MAKERERE UNIVERSITY
COLLEGE OF BUSINESS AND MANEGEMENT SCIENCE
MICRO CREDIT POLICY AND CUSTOMER RETENTION IN MICRO
FINANCE INSTITUTIONS IN UGANDA:
A CASE STUDY OF HOFOKAM LIMITED – KASESE BRANCH.
KIRUNGI FRANK FRED
04/U/13449/Ext
SUPERVISOR: Mr. NUWAGABA GEOFFREY
A RESEARCH REPORT SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE
REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF BACHELOR OF COMMERCE OF
MAKERERE UNIVERSITY
JULY 2011
1
DECLARATION
I declare that this research report is my original work and has never been submitted to any other
institution of higher learning for any other award.
Signature: ………………………………………. Date:…………………………………..
Kirungi Frank Fred
(Student)
i
APPROVAL
This is to certify that this research report on “Micro Credit Policy On Customer Retention In
Micro Finance Institutions In Uganda A Case Study: HOFOKAM Limited - Kasese Branch, has
been under my supervision and is now ready for submission and examination
Signed:…………………………… Date:……………………………………………..
Mr. NUWAGABA GEOFFREY
(Supervisor)
ii
DEDICATION
I dedicate this report top my mother, Mrs. Y. Rwaheeru, my brothers John and Godfrey, my wife
Patra and to my daughter Isabel for their great support during my studies.
God Bless You.
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I first thank God for seeing me through this adventurous exercise of research with all the huddles
I went through
Special thanks to my supervisor Mr. Nuwagaba Geoffrey for all the guidance and support. His
unwavering perseverance and presence guaranteed success of this work.
Am grateful to the staff of HOFOKAM Ltd for all the information, cooperation and guidance.
My friends Julius, Albert and Bernard, I thank you, not forgetting Margaret and my Mother.
Special recognition goes to my course mates for all the love, support and care.
Lastly my family for all the support and perseverance.
iv
LIST OF ABREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS
ACP Average Collection Period
AMFIU Association of Micro Finance Institutions in Uganda
HOFOKAM Hoima, Fort Portal, Kasese Microfinance Company
Ltd Limited
MFIs Micro Finance Institutions
SPSS Statistical Package for Social Sciences
v
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DECLARATION..............................................................................................................................i
APPROVAL.....................................................................................................................................i
DEDICATION...............................................................................................................................iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT..............................................................................................................iv
LIST OF ABREVIATIONS AND ACRONYMS...........................................................................v
TABLE OF CONTENTS...............................................................................................................vi
List of Tables...................................................................................................................................x
List of figures..................................................................................................................................xi
ABSTRACT..................................................................................................................................xii
CHAPTER ONE............................................................................................................................1
1.0 Introduction..............................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background to the study..........................................................................................................1
1.2 Problem Statement...................................................................................................................4
1.3 Purpose of the study.................................................................................................................4
1.4 Objectives of the study............................................................................................................5
1.5 Research questions...................................................................................................................5
1.7 Significance of the study.........................................................................................................6
vi
CHAPTER TWO:LITERATURE REVIEW..............................................................................7
2.1 Introduction..............................................................................................................................7
2.2 Credit Policies used by MFIs...................................................................................................7
2.3 Customer Retention.................................................................................................................15
2.3.2 How Customer retention can be enhanced...........................................................................23
2.3.2.1Listening to customers’ complaints....................................................................................23
2.3.2.2 Creating a Complaint and Suggestion System..................................................................25
2.3.2.3Employing a customer service representative....................................................................26
2.3.2.3Implementing a Complaint Solicitation Strategy..............................................................27
2.2.3.4 Instituting a Customer Advisory Board.............................................................................27
2.4 Relationship between credit facilities and customer retention................................................29
2.4 Conclusion...............................................................................................................................32
CHAPTER THREE:METHODOLOGY..................................................................................33
3.1 Introduction..............................................................................................................................33
3.2 Research design.......................................................................................................................33
3.3 Study area................................................................................................................................33
3.4 Study population......................................................................................................................33
3.5 Sampling Design......................................................................................................................33
vii
3.6 Sources of Data........................................................................................................................34
3.6.1 Secondary data sources.........................................................................................................34
3.6.2 Primary data sources.............................................................................................................34
3.7 Data Collection Methods/ Instruments....................................................................................35
3.7.2 Interview guide.....................................................................................................................35
3.7.3 Observation...........................................................................................................................35
3.8 Data processing, analysis and presentation.............................................................................35
3.8.1 Data processing.....................................................................................................................35
3.8.2 Data analysis.........................................................................................................................35
3.8.3 Data Presentation..................................................................................................................36
3.9 Limitations of the study...........................................................................................................36
CHAPTER FOUR:PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS OF FINDINGS.............................37
4.2. Background characteristics of the respondents;.....................................................................37
4.3 Credit policies used by HOFOKAM.....................................................................................40
4.3.1 HOFOKAM has a credit management committee that is responsible for reviewing and
monitoring risk management policies............................................................................................40
4.3.2 Application forms are used by clients applying for credit....................................................41
4.3.3. HOFOKAM bases on the value of security to advance loans.............................................42
4.3.5 The character of the clients is considered when processing a loan for a client....................43
viii
4.3.7 HOFOKAM Ltd has an upper credit limit.........................................................................45
4.3.8 The terms of getting loans from HOFOKAM Limited are favourable.................................45
4.3.9 The Nature of the business operated by the client is considered before extending the credit
.......................................................................................................................................................46
4.4 Level of Customer retention in HOFOKAM Ltd..................................................................48
4.4.1 HOFOKAM Limited keeps client’s records.....................................................................48
4.4.2 Rate of desertion of the clients.............................................................................................49
4.4.3 The clients of this institution have on average been getting services for the last three years
.......................................................................................................................................................50
4.5 The relationship between credit policy and customer retention in HOFOKAM Ltd..............50
CHAPTER FIVE:SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS................52
5.1 Introduction............................................................................................................................52
5.2 Summary of major findings...................................................................................................52
5.3 Conclusion.............................................................................................................................53
5.4 Recommendations and suggestions.......................................................................................54
REFERENCES..............................................................................................................................56
Appendices....................................................................................................................................59
Appendix A: QUESTIONNAIRE................................................................................................59
Appendix II: Interview Guide.......................................................................................................64
ix
List of Tables
Table 1 : Description of respondents by Gender...........................................................................37
Table 2: Description of respondents by working experience........................................................38
Table 3: HOFOKAM has a credit management committee for reviewing and monitoring the risk
management policies.....................................................................................................................41
Table 4: HOFOKAM has application forms that are use by clients in applying for loans............41
Table 5: HOFOKAM bases on the value of security before advancing loans..............................42
Table 6: HOFOKAM considers the adequacy of information before extending a loan to the client
.......................................................................................................................................................43
Table 7: The character of the clients is considered while processing the loans for clients..........43
Table 8: Capacity to pay is considered when processing loans for clients....................................44
Table 9: HOFOKAM has an upper limit on the loans...................................................................45
Table 10: Terms of getting loans from HOFOKAM are favourable.............................................45
Table 11: The nature of the business run by the clients is considered when advancing credit.....46
Table 12: Clients are given a satisfactory credit period to pay back.............................................47
Table 13: Clients are sent reminder letters....................................................................................47
Table 14: Loans officials pay visit to the clients reminding them of the dates to pay back.........48
Table 15: HOFOKAM Limited keeps clients records..................................................................48
Table 16: Rate of desertion of the clients from HOFOKAM Limited..........................................49
Table 17: Relationship between credit policy and customer retention..........................................50
x
List of figures
Figure 1: Customer complaint map...............................................................................................25
Figure 2: A customer complaint card............................................................................................26
Figure 3: Interpretation and use of customer feed backs...............................................................29
Figure 4: Description of respondents by age.................................................................................38
Figure 5: Description of respondents by level of education..........................................................39
Figure 6: Description of respondents by designation....................................................................40
xi
ABSTRACT
This study was designed to find out the relationship between credit policy and customer retention
in Micro finance Institutions (MFIs) in Uganda taking Hoima, Fort portal, Kasese Microfinance
Company (HOFOKAM) as a case study. It describes how credit policy has an effect on
customer retention in MFIs.
The study used both qualitative and quantitative methods through questionnaire and semi
structured interviews. A simple random sampling design was used to select respondents from the
clients and purposive sampling was used to select staff respondents. The study covered 20
respondents and data was collected with the help of questionnaires and an interview guide. Data
presentation was done using tables showing frequencies and percentages. Data analysis was done
using a computer package of SPSS.
The findings were that HOFOKAM has credit policies in place which it was using, that the level
of client dropout was relatively high (moderate) and that credit policy and customer retention had
a negative relationship as evidenced from Pearson correlation coefficient of r=-0.803. The results
indicated that the increased client dropouts were as a result of high interest rates put in place as a
credit policy forcing borrowers to join other financial institutions.
The study recommended that interest rates should be revised; clients should be given a grace
period in case they fail to repay their loan in time, need for periodic review of credit policy and
training of staff. Clients also recommended the encouragement of individual loans so as to
prevent loyal clients from being penalized for those members of the group who fail to fulfill their
loan obligations.
xii
CHAPTER ONE1.0 Introduction
This chapter presented the background information about the variables of the study, the problem
statement, purpose of the study, objectives, research questions, scope, and significance of the
study
1.1 Background to the study
Microfinance institutions (MFIs) are those institutions that provide credit or savings facilities to
small scale enterprises. MFIs provide financial support to people especially those in rural areas
that cannot obtain these services from the formal banking and credit institutions because their
businesses, savings levels and credit needs are all small Wright, (1999). However, most MFIs
have sometimes disappointed its supporters. Only few of the hundreds of microfinance programs
inaugurated in the last decade have proven their sustainability AMFIU, (2002).
