![Page 1: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
C.W. Beausang, Physics Department, University of Richmond
Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region
![Page 2: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
The University of Richmond
![Page 3: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The Surrogate Reaction Technique … a brief tour …
The Problem Neutron induced reactions on unstable nuclei are difficult or impossible to measure directly.
E.g. Half life of 237U is only about one week.
Tough to make a target.
A solution … (?) Pioneered by Chip Britt, Jerry Wilhelmy etc., in the 70’s
Produce the same (compound) system at similar excitation energies and spins using light charged particle induced reactions on stable targets.
Measure the decay probabilities, using particle and / or gamma-rays as tags.
Charged particle tag identifies
a) The final nucleus
b) The excitation energy
![Page 4: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
237U n
Desired reaction 238U*
Fission “(n,γ)”
238U*
(d, d’γ)
Pγ
“(n,n’)”
237U*
(d, d’nγ) Pn
The Surrogate Reaction Technique
“Surrogate” reactions
238U d d
238U α
α
σ(n,f) = Σ(states) σabsorption Pfission
![Page 5: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
237U n
Desired reaction
“Surrogate” reactions
238U d d
238U*
σ(n,f) = Σ(states) σabsorption Pfission
Fission
∝ N(d,d’)(238U)
N(d,d’f)(238U)
Hauser-Feshbach σα = ΣJ,π σαCN (E,J,π) . GCN(E,J,π)
Weisskopf-Ewing limit: Decay probabilities are independent of J,π: GCN(E,J,π) ------> GCN(E)
Target contaminants (C, N and O) make extraction of absolute cross sections difficult.
P(d,d’f)(238U) ∝ N(d,d’)(238U)
N(d,d’f)(238U)
![Page 6: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
The External Ratio Method
σ (d, df) (236U) ∝
N (d, df) (236U) N (d, d) (236U) σ(d, df) (238U)
N (d, d) (238U) N (d, df) (238U)
σ formation(238U) σ(n,f) (236U) σ formation(236U) σ(n,f) (238U)
σ (n, f) (236U) N (d, df) (236U) σ (n, f) (238U) N (d, df) (238U) =
![Page 7: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Challenges (Theory and Experimental):
2. Accounting for the J π population mismatch:
1. The role of pre-equilibrium reactions - or:
Is the intermediate nucleus truly in a compound state?: Bohr Model 1936
3. Choice of the reaction:
Benchmarking
![Page 8: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
What do you need to make this work? 1. An efficient charged particle detector array
… to tag / select the excitation energy in the compound system and to select a decay path (gamma-decay, fission).
STARS 2. An efficient gamma-ray detector array
…to i.d. & to measure the decay products.
Liberace (LBNL) 3. Help from theorists and modelers
LLNL Nuclear Theory Group
![Page 9: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
“clover” Ge g-ray detectors
1000 µm E detectors
Al δ-electron & fission fragment shield
55 MeV a’s
140 µm ΔE detector
Fission Fragments
γ
γ
140 µm fission detector
238U target
Fron
t En
ergy
Back Energy
α
p,d,t
3He
STARS: Silicon Telescope Array for Reaction Studies
![Page 10: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
STARS-LIBERACE Can achieve relatively high particle-γ coincidence statistics!!!
![Page 11: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
• Targets: 238U and 236U (300 µg/cm2), each on a carbon backing of 200 µg/cm2
• Beam: Deuterium at 24 and 32 MeV
• Reactions of interest: Surrogate: – 237U(n, f) 238U(d, d’f) – 235U(n, f) 236U(d, d’f) – 238U(n, f) 238U(d, pf) – 236U(n, f) 236U(d, pf)
1st Experiment: STARS at Yale (2004)
Benchmark
New
![Page 12: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
C. Plettner, et. al., Phys. Rev. C 71, 051602 (2005).
Benchmark
New
236U(d,pf) / 238U(d,pf)
238U(d,d’f) / 236U(d,d’f)
1st Experiment: STARS at Yale (2004)
![Page 13: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
SETUP STARS at Berkeley:
• Advantages: Self supporting 238U target, which removes contaminations for
the 238U measurement. Alpha beam, which reduces activation (dead-time).
