![Page 1: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
The age-period cohortproblem: set identificationand point identification
Martin BrowningIan CrawfordMarike Knoef
The Institute for Fiscal StudiesDepartment of Economics, UCL
cemmap working paper CWP02/12
![Page 2: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
!"# $%#&'#()*+&,*"*(- .(*/0#12 3#-
)+#4-)5),6-)*4 64+ '*)4- )+#4-)5),6-)*4
!"#$%& '#()&%&*+&%,-#.%$/ (0 120(#3
4"& 5#")0(#3+&%,-#.%$/ (0 120(#3 6 478
!"#%9- ;&(-0<-%3-& +&%,-#.%$/ 6 5-&$=>3"$"
!"#$%&'$
?1&@/ -&$#(A/ B(C-. -".%@/D E F&$(& 5G-9G(,
H"#%(I. C-$G(3. G",- J--& I.-3 $( (,-#B(C- $G- A(%&$ %3-&$%KB"$%(& A#(J@-C %&G-#-&$%& $G- @%&-"# "*-EA-#%(3EB(G(#$ C(3-@L MG%. A"A-# A#-.-&$. " .-$E%3-&$%KB"$%(& #-.I@$ 0(#$G- C(3-@ "&3 $G-& B(&.%3-#. $G- I.- (0 $G- C"2%CICE-&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@- ". " ,-G%B@-0(# "BG%-,%&* A(%&$ %3-&$%KB"$%(&L N- A#-.-&$ $)( .IJ.$"&$%,- "AA@%B"$%(&. O+8 0-C"@-C(#$"@%$/ 3"$" "&3 "&3 +; 0-C"@- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(&P "&3 B(CA"#- $G- #-.I@$. 0#(C(I# "AA#("BG $( .(C- (0 $G- .(@I$%(&. %& $G- @%$-#"$I#-L
!'()*+,-./-0-)$#1 N- "#- ,-#/ *#"$-0I@ $( M"9 N%&* 5G"&Q 5(#C"B 1RS-" "&3 $(.-C%&"# A"#$%BA"&$. %& M%@JI#*Q 120(#3 "&3 "$ $G- 4&.$%$I$- 0(# 7%.B"@ 8$I3%-. 0(# G-@A0I@3%.BI..%(&. "&3 .I**-.$%(&.L '#()&%&* "&3 5#")0(#3 *#"$-0I@@/ "B9&()@-3*- K&"&B%"@.IAA(#$ 0(# $G%. #-.-"#BG 0#(C $G- +; =B(&(C%B "&3 8(B%"@ >-.-"#BG 5(I&B%@L
8$"$" B(3- $( -.$%C"$- $G- C(3-@ 3-.B#%J-3 %& $G%. A"A-# %. ","%@"J@- 0#(C $G- "I$G(#.L
2 3)$%*.4'$5*)
MG- "*-EA-#%(3EB(G(#$ OG-&B-0(#$G !"#$ C(3-@ %. I.-3 )%3-@/ %& &ICJ-# (0 3%.B%A@%&-. .IBG ".
.(B%(@(*/Q 3-C(*#"AG/Q -B(&(C%B. "&3 -A%3-C%(@(*/L 4$ "%C. $( .-A"#"$-Q 0(# .(C- (I$B(C-
(0 %&$-#-.$Q $G(.- %&TI-&B-. "..(B%"$-3 )%$G $G- A#(B-.. (0 "*%&*Q 0#(C $G(.- %&TI-&B-. "..(E
B%"$-3 )%$G $G- 3"$- "$ )G%BG .IJU-B$. "#- (J.-#,-3Q 0#(C $G(.- %&TI-&B-. "..(B%"$-3 )%$G "
.IJU-B$R. 3"$- (0 J%#$GL MG"$ $G- $G#-- -V-B$. B"& J- B(&B-A$I"@%W-3 ". 3%.$%&B$ )". "#*I-3 "$
@-".$ ". 0"# J"B9 ". >/3-# OXYZ[P\ 3%V-#-&$ "*- *#(IA. )%$G%& $G- A(AI@"$%(& "#- "$ 3%V-#-&$
.$"*-. (0 @%0- #-@"$%&* $( -3IB"$%(&Q )(#9 "&3 0-#$%@%$/\ "$ ,"#%(I. 3"$-. %&3%,%3I"@. "#- -2A(.-3
$( 3%V-#-&$ -,-&$. )G%BG G",- A(AI@"$%(&E)%3- -V-B$. .IBG ". 0"C%&-.Q )"#.Q #-B-..%(&. "&3
X
![Page 3: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
-A%3-C%B.\ .IBB-..%,- 3"$-E(0EJ%#$G B(G(#$. -2A-#%-&B- 3%V-#-&$ G%.$(#%-.Q %&.$%$I$%(&. "&3 A--#E
*#(IA .(B%"@%W"$%(&L MGI.Q %$ %. "#*I-3Q "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ "@@ G",- 3%.$%&B$%,- %&TI-&B-.
(& %&3%,%3I"@. "&3 *#(IA. (0 %&3%,%3I"@.L MG- !"# C(3-@ "%C. $( 3%.-&$"&*@- $G-.- %&TI-&B-.L
+&0(#$I&"$-@/Q $G- @%&-"# !"# C(3-@ .IV-#. 0#(C " )-@@E9&()& 0I&3"C-&$"@ %3-&$%KB"$%(&
A#(J@-CQ &"C-@/ $G"$ $G-#- %. " A-#0-B$ @%&-"# #-@"$%(&.G%A J-$)--& $G-.- -V-B$.] A-#%(3 -^I"@.
/-"# (0 J%#$G A@I. "*-L 4$ %. %CA(..%J@- $G-#-0(#- $( (J.-#,- %&3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"$%(& %& $G-.-
B(&3%$%(&%&* ,"#%"J@-. "&3 G-&B- .$"&3"#3 @%&-"# #-*#-..%(& $-BG&%^I-. B"&&($ .-A"#"$- $G-CL
MG- A-#0-B$ CI@$%B(@@%&-"#%$/ %& $G-.- ,"#%"J@-. C"9-. A(%&$ %3-&$%KB"$%(& (0 $G- .-A"#"$- -V-B$.
%CA(..%J@-L
+&3-$-##-3Q #-.-"#BG-#. G",- G-@3 $( $G- ,%-) $G"$ $G-.- %&TI-&B-. "#- J($G %CA(#$"&$ "&3
3%.$%&B$ "&3 .( " @"#*- @%$-#"$I#- *(%&* J"B9 $( $G- XY_`. G". *#()& IA "#(I&3 $G- A#(J@-C
(0 %3-&$%0/%&* !"# C(3-@.\ .--Q 0(# -2"CA@-Q !".(& -$ "@L OXY_aPQ b@-&& OXY_ZPQ 7%-&J-#*
"&3 !".(& OXY_YPQ ;IAA-# -$ "@L OXYc[PXL F$ G-"#$ $G- !"# C(3-@ A(.-. "& %@@EA(.-3 %&,-#.-
A#(J@-C "&3 .( C(.$ .(@I$%(&. A#(B--3 J/ I.%&* "..ICA$%(&. (# A#%(# %&0(#C"$%(& $( $#"&.0(#C
%$ %&$( " )-@@EA(.-3 A#(J@-C )G%BG B"& J- .(@,-3 J/ .$"&3"#3 .$"$%.$%B"@ C-$G(3.L 4& $G%. ,-%&
" &ICJ-# (0 .(@I$%(&. G",- J--& AI$ 0(#)"#3] (&- %. $( #-E.A-B%0/ $G- C(3-@ "&3 $( -%$G-#
C"9- %$ &(&E@%&-"# (# $( -.$%C"$- %$ %& 3%V-#-&B-.\ "&($G-# %. $( %CA(.- " A"#"C-$-# #-.$#%B$%(&
(0 .(C- 9%&3 O(&- %. -&(I*GP\ " 0(I#$G %. $( #-A@"B- $G- 3ICC%-. )G%BG B"A$I#- (&- (0 $G-
-V-B$. )%$G 3"$" )G%BG #-T-B$ " B"I."@ C-BG"&%.CL >-B-&$@/ "& "@$-#&"$%,- *-&-#%B E B(&$-2$
%&3-A-&3-&$ E .(@I$%(& G". J--& .I**-.$-3 J/ d"&* -$ "@L Oe``fQ e``_Q e``cP )G( %&$#(3IB-3
$G- %&'(%&)%# *)'%+!',(L MG%. "AA#("BG 3(-. &($ I.- #-*I@"#%W%&* %3-&$%0/%&* "..ICA$%(&. %& $G-
I.I"@ .-&.-Q JI$ 3(-. %CA(.- .(C- #-^I%#-C-&$. (& $G- *-(C-$#%B (#%-&$"$%(& (0 $G- A"#"C-$-#
,-B$(# %& $G- A"#"C-$-# .A"B-L
X =2"CA@-. (0 "AA@%-3 )(#9 %&B@I3- 3-,-@(AC-&$. %& .(B%"@ BG"&*-. .IBG ". C"##%"*- Og-#&-. XY_ePQ $#-&3.%& C(#$"@%$/ O5".- XYZ[\ 5(@@%&. XYce\ 5"/I-@" -$ "@L e``fPQ 3-,-@(AC-&$. %& %&B(C- "&3 )-"@$G O;"A$-/& -$"@L e``[PQ O0-C"@-P @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& O5(&$#-#". -$ "@L e``[\ =I)"@. -$ "@L e`XX\ '"@@--# -$ "@L e``YPQ)"*-. O!-*G%# "&3 NG%$-G(I.- XYYZ\ ;"@)%U "&3 F@-..%- e``_PQ "&3 .",%&*. J-G",%(# OF$$"&".%( XYYcPL
e
![Page 4: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
MG%. A"A-# .I**-.$. "&($G-# *-&-#%B "AA#("BG $( !"# C([email protected] N- K#.$ .G() $G"$ %& B".-.
%& )G%BG $G- #"&*- (0 $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- %. J(I&3-3 %& $G- A(AI@"$%(& O0(# -2"CA@-Q )G-&
%$ C-".I#-. " J%&"#/ -,-&$P $G- C(3-@ %. A"#$%"@@/ %3-&$%K-3 %& $G- .-&.- (0 !"&.9% Oe``aP] $G-
A"#"C-$-#. (0 $G- C(3-@ B"& J- .G()& $( J- B(&K&-3 $( " B@(.-3Q B(&,-2 .-$L
7(# .(C- AI#A(.-. %$ C"/ J- .IhB%-&$ $( )(#9 )%$G $G- %3-&$%K-3 .-$L 10$-&Q G()-,-#Q
)- .--9 " A(%&$ )%$G%& $G"$ .-$\ )- A#(A(.- I.%&* " C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$(# $( A(%&$
%3-&$%0/ $G- !"# A"#"C-$-#.L MG%. "AA#("BG G". %$. #(($. %& .$"$%.$%B"@ C-BG"&%B. "&3 @"$-#
%&0(#C"$%(& $G-(#/eL 4$ A#(B--3. J/ #-A#-.-&$%&* I&B-#$"%&$/ "J(I$ .(C- (JU-B$ (0 %&$-#-.$
O%& $G%. B".- $G- B(-hB%-&$ ,-B$(# (0 $G- !"# C(3-@P %& $-#C. (0 " A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&
O)G-#- A#(J"J%@%$/ %. %&$-#A#-$-3 ". " C-".I#- (0 " .$"$- (0 9&()@-3*- #"$G-# $G"& " @%C%$%&*
0#-^I-&B/PL 4$ $G-& 0(BI..-. (& $G%. A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& "&3 B(&.%3-#. G() $( "##"&*- $G%.
3%.$#%JI$%(& %& " )"/ $G"$ J-.$ #-A#-.-&$. $G- BI##-&$ .$"$- (0 9&()@-3*- ". #-,-"@-3 J/Q "&3
B(&.%.$-&$ )%$GQ $G- 3"$" "$ G"&3L MG- B#%$-#%(& 0I&B$%(& I.-3 $( .-@-B$ $G- A#(J"J%@%$%-. %.
"& -&$#(A/ C-".I#- )G%BG 8G"&&(& OXYfcP .G()-3 )". %3-&$%K-3 OIA $( " B(&.$"&$P J/ $G-
#-^I%#-C-&$. $G"$ "&/ C-".I#- (0 I&B-#$"%&$/ .G(I@3 J- B(&$%&I(I.Q ./CC-$#%B O)%$G #-.A-B$
$( #-(#3-#%&* (0 $G- (I$B(C-.PQ C"2%C%W-3 )G-& "@@ -,-&$. "#- -^I%A#(J"J@- "&3 "33%$%,-@/
3-B(CA(."J@- O.( $G"$ $G- $($"@ "C(I&$ (0 I&B-#$"%&$/ %& " A#(B-.. %. %&3-A-&3-&$ (0 G()
$G- A#(B-.. C%*G$ J- #-*"#3-3 ". J-%&* 3%,%3-3 %&$( A"#$.PL MG- -&$#(A/ C-".I#- )- I.- %.Q
%& 0"B$Q " .A-B%"@ B".- (0 $G- C(#- *-&-#"@ B#(..E-&$#(A/ B#%$-#%" .I**-.$-3 J/ b((3 OXYZaP
"&3 ;I@@J"B9 OXY[YP )G%BG %&B@I3-. A#%(# %&0(#C"$%(& (& $G- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&L '($G
$G- C"2%CIC B#(..E-&$#(A/ -.$%C"$(# "&3 $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$(#. "#- $G-#-0(#-
-2"CA@-. (0 .G#%&9"*- -.$%C"$(#. O.-- 0(# -2"CA@- 8$-%& OXYcXP "&3 S-&W"I -$ "@L OXYcYPPL
!"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$%(& C-$G(3. "#- &() ^I%$- )-@@ -.$"J@%.G-3 O.-- b(@"& -$ "@L XYYZP
JI$ $G-%# I.- %& $G%. B(&$-2$ %.Q ". 0"# ". )- 9&()Q &(,-@L F. )- .G() %& $G%. A"A-# $G-.-
e '(@$WC"& OXc_ePQ i"/&-. OXY[_"Q XY[_JPQ 8G"&&(& OXYfcPL
a
![Page 5: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
C-$G(3. "#- .$#"%*G$0(#)"#3 $( "AA@/ "&3 A#(3IB- #-.I@$. )G%BG B(CA"#- A@"I.%J@/ )%$G $G(.-
3-#%,-3 $G#(I*G ($G-# C-$G(3.L
MG- A"A-# %. (#*"&%W-3 ". 0(@@().L 8-B$%(& e -2A@"%&. $G- %3-&$%KB"$%(& A#(J@-CL 8-B$%(&
a 3-.B#%J-. $G- A"#$%"@ %3-&$%KB"$%(& (0 $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$. )G-& $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- G". "
9&()& .IAA(#$ %& $G- A(AI@"$%(& "&3 A#-.-&$. $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ J".-3 "AA#("BGL 8-B$%(&
f *%,-. " J#%-0 (,-#,%-) (0 .(C- -2%.$%&* .$#"$-*%-. 3-.%*&-3 $( 3-"@ )%$G $G- %3-&$%KB"$%(&
A#(J@-CL 8-B$%(& [ 3-.B#%J-. $G- %&0(#C"$%(&EJ".-3 "AA#("BG $( A(%&$ %3-&$%KB"$%(&L 8-B$%(&
Z (V-#. $)( -CA%#%B"@ -2"CA@-. "&3 .-B$%(& _ B(&[email protected]
6 78- 9%*",-0
8IAA(.- $G"$ )- G",- A"&-@ 3"$" O(# ^I".%EA"&[email protected] (& " *#(IA (0 .IJU-B$.L 7(# A-#.(& ! %&
A-#%(3 " )- (J.-#,- "*- O"$ $G- -&3 (0 $G- .I#,-/ /-"#PQ 3-&($-3 #!"Q 0#(C )G%BG )- B"&
B(&.$#IB$ " /-"# (0 J%#$G OB(G(#$P ,"#%"J@-Q $! ! " ! #!"L N- "@.( (J.-#,- .(C- ,"#%"J@- (0
%&$-#-.$ %!"L 4$ %. (0$-& (0 %&$-#-.$ $( 3-.B#%J- $G- -,(@I$%(& (0 $G%. ,"#%"J@- J/ " 3-B(CA(.%$%(&
%&$( "33%$%,- "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ O"ABP B(CA(&-&$.aL 8%&B- "@@ $G- #%*G$ G"&3 .%3- ,"#%"J@-.
