8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 1/9
DG V@I YGDVIF SVMVIS FDSVZDCV CNYZV
ONZ V@I FDSVZDCV NO FIEMXMZI
SYGN_DNG \@MZBMCIYVDCMES DGC'%
\emdgvdoo%
v'
FIT \@MZBM'% E'\'% FIT% DGC'%
BTEMG DGC'% mgf BTEMG
\@MZBMCIYVDCMES DGC'%
Fioigfmgvs'
; Cdde Mcvdng Gn' <?"==3"E\S
V`nbms @' Jica% Is}ydzi mgf Gime A' Fm`dtm% Is}ydzi no SDFEIT MYSVDG EE\% Gix Tnza%
GT' \mye K' [ihhiz% Is}ydzi no SDFEIT MYSVDG EE\% Xms`dghvng% FC'
Kmca J' Jeybigoief% Is}ydzi mgf Amzig Kmcnjs Enyfig% Is}ydzi noBNZZDS% GDC@NES%
MZS@V / VYGGIEE EE\% Xdebdghvng% FI'
Mvvnzgits onz \emdgvdoo'
Ifhmz @' @myh% Is}ydzi mgf Smb _' Fismd% Is}ydzi noOZNBBIZ EMXZIGCI / @MYH
EE\% Gix Tnza% GT' Ied{mjiv` M' Eioo% Is}ydzi noOZNBBIZ EMXZIGCI / @MYH EE\%
Xms`dghvng% FC'
Zdc`mzf E' @nzxdv{% Is}ydzi mgf Fmdf I' Bnnzi% Is}ydzi no \NVVIZ MGFIZSNG /
CNZZNNG EE\% Xdebdghvng% FI'
Mvvnzgits onz Fioigfmgvs'
Kmgymzt =0% :<=:
Xdebdghvng% Fiemxmzi'
BIBNZMGFYB N\DGDNG
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 2/9
v w > % $ v 1 SVMZA% Y'S' Fdsvzdcv Kyfhi;
D' DGVZNFYCVDNG
\zisigvet jionzi v`i Cnyzv ds v`i dssyi no dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci% x`dc` v`i |mzvdis
`mi zmdsif dg cnggicvdng xdv` Fioigfmgvs( moodzbmvdi fioigsi mgf cnygvizcemdb meeihdgh v`mv
v`i |mvigvs"dg"sydv mzi dgmedf onz mgvdcd|mvdng' Onz v`i zimsngs siv onzv` jienx% v`i Cnyzv mhziis
xdv` Fioigfmgvs v`mv v`i `nsv fncybigv% Jzdvds` |mvigv HJ = :40 646% dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigci
v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i cnb|nygfs fisczdjif dg v`i s|icdodcmvdng noJzdvds` |mvigv HJ = :<<
00?' Mccnzfdghet% v`mv bmvizdme xdee ji cngsdfizif vnhiv`iz ms m sdghei zioizigci onz |yz|nsis no
mgvdcd|mvdng mv vzdme% x`dc` ds sc`ifyeif vn jihdg ng Kmgymzt 3<% :<=:'
DD' JMCAHZNYGF
V`i |zisigv edvdhmvdng ds m @mvc`"Xmpbmg |mvigv dgozdghibigv sydv jznyh`v jt \emdgvdoo
Sygndng \`mzbmciyvdcmes Dgc' *Sygndng*$ dg zis|ngsi vn Fioigfmgvs( m||edcmvdng onz OFM
m||znme vn bmzaiv higizdc eimejyvizne' Fioigfmgvs cngvigf v`mv v`i |mvigvs"dg"sydv mzi dgmedf
onz mgvdcd|mvdng dg dix no m Jzdvds` |mvigv% HJ = :40 646 *v`i HJ (646 |mvigv*$% x`dc` v`it
