![Page 1: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
June 14, 2016 Lake Elsinore/Canyon Lake Task Force Meeting
Revision of the Lake Elsinore & Canyon Lake Nutrient TMDL
CDM Smith Team & Risk Sciences
Chapter 3: Numeric Targets Chapter 4: Source Assessment
![Page 2: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Presentation Outline
• Project Progress/Status • Estimation of Potential Lake Elsinore Numeric Targets • Canyon Lake Model Results • Paleolimnology Study • Source Assessment
![Page 3: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Project Schedule 2020
J F M A M J J A S O N DJan-Mar
Apr - June
July - Sept
Oct - Dec
Jan-Mar
Apr - June
July - Sept
Oct - Dec
Jan-Mar
Apr - June
July - Sept
Oct - Dec
Jan-Mar
1.1 Introduction1.2 Problem Statement1.3 Numeric Target (Response)1.3 Numeric Target (Causal)1.4 Source Analysis1.5 Linkage Analysis1.6 WLA & LA1.7 Implementation Plan1.8 Monitoring Program1.9 References
2 CEQA - SED Analysis3 Economics Analysis4 Administrative Record5 Basin Plan Amendment Pkg6 Task Force Coordination
Scientific Peer ReviewRB Staff ReportRB Workshop & Request for CommentResponse to Public CommentsRB Hearing to Consider Adoption of BPAResponse to Public Comments to State BoardState Board Hearing for BPASubmit BPA to OALOAL Review CompleteSubmit BPA to EPA
2016 2017 2018 2019
Regi
onal
Boa
rd (R
B) T
asks
1
Complete Technical Document
TasksSub-tasks
Activity
- 1st Draft Deliverable
- 2nd Draft Deliverable
- Final Deliverable
- RB Deliverables/Actions
![Page 4: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Historical Records Search - Acquired • Engineering Science, LEMA, Final Environmental Assessment: Proposed LEMP 11/1/1984 • Chambers Group, LEMA, Draft EIR: East Lake Specific Plan, 2/1/1993 • Engineering Science, LEMA, Final EIR/ Environmental Assessment: Proposed Lake
Management 1/1/1988 • Army Corp of Engineers (ACOE), LEMA, Final Environmental Assessment Lake Elsinore
Project , 6/1/1988 • Army Corp of Engineer (ACOE), LEMA, Lake Elsinore Small Flood Control Project Authority
Definite Project Report, 4/1/1987 • Engineering Science, LEMA, Preliminary Proposed Mitigation Plan for the Elsinore Lake
Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications, Elsinore Basin, 2/1/1953 • SWRCB, Bulletin No. 9, Elsinore Basin, 2/1/1953 • Glenn Lukos Association, LEMA, Army Corp of Engineers Permitting Requirements Behind
Levee, 3/25/1993
![Page 5: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Historical Records Search – In Search Mode
• Army Corps of Engineers 404 Permit • State 401 Certification • Lake Alteration (1603) Permit from California Fish & Game
![Page 6: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
NUMERIC TARGETS FOR LAKE ELSINORE
6
![Page 7: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Lake Elsinore Chlorophyll-a Revisited
• Narrative water quality objective – “Waste discharges shall not contribute to excessive algal growth in inland
surface receiving waters”
• Chlorophyll-a is a measure of algae • What constitutes excessive is highly variable and driven by multi-
decadal hydrologic patterns – 10-yr averaging period may not be appropriate
• Consider other alternatives to setting numeric targets – Use of tiers based on TDS – Much longer averaging periods
![Page 8: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Lake Elsinore Chlorophyll-a Revisited
• Predevelopment scenario to set a reference watershed numeric target
• Median daily chlorophyll-a is 75 µg/L
• Averaging period to account for full range of hydrologies
![Page 9: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Lake Elsinore Chlorophyll-a Revisited
• Averaging period: 1-year rolling geomeans
100 year geomean
Predevelopment Scenario
![Page 10: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Lake Elsinore Chlorophyll-a Revisited
• Averaging period: 10-year rolling geomeans
100 year geomean
Predevelopment Scenario
![Page 11: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Lake Elsinore Chlorophyll-a Revisited
• 1-yr geomean
comparison plot • 10-yr geomean
from 2003-12 – Predeveloped
model: 102 µg/L – Monitoring Data
(n=177) at LEE2: 106 µg/L
• Existing BMPs are making progress toward natural condition
1-yr rolling geomeans
![Page 12: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
NUMERIC TARGETS FOR CANYON LAKE
12
![Page 13: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Numeric Target Development
• Set numeric targets that represent a state that is equal to or better than that which occurs naturally
• Consideration of the entire hydrologic variability of external loads • Water quality model (CAEDYM) to characterize long term dynamics of
nutrients and biological communities • Hydrodynamic model to separate lake distinct lake segments and to
accurately represent exchanges between segments and overflows to Lake Elsinore
![Page 14: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Canyon Lake Target Development
• ELCOM-CAEDYM model development ongoing
• Preliminary results for all constituents complete
• Simulation developed for a predeveloped nutrient loading scenario
![Page 15: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Canyon Lake Target Development
• Severe algae blooms occur in predeveloped scenario
• Greatest Chl-a immediately following wet season
• Maximum runoff volume retained within CL in 2003
Main Lake
East Bay
Wet weather inflow
![Page 16: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Canyon Lake Target Development
• Main Lake shows N-limitation
• External N inputs and retention are most important External-N
Internal-N
Turnover
![Page 17: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Canyon Lake Target Development
• Less evidence of P-limitation in Main Lake
• Phosphorus concentrations are persistently high
• No correlation with P and Chl-a
![Page 18: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Canyon Lake Target Development