The success of any micro finance institution involved in lending money to its customers should
rely on its credit policy which in any case should be developed with customer needs and
expectations at the back of their mind, the neglect of which can lead to lending disaster. The
credit policy should be a living document. Besides there are some lending guidelines that
financial institutions can follow so as to ensure that the borrower will be able to schedule
payment in full and within the required period of time. It is probable that financial institutions
should follow a logical approach taking each important factor in the lending process one at a
time and assessing with the pending preposition.
1
A credit policy is a framework formulated by an organization as a guide to credit decisions.
Credit is one of the most important inputs in assisting community enterprises to grow Kakuru,
(2000). Credit policy combines three decision variables that is, credit standards which are
predetermined criteria to establish credit worthiness of a customer, credit terms as conditions or
stipulations under which credit is granted Pandey, (1995) and then collection efforts referring to
efforts applied in order to accelerate collection from slow paying customers and to reduce debt
losses.
Customer retention on the other hand is a strategy whose objective is to keep a company’s
customer, building a big customer base and to retain their revenue contribution. Customer
retention also refers to the creation of loyal customers, who feel satisfied with the services of the
micro finance institution’s products and come back to buy again and again Mbonigaba, (1998). It
also means having the same customers enjoying the same organization’s services, clients
referencing their friends to a particular organization for services, clients talking favorably about
the company and its services, less attention being paid by clients to competing institutions, and
clients are positively appreciating and tolerating some problems encountered by the organization
Kotler, (1998).
Thus customer retention is related to customer satisfaction as dissatisfied customers do not
return. It is a tactically driven approach based on customer behavior and a core activity going on
behind the scenes in relationship to marketing, loyalty marketing and so forth.
2
Positive impacts have been detected at the enterprise as well as household level. Several studies
indicate microfinance services help the poor to diversifying their income sources, building up
physical, human and social assets, and focus on good money management, rebuild the
household’s base of income and assets after economic shocks have occurred and to smooth
consumption (Cohen 1997; Cohen 1999; Hulme 1998, Ito 1998; Sebstad and Chen 1996).
In addition, interest in microfinance has soared in the recent decade and the instrument is now
seen as one of the most promising tools to tackle poverty in the developing world. The
fascination with microfinance derives from the fact that the provision of financial services can
contribute to poverty reduction and pass the test of sustainability at the same time Uganda
Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper Progress Report, (2000). For donors, microfinance is
especially attractive as it can be delivered in an institutional and financially sustainable manner
that permits them to withdraw after making relatively modest investments.
HOFOKAM is an acronym meaning Hoima , Fort portal, Kasese Micro finance company,
limited by guarantee. The company started in 1993 as three separate savings and credit
institutions in three Dioceses of Hoima, Fort portal and Kasese but all with funding and technical
support from Catholic Relief Services (CRS). In 2003, these three diocesan programmes on an
understanding of the three Bishops of the above Dioceses and CRS the joint main donor, were
merged to form one credit institution – HOFOKAM.
The company operates in the districts of Bushenyi, Kasese, Kabarole, Ibanda, Kamwenge,
Bundibugyo, Kyenjojo, Kibaale, Buliisa, Hoima, Masindi, and Oyam, It has got main branches
3
in Hoima, Kyenjojo and Fort portal and Kasese with field offices in Bundibugyo, Kamwenge,
Kibaale, Kagadi, Nalweyo, Oyam, Buliisa, Kyenjojo, Masindi Hiima, Bwera, Nyakasharu,
Katerera and Kisinga . The head office is in Kabarole - Fort portal town.
1.2 Problem Statement
While Uganda boasts of a long history of informal finance, semi-formalized micro finance began
emerging as an industry in the early 1990’s. There are approximately 100 registered operators
and more than 100 unregistered MFIs offering Microfinance services in Uganda AMFIU, (2002).
Microfinance institutions such as HOFOKAM Limited have adopted various measures to
increase on the accessibility of the services such as opening up out reach centres in rural areas,
encouraging group lending where group members access bank credit without physical collateral
security, adequate customer care, long opening hours and training of the clients on better loan
investment decisions, most MFIs including HOFOKAM limited have continued to experience a
problem of low customer loyalty leading to desertion Urquizo, (2006). According to
HOFOKAM limited Social Performance Audit report (2006), the company has been faced with
increased number of client dropouts for the last three years. The probable cause could be
stringent credit management policies. If this situation is left unchecked, it could lead to more
dropouts, which can have significant consequences on the future operations of the institution
which could lead to closure of the institution.
1.3 Purpose of the study
The study aimed at finding out the relationship between credit policy and customer retention in
HOFOKAM Ltd
4
1.4 Objectives of the study
1. To assess the credit policy of HOFOKAM ltd
2. To establish the level of customer retention in HOFOKAM
3. To establish the relationship between credit policy and customer retention in HOFOKAM
LTD
1.5 Research questions
1. What are the credit policies used by HOFOKAM ltd?
2. What is the level of customer retention in HOFOKAM Ltd?
3. What is the relationship between credit policy and customer retention in HOFOKAM
Ltd?
1.6 Scope of the study
1.6.1 Geographical scope
The study was carried out at HOFOKAM Ltd, Kasese Branch. It focused on the micro credit
policies as used by HOFOKAM Ltd as an independent variable and Customer retention as a
dependent variable.
1.6.2 Time scope
The study considered the period between 2006 and 2010. This was considered because the period
was long enough to enable the researcher come up with a comparative analysis of the status of
customer retention and the varied credit policies that have been adopted by the institution over
time.
5
1.7 Significance of the study
The study findings will help in the following:
(1) The Management of HOFOKAM Micro finance Ltd in making proper policies that are
aimed at having the Institution achieve its goals.
(ii) The Staff of HOFOKAM will be able to focus on quality client selection and carry out
feasibility analysis for prospective borrowers with the background of customer retention.
(iii) Other institutions may use the findings of this study for example other MFIs in making
policies on products development and refining to reflect customer satisfaction and
consequent retention.
(iv) Academicians may use it a useful addition to the body of the available information on
credit policies and their effects.
(v) The Government can use this research especially in the impending Micro finance bill to
moderate the policies of micro lending as the level of client rotation has a direct bearing
on the socio-economic standards and activities of the active poor, who contribute the
greatest percentage of the population in developing countries.
6
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW2.1 Introduction
In this chapter, discusses the available literature as regards to credit policies and customer
retention. It also presents an overview of MFIs in Uganda and specifically it provides detailed
background information about HOKOFAM.
2.2 Credit Policies used by MFIs
A credit policy is a set of policy actions designed to minimize costs associated with credit while
maximizing the benefit Kakuru, (2000). A credit period is a length of time for which credit is
extended to customers normally stated in terms of net date. Credit institutions can lengthen or
tighten the credit period depending on the norms of the industry, objectives of the firm and if
customers are frequently building up debts Semukono, (1997). However with the credit
institutions these days, the credit period is so tightened that clients have no room for adjustment
in case of situational changes.
The Credit Standards set by MFIs are levels or trends that are predetermined guidelines to enable
credit officers to make decisions; this is the criterion, which a firm follows, in selecting
customers for the purpose of extending credit. Credit standards provide guidelines for
determining whether to extend credit to a customer or not. In this case two aspects are
considered, the average collection period (ACP) that is the period in which the debts remain
outstanding and the ratio of uncollected receivables to the total receivables. From the ACP, the
firm can be able to determine whether the customer will meet his credit obligations or not. The
7
institutions need to consider the aspects of character, capacity, condition, capital and collateral to
estimate the profitability.
The overall debt collection policy of the firm should be such that the administration costs do not
exceed the benefit of incurring those costs. Most MFIs employ extra abnormal costs charged to
clients who fail to pay on time, but make efforts to pay later with out an MFI chasing them. A
tight collection procedure may offend and send away customers Don, (1998)
Findings by Okumu and Opondo, (2000) show that 50% of the interest rates charged by MFI’s
are the interests on operating costs and that not only are they increasing but also highly varying
and non uniform, yet most depend on the loan savings for the group loans. However, this view
has been overtaken by the coming into force of the Micro Deposit taking Institutions Act where
MFIs are prohibited from savings intermediation and this accounts for the high interest rates
charged by these institutions as a window for their inability to use savings as a cheap source of
loan-able funds Okumu an Opondo, (2000).
Benjamin and Ledgerwood, (1998) ADEMI (Association To The Development Of Micro
Enterprises) also strongly advocates that applicants who are unable to provide collateral should
not be limited in their ability to access credit. However, this argument should also have its
limitations based on amounts involved lest the institution risks heavy losses if clients failed to
pay back genuinely or otherwise
8
Micro finance institutions have the credit policy as one of their mainstream activities that
smoothens their capacity of operation, given the fact they are meant extend credit to the clients.
According to Brockington, (1987) all corporate plans enunciate a profit objective and financial
policy is designed mainly to achieve profit as an objective, growth and liquidity stability through
the credit policy formulated.
According to Pandey, (1995) should the institution fail to put in place favorable viable credit
policies, it will not only fail to operate and realize its objectives but may also find its self out of
business. Accordingly, the institution should evolve policies that would allow it to deliver a
service or product with the expectation of receiving back the reward later from the customers.
The credit must have an acceptable level of acceptance to allow the operators give a maximum
amount of credit at the lowest possible cost. The assessment exercise of risks should be
embedded with in the policy.
Giving credit is the most controversial and risky business as it is looked at by both sellers and
buyers. Van Horne, (1989) narrates that sellers looks at consumer credit as an opportunity for
gaining a competitive marketing advantage over others (Competitors) through expanding the
market share and general appeal of the people they serve. And to the buyer, she looks at it as way
of exploiting her, generally making her loose in the return.
