr,mU icr:gfv,egv; mI:dcr:nmrywr x>
dUwrsdr:anraicrbJcr;tUinr,bv, mUinrncr, j/crxtUinr,< sUiwr< jUcr<nUgr xgU;mqwr:mqwr:jU iwr:no x lo;y/o xb/o;kwr;jU:mU icr:himr:Wmr:mU inrncr, mU icr:to:< mU icr:l/wr:<
mU icr:Ek,< mU icr:glv: (ainr:dI:yU iwr:) jU iwr:no xsqcr;ywr x>
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
53/70
53
4.4.4.4.4. dI;yU,dnr:swr:muinr.gznr,dI;yU,dnr:swr:muinr.gznr,dI;yU,dnr:swr:muinr.gznr,dI;yU,dnr:swr:muinr.gznr,dI;yU,dnr:swr:mu inr.gznr,dI;yU,dnr:swr:mUiwr;gznr,mUiwr;mJnrx mUinrncr, hunr,h/cr;Cpv:bqnrjwr;<
gzcr:mU:< wdr xgGcr:< h/cr;ehvjwr;Fv. jU iwr:no xegv; gzbr;bU iwr;wv; amr,mI:lzcr;ticr:simr:
himr:Wmr:es lo;lU.lQwrgfv,jzmr:yU,ywr x>[[[[[^dI;dQgr;mnr:&
yznr xbU iwr;dqcrp/olUcrmU icr:b/o:El; mU,w/nr;< Ej;wqcr: yzcr;hUYr,< mU icr:jgz o,<j/mrgv: jU iwr:no xlo;tUmr;h/ogfv,El; kUwr:kzcrgJgr:bJnr:< dI;yU,dnr:swr:gznr,mJnr xhwr: lo;lU.lQwrjUmrh/ogfv,jzmr:yU,ywr x>
gzbr;bU iwr;wv;lUcrbzcrjJcr;sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr bUnr xbQnrlzcrticr:simr:himr:Wmr:nT:jJcr;do:hwr:no x mnr:bqnrpQnrg/nranrkwrdmr:w/cr:wo x lzcr;dv,pqwr;mUYr xj/wr:kUiwr:nnrxywrx> gzbr;nnrlzcr;lU.sumr:jUiwr:nox mI:bunr;pznr:nUiwrlUcrbzcrjJcr;sJgr:m/nr;kf/gr;mU icr:kwr dcr:sqcr;dcr:mUdr:ywr x>]]]]]
5.5.5.5.5. bunr;pznr:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>bunr;pznr:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>bunr;pznr:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>bunr;pznr:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>bunr;pznr:lzcr;ticr:simr:himr:Wmr:>
aicrnUiwrspv,whimr:Wmr: nT:juicr;do:hwr: lo;tugr,yv.dwr gUnr,mUYr.lU.lQwryU, ncr,wv;mv:no. ncr,hu iwrebv:edamr,su ibr,gfv,lo;tQcr;nnr x gUnr:mU icr:
juicr;do:hwr: gU;j/wr:kUiwr:gU;egv. mI:bunr;pznr: gQdr,EkEh.gcr; timr:simr:
lumr:lv:yU,ywr.>
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
54/70
54
KWc],SI,Aw]Ki un];si uc]:t};
kn] (10)nL:kan] Pa},Aup].pi Uc],kUn];mi Uc];"
1. kQp];Sa}ma} lc] hi Bn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t}; kU:pI"2. kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];yU,ki uk];hi Bn]; An]yU,nC ];si uc]:t}; kU:pI"3. hQt];pn] wC ]kp];tUw]kUn]; An]yU,nC ];si uc]:t}; hG ]:mI;w}.kU:ekL."4. Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk], nC ];wan]: nC ];Ai Uc], nC ];si uc]:mi Uc];"
5. yip];Tic]; Aup].pi Uc], nC ];wan]:'Ai Uc],'wQc];"6. SUn];tum]kUn];mi Uc];"7. kQp];KWn], nc],pk];pi Uc] KWc],SI,Aw]Ki un];si uc]:t}; tqp];tt];mk];mn]:w}."8. pUk];pWc]pn] hqc]; pa};pic],vL,nC ];mi Uc];El: nC ];wan]:'nC ];Ai Uc]," hG ]:luk]:AWn],
mi Uc];t}; emLlik]:El:mI;kCam];hB. Ki ut];kap]:pan]"9. pUk];pWc] pn] hqc]; Pa},yU,lI hG ]:mI;kU:wan]:kU:Ai Uc],"10. Tic];Sim];hk].SL pL,m}.El: KUw];KWc]tC ]:lin]ni Uw]lin] nc],hi bw]Ti Un],nm].