"#- 3%.B#-$-Q )- B"& $"9- " j&(&A"#"C-$#%BRk@(B"@ ",-#"*%&* "AA#("BG]
%!" !!
#
&#'#!" "
!
"
("'" "!
$
)$'$!" " *!" OXP
)G-#- '#!" %. " 3ICC/ ,"#%"J@- $G"$ %. .-$ $( (&- %0 A-#.(& ! %. "*-3 # "$ $G- -&3 (0 .I#,-/
/-"# "\ '$! %. .-$ $( (&- %0 A-#.(& ! )". J(#& %& /-"# $ "&3 '" %. .-$ $( (&- %0 %!" )". #-B(#3-3
0(# A-#.(& ! %& A-#%(3 "L MG- .IC. "#- $"9-& (,-# "@@ A(..%J@- ,"@I-. (0 $G- $G#-- ,"#%"[email protected]
MG%. 0(#CI@"$%(& J#%&*. (I$ B@-"#@/ $G"$ $G- "33%$%,%$/ %CA(.-. ^I%$- .$#(&* #-.$#%B$%(&. (&
$G- 3-.B#%A$%(& (0 $G- -,(@I$%(& (0 $G- ,"#%"J@- (0 %&$-#-.$ .%&B- "@@ jB#(.. $-#C.R O0(# -2"CA@-Q
'#!"'"P "#- 3ICA-3 %&$( $G- #-.%3I"@ $-#C *!"L
a 4& $G%. &($- )- $"9- $G%. ". *%,-&L MG- .$#-&*$G (0 "& "33%$%,- 3-B(CA(.%$%(& %. $G"$ %$ %. AI#-@/ .$"$%.$%B"@O(# C-BG"&%B"@P\ $G- )-"9&-.. O"A"#$ 0#(C $G- &(&E%3-&$%KB"$%(&P %. $G"$ %$ 3(-. &($ j-2A@"%&R $G- .(I#B-. (0"&/ -V-B$. %$ I&B(,-#.L
f
![Page 6: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
4& (I# 3%.BI..%(& (0 $G- %3-&$%KB"$%(& (0 !"# -V-B$. )- .G"@@ B(&.%3-# " .%CA@- ."CA@%&*
.BG-C- %& )G%BG $)( B(G(#$. #$ ! $+ %& "#- 0(@@()-3 0(# $G#-- A-#%(3. #" ! '+ (+ )& .( $G"$ "*-
#"&*-. 0#(C $ $( ( ## ! $+ %+ '+ (& , N- G",-]
%!" ! &!'#"!!" " &#'#"#
!" " &$'#"$!" " &%'#"%
!" " ($'$ " (%'% " (&'& " )!'$"!! " )#'$"#
! " *!" OeP
M)( .-$. (0 %3-&$%KB"$%(& A#(J@-C. "#%.-L MG- K#.$ %. $G"$ -"BG (0 $G- .-$. (0 3ICC%-. .IC.
$( (&-L MG%. %. -".%@/ 3-"@$ )%$G J/Q 0(# -2"CA@-Q .-$$%&* $G- B(-hB%-&$. 0(# $G- /(I&*-.$ "*-
"&3 $G- C(.$ #-B-&$ B(G(#$ #&!+ )#& $( W-#( "&3 %&$-#A#-$%&* $G- #-.$ (0 $G- -V-B$. #-@"$%,- $(
$G%. &(#C"@%W"$%(&L
%!" ! &#'#"#!" " &$'#"$
!" " &%'#"%!" " ($'$ " (%'% " (&'& " )!'$"!
! " *!" OaP
MGI.Q $G- B(-hB%-&$ (& $G- K#.$ A-#%(3 *%,-. $G- -2A-B$-3 (I$B(C- 0(# $G- #-0-#-&B- "*-E
A-#%(3EB(G(#$ )G%BG "#- $G(.- %&3%,%3I"@. )G( )-#- J(#& %& A-#%(3 %Q (J.-#,-3 %& /-"# 'Q "$
$G- "*- (0 $L MG- .-B(&3 %3-&$%KB"$%(& %..I- %. CIBG C(#- .-#%(I.L =,-& )%$G $G- &(#C"@%W"$%(&
"3(A$-3 G-#-Q $G- @%&-"# #-@"$%(&.G%A J-$)--& "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ OA-#%(3 -^I"@. /-"# (0
J%#$G A@I. "*-P %CA(.-. " @%&-"# #-@"$%(&.G%A (& $G- 3ICC/ ,"#%"J@-. %& -^I"$%(& OaPL 4& $G-
A#-.-&$ B(&$-2$ $G%. #-@"$%(&.G%A %.]
!'#"#!" ! %'#"$
!" ! ''#"%!" " '% " %'& " '$"!
!" ! * OfP
8(@,%&* OfP 0(# '#"#!" "&3 .IJ.$%$I$%&* %&$( OaP *%,-. $G- #-3IB-3 0(#C
%!" ! -!'#"$!" " -#'#"%
!" " -$'$ " -%'% " -&'& " -''%"!!" " *!" O[P
)G-#- $G- C"$#%2 (0 #-*#-..(#. G". 0I@@ B(@IC& #"&9 "&3 .( $G- A"#"C-$-#. (0 O[P B"& J-
-.$%C"$-3 J/ (#3%&"#/ @-".$ .^I"#-.L MG- #-@"$%(&.G%A J-$)--& $G- #-3IB-3 0(#C A"#"C-$-#.
[
![Page 7: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
"&3 $G- A"#"C-$-#. (0 %&$-#-.$ C"/ J- )#%$$-& ".
"
######$
-!
-#
-$
-%
-&
-'
%
&&&&&&'
!
"
######$
!% $ * * * * *!' * $ * * * ** * * $ * * *$ * * * $ * *% * * * * $ *$ * * * * * $
%
&&&&&&'
"
########$
&#
&$
&%
($
(%
(&
)!
%
&&&&&&&&'
OZP
(#Q C(#- .IBB%&B$@/]
!! "! O_P
MG%. 3-.B#%J-. " @%&-"# .%CI@$"&-(I. -^I"$%(& ./.$-C )%$G .-,-& I&9&()&. "&3 .%2 -^I"$%(&.
"&3 .-#,-. $( -CAG".%. $G- %@@EA(.-3 %&,-#.- A#(J@-C "$ $G- G-"#$ (0 $G- !"# C(3-@L NG%@.$ )-
C"/ -.$%C"$- $G- .%2 #-3IB-3 0(#C A"#"C-$-#. ! ! +-!+ ,,,+ -',! )- "#- I&"J@-Q ". %$ .$"&3.Q $(
#-B(,-# 0#(C $G-C $G- .-,-& A"#"C-$-#. (0 %&$-#-.$ ! ! +&#+ &$+ &%+ ($+ (%+ (&+ )!,!L MG- ./.$-C
%. I&3-#E3-$-#C%&-3] $G-#- "#- "& %&K&%$/ (0 .(@I$%(&. *%,-& J/
! ! "(!!(#) ! "("
)$ OcP
)G-#- "( %. $G- !((#-El-&#(.- %&,-#.- (0 " "&3 $ %. "& "#J%$#"#/ .-,-&E,-B$(#L N- G",-
&( B(&.$#IB$%,- J".%. 0(# .-@-B$%&*Q 0#(C $G%. I&B(I&$"J@/ %&K&%$- 0-".%J@- .-$Q " A"#$%BI@"#
.(@I$%(& ,-B$(# 0(# !L
; <-$ 5.-)$5='&$5*)
N- &() .G() $G"$ "@$G(I*G $G- A"#"C-$-#. ! "#- &($ A(%&$ %3-&$%K-3Q $G-/ "#- .-$ %3-&$%K-3
%0 $G- .IAA(#$ (0 % %. J(I&3-3L MG- !"# C(3-@ %. " 0I@@/ ."$I#"$-3 #-*#-..%(& C(3-@ %& )G%BG
"@@ (0 $G- #-*#-..(#. "#- 3ICC/ ,"#%"J@-. "&3 .IC. (0 #-*#-..%(& B(-hB%-&$. B(##-.A(&3 $(
B(&3%$%(&"@ OB-@@P C-"&.L 8-$ %3-&$%KB"$%(& 0(@@(). .%&B- %0 $G- (I$B(C- ,"#%"J@- G". " J(I&3-3
#"&*- %& $G- A(AI@"$%(& $G-& J/ $G- @") (0 %$-#"$-3 -2A-B$"$%(&. "@@ (0 %$. B(&3%$%(&"@ C-"&.
"#- &-B-.."#%@/ J(I&3-3L M( .-- $G%.Q )%$G(I$ @(.. (0 *-&-#"@%$/Q B(&.%3-# "*"%& (I# .%CA@-
."CA@%&* .BG-C- %& )G%BG $)( B(G(#$. "#- 0(@@()-3 0(# $G#-- A-#%(3. .( $G"$ "*- #"&*-. 0#(C
Z
![Page 8: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
$ $( ( "&3 B(&.%3-# (I# -^I"$%(& (0 %&$-#-.$ OaP]
%!" ! &#'#"#!" " &$'#"$
!" " &%'#"%!" " ($'$ " (%'% " (&'& " )!'$"!
! " *!"
MG-& .IC. (0 $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$. B(##-.A(&3 $( B(&3%$%(&"@ -2A-B$"$%(&. 0(# "@@ (J.-#,"J@-
"&3 I&(J.-#,"J@-kB(I&$-#0"B$I"@ B(CJ%&"$%(&. (0 "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$. ". 0(@@().]
"
###########################################$
. #% "# ! $+ / ! '+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! '+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! '+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! '+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! $+ / ! '+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! '+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! '+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! '+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! $+ / ! (+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! (+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! (+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! (+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! $+ / ! (+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! (+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! (+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! (+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! $+ / ! )+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! )+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! )+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! )+ $ ! %&
. #% "# ! $+ / ! )+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! %+ / ! )+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! '+ / ! )+ $ ! $&
. #% "# ! (+ / ! )+ $ ! $&
%
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&'
!
"
###########################################$
* * * $ * * *$ * * $ * * ** $ * $ * * ** * $ $ * * ** * * $ * * $$ * * $ * * $* $ * $ * * $* * $ $ * * $* * * * $ * *$ * * * $ * ** $ * * $ * ** * $ * $ * ** * * * $ * $$ * * * $ * $* $ * * $ * $* * $ * $ * $* * * * * $ *$ * * * * $ ** $ * * * $ ** * $ * * $ ** * * * * $ $$ * * * * $ $* $ * * * $ $* * $ * * $ $
%
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&'
"
########$
&#
&$
&%
($
(%
(&
)!
%
&&&&&&&&'
)G%BG )- )%@@ )#%$- C(#- B(CA"B$@/ ". % ! &!L N- K#.$ .G() .-$ %3-&$%KB"$%(& (0 ! %0 $G-
B(&3%$%(&"@ -2A-B$"$%(&. "#- J-$)--& W-#( "&3 I&%$/\ $G"$ %. % # +*+ $,#%L MG- %3-&$%KB"$%(& %&
$G- C(#- *-&-#"@ B".- %& )G%BG % %. J(I&3-3 0(@@(). I.%&* $G- (J,%(I. $#"&.0(#C"$%(&L
>-00&? 40 % # +*+ $, $G-& 0& # +!$+ $, 0(# "@@ 1L
9%**@? N- B"& )#%$- $G- -^I"@%$/ #-.$#%B$%(&. % ! &! # +*+ $,#% ". $G- C"$#%2%&-^I"@%$/ '! $ ( )G-#- ' ! +&! - !&!,! "&3 (m+)!
#% - *!#%,!L N- B"& "@.( )#%$-
$G- #"&*- #-.$#%B$%(& #-@"$%&* $( ! # +!$+ $,) ". +! $ , )G-#- + ! +#) - !#),! "&3, ! +)!%,L N- &--3 $( .G() $G"$ ' ! $ ( %CA@%-. + ! $ ,L MG- B(&3%$%(& I&3-#)G%BG $G%. %. $G- B".- %. *%,-& %& >(B9"0-@@"# OXY_`Q AL XYYQ MG-(#-C eeLaP "&3 %$ %.$G"$ $G-#- -2%.$. " #-"@ &(&E&-*"$%,- C"$#%2 " .IBG $G"$ '!" ! +! "&3 (!" $ ,!L
_
![Page 9: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
MG- A#(J@-C (0 3-B%3%&* )G-$G-# " .I%$"J@- " ,-B$(# -2%.$. B"& J- 3-$-#C%&-3 J/#I&&%&* lG".- X (0 $G- 8%CA@-2 "@*(#%$GC )G%BG )%@@ K&3Q %& " K&%$- &ICJ-# (0.$-A.Q " 0-".%J@- ,-B$(# %V .IBG " ,-B$(# -2%.$.L 4& $G- "AA-&3%2 )- B(&.$#IB$ ".I%$"J@- " C"$#%2 )G%BG ."$%.K-. $G- B(&3%$%(&L 5(&.-^I-&$@/ )- G",- ' ! $ (,!
7(# B".-. %& )G%BG $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- %. J(I&3-3 %& $G- A(AI@"$%(& % # +%*+,+ %*-., $G-&
)- B"& $#"&.0(#C %$ .IBG $G"$ .% ! #% ! %*+,& 2#%*-. ! %*+,& .( $G"$ .% # +*+ $, "&3 "AA@/ $G-
"J(,- "#*IC-&$.L M#"&.0(#C%&* J"B9 I.%&*
% ! %*+, " #%*-. ! %*+,& .% OYP
)- G",- $G- #-.I@$]
A*%%*,&%B 40 % # +%*+,+ %*-., $G-& 0& # +%*+, ! %*-.+ %*-. ! %*+,, 0(# "@@ 1L
MG%. A"#$%"@ %3-&$%KB"$%(& #-.I@$ .G(). $G"$Q )G-& $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- G". " 9&()&
B@(.-3 .IAA(#$ %& $G- A(AI@"$%(&Q $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$ ,-B$(# ! @%-. %& " B@(.-3Q B(&,-2 A"#"C-$-#
.A"B- *%,-& J/ $G- G/A-#BIJ- %Q B-&$-#-3 "$ W-#( )%$G -"BG .%3- (0 @-&*$G % +%*-. ! %*+,,L
C <*0- D*5)$ 5.-)$5@B5)/ &##40D$5*)#
H"#%(I. .(@I$%(&. $( $G- !"# A#(J@-C G",- J--& .I**-.$-3L !(.$ (0 $G-C I.- "..ICA$%(&.
(# A#%(# %&0(#C"$%(& $( $#"&.0(#C $G- I&3-#@/%&* %@@EA(.-3 %&,-#.- A#(J@-C %&$( " )-@@EA(.-3
A#(J@-C )G%BG %. "C-&3"J@- $( .(@I$%(& ,%" .$"&3"#3 C"2%CIC @%9-@%G((3 C-$G(3.L 1&- .IBG
%. $( "J"&3(& $G- j&(&A"#"C-$#%BR C(3-@ "&3 $( A"#"C-$-#%W- (&- (# C(#- (0 $G- -2A@"&"$(#/
,"#%"J@-. )%$GQ 0(# -2"CA@-Q " A(@/&(C%"@ "&3 %CA(.- $G"$ O"$ @-".$P (&- (0 $G- @%&-"# -V-B$. %.
