PT 168 Benoa
Semester Report of
Seafood Savers Membership
Summary of improvement development Handline Tuna, Malang, East Java January 2016 - Juni 2016 Muhammad Maskur Tamanyira – Seafood Savers Officer
General Information
1.
Location : Coastal Fishing Port (PPP) Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, Malang, East Java
First Surey : April 2015
Number of farmers/fishermen : The number of total fleets that were recorded as active members of PT. 168 Benoa supply chain in 2015 were
40 fleets categorized as canoe and all of them were already registered to DKP East Java Province
2.
Fishing Method
- Minimum harvest size : Juvenile tuna, about 10-15 kg (weight is an estimate, as tuna weighing less than 20 kg are not weighed
individually)
- Method of capture : Handline, with fishing fleets GT 5-17
- Price range : Rp. 35.000 – 50.000/ Kg
In Sendangbiru, the type of fish that has become a commodity is Tuna, such as the Yellow Fin Tuna (Thunnus albacares). Caught by handlining fishing techinique, Tuna has become a major target of importers from the surrounding area. The transaction process is by way of auction which is organized by local port authorities.
3. Production Capacity
Generally, the total tuna landed in PPP Pondokdadap reached up to 5273.27 tons with the value of Rp 55,244,988,963. The production of Tuna,
Skipjack and Mackerel amounted to 3378.55 tons equaled to 64.06% of the total production of fish landed in PPP Pondokdadap. The types of Tuna caught were Yellowfin (Thunnus albacares), Bigeye (Thunnus obesus) and Albacore (Thunnus alalunga) which reached 1012.10 tons (19.19%).
Meanwhile, Skipjack (Katsuwonus pelamis) amounted to 600.81 tons (11.39%) and Mackerel 1765.64 tons (33.48%) (PPP Pondokdadap 2012, in
Annual report LOKA Tuna Benoa 2013).
Based on the information submitted, 168 Benoa took advantage of 51,359 Kg madidihana from Sendangbiru. This number was obtained from purchasing activities performed in January to June 2016. This number was also gained from 24 Tuna fishing fleets or canoe with 17 fleets that were fully operated in Sendangbiru
4. Additional Information
PT. 168 Benoa and PT. Hatindo Makmur cooperate in the Seafood Savers scheme and work toward improving tuna fishing in Sendangbiru. In September 2015, PT. 168 Benoa reported changes in the number of fleets under their production chain. In addition, information was given on the number of catches which were purchased by 168 in Sendangbiru. An action that should be appreciated. Periodic reporting of this kind, is an important aspect for improving future FIPs.
Data Recap of fleet and amount of fishing:
NO Fleet Name Port Base Fleet Information Date
Big Tuna Total–
YFT (kg) Depart Return
1 MANDIRI 275 SENDANG BIRU GT. 12 NO. 1214/Mp 8-Jul-16 19-Jul-16 3,742
2 ALIF JAYA SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 3493 11-Jul-16 19-Jul-16 2,129
3 TELUK BONE 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO. 023 7-Jul-16 20-Jul-16 1,924
4 INDRIANI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 7 C. 12 NO. 3179 12-Jul-16 20-Jul-16 2,317
5 BERKAT ILAHI 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 J.113 NO. 2575 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,315
6 BERKAH ALAM 06 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 11 NO. 51 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,413
7 BERKAT ILAHI 02 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 2482 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,131
8 BERKAT ILAHI 04 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 3855 11-Jul-16 21/17/16 2,002
9 BERKAH ILAHI 05 SENDANG BIRU GT. 7 C. 12 NO. 868 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,102
10 TELUK BONE 09 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO. 854 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 1,973
11 TIGA PUTRA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO. 1668 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,142
12 TITIPAN ILAHI 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 3364 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,127
13 CAHAYA MURNI 03 SENDANG BIRU 128 SB. J-117 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 3,515
14 RESKI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 3168 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,205
15 ADITIA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 4402 9-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,110
16 TELUK BONE 07 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 4033 9-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,310
17 LIMA PUTRA SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 60 NO. 3897 11-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,130
18 RAMA JAYA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO. 54 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,105
19 PENJURU BINTANG 04 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 3083 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,504
20 PENJURU BINTANG 05 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 3566 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,113
21 TIGA PUTRA 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 6 C. 12 NO. 1668 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,114
22 DUA PUTRA SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 3903 12-Jul-16 22-Jul-16 2,215
23 SARINAH 01 SENDANG BIRU GT. 11 NO. 1268/Mp 12-Jul-16 23-Jul-16 3,570
24 WAHYU RESKI 03 SENDANG BIRU GT. 5 C. 60 NO. 3920 11-Jul-16 21-Jul-16 2,145
Details of PT 168 Benoa's membership evaluation, based on the Fisheries Improvement Program (FIP) that has been implemented:
SEAFOOD
SAVERS
OUTPUT AND DETAIL ACTION
stage
ACTION / ACTION LEAD
FOLLOW-UP
INDIKATOR FOR (for the Seafood
EVALUATION RESULT