cngvigf dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigci mffdvdngme bmvizdme si|mzmviet fisczdjif dg mgnv`iz Jzdvds`
|mvigv% HJ = :<< 00? *v`i HJ (00? |mvigv*$' Dg :<<4% v`i |mzvdis odeif cznss"bnvdngs onz
sybbmzt kyfhbigv ng v`i dssyi no mgvdcd|mvdng' Kyfhi Omzgmg% v`ig |zisdfdgh niz v`i cmsi%
dssyif mg n|dgdng mgf nzfiz figtdgh Sygndng(s bnvdng mgf hzmgvdgh dg |mzv mgf figtdgh dg |mzv
Fit(s bnvdng' F'D' 34:1 F'D' 343$ Kyfhi Omzgmg *zisiziQfR ficdsdng ng v`i dssyi nox`iv`iz
mgf vn x`mv ipvigv HJ (646 dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigciQR HJ (00?'* F'D' 34: mv =9 g'3$ V`i
|mzvdis syjsi}yigvet zi"jzdioif v`i dssyi no dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci |yzsymgv vn v`ds Cnyzv(s
Gnibjiz :3% :<== Nzfiz' F'D' 6891 F'D' 6881 F'D' 6081 F'D' 604$
=
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 3/9
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 4/9
fivizbdgmvdng db|edcmvis dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci% v`i cnyzv(s znei ds vn fivizbdgi x`mv
bmvizdme dg mffdvdng vn v`i `nsv fncybigv cngsvdvyvis v`i sdghei zioizigci' V`i omcvodgfiz( s znei%
dg vyb% ds vn fivizbdgi x`iv`iz v`mv sdghei zioizigci fisczdjis v`i cemdbif dgigvdng' Sii df'
D_' FDSCYSSDNG
Ms gnvif% v`i |mzvdis ( fds|yvi cngcizgs x`iv`iz v`i HJ (646 |mvigv mfi}ymviet
dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigci v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i zmcibdc cnb|nygfs si|mzmviet fisczdjif dg
v`i HJ (00? |mvigv% syc` v`mv v`i |izvdgigv bmvizdme oznb jnv` |mvigvs |zn|izet cmg ji cngsdfizif
vnhiv`iz ms m *sdghei zioizigci* onz mgvdcd|mvdng' Fit cngcifis v`mv dvs snei mgvdcd|mvdng fioigsi
ds dmjei nget do v`i Cnyzv odgfs dg dvs omnz ng v`i dssyi no dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci' F'D' 683
mv ?9;=4":9$
Ms zi|znfycif jienx% v`i HJ (646 |mvigv svmvis dg zieimgv |mzv;
V`ds dgigvdng ds cngcizgif xdv` m |znciss onz v`i |zi|mzmvdng no n|vdcme
igmgvdnbizs no cizvmdg ="|`igte":"mbdgniv`mgne fizdmvdis x`dc` mzi fisczdjif dg
|mzvdcyemz dg nyz Ygdvif Adghfnb S|icdodcmvdng Gn' = :<<%00?'
