Download - Report Zzz
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
1/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
CANON 21
TEJANO, TIONGCO, VALDEZLegal ProfessionAtty. Fina Tantuico
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
2/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
CANON 21: A lawyer shallpreserve the confidence
and secrets of his clienteven after the attorney-client relationship is
terminated.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
3/59
3/18/13
Duty to preserve clientsconfidenceNeither attorney nor client nor anyone whostands in a peculiar relation of confidencewith either of them can be compelled todisclose any privileged communication.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
4/59
3/18/13
Duration of duty
General rule: PERPETUAL Outlasts:
Professional employment
Death of client
Exception: Some privileged communicationslose privilege character by somesupervening act pursuant to the purpose ofcommunication Communication intended to be sent to 3rd person
loses privilege character upon reaching 3rdperson
Pleading privileged before but not after filing
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
5/59
3/18/13
Reason for the rule
Two reasons: To encourage a client to make full disclosure to his
attorney in matters affecting his rights andobligations.
Information secured from client is sacred to legalemployment.
Privilege is founded on public policy Benefits justify the risk of unjust decisions due to
suppression of evidence.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
6/59
3/18/13
Requisites of privilege
Attorney-client relationshipCommunication between client & attorney
Communication of client to attorney; or Legal advice of attorney to client
ConfidentialityDuring professional employment
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
7/593/18/13
Requisites of privilege
Question of privilege is for the court todetermine, considering: Nature of suit Circumstances & conditions of questions Circumstances & conditions of answers
Party asserting privilege has burden of proof Unless it appears from the face of the document
that it is privileged
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
8/593/18/13
Attorney-clientrelationshipGeneral rule: No privilege for
communication between client and non-lawyer Exception: If person poses as a lawyer
Must be the reason for client to make thecommunication
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
9/593/18/13
Confidentiality
Mere attorney-client relationship does notraise presumption of confidentiality Client should have intended the communication to
be confidential
Privilege not destroyed by eavesdropperPrivilege not destroyed by representation
later of client by other attorney
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
10/59
3/18/13
Form of communication
Not only oral or written, but also signs orother means of communication
Communication may be transmitted byagency
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
11/59
3/18/13
Persons entitled to claimprivilegePersons covered by privilege:
Attorney Client Attorneys secretary, stenographer, clerk Interpreter, messenger, other agent of
transmission of communication Experts hired for effective communication
between attorney and client, e.g. accountant,
scientist, engineer, physician
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
12/59
3/18/13
Persons entitled to claimprivilegePrivilege primarily for client, incidentally for
attorney Client is entitled primarily to assert privilege
For attorneys secretary, stenographer, or
clerk to reveal, client and attorney mustwaive privilege
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
13/59
3/18/13
Application of rule
Attorney may legally refuse to testify onlyon privileged but not unprivilegedcommunication
However, attorney may not volunteer bothprivileged and unprivileged communication
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
14/59
3/18/13
Privileged matters
Work product contained in filesDocument privileged upon delivery to
attorney still privileged when with clientCrimes or frauds committed in the past
Not crimes or frauds being committed or about tobe committed
Identity and name of client
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
15/59
3/18/13
Unprivileged matters
Any communication lacking any requisiteLetter not made in the course of judicial
proceedingsUnprivileged document delivered to
attorneyCommunications concerning creation of
attorney-client relationship
Contracts relating to attorneys fees
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
16/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
RULE 21.01. Lawyer shall
not reveal clientsconfidence
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
17/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.01
A lawyer shall not reveal the confidence orsecrets of his client except:
a) When authorized by the client afteracquainting him of the consequences of thedisclosure;
b) When required by law;
c) When necessary to collect his fees or todefend himself, his employees or associates
or by judicial action.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
18/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.01
If lawyer requested for some records andopposing counsel sent even confidentialfiles, lawyer must withdraw from action
If witness is third party who illegallyacquired privileged communication fromother party, opposing counsel cannot usesuch witness
Lawyer may not disclose clients funds toclients creditor for attachment
Lawyer may disclose to corporationsdirectors
If client confides perjury, attorney shouldretire from the case
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
19/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.01
Exceptions Authorized by client
Attorneys implied power of waiver
No partial waiver
Required by law Necessary to collect fees or defend himself Additional: commission of contemplated crime or
fraud
Solution: restrain client
If client does not know the act/omission is a crimeand therefore desists upon knowledge: covered byprivilege
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
20/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
RULE 21.02. Lawyer shall
not use clients secretswithout consent
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
21/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.02
A lawyer shall not, to the disadvantage ofhis client, use information acquired in thecourse of employment, nor shall he use thesame to his advantage or that of a third
person, unless the client with full knowledgeof the circumstances consents thereto.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
22/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.02
Lawyer may use privileged information tothe disadvantage of client only when: Client consented Collecting fees Defending self, employee, or associate
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
23/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
RULE 21.03. Lawyer shall
not give informationfrom his files
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
24/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.03
A lawyer shall not, without the writtenconsent of his client, give information fromhis files to an outside agency seeking suchinformation for auditing, statistical,
bookkeeping, accounting, data processing,or any similar purpose.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
25/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
RULE 21.04. Lawyer maydisclose to partners
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
26/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.04
A lawyer may disclose the affairs of a clientof the firm to partners or associates thereofunless prohibited by the client.