INTERMEDIATE
ADVANCE TASK ACTION/TASK Savers member) & PARTNERS PLAN/DIFFICULTIES
1. GOVERNANCE AND DEFINITION OF NATIONAL FISHERY MANAGEMENT OBJECTIVES
1.1. Refine Mechanism to
objectives to potentially
ensure that extend the 1.1.1. facilitate EAFM for Tuna fishing has priority is current law to the been studied jointly by the given to prioritise development College of Fisheries,
sustainable fisheries process of EAFM Jakarta and WWF- fisheries and sustainability, and or other SDI, P4KSI Not yet fully implemented Indonesia and will be the ecosystem against regulations presented in the National approach to production and which promotes Tuna Symposium, 2014 fisheries growth sustainable
management objectives, and fishery principles
at national accommodate
and local level EAFM principles
1.1.2. develop
company
regulation to EAFM for Tuna fishing has support the
been studied jointly by the implementation
College of Fisheries, of EAFM and or Company Not yet fully implemented Jakarta and WWF- other
Indonesia and will be regulations
presented in the National which promotes
Tuna Symposium, 2014 sustainable
fishery principles
Difficulties:
Information in the
1.2.1 facilitates logbook has not been
standardized. In many All fishery
the
Province/District cases, local names for management
regulation as SDI, P4KSI, various fish types are still 1.2. Extension principles,
interpretation of Agency of used in the logs. of the including
ministerial MAF in
Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru,
management precautionary
decree on Province & has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing
system to local approach should
fishery District, PLN,
Recommended solution: level be extended to
management PSDP
provincial and
plan, which
Create a standard for district levels;
include Harvest
logging, involving the local
Control Rule provincial office and/or
the marine and fisheries
ministry
1.2.2. Company
implement
measures
regulated in
Province/District Difficulties: fishery
Information in the management
logbook has not been plan as a patron
standardized. In many on the
development cases, local names for and various fish types are still implementation used in the logs. in the area. The
Company Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru,
plan will have has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing
harvest control Recommended solution:
rule with
sustainable Create a standard for
principles logging, involving the local involve e.g. provincial office and/or
minimum
the marine and fisheries
capture size,
ministry
adjusting the
number of effort
following the
stock carrying
capacity
1.2.3. facilitate
the SDI, Agency
province/district EAFM for Tuna fishing has of MAF in
regulation as an Not yet fully implemented been studied jointly by the Province &
extention of College of Fisheries, District
EAFM regulation Jakarta and WWF-
and or other Indonesia and will be
national presented in the National regulations Tuna Symposium, 2014 which promotes
sustainable tuna
fishery principles
1.2.4 Company
implement
measures
regulated in
Indonesian EAFM for Tuna fishing has EAFM guideline been studied jointly by the and or other College of Fisheries, national Jakarta and WWF- regulations Indonesia and will be
which promotes Company
Not yet fully implemented
presented in the National sustainable tuna Tuna Symposium, 2014
fishery principles
as a patron for
the
development
and
implementation
of EAFM in
Province/District
level
1.3.1. Company proactively
suport Indonesia
to be WCPFC So far, PT. 168 Benoa
member (e.g. Company
actively participates in Sending letter to events held by WWF,
MMAF, especially during visits or
To continue the
attending information sharing to WCPFC meetings stakeholders
1.3. Indonesia process to
if required)
becomes a full become full
Member of member of
WCPFC and is WCPFC 1.3.2. Monitor
instrumental and provide
in formulating support on KKP (SDI,
Indonesia has become a
strong ensuring the member of the WCPFC. P4KSI,
precautionary continuation
PUSKITA),
policies at process of In addition, PT. 168 Benoa KTI, KEMLU,
both RFMOs Indonesia - fishes in the Indian Ocean, SetKab
and becoming full which is under the
implements member of jurisdiction of the Indian
decisions WCPFC Ocean Tuna Commission
Actively 1.3.3. Ensuring
the Decree 12/2012 and
participated in
precautionary 30/2012 regarding the adoption
principles is requirement to land a full process of
adopted in body of shark with fins precautionary SDI, P4KSI
Not yet fully implemented national attached in a case where a policies in the
regulations (e.g. shark is incidentally fishery
Ministerial caught in the ZEEI and free management in
decrees, fishery waters area RFMOs
management
plan)
1.3.4. Promoting Decree 12/2012 and
the 30/2012 regarding the
precautionary requirement to land a full
principles SDI, P4KSI,
body of shark with fins adoption in PLN attached in a case where a
RFMOs following shark is incidentally international caught in the ZEEI and free
conventions waters area
1.3.5. Indonesia
Preparing report Indonesia sends a Regular and attendance
representative annually to attendance at meeting of the SDI, P4KSI attend RFMO (Indian meetings WCPFC and
Ocean and Pacific Ocean) others rellevant
RFMOs
Definition of SDI, P4KSI,
goals and
PUP, PSDP,
objectives,
KTI dan
Adherence to
1.4. 1.4.1 Tuna stakeholder
RFMO National action plan for Development management lainnya
conventions, Skipjack Tuna is available of fisheries plan document (ASTUIN,
Implementing Not yet fully implemented (Decree 107/ 2015). The specific development ATLI, Agency
national tools action plan was released management following FIP of MAF in
and HCRs (See in August 2015 plans suggestions Province &
also 3.4 below),
District, dll)
implementing
and
precautionary
WWF/SFP.