Dg nyz smdf Ygdvif Adghfnb S|icdodcmvdng Gn' =%:<<%00? v`izi mzi fisczdjif
|`igtembdgniv`mgne fizdmvdis x`dc` bmt svdbyemvi \"mfzigizhdc zici|vnzs '''V`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt nosyc` mcvddvt ds bnzi oyeet fisczdjif dg smdf s|icdodcmvdng'
V`i |`igtembdgniv`mgne fizdmvdis D$ bmt ipdsv dg vxn n|vdcmeet dsnbizdc
onzbs mgf mccnzfdgh vn v`i dgigvdng xi `mi fdscnizif m gix |znciss onz v`i
|zi|mzmvdng no syc` dsnbizs1 v`i mfmgvmhi no v`ds |znciss ds v`mv dv omcdedvmvis v`i
|znfycvdng no |yzi dsnbizs' V`ds ds no |mzvdcyemz db|nzvmgci dg v`ds cmsi sdgci v`i
|`mzbmcnenhdcme mcvddvt nongi dsnbiz dg svmgfmzf visvs onz jzngc`nfdemvnz mcvdng ds
izt byc` hzimviz v`mg v`mv no v`i nv`iz'
HJ (646 |mvigv mv =;4"36$ ib|`msds mffif$'
Sygndng cngvigfs v`mv v`ds |mssmhi fnis gnv smvdsot v`i eihme svmgfmzf onz dgcnz|nzmvdng
jt zioizigci jicmysi v`i HJ (646 |mvigv ds fdzicvif vn mg igvdziet fdooizigv dgigvdng v`mv biziet
zioizs vn v`i HJ (00? |mvigv ms jmcahznygf% mgf *gnv ms |mzv no v`i syjsvmgvdi fisczd|vdng no v`i
3
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 5/9
dgigvdng'* F'D' 688 mv 3$ Sygndng oyzv`iz cngvigfs v`mv v`i HJ (646 |mvigv omdes vn dfigvdot
*xdv` fivmdeif |mzvdcyemzdvt x`mv s|icdodc bmvizdme dv dgcnz|nzmvis* mgf edaixdsi fnis gnv *ceimzet
dgfdcmvi x`izi v`mv bmvizdme ds onygf* dg v`i HJ (00? |mvigv' (Df mv 9$
Fioigfmgvs zis|ngf v`mv v`i HJ (646 |mvigv smvdsodis v`i zi}ydzibigvs onz dgcnz|nzmvdng
jt zioizigci jicmysi dv mfi}ymviet fisczdjis xdv` fivmdeif |mzvdcyemzdvt v`i s|icdodc bmvizdme
dgcnz|nzmvif d'i'% v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i zmcibdc cnb|nygfs( |`mzbmcnenhdcme mcvddvt$ mgf
mesn ceimzet dgfdcmvis x`izi v`mv bmvizdme ds onygf dg v`i s|icdodcmvdng no v`i HJ (00? |mvigv$'
F'D' 689 mv 6$
Mev`nyh` m censi }yisvdng% ng jmemgci v`i Cnyzv mhziis xdv` Fioigfmgvs v`mv v`i HJ (646
|mvigv mfi}ymviet dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigci v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i cnb|nygfs fisczdjif dg
v`i HJ (00? |mvigv' V`i Oifizme Cdzcydv `ms ̀ ief v`mv mgmenhnys svmvibigvs cngvmdgdgh sdbdemz
eiies no fivmde xizi syoodcdigvet s|icdodc onz dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci' Sii Cmeemxmt HneoCn'
v' Mcys`giv Cn'% 98? O'3f =33=% =369"68 Oif' Cdz' :<<4$ *Zioizigci ds bmfi vn ' ' ' Y'S' \mv'
Gn' 6%:86%?38 x`dc` fisczdjis m gybjiz noonmbmjei cnb|nsdvdngs no m c`mzmcviz x`dc` bmt ji
ib|entif ' ' ' onz v`i hneojmees no v`ds dgigvdng'*$1 Dg zi _nss% 998 O':f 0=:% 0=?"=8 CC\M
=488$ *Zioizigci ds bmfi vn Ygdvif Svmvis \mvigv Gn' :%4:<%48= ' ' ' onz m higizme fdscyssdng no
hemss"cizmbdc bmvizdmes mgf v`idz |znfycvdng'*$1 Dg zi @yh`is% 99< O':f =:83% =:89"8? CC\M
=488$ *Zioizigci ds bmfi vn m||edcmvdng Siz' Gn' =3=%=<0 onz cnb|eivi fisczd|vdngs nobiv`nfs
no |zi|mzdgh m}yinys |netbizdc fds|izsdngs m||edcmjei dg v`i `izidgmoviz fisczdjif dgigvdng'*$1
co Cnbbngximev` Scd' / Dgfys' Zisimzc` Nzh' v' Jyoomen Vic`' (YSM$% Dgc'% 96: O'3f =3?3%