Targets: Self Supporting 238U, and 236U on a natural Tantalum backing. Beam: Alpha particles at 55 MeV. Reaction of interest:
238U(α, α’f) 237U(n, f) 236U(α, α’f) 235U(n, f)
![Page 14: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Particle I.D. Spectrum
… much cleaner than the previous Yale data.
Gate on alpha’s and select fission in coincidence …
![Page 15: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Fission Fragment and α Particle Spectra
Energy (channels)
238U
Blank target frame
Energy (channels)
Total α energy
![Page 16: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Cross Section Ratios 236U / 238U
(a, a’f) (d, d’f)
Jason Burke et al., Phys. Rev. C73 054604 (2006).
236U(a,a’f) / 238U(a,a’f)
235U(n,n’f) / 237U(n,n’f)
![Page 17: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
S.R. Lesher et al. Phys. Rev. C79 044609 (2009)
Benchmark:
Experimental cross section ratio agrees with evaluation to ~5% over 20 MeV energy range. 233U(n,f)/235U(n,f)
vs. 234U(α,α’f) / 236U(α, α’f)
Alpha’s in coincidence with fission
![Page 18: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Internal Surrogate Ratio Method
Measured
Measured
ENDF
ENDF
![Page 19: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Internal Surrogate Ratio Method
![Page 20: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
ENDF Cross Sections for 235U(n,x)
Ex(236U) = 6.55 MeV = Sn
γ-channel probabilitiy drops dramatically > Sn; hard to measure with neutrons!!!
![Page 21: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Energy-Spin Distributions
![Page 22: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
STARS-LIBERACE
d Beam @
21 MeV 235U
ΔE E1 E2
Clover (5 used)
Clover (5 used)
p
Fission-E
Si Det"
fis
Si Det"
γ .5mm 1mm 1mm .14mm
+ 12C**
** 450 µg/cm2 target with 12C backing
“raytrace”"
Can achieve relatively high particle-γ coincidence statistics!!!
![Page 23: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Identification of 235U(d,pxn)
Particle ID:
Banana gate on p
p-γ
p-f
![Page 24: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Fission and γ Spectra: 235U(d,p)236U 642 keV γ-ray has the highest statsitics and is well “isolated” from doublets!!!
![Page 25: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Partial Level Scheme: 235U(d,pγ) 236U
N235U-γ = Inttot(0+) Effγ -ch “γ-ch yield”
The γ-channel yield is defined as the total “parallel” yield to the ground state
=“γ-ch yield”
![Page 26: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
γ-Channel Yield (by 642 keV)
Inttot(0+) = Int(687) + Int(958) + Int(966) + Inttot(2+) + Γunseen
642 keV Fraction for interval (2.6 MeV<E*<6.5 MeV) = Int(642) / Inttot(0+) = 36.3 +/- 1.2 % for Γunseen =0
γ-channel yield =
Can only measure 642 keV γ-ray for E*>Sn; determine fraction of γ-channel < Sn
![Page 27: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
γ-Channel Yield (by 642 keV)
Inttot(0+) = Int(687) + Int(958) + Int(966) + Inttot(2+) + Γunseen 642 keV Fraction for interval (2.6 MeV<E*<6.5 MeV) = Int(642) / Inttot(0+) = 36.3 +/- 1.2 % for Γunseen =0
γ-channel yield =
Is “Unobserved” side feeding a BIG contribution to γ-channel yield, Inttot(0+) ???
Can only measure 642 keV γ-ray for E*>Sn; determine fraction of γ-channel < Sn
![Page 28: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
“Unobserved” Feeding Distribution
Intout
Intin-discrete
U(J)=Intout- Intin-discrete
Unobserved Feeding to 0+ and 2+ (Γ) small?
“Unobserved” Side Feeding
Continuum
J
Can we infer unobserved side feeding to J=0,2 yrast?