management
measures, 1.4.2 Adoption
developing of the tuna
bycatch management SDI, Agency
Not yet fully implemented
National action plan for mitigation plan principles Skipjack Tuna is available of MAF in
strategies (3.5), into existing (Decree 107/ 2015). The Province &
Applying MCS, area based action plan was released District
and reviewing fishery in August 2015
strategies management
plan
1.4.3 Company
proactively
support and
implement the
management So far, PT. 168 Benoa plan (e.g.
Company actively participates in
Provide letter on events held by WWF,
on the Not yet fully implemented
especially during visits or management information sharing to
plan, proactively stakeholders attend meetings
if required)
2. STRENGTHENING THE INSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK
2.1. Decision Legalize FKPPS
2.1.1 Facilitate Forum for the making and the availability coordination of the and the
consultation of regulation management and Management Not yet fully implemented processes (e.g. ministrial SDI, Agency utilization of Fish Committee as a
consolidated decrees) which of MAF in resources (FKPPS) exists, formal apex
through FKPPS promotes FKPPS Province & but still largely institution for
and the Tuna and or national District, volunterary, and there is Indonesian
Management management stakeholder, no binding decisions from fishery
Committee, authority (e.g. FKPPS meetings managemet role
which KTI, task force)
as defined
implements to responsible
management on the tuna strategies in fishery territorial, management
archipelagic and EEZ
waters
2.1.2 Monitor
and evaluate the
performance of
FKPPS and or
national
management SDI, Agency
Not yet fully implemented FKPPS exists, but still authority (e.g. largely volunterary, and of MAF in
KTI, task force) there is no binding Province &
conducted by decisions from FKPPS District,
internal and meetings stakeholder,
external
agencies of
MMAF to be
responsible on
the tuna fishery
management
Decisions 2.1.3 Facilitate
implemented the FKPPS exists, but still centrally, and establishment of Not yet fully implemented SDI, Agency largely volunterary, and not at authority to
of MAF in there is no binding decentralized implement
Province & decisions from FKPPS level. Provinsi measures in
District, meetings and District area based
stakeholder,
implement fishery
policy, but not management
responsible for plan (RPP WPP)
formulating and in
making decisions Province/District
which are at
variance with
national
management requirements
2.1.4 Monitor
and evaluate the
performance of
Province/District
management FKPPS exists, but still authority which Not yet fully implemented SDI, Agency largely volunterary, and conducted by
of MAF in there is no binding internal and
Province & decisions from FKPPS external
District, meetings agencies of
stakeholder,
MMAF-MAF of
Province/District
to be
responsible on
the tuna fishery
management
SDI, P4KSI,
2.1.5 Actively
PUP, PSDP, Allow for active KTI dan
involve industry, So far, PT. 168 Benoa engagement stakeholder
research agency,
actively participates in from lainnya
NGOs in Not yet fully implemented events held by WWF, stakeholders in (ASTUIN,
meetings related especially during visits or management ATLI, Agency
to the fishery information sharing to decision making. of MAF in
decision making stakeholders Province &
District, dll)
2.1.6 Company
proactively
supported and
involved in the So far, PT. 168 Benoa decision making
actively participates in process in Company
events held by WWF, national and
especially during visits or province/District
Not yet fully implemented information sharing to levels (e.g
stakeholders attending
meetings)
2.2.1 Facilitate
the availability Difficulties: of regulation Iinformation in the
2.2. Allocation of (e.g. ministerial logbook has not been Identification tasks to specific decrees, SDI, Agency standardized. In many
of stakeholders; directorate of MAF in cases, local names for responsibility Tuna Fisheries general decrees) Province & various fish types are still and capacity Satker, KKP, DKP on tasks District, Coastal Fishing Port of Pondokdadap, Sendangbiru, used in the logs.