Accordingly institutions should develop policies that strike a balance between the two aspects.
One that make them stay in business, and one that put customers in a position to pay back the
principle together with the interest with out leaving a strain on the businesses. It is against that
9
background that Armstrong, (1993) agued that if any micro finance is to realize its objectives as
well as help communities break the cycles of poverty, should use the credit policies as a weapon.
In the rural Uganda, the problem arises as credit policies are basically set along town setting and
does not suitably appeal to people in the rural areas. According to Pandey, (1995) a wrong
judgment is made by these institutions over helping people assess their projects and how they
can best return those money(s) borrowed.
Virtually all organization both Government and non governmental have the reduction or
elimination of poverty at the heart of their operations. Like wise, micro finance institutions have
got the primary purpose of helping in reducing poverty in specifically the rural areas. According
to Kakuru, (2000) firms advance credit to customers with a view to make a profit in return for
sacrifice made. In the event of that they help people get their projects financed.
The firm needs to assess the impact of credit to both their operation and its impact on the
proposed project of the customer. According to Van Horne, (1989) a financial institution should
look at its credit policy in terms of returns and cost. The costs involved in the selling of the
product (advancing the loan to the customer), the cost of servicing it, and the collection cost on
top of the risk involved in not being collectable.
The institution has got to strike a balance between the costs if they are to remain in business.
According to Ross & water field (1988), there are two disguised costs involved in credit
advancement. The carrying costs – costs associated with credit extension and investment in
10
receivables; they include the required rate of return from bad debts and the costs pertaining to
credit analysis, monitoring and collection. Opportunity cost – costs related to loss of sales as a
result of grant credit.
Micro finance institutions operate with a view to realize a profit on their credit advanced to the
customers, and for the recipient to better her economic life in terms of breaking the poverty
cycle. However for this to happen, the cost involved either side has got to be analyzed, measured,
and translated into the policies effected in the extension of this credit. According to Water field,
(1988) the costs have got a fundamental role in the execution of credit. The failure of the firm to
put in place proper efficient policies would cast doom over its operations.
The formulated credit polices act as guidelines for the assessment of the person to extend credit
to and how much the principal should be. Normally the institution looks at what is stipulated in
its guidelines and determine who to give. According to Edminster, (1980) the institution must
bare in mind not only the established credit standards but also credential concern must be paid to
the correct adherence to those standards in the making of the credit award decision.
Gitman, (1976) agrees when he says that many Institutions forget that they have a moral
obligation to guide their customers on how to best use the money borrowed. According to him
obscured implementation of a credit policy will not produce optimal results.
The financial credit has got a combination of three credible aspects; credit terms, credit standards
and collection measures.Before a credit is given to a customer, there are various criteria’s that
11
the customer must first fulfill. Credit standards according to van Horn, (1994) are the minimum
criteria’s that has got to be considered for the extension of the loan. Such criteria’s include credit
rating of the customer, reference, average payment periods and other relative financial aspects
that together form a prudent assessment of the customer claim for the loan.
Since the primary aim of the financial institution is to foster reductions in the poverty levels in
particularly the rural Ugandan community, they have the moral obligation to assess the viability
of the proposed project of the customer and help the customer in looking at how best the
customer can best reap from the venture. According to Pandey, (1993) this is the basic stage in
the lending process, by assessing the risks involved.
From the ancient periods, the fundamental risks have been categorized as including character,
capital, capacity, conditions, and collateral.
Character; the process should involve the aspect of looking at the true picture of the customer.
The borrowers’ honest and trustworthiness. The loan officer must consider the integrity and
transparence of the potential customer and his will to pay back. Should there be any element of
doubt over those aspects; the loan should not be advanced.
Capital: the borrowers’ wealth position measured by the financial muscle of the customer in
terms of soundness and market standing. Can the firm withstand or individual withstand any
deviation from such balances? Pandey, (1995) was particularly concerned over this as most rural
based people do lack this aspect.
Capacity; this involves the borrower’s legal standing and management expertise in facing the
challenges of the operations of the project proposed. This further looked at in the rural contest
12
leaves a lot wanting as rural Ugandan community lacks the skills to management fragmented
projects.
Conditions; this refers to the economic environment or industrial specific supply, production
and distribution factors influencing a firm’s operations.
Collateral; this refers to the customers’ asset staked against the loan advanced that would act as
a source of income in case of default. This is the asset that the institution can seize and
eventually sell to recoup its principal amount.
Pandey, (1993) observed that loose credit standards would lead the bank to having a lot of
money advanced as loans; however the risk will as well be great. On the other hand, the bank if it
extends credit only to those most reliable and strong may not be able to expand lending.
The fact that most of the 5Cs do apply in an urban setting where people have got some money
and assets but not applicable in the rural setting. Walker, (1993) identified the 5Cs of bad credit
representing facts to guard against in any micro financial institution. These include complacency,
carelessness, communication breakdown, contingencies and competition. They should be looked
at more carefully to safe guard against defaulting.
When structuring those traits, the institution must put in consideration the rural poor, the people
who are going to borrow from those firms. For instance, the rural poor lacks the professional
management skills of business, the firm should be prepared to help them realize their dream of
breaking the poverty cycles through accelerating proper management of businesses.
13
The credit to be advanced must be stipulated. The lengths of the credit period and the interest and
how it is charged must all be stipulated. The cash discount, the period, and terms of repayment
have got all to be stipulated. The way those three aspect are structured have got a burning effect
on the lending profit, average collection period and loan expenses. Van Horne, (1994) noted that
the exact effects of a decision to change any of the three credit term components depend on the
direction and degree of change.
Any institution has got procedures in place that facilitate the collection of these loans. According
to Kabir Hassan, (2002) it should be done in an organized manner that would accelerate the
collection of the loan without straining the relationship with the customer. The inability of clients
to pay back may result from the short falls from the amounts realized or the will not to pay at all.
The procedures should be in place to collect money from non responding customers.
Reminders should be sent reminding her of the due date of payment and the exact amount to pay
in for of a credit note. Further development in micro finance credit requires that the firm takes an
insurance policy against debtors since they cannot accurately measure the risk. They also adopt
the method of factoring of debtors to other firms who can collect on the behalf of the firm.
According to Buckley, (1993) most of the micro finance institutions have no systematic credit
collection measures blended on the rural poor, they just resort to more aggressive collection
techniques like confiscation of property and eviction of clients from the staked property. This has
been a common scenario in both the urban and the rural Uganda leading to the potential
customers to shun them; only to leave them plunged in the desperate levels of poverty.
14
2.3 Customer Retention
Few studies have been carried out on the dropout issue, not because it is unimportant, but
because it is difficult and expensive to locate clients once they leave an MFI. The factors for
dropping out identified by previous studies are many and illustrate a wide range of reasons. In
overall, the majority of studies found that most clients exit due to organizational failures,
idiosyncratic shocks and/or systemic shocks, client maturity and competition (Meyer et al, 2001;
Wright and Al, 2001; Hulme et al, 1999; Stark and Nyirumuringa, 2002; Musona and Coetzee,
2001). However, Pagura, (2004) has taken the debate a step further in making an in-depth
analysis of the factors leading to clients‟ dropouts, using duration models in order to examine the
clients decision to remain or exit the borrowing relationship in group loan program state in Mali.
In line with the above insights, this study aims to analyze some elements of dropout issue that
Pagura, (2004) did not explicitly study, namely (i) the determination of the profile of ex-clients;
(ii) the identification of the main reason leading to dropout and (iii) the determination of the
variables which influence the length of time in the MFI which is the cornerstone of this research.
The greatest business secret in the world is the value of a satisfied customer. A satisfied
customer will buy again and again and in large amounts and will be considered retained, thus
providing a free yet highly credible advertising. In the business world there are three major
challenges, customer attraction, satisfaction and retention. To attract a customer in business, the
focus should be put on his needs and his buying behavior. Although majority purchases are made
emotionally, boosting customer image and making them feel important is the key to customer
attraction Bara, (2001).
Customer satisfaction is one of the factors of customer retention and as one of the challenges of
business today. It is reported that to win a customer (attraction, satisfaction and retention); a
15
business must focus on the needs of customers and his buying behaviors Balunywa, (1995).
Customer retention can only be talked of when the company has successfully delighted and
satisfied its customers. A satisfied customer will buy again and again and in large amounts and
will be considered retained Kambuga, (2000). This is supported by Bara, (2001) who expressed
that the greatest business secret in the world is the value of a satisfied customer. A satisfied
customer can be considered retained and provides free, yet highly credible advertising.
A customer is not a stranger on our business premises therefore, deserves the best services
(Tumwesige 2003). Clients must be sweet talked especially at getting loans, but on recovery they
wear different faces. This is contrary to the principle of positive expression and being neutral.
Bank of Uganda internal Journal, (2001).
Furthermore, Survey, (2000) indicates that customer retention reflects “the mind that customers
have about a company and its products or services when their expectations have been met or
exceeded and that this state reflects the life time of the product or service experience”.
Despite all this international consecration, there are still dropouts from MFI. The East African1
MFIs case illustrates the high rate of dropouts (25%-60%) some MFI can face and that could
undermine the success of the programs. Although clients dropout over-time, even from the most
successful organisations, in microfinance sector, dropout is portrayed as a negative phenomenon
by many practitioners, because both MFI and clients have much to gain from a long-tem banking
relationship. For those authors, customer loyalty reinforce interactions between clients and MFI,
it mitigates the two mains problems of credit market: moral hazard and adverse selection and
also increases the availability of credit Duflo, (2010).