=38: Oif' Cdz' :<<0$ odgfdgh gn dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci x`izi `nsv fncybigv biziet cdvif
6
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 6/9
mgnv`iz fncybigv dg onnvgnvi xdv`nyv mgt oyzv`iz ip|emgmvdng nz fdscyssdng$': Dg dix no v`ds
|zicifigv% v̀ i Cnyzv odgfs v`mv v`i HJ (646 |mvigv mfi}ymviet zioizigcis v`i HJ (00? |mvigv xdv`
syoodcdigvet *fivmdeif |mzvdcyemzdvt* zihmzfdgh v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i cnb|nygfs fdscensif dg
v`i HJ (00? |mvigv'
V`i Cnyzv fdsmhziis xdv` Sygndng(s mssizvdng v`mv v`i HJ (646 |mvigv zioizs vn v`i
cnb|nygfs( |zmcvdcme yvdedvt biziet ms *jmcahznygf* mgf *gnv ms |mzv no v`i syjsvmgvdi
fisczd|vdng no v`i dgigvdng'* F'D' 688 mv 3$ Vn v`i cngvzmzt% v`i HJ (646 |mvigv bmais ceimz
v`mv v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i cnb|nygfs fisczdjif dg v`i HJ (00? |mvigv ds mg dgvihzme ms|icv
no v`i dgigvdng cemdbif dg v`i HJ (646 |mvigv' S|icdodcmeet% v`i HJ (646 |mvigv gnvis v`mv v`i
zmcibdc cnb|nygfs no v`i HJ (00? |mvigv *svdbyemvi w " m f z i g i z h d c zici|vnzs* mgf v`mv *v`i
|zmcvdcme yvdedvt no syc` mcvddvt ds bnzi oyeet fisczdjif* dg v`i s|icdodcmvdng no v`i HJ (00?
|mvigv' HJ (646 |mvigv mv =; =0"::$ Dbbifdmviet v`izimoviz% dg v`i gipv |mzmhzm|`% v`i dgigvnz
ib|`msd{if v`mv v`i dgigvdng dgneif v`i fdscnizt no m gix |znciss onz |zi|mzdgh v`i
dgfddfyme dsnbizs no mejyvizne% mgf v`mv *v`i mfmgvmhi no v`ds |znciss ' ' ' ds no|mzvdcyemz
db|nzvmgci ' ' ' sdgci v`i |`mzbmcnenhdcme mcvddvt no ngi dsnbiz dg svmgfmzf visvs onz
jzngc`nfdemvnz mcvdng ds izt byc` hzimviz v`mg v`mv no v`i nv`iz'* (Df mv = :9"36$ V`i dgigvnz
v`ys ceimzet dgfdcmvif v`mv v`i cemdbif |znciss onz |zi|mzdgh dsnbizs xms mfmgvmhinys mgf
db|nzvmgv |zicdsiet jicmysi v`i |`mzbmcnenhdcme mcvddvt " mgf% dg vyzg% v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt "
v`mv ds bnzi oyeet fisczdjif dg v`i HJ (00? |mvigv xms *izt byc` hzimviz* onz ngi dsnbiz
:Mev`nyh` v`i HJ (646 |mvigv fnis gnv s|icdodcmeet ysi v`i |`zmsi *dgcnz|nzmvi jt zioizigci%* v`i
cmsis cdvif mjni deeysvzmvi v`mv v`nsi s|icdodc xnzfs mzi gnv zi}ydzif' Bnziniz% v`i Oifizme
Cdzcydv `ms dgfdcmvif v`mv *gn |mzvdcyemz (bmhdc xnzfs( mzi zi}ydzif vn dgcnz|nzmvi m fncybigv jt
zioizigci'* Gnzv`zn| Hzybbmg% 939 O'3f mv =36?' Dgsvimf% x`mv ds zi}ydzif ds v`mv v`i m||edcmgv
*cdvQiR syc` bmvizdme dg m bmggiz v`mv bmais ceimz v`mv v`i bmvizdme ds iooicvdiet |mzv no v`i `nsv
fncybigv ms do dv xizi ip|edcdvet cngvmdgif v`izidg'* Mfmgcif Fds|emt% :=: O'3f mv =:0:'
9
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 7/9
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 8/9
fivizbdgmvdng onz v`i omcvodgfiz vn zisnei mv vzdme' 6
_' CNGCEYSDNG
Onz v̀ i onzihndgh zimsngs% v`i Cnyzv cngceyfis v`mv v`i HJ (646 |mvigv dgcnz|nzmvis jt
zioizigci v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i cnb|nygfs fisczdjif dg v`i s|icdodcmvdng no v`i HJ (00?