building across Provinsi and allocation with stakeholder s has maintained a logbook record for tuna fishing
the range of District and specific job as described Recommended solution: implementing Community description to above. Create a standard for
bodies groups the right agency logging, involving the local to support the provincial office and/or fishery the marine and fisheries management ministry
3. RESEARCH ACTIVITIES
3.1.1 Workshop
to identify and
ensure the
authority who is
in charge to do
stock Not yet fully implemented National action plan for assessment P4KSI, BPPL,
3.1. National Skipjack Tuna is available analysis, KOMNAS
scientific stock
(Decree 107/ 2015). The Human capacity strengthened KAJISKAN,
assessment action plan was released building in stock and agreed on BPSDM.
capacity in August 2015 assessment and the
strengthened
establishing methodology to
to support
regio specifc do assessment
management
research (which also
taking onto
stations at address the MSC
account the
Benoa and needs)
major
Bitung
biological
factors 3.1.2 Training on Not yet fully implemented
stock P4KSI, BPPL,
Indonesia through P4KSI assessment, KOMNAS
(Balitbang KP, BRPL, and fisheries biology KAJISKAN,
LOKA Tuna Benoa) and fishing BPSDM.
participated and wrote a capacity
series of record to be
reported for RFMO 3.2. Indonesia
Stock 3.2.1 Sampling
strengthens its methodology Not yet fully implemented
abundance,
commitment module
Fleet
to data development P4KSI, BPPL,
Indonesia through P4KSI composition,
collection and and conduct SDI
(Balitbang KP, BRPL, and Stock
collation, training on tuna LOKA Tuna Benoa) productivity,
especially in Stock participated and wrote a Stock structure
the form of abundance, series of record to be
stock Fleet reported for RFMO structure, composition,
stock Stock
abundance productivity, and fleet Stock structure
composition
3.2.2 Increase
private
awareness and
participation in Not yet fully implemented
the tuna data P4KSI, BPPL,
Indonesia through P4KSI collection by SDI, industry
(Balitbang KP, BRPL, and facilitating (direct and
LOKA Tuna Benoa) research via industry
participated and wrote a activities and associations)
series of record to be providing access
reported for RFMO to their
production
facilities
3.2.3 Research
on tuna Stock
abundance, Not yet fully implemented
Fleet P4KSI, BPPL,
Indonesia through P4KSI composition,
KOMNAS (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and Stock
KAJISKAN
LOKA Tuna Benoa) productivity,
participated and wrote a Stock structure
series of record to be using the agreed
reported for RFMO methodology
3.2.4 Increase
research
activities of the
newly Not yet fully implemented
established
Indonesia through P4KSI research P4KSI, BPPL,
(Balitbang KP, BRPL, and institute for KOMNAS
LOKA Tuna Benoa) indian tuna in KAJISKAN
participated and wrote a benoa and
series of record to be encourage the
reported for RFMO establishment of
the institute in
bitung
National action plan for
Not yet fully implemented Skipjack Tuna is available
3.3.1 Conduct (Decree 107/ 2015). The 3.3. Indonesia
stock P4KSI, BPPL, action plan was released should adopt
assessment for KOMNAS in August 2015 its own LRPs
tuna (YFT, SKJ, KAJISKAN Indonesia will build HCR based on
BET and others) national waters. In national and
accordance with guidance RFMO advice Stock
from CSIRO (WCPFC) so that stocks assessment
3.3.2 Company
are strengthened participation in National action plan for maintained (YFT, SKJ, BET the tuna data Skipjack Tuna is available above the and others) Not yet fully implemented collection by P4KSI, BPPL, (Decree 107/ 2015). The biomass levels
facilitating SDI, industry action plan was released providing
research (direct and
in August 2015 maximum
activities and via industry
Indonesia will build HCR sustainable
providing access associations)
national waters. In yield Points
to their
accordance with guidance
production from CSIRO (WCPFC)
facilities (e.g.