16
Meyer and Al, (2001) in their paper examining the determinants of borrower dropouts in Mali,
said that retaining clients is very important for MFIs because it reduces MFI‟s administrative
costs, lowers default risks and increases the average loan balance as well as the institution‟s
productivity. This is confirmed by Schreiner, (2004) according to whom, the cost of acquiring
new clients is higher than keeping old ones, a conclusion he arrived at when scoring dropouts at
a micro lender in Bolivia.
Ongena and Smith, (2001) who have focused more on the client benefit, believed that, by staying
with the MFI, clients‟ income increases because they have an ongoing access to financial
services which helps to boost their confidence. Moreover, the customer loyalty contributes to
lower interest rate (Berger and Dell, 1995; Angelini and Al, 1998; Uzzi, 1999) and can also be a
competitive advantage value Wright and Al, (1999). However, other practitioners highlight that,
this is valid portrayal when MFIs are losing “good” clients. When MFIs are losing “bad” clients,
dropouts can be a positive phenomenon. It is for this reason that many employees, especially
credit officers argued in the Hulme et al. (1999) paper presenting East African microfinance
institutions that “they have to remove the weed to get a good harvest”. In some cases, dropouts
may also represent a success, when the client has graduated beyond the need for the MFI‟s
services Simanowitz, (2000).
However, whether “good” or “bad” client or graduated client, understanding why clients dropout
can provide a valuable source of information about the program. Indeed, by understanding why
clients exit, a clearer picture of MFI strengths and weaknesses can emerge, notably for policies
of clients‟ retention, which is a proof of sustainability Simanowitz, (2000).
17
2.3.1 Causes of withdraw of desertion of microfinance clients
2.3.1.1 Inadapted products
Many authors in microfinance literature found that financial services of MFIs are inflexible.
Guérin, (2009) has shown that MFIs still had difficulties to adapt their offer to the diversity of
clients‟ needs. Hulme and Mosley, (1999) have pointed to similar observations and therefore
have called MFIs to more diversification of products and segmentation of the clientele in order to
better serve them. In the same line of ideas Wright, (1999) has stated that MFIs would gain by
standardizing less their products and services. He has emphasised as has Hulme et al, (1999) that,
much of this standardizing problem is driven by the attempts to “replicate” products and services
from foreign cultures without taking into account the socio economic environment into which
they are being imported. Thus, when MFIs products and services do not meet clients‟ needs,
there is a high dropout rate. Loan size, delays in loan disbursement, repayment schedule, costs of
loan, loan eligibility criteria, group lending issue are the variables most cited as proof of this
inadaptation.
Loan size
Hulme et al, (1999) have pointed out that many clients voluntarily withdrew from MFIs due to
the loan amount. In fact, the group has shown that, when the loan amount is small, leading
wealthier clients to dropout. The opposite holds insofar that when the loan amount is increased,
poorer clients voluntarily dropout.
Repayment schedule and delays in loan disbursement
Musona and Coetzee, (2001) have highlighted that the repayment schedule was perceived as too
rigid and therefore not adequately taking into account the realities of micro businesses. Hulme et
al,(1999) in the same line of thought, have observed that a long period of waiting for
18
disbursement of a loan, most of the time, pushes clients out of MFIs Hulme et al., (1999). This
means that the longer the loan disbursement takes the more clients exit from MFIs.
Group lending
Problems related to group borrowing concerned group dynamics issue such as group size, group
liability and the lack of time for weekly meetings Painter and Mc Knelly, (1998), Mustafa and
Al, (1996) Wilson, (2001) Meyer and Al, (2001), Wright, (1999).
Staff attitude
In a study done in South Africa, Stark and Nyirumuringa, (2002) have shown that the lack of
products and services information between management staff and clients lead to clients‟
dropouts. However, Urquizo, (2006) has a different opinion about the quality of services. He
contends that the staff attitude rarely accounts for clients‟ desertion, because the clients have
lower expectations towards it. He gets support from Dackauskaite, (2009) whose study was
carried out in Ethiopia.
Competitive environment
As far as the competitive environment is concerned, many authors have recognized that over the
past few years, microfinance sector has faced high competition. The so many institutions which
have been created over the last years and which are competing in the same market account for
the above. As observed by Wright, (2001) and Pagura, (2004) dropouts are frequent because of
dissatisfaction with the financial services being offered by one MFI and the belief that other
MFIs or other financial institutions can offer better facilities. Thus, they switch from one
financial institution to another.
19
In brief, inadapted products and competition have been unanimously recognized by the
microfinance practitioners, as reasons which lead to high dropout rate. However, authors have
different opinions concerning the relationship between staff attitude and clients.
2.3.1.2 Demand reasons
This group is more related to crisis reasons, socio economic characteristics and clients‟ maturity.
Crisis reasons
It is stated by many practitioners that microfinance allows poor people to increase their income
and assets and decrease their vulnerability because households have better health outcomes
Morduch and Hashemi, (2003); Armendáriz and Morduch, (2007). Therefore, microfinance is
being seen as a virtuous circle which has increased well-being, economic, social and political
empowerment especially of women. However, sometimes, the reality is often much complicated.
Some studies have shown different results: over-indebtedness of many clients, reallocation of
loan, clients‟ delinquency and the decrease of schooling levels Meyer et al., (1999). One reason
for the conflicting results could be that the poor face continual risks and unexpected events such
as illnesses, death of a family member, the loss of a job, funeral expenses and wedding or
children‟s education Rutherford, (1999).
Socio economic characteristics
This group includes variables such as age, gender, location of residence and occupation as well
as socio economic characteristics.
20
Age and dropouts
PRIDE, a Tanzania‟s Arusha Branch has revealed that age clearly plays a role in those
individuals who are recruited and their likelihood to dropout. The 21 year olds and less dropped
out at the highest rate while 60 years old and more dropped out at the lowest rate. However, most
MFIs highlight that members must dropout of the organisation on retirement because they stop to
be an entrepreneur Musona and Coetzee, (2001).
Gender and dropouts
Many studies has argued that one of the main reasons for the success of microfinance institutions
is because they target women Armendáriz and Morduch, (2007); Guérin et al., (2009). In dropout
issue, Schreiner, (2004) has shown with empirical evidence that women are less likely to exit
than men and also that occupation is correlated with dropout. In the East African research
however, there was no clear evidence indicating that women were more or less likely to drop out
of MFIs that serve both men and women Wright et al., (1999). Moreover, while some credit
officers in Uganda have claimed that women were more likely to dropout than men Hulme et al.,
(1999), other studies have implicitly argued that men can dropout more than women, because,
they are less reliable.
Location of residence and occupation and dropouts
Pagura, (2004) and Lehner, (2009) have shown that crisis reasons are generally the main factors
for dropouts. In Bangladesh and in Africa for instance, many clients migrate to other areas
because they are looking for better life conditions6 or news markets, therefore resulting in
dropouts. Other studies have just mentioned occupation and location of residence without giving
a real correlation between those variables and the causes of departure Musona and Coetzee,
(2001).
21
Client maturity
Client maturity means that clients will take larger loans to expand or maintain the working
capital of their business or to finance asset acquisition (Wright, 1999; Simanowith, 2000;
Dackauskaite, 2009). Client maturity also means that clients will accumulate enough capital and
they do not need another loan (Dackauskaite, 2009).Therefore, this phenomenon can also
lead to clients‟ exit. In the same of thought Wright, (1999) has shown that there were two
schools of graduation: One held that after a limited number of subsidized loan cycles, the
beneficiaries would no longer need credit. However, for Wright, this was a supreme naïveté,
because there is scarcely a business in the world that does not use overdraft facilities. The other
school, more plausibly, believed that poor clients could “graduate” with enough wealth and self-
confidence to become the clients of commercial banks.
In their East African studies, Wright et al. (1999) has observed that socio economic
characteristics and crisis reasons play a tremendous role in the reasons that lead to clients
dropouts. However, based on the above development and considering that this study will be done
in Mali, one of the poorest countries in the world, Malian people will be more vulnerable to
financial difficulties due to crisis as illness, death of a member, or loss of job. It seems scarce
that client maturity be the reason of the high dropout rate. Therefore, we can draw our second
group of hypotheses.
2.3.1.3. Environmental reasons
22
Environmental reasons are linked to downturn in the national economy and adverse climatic
conditions. Clients generally served by MFIs have fewer assets and their income is not
diversified. Thus, the poor are more vulnerable to financial difficulties due to economic
downturns or other crises. All the African MFIs studies have reported that dropout rates increase
when there is a bad economic climate, seasonality and natural calamities Wright and al., (1999);
Meyer et al., (2001), because clients have fewer ways of coping with such events and are more
likely to drop out. African countries as others faced climatic conditions these last years.
However, in Africa more than other countries, people who face economic downturns or other
crises receive fewer supports.
2.3.2 How Customer retention can be enhanced
2.3.2.1Listening to customers’ complaints
Chances are that if good customers are dissatisfied with the offerings of your institution, they
will borrow elsewhere. When an unhappy customer leaves, it is estimated that she will tell at
least ten other people of the bad experience. Often, the institution doesn’t suspect that a problem
exists in the first place, but the result is negative advertising, declining profits, and lost
opportunities to serve customers. The good news is that this scenario is avoidable. By actively
soliciting complaints, MFIs can spot dissatisfied customers, resolve their complaints, find ways
to meet their needs, and ultimately retain highly-valuable repeat customers who will spread the
good news about your institution.
The best way to prevent defection is by listening to customer complaints and quickly acting upon
them, through the following steps:
Create channels for dissatisfied customers to complain
23
Encourage all customers to use these channels
Personally attend to customers who are dissatisfied
Quickly resolve customer complaints to turn dissatisfied customers into long-term, happy
customers who will be loyal to the institution
Following these steps will allow MFIs to avoid costly defections while enhancing their long-term
relationships with customers who are crucial to lasting growth and profitability.