W-#( O-L*L 7%$W-&J-#*-# -$ "@L e``fPL F&($G-# .(@I$%(&Q "@(&* $G- ."C- @%&-.Q %. $( A#(2/ (&- (0
$G- ,"#%"J@-. )%$G .(C-$G%&* C-"&%&*0I@ %& $G- B(&$-2$L 7(# -2"CA@-Q %0 $G- (I$B(C- (0 %&$-#-.$
%. G(I.-G(@3 B(&.ICA$%(& "&3 $G- $%C- -V-B$. "#- $G-#- $( #-T-B$ B(CC(& C"B#(-B(&(C%B
-V-B$. $G-& %$ G". J--& .I**-.$-3 $( A#(2/ $G-C )%$G " C"B#(-B(&(C%B $%C- .-#%-.Lf 1&-
f MG%. "AA#("BG %.Q "C(&* ($G-#.Q I.-3 J/ g-B9C"& "&3 >(JJ OXYc[PQ ;"A$-/& -$ "@L Oe``[PQ N%&.G%A "&3g"#3%&* Oe``[PQ l(#$#"%$ -$ "@L Oe`X`PQ =I)"@. -$ "@L Oe`XXPL
c
![Page 10: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
B"& "@.( "..IC- ")"/ (&- (0 $G- 0"B$(#. O0(# -2"CA@-Q 7%#-J"I*G "&3 S",%. XYcc\ !/-#. "&3
<-- XYYc\ H"& 3-# 8BG(#. -$ "@L e``_PL MG%. )%@@ "@@() $G- ($G-#. $( J- #-B(,-#-3 JI$ %.
,".$@/ (,-#E.IhB%-&$Q .%&B- )- (&@/ &--3 ,&* #-.$#%B$%(& $( "BG%-,- %3-&$%KB"$%(& &( C"$$-#
G() C"&/ /-"#.Q "*-. "&3 B(G(#$. )- G",- ". @(&* ". $G- "33%$%(&"@ #-.$#%B$%(& %. &($ "
@%&-"# B(CJ%&"$%(& (0 $G(.- "@#-"3/ -CJ(3%-3 %& O_PL S#(AA%&* (&- (0 $G- -V-B$. "@$(*-$G-#
*-&-#"@@/ #-.I@$. %& (,-#E%3-&$%KB"$%(& )G%BG *%,-. $-.$"J@- #-.$#%B$%(&.L 8%&B- )- (&@/ &--3
(&- #-.$#%B$%(& $( %3-&$%0/ "@@ $G- A"#"C-$-#. $G%. .I**-.$. $G"$ )- C"/ J- "J@- $( *-$ ")"/
)%$G )-"9-# "..ICA$%(&.Q 0(# -2"CA@-Q $G"$ $G- -V-B$. (0 $)( "3U"B-&$ "*-. "#- $G- ."C-L 40
)- I.- $G%. $( "I*C-&$ " "&3 ! $G-& ""! -2%.$. "&3 $G- ./.$-C B"& J- .(@,-3 I&%^I-@/L MG%.
B(CC(&@/ I.-3 C-$G(3 )". %&$#(3IB-3 J/ !".(& -$ "@L OXY_aPL F&($G-# "AA#("BG )G%BG "@.(
UI.$ %3-&$%K-. %. $G- .I**-.$%(& (0 g"&(BG "&3 g(&%* OXYc[P "&3 S-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& OXYYfP
)G%BG %&,(@,-. 3-$#-&3%&* .IBG $G"$ $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$ %. (#$G(*(&"@ $( " $#-&3 "&3 .IC. $(
W-#(L g()-,-#Q %$ %. %CA(#$"&$ $( &($- $G"$Q ". S-"$(& OXYY_Q AL XeZPQ A(%&$. (I$
?MG%. A#(B-3I#- %. 3"&*-#(I. )G-& $G-#- "#- 0-) .I#,-/.Q )G-#- %$ %. 3%hBI@$ $(
.-A"#"$- $#-&3. 0#(C $#"&.%$(#/ .G(B9.LLLL 1&@/ )G-& $G-#- "#- .IhB%-&$ /-"#.
0(# $#-&3 "&3 B/B@- $( J- .-A"#"$-3 B"& )- C"9- $G- 3-B(CA(.%$%(& )%$G "&/
B(&K3-&B-LD
MG%. A(%&$. $( " *-&-#"@ %..I-Q &($ (&- )G%BG A-#$"%&. (&@/ $( $G- S-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#E
C"@%W"$%(&] B#-3%J@- %3-&$%0/%&* "..ICA$%(& CI.$ J- UI.$%K-3 %& -"BG &-) B(&$-2$ E $G-#- %.
&( I&%,-#."@@/ B#-3%J@- "..ICA$%(&L 7I#$G-#C(#-Q B(-hB%-&$ -.$%C"$-. "#- ,-#/ .-&.%$%,- $(
$G- BG(%B- (0 $G- %3-&$%0/%&* B(&.$#"%&$Q -,-& %0 (&- BG((.-. (&@/ (&- (0 $G-.- O$( *%,- " UI.$
%3-&$%K-3 C(3-@P\ )- %@@I.$#"$- $G%. J-@()L 7(# %3-&$%0/%&* $G- !"# A#(J@-CQ $G- C"%& A#(J@-C
%. $G"$ $G- ! "(%,(% %&0(#C"$%(& &--3-3 0(# #-".(&"J@- %3-&$%0/%&* B(&.$#"%&$. %. .B"#B- Ob@-&&Q
XY_ZPL
F& "@$-#&"$%,- "AA#("BG 3I- $( 7I Oe```P "&3 d"&* -$ "@L Oe``fQ e``cP .I**-.$. $G- I.- (0
$G- j%&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#RL MG%. B(##-.A(&3. $( $G- K#.$ $-#C %& $G- *-&-#"@ .(@I$%(& OcPL MG-
Y
![Page 11: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
"#*IC-&$ 0(# 0(BI..%&* (& $G%. B(CA(&-&$ "AA-"#. $( J- $G"$ $G- .-B(&3 $-#C %. "#J%$#"#/ O3I-
$( $G- #"&3(C ,-B$(# $P .( .G(I@3 &($ A@"/ " #(@- )G-#-". $G- K#.$ $-#C %. " 3-$-#C%&%.$%B
O%&$#%&.%BnP B(CA(&-&$ (0 "@@ A(..%J@- .(@I$%(&.L MG%. 3-$-#C%&%.$%B B(CA(&-&$ A#(,%3-. "
.(@I$%(& 0(# ! )G%BG G". C%&%CIC =IB@%3-"& &(#C "C(&* "@@ .(@I$%(&. E %$ %. %& $G%. .-&.-
$G- .C"@@-.$ .(@I$%(&Q "&3 $G%. C"/ J- " 3-.%#"J@- A#(A-#$/ O.-- d"&* -$ "@L Oe``cP 0(# "
J-$$-# -2A@"&"$%(& (0 $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#Q %$. A#(A-#$%-. "&3 "#*IC-&$. 0(# 0(BI..%&* (& $G-
.(@I$%(& )%$G $ ! *PL F& "AA@%B"$%(& (0 $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(# B"& J- 0(I&3 %& d"&* Oe``cPL
F&($G-# "AA#("BG %. 3I- $( ;I"&* -$ "@L Oe``cPL MG-/ #-%$-#"$- $G- A(%&$ $G"$ ! B"&&($Q %&
*-&-#"@Q J- A(%&$ %3-&$%K-3 0#(C $G- 3"$" "@(&- "&3 .I**-.$Q -&$%#-@/ .-&.%J@/Q $G"$ #-.-"#BG-#.
0(BI. %&.$-"3 (& $G(.- 0-"$I#-. (0 $G- C(3-@ )G%BG #!& J- %3-&$%K-3 0#(C $G- 3"$"L MG-/ B(C-
IA )%$G " #-A"#"C-$-#%W"$%(& (0 $G- C(3-@ )G%BG "@@(). $G- -V-B$. (0 .-B(&3 3%V-#-&B-. $( J-
-.$%C"$-3 "&3 $G- C(3-@ $( J- I.-3 0(# 0(#-B".$%&*L
1I# "AA#("BGQ )G%@.$ 3%V-#-&$ 0#(C ;I"&* -$ "@L Oe``c"QJPQ %. %& ./CA"$G/ )%$G $G-%#
*-&-#"@ AG%@(.(AG/] $G-#- %. &( )"/ $( A(%&$E%3-&$%0/ $G- !"# C(3-@Q /-$ $G- 3"$" 3( $-@@ I.
),+*'-%&.Q .( )- .G(I@3 $G-#-0(#- $#/ $( K&3 )"/. (0 C"9%&* J-.$ I.- (0 $G- %&0(#C"$%(& %&
$G- 3"$"L
E !) 3)@*%0&$5*) F&#-. !DD%*&'8
N- A#(A(.- I.%&* $G- C"2%CICE-&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@- $( "33#-.. $G- A#(J@-CL N- .$#-.. $G"$ $G%.
%. &($ #-"@@/ " ),/0'%,& $( $G- !"# A#(J@-CL 4& (I# ,%-) $G- A#(J@-C G". &( I&%^I- .(@I$%(&
E $G-#- %. &($ -&(I*G %&0(#C"$%(& %& $G- 3"$" $( A#(,%3- (&-L NG%@.$ $G- 3"$" 3( B(&,-/
" B-#$"%& "C(I&$ (0 %&0(#C"$%(& "J(I$ $G- !"# 3-B(CA(.%$%(&Q (,-# "&3 "J(,- $G%. )- CI.$
#-C"%& I&B-#$"%& ". $( $G- A#-B%.- .(@I$%(&L >"$G-# $G"& $#/%&* $( .(@,- $G- A(%&$ %3-&$%KB"$%(&
A#(J@-C 3%#-B$@/Q $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@-[ A#(,%3-. " 0#"C-)(#9 )%$G%& )G%BG )- B"&
[ 7(# " 0I@@ -2A(.%$%(& (0 $G- C"2%CICE-&$#(A/ "AA#("BG .-- !%$$-@G"CC-# -$ "@L Oe```PL
X`
![Page 12: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
0(#C"@%W- $G%. I&B-#$"%&$/L
MG- -..-&$%"@ %3-" %. 3I- $( i"/&-. OXY[_"Q XY[_JP )G( .I**-.$-3 $G"$ (&- .G(I@3 #-A"#"C-E
$-#%W- $G- (JU-B$ (0 %&$-#-.$ O%& $G%. B".- $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$ ,-B$(# !P %& $-#C. (0 " A#(J"J%@%$/
3%.$#%JI$%(& (,-# $G- .-$ (0 A(..%J@- .(@I$%(&.Q "&3 $G-& .-@-B$ $G- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&
)G%BG #-T-B$. $G- @-,-@ (0 (&-R. I&B-#$"%&$/ *%,-& $G- %&0(#C"$%(& ","%@"J@- %& $G- 3"$"L 4&
(#3-# $( 3( $G%.Q $G- C-$G(3 I.-. " C-".I#- (0 %&0(#C"$%(& -&$#(A/ 3I- $( 8G"&&(& OXYfcP
)G%BG %. " .A-B%"@ B".- (0 $G- ;I@@J"B9E<-%J@-#Z 3%.$"&B-L '/ BG((.%&* $( I.- $G- A#(J"J%@%$/
3%.$#%JI$%(& (,-# $G- .-$ (0 A(..%J@- (I$B(C-. )G%BG G". $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ "@@()-3 J/ $G-
3"$"Q $G- "#*IC-&$ *(-.Q )- "#- BG((.%&* $G- C(.$ I&%&0(#C"$%,- 3%.$#%JI$%(& A(..%J@-L M(
BG((.- " 3%.$#%JI$%(& )%$G @()-# -&$#(A/ )(I@3 J- $( "..IC- %&0(#C"$%(& )G%BG )- 3( &($
A(..-..L M( BG((.- " 3%.$#%JI$%(& )%$G G%*G-# -&$#(A/ )(I@3 ,%(@"$- $G- B(&.$#"%&$. A#(,%3-3
J/ $G- %&0(#C"$%(& )G%BG )- 3( A(..-.. 0#(C $G- 3"$"L MGI. $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ 3%.$#%E
JI$%(& (,-# $G- A(..%J@- .(@I$%(&. J-.$ #-A#-.-&$. $G- BI##-&$ .$"$- (0 9&()@-3*-L MG"$Q "$
@-".$Q %. $G- "#*IC-&$L H"#%(I. "I$G(#._ G",- "$$-CA$-3 $( .G() $G"$ BG((.%&* A#(J"J%@%$%-.
%& (#3-# $( C"2%C%W- -&$#(A/ O". C-".I#-3 J/ $G%. B@".. (0 0I&B$%(&.P %. $G- I&%^I-@/ B(##-B$
C-$G(3 (0 C"9%&* %&0-#-&B-. )G%BG ."$%.0/ $G- %&0(#C"$%(& %& $G- 3"$"L NG-$G-# (# &($ $G-/
G",- J--& -&$%#-@/ .IBB-..0I@ %. "& (A-& ^I-.$%(& O.--Q 0(# -2"CA@-Q +h&9 XYY[PL 4& (I# ,%-)
$G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@- %. A@"I.%J@-Q JI$ &($ B(CA@-$-@/ B(CA-@@%&*L iI.$%0/%&* $G-
A#%&B%A@- %.Q G()-,-#Q &($ $G- (JU-B$ (0 $G%. A"A-#L MG- AI#A(.- (0 $G%. A"A-# %. $( %@@I.$#"$- %$.
"AA@%B"$%(& $( " @(&* .$"&3%&* "&3 $G(#&/ %&,-#.- A#(J@-C )G%BG G". @(&* $#(IJ@-3 .(B%(@(*%.$.Q
3-C(*#"AG-#.Q -A%3-C%(@(*%.$. "&3Q (BB".%(&"@@/Q -B(&(C%.$.L
MG-#- %.Q G()-,-# (&- %CA(#$"&$ @%C%$"$%(&] $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ "AA#("BG %. J-.$ "AA@%-3
%& .%$I"$%(&. %& )G%BG $G- .-$ (0 A(..%J@- .(@I$%(&. %. J(I&3-3 "&3 $G%. %. &($ $G- B".- )%$G
Z ;I@@J"B9 "&3 <-%J@-# OXY[XPQ ;I@@J"B9 OXY[YPL_ 7(# -2"CA@-Q 8G(#- "&3 i(G&.(& OXYc`PQ M%9(BG%&.9/ -$ "@L OXYcfPQ 89%@@%&* OXYcYPQ l"#%. "&3 H-&B(,.9"
OXYY`PQ 5.%.Wo# OXYYXPL
XX
![Page 13: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
$G- !"# A#(J@-C %& *-&-#"@L MG%. @%C%$. $G- #"&*- (0 "AA@%B"$%(&. (0 $G- "AA#("BG $( $G(.-
)G-#- )- G",- " A"#$%"@ %3-&$%KB"$%(& #-.I@$ @%9- $G- (&- 3-.B#%J-3 %& $G- A#-,%(I. .-B$%(&L
p(&[email protected] %& C"&/ 3-C(*#"AG%BQ -B(&(C%B "&3 .(B%(@(*%B"@ "AA@%B"$%(&. )G-#- $G- !"#
3-B(CA(.%$%(& %. (0 %&$-#-.$ $G- (I$B(C- ,"#%"J@- %. &"$I#"@@/ J(I&3-3 "&3 %& $G-.- B".-.
C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3. "#- ,-#/ -"./ $( "AA@/L N- $G-#-0(#- #-.$#%B$ (I# "$$-&$%(& $( $G%.
B@".. (0 A#(J@-C. "&3 )- )%@@ 3-.B#%J- $G- "AA@%B"$%(& (0 C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3. $( $G-
!"# A#(J@-CL F0$-# 3-#%,%&* $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$- )- %@@I.$#"$- I.%&* $)( -2"CA@-.