Logbook, onboard
observer, gonad sampling, annual catch data etc)
National action plan for
3.3.3 Develop
Not yet fully implemented Skipjack Tuna is available P4KSI, BPPL, (Decree 107/ 2015). The draft on national
KOMNAS action plan was released level Reference
KAJISKAN, in August 2015 Points for each
SDI Indonesia will build HCR tuna species
national waters. In
accordance with guidance Setting national from CSIRO (WCPFC)
level Reference
Points for each
species
3.3.4 establish Not yet fully implemented National action plan for
regulation on Skipjack Tuna is available
the national P4KSI, SDI
(Decree 107/ 2015). The
level Reference
action plan was released
Points for each in August 2015 tuna species Indonesia will build HCR national waters. In accordance with guidance from CSIRO (WCPFC)
Recommend to 3.3.5 develop Not yet fully implemented
WCPFC and IOTC policy paper on SDI, WWF
to have a regional LRP that
regional LRP should be set on National action plan for
biological Skipjack Tuna is available carrying capacity (Decree 107/ 2015). The action plan was released
in August 2015
3.3.6 proactively Not yet fully implemented National action plan for advocates
SDI, P4KSI, Skipjack Tuna is available WCPFC and IOTC
KTI, WWF (Decree 107/ 2015). The to have regional
action plan was released LRP
in August 2015
Indonesia will build HCR
national waters
3.4. Formal MMAF develops 3.4.1 Support
harvest Harvest Strategy
P4KSI on the
strategy linked to CMM
development of
adopted for 2008-01 for Not yet fully implemented National action plan for scientific paper
Indonesian EEZ/YFT and BET Skipjack Tuna is available with regard to
Pacific and activities and (Decree 107/ 2015). The tuna resources SDI, FKKP, KTI
Indian Ocean restrictions on action plan was released and fisheries as
tunas linked to effort capped at in August 2015 a basis to
a set of 2001-2004 Indonesia will build HCR develop the
(National or levels, In national waters. In policy paper
RFMO) Limit addition, the accordance with guidance document
Reference spirit of the from CSIRO (WCPFC)
Points, measures (i.e 3.4.2 Directorate
covering the effort General of
range of control/capacity Capture
fisheries reduction in Fisheries of (including territorial MMAF develops
those < 30 GT /archipelagic Harvest Strategy and 5 GT). The waters if linked to CMM
object should interactions with 2008-01 for National action plan for be consistent juvenile YFT/BET EEZ/YFT and BET Not yet fully implemented Skipjack Tuna is available
with RFMO are significant activities and (Decree 107/ 2015). The advice, which restrictions on action plan was released in the case of effort capped at in August 2015 the Pacific, is 2001-2004
SDI, FKKP, KTI Indonesia will build HCR
to limit effort levels, In national waters. In
to 2004 levels, addition, the accordance with guidance and to reduce spirit of the from CSIRO (WCPFC) effort on YFT measures (i.e
and BET by effort
30% control/capacity
reduction in
territorial
/archipelagic
waters if
interactions with
juvenile YFT/BET
are significant
3.5. Fisheries Develop 3.5.1 Facilitate SDI, P4KSI,
Not yet fully implemented
specific fisheries specific the
Agency of
management management development National action plan for MAF in
plans set plan (national process on tuna Skipjack Tuna is available Province &
encompassing fishery management (Decree 107/ 2015). The District, PLN,
a set of well management regulation in action plan was released KKJI, PSDP
defined plan for Tuna) Indonesia which in August 2015
control rules controls the Indonesia will build HCR limiting effort harvest (HCR) national waters. In (by restricted following the accordance with guidance
entry sustainable from CSIRO (WCPFC) licensing, principles,
especially at restrict entry provincial licensing
level) and the especially at impact of provincial level,
juvenile BET reducing impact (restrictions of juvenile BET
on the use of (through e.g. FADs (across al restrictions on
levels of the use of FADs
Government), across all levels
raising the of Government),
minimum raising the
mesh size, minimum mesh
closed areas size, closed
and others). areas and
The tools used others). The
should take tools used into account should take into
uncertainties account
uncertainties
3.5.2 Company
participation to
support tuna
management
plan which
mentioning on
Harvest Control
Rule e.g. PT. 168 Benoa and its minimum size Not yet fully implemented supply chain have not limit; adjusting
established regulations the number of
regarding their effort following Company
involvement in the the carrying
improvement program, in capacity and
both national and local regulation;
levels. completion of all
fishing licenses,
FADs; using
environmentally
friendly fishing
gears; fishing in
the right
lozation etc
Review of 3.6.1 Conduct a
review of
available
available
information on
information on Bycatch data of small stock status P4KSI,
3.6. By catch stock status scale handline tuna including bait KOMNAS Not yet fully implemented
data collection including bait fisheries has not been fisheries, sharks, KAJISKAN
fisheries, sharks, fully recorded marlins and
marlins and
other 'main'
other 'main'
pelagic species
pelagic species
3.6.2 Company Provide
Bycatch data recording in information on
small scale tuna fisheries stock status
Not yet fully implemented has not been including bait
implemented in both fisheries, sharks,
Company national and company marlins and
levels. other 'main'
pelagic species
(e.g via log book
and or research
forms)
3.6.3 Improve
the existing
observer
training module, Bycatch data recording in
Development of especially on small scale tuna fisheries
observe training bycatch data P4KSI, BPPL, Not yet fully implemented has not been module (from recording (need SDI, industry, implemented in both WWF/SPC to be detailed WWF/NGO, national and company examples) and than the current universities, levels.