Figure 1 provides a rough map of what kinds of complaints to expect and a general idea of what
to do with them. Using this framework, MFIs might consider developing their own tailored
guidelines to clearly indicate to branch staff what they can and cannot resolve. Not all complaints
have immediately apparent answers. Some can (and should) be solved immediately, while others
require some investigation. The most important response to any complaint is concern and
appreciation. A complaint not only provides useful feedback, but it also creates an opportunity
for you to exceed the customer’s expectations. With this in mind, you should make it easy for the
dissatisfied customer to complain.
24
Figure 1: Customer complaint map
2.3.2.2 Creating a Complaint and Suggestion System
A complaint and suggestion system provides a communication channel for unhappy customers. It
enables them to share their dissatisfaction with the institution and (hopefully) to suggest ways to
improve conditions. A complaint and suggestion system typically consists of comment cards, a
receptacle for the cards, and an attention-getting display to encourage its use. Comment cards
should have ample room for all complaints and suggestions. The display might say something
like, “We care about your concerns,” to let customers know that you value their opinions.
Figure 2 provides a sample comment card.
25
Figure 2: A customer complaint card
2.3.2.3Employing a customer service representative
A customer service representative, prominently positioned at a desk in each branch, is a live
version of the complaints and suggestions box. The customer service representative is trained to
listen to customers and respond to their complaints. As with the complaints and suggestions
system, the customer service desk includes a sign that says, “We care about you” and an eye-
catching display about the institution’s commitment to customer satisfaction. It is best if the
customer service representative has sufficient authority to quickly solve customer complaints. To
make the position most cost-effective, the customer service representative can assume other
responsibilities, such as welcoming new customers and opening new accounts. The customer
26
service desk provides an easy-access channel for customers to voice their concerns and resolve
their complaints. Often, when a customer is unhappy, he feels (often rightfully) that there is no
one who can address his concerns. Many times, customers will simply leave rather than taking
the time to find out whom to talk to. The option to talk to the representative is also useful for
illiterate customers.
2.3.2.3Implementing a Complaint Solicitation StrategySince credit officers and other frontline staff have the most contact with customers, they are in an
ideal position to observe customer preferences, needs, and sources of dissatisfaction. Customers
will casually comment on operations while making loan repayments or filling out loan
applications, and frontline employees have to keep an open ear to customers’ thoughts. Not only
are employees in an ideal position to identify dissatisfied customers, they are also in an ideal
position to suggest solutions that will make customers happier. To encourage this behavior and
boost customer satisfaction, MFIs could reward loan officers who make the best suggestions.
The customer information generated by your staff members is most valuable if it is documented,
collated and analyzed.
2.2.3.4 Instituting a Customer Advisory BoardCustomers are an effective and reliable source of advice for finding ways to prevent defections.
A customer advisory board can formalize this function. The advisory board consists of a small
group of customer representatives who meet periodically to discuss the current state of affairs in
the institution from the customers’ point of view. A customer advisory board assumes a
preventive role for customer dissatisfaction, pinpointing small problems before they become
sources of major disappointment. The advisory board can provide ideas for product or service
27
innovations, alert the MFI to the greatest sources of customer dissatisfaction, and otherwise act
as a voice for customers. Unlike focus groups, a customer advisory board consists of a fixed or
rotating group of customers. Since not everyone feels comfortable complaining directly to staff
members, customers need to know that they can share their concerns with their local
representatives on the customer advisory board.
2.3.2.5 Establishing a Customer Feedback Database
The customer feedback database aggregates data gathered by all four information gathering
methods. Without a formal tabulation of customer feedback, it will be difficult to filter and
respond most quickly to the more serious complaints (e.g. fraud or mistreatment), as opposed to
more common problems with easier remedies. One staff member should manage input of data.
The database includes the following categories:
Type of feedback (complaint/suggestion)
Description of complaint
Date of complaint
Description of customer (length of relationship with MFI, size of business, type of business,
etc)
Recommended action
Follow-up procedures
28
Figure 3: Interpretation and use of customer feed backs
2.4 Relationship between credit facilities and customer retention
A growing body of evidence show that few micro enterprises experience sustained growth, while
the majority grow only a little or maintain their operations at a constant level Kakuru, (2000). It
is also unusual for credit to trigger a continuous increase in technical sophistication, output or
employment. It is much more common for each of these variables to reach a plateau after one or
29
two loans and remain in a steady state. As far as empowerment is concerned, microfinance
services have shown little potential to thoroughly change existing inequalities in power relations
or the role of women in society (Buckley 1997; Goetz and Gupta 1996; Hulme and Mosley 1996;
Zaman 1998). However, empirical evidence shows that microfinance interventions have indeed
the capacity to reduce poverty, contribute to food security, and change social relations for the
better.
In some cases there is also extreme precaution by the loan officers to reduce the amount the
customer may access in order to assure the payment. Ironically, however, customers requiring
additional amounts will look for other credit providers, increasing the institution’s risk. Also, the
research in a Central American country revealed different correlation with some customer
service satisfaction issues depending on the loan amount. The higher the amount, the lower the
satisfaction with “service hours” and “service speed” and also more demands for other financial
services as well as fewer requirements of other related services such as training. This shows us
how important it is to fine-tune the target and align the capacities of the MFI to the market being
targeted.
Although, lowering the interest rate for the best customers has been demonstrated to be an
effective short term retention tactic. For now it is complicated to reward customers with good
payment behavior with a lower interest rate, since the budgets and projections of most MFIs
work with average pricing, which creates constraints on offering price discounts without
negatively impacting MFI income. In fact, MFIs are very inelastic in terms of decreasing interest
rates, unless there exists an institutional commitment for improving efficiency and transfer those
gains to the clients or the competition forces this efficiency.
30
Various sources indicate that customer service is not the main factor for desertion, such as the
research undertaken by Inez Murray which shows that, in Bangladesh, desertion for service-
related reasons represented only 3% of the stated cause for desertion, as opposed to another
investigation made in Uganda, where this percentage was 9%.
Research done by ACCION International similarly illustrates that poor service is not an
important driver of client desertion. In the case of the MFIs studied in Central America, it was
found that only 3% of desertion was due to service issues, and it was 10% in the MFI in South
America. Nevertheless, improving customer service is essential to permit the MFI to accomplish
its social mission, balancing the Customer-MFI relationship: going from a LOSE-WIN to a
WIN-WIN perceived relationship will establish the basis for loyalty.
Customers with potential payment problems are, in general, rejected for loan renewals. Research
undertaken with former customers of individual loans indicates that customers, who were
rejected by their own loan officer or because of a MFI policy, account for between 12% and 15%
of the desertion. In addition, Kim Wilson shows a chart of a MFI where involuntary desertion
(due to delinquency issues) was about 13%. Many MFI incentive systems penalize loan officers
for their delinquent accounts, leading them to be more conservative in accepting renewals. The
research done in a Central American country with solidarity and individual loans indicates that 2
out of 5 former customers left involuntarily based on the group or loan officer decision.
As indicated below, it is recommendable when monitoring desertion to adjust the rate to account
for involuntary client desertion by registering those who leave as a result of being rejected by
MFI policies
31
2.4 Conclusion
As much as the above literature demonstrates the importance, of MFI in reducing poverty, it is
clear that there are many challenges on the both sides of the MFIs and the clients. Moreover,
little attention in the literature has been given to the relationship that exists between the credit
policy and customer retention. Therefore this study intended to establish this relationship.
32
CHAPTER THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.1 Introduction
This chapter is about the methodology that was used in the study. It includes research design,
study area, study population, sample size and selection, research tools, data collection and data
analysis.
3.2 Research design
A cross sectional research design was used. This is a basic research method in which a bigger
number of respondents was studied at one specific time and the difference between individual
groups within the population compared, therefore workers at HOFOKAM limited were studied
and the differences or similarities between them were compared.
3.3 Study area
The study was conducted from HOFOKAM Limited, Fort Portal Branch, and Western Uganda.
The area was selected because of being within the easy reach of the researcher and so data was
easily collected at minimum cost.
3.4 Study population
The study targeted employees and clients of HOFOKAM limited
3.5.1 Sample size
The study involved 20 respondents. These were staff of the institution but working under
different departments
3.5.2 Sampling design
The researcher adopted stratified random sampling where by the departments in HOFOKAM
Limited constituted the strata. From Each stratum, simple random sampling technique was used
33
so as to enable the employees under each department have an equal representation and therefore
avoid bias. This enabled the researcher to come up with findings that were reliable and valid. The
clients were selected using convenience sampling. This was selected because only those who
were willing to participate were selected as found at the premises of the institution.
3.6 Sources of DataThe study employed both primary and secondary data collection approaches.
3.6.1 Secondary data sources
Roston, (2001) defines secondary data as that kind of data that is available, already reported by
some other scholars. Secondary data included policy documents and abstracts of the various
scholars relating to the topic of discussion in question. Secondary data for this study was got
from sources like libraries, archived records from HOFOKAM Limited. This was because it was
readily available and easier to comprehend, as it comprised of extensively researched work.
3.6.2 Primary data sources
According to Roston, (2001) primary data is that kind of data that has been gathered for the first
time, it has never been reported anywhere. Short comings of secondary data sources such as out
datedness and inadequacy in terms of coverage, necessitated the use of primary source for first
data. Self administered questionnaire was used and this enabled the researcher to cover a large
population quickly and at a reasonable cost.
3.7 Data Collection Methods/ Instruments
The researcher used the following instruments to collect data for this study
3.7.1 Questionnaire
34
Semi structured Questionnaire was used to obtain responses from the respondents. The
questionnaire was semi structured according to the study objectives. Semi structured questions
was used to help the respondents make quick responses.