• East Bay has persistently high Chl-a following wet season in predevelopment scenario results
• Decline in wet season from flushing
![Page 19: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
PALEOLIMNOLOGY STUDY
19
![Page 20: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Paleolimnology Study
• Paleolimnology study results provide an additional line of evidence to describe naturally occurring water quality (basis for TMDL)
• Developing a Baseline of Natural Lake Level / Hydrologic Variability and Understanding Past Versus Present Lake Productivity over the Late-Holocene: A Paleo-Perspective for Management of Modern Lake Elsinore (Kirby et al., 2005)
• Task Force commissioned a study to collect sediment cores to assess cumulative benefits of in-lake nutrient management (Anderson, 2016)
![Page 21: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Paleolimnology Studies
10 cm ~ 100 yrs • Aging model based on carbon isotopes
![Page 22: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Key Findings
• Multi-decadal and centennial scale climate variability measured by oxygen isotopes (O-18 composition a function of Precip:Evap ratio)
• Currently in a wet cycle, which can include extended drought
![Page 23: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Key Findings
• Historical estimation of sediment nutrients in Lake Elsinore
Years Before Present Day
![Page 24: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Key Findings
• Anthropogenic impacts have affected trophic status • Change in nutrients supports assumptions for predevelopment model
• Recent LE inflow monitoring 2-3 times greater nutrients than reference watershed
![Page 25: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Key Findings
• TP in sediment cores collected in 2014 from top 50 cm
• Representative of modern developed watershed
• Sediment TP in 1,000 – 1,500 mg/kg range
Core Stations
![Page 26: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
SOURCE ASSESSMENT
26
![Page 27: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Key Elements of Source Assessment
• External Sources – Watershed nutrient washoff – Overflows from Mystic Lake – Septic systems – Nutrient attenuation – Reclaimed water
• Internal Sources – Internal sediment nutrient flux – Resuspension – Atmospheric deposition – Nitrogen fixation – Evapo-concentration
![Page 28: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Watershed Nutrient Washoff
• LSPC model used for TMDL and 2010 Update – Buildup / washoff of nutrients – Complex, costly to develop – Only as good as data and modeler
• TMDL revision to use a simplified approach – Data driven – Clearly defined and referenced unit area loading rates – Transparent and explicit quantifications of watershed specific conditions (e.g.
nutrient attenuation, runoff retention)
![Page 29: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Simplified Approach
• Leverage continuous historical hydrologic data
![Page 30: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Simplified Approach
• Use extensive monitoring results from watershed monitoring program since 2007 (n=25 storm events)
![Page 31: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Simplified Approach
• Interpolation of nutrient concentrations to estimate annual loads
![Page 32: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Washoff from Unique Land Cover Types
• Nutrient washoff from watershed lands is key for allocation of estimated downstream loads to upstream jurisdictions
• From Beaulac and Reckhow (1982): – As watersheds shift from natural, undisturbed conditions to increasing levels of human
disturbance, the ecological mechanisms controlling nutrient flux become more complex and less understood. Therefore, the ability to accurately quantify or predict interactions between land use and aquatic conditions or responses becomes less precise and more uncertain
– For management of water resources, the use of nutrient loading coefficients for predicting changes in water quality conditions that follow changing land use is highly subjective. To reduce uncertainty in this use, the user of these coefficients must be familiar with the biogeochemical processes that influence nutrient fluxes
• Simplified approach to focus on specific biogeochemical processes by leveraging current scientific understanding
![Page 33: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Phosphorus Washoff Rates in 2010 LSPC Update
Note: Dairy / CAFO not shown
![Page 34: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
Nitrogen Washoff Rates in 2010 LSPC Update
Note: Dairy / CAFO not shown
![Page 35: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
Comparison with Literature Values
Land Use CL / LE LSPC Model Average reported in
Reckhow et al., 1980
TP TN TP TN
Irrigated Cropland 0.08 0.13 1.81 6.51
Non-Irrigated Cropland 0.08 0.13 0.44 2.10
Orchards/Vineyards 0.09 0.14 1.46 1.94
Pasture/Hay 0.06 0.07 0.61 3.50
Urban 0.01 0.03 0.77 4.04
High-Density Residential 0.06 0.31
Med-Density Residential 0.07 0.47
Low-Density Residential 0.08 0.50
Open Space 0.03 0.17
Forested 0.01 0.03 0.10 1.16
![Page 36: Revision of the Lake Elsinore & CDM Smith Team & Risk ......Jun 14, 2016 · Management Plan, 5/1/1987 • SWRCB, Useful Waters for California, 11/31/1967 • SWRCB, California Publications,](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022050103/5f423841f22e18517351d7bd/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Washoff from Unique Land Cover Types
• LSPC calibration focused on adjustment to empirical buildup/washoff washoff coefficients
• Simplified approach based on nutrient balance with each source/sink developed independently – Update washoff rates based on higher reference values – Maintain single washoff rate for distinct land uses across all jurisdictions – Quantify in-stream nutrient attenuation and assign credit by jurisdiction
based on travel time to lake inflow – Separate nutrient budgets for Salt Creek – East Bay and San Jacinto River –
Main Lake