training of data available) SPC
observers and implement
Observer
program based
on the improved
modul
Bycatch data recording in 3.6.4. Company small scale tuna fisheries
implement Not yet fully implemented has not been
observer Company
implemented in both program for national and company
their fishing levels.
fleet
Not yet fully implemented RPP Tuna is not yet
Requires 3.6.5. conduct available, and the Limit
Reference needs have not monitoring study and
been discussed in the aggregate fish monitoring on
P4KSI, BPPL, national level. Regulation densities and the status and
SDI, industry, regarding Fish Aggregating size on FADs impact of the
WWF/NGO, Devices (FADs) have been over periods to aggregate fish
universities, made available, under determine the densities, size
SPC Decree 30/ year 2004, likely impact on and associated
however the associated fish fish species on
implementation of species FADs
compliance in the field
remains unknown
Not yet fully implemented RPP Tuna is not yet
3.6.6. Company available, and the Limit
provide Reference needs have not
information and been discussed in the
conduct national level. Regulation monitoring on regarding Fish Aggregating the impact of Company Devices (FADs) have been
the FAD to made available, under aggregate fish Decree 30/ year 2004, densities, size however the and associated implementation of
fish species compliance in the field
remains unknown
3.6.7. encourage
Modeling of
RFMO to conduct the
fishery removals Not yet fully implemented No available ecosystem modeling of
to assess the model to be used as a fishery removals
impact on the P4KSI, SPC, basis to assess the
ecosystem using CSIRO
impact on the
existing SPC
ecosystem using
tools – ECOPATH
existing SPC
etc
tools – ECOPATH
etc
3.7. Completion of
a risk based framework for retained and
bycatch species
(skipjack. Small tunas, mahimahi, kawakawa, sharks) and
Bait fish. Requires
independent research to
collect qualitative and
quantitative information to perform a risk
based approach
covering SICA and PSA
P4KSI, BPPL, Stakeholders SDI, PSDP,
receive training 3.7.1 Conduct
industry, in risk WWF/NGO, RBF assessment has
training for
assessment and University, revealed plenty of room stakeholders for
participate in multi- WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement risk assessment
method specific stakeholder PSA of MSC
to determine
workshops to involvement, RBF can be implemented risk to non
determine risk RFMOs, per certification unit target species.
to non target external
species. research
bodies
3.7.2 conduct RBF assessment has undertake the
revealed plenty of room Risk Based
WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement Assessment to P4KSI, BPPL
PSA of MSC
determine risk
RBF can be implemented to non target
per certification unit species.
3.7.3 Company
Drawing from support RBF assessment has
the information informatin
revealed plenty of room in 4.1 and needed for the
WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using for improvement undertake a risk Risk Based Company
PSA of MSC
assessment Assessment to
RBF can be implemented determine risk
per certification unit to non target
species.