Determined for gate on 2.6 MeV<E*<6.5 MeV
![Page 29: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
“Unobserved” Feeding Distribution
Intout
Intin-discrete
U(J)=Intout- Intin-discrete Unobserved Feeding to 0+ and 2+ (Γ) looks small
“Unobserved” Side Feeding
Continuum
J
Unobserved side feeding to J=0,1,2,3 is less than that to J=4!!!
Determined for gate on 2.6 MeV<E*<6.5 MeV
![Page 30: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
“Unobserved” Feeding Distribution
Intout
Intin-discrete
U(J)=Intout- Intin-discrete
“Unobserved” Side Feeding
Continuum
J
100% error
Unobserved Feeding = 4.6% of γ-channel yield, Inttot(0+)
Infer unobserved side feeding to J=0,2 yrast by extrapolation.
Determined for gate on 2.6 MeV<E*<6.5 MeV
![Page 31: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
N235U-γ / Effγ-ch ---> Inttot(0+) ---> Int(642) / Fraction(642) γ-ch-yield:
642 keV Fraction of γ-channel Yield
642 keV fraction of γ-channel is independent of excitation energy within error!!!
![Page 32: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Internal Ratio Result for 235U(n,γ)
ZOOM IN
γ-channel probabilitiy drops dramatically > Sn
![Page 33: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Internal Ratio Result for 235U(n,γ)
ENDF
Stars-Liberace
Within error, the surrogate γ-to-f ratio is similar to the neutron induced reaction
J.M. Allmond et al., Phys. Rev. C79, 054610 (2009).
![Page 34: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
236U
232Th
238U(p, t) 235U(d, p)
236U(p, p’)
236U(a, a’)
237Np(d, 3He)
232Th(6Li, d)
Benchmarking: Choice of Reaction Populate the same nucleus via several different surrogate reactions.
Compare the resulting cross section (ratios)
238U(p, t)236U
Multiple surrogate measurements in a single experiment
Approved to run at the 88-Inch this fall.
![Page 35: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
157Gd(n,g) 155Gd(n,g)
Absolute cross section
![Page 36: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
Investigating the N = 90 Region via (p, t), (p, d) & (p, p’)Reactions
N = 90
Gd 152 154 156 158
2.19 3.01 3.24 3.30
(p, t)
(p, d)
R(4/2)
Spherical Deformed Abundance of low
lying 0+ states
D.A. Meyer, et al., Phys. Rev. C 74, 044309 (2006)
Transitional
0+ 0+
0+
![Page 37: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Identification of 156Gd(p,t)154Gd
![Page 38: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
t-γ Example: Triton Spectra
# Tritons
Gate on γ
Gamma gated triton spectra show the ensemble of states which are directly populated and subsequently gamma decay to the level selected.
![Page 39: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
154Gd
156Gd 152Gd
Total Proj
Gate: 2+ 0+
Gate: 02 2+
0+
2+
![Page 40: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
-1.0000000000
0.0000000000
1.0000000000
2.0000000000
3.0000000000
4.0000000000
5.0000000000
6.0000000000
2 --> 0 4 --> 2 6 --> 4 8 --> 6 0 --> 2 0.0
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0 N
orm
aliz
ed S
lope
(a
rb. U
nits
) 154Gd
152Gd
156Gd
Slope: Measures the continuum population which feeds the selected level Larger slope for spherical and transitional nuclei => less feeding from very high in the continuum?
![Page 41: Surrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Regionmantica/radio-frib/beausang-acsboston.pdfSurrogate Ratio Method Measurements in the Actinide Region . The University of Richmond](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022042005/5e6f4bc07a0511696211223c/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
Surrogate Reactions Summary • Fission: Seems to work within a few percent over large energy range.
• (n,γ) and (n,2nγ) … initial results show agreement to ~20%. Now working on other benchmarking experiments in mass 90 and mass 150 regions.
• Benchmarking using different entrance channels!
• Looking at structure/surrogates for (n, γ) in mass 150 (and other regions)
Conclusions and future outlook: Need systematics!!!