lin] hin]PLhw]; etAm],lU.lqw] hG ]:SPL,wmi Uc];t};hw]; hac]:lIKi un]:mL;"
(1) kQp];Sa}ma} lc]hi Bn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t};"(1) kQp];Sa}ma} lc]hi Bn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t};"(1) kQp];Sa}ma} lc] hiBn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t};"(1) kQp];Sa}ma} lc] hiBn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t};"(1) kQp];Sa}ma} lc] hi Bn];tm];lin] nC ];si uc]:t};"
1. nc],hi bw]ethB.Sa}ma}lc] hi Bn]; nC ];wan]:'Ai Uc],'si uc]:mi Uc]; nC ];mi Uc];t};pt];pi un].mI;kL:hi bw]"
2. lUw],Tt];Sac] hB.wL: kU:pIpInn]. Sa}ma}lc] hi Bn]; mn];tUw];'yWm];kL:hibw]"
3. lUw],l}:hB.wL: Ka}.pa}:kC L,yU,tI:lC ] wan]:lC ] Ai Uc],lC ] mi Uc];lC ] El:etl}:hB.pL; lWc]:tac];mn];"
4. Ka}.wan]:kC L,wan]:ni uc]:yw].wan]:ni uc]:nn]. lUw],l}:yWn];AKCac].
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
55/70
55
wan]:'Ai Uc],yw]. lW };pL;Sa}ma}lc] hi Bn];Kw]:/AWk],wan]:sWm];"5. Sa}ma}lc] hi Bn];tm];n}. epL;pUk];Sw] hi Bn];yU,hc];eKLyw]. hBm]:Kw]:
ey;lQw]kn]ekL: etl}:SWn],pQn]SWc] hi Bn];yU,yw]." hi Bn];lQw]
Am],mk];mn]:l}:"6.6.6.6.6. gUnr:yU,swr:nT:w/nr;d/cr:sqcr; dgr:edlo;mI:wo x wTgJgr:hU inr:(Sa}ma}
gUnr:nT:hU inr:)El; wTgJgr:dUwr(m/dr;bucr,d/cr,)anrkunrm/nr;hqdr:
bnr anrbqnrs/om/ogUnr:gJgr:mU icr:nonnr xdcr:sqcr; scrwv;Kun]man]:
amr,hqdr:bnregv; gUnr:lUcrw/nr;nnrP dgr:edlo;hqdr:wo x Sa}ma}
gUnr:hU inr:lr fhU inr:nnr xEl; wTgUnr:w/nr;dUwrgwr,nnr xwo xdcr:sqcr;>7.7.7.7.7. mU iwr;anrhU. s/om/o gUnr:w/nr;ywr xnnr x edlo; jQgr,t/nr; av,yU.