3.7.2 Interview guide
These were administered to the top managers of HOFOKAM Limited. The interviews were
meant to enable the researcher come up with detailed information to back the information that
was got through questionnaires.
3.7.3 Observation
The researcher observed the charts that were pinned in the Loans office depicting the trend of
clients joining the institution as well as the trend of client desertion.
3.8 Data processing, analysis and presentation
3.8.1 Data processing
Data collected was checked for completeness, categorized and coded and entered into a computer
where it was summarized into frequency tables.
3.8.2 Data analysis
The data got was analyzed automatically using SPSS (Statistical Package for Social Sciences).
The SPSS package was opted for, because it handles a large number of variables. Pearson’s
linear correlation index was used in order to correlate credit policy and customer retention. The
index was selected because it measures the degree and direction of the relationship between
variables.
3.8.3 Data Presentation
Quantitative data was presented in form of descriptive statistics using frequency tables, graphs
and pie-charts. Pie charts and graphs were generated using Microsoft Excel 2007 Version.
35
Qualitative data was sorted and grouped into themes. The researcher thereafter evaluated and
analyzes the adequacy of information in answering the research questions through coding of
data, identifying categories and parameters that emerge in the responses to the variables of the
study. Qualitative data was presented using narrative text.
3.9 Limitations of the study
Financial constraints: Financing the research study was too costly in terms of transport
costs, feeding and processing of the proposal and research report
Limited time: Inadequate time frame required for a detailed research study. Comprehensive
research study involves a great deal of collecting, analyzing and processing that requires a
lot of time
Hesitation of the respondents: The respondents were hesitant to release information to the
researcher. However, the researcher having made the questionnaire anonymous assured
them that the study was purely for academic purposes.
36
CHAPTER FOUR
DATA PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION OF FINDINGS
4.1 IntroductionIn this chapter presentation and analysis of findings in relation to the research objectives will be
made. The chapter incorporates the background, response rate, age structure of respondents, sex
of the respondents and findings on the objectives of the study and the summary. These findings
are presented in tables showing frequencies and percentages obtained from the primary sources.
4.2. Background characteristics of the respondents;
Table 1 : Description of respondents by Gender
Frequency Percent Valid Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Valid Male 16 80.0 80.0 80.0
Female 4 20.0 20.0 100.0
Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 1 above shows that majority of the respondents, 16(80.0 %) were male as compared to
females, 4(20.0%). This finding indicates that males continue to dominate positions of
responsibility in financial institutions as well as business enterprises as compared of women.
37
Figure 4: Description of respondents by age.
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
15.020.0
55.0
10.0
Series1
Age group
Perc
enta
ge
Figure 1 above indicates that 10 % of the respondents were aged 25 years and below, 55.0%
were aged between 26 and 36, 20.0% were aged between 37 and 47, 32% were aged between
48 and 58 while 32% were above 48 years of age. By implication, majority of the respondents
being mature meant that they were informed and knowledgeable about the variables.
Table 2: Description of respondents by working experience
Frequency Percent Valid Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Valid Below 3 year 6 30.0 30.0 30.0
3-5 years 4 20.0 20.0 50.0
6 -8years 10 50.0 50.0 100.0
9 years and above 0 0 0 100.0
Total 20 100.0 100.0
38
Table 2 shows that 30% of the respondents indicated that they have been engaged with their
respective departments for a period less than 1 year, 20.0% indicated that they have been
engaged with their departments for the period between 1-2 years while 50.0% indicated that they
have been engaged for more than 3 years. In all, majority, 50.0% indicated that they have been
engage with the institution for the last three years. This creates an impression that the
respondents had a vast experience on the dynamics of the institutions and therefore more
knowledgeable and informative as regards the operations of HOFOKAM Limited.
Figure 5: Description of respondents by level of education
2; 10%
13; 65%
3; 15% 2; 10%
Diploma Degree MastersOthers
Figure 2 shows that 2(10.0%) of the respondents were diploma holders, 13(65%) were degree
holders, 3(15.0%) had completed masters degree while 2(10.0%) had professional accreditations
such as Diploma in Banking and ACCA. Majority respondents (75%) were degree holders
( Bachelors and Masters) implying that HOFOKAM Limited considers graduate employees to
be very creative, knowledgeable and possessing expertise in varied areas of banking as compared
to employees from other cadres.
39
Figure 6: Description of respondents by designation
0%5%
10%15%20%25%30%35%40%45%
45%
20%
30%
5%
Series1
Designation of the Respondents
Perc
enta
ge
Figure 2 shows that 9(45.0%) of the respondents were credit officers, 4(20.0%) were loans
officers 6(30.0%) were finance officers while 1(5.0%) was a Public Relations Officer. The
representation of he key respondents from the most crucial departments regarding information on
interest rates and loan portfolio investment implies that the responses given were cross cutting
the departments in the bank and therefore were reliable.
4.3 Credit policies used by HOFOKAM
This section presents findings of the credit policy used by HOFOKAM Ltd
4.3.1 HOFOKAM has a credit management committee that is responsible for reviewing
and monitoring risk management policies
Findings on whether HOFOKAM has a credit management committee that is responsible for
reviewing and monitoring the risk management policies were considered and the results are
shown in the Table below
40
Table 3: HOFOKAM has a credit management committee for reviewing and monitoring the risk management policies
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 1 5.0 5.0 5.0
Disagree 1 5.0 5.0 10.0Not sure 1 5.0 5.0 15.0Agree 11 55.0 55.0 70.0Strongly Agree 6 30.0 30.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 3 shows that 1(5.0%) of the respondents strongly disagreed there is a credit management
committee that is responsible for reviewing and monitoring risk management policies in
HOFOKAM Limited 1(5.0%) disagreed, 1(5.0% were not sure, 11(55.0%) agreed while 6(30%)
strongly agreed. In all, majority respondents 85% agreed that there is a credit management
committee that is responsible for reviewing and monitoring risk management policies in
HOFOKAM Limited.
4.3.2 Application forms are used by clients applying for credit
Findings on whether HOFOKAM had application forms for clients to use while applying for
credit were considered and the results are shown in the Table below;
Table 4: HOFOKAM has application forms that are use by clients in applying for loans
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 3 15.0 15.0 15.0Not sure 0 0.0 0.0 15.0Agree 8 40.0 40.0 55.0Strongly Agree 9 45.0 50.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
41
Table 4 shows that 5(25.0%) of the respondents strongly disagreed that people apply for credit
using application forms, 3(15.0%) disagreed, 2(10.0%) were not sure, 6(30.0%) agreed while
4(20.0%) strongly agreed. Majority respondents (50.0%) agreed that clients of HOFOKAM
Limited apply for credit using application forms. This is a better credit management practice
because it enables management to keep track of the records pertaining to the funds that have
been borrowed by the clients.
4.3.3. HOFOKAM bases on the value of security to advance loans
The study investigated whether the institution based on the value of security to extend credit to
the clients. The following results were obtained.
Table 5: HOFOKAM bases on the value of security before advancing loans
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0Not sure 2 10.0 10.0 20.0Agree 6 30.0 30.0 50.0Strongly Agree 10 50.0 50.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 5 shows that none of the respondents strongly disagreed that HOFOKAM Limited bases
on the value of security, 2(10%) disagreed, 2(10%) were not sure, 6(30%) agreed while
10(50.0%) strongly agreed. In all 80% of the respondents agreed that the value of the property
mortgaged is considered greatly because this enables the staff of the SACCO to easily convert
the property into money to recover the funds given to the clients
42
4.3.4 The institution considers adequacy of information about the clients
The study further investigated as to whether HOFOKAM considered adequacy of information
about the clients before extending credit. The following results were obtained;
Table 6: HOFOKAM considers the adequacy of information before extending a loan to the client
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0
Disagree 3 15.0 15.0 25.0Not sure 2 10.0 10.0 35.0Agree 6 30.0 30.0 65.0Strongly Agree 7 35.0 35.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 4 shows that 2(10.0%) of the respondents strongly disagreed that HOFOKAM Limited
considers adequacy of information, 3(15.0%) disagreed, 2(10.0%) were not sure, 6(30.0%)
agreed while 7(35.0%) strongly agreed. Majority respondents (65.0%) agreed that clients of
HOFOKAM Limited considers adequacy of information. This narrows down the chances of
default that may arise due to deficiency information provided.
4.3.5 The character of the clients is considered when processing a loan for a client
Findings on whether management of HOFOKAM Limited based on the character of the clients in
processing of the loans were considered and the results are shown in the Table below;
Table 7: The character of the clients is considered while processing the loans for clients
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0Not sure 2 10.0 10.0 10.0Agree 8 40.0 40.0 50.0Strongly Agree 10 50.0 50.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
43
Source: Primary Data
Table 7 above shows that none of the respondents strongly disagreed and disagreed that
HOFOKAM Limited extended credit to the clients basing on their character 2(10.0%) were not
sure , 8(40%) agreed while 10(50.0%) strongly agreed. This implies that the character of clients
was considered by the institution before they were given a loan since majority of clients
responded positively to the statement.
4.3.6 Findings on capacity as a mode of assessing clients
The findings on whether the capacity of the clients to repay the loan was considered before they
are given a loan and the responses were as follows;
Table 8: Capacity to pay is considered when processing loans for clients
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly
Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0Not Sure 2 10.0 10.0 20.0Agree 4 20.0 20.0 40.0Strongly Agree 12 60.0 60.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
The table above shows that none of the respondents strongly disagreed that capacity to pay is
considered when processing loans for clients, 2(10.0%) disagreed, 2(10.0%) were not sure,
4(20.0%) agreed while 12(60.0%) strongly agreed. This implies that no staff member will grant a
client of doubtable character a repeat loan, thus letting them go.