3.7.4 strategy
RBF assessment has
development on P4KSI, BPPL,
WWF-ID collaborate with FPIK-IPB to RBF by using
revealed plenty of room using the data for improvement WWF PSA of MSC from RBA for
MSC evaluation RBF can be implemented
per certification unit No existing regulation
3.8. National
Not yet fully implemented regarding the use of
3.8.1 Develop bycatch on the national
limits for ETP
level(except for turtles) interactions
NPOA of ETP
set and species in In SDI, FKPPS,
independent
Indonesia
KTI
data collected
(sharks, turtles,
on ETPs limits NPOAs finalised cetaceans and
to ensure that or amended to birds) bycatches are take account of
within WCPFC CMMs national and (sharks, turtles,
3.8.2 Company
international cetaceans and National action plan for provide
requirements. birds) Skipjack Tuna is available
information and
This may (Decree 107/ 2015). The implement Not yet fully implemented require action plan was released NPOA of ETP
observers to Company in August 2015. Stating species In
be present that Indonesia will create Indonesia
across a range a bycatch mitigation (sharks, turtles,
of fisheries program cetaceans
and birds)
Developing a 3.9.1 P4KSI will
National action plan for management provide scientific
Not yet fully implemented Skipjack Tuna is available strategy for paper with
3.9. (Decree 107/ 2015). The bycatch species regard to tuna SDI, FKPPS,
Management action plan was released and baitfish to resources and KTI, KAPI,
strategy and in August 2015. Stating be incorporated fisheries as a P4KSI
mitigation that Indonesia will create into a basis to develop
a bycatch mitigation management the policy paper
program plan (1.4) document
3.9.2 Company
National action plan for Skipjack Tuna is available provide
(Decree 107/ 2015). The information
action plan was released needed to
in August 2015. Stating develop the
that Indonesia will create scientific paper Company Not yet fully implemented
on management a bycatch mitigation strategy and program mitigation for
No existing regulation bycatch and
regarding the use of fish baitfish fisheries
bait on the national level
3.9.3 Capture National action plan for DG - fishery Skipjack Tuna is available resources (Decree 107/ 2015). The
management action plan was released Directorate will in August 2015. Stating
develop SDI, KAPI,
Not yet fully implemented that Indonesia will create
management P4KSI
a bycatch mitigation
strategy and
program
mitigation
document for No existing regulation bycatch and regarding the use of fish baitfish fisheries bait on the national level
3.9.4 Company
have policies to
support the No existing regulation management regarding bycatch
strategy and Company Not yet fully implemented mitigation or the use of
mitigation fish bait on the national
document for level
bycatch and
baitfish fisheries
Information 3.10.1 workshop
gathering to on information
3.10. determine data gathering to
Indonesian gaps, tactical determine data
Research Plan focus on critical gaps, tactical
prepared to target stocks focus on critical
take account (and not target stocks
of national confined to (and not
and current FMA confined to So far, PT. 168 Benoa international review process), current FMA
P4KSI, actively participates in
demands and Cost effective review process), events held by WWF, (BPPL.,BBRSE, Not yet fully implemented
obligations risk assessment Cost effective especially during visits or KAPI)
with ingrained into risk assessment information sharing to
appropriate analytical tools, ingrained into stakeholders budget application of analytical tools,
funding ecosystem application of
secured from models, capacity ecosystem
industry, building to models, capacity
government support the building to and donors. above, support the
awareness above,
raising of awareness
activites raising of
undertaken and activites periodic review undertaken and
(includingsubject periodic review to external (includingsubject scrutiny). to external
scrutiny)
3.10.2 Company So far, PT. 168 Benoa provide actively participates in
information Company events held by WWF, needed for the
Not yet fully implemented especially during visits or
workshop information sharing to
stakeholders
seek
3.10.3 P4KSI to Indonesia through P4KSI have
cooperation (Balitbang KP, BRPL, and cooperation
with SPC/CSIRO LOKA Tuna Benoa) with SPC/CSIRO P4KSI Not yet fully implemented with respect to participated and wrote a with respect to
ecosystem data series of record to be ecosystem data
collection reported for RFMO collection
3.10.4 involve SDI, P4KSI,
the stakeholders
Agency of
in national, Activities related to this MAF in
incorporate districts on
Not yet fully implemented program have not been Province &
raising research plan
fully implemented District, PLN,
awareness of socialization and
KKJI, PSDP
the research implementation
plan to improve 3.10.5 sharing
SDI, P4KSI,
understanding Agency of
the result of Activities related to this
among MAF in
research to the Not yet fully implemented program have not been stakeholders in Province &
national and fully implemented
national, District, PLN,
districts
provincial and KKJI, PSDP
district level 3.10.6 Company
Activities related to this
involving in Company Not yet fully implemented program have not been research fully implemented
extend internal 3.10.7 extend
internal review
review process
process (e.g. SDI, P4KSI,
(e.g. research,
research, Agency of Activities related to this management)
management) MAF in Not yet fully implemented program have not been incorporating
incorporating Province & fully implemented inputs from
inputs from District
provincial and
provincial and
district levels
district levels
to plan an 3.10.8 to plan an
external review external review
process, as well process, as well Activities related to this
as the as the BPK, KTI Not yet fully implemented program have not been
monitoring of monitoring of fully implemented
implementation implementation
of plan of plan
4. COMPLIANCE STRENGTHENING
4.1.
