1
Information Literacy for Scanning the External Business Environment
Xue Zhang, Shaheen Majid and Schubert Foo
Information Literacy at Workplace
One of the objectives of IL instruction is to prepare independent and lifelong learners
However, a majority of the IL studies have been conducted in academic settings.
Recently several studies have highlighted the importance of IL skills for business organizations (Karim & Hussein, 2008; Zhang, Majid & Foo , 2012).
Some previous studies also reported a lack of desired IL skills among employees (Bruce, 1999;
O'Sullivan, 2002; Cheuk, 2002).
Only a few studies have investigated the impact of IL skills on different business operations such as Environment Scanning (ES), strategic planning, Evidence-Based Practice (EBP), etc.
2
What is Environment Scanning?
It is a process of identifying, collecting, processing, analyzing and interpreting information about an organization’s external business environments, to be used for tactical and strategic decision-making.
Creates awareness about emerging business trends, new business opportunities and potential threats.
Continuous and systematic environment scanning enables an organization to avoid surprises and gain competitive edge over its competitors.
3
ES is an ‘information intense’ process and needs good information skills
ES – An Information Intense Process
4
Information Needs
Identification
Information
Collection
Information Organization & Storage
Info Processing
& Synthesizing
Information
Distribution
Info Evaluation
& Use
Zhang, Majid & Foo (2010) - Adapted from Choo’s (2002) Information Management Model
Mapping of ES Process and IL Skills
5
Scanning needs identification - To define & articulate info. needs
Acquisition of environmental information
- To identify potential info. sources
- To consider cost/benefit of info. - To select the most appropriate
access method - To develop /refine search strategy - To retrieve & extract information
Information organization and storage
- To properly organize and store
the retrieved information for current and future use
Environment Scanning Desired IL Skills
Mapping of ES Process and IL Skills
6
Information synthesis and analysis
- To filter, interpret, analyse, and summarize information from multiple sources
Information distribution and sharing
- To distribute information to the right person at the right time and in an appropriate format
Information evaluation and use
- To evaluate the quality of info. - To use information for decision
making
Environment Scanning Desired IL Skills
The Study Setting Travel Agencies in Singapore
Very competitive and dynamic industry, directly influenced by several environmental factors such as economic crises, epidemics, and natural disasters.
Travel agencies need to quickly adjust according to the rapidly changing business environment.
The tourism industry is an important and major contributor to Singapore economy.
Only a few studies have investigated the environmental scanning practices of travel agencies.
7
Research Objective
To study the role of Information Literacy in environmental scanning process through a combination of quantitative and qualitative methods.
8
Phase one - Questionnaire Survey
Sample - All 319 NATAS* member travel agencies
42 companies participated in the study (13.2% response rate)
Phase two – Face-to-Face Interviews
13 individuals from 5 companies were interviewed
Companies were selected based on their size and business focus (in-bound, out-bound, transportation)
Interviewees were from different functional units
and hierarchical levels
9
Research Method
* NATAS = National Association of Travel Agents Singapore
Human sources 3.70 (colleagues, external contacts)
Traditional Sources 3.00 (Newspapers, TV, magazines)
Online Info. Sources 2.77
(websites, travel blogs, databases)
10
Survey Findings
Use Frequency of Information Sources
Low use of online information sources was probably due to limited IL/searching skills
11
Survey Findings
Conduct of various ES activities
ES Activity CEO/
Director
Assigned
person(s) Everyone
Identify the need to collect information 32.5% 53.5% 14.0%
Collect information 11.4% 63.6% 22.0%
Filter, interpret and merge information 30.2% 62.8% 7.0%
Organise and store information 12.8% 79.5% 7.7%
Distribute information to needed people 20.0% 71.1% 8.9%
Use the information for decision-making 58.3% 37.5% 4.2%
A majority of the employees were involved in ES activities
Lack of time 56.5%
Shortage of manpower 64.1%
Lack of information skills 40.7%
Limited access to info sources 33.3%
12
Survey Findings
Barriers to Environment Scanning
13
Hypotheses Testing
H1: The frequency of each scanning step is positively correlated with the quality of
information available for decision-making.
H2: The overall level of information literacy of employees responsible of scanning
activities is positively correlated with the quality of information made
available for decision-making.
Frequency of Environmental
Scanning
Level of Information
Literacy Skills
Quality of Information
for Use
H1
H2
Inability to identify appropriate information sources
14
IL-Related Problems in ES - Interviews
Overreliance on human information sources
15
IL-Related Problems in ES - Interviews
No/limited storage of strategic information
16
IL-Related Problems in ES - Interviews
Improper storage of information
17
IL-Related Problems in ES - Interviews
IL training programs need to realize that applications and benefits of IL skills are not confined to academic settings.
Many organizational activities need up-to-date, accurate, and high quality information for tactical and strategic decision-making.
Employees of all organizations need to possess an adequate level of information skills.
There is a need to create awareness as well as develop special IL training programs for working individuals.
18
Conclusion
19
Information Literacy for Scanning the External Business Environment
Xue Zhang, Shaheen Majid and Schubert Foo