b/nrlTb/nrnnr xes edlo;H;kwr;bv: h/br,bunr;pznr:wo xnT: @@jumr:nv;w/nr;##yU,ywr x> jumr:nv;w/nr;nnr x bqnr jumr:j/o:yicr:< jumr:j/o:c/nrw/nr; El; jumr:twr;w/nr;
(2) kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];ki uk];hi Bn]; An]yU,nC ];mi Uc];si uc]:t};"(2) kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];ki uk];hiBn]; An]yU,nC];mi Uc];si uc]:t};"(2) kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];ki uk];hi Bn]; An]yU,nC ];mi Uc];siuc]:t};"(2) kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];ki uk];hi Bn]; An]yU,nC];mi Uc];si uc]:t};"(2) kQp];Sa}ma} kUn];ki uk];hi Bn]; An]yU,nC ];miUc];si uc]:t};"1. kUn];epL;kU it],hn]nL:mL; l}:(1)li Un]yw]. ti un];lUw],SUc],Sa}ma}
hQt];wC ]ki Ut], ki uk];hi Bn];w}."2. kUn];nC ];hi Bn];mI;la}ekL. tUw];yWm];kL:hi bw] lUw],SUc],Sa}ma} tI:wan]:'Ai Uc],
sWm];kU:pI"3. kUn];nC ];hi Bn];tUw];yWm]; Am],SUc],Sa}ma}nn]. epL;Tt];hB.mL; nC ];hi Bn];
nn]. cw]:hi Bn];etl}:Ek:K} mI;tam],hgn];Pi un];kzc];(3)wL;"4. Sa}ma}kUn];n}. etl}:mI;"
(1)siuw]:epL: (2)si uw]:Em: (3)tI:ki Ut], (4)pIki Ut],
(5)saw];Ki Uw];Sc] (6)luk].lC ]mL;yU, (7)hQt];kin]kan]Sc]
-
8/20/2019 Rcss Rule of Law
56/70
56
(8)np].Ti uw]SL,SnL,Sc]"(3) Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk],"(3) Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk],"(3) Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk],"(3) Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk],"(3) Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk],"
1. etl}:Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:/AWk], nC ];wan]:Ai Uc],"
2. etl}:pWc],lqc]; kUn];mL;nWn];hQt];Kqk]," nC ];hi Bn];Kqk],nn]. si uw]:SQc]'tI:yU,'mL;hQt];Sc]'etSi up],kC L,lC ] hG ]:pWc],lqc];tqt]:etL;" epL;AWk],yw].ekL: lUw],pWc],El: EnKi un];wL: Kqk],AWk],mi Uw];yw]."
3. kUn];AWk],kC L,hLkL.Ka} hLhQt];kan]nWk]:Ai Uc],nWk]:mi Uc]; nWn];Ki un];nWn];li Un]nn]. lUw],l}:pWc],lqc];kac].'Ai Uc]," kC L,tac];lC ] mi Uc];lC ]n}
hG ]:hB.lWc]:tac];kUn];kC L," epL;mI;pn] hLha}mL;ekL: sac]:Tt];Sac]ca}:"4. kUn];nWk]:mi Uc]; Kw]:mL;nC ];mi Uc]; lUw],l}:Tt];Sac]wC ]AWk],tac];Kw]pQn]kUn];mi Uc];lC ] etkC L,lC ] kC L,hQt];Sc] PC ] hgc].mL; etkC L,sU;PC ]mI;kan]Sc] lUw],l}:tWc]:Tam] hG ]:tqt]:etL;yw].pWc],lqc];pn]Kic];kac].'Kic];hQc]'sw]:nL:tI:Aup].pi Uc],km];lQw]"
5. kUn];nC ];wan]:nC ];Ai Uc], lUw],l}:Tt];kUn];Kw]:/AWk],wan]:'Ai Uc], epL;
mI;kUn];pqk],nL:Kw]:mL; nC ];wan]:nC ];Ai Uc],si uc] etl}:hgc].sa};can]wan]:kum];Tic];w}.yw]. pWc],lqc];kUn];PU:mI;pun]:PWn];nC ];wan]:km];lQw]"
6. etl}:mI;pp].Tt];Sac] kUn];Kw]:AWk],nC ];wan]:nC ];Ai Uc],w}. kU:wan]:kU:Ai Uc]," ni uc]:li Un]lUw],Tt];Sac] tac],sw]:nL:tI:(1)pWk]: lWc]:wL:kUn];Kw]:AWk],wan]:'Ai Uc], mI;kL:hi bw]"
tL,tWc];"tL,tWc];"tL,tWc];"tL,tWc];"tL,tWc];" kUn];nC ];wan]:lQw]'Ai Uc],lQw