44
4.3.7 HOFOKAM Ltd has an upper credit limit.
The findings on whether the institution had a maximum amount it lends to clients are shown in
the table below;
Table 9: HOFOKAM has an upper limit on the loans
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0Not sure 0 0.0 0.0 0.0Agree 10 50.0 50.0 60.0Strongly Agree 8 40.0 40.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 9 shows that none of the respondents strongly disagreed that the institution has an upper
limit on the loans, 2(10.0%) disagreed, none indicated they were not sure, 10(50.0%) agreed
while 8(40.0%) strongly agreed. In all, majority of the respondents (90.0%) agreed that the
institution has an upper limit on the credit that it extends to the clients. This implies that the
institution cannot grant a loan which is above the credit limit for that specific category of loan.
4.3.8 The terms of getting loans from HOFOKAM Limited are favourable
Findings on whether the terms for getting loans from HOFOKAM were favourable were
considered and the results are shown in the Table below
Table 10: Terms of getting loans from HOFOKAM are favourable
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0
Disagree 1 5.0 5.0 15.0Not sure 3 15.0 15.0 30.0Agree 6 30.0 30.0 60.0Strongly Agree 8 40.0 40.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
45
Table 10 shows that 2(10.0%) of the respondents strongly disagreed that the terms of
getting loans from HOFOKAM Limited were favorable, 1(5.0%) disagreed, 3(15.0%) were
not sure, 6(30.0%) agreed while 8(40.0%) strongly agreed. In all, majority of the respondents
(70.0 %) agreed that accessing and processing loans from HOFOKAM Limited was easy. This
could imply that holding other factors constant, HOFOKAM Limited has more clients than
could be other microfinance institutions.
4.3.9 The Nature of the business operated by the client is considered before extending the credit Findings on whether the nature of the business run by the clients was considered and the results are shown in the Table below:
Table 11: The nature of the business run by the clients is considered when advancing credit
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0
Disagree 3 15.0 15.0 25.0Not sure 1 5.0 5.0 30.0Agree 7 35.0 35.0 65.0Strongly Agree 7 35.0 35.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 11 shows that 1(5.0%) strongly disagreed that HOFOKAM Limited also considers the
nature of business, 2(10.0%) disagreed, (5.0%) were not sure, 5(25.0%) agreed while 11(55.0%)
strongly agreed. Such ensures that credit is accessed by people with high propensity of paying
back.
4.3.10 Findings on whether the institution extends a satisfactory credit period to the
clients.
The findings on whether the clients given a satisfactory credit period were considered and the
results obtained were as follows;
46
Table 12: Clients are given a satisfactory credit period to pay back.
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 10.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 20.0Agree 9 45.0 45.0 65.0Strongly Agree 7 35.0 35.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 12 shows that 2(10.0%) of the respondents strongly disagreed that HOFOKAM limited
gave them a satisfactory period to pay back, 2(10.0%) disagreed, none were not sure, 9(45.0%)
agreed while 7(35.0%) strongly agreed. In all, majority of the respondents (80.0 %) agreed that
clients are given a satisfactory period to pay back. This could imply that holding other factors
constant, HOFOKAM Limited has more clients than could be other microfinance institutions.
4.3.11 Clients are sent reminder letters
Findings on whether clients were sent reminder letters considered and the results are shown in
the Table below:
Table 13: Clients are sent reminder letters
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 3 15.0 15.0 15.0
Disagree 3 15.0 15.0 30.0Not sure 1 5.0 5.0 35.0Agree 6 30.0 30.0 65.0Strongly Agree 7 35.0 35.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 13 shows that 3(15.0%) of the clients strongly disagreed and disagreed respectively that
clients are reminded about their obligation to pay using reminder letters,1(5.0%) were not sure,
6(30.0%) agreed while 7(35.0%) strongly agreed. Sending reminders to clients pertaining to
their obligations to clear is a better credit management policy because it enables management of
the institution to keep the clients focused about the dates of clearing the installments.
47
4.3.12 Clients are visited to remind them to pay their loan.
Findings on whether clients were visited were considered and the results are shown in the Table below:Table 14: Loans officials pay visit to the clients reminding them of the dates to pay back
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Agree 1 5.0 5.0 5.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 15.0Not Sure 3 15.0 15.0 30.0Agree 4 20.0 20.0 50.0Strongly agree 10 50.0 50.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
The above table shows that 1(5.0%) of the staff strongly disagreed that visits were paid to clients
reminding them of the dates to pay back, 2(10.0%) disagreed, 3(15.0%) were not sure, 4(20.0%)
agreed while 10(50.0%) strongly agreed. The clients are visited to be reminded about repaying
their loan if the credit period given to them elapses. This implies that once the period given to a
client elapses, he/she can be visited by the field staff and reminded about repaying the loan.
4.4 Level of Customer retention in HOFOKAM Ltd.
4.4.1 HOFOKAM Limited keeps client’s records.
The researcher inquired from the staff as to whether they kept or maintained their clientele
records and the findings were as follows:
Table 15: HOFOKAM Limited keeps clients records
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0
Disagree 0 0.0 0.0 0.0Not Sure 0 0.0 0.0 0.0Agree 6 30.0 30.0 30.0Strongly Agree 14 70.0 70.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
48
Table 15 shows that none of the respondents strongly disagreed, disagreed and were not sure that
HOFOKAM kept and maintained the records of clients, 6(30.0%) agreed, while 14(70.0%)
strongly agreed. This implies that the institution maintained proper records as regards their
clients and this provided basis for the comparative analysis of the entry and exit of the clients as
well as the repetitive applications made by clients for credit.
4.4.2 Rate of desertion of the clients
The respondents were asked to indicate as to whether the institution had registered the problem
of clients deserting from the institution. The following results were obtained.
Table 16: Rate of desertion of the clients from HOFOKAM Limited
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Very Low 2 10.0 10.0 10.0
Low 9 45.0 45.0 55.0Moderate 4 20.0 20.0 75.0High 3 15.0 15.0 80.0Very high 2 10.0 10.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
Table 16 shows that the 2(10.0%) of the respondents indicated that the rate of desertion of the
clients was very low, 9(45%) indicated that it was low, 4(20.0%) indicated that it was moderate,
3(15.0%) indicated that it was high while 2(10.0%) indicated that it was very high.
4.4.3 The clients of this institution have on average been getting services for the last three years
49
The respondents were asked to indicate as to whether the clients of HOFOKAM Limited had
stayed with institution for more than three years. The following results were obtained.
Table 17: Clients from HOFOKAM Limited have stayed with the institution for more than 3 years
Frequency Percent Valid PercentCumulative
PercentValid Strongly Agree 1 5.0 5.0 5.0
Disagree 2 10.0 10.0 15.0Not Sure 3 15.0 15.0 30.0Agree 4 20.0 20.0 50.0Strongly agree 10 50.0 50.0 100.0Total 20 100.0 100.0
The above table shows that 1(5.0%) of the staff strongly disagreed that clients of HOFOKAM
limited had stayed with the institution for more than 3 years, 2(10.0%) disagreed, 3(15.0%) were
not sure, 4(20.0%) agreed while 10(50.0%) strongly agreed. This implies that the clients have
stayed with the institution for a reasonable period of time.
4.5 The relationship between credit policy and customer retention in HOFOKAM Ltd.
The relationship between credit policy and financial performance was statistically tested using
Pearson’s correlation matrix. This was used because both credit policy and customer retention
were numerical. The results obtained are shown in Table 17 below
Table 18: Relationship between credit policy and customer retention Credit policies customer retention
credit policies Pearson Correlation 1 .703** Sig. (2-tailed) .000 N 20 20customer retention Pearson Correlation .703** 1 Sig. (2-tailed) .000 N 20 20
** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
50
A strong positive relationship (r=.803*, p<0.01) was established because .803 is close to 1, with
a p-value of 0.000 which is less than 0.01 implying that a positive relationship that was
significant at 0.01 level existed between credit policy and customer retention
To further establish the significance of the contribution of credit policy to customer retention the
coefficient of determination (r2) was computed. Since r=0.803, r2=0.644. This implies that
effective credit management contributed 64% on the levels of customer retention of HOFOKAM
Limited while 36% was contributed by other factors. The implication of the above relationship
is that effective credit policy procedures positively influence customer retention and therefore
reminds the management of HOFOKAM Limited of the need to effectively streamline credit
management procedures and strategies if they are to achieve higher levels of customer retention
51
CHAPTER FIVE
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 Introduction
This chapter includes the summary of the findings from the study, the conclusions drawn from
the same findings and the recommendations made by the researcher on how to improve the credit
policy in MFI’s especially in HOFOKAM Ltd where the research was conducted.
5.2 Summary of major findings
The research findings revealed that HOFOKAM Ltd has a strong credit policy it uses when
carrying out its lending business. The institution’s credit standards are put into consideration
before a client is granted a loan.
For credit limit, the institution has different credit limits which are based on the type of loan
given and the graduation policy of growing clients’ loan sizes in phases to avoid over financing
and trickery by unscrupulous clients.
For the collection efforts, the institution has a well organized collection procedures, however,
high cost are incurred in the loan collection mechanism and clients are not comfortable with
some especially arresting, and embarrassing them.
The research findings revealed that the institution is having a moderate rate of client desertion
The researcher noted that the major cause of desertion was the high interest rate charged by the
institution poor customer handling especially by the field staff, credit terms and policies, failure
of the clients to honor their loan obligations thereby forcing the institution to do away with them
and the mushrooming competing alternative lending institutions with apparent or relative better
policies.
52
Some policies are not being followed like agricultural loans are extended to commercial farmers
with payments expected in a balloon form taking care of the crops gestation period but which
condition does not actually apply as they also pay monthly.
The findings from the study revealed that there is a significant inverse relationship between the
credit policy and customer relation of 0.803 (as shown by Pearson correlation coefficient). This
implies that the level of customer relation in HOFOKAM is influenced by the credit policy being
used.
5.3 Conclusion
The Conclusion from the research findings as guided by the study objectives:
The Interest rate is high and repayment schedules are not favorable to some clients. However
there may be other factors that affect the customer retention levels of MFI,s such as ignorance of
the client on how to use the loans properly and pay back the required interest and principal
amount in the stipulated period which prompts the institution to discard such clients.
The level of customer retention was established basing on the indicators of the clients going back
to borrow from the institution again and again. The researcher was also notified that some clients
especially those who acquire salary loans may drop out just the reason as to why they had
acquired the loan was to solve a certain problem in which case if the problem is solved, such
clients drop out.
53
From the Summary of findings from the study, it can be concluded that the credit policy used by
the Institution has an effect on their customer retention levels. The Institution credit policy is so
stringent thus affecting the level of customer retention.
5.4 Recommendations and suggestions
In light of the above findings and conclusions the researcher suggests the following
recommendations to improve credit policy in HOFOKAM ltd
The management of HOFOKAM should charge competitive interest rates and on a reducing
balance if possible. Clients should be extended a period of grace at least two weeks in case they
delay to pay their loan in time. Agricultural borrowers should be allowed to pay periodically.
Management should encourage clients to acquire individual loans so as to prevent the loyal
clients from being penalized on behalf those members of the group who fail to fulfill their part.
Loan officers should emphasize constant monitoring and training of clients on how to manage
their businesses in order to pay back the loan promptly. These will reduce client diverging loaned
money for other purposes other than the intended one and hence fail to pay back the loan.
There is need for periodic review of the credit policy and management should ensure that staff
members are well trained and are aware of the credit policy in place.
54
Management should endeavor to compare their services with those of other service providers so
as to improve on the weak areas as regards their credit policy.
Credit officers should emphasize reminder letters, reminder visits and reminder calls before
embarking on harsher measures of recovery which scare off clients.
55
REFERENCES
Armendáriz de Aghion, B. and Morduch, J. (2007). The Economics of Microfinance. London, First MIT Press paperback edition.
Armstrong K.R (1993); Financial Management fifth Edition Allan and Baan, Boston United
States of America.
Association of Micro finance Institutions of (Uganda AMFIU) publications 2002
Awava J. (2000), An assessment of the role of MFIs in development of small scale business
Balunywa W. (1995). Customer service and the business. Paper presentation, Uganda Investment
Authority, pp.1-7.
Bank of Uganda internal records (2001)
Bank of Uganda presentation at the AMFIU workshop. December (1997)
Bara V. (2001) customer satisfaction and delight. The micro finance banker. Issue 1 vol.4,pp.4
Dackauskaite, A. (2009). Client Exit in Microfinance, Utrecht University
Edminister Robert (1980); Financial Institutions Markets and Management revised Edition
McGraw Hill Publications France
EPRC (1996) Credit Accessibility to the Rural poor in Uganda. Economic Research Policy
Bulletin, Vol 2 no .1 April. (1996)
Gopaal, E.G (1997). Marketing and Business Management. (3rd ed) England : Colleen publishers
ltd
HOFOKAM ltd (2004-2009) business plan
56
Hulme, D. ; Mutesasira, L.; Mugwanga, H. ; Kashangaki, J. ; Maximambali, F. ; Lwoga, C. ;
Wright, G. ; Rutherford, S. (1999) “Client Drop-outs From East African Microfinance
Institutions”. - MicroSave Report, Kampala.
Hulme, D. and Mosley, P. (1997) “Finance for the Poor or the Poorest? Financial Innovation,
Poverty and Vulnerability.” In who Needs Credit? Poverty and Finance in
Bangladesh. G.D. Wood and I. Sharif, eds. Dhaka, Bangladesh : The University Press
Limited.
Kakuru J (2000). Financial dimensions and the business (1st ed). MUBS
Kakuru J (2000). Financial dimensions and the business (2nd ed). MUBS
Kambugu A M (2002) Investigating how organization culture and climate customer orientation,
and innovation affect performance of service firms.
Kotler P and Gray, A. (1998) Principles of marketing (8th ed) New Jersey: prentice Hall incl.
Maximambali, F. (1999).“Client Exits (Drop-outs) amongst Tanzanian MFIs”. MicroSave- Africa Research Report.
Mbonigaba, W (1998). Internal bench marking and business process. Industry newsletters
Meyer, R.; Graham, D. and Pagura, M. (2001) “Determinants of borrower drop out in microfinance: an empirical investigation in Mali”.
Mukweli, J. (2001). Business administration and Management (2nd ed). London: Gee and
Company publishers.
Murray, I. (2001). “Cultivating Client Loyalty”. - The Microbanking Bulletin, Washington, D.C.; Issue no. 6, pp. 20-24
Ngahu, C. (2001) Customer care and delight. The profoto Magazine vol. 5 no 2. pp. 14-16
No 159. Pp.8-9
57
Ongena, S., and Smith, D.C. (2001). “The Duration of Bank Relation Ships”. Journal of Financial Economics 61 449-475.
Pagura, M. (2003). “Examining Client Exit in Microfinance : Theoretical and Empirical
perspectives”. PhD Dissertation, The Ohio State University.
Pagura, M. (2004). “Client Exit in Microfinance : A conceptual Framework with Empirical
Results From Mali”. CSAE Conference : Growth, Human Capital, and Povert
Reduction in Africa.
Painter, J., and MKNelly, B. (1999). “Village Banking Dynamics Study: Evidence from Seven Programs.” Journal of Microfinance1 (Fall 1999) : 91-116.
Pandey .I.M.(1995); Financial Management seventh Edition New Delhi India
Pandey, M. (1995). Financial Management.
Roston.J.F (2001): Research report writing (A contemporary Approach for beginners) Koran
page limited London.
Schreiner, M. (2001). “Scoring drop out at a Micro lender in Bolivia”. Center for Social Development. Washington University in St. Louis.
Schreirer,M.(2002).Credit Scorching for micro finance:Can it work?Journal of micro finance
Vol 2
Simanowitz, A. (1999). “Client Exit Surveys: A tool for understanding client drop out”. Journal of Microfinance 2: 91-116.
Tumwesige, G (2003). The art of Customer design. MCC reports, pp. 22-26
Uganda Poverty reduction strategy paper progress report (2002
Urquizo, J. (2006). “Improving And Monotoring Customer Retention”. - Paper prepared for the Microcredit Summit Campain.
58
Van Horne (1994); Financial Management and Policy (Fifth Edition) Prentice Hall Englewood.
Wright, G. (2001). “Drop-outs and Graduates: Lessons from Bangladesh”. - The Micro-banking
Bulletin, Washington, D.C. Issue no. 6pp. 14-16.
59
Appendices
Appendix A: QUESTIONNAIRE
Dear respondent,
The questions here set under are intended to facilitate the study on micro finance institution’s
credit policy and customer retention, a case study of HOFOKAM ltd.
You are kindly requested to give in some time to provide you opinion by answering the
following questions, by placing a tick in the appropriate box.
The questions are entirely for academic purposes and all the information provided will be treated
with utmost confidentiality.
Section A: General information
(Tick the appropriate answer)
1. Gender
Male Female
2. Age
Below 20 years 20-30 years 31-40 years Above 40years
3. What is your highest qualification level
Certificate Diploma Degree Others Specify
4. What position do you hold in HOFOKAM
Senior Management Middle Management Other (Specify)
60
Section B: Credit standards
5. Is the character and credit history of a client considered when evaluating him or her for a
loan?
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
6. Is the capacity of a client to use and repay the loan considered before giving a loan?
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
7. The client’s security, its value and ownership are always considered before loan approval.
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
8. HOFOKAM considers clients capital contribution into the business before giving a loan.
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
Section c: Credit terms
9. The institution has credit limits for each specific group of clients.
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
10. The institution has a credit period it extends to clients to pay a loan considering the
inability to pay due to certified conditions.
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
11. The interest rates payable to the institution are affordable to all clients.
Strongly Disagree Disagre Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
61
e
12. A client can be allowed to negotiate on the terms of the loan given his /her type of
business.
Strongly Disagree Disagre
e
Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
Section D: Collection procedures
13. HOFOKAM Ltd rings clients to discuss about loan payments.
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
14. Reminder letters are sent to clients about paying up their loans
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
15. Visits are made to clients to remind them of their loan obligation
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
Section E: Customer retention
16. Proper records about clients of the institution are maintained
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
17. All clients come back to borrow again
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
62
18. The prevailing rate of the number of clients dropping out of HOFOKAM ltd is
Very low Low Moderate High Very high
19. High interest rates cause HOFOKAM clients to drop out of the institution
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
20. HOFOKAM loan collection methods cause clients to drop out of the institution
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
21. The credit policy in use by HOFOKAM Ltd has an effect on the customer retention level
Strongly Disagree Disagree Not sure Agree Strongly Agree
22. Suggest ways of improving credit policy in HOFOKAM Ltd
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
Thank you for being part of this academic research.
63
Appendix II: Interview Guide
Questions for the management of HOFOKAM Ltd
1) Under what circumstances do you call clients?
2) Under what circumstances do you send clients remainder letters?
3) Under what circumstances do you visit clients to remind them to pay their loans?
4) Does the institution offer services on credit?
5) Do some clients fail to fulfill their loan obligations?
6) What do you do to such clients?
7) Do you receive complaints from the clients concerning the quality of your services?
64