The W inSlow Play
JOHN BRIAN MCCARTHY
NORTHEAST JUDGE CONFERENCE
DECEMBER 2014
A player facing a really complicated board state?
Players sideboardingand shuffling?
A player with 40 minutes left on the clock?
Judges playing in your events?
Players in untimed rounds?
Players new at Magic?
Players at end of round?
Players at Friday Night Magic?
That guy in your Commander game who keeps asking whose turn it is?
What isn’t Slow Play?
Tardiness Stalling
Most common types of slow play
I have no idea who has priority
The “Do this combat right or die” tank
The “Do I counter this spell?” tank
The “Last turn miracle” tank
The stuff mentioned in the IPG
How to call slow play
Know when to derail their train of thought
Caution before warning
Be firm but compassionate
Stay around to make sure play speed increases
Give them +2 Turns
Be ready to discuss your ruling after the match
If a player asks you watch his or her match for slow play
Questions and discussion