Compliance action to be
implemented
based on risk
analysis and
determine
enforcement
priorities
across the
range of tuna
fisheries
Compliance plans are
developed in conjunction with
national, provincial, district and community
organizations
4.1.1 Initiate the
development of
compliance
plans (incl PSDP, Agency
activity, partner,
of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer budget)
Province & Not yet fully implemented group has not been involving
District / identified national,
POKMAS
provincial,
district and
community
organizations
4.1.2 PSDP, Agency
of MAF in
Dissemination of POKMASWAS pioneer Province &
compliance Not yet fully implemented group has not been District /
plans for tuna identified POKMAS,
fisheries
associations
4.1.3 Company
develop policy POKMASWAS pioneer ensuring the
Company Not yet fully implemented group has not been adoption and
identified implementation
of the plan
4.2.1 Facilitate
the government
Upgrading on improving Updated regulations
existing the sanctions of
Not yet fully implemented PSDP/MMAF related to supervision and
violations regulations,
Legal sanction has not been schedules to improving the
Department established
4.2. account for surveillance
application to mechanism, and
Strengthtening
new enforcement to
the legislation
management law violations
on sanctions
measures and 4.2.2
across the range Socialization of PSDP/MMAF Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations of fisheries (EEZ,
legislation on Legal
related to supervision and archipelagic and
sanctions for Department,
sanction has not been coastal) tuna fisheries associations established
stakeholders
4.2.3 Company Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations develop policy
related to supervision and on the Company
sanction has not been implementation
established of the legislation
4.3.1 Training on
management
measures (e.g.
target species,
bycatch
reduction and
4.3. Education Applied to all consequences of PSDP, BPSDM
BMP training Tuna handline, Sendangbiru, 2 process for stakeholder ecosystem November 2015
KP, SDI,
fishers on groups, and interactions) for Participants who attended the fishermen, collectors, Companies or collectors P4KSI, KAPI,
management extended to the fishers: KUD Minajaya Sendangbiru, superintendent of should ensure fishing Agency of
measures for POKMAS - using BMP for fisheries, water police and navy task force. With a practices in the field are as MAF in
target species, network. sustainable total number of participants (based on attendance) per training. Henceforth, Province &
bycatch Requires fishing practices as many as 27 people. monitoring will be District,
reduction and considerable - using BMP for Info about activity can be seen di: performed a year after the Processors,
consequences buy in from increase high http://www.seafoodsavers.org/news/read/Langkah- training middlemen
of ecosystem middlemen and fish quality to awal-PT-Hatindo-Sukses%20Makmur-dan-PT-168-
and WWF.
interactions processors. reduce Benoa-Sebagai-Anggota-Seafood-Savers
overfishing
- using BMP for
bycatch
mitigation
- traceability
record
4.3.2 Ensures
fishermen Training Tuna BMPs have been implemented. Ensure the
conducting the
implementation of
sustainable Company corrective measures in the fishing practices BMP by collectors in the
as trained on the field
4.3.1
4.4.1 Facilitate
the
establishment of
PokMasWas, PSDP, Agency
prepared with
of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer surveillance and
Province & Not yet fully implemented group has not been monitoring plan
District, all identified
Arguably on fishing
stakeholder
practices (incl.
4.4. existing on some
Institutional and
Strengthen basis already,
capacity
Community but requires
building)
based considerable
management strengthening of 4.4.2 Monitor PSDP, Agency
systems for PokMasWas the performance
of MAF in POKMASWAS pioneer hand-line and dedicated of PokMasWas
Province & Not yet fully implemented group has not been other coastal functions, as part of
District, all identified fisheries. resourcing and management
stakeholder
support. system
4.4.3 Company
develop policy POKMASWAS pioneer to support the
Company Not yet fully implemented group has not been establishment
identified and operation of
PokMasWas
4.5.1 Facilitate PSDP, Agency
Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations the collection of related to supervision and of MAF in
report on sanction has not been Province &
regulation established District
compliance
Reports are
4.5. Reports prepared and prepared and identifying the
publicly result of 4.5.2 Facilitate PSDP, Agency Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations
available inspection the report of MAF in related to supervision and
identifying activities, uploading to the Province & sanction has not been
violations especially in MMAF website District established detected relation with
fishing activities
4.5.3 Company
develop policy
on supporting Not yet fully implemented
Updated regulations datac ollectiona related to supervision and Company
dn report sanction has not been
preparation on established regulation
violation
4.6. Train and Upgrading of 4.6.1 Training on PSDP, Agency
Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations
improve the existing PSDP surveillance to
of MAF in related to supervision and effectiveness training PokMasWas and
Province & sanction has not been of programme, but PSDP in the
District established enforcement extended to provincial and
officers and Provincial and districts
add District
supporting participation.
4.6.2 Facilitate
hardware
the workplan
synchronization PSDP, Agency Not yet fully implemented Updated regulations with other of MAF in
related to supervision and surveillance Province &
sanction has not been stakeholders to District, all
established improve the stakeholder
surveillance and
enforcement
4.6.3 Company
develop policy Updated regulations on supporting
Company related to supervision and
enforcement sanction has not been
officers work in established
the field