Partners and associates of a law firm are
considered one person
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
27/59
Click to edit Master subtitle style
3/18/13
RULE 21.05. Lawyer shall
adopt measures againstdisclosure
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
28/59
3/18/13
RULE 21.05
A lawyer shall adopt such measures asmay be required to prevent those whoseservices are utilized by him, from disclosingor using confidences or secrets of the
client.Lawyer must prevent leaks of privileged
communication known by clerical aids andhired experts
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
29/59
3/18/13
Canon 21: Preservation ofClient's Confidence Involves the application of rules of
evidence and of professional ethics, bothof which seeks to safeguard the client'sconfidence
Duration of the duty perpetual, unlessremoved by the client himself or hisrepresentatives or heirs. Anything which may injure the client Disclose information acquired in a professional
capacity
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
30/59
3/18/13
Canon 21: Preservation ofClient's Confidence Reason for the Rule
Adequate legal representation requires a fulldisclosure of the facts by the client to hisattorney. Without the privilege, the client will
withhold information that he thinks to beunfavorable.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
31/59
3/18/13
Canon 21: Preservation ofClient's Confidence
Requisites of the Rule
The attorney-client privilege exists where legaladvice of any kind is sought form an attorney inhis professional capacity with respect tocommunications relating to that purpose, madein confidence by the client so as to permanentlyprotect such communication from disclosure by
himself or by the attorney, unless the privilegeis waived.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
32/59
3/18/13
Canon 21: Preservation ofClient's Confidence Requires an attorney client relationship The mere relation of attorney and client
does not raise the presumption of
confidentiality The client must haveintended the communication to beconfidential.
Any form or mode
Extended to experts and clerks
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
33/59
3/18/13
Other Applicable Rules
Rule 138, Rules of Court Section 20. Duties of attorneys - It is the duty of
an attorney: (e) To maintain inviolate the confidence, and at
every peril to himself, to preserve the secrets ofhis client, and to accept no compensation inconnection with his clients business except fromhm or with his knowledge and approval.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
34/59
3/18/13
Other Applicable Rules
Rule 130, Rules of Court Section 24 (b)
An attorney cannot, without the consent of hisclient, be examined as to any communication
made by the client to him, or his advice giventhereon in the course of, or with a view to ,professional employment, nor can an attorneyssecretary, stenographer, or clerk be examined,without the consent of the client and his
employer, concerning any fact the knowledge ofwhich has been acquired in such capacity.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
35/59
3/18/13
Other Applicable Rules
Art. 208, Revised Penal Code:Prosecution of offenses; negligence and
tolerance. - The penalty of prision correccionalin its minimum period and suspension shall be
imposed upon any public officers or officer ofthe law, who , in dereliction of the duties of hisoffice, shall maliciously refrain from institutingprosecution for the punishment of violators ofthe law, or shall tolerate the commission of
offenses.
Art 208: Prosecution of
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
36/59
3/18/13
Art. 208: Prosecution ofOffenses; negligence and
tolerance. Acts punishable: By maliciously refraining from instituting
prosecution against violators of the law. By maliciously tolerating the commission of
offenses. Negligence here means neglect of the
duties of his office. Malice is an important element.