|mvigv% mgf v`mv syc` bmvizdme xdee ji cngsdfizif ms m sdghei zioizigci onz |yz|nsis no
mgvdcd|mvdng mv vzdme' Mg m||zn|zdmvi Nzfiz oneenxs'
6V`i |mzvdis `mi mesn cdvif vn visvdbngt |zndfif jt mg dgigvnz mgf mg myv`nz no v`i
dgcnz|nzmvdgh `nsv zioizigci' V`i syjkicvdi dixs no v`isi dgfddfymes mzi gnv `ie|oye dg
zisnedgh v`i fds|yvi |zisigvet jionzi v`i Cnyzv% sdgci dv ds v`i njkicvdi svmgfmzf no *ngi
zimsngmjet sadeeif dg v`i mzv Qv`mvR s`nyef ji ysif vn fivizbdgi x`iv`iz v`i `nsv fncybigv
fisczdjis v`i bmvizdme vn ji dgcnz|nzmvif jt zioizigci'* Mfvmgcif Fds|emt% :=: O'3f mv =:03'
Sdbdemzet% v`i ip|izv visvdbngt cdvif jt Sygndng ds emzhiet fdzicvif gnv vn v`i dssyi no
dgcnz|nzmvdng jt zioizigci jyv% zmv`iz% vn v`i bizdvs no v`i yevdbmvi mgvdcd|mvdng fivizbdgmvdng%
mgf onz v`ds zimsng ds higizmeet yg`ie|oye `izi'
8
8/3/2019 Sunovion Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Dey Pharma., L.P., et al., C.A. No. 06-113-LPS
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/sunovion-pharmaceuticals-inc-v-dey-pharma-lp-et-al-ca-no-06-113-lps 9/9
DG V@I YGDVIF SVMVIS FDSVZDCV CNYZV
ONZ V@I FDSVZDCV NO FIEMXMZI
SYGN_DNG \@MZBMCIYVDCMES DGC'%
\emdgvdoo%
v'
FIT \@MZBM'% E'\'% FIT% DGC'%
BTEMG DGC'% mgf BTEMG
\@MZBMCIYVDCMES DGC'%
Fioigfmgvs'
Cdde Mcvdng Gn' <?"==3"E\S
NZFIZ
Mv Xdebdghvng% v`ds =0v` fmt no Kmgymzt :<=:%
Onz v`i zimsngs siv onzv` dg v`i Bibnzmgfyb N|dgdng dssyif v`ds fmvi%
DV DS @IZIJT NZFIZIF v`mv;
Jzdvds` |mvigv HJ = :40 646 dgcnz|nzmvis jt zioizigci v`i |zmcvdcme yvdedvt no v`i
cnb|nygfs fisczdjif dg v`i s|icdodcmvdng noJzdvds` |mvigv HJ = :<< 00?' Fioigfmgvs xdee ji
|izbdvvif vn |zisigv syc` bmvizdme m v vzdme ms m sdghei zioizigci dg sy||nzv no v`idz mgvdcd|mvdng
moodzbmvdi fioigsi mgf cnygvizcemdb'