%& )G%BG $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- %. .I%$"J@/ J(I&3-3] " 3-C(*#"AG%B C(3-@ (0 +8 C(#$"@%$/
#"$-. "&3 " .(B%(-B(&(C%B C(3-@ (0 0-C"@- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& %& $G- +;L
N- J-*%& J/ #-A#-.-&$%&* $G- %3-&$%K-3 .-$ *%,-& J/ $G- G/A-#BIJ- % J/]
% ! &!"! ! -.' OX`P
)G-#- - ! +/!+ /#+ ,,,+ /' ,Q $G- /( "#- ,-B$(#. #-A#-.-&$%&* $G- ,-#$%B-. (0 $G- BIJ- "&3 . %. "
,-B$(# (0 &(&E&-*"$%,- )-%*G$. )G%BG .IC $( (&- "&3 )G%BG "#- I.-3 $( 0(#C "@@ (0 $G- B(&,-2
B(CJ%&"$%(&. (0 $G- ,-#$%B-.L +.%&* $G%. #-A"#"C-$-#%W"$%(& C-"&. $G"$ ! B"& J- -2A#-..-3 ".
" B(&,-2 B(CJ%&"$%(& (0 $G- -2$#-C- A(%&$. (0 % )- B"& %&.-#$ OX`P %&$( O_P "&3 #-)#%$- %$ ".
! ! "-. OXXP
MG- A#(J@-C (0 .(@,%&* O_P 0(# !Q %. &() #-0(#CI@"$-3 ". $G- A#(J@-C (0 .(@,%&* OXXP 0(# .
10 B(I#.-Q )G%@.$ )- G",- #-A"#"C-$-#%W-3 $G- A#(J@-C %& OXXPQ )- G",- *($ &( B@(.-# $(
.(@,%&* %$ ". $G- ./.$-C %. .$%@@ I&3-#E3-$-#C%&-3 O.%&B- 3 4 /PL g()-,-#Q )- "#- &() "J@- $(
#-%&$-#A#-$ $G- A#(J@-C %& " )"/ )G%BG "@@(). I. $( I.- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3.L 8%&B-
$G- /( R. G",- "@@ (0 $G- &-B-.."#/ BG"#"B$-#%.$%B. (0 A#(J"J%@%$%-. O%& $G%. B(&$-2$ A#(J"J%@%$/
%. %&$-#A#-$-3 ". " C-".I#- (0 " .$"$- (0 9&()@-3*- #"$G-# $G"& " @%C%$%&* 0#-^I-&B/PQ )-
B"& $#-"$ $G- . ,-B$(# ". " 3%.B#-$- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& (,-# $G- 3 CI@$%,"#%"$- (I$B(C-.
#-A#-.-&$-3 J/ $G- B(@IC&. (0 $G- C"$#%2 -L 4& ($G-# )(#3.Q $G- .(@I$%(& (0 OXXP #-^I%#-. I.
Xe
![Page 14: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
$( .IAA@/ " B(&.$#IB$%,- A#%&B%A@- 0(# BG((.%&* (&- "(,1!1%/%'2 3%)'(%10'%,& (,-# "&($G-# #"$G-#
$G"& BG((.%&* (&- "!(!+*'*( 4*#',( (,-# "&($G-#L N- $G-#-0(#- &--3 " A#%&B%A@- )G%BG "@@().
I. $( B@"%C $G"$ (&- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& %. ?J-$$-#D %& .(C- #-.A-B$ (# ($G-# $G"& "&($G-#
A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&L
MG- A#%&B%A@- )G%BG )- "3(A$ )". .I**-.$-3 J/ i"/&-. OXY[_"Q XY[_JP "&3 %. "& -2$-&.%(&
(0 <"l@"B-R. "(%&#%"/* ,5 %&)06#%*&' (*!),&c $( .%$I"$%(&. %& )G%BG .(C- %&0(#C"$%(& "J(I$ $G-
A#(J@-C %. ","%@"J@- 0#(C 3"$"L MG- %3-" %. $G"$ (&- .G(I@3 BG((.- " 3%.$#%JI$%(& )G%BG 3(-.
&($ I&3I@/ 0",(# (&- (I$B(C- (,-# "&($G-# .IJU-B$ $( $G- #-^I%#-C-&$. $G"$ $G- A#(J"J%@%$%-.
"#- &(&E&-*"$%,-Q .IC $( (&- "&3 ."$%.0/ "&/ 3"$"EJ".-3 #-.$#%B$%(&. (&- C%*G$ G",- O%& $G%.
B".- $G- #-3IB-3 0(#C -.$%C"$-.PL 4& $G- A#-.-&$ B(&$-2$ $G%. C-"&. $G"$ $G- A#(J"J%@%$/
3%.$#%JI$%(& CI.$ ."$%.0/ -^I"$%(& OXXPL F &"$I#"@ (JU-B$%,- 0I&B$%(& )G%BG )%@@ "BG%-,- $G%.
%. $G- -&$#(A/ 0I&B$%(&
5 #.& ! !.! 01 . OXeP
)G-#- %& $G- B".- (0 -@-C-&$. (0 . )%$G W-#( A#(J"J%@%$/Q * 01 #*& ( *L MG- 0I&B$%(& OXeP )".
.I**-.$-3 J/ 8G"&&(& OXYfcP ". " C-".I#- (0 I&B-#$"%&$/YL 4$ %. C"2%C%W-3 )G-& $G- A#(JE
"J%@%$%-. "#- I&%0(#C O"@@ (I$B(C-. "#- -^I"@@/ @%9-@/ )G%BG %. %&$-#A#-$-3 ". J-%&* C"2%C"@@/
I&B-#$"%&PQ "&3 %$ %. C%&%C%W-3 %0 $G- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& %. 3-*-&-#"$- (& " A"#$%BI@"#
(I$B(C- O%&$-#A#-$-3 ". A-#0-B$ B-#$"%&$/ "J(I$ $G"$ (I$B(C-PL MG- B(&.$#"%&-3 (A$%C%W"$%(&
A#(J@-C %. $G-#-0(#- $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A#(J@-C]
234!#") # !!"!
!.! 01 . .IJU-B$ $( ! ! "-. OXaP
MG%. %. " .$#"%*G$0(#)"#3 &(&@%&-"# (A$%C%W"$%(& A#(J@-C )%$G " I&%^I- .(@I$%(&L '-B"I.- $G-
.$ )G%BG .(@,-. $G%. A#(J@-C %. %&$-#A#-$"J@- ". " ,-B$(# (0 A#(J"J%@%$%-. (,-# .IAA(#$ A(%&$.Q
c MG"$Q I&@-.. $G-#- %. " #-".(& 0(# J-@%-,%&* ($G-#)%.-Q -"BG A(..%J@- (I$B(C- .G(I@3 J- #-*"#3-3 ". -^I"@@/@%9-@/L MG- l4> G".Q UI.$%K"J@/Q G"3 " J"3 A#-..L MG- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@- ",(%3. C"&/ (0 $G- A%$0"@@)G%BG J-.-$ $G- l4>L 8-- +h&9 OXYY[P 0(# " 3%.BI..%(&L
Y MG- J".- (0 $G- @(*"#%$GC I.-3 (&@/ "V-B$. $G- I&%$.L 40 !"#!
%. I.-3 $G-& $G- %&0(#C"$%(& I&B-#$"%&$/ %.C-".I#-3 %& ?J%$.DQ %0 $G- &"$I#"@ @(* %. I.-3 %$ %. C-".I#-. %& ?&"$.DL
Xa
![Page 15: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
"&3 $G- -2A-B$"$%(& (A-#"$(# 0(# " 3%.B#-$- #"&3(C ,"#%"J@- %. " A#(J"J%@%$/E)-%*G$-3 B(&,-2
B(CJ%&"$%(& (0 .IAA(#$ A(%&$. $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$. !$! -.$ ."$%.0/ $G- 3"$" B(&.$#"%&$. %& O_P
-2"B$@/ "&3 B"& J- %&$-#A#-$-3 ". $G- -2A-B$-3 ,"@I- (0 " 3%.B#-$- CI@$%3%C-&.%(&"@ #"&3(C
,"#%"J@- B(&.%.$-&$ )%$G $G- -&$#(A/ C"2%C%W%&* BG(%B- (0 I&3-#@/%&* A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&L
40 $G- #-.-"#BG-# G". &(&E."CA@- (# A#-E."CA@- A#%(# %&0(#C"$%(& (& $G- A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.E
$#%JI$%(& (0 $G- B(-hB%-&$ ,-B$(# #-A#-.-&$-3 J/ $G- ,-B$(# $Q $G-& $G- (JU-B$%,- 0I&B$%(&
B"& J- #-0(#CI@"$-3 $( C%&%C%W- $G- A#(J"J%@%.$%B 3%,-#*-&B- J-$)--& $G- A#(J"J%@%$%-. )G%BG
"#- B(&.%.$-&$ )%$G $G- 3"$" .G "&3 $G- A#%(# A#(J"J%@%$%-. $ O.-- ;I@@J"B9 "&3 <-%J@-# XY[X\
;I@@J"B9 XY[Y\ b((3 XYZaPL MG%. C(3%K-. $G- (JU-B$%,- 0I&B$%(& )G%BG J-B(C-. $G- ;I@@J"B9E
<-%J@-#kB#(..E-&$#(A/ C-".I#-
!.! 01 . ! .! 01 $ OXfP
MG- B#(..E-&$#(A/ OXfP B"& J- %&$-#A#-$-3 ". " C-".I#- (0 $G- &-) %&0(#C"$%(& (& $G- B(-hE
B%-&$. A#(,%3-3 J/ $G- 3"$" #-@"$%,- $( $G- A#%(# 3%.$#%JI$%(&L NG-& $G- A#%(# %. I&%0(#C (,-#
$G- G/A-#BIJ- $G-& 6( ! $23 "&3 OXfP C-".I#-. $G- "33%$%(&"@ %&0(#C"$%(& #-T-B$-3 %& . #-@E
"$%,- $( $G- C"2%C"@@/ I&%&0(#C"$%,- 3%.$#%JI$%(& "&3 $G- #-.I@$%&* C"2%CIC B#(..E-&$#(A/
.(@I$%(& %. "@.( $G-& $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ .(@I$%(&L N- "@.( &($- $G"$ ! "(%,(% #-.$#%B$%(&.
O-L*L $G"$ B-#$"%& -V-B$. C"/ J- C(&($(&-P B"& J- %&B@I3-3 ". "33%$%(&"@ B(&.$#"%&$. $( $G-
C"2%C%W"$%(& -^I"$%(& OXaP E @%&-"#Q &(&@%&-"#Q -^I"@%$/ (# %&-^I"@%$/ B(&.$#"%&$. B"& "@@ J-
%CA(.-3 -".%@/L
M( .ICC"#%W-] )G-& $G- (I$B(C- ,"#%"J@- %. J(I&3-3 %& $G- A(AI@"$%(& $G- !"# A#(J@-C
B"& J- #-0(#CI@"$-3 %& $-#C. (0 "& I&9&()& A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& (,-# " B(&,-2 .-$L N-
I.- $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A#%&B%A@- $( .-@-B$ " A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& )G%BG %. ". T"$ ".
A(..%J@- (,-# $G- .-$Q .IJU-B$ $( $G- %&0(#C"$%(&"@ B(&.$#"%&$. A#(,%3-3 J/ $G- #-3IB-3 0(#C
-.$%C"$-. "&3 $G- #-^I%#-C-&$ $G"$ $G- A#(J"J%@%$%-. "#- &(&E&-*"$%,- "&3 .IC $( (&-L N- B"&
$G-& #-B(,-# $G- -2A-B$-3 ,"@I-. (0 $G- A"#"C-$-#. (0 %&$-#-.$ B(&.%.$-&$ )%$G $G- C"2%CIC
Xf
![Page 16: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
-&$#(A/ A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&L '/ B(&.$#IB$%(&Q $G-.- ,"@I-. ."$%.0/ $G- 3"$" B(&.$#"%&$. O_P
-2"B$@/ )G%@.$ "$ $G- ."C- $%C- $G- "..(B%"$-3 A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(& #-T-B$.Q %& " A#-B%.-
.-&.-Q $G- I&B-#$"%&$/ )G%BG #-C"%&. "0$-# $G- -.$%C"$%(& (0 $G- #-3IB-3 0(#CL
H I0D5%5'&, IJ&0D,-#
4& $G%. .-B$%(& )- A#-.-&$ $)( "AA@%B"$%(&.L MG- K#.$ B(&B-#&. "& "&"@/.%. (0 C(#$"@%$/ 3"$"
0(# 0-C"@-. %& $G- +8Q $G- .-B(&3 @((9. "$ @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& J/ )(C-& %& $G- +;L 4$
%. %CA(#$"&$ $( I&3-#.$"&3 $G"$ %$ %. &($ A(..%J@- $( "#*I- $G"$ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ #-.I@$.
B(##-B$@/ B"A$I#- '-* $#I- ,"@I-. (0 $G- !"# B(-hB%-&$.L F0$-# "@@Q $G- )G(@- A(%&$ (0 $G- !"#
A#(J@-C %. $G"$ " I&%^I- .(@I$%(&Q $#I- (# &($Q 3,*) &,' *7%)'L N- B"&Q "&3 3(Q G()-,-# "#*I-
$G"$ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ "AA#("BG #-A#-.-&$. " B(G-#-&$ "&3 @(*%B"@@/EB(&.%.$-&$ "AA#("BG
$( $G- %@@EA(.-3 %&,-#.- A#(J@-C "&3 )- B"& B(CA"#- $G- #-.I@$. %$ A#(3IB-. $( $G(.- "@$-#&"$%,-
.(@I$%(&. )G%BG $G- @%$-#"$I#- G". .I**-.$-3L 4& -"BG B".- O)%$G $G- -2B-A$%(& (0 $G- %&$#%&.%B
-.$%C"$(#P $G- -2%.$%&* .(@I$%(&. C"9- "& "33%$%(&"@ "..ICA$%(& )G%BG #-&3-#. $G- A#(J@-C
)-@@EA(.-3 "&3 "C-&"J@- $( I&%^I- .(@I$%(& J/ .$"&3"#3 .$"$%.$%B"@ C-$G(3.L MG- %3-&$%0/%&*
"..ICA$%(& %& -"BG B".- C%*G$ J- .(C-)G"$ "#J%$#"#/Q JI$ *#-"$-# B(&K3-&B- "J(I$ $G- #-.I@$E
%&* !"# A#(K@-. %. *"%&-3 %0 $G- #-.I@$. 0#(C -"BG "AA#("BG -2G%J%$ B(CC(&Q A@"I.%J@- 0-"$I#-.
O$G- B@"%C )(I@3 J- $G"$ $G- %3-&$%0/%&* "..ICA$%(&Q $G(I*G "#J%$#"#/Q ?3(-. &($ .--C $( C"$E
$-# CIBGDPL 8%C%@"#@/Q $G- -CA%#%B"@ A@"I.%J%@%$/ (0 $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ A"#$%"@@/ 3-A-&3.
(& )G-$G-# $G-/ "@.( B"A$I#- .(C- (0 $G- ."C- 0-"$I#-. )G%BG -C-#*- 0#(C -2%.$%&* C-$G(3.
E $G- "AA#("BG C"/ J- @(*%B"@@/ %CA-BB"J@-Q JI$ %0 $G- #-.I@$. "#- )%@3@/ 3%..%C%@"# 0#(C $G(.-
A#(3IB-3 J/ .$"&3"#3 C-$G(3. )%$G )G%BG #-.-"#BG-#. "#- C(#- 0"C%@%"# "&3 B(C0(#$"J@- $G-&
%$ %. I&@%9-@/ $( B"$BG (&L
X[
![Page 17: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
H?2 K< L-0&,- M*%$&,5$B
7(# $G%. K#.$ -2"CA@- )- I.- C(#$"@%$/ 3"$" 0(# +L8L 0-C"@-. J-$)--& XYaa "&3 e``_LX` MG-
3"$" B(&$"%& B(G(#$. J(#& J-$)--& Xcea "&3 e``_L 7%*I#- X .G(). $G- #") 3"$" E %& -"BG A"&-@
)- G",- A@($$-3 -,-#/ $-&$G "*-kA-#%(3kB(G(#$ .( $G"$ $G- 0-"$I#-. (0 $G- 3"$" "#- -".%-# $(
A%B9 (I$L
F. $G- K*I#- .G().Q C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. %&B#-".- )%$G "*- O"B$I"@@/Q $G- BG"&*- J-$)--& $)(
"*-. %& $G- J($$(C @-0$ K*I#- "#- "*-EA-#%(3 -V-B$.Q .%&B- "*-Q A-#%(3Q "&3 B(G(#$ -V-B$.
B"&&($ J- %3-&$%K-3 %& $G- K*I#-PL 7I#$G-#C(#-Q %& *-&-#"@ /(I&*-# B(G(#$. .--C $( G",-
@()-# C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. $G"& (@3-# B(G(#$.L M/A%B"@@/ $G- %&$-#A#-$"$%(& %. $G"$ "*- -V-B$. #-@"$-
$( $G- J%(@(*%B"@ A#(B-.. (0 "*%&*Q )G-#-". A-#%(3 -V-B$. B(&$"%& G%.$(#%B"@ -,-&$. .IBG ". )"#.Q
0"C%&-.Q "&3 %&0-B$%(I. 3%.-".-. Od"&* e``cPL 4CA#(,-C-&$. %& $G- C-3%B"@ $-BG&(@(*/ "V-B$
C(#$"@%$/ "&3 C"/ "@.( J- #-*"#3-3 ". A-#%(3 -V-B$. ". 0"# ". $G-.- C-3%B"@ J#-"9$G#(I*G.
#-3IB- C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. %& "@@ "*- *#(IA.L 5(G(#$ -V-B$. C"/ #-T-B$ -"#@/ @%0- B(&3%$%(&. $G"$
%&TI-&B- C(#$"@%$/ @"$-# %& @%0-Q .IBG ". $G- A#-.-&B- (0 " 0"C%&- %& -"#@/ BG%@3G((3Q "&3
3%V-#-&$ @-,-@. (0 G/*%-&-L 4& "33%$%(&Q 3%V-#-&$ B(G(#$. "BBICI@"$- 3%V-#-&$ -&,%#(&C-&$"@
"&3 .(B%(-B(&(C%B -2A-#%-&B-. 3I#%&* $G-%# @%0- $G"$ C"/ "V-B$ $G-%# C(#$"@%$/ @"$-# %& @%0-L
N- J-*%& )%$G $G- #-.I@$. )G%BG "#- A#(3IB-3 J/ &(#C"@%W%&*Q %& $I#&Q $G- "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3
B(G(#$ -V-B$. $( W-#( OK*I#- ePXXL p(#C"@%W%&* "*- -V-B$. $( W-#( %. B@-"#@/ " J%W"##- "..ICA$%(&
%& $G%. B(&$-2$ "&3 %$ #-.I@$. %& .(C- %CA@"I.%J@- A-#%(3 -V-B$. )G-#- $G- C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. "#-
%&B#-".%&* /-"#E(&E/-"#L p(&[email protected] "&3 A"#$@/ ". " #-.I@$ (0 $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. G",%&* $G%.
A"$$-#&Q $G- B(G(#$ -V-B$. 3( &($ .--C #%3%BI@(I. )%$G /(I&*-# B(G(#$. -&U(/%&* .IBB-..%,-@/
@()-# C(#$"@%$/ #"$-.L >-@"2%&* $G- #-.$#%B$%(& (& "*- -V-B$. O-%$G-# J/ %CA(.%&* %$ (& $G-
A-#%(3 (# $G- B(G(#$ -V-B$. %&.$-"3P #-.I@$. %& CIBG C(#- A@"I.%J@- "*- -V-B$. )G%BG #%.- )%$G
X` MG-.- 3"$" B"& J- 3()&@("3-3 0#(C $G- '-#9-@-/ gIC"& !(#$"@%$/ S"$"J".-] )))LC(#$"@%$/L(#*LXX N- G",- (C%$$-3 B(&K3-&B- %&$-#,"@. 0#(C $G- A#(K@- K*I#-. .( $G"$ $G- A"$$-#&. "#- -".%-# $( .--L 7I@@
#-.I@$. "#- ","%@"J@- 0#(C $G- "I$G(#.L
XZ
![Page 18: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
"*- "&3 )G%BG "@.( .G() "& %&B#-".- "$ W-#( /-"#. B(&.%.$-&$ )%$G -@-,"$-3 %&0"&$ C(#$"@%$/
#"$-. #-@"$%,- $( $G(.- (0 /(I&* BG%@3#-&L 8-$$%&* $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. $( W-#( -V-B$%,-@/ #-C(,-.
$G- A(..%J%@%$/ (0 A(AI@"$%(&E)%3- -V-B$. #-@"$-3 $( B(CC(& -2A(.I#- $( -A%3-C%B.Q C-3%B"@
%CA#(,-C-&$. -$BL 4$ #-.I@$. %& " A"$$-#&. (0 B(G(#$ -V-B$. )G%BG %&3%B"$- )(#.-&%&* C(#$"@%$/
#"$-. 0(# B(G(#$. J(#& IA I&$%@ $G- C%3 Xc``R. %& $G- +8 )%$G %CA#(,-C-&$. $G-#-"0$-#L MG%.
C"/ "B$I"@@/ J- A@"I.%J@- ". $G- C%3 Xc``R. )-#- " J"3 $%C- $( J- %& $G- +8 "&3 "& -.A-B%"@@/
J"3 $%C- $( J- %& $G- +8 "&3 /(I&* E $G-#- )-#- -A%3-C%B. (0 BG(@-#" %& p(#$G FC-#%B"
%& XcfcEYQ /-@@() 0-,-# %& $G- +8 %& Xc[`Q %&TI-&W" %& p(#$G FC-#%B" %& Xc[`EX "&3 0I#$G-#
C(#- @(B"@%W-3 -A%3-C%B. (0 BG(@-#" "&3 /-@@() 0-,-# %& Xc[XEe %& A(AI@"$%(& B-&$#-. %& 4@@%&(%.Q
$G- b#-"$ l@"%&.Q !%..(I#% "&3 p-) 1#@-"&.L >-C(,%&* $G-.- B(G(#$ -V-B$. J/ "..ICA$%(&
A#(3IB-. $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. .--& %& $G- K&"@ .-$ (0 3%"*#"C. %& K*I#- XL MG%. .G(). " &(%./ JI$
3-B@%&%&* $#-&3L S(IJ$@-.. $G-#- )-#- %CA#(,-C-&$. %& AIJ@%B G-"@$G 3I#%&* $G- A-#%(3 B(,-#-3
OXYaaEe``_P JI$ g"%&-. Oe``cPQ 0(# -2"CA@-Q "#*I-. $G"$ $G- C(.$ .%*&%KB"&$ %CA#(,-C-&$. %&
AIJ@%B G-"@$G "&3 ."&%$"$%(& "&3 %& A"#$%BI@"# $G- %&B#-".-3 ","%@"J%@%$/ (0 B@-"& )"$-# .IAA@%-.
"&3 -V-B$%,- .-)"*- $#-"$C-&$. $((9 A@"B- %& $G- @"$- Xc``R. "&3 $G-#-0(#- A#-E3"$- $G%. A-#%(3L
MG-.- C"U(# %CA#(,-C-&$. C"/ G",- %&TI-&B-3 -"#@%-# 3"$- (0 J%#$G B(G(#$. JI$ .%&B- .IBG
-V-B$. "#- -2B@I3-3 J/ "..ICA$%(& %$ %. A(..%J@- $G"$ $G- -.$%C"$-3 -V-B$ (& $G- A-#%(3 A#(K@-
-2"**-#"$-. $G%. %CA#(,%&* $#-&3L M( .ICC"#%W-] &(&- (0 $G-.- $G#-- &(#C"@%W"$%(&. .--C
^I%$- #%*G$L q-#(%&* (I$ "*- -V-B$. %. B@-"#@/ %&"AA#(A#%"$- JI$ 3#(AA%&* B(G(#$ -V-B$. )G-&
)- 9&() 0#(C $G- G%.$(#%B"@ #-B(#3 $G"$ B-#$"%& J%#$G B(G(#$. )-#- -2A(.-3 $( -A%3-C%B. (0
A"#$%BI@"#@/ &".$/ 3%.-".-. %& %&0"&B/ .--C. %CA@"I.%J@- ". )-@@Q )G%@.$ #-C(,%&* A-#%(3 -V-B$.
"@.( #-C(,-. " #(@- 0(# $G- AIJ@%B G-"@$G %CA#(,-C-&$. )G%BG C"/ G",- (BBI##-3 (,-# $G-
A-#%(3L
p(#C"@%W%&* " A"%# (0 "3U"B-&$ B(G(#$ -V-B$. $( J- $G- ."C- %. " .$"&3"#3 "..ICA$%(& %&
$G- !"# "&"@/.%. (0 C(#$"@%$/ 3"$" O.-- !".(& -$ "@L XY_aPL 1& $G- 0"B- (0 %$ .--C. #-".(&"J@- E
X_
![Page 19: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
)G/Q "0$-# "@@Q .G(I@3 $G- C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. (0 $G(.- J(#& " /-"# "A"#$ J- C"#9-3@/ 3%V-#-&$n MG-
3%hBI@$/ "#%.-. %& 3-B%3%&* -2"B$@/ )G%BG B(G(#$EA"%#. $( &(#C"@%W-L MG- -V-B$. (0 3%V-#-&$
BG(%B-. O"@@ -^I"@@/ A@"I.%J@- JI$ &(&- -.A-B%"@@/ B(CA-@@%&*P "#- %@@I.$#"$-3 %& K*I#- aL MG-
A#(K@-. O-,-& 0(# $G- "*- -V-B$ )G%BG %. $G- C(.$ #(JI.$ #-@"$%,-@/P "#- "@@ (,-# $G- A@"B-] $G-
A-#%(3 -V-B$. B(I@3 J- %&B#-".%&*Q 3-B#-".%&* (# "AA#(2%C"$-@/ T"$ "BB(#3%&* $( $".$-L
7%*I#- f #-A(#$. $G- #-.I@$. I.%&* $G- g"&(BG "&3 g(&%*kS-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(&
%& )G%BG $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. "#- B(&.$#IB$-3 $( J- (#$G(*(&"@ $( " @%&-"# $#-&3L MG%. C"9-.
$G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. B/B@%B"@ "&3 $G%. A#(J"J@/ "BB(I&$. 0(# $G%. &(#C"@%W"$%(&R. A(AI@"#%$/ )%$G
-B(&(C%.$. )G-#- $%C- -V-B$. #-T-B$ B(CC(&Q A(AI@"$%(&E)%3- C"B#(-B(&(C%B -V-B$. E 0(#
-2"CA@-Q ?$G- JI.%&-.. B/B@-DL F. &($-3 "J(,- OS-"$(& XYY_Q ALXeZP $G%. "AA#("BG (&@/ )(#9.
)G-& $G- 3"$" B(,-# " @(&* -&(I*G .A"& $( %&B@I3- " 0I@@ B/B@-L MG- B/B@%B"@ A-#%(3 -V-B$.
.--& %& K*I#- a "#- $G-#-0(#- " &-B-.."#/ B(&.-^I-&B- (0 $G- &(#C"@%W"$%(&L 4& $G- A#-.-&$
B(&$-2$ %$ C"/ &($ J- "AA#(A#%"$- $( "..IC- $G"$ A-#%(3 -V-B$. (& 0-C"@- C(#$"@%$/ %& $G-
+8 "#- -..-&$%"@@/ T"$ (,-# $G- A-#%(3 E .(C- %CA#(,-C-&$ %. $( J- -2A-B$-3L p(&-$G-@-.. $G-
"*- "&3 B(G(#$ -V-B$. )G%BG $G- &(#C"@%W"$%(& A#(3IB-. 3( .--C $( J- A@"I.%J@- E "*- -V-B$.
"#- %&B#-".%&* "0$-# $G- .IJU-B$ .I#,%,-. %&0"&B/ "&3 B(G(#$ -V-B$. .--C $( K$ )G"$ )- 9&()
0#(C $G- G%.$(#%B #-B(#3L
MG- #-.I@$. 0#(C $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(# (0 d"&* -$ "@L Oe``fP "#- .G()& %& K*I#- [L >-B"@@
$G"$ $G%. -.$%C"$(# I.-. $G- !((#-El-&#(.- %&,-#.- %& -^I"$%(& OcP )%$G $G- #"&3(C ,-B$(# $
.-$ $( W-#(L MG%. -.$%C"$(# $G-#-0(#- 3(-. &($ #-@/ (& " &(#C"@%W"$%(& $( #-*I@"#%W- $G- !"#
C(3-@R. %&,-#.- A#(J@-CL p-%$G-#Q $G-#-0(#-Q 3(-. %$ 0(#B- "&/ A"#$%BI@"# A#(A-#$%-. (& $G- "*-Q
A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ A#(K@-. )G%BG -C-#*-L MG- A#(K@-. )G%BG "#- #-B(,-#-3 J/ $G%. C-$G(3
"#- %&$-#-.$%&*L MG- "*- A#(K@- .G(). )G"$ )-Q J/ &()Q $"9- $( J- $G- #(JI.$ A"$$-#& )%$G
" 3#(A %& C(#$"@%$/ "0$-# $G- K#.$ /-"# (0 @%0- 0(@@()-3 J/ /-"#E(&E/-"# %&B#-".-.L MG- B(G(#$
A#(K@- "@.( .G(). $G- (0$E(J.-#,-3 A"$$-#& )G-#-%& C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. A-"9 %& $G- C%3EXc``R.L
Xc
![Page 20: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
MG- A-#%(3 -V-B$. @((9 @%9- $G-/ "#- 0(@@()%&* " B/B@%B"@Q JI$ .@%*G$@/ #%.%&* $#-&3 (,-# $G-
A-#%(3L g()-,-# $G- %&B#-".- %. &($ .$"$%.$%B"@@/ .%*&%KB"&$ "&3 $G- ,-#$%B"@ .B"@- %. CIBG
-2A"&3-3 .( $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. "#- #-"@@/ UI.$ .C"@@ TIB$I"$%(&. "#(I&3 " T"$ A#(K@- E ,-#/
.%C%@"# $( $G- S-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(&L
7%*I#- Z A@($. $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$-.L MG- "*- -V-B$. "#- &($ ^I%$- C(&($(&%B
". $G-/ A%B9 IA $G- #"%.-3 C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. %& $G- K#.$ /-"# (0 @%0-Q JI$ $G-#-"0$-# C(#$"@%$/ #"$-.
%&B#-".- )%$G -"BG /-"# (0 @%0-L MG- A-#%(3 -V-B$. #-T-B$ $G- %&TI-&B-. (& C(#$"@%$/ #"$-.
)G%BG J-"# -^I"@@/ (& "@@ "*-. "&3 "@@ 3"$" (0 J%#$G B(G(#$.L F. B"& J- .--&Q $G-.- -V-B$.
.G() " B-#$"%& "C(I&$ (0 /-"#E$(E/-"# ,"#%"J%@%$/ JI$ "#- -..-&$%"@@/ T"$L MG-.- -V-B$. "#-
A#(J"J@/ )G"$ %&$I%$%(& )(I@3 -2A-B$ "&3 .--C $( C%##(# )G"$ )- .-- %& $G- #") 3"$" )G-&
)- A@($ C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. J/ "*- "*"%&.$ J($G B(G(#$ "&3 A-#%(3L MG- B(G(#$ -V-B$. "#- #"$G-#
%&$-#-.$%&* "&3 -BG( )G"$ )- G",- .--& J-0(#-] $G-/ $(( .G() $G- .$#(&* A"$$-#& %& )G%BG
C(#$"@%$/ #"$-. K#.$ #%.- )%$G 3"$- (0 J%#$G O.( $G"$ (@3-# B(G(#$. G",- J-$$-# C(#$"@%$/ #"$-.P
I&$%@ "#(I&3 $G- Xc[` B(G(#$ 0"@@%&* $G-#-"0$-#L
N- .-- $G"$ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ #-.I@$. C%##(# C"&/ (0 $G- 0-"$I#-. )G%BG B#(A IA %&
($G-# &(#C"@%W"$%(&.L 4& A"#$%BI@"# )- .-- $G"$ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ -.$%C"$-. "#- ^I"@%$"E
$%,-@/ C(.$ .%C%@"# $( $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(# "&3 $G- S-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(& E $G-
#-".(& )G/ $G- S-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& C-$G(3 *%,-. .%C%@"# #-.I@$. C"/ J- $G"$ $G- %3-&$%0/E
%&* "..ICA$%(& $G"$ A-#%(3 -V-B$. "#- C-"&EW-#( TIB$I"$%(&. "#(I&3 " .$#"%*G$ @%&- %.Q %0 $G-
C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ #-.I@$. "#- $( J- J-@%-,-3Q "AA#(2%C"$-@/ B(##-B$ 0(# $G-.- 3"$"L F. ($G-#
.$I3%-. #(I$%&-@/ K&3\ $G- %&$I%$%,-@/ 0"%#@/ )-"9 #-^I%#-C-&$ $G"$ $G- B(G(#$ -V-B$. 0(# $)(
"3U"B-&$ B(G(#$. "#- -^I"@ B"& G",- A#(0(I&3 %&TI-&B-. (& $G- -.$%C"$-3 -V-B$.L
XY
![Page 21: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
H?6 KN L-0&,- >&"*% L*%'- 9&%$5'5D&$5*)
1I# .-B(&3 -2"CA@- %. " C(3-@ (0 0-C"@- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& J".-3 (& +; 3"$"L MG-.-
3"$" "#- 0#(C $G- +; 7"C%@/ =2A-&3%$I#- 8I#,-/ )G%BG %. " @(&* #I&&%&* B#(.. .-B$%(&"@
3"$".-$L MG- 3"$" #-B(#3 $G- @"J(# C"#9-$ .$"$I. (0 )(C-& %& $G- .I#,-/-3 G(I.-G(@3.
(,-# $G- af /-"# A-#%(3 0#(C XY_f $( e``_L MG- #") 3"$" O(&B- C(#-Q 0(# " .IJ.-$ (0 $G-
"*-kA-#%(3kB(G(#$ *#(IA. %& $G- %&$-#-.$. (0 ,%.%J%@%$/P "#- A@($$-3 %& K*I#- _L MG- .IJEA"&-@
.G()%&* $G- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& #"$-. (0 3%V-#-&$ B(G(#$. (,-# $G- @%0-EB/B@- O$G- $(A @-0$
K*I#-P -2G%J%$. ,-#$%B"@ 3%V-#-&B-. J-$)--& $G- @%&-. C-".I#%&* jB(G(#$E$%C-R -V-B$.L N- I.-
$G%. $-#C%&(@(*/ $( -CAG".%W- $G"$ %$ %. &($ A(..%J@- $( 3%.-&$"&*@- "*- 0#(C B(G(#$ "&3 $%C-
-V-B$. %& $G%. K*I#-L MG- #") 3"$" .G() " BG"#"B$-#%.$%B GICAE.G"A-3 A"$$-#& %& $G- @"J(#
0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& (,-# $G- @%0-EB/B@-Q )%$G " C"#9-3 3#(A "$ $G- #-$%#-C-&$ "*- "B#(.. J%#$G
B(G(#$.L
4& $G- B(&$-2$ (0 $G- 0-C"@- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(&Q "*- -V-B$. C"/ %&B@I3- @%0-EB/B@-
3-B%.%(&. .IBG ". $G- $%C%&* (0 -3IB"$%(&Q BG%@3#-&Q "&3 #-$%#-C-&$L l-#%(3 -V-B$. C"/ %&B@I3-
JI.%&-.. B/B@- -V-B$. (# A(@%B/ BG"&*-. $G"$ -V-B$ $G- 0-C"@- @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(&L 7%&"@@/Q
B(G(#$ -V-B$. C"/ %&B@I3- $G- %CA#(,-3 -3IB"$%(&"@ "$$"%&C-&$ "&3 @()-# 0-#$%@%$/ #"$-. (0
/(I&*-# B(G(#$.Q "&3 BG"&*-3 .(B%"@ &(#C.L
7%*I#- c .G(). $G- A#(K@-. A#(3IB-3 J/ .-$$%&* "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ -V-B$. $( W-#( %&
$I#&L 1&B- "*"%& (C%$$%&* $G- "*- -V-B$.Q $G%. $%C- %& " C(3-@ (0 @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(&Q
.--C. $( J- $G- )#(&* $G%&* $( 3(L 1&B- "*- -V-B$. "#- "3C%$$-3 $( $G- C(3-@ $G-/ 3%.A@"/
$G- -2A-B$-3 ?GICA .G"A-D )G-#- A"#$%B%A"$%(& #"$-. #%.- %& -"#@/ "3I@$G((3Q @-,-@ (V %&
C%33@- "*- "&3 3#(A "J#IA$@/ "$ #-$%#-C-&$ "*- OI&$%@ #-B-&$@/ $G- .$"$- #-$%#-C-&$ "*- )".
Z` 0(# )(C-& %& $G- +;PL 5@(.- %&.A-B$%(& (0 $G- "*- A#(K@-. %& $G- .-B(&3 $)( #(). C%*G$
-,-& .I**-.$ " G%&$ (0 " @-,-@@%&*E(V %& $G- *#()$G (0 A"#$%B%A"$%(& #"$-. %& $G- @"$- $)-&$%-.
B(&.%.$-&$ )%$G )(C-& @-",%&* )(#9 $( G",- BG%@3#-& J-0(#- #-E-&$-#%&* $G- @"J(# C"#9-$ "$ "
e`
![Page 22: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
.@%*G$@/ @()-# #"$- $G"& J-0(#-L
1C%$$%&* "*- -V-B$. A#(3IB-. -.$%C"$-. (0 A-#%(3 -V-B$. )G%BG 3-B@%&- (,-# $%C- )G%@.$
$G- B(G(#$ -V-B$. .--C $( $"9- (& $G- GICA .G"A- )G%BG (&- )(I@3 -2A-B$ (0 "*- -V-B$.L p($-
$G"$ $G- -.$%C"$-. 0(# $G- /(I&*-.$ B(G(#$. "#- I&.$"J@- 3I- $( .C"@@ &ICJ-#. (0 (J.-#,"$%(&.
0(# $G-.- B(G(#$.L 1C%$$%&* A-#%(3 -V-B$. )G%@.$ "@@()%&* 0(# " A@"I.%J@- "*- A#(K@- .--C. $(
*%,- 3-B@%&%&* B(G(#$ -V-B$. )G%BG %. G"#3 $( #-B(&B%@- )%$G #-B-&$ @"J(# C"#9-$ G%.$(#/ %& $G-
+; )G-#- )(C-& %& /(I&*-# 3"$-E(0EJ%#$G B(G(#$. "#- *-&-#"@@/ C(#- @%9-@/ $( )(#9 O"$ @-".$
A"#$ $%C-P #"$G-# $G"& @-.. @%9-@/L F*"%&Q $G- .$#"$-*/ (0 (C%$$%&* -%$G-# "*-Q A-#%(3 (# B(G(#$
-V-B$. -&$%#-@/ 3(-. &($ .--C %& -"BG B".- $( A#(3IB- -.$%C"$-. )G%BG "#- -&$%#-@/ A@"I.%J@-
MG- &-2$ .-$ (0 #-.I@$. #-A(#$. .(C- -2A-#%C-&$. )%$G .-$$%&* $)( "3U"B-&$ "*- -V-B$. $(
J- -^I"@ OK*I#- YPL MG"$ $)( "*- *#(IA. .-A"#"$-3 J/ (&- /-"# .G(I@3 G",- "AA#(2%C"$-@/
$G- ."C- #"$- (0 @"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& .--C. A@"I.%J@-Q JI$ )- "#- "*&(.$%B "J(I$ )G%BG
$)( "*-. $( BG((.-L N- $G-#-0(#- G",- BG(.-& $G#-- "@$-#&"$%,- &(#C"@%W"$%(&. "$ #-*I@"#
%&$-#,"@.L 4&$-#-.$%&*@/ $G- A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ -V-B$. "#- ^I"@%$"$%,-@/ .%C%@"# %& -"BG B".-L
MG- "*- -V-B$. "#- 3%V-#-&$ G()-,-# "&3 (&@/ $G- aYmf` &(#C"@%W"$%(& "AA-"#. $( A%B9 IA $G-
GICA .G"A- )- )(I@3 -2A-B$ $( .-- E A(..%J@/ J-B"I.- $G- &(#C"@%W"$%(& %& $G%. B".- %. C(#-
"AA#(A#%"$-L 4& $G- ($G-# $)( &(#C"@%W"$%(&.Q $G- #-$%#-C-&$ -V-B$ %. (&@/ UI.$ 3%.B-#&%J@- "&3
$G- (,-#"@@ A"$$-#& (0 "*- -V-B$. %. 0"# 0#(C )G"$ )- C%*G$ #-".(&"J@/ -2A-B$L 7I#$G-#C(#- $G-
-.$%C"$-3 -V-B$. %& $G-.- $)( B".-. @%- )-@@ (I$.%3- $G- A"#$%"@E%3-&$%KB"$%(& J(I&3. %CA@/%&*
$G"$ B(I&$-#0"B$I"@ A"#$%B%A"$%(& #"$-. 0(# .(C- B(CJ%&"$%(&. (0 "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ 0"#
-2B--3. X``r %& .(C- B".-. "&3 %. CIBG @-.. $G"& `r %& ($G-#.L
7%*I#- X` .G(). $G- A#(K@-. )G%BG "#- 3-#%,-3 $G#(I*G $G- g"&(BG "&3 g(%&*kS-"$(&
"&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(&L MG- GICAE.G"A-3 "*- A#(K@- %. -,%3-&$ )%$G " .$--A 3#(A %&
A"#$%B%A"$%(& "#(I&3 $G- .$"$- #-$%#-C-&$ "*-L MG- A-#%(3 -V-B$. "#- &(#C"@%W-3 $( .IC $(
W-#( "&3 $( J- (#$G(*(&"@ $( " @%&-"# $#-&3L MG%. #-.I@$. %& " &(%./ B/B@- #"$G-# $G-& $G-
eX
![Page 23: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
3-B@%&%&* A-#%(3 -V-B$. )G%BG "@@ (0 $G- ($G-# &(#C"@%W"$%(&. G",- A#(3IB-3L MG%. C"/ J-
-,%3-&B- $G"$Q %& $G%. B(&$-2$Q $G- B/B@%B"@%$/ "..ICA$%(& %. &($ "AA#(A#%"$-L MG- B(G(#$
-V-B$. .--C $( $"9- (& $G- 3-B@%&%&* A"$$-#& (0 $G- O(C%$$-3P A-#%(3 -V-B$.L F*- -V-B$. ".%3-Q
$G-.- A#(K@-. "#- ^I"@%$"$%,-@/ 3%V-#-&$ 0#(C C(.$ (0 $G(.- A#(3IB-3 J/ ($G-# &(#C"@%W"$%(&.
E $G- C(.$ .%C%@"# A#(K@-. "#- $G(.- (0 $G- ?&( A-#%(3 -V-B$.D C(3-@ "&3 $G%. %.Q (0 B(I#.-Q
J-B"I.- $G- g"&(BG "&3 g(%&*kS-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(& %. "& "AA#(2%C"$- ,-#.%(&
(0 $G- ."C- %3-"L
MG- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(# %& K*I#- XX (&B- "*"%& A#(3IB-. -.$%C"$-. )G%BG .--C -&$%#-@/ A@"IE
.%J@-L MG- "*- A#(K@- #-T-B$. )G"$ )- &()Q $G#(I*G )-%*G$ (0 -,%3-&B- 0#(C $G- &(#C"@%W"$%(&E
3-A-&3-&$ #-.I@$.Q $"9- ". #(JI.$ A"$$-#&L MG- B(G(#$ -V-B$. #%.- 0(# .IBB-..%,- 3"$- (0 J%#$G
B(G(#$. "&3 $G- A-#%(3 -V-B$. .G() $G- 3-B@%&%&* A"$$-#& 3%.A@"/-3 J/ -,-#/ &(#C"@%W"$%(&
)G%BG %. "J@- $( "@@() 0(# " A#(K@- )G%BG %.&R$ -%$G-# T"$ (# "AA#(2%C"$-@/ .(L
MG- !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ -.$%C"$-. "#- %@@I.$#"$-3 %& K*I#- XeL MG-/ .G() " GICA .G"A-
%& $G- "*- -V-B$.Q "&3 " #-$%#-C-&$ -V-B$ $G"$ %. B@-"#@/ A#-.-&$L MG- A-#%(3 -V-B$ .G(). "
C%@3 3-B@%&- (,-# $%C-L MG- B(G(#$ -V-B$ O-2B@I3%&* $G- K&"@ 0-) B(G(#$. )G%BG "#- "s%B$-3
J/ .C"@@ ."CA@-E.%W-.P .G(). " B@-"# A"$$-#& %& )G%BG )(C-& %& /(I&*-# B(G(#$. A"#$%B%A"$-
C(#- (0$-& %& $G- @"J(# C"#9-$L MG-.- #-.I@$. .--C $( 3%.A@"/ " .-$ (0 0-"$I#-. )G%BG "#-
B(CC(& $( $G- C(.$ A@"I.%J@- #-.I@$. 3-#%,-3 0#(C ($G-# C-$G(3. J".-3 (& &(#C"@%W"$%(&.
"&3 "#- -2$#-C-@/ B@(.-Q J/ &($ %3-&$%B"@ $(Q $G(.- 0#(C $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#L
O A*)',4#5*)#
N- A#-.-&$ " &-) "AA#("BG $( $G- !"# A#(J@-C J".-3 (& " C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3 )G%BG
B"& J- "AA@%-3 )G-& $G- 3-A-&3-&$ ,"#%"J@- G". " K&%$- .IAA(#$ %& $G- A(AI@"$%(&L NG%@.$ $G-
"AA#("BG )(I@3 #-^I%#- 0I#$G-# 3-,-@(AC-&$ J-0(#- %$ B"& J- "AA@%-3 $( I&J(I&3-3 (I$B(C-
3"$" O.-- b(@"& -$ "@L OXYYZP 0(# " 3%.BI..%(& (0 C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3. 0(# (I$B(C-. )%$G
ee
![Page 24: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
I&J(I&3-3 .IAA(#$P %$ 3(-.Q ". %$ .$"&3.Q B(,-# " *#-"$ C"&/ B".-. (0 "AA@%-3 %&$-#-.$L N-
"@.( &($- $G"$ $G- C-$G(3 B"& J- -2$-&3-3 -".%@/ $( %&B@I3- " A#%(# A#(J"J%@%$/ 3%.$#%JI$%(&
(& $G- A"#"C-$-# ,"@I-. O)G-#- .IBG " A#%(# %. ","%@"J@- $( $G- #-.-"#BG-#P J/ I.%&* $G- B#(..E
-&$#(A/ B#%$-#%" "&3 0I#$G-# -^I"@%$/ "&3 %&-^I"@%$/ B(&.$#"%&$. (& $G- C(C-&$ B(&3%$%(&. B"&
J- JI%@$ %&$( $G- -.$%C"$%(& A#(B-3I#- ,-#/ -".%@/L N- "@.( A#(,%3- $)( %@@I.$#"$%(&. (0 $G-
C-$G(3 "AA@%-3 $( #-"@ 3"$"L MG-.- "AA@%B"$%(&. $( 0-C"@- C(#$"@%$/ %& $G- +8 "&3 0-C"@-
@"J(# 0(#B- A"#$%B%A"$%(& %& $G- +; "#- (0 .IJ.$"&$%,- %&$-#-.$ %& $G-C.-@,-.L p(&-$G-@-.. (I#
"%C )". A#%&B%A"@@/ $( .-- )G-$G-# (# &($ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ C-$G(3 B(I@3 A#(3IB- #-.I@$.
%& )G%BG #-.-"#BG-#. B(I@3 J- B(&K3-&$ E "#*IC-&$. %& 0",(# (0 $G- $G-(#-$%B"@ B(G-#-&B- C"/
(# C"/ &($ J- .IBB-..0I@ JI$ %$ .--C. $( I. $( J- -..-&$%"@ $G"$ $G- -.$%C"$(# "B$I"@ ?)(#9.DL
M( 3( $G%. )- B(CA"#-3 $G- #-.I@$. 0#(C $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/ "AA#("BG $( $G(.- A#(3IB-3
J/ " &ICJ-# (0 C-$G(3. J".-3 (& ,"#%(I. &(#C"@%W"$%(& ". )-@@ ". $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#
(0 d"&* -$ "@L Oe``fQ e``_Q e``cPL 4& J($G B".-. )- 0(I&3 $G"$ $G- C"2%CIC -&$#(A/EJ".-3
C-$G(3 #-A#(3IB-3 A"$$-#&. %& $G- "*-Q A-#%(3 "&3 B(G(#$ A#(K@-. )G%BG "*#--3 )%$G $G- C(.$
A@"I.%J@- &(#C"@%W"$%(&.L 4$ "@.( "*#--3 B@(.-@/ )%$G $G- #-.I@$. 0#(C $G- %&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#
E )G%BG 3(-. &($ #-@/ (& " &(#C"@%W"$%(& %& $G- I.I"@ .-&.- E "&3 $G-#-0(#- A-#G"A. @-&3.
0I#$G-# .IAA(#$ $( $G"$ A"#$%BI@"# C-$G(3 O"&3 4%#* 4*()!PL N- B(&B@I3- $G"$ C"2%CIC
-&$#(A/ C-$G(3. A#(,%3- " B(G-#-&$ "&3 I.-0I@ "AA#("BG $( $G- !"# A#(J@-CL
ea
![Page 25: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
!DD-).5J P 9&%$5&, 3.-)$5='&$5*) *@ $8- !"# '*-Q'5-)$#
" !$
$%
"
#############################################################################################$
* * * $% * * * % % % * * * $% * * * * * * * * * * * * $* % * * * * * * * * * * * $* * % * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * $ % % % * * * *% * * * * * $ * * * * * * ** % * * * * $ * * * * * * ** * % * * * $ * * * * * * ** * * * $% * * % % % * * * $% * * * * * * * * * * * * $* % * * * * * * * * * * * $* * % * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * $ % % % * * * *% * * * * * $ * * * * * * ** % * * * * $ * * * * * * ** * % * * * $ * * * * * * ** * * * * $% * % % % * * * $% * * * * * * * * * * * * $* % * * * * * * * * * * * $* * % * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * $ % % % * * * *% * * * * * $ * * * * * * ** % * * * * $ * * * * * * ** * % * * * $ * * * * * * *% % % * * * $ * * * $% * * ** * * * * * $ % * * * * * ** * * * * * $ * % * * * * ** * * * * * $ * * % * * * *% % % * * * * * * * * * * $* * * * * * * % * * * * * $* * * * * * * * % * * * * $* * * * * * * * * % * * * $% % % * * * $ * * * * $% * ** * * * * * $ % * * * * * ** * * * * * $ * % * * * * ** * * * * * $ * * % * * * *% % % * * * * * * * * * * $* * * * * * * % * * * * * $* * * * * * * * % * * * * $* * * * * * * * * % * * * $% % % * * * $ * * * * * $% ** * * * * * $ % * * * * * ** * * * * * $ * % * * * * ** * * * * * $ * * % * * * *% % % * * * * * * * * * * $* * * * * * * % * * * * * $* * * * * * * * % * * * * $* * * * * * * * * % * * * $
%
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&'
ef
![Page 26: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
R-@-%-)'-#
tXu F$$"&".%(Q 1#"W%(L XYYcL ?5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. (0 8",%&* '-G",%(# J/ +L8L g(I.-G(@3.LD 8-*
9,0(&!/ ,5 ;0+!& <*),0(#*) aaOaP] [_[vZ`Y
teu '"@@--#Q F@CI$Q >"C(& b(C-WE8"@,"3(#Q "&3 i"#99( MI#I&-&L e``YL ?<"J(I# 7(#B- l"#E
$%B%A"$%(& %& $G- =I#( F#-" E F 5(G(#$ '".-3 F&"@/.%.LD M-BG&%B"@ #-A(#$ X`fYL =0(,"*!&
>*&'(!/ ?!&@ A,(@%&. "!"*( )*(%*)L
tau '(@$WC"&&Q <I3)%*L Xc_eL ?7I#$G-# 8$I3%-. (& $G- MG-#C"@ =^I%@%J#%IC (0 b". !(@-E
[email protected] B%*&*( ?*(%#-'* ZZ] e_[va_`
tfu 5".-Q >(J-#$ F@0#-3 !"#$%&L XY[ZL ?5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. (0 !(#$"@%$/ >"$-. ". "& g%.$(#%B"@
(# p"##"$%,- M-BG&%^I-LD ?(%' 9 C(*4 D,# E*3 X`OfP] X[YvX_XL
t[u 5"/I-@"Q FI#-@%(Q 8I."&" >(3#%^I-WES(C%&^I-WQ !L >I%WE'(##-*(Q "&3 !L b%@%L e``fL
?F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. (0 '#-".$ 5"&B-# !(#$"@%$/ >"$-. %& F&3"@IB%" O8A"%&PLD
F&&!/) ,5 G&#,/,.2 X[] ZcZvZcc
tZu 5(@@%&.Q i"C-. iL XYceL ?MG- 5(&$#%JI$%(& (0 !-3%B"@ !-".I#-. $( $G- S-B@%&- (0 !(#$"@%$/
0#(C >-.A%#"$(#/ MIJ-#BI@(.%.] F& F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ !(3-@LD H*+,.(!"-2 XY] f`Yvfe_
t_u 5(&$#-#".Q S"&$-Q =.$-J"& lI-&$-.Q "&3 S",%3 '#",(L e``[L ?7-C"@- <"J(I# 7(#B- l"#E
$%B%A"$%(& %& b#-"$-# 8"&$%"*(Q 5G%@-] XY[_EXYY_L F 8/&$G-$%B 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.LD 9,0(&!/
,5 I&'*(&!'%,&!/ H*4*/,"+*&' X_] XZYvXcZ
tcu 5.%.W"#Q 4C#-L XYYXL ?NG/ <-".$ 8^I"#-. "&3 !"2%CIC =&$#(A/n F& F2%(C"$%B FAE
A#("BG $( 4&0-#-&B- 0(# <%&-"# 4&,-#.- l#([email protected] F&&!/) ,5 D'!'%)'%#) XYOfP] e`aeve`ZZ
tYu S-"$(&Q F&*I.L XYY_L 8-* F&!/2)%) ,5 ;,0)*-,/3 D0(4*2)Q i(G&. g(A9%&. +&%,-#.%$/
l#-..L
e[
![Page 27: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
tX`u S-"$(&Q F&*I.Q "&3 5G#%.$%&" l"2.(&L XYYfL ?8",%&*Q b#()$GQ "&3 F*%&* %& M"%)"&QD
%& SL N%.- O-3P D'03%*) %& '-* =#,&,+%#) ,5 F.%&.Q AAL aaXvaZe p"$%(&"@ 'I#-"I (0
=B(&(C%B >-.-"#BGL
tXXu S-&W"IQ F#$GI# MLQ l"$#%B9 5L b%JJ(&.Q "&3 =3)"#3 b#--&J-#*L XYcYL ?'"/-.%"& =.$%C"E
$%(& (0 l#(A(#$%(&. )%$G " 5#(..E=&$#(A/ l#%(#LD >,++0&%#!'%,&) %& D'!'%)'%#) J 8-*,(2
!&3 E*'-,3) XcO[P] XcfavXcZX
tXeu =I)"@.Q >(JQ !"#%9- ;&(-0Q "&3 S"&%-@ ,"& HII#-&L e`XXL ?MG- M#-&3 %& 7-C"@- <"J(I#
7(#B- l"#$%B%A"$%(&] NG"$ B"& J- =2A-B$-3 0(# $G- 7I$I#-nD =+"%(%#!/ =#,&,+%#) f`OaP]
_eYv_[a
tXau 7%-&J-#*Q 8$-AG-& =LQ "&3 N%@@%"C !L !".(&L XY_YL ?43-&$%KB"$%(& "&3 =.$%C"$%(&
(0 F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ !(3-@. %& $G- F&"@/.%. (0 S%.B#-$- F#BG%,"@ S"$"LD D,#%,/,.%#!/
+*'-,3,/,.2 X`] XvZ_
tXfu 7%#-J"I*GQ b@-&&Q "&3 ;-&&-$G =L S",%.L XYccL ?M#-&3. %& F&$%J@"B9 l#-UI3%B-Q XY_eE
XYcf] >-*%(& "&3 5(G(#$ =V-B$.LD 8-* F+*(%#!& 9,0(&!/ ,5 D,#%,/,.2 YfOeP] e[Xve_e
tX[u 7%$W-&J-#*-#Q '-#&3Q >-%&G(@3 8BG&"J-@Q "&3 b"J/ NI&3-#@%BGL e``fL ?MG- b-&3-# b"A
%& <"J(# !"#9-$ l"#$%B%A"$%(& "&3 =CA@(/C-&$] F 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. 0(# N-.$ b-#C"&/LD
9,0(&!/ ,5 C,"0/!'%,& =#,&,+%#) X_OXP] cavXXZ
tXZu 7IQ N-&U%"&* iL e```L ?>%3*- =.$%C"$(# %& 8%&*I@"# S-.%*& )%$G FAA@%B"$%(& $( F*-E
l-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. (0 S%.-".- >"$-.LD >,++0&%#!'%,&) %& D'!'%)'%#)K8-*,(2 !&3
E*'-,3 eYOeP] eZave_c
tX_u b@-&&Q p(#,"@ SL XY_ZL ?5(G(#$ F&"@/.$.R 7I$%@- wI-.$] 8$"$%.$%B"@ F$$-CA$. $( 8-A"#"$-
F*-Q l-#%(3Q "&3 5(G(#$ =V-B$.LD F+*(%#!& D,#%,/,.%#!/ <*4%*A fX] Y``vY`fL
eZ
![Page 28: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
tXcu b@-&&Q p(#,"@ SL XYcYL ?F 5"I$%(& "J(I$ !-BG"&%B"@ 8(@I$%(&. $( $G- 43-&$%KB"$%(&
l#(J@-C %& 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.] 5(CC-&$ (& 8"."9% "&3 8IWI9%LD F+*(%#!& 9,0(&!/ ,5
D,#%,/,.2 Y[] _[fv_ZX
tXYu b(@"&Q FC(.Q b-(#*- iI3*-Q "&3 i-V#-/ !L l-#@(VL XYYZL ?F !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ FAE
A#("BG $( >-B(,-#%&* 4&0(#C"$%(& 0#(C !I@$%&(C%"@ >-.A(&.- S"$"LD 9,0(&!/ ,5 '-*
F+*(%#!& D'!'%)'%#!/ F)),#%!'%,& YXOfafP] cfXvc[a
te`u b((3Q 4LiL XYZaL ?!"2%CIC =&$#(A/ 0(# g/A($G-.%. 7(#CI@"$%(&Q =.A-B%"@@/ 0(# !I@$%E
3%C-&.%(&"@ 5(&$%&*-&B/ M"[email protected] F&&!/) ,5 E!'-*+!'%#!/ D'!'%)'%#) afOaP] YXXxYaf
teXu g"%&-.Q !%BG"-@L e``cL ?7-#$%@%$/ "&3 !(#$"@%$/ %& $G- +&%$-3 8$"$-.LD =gLp-$ =&B/B@(E
A-3%"Q -3%$-3 J/ >(J-#$ NG"[email protected] !"#BG XYL
teeu g"&(BGQ b%(#"Q "&3 !"#U(#%- g(&%*L XYc[L ?jM#I-R F*- l#(K@-. (0 ="#&%&*.] F3UI.$%&*
0(# 5-&.(#%&* "&3 0(# l-#%(3 "&3 5(G(#$ =V-B$.LD <*4%*A ,5 =#,&,+%#) !&3 D'!'%)'%#)
Z_OaP] acavYf
teau g"#3%&*Q S",%3 iL e``YL ?>-B-&$ F3,"&B-. %& F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.L F 5(CC-&E
$"#/ (& S#-*"& "&3 F#C.$#(&*Q "&3 (& >-%$G-#Q g"I.-# "&3 d"&*LD D,#%!/ D#%*&#* !&3
E*3%#%&* ZY] XffYvXf[XL
tefu g"#3%&*Q S",%3 iLQ "&3 5G#%.$(AG-# i-&B9.L e``aL ?5G"&*%&* F$$%$I3-. M()"#3 l#-E
C"#%$"@ 8-2] 5(G(#$Q l-#%(3Q "&3 F*%&* =V-B$.LD C01/%# G"%&%,& L0!('*(/2 Z_OeP] eXXv
eeZ
te[u g".$%&*.Q S(&"@3 NLQ "&3 iL b#-*(#/ >(J%&.(&L XY_fL ?4&B%3-&B- (0 5G%@3@-..&-.. 0(#
+&%$-3 8$"$-. N(C-&Q 5(G(#$. J(#& XcYXEXYf[LD D,#%!/ ?%,/,.2 eX] X_cvXcf
teZu g-B9C"&Q i"C-.Q "&3 >%BG"#3 >(JJL XYc[L ?+.%&* <(&*%$I3%&"@ S"$" $( -.$%C"$- F*-Q
l-#%(3 "&3 5(G(#$ =V-B$. %& ="#&%&*. =^I"$%(&.LD 4& !".(&Q N%@@%"C !L "&3 8$-AG-& =L
e_
![Page 29: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
7%-&J-#*] 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. %& 8(B%"@ >-.-"#BGL '-/(&3 $G- 43-&$%KB"$%(& l#(J@-CL p-)
d(#9] 8A#%&*-#vH-#@"* Xa_vX[`
te_u g-#&-.Q bI3CI&3L XY_eL ?MG- l#(B-.. (0 =&$#/ %&$( 7%#.$ !"##%"*-LD F+*(%#!& D,#%,J
/,.%#!/ <*4%*A a_] X_avXce
tecu g(&%*Q !"#U(#%-Q "&3 b%(#" g"&(BGL XYc[L ?l"#$%"@ >-$%#-C-&$ ". " 8-A"#"$- !(3- (0
>-$%#-C-&$ '-G",%(#LD 9,0(&!/ ,5 ;0+!& <*),0(#*) e`OXP] eXvfZ
teYu i"/&-.Q =3)%& MG(CA.(&L XY[_"L ?4&0(#C"$%(& MG-(#/ "&3 8$"$%.$%B"@ !-BG"&%B.LD C-2)J
%#!/ <*4%*A X`ZvZe`
ta`u i"/&-.Q =3)%& MG(CA.(& XY[_JL ?4&0(#C"$%(& MG-(#/ "&3 8$"$%.$%B"@ !-BG"&%B. 44D
C-2)%#!/ <*4%*A X`cvX_X
taXu ;"@)%UQ F3#%""&Q "&3 >(J F@-..%-L e``_L ?l-#C"&-&$ "&3 M#"&.%$(#/ N"*-. (0 '#%$%.G
!-&Q XY_[Ee``X] d-"#Q F*- "&3 5(G(#$ =V-B$.LD 9,0(&!/ ,5 !""/%*3 *#,&,+*'(%#) eeOZP]
X`ZavX`YaL
taeu ;"A$-/&Q F#%-Q >(J F@-..%-Q "&3 F&&"C"#%" <I."#3%L e``[L ?=2A@"%&%&* $G- N-"@$G g(@3E
%&*. (0 S%V-#-&$ 5(G(#$.] l#(3IB$%,%$/ b#()$G "&3 8(B%"@ 8-BI#%$/LD =0(,"*!& =#,&,+%#
<*4%*A fY] XaZXvXaYX
taau ;&(-0Q !"#%9-Q >(J F@-..%-Q "&3 F3#%""& ;"@)%UL e``YL ?5G"&*-. %& $G- 4&B(C- S%.E
$#%JI$%(& (0 $G- SI$BG =@3-#@/ (,-# $G- d-"#. XYcYEe`e`] " !%B#(.%CI@"$%(&LD M*')"!(
H%)#0))%,& C!"*(N `Yke``YE`a`e``Y
tafu ;I"&*Q S%Q '-&$ p%[email protected]&Q "&3 i-&. l-#BG p%[email protected]&L e``cL ?7(#-B".$%&* )%$G $G- F*-El-#%(3E
5(G(#$ !(3-@ "&3 $G- -2$-&3-3 5G"%&E<"33-# !(3-@LD ?%,+*'(%@! Y[OfP] Yc_xYYX
ec
![Page 30: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
ta[u ;I@@J"B9Q 8(@(C(&L XY[YL I&5,(+!'%,& 8-*,(2 !&3 D'!'%)'%#)L p-) d(#9] i(G& N%@-/ 6
8(&.L
taZu ;I@@J"B9Q 8(@(C(&Q "&3 >%BG"#3 FL <-%J@-#L XY[XL ?1& 4&0(#C"$%(& "&3 8IhB%-&B/LD 8-*
F&&!/) ,5 E!'-*+!'%#!/ D'!'%)'%#) eeOXP] _YvcZ
ta_u ;IAA-#Q <")#-&B- <LQ i(.-AG !L i"&%.Q FWW" ;"#C(I.Q "&3 '-#&"#3 bL b#--&J-#*L XYc[L
?8$"$%.$%B"@ F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.] F >-,%-) "&3 5#%$%^I-LD 9,0(&!/ ,5 >-(,&%#
H%)*!)*) ac] cXXvca`
tacu !"&.9%Q 5G"#@-. 7L e``aL ?43-&$%KB"$%(& l#(J@-C. %& $G- 8(B%"@ 8B%-&B-. "&3 =,-#/3"/
<%0-LD D,0'-*(& =#,&,+%# 9,0(&!/ _`OXP] XXveX
taYu !".(&Q ;"#-& 1AA-&G-%CQ N%@@%"C !L !".(&Q g"@@%C"& gL N%&.J(#(I*GQ "&3 NL ;-&E
&-$G l((@-L XY_aL ?8(C- !-$G(3(@(*%B"@ 4..I-. %& 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. (0 F#BG%,"@ S"$"LD
F+*(%#!& D,#%,/,.%#!/ <*4%*A ac] efeve[c
tf`u !-*G%#Q 5(.$".Q "&3 =3)"#3 NG%$-G(I.-L XYYZL ?MG- =,(@I$%(& (0 N"*-. %& $G- +&%$-3
;%&*3(C] =,%3-&B- 0#(C !%B#( S"$"LD 9,0(&!/ ,5 O!1,( =#,&,+%#) XfOXP] Xve[
tfXu !%$$-@G"CC-#Q >(& 5LQ b-(#*- bL iI3*-Q "&3 S(I*@". !%@@-#L e```L =#,&,+*'(%# 5,0&J
3!'%,&)N P,/0+* QL 5"CJ#%3*- +&%,-#.%$/ l#-..L
tfeu !/-#.Q S()-@@Q "&3 8-(&* N(( <--L XYYcL ?4CC%*#"&$ M#"U-B$(#%-. %&$( g(C-()&-#.G%A]
F M-CA(#"@ F&"@/.%. (0 >-.%3-&$%"@ F..%C%@"$%(&LD I&'*(&!'%,&!/ E%.(!'%,& <*4%*A aeOaP]
[YavZe[
tfau p"9"CI#"Q M"9".G%L XYcZL ?'"/-.%"& 5(G(#$ !(3-@. 0(# b-&-#"@ 5(G(#$ M"J@- F&"@/.-.LD
F&&!/) ,5 '-* %&)'%'0'* ,5 D'!'%)'%#!/ E!'-*+!'%#) ac] a[ava_`
eY
![Page 31: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
tffu 1R'#%-&Q >(J-#$ !L e```L F*- l-#%(3 5(G(#$ 5G"#"B$-#%.$%B !([email protected] D,#%!/ D#%*&#* <*J
)*!(#- eY] XeavXaY
tf[u 1R'#%-&Q >(J-#$ !LQ "&3 i-"& 8$(B9"#3L e``eL ?H"#%"$%(&. %& F*-E8A-B%KB g(C%B%3- S-"$G
>"$-.] " 5(G(#$ =2A@"&"$%(& 0(# 5G"&*-. %& $G- F*- S%.$#%JI$%(& (0 g(C%B%3- S-"$G.LD
D,#%!/ D#%*&#* <*)*!(#- aX] XefvX[`
tfZu l"#%.Q i-V 'LQ "&3 F@-&" H-&B(,.9"L XYY`L ?F p($- (& $G- 4&-,%$"J%@%$/ (0 !"2%CIC
=&$#(A/LD I&'*(&!'%,&!/ 9,0(&!/ ,5 F""(,7%+!'* <*!),&%&. fOaP] Xcaxeea
tf_u l(#$#"%$Q 7#"&B-Q >(J F@-..%-Q "&3 S(#@/ S--*L e`X`L ?S( ="#@/ <%0- "&3 5(&$-CA(#"&-E
(I. !"B#(B(&3%$%(&. =2A@"%& g-"@$G "$ 1@3-# F*-.nDL 9,0(&!/ ,5 C,"0/!'%,& =#,&,+%#)
eaOeP] ZX_vZfe
tfcu >(B9"0-@@"#Q >L M/##-@@L XY_`L >,&4*7 !&!/2)%)L l#%&B-$(& pi] l#%&B-$(& +&%,-#.%$/ l#-..L
tfYu >/3-#Q p(#C"& 'L XYZ[L MG- 5(G(#$ ". " 5(&B-A$ %& $G- 8$I3/ (0 8(B%"@ 5G"&*-L F+*(J
%#!& D,#%,/,.%#!/ <*4%*A a`] cfavcZX
t[`u 8"."9%Q !"."C%BG% 8LQ "&3 M"$.IW( 8IWI9%L XYc_L ?5G"&*-. %& >-@%*%(I. 5(CC%$C-&$ %&
$G- +&%$-3 8$"$-.Q g(@@"&3Q "&3 i"A"&LD F+*(%#!& 9,0(&!/ ,5 D,#%,/,.2 Ye] X`[[vX`_Z
t[Xu 8"."9%Q !"."C%BG% 8LQ "&3 M"$.IW( 8IWI9%L XYcYL ?F 5"I$%(& "J(I$ $G- S"$" $( J- I.-3
0(# 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.] >-A@/ $( b@-&&LD F+*(%#!& 9,0(&!/ ,5 D,#%,/,.2 Y[] _ZXv_Z[
t[eu 8G"&&(&Q 5@"I3- =L XYfcL ?F !"$G-C"$%B"@ MG-(#/ (0 5(CCI&%B"$%(&DL ?*// D2)'*+
8*#-&%#!/ 9,0(&!/ e_] a_Yvfea
t[au 8G(#-Q i(G& =LQ "&3 >(3&-/ NL i(G&.(&L XYc`L ?F2%(C"$%B S-#%,"$%(& (0 $G- l#%&B%A@-
(0 !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ "&3 $G- l#%&B%A@- (0 !%&%CIC 5#(..E=&$#(A/LD I=== 8(!&)!#'%,&)
,& I&5,(+!'%,& 8-*,(2 eZOXP] eZva_
a`
![Page 32: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
t[fu 89%@@%&*Q i(G&L XYcYL ?5@"..%B !"2%CIC =&$#(A/LD 4&] E!7%+0+ =&'(,"2 !&3 ?!2*)%!&
E*'-,3)L iL 89%@@%&*Q -3%$(#L ;@I)-# FB"3-C%BQ p(#)-@@Q !FL f[v[eL
t[[u 8C%$GQ g-#J-#$ <L e``fL ?>-.A(&.-] 5(G(#$ F&"@/.%. >-3I2LD D,#%,/,.%#!/ E*'-,3,/,.2
af] XXXvXXY
t[Zu 8$-%&Q 5G"#@-. !L XYcXL ?=.$%C"$%(& (0 $G- !-"& (0 " !I@$%,"#%"$- p(#C"@ S%.$#%JI$%(&LD
F&&!/) ,5 D'!'%)'%#) YOZP] XXa[xXX[X
t[_u M%9(BG%&.9/Q dLQ p"0$"@% M%.GJ/ "&3 >"AG"-@ S",%3 <-,%&-L ?F@$-#&"$%,- FAA#("BG $(
!"2%CICE=&$#(A/ 4&0-#-&B-LD C-2)%#!/ <*4%*A F a`O[P] eZacEeZff
t[cu +h&9Q i(.L XYY[L ?5"& $G- !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ l#%&B%A@- '- =2A@"%&-3 ". " 5(&.%.$-&B/
>-^I%#-C-&$nD D'03%*) %& ;%)',(2 !&3 C-%/,),"-2 ,5 D#%*&#* C!(' ? eZOaP] eeaEeZXL
t[Yu H"& 3-# 8BG(#.Q F&&"Q >(J F@-..%-Q "&3 !"I#( !".$#(*%"B(C(L e``_L ?g(C- "&3 !(#$E
*"*- 1)&-#.G%A (0 $G- SI$BG =@3-#@/] -2A@"%&%&* 5(G(#$Q M%C- "&3 F*- =V-B$.LD H*
=#,&,+%)'N X[[] YYvXeX
tZ`u N%&.G%AQ 5G#%.$(AG-#Q "&3 S",%3 iL g"#3%&*L e``cL ?F !-BG"&%.CE'".-3 FAA#("BG $( $G-
43-&$%KB"$%(& (0 F*- l-#%(3 5(G(#$ !([email protected] D,#%,/,.%#!/ E*'-,3) !&3 <*)*!(#- aZOaP]
aZevf`X
tZXu d"&*Q d"&*Q N-&U%"&* 7IQ "&3 ;-&&-$G 5L <"&3L e``fL ?F !-$G(3(@(*%B"@ 5(CA"#%.(&
(0 F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ !(3-@.] MG- 4&$#%&.%B =.$%C"$(# "&3 5(&,-&$%(&"@ b-&-#"@%W-3
<%&-"# !([email protected] D,#%,/,.%#!/ E*'-,3,/,.2 af] _[vXX`
tZeu d"&* d"&*L e``cL ?M#-&3. %& +L8L F3I@$ 5G#(&%B S%.-".- !(#$"@%$/Q XYZ`xXYYY] F*-Q
l-#%(3Q "&3 5(G(#$ H"#%"$%(&.LD H*+,.(!"-2 f[OeP] ac_vfXZ
aX
![Page 33: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
tZau d"&*Q d"&*Q N-&U%"&* 7IQ "&3 ;-&&-$G 5L <"&3L e``cL ?MG- 4&$#%&.%B =.$%C"$(# 0(# F*-E
l-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.] NG"$ 4$ 4. "&3 g() $( +.- 4$LD F+*(%#!& 9,0(&!/ ,5 D,#%,/,.2
XXaOZP] XZY_vX_aZ
tZfu d"&*Q d"&*Q 8"C 8BGI@G(0-#EN(G@Q "&3 ;-&&-$G 5L <"&3L e``_L ?F 8%CI@"$%(& 8$I3/ (0
$G- 4&$#%&.%B =.$%C"$(# 0(# F*-El-#%(3E5(G(#$ F&"@/.%.LD l"A-# A#-.-&$-3 "$ $G- !-$G(3E
(@(*/ l"A-# 8-..%(& "$ $G- F&&I"@ !--$%&*. (0 $G- FC-#%B"& 8(B%(@(*%B"@ F..(B%"$%(& %&
p-) d(#9Q FI*I.$ e``_L
ae
![Page 34: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
7)%8(# 92 +8 7-C"@- !(#$"@%$/ S"$"
0 20 40 60 80 1000
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against age, by cohort
Age
0 20 40 60 80 1000
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against age, by period
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against period, by age
Period
110
100
90
80
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against period, by cohort
Period
1834
1844
18541864 1874 1884 1894 1904
19141924
1850 1900 1950 20000
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against cohort, by age
Cohort
110
100
90
80 0
1850 1900 1950 20000
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
Against cohort, by period
Cohort
1934
1944195419641974
198419942004
aa
![Page 35: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
7)%8(# ;] 8-$$%&* "*- O$(APQ A-#%(3 OC%33@-PQ B(G(#$ OJ($$(CP -V-B$. $( W-#(
0 20 40 60 80 100-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
Cohort Effects
Cohort
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08Cohort Effects
Cohort
0 20 40 60 80 1000
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-0.03
-0.02
-0.01
0
0.01
0.02PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1Cohort Effects
Cohort
af
![Page 36: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
7)%8(# <] 8-$$%&* "3U"B-&$ B(G(#$. $( J- -^I"@O$(A] XcfYmXc[`Q C%33@- XcYYmXY``Q J($$(C] XYfYmXY[`P
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-0.08
-0.06
-0.04
-0.02
0
0.02
PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 20000
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
Cohort Effects
Cohort
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-0.3
-0.25
-0.2
-0.15
-0.1
-0.05
0
0.05Cohort Effects
Cohort
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20100
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08Cohort Effects
Cohort
a[
![Page 37: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
7)%8(# =] g"&(BG "&3 g(&%*kS-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%W"$%(&
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-0.01
-0.005
0
0.005
0.01PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 2000-0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1Cohort Effects
Cohort
7)%8(# >] MG- 4&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-5
0
5
10
15x 10
-3 PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 20000
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
Cohort Effects
Cohort
7)%8(# ?2 !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ =.$%C"$-.
0 20 40 60 80 100-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
AgeEffects
Age
1930 1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010-5
0
5
10
15x 10
-3 PeriodEffects
Period
1850 1900 1950 20000
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
Cohort Effects
Cohort
aZ
![Page 38: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
7)%8(# @2 +; 7-C"@- <"J(# 7(#B- l"#$%B%A"$%(& S"$"
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.5
1
Against age, by cohort
Age
1974
1959
1944
1929
1914
1899
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.5
1
Against age, by period
Age
1974
19892004
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 20100
0.5
1
Against period, by age
Period
1832
46
60
74
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 20100
0.5
1
Against period, by cohort
Period
1909
1937
1923
1951
1965 1979
1900 1920 1940 1960 19800
0.5
1
Against cohort, by age
Cohort
60
70
20
304050
1900 1920 1940 1960 19800
0.5
1
Against cohort, by period
Cohort
1974 1982 19901998 2006
a_
![Page 39: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
7)%8(# A2 8-$$%&* "*- O$(APQ A-#%(3 OC%33@-PQ B(G(#$ OJ($$(CP -V-B$. $( W-#(
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1Cohort Effects
Cohort
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 19800
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8Cohort Effects
Cohort
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.12
-0.1
-0.08
-0.06
-0.04
-0.02
0
0.02PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1Cohort Effects
Cohort
ac
![Page 40: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
7)%8(# B2 8-$$%&* "3U"B-&$ "*-. $( J- -^I"@O$(A] eYma`Q C%33@- aYmf`Q J($$(C] fYm[`P
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-4
-3
-2
-1
0
1Cohort Effects
Cohort
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1Cohort Effects
Cohort
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 800
2
4
6
8
10AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
6PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5Cohort Effects
Cohort
aY
![Page 41: The age-period cohort problem: set identification and ... · The age-period cohort problem: set identification and point identification Martin Browning Ian Crawford Marike Knoef The](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041502/5e225590fd7b8215b83ffc44/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
7)%8(# 9C2 g"&(BG "&3 g(%&*kS-"$(& "&3 l"2.(& &(#C"@%."$%(&
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
0
0.2
0.4AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.04
-0.02
0
0.02
0.04
0.06PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8Cohort Effects
Cohort
7)%8(# 992 4&$#%&.%B -.$%C"$(#
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.05
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8Cohort Effects
Cohort
7)%8(# 9;2 !"2%CIC =&$#(A/ =.$%C"$-.
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6AgeEffects
Age
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010-0.05
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3PeriodEffects
Period
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980-0.2
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8Cohort Effects
Cohort
f`