Art 208 Prosecution of
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
37/59
3/18/13
Art. 208. Prosecution ofOffenses; negligence and
tolerance. Elements of dereliction of duty in theprosecution of offenses: Offender is a public officer or officer of the law
who has a duty to cause the prosecution of
offenses. There is dereliction of the duties of his office,
i.e., knowing the commission of the crime, hedoes not cause the prosecution of the criminal,
or, knowing that a crime is to be committed, hetolerates its commission.
Art 208 Prosecution of
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
38/59
3/18/13
Art. 208. Prosecution ofOffenses; negligence and
tolerance. Applies to public officers and officers of thelaw with duty to prosecute.
The fiscal or prosecutor, is under no
compulsion to file information where he isnot convinced that the evidence warrantsthe filing of an action.
A dereliction of duty caused by poorjudgment or honest mistake is not
punishable. Crime must be proved before conviction for
dereliction
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
39/59
3/18/13
Other Applicable Laws
Art. 209, Revised Penal Code:Betrayal of trust by an attorney or solicitor. -
Revelation of secrets. - ... any attorney-at-lawor solicitor who, by any malicious breach of
professional duty or of inexcusable negligenceor ignorance, shall prejudice his client, or revealany of the secrets of the latter learned by himin his professional capacity. xxx (or) who,having undertaken the defense of a client or
having received confidential information fromsaid client in a case, shall undertake thedefense of the opposing party in the samecase, without the consent of his first client.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
40/59
3/18/13
Rule 21.06
A lawyer shall not avoid indiscreetconversations about a client's affairs evenwith members of his family. Intended to better preserve the client's
confidence and secrets. Indiscreet conversation can result in prejudice
to the client and will lessen the respect due thelegal profession.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
41/59
3/18/13
Rule 21.07
A lawyer shall not reveal that he has beenconsulted about a particular case except toavoid possible conflict of interests. Rule on privileged communication applies to
matters disclosed to a layer by a prospectiveclient.
Reason: disclosure and the lawyer's opinionscreate an attorney-client relationship , even
though the lawyer does not eventually acceptthe employment.
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
42/59
3/18/13
FACTS:On 4/23/1945, Blandina Gamboa Hilado (Hilado) brought
an action against Selim Jacob Assad to ANNUL the sale ofseveral houses and lots executed by the deceased Mr.Hilado
On 1/28/1946, defendant Atty. Vicente Francisco (Dizon)entered as attorney of record for Assad. Atty. Dizon, counselfor petitioner, urged him to discontinue representing Assad
Apparently Hilado communicated Francisco prior to thecase, submitting expedientes, to which the latter gave hiswritten opinion
Hilado filed a motion for disqualification against Francisco
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
43/59
3/18/13
FACTS FOR THE DEFENSE:A real estate broker introduced Hilados case to him, but
averred he would rather take the Syrians cause
Petitioners case was as lost cause; Torrens title was in
her husbands name Hilado came in with the expediente of her case, which
Francisco returned
He took Assads case when the latters lawyer went abroad
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
44/59
3/18/13
ISSUE:
Was there an attorney-client relationshipestablished between Hilado and Francisco?
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
45/59
3/18/13
HELD: Motion for disqualification ALLOWEDRATIO:
q Professional attorney-client relationship established whenattorney is employed eitherto give advice upon a legal
point, to prosecute or defend an action in a court of justice,or to prepare and draft, in legal form such papers as deeds,bills, contracts and the like (Atkinson v. Howlett)
q Not necessary that client should have employed theattorney professionally on any previous occasion; immaterialwhether the attorney took up the case on which he was
consulted forq Attorney is employed when he is engaged in his professional
capacity as a lawyer or counselor when he is listening to hisclients preliminary statement of his case, or when he isgiving advice thereon
q Formality not an essential element of the employment of an
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
46/59
3/18/13
HELD: Motion for Disqualification ALLOWEDRATIO:q that only copies of pleadings were furnished
by Hilado is immaterial; nature of papers,
either public/private, does not matterbecause mere relation of attorney and clientought to preclude the attorney fromaccepting opposing partys retainer
q To make the passing of confidentialcommunication a condition precedent; i.e. tomake the employment conditioned on thescope and character of the knowledgeacquired by an attorney in determining his
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
47/59
3/18/13
HELD: Motion for Disqualification ALLOWEDRATIO:q retaining fee a preliminary fee given to
an attorney or counsel to insure and secure
his future services, and induce him to act forthe client
q Even if Francisco did not read the copy ofproceedings, the fact that he gave hisprofessional advice on the matter, fromwherein arose the attorney-clientrelationship
q Petitioners objection only after (4) monthsfrom the date Francisco first a eared for
HILADO v. DAVID
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
48/59
3/18/13
FACTS for PROSECUTION:On July 1992, Atty. Essex Silapan asked William Genato if
he could rent a small office space in the latters bulding inQC
Silapan thereupon handled most of complainants cases
start of attorney-client relationship
Respondent borrowed P200,000 for the downpayment of acar. Respondent issued a P176,528 postdated check toanswer for (6) mos. interest on the loan. Also mortgagedhis house in QC but did not surrender title to complainant.
Respondent purchased new car; title was in the name ofcomplainant
January 1993, respondent introduced complainant to acertain Emmanuel Romero, who borrowed money fromcomplainant.
Respondent earned commission from the transaction, used
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
49/59
3/18/13
FACTS for PROSECUTION: Respondent failed to pay for his cars amortization
Respondents postdated checks bounced
Complainant filed a criminal case for violation ofB.P. 22
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
50/59
3/18/13
RESPONDENT: Complainant was involved in shady deals and shark loans
Complainant wanted respondent to bribe members of theDOJ (judge, prosecutor) to acquit him in his criminal case
It was complainant who offered the office space andengaged his legal services
Real estate mortgage was only a formal requiremet so hecould obtain P200,000 loan
Postdated check was some kind of acknowledgment forattorneys fees and a form of assurance that he wont
abandon complainants case Commission from Romero was in fact attorneys fees from
the latter
IBP: respondent guilty; suspended for (1) year
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
51/59
3/18/13
ISSUE:
Whether respondent committed a breach oftrust and confidence by imputing to
complainant illegal practices and disclosingcomplainants alleged intention to bribe govt
officials in connection with a pending case
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
52/59
3/18/13
HELD: IBP Resolution AFFIRMED withMODIFICATION; (6) months SUSPENSION
q Canon 17: A lawyer owes fidelity to the
cause of his client and shal be mindful ofthe trust and confidence reposed on him.
q GENERAL RULE: An attorney is NOTpermitted to disclose communications madeto him in his professional character by aclient, unless the latter consents.
q Protection is afforded the clients secrets atthe inception of the relationship; protectionis er etual and does not cease with
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
53/59
3/18/13
HELD: IBP Resolution AFFIRMED withMODIFICATION; (6) months SUSPENSION
q HOWEVER, such privilege against disclosure
of confidential communications orinformation limited only to communicationswhich are legitimately and properly withinthe scope of a lawful employment of the
lawyerq Does not extend to those made in
contemplation of a crime or perpetration ofa fraud
q IF unlawful ur ose is avowed
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
54/59
3/18/13
HELD: IBP Resolution AFFIRMED withMODIFICATION; (6) months SUSPENSION
q Respondents disclosures were immaterial
to the case and are thus disregardedq Such statements were not the subject
matter of litigation for foreclosure caseqTo disclose such was a breach of fidelity
sufficient to warrant (6) months ofsuspension
GENATO v. SILAPAN
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
55/59
3/18/13
RECOMMENDED VIEWING(because summer is near and
torrents are free)
Primal Fear
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
56/59
3/18/13
RECOMMENDED VIEWING(because summer is near and
torrents are free)
The Good Wife
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
57/59
3/18/13
RECOMMENDED VIEWING(because summer is near and
torrents are free)
The Lincoln Lawyer
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
58/59
3/18/13
RECOMMENDED VIEWING(because summer is near and
torrents are free)
Legally Blonde
-
7/29/2019 Report Zzz
59/59
RECOMMENDED VIEWING(because summer is near and
torrents are free)
Breaking